Comments on Siren Song

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.

Yesss this suits him so well! Lying Maglor with his lying tongue...And the siren taking the form of the Silmaril! Excellent emphasis on how sirens' temptations are not all beautiful women and sex appeal. (Also how even now, trying to return home, Maglor can STILL be tempted with the sight of a Silmaril!) I would definitely read more of this AU from you eue

A very clever take on Maglysseus's out-sirening a siren!

I love the language you used for it, a touch of the epic!

Maybe I should have a closer look, but after the first reading it seemed to me that you might have left it a bit ambiguous,  deliberately, whether this is actually the curse and the silmaril re-surfacing or whether there is an animate malicious being, like a mythological siren, trying to delude Maglor?

I felt in any case the outcome was a real victory.

Thank you! You need not take a closer look, you're quite right that it's ambiguous :). Perhaps it would be less so in a longer scene. Though I was surprised to find/be reminded that the Sirens episode in the actual Odyssey is about the same length as this ficlet. (Also that it's narrated by Odysseus in first person, hence the choice here). It's certainly made an imaginative impact for only a handful of lines of the poem.

It seems like little more than a diversion along the way for Odysseus; I think I made it more significant for Maglor and yes, a victory. I'm glad you enjoyed!