Comments on All Our Yesterdays

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.

If I have reviewed this somewhere else forgive me for repeating myself. I really love this story. Also, just wanted to let you know I borrowed a bit of your younger Elrond's personality for a ficlet I posted here (of course I mized it all up and for my own wicked purposes--please forgive me). It is a chapter (8-Forbidden Lore) in my drabble/ficket series here "It Gives A Lovely Light."

No, I don't think you've reviewed it before... thank you so much for commenting, I'm glad you enjoyed it.

I read the ficlet and see the resemblance in the paragraph about him and Elros, yes. The interaction with Gil-galad was your own *smiles*. I've only written them together once, and I struggled - though I really should look through the rules and see if I could post that here. It goes from First Age through to Valinor.

Thank you, my dear, you've paid me a lovely compliment. I must go and read the rest of your series now.

~Kei

Oh wow, thank you so much for the lovely review :) This was a birthday gift originally, and was a projection of what might have happened during that final day to the people I'd been writing about in Even Quicker than Doubt -- sort of a spin off, I guess (Doubt is set at the beginning of the second age) I'm specially glad you enjoyed the historical and cultural background, because I like playing with those themes.