Comments on A Promise Lives Within You

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


What a lovely blessing song! After so much loss (and all those lost mariners Turgon sent) no wonder he's afraid for Eärendil.

Thank you very much!

Yes, Egalmoth knows about previous failures and has heard from Voronwe about his harrowing experiences! But also, he has premonitions and is not sure whether they are for Vingilot's voyage or for Sirion's safety, while Earendil is away...

(In one early version in BOLT II, Egalmoth gets killed in Sirion, in another he survives and gets back to Valinor. Tolkien Gateway says "killed by the Sons of Feanor", but that seems to be not quite right, as far as I can tell. In the version in which Egalmoth gets killed, it is apparently Morgoth who attacks Sirion, not the SoF.)