Comments on Unexpected Commonalities

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


I really love this intimate and revealing moment of connection between these two! A truly comforting story!

I'm so happy to be able to listen to you reading this again. It's a wonderful idea for these two to meet and find common ground, and I love the little details such as Boromir's comments and thoughts about Faramir. (And it's so poignant and believable that Boromir genuinely intends to protect Frodo, knowing what comes later).

I love to have people meet who don't in canon (at least not alone) but very possibly could. I see Boromir as ultimately well intentioned. He means to do his best for this quest to succeed, even if he doesn't entirely agree with its goal. He's a warrior and he thinks it's his job to protect people less strong than him.

I'm happy that you like my reading :)