TheSilmarillionWriters'Guild

Home  |  Most Recent  |  Authors  |  Titles  |  Search  |  Series  |  Podfics  |  Top Tens  |  Login  |    |  




Reviews For All the Answers

You must login (register) to review.

Reviewer: Alasse Signed [Report This]
Date: August 28, 2010 - 08:12 am
Title: A Word In

‘I just did’, he said softly. ‘It is all, all Noldolante—because it is I who play it.’


Wonderful, and so true. Daeron's comment on the Noldor shows us they don't know the real Noldor, and how much the Noldor have changed.


the young Noldo sat bolt upright, suddenly stone-cold sober, and began considering what else Maedhros might have meant to imply.



I too am considering. Is it because Morgoth didn't have anough time before Fingon rescued him? Because Maedhros was already broken by his father, or by himself or by what happened? All of the above? None? ... I love how everyone could have their own interpretation :)



Author's Response:

Thank you very much! I'm glad these short pieces seem to work for you as a pair. I think that there are some suggestions in my other stories what Maedhros could have been hinting at. But, of course, he mainly wanted the bystanders to understand his answer as they did--although the atmosphere at the Feast of Reuniting was friendly and optimistic, the question he was being asked was actually quite a dangerous one, politically, and he was aware of that.

Reviewer: Angelica Signed [Report This]
Date: May 15, 2010 - 02:52 pm
Title: Musician

Poor Maglor! He can't forget even when he is having fun, can he?

Author's Response: No, I guess he can't--not, at least, when he is practising his art, not without losing his integrity as an artist. As a performer, I think he's still enjoying himself, though, startling Daeron not once, but twice over! I am very grateful that you and Oshun chose to comment on different aspects of this piece, because I was trying to balance both these points of view against each other.

Reviewer: oshun Signed [Report This]
Date: May 15, 2010 - 08:08 am
Title: Musician

I love this! You really know how to push my buttons. I have always imagined that the Noldolante was not just a tragic tear-jerker, but comprised the entire emotional gamut--the moments of levity as well as those of sorrow.

Author's Response: Thank you! In my more off-beat moments, I imagine that we are, all of us together, trying to write (or re-write) the Noldolante for Maglor, that is, not just when we write about the Noldolante itself, but in anything we write about the Noldor--in which case, the Noldolante indeed contains just about everything and the kitchen sink... On a more literal level, the Noldolante seems to have been a longish work, not just a short lyric, so it was probably not, as you say, merely a tear-jerker, because I suspect Maglor was too great an artist to restrict himself to a single emotional note in a major work like that.




You must login (register) to review.