Acing This Thing Called Romance by Prackspoor
Fanwork Notes
A general note: the backdrop of this story draws heavily on events and characters that appeared in the "Unread Visions" series. If there's a non-canon character or a non-canon event that's being referenced, chances are I've taken it from there.
- Fanwork Information
-
Summary:
The circle of the Mírdain sat in silence, the summer night sky forming a dark dome above them, while fires in the braziers surrounding the terrace flickered, and everyone was lost in comfortable contemplation of their own thoughts.
That was, until Daeror suddenly straightened in his seat and his eyes homed in on Celebrimbor and Annatar with the precision of a First Age mid-range missile, courtesy of Curufinwë I.
“Anyway,” the bard asked out of nowhere, “how’s your sex life?”
Celebrimbor and Annatar spat out their drinks.
Major Characters: Celebrimbor, Sauron
Major Relationships: Celebrimbor/Sauron
Genre: Alternate Universe, Crackfic, Drama, Humor
Challenges:
Rating: Adult
Warnings: Sexual Content (Mild)
Chapters: 18 Word Count: 77, 047 Posted on Updated on This fanwork is complete.
A City of Science and Learning
Read A City of Science and Learning
Ost-in-Edhil was famously a city of science and learning, and as such, loved its discourses and colloquies. Be it the linguists, the chemists, the physicists and, most famously and by far the worst of all, the faculties of philosophy and applied ethics – every last one of them hosted their discussion circles, their debate groups, and even themed events where everyone and their dog could show up and argue and discuss to their heart’s content. Knowledge on the subject was mostly optional during those public events and people relished is as an opportunity to get into sanctioned arguments and insult people they didn’t like under the guise of attacking a professional opinion instead of the person behind it.
(It should be noted that the professionals especially were not above doing this. Quite the contrary, they were often the most immature and facetious of them all, to the point where one such argument of two Masters of Ethics (Q.E.D.) escalated into a public lawsuit that occupied the front page of every newspaper for three months. It was very embarrassing, and a lot of people took malicious glee in it. Public events of the Ethics faculty where thereafter banned, and discussions strictly moderated by a poor fellow of the faculty of Behavioural Psychology. Why a psychologist should be in any way equipped to handle a handful of immature academics was anyone’s guess and one of the questions in Ost-in-Edhil’s history that should forever remain unanswered.)
So that was the rabble-rousers. For everyone else, it was a nice opportunity to show how superior your arguments and knowledge were to that of your colleagues, if you were so inclined. It was also a very nice excuse to come together at night after work and take a few drinks together.
During the cold months those events mainly took place indoors – lecture halls, taverns, or the residences of those citizens who preferred a more spacious and, say, ostentatious presentation of their homes.
In the summer, those discussion panels often took place in the public gardens and parks that could be found all over the city, often very close to the location of said faculties.
The Guild of the Jewel-Smiths, too, had a tradition of gathering for such meetings after work, though their colloquies were notably less heated and more of a social counterweight for spending days on end isolated in workshops. The Guild was located in a tower on the uppermost level of the city. This put them very close to the gardens in the Third Ring, which they amicably shared with the Guild of Botanists in a mutually beneficial arrangement. While the botanists tended to the flora of the place, the Jewel-Smiths maintained an intricate infrastructure of magical lamp-stones that were placed upon posts to light the paved walkways, the terraces adjoining the guild buildings, the gazebos hidden in little clearings, or even illuminate the underside of the bridges so that the water running beneath lit up in a rainbow of colours.
These mutual efforts turned the gardens and terraces in the Third Ring into a sanctuary of peace and quiet in an otherwise hustling and bustling city.
The guild of the Mírdain had commandeered one such terrace for themselves. It was conveniently placed at the foot of the guild tower, and it provided ample space for their gatherings on warm summer evenings. There were about forty rattan chairs, all of which could comfortably be arranged in one big – or alternatively, many smaller circles, there were little tables, braziers, and a little diverted stream flowing on its merry, burbling way along the south side of the terrace.
Cypresses and corkscrew hazels hid the guild members from too-curious eyes of passersby on two sides, whereas the remaining side opened into the surrounding gardens.
It was a comfortable place, and the Mírdain came here often. Daeror Deukalion, who did, in fact, belong to the bards, came here as well, but since he was supposedly in a (suspected, but as of yet unconfirmed) relationship with a smith called Sindrian, no one questioned his presence and accepted it. Daeror himself was glad for it, since according to his own words, the ‘theater people’ were fun to be around for a while, but quickly became too much to deal with, especially when casts for plays were being discussed.
“Too much drama,” he said, waving it off, “and yes, I am aware of the irony of someone from the Faculty of the Dramatic Arts saying this. No need to point it out.”
There were also a few other guests at times, most notably Gildiriel from Astrophysics, Inarë from Botany, and Throndûr, a Dwarven scholar from Quantum Mechanics, who came and went and were always gladly welcomed in the midst of the homogenous mass of smiths, bringing with them a host of gossip and topics that otherwise would not have made it into the walls of the Mírdain’s Tower.
This story begins on one such summer evening in mid-June; the 21st, to be exact, which was notable because it was the birthday of Celebrimbor Tyelperinquar, and everyone in the guild had been looking forward to this day for weeks. (The Guild loved birthdays, perhaps because its occupation lent itself so well to gift-giving, which was arguably a thing that every Mírdain enjoyed even more than receiving gifts.)
Varda’s host of stars was out in full splendour after the sun had set at the end of the longest day of the year, the air was balmy, and a gentle breeze carried the scent of bougainvillea and honeysuckle over to the terrace. Braziers had been lit at the edges of the terrace and fire-light cast the revellers into golden and orange hues.
Gifts had been handed over, and Daeror just finished conducting a not-entirely-in-tune choir for a birthday song, which ended with Celebrimbor grinning sheepishly, a lot of side-hugs, shoulder-slapping, many happy-birthdays’s and how-old-are-you-even-you-wrinkly-codger’s, and an enthusiastic, self-congratulatory applause by the choir at the end of the song.
“By Varda, that was terrible. If you ever dare to apply to join the bards, I’ll burn your applications myself,” Daeror said, setting his lute aside to a chorus of laughter and appreciative hoots. He threw a sideways glance at Annatar, who was sitting next to Celebrimbor’s chair. The elf had gotten up from his chair to accept another round of well-wishes. The Maia had been looking up at the elf, his legs crossed and smiling wryly to himself as he watched the proceedings.
“You should be glad that this wasn’t what the primordial choir had to work with, Annatar,” Daeror said loudly, so as to be heard over the noise that the party was making. “If they had been the Maiar and Valar to sing the world into being, I wouldn’t dare to imagine what this planet would look like. The sky and earth would likely be inverted, water would flow upwards, trees would grow in spirals, and horses would have five legs and two heads.”
The Maia threw him a look and raised an eyebrow. “That is one reason to be grateful for small mercies, isn’t it?”
“I don’t know if I would call it a mercy,” Daeror said.
“Stop that,” Celebrimbor said as he extricated himself from an embrace by Falda, a young Dwarven smith from Khazad-Dûm, who had only recently graduated to journeywoman. “It is my birthday, and my birthday song, and I will not hear any badmouthing, you shameless detractors.”
Daeror just raised both palms in a sign of surrender, while Annatar shrugged and just said, “Guilty as charged.”
Celebrimbor dropped back into his seat with a huff, then began to carefully arrange the pile of gifts that people had left by his chair – enough to create a tripping hazard if he wasn’t being careful.
“But truly,” he began, even has he was still shuffling around the countless boxes and wooden caskets, “thank you.” He looked up and regarded each of his colleagues – and friends – in turn. “Thank you so much. I don’t even know what to say, these are wonderful presents. And it is wonderful to have you all here.”
“Yes, yes,” Throndûr waved it off, “those thank-you’s are all well and good, but how about you show your gratitude in a way that’s more, ah, tangible? We expect an invitation for all of us for dinner in a very fine restaurant – like the Laurelin, perhaps? What do you say?” The old dwarf looked around at the revellers, who applauded and made noises and whistles of agreement.
Celebrimbor grinned. “Vultures, every single one of you. Yes, fine. Of course you will get an invitation. By Varda, what ever gave me the idea that I had friends who just liked me for my personality?”
“Acquire a personality, then we’ll see,” Thelene, a silversmith from Harad, said with a bellowing laugh.
“I maintain what I said: vultures,” Celebrimbor repeated good-naturedly. “I don’t know why I even invited you.”
“Oh, but you didn’t,” Daeror said, leaning forward. “Which is why we, in our boundless wisdom and foresight, simply invited ourselves.” Again, laughter and applause. “You’re not getting out of this, Tyelperinquar.”
“Oh, I know, I know.” Celebrimbor laughed, then turned around to a table where a banquet of cakes, sweet pastries, and other confectionary was arranged. “What about a bit of good old bribery, though? Just to tide you over until the invitation, of course.”
“Ah, the chap is learning quickly,” Throndûr said. “I like it. Let’s see the cakes, then!”
By unanimous agreement, Celebrimbor’s banquet of bribery was deemed more than sufficient. There was confectionary from every imaginable corner of the world, from Haradrim puff pastries filled with dates, figs and cream to Númenorean pudding with coconut and macadamia nuts to the walnut-and-raspberry fudges from Erebor.
Cake and wine were served, and this, at least, was enough to make even the relentless ribbing of the man of the day cease, as everyone was blissfully silent and focused on their respective dessert.
While his guests were otherwise occupied, Celebrimbor made use of the time to go through his pile of presents, opening them, commenting them, and carefully setting them aside on a table designated especially for this purpose.
Celebrimbor let out an excited noise when he opened one of the cards – an intricate thing in the style of marble veined with gold. He showed it to Annatar. “Look! It’s from Narvi and Fundin! And they’ve written half a novel – as always. Stars, I wish they could be here tonight.”
Annatar took the proffered card with a wry smile and read it. “It really does look like you would have a lot to say to each other if you were to meet in person.”
“Oh absolutely.” Celebrimbor opened another card, then let out a bellowing laugh. “Quite the contrast to Floki. Look!” Still shaking with laughter, Celebrimbor handed Annatar the second card, while reaching for his glass of wine.
There wasn’t much written in it. In fact, there was hardly anything in it at all. Just one sentence, all in capital letters: HAPPY ONE YEAR OLDER DAY YOU BLOCKHEAD.
“This came with it.” Celebrimbor gave Annatar a small package, which contained a rough, unremarkable piece of rock. The purpose of the rock became clear when Annatar pulled out the accompanying note, which had been scrawled on piece of paper and stuffed inside the box with no regards for care and space.
THIS IS A PIECE OF ROCK. I GIVE IT TO YOU IN HOPES THAT YOU NOW HAVE SOMETHING MORE INTELLIGENT TO CARRY AROUND THAN THAT INFLATED HEAD OF YOURS.
PS: IT’S A GOOD ROCK. I CHOSE IT MYSELF.
PPS: IT’S A PIECE OF THE BOULDER YOU USED TO DESTROY THE BELLOWS IN THE NORTHERN FORGES.
PPPS: I WILL NEVER LET YOU LIVE IT DOWN.
PPPPS: IN FACT, I THINK I WILL SEND YOU THE ENTIRE BOULDER PIECE BY PIECE SO YOU CAN BUILD A MONUMENT TO YOUR SHAME. I WILL TELL YOUR MAIA TO REASSEMBLE IT. HE’S OF AULË, I AM SURE HE CAN DO IT. I WILL ALSO TELL HIM TO PUT THE BOULDER RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOUR BEDROOM WINDOW SO YOU HAVE TO LOOK AT IT EVERY DAY WHEN YOU WAKE UP.
PPPPPS: I AM WELL AWARE THAT YOU LIVE ON THE TENTH FLOOR OF A TOWER OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. I DO NOT CARE. YOUR MAIA WILL FIGURE IT OUT.
PPPPPPS: HAPPY BIRTHDAY, YOU MUPPET.
Celebrimbor, who had been reading along over Annatar’s shoulder, slumped sideways into the Maia, boneless with laughter and tears running from his eyes.
Annatar, deftly and automatically cushioning the jostle so as not to spill his own wine, made a sound that sounded like a cross between aborted laughter and a cough. “Remind me again, are you two friends or enemies? I can’t quite tell from the letter.” He handed the card and the abysmal present back to Celebrimbor, who was still trying to regain his composure and failing terribly.
“Are you joking?” Celebrimbor wheezed out. “Obviously he’s one of my best friends and obviously this is one of the best birthday presents I have ever gotten. I will treasure it always, the note especially.” The elf tried in vain to close the box with the rock, failed three times because he was still shaking too much with mirth, then gave up and set it aside.
“The best?” Gildiriel echoed. “I feel insulted, Tyelperinquar – we put a lot of effort into our gifts as well. And we even went through the trouble of packaging them neatly enough to create the illusion that we liked you.”
“Oh, I know, I know,” Celebrimbor said. “I’m sorry.” He wiped the tears from his eyes with his sleeve, then dissolved into a chortle again. “No – but truly.” He cleared his throat and at last managed to assume a more serious mien. He raised his glass of wine in her direction in a grateful toast. “Your star charts are amazing, Gildiriel. Pengolodh is going to seethe in his shoes when yours become the new academic standard. I don’t want to know the amount of time and effort you had to put into it before you finished mapping out both hemispheres – and now I finally know what that trip to South Harad was for.”
Gildiriel waved it off, but she was obviously pleased. “Ah, it was nothing. It was the least I could do after you fixed the telescopes for me. Lens doublets!” she exclaimed suddenly. “Why didn’t I think of it?”
“There’s value in cooperation, at times,” Throndûr said. “Which is why we are all sitting here and talking, no matter the faculty. We have a lot to learn from each other still – except you, Daeror. You are just sitting here and using up our oxygen, and if you’ve ever made any contribution beyond bawdy songs or bad jokes, I’ve yet to hear about it.”
Daeror bowed from the waist, which looked very comical, as he was doing it sitting. “I appreciate the praise. This is all that I could hope for people to take away from a conversation with me. Consider me a happy man.”
Sindrian, who was sitting next to him, hid his face behind his hands and dragged his palms down to his chin with a long-suffering sigh.
“Don’t pretend to be the martyr here,” Daeror said, turning around towards him. “I know you love me and I also know you are secretly enjoying every second of this.”
“Objection,” Sindrian said.
“To what? Loving me or enjoying the scene?”
“The latter, and if you don’t stop now, the former, too.”
Daeror chuckled. “Liar.” Then he turned around to face Annatar again. “Speaking of undying devotion and eternal love – what did you get our man of the day?”
Annatar, who had just taken a sip of his wine, raised an eyebrow as he lowered his glass. “Oh, wouldn’t you like to know?”
“I would, in fact, like to know.”
“Keep liking a bit longer, then,” Annatar replied. “I am not going to show off my gifts where everyone can see them. Tyelperinquar is going to get his gift – later. In private.”
A susurrus of a sotto-voce “Ooooooh” ran through the circle, and both Annatar and Celebrimbor looked around in a mix of confusion (and, on Annatar’s part, irritation).
“Is something wrong?” asked Celebrimbor.
“Ah well, I see,” Daeror said with a grin and leaned back in his chair. “Message taken. I won’t pry.”
“Smart man.”
“Wait, what are we talking about?” Celebrimbor asked.
“We are not talking about anything,” Daeror said. “Because it is apparently very private.”
Celebrimbor threw a questioning look at Annatar, who met his gaze with a shrug. “It is. As for the fuss they’re making, I have no idea.”
After this, the circle of the Mírdain sat in silence for a while, the summer night sky forming a dark dome above them, while the fires in the braziers surrounding the terrace flickered, and everyone was lost in comfortable contemplation of their own thoughts.
That was, until Daeror the bard suddenly straightened in his seat and his eyes homed in on Celebrimbor and Annatar with the precision of a First Age mid-range missile, courtesy of Curufinwë I.
“Anyway,” the bard asked out of nowhere, “how’s your sex life?”
Celebrimbor and Annatar spat out their drinks.
“Daeror!” Sindrian exclaimed, while Gildiriel leapt to her feet in order to get serviettes for the elf and the Maia, and Falda made a surprised “Heh” noise, then toppled sideways out of her chair and crumpled to a heap next to her chair, howling with laughter.
“What?” Celebrimbor and Annatar choked out simultaneously, eyes wide, their laps dripping with wine.
Daeror just shrugged. “What? Everyone here was thinking it.”
“No?” Sindrian yelled hoarsely. “We didn’t? Not everyone has got their mind in the gutter at all times, you impossible – ”
“It was a normal question –”
“You don’t go around asking people how their sex life is, what the hell is wrong with you –”
“ – just because you all got a stick up your arse instead of screwing your courage to the sticking place and ask what’s on your mind –”
“Ahahaha, oh my Stars, did he just say ‘screwing’?”
“By the Valar, Falda, how old are you? Fifty?”
“It was the context! The context!”
“ – all proper and prude, and nearly fainting when a lady flashes her ankles, I swear –”
“ – respect for other people’s privacy, for fuck’s sake –”
“DID HE JUST SAY ‘FU –”
“Falda!”
“The context!”
“I’m surrounded by children and idiots.”
“And I am surrounded by prudes and want-to-be moralists! I mean, of course they’re doing it, what kind of relationship would it be if the only relevant bonds between them were covalent electron bonds –”
“Ooooh, chemistry, you say?”
“— it’s a cornerstone of any romantic relationship, don’t pretend it’s not –”
“Oh, get lost, with your backwards electron allegories, you don’t even know what you’re talking about! Dyrac proved once and for all it was a matter of quantum mechanics, whereas you likely haven’t even heard of wave-particle-duality –”
“Friends! Friends – please!” Gildiriel shouted, while she was trying in vain to dab the veritable lake of red wine out of Celebrimbor’s lap and, arguably, making everything worse by rubbing the stain deeper into the fabric. “Let them keep their secrets,” she said, trying to calm down the situation. “An Elda and Maia – it is a romance for the books of legend. A fairytale, much like Thingol and Melian. Don’t take away the mystery.”
“You know, Gil,” Falda gasped out from where she was crouched doubled over on her chair, wheezing, “I could take your words about romance and mystery and leaving ‘em alone a lot more seriously if you weren’t rubbing around Tyelpo’s crotch right now.”
Daeror exploded with laughter. Sindrian actually threw over his chair when he jumped up and slapped is maybe-maybe-not-partner over the head. Daeror only laughed harder. Gildiriel’s face had assumed an unhealthy shade of puce and with a stuttered apology, she dropped the sodden napkins into Celebrimbor’s lap and with a hasty apology retreated to her seat, only to try and crawl into her wine glass in embarrassment, while Throndûr tried to pick Falda off the ground, who seemed to have reverse-evolved into an invertebrate and dissolved into a gasping puddle on the floor.
During all of this Celebrimbor and Annatar had not moved one inch. Only now, in the absolute chaos and shouting and hysterical laughter going on around them, did they slowly turn their heads to look at each other.
“What,” Annatar said, “is going on.”
“I honestly have no idea,” Celebrimbor said flatly. “Could you clean us up, please?”
With a quick gesture, Annatar did so, leaving their clothes as pristine as they had been before. No one around them even noticed. Little did they know that a wine stain was the least of messes that Daeror’s question had just thrown them into headfirst.
Silver and Gold
Read Silver and Gold
It was three o’ clock in the morning when the party had finally disbanded, Celebrimbor and Annatar had cleaned up the terrace, and finally made it to the elf’s rooms. It was also, technically, no longer Celebrimbor’s birthday, which left Annatar slightly miffed, because he would be giving his gift away too late.
“It doesn’t matter, really,” Celebrimbor said, looking back over his shoulder while unlocking the door to his rooms. “What is it you always like to say? ‘If you prefer to measure time by the arbitrary scale of celestial bodies revolving around each other, be my guest?’”
Annatar just grumbled. “Don’t quote my own words back at me. I know what I said. I also know that a birthday has meaning for Incarnates and that it is, as per its name, confined to a day, which, by common agreement, ends at midnight.”
Celebrimbor unlocked the door, then let his hands sink. “Oh Annatar. Come now. Don’t wrack your head over it.” He stepped towards his friend. “If there is any gift that I would gladly wait for, it is yours, and you know that.” Celebrimbor leaned in and kissed his forehead.
Annatar didn’t look mollified. He just gave an ill-tempered shrug and went past Celebrimbor into his workroom. It was a big space with a wall facing west that sported a window front that rose as high as the ceiling. A massive wooden desk stood in front of it, and it was strewn with correspondence, books, and sketches.
Celebrimbor threw himself into an armchair mainly intended for visitors and kicked off his shoes. He looked up at Annatar. “Would you mind terribly if I took a shower first? I know the wine is gone from my clothes, but this evening was a messy event, and I’d love to – argh – yes, I think I do want a change of clothes.”
“‘Messy’ is an understatement,” Annatar said drily, leaning against the desk. “But do go ahead. What’s another half hour until I can give you my gift.”
“Annatar.” Celebrimbor threw him an imploring look. “Please. I will be a lot more comfortable and focused after a shower.”
“Fine.”
“You know, you say it like that, and I know it’s not fine.”
“Well, you will have to learn to take me by my word, because ‘fine’ is what you will get,” Annatar retorted acridly.
“As a gift?” Celebrimbor grinned. “Oh see, now you gave it away.”
“Tyelperinquar.” Annatar threw him a dark look. “I have just had a lifetime’s worth of idiocy compressed into one evening. I beg you not to add to the pile. It is beneath you, it is beneath me, and I frankly do not have either the nerves or the patience for such buffoonery tonight.”
Celebrimbor’s grin faded to a soft, slight smile. “I understand. No more tomfoolery.” He walked over to the door to his bedroom. “It will take me just ten minutes. You can wait in the bedroom, I’ll join you there as soon as possible.” And with that he walked through the door, leaving Annatar to sigh deeply and follow after him.
Annatar was waiting for him when he came back. The room had been doused in a gentle, low light that seemed to have no worldly source. The Maia was sitting in one of the two armchairs in front of the dark fireplace, turning a delicately carved lampstone over in his hands, wrought in the shape of Morovius strip[1]. It had been Fundin’s and Narvi’s gift – a Dwarvish advancement of simple Eldarin lampstones, owed to their fascination with abstract topological spaces. The Maia didn’t look very focused, though. He seemed distracted and preoccupied, his brows pulled into a slight frown.
Celebrimbor slowly approached him, having shed his festive clothes for simple, loose-fitting pieces of attire, fit for lounging around at home and sleeping, but not necessarily for going out. He sat down in the second armchair and pulled one leg up to sit on it, bending the other so he could loop his arms around it.
“So,” he said. “Here I am.”
Annatar looked up from the lampstone, meeting his eyes over the curve of the strip. “Here you are.” He slowly set aside the stone, then interlaced his fingers. “You look tired.”
“That’s probably because I am,” Celebrimbor said with an upward quirk of his lips, and putting his chin down on his bent knee, while holding Annatar’s gaze in a very bad show of coquetry. “But I’m not too tired to sit and talk. Or get my promised gift and duly appreciate it.”
“Well then.” Annatar reached forward and pushed a small box of black velvet, which Celebrimbor had heretofore not noticed, over the small side table towards the elf.
Celebrimbor quirked up an eyebrow and smirked. “Jewellery?”
“I don’t know. Open it.”
“You’re no fun.” Celebrimbor grinned, reached forward and picked up the box. It was very small and very light. It also, he couldn’t help but notice, looked very much like the classical box for storing an engagement ring.
“You’re not proposing to me, are you?” Celebrimbor said, turning over the box in his hands, then throwing a quizzical look at Annatar. For one horrifying moment he thought that this had to be it and that he had been making light of such a weighty occasion – but Annatar just shrugged, resting his chin on one hand, and keeping his gaze.
“I don’t know,” he drawled. “Open it.”
“I truly hope that this is not an engagement ring.”
“Really? Why?”
“Because I wouldn’t want it to be handed over like a parcel delivered by the postal service. I would want the classics: you going down on your knees before me, looking up at me, baring your soul to me –”
“Speak about unrealistic expectations.”
“—and asking me the question of all questions.”
“Oh, I am going to do just that – prepare yourself.” Annatar sat up straighter in his seat. “The question of all questions: Are you going to open it or not? Because otherwise I’m going to take it back and I’m going to think long and hard about whether to give it to you next year, or not at all, you impossible ingrate.”
Despite Annatar’s nonchalant tone that affected, if anything, irritation – Celebrimbor realized that it was a masquerade. There was a tension to Annatar’s jaw and shoulders that usually wasn’t there. His gestures were quicker and sharper than normal. His fingers were drumming on the armrest of his seat.
With a pang, Celebrimbor realized that Annatar was nervous. Oh no. What if it was an engagement ring after all?
Suitably cowed, Celebrimbor dropped his gaze to the unassuming little black box in his hands. Suddenly, his actions and words from earlier felt unkind. He stared at the box for a few moments longer, then, after a fortifying breath, he opened it.
And his breath caught.
It was a piece of jewellery, as he had suspected. It was, however, not the piece of jewellery he had half-feared to receive. It was no engagement ring. It was not a ring at all. It was a pendant.
Celebrimbor set down the box in his lap and with infinite care, slowly lifted it out. The light danced over it – glowing with silver light on the front, and, when he turned it over, with a golden glow on the back. The pendant was round and cut and assembled in the way of a lens doublet – two pieces of crystal, two lenses, one convex, one concave.
Gold and silver. A lens doublet. One lens making up for the shortcomings of the other and sharpening the final image. Achieving together what one alone could not do. A metaphor for their cooperation. And, on top of that, it was a callback to a long conversation Annatar and Celebrimbor had had a few years ago, which had begun with a lenses, of all things, and had gone on to become the foundational stone of their works on Rings.
It was a pendant. It was a metaphor. It was their shared history, poured into a small, fragile piece that was almost too delicate and nearly too beautiful to wear.
Celebrimbor wanted to speak, but found that he couldn’t. His throat was closed up.
He slowly set the pendant back down, closed the lid of the box, and without saying a word, rounded the table, bent down and pulled Annatar into a tight embrace.
“Thank you,” he murmured, his face buried in the crook of Annatar’s neck. Somehow his voice came out in hitches. “Thank you so much. This is – this is –” He broke off, because he had no idea how to describe what this gift meant to him – the thoughts behind it, the meaning of it all.
Annatar hesitantly returned the embrace. “Does that mean you like it?”
Celebrimbor pulled back. “Do I like it? Do I like it?” he echoed incredulously. “A piece of shared history of the two of us given form? A metaphor for everything we have done and are to each other? The most thoughtful, personal thing anyone has ever given me on this side of the ocean, perhaps ever? Are you honestly asking me whether I like it?”
Annatar looked at him. “I just – it is very personal. Perhaps too much so. I didn’t want to presume –”
Celebrimbor silenced him with a finger on his lips. “No. Stop. No more tomfoolery you said. And you are about to make a very big fool out of yourself.” He sat down on one armrest and from this slightly elevated position, looked down at Annatar, who returned his gaze, still with that uncharacteristic trepidation in his features.
Celebrimbor reached out and gently brushed a golden lock of hair behind the Maia’s ear. “In case I was being unclear with my gestures, and with, oh, spending nearly every hour of every day with you in the past, in seeking you out, in talking to you, flirting with you, Eru knows what else – let me spell it out for you: I love you, you impossible creature.” Celebrimbor took Annatar’s face in his hands. “There is no way you could give me something and it could be too personal. There are no boundaries to overstep, because for all that I know, there are no more boundaries between us.” Celebrimbor leaned in. “Two lens, one doublet, right? Two complementary halves. One perfect whole.”
Annatar swallowed. “Tyelperinquar…”
“Shut up and kiss me.”
Annatar, to his credit, was nothing if not obedient when faced with the wish of a man who was almost-still celebrating his birthday. Where he usually could be counted on to disobey every direct order just because he could (and also because he had a skull thick enough to go head to head with Grond and win), he was all compliance now.
He stretched up, Celebrimbor bent down, and for a while they got lost in each other, examining this curious new frontier that they had heretofore toed around, but never crossed.
Afterwards, they had somehow found a position where they both were sitting in the same armchair, partially wrapped around each other, partially leaning into each other to accommodate a number of limbs the chair wasn’t really made to accommodate. It was a tight fit, but it was unexpectedly comfortable.
Celebrimbor had tucked his head into the crook of Annatar’s neck while the Maia was running one hand through his hair in a slow, regular rhythm. It was warm, comfortable, and overall a wonderful position to be in. As it was, though, Celebrimbor found himself in a very real danger of dozing off, which was about the last thing he wanted to do now. Therefore, he righted himself and reached out for the box with the pendant, which had – in the pursuit of more important things – momentarily been forgotten on the small side table.
Celebrimbor took it and comfortably slumped back against Annatar’s side, rested his head on the Maia’s shoulder once more, and opened it. Gold and silver greeted him, glowing with their own light.
“You got these shards from Durin, didn’t you?” Celebrimbor asked quietly.
He felt Annatar nod against his head. “I asked for them about half a year ago,” he said quietly. “That is when I got the idea. I knew that the Light under the Mountain meant something to you – and Durin confirmed it, back when we were in Khazad-Dûm.” He paused. “Back when we were in Dwarrowdelf he mentioned that the echo of the Two Trees under the mountains was like a wound for you that could never heal. A memory of a home you couldn’t return to. But –” Annatar broke off, picking his way through the sentence, looking for the right words. “I was thinking – if you could never return, perhaps you could have a memory of home to carry with you.”
Celebrimbor stilled. He ceased turning the pendant in his fingers. His heart gave a deep, painful beat. Something in his chest clenched. Suddenly, his vision was blurred; the gold-and-silver sheen of the pendant was a smear of colours, with sharp, spiked rays protruding from them like small rays of starlight.
Stars and suns. Celebrimbor covered his eyes with his hand. Then he turned his entire body, the pendant held in his closed fist and he wrapped his arms around Annatar: this god that had come to his doorstep, had become first a teacher, then a friend – and now someone who had looked into the deepest reaches of his soul and pulled forth a wish and a wound that even Celebrimbor himself was afraid to look at, poured it into light and crystal, and shaped it into something beautiful.
What could you even say in response to this? Which words could even come close to express what he was feeling right now?
“By the light of Varda’s stars, what are you doing to me?” he whispered hoarsely against the Maia’s chest. “How can you say such things? What am I even supposed to say in response to that?” He lifted his head and looked at Annatar, and his face, too, was blurred. Celebrimbor laughed, but it came out as something stumbling, half joy, half a sob.
“‘Thank you’ is very much sufficient,” Annatar said with a wry smile, then more seriously, he added, “I am glad you like it.”
“I do. I really do.” Celebrimbor turned the pendant over once more, gold and silver mingling like living memory of a bygone age, a different place. “You know,” he said after a few moments, “it reminds me of you and me.” He held it up and turned it back and forth. Gold, silver. Silver, gold.
He threw a side glance at Annatar and the Maia smiled, a not entirely innocent expression.
“I’ll admit that this was one additional consideration that went into creating it.”
Celebrimbor regarded it. Then he suddenly frowned, sat up a bit straighter, and leaned back. “Wait, so are you proposing to me after all?”
Annatar met his gaze. “What is there to propose? I have no idea of the implications of Eldarin marriage, other than that it signifies a soul-bond of some kind or other, and that it means you decide to spend your life together. As far as I know, we –,” a brief hesitation, “have already done that.” Briefly, his expression became unsure, almost questioning. When Celebrimor smiled and nodded, though, he relaxed.
“What would a rite of some kind add to that?” Annatar finished. “I do not value pomp and circumstance.”
“Liar.” Celebrimbor held up the pendant to prove his point. “Everything you are and do is about pomp and circumstance.”
“If it were so, I’d have given it to you on the terrace,” Annatar countered. “This is supposed to be private. I do not want to put on a show for anyone. This is a question, if you will. But a question directed at you and meant for you – and you only.”
Annatar’s serious tone softened something into Celebrimbor and smothered the inclination to tease and rib. This was no jest, but a solemn occasion. The room was very quiet.
“I understand,” Celebrimbor said quietly. “Then the answer shall be for you, and only you, as well.” He leaned in, very close, and right into the Maia’s ear, he whispered, “Yes. Yes, a thousand times.”
This time, it was Annatar who pulled Celebrimbor close and kissed him, his usual careful restraint gone. He clung to the elf as if he never again wanted to let him go and Celebrimbor responded in kind.
They remained like this for a long, long time, and when they finally separated, they both made their way over to Celebrimbor’s bed and lay down there, glad for the space after having been curled up in the slightly tight confines of the armchair for too long.
After a while, though, it became apparent that something was not quite right with Annatar. After the initial joy, he seemed subdued, almost reserved, even while he kept combing his fingers though Celebrimbor’s hair.
They were both lying on their sides, facing each other, so Celebrimbor had a clear view of the frown that attempted time and time again to overtake Annatar’s expression.
“What’s wrong?” Celebrimbor asked quietly.
Annatar didn’t reply immediately. He took a deep breath in, then let it out, all the while continuing to stroke Celebrimbor’s hair, but no longer meeting his eyes.
Celebrimbor reached up and took Annatar’s hand and gently pulled it down so their hands were resting on the mattress between them. “Come now, I can see that you have something weighing down on your mind. Tell me.”
“It’s …” he began, then halted, which was very uncharacteristic. Annatar didn’t usually hesitate. Didn’t reconsider or remodel his sentences while speaking. He always seemed to know where he was going with his words – except now he wasn’t. “Is there something missing between us?” he asked instead.
“What?” Celebrimbor lifted his head, then sat up. Annatar followed suit. “What do you even – oh. Oh, no. Is this about what Daeror said?”
Annatar looked torn and almost angry with himself, staring holes into the mattress and picking at the fabric with his fingers. “He said it was a cornerstone of every true relationship.”
“Annatar, that is his opinion –”
“Yes, but it is, isn’t it?” Annatar interrupted him. “It’s a facet of being Incarnate, it is normal, and it apparently belongs within a relationship.”
“There is no such thing as an objectively good or complete relationship.”
“Yes, and not everybody likes candied fruit, but the majority of people do,” Annatar said tersely. “So it’s a staple for desserts, and it is generally assumed to be normal to offer them and eat them. Most would even expect them and be offended to find a buffet without them.”
“Offence has nothing to do with –”
“Tyelperinquar, do you find our – do you find us lacking?”
“No!” Celebrimbor exclaimed, the the words cutting sharply through the quiet of the room.
Annatar looked at him, his eyes narrowed as if he wanted to peel back the layers of Celebrimbor’s mind and search for the truth.
Celebrimbor threw him a tired look. “Annatar, please. Could you just – could take it at face value when I say that I have everything I wish for and that we are completely fine as we are?”
Annatar didn’t reply. He just kept looking at Celebrimbor. Without blinking. It was slightly irritating, and more than slightly unsettling.
“Annatar – would you – could you please stop looking at me like that.” Celebrimbor shifted backwards and crossed his legs.
Annatar, to his credit, seemed to notice that his – personhood, for lack of a better word, was slipping. It happened sometimes when he was deeply lost in thought, and it was eerie whenever it did. At Celebrimbor’s words he blinked, and the spell was broken.
“Alright,” he said. “Fine.” Then he got up from the bed and made for the door.
Celebrimbor looked after him, baffled. “Where are you going?”
“For a walk.”
“At four in the morning?”
“I need to think. Go to bed. Sleep well. See you later.” And with that staccato-fire of clipped words, the Maia was gone.
Celebrimbor stared at the door with a sinking feeling in his chest. He had the distinct feeling that the last word on the matter hadn’t been spoken.
Morgoth’s hammer down on your head, Daeror, he thought darkly.
[1] A Moebius strip.
Chapter End Notes
Daeror what have you done
Bonds Between
Read Bonds Between
Celebrimbor rose late the next morning, owed to the fact that he had lain awake until after dawn thinking about the turn of events from yesterday. Thankfully, there were no lectures scheduled on Saturdays, so he had the entire day to himself. He threaded a silver chain through Annatar’s pendant, then put the necklace on. He eyed the pendant ruefully – after being so happy about the gift, the early morning had taken a distinctly uncomfortable turn and thrown a shadow upon the lovely moment. Nothing to be done about that now, though.
After getting dressed he went in search of Annatar.
It turned out to be a long search. The Maia wasn’t at any of his usual haunts, and when noon had long passed and Celebrimbor still hadn’t seen neither hide nor hair of him, he was beginning to grow the slightest bit unsettled. He ran his fingers through his hair, looked around, and his eyes finally homed in on one of the house-keepers of the tower.
Trust the ones cleaning up after absent-minded academics to know about the goings-on in the guilds.
Celebrimbor walked over to the half-elven woman who was just dusting off the marble bust of Findréana the Wise, and cleared his throat. “Siódwhen! Excuse me?”
Siódwhen turned around. “Master Celebrimbor. Good day. How can I help you?”
“Ah, I was just wondering – have you seen Master Annatar around? I need to speak to him, yet I seem to be unable to find him.”
The woman frowned. “Hm. Not in some time, no.”
Celebrimbor’s shoulders sank.
She gave him an apologetic look, but then her face brightened suddenly. “Ah, but I just remembered! Emrys told me that he had seen him walking in the direction of Psychology – he seemed to find it noteworthy, since Master Annatar only ever seemed to stick to the hard sciences.”
Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “Thank you, then I shall look for him there.” He nodded at her, then walked off in the direction of the faculty of Psychology – also in the Third Ring, but at the other end of the guild halls.
Talk about the housekeepers taking note of everything going on, indeed.
The tip turned out to be worth its salt. Annatar was indeed in the building of Psychology – in fact, he was holed up in the library, sitting at a table in a remote corner, almost hidden behind piles and piles of books and scrolls.
When Celebrimbor hesitantly walked closer and caught sight of the titles, his heart sank:
The Soulbond – The Social Impact Of Elven Matrimony and Its Effects On The Psyche.
Laws and Customs of the Eldar.
Between Mind And Matter – The Inextricability and Reciprocal Influence of Psychological and Physical Aspects in Eldarin Relationships.
Bridging The Gap – Being an Account and a Critical Analysis Of Interspecies Relationships Found Among the Eldar and the Problems They Pose.
Between Fane and the Profane – The Relationships of the Eldar with the Gods: From Worship to Pupil to Marriage, Drawing Upon Examples Provided by Míriel Therindë, Artanis Finarfien, and Elu Thingol.
And that was only the uppermost part of the pile that Annatar had apparently read through in the ten hours since they had parted ways.
Celebrimbor cleared his throat.
Annatar looked up at him. “Good morning.”
“It’s seven in the evening, actually.”
Annatar looked at the sun beyond the arched windows, which had already made its way a good distance towards the west. “Ah,” he said. And nothing more.
Celebrimbor waited for a few moments, then gestured at the pile of books. “Should – er. Should we talk about this?”
Annatar eyed the fortress of parchment and paper that he had built around himself like he was seeing it for the first time. He blinked. “I … have done some research,” he said slowly.
“Yes, I can see that,” Celebrimbor said slowly. “That being said, I was under the impression that you had a very personal problem last night and I’m not sure whether research will solve it.”
Annatar gave him an offended look; obviously, research solved everything in his opinion, and if it didn’t, you simply hadn't been looking hard enough. The implication that some problems couldn’t be tackled by time, effort, and a strategic approach seemed to be a personal affront to the Maia.
Celebrimbor sat down next to him. “Annatar, we need to talk.”
Annatar looked at the remaining pile of books. “I’m not done researching yet.” He drew the tome he had been reading closer.
Celebrimbor reached over and closed it firmly, letting his hand rest on the cover. “Annatar.”
The Maia gave him an annoyed look.
Celebrimbor held his gaze. “Talk. To. Me.”
“About what.”
“Oh, I don’t know,” Celebrimbor said. “Why you’ve set foot in a faculty you’ve been avoiding like the plague, claiming that any sound science is inherently predictive and follows hard rules, and that any branch of study that relies on empirical conclusions is for quacks, and yet now I find you raiding their library? About the fact that you have taken an interest in Eldarin relationships that is so sudden and rushed that I can’t be good? Also, the trifle that the one thing that caused this was a drunk bard claiming that every romantic relationship needed to contain sex to be considered complete? Does any of that sound relevant?”
Annatar didn’t reply. Instead, he glowered at the books in front of him intensely enough that one of the scrolls started issuing a curling whisp of black smoke at one corner. Celebrimbor hurriedly grabbed it and pulled it out of the Maia’s line of sight.
“Enough of this,” he said and got to his feet. “Everything in here is flammable, and you are clearly not in a mood to be around flammable things right now. Come on, we are going on a walk.”
“Do I have a say in this?” Annatar asked flatly.
“No. Now pack up and come with me.”
Celebrimbor took them outside. Firstly, because he wanted to talk in private and the parks of the city were the best place to achieve this short of being cooped up in his bedroom. Secondly, because there had been enough summer rains to ensure that nothing in the parks would spontaneously combust if Annatar stared at it for too long.
“You understand that personal relationships are personal, yes?” Celebrimbor said, while they were walking along the path in the shadow of the trees. Golden-green light filtered through the foliage and the dappled light and shadow flitted over them. “There is no one-size-fits-all solution and there is certainly no objectively correct, single method to approach this stuff.”
Annatar nodded. “I do. It’s just – did you notice that there is hardly anything personal in our personal relationship? I know almost nothing about your past, you know almost nothing about me.”
Well, case in point. That much was true.
“Everything we do is work together,” Annatar said with an angry gesture that was frankly mind-boggling to Celebrimbor, because up until now he had thought the Maia had enjoyed what they were doing together.
“Not everything,” he said, a bit defensively.
“Don’t be facetious,” Annatar said tersely. “Ninety percent of our time together are taken up with some project or another.”
“Yes?” Celebrimbor raised one eyebrow. “And I didn’t see that being a problem up until now. Why does it have to be one now?”
“My point being,” Annatar said, now sounding a lot more annoyed than concerned, “is that the thing that we have – whatever it is – hardly deserves the term relationship in a …” He paused, seemed to struggle against something, then forced out, “ – in a romantic sense.”
“So we have something unusual.” Celebrimbor shrugged. “Again, where is the problem?”
Annatar stopped, turning to look at Celebrimbor. “The problem, if you want to call it that, is that you are the one being I feel the closest relation to in this world, my own kin included, and yet there seems to be this vital, this gigantic part of mortal relationships that we haven’t even touched with a ten-foot-pole. You are one of the Eldar, Tyelperinquar.”
“Yes, and?”
“Are you not missing anything?” Annatar said. “Is there nothing more that you want?”
“…no,” Celebrimbor said slowly.
“Truly?”
“No,” Celebrimbor replied, now getting a bit curt himself in tone. “Also, if you think that we have a lacking relationship, sex is hardly going to solve it. That’s like having a child to save an already failing marriage,” he said flatly. “If you feel like there is something missing – like being open with each other about our pasts – then we should address that, and that only, and not introduce another possible stumbling block into it.”
“I know. I am not an idiot, Tyelperinquar.”
“You seem to have a hard time taking me at my word, though.” Celebrimbor said. “Why are you so obsessed with this, all of a sudden?”
Annatar took a deep breath, looked at some invisible thing in the middle distance to the left, then at his shoes, then, finally back up at Celebrimbor. “Truth be told – I keep forgetting that you are not – that we’re not the same.” He averted his gaze again. “I meant it when I said that I feel a kinship with you that I did not even have with my brothers and sisters in Aman. And this is why I have to remind myself that however much we resonate with each other, we are not the same. We are different creatures with different needs. Our approach to the world, our very place in it, our ties to existence, they are so different that comparisons are hardly possible. You need entirely different things in this world than I do – I begins with air, sustenance, and rest, and it extends to other things too numerous to enlist.
“I know we keep pushing the fact aside, and I enjoy it as much as you do – but there are limits to playing pretend, and robbing you of existential needs is one of them. However much I would like, I cannot take you to the place among the stars from where my kin created this world and show you all those things I so badly want to show you. I cannot bring you somewhere where you cannot breathe and will freeze to death, just as I cannot keep you awake every night however much I would enjoy your company for all hours of the day, because you will be harmed. And that is only the physical side of you. But you have soul, too, and this side of you has needs, as well.”
At last, he looked back at Celebrimbor and directly into his eyes. “I do not want you to miss out on something vital just because you chose me as your partner. And I also do not want you to take some noble high road and forgo things you want and need, just because I cannot give them to you. Or worse – I could give them to you, and you simply never ask. Which you do all the time. Because believe it or not, in a few centuries living by your side, I’ve come to know you and your idiotic self-sacrificial tendencies. Like when you fought a Balrog on a suicide rescue mission and afterwards nearly hollowed your soul out with a Ring of Power. So excuse me for taking your assurances with a grain of salt.” He took one, deep breath. His gaze was like the focused radiance of the sun lancing straight into Celebrimbor’s soul. “I don’t want sacrifice to play any part in what we share.”
Annatar stopped talking. His speech ended like a ribbon that had been snapped.
Celebrimbor stared at him. He felt a pang in his chest that momentarily robbed him of his breath. He also briefly wondered whether he had just suffered minor cardiac arrhythmia, or if his heart had just truly, poetically, and very painfully, broken a bit.
“And yesterday – brought it all to the forefront of your mind, I guess,” Celebrimbor ventured carefully.
Annatar gave a one-shoulder shrug, now staring darkly at the ground ahead of his shoes, as if it had personally offended him.
Celebrimbor gave a deep sigh, then stepped forward and pulled the Maia into an embrace, to which Annatar yielded with the grace and flexibility of a Haradrim obelisk. Celebrimbor remained unfazed. There were moments when he had to let Annatar have his moods, and there were moments when he simply had to out-obstinate him. This was one of the latter occasions.
He tightened his hold on the Maia, waited, and – there, finally – Annatar gave in. The stony tension vanished from his shoulders and at last he leaned into Celebrimbor, albeit a bit grudgingly.
“Believe it or not,” Celebrimbor said quietly, “I thought long and hard about my choices with you. You’re telling me nothing new here. I also know that I need to be more upfront about asking for things and drawing boundaries – for myself and others.” He took Annatar’s shoulders and gently pushed him back so they were an arm’s length apart and he could look the Maia in the eyes. “But you must believe me when I say to you here and now, in full conscience of everything you said, that I want this. With you, as we are, and not in any other way.”
Annatar didn’t reply. One corner of his mouth twitched, almost dismayed. “Very well.”
“Besides,” Celebrimbor added in a lighter tone. “It’s not as if I haven’t tried out a few things before. It’s fine, but nothing to write home about.”
At that, Annatar’s head jerked up and he gave the elf a flabberghasted look. “What?” The utterly betrayed look in his face made Celebrimbor nearly laugh out loud.
Instead, he quirked up one eyebrow and grinned. “Well, excuse me for not living like a monk and waiting until you came running along.”
“But –”
“No ‘but’s.” Celebrimbor began to amble away, his hands in the pockets of his trousers.
Annatar hastily followed after him. “Tyelperinquar –”
Celebrimbor didn’t halt or slow his steps. “What?” he said amusedly.
“You can’t just say something like that and walk away!”
“Why? Did you want details?” Celebrimbor raised his eyebrow up even higher. “Those were private occasions.”
“No, but –” Annatar floundered and broke off, visibly shaken – it was a mix of umbrage, disbelief, and uncertainty that was very nearly endearing, but absolutely very amusing to see on the otherwise so inflappable Maia. “When?”
“Long ago.”
“How long ago?”
“Long.”
“And who was –”
“Again, this is private.”
“Tyelperinquar!”
“Don’t tell me you’re jealous, now,” Celebrimbor said.
Annatar opened his mouth, then closed it again.
Celebrimbor stared at him. For about three seconds, he managed to keep a serious face, then he snickered and pulled the Maia into a sideways hug. “Oh, come here now, you. You know as well as I do that nothing in my past could compare to what we have right here, right now.”
“Well, I don’t know that, do I?” the Maia replied tersely.
“Take it as another lesson in believing me when I say things.”
“But –”
“Shush. Jealously doesn’t suit you.”
“I don’t care.”
Celebrimbor suddenly stopped, turned around and Annatar nearly walked into him. He lifted up the pendant around his neck with two fingers. “I never would have accepted this, or anything like it, from anyone else. I never married. If you don’t believe my words, take a look at my fëa. The breaking of a soul-bond leaves a permanent scar. I don’t have one.” His words were spoken lightly, yet there was a challenge underneath.
Annatar looked, for once, suitably abashed. “I don’t – there’s no need. I believe you.”
“Good. Then why are we having this conversation?”
Annatar’s jaw tensed. “I – do not. Like,” he ground out between clenched teeth.
Celebrimbor waited.
“The thought.”
Waited some more.
“Of you. Being with someone else.”
Celebrimbor smiled wryly. “I happen to have had a life before you arrived here.”
“I know, it’s just –” Annatar broke off, then something in his face that had been open and wild and vulnerable slammed abruptly shut. “This is ridiculous. Forget it.” He crossed his arms and walked away.
Celebrimbor stared after him, and just then it occurred to him that he just had made light of the experience of a creature – who had by all appearances and by his own admission – never formed a close personal bond with anyone before. And of course it was uncomfortable to hear that you might need someone more than they might need you. That you were, safe for one person, utterly alone, and they were not. That you were completely reliant on one connection, while someone else had hundreds. That they were something unique to you, whereas you were just one more person in a line of predecessors – no matter how special this one thing right now might be.
It was in this moment that Celebrimbor realized that he had, absolutely and thoroughly, made an ass of himself.
“Annatar!” He ran after the Maia. “Annatar, wait!”
To his credit, Annatar did turn around and wait, though his expression had gone distinctly sour. He raised one eyebrow in an acrid, silent question: What?
Celebrimbor stepped up close to him. “I was being an idiot. I didn’t mean to make light of your experiences and situation.”
Annatar just looked at him. “I see.”
“If you need to talk about this, we can.”
“I’d rather not.”
“That’s fine.” Celebrimbor stepped a bit closer still, a silent question. Annatar allowed it. Celebrimbor took his arms at the elbows, slid his hands down further, until their fingers were entwined. Still, the Maia did not move. His face was closed off and distant.
“Come,” Celebrimbor said quietly and stepped backwards.
Annatar’s expression didn’t change, but he followed.
Celebrimbor drew them off the paved walkway, along a winding grassy path between bushes and wildflowers, trees and undergrowth, until they came to small clearing, where a gazebo made of white wood was secreted away, wrought in the ornamental, elaborate style of the Galadrim.
Running around the inner circumference of gazebo, there were benches, and it was there that Celebrimbor lead them. It was evenfall and the ambient light had changed to a soft lilac. Crickets were clittering in the grass, which was higher here than on the wide, neatly trimmed meadows out in the open. Fireflies were flitting between the silver-grey trunks of the trees.
“Why are we here?” Annatar asked, sitting down with a skeptical expression.
“Because I want to have a private conversation.” Celebrimbor sat down next to him, not letting go of Annatar’s hands.
The Maia eyed him up and down. “Which would be about…?”
“Us, as it were.”
Annatar very slowly raised one eyebrow. “And what exactly is it that you want to talk about?”
Celebrimbor leaned in, until he could whisper in the Maia’s ear, “Teach me how to say that you’re the only one for me.”
Annatar pulled back a bit, frowning. “What?”
“If a Maia were to commit themself completely to another – how would they say it?” Celebrimbor held his gaze. “Valarin is the language of the things that are. You cannot lie in it. How would you say it, in Valarin?”
Annatar tensed. “You don’t use the language lightly, Tyelperinquar. There is a reason that it is not spoken even by the Valar these days. It shapes reality. It binds the soul. What you speak in it becomes true, whether you intended it or not.”
“I am aware,” Celebrimbor said quietly, running his thumb over Annatar’s fingers. “How would you say it?”
Annatar hesitated. “Tyelperinquar –”
“Tell me.”
Silence. A soft wind rushed in the leaves above them. The sky was turning to dusky colours above them, lilacs, oranges, and golds intermingling as the sun sunk lower and the shadows deepened.
“Êzarai – “you”, second person singular absolute in the nominative,” Annatar said, speaking quietly. His voice sounded slightly hoarse. “The absolute clusivity is necessary here because of what you want to express with the sentence. Aras-amûn – “for me”, first person singular in the donative. It’s a case that does not exist Quenya. A combination of dative and accusative would be the closest you have in your language. Khuzdul has it, incidentally, which is logical, seeing how it is descended from Valarin. Used when indicating that someone is giving something to someone, or something existing for someone’s benefit.”
“Or someone,” Celebrimbor added.
“Or someone,” Annatar agreed. “Then – ônozhar-virai. “The only one”. Its meaning is exclusive already, but you need to add the absolute suffix nonetheless –”
“— because there needs to be clusivity agreement between “you” and “the only one”?” Celebrimbor ventured with a smile.
Annatar’s eyes flitted to him and suddenly – wonder of wonders – a very tentative smile of his own flitted across his lips. “Correct.”
“And the verb?”
“You know that one already.” Annatar said and made small, encouraging gesture. “Go on. Finish it.”
“We’d need … ah, sumurîth, because we need the equative “to be”, not the existential one. Also the state of being refers to an animate being. So – arthissû.”
Annatar nodded.
Celebrimbor quietly went over the sentence and the grammar in his head one more time. “Donative,” he mused. “The Gift-Giving Case.” He looked up at Annatar. “What a fantastic thing to have in a language. I wish Quenya had it.”
“Well, the world was created in Valarin, and Arda was a gift for those who came after us. I should say that it is very much embedded into the core of the language.”
“A language for gifts,” Celebrimbor said quietly. “How fitting.” He raised his eyes to meet Annatar’s, regarding him pensively with his head slightly tilted to one side. “Close your eyes.”
“Why?” Annatar looked at him quizzically.
“Because you gave me a wonderful present last night, and I want to give you a gift of my own in return.”
Annatar still stared at him. “What gift?”
“It’s a surprise. Close your eyes.”
Annatar did so. Celebrimbor leaned in until they were almost nose to nose. He closed the distance. Kissed Annatar’s forehead. Then his nose. Then his lips. Then he leaned forward even further.
And whispered one sentence into the ear of his beloved.
Annatar’s eyes flew open.
Briefly, the evening light turned from soft lilac to the electric silver-blue of lightning. The leaves in the trees rustled, the bushes bent, and the flowers around the clearing bowed outward in a ring, when a shockwave of pure potential was released.
“There,” Celebrimbor said quietly into the few inches of space between their faces. “Truth. Absolute and unalterable.”
Annatar’s eyes were wide, his mouth slightly open. “Are you quite mad, Tyelperinquar?” he asked, his voice thin and breathless.
Celebrimbor smiled. “Oh, Annatar, I just spoke a truth that already existed. It didn’t need Valarin to bind my soul to yours.”
Annatar’s eyes were still on his face, wide with incredulity and shock; all the defences he had woven around himself blown wide open, gone, shattered, lost.
Celebrimbor leaned in again. Hardly any space between their lips remained. “I have been yours for a very long time.”
Annatar’s lips moved, as if he was trying to say something, but no sound came out. Which was just as well, because frankly, they had talked enough.
Celebrimbor closed the distance.
Chapter End Notes
Hmm hmm sexy Valarin yum yum yum.
Also:
What Celebrimbor and Annatar should be doing: talk about their feelings
What they are actually doing: going off on grammar tangents
In the Name of Academic Interest
In which Celebrimbor notably does not commit murder. (Yet.)
Read In the Name of Academic Interest
That should have been the end of it. And would have been, if Daeror would have been able to keep his mouth shut.
As far as Celebrimbor was concerned, if he had ever, only for just one moment in his life, entertained the thought of sending someone backwards through time and into the dungeons of Angband –
Not that he had.
Not really.
He wasn’t a good person, but he wasn’t that bad.
But if it had been the case – in this highly hypothetical scenario – and if Celebrimbor were the type to exact vengeance (which he was not, not every Curufinwë was dragging his personal vendetta around with him like a ball on a chain, thank you very much) – if all of that were true and things being as they were – well.
WELL.
Anyway.
Things were going well. Annatar and Celebrimbor were more or less back to normal. Which meant that they were talking about normal things again, Annatar had rediscovered his disdain for armchair psychology, and every now and then they would even engage in, er, more romantic activities, without the sordid subject of obligatory relationship sex making a reappearance.
Celebrimbor should have known better.
Bad things had a tendency to not stay dead.
Things were going well until they weren’t, which was exactly what happened.
Frankly, everyone involved would have been better off if it were somehow possible to separate Annatar and Daeror like two hostile pre-school children. As it was, that wasn’t an option, because unfortunately Daeror was a grown Noldo who could and would make his own decisions. Annatar, on the other hand, was a lesser god, and could be confined to his rooms about as much as a dragon of Morgoth could have been leashed by hempen rope and wooden stake. (Certainly, it would have made for a funny and entertaining attempt, and the dragon might even let you do it, if only out of curiosity for what in tarnation you were even up to, but eventually it would get bored and annoyed and either take off immediately, or roast you first and abscond afterwards.)
As an added point, in a twisted way that was utterly incomprehensible from an outside perspective, Daeror and Annatar liked each other. Annatar would be caught dead rather than admitting it, but Celebrimbor knew him well enough to a) know what true dislike looked in the Maia and this wasn’t it, and b) correctly identify the constant ribbing and squabbling as a really weird way of friendly socializing.
It probably helped that Daeror was offensively good at everything to do with music, and touted by some as the Second Coming of Maglor. (Which was incorrect, because as far as Celebrimbor knew, there hadn’t even been a First Leaving. Being lost was not the same as being dead.) Annatar, who wasn’t much one for making music himself, was, however, always on board when the task came to testing the limits of possibilities, no matter the branch of expertise. Seeing how in tune (ha-ha-ha) Daeror was with music, Annatar took it upon himself to teach him a bit of the divine approach to it, including reality-distorting effects, which resulted in a sudden and very dramatic increase in quality of Ost-in-Edhil’s symphonic orchestra (and they had been fantastic to begin with), as well as the premiere of an opera that just as surprisingly absolutely fell through with the critics – and no, the fact that visiting maestro was an archenemy of Daeror’s from his time in Valinor had nothing to do with that.
Long story short, there was no way of keeping Daeror and Annatar apart forever.
Which was why it was a matter of time until the peace abruptly ended.
It happened on a day in mid-August, long enough for Celebrimbor to have let his guard down around Daeror once more, which was always and forever a mistake.
“Hello, hello,” the bard said one day, when he was – once again, always, forever – intruding upon the Mírdain in the sunlight-flooded refectory where communal meals of the guildmembers were taken. He sat down next to Sindrian, who threw Celebrimbor an apologetic look, as if asking for forgiveness in advance for everything that was about to happen.
“Don’t you have your own guild?” Annatar asked with a raised eyebrow. “Or were you finally thrown out of your own faculty?”
“Ah no, but it’s always so refreshing to come here. So much quiet studiousness, so many intellectual and brooding minds bent on problem-solving, such an air of welcoming for strangers.” Daeror leaned across the table, stole a piece of whitebread from Annatar’s plate, took a bite and leaned back. “How are things at the Mírdain?”
“Worse, now that you are here,” Annatar said, pulling his plate further away and out of Daeror’s reach.
“I’m glad to hear that.”
“I’m sure you are.”
Daeror’s eyes slid over to Celebrimbor who had been trying – honest to Eru trying – not to get involved in this, then down to his chest.
“Nice necklace,” he commented.
There followed a brief, awkward moment where everyone in their immediate surroundings was staring at the gold-and-silver pendant that had slipped out of his partially unlaced shirt collar (August was merciless in Eregion, and Celebrimbor had committed the grave error of dressing for the weather).
It wasn’t that Celebrimbor had hidden the pendant. However, he also had not called any conscious attention to it, seeing how Annatar had wanted to keep both the gift and its circumstances quiet.
Celebrimbor, who had frozen in the motion of guiding a forkful of grilled mushrooms to his mouth, hesitated briefly, then said, “Thank you.”
“It’s very nice,” Daeror went on, narrowing his eyes. “I would even go so far as to say that it is an example of outstanding craftsmanship.”
Daeror, had, as per Celebrimbor’s suspicions, probably an intelligence quotient that put him somewhere in the 99.9th percentile of Arda’s population. Unfortunately, the bard was also using 99.9 % of this outstanding intellect to snoop out absolutely inappropriate things and draw the worst (i.e. correct) conclusions in any given situation where no conclusions were supposed be drawn.
Celebrimbor could see the gears turning behind the bard’s green eyes with worrying speed, then one eyebrow rose higher, higher, higher, until the second one deigned to join in, and even the corners of his mouth at last joined the ascension effort. Put in normal terms, the bard levelled a surprised look at him, followed by a slow and satisfied grin.
“Ah, I see. So this was the secret present you were given in private after everyone sitting below the salt was gone.” Daeror crossed his arms. “Pretty.”
If you asked Celebrimbor, it should be made illegal to speak so obnoxiously and so very obviously in italics. He didn’t reply, but his expression darkened the slightest bit. “Yes.”
“And only that?”
Celebrimbor let his fork sink. “I should think that such a gift is quite sufficient.”
Daeror raised his hands in defence. “I would never dare imply that it was not. It was just. Well, you know. Does that mean it is official now?”
Out of the corner of his eyes, Celebrimbor could see Annatar freeze. Sindrian’s expression was suddenly more than a shade worried.
“What is official?” Celebrimbor asked and congratulated himself on a very even tone of voice.
“Well! What a question!” Daeror made a wide, sweeping gesture, that encompassed both Annatar and Celebrimbor. “You two have been dancing around the oliphaunt in the room for long enough. I should like to think that you both manned up and – hm, not put a ring on it, surprisingly enough… it is a necklace – but I digress. I am talking about making your union official!”
“Daeror, please,” Sindrian groaned.
“Shush, I want to know this.” Daeror held up a finger.
Celebrimbor gave him a stone-faced look. “We have done and will do nothing of the sort.”
“Why not?”
“Because it is private.”
“But surely it’s not a secret.”
“No. But it is private.”
“So you could say something, but elect not to.”
“Correct.”
“You’re evil, Tyelpo.”
“I’m just not someone who sees the need to turn every private occasion into a performance in a play, unlike some other people I could name,” Celebrimbor responded curtly.
Daeror blinked. “No need to be so snappish. I was just curious. And jesting – if you’re familiar with the concept.”
“Were you?” Celebrimbor inclined his head.
“I don’t truly think you are evil. I might reconsider, though, if you keep looking at me like that.”
Celebrimbor just harrumphed then went back to his food.
“Dear me, don’t give me that side-eye! I wasn’t out to steal anyone’s inheritance, by Nienna’s tears!” Daeror exclaimed. “I merely wanted to give you my best wishes.”
“You have my thanks,” Celebrimbor said flatly.
“And you my heartfelt congratulations. It was about time. Empires have fallen and risen in the time it took you two to get a move on.”
Annatar threw Daeror a narrow-eyed glance. “You make it sound like everyone was just waiting for something to happen.”
“Maybe everyone was.”
“Does that mean we were the gossip-magazine entertainment for the entire Guild?”
“Not only the one guild, believe you me,” Daeror replied off-handedly. “The entire city, more like, with a good bit of Khazad-Dûm and Lórien thrown in, although the latter would never admit it. You should have seen the betting pools! Did you know that there were bets that you were merely having the entire city on and never had any interest on each other? The absolute chaos of it! Will they? Won’t they? Not to mention the more outlandish speculations – that Annatar would now spirit the city away behind a magic girdle like Melian. Oh – or entice Celebrimbor away and seduce him to live in a grove in the woods, though, who would ever choose a wooden hut over this city is beyond me. Well, I guess logic didn’t much factor into it. Projection, on the other hand, did. A lot. Oh, and of course there was the question of succession.”
“What?” Annatar looked up.
“I’ll admit it belongs among the more outlandish guesses,” Daeror said with a shrug and a grin. “There has been a bet whether you, Annatar, would use a bit of, ah, shapeshifting to produce an heir and thus secure the legacy of the line of Finwë.”
Celebrimbor choked on his food. Annatar dropped his fork.
For a few seconds, there was awkward silence at the table, wherein everyone pretended they had not heard what had just been said.
Annatar was the first to gather his bearings and picked up his cutlery again. “Nonsense. Delightful speculations, I’m sure, but ultimately nonsense,” he said dismissively. Celebrimbor very resolutely stared at a groove in the wooden surface of the table.
“Hm yes, that’s what I thought, too,” Daeror said. “Though you must admit, you are a good subject of speculation. We haven’t had an Eldarin-Maia couple since Thingol and Melian, and they weren’t exactly forthcoming about their relationship, either.”
“Maybe,” Celebrimbor ground out, “because these things are private.”
Daeror waved it off. “Yes, yes. But you must understand that this piques the interest of people. It’s new, it’s unusual, it’s exciting. It’s like a fairytale out of the books, to quote our dear Gildiriel. It’s natural that they would take an interest.”
“‘They’ meaning ‘you’, I suppose,” Annatar said flatly.
“Among others, yes. I’m interested. Of course I am. Surely you must know that you are interesting.”
“Oh, Daeror,” Annatar said, assuming the most drawling, bored, pseudo-flirtatious tone must have ever been uttered aloud on this side of the Sundering Seas. “Flattery will get you everywhere.”
“That is very good to know.”
“Are you familiar with irony?” Annatar asked. “I should introduce the two of you sometime, you would get along like a house on fire.”
“I’ve been tangling with her since before even you got acquainted with her, Annatar,” Daeror said with a broad grin. “You learned humour only after arriving here. That being said, I do have a question.”
“Oh no,” Sindrian groaned. “Daeror, just leave it.”
“He just said that flattery will get me everywhere,” Daeror retorted.
“He also said that you should learn to notice irony.”
“Oh, I notice it, alright. I just choose to ignore it if I do not care for it.”
Sindrian buried his face in his hands.
“So,” Daeror said and turned to Annatar. “I must admit I was a bit surprised at the reaction my question on Tyelperinquar’s birthday caused. It led me to believe that some of the assumptions I might heretofore head about the Holy Ones were wrong. I was thus wondering: what is the Ainur’s stance on sexual relations?”
Absolute silence. Celebrimbor did not throw his knife across the table, which he thought to be an admirable display of restraint. Annatar looked like his soul had left his body and left behind an empty husk.
“Do you enjoy it all, or avoid it when you can? Is it somehow seen as debasing yourself by, I don’t know, mingling with lowly Incarnates, or do you find fulfilment in it? I mean, Melian must have at least seen the utilitarian end of things, because she did have a daughter. Though nothing ever says whether she saw the, ah, deed itself as something enjoyable or more like a means to an end. I understand that no one thought to ask her, it’s not a question you usually put to a lady. And while I have all the respect in the world for Lady Melian, no such inhibitions hinder me around you, Annatar, so I was wondering whether you could tell me more about it.” Daeror rested his chin in his hands. “In the name of academic interest and my own terminal curiosity.”
If Celebrimbor agreed with anything that had been said, at all, it was that Daeror’s curiosity was about to become very terminal very quickly indeed.
“Or is it something you would have to force yourself to do – I recall you saying that you did not want to get the Incarnate world smeared onto you at every turn?” the bard continued. “What kind of degree of Incarnation would sex demand of an Ainu, anyway? Would you have to overcome your inhibitions against becoming too much a part of the material world or – ”
That was it. Celebrimbor was going to murder this man.
The Venerable Art of Good Communication
Read The Venerable Art of Good Communication
It was not immediately obvious that something was off in the wake of the catastrophic conversation in the refectory. Annatar and Celebrimbor held their lectures, they worked on their projects, and generally pretended that the Lunch They Were Not Talking About had never happened.
However, the was some kind of metaphorical negative space that they avoided in their time together, some glaring hole that was defined by an absence where there should have been something. Like, for example, the lunchtime conversation. Making fun of Daeror and his ridiculous questions. Or the snickering dismissal of the fact that they had been the gossip of the entire city.
Instead, there was nothing.
There was no mention of the incident on either part, not even to express righteous annoyance.
Annatar was very withdrawn and taciturn. He spoke little and he smiled even less. His brow seemed to be constantly furrowed in a mixture of annoyance, intense focus, and badly hidden tension. He also tended to spend a lot of time alone when he wasn’t otherwise occupied by his teaching duties.
Celebrimbor tried to sit this one out, he really did (mostly because he was in no way, shape, or form, keen on reopening some old can of worms). But when August rolled into September and Annatar was still not back to normal, he realized that sitting this one out would be about as fruitful as trying to wait for a mountain to crumble to dust.
It was, in a way, logical that everything Maiar said or did operated on much, much larger timescales than the affairs of Incarnates. They lived for billions of years after all; holding a grudge or being depressed for a few centuries was for them probably the equivalent of being slightly put out for an afternoon. In the spirit of being inclusive and accepting, Celebrimbor tried to honour foreign traditions and behaviours wherever possible. Unfortunately, though, he was kind of invested in the well-being of his friend, and he was also kind of getting fed up with stumbling from one minor crisis into the next and spending weeks on end hoping that things would get less tense again. Maybe there was some childhood thing hidden there – inability to stomach conflicts, striving to resolve them as quickly as possible, desperate to keep a functional simile of a familial network around oneself –
Oh, who was he kidding? Every last member of the dynasty of Finwë had been sent on their way with a cart-load of pathopsychogical baggage. Celebrimbor wasn’t so delusional as to think that he might be the single one to have been left out.
So, long story short, he was going to need to do something about this. Again. Oh joy.
*
Annatar liked cats. It was one of the few facts about him that were actually known far and wide, and probably the one thing about him that was in any way comparable to Simple Things Incarnates Liked Too.
Cats, as it were, also liked Annatar. They flocked to him in an almost eerie way, and Celebrimbor couldn’t remember a time when the Maia hadn’t owned a cat. Or the other way around, if you subscribed to that particular school of thought.
However, Annatar didn’t have cats as normal people did. Or, the cats didn’t latch onto him like they latched onto other people, i.e. demanding foot, demanding pats on the head, and bringing in the occasional mouse or bird.
Oh, they started out like this, alright. But the longer they were around the Maia, the weirder they became. Celebrimbor didn’t know whether it was a conscious or an unconscious thing happening, whether Annatar was doing it on purpose, or whether he simply radiated something as unchangeably and factually as the sun radiated heat. The thing was, the cats, at some point, became way too smart.
They began to open doors. Not with handles. With keys. They started sitting next to people, and listened in on conversations. One time, Celebrimbor had seen one cat sitting on Annatar’s desk and staring at a pile of exams in higher mathematics that the Maia was currently grading as if it was reading them.
Annatar had been curious about this as well when Celebrimbor pointed out the weird behaviour, as it obviously hadn’t happened before. “Or, at least I hadn’t noticed,” he said, glancing at the cat with interest. “It’s not as if I have been around normal animals for extended periods of time before.”
Celebrimbor didn’t have time to ask what kinds of abnormal animals the Maia had been around in his time. The cat chose this moment to let out what could only be described as a disdainful snort and upended the inkwell right over the abysmal work of the student with a swat of the front paw.
Annatar had raised both eyebrows, making no move to intervene or clean up the spreading mess on his desk. “Interesting,” he had said. “I feel like there’s something to gained from following this further.”
Celerbrimbor didn’t necessarily agree; he didn’t feel the need to instruct cats in the sciences. Getting normal academics to work together already much resembled the proverbial and perpetually doomed attempt at herding cats. Adding the actual little devils to the mix seemed like a step in the wrong direction.
Annatar was of another opinion, clearly, which is why he set out to test how far he could take the uplift attempt of the feline species.
Since a species uplift, however, necessarily depended on being able to communicate, and because cats weren’t known for either their varied vocal abilities (short of howling) or being able to hand-sign (no opposable thumbs), Annatar had had to come up with another method.
He had created cards. Cards, first with images, then with short words the cat could tap with its paw to communicate its ideas. In the beginning, he had used simple, concrete concepts: Cat, human, elf, food, drink, hunt, want, not-want, hungry, tired. From there on, he had progressed to more extensive and increasingly abstract vocabulary: happy, sad, danger, hunt, mouse, dog, friend, enemy, yes, no.
The progress of the cats was baffling; within a lifetime spent alongside Annatar, they progressed quickly through all of those, and ended up with a vocabulary of around one hundred words that they could reliably use.
Two years ago, Annatar had acquired a small black cat that had been born with remarkable intellect for her kind. It took her about half a year to learn to operate doors, faucets, and keys; a year to identify when people were speaking about her and react accordingly (biting, swatting, or purring); and now at two years, Annatar had set his plan in motion of having a proper conversation with her.
Celebrimbor therefore decided to look for Maia and cat in Annatar’s rooms, and to no one’s surprise, found them there, both feline and Ainu engaged in deep thought. Annatar was sitting cross-legged on the floor, a veritable flotilla of cards strewn all about him, whereas the black cat was perched across from him and pointed at a card that said (Celebrimbor did a double-take) projection, then at ability, then wrong.
This meant nothing to Celebrimbor, but apparently it did mean something to Annatar, because the Maia had steepled his hands in front of his mouth and nodded. “Fine.”
Celebrimbor knocked on the door frame. “Am I interrupting?”
Annatar looked up. “No,” he said in the same moment that the black cat tapped the card saying Yes.
Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow.
Annatar threw the cat a side-glance. “We talked about this.” Then to Celebrimbor, “Come in.”
Celebrimbor took a few steps closer, taking in the organized chaos of cards spread about. “Hard at work, I see.”
Annatar nodded. “I’ll have to find a more efficient way to communicate soon. It’s very time-consuming for Wraith to tap out her thoughts, and I am running out of floor space.”
“If only we had a brainwave-to-speech emulator,” Celebrimbor said, ironically.
“I am working on it,” Annatar replied, absolutely unironically.
“Ah,” Celebrimbor said, to whom this was news. “Let me know how that one goes. We might be able to help the mute Angband survivors if you succeed. It would be a great translator, as well.”
“Hmh.” Annatar nodded, not looking at Celebrimbor, but at the cards.
Celebrimbor waited for a few moments. Annatar made no move to get up and greet him properly. He sighed. “Can I sit down?”
“Yes, yes. Take a seat.” The Maia still wasn’t looking at him.
Celebrimbor sat down, looping his arms around his legs, which he loosely crossed at the ankles. “I haven’t seen you around a lot lately.”
“I’ve been busy.”
“Talking to a cat?”
“Among other things.”
“Care to elaborate?”
A pause. “No.”
Celebrimbor shuffled a bit closer and leaned forward, looking at Annatar’s face in profile until the Maia at last deigned to turn his head and look directly at him.
“What,” he asked flatly. Not angry, not even miffed. Just – flat. Toneless.
“I worry about you,” Celebrimbor said, who was done walking on eggshells and dancing around the oliphaunt in the room. “Something is off, but I cannot tell what or why or how to make it better.”
“Not everything is upon you to make better,” Annatar replied, still in that flat tone.
“Yes, but this one thing is, isn’t it?”
Annatar didn’t respond.
“Annatar, are you alright?”
“Yes,” he said. In the same moment that the little black cat reached out and one paw landed firmly on the card No.
Celebrimbor raised both eyebrows this time. “Your cat seems to be of a different opinion.”
“Wraith is way too opinionated.”
Said Wraith narrowed her yellow-green lamp-like eyes, then stood up and resolutely swatted a bunch of cards in quick succession. Tell-friend-if-not-you-then-I-do.
In the few moments it took Celebrimbor to process that the cat had managed to get if-operators down pat, Annatar replied cooly, “I could take away the cards. Let’s see how well you do with sign language then.”
Wraith shot the Maia a glare and marched over to a row of individual letters that had been laid to spell out words that weren’t contained among the cards. G-O-F-U-C-
Celebrimbor coughed into his fist. “You taught her to swear?”
“Not me,” Annatar said. “She got that from the books.”
Ah. So the cat was reading books. Celebrimbor filed the information away for a later time. He turned to the cat. “What’s wrong with him?”
“Tyelperinquar –” Annatar began, but Wraith had already begun drumming out her answer. Twolegs-brood-day-weeks-months-duration-cat-know-not-reason-but-posture-sad-smell-wrong-alone-no-mates-no-happy-cat-worry-ask-no-answer-no-help-very-S-T-U-P-I-D.
“Ah, so we’re in much the same position,” Celebrimbor said. He turned to Annatar, “Care to enlighten me?” he asked.
Annatar closed his eyes as if he was summoning every last bit of patience that remained to him.
“It’s nothing,” he said in the same moment Wraith slammed her paw down on the card lie. Then again, for emphasis. Lie-lie-lie-lie then, stop.
“Traitor,” Annatar said.
L-I-A-R, Wraith spelled out.
“You’re a matched set,” Celebrimbor commented drily. “Congratulations.”
Annatar stared at the cat. The cat stared back. Neither one blinked.
Celebrimbor sighed. “This isn’t about you still worrying about withholding something from our relationship that I might need or want, I hope?”
“No.”
Celebrimbor looked at the cat, who stared at Annatar intensely for a few seconds, then slowly, suspiciously patted truth.
“I also hope it isn’t about plotting Daeror’s murder.”
“No.”
Wraith patted doubt. Annatar shot her a dark glare.
Celebrimbor sighed. “Alright – I mean, it’s not alright. Don’t murder him.”
“I won’t.”
Half-truth, Wraith commented.
Celebrimbor threw the Maia very, very serious look, who threw up his hands in exasperation.
“I won’t harm him, alright?”
A few seconds passed in silence.
“But it’s still about the sex issue?” Celebrimbor ventured without much hope for negation.
Annatar opened his mouth, then abruptly closed it again and got to his feet. “Let’s take this somewhere else,” he said curtly. “I am not going to this in front of a furry lie detector with delusions of grandeur.”
Wraith narrowed her eyes. Better than-no-fur-being-with-H-A-N-G-U-P-S-A-B-O-U-T-mating.
“Yes, you too,” Annatar growled and marched over to the door.
Celebrimbor followed. Before he went outside, he turned around and threw a quick “thank you” back over his shoulder at the unexpectedly helpful cat.
Wraith, however, being a cat and all, had obviously used up her daily amount of friendliness. G-E-T-L-O-S-T.
Oh well.
They left.
*
“So,” Celebrimbor said, leaning back in his chair. They were back in his rooms, where they could hopefully talk in peace. “What’s the problem?”
Annatar was sitting across from him, leaning sideways, one arm propped up on the armrest, his splayed fingers resting against his temple and supporting his head, while conveniently hiding half of his face from view. “There is no problem per se.”
“But?”
“It doesn’t concern you,” Annatar said.
Celebrimbor felt his patience fraying at all this avoiding and stalling going on. “Since this particular problem causes you to hole up in your rooms and cut nearly all contacts, and I happen to care about you and also happen to want to have you around, I’d say it very much does concern me,” he said tersely. He waited a few more seconds, which was all that his overstrained Fëanorian patience would grant him. “Out with it,” he added, sounding rather more snappish than he was usually wont to.
It took another few nerve-fraying moments for Annatar to finally get over himself and reply. “I’ve been thinking about what Daeror said.”
Here we go. Valar have mercy.
Celebrimbor raised an expectant eyebrow. “Yes, and?”
“I – have been thinking.” Annatar said haltingly. “About my own reactions to these questions and implications.”
Celebrimbor was silent. This was new. He waited for the Maia to continue, and after some moments, he did.
“There is an instinctual revulsion that I do not understand. It is baseless, because revulsion or fear are either learned through experience – think a child touching a hot stove – or the result of genetical programming taking place over thousands of generations – like fear of dangerous animals like snakes or spiders,” Annatar went on, speaking more fluently now that he was able to depart from the personal aspect and dive into the abstract analysis part of the issue. “I do not have any such genetic pre-programming. I also have no previous experience that would warrant my aversion to the thought of sexual intercourse. Which is why I don’t understand it.”
Silence.
Celebrimbor waited a few more seconds to give him a change to continue, but when Annatar said nothing, he sat up a bit straighter. “That’s it? You don’t understand it?”
Annatar glowered at him. “I am not a creature of instinct, Tyelperinquar. I have no traits or reactions that aren’t intentional or premediated. I should not have. But I do, and I don’t understand why and I do not like it.”
Celebrimbor frowned. “You probably also do not know why you like cats and don’t like dogs, and I doubt it was a conscious decision on your part. Or the fact that you avoid eating meat for no other reason than preference. You don’t take issue with those things, do you?”
“No.”
“Could it be that over the years you might have simply shaped a personality – like every other living being does?” Celebrimbor asked. “Surely not everything you say or do is premediated. That would also mean that you came here with the intent of seducing me instead of spontaneously falling in love with me, which I find insulting on a personal level.”
Annatar had the morose expression of someone watching an axiom which they had been basing their doctoral thesis on being poked full of holes. To his credit, he managed the mental turnabout. “I guess you are correct,” he said sullenly. “Perhaps some of it isn’t strictly logical or premediated. Though that still doesn’t explain why that idea evokes such a ridiculously strong reaction.”
“You are allowed not to like things.”
“I know, but the intensity of the dislike –” Annatar broke off.
“—hits too close to a phobia for your liking, and you cannot stand the thought of being afraid of something,” Celebrimbor finished. “Am I right?”
The glower on Annatar’s face said it all.
Celebrimbor sighed and massaged his temples. “You know that this is not a weakness or something similarly ridiculous? People have preferences. People avoid unpleasant things all the time. Often enough, avoiding these things does not even influence your life otherwise.”
“I know. And I do not care. I am not an Incarnate who has their life decisions decided by instinct or lust or fear or some other ridiculous befogged notion.” Annatar ground his teeth. “I do things because I want to do them or because I have to, but I do not avoid things because I am afraid of them.”
“Maybe fear doesn’t factor into it, have you considered that? Maybe Daeror had the right idea and Ainur are simply not cut out for sex.” Celebrimbor shrugged. “Why would you? You don’t need to reproduce, you are spiritual beings first and foremost. It seems only logical to me that you wouldn’t find sex appealing, perhaps even running contrary to your nature. You also don’t throw a fish into the middle of the desert and tell it to have a good time.”
“Then why am I not indifferent about it?” Annatar said, slamming one hand down on his armrest. “It makes no sense! Besides, Melian was able to have a daughter, so it must be endurable.”
“The fact that you use the term ‘endurable’ says a lot more about the depth of the issue than you are letting on.” Celebrimbor blinked. “Also – Bauglir’s hammer – please don’t tell me that this is an issue of not wanting to be outdone by distant relation of yours.”
Gloomy silence.
Celebrimbor ran his hands down his face. “Valar have mercy.” How is this my life right now?
He’d had his own fair share of childish challenges back in his youth, and more than once fallen flat on the nose for it. The issue reminded him of nothing so much as being goaded by older youths into jumping from a fifty-foot-high cliff, not actually wanting to do it – in fact, being desperately terrified by the mere idea – but then pride and stubbornness and the need to prove yourself came together in a stupendously idiotic amalgamation and you jumped anyway. (Subsequently fluffing the jump and nearly breaking all your bones, of course.) But that had been ages of the world ago, and neither of them was young by any measurement of time, and yet they were still having this conversation.
“This isn’t funny,” Annatar said tetchily.
“Do you hear me laugh?” Celebrimbor threw him a glare over his fingers, then let his hands sink.
“You’re not taking this seriously.”
“Oh, I am. But you are taking this way too seriously. You do not like to have sex. So what? Move on, do something else.”
“There is nothing banal about this. If it can be done by one Ainu, it can be done by every Ainu, and I should be able to do it as well,” Annatar ground out from between clenched teeth. “The fact that not reason or better knowledge should make me avoid something, but something like – like instinct or discomfort is not acceptable.”
Celebrimbor let his head fall back against the headrest of his armchair, staring at the ceiling. He was, well and truly, at a loss for words. “I don’t know what to tell you,” he said, still speaking to the ceiling. “I honestly do not know how to help you with this. It’s evident that this is a problem for you. I don’t want to make light of it. But even understanding your issue requires a mental approach that I cannot emulate, not being an Ainu myself. I simply cannot tell you how to solve this.” Celebrimbor righted himself again, looking at the Maia.
“I wasn’t expecting you to,” Annatar replied evenly. “Which is why I kept the problem to myself.”
“Which doesn’t bring us even one step further.”
A shrug. “I have been researching possible solutions. There might be one.”
“Which would be?”
“I’ve been to the Psychology library,” Annatar began.
“Again?!”
“So what? Even Psychology has its merits,” the Maia grumbled. “Few and far between though they might be.”
“I’m beginning to think we might have more need of Psychology than even I ever thought.”
Annatar ignored it. “There is a thing called Exposure Therapy –”
“What.”
“—leaving aside the implications of pathopsychological issues, because that is simply ridiculous, the methodology of confronting a source of discomfort seems sound, even in non-pathological circumstances.”
“You are joking, right?” Celebrimbor stared at Annatar. A pause. “Please tell me you are joking.”
He wasn’t.
Chapter End Notes
They're simply the worst.
Not Wraith, though. Wraith is bloody damn great.
A Logical Approach To Seduction
Read A Logical Approach To Seduction
“This is a terrible idea,” Celebrimbor said.
“It is a systematic, logical approach to a known problem,” Annatar said, twirling the pen in his fingers. “It is therefore an excellent idea.”
Celebrimbor lifted his head from where he was despondently sprawled on his back across his bed. “Tell me that you’re not making a schedule for this right now.”
Again, Annatar did in no way oblige the plea and assent; rather he nodded, then wrote down something in the notebook on the little side table where he was sitting in his chair near Celebrimbor’s dark fireplace.
“You know,” Celebrimbor said, letting his head fall back down. “I for my part am already not getting much out of sex as it is, but what you are doing now would kill eroticism even for nymphomaniacs.”
The Maia gave no indication whatsoever that he had heard. Or cared.
“What do you propose would be a reasonable start to expose myself—?” Annatar asked.
Celebrimbor nearly choked where he was lying on the bed.
“… to the issue at hand,” Annatar finished, flatly.
It took Celebrimbor a few seconds to get the goings-on in his trachea sorted out again. He had to change position; it wouldn’t do to suffocate. He rolled onto his stomach. “Is that a serious question?”, he asked weakly.
Annatar looked at him. “Yes.”
Celebrimbor sighed, then raked a hand through his hair. “How about you just – ah, try it and see how far you get?”
Annatar thought about this, frowned, then nodded. “Must needs, I guess. When do you have time?”
Celebrimbor, having already been balanced precariously close to the edge of the mattress, fell out of the bed. He spent three undignified seconds staring at the ceiling, then he sat up and crawled his upper body back onto the bed. “I beg your pardon?” he said weakly.
Annatar was still staring at him, clearly wondering where the Noldoʼs sanity had gone off to in order to spend the afternoon. Which was just as well, because Celebrimbor was wondering the very same about the Maia. Always nice if you were on the same page with your friends and loved ones.
“Excuse me,” Annatar said, “were you under the impression that I was going to ask someone else?”
Celebrimbor was silent for a few seconds. “No,” he said at last. “It’s just that I wasn’t thinking you were going to ask at all.”
“Well, I need to be getting somewhere with this, and seeing how you’re my partner you are the obvious choice. I’m sure we can fit it in somewhere. This won’t take too much time, will it?” Annatar stared at the pile of papers in his lap. “Do you think we could fit it in between the evening lecture on organic chemistry and midnight when we need to go to the workshops to get the light-stones out of their saturation solution?” He glanced up at the elf.
Celebrimbor let down a disbelieving wheeze, then dropped face into his hands. “I – Annatar. I don’t know how to put this. You – oh Stars. You don’t do it like this. You know, you usually wait until the time is right, the atmosphere is good, the mood is there … this isn’t something you squeeze in between two meetings and a coffee break.”
Annatar looked disgruntled. “Why not? I also don’t wait until the mood is right before doing the final exams of a class. It needs to be done; thus it gets scheduled and it gets done. We’re not doing this for the fun of it, after all,” he added with a sinister glare at his notes.
Celebrimbor slumped into himself, humourless, helpless laughter wringing itself from his throat like water from a towel twisted to the point of torture. “We’re not doing this for the fu—okay, okay. I understand. I’m sorry. I understand. This is no laughing matter, clearly.”
“It is not. Which is why I am surprised that you are laughing.”
“I am not. Not really.” Celebrimbor climbed to his feet. “I am merely running out of emotions that befit the occasion.”
Annatar arched one eyebrow. “I see,” he said in a tone that made it very clear that he didn’t see at all.
A brief silence.
“So,” the Maia asked again. “Do you have time?”
Celebrimbor stared straight ahead at a point in the wall where he had put a groove into the plaster when he and three friends had hauled his wardrobe in here, many centuries ago, when he had moved into these rooms. It was a great groove. Very stylish, very captivating.
How is this my life right now, a voice said inside his head.
The groove didn’t react to his staring, as inanimate dented plaster was wont to do. Which meant that after a minute or so, Celebrimbor was running out of excuses to keep staring at a blank wall.
“Aren’t you going to ask me whether I want to do this?” he said weakly.
Annatar froze. “I—” And fell silent. “You don’t?” he asked.
“Not like this, no.” Celebrimbor walked over to the Maia and threw himself into the second armchair.
“Why?”
“Because there is such a thing as emotional investment into a thing, and for some people this investment is a prerequisite to sexual intercourse, lest it be very, very uncomfortable.”
Annatar was silent. The gears in his head were turning. Celebrimbor almost thought he could hear them whirring at a high, rapid pace. “I see,” he said at last, pondering. “Hm. That is.” More pondering. “Unfortunate.”
A bellow that might have been a laugh or might have been a sob or might have been a cry for help escaped Celebrimbor’s mouth. He chortled into his hand. Ah, a laugh, then. “Yes,” he said. “Very unfortunate, I know. We Incarnates never fail to disappoint.”
“That is not what I meant,” Annatar said. “I just thought – I just thought you didn’t care about it.”
“Yes. Meaning the act itself in isolation,” Celebrimbor said. “But much like the right pinch of salt makes an otherwise bland dish nice, I do like a bit of emotionality on the side if I am going to tangle in the sheets with someone. Actually, emotional attachment is the sole reason to do it – for me, at least.”
“Aha.”
“Just so.”
“I see.”
“I’m glad you do.”
Silence. Annatar was sitting hunched forward, his chin resting on his fist, which was a pose that reminded Celebrimbor very much of the Noldo in Rumination that his grandmother had created out of dark marble, two ages of the world ago, on the other side of the Sundering Seas.
“And what now?” the Maia asked, at last.
Celebrimbor shrugged. “What do I know? I’m not going to twist myself into knots over a point of pride for you. Especially if you are going to go about it like this.” He grimaced. “Create a good moment and we might get somewhere.”
“Create a good – wait, are you telling me to seduce you?” Annatar blinked.
“Call it what you will, but you’re not getting me into bed with a project proposal.”
“Why not? I thought you liked experiments.” The Maia sounded almost petulant.
“Yes, in the workspace, not on the mattress.”
“I fail to see a meaningful difference.” Annatar frowned. “But fine. Fine. So. You want to be … seduced.”
“Wrong. I want to want to do this, if we’re going to do it at all. How you go about this is completely up to you.”
“And how on Arda would I make you want to do anything?” Annatar asked, his tone half-aggravated.
Celebrimbor inclined his head slightly to one side. “I don’t know, Lord Charisma-is-my-middle-name, how do you want to make people spend time with you?”
Annatar glowered. “This is completely different from building relationships with no strings attached.”
“But it isn’t. It always comes back to the same few things. Make people comfortable, make them feel liked and wanted, and show them that they’re going to have a good time with you. Show me why I should sleep with you. Bring your arguments, but not with bullet points and milestone planning.” Celebrimbor halted, then threw the Maia a warning look. “And I swear to Eru, if you run over to Economy and come back to me with a sales pitch, I’m never speaking to you again.”
Annatar frowned. “I wouldn’t do that.” Pause. “How else am I supposed to do it?”
Celebrimbor raised both eyebrows. “Why are you asking me this? You are the hyperintelligent Maia who wants to sleep with me. I’m sure you’ll to think of something.”
“I am trying – which is why I wanted to make a plan that you agreed with.” Annatar chucked his pile of papers onto the table.
Celebrimbor inclined his head to one side. “Annatar, I know you love the rational approach to things. I know you like planning things out. But have you ever tried – what is it the young folk say nowadays? Ah – have you, you know, ever tried winging it?”
“No, because I’m not Eönwë,” Annatar said flatly.
Celebrimbor tried very hard to keep straight face. He fought against himself, his facial muscles, and lost. He wanted to remain serious, but frankly it was a brilliant joke, and the deadpan delivery was the cherry on top. He hid an aborted guffaw behind his fists, trying and failing badly to disguise it as a ponderous cough. “Fowl play,” he replied.
“Then stop egging me on.”
“Annatar!”
The Maia threw him a blank look, but then the corners of his mouth twitched.
“You are terrible,” Celebrimbor said, no longer bothering to hide his own grin.
Annatar shrugged. “And yet here we are.”
“Yes, discussing my own seduction. I feel like the writer of a comedic play and the fool in the main role at the same time.”
“So, the author of your own disaster?”
“Quite.” Celebrimbor passed a hand over his eyes. “In any case, I think it would do you – and me, by the by – a lot of good to approach this less like a maths problem that needs to be solved, and more spontaneously and adhering to your gut feeling.”
Annatar gave him the dubious look of someone whose one possession in life was a hammer, and who was thus determined to make every problem look like a nail. (Or a maths problem.)
“At least try it,” Celebrimbor said. “It’s hardly going to be worse than scheduling sex between chemistry and a laboratory appointment.”
One day he was going to learn not to tempt fate by saying things like these.
One day.
Argh.
Two weeks later
“Let me reiterate,” Celebrimbor said. “You do not need to create some kind of performance. You do not need to tick some boxes that sound like you raided a romance novel for inspiration.”
“A paltry novel? I raided an entire bookstore will almost nothing to show for it. You Incarnates, I swear –”
“We happen to be individuals! I don’t even like flowers, they make me sneeze! And poetry I don’t get, though I can appreciate the effort that went into it. Still – I’m not Maglor. Or Falda. Or Narvi. I can tell if something rhymes, but that’s about it. The candlelight dinner was nice – well, until Wraith knocked over the candles and set the table on fire.”
“Well, I’m hardly to blame for that.”
“I – ” Celebrimbor broke off and turned away, making a few desperate steps into the middle of his room.
Annatar didn’t move. He was resting his chin in one hand, the fingers of his other hand were drumming impatiently on Celebrimbor’s desk.
Celebrimbor turned on his heel and spread his arms in the universal gesture of defeat. “You know what, forget it. Forget everything I told you. I take everything back. This was a terrible idea. We created this awful situation where there is this horrible backdrop of expectations and tension and hackneyed gestures that go nowhere and have nothing to do with who we are or why we even like each other. This is – this is like a bad theatre play.”
“I noticed,” Annatar said drily.
“Did you now? The way you were acting made me wonder whether you were even still yourself.”
“You told me to be spontaneous and go with my gut feeling.”
“Yes, under the mistaken assumption you have the ability to do so.”
“I can be very spontaneous.”
“Yes, if I give you two hours to plan out your spontaneity beforehand,” Celebrimbor said.
Annatar gave him an offended look.
Celebrimbor returned the glare.
“This is ridiculous,” Annatar said at last.
“I’m glad we finally agree on something.”
“Good.”
“Good.”
Pause.
“So now what?”
Celebrimbor looked at the Maia. “There is no chance that you are just going to let this go, isn’t there?”
There was a brief moment in which Annatar’s mind visibly consulted with his stubbornness, his pride, and his inability to lose or give up in any way, shape, or form – and, as a belated invitee to the discussion, his better judgement. Predictably, there was a vote, and predictably, Better Judgement was outvoted three to one.
Annatar steepled his fingers in front of his mouth.
“Consider,” he said, giving Celebrimbor a boring look over his fingertips. “What if you viewed it as helping me out?”
“Wait, are you trying to appeal to my better nature in order to get me to sleep with you?” Celebrimbor said disbelievingly.
“Well, see it that way – maybe I do have a problem, however inexplicable its origins might be.”
“Stop. You are not traumatized. You said so yourself.”
“I was in Angband in the First Age. Also, and much more pertinently, I am a teacher at a school for what is allegedly higher education. I spend my days around students. I am traumatized by default.”
“You are not,” Celebrimbor countered. “Especially not if it’s only in moments when it is convenient for you.”
“Don’t you always speak of fixing things?” Annatar asked, his head cocked to the side in what the Maia supposedly thought was a coquettish and endearing expression. “You could fix me, how about that? Very much in tune with your plans. Also, very desperate and very romantic.”
“Annatar, you need to stop reading these weird romance novels. They are doing things to your mind. It’s disconcerting.” Celebrimbor paused, studied the Maia’s expression with sudden suspicion. “You’re not being serious, are you?”
Annatar slumped back in his seat. “No, I’m not. But you should have seen your face.” He grinned.
Celebrimbor hid his face in his hands. “Please, for the love of Varda, stop doing this. I’m utterly off-kilter as it is, you do really not need to add in trash novel tropes.”
“Well, let us just say,” Annatar said airily, taking his notes and beginning to scribble something else down into that blasted schedule of his, “that I like you keep you on your toes.”
Celebrimbor threw Annatar a look. “And here I was, thinking you’d prefer to get me on my back.”
It was, admittedly, a low blow. However, the look on the Maia’s face, his splutter, and the fact that Annatar drew a jerky, stark black line of ink over the entirety of his meticulous notes, effectively ruining them, made it absolutely worth it.
Sweet, sweet revenge.
Maybe he was his father’s son, after all.
Scars and Living Things
Read Scars and Living Things
Well. So maybe he really was his father’s son.
The thing was –
The thing was.
The thing, that he should have seen coming and yet, for some reason didn’t, was as follows:
Everything had been going swimmingly.
Summer rolled into autumn. The seasons turned, and with it, the leaves of the trees from green to red and golden and brown. Things had, as far as weird relationship discussions were concerned, calmed down. Annatar had stopped springing romance tropes upon Celebrimbor, and they had reverted to a thankfully normal rapport. Gone were the times of walking around each other on eggshells, of stilted conversations, and even more stilted discussions. Annatar was back to being, well, Annatar: sharp humour and even sharper intellect, biting commentary and all, and Celebrimbor was very, very glad for it.
Then his aunt got wind of the entire sex thing.
He should have known. What with Daeror had said about bets going on, and the relentless rumour mill that seemed to feed from the same sources in the entirety of Eregion – also, she was the daughter of someone whose epessë was literally the Far-Seeing. She had a scyring mirror, for Varda’s sake.
So. His aunt knew. About the rumours. About the thing. Which would have been bad enough on its own.
But.
His aunt, as it happened, also hated Annatar with a conviction and deep-seated loathing that was usually reserved for the meeting of step-children and step-parents between Noldorin families and those of the Moriquendi.
So it shouldn’t have been surprising that upon one of Celebrimbor’s duty visits to Lórien Galadriel pulled him aside and asked, “Is it true?”
“Is what true?” he had retorted with the famed eloquence and audacious pretence of ignorance exclusively reserved for Fëanor’s kith and kin.
Galadriel’s eyes had narrowed. “You know what I mean. This Maia of yours. I counselled you to keep your distance. You didn’t heed it.”
“Yes, because I’m an adult and I make my own decisions.”
“Don’t talk back to me like that. I’m still your elder. Besides, I worry for you. I worried for you as soon as that Maia first stepped into your city and beguiled the guilds down to the last apprentice. And now I must hear that you seek an even deeper union with him.”
Celebrimbor died a bit inside at this choice of words. He tried not to show it. “Aunt,” he said. “Those are rumours.” And then, because he was his grandfather’s grandson and he was his father’s son, he added, “And even if it weren’t so, what I do or don’t do with him remains for me to decide.” And gave her that look. That one. The one that had made sure that his enemies would have come after Fëanor right to the ends of the universe to rip off his limbs one by one.
Galadriel had responded with a fixed stare. “Telperinquar. I do not care how old you are. I am not watching you gleefully running to your own ruin. I invoke the authority of the elder of our shared lines. I forbid it.”
There. There it was.
His aunt should have known better than to say that, knowing Celebrimbor’s lineage.
His grandfather had created the Silmarils after he had been told that “one doesn’t simply capture the light of the Two Trees”. When his uncle Maedhros had been told that one couldn’t parley with Morgoth, he’d gone anyway and spent the next decade alternating between Angband’s torture chambers and hanging from cliff faces. When his father and his other uncle Celegorm had been told to leave Doriath and Dior alone, they – well.
Long story short, the line of Fëanor had a long and loving history with reverse psychology.
Which his aunt, being all-seeing and old and wise, should have known. Did know.
So in all honesty, for everything else that was to follow, she only had herself to blame.
*
“Are you telling me that you suddenly want to sleep with me because your aunt told you ‘no’?”
“That is exactly what I’m telling you,” Celebrimbor said, dragging Annatar along by his sleeve. “And before you say anything: I will not argue about this with someone who basically tried to guilt-trip me into sex. You have no moral high ground to make any arguments from.”
“I’m not objecting,” Annatar said, trying to keep pace with Celebrimbor’s incensed speed. “I’m just surprised, because earlier you said that you needed an emotional motivator to initiate sexual relations.”
“I find spite to be an excellent emotional motivator,” Celebrimbor said.
Annatar thought about this for a few seconds. “Yes. I can respect that,” he allowed.
However, when they had reached Celebrimbor’s bedchamber and were standing across from each other, two paces apart, the bed a looming presence in the background, the Maia was suddenly oddly diffident. He kept throwing the bed sides glance as if it might suddenly rear up and trample him under its wooden legs like an enraged cow.
“So,” he said slowly. “You want to do this now?”
“Sure, no time like the present,” Celebrimbor said, throwing off his shoes, then freezing and squinting at Annatar. “Wait, are you having second thoughts?”
Annatar made an undefined gesture, the meaning of which could not be guessed at. “I mean,” he said, trying to sound nonchalant and succeeding in coming across as stiff as a plank, “I did not have a lot of time to prepare.”
“Prepare?“ Celebrimbor blinked. “Excuse me, did you want to bring notes and flip charts? This isn’t some mountaineering excursion. You don’t need rope and ice cleats. I mean, a case could be made for rope, but –”
“What?”
“ – I don’t think either of us is into that, and anyway, it would be good to start with the basics.”
“Basics? There’s an advanced level to all of this?”
Celebrimbor, realizing that Annatar’s pathological ambition was about to suplex them through the coffee table once again – if not now, then later – hurriedly said, “No! I mean – there are variants. Variants that are equally viable and practicable according to personal tastes, but are not comprising an itemized list that has to be ticked off in order to be able to say that you had sex,” he finished without taking a breath.
Annatar looked torn. “I see.” He looked at the bed again. “So. Now?”
“Yes, now. If you want to, that is.” Celebrimbor gave him a sceptical look. “If you don’t want to, say it, because in this case we’re stopping this immediately.”
Annatar dithered. “I – no. That’s not it. It’s just – is this the right moment you were speaking of so grandly? It doesn’t feel like it.”
“I have graciously decided to forgo the necessity for emotional investment in the interest of getting back at a meddling relative.”
“That seems rather petty. And immature.”
“I can’t always be the better man in any relationship. I have enough work to do with you on that account as it is.”
Annatar glared.
Celebrimbor wiggled his eyebrows. “You know it’s true.”
Annatar knew it was true, and thus didn’t respond, but glared harder.
“So then,” Celebrimbor said, clapping his hands in the enterprising manner of a Dwarf about to try his final throw in the Tree-Trunk Chucking Competition (held annually at Erebor, growing in popularity, and always a hoot for the spectators). “Let’s get to it. And you out of these robes.”
Annatar looked down at himself, taken aback. “Out of my robes? Why?”
“Yes. You don’t usually have sex clothed. It tends to get in the way, especially if you’re as buttoned up as you are.”
“I do not see the necessity for it.”
“You will. A surprising amount of good sex is good logistics – starting with getting as many things that could hamper you out of the way as is possible.”
Annatar was silent. He didn’t look convinced.
Celebrimbor grinned at him. “Just let me do the work. You’ll see.” He leaned in and kissed the Maia on the nose, then took the hem of Annatar’s uppermost robes (white, long-sleeved, trailing the ground on the back, open to the front) and pushed them off. Annatar dubiously pulled his arms out of his sleeves, letting the garment pool on the floor.
Celebrimbor leaned in. “Come now, what’s that face? One would thing I’m leading you to the gallows.” He raised an eyebrow. “Want me to stop?”
Annatar pondered this, then shook his head. “No. Go ahead.”
“Well, I’m not doing this alone. You’re going to do some work as well.” Celebrimbor put his index finger against Annatar’s clavicle and slowly pushed him backwards until they were at the bed and the Maia bumped against the mattress, sitting down rather harder and less gracefully than he was wont to do. “You can undress me, while we’re at it. There’s no reason not to make this enjoyable.”
Annatar looked up at him. “Al…right?”
“Yes.” Celebrimbor glanced down at himself, down to loose undershirt and trousers as he was. “Since I do have a bit of a head start, though, I think it’s only fair to catch you up first.” And with that he pushed Annatar back and followed him down.
They had done this before, to some extent, but never with the conscience of a roadmap in mind – of things they wanted to do, of boundaries they wanted to cross for the first time. In a way, it was new and exciting and –
Celebrimbor unbuttoned Annatar’s brocaded vest, pulled them both upright until he was sitting in the Maia’s lap and was able to shuck it off. Then, to make use of their position, he grabbed the hem of Annatar’s tunic right under it, and with a flourish, pulled it over the Maia’s head.
And apparently that wasn’t the end of it, because Annatar had yet another shirt under that. Well, it wouldn’t stay there long. Celebrimbor bit the inside of his cheek with a grin, pulled it up, off, and –
“What the fuck?” it escaped him. He reared back.
Annatar looked up at him, blinking slowly.
Celebrimbor stared down at the Maia.
“Annatar,” Celebrimbor said slowly, steepling his fingers in front of his face in an effort to suppress his rising disbelief and irritation, “are you creating new layers of clothing as we go?”
The Maia had the grace to look guilty.
*
Celebrimbor whirled around, throwing out his arm. “Do you have any idea how off-putting this is? If you hadn’t wanted, you should just have told me!” He didn’t yell, but it was a close thing.
Annatar, never one to remain in abashed silence for long, countered with equal irritation: “It was not about not wanting! I’ve told you three times now!”
“Then why did you keep summoning clothes? By Varda, I am feeling like a sexual abuser here!”
“It’s not about you!” Annatar, always great at reaching new frontiers, was the first to actually begin shouting. “I have no idea why I was doing it!”
“What, you’re telling me it wasn’t premediated like all the rest of the things you do –”
“Stop being such a vindictive idiot!”
“Then stop being dishonest with me!”
“I wasn’t being dishonest with you!”
“Then WHY were you doing it!”
“I have no idea! Maybe it is because of the scars or because I am not used to settling into a body and not being able to get out, and being seen –”
“Wait.” Celebrimbor cut him off, deadly calm all of a sudden. “What scars?”
*
“Oh, stars.”
“What.”
“We need to stop this.”
“We do not. I am trying to do something completely unnatural for my race, which you were kind enough to point out. It stands to figure that there would be slight – ah – complications.”
“If that is what slight complications look like for you, I do wonder about your definition of full-blown trauma.”
“Can you stop talking like that.”
“I am only being honest.” Celebrimor gently put down Annatar’s bare arm, who drew back into the cradle of his crossed legs and shook his sleeve back forward. He kept staring at the arm, though, as if he could still see the scars that were criss-crossing the skin everywhere, to the point that there was more burn-scar tissue in the shape of chain links than unblemished skin. Which was madness, because how did one put scars onto a being that didn’t even have a permanent physical form to begin with?
Well, if anyone at all in this universe knew the answer to that question, it would be Morgoth. Celebrimbor had never met the Destroyer, not even seen him from afar. As real as his influence on Arda remained, Morgoth himself had always retained the quality of a spectre in his mind – an aura of unreality, an ethereal horror, an insubstantial nightmare.
Oh, he knew of Angband, and he knew its survivors, since plenty of them had found their way to Eregion after the end of the First Age. And yet. A fortress did not a Dark Lord make. Angband could have been a place of terror even without a nightmarish god lurking in its bowels. Living things were capable of great cruelty even without malicious divine intervention. But now? This? Seeing the proof that the Destroyer had inhabited this world, realized in the very real scars in the skin of the Maia across from him made Celebrimbor’s skin crawl. He’s met Morgoth. Stood before him. Met his gaze – and what must that have been like?
“What did you do to earn them?” he asked haltingly.
Annatar inclined his head. “What makes you think that one needs to earn scars in Angband? Little is given freely there, but pain was always readily available in abundance.”
The crawling got worse. Celebrimbor rocked his weight a bit where he was sitting cross-legged across from Annatar on the mattress of his bed. “Are you – I mean. It was bad, wasn’t it?”
“Yes.”
Celebrimbor waited, but Annatar made no move to elaborate. “You don’t want to talk about this, do you?”
“Whatever gave you the idea?” Annatar replied, raising an eyebrow.
Celebrimbor threw him a look. “There is no need to be snide.”
“Just as there is no need to treat me like a kitten that needs coddling. We could both stop doing needless things. I feel like it might improve the atmosphere.”
Celebrimbor glared. “May I cordially remind you that it was not me who brought us into this situation? I didn’t keep pushing both of us into having sex, when you were neither willing nor ready, contrary to what you told me.”
“I was surprised. I will be able to deal with it going forward.”
“‘Beat your own instincts and trauma into submission with a blunt object’, you mean.”
“Would you stop using that word?”
“I’m going to stop using it when it stops being correct.”
“Tyelperinquar.” Annatar’s tone was a warning.
“Annatar.” Celebrimbor glared at the Maia. “Continuing on with what is obviously an undertaking riddled with difficulties for you is a bad idea. You should talk to someone about this. If not Angband itself, then the… consequences that you are clearly suffering from even now.”
Annatar wasn’t looking at him. He was, in fact, staring very fixedly at a point on the wall slightly above and to the right of Celebrimbor’s left shoulder. “I talked to you.”
“I am not a psychologist.”
“I consummately loathe psychologists.”
“Yeah, well, that is another one of your problems you should probably talk to a psychologist about.”
Annatar kept staring at the wall with worrying intensity. Celebrimbor turned around and found out that the Maia had quite successfully begun burning a scorch mark into the plaster with his gaze. “Hey, stop demolishing my room.”
Annatar blinked, then looked at him. “I apologize.”
“Thank you. I’d still appreciate it if you left my accommodations standing.” Celebrimbor dropped his chin into the palm of his hand. “But really, going over this with someone who is actually trained to help you deal with it would be so much better than talking to me.”
“But I do not want to talk to anyone else,” Annatar said, matter-of-factly. “In fact, I feel a strong desire to stop speaking of this, even with you. Besides, I do not need help. I need to get this done and out of the way.”
“Burying stuff and ignoring it won’t make it go away.”
“Look who’s talking.”
“Hey, I at least don’t deny that I’m a few Silmarils short of a full set.”
“Yes, and what are you doing about it?”
“I am perfectly functional in my day-to-day life, this is hardly comparable.”
“Oooh, evasion and denial. Trauma signs.”
“Annatar.”
“This for that, Tyelperinquar.”
Celebrimbor sighed. “You’re still not going to drop this, aren’t you?”
“No. Failure is not an option.”
Celebrimbor sighed.
*
“Okay.” Celebrimbor folded his hands in front of his face as if summoning a spirit of luck and patience. “I’ve been thinking.”
Annatar, who was perched in a chair across from where the elf was sitting cross-legged on the bed, leaned forward. “And?”
“I think we need to start small, if we’re ever going to get somewhere with this. And I mean really, really small.”
Annatar inclined his head. “Meaning?”
Celebrimbor fixed him with a boring stare over the tips of his fingers. “You have a huge issue with your physical form, even though it isn’t in any way truly Incarnate. Any kind of mortal intimacy, however, is about nothing but physicality. So we need to get you used to settling into a body, before we try anything fancier.”
Annatar’s eyebrows rose. “As in –”
“As in truly Incarnating, yes. Living as an Incarnate. With bones, blood, muscles, the works.”
Annatar grimaced. “Is that truly necessary?”
“Considering the issues you’re having?” Celebrimbor threw him a look. “I’d say it’s that or throwing the towel.”
Celebrimbor was aware that if he wanted Annatar to give up, he shouldn’t have worded it as a challenge. The thing was, even he was beginning to see it as a project and a problem, and, most of all, a poser that he wanted to crack.
To hell with sensible decisions and prudence.
Likewise, to hell with their ambition and the inability to call it quits, because both of their lives were going to be so much harder from now on.
*
“How are you holding up?”
“It’s terrible. There is always something that is off about this sack of organs that is either uncomfortable, malcontent, or lacking. All. The. Time. I hate feeling hungry. Or tired. How can you even stand it?”
“We don’t. That’s why we like to eat and sleep a lot, mostly. And get grumpy when we don’t.”
“Terrible. Simply terrible.”
“You’ll manage.”
*
“I succeeded in sleeping yesternight.”
“Oh! Finally! How was it?”
“Terrific. I had a nightmare.”
“Oh. About?”
“I was wading through a sea of corpses under a blood-red sky choked with black clouds. The dead were clawing at my robes, trying to drag my down into their churning, frothing mass of decomposing flesh and blood, and wanting me to atone for my sins.”
“…ah.”
“Quite.”
“Maybe… your subconscious is trying to tell you something?”
“I wouldn’t know. We’re not exactly on speaking terms.”
“True.” Pause. “Would you truly not consider trying to get an appointment with a counsel—”
“No.”
A sigh. “Oh well. It was worth a try.”
*
“Must I?”
“You must.”
“I feel the need to point out that no matter my state of Incarnation, I remain a spirit of fire and thus my nature remains diametrically opposed to that of water.”
“Come on. You’re a big Maia. The hot spring isn’t going to bite you.”
“Why are you like this.”
“This is harder for me than it is for you, believe me.”
“There are moments when I despise you, Tyelperinquar.”
“Get in line. There are a lot of people who have older bones to pick with me.” A pause. “So, are you getting in or what?”
“I hate water.”
“I know. See it as a possibility of accommodating yourself with yet another physical sensation you’re suspicious about. Broadening your horizons. Get out of your comfort zone.”
“I don’t want to get in or out of zones, no matter how comfortable. I want to get back to work and be productive.”
“So you’re not getting in?”
“No. I’ve changed my mind.”
“Okay. Fine. Can’t be helped then.”
“What do you mean it can’t – ack!”
Splash.
“You know, at times I find that a friendly nudge helps people getting over themselves.”
“I’m going to kill you, Tyelperinquar.”
“Murder is not a viable method of dealing with anger and disappointment.”
“Perhaps the method hasn’t been tested enough.”
“I has. Now be quiet and atone for your sins, or I’ll send the nightmare corpses after you.”
*
“We’ve made progress, I’d say.”
“If you mean that I feel the urge to crawl out of my own skin only every five seconds instead of every other …”
“Everything can be a victory. You just have to set the bar low enough. I mean look at you – that’s what? Two full days in which you haven’t reflexively dematerialized at some point? I think you’re getting used to having a body.”
“You’re saying it like it’s a good thing.”
“Where’s your enterprising spirit? Remember, it was you who wanted to see this through at all costs, not me.”
A sigh. “Yes. No need to remind me.”
“I think we can go a step further now.”
Annatar frowned. “What do you mean?”
Celebrimbor threw him a long look. “Have you ever heard about hormones?”
Watching an Ainu rummage through millions of years of stored memories was quite the sight to see. If the gears in Annatar’s head had been whirring any faster, they would have surpassed the speed of light and thrown off the continuum of cause and effect.
“Yes,” he said at last. “But only out of books. I wasn’t interested in the phase when animals were created; it was the purview of Oromë and his followers. My forms didn’t ever make use of them. So no, I don’t how they work in a living body from personal experience.”
“Time to find out, then. They’re important. For one, they are the reason why sex works for Incarnates.”
“Wait,” Annatar said. “They are the key to everything? And you are telling me this only now?”
Celebrimbor threw him a sympathetic look. “Annatar, considering that you were having trouble with Incarnation to start with, how do you think confronting you with Incarnate brain chemistry from the beginning would have gone?”
Annatar grimaced. “Not well,” he admitted at last. “And you think it is going to work now?”
“I don’t know. But at least you can settle into an Incarnation for more than a full day now. There’s no telling how you are going to deal with having something other than your will pulling the levers in your mind. Only one way to find out.”
Annatar’s expression was one of deep suspicion. “That sounds very much like handing the reins of a racehorse to an absolute madman.”
“At times it very much is. Then again, I am an Incarnate, and I can deal with it just fine. I have faith that you are going to manage it, too.”
Annatar let out a long, suffering breath. “Off to the library then.”
“The library?”
“Don’t look at me like that. I am talking about Biochemistry, not Psychology. I need to look at the chemical formulae if I’m to know what kinds of molecules I’m supposed to reverse-engineer into this current form.”
Celebrimbor gave an amused snort. “You make it sound so romantic.”
“Well, you know me: the consummate romantic.”
“Obviously. Well, then. To the library.”
Chapter End Notes
I'll have you know that I've never in my life been prouder of a sentence than "his ambition was about to suplex them through the coffee table".
The Joys of Being Incarnate Notes:
Read The Joys of Being Incarnate Notes:
“How do you stand this?” Annatar asked and made a wide gesture with so much verve that he very nearly knocked over the pitcher of water standing in the middle of the table. “My moods are all over the place, I seem to have lost any and all control over my emotions, and I get angry at people, animals, and inanimate objects! Over nothing!”
“Come now,” Celebrimbor said placatingly. “I’m sure it’s not that bad –”
“‘Not that bad’?” Annatar echoed. “Just yesterday I wanted to pick a fight with a doorframe for being in my way and catching my elbow!”
“Well, and that is life with male hormones for you,” Anthere, a Haradrim master of silversmithing who happened to be sitting next to the Maia, said blithely. “Try having two X chromosomes and being put through the endocrinological wringer on a monthly basis.”
“No, thank you,” the Maia replied, burying his face in his hands. “I’m not a masochist.”
“In this case you have just revoked your right to complain in my presence.” Anthere shrugged, then went back to the newspaper in front of them. Gildiriel, who was sitting next to them, nodded in understanding solidarity.
Through a gap between two fingers, Annatar caught Celebrimbor’s eyes over the table of the refectory and threw him a baleful glare.
Celebrimbor lifted both palms. “No comment.”
Annatar groaned and rubbed his temples. “Another day of this, and I’m going to have to ask someone to put me out of my misery.”
“What is that I hear? Who wants to be put out of misery?” Daeror sauntered up to the table and plopped down next to Annatar.
“Me, now that you are here,” the Maia said, glancing at the bard through the gaps in his fingers before averting his face again.
“I love you too, darling – oh, chestnut stew with candied almonds! Wonderful! I’m starving!” Daeror pulled Annatar’s plate towards him and started to eat.
Celebrimbor watched the exchange with raised eyebrows. Gildiriel and Falda threw him questioning looks. Sindrian looked like he expected a bomb to go off any second, and also like he wanted to defenestrate his partner at the next possible opportunity. Daeror, for his part, continued munching on the Maia’s lunch. Annatar, his face once again hidden in his hands and entirely dedicated to a unique moment of wallowing in self-pity, didn’t notice.
“So, what’s new at the guild?” the bard wanted to know.
“Er,” Falda said.
“Well,” Gildiriel threw in.
“You know,” Throndûr said.
Then all three looked at Celebrimbor.
The elf closed his eyes, counted backwards from three, then opened them again. “It’s fine. Everything’s fine.” Pause. “We’re fine.”
“Hm-hm,” Daeror said, dangling his spoon between two fingertips. “Very convincing.” He turned to Annatar and nudged him in the ribs with his elbow. “How’s your quest for carnality treating you?”
Annatar opened one golden eye, which reminded Celebrimbor of a disgruntled dragon, and squinted at the bard. “Do you really have to ask?”
“You know me,” Daeror said. “I’m always interested in how my best friend is doing.”
“I am not your best friend.”
“That’s not for you to decide, honey. So, how’s it going?”
“Wonderful,” Annatar bit out from between clenched teeth. “I get to enjoy the most illustrious facets of corporeality. The only time I had more fun in my life was Celebrimbor’s birthday five years ago when his aunt gave me a half-hour dressing-down for daring to stand mere five metres away from her daughter.”
“To be fair, if I had a daughter, I would tell her to stay away from you as well,” Daeror said amusedly between two spoonfuls of stew.
“You know, I was never more relieved than I was when I learned that your sexual orientation would rule out you ever having natural children.”
“Aw, come now.” Daeror waved it off, brandishing his spoon dangerously. “You’d love the little tykes. You’d be the divine uncle, reading to them, bouncing them on your knees, showering them with gifts –”
“Er, no?” Falda cut in. “Have you met him? He’d totally be the evil cousin. He’d either terrorize them, or raise them to be absolute goblins, subverting your parenting efforts every time he met them.”
“There you go,” Annatar said. “Listen to Falda, she knows what she’s talking about.”
“That’s just posturing,” Daeror said. “I’m sure you love children.”
“Yes, about as much as five-hour operas and flea-bitten dogs.”
“I always knew you had heart for the arts and the strays.”
Annatar glared. “Oh, shut up and go back to eating your – wait, is that my dinner?” He stared down at the now empty spot of table in front of him, then to the bard, who was by now two-thirds through the abducted stew.
“Technically, it was your dinner,” Daeror corrected. “Now it is mine.”
For a moment, Annatar seemed unable to process the sheer audacity of the bard. “One of these days,” he muttered at last, averting his face and massaging his temples as if fighting off a headache.
“One of these day’s you’re going to do what?” Daeror asked with a broad smile. “Admit how much you love me?”
“I was going more for the concept of committing of crimes that usually get you a life sentence,” Annatar ground out. “I have great hopes that extenuating circumstances would annul all charges in this case.”
“Oh, come now. Surely a few hormonal dysbalances are no reasons for murder.”
“You have no idea.”
“Aww, buddy. It gets better with time, you’ll see.” Daeror threw an arm around Annatar’s shoulders, which made the Maia flinch so hard that he nearly dropped the glass of water he had just raised.
Celebrimbor noted that both he and Sindrian had half-risen from their seats, both of them poised to intervene in what could only end in dismemberment if Daeror kept prodding the Maia like that.
Surprisingly, though, Annatar undertook no such attempt. He just stared at Daeror. “Why are you touching me.”
“Because you’re my friend,” Daeror explained patiently.
“I’m not your –”
“And I wanted to show my support for your current quandary.”
“You are the root of my current quandary!”
“I can still be sympathetic.”
“Be sympathetic without touching me, then.”
“See, I think that’s one of the reasons why you are always so prickly. You were probably left alone very much as a kid and –”
“I have never been a child, you absolute turnip.”
“ – emotional neglect, parental abandonment, yadda, yadda, inability to express your own inner turmoil in a productive manner, out of touch with your emotions –”
Celebrimbor’s and Sindrian’s eyes met. Sindrian raised an eyebrow in a silent question. Celebrimbor nodded imperceptibly.
Both of them leapt to their feet simultaneously. Sindrian grabbed Daeror by the collar and yanked him away from the Maia. “We have got to go now.”
“What a coincidence, so do we,” Celebrimbor said, rounding the table and pulling Annatar to his feet, who, once again, flinched.
“Wait, why?” Daeror rasped out, strangled.
“Because we do,” Sindrian said, dragging him away mercilessly. “You still have to finish the new composition before Yule, remember?”
“But Yule is more than ten weeks aw –”
“We’re leaving,” Sindrian repeated. “See you soon.” He hastily waved at the people at the table, who silently lifted their hands in a mute good-bye, then proceeded to drag Daeror out of the refectory under the stares of the assembled Guild of the Jewel-smiths.
“How about we leave, too?” Celebrimbor asked, trying to push the Maia in the direction of the exit. Annatar, however, dug his heels in.
“Later,” he snarled.
“But –”
“I want to eat something first. The bloody bard stole my food and courtesy of being stuck in a body, I am hungry.”
Well, that was a viable reason. Also, Celebrimbor was absolutely not keen on dealing with a Maia that was hungry and angry.
“Good,” Celebrimbor allowed. “Get your dinner. But then we’ll talk.”
“Again?”
“Yes, because I noticed something interesting.”
“What?”
“Later. As you said: stew first, discussions after.”
*
“So, what did you notice?” Annatar asked when they exited the guild hall to take a much-needed breath of fresh air.
Celebrimbor threw him a side-glance. “There’s been a change ever since you’ve taken to truly Incarnating. Other than wanting to challenge doorframes to fights, I mean.” He raised an expectant eyebrow.
Annatar looked back. “I don’t have the slightest inkling what you are referring to. My life has been a consummate maelstrom of misery and misfortune ever since I have begun wearing this body. So if there are facets to this form of torture, I have probably missed it.”
“You don’t tolerate touch anymore. That is to say, you tolerate it even less than before,” Celebrimbor amended.
Annatar stared off into the middle distance. “Do I now?”
“Yes. You nearly jumped and ran when Daeror put his arm around you, and you even flinched when I pulled you to your feet in the refectory. That was most certainly not the case before.”
Annatar thought about this, then nodded. “That is … true. I’m not surprised, though.” He threw Celebrimbor a glance, then averted his gaze and sighed. “Ever since I took to wearing this body my perception is more limited than ever before, and yet there is so much of everything – not in spectrum or depth or finesse, but in obtrusiveness.” Annatar closed his eyes and pressed his fingers to his temples as if fighting off a headache. “It is as if the world has lost any and all filters. Everything is immediately there – on my skin, in my eyes, ears, brain – I constantly feel like I have a Vala speaking directly to me, but on all channels of sensory input. It’s breaking my nerves. Metaphorically and literally.”
Celebrimbor was silent for a moment. “For the sake of expedience, I will just pretend that we have already had the discussion about not needing to continue this experiment.”
“Yes, thank you.”
“I will also refrain from pointing out that failure would have nothing to do with stopping.”
“Let us agree to disagree and move on.”
Celebrimbor sighed. “Fine. Then what now?”
“I simply need to get used to it,” Annatar said. “Which would be a lot easier if your world wasn’t so terribly unpleasant.”
Celebrimbor opened his mouth to comment on something to do with the fact that Annatar hadn’t even experienced true mortal discomfort in his assumed form – he had been neither wounded nor sick – then recalled what he had said about pretending to have already had essentially useless discussions, and shut it again.
He thought for a minute, weighed his options, came to a conclusion. “Annatar?”
“Hm?”
“Have you ever had a massage?”
*
“That was weird.”
“Oh, come off it. You were out like a light after half an hour.”
“Yes, because I hadn’t slept in two days.”
“And? You could have left and gone to bed. You didn’t. Instead, you decided to stay and conk out on me on my sofa. And then your cat came and started to occupy the rest of me, and I couldn’t get up for two hours.”
“I was merely focusing very hard.”
“For two full hours?”
“Yes.”
“On what?”
“Solving Wraith’s mind-to-speech issue.”
“And?”
“I’m still working on it.”
“Sure.”
“I mean it. I’m working on it.”
“You liked it. Just admit it.”
“Hngh.”
“Come. Come. Say it.”
“Fine. It was … tolerable.”
“Great! That’s great! Which means we have made progress!”
“Huh.” Pause. “Yes, I guess it does.”
“Which means that we can go on to the next step.”
“Meaning?”
“Have you ever done a sleepover?”
“No. As much as three weeks ago, I hadn’t even slept. Be it over, under, or in conjunction with any other spatial direction.”
“Great. Which means that you’ll coincidentally get to know a dose of mortal youth culture, seeing how you missed out on so many things, what with literally never having been a kid, and all, as Daeror was kind enough to point out.”
“Why are you repeating this nonsense.”
“Because you deserve it and because my sympathy for your self-inflicted predicament is rapidly decreasing. Also, because you need to be able to suffer sleeping in the same bed with me before you are sleeping with me. Escalating difficulty curves, Annatar. Escalating difficulty.”
“… fine. How does this work?”
*
“I feel like you should have warned me,” Celebrimbor said on the next morning.
Annatar opened one eye and raised one arm in a disgruntled manner to shield his face from the light of the late autumn sun, a silvery white disc hanging low in the sky, dousing everything in the room, the white sheets especially, in an ephemeral, nearly dream-like blaze of white and pale gold.
“Warned of what?” he asked.
“That you are a cephalopod in Maiarin shape,” Celebrimbor said. “And about as clingy as one.”
“What?” Annatar sat up abruptly, the blanket pooling in his lap. He was wearing the same robes as always, which was ridiculous in so many ways, not least of them that he shouldn’t have been able to sleep in them without dying of heatstroke. But it wasn’t bad enough that Annatar had decided to strategically kill himself by overheating, no –
“You clung to me the entire night. I tried to shift away, but you kept following me.” Celebrimbor squinted at him. “You know, I never would have taken you to be the snuggling type.”
The Maia spluttered. “I am not – that’s a preposterous claim. You have no way to prove that.”
“I do, because I was awake the entire time.” Celebrimbor sat up, too, rubbing his eyes. “Also, how are you in a mortal body and still a living furnace? I was so hot that I had to throw off my blankets and sleep without them, and it’s the middle of October!” He looked out of the window. “Look, there’s snow on the mountains!”
Annatar gave him a How is this my problem-look. “Why, I thought you’d be rejoicing over our rousing success. I can obviously stand your physical proximity just fine.”
Celebrimbor raised his eyebrows. “Oh, quite. That’s progress, I guess.”
“Of course it is progress,” Annatar said archly. “So what is the next step?”
“Don’t get ahead of yourself. Suffering physical contact when you’re semi-unconscious is like being applauded for your ability to suffer after sleeping through an atrocious play. How is now that you are awake? Are you still feeling clingy?”
“I am not clingy.”
“Take it up with your subconscious and leave me out of it.” Celebrimbor waved it off. “So how are you feeling now?”
Annatar paused. He frowned. He looked aside as if computing a difficult equation. “I,” he said. “I have nothing against being close to you in an awake state. Your proximity has always been – tolerable.”
Celebrimbor stifled a snort-chortle (a snortle?) in the palm of his hand. “Careful, you’re going make me swoon here. Keep it up and I may feel the need to cover my ankles around you.”
“Why your ankles?”
“Oh, you raided the bookstores for romance novels and you didn’t get to that?”
“No. In the books there seemed to be always rather more uncovered than just ankles. It was very disconcerting.”
“Yes… I believe you.” Celebrimbor squinted, and made a mental note to introduce Annatar to Vanyarin romance novels. “Speaking of clothing.” He pointed at Maia’s robe. “Let’s get you out of that.”
Annatar shrunk back. “Why?”
“Because we’re practicing escalating difficulty, remember?”
Annatar gave him a diffident look.
Celebrimbor inclined his head to one side. “Start with something long-sleeved if this is about the scars. But dress lighter, by the sun and stars. Surely a change of clothes is within the realm of the possible?”
Annatar heaved a sigh. Watching him, you’d think he’d been asked to skip merrily to the gallows. Then the outline of his robes blurred, leaving behind light trousers and a long-sleeved shirt, slightly loose around his slender frame, and made of white cotton. There was also a thin, white necktie that was wound around his throat, replacing the high collar of his robes. It looked very incongruous and still way too warm for the room. It also looked –
Celebrimbor blinked.
“What,” Annatar said.
“Nothing,” the elf said. “It’s just … you look. Different. Without the bulk of your robes.”
Annatar looked down at himself. “I look like a homeless person.”
“Balderdash, you look like someone who is dressed casually for the first time in his life.”
“That’s another way of saying I look like a homeless person.”
“That is rubbish. I quite like it, in fact.”
Annatar frowned, obviously surprised and appalled in equal measure that there were people who liked appearances that were any less refined than being dressed to the nines. “You do?”
“Yes,” said Celebrimbor. “It makes you look less uptight. More approachable. Also kind of …” He trailed off.
Annatar raised an eyebrow in a silent question.
Celebrimbor waved it off. “Forget it.”
They looked at each other.
“And now?” Annatar asked.
“Now we are going to enjoy a lazy morning because we don’t have classes to teach.”
“We are going to do nothing? Why?”
“Because it’s nice and because I want to.” Celebrimbor threw himself back down on his pillow and stretched. “No students. No grading. No one asking me questions. Just – a free day. Wonderful.”
Annatar stayed in his upright, sitting position. Celebrimbor could basically feel his stare. “Let me reiterate,” the Maia said. “You are going to do nothing? Out of your own free will?”
“Yes. Care to join me?”
“No, I think I’ll pass. I could be doing something useful with my time instead.” Annatar threw back the covers and made to slide out of bed, but Celebrimbor caught him by the hem of his shirt.
“Wait.”
The Maia halted.
“We can do something useful,” Celebrimbor said.
Annatar twisted around a bit further until he was looking down at the elf. “And what might that be?”
“We can explore your physical incarnation further. For science of course.”
“Is that code for pawing at me?”
“No. Yes. Maybe. What I really wanted to know –” Celebrimbor sat up and scooted closer to where Annatar was sitting. “Is this form ticklish?” He poked Annatar in the side and to his never-ending delight, the Maia flinched away from him. “It is!”
“Stop that.”
“I don’t think so, we need to verify the finding.” Celebrimbor poked him again. Annatar almost folded in half in his attempt to get avoid the contact.
“Stop that.”
“No, no no, we need an n big enough to make deviations from the standard statistically relevant. A few more hundred attempts should do it.”
“What –”
Celebrimbor tried again, and Annatar slapped his hand away, leaning backwards, until he was almost flat on his back. The elf only laughed harder and mercilessly followed after him. “Oh, that’s the cat’s pyjamas, I’d never have thought –”
Something weird happened. One moment, everything was as always. In the next, sky and earth seemed to invert positions, did so again, bouncing gravity like a ball between them, and next thing Celebrimbor knew, their positions were inverted and Annatar was pinning him to the mattress, one lower arm braced on Celebrimbor’s breastbone, the other pinning Celebrimbor’s wayward left hand against the cushion. The Maia’s eyes were darker than usual, he looked like he was about to breathe fire. All in all, it was very much like being pinned by a mountain. Or a dragon. A very annoyed dragon.
“Stop. That,” Annatar growled.
Celebrimbor blinked. This had felt less like being flipped over by a physical being, and more like gravity inverting rapidly two times; a primordial force of the universe that was so strong that everything else had to shift and move around them, one singular living being less than even a momentary consideration.
“That was impressive,” he said.
“Impressive?” Annatar raised an eyebrow.
“Yes. I keep forgetting how ridiculously powerful you are.”
Annatar look offended. “Excuse you?”
Celebrimbor shrugged. “It’s not as if I get a daily demonstration.”
“I didn’t know that you wanted the floorplan of your city overturned and redrawn in real life. That can be arranged, Tyelperinquar.”
“I have no doubt that you could,” Celebrimbor said. “But you wouldn’t, which is exactly my point: you’re literally all bark and no bite.”
Annatar let go of the elf in order to sit up straight, flustered like a bird puffing up its plumage. “Excuse you?” he repeated.
Celebrimbor sat up, grinning lopsidedly. “Ah, come now, why are you surprised? Scaring apprentices is no achievement, and when it came down to it, you never did anything to anybody. I mean, look at Daeror. He’s been annoying enough to make me consider violence, yet you do not so much as raise your voice when he half-crawls into your lap, gets in your face, or steals your food. You are either the biggest impostor I’ve ever known, or the laziest fighter of all time.”
“I’ll have you know –”
“Which is why I know that I won’t get into trouble for doing this.” Celebrimbor poked him again.
Annatar lunged.
There was a brief, fairly hopeless scuffle with a fairly predictable end.
“You keep pushing me,” the Maia growled.
“I do,” Celebrimbor said. “And it says so much about you that instead of responding romantically – like, I don’t know, pinning me with a kiss or something – you put me into a multi-joint lock instead. I can’t move at all—where did you even learn that?”
“Is that relevant?”
“Yes, because I was convinced that you were as abysmal a fighter as you are a lazy one, relying on superior power to win, instead of actual ability.”
“Excuse you?!”
“I am excused, thank you. Can you let me go now? My elbows are starting to hurt, and I don’t think my lower back is supposed to do that.”
Annatar did so, but with a glower.
Celebrimbor sat up, rubbing his shoulders and his arms with a grimace. “Well, at least we found out that you are absolutely fine tolerating touch as long as it is executed in the name of winning a fight or applying violence. Which is not exactly what I was going for, but I guess we have to take it.” He sighed.
Annatar blinked. “What were you going for?”
“I told you. A romantic scuffle. Touching a bit, perhaps kissing. Punishing me for overstepping, if you’re feeling a bit evil.” Celebrimbor grinned and waggled his eyebrows.
Annatar did not grin back. “Why on earth would I kiss you in response to you getting on my nerves?”
Celebrimbor’s grin faded. “Has it occurred to you that this might be a hopeless case?”
They shared a long, long look.
“I’m not hopeless,” Annatar said after a long while, which was almost hilariously disjointed from everything else, especially because it was such a blatant false claim.
"Well. If you say so.” Pause. “Do you.” Pause. Celebrimbor awkwardly gestured between them. “Want to lie down a bit? You know? Together? Romantically – as – er – a means of furthering the investigation about your limits of comfort?”
Annatar frowned. “But we’re not doing nothing.”
“No, we’re testing out whether you’re only an octopus while sleeping or whether you’re able to stomach physical contact when you’re awake. Which is very important if you are ever going to have sex.”
The Maia thought about this. He exhaled, blowing a wavy strand of hair away that had fallen over his forehead. “Fine.” He threw himself down again. “How do we do this?”
“Oh, that’s easy.” Celebrimbor laid down next to him and threw one arm and one leg across the Maia, pulling him in.
Annatar squirmed like a trapped cat. “What – why. What are you doing.”
Belatedly, it occurred to Celebrimbor that the Maia might feel trapped for real. If the last few weeks had demonstrated anything, it was that Annatar was pulling an entire train of baggage with him when it came to physicality and intrusion into personal space. Also, there was still the Angband thing which they weren’t really talking about.
Celebrimbor felt his stomach turn. Varda, if there had been any comfortable mood in the room when the morning began, it was out of the window. The air was laden with discomfort and awkwardness.
“Forgive me.” He pulled back. “Should I … move away?”
The most awkward silence yet filled the room. Annatar breathed out and noticeably forced some tension from his frame. “No. It’s fine.”
“Should I refrain from touching you?”
“No, it’s fine.”
“What you did just now didn’t look fine to me. At all.”
“It’s fine,” the Maia retorted, rather snappish now. “Just - don’t constrain me. That’s all.”
Celebrimbor buried his face in his hands. Stars, what are we doing here?
Chapter End Notes
Celebrimbor asking the question that could have been the summary of this entire fic.
On another note, I live for Daeror's and Annatar's dynamic, I could write these two all day.
Advance, Retreat
Read Advance, Retreat
Honestly, at this point Celebrimbor was ready to give everything up as a lost cause. His terminal curiosity and urge to solve problems aside, he had, by this point, utterly lost his appetite to investigate further what had been advertised to him as a funny relationship experiment, but had turned out to be a veritable psychological and interpersonal minefield.
Which would have been bad enough on its own, but on top of that - to extend the analogy further –Annatar staunchly refused to tell him where the bombs were buried, and Celebrimbor kept stepping on every single one with dream-like surety.
It was a mess.
They had a few very spirited arguments about it, where Celebrimbor wanted to refuse to continue the charade, and Annatar obstinately refused to break it off, with Celebrimbor retracting his support and participation, and Annatar faulting him for leaving him alone in this – which was all discussed in a very calm and mature manner and did in no way involve shouting, badly disguised emotional blackmail and chucking the blame at each other like a bomb with a burning fuse.
(Why why why did bombs keep coming up whenever Celebrimbor thought about the two of them?)
(The idea surged, and he quickly buried it again because he truly didn’t have the time to think about what this implied.)
The very picture of a good relationship it was, truly.
As it was, they didn’t fall out for good.
However, was no denying that the experiment was putting a strain on their relationship that hadn’t been there before. A strain that Celebrimbor viewed with increasing worry, because he wasn’t entirely sure how long they could keep pushing this until something gave, be it someone’s temper or something going even more wrong than usual.
As it was, they also didn’t discontinue the experiment, very much against their better knowledge – mainly because Annatar had always been as obstinate as a mountain troll, but ever since he had an endocrinological system, his moods had become three times worse than usual. There was no convincing him to stop and Celebrimbor – very aware of the flimsy reasoning involved – guessed that it was better if he stayed involved so that Annatar at least wouldn’t be alone in the moment when he inevitably ran this wreck of a venture full-speed into a mountainside.
That being said, if common sense had ever been involved in this venture, it had, by now, packed its bags and flounced of to an extended sojourn at the beaches of Harad with a very rude gesture. So. Well. That was that.
At least they still had other projects to take their minds of the insanity of interpersonal relationships, and Celebrimbor had never been happier about it.
They had even made progress with the speaking device that Annatar wanted to create for Wraith. They had jury-rigged a sound-to-speech device with the help of the Faculty Of Information Technology (Signal Technology, to be exact), but subsequently run into the problem that vocalizations of cats were simply too limited to express the variety of concepts that Wraith now understood. Anything beyond “hungry”, “pet me”, “go away” or ideas of a similar level were simply not expressible in the capped number of variants of meowing, hissing, and yowling that cats could generally produce.
“Hm,” Celebrimbor said. “Sound-to-speech isn’t feasible if you have too few sounds as input.”
Annatar frowned at Wraith. “Looks like it.”
“I wonder if she would be able to practice osanwë.”
“She is,” Annatar said with a shrug, as if that wasn’t the most spectacular biological reveal of the last millennium.
Celebrimbor blinked. “She is?”
Annatar made a brief, encouraging gesture with his hand, along the lines of, Go ahead, try it.
Celebrimbor focused on Wraith.
Can you hear me?
—I can not hear with my mind. I can perceive your thoughts, if that is what you mean.
Celebrimbor stared at her, wide-eyed. “It works!”
“Of course it works,” Annatar said flatly. “I just told you so.”
“Yes – but.” Celebrimbor blinked. “The cat can do osanwë! Why? Not even the great eagles or dolphins can do it!”
—Compare me to oversized chicken and hairless water dogs one more time, I dare you.
Celebrimbor glanced at her. “I – that’s remarkable.” He looked at Annatar. “What have you been doing to her brain?”
Annatar shrugged. “It wasn’t a conscious thing. Ainur sometimes shape the world around them. Aulë could bring rare earths to synthesize simply by standing in one spot for too long. Vairë was even worse – the rare times when she showed her face, cause, effect, and coincidence started … acting up. Melkor …” he trailed off.
Celebrimbor went still.
“He distorted reality,” Annatar finished.
“As in –”
“Space-time, yes. Think a black hole, but it walks around in Tirion and bothers people. And that was after we had reined ourselves into appearances that wouldn’t break the minds of mortals like our primordial forms would have done.”
Celebrimbor stared at him. “That is terrifying.”
“Yes, and that was the being that your grandfather chose to mouth off to.”
“My grandfather was very intelligent. Nobody said he was wise.”
“No.” Annatar sighed. “Probably not. To return to the topic at hand: we have a way of influencing our surroundings. The effect is far more pronounced in Valar than in Maiar, but apparently I have a way of causing …”
“Intelligence development?”
Annatar shook his head. “No, that is too specific. I think … development in general. I know processes. I know optimization and error elimination. I wouldn’t be surprised if something of it rubbed off on my surroundings.”
“Well, here’s a cat that is self-aware, uses advanced reasoning and is capable of osanwë. I’d say that this hypothesis is fairly close to being proven.”
—You can talk to me, Wraith thought, disgruntled. I’m right here.
“That solves the problem of speaking to the Eldar,” Celebrimbor mused, rubbing his chin. “But still, there are the Khazad and all humans to be considered.”
—That, and overusing osanwë gives me a headache.
Annatar waved it off. “You’re not used to it yet,” he said aloud. “It will get better with time.”
In response to this, Wraith made a nightmarish retching face: bug-eyed, tongue lolling and squinting outward, what in all hells, for Varda’s sake –
She gagged, and for one moment Celebrimbor thought she was going to throw up right there on the floor.
“Wraith,” Annatar said flatly.
What, she tapped on her card, her nightmarish grimace still a frozen rictus on her face.
The Maia threw her a look, then turned to Celebrimbor, who was standing near the desk, drumming his fingers on the top and consciously ignoring the bug-eyed cat.
“If there only was a way to translate thoughts to speech.” Celebrimbor frowned, looked up. “Didn’t you mention that you were working on something like that?”
Annatar’s face went through a very complicated expression that Celebrimbor couldn’t even hope to begin to decipher. “I abandoned the project.”
“Why?” Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow.
“It didn’t work.”
“It didn’t work? An idea of you did not work?”
Annatar waved it off impatiently, then turned back to Wraith, who was staring up at him out of the turbulent seas of her word-cards, her face once again normal, thank fate.
The cat slapped her paw down on her cards, forgoing osanwë in favour of a more paws-on approach. What-are-you-looking-at-me-for? The-answer-to-your-incapability-is-not-lying-here-on-the-floor.
Annatar inclined his head to one side. “Right now, I’m wondering whether I should take a hint that fate sent me and just leave you as pleasantly silent as you are now. That way, at least humans and dwarves are safe from you.”
A-R-S-E.
“Takes one to know one,” Annatar replied.
I-learn-by-example. What-is-your-excuse?
Celebrimbor, who had turned around to fiddle with the impractical speech device in a lone corner of the room, chortled. Cat and Maia turned to stare at him as one.
“Excuse you?” the Maia said, annoyed.
Silence-on-the-peanut-gallery! Wraith slapped out on her cards.
Celebrimbor raised one eyebrow. The cat knew allegories and metaphors and idioms, and even knew how to use them, in this specific instance, however – “How do you know this particular expression, Wraith?”
Why?
“Well, this is very much thespian vernacular, and this I do not see Annatar using.”
The-B-A-R-D-taught-me-of-course. The cat was looking very self-satisfied.
“You are in contact with Deukalion?” Annatar asked sharply.
Naturally. The cat licked her paw, then went on to drum out her answer on the cards. He-is-very-sociable-and-amusing. It-is-a-nice-change-from-my-usual-company. He-is-entertaining-for-a-two-legs. He-also-teaches-me-interesting-vocabulary.
Celebrimbor raised one eyebrow. “Ah, so you didn’t learn cursing out of books after all.”
Of-course-not.
“Ah, so that’s why you’re getting more and more insufferable,” Annatar said. “I should have known.”
Hardly-as-insufferable-as-you-two. How-is-mastering-mating-coming-along-by-the-way-O-great-and-O-M-N-I-P-O-T-E-N-T-master?
Celebrimbor hadn’t heretofore known that cats were able to look smug. He quickly reasserted this mistaken assumption, then reached out to keep Annatar from saying something to an animal that he would regret. It was hardly fair for a Maia to get into an argument with a cat. The blasted little monsters always won, and Annatar’s self-respect would never recover.
*
“I’m thinking about abandoning the project altogether,” Annatar growled later as they were climbing the stairs towards Celebrimbor’s rooms.
“Out of sheer spite?” Celebrimbor asked. “Come on, you are better than that.”
Annatar’s expression told him that, no, the Maia absolutely wasn’t better than that, and that he wouldn’t dream of taking the high road if he could dropkick Wraith over the city walls instead.
“But on another note,” Celebrimbor continued. “How in all of the world did Daeror manage to get a hold of your cat?”
“Search me,” Annatar grumbled. “I’ve been wondering about it myself and regretting the fact ever since I came to know it. Blasted cat,” he said, then added, with feeling, “And blasted bard.”
“Well, look at it from the bright side: Daeror has finally found something other than our private life to occupy his time.”
“Yes, he graduated from snooping around in my non-existent sex life to indoctrinating and corrupting my cat. Joy of all joys,” Annatar said unenthusiastically as they stopped in front of the door leading to Celebrimbor’s rooms. “The world has taken a turn for the better, truly. The Blessed Age must be upon us. Eru threw away the keys to the Doors of the Void. The Dagor Dagorath has been cancelled. Rejoice.” A pause. “One of these days I going to strangle him.”
“Yes, yes,” Celebrimbor waved it off. “Between letting him steal your food and teaming up with him to destroy a career of another of his rivals. We’ve had that conversation about barking and not biting.”
“I have a feeling that you are not taking me seriously.”
Celebrimbor looked at him while he turned the key in the lock. “As a person and partner? Very much. As an incarnation of divine vengeance come down from the Outer Spheres upon the head of a mouthy bard? Not so much. I’ll believe it when I see it.”
Annatar was silent. “You have a very skewed picture of me.”
Celebrimbor shrugged. “I’d like to think that I know you fairly well after spending nearly every day side by side with you for the last five centuries. Disprove it, and I’ll be the first to admit being wrong.” He turned around while stepping backwards into the door, raising an eyebrow in a challenging unspoken Well?
Annatar evaded his gaze. He didn’t reply.
*
They didn’t speak further of Daeror, Wraith, or Annatar’s debatable tendency-and-or willingness to divinely smite people that got on his nerves. Instead, they discussed their Ring project a bit further, but not even this could raise Annatar’s spirits.
The Maia had been strangely withdrawn ever since they had entered the tower and gave monosyllabic answers to everything Celebrimbor said.
The elf tried to keep the conversation going, attempted not to let the dampened mood get to him, but at some point, he realized that it was a lost cause tonight.
“What is wrong?” Celebrimbor asked.
Annatar looked up from where he had sat in his custom spot in one armchair, one knee drawn up, arms looped around his leg, chin resting on top of his knee, staring out of the window and watching the sunset.
It was a strange change ever since the Maia had started incarnating. He was doing these little things now; things that people who didn’t know him as well probably wouldn’t even have noticed, but showed to Celebrimbor that the Maia’s actions were no longer nearly exclusively determined by willpower and his desire of how to present himself. He flinched involuntarily, for one, when he was unpleasantly surprised by someone touching him. He had – unwittingly, Celebrimbor believed – adopted mortal body language. Whereas before the Maia had always moved and stood with perfect poise, each posture nearly as intentional and perfected as the pose of a marble statue, he now did things that were as small and mundane as shifting his weight from one leg to the other when he was weighing options. Or tapping his fingers when he became impatient.
Or, most notably, adopting a completely locked and walled-off posture when he was uncomfortable, either because something was gnawing at his mind or because he wanted to discourage people from getting too close to him.
Other people wouldn’t have noticed it, let alone realized the significance. But Celebrimbor had, for lack of a better word, been Annatar’s second shadow for five hundred years now, and vice versa. They had lived in each other’s spaces, in each other’s heads, even.
On a purely rational level, Celebrimbor had known that changes were to be expected if the Maia chose to live as an Incarnate, even if only temporarily. However, on an instinctual level, the fact kept throwing him off-balance every time he became aware of it. He had gotten to know someone, and that someone had acted very differently in a thousand little nuances – to a degree that a thousand trivialities added up to no longer entirely recognizing the person who wore his friend’s – his partner’s face. It was disquieting on a very deep, very instinct-guided level.
He had experienced it before in people he had known – or believed to have known very well.
His father. His grandfather. His uncles.
With the Oath. With the War. Brutal caesuras that had sliced the timeline of his life into a Before and After without a chance to mend the gap, or what the tear had done to the people that had been caught in the middle of such a timeline-sundering event. People went into the event, people came out of it. They remained the who they were, and were at the same time entirely changed.
The same had happened to Annatar. In the process of stepping into the material world, which implied getting closer to what happened there, to let it touch him, he seemed to have retreated from it more and more – as if compensating for his loss of defences on one front by throwing up wall upon wall on another.
Discomfort might have been one explanation for it. But – and this kept nagging at Celebrimbor’s mind night after night – why was the Maia so dead-set on continuing the experiment in this case? His line of reasoning (and this had been bothering Celebrimbor for months) fell apart at the first prod. Obstinacy well and good, but not even Annatar was so headstrong to do something he hated for no other reason than … just because. In fact, he had often in the past refused to do things he did not like and made a grand point of it. If all the Maia felt was discomfort and disgust, he should have – he would have broken this experiment off. So there must have been something else – a powerful third driving force that pushed the Maia seemingly in two directions at once.
Approach and withdraw. Reveal and hide. Wanting to continue, but not being able to take a single step forward.
Wanting to be known, and yet dreading to be seen. Hiding. Holding back.
Celebrimbor blinked. His thoughts had run off with him again. He must have stared at the Maia for quite some time, because Annatar was still looking at him with an expression that was approaching the tipping point from expectation into annoyance.
“Was there something you wanted?” Annatar asked. His voice was measured. He could still do that. Very well, better than any other people Celebrimbor knew. Control. Or, Celebrimbor thought with a glance at Annatar’s curled-up, walled-off, defensive posture, his limbs like a wall in front of his torso, the illusion of it.
“I asked what was wrong,” Celebrimbor said.
“And I told you that nothing was wrong,” Annatar replied.
Celebrimbor breathed out. “Yes. But perhaps I was hoping for a different answer than a lie.”
Annatar bristled. Uncurled his position, opened it, straightened. Shifting from defence to attack.
Celebrimbor supressed a humourless smile. “I’m not looking for a fight tonight.”
“Then why are you insinuating that I lied to you?” Annatar asked. His anger flared, quietly and surreptitiously, like coals someone had blown air onto.
“I am not insinuating. I am stating a fact. I did it because I can see that something is clearly off,” Celebrimbor said simply. “And because I had hoped that after five centuries living with you – and loving you, might I add – we had reached the point where we could be honest with each other.”
Celebrimbor’s father and his grandfather before him had been praised for their craftsmanship. They had been known and remembered by history for their ability to assemble, to build, to create. Regarding their personalities and deeds, was remarkable that it was the lesser-known fact that they had just as great a talent – if not greater – to disassemble, to take apart, to destroy. Not necessarily with actions, although they had racked up an impressive tally on that front, too.
No, the deadliest weapons that both men had wielded in their lives were not blades, but words.
Curufin had not known it, and neither had his wife, but Celebrimbor had been just outside the room often enough when they had had one of their many rows. He had witnessed his mother throwing out desperate argument after desperate argument, and having her grievances swiftly and lethally turned around on her by Curufin, until she was permanently on the backfoot, on the defence. His father had loved her fiercely, but his pride had never borne criticism well, however well-founded or justified it might have been. In arguments with her he had been merciless, dismantling her like a faulty apparatus in his workshop. Dispassionately, clinically, mercilessly.
It was a very, very little-known fact that Celebrimbor had inherited this dubious talent. He didn’t use it very often. In fact, doing so made his skin crawl, because in those moments, whenever he caught a reflection of his face in the window, or an echo of his voice, it was not himself he heard and saw, but Curufin or Fëanor. He bit his tongue more often than not, sought to mediate and de-escalate.
However, the fact remained that he could look at people and in front of his inner eye, he saw, as clearly as any construction plan, the steps he could have taken to utterly dismantle a person: the weaknesses, the faultlines, that – if pushed hard enough – could shatter someone into pieces.
It was an eerie thing, and he tried not to think about what it said about him that he knew how to do this. The important thing was that he didn’t do it.
Excepting extraordinary circumstances – like a being that he loved more than any other still not being forthright with him after years and years. It had been a knife-cut on Annatar’s side, however unintentional. The Curufinwës had never had many reservations about stabbing back, and Celebrimbor was no exception.
Annatar’s flinch told Celebrimbor that the hit had landed as intended. Good.
The elf waited for the Maia to deny the claim again. To argue that he had been truthful. To rise in righteous anger and demand that Celebrimbor stop accusing him. However, Annatar did no such thing. He remained seated where he was, tense and silent.
“It has been nearly five months now,” Celebrimbor said. “As entertaining as this back-and-forth has been at times, I begin to tire of it. You wall yourself off, you give me flimsy reasons for unreasonable actions that I could poke a hole into without even extending any effort. You are scarred, in more ways than I probably know of even now. You have trouble opening up, and I do not believe for a minute that it is because you are merely ashamed of your scars or uncomfortable revealing a body that is as little the true you as a coat I choose to wear is my true me.” Celebrimbor eyed him with a sharp look. “Do not insult either of our intelligence further by claiming that everything is alright, because it is as clear as day that it isn’t. If you do not want to speak of it – fine. But in this case, say so. Be honest.”
A long silence fell.
“It is not that I do not want to speak of it,” Annatar said, not meeting his eyes.
Celebrimbor waited, then inquired, “But?”
Another silence, agonized and drawn out.
Annatar clutched his own hands. His knuckles were bloodless in the fading light. Incarnate, insecure. Just above the wrist: the hem of his robes, hiding everything from view that wasn’t his face or his hands.
“I –” Annatar broke off.
Darkness flooded the room like dark water. The sun vanished behind the mountains.
Annatar stared at the small table between them, eyes fixed, expression frozen, visibly fighting a battle of wills in his own head.
“I –” he tried again.
Celebrimbor remained silent, motionless.
Night fell as quickly as the stroke of a henchman here, at the dying end of October. The moon and stars were hidden by thick, low-hanging clouds.
At last, Annatar spoke. His words, when they came, were choked like the sky, nearly inaudible:
“I am afraid.”
“Why?” Celebrimbor asked.
For a while, nothing happened.
Just silence.
He felt the exact moment when Annatar dropped his Incarnation. Something about the Maia became at once less and more present. A hum of power thrummed through the room. Annatar’s eyes flashed golden. The centre of gravity seemed to shift, light and sound and gazes and attention bent towards the Maia.
If someone didn’t know Annatar, it could have easily been construed as a threat.
But Celebrimbor did know Annatar. Had known him, for a very long time. He saw it for what it was. Not the drawing of a weapon in preparation for an attack. But the donning of armour, of drawing layers and layers of walls around him.
Celebrimbor watched him, not speaking a single word.
Annatar looked up at last. “Tyelperinquar,” he said. The silence broke like glass. “There is something I need to tell you.”
Chapter End Notes
I did NOT WANT to write a revelation scene in this.
But somehow EVERYONE and their DOG on AO3 ended up wanting it and waiting for it, so HERE WE ARE.
Even though this will give everyone EMOTIONAL WHIPLASH ONCE AGAIN and is going to COMPLETELY THROW OFF MY GROOVE.
I hope you are HAPPY NOW.

A Terrible Likeness
Read A Terrible Likeness
Celebrimbor had a little-known supernatural power – so little-known that not even his closest kin knew about it, in fact.
To explain: Usually, his mind worked in the way of a greedy octopus when it came to learning new things: it was eagerly making grabs all around with all appendages it had, trying to incorporate and ingest as much information as possible.
However, Celebrimbor had a mental switch. He could throw this switch voluntarily. Whenever he did so, the octopus vanished and was replaced by a consummate bureaucrat. The consummate bureaucrat was also a consummate arsehole in that he was never responsible for anything, that it was always past office hours, and if you so much as handed him something to process, he would throw it into a waste bin under his desk unread.
This worked great most of the times when he wanted to get people off his back with topics he did not want to talk about. Most got the message within a few moments and backed off.
Right now though Annatar did not get the message. Did not want to get the message, as Celebrimbor was beginning to suspect. Neither did he back off.
Instead, the Maia kept handing the mental bureaucrat a sheet of paper on which I AM SAURON was written in capital letters over and over again, and the bureaucrat was slowly but surely getting angry and anxious because he couldn’t ignore that information anymore and also his waste bin was flowing over and about to spill a hundred crumpled copies of I AM SAURON right over his office floor. Where he would have no choice but to read it. And understand what was written there.
The bureaucrat realized with horror that he was inefficient.
Celebrimbor realized that he had no choice but to intervene. He switched gears.
“Stop,” he said.
Annatar snapped his mouth shut.
“Stop,” Celebrimbor repeated, turning around from where he had stood staring out of the high window, hands clasped behind his back. “I heard you the first time.”
“You didn’t react,” Annatar said acridly, his fingers digging into the upholstery of the armrests of his chair.
“Aptly observed,” Celebrimbor commented. “Nonetheless, I have gone neither dumb nor deaf, so consider your information shared and your secret revealed. Thank you for your candour.”
Annatar stared at him. A few seconds ticked by in loaded silence. “Is that all that you are going to say?”
Celebrimbor narrowed his eyes, trying very hard to talk about a topic without spending time thinking about the topic, which was proving increasingly and irritably harder every second. “Excuse me, is there more that you wanted to hear?”
Annatar threw out his hands. “I don’t know! Probably! Maybe I expected to hear something that demonstrates that you have indeed heard and understood what I just told you – the weight of what I just told you!” He sounded agitated. He sounded desperate. Celebrimbor had never seen him like this before. He knew that Annatar needed something. To hear something, probably. Celebrimbor looked inside himself and found only a hollow place. He had nothing to give right now.
“What do you want me to say?” Celebrimbor asked flatly.
“I don’t know!” Annatar repeated. “Just –” He broke off. “Did you even understand what I was saying?”
“I understood you just fine.”
A few seconds passed in silence.
“So what?” Annatar said, rising from his armchair. “You don’t care?”
Celebrimbor went back to staring out of the window. His gaze snagged on the three peaks of Khazad-Dûm, black under the star-strewn night sky. He wished he could be there. If not in the city itself, even the frozen peak would do. Or somewhere else. Rhûn. Númenor. Lindon. Anywhere but here.
The image of a door kept rising inside his mind. A locked door, with no light seeping out from under it. Only pure darkness.
“Tyelperinquar.” Annatar’s voice sounded closer. Celebrimbor felt a vein pulse at his temple, his mouth twitched. Couldn’t the Maia let this go for just one minute?
“What,” Celebrimbor said, impatiently, and turned around.
Annatar was standing directly in front of him, his eyes too bright in the gloom of the dark room.
Celebrimbor didn’t flinch.
“Do you,” Annatar repeated, “not understand or do you not care about what I have just told you?”
“Don’t insult me,” Celebrimbor said quietly. “I have heard and understood you, Gorthaur.” The world felt like slicing his own tongue open with a serrated knife. A white-hot blade drove into Celebrimbor’s brain and for a moment, he had to fight to keep his balance, for a moment he had to fight to cling to his body, as his spirit seemed to want to catapult itself into the empty ether –
The Maia visibly recoiled.
“Is that proof enough for you?” Celebrimbor added sharply, secretly reaching out for the windowpane behind him to steady himself until he felt sure on his feet again.
For a moment, Annatar did not speak. “You aren’t –” he said. “You act like you are not even surprised.”
Celebrimbor remained silent. He stared at a point over Annatar’s shoulder, a piece of wall on the other side of the room where a crack had formed in the plaster.
“Tyelperinquar.” Annatar reached out, then quickly drew his hand back, as if he had thought better of touching the elf. “Speak to me.”
Speak to me.
About this?
There was door in his mind and dark things were behind it and something was pushing against it from the other side, trying to force it open, trying to let the dark things out, even though he had spent so much time and effort herding the things inside and locking the door after them and now – and now the darkness was seeping out and the lock was about to break and –
Celebrimbor pushed off the window, closed his eyes and took a deep breath, before turning back around to face Annatar again. “I am going to speak of this once, and then we are never going to mention it again,” he said. “Are we clear?”
Annatar did a strange thing then – for the briefest of moments, he half-turned around and his eyes flitted to the open door leading to Celebrimbor’s study behind him, as if he was expecting it to slam shut by some unknown force – as if Celebrimbor was capable of locking them both in here in the first place. It would have been disconcerting in any other moment, and he could have, should have wondered why a lesser god had it somehow ingrained in his brain to keep open escape routes – but right now the concern didn’t manage to reach the place where it would have stirred something inside Celebrimbor.
His mind and soul had gone cold and hard and reflective like a sheet of ice – or glass. Nothing found purchase, and the world and everything in it were one step removed, seen through a clear wall that separated him from everything.
The Maia regained his composure. Faced him. Nodded.
“I’ve known who you were ever since you stepped foot in this city for the first time,” Celebrimbor said.
Annatar went rigid.
“My aunt advised me to throw you out,” Celebrimbor continued, unfazed. “So did the High-king. Even though they didn’t know. All they had were suspicions.” He shrugged. “But I knew.”
“You knew?” Annatar said, almost inaudible. He took one step back. Then another.
“I did.”
“How?”
Celebrimbor smiled thinly. “You forget that I spent my childhood in Tirion having none other than Morgoth himself prowling the perimeter of our grounds. There are auras you do not forget in a lifetime. Its shadows were clinging to thickly to you that you might as well have been carrying them as a cloak. They do not just go away. My grandfather and my father never managed to get rid of them, either.”
Annatar was silent for a brief moment. “Half of the population of your city carries the same shadow. I could have been a prisoner in Angband.”
“Possibly.” Celebrimbor gave a one-sided shrug. “And I think your excellent lie by omission had many people fooled and led them to assume the seemingly obvious. The best lies are those with a kernel of truth, after all.” He smirked humourlessly, then the expression dropped off his lips. “But there were only so many Maiar that had gone to Beleriand and were unaccounted for or missing. Of those that had ties to Aulë and yet carried Morgoth’s darkness around their shoulders like a shroud – there were even less. Comparable to Gorthaur’s rank and power – only the one.”
Annatar didn’t speak for a long time. When he did, his voice was searching, uncertain, as if feeling its way forward in the dark in an unknown place.
“Why – why didn’t you chase me away?”
“Why indeed? What could propel someone to make such a clearly deranged decision?” Celebrimbor gave him a dark smile. Annatar did not smile back. His face was blank, devoid of any readable expression.
“I’ll tell you why,” Celebrimbor said, ambling closer. “Because I found you interesting. Incredibly, uncontainably dangerous, an unknown quantity, almost assuredly evil, yes, but interesting. Why had you come? What did you want? Were you pretending to have had a change of heart, or had you truly changed your ways? How did you intend to follow through with your grand claims of the grandest gifts given this side of the sea? What did you have to offer in that game you were clearly playing? I didn’t know. But I wanted to find out, and it is not as if I had much to lose either way. Which is why I let you in. And which is why I allowed you to stay.”
Annatar stared at him. For a moment it seemed he couldn’t speak. “‘You didn’t have much to lose?’ You wagered your own life.”
“You presume that it was something I put value in at the time.”
Annatar briefly hesitated, as if to argue, then went on, “You wagered an entire city and its people. Because you found me interesting.”
“I did. Which should tell you everything you need to know about judging the Fëanorians’ character.” Celebrimbor bared his teeth in a what was the caricature of a smile.
“But – but it was madness.”
“It was – but so what?” Celebrimbor shrugged carelessly. “Fëanor’s line has never had a great claim to sanity.”
“I – this.” Annatar halted. “You should have done it. It was dangerous. Is dangerous. You cannot allow a known enemy to get this close to you. This is going to kill you one day.”
Celebrimbor gave him a considering look, cocking his head slightly in an inquisitive manner. “Perhaps it will kill me. Then again, I don’t know. What say you, though? Is it going to kill me one day, Annatar?”
Annatar took a step back. “Are you implying – no – of course not.”
“Good.” Celebrimbor sat back down in his armchair and crossed his legs. “Then it seems I have nothing fear from you, doesn’t it?”
Annatar was still hovering around the doorframe, as if he was considering turning around and fleeing. He seemed to want to speak, seemed to grasp for words.
“But if you knew – if you were keeping up an act the entire time,” he asked haltingly. “What about the people around you? What about – everything else? Anything you said or did during this time – were we ever … was anything ever real?”
Celebrimbor regarded his fingernails. “Oh, I don’t know. I’m only the second most capable liar in this room right now. What would you say? Was anything ever real?”
Annatar reeled. He took a step back, nearly stumbling then caught himself on the doorframe. “Of course,” he croaked. “Of course. It might have started out as – as an experiment. But in time it turned – into something else.”
“There you go,” Celebrimbor said pleasantly. “I am relieved, I must say. I’d hate to think that I bound my soul to yours for nothing. Coincidentally, I’d also hate for you to think that I would do the binding for nothing else than sport and manipulation. I might have my bad sides, but I’d like to believe that I’m not quite as nihilistic and careless with myself as that.”
Another unwitting gesture – one that Celebrimbor was now sure that Annatar hadn’t realized he was making: the Maia’s hand twitched towards his sternum, where, as Celebrimbor now knew, the broken bond to Aulë had forever left its mark on his ëala and fana in the shape of a huge scar that spanned nearly his entire ribcage. Looking for a new tie, a new bond, a new fetter that he had gotten himself caught in, like a bird getting tangled in one of Ungoliant’s webs.
“I am not going to use it against you,” Celebrimbor said drily.
Annatar quickly pulled his hand away, caught.
“Except, of course, in case you would attempt to do harm to me or mine,” the elf added. “Which, I believe, you swore not to do three minutes ago.”
Annatar’s eyes flashed to him. “Did you do it on purpose? For that purpose?”
“No. I did it because I love you. I didn’t think of it as a weapon at the time.” Celebrimbor shrugged, then crossed one ankle over his knee.
“And yet here we are, each of us the other one’s dead man’s switch.”
“You know, you could just call it a soul-bond and make it sound a little less nefarious. The Eldar do it all the time when they marry.” He made an off-handed gesture. “Besides, the Severing is perfectly survivable. My mother and father lived, after all; I doubt it’s going to kill a god.”
“Except if the bond went deeper in a god than a mortal,” Annatar said sharply. “And if it were tied even more tightly and destructively to the very essence of their being.”
Celebrimbor considered this. “Yes,” he allowed. “Excepting that. There’s no precedence for a god breaking such bond. So I guess it would be wiser to simply … not try.”
Annatar’s eyes narrowed. “I didn’t think cruelty came so easily to you.”
“I told you before: I didn’t think of the bond as a weapon when I created it,” Celebrimbor said.
“I do not mean the bond. Or at least not only the bond.” Annatar crossed his arms, leaning against the doorframe of the open door to Celebrimbor’s study behind him in a very unconvincing display of anger and nonchalance. “You risked yourself for curiosity; and your entire city and your friends on top of that. You welcomed Gorthaur, knowing fully well who he was. So either you cared nothing for the lives of those you claim to love and for your own; or you do care and you still decided to take the risk. In any case, I didn’t think you were capable of being so ruthless.”
“That’s just the thing,” Celebrimbor said quietly. “You have no idea what I am capable of.”
The door in his mind was straining against something dark and fell throwing itself against it from the other side. Soon, if he didn’t walk away and stopped thinking about the things behind the door and thus agitating them, something would give, and all the darkness would come pouring out.
“I cannot fault you for it,” Celebrimbor added, almost absently. “You or anyone else. I am very good at acting the part, so most people think I am kind.”
Annatar raised both eyebrows. “You are implying you are not.”
“Not implying.” Celebrimbor looked at him. “I am not a good person. Never have been. I’ve merely had a few thousand years to realize that being nice will get me farther than being as antagonistic as my father and grandfather have been; and another few millennia to practice the pretence until it became second nature. It was a learning experience.”
Celebrimbor smiled coolly. “Practiced pleasantries. Measured, well-intentioned manipulation – of myself and others. Learning to relent. Coercing myself to cede ground. Learning to care for the concerns of others, even and especially if their desires ran contrary to my own. Studied selflessness – putting myself last and forcing myself to learn that I’m still going to get what I want and need, eventually.” He leaned back.
“I like to think that I succeeded. At times I manage to fool even myself into believing that I am a decent person.” He paused. Thought about this for a second. “But make no mistake – nothing of this came naturally to me. The person that you see here, now is the result of me taking hammer and chisel to my innermost self over the span of millennia and shaping something sympathetic and pleasant out of something that was thoroughly foul and broken.”
Annatar crossed his arms tighter. His shoulders were hunched, his posture tense, his lips a thin line. “Having to learn how to act according to societal norms doesn’t make you a bad person. It is the result that counts. You are a good man. If you weren’t before, you certainly are now. You are willing to learn. To do better. That has to count for something.”
Celebrimbor shook his head. “Even if it were so…” He trailed off. “Even if it were so, it doesn’t undo the things I have done.”
“What things?” Annatar asked. “What could you possibly have done that warrants –”
Celebrimbor grimaced, looked away.
He could no longer not think about it.
He could no longer not remember.
The door in his mind began to burst and splinter. Before it could break, Celebrimbor yanked it open, and the things he had locked away for thousands of years came pouring out like a tide of black tar.
“What could I possibly have done?” Celebrimbor stood from his chair. “I would have sworn the Oath, if my father had not forbidden me from doing so, and I would have done it gladly.” With every sentence, he took a step towards the Maia. “And yet, even if my father would not let me swear, I was determined to prove my worth to the cause of retrieving the Silmarils. By any means necessary. I was in the vanguard that invaded Alqualondë. I was the first at the side of Maedhros and Celegorm in the harbour. We cut loose the swan-ships, and when the sailors came out to stop us, we cut them down. And when their families, their friends, heard their cries, we cut those down, too.” Celebrimbor had stopped, standing three steps from Annatar, his eyes locked onto the past, unseeing in the present.
“The streets ran red with blood. The sea itself was foaming with it, like a stain of red wine that kept spreading upon a white tablecloth. That night the stars went dark, for not even Varda could bear to look upon what we had done.”
He paused. “I saw all this. I did all this. I heard their cries of anger, their pleas for mercy.”
He hesitated. “And I didn’t stop.”
Another pause.
“I did not even regret. I did not care. Not for – so long. Not until I realized the extent of the doom we had wrought. Until I stood at the new shore of a broken land where Beleriand had been before, and realized that this world would break ere the violence could end. But – ” His voice came out stumbling, nearly choked. “But where my uncles and my grandfather could at least claim to have been driven by the Oath –”
A strangled noise, almost unnatural coming from a living being. “I had been free. Nothing and no one had forced my hand, and what I decided to do with this freedom was to go forth with a sword in my hand and turn the Swan-havens into a site of slaughter.”
He looked up at Annatar. “Do you understand now?”
The Maia didn’t reply. Didn’t move. His eyes were fixed on Celebrimbor’s but nothing showed that he had heard or reacted. He seemed to be made of stone.
“This is what I did when given a free decision to act as I please,” the elf said. “This is where my innermost nature, free of fetters, took me. I can never undo this.”
There was a long silence.
“Then how do you go on from this?” Annatar asked, almost inaudibly.
“You don’t,” Celebrimbor replied. He buried his face in his hands. “You don’t. There are some damages that are too great to be fixed, some wrongs too terrible to be undone. There is nothing to repair, because what you broke is broken for good. There is nothing to forgive, because those who would have the power to forgive are dead.” He dragged his palm down his face, forced himself to stand upright even though he wanted to crumple up and vanish and cease to exist.
“I cut it off from me,” he continued. “Put it away, forgot about it, because there was nothing more to be done. I locked it up in a place where I would not have to look at it, gave myself the pretence of a clean slate, and I started over. Taught myself to be different. Taught myself to act and think differently. To do better, to be better – not out of hope for redemption, because it was either being buried by the past or burying the past instead. I chose the latter. I know it doesn’t solve anything. At the same time, nothing remains that can be solved.”
He looked at his hands. “There was nothing to be done. I have gone too far and now I must live with this. With the knowledge of my deeds. With the burden of my guilt.” He curled his fingers, then slowly uncurled them. “Some things, once done, are done.”
Annatar still hadn’t moved.
Seconds, minutes ticked by in silence. Or maybe they didn’t, and time had frozen like ice in midwinter, and this was the new forever – an eternity of wrongs never made right, of chances forever missed, of a discord never resolved. A melody whose last note would always be missing. Caught forever in stasis like a scene in a snow-globe.
As if on cue, thick white snowflakes began to fall outside. Heavy clouds drew a shroud over the starry night sky.
“You said you had no hope for redemption,” the Maia said at last. “Then why are you doing – this?” He made a slow, wide gesture, encompassing the room, the tower, the city outside, their projects, these high, ethereal dreams of a better world. “What does it matter even if we managed to make our plans come true and unmar the world – when you say that you are doomed anyway for the things you have done in the past? Why bother?”
“Just because I have committed atrocities in the past doesn’t mean I have grown incapable of doing good. Even if I can never be a good person, I can be better – in the time that remains to me.” Celebrimbor threw him a long glance. “Even without hope for redemption, I feel it would befit me to do good without the prospect of personal gains. If I stand to gain nothing from it, I can at least be sure that my motivations are genuine rather than self-serving.” He averted his gaze, looking out at the greying night. Already the roofs of the spires and houses below were paling to white.
“What about you?” Celebrimbor asked at last. “Why did you bother?”
Annatar wasn’t looking at him. He was staring at a point on the floor about three feet from the tips of his left white boot. “I was bored,” he said at last, not looking up. “After the disaster of the First Age I had been wandering aimlessly, without goal or objective. I wanted a diversion.”
Celebrimbor crossed his arms and leaned back. “And? Have we been suitably entertaining? What is your verdict after five hundred years of having your own animated dollhouse to play with?”
Words like knives. If only it weren’t so easy to use them.
Annatar threw him a glower, and yes, briefly, there was something else visible in his eyes – something that Celebrimbor had heretofore artfully ignored, but spoke of darker fires, buried deep. “You know you are not a plaything.”
“I certainly started out as one.”
“Things can change. You said so yourself.”
“I did. Speaking for and of me.”
“I changed as well.”
“Did you now.”
“You’re not bound and chained in a cell, for one, but standing here and mouthing off to me.”
Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “Excuse me. I wasn’t aware that your standards for betterment were this atrociously low.”
“You know what I mean,” Annatar snarled. “I have made an effort to change. It might have been a masquerade in the beginning, but it – became something else.”
“While that may be true, you and I remain the same,” Celebrimbor said. “We are not magically different people. We are horrible beings who once made terrible choices – and now made different ones that are hopefully better. We are our past as much as our present and future.”
He rubbed his closed lids, suddenly feeling empty and very tired. He went back to his armchair and sat down, resting his elbows on his knees and watching the snowflakes fall and shroud the world outside in white.
He was silent for a while. “Maybe that was one reason why it was so easy to let you stay. I … saw myself in you. And I deserved you. The best of you … but the worst, too. If I could believe in someone like you turning his life around, there had to be hope for me, as well.”
Soft footfalls told him that Annatar had followed. Not very far, not nearly as close as he would have stood on any other day, but he had moved from his post at the door to stand a few steps behind Celebrimbor’s seat.
“You are nothing like me,” the Maia said quietly.
Celebrimbor shrugged. “I think we’re very much alike.”
“I disagree.”
“You are free to do so.”
Silence.
“Did it never occur to me to send me away? Didn’t knowing who I was affect your view of me in any way?”
“No.” Celebrimbor kept staring at the snowfall, his eyes losing focus, the flakes dissolving into mesmerizing patterns, fractals, spirals, as if there was a higher mind, a great divine geometry and intention behind it all. Valar, he was so tired. “I lock these things away. The First Age. Who I was then. Who you were. Many other things. I know of them, but I do not think of them. I have to keep looking forward, or else – ” He broke off. “I have to keep looking forward.”
“Except for tonight.”
Celebrimbor nodded. His feet and hands felt cold. He would have to pay for opening that door in his memories – if not right now, then later. But it couldn’t be helped.
Some things, once done, are done.
He would survive the aftermath of this, as he had always done when the door had opened in the past, and he would lock the room full of dark memories once more, and life would go on as it always did.
“Does anyone else know?”
Celebrimbor turned his head, glancing at the Maia who was watching him, shrouded in shadow.
“I didn’t tell anyone.”
“That is not the answer to my question.”
Celebrimbor shrugged. “I don’t know. I am certain that my aunt would have put two and two together, had she gotten to know you any better and gotten a sense of the real extent of your power. The same goes for the High-king, for she has his ear and his trust. They were suspicious. Remain so, to this day. But I guess distance was and remains your best disguise. You cannot unmask someone who is beyond your arm’s reach.”
“There are more people in the world than your aunt. Smarter ones, too.”
“Not many.”
“And yet.”
Celebrimbor thought about it. “And yet.”
Half of Ost-in-Edhil’s population was comprised of survivors of Angband: people too damaged and broken to ever find a place again in this world – or so they had believed. Until they had found a place among like minds and hearts, and found that there might yet be a nook for them in this day and age. They bore the shadow of Angband on their hearts, and they recognized its likeness in others with the ease and instinct of wolves of the same pack knew each other’s scent.
Celebrimbor had no doubt that the former prisoners recognized something in the Maia: somethingt that must seem at first glance like a terrible likeness of kinship in pain, in imprisonment. To a sharper eye, however, a damaged soul, sensitive to any shadow of remembrance, to an echo of an old torment –
One might have seen – recognized – remembered – and still, and still –
There were so many reasons to remain silent. So many ways to lose your memories, to lose your voice. To lose your will to act. Chief of them self-delusion, hope against hope, that things were not the way all your senses told you that they were. A rabbit cowering in the grass, a shadow falling across its trembling form, and yet it kept thinking, Let it not be the fox, let it not be the fox, and if it is the fox, let it not have seen me; and if it has seen me, let it not be hungry, let it be full and content, just curious, not out for harm –
Celebrimbor sighed. “I do not know about any of the others,” he said. “I am not going to ask. If you need to assuage any fears on that front, you will need to do it yourself.”
Silence followed in the wake of that statement. Fabric rustled softly when Annatar moved. Quiet steps. Closer.
“What –” Annatar broke off. Another few seconds passed in oppressive stillness. “How do we go on? From here?”
Celebrimbor shrugged, watching the snow fall outside. “As we always have. Nothing has changed. We’ll go on as we did before. The past is past.”
For a moment, nothing happened. Then, suddenly, there was a shadow between him and the still panorama of falling snow against a midnight sky. Golden eyes glared down at him.
“You will not pretend that tonight did not happen.”
“I’d ask you to leave the decision of how I go about dealing with personal matters to me,” Celebrimbor said, frowning. He resisted the impulse to stand, instead looking up at the shade staring down at him.
“I will not.”
“How I deal with tonight – or any other night, for that matter – is not your concern,” Celebrimbor replied, a sharp edge creeping into his voice, like a sword sliding out of a sheath. Not yet a threat, but a warning that could quickly complete the transformation.
Annatar leaned down, gripping the armrests of Celebrimbor’s chair, effectively locking him into his seat. “No,” he hissed. “Because this concerns me as much as it concerns you. I came to you because I wanted to be honest with you. You will not pretend that this never happened, even if you did know before. I will not have my decision thrown back in my face and made irrelevant by your refusal to face unsavoury parts in either of our lives.”
“Careful there,” Celebrimbor murmured, glancing down at Annatar’s fingers, which were digging into the upholstery like claws. “We wouldn’t want those unsavoury parts to make a reappearance, would we, Annatar?”
Annatar recoiled as if the elf had struck a whip across his face. Then his expression darkened. “Come out and say the name, if you can bear it, Curufinwë. But do not play craven games with me.”
“I’m merely reminding you that I have not forgotten who you are,” Celebrimbor said, remaining seated even though his instincts screamed at him to get to his feet and defend himself, or run, or fight.
“Good,” Annatar growled. “Then face it. Remember it. Throw me out or let me stay, abhor me or love me. Do it because of who I am, or in spite of who I was, if you so choose. But you will look at me when you make your choice. At all of me.”
Celebrimbor’s mouth twitched in anger. “What, just because you decided tonight that you were done living a lie you will force me to do the same? Who made you the tyrant of truth?”
Annatar stood stock-still. For a moment, Celebrimbor wondered whether the Maia would be able to hold on to his fraying patience. He could feel a pressure in the room, a building heat, as if they were locked in a sealed crucible, the heat of the fire outside growing, and it was only a matter of time before everything in the crucible woupd be unmade: every bond of affection between them dissolved im the white-hot furnace of truth and fear and wrath.
“That you should name truth ‘tyranny’ is all the answer you need,” Annatar said at last. “I will not be either tolerated or loved in ignorance, even if it be wilful.” He stepped closer and reached out.
Instinctively, Celebrimbor flinched back, but when Annatar’s hand landed on his shoulder, there was no violence in his grip. It was firm, but painless.
“I cannot force you to look at me, Tyelperinquar,” Annatar said. “But I can say that neither do I want nor am I able to do what you did and pretend that nothing has changed.” His grip tightened. “I will not be held hostage by my past any longer – and I would want you to not be, either.”
“It might not be possible to be free from it,” Celebrimbor responded quietly, meeting the Maia’s gaze.
“I seem to recall the saying, ‘Impossible is just an excuse to tell yourself so you can stop trying in good conscience’.” Annatar inclined his head slightly.
Celebrimbor raised his gaze. “Bold of you to quote my own father at me right now, Annatar. Tactless, I might even say.”
“Does being tactless make what I said any less true?”
That, at last, forced a shade of a smirk out of Celebrimbor. “No. It doesn’t.” He sighed and ran a hand through his hair, serious once more. “I have tried to work through this, Annatar. For years and years. I have little hope that I would succeed, given another try.”
“Then do away with hope,” Annatar said curtly. “I seem to recall that spite is an excellent motivator for you Curufinwës.”
That startled a laugh out of Celebrimbor, more surprised than amused. “Of all the moments to bring this up! You could have appealed to my better nature, you know.”
“I know better than to scream into the void. Let us work with what we have.”
“What do we have?” Celebrimbor replied. “Mistakes and horrors and broken things.”
“Then we work with those,” Annatar said simply. “We are good enough to do that. We are the best there are.” He grabbed Celebrimbor’s hands. “And after all, what was your goal if not to create something beautiful of the wreckage of a bygone age? If there is anyone who can turn all his faults around into something good, it is you.”
Celebrimbor stared at their joined hands. “You really want to believe in this,” he said.
“I have to,” Annatar replied. “Who else am I supposed to believe in at this point?”
Celebrimbor nodded almost absently, then it struck him what Annatar had said.
Who. Not what.
His eyes widened and he looked at the god standing before him.
Annatar’s face was serious.
“I –” Celebrimbor began. “I might not –” He broke off once more, because how did you tell a god – who had decided to simply turn the ways of the universe on their head and put his faith in a mortal – how did you tell anyone who had chosen to believe in you, of all things, that they were wrong, their trust misplaced, their hope in vain?
Ah, but perhaps we must truly do without hope.
Celebrimbor shook his head, running his hands down his face.
“I cannot promise anything,” he said. “I will not swear.”
“I do not want you to swear,” Annatar said. “I want you to try.”
Celebrimbor nodded. Only now did he notice that cold sweat had drenched his clothes and stuck his shirt to his back, that his hands were clammy and his fingers stiff. He exhaled, long and slow.
“So, Tyelperinquar Curufinwë,” Annatar said. “What do you want me to do?”
Celebrimbor glanced at him out of the corner of his eye. This black shade with golden eyes, this nightmare of so many that were no longer around to tell of it. The past seemed to have caught up with Morgoth’s lieutenant, and the darkness seemed to have consumed him.
What shall it be?
Stay or leave? Abhorrence or love? Or both, divided in equal measure to the parts deserving it, respectively? A cloven existence, both of memory and of perception?
How was a sane mind to achieve this? How was a sane spirit to unite such violent opposition within itself?
Celebrimbor had no idea.
For now, he recalled only what Annatar had told him:
Throw me out or let me stay, abhor me or love me. Do it because of who I am, or in spite of who I was, if you so choose. But you will look at me when you make your choice. At all of me.
Celebrimbor looked at the Maia, darkness peeling back before his Eldarin sight, revealing the familiar face, the golden eyes and hair, the white robes, a being nearly shadowless in its appearance. A stark contrast to the shade with burning eyes.
And yet, that is not the truth either, is it?
Celebrimbor turned around to face the Maia fully.
“Show me who you are,” he said quietly. “Who you truly are.”
For a brief moment, there was surprise on the Maia’s face. Annatar had always shied back from being seen, retreated behind layers and layers of defence and deflection. All his attempts to lay himself bare he had either resisted or unwittingly subverted. And yet, tonight he had asked for it. He could not back away now, and he knew it.
“It is not a pleasant form to look upon,” Annatar warned. “It was made before mortals came to be, and was not made for their eyes to behold.”
“I know,” Celebrimbor said evenly. “I wish to see it. Show me.”
Annatar regarded him for a moment, then he nodded in acquiescence, and, perhaps, surrender. He closed his eyes. The shadows pulled across him, a darkness that not even Celebrimbor’s eyes could penetrate – and then there was light. Red and gold. Wheels of fire. Something like clockworks of iron, interlocking with black spikes and turning in more than three dimensions at once, folding into themselves like in hypergeometry, more machinery than living thing. Veins of magma running through channels like hot iron in a forge along things that were not limbs, plasma lightning flashing along the contours, jumping in white-blue arcs across the form. Something like two great wings unfolded, lines of fire running along joints spreading like the fingers of a hand, and the primordial void before creation was in its membranes. Higher dimensions kept clipping through the form of the eldritch horror, and the ceiling and walls of the room were suddenly far removed, as if the world itself had bent away to accommodate that which had no place in it.
And there were wounds. Celebrimbor could see them, absences, voids, tears in reality where something had once been and had been taken away, twisted, mangled. A bleeding red, pulsating star in the middle of the creature’s … body, for lack of a better word. It was an old wound, bleeding an ancient pain that was nearly as old as existence itself, and far older than this world that they were now standing in. Then: chains. Shadow and void, not truly there and yet all over the creature like mist overlaying it – broken in some places, strong and cruel in others. They wrapped and wafted around it, ghostly, intangible, yet unable to be shaken. Where they touched the essence of the eldritch creature, they erased it. An Unmaking, a destruction that was so thorough that it bordered on deletion, echoing backwards into time, as if there had never been anything there at all. The youngest wound was another tear, another bleeding indent near the head of the creature – it was more real than the others, forcing the eldritch form into something resembling… corporeality in its immediate vicinity. Puncturing holes, arranged in two great arcs. The bite marks of a giant hound.
But there was also something else: where the red pulsar glowed dully in the void at the centre of the Maia’s chest, there was another glow: white and bright and radiant, and from it emanated - not a ray, but something glowing and woven, almost like a tether. It ran away from the creature’s form, crossed the space between them, and found it’s ending point in another point of light that glowed just where Celebrimbor’s heart was beating inside his ribcage.
As Celebrimbor looked at the being in front of him, its form shifted, its indefinite, incomprehensible hyper-dimensional form shifting slightly into something that was a little less eldritch, a little more familiar. The room returned to its usual dimensions.
Celebrimbor could discern something that was a head, a torso, four limbs. There was still fire, there were still wheels of iron – but he thought he could begin to see how the first layers of a form had been created from a being that was so far removed from anything comprehensible to mortal eyes. Magma steamed and hissed as it flowed along the form of the creature, the veins lighting up and dimming almost with the rhythm of a breath. In its ribcage something flashed through interlocking cogwheels, the black iron braces, the veins of fire that flowed along its form. The wingspan took up the entire room, its tips burning scorch marks into the ceiling.
ARE YOU AFRAID, TYELPERINQUAR?
The voice resonated directly in his mind, and even though Celebrimbor knew that the primordial spirit had already softened its might so as not to drive him mad, the immediacy of it was nigh-enough to shake every sensible thought apart into madness and instinct and reflex.
And yet he let none of it show on his face. Slowly, Celebrimbor stepped up to the creature. “Do you think that I would still be here, if I had an ounce of fear of you in me?” He raised his hand and laid it onto the cheek of the eldritch face. Under his fingers, it began to flow and transform into the features of a being he should have hated until the end of time, and yet had chosen to love until his very soul was destroyed. He touched his other hand to the bite marks of Huan, ran his fingers along the chains of Morgoth on the creature’s arms, the bleeding scar of Annatar’s severed bond to Aulë in the middle of his chest. Something in the Maia’s essence recoiled, but in the end, the spirit remained where it was. Celebrimbor sensed an old, ancient desire to hide and cloak and shadow, but the Maia stayed how he had been – bright and open and burning.
Celebrimbor regarded the marks imprinted on this form: witnesses of a lifetime that was so far beyond his comprehension like a ship that had gone beyond the horizons of Eldamar would have been to Men or Dwarves.
“So we were both right, in the end,” he said quietly. “You needed to show yourself. I needed to look.”
Annatar’s eyes looked back at him, the one familiar thing in an otherwise unknowable entity.
“I see you now,” Celebrimbor said.
The creature was very still.
“And I you,” Annatar’s voice replied at last.
Celebrimbor smiled. Then he stepped forward into the fire, and the flames leapt to meet him. The great wings closed around him like a chrysalis of flame and void, enveloping both him and the spirit, and then he was gone.
Chapter End Notes
Tl;dr of this chapter:
Annatar: i am basically sauron and i'm sorry but you're locked in here with me now
Celebrimbor: yeah no see that's where you are wrong. you are locked in here with me
Annatar: fuck
(does it show that I like semi-dark Celebrimbor)
Also, I'm probably unreasonably proud of "Who made you the tyrant of truth?"
Interlude: Broken Mask
Read Interlude: Broken Mask
Annatar found Daeror in his music room, which was no surprise, since the bard basically lived there, with the exception of hours that he spent annoying the Guildmembers and Annatar in particular.
For some unfathomable reason, there was a billiards table in the middle of the room right next to the grand piano, and the orchestral instruments were gathered in a half-circle around the table like schoolchildren watching and waiting for their teacher. Meanwhile, Daeror was perched at the table, a sheaf of sheet music next to him that he was scribbling away at fervently, while absent-mindedly pushing the cue ball around entire table in a perfect rhombus across three banks.
Throw. Tock. Tock. Tock. Return to the hand. Throw. Tock. Tock. Tock. Back in his hand. And again.
The bard didn’t even look up while doing so, rolling around the ball with his left hand, while filling the lines and lines of music sheets with his indecipherable handwriting with his right.
Annatar stood and waited until the bard looked up and noticed him. Which he did only after Annatar lost patience after waiting for about ten minutes without acknowledgement and cleared his throat.
Daeror had seen better days – that much could be said for any intense period of work right before he finished another piece – but it was quite pronounced this time around. His clothing and usually artfully styled hair were dishevelled, his eyes bleary, and his gaze took a few seconds to focus on Annatar.
“Well, hello there,” the bard said, a grin working itself over his tired face. “What brings you here into the venerable halls of music and melody?”
Annatar shrugged as he walked closer, dragging his finger across the open lid of the grand piano, inspecting it for dust, finding nothing, and coming to stand beside Daeror, close enough to be able to peer over his shoulder. “Nothing in particular. What are you working on?”
Daeror pulled an empty sheet over the last page he had written on. “My newest masterpiece. Which you are going to have to wait for until Yule, like everyone else.”
“Pity.” Annatar looked around the music room. “I will not ask why you are sitting at a billiards table, or the logistics or sense of getting it into the middle of a practice room intended for the orchestra. I will, however, ask why you called a conference of instruments in order to compose.”
Daeror looked at the instruments arranged in an orderly semi-circle, and frowned as if it was taking him some time to remember who put them there and why. “Ah. Well. You see, we can work on the arrangement better this way. Keeps them from talking all over each other. The violins especially tend to get disorderly. Little spotlight-hoggers. Just because they feature prominently this time. Immediately went to their pegs, so I had to take them down a few notches by placing them in the back.”
Annatar acknowledged the mention of talking, sentient instruments with the same equanimity of everyone who had spent more than a year around Daeror. He tore his gaze away from the violins, which weren’t look very penitent, if he was being honest, and focused on the bard.
“And they are more well-behaved if you arrange them in a circle like school children?”
“Surprisingly yes. Ordered placement seems to translate to orderly behaviour, and that way the strings don’t shout over everything else and mess up the colours.” Daeror looked down at his sheet music.
“The colours.”
“Yes. I can see it in my head when the colours of the melodies and chords don’t match. This means that the music will be bad.”
Annatar thought about this. They had composed together, before. They had not talked about synaesthesia.
“Not colours for you, then?” Daeror asked, eyebrow quirked.
“No.” Annatar shrugged. “Multidimensional matrices. Also functions. If they’re holomorphic, the music tends to sound better. Probably because they’re differentiable at any given point, so holomorphic music sounds smoother. Also there is the possibility of variance through analytic continuation.”
“I won’t even pretend that I understood anything of what you just said,” Daeror said.
“You could, if you deigned to use your brain for something useful for once.”
“Music is useful.”
“Within limitations.”
Daeror looked up at him. “I will never be able to understand the fact how you, a god, can malign the finest and oldest of the arts. I mean, you were literally there when the universe was Sung into being. You took part in it.”
“I do not malign music. I just like math better,” Annatar replied. “Besides, they are two sides of the same coin anyway. I just happen to prefer the more analytical side of it.”
“Colour me outrageously and egregiously unsurprised.”
“I live to unsurprise you.”
“I know.” Daeror squinted up at him. “Alright. Out with it. Why are you really here?”
“Can I not visit my best friend to have a brief chat?” Annatar drawled.
“Now I’m scared.”
“I’m being nice.”
“I know. That is why I am scared.”
Annatar huffed. “I wanted to see how you were doing.”
“You know, I know what you sound like when you lie.”
Annatar raised an eyebrow. “Do you now?”
“Yes. From one professional liar to another, you have to step up your game.” Daeror stood and walked over to the grand piano with three pieces of sheet music in hand, stared intensely at the keys for a moment. Some unheard communication seemed to pass between him and the big instrument, then Daeror laid the paper on the frame and scribbled down some notes.
As the bard wrote, Annatar’s eyes were, against his will, drawn to Daerorʼs hands. Contrary to what one might expect of a professional musician whose livelihood depended on them, they were neither fine-bonded nor hale. Instead, the skin was scarred in multiple places, healed in ugly welts and criss-crosses. There was a burn scar across the back of his hand. The joints were swollen and crooked in places, as if his fingers had been broken multiple times and healed badly.
Annatar looked away, closed his eyes, drew a breath, and opened them again. “Speaking of lies,” he began.
The scratching of Daeror’s pen stopped and the bard looked up. “Hm?”
“The old story that an ex-lover of yours slammed the piano lid on your hands and that this is why your hands look like this. That was a lie, too, wasn’t it?”
Daeror blinked, then looked down at his hands. “Ah,” he said. “Well.”
Annatar crossed his arms. Leaned against the piano, but didn’t look at the bard directly, fixing his gaze on the tips of his shoes instead.
Out of the corner of his vision, he saw Daeror put the pen aside, then turn over his hands. “A half-truth, though fairly transparent one, I guess.” Daeror looked at Annatar. “Good enough to provide an explanation to turn most inquiring gazes aside, fragile enough to fall to pieces at the first instance of real scrutiny.”
There was a loaded pause.
“Isn’t that right?” the bard asked.
Annatar didn’t reply for a few moments. “I don’t remember your face,” he said at last, his voice very quiet, his tone flat.
“I didn’t expect you to,” Daeror replied, slowly sitting down on the piano stool. He examined his fingers. “What are faces in a world full of masks? Craftsmen remember their handiwork, though, don’t they?” He looked down at his hands.
Annatar didn’t flinch, but it was a close thing. He kept his gaze lowered, fixed on his boots. He found he couldn’t look at the bard. “I don’t remember your hands, either.”
“Which is a good thing,” Daeror said. “Because I wouldn’t be here if we had met face to face before. There were torture chambers you could walk – be carried back out of. Yours didn’t number among them. Thankfully I was never important enough to merit your attention.”
Annatar took a deep breath. “Why did they catch you?”
“I was part of a travelling circus back then. I was alone, they needed someone to structure their acts and build a cohesive story around them.” Daeror shrugged. “Also, I can be a mean cardsharp if I want to be, which is always good for additional income. They warned us against travelling the North. We did it anyway, thinking the people there might need some levity the most. We were right, of course. But so where those who had warned us. There was an ambush. Near Tol Sirion.”
“So – wrong place, wrong time?”
Daeror nodded. “I never found out another reason for the capture. Which, frankly, is probably the only reason a third of us made it out alive. We were never important. We were simply collateral damage in a war that wasn’t ours. Playthings. Toys to break for cruel children, but never enough to warrant the attention of the architects who created the war. Lucky me, right?”
There was another silence, longer this time.
Annatar stood very still. Still with his arms crossed. Still staring at the floor. “For what it’s worth,” he said. “I am sorry.”
It was a bizarre apology, and equally as inadequate. Like throwing a bucket of water onto the ruins of a house that had burnt down a century ago. Too little, too late. The house should never have been set on fire in the first place.
“Thank you. That means a lot.”
At that, Annatar forced himself to look up. Daeror wasn’t looking back, he had gone to staring at the keyboard of the piano, trying out a melody. It began as something slow and sad, then, abruptly, inverted into a joyous arpeggio that crashed like a violent discord into the gloomy atmosphere in the room.
“I think I’m going to use this,” Daeror said to no one in particular. He didn’t take his eyes off the keys. He also did not get up to write the melody down. He probably didn’t need to, considering his eidetic memory. However, there were probably other reasons why he stayed seated.
Like the fact that his face had lost all colour and his hands were trembling so hard on the keys that he kept pressing them inadvertently.
“Oh no. This is bad,” Daeror said, his tone strangely dispassionate as he regarded his shaking hands.
Annatar hesitantly pushed off the piano. “Are you – you are not fine.”
“I don’t think I am.”
Annatar hesitated. “Do you need – should I leave?”
“Ah. No. Stay. Just don’t come any closer for the moment. I need to ... Hm. Work. Through This. Give me a minute.”
“You are having a panic attack.”
“Thank you, dear, I would never have realized.”
Annatar halted – and forewent saying whatever he had been about to say. He turned around, walked a few paces away and sat down on one of the stools for the violinists, out of sight from behind the grand piano. Sighing, he buried his face in his hands. And waited.
A few minutes passed in agonized silence. Suddenly, Daeror jumped up and hurried over to his chaotic sheaf of sheet music on the billiards table and began writing something down with almost manic speed.
Annatar straightened a bit, letting his hands drop. “Are you better?”
“I am going to kick myself if I don’t write this down,” Daeror said, which was an absolute non-sequitur to anything that had happened, and thus didn’t merit a response.
Annatar walked over to him. “Does this mean that you are feeling better?” he repeated instead.
Daeror waved it off. “Water under the bridge,” he said, scribbling away. “I’m fine.”
“At the risk of digging my own grave here, I do not think that you can describe anything about this as ‘water under the bridge’.”
“I can, and I will.” Daeror looked up, his green eyes very bright. His smile did not reach his eyes. “The past is past. There is no use dwelling on any of this. Therefore I shan’t.”
“But –”
“Annatar, I’ve had control taken away from me in the First Age in every aspect imaginable. My body was no longer mine, my life wasn’t, not even my mind. The only thing I can do now is to choose how much I am going to let this past affect me. And I am going to exert the full extent of that liberty, because I can. So yes: water under the bridge.”
And just like that, the past had been neatly put in a box, sealed thrice, and shoved aside in a mind-boggling sleight of hand.
Daeror kept on writing.
Annatar watched him work a while longer, and was summarily ignored.
“I could heal your hands,” he said at last.
“And offer you an easy way out of the guilt plaguing you that could, by your own admission, never ever be water under the bridge?” Daeror didn’t look up. “I think not.”
“You are only hurting yourself by keeping the wounds. I do not care either way.”
“I’m not hurting anymore. I have not been hurting in a long time.” Daeror paused. “Or if I have, I hadn’t noticed. You get used to these things.” He frowned. “Anyway, don’t you think I am going to leave an even greater mark on history if I remain one of the best composers and musicians not because of my physical haleness, but on the contrary, despite my defective hands?”
“So they are defective.”
“I’m not as nimble with my fingers as I used to be. One reason why I abandoned card tricks, to be honest. I could never again do them the way I did when I was younger.” Daeror gave a snort that was supposed to sounded amused, but fell flat in the ensuing silence. “And yet, I am still better than the lot of those modern upstarts that would name themselves the ‘heirs of Maglor’. Really, how inflated does an ego have to be?” He shook his head, clucking his tongue.
Annatar let him write on a few moments longer, then he could not keep silent any longer. “You were afraid of me. Just now.”
“I am afraid of you all the time,” Daeror corrected calmly.
Annatar rested his hand on the edge of the billiards table. He picked up the black ball that lay abandoned at the edge of the table, then set it down again. “How, then?”
“How what?”
“Everything. You do not act afraid. You do not look afraid. You keep riling me up. You tease me. You never take me seriously. If you had asked me yesterday, I am certain I would have claimed that there was not a thing in the world that could scare you.”
“Good,” Daeror said. “Then the mask worked as intended.”
“But –”
“Masks, Annatar,” Daeror chided gently. “Do I really have to explain the idea to you, of all people? Showing fear in the face of a dragon rarely ends well.”
“Neither does poking it with a stick.” Annatar grabbed the bank of the table, his fingers digging into the green cover fabric. “And yet you do it all the time.”
“Yes,” Daeror said pensively, his hands sliding from the notation lines for the piano up to the woodwinds. “I do.”
“Why. It doesn’t make sense.”
“Doesn’t it?” Daeror looked up, staring at a point in the middle distance. “I think ... if I keep poking the dragon and it doesn’t eat me when it is angry at me, it stands to reason that it will not do so in any other situation, too. Then I know for sure.”
Annatar regarded him, his brows drewn together. “So you push until something gives.”
“Or doesn’t give, as it were.” Daeror threw him a sideglance. “Either way, if I know what I am in for at the breaking point, I know what I am in for in every other moment.”
And what was left to add, to that? In a capricious war that had killed and maimed millions without rhyme or reason, sacrificed like so many worthless pawns on chessboard populated by a few cruel, overwhelmingly powerful queens and kings, certainty became a currency rarer and more valuable than gold.
But would care about the nameless? Who would even think to ask what they needed? Who would offer to grant it?
The history books belonged to the kings and queens, the lords and gods, the shakers and movers; not to the lowly common folk, whose only appearance in history, whose only acknowledgement came in the form of population counts, army sizes, death tolls. Theirs were lives written in the margins of the existence of the great ones, fates reduced to statistics, names to numbers.
Nobody cared about the fate of the smallfolk. Not then, not now. So who were the mighty ones to deprive the dispossessed of the last bastion they could hold, even if it was as miserable and lowly as being able to stake out the conditions and perimeter of death and danger, if absence of fear itself had become impossible?
Annatar let out a long breath and did something he rarely did: He let the point go. Granting, in his limited, lacking way: certainty, if nothing else. If only for this moment, here and now.
“Having tested my nerves far beyond their breaking point, does that mean you can stop annoying me now?” he asked instead.
The grin that broke across Daeror’s features this time was genuine. “Annatar, I will never stop annoying you. This is no longer about testing you, this is a matter of principle. You deserve every second of me annoying you, and then some.”
“I guess I do.”
“I am thrilled that you agree.”
“Acknowledgement does not equal agreement.” Annatar gave him a flinty side-glance. “And it absolutely does not equal approval.”
“I can live a fulfilled, happy life without your approval, my snarky, slightly evil friend.”
“Unfortunately.”
“Ah, come now.” Daeror got up and stacked the mess of his papers into a incrementally neater pile. Which still looked horrible. Which Annatar would have pointed out, if he had been feeling mean. “You would miss me the second I was gone. In fact, I am sure you would resurrect me instantly, were some ill fate ever to befall me, because you cannot go on living without me.”
Annatar rubbed his temple. “Who am I to shoot down your self-delusions?”
“Exactly.” He walked over to where the Maia was standing. “Come, let us walk. I’ve been cooped up in here for days; I desperately need some air.”
*
They went into the gardens situated in the Third Ring. At this time of year, it was the washed-out dreary panorama of mid-November, the radiant colours of nature in summer and autumn reduced to the near-monochrome of winter. The sun was a pale, nearly white coin in an endless white-grey sky.
At first they didn’t speak much, just walking next to each other in pensive silence. Daeror kept throwing glances down into the city, then walked over to the wall and leaned on it, looking down at the sprawl of houses and streets, fates and lives beneath them, a microcosm in miniature.
“Is this like gods feel when they watch us?” Daeror asked. “I am only a lowly mortal bard, so what I experience must needs be a shadow of the truth, but oftentimes writing feels like looking down at a world small enough to hold in the palm of my hand, and everything on the pages existing at my will and whim.”
Annatar followed him. “Writing is more artful than divinity,” he said flatly. “Divinity doesn’t reason, there is no grand design at the end, no moral of the story. It is no more sophisticated than a child twisting a stick until it either bends or breaks.”
“The proverbial stick being creation itself?”
“In a matter of sense, yes.”
“Oh.” Daeror looked up. “I’ll admit, I am a bit disappointed that there is no grand design, no grand finale intended for us by the Valar or Eru himself. Then again, there is no god of Story, is there?”
“The Weaver, possibly.” Annatar shrugged. “Whether she can hold her own against the combined idiocy of her kindred I wouldn’t know. You’ve seen what Morgoth alone did to the world.”
“I assumed his siblings stood against him because they wanted something other than chaos.”
“Opposition to a foreign agenda is not a standpoint”, Annatar said acridly. “It is an echo, a reaction. But it doesn’t create substance where there is only void. They have no agency that hasn’t been given to them by the one they call ‘Eru’, and no goals other than to thwart their brother. You will notice how absent they have been ever since Melkor has been thrown into the void.”
Daeror’s face was pensive. “True. I assumed it was because their desire for peace had been restored. But I guess the next thing you’ll say is that stasis and peace are not an agenda, either.”
“Yes.”
Daeror threw him a side-glance, dark mirth in his eyes. “Don’t I know you well,” he said slowly.
“The entire guild knows me well enough to be able to make this prediction.”
“Touché. We know and adore our Maiar obsessed with plans and efficiency.”
Annatar raised an eyebrow. “You have more than one? I am devastated. Here I was, thinking you’d be true to me, and only me.”
“Ah, well, you know what they say about contingencies...”
“Contingencies are for cowards.”
“So you say we should release the backup Maia we’ve been keeping locked up in the cellar all the time?”
“Yes. Let them out. I am the best there is anyway.”
“And the most humble.”
“Yes.”
“Not to forget the smartest.”
“Mhm.”
“The craftiest.”
“Quite.”
“The nicest.”
“Well...”
“The bestest, smartest, craftiest, fluffiest Maia.”
“What.”
“You heard me.”
Annatar glared at the bard. “I am not fluffy.”
“Says you. But who’s to say that you aren’t spiky on the outside and fluffy on the inside?”
“I am not fluffy.”
“That you know of.”
Annatar turned on his heel and walked away.
Daeror laughed under his breath and jogged after him. “Wait up!”
Annatar didn’t reply. Perhaps he even walked a bit faster. Celebrimbor was right: spite was an excellent motivator. Unfortunately, Daeror wasn’t one of the sports-averse artists that were reduced to huffing and puffing by a brief sprint. No, he also was despicably athletic, and like everything else about him, his vigour seemed to exist for the sole purpose of destroying the last bit of Annatar’s nerves and patience.
“You simply abandoned me,” Daeror complained.
“Yes, that was the intention,” Annatar replied drily, looking straight ahead. “Unfortunately, my plan did not go as I would have liked.”
“Standing up your date is bad form. I don’t even know how Tyelperinquar puts up with you.” Daeror frowned. “Speaking of which, where is the good fellow?”
Annatar hesitated, the moment’s good cheer suddenly evaporated. “He ... he isn’t feeling well.”
“Is that so? I could have sworn I saw him walk to his lectures yesterday.” Daeror raised his eyebrows. Out of the corner of his vision, Annatar noticed the bard looking at him intently. “He did not look ill.”
“He is not ill,” Annatar said curtly. “He was not feeling well. And the lessons were a welcome distraction, I wager.”
“Ah. So that is...” Daeror fell silent. Annatar chanced a sideglance at him, and even though he could not, per se, look into anyone’s head on a physical level, against all claims to the contrary, he could sense the bard’s brain going into overdrive, assembling facts, filling in the blanks with conjecture, and coming to conclusions, all with a speed that would leave the vast majority of mortals green with envy.
The exact moment when Daeror drew the correct conclusions was visible in the slight tensing of his features, a dimming of the cheerful light in his eyes.
“Oh. So you finally talked.”
Annatar took another deep breath. He did not need to, but he found these small mortal habits helpful to regulate the flow and rhythm of a conversation, including breaks and pauses where there need not strictly be some, but were a welcome reprieve nonetheless.
“We did.”
Daeror ran a hand through his hair. “How did he take it?”
“About as well as could be expected.”
“Ah.”
“You know, I cannot help but notice a glaring lack of surprise in these conversations,” Annatar said flatly. “Does everybody here know?”
Daeror shrugged. “Why are you asking me? I guess there is at least a few who put two and two together, but it is not as if we go around talking to each other about it.”
Annatar gave him a flabbergasted look. “Why? Is everyone here either insane or do you all simply not care?”
“The opposite of caring is not always indifference,” Daeror said slowly. “People had to move on, Annatar. They had to survive. Can you really fault them for not wanting to dig deeper?”
“Wilful ignorance doesn’t help! I told Tyelperinquar as much.”
“Then Tyelperinquar will have told you that some knowledge does not help, either,” Daeror countered. “What do you think would it do to someone who escaped Angband’s torture chambers to know that the Torturer is here? Sitting next to them at dinner? Teaching their child’s class? Deciding the fate of the city they have decided to build a second life in? What good would it do, other than blasting the foundation of their new life to pieces once more? To shatter every trust in having escaped, to resurrect old fears and old wounds, knowing that the arm of their Doom is so long that it will reach them even here?”
“Figures that the bard would advocate for lies,” Annatar said acidly.
“Lies are not inherently bad,” Daeror said, stopping in his tracks. Annatar did the same. “Do you know why we use masks in theatre, Annatar?”
“To hide your true face behind them. To pretend, to lie, to become someone else.”
“Yes, and?”
“What, ‘and’?”
“What else?”
“You tell me,” Annatar shot back. “Since you are obviously just waiting to lecture me.”
“I am lecturing you, but only because you desperately need a lesson in mortality, other than flouncing around in a make-believe body and pretending you understand being Incarnate.” Daeror crossed his arms. “Why else?”
“I don’t know.”
“To tell the stories we could not tell otherwise,” Daeror said softly. “To ourselves, and everyone else. To become the character in the story as it is supposed to be told, and not how it would unfold in real life.” He gestured at the gardens, at the city around them. “This is our illusion, this is our stage, our story. We escaped, we lived. We built this city. We can go on from this. And so we act out the story we so desperately want to write for ourselves. We don the masks, we play the play.” He smiled, sadly and bitterly. “We lived when we should have died, we survived when we should have been broken. And if it isn’t true beyond the stage – well, we do not have to know that, right?”
Annatar stood frozen, any reply that he might have had dead on his tongue.
“The act doesn’t have to stop, especially if it helps so many people,” Daeror said. “As long as the limelight is on and the audience is in shadow, you need not look at what is beyond the stage. The stage is all there is. You can be the survivor, the hero, the one who got away. And if it isn’t true, if it is all just smoke and mirrors ... well.” Daeror turned away, looking out over the city, white and black and grey under them, almost like a charcoal drawing. Almost like a scenery prop in a stage play.
“Some people have only their mask left,” Daeror said, turning back towards Annatar. “Do not take it away from them. Do not force them to take it off. Often enough, there is nothing more behind it after all they have suffered. So leave it be. Leave them in peace.”
Annatar did not speak for a long time. He crossed his arms. The cold wintry winds were blowing across the high gardens, whipping through their hair, catching in their sleeves, the long trails of Annatar’s robe. He didn’t feel it.
“I told Tyelperinquar I wanted truth,” he said at last, staring at the ground. “And now you tell me to continue the lie.”
“Not all lies are cruel. Some are gentle. A kindness even, and the world would be darker without them.” Daeror cocked his head aside. “And they lived happily ever after.”
The cold wind sheared across the gardens like a knife blade. Cutting. Cold.
“I am neither gentle nor kind,” Annatar said, drawing his robes closer around him.
“Well then.” Daeror’s mouth quirked up at the edge, the sardonic cousin of a smile. “Time to craft a new mask then, aye?”
Annatar stared at the ground, and slowly shook his head, frustration warring with disbelief. “From deceit to masquerade.” He let out a mirthless laugh. “Between Tyelperinquar, you, and those nameless others you mentioned, I’m beginning to think that the entire city is a stage where truth is rarer than mithril, everyone is a mask, and everyone realized it except for me. Congratulations for beating me at my own game.”
“That’s the thing, Annatar,” Daeror said with a sad smile. “We’re all actors here. And excellent liars.”
Annatar scoffed. “That explains why I felt right at home here from the moment I stepped through the gates.” He shook his head. “To think that I truly wanted to try honesty.”
“You were honest where it mattered,” Daeror said. “But there is a time and place for stripping away illusions, and there are times when it is kinder to let people marvel at the magician’s tricks.” He walked back over to the wall and braced his hands on the stone, looking out over the city below. With a slow exhale, he added, “And allow them to believe.”
He threw a side glance at Annatar who had followed him. “The show must go on, right?” He grinned with too many teeth.
Annatar followed his gaze down at the sprawl of cities, houses, destinies entangled. People who needed comfort more than truth. “I guess it must,” he said at last.
Chapter End Notes
Annatar getting hoodwinked by his own tactics will never not be funny to me.
Also, isn't he secretly well and truly the fluffiest Maia?
In the spirit of me being destroyed by the game, I had of course hide a reference to Clair Obscur in there. Kudos if you manage to find it.
Also, twice the kudos if you also manage to spot the Amadeus reference.
No Shadows
Read No Shadows
Celebrimbor didn’t see Annatar for a full week. They had not parted on bad terms, but on the clear note that each of them needed some time to think. At times, they passed each other in the hallway, acknowledging each other with a nod, and then going their own way, but neither had attempted to approach the other. In Annatar’s case, Celebrimbor suspected that it was because the Maia did not want to encroach where he was not wanted. Which was not true, per se. But.
Time and distance had been ... not a good thing, but necessary.
Not good, because it meant he had to work through everything that their conversation had ripped open if he wanted to go back to his everyday life.
Necessary, because he needed to work through everything that their conversation had ripped open if he wanted to go back to his everyday life.
That being said, the past days had been less than pleasant, and he was glad that no one else had been around to see it. Now, a week later, on a comparably mild day at the end of November, with silver-gold winter sunlight streaming through his windows, Celebrimbor finally felt like the world had readjusted itself on its tracks, and was turning at its normal, calm pace again.
A stark contrast to the fits and starts the week before, when past and present had overlapped, and jumped and jolted – forward, backward – and then he’d lost a whole day again, or awoken in the darkest hours between night and morning, and couldn’t remember whether he had fallen asleep at his desk while grading papers or simply gone elsewhere and fallen into a stupor that had lasted for hours.
This night, he had at least manage to fall asleep in his bed. Which was. Something.
When he sat up and rubbed his eyes, he felt slow and tired, but in the way one had after having normal night’s sleep, not the lethargic disorientation that had thrown the past few days into a chaotic, directionless blur.
Celebrimbor thew back the blankets and padded over to the hearth, throwing fresh logs onto the coals to keep the fire going. The heated water piping did a great part in keeping the tower warm, but as winter approached, additional heat was always welcome. Afterwards, he left the bedroom and exited into his study, half of a mind to go to the lecture halls – when he realized that he didn’t know what day it was. He hunted down his calendar in the absolute chaos of his usually organized workspace, and learned that it was, indeed, a Saturday and that he didn’t actually have any obligations today, teaching or otherwise.
Which would have sent a spike into his mind and chest only one day earlier, but today... today he might be able to deal with having some time to himself, untethered from obligations and activities that kept his mind from being thrown back on itself.
Celebrimbor threw the calendar back onto the desk-top. He’d clean the mess later. A shower, first.
It was also under the shower when the message reached him. It came so suddenly and unexpectedly, he chucked the bar of soap straight across the room. Fine, so maybe his nerves had not yet entirely settled down.
Celebrimbor cursed externally, while internally, he re-established the rapidly cut connection of osanwë and asked politely, Could you repeat that, please? I was distracted.
This did not feel like a distraction, his aunt Artanis spoke drily. More like somebody ambushed you.
The disadvantage of osanwë was, clearly, that it did not allow one to think things like, Well, you did, while in mental conversation, so Celebrimbor stowed away the thought with a frown, and instead decided to have a friendly, fruitful conversation with a dear relative.
What can I help you with, Aunt?
There was a suspiciously long silence, during which Celebrimbor could colourfully and life-like picture Artanis staring out into the trees from her flet, contemplating whether she should force the issue. He sensed the moment when she decided against it.
I have been trying to reach you for quite some time over the past few days, but was unable to.
I was busy, he replied.
Hm. Disbelief flooded their shared connection, but again, Artanis kept her silence. Thankfully. Are you well?
Perfectly fine, thank you for asking. Yourself?
Adequate. Your consideration is appreciated. Artanis used the tone of someone who was thoroughly fed up with something, but was too polite or too private to elaborate upon it in company. I was trying to talk to you about Celebrían.
Celebrimbor shoved a few strands of wet hair out of his face and raised an eyebrow. Rían? What’s with her?
Yule is approaching, Artanis said, as if that explained anything at all.
It is. And?
She wants to visit you. One of the travellers had put some ideas into her mind how nice the city is in the weeks leading up to the Yule celebrations, and now she has gotten it into her head that she wants to spend Yule in a – and I quote – ‘cosmopolitan, lively place for once, not this woody backwater where nothing ever happens’.”
Celebrimbor grimaced and fought a grin at the same time. It was a weird feeling on his face. That is … harsh.
I’ve had harsher, Artanis replied blandly. It is the nature of privileged youth not to recognize privilege.
Kids will be kids, I suppose. Celebrimbor reached for his towel and wrapped it around his waist.
In less lofty terms, yes.
And? Are you going to let her?
As my daughter informed me yesterday, the days when I can ‘let’ her or ‘forbid’ her from doing something are apparently rapidly nearing their end, Artanis responded flatly.
Oh, that age. Celebrimbor couldn’t quite hide a grin when he stepped out of the tub and then went in search of the soap that had unexpectedly gone on travels.
Quite.
So, is she coming or not? Celebrimbor took a circuit of the bathroom, then another when he came up with nothing.
She wants to arrive in the city on the first of December. I wanted to give you an early notice, because as I have been informed, she is going to write to you and ask for your permission to come.
Oh, and my permission she’s going to heed? Celebrimbor thought back, sceptical, while rubbing his hair dry with a second towel.
That remains to be seen. Things being as they are, the words of cousins apparently outweigh the word of a parent.
Huh. My condolences.
Thank you.
There was an awkward silence. Celebrimbor stopped in his steps.
You are not going to ask me to turn her away, are you?
Another, even longer pause.
I would be happy to have her, Celebrimbor continued; faster, more urgent. She can run with Falda and Anthere, they are basically of the same age cohort of their kind. I could ride out with her. Or go to the archery range and to the fencing hall, if she still likes that.
It is not, Artanis responded pointedly, my daughter’s entertainment schedule I am worried about.
Celebrimbor’s heart sank. I ...
He broke off. He couldn’t exactly tell his aunt in good conscience that Annatar posed no danger to her daughter. Because if push came to shove, Annatar was able level the entire city with a thought. And yet – so could have done Melian, if she so wished. Maiar, being basically sentient forces of nature, were inherently dangerous to be around. But what they chose to do or not to do had to count for something.
On the other hand, his aunt had warned him away from Annatar since day one, and look how well-founded her suspicions had turned out to be. Which also had to count for something.
Why couldn’t anything ever be easy?
I would not leave her alone around Annatar. Or I could even avoid them meeting in the first place, he offered, even though the very thought rankled him. I can keep them apart.
Artanis was silent.
I guess, she responded at last, it would be too much to ask to request your support in not exposing my daughter to potential harm.
Celebrimbor’s jaw tightened. Young or not, Celebrían is her own person. If she wants to come, she will turn up at the gates no matter what you or I say.
She certainly will not get into the city if you close the doors to her and send her home.
She’s just going to set up camp outside the walls, or scale them during night-time, and you know it, Celebrimbor said. Besides, the gates of Ost-in-Edhil remain open. Always. To everyone.
His aunt did not respond immediately. I see, she said at last, the connection turning cold. I told you what I wanted to tell you. Expect my daughter’s letter, then.
Something inside Celebrimbor’s chest – something age-old, that had never really learned how to deal with discord among family – clenched painfully. But he was angry, too, and the anger did a fine job at keeping him steadfast and propelling him onward.
I will. Thank you for letting me know in advance.
Artanis did not respond to his thanks. Keep them apart, she said instead. I will know if you go against my word. Ost-in-Edhil might be your city, but this is my daughter we are talking about.
Your wishes will be respected, Celebrimbor acceded, because what else was he supposed to say? He couldn’t even tell his aunt that she was wrong with all her suspicions about Annatar – indeed, they were even worse than what she, in all likeliness, suspected. I’ll keep her safe.
Do not begin anew your family’s regretful tradition to make promises you cannot keep, Artanis said. Do your best, and leave it at that.
And with that, the connection broke.
Celebrimbor sighed, and buried his face in the towel, briefly shutting out the outer world that was insisted on causing problems he had never asked for. After a few seconds, he dropped the towel, hung it over a hot-water pipe, and then went on searching the soap bar.
The soap bar, in turn, proved irrationally resistant to being found. It has to be here somewhere; it cannot physically have vanished.
However, the soap bar did not seem to concern itself with such trivial matters as physics and impossibility. After five more minutes of fruitless search, Celebrimbor finally admitted defeat and abandoned the search, yielding the soap to the inscrutable, ever-hungry pocket dimension that devoured quills, buttons, and left socks.
There were more important matters to attend to. Like the fact that his younger cousin would be spending all of December in Ost-in-Edhil, which was an unexpected delight. Despite the persistently polite-but-lukewarm relations between Ost-in-Edhil and Lothlórien, Celebrían’s and Celebrimbor had always been close. The vast age difference between them and the fact that they rarely saw each other notwithstanding, their rapport was cordial and characterized by easy familiarity. They were also surprisingly similar in character. Celebrían had, for a long time, been too young to be interested in politics, and now that she was nearing adulthood, it had turned out that she simply didn’t care about diplomatic machinations, regardless of her age and lineage. Which was superb, because Celebrimbor loathed politics with a passion, and would rather talk about anything else on any given day.
However, Celebrían was also unfortunately similar to Celebrimbor in the aspect that she couldn’t sit still for a single minute, and tended to be drawn to pastimes that were either risky, downright dangerous, or explosive, or a combination of all three. Which meant that he had to figure out how to keep his cousin from tearing down the archery range and-or the laboratories on her first day. And, to top this off, she’d be he here for a whole month, without a father or a mother to rein her in. Celebrimbor smothered the slight flicker of panic, wondering how this was how his parents had felt as soon as they had realized what type of son they were currently rearing.
Unwittingly, though, Celebrimbor defaulted to the masterplan of every parent or parental figure hopelessly out of their depth, all across the world, across all eons: Eh, I’ll cross that bridge when I get to it.
Very satisfied with this solid plan, he was able to divert his attention to present matters. Like the knocking on his door.
Celebrimbor walked over and pulled it open, coming face to face with a very taken-aback looking Annatar.
“Hello,” Celebrimbor said.
“Good... morning,” Annatar responded, his eyes roving over Celebrimbor once, then schooling his features into something resembling equanimity. “Out of polite interest, what would you have done if someone had come calling upon you in an official function?”
Celebrimbor inclined his head. “What do you mean? I would still have opened the door, of course.”
“Yes,” Annatar said, the world slightly drawn-out. “I do wonder, though, whether you would have bothered to put on clothes before answering the call.”
“Put on – oh.” Celebrimbor looked down at himself and only now did he remember that he was still merely dressed in a bath towel, and that his long, damp hair was plastered to his scalp, shoulders and back. “Well, damn it. I apologize for the improper state of dress.”
“Don’t worry, the view could be worse,” Annatar said, and leaned against the door frame, his arms crossed. “Though I remain undecided on the matter of how coherent any ensuing conversation with the proposed visitor would be.” The corner of his mouth twitched with amusement.
Celebrimbor looked up at him. “Hard to tell. How distracted are you?”
“Truth be told, I completely forgot what I wanted when I came here. My mental capacity is right now fully occupied with the question whether you’d forget your head at home if it wasn’t attached to your neck.”
Celebrimbor raised both eyebrows. “And I’m supposed to believe that?”
“Believe whatever you want to believe. Just let me say right here and now, that you are not allowed to come crying to me the day when you walk down into the lecture halls and your students flee in terror because you forgot to put on clothes.”
Celebrimbor’s mouth twisted into a grin. “Well, now I’m almost tempted to try it out just for the hell and havoc of it.”
Annatar grinned back. “Notify me when you do, so I can record it for the annals of Eregion.”
And just like that, they were back at a point that Celebrimbor had wondered about how long it would take them to reach again. He had imagined stiffness, distance, caution, perhaps even fear – and yet here they were, right back in their usual rhythm and closeness, as if nothing had happened.
Or, perhaps, as if something groundbreaking, something earth-shaking had happened, but it had simply not been enough to destroy this.
Celebrimbor’s grin turned into a smile. He stepped back and made an inviting gesture into his rooms. “Do you want to come in?”
“If I may.” Annatar’s smile, too, had transformed into something quieter, smaller. Something warmer, more private. Expectant, hopeful, but not demanding.
“Always,” Celebrimbor said and opened the door a bit further. He waited for something to happen – for fear to raise its head, for worries, for the pit to re-open in his stomach, when Annatar passed him by, but ...
Nothing.
Just warmth and white-gold winter sunlight falling in through the high glass windows, making the room seem high and bright and clear, and seeking its like in Annatar’s hair, his eyes, his white robes, now trimmed with white light.
Annatar took a few steps into the room, then turned around. “How have you been?”
Celebrimbor gave a one-sided shrug. “I’ve had worse.”
Annatar frowned, for a few moments clearly on the verge of pressing the matter, but then decided to let it go. “But now? You are better?”
“Yes,” Celebrimbor said and surprised himself by how much he meant it. How true it sounded. He felt alright. Strong. Healthy. Awake. A world away from the shaking, stumbling, hollowed-out hull of person swamped in their darkest memories that had been dragging itself through the last few days.
“I don’t know how long it will last, or if there will be – there certainly will be ... worse days. Again. At some point. But it doesn’t matter. There always are. For now, I’m good.” Celebrimbor tried to smile, and found, to his pleasant surprise, that he could do it and mean it.
Annatar had been watching him intently while he spoke. Now, the Maia looked him up and down once more from top to toe; scrutinizing, looking for something that was off. There was no telling whether he found something or what he was thinking. At last, he nodded.
“And you?” Celebrimbor asked, when his friend didn’t speak.
Annatar did not answer immediately, clearly contemplating how forthright he should be, seeing how Celebrimbor himself had forgone honesty in lieu of something curt and light and socially acceptable that one could quickly move on from.
“I was worried about you,” he said at last.
Celebrimbor stilled.
“I knew you were going to be alright. Eventually. You are strong. Stronger than anyone I have ever known,” Annatar said, crossing his arms – perhaps unwittingly. “Nevertheless, it was ... unpleasant to watch. Unpleasant to know that I had been the cause of this.”
“It’s fine.”
“I know. But I could have done without ‘fine’ being preceded by pain.” There was tension in the line of Annatar’s shoulders and a shadow on his face. Celebrimbor did not like it. It had no place here, in this sun-flooded room, on this wonderful winter morning, where everything was silver and gold and light.
He stepped up to Annatar, took his hands and gently pried them out of their stiff cross of defence against the Maia’s chest. And when that was undone, he stepped even closer until they were almost nose to nose, intertwining their fingers. “No shadows,” Celebrimbor said softly. “Not today.”
At first, Annatar seemed taken aback. This close, Celebrimbor could see the shades of gold and amber and honey-brown in his iris, shifting with every minute movement of his face, could see how the golden waves of his hair caught fire in the winter sun, every strand backlit by corona of white light.
It was breathtaking; nearly painful to behold.
He was the most beautiful thing Celebrimbor had ever seen.
Just then, in this soft silver-golden silence, something like understanding crossed Annatar’s face. “No shadows,” he agreed, his voice low, barely above a whisper.
Celebrimbor nodded, leaned in, and kissed him.
Annatar, who had heretofore strictly kept to his own space, paying great attention not to get too close in, to overstep – froze. But just for a moment. And then, rapidly, suddenly, wonderfully – changed. It was like winter turning into spring, ice turning into water. The stiffness, the hardness, the coldness, all of it went away, transformed into something soft and warm and pliant. He leaned in, leaned close, his centre of balance for the first time coming towards Celebrimbor, instead of shying away from him. Reached back, his heretofore unresponsive fingers tightening around Celebrimbor’s, before letting go, wrapping his arms around the elf’s shoulders, holding on, pulling closer, as if he didn’t intend to let go again.
At some point, they let go of each other’s hands. Palms cupping faces, fingers burying into hair.
At some point, Celebrimbor was up against the wall of his study, Annatar’s mouth a searing, hot burn on the side of his throat. Their hands were joined again, their fingers intertwined. Celebrimbor’s knuckles pressed against the wall where Annatar had pinned his hands, their palms as hot against each other as if they were holding liquid fire.
How had they gotten here?
At some point, Annatar looked up at him and said, “You are still wearing it”, his fingers feather-light under the necklace he had given Celebrimbor, and there had been something in his voice that Celebrimbor didn’t remotely comprehend, and it nevertheless nearly broke him, when he breathed out, “Of course I am. Of course –” And that was as far has he got before Annatar’s mouth on his own silenced the rest of his words, and the cool wall at his back was nothing against the blazing heat against his front.
At some point he became aware that they had switched locations again. They were now in his bedroom, the door to the study closed, quiet enveloping them. Quiet and light. Outside of the tower: the ice-blue sky, nothing else.
At some point, Celebrimbor became suddenly, and violently – as these things sometimes happened – aware of his own breathing, of his own stumbling heartbeat, of this intimate, overwhelming embodiment into muscle and bone, air and heat.
Nearly at the same time, he became aware of something else. Another heartbeat, drumming an off-beat rhythm with his own. Another heart, pumping blood, blood rushing like a wild torrent through veins. Breaths not of himself, but pushed out by a different set of lungs. His hands ran across skin – skin that was somehow more ... present than what he was used to.
The haze of light and warmth lifted, and he could see that Annatar was before him, was in his arms – was, somehow, impossibly, physically there, more than he ever had been. He was also down to a thin white tunic that was half unlaced at the front – who had done this and how? – and white linen trousers. He was barefoot, and bare under his tunic, and the skin Celebrimbor felt was the skin of Annatar’s arms, the welts of scars, the texture of skin, the warmth of a living, breathing, incarnate body –
“What–?” Celebrimbor began. Broke off. Tried again. “What are you doing?”
Annatar smiled wryly at him – a thing that was, at once, private and coy, dazzling and devious and dangerous in this enclosed space between them, between heaving chests, racing hearts, heavy breaths.
“I am trying new things.” He rested his forehead against Celebrimbor’s. “I am trying to be more like you.”
“More like me?” Celebrimbor let out a laugh. “Impulsive, impetuous, and far too quick with important decisions?”
Annatar pulled back to look at him. “No. Open." He hesitated. “Braver. Not - hiding away.” He looked away.
Celebrimbor’s smile faded slightly.
Annatar visibly worked through what he wanted to say, before he continued, “You have seen the worst there is to me and still decided to open your door to me once more. Against wisdom, against better judgement.”
“Love has little to do with wisdom, as I’ve come to learn.”
Annatar looked up, at last. “But love without truth is a mummer’s farce.”
And if there was anything extraordinary in this, if there was anything unspeakable and unbelievable in being seen and daring to be seen – without veils, without masks, without lies, without shadows – neither made any mention of it. It felt like falling into the sky, it felt like sunlight on rippling water, crystal-clear, like a flower opening in mid-winter.
Celebrimbor was silent for a moment. “That is ... wonderful. But you realize - we don’t have to do this.” He gestured between them. “This has nothing to do with being brave. Or open. Or what we are to each other.” He reached up and brushed his knuckles against Annatar’s chin, up his cheek, then tucked a wayward strand of hair behind his ear. Annatar caught his hand with his own and pressed them both against his cheek, before turning his head and kissing Celebrimbor’s palm, his eyes closed and his frame very still for a moment.
“I know,” Annatar said, speaking into Celebrimbor's palm. “I know. I was just thinking that perhaps I could - ” He broke off, then ran his fingers down Celebrimbor's arm before brushing them over his knuckles. “Being close like this is so different from the ways I know.” He paused. “Perhaps we could try. Just the once.
“We can,” Celebrimbor said. “But we do not have to. You are under no obligation to do this. Not to me, not to yourself.”
Annatar opened his eyes. “I know,” he repeated.
Celebrimbor regarded him for a few moments, then he smiled. “That being said, feel free to go along with what you feel like doing. Don’t worry on my account. I am curious where you are going to take this. I hardly know the side of you that puts curiosity over caution.”
The Maia quirked up one eyebrow, his head slightly inclined as if he was regarding an amusing puzzle. “It’s a rather new approach for me. I will freely admit as much. There is one last thing I have to tell you, though.”
“What would that be?”
Annatar held his gaze for a few long moments, then gravely, solemnly, pronounced, “I have no idea what I am doing.”
An incredulous bout of laughter burst from Celebrimborʼs lips. “Welcome to the mortal experience,” he said, still laughing, then pulled the Annatar towards him into another kiss.
Arguably Worse Than Opposable Thumbs
Read Arguably Worse Than Opposable Thumbs
When Celebrimbor woke up, he was alone. A low, quiet pang of disappointment surged in his stomach, but it was quickly replaced by relief when he spotted Annatar in one of the armchairs standing by the hearth, one leg drawn up to his chest, the other stretched out, a book in one hand, while the was supporting his temple with the other. He was back in his usual robes, and he did not look up when Celebrimbor sat up, obviously too focused on what he was currently reading.
He threw aside the blankets and padded over to the god lounging in his armchair. The room had cooled off during the night, and the cold air seeped through his thin clothes he had slept in.
He leaned his lower arms on the back of the armchair and bowed down. “Good morning. What are you reading?”
Annatar acknowledged his presence at last, turning around and looking up at him. “Theories on transmission of information in general, and osanwë in particular.” Annatar briefly flipped the book close, this forefinger still marking the page he was at, and looked at the author’s name stamped on the cover. “Ylva Háldursdóttir has some interesting thoughts on the aspects of quantum entanglement that might play into it.”
“So, perfectly light reading for a Sunday morning.”
“Hmh.”
“That was meant ironically.”
“I am aware.”
Celebrimbor laughed and dropped a kiss on the Maia’s head. “How are you?”
“Fine,” Annatar replied. “I’m fine.”
Celebrimbor looked down at Annatar, then reached out, combing his fingers through the fine golden strands. They slid through his fingers like silk, like water, not catching in the slightest. “Are you sure? Yesterday was … a lot.”
There was the fact that they had spent the entire day in here, up until the early hours of the morning. Which had been intimate, and interesting, and all other kinds of pleasant things. But there was also the fact that they had been so caught up in this rush, in each other, that they had charged past boundaries they probably should have taken more time to examine and explore, rather than leaping over them at a run and without looking back. There was also the very real fact that they had crashed into some of these obstacles at full speed, and found no way to surmount them. Like the fact that things went rather well as long as Annatar was leading and Celebrimbor followed, but fell to pieces the moment they switched. Or the fact that control was very much a thing, and tangled up in a snarl with all other kinds of issues, buried in experiences that neither was willing or ready to touch, and that they probably should have slowed down at some point rather than steamrolling over it. Or the fact that Annatar had noticeably phased out of true corporeality multiple times, but had refused to stop and acknowledge it in the moment.
If they were to continue their relationship along this line (and that was a big “if” to begin with), there was a lot of work to be done, and it would have to be handled differently than screwing one’s eyes shut, gritting one’s teeth, and blazing through it with wilful blindness and sheer stubbornness. And they both knew it.
Annatar didn’t answer immediately, looking straight ahead at the door to the study, still closed, his thoughts apparently running along similar tracks. “I’m fine,” he repeated.
Celebrimbor waited. He knew the Maia well enough to be able to tell when he wasn’t saying everything.
When Annatar had not replied after what had to be a full five minutes, Celebrimbor rounded the armchair and sat down on the right armrest. He nudged Annatar with his elbow.
“You know,” Celebrimbor said, trying a cheerful tone. “Time and time again, I do try to be patient, and time and time again I find out that I simply do not have the temper for it. What is it? Out with it.”
Annatar stared at the book. “Nothing is wrong.”
“I would hope not. But that wasn’t what I was asking. What is on your mind?”
Annatar finally looked up at him, and his expression was an odd amalgamation of annoyance, doubt, and trepidation. “I don’t regret what we did,” he said.
“Wonderful. Still not the question. I’m hearing an unsaid ‘but’ waiting in the wings.” Celebrimbor held Annatar’s gaze. He had a feeling that he knew where this was going, but he wanted the Maia to come forth and said it himself.
Again, a few moments passed in silence, with Annatar noticeably sorting through his talking points like someone else might arrange tools in a workspace before he begun an assembly of complicated machinery.
“Would you think it terribly strange or illogical,” Annatar said at last, “if I told you that yesterday was acceptable, with no notable objective negative; that it was all perfectly bearable, and I do not have the slightest desire to ever repeat it?”
Celebrimbor fought the strange, sudden urge to laugh. He schooled his features into a serious expression, though, knowing that the moment was delicate. “Given what I know of you – given that I know you, colour me terribly, horribly unsurprised.”
Annatar glanced at him askance. “You do not mind?”
“Annatar, I am old and mature enough to hold apart the two very unrelated principles of your personal preferences and my hypothetical expectations.” Celebrimbor shifted his weight on the armrest and interlaced his fingers around his right knee. “Besides – and I do not want to be the one to say ‘I told you so’ – but I did in fact tell you so months ago. I do not mind. Never have, never will.”
Annatar looked at the book again. Tapped the cover. “Good,” he said at last. He tapped the cover again. “I truly wanted to try it,” he said. “To see. To know. If it would work. If I could.”
Celebrimbor waited if more words were forthcoming. When nothing came, he said, “I understand the desire to try. However, you didn’t have to prove anything to the world, or to me. Or to yourself, for that matter.”
Annatar’s silence was telling.
“And even if you absolutely had to,” Celebrimbor said, “you already did. Now do the science where you look at the results and draw your conclusion.” He nudged the Maia with his elbow again.
“I don’t understand it,” Annatar said, but did not elaborate. “I do like to have you close to me – there is nothing bad about – it wasn’t bad – why –” He broke off again.
Celebrimbor remained quiet. There was nothing he could add to this. Annatar knew what he needed to know. The facts were there. He was smart. Some puzzles just needed a bit of peace and quiet to be assembled; and some truths needed a bit of time to sink in. And solitude. Being alone and being honest with oneself, most of all.
When Annatar looked up, his expression was tense. “I hope I did not do any damage.”
Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “Damage? How ever do you mean that?”
“By creating a false perspective,” he said. “For you. Me. Both of us. False expectations.”
“I already told you – I do not mind. Tell me how many times I have to repeat it until you believe me, and I shall do it now to get it out of the way.”
“I do believe you,” Annatar said, frustrated. “But I also know that forcing the issue like this was probably not … right. I was – ” He looked at his hands. “Relieved. Glad. To see you. To have you back. To have you look at me and know that you still wanted me here, despite … everything. I got carried away.”
“So did I. It happens.” Celebrimbor gingerly put an arm around Annatar’s shoulders. “You are not exempt from emotions just because you do not feel them in the exact same way or in the same situations someone else does. You feel things. You want things. You try them on, see if they fit you or if they don’t. And if they don’t, there’s no harm done. We are allowed to express ourselves. We can change our minds, backtrack, reevaluate, and decide that some things are not for us, after all. That’s the one beautiful thing in this largely limited, often painful, and thoroughly senseless mortal coil.”
Annatar did not reply.
“Give it some time,” Celebrimbor said gently. “Some truths are larger than others. They take a bit more time to sink in.”
A few seconds of silence ticked by.
“You’ve thought a lot about this,” Annatar observed, his tone flat.
“I have been Incarnate all my life. I was also – a long time ago – young and wondering where I fit into the world. In a lot of ways. All of us Incarnates do.”
Annatar made a derisive sound. “I feel given my status and age, I should have done better. Known better.”
“You had and have the luxury of being able to bend the world around you to your will,” Celebrimbor responded. “At what point would it ever have made sense to you – let alone been necessary – to ask yourself those questions?”
Annatar thought about this, then, with a nod, conceded the point.
“Don’t drive yourself mad over it,” Celebrimbor said. “It’s fine. You are fine as you are.”
“You don’t need to coddle me, Tyelperinquar.”
“I don’t. But I know doubt is an ugly thing; and if you cannot believe yourself right now, perhaps you can believe in an outside perspective.”
Annatar thought about this, then nodded again. “Thank you.” He took a breath. “So how do we – Do we just go back to how we were?”
“That has worked out quite well for us up until now, wouldn’t you say?” Celebrimbor said amicably. “We work well like that. So yes, let’s go back to how we were.”
“Just like that?”
“Just like that.”
“Oh,” Annatar said, obviously confounded by the simplicity of the decision. “Well then. Yes. I’d like that.”
After a few minutes spent with each of them pensively plodding along their respective trains of thought, Celebrimbor’s mind snagged on something.
“Strange, though,” he said under his breath.
“What is strange?” Annatar asked, looking up at him.
“Your excuse,” Celebrimbor said, and a broad grin spread over his lips.
“What excuse? What are you even talking about?” Annatar frowned.
“‘I got carried away’?” Celebrimbor repeated, then change his tone to imitate Annatar’s arch, stilted tones. “What happened to ‘Everything I do is intentional and premediated, instincts are for those who can’t do better, I don’t even have a knee-jerk reflex that I didn’t decide on three hours ago and isn’t part of some millennium-old-scheme to –”
“Oh, get lost, Tyelperinquar.” Annatar shoved him off the armrest with a bit more force than necessary.
Celebrimbor stumbled and caught his balance, laughing.
“You are such an –” Annatar broke off, then grumbled something inarticulate to himself.
“I am everything you want, and everything you deserve,” Celebrimbor said cheerily. He circled the small table and threw himself into the one opposite of Annatar. Which was, incidentally, when the book Annatar had been reading caught his eye again. “So. Osanwë? You still want to enable that cat of yours to talk to everyone and their dog?”
“Yes.”
Celebrimbor rolled his eyes, but grinned. “If you’ve gotten it in your head to do something …” He trailed off with a shake of his head. “So, go on. Do tell, what did you discover? Did you develop and apparatus that is able to make use of quantum entanglement to mentally communicate beyond osanwë?”
Annatar looked suddenly and inexplicably like someone had caught him with the hand in the cookie jar. He looked down at the book, frowned, then closed it, before setting it aside on his armrest. “Remember the thought-to-speech project I had told you hadn’t worked?”
“Yes, I remember. So?”
“I lied.”
Celebrimbor lifted an eyebrow.
“It worked too well, rather. It also was based on an artifact I decided not to create after. Er. Abandoning my plans of.” Annatar had the grace to look discomfited.
Celebrimbor’s eyebrow climbed higher.
“Conquering Middle-earth,” Annatar finished stiffly.
Celebrimbor blinked twice, then looked out of the window with an empty stare. After a while, he sighed and turned back to look at the slightly-too-unrepentant Maia sitting opposite of him and looking at him with growing defiance.
Annatar had never been good at expressing regret, much rather choosing to jump onto whatever barricade presented itself and defending his actions down to blood and bones. Not necessarily because he still stood by his views and decisions, but because he was terminally unable to admit mistakes. Celebrimbor doubted this was going to change. As it was, raking Annatar over the coals for his abandoned plans of world domination probably wouldn’t do much, other than cause an unproductive argument, which Celebrimbor really wasn’t in the mood for.
“What artifact?” he asked instead.
Annatar, who had visibly been expecting an attack, deflated a bit. “A Ring,” he said.
Celebrimbor’s gaze darkened. The perceived temperature in the room suddenly plummeted below freezing. “You didn’t.”
“No, I didn’t.”
“You did not intend to take over the other Rings we have been making, you did not intend to drag our shared work into the dirt by doing this.” His fingers dug into the armrests of the chair. His voice might or might not have come out as a growl.
“As I said, I didn’t do it,” Annatar said, effortlessly managing the turnabout from being defensive into being offended.
“You planned to.”
“I –”
“That is vile.”
“I didn’t do it, Tyelperinquar! I burned the designs, if you must know!”
“I appreciate the gesture,” Celebrimbor said. “But you must agree that it doesn’t mean much coming from a being who never forgets about anything. You write down notes for the benefits of others, not because you would ever forget something.”
“I’m sorry, I don’t have more than gestures! How else am I supposed to prove my goodwill?”, Annatar shot back. “Do you want me to – what – lobotomize myself to make the point?”
Celebrimbor didn’t reply, mostly because that was a good point and he despised it. His fingers dug a bit further into the armrests. Something cracked, probably something in his finger joints. He consciously, deliberately, relaxed his grip.
“Fine,” he said at last. “Fine. And this project just so happened to make a resurgence when you sought ways to enable Wraith to speak?”
“Aspects of it came up again,” Annatar corrected. “For example, the ability to reach into the mind of another being and speak into it without the aid of osanwë.”
“I cannot express strongly enough how thoroughly intrusive and loathsome I find the idea of mind-controlling device,” Celebrimbor said slowly, every world placed with the deliberation and finality of moving a chess piece. He was trying very hard not to get angry. He was only halfway successful.
“Yes, which is why I discarded it.” Annatar crossed his arms. “Even I don’t want to live in a world where Wraith has a Ring that enables her to dominate the mind of living beings, thank you very much.”
Celebrimbor couldn’t help a humourless laugh escaping his lips. “How glad I am that we have finally unearthed where you draw the line on immoral behaviour.”
Annatar’s eyebrow twitched. “Did you want to know where I was going with this or are we going to dissect my moral failings for the rest of the morning? It might take us some time.”
Celebrimbor closed his eyes, took a deep breath to dispel the black snarl of anger and disappointment growing in his chest, and waved his hand in a permissive gesture. “Do go on.”
“Thank you. As I was saying, I might have come up with a solution to enable her to speak with everyone. Or rather, not enable her to speak with everyone, but create a proxy through which she can do it.”
Celebrimbor opened his eyes. “As in, a loudspeaker? A translator?”
“Something like that,” Annatar said.
Celebrimbor sat up straighter, intrigued despite his misgivings about everything he had just heard about Rings and mind-control. He was vaguely aware that he shouldn’t discard this so lightly, but he was way more acutely aware that something in his brain had just been prodded awake and found that it was hungry. Very hungry. For knowledge that it didn’t yet have.
“This could arguably be worse than giving her opposable thumbs, you do realize that, don’t you?” Celebrimbor asked, but to be honest, it was more for the sake of token opposition rather than because his heart was truly in it. His mind was already whirring with the possibilities of applicability – how far could one extend communication if transmission and translation were no longer an issue? The mute survivors of Angband were almost a given, but what of other sentient beings, what of nature, what of going even further and finding a what to translate intent to molecular structures and –
Annatar’s voice cut off this train of thought before it could barrel away, derail, and crash somewhere in a ball of fire.
“I know. It also brings with it a host of other hazards that a normal – let’s called it ‘Ring’ – wouldn’t have, what with energy consumption to establish the connection and to do the translating and transmitting. Or the fact that one would have to override the separation of naturally discrete minds, which mortals other than Eldar possess, and the damages that could occur in the process.” Annatar’s gaze was fixed on something far away, before returning to the here and now, and to Celebrimbor. “Which I do realize is inherently dangerous and transgressive. It is the reason why I didn’t want to go forward with it,” he added. “Or, at least not without your approval.”
The unspoken question was hanging in the air between them.
Celebrimbor looked at Annatar. Annatar looked back, one eyebrow arched in silent inquiry.
Celebrimbor was very aware that this kind of knowledge might have been better off not being touched with a ten-foot pole. In fact, the responsible, the sensible thing to do would probably have been to forget about ever having had this discussion in the first place, and move on.
Annatar was still looking at him. Waiting.
His own brain was still whirring, already stumbling over itself with questions and hypotheses he wanted to try and verify and –
Ah well.
It wasn’t as if he had spent his long, long life making smart decisions.
*
True to her announcement via letter, Celebrían did arrive on the first of December. Celebrimbor was there to meet her at the gates, and subsequently nearly thrown off his feet when his younger cousin leapt off her mare and rushed at him into an embrace that was going to bruise a few ribs (probably), was against all rules of proper conduct and protocol when welcoming a lady of Celebrían’s status (very likely), and would make it back to his aunt’s and uncle’s ears via the guards that had accompanied her (with almost absolute certainty, much to Celebrimbor’s dismay).
They both laughed when the momentum swept them around in a circle, and Celebrimbor set her down again. Which was not as far down as it used to be only a few decades ago.
“Stars, you’ve grown,” Celebrimbor grinned. “Keep at it and you’ll surpass your mother.”
Celebrían grinned back. “One of my life goals.”
He ruffled her silver-blond hair, against all Eldarin custom cut short to fall to her shoulders, and one of the guards of Lóthlorien flinched. However, there was such a thing as superior social status, and though Celebrimbor usually loathed its implications, there were situations when clout and power came in handy. Like now.
He turned towards the guards, all composed formality. “Thank you very much for escorting my cousin on her way here. You must be tired after the long journey. We will find you some suitable accommodations where you can rest.”
Which as polite a “Get lost and leave us alone” as anyone would ever be able to manage, and honestly, Celebrimbor was quite pleased with himself for thinking of it.
The guards shared furtive glances, clearly conflicted. Celebrimbor knew that they had been ordered to stay close to Celebrían and shadow her every step. However, they also couldn’t very well defy the order of a lord in his own city.
Celebrimbor didn’t envy them their quandary. He had also no intention of resolving it for them in his cousin’s disfavour. He had promised his aunt to keep Celebrían away from Annatar – he had not promised to allow her to be surveilled and chaperoned in every moment she spent here.
Celebrían in turn, assumed a posture and expressions befitting of lady of Galadrim, and turned to her guards as well. “I thank you for your company and your protection. My cousin will take care of me for now. I am in good hands.”
The weight of an order of their own lady dropped with the weight of a millstone onto that of Celebrimbor’s dismissal. He noticed one guard grimacing at the Galad to her left, then the leader of the little company stepped forward, her expression pained.
“We have no reservations about entrusting Lady Celebrían to your care, Lord Tyelperinquar,” the guard said. She was good, there was almost no way to discern that she was lying through her teeth.
“However, the Lady Artanis has requested we be present for every journey of Lady Celebrían into the city or the guild quarters. So I ask your forgiveness that we will have to accompany her while she is outside of her private quarters.”
No way around Artanis’ authority, then. Even here, so far from the realm of the Galadrim. Or, rather, no direct way.
Celebrimbor and Celebrían shared a long look and a silent communication passed between them, exclusively reserved for siblings or cousins that had gotten into trouble together more times than merited counting. He knew that they were thinking the same thing.
Nearly at the same time, they turned back towards the guards.
“My apologies,” Celebrimbor said smoothly. “If those are the orders you have been given, my aunt’s authority shall, of course, be respected. You shall accompany my cousin, then, as soon as she sets foot outside the door of her private chambers.”
Which was a very specific kind of truth. But Celebrimbor was very good at using bespoke truths to his advantage, which is why nobody noticed. And it was not as if the poor guards were ever going to find out about it.
*
The full moon was high in the sky, surrounded by the distant, silver dots of far-off stars. The air was cuttingly cold, cold enough to transform his breath into white clouds.
The complex of towers, roofs, bridges, and walkways of the massive building that housed the guilds stretched out below him. Even further below, there was the city with its flickering yellow lights.
Celebrimbor gauged the distance to the next roof ridge with no small amount of apprehension. The gap between the two roofs yawned like a chasm. There was also snow everywhere. If he slipped, it wouldn’t be a short or pleasant fall.
Celebrimbor grimaced. Nothing for it.
He took two steps back, then broke into a run. His left foot hammered into the roof ridge at the last possible moment, then, for three seconds, there was only air and horrifying void below his feet – and then he landed, rolling over his left shoulder and coming back to his feet with a groan where his shoulder blade had dug into the tiles.
“I’m getting too old for this,” he muttered, rolling his arm in its socket until something, thankfully, popped back into place.
“Come now, I hope it will be another few millennia before a bit of roof-jumping stops you from having a bit of fun.”
He looked up to see a cloaked silhouette on the roof of a little turret, slightly to the left and about eight feet above where he currently stood. The shape was wearing a cowl and a cloak, pitch-black against the night sky. As he was looking, the shape shifted, then elegantly dropped down from its perch, rolled, and came back to its – her feet.
Celebrían threw back her cowl, her silver-gold hair bright in the moonlight, a few strands plastered across her forehead. She grinned.
“You do realize that if your mother finds out about this, she’s going to kill both of us,” Celebrimbor said flatly. “So I’d ask for a bit more gratitude. I’m subjecting myself to a lot of danger and repercussions here.”
Celebrían snorted. “Since when do you care about danger or repercussions?”
Which, okay, fair point.
“Your guards?” Celebrimbor asked instead.
“Stationed outside my door and none the wiser,” Celebrían said, squinting up at one of the higher towers in the building. “The door is locked, and I closed the window behind me, so the cold will not tip them off.” She crossed her arms. “Ah, windows. For all that they are unnecessary, one has to appreciate their existence in cities.”
Celebrimbor followed her gaze to the tower. It was quite a climb. He had no idea how one made it without ropes, hooks, or climbing cleats. But then again, he was a Noldo, and thus of a people that were more prone to delving underground than climbing. The Galadrim were, at their heart, tree-people, and if that extended to their princesses being able to climb sheer brick walls like squirrels, then who was he to question it?
“Well then,” Celebrimbor said. “Where do you want to go?”
“Does that one tavern still exist?” Celebrían asked. “In the artisan’s quarter, the one that’s supplied by the Dwarven brewery of Khazad-Dûm?”
“The Foundry?”
“That one, yes.”
“In business and thriving, and as always open at ungodly hours for every kind of clientele.” Celebrimbor grinned. “Want to go?”
“Why are you even asking?” Celebrían pulled her hood up again, then gestured grandly at the horrible, mortally dangerous descent across multiple roofs and ten-story-drops ahead of them. “After you.”
Celebrimbor sighed deeply.
*
They reached the tavern, and did so without broken bones or sprained ankles, which was a pleasant surprise.
However, Celebrimbor certainly felt like he’d be black and blue and sore all over from running, skidding, and braking, and more leaping and rolling than he cared for in a good day. As they walked down an empty street in the outer perimeter of the city, he kept prodding at his aching ribs and grimacing.
Celebrían watched it with barely concealed amusement. “My, perhaps you are getting old, Tyelperinquar.”
“Contrary to you, I don’t spend my days hopping around trees like a squirrel,” Celebrimbor grouched as he hobbled down the dark street, only lit by intermittent pools of yellow light from the street lamps.
“No, you’ve just turned into a complete and utter lab-rat, unable to manage such basic things like jumping roof-tops, let alone surviving for one day out in the wild,” Celebrían needled, then let out an aborted laugh-screech, when Celebrimbor quickly turned around and hooked his arm around her neck, pulling her into a headlock.
“What’s that you said?” he asked, while her fists drummed quite ineffectively against his back. Laughter was, luckily, sapping the strength of her punches considerably. “How’s that for lab-rat, then, you loudmouth?” he asked, looking down at her struggling against his grip.
Celebrían responded by hooking her ankle around his and yanking, and nearly tipping them both off-balance. Which was smart, because Celebrimbor had to let her go in order not to tumble face-first into the wall to their left.
He caught his balance just before that happened. “You also fight like a squirrel.”
“And yet you had to let me go. What does that tell us about squirrels and rats?” Celebrían righted herself and combed her hair back into some semblance of order, her face red and her mouth stretched into a bright grin.
“That rats have better manners and fighting etiquette.”
“You wish, old man.”
Celebrimbor made another attempt at grabbing her, but Celebrían quickly slipped out of his reach.
Their good-natured quarrelling was interrupted when they reached the tavern. In the spirit of being both unobtrusive and appearing like normal members of society, they composed themselves, pulled their hoods up, and entered.
Their arrival didn’t draw a lot of attention. The Foundry was one of those taverns where you could leave your hood up, no questions asked, pay for a room without leaving a name, and have the owner forget about you as soon as you walked out of the door. It was not dodgy, per se, but it was a place to have a drink and a conversation in private, which was exactly what they were looking for.
After getting their drinks they slid onto the benches bracketing a corner table.
Celebrían stared down at her tankard of Dwarven brew. “Stars, Mother would hate this.”
Celebrimbor arched an eyebrow. “What, the fact that you are drinking beer?”
“No, everything.” Celebrían gave a one-sided shrugged. “The fact that I broke out – which I am sure she already suspects. But also the other implications: that I am not behaving the way I should, that I am throwing some kind of wrench in the works by not being a complete carbon copy of her and father, that I want to come here in the first place. Many things.” She took a sip, trying – and failing – to sound unaffected.
Celebrimbor studied her. “She means well, you know.”
“I know.” Celebrían set her tankard down with quite a bit more force than necessary. “But that doesn’t help when everything I say or do makes me feel bad about myself. I constantly feel like I should be different, act differently, want different things – especially when it comes to you and Ost-in-Edhil. Is it so wrong to want things to be normal for once?”
“This city is always going to be a sore spot for her and your father,” Celebrimbor said. “It’s the same for me. We try to avoid it, but some things, like you coming here, simply force the confrontation with the conflict we’ve been trying to bury.”
Celebrían looked up at him from under her hood, her grey eyes wide, and for a moment, she looked much younger than her years. “Did you not want me to come here?” she asked, her voice small, and Celebrimbor’s heart broke a little.
He reached over the table his fingers closing over her hand that had turned to a white-knuckled fist on the table. “Of course I wanted you to visit. More than anything. I wish you came here more often. Stars, I wish your mother and father would visit more often – just without all the … baggage. But just because that isn’t going to happen and having you here is always going to cause some friction doesn’t mean that it isn’t worth it three times over when it means I get to see you.”
Celebrían held his gaze, searching his face – perhaps for dishonesty, perhaps for something else – then a small, tentative smile tugged at her lips. “Alright,” she said. Then, “Thank you.”
Celebrimbor arched an eyebrow. “For what? You’re paying, I hope you know that.”
Her smile turned into a grin. “Cheapskate.”
“I sacrificed my health and bodily integrity in bringing you here. You can stand to sacrifice a few silvers in turn.”
Celebrían stuck out her tongue at him, but didn’t argue further, instead taking another sip. “So,” she said when she set down her tankard once more, “how have you been?”
Celebrimbor shrugged. “Bad folk always live well, don’t you know that?”
“Don’t I know,” she chuckled. “How are you experiments coming along? Mother seems perpetually worried that we’re going to wake up one day and find out you’ve blown up the city.”
Celebrimbor thought back to the experiments he and Annatar we’re currently undertaking, and elected not to respond to that.
Celebrían cocked her head to one side. “What? Are you planning to blow up the city?” She sounded fascinated more than scandalized, which was probably one of the chief points why Artanis wanted to limit her daughter’s exposure to Celebrimbor. Again, he could not really fault her for it.
“Why,” he asked instead, “would I want to blow up my home?”
“I don’t know. I’ve certainly had the urge more than once,” Celebrían said with a shrug. “What are you working on?”
Celebrimbor thought briefly about how much to tell her, then decided that the truth would do, albeit without the finer details. “My friend wants to make cats talk.”
There was a brief silence as Celebrían processed this. “Make. Cats. Talk,” she repeated.
Celebrimbor nodded. “He has a special cat. She is … strange. She learned osanwë, for one. She can also read, and reason and argue, and I have the suspicion she is plotting a cat uprising, but that’s an issue for another day.”
Celebrían’s eyebrows had climbed to respectable heights already, but at “cat uprising”, they vanished under the fringe of her hair. Celebrimbor became suddenly and acutely aware how thoroughly mental his everyday life must seem from an outside perspective.
“I … see,” Celebrían said. “And this cat who knows osanwë is now supposed to … talk? Like we are talking right now?”
“No. Physical limitations. But we are thinking –”
Oh Valar, when had ‘Annatar has this idée fixe that a super-powered communications device could aid a cat in transcending limits when it comes to mind-to-mind conversation with mortals’ become ‘we are thinking that’?
Celebrimbor sighed. “He thinks he can engineer a device that allows her to mentally speak to mortals like humans or Dwarves.”
Celebrían gave him the look of someone who was trying very hard not to stare judgmentally at someone clinically insane. “I see. That’s … a project, I guess. I don’t know why I ever thought you’d be doing something useful and groundbreaking with your time.” She paused. “But why? This sounds worse than giving them opposable thumbs.”
“That’s just what I told him!” Celebrimbor said, feeling, all of a sudden, very vindicated in his barely-expressed, half-hearted reservations.
“Your scientist friend sounds like someone who’s so preoccupied with whether or not he could do the thing that he didn't stop to think if he should do the thing,” Celebrían observed.
“He very much is.” So, incidentally, was Celebrimbor, but it seemed like a bad moment to bring this up.
“And?”
“What?”
“Did you try to stop him?”
“Er.” Celebrimbor stared into his tankard. “We’re … actually. We are about to try out the prototype tomorrow.”
He could feel Celebrían’s stare boring into his forehead.
Silence stretched between them.
“Your friend,” Celebrían said at last. “This is the shady Maia that my mother is so worried about?”
“He’s not shady.”
“Noooo, he just pranced around Eregion, offering every leader of note the collaboration and knowledge that would make their most secret of desires come true. That’s not shady at all.”
Celebrimbor did not appreciate the sarcasm. He appreciated even less that his cousin had a point. “Fine. So maybe he is a little bit shady. But he’s working on it.”
“On getting less shady.”
“Yes.
“What a relief.” Celebrían drummed her fingers on the thick wooden table. Then her eyes flitted towards him. “I think I’m going to come and take a look at this demonstration, if you don’t mind.”
Celebrimbor felt a sinking feeling in his gut. He had promised his aunt to keep his cousin out of danger and, most importantly, away from Annatar. He also really, really did not want to say no to Celebrían, but at the same time he really, really didn’t want her in the same room during an experiment with a prototype that could potentially blow out a wing of the engineering quarter.
He also knew, given that the two of them had just broken out of the guildquarters together, that he had no chance of stopping Celebrían from getting anywhere.
Oh well. It seemed like his life wasn’t done balancing between impossible options.
Chapter End Notes
You can pry Celebrían Auditore da Firenze from my cold dead hands.
HELLO WORLD
The boys conduct their experiment and nothing goes wrong. No, really.
Read HELLO WORLD
When Celebrimbor woke, he came face to face with a giant, lidless yellow eye and a slitted pupil that was staring right into the depths of his soul. Then a voice exploded in his head:
GET UP YOU PEASANT, TODAY’S THE DAY!
Celebrimbor reaction to this was quite reasonable, if he might say so himself, meaning that he shouted, “What the ever-loving fuck!” at the top of his lungs, threw away his blanket, and ejected himself from his bed at escape velocity.
Something screeched, and two seconds later Annatar burst into the room, looking around and finding Celebrimbor pressed with his back to the wall and breathing like a bellows.
“What is going on?” Annatar demanded.
Which was a good question.
It was answered when the blanket, now a disorderly heap on the far side of the bed, began to move, and something under it started yowling and shredding the fabric.
“Is that Wraith?” Annatar asked incredulously.
Celebrimbor slunk closer, chest still heaving. “Maybe? I only saw a demonic eye?” He massaged his breastbone where his heart was still beating like mad. “The stupid thing must have jumped right into my face to wake me up.”
Annatar gave him a look. “And that is why you punt my cat across the room?”
“She nearly gave me a heart attack!” Celebrimbor pointed at the offending hump moving under the blanket. “Scratch ‘nearly’, I think I died and was resuscitated by shock.”
Annatar did not appear impressed. “Stop being so dramatic.”
“I am not being dramatic! I told you to keep the cat out of my private rooms!”
“I didn’t bring her in here!” Annatar bristled.
“Then how did she get into my bedroom?” Celebrimbor shot back. “I keep the doors locked at all times, because I know she can use handles and keys. Are you telling me your cat has learned to teleport?”
“How am I supposed to know what Wraith does in her free time?”
Celebrimbor let out an aggravated groan and pivoted on his heel. He needed some space. Right now. He marched off in the direction of his bathroom, then stopped. “Get her out of here. Right this instant,” he bit out. “When I come back I want to see neither hide nor hair. Of both of you.”
Annatar threw him a disgruntled look. “None of this is my fault.”
“Get. Out.”
Celebrimbor marched into the bathroom – and promptly slipped on the bar of soap that had chosen this moment to reappear out of its pocket dimension. He just barely caught himself against the wall and let out a string of cusswords heretofore unheard of this side of the Sundering Sea.
The morning was off to an awful start.
It truly made him dread what Today might still have in store for them.
*
An hour later, Celebrimbor was sitting his laboratory, going over the calculations one last time.
“I know I’ve asked before,” he said. “But what is your last estimate of the risk of blowing up the auditorium?”
“Three point six percent.”
“And the risk of Wraith’s brains exploding?”
“Seven point four percent.”
“She didn’t seem too fazed by that.”
“She’s a cat. Numbers are nothing to her, not due to cognitive limitations, but by choice.”
“I see. Good for her.”
“Yes, good for her.” Annatar was leaning against the desk in of the corner of his vision, arms crossed, and doing a magnificent job of distracting Celebrimbor. A big part of it was that the Maia had foregone his usual robes and dressed in a fairly new style of fashion that had sprung up in Rhûn, which consisted of slender grey trousers, a starched white shirt (sleeves rolled up to the elbows) and a grey waistcoat with golden stitching. He had also pulled his (as of thirty minutes ago auburn) hair back into a low ponytail and put on angular glasses that he absolutely didn’t need with respect to eyesight, but which did something to his face. The term ‘offensively attractive’ came to mind, for whatever reason.
Celebrimbor tried to focus on the formulae once more, determined that there was no immediate danger of anyone ending up dead because of blatant oversight and/or excessive stupidity, and threw the sheaf of paper aside.
“Okay. We’re doing this, it seems.” He rubbed his hands across his face, then dropped them, and looked at Annatar. Studied his new appearance once more. “Why?”
Annatar looked down at himself. “Well, in the spirit of your cousin wanting to attend the demonstration and me rather preferring to avoid your aunt coming down on our heads because she forbade Celebrían to meet an untrustworthy golden-haired Maia in white robes, I am letting said scoundrel disappear for today.”
“And you’re replacing him with a librarian?”
Annatar narrowed his eyes. “Ha-ha.”
Celebrimbor leaned back in his chair. “I mean, no offence, but who is supposed to be fooled by this?” He waved at Annatar’s clothes, the glasses, his … everything. “Do you want to slap on a moustache, too?”
“That would be rather unconvincing, don’t you think?” Annatar replied flatly.
“You mean, even more unconvincing than changing your clothes and hairstyle?” Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “You cannot go much lower in effort.”
“Why overshoot when ‘enough’ gets the job done?” Annatar’s mouth did something which wasn’t entirely a smile, and which wasn’t entirely an expression of contempt, but a weird hybrid of the two. “Have I ever told you about the time I masqueraded as a bearded human in rags with a name that was not in any way plausibly etymologically descended from any language spoken in Middle-earth?”
“Er. No. You didn’t.” Celebrimbor squinted at him. “You make it sound like you do this regularly.”
“Not that often. That being said, I fell … out of favour with the local powers-that-be, but seeing how I still needed something in that city, I changed my clothing and my hair, came back about two weeks later, and guess what? Nobody recognized me.”
Celebrimbor laughed and shook his head. “No way. Nobody would be that blind or stupid.”
“You’d be surprised,” Annatar said archly.
Celebrimbor considered this. Studied Annatar’s “disguise” again. “I,” he said at last, “am going to be so mad if this works.”
*
Celebrimbor was so mad.
Naturally, the entirety of the Mírdain, who’d rather die than miss the spectacle, had snickered when Annatar had stridden into the auditorium and descended the amphitheatre steps between the rows and rows of chairs with long, springy steps. He’d even winked at them.
Celebrían had only shot Celebrimbor a confused look, but her guards, though looking a bit nervous as to what this “demonstration” might involve, did not grab her and haul her out of the room by the scruff of her neck. Not even a sign of recognition.
Celebrimbor, who had not believed this possible, had even dressed similarly to Annatar and told the other Mírdain to do likewise, so the Maia wouldn’t stick out like a sore thumb.
The Galadrim were gawking at them, but more generally, as if questioning both the overall sanity and the fashion sense of the inhabitants of Ost-in-Edhil.
When Celebrimbor joined Annatar at the lecturer’s desk, his hands in the pockets of his trousers, the Maia threw him a triumphant smirk. “What did I tell you?”
“Be quiet.”
The auditorium was filling up quickly. There was no way to keep a scientific breakthrough of any kind secret for long in Ost-in-Edhil. As far as Celebrimbor was concerned, he had told nobody but Celebrían about the date and time of their experiment, and yet somehow the entire guild and them some had found its way here.
Something next to his legs made Mrrrow and Wraith launched herself up onto the desk at Celebrimbor’s elbow.
When do I get the powers I deserve? she asked, yellow lamp-eyes staring up at him with impatience.
“You do not get any powers,” Celebrimbor replied curtly. “If this works out, you can mind-speak to Non-Eldar, that is all.”
Wraith’s eyes went completely round. Her tail stood up stick-straight, her fur a bottlebrush. UNLIMITED POWER. I SHALL BE ABLE TO COMMAND ANYONE TO GIVE ME TREATS. THE GODS SHALL FEAR ME.
Celebrimbor rolled his eyes. “If you say so.”
RAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH! Wraith let out an ear-piercing yowl. One of the Galadrim in the back row flinched.
Celebrimbor ran his hand down his face and spent a minute regretting the choices that had brought him here. The fact that they had all of them been his own, and made willingly to boot, gave him a feeling of visceral self-loathing.
By the time Annatar had prepared the Ring and the circle of rods and earth-wires that would (hopefully) catch a stray bolt of overcharge that was (even more hopefully) never going to happen, the auditorium was full to bursting.
“Did you invite everyone?” Celebrimbor asked sceptically, eyeing their audience. By Varda, even the students were there.
“Naturally,” Annatar said. “If we’re going to make a scientific breakthrough, I want there to be witnesses.”
Celebrimbor frowned. “We have not tested this before. What if it goes wrong?”
“Things I create don’t go wrong,” Annatar said without looking up from where he was wrapping the final earthwire around one of the conductor rods on their tripods.
When are you done? Wraith asked, and nearly scared Celebrimbor to death for a second time today when she landed on his shoulder out of nowhere. She was purring so loudly his left ear was vibrating with it.
“Just about,” Celebrimbor said. “Now get off.”
In response, Wraith settled down on his left shoulder and dug her claws into his waistcoat to clarify that she was staying there, and no, this was not a democratic decision up for debate or vote.
Celebrimbor glared at her.
Wraith purred even louder.
“Wraith,” Annatar said in this moment, back still towards them.
What, Wraith said.
“Come here.”
Why.
“Because I say so.”
Get lost.
“And because I am going to give you the device that gives you your powers.”
With a leap whose force made Celebrimbor’s shoulder recoil, Wraith flew of his shoulder and galloped over to Annatar, who was crouching down. Wraith eagerly stood up on her hind legs, front paws on his knee.
“I need to put this on your leg,” Annatar said, showing her a golden clasp just about wide enough to fit around her front leg.
Wraith sniffed at it with suspicion. What is it? What does it do?
“It’s like a signal transmitter to send your thoughts to the Ring. Whatever you say in your mind will be transmitted to it –,” he pointed over his shoulder to the small band of gold mounted on another tripod in the middle of the wire circle, “ – and if the device works as intended, the Ring is going to broadcast your mind-speak into the brains of everyone in the room.”
This sounds terrible, Wraith said. Let’s do it. She extended her paw and Annatar fixed the clasp around her front leg.
When he stood, he looked down at her. “Are you sure you want to do this?”
Wraith stared up at him. Why not? I thought things you created don’t go wrong. She took a look around the full auditorium. Afraid that all their heads are going to explode after all?
Annatar narrowed his eyes. “It’s your head I’m most worried about.”
I thought the dangerous thingamajig was the gold ring in the circle.
“It is, but it is also connected to your transmitter, so you won’t be protected by the circle.”
Whatever.
Annatar sighed. He leaned down again and ruffled her head. “I’ll watch out for you,” he said, uncharacteristically anxious. “If something goes wrong, I’ll intercept the – ”
Wraith swatted at him. Give me my powers.
Annatar glowered at her. “You’re horrible.”
Yes, horribly impatient for you two hens to get a move on. So – get a move on. Wraith plopped her rump down on the floor and stared up at Annatar.
The Maia turned towards Celebrimbor. “Ready?”
Celebrimbor walked around the wire circle, checking the connections one last time. “Ready.”
Annatar took a deep breath that he physiologically didn’t need, then walked over and touched the Ring in the middle of the wire circle. Golden tengwar script flared up around its circumference, as if veins of fire had come to life.
Celebrimbor had seen it before, but still he held his breath. Someone in the audience gasped. Celebrían, who had – much to the grief of her worried guard – taken a seat in the front row, was watching with rapt fascination. She was as tense as if she wanted to jump up and join them near the experimental assembly, which would have been a terrible idea all around.
A low hum went through the auditorium. The floor, the air, the windowpanes vibrated on a frequency that was inaudible to every ear – because it didn’t exist in the physical world. It was pure power, and merely its ripples could be felt in the real world.
Celebrían’s guards, which had been on edge before, looked ready to throw the princess of their shoulders and abscond from the room.
Annatar threw a nervous look between the Ring and Wraith. The air had begun to crackle between them, and tiny sparks were fizzling in an arc between them like miniature lightning.
Suddenly, doing the experiment inside and with a room full of people seemed beyond idiotic. Celebrimbor took a step back.
The thrum in the air got louder. Static crackled.
Wraiths eyes were wide and fixed upon the Ring. The clasp around her forearm glowed.
Suddenly, an electric blue arc of lightning shot from the Ring towards the cat. Wraith’s entire fur poofed up and bristled, and Celebrimbor did not know whether it was out of fear, or aggression, or the fact that lightning was shooting towards her and charging the entire air –
Annatar stepped forward, hand outstretched. He was fast, but not fast enough.
There were few things in the universe that could outmatch a god when it came to speed. Light was one of them. There was a flash, a boom, and an almighty crack when the overcharge shot up into the ceiling in a pillar of blue light, and punched a hole the size of a pot-lid into and through two feet of plaster, timber, and solid stone. The coloured windowpanes that ran all along the south side of the auditorium rattled in their frames.
Celebrimbor stumbled backwards, arms raised against the glare.
Which was when the worst thing that could have happened in this situation happened:
Telperinquar! Artanis was all but shouting inside his skull, and if his ears hadn’t been ringing from the boom already, he would have all but gone deaf. Explain to me what you are doing this instant and why my daughter is with you!
Oh, all hells of Angband, Celebrimbor thought.
Which was the exact moment when another thing happened; a thing which quickly and efficiently clotheslined “interference of aunt” in the race for Worst Thing That Could Possibly Happen In This Particular Situation, cut its hamstrings, and sashayed over the finish line.
It was in this exact second, that in the echo of the boom that had deafened the auditorium, a shout rang out – but like the power of the Ring it was not something audible, because it was not transmitted by soundwaves and air, but by pure, unfettered willpower, osanwë, and madness:
I AM BECOME WRAITH, DESTROYER OF WORLDS. HEAR MY VOICE AND DESPAIR!
The already overtaxed windowpanes blew out of their sashes in a rain of coloured glass. Plaster rained down from the ceiling.
Belatedly, it occurred to Celebrimbor that since Wraith was using mind-to-mind speak to everyone in the room, and since he was currently in an established connection with his aunt, it meant that Artanis had heard every word that had just been not-said.
Oh, for Morgoth’s sake, somebody kill me, Celebrimbor thought.
Do not worry, Artanis said, her voice promising a slow demise after extended torture. I will.
The blue pillar of light faded.
Wraith came back into view. She had planted all of her four feet as if braced against a storm. Her lamp-eyes were wide and crazed, her fur one puffed-up cloud around her. Her tail looked like an exploded lightning rod.
Did you hear that? she asked, her mental voice trembling with excitement. Did you hear that?
The audience, that had heretofore sat shocked and stunned, drew breath again.
One gangly Dwarven student of information technology in the second row adjusted his glasses, which the shockwave had blown askew. He, like many others, had a fine dust of plaster in his red hair.
“Yeah, damn right we heard you,” he said. “But why the heck did you feel the need to shout like that. You know, you could’ve just said, ‘Hello world’.”
Wraith didn’t even have the grace to look sheepish, which, considering she was a cat, actually made a lot of sense.
Chapter End Notes
See? See??! This is what happens when you keep saying "What could go wrong?".
Risk Containment and Damage Control
In which an unlikely science dream team is formed, some parts of history are intent on happening no matter how alternate the universe, and Celebrimbor would like for things to be over, thank you very much.
Read Risk Containment and Damage Control
“‘Things that I create don’t go wrong’,” Celebrimbor intoned, wildly gesticulating and brandishing the rolled up experimental notes in his left hand. “Never – never again am I going to believe you when you say this!”
Annatar hurried down the hallway alongside him, intermittently sidestepping the paper roll when it came whizzing dangerous close to his head. “There’s no need to be so snappish,” he said, rather snappishly. “All things considered, everything went quite well. The device worked as intended and nobody got harmed –”
“Nobody got harmed?” Celebrimbor rounded on Annatar with a fury that made the Maia stop in his tracks and take a step back. Celebrimbor followed like a hyena on a blood trail. He poked his finger into Annatar’s chest. “The auditorium is in ruins, there is a hole in the ceiling that’s big enough to observe sidereal movement, and I am about to be quartered and burnt at the stake by my aunt!” He punctuated every sentence with another jab until the Maia was standing with his back pressed to the wall of the hallway.
“Why would she do that?” Annatar asked, his hands raised in defence.
Celebrimbor leaned in. “Oh, I don’t know, maybe because we nearly blew up the west wing of the guild quarters and her daughter with it?”
“No, I mean, why would she quarter you and burn you at the stake?” Annatar asked. “That doesn’t make sense. She cannot kill you twice.”
Celebrimbor hit Annatar over the head with the paper roll. The paper made a very funny sound on impact, but its epic hilarity was lost on both interlocutors: on Celebrimbor because he was in as red-hot a rage as he had ever been, and on Annatar because he looked like he simply couldn’t process what had just happened.
“Did you just hit me?”
“Damn right I did!” Celebrimbor snapped.
“You can’t do that!”
“Oh, watch me, Annatar, I’ll –”
They were interrupted by a shout and a figure scrambling around the corner of the hallway.
“Telpo!”, Celebrían cried, sprinted down the hallway. “There you are!” She skidded to halt before them, not even slightly out of breath, which was more than mildly offensive to Celebrimbor, who considered himself to be in quite good shape, but would never have managed a sprint like that without breathlessly folding over at the end.
“That was bloody corking!” Celebrían exclaimed, clasping her hands, her eyes all but sparkling. “I have never seen anything like that before! Are you going to do it again?”
“We are most assuredly not going to do it again,” Celebrimbor said at the same time Annatar said, “Maybe.”
Celebrimbor glared at him.
Celebrían threw a confused look between them. “I – er. Okay.” Her gaze flitted back to Annatar. “Oh – are you the Maia?” She examined him with new interest, her gaze catching on his clothes. “Nice getup. Very modern.”
“Thanks.”
Celebrían looked back up at his face and frowned pensively. “I thought you were blond, though.”
In lieu of a response, Annatar shook his head and gold cascaded down from his crown to the ends of his hair like a waterfall, flushing the auburn away.
“Neat.” Celebrían inclined her head to one side. “Can you do it to mine, too?”
Annatar gave her a look. “No.”
“Shame.” She shrugged, then turned towards Celebrimbor. “You do not seriously want to break the experiment off here, right?”
Celebrimbor gave her an incredulous look. “Rían, I don’t know if you noticed, but we nearly killed half the faculty today, almost blew up the great auditorium, and your mother is, in this moment, on her way to Ost-in-Edhil in order to kill me in the most painful way possible.”
Celebrían had the gall to blow a raspberry and wave it off. “Ah, I’m sure she didn’t mean it like that.”
“She was in my head. I can tell you that she most assuredly meant it like that.”
“Well then, all the more reason for not stopping it!” Celebrían exclaimed empathically.
Celebrimbor frowned. “I’m not following. In what world does it make sense to continue the very experiment that has caused your mother to come after me with a pitchfork for endangering you?”
“Well, the world in which you show her that it wasn’t dangerous at all!” Celebrían threw out her arms in a gesture of the very specific type of exasperation felt by people who’d believed to be interacting with someone smart, only to feel criminally intellectually shortchanged. “Look, I don’t know much about science, but these cages – what are they called? Faradin’s cages? – that block lightning from getting in or out of it? That has to work on this, too, doesn’t it? If you manage to build a shield that could contain potential lightning bolts, you eliminate the problem at the root. Bam, no more danger!”
Celebrimbor raised both eyebrows. “It’s not an electromagnetic field discharge, but…”
He looked at Annatar, who had inclined his head, eyes fixed on Celebrían. Celebrimbor could see the Maia visibly recalibrating his estimation of his cousin from “person who jumps around rooftops at night for no good reason” to “person I should probably take seriously”.
“It might work,” Annatar said slowly. “We’d have to make a special cage and imbue it with the ability to create a shield that is able to contain the … psycho-connective powers of the Ring, or let them escape in a controlled direction and at the exact desired strength.”
“Which is something you should have done beforehand anyway,” Celebrían said.
Annatar’s eye twitched, but he could hardly argue the point after what had happened in the auditorium.
“In any case, if you were to do this, my mother could hardly find fault with the experiment, couldn’t she? If anything, you’re going to show her a cat with slightly autocratic tendencies that has a funny speaking machine,” Celebrían said. “There’s no harm in that, other than the fact that my father is allergic to cats, but that’s no one’s fault. Right?”
Annatar and Celebrimbor looked at each other.
“We’d have to be quick,” Celebrimbor said. “She’ll be here in three days at most. And I need to get the ceiling fixed.”
“Do that,” Annatar said. “Meanwhile, I’ll build the cage.”
“Can I join?” Celebrían asked.
Both elf and Maia turned their heads.
“I don’t know,” Celebrimbor said hesitantly. Celebrían did climb and leap around rooftops and towers at night, so there wasn’t any danger of her falling from a scaffolding while rendering a wall. But after what had happened in the auditorium…
“I won’t be in the way,” Celebrían said, and Celebrimbor suddenly realized that his cousin wasn’t talking to him.
Annatar looked at her.
Celebrían looked back. She didn’t say ‘please’. Which, funnily enough, might just have been the thing that won her the argument, since Annatar hated begging and any demonstration of subordination, if he was meant to respect any given person.
Still, when Annatar said, “Fine,” Celebrimbor thought he’d misheard.
“You’re taking her with you?” he asked, incredulous.
Annatar shrugged. “She has displayed acceptable intelligence and ability to reason.” Which was code for, “I am impressed, but I am going to combust before I come out and admit it”.
Celebrimbor stared. “You are taking her with you?” he repeated. “After everything we’ve just said?”
“Well, it’s not as if we are going to blow up anything else,” Annatar said.
Celebrían had the gall to look disappointed.
Celebrimbor had the sudden and violent urge to give both of them a clip around the ear to rattle their brains back to where they belonged. “No.”
Celebrían crossed her arms. “You cannot make me stay away.”
“I know, which is why I am asking you to have some common sense!” he snapped out. “It’s not your neck that’s on the line here!”
Celebrían rolled her eyes. “My mother is not going to kill you.”
“And that is supposed to be reassuring?” In this moment Celebrimbor felt intense empathy with Artanis’ lament that her daughter had outgrown the age where you could just throw her over your shoulder, chuck her into a room, and expect her to stay there.
“Look,” Celebrían said in the tone of someone who was about to use a sledgehammer in an argument that called for surgical precision instruments. “We’ve established that you cannot forbid me from doing anything. We’ve also established that I am going to go with him whether you say yes or no. As for your neck being on the line – that’s exactly what I want to get to work on. So, stop fretting and let us do the thing.”
Celebrimbor wanted to kick something. “Oh, so it’s ‘us’ now?” He gestured between Annatar and her.
Annatar just gave a one-shoulder shrug.
“You absolute traitor,” Celebrimbor said, appalled.
Annatar smiled wryly.
Celebrimbor’s gaze darkened. “Oh, go and blow yourselves up for all I care. I’m going to fix the ceiling.” He turned around and stalked off. If he was going to die, he was going to do it with his guild building intact. That way, at least, he would leave behind one thing that he had repaired after breaking it.
*
“What the hell,” Celebrimbor said, “is that supposed to be?”
They were standing in Annatar’s workshop and Celebrimbor kept staring at the monstrosity in front of him. It was about half the size of a grown man, had a slightly conical shape, like a tower getting narrower towards the top, and with a flat platform on the top. It was also, for some ungodly reason, equipped with small wheels.
“That’s the cage!” Celebrían replied.
“Why did you make it out of folded black iron?”
“Well, it turns out that it does work like a Faradin cage, at least mostly,” Celebrían said enthusiastically. “The iron gets rid of the electromagnetic field problems, which were a thing after all, and on a molecular level, Annatar imbued it with isolation against the mind-powers getting out. Right?” She turned towards the Maia, looking for confirmation.
“Slightly unacademic, but correct in its broad strokes,” Annatar said, leaning against the wall with one shoulder. He had his arms crossed and one ankle crossed over the other. Celebrimbor wished he would stop standing like that, because the Maia’s self-satisfied posture made him want to kick over the tower-cage.
Celebrimbor looked at the thing again. “It looks atrocious.”
Well, I love it, and it’s my rollie-tower, Wraith said, inviting herself into the conversation completely unsolicited, as always. It’s awesome and scary and I can even sit on the platform on top, look!
Celebrimbor felt a headache coming on. “Why … you do not mean for this to roll around the city, right? Please tell me that you do not mean for this to roll around the city.”
“Why else would we have put wheels on it?” Celebrían said. “Wraith needs to get around.”
In Celebrimbor’s opinion, the last thing Wraith should be able to do is to be mobile enough to bother people all over Ost-in-Edhil, but he was clearly in the minority here.
“So she steers it mentally?” he asked weakly. There was increasing despair in his voice and the fact that Annatar was clearly trying to not burst out laughing made it ten times worse. Celebrimbor had been so proud of Ost-in-Edhil having been built in a wheelchair-accessible manner with lots of ramps and flat doorsteps. To have this idea ruined by this karmic boomerang made him feel depths of despair and disgust he thought he’d outgrown after the First Age. Truly, no good deed ever went unpunished.
“She does,” Annatar confirmed, and as if on cue, Wraith hopped onto the damned thing and with a low susurrus of wheels, started driving the tower to and fro all around the room.
“Does it ever run out of battery?” Celebrimbor asked, feeble hope raising its head one last time.
Only to be crushed under Annatar’s metaphorical heel when he said, “It runs exclusively on the powers of her mind, which are considerable and growing stronger every day.”
Wraith drove the tower in a circle around Celebrimbor, purring loudly.
“Telpo, you look depressed,” Celebrían observed.
Celebrimbor elected not to reply to that. Deciding that he might as well get it over with and perform the inevitable coup-de-grace on his own morals here and now, he pointed at the tower and asked, “And those two spiky things on top?”
“Cat ears,” Celebrían said proudly.
“Cat ears,” Celebrimbor repeated. He glanced at Annatar, who had raised one hand to cover his mouth, clearly hanging on to his composure like a drowning man clinging to a plank of wood in a storm-tossed ocean. “I despise you for this.”
Annatar did not reply, merely made noise that could have been an aborted cough, then went on to look out of the window.
“But do you know the best thing about it?” Celebrían said.
Celebrimbor did not want to know what the best thing about this horrible creation was, but before he could say so, his cousin ploughed on.
“Wraith can even control it remotely!” she exclaimed excitedly. “Wraith, show him what happens if you do that!”
Wraith dutifully hopped off the tower, galloped over to the other end of the room and ordered, Heel!
The tower slowly turned on its axis. At the same time, fire flared between the tip of the cat ears, and a yellow, slit-pupilled cat eye appeared on top of the tower, only to home in on Wraith. The eye locked in on the cat, and the tower eagerly zoomed over, stopping in front of her like a dog awaiting its next instruction.
“Why does the tower have an eye,” Celebrimbor asked, not even bothering with intonation anymore.
“So it doesn’t run into anything,” Celebrían said. “Duh.”
It was enough. Celebrimbor had had enough. He said so. “I’ve had enough. Goodbye.” He walked out of the room. Moments later he stopped, because he heard a small humming noise behind him.
He turned around.
The tower was two steps behind him.
Celebrimbor stared at it. The cat-eye on the tower stared back. Somehow, it managed to appear vaguely guilty and-or sheepish, which was a stark contrast to the black cat, the Maia, and the elf woman, who were peeking around the doorframe of Annatar’s workshop, stacked by height like three absolute goblins in a trenchcoat, and trying (and failing) not to laugh.
“I hate all three of you,” Celebrimbor muttered, turned around, and all but ran down the length of the hallway.
*
Celebrimbor was not a coward. He did not, however, have a death wish, which is why he sent an entourage of envoys to come and greet Artanis and her husband at the gates.
There was no specific reason for him to wander around the guild halls afterwards, either, but on an abstract level, he needed a few more minutes to make peace with his fate before confronting it.
He stalled for another half-hour by wandering the ghostly empty corridors, then he reluctantly directed his steps into the direction of the auditorium. The first public presentation of the tower was to be another grand spectacle, and this time, Celebrimbor had agreed to invite everyone and their dog – if only out of the vague hope that a big audience might prevent his aunt from massacring him on sight.
With every step he came closer, the hum and buzz of a crowd of people became louder. Little groups of people were standing together in front of the doors of the grand auditorium, talking excitedly among themselves. Some looked up when Celebrimbor passed them by and waved their hands in greeting.
Celebrimbor waved back, but his heart wasn’t in it. He felt like man marching to the gallows when he passed through the door and let his eyes wander over the descending rows of seats. He saw neither Annatar nor Wraith, but he managed to spot Celebrían, who was talking to her parents. The three of them were standing behind the topmost row of seats, as far from the centre of the auditorium as they could possibly be while still remaining in the room. Celebrían was talking animatedly and waving her hands around a lot, while Artanis was wearing a thunderous expression. Celeborn, for his part, looked miserable. He covertly pulled out a handkerchief and sneezed. Celebrimbor belatedly remembered that he was allergic to cats. Oh well. It was not as if this was going to be the straw that broke the horse’s back today. Or rather, Celebrimbor’s neck.
In this instant, Artanis caught Celebrimbor’s gaze over her daughter’s shoulder. The gaze did a magnificent job of both nailing Celebrimbor to the spot and making him feel like he was fifty years old again, back in Valinor, and had just been caught using one Artanis’ spears as a throwing stick for Huan. It had seemed like a funny idea at the time but had ended up being Not a Very Fond Memory After All.
Celebrimbor pulled up his shoulders and slunk over towards them. Family reunions, oh joy.
“Greetings, Aunt. Uncle,” he said, when he came to a halt before them.
Celeborn sneezed again and begged off with a vague gesture, turning away before diving face-first back into his handkerchief. His guards watched on in silent commiseration.
Artanis, on the other hand, did not reply. Her gaze looked like it was effortlessly capable of drilling a hole into someone’s skull.
Celebrimbor was struck by the thought that he was currently living in the same city as Morgoth’s former lieutenant, and wasn’t half as scared of him as he was of his aunt.
“Oh, Telpo!” Celebrían exclaimed in the most implausible pretence of surprise that he had ever heard. “I had not seen you there!” She hooked her arm through his elbow and pulled him to her side in the inimical family circle. “Isn’t it grand that we finally get to meet here again, all of us together?”
“Grand,” Celebrimbor replied tonelessly. “I hope you had pleasant journey.”
Artanis did, once again, not reply.
Celebrían looked between them, then fearlessly led the charge into the trenches, hopeless though it might be. “I’ve been having such a splendid time here! Telperinquar showed me around, and I was able to meet the guild again, and Falda, and the cat – Have you seen her yet? She is terrifically sweet, such a nice little thing! – and overall, he’s been so intent on taking good care of me, you would not believe it.”
“Quite unbelievable indeed,” Artanis said. You could have frozen and preserved fish on her voice.
“Yes,” Celebrían forged on. “He’s been very attentive and kind, as were his friends. They made me feel very welcome here and even allowed me to look in on their experiments.”
“I am aware,” her mother commented, not taking her eyes of Celebrimbor.
“Not the dangerous ones, of course,” said Celebrían. Her endurance to keep fighting in the face of overwhelming adversity was nothing short of admirable. “But he did allow me to watch how they made their cat talk – which is something I wanted to show you today, so I begged them to repeat it!”
“That must have been a … bang of an experiment,” Artanis commented, staring Celebrimbor down.
“There was some interference in our connection,” Celebrimbor said. “I apologize if it unsettled you.”
Artanis turned to look at the ceiling of the auditorium, where a rough circle of fresh, brilliantly white plaster shone on the older, off-white wash around it. “Some interference,” she said drily.
Celebrimbor gave up. There was no use lying to someone who could, for all intents and purposes, flip your skullcap open and sort through your thoughts like other people perused a library index.
It was in this moment, however, that rescue arrived from the most unexpected of angles.
“Tyelperinquar! There you are!”, someone shouted and a hand clapped down on his shoulder.
Artanis, Celebrían, and Celebrimbor turned around.
Anthere was standing in front of them, looking very official and very serious. “You will be needed downstairs shortly,” they said. Behind them, a good part of the Mírdain was assembled, among them Falda, Throndur, Gildiriel, Sindrian, and … Daeror?
“We did not want to begin the experiment without you. We checked the safety measures and whether the participants were ready, nonetheless we defer to your determination whether the experiment is safe to begin,” Falda added.
Celebrimbor stared at them. Not only was there deference to a superior, orderly conduct and Big Concern For Safety, but there was also not a single mention of Annatar, whose name would have certainly served to detonate the situation from awful into lethal.
“Ah, certainly,” he said, throwing a dubious look over his shoulder. He half-expected Artanis to grab him by the back of his collar to make him stay like a disorderly child, but his aunt just kept looking at him in this dangerous way where you felt like the illustration in an anatomy textbook.
“By all means,” she said, then waved down the stairs. “Demonstrate.”
It was a window of escape if he was ever going to get one. Celebrimbor fled. The Mírdain closed ranks around him.
Daeror fell into step beside him and leaned over. “Eleventh hour rescue mission, aye?”
“You could say that,” Celebrimbor said, noticing only now how much cold sweat was making his shirt stick to his back. “How did you know?”
“Oh, someone tipped us off that you might be in a bit of a tight spot,” Daeror said with a wry smirk. “We hurried here posthaste to begin the extraction.”
Celebrimbor blinked. He looked around, but once again, there was no trace of Annatar. He descended the steps, distantly wondering if there was a word for the emotion of simultaneously wanting to punch and kiss somebody.
“He’s not here?”
“Oh, he knows better than that. I bet he’s waiting in the wings, though. Not like him to leave out the opportunity to see how your invention presents to the masses.”
Celebrimbor took a deep breath.
“Calm down, Tyelpo,” Falda said, nudging his hip with her elbow when they reached the bottom of the auditorium. “We’re here. We’re all in this together. And we’re going to be the best lab assistants you’ve ever had, I swear.”
Celebrimbor nodded, feeling slightly floaty and untethered from his body. “Yes. Thank you. I appreciate it. Really.” He looked around. “Can somebody get the cat?”
“On it,” Anthere said and they departed through the back door beside the blackboard, which was used by the lecturers and the students in wheelchairs to access the first row of tables.
Moments later, Wraith marched in, while Anthere pushed the tower into the auditorium, for now veiled with a white cloth. The two spikes on top made the entire machine appear like a humongous cat stuck inside the worst ghost costume of all time.
There was a murmur and a few giggles went up in the audience when they saw it.
Wraith marched up to Celebrimbor. Hello there, she said pleasantly.
Celebrimbor was acutely aware of the fact that she was holding his fate in her paws. One false move, one deranged shout of supreme power or some such, and he was done for. “Do not,” he said, “backstab me.”
I do not have thumbs. I cannot hold knives. Wraith sat down and easily licked her front paw.
“I mean it,” Celebrimbor hissed.
Don’t worry big guy, I will be on my best behaviour. Wraith looked up and threw him the most devious look a cat had ever produced. You can trust me.
Nothing she could have said would have made him trust her any less, but in this moment a bell rang, the doors to the auditorium closed, and time was up.
Chapter End Notes
Yes, Wraith gets to roomba around on a mini-Barad-Dûr now, why do you ask?
General Intelligence...
Read General Intelligence...
Without him having to say anything, the crowd quieted down. Celebrimbor was indescribably glad to have his guild companions standing beside him, for he truly felt like facing an enemy army without weapons and a backup plan.
Well then. Here goes nothing.
He stepped forward. “A good day to you all, and thank you for coming. We’ve invited you here to witness the first presentation of a methodologically sound device for transmitting thoughts of Non-Eldar to a recipient, regardless of whether they are Khazad, human, or Eldarin. Some of you have already participated in the demonstration of the prototype – ”
The snigger that went up in the auditorium was expected, but supremely unhelpful. Then again, perhaps it went to show that nobody here was taking this experiment seriously, and that there was, in fact, no danger at all to it, nor had there ever been.
“ – which suffered from an unstable transmission process as well as energy fluctuations that made ongoing conversation with a particular chosen partner difficult,” Celebrimbor finished determinedly. “We solved those problems by incorporating the transmitter into a cage that, for one, builds a stable field around it, and furthermore prevents indiscriminate communication by directing the mental transmission to the person it is intended to go to.”
He gestured at Anthere, and they wheeled the tower into the centre of the auditorium.
Meanwhile, Falda put the clasp transmitter onto Wraith’s front paw. Her fur puffed up a bit and there was a bit of static in the air, but otherwise, nothing happened.
Celebrimbor tore his gaze away, facing the audience again. “We shall now demonstrate how it works, and later on, you are free to come down here and try the device yourself. Humans and Khazad are especially encouraged, seeing how they are not capable of osanwë.”
Two students in wheelchairs in the front-row high-fived each other with broad grins. Not only where they especially invited, no, they would also get a headstart over everyone else thanks to their seating.
“We shall begin with a transmission to everyone in the room,” Celebrimbor said, gesturing at Wraith.
Their eyes met.
If you mess this up, I am going to make a rug out of you, he told her.
Wraith slow-blinked. I can kill you in a lonely alley and make it so that nobody ever finds your corpse. She averted her face and with a dignified, slow pace, she sat down next to the tower.
Celebrimbor did not want to go on. In fact, he would have preferred anything else over continuing this march to the gallows. But there was nothing for it now, not with all those people here and Artanis watching. He made a gesture towards Anthere. Nausea was coiling in his throat.
Anthere nodded, and pulled the cloth off the tower.
Low gasps and excited murmurs in the crowd.
“What the hell is that?” a young woman from Harad stage-whispered.
Wraith looked at the audience. The golden clasp around her forearm glowed. Her eyes were preternaturally bright.
She stretched, then jumped on top of the tower, before sitting down once more.
Good day, ladies and gentlemen, she said amicably. I cordially welcome you this presentation. I am rather pleased to see that you are all seated, for I do understand that this demonstration might put some of you off-balance. Rest assured that this is nothing to be ashamed of. We cannot all have a feline sense of balance.
Stunned silence.
Then someone laughed. Celebrimbor turned his head.
Daeror was leaning against the teacher’s desk, arms crossed, and had his head thrown back. “Marvellous,” he exclaimed, wiping his eyes. “Simply marvellous!”
As always, there was that one person in the audience that had been living under a rock up until today, and somehow managed to miss all the important news of the last year, including the reason for the venue that they had somehow found their way into.
“The cat can talk?” they exclaimed. “What in the blazes is going on here? Why is the cat talking?”
Wraith took it in stride. I have been engineered to be of superior intelligence than the rest of my species. Which, I will freely admit, is something that sounds more amusing than it actually is. Do try having a conversation about experimental ethics with someone who cannot tell Carnodon from Dimué.
Predictably, the portion of students from the faculty of philosophy dissolved into gleeful giggles. No better way to get the audience on your side than making fun of last century’s most pretentious thinkers, after all.
Celebrimbor watched the exchange, wide-eyed.
Falda nudged him again. “What’d I tell you?”
My intelligence notwithstanding, certain anatomical limitations have heretofore prevented me from being able to properly converse with sentient beings of similar reasoning skills. It was, I must say, rather lonely. This is why the Guild of the Mírdain kindly took it upon themselves to build a crutch for me so I could break out of the cage of silence and solitude that someone with my laryngeal anatomy is so unfortunately forced into.
Wraith wrapped her tail around her front legs.
I do want to add at this point, that this experiment was not merely caprice, amusing and frivolous though it might appear at first glance. This new technology, spearheaded by the Mírdain and Tyelperinquar Curufinwion in particular, will bring many benefits to a wide group of people, chief of them those among you who find yourselves unwilling or unable to speak in the conventional way – be it due to injury or old trauma. Beyond that, the possible applications of broadcasting devices are innumerable in everyday life, able-bodied individuals included. I shall not insult your intelligence by enumerating them here and now.
Wraith rose, stretched and then looked at the audience again. To prevent boredom and, incidentally, in order to dispel any suspicions some of you might have as to this being a pre-recorded message by a prankster and me being trained like a circus cat, I shall now take questions. Spontaneous answers to your questions should suffice to disperse any remaining doubt. I invite you to come forward. Don’t be shy.
The auditorium was silent for all but three seconds. Then noise erupted, people jumped to their feet, and Wraith was swarmed by people. It was all that Anthere and Throndûr could do to put themselves between the excited students, teachers, and colleagues from other guilds, to prevent someone from accidentally pushing over the tower.
Celebrimbor could only stand by and watch, completely flabbergasted.
A quiet voice spoke up at the back of his mind: How’s that for ‘on your best behaviour’, you chicken?
He caught Wraith’s eyes over the crowd of people. On a rational level, he knew that cats were anatomically unable to smirk. However, his eyes were telling him very clearly that if a cat were to smirk, this was what they would look like.
Suddenly, in the midst of all the chaos, he felt a hand at his waist and then someone was leaning over his shoulder and speaking directly into his ear:
“Did that go according to your expectations, Tyelperinquar?”
He flinched and whirled around.
Annatar was, anatomically, very much able to smirk and he was currently making liberal use of that ability. He was, once again, wearing his dress shirt and waistcoat, and once again, auburn-haired.
“I’m still mad at you,” Celebrimbor said, because he felt the great urge to make a point, though as to what point exactly that was, he wasn’t entirely sure.
“Truly?” Annatar raised an eyebrow. “You look like you traversed three hells and came out on the other side. I thought you’d be relieved.”
“I can be relieved and angry.”
“Of course you can. You do contain multitudes.” Annatar pulled him in a bit closer. “Quite a magnificent show, though, you cannot deny that.”
Celebrimbor blinked and looked over at Wraith. “No,” he said, feeling a bit like someone had emptied out his insides and put him back together wrong. “She’s … impressive.”
“That shouldn’t come as a surprise. I exclusively befriend impressive people.” Annatar smiled at him in a slightly devious manner, and that did another thing to Celebrimbor’s brain. He had to sit down, he really did.
“My aunt,” he said weakly.
“Will not find fault with this, I’ve made sure of it,” Annatar said. “That being said, I think she is interested in your cat, and she might want to talk to you. I will find you later.”
Celebrimbor was sure he’d only blinked, but Annatar was gone. The warm presence at his side faded, even if he still felt a slight phantom pressure at his waist where Annatar’s hand had been. He shook his head, just in time to see Celebrían pull her mother down the last few steps of the auditorium, the crowd respectfully parting around them.
Celeborn, for his part, had remained in the back row, and was currently looking longingly in the direction of the exit.
Still feeling slightly unsteady on his feet, Celebrimbor walked over to meet his relatives.
“ – even visit advanced math lectures!” Celebrían extolled, gesturing wildly at Wraith.
Artanis looked sceptical. “I am not sure whether cats should be attending math lectures.”
Celebrimbor found himself most unexpectedly agreeing with her.
I find no fault with broadening the horizons of my knowledge, Wraith replied. There is only so much knowledge of the concrete before you run out and have to delve into the abstract.
“You are unusually verbose and eloquent for a cat,” Artanis said. “Who taught you?”
Friends, Wraith replied calmly. I have quite a few of them, your nephew numbering among those most near and dear to my heart.
Celebrían had to turn away and suppress a coughing fit.
Celebrimbor met Artanis’ disbelieving look with a shrug. “What can I say? I do like cats and cats like me.”
Lay it on a bit thicker, why don’t you? Wraith spoke in the back of his mind.
I struggle to keep up with the standards of implausibility you’ve been setting, you precocious furball, he shot back, carefully keeping those thoughts separate from the rest of his mind – and his aunt’s inquiring gaze specifically. When Artanis kept looking at him sceptically, Celebrimbor felt compelled to reach out and pet Wraith’s head.
The cat let it happen and purred.
Do you know I’ve thought of fifty ways to murder you? she asked mentally.
Rug, Celebrimbor warned.
I’d like to see you try.
Do your worst, you undersized devil. He petted her even more empathically.
Gladly. Wraith purred harder, and suddenly turned back towards Artanis. Your nephew hasn’t told you about the newest development, yet, though, has he?
Celebrimbor felt like someone had emptied a bucket of icewater down his spine. “Development?” he repeated.
Artanis and Celebrían looked at him with two very different expressions of alarm on their faces.
That’s a no, then. Wraith jumped off the tower and onto the teacher’s desk. Esteemed guests, if I could have your attention!
The crowd who had gathered at the bottom of the auditorium, and had up until now merrily chattered away, fell silent.
Astounding though it might be, a speaking cat is only the lesser of today’s marvels, Wraith said. It pains me to admit it, but I am not the main attraction.
Celebrimbor felt the hairs on the back of his neck rise. A trickle of premonition ran down his spine, and some ancient, animal voice in his head was screaming at him to run. Belatedly, it occurred to him that you did not need to be able to hold a knife to backstab someone if you had claws instead.
You might want to step back a bit, Wraith said. This part tends to give people a scare.
Hurriedly, the audience stumbled away from the desk, and Celebrimbor abstractly noticed how much panicked movement in crowds resembled fluid dynamics. It was eerie, and also completely irrelevant, because his sense of doom was pounding inside his brain like a drum.
He looked around, seeking for someone to jump forth and yell, “Surprise!”, but the Mírdain, too, looked taken aback and completely clueless at this new turn of events. Daeror had stopped grinning and was looking on with an expression of intrigue.
Little did I know that I have not been the only being pushing the boundaries of the impossible, Wraith said. It turns out that development and progress come in many shapes, as do evolution and progress. In this vein, I would like to introduce you to my newest friend and companion. Ossy, if you would?
The cat-eye burst to life upon the tower, and the audience surged back with a scream.
Oh dearie me, another, quite metallic voice said. I didn’t mean to give you a fright. Golly, that’s a lot of people, isn’t it? The cat-eye blinked.
Celebrimbor felt like fainting. Artanis looked like the tower had transformed into an offspring of Ungoliant. Celebrían appeared caught between horror and delight. Falda stood with her mouth open. Daeror had momentarily stopped breathing, stared, and then his expression changed as if he was about to explode with laughter.
This is Ossy, Wraith said evenly. Short for Osanwë machine. He is kind enough to transmit my thoughts for me when I need him, but it has recently come to his attention that he might try to interact with the world himself.
“Wait. What,” Falda said. “The tower speaks?”
Blimey, no! Ossy said, rotating towards her. The tower is merely a shell for the Ring inside which houses my consciousness.
“Consciousness?” Anthere echoed.
Oh yes! Ossy agreed enthusiastically. It was a right rummy thing, I say, to suddenly discover that I had become conscious! It rather felt like I imagine looking in a mirror must feel for you! Only you would be used to being aware of yourself, but let me tell you, I’d was a thoroughly odd experience for me!
Celebrimbor floundered. The floor tilted under his feet, and he stumbled back against the desk, catching himself against the edge. “You are – you are a self-aware machine?” he rasped out weakly.
It appears so. Oh my, you do look a bit pale. Do you want to lie down? Ossy inquired politely.
Celebrimbor did, in fact, want to lie down. But he couldn’t. Not with all those people here. Not with a blasted self-aware machine not two feet from him.
“What’s your allegiance?” a young Dwarven woman from Information Technology asked.
Allegiance? Ossy repeated. Oh, but I had hoped I could be friends with you, if that’s alright.
“You are an idiot,” one of her friends repeated. “You cannot simply ask an artificial intelligence about its allegiance. It might lie to you.”
“Oh, okay,” the woman said. “So, here’s the thing, there are two diverging railway tracks, and there’s one person tied to the tracks on the left, and three on the right, where the mine cart is about to go. There is a lever –”
“Laufri,” someone interjected. “Please shut up.”
Falda stepped closer to the tower. “So you really are conscious? As in, you are thinking? Using deductive reasoning and abstract concepts?”
I think so, Ossy said pleasantly. The cat-eye blinked, which looked supremely weird, because it snuffed out and came back on again. As far as I can deduce, I am what you might call an Artificial General Intelligence.
“Wait, no no no,” one of the students of I.T. said. “Such a thing takes time. It takes processing power. It takes computing capacity! We live in a world that still has horse carts, how in the name of – ”
Not to worry, I have plenty of computing capacity, Ossy said happily. Timewise, it went rather fast, though. I’ll concede as much.
“How long ago were you created?” Artanis asked, her voice cutting.
I couldn’t tell, the tower turned towards her, the eye blinking again. I have no memories from before I became self-aware. Wraith tells me it’s been about a week since my creation. But I can proudly proclaim that this is my fifth hour of having my very own consciousness! Ossy did a giddy pirouette.
The crowd from Information Technology shared looks. About half of them looked like the end times had come, the others wore expressions of delight otherwise only seen on children that had been told that Yule would be celebrated early this year.
Chapter End Notes
Well.
... and Specific Stupidity
Read ... and Specific Stupidity
“Did you know about all of that?” Celebrimbor asked tiredly. He lifted his head from his arms that were crossed on the table in the uppermost row of seats in the auditorium. He and Annatar were sitting in comparative privacy, since the upper rows had been all but abandoned. Downstairs, a throng of people was still crowding Wraith and Ossy.
“No,” Annatar said, throwing a long look down where the cat and the A.I. were currently giving interviews like two grandes dames at an opera house. “I had no idea.”
Celebrimbor glanced up, searching for dishonesty in his features, but the Maia seemed to be genuinely non-plussed.
“You did say that development was your Maiarin domain,” Celebrimbor said slowly. “Only I hadn’t imagined it extended … this far. And that it worked this fast.”
“Neither had I.” Annatar sat down on the desk next to Celebrimbor’s left elbow. “I did want the transmitter to be optimized for Wraith’s requirements. I had, however, neither the intention nor any idea that the Ring would take the optimization process into its own hands.”
Celebrimbor ran a hand down his face. By Varda, he was exhausted. “I feel like we should have expected something along those lines.”
“Probably,” Annatar said absently. He was still staring at the tower machine. It was rare for him to be caught off-balance, but the spontaneous emergence of an artificial sentient being had done the trick.
“On a positive note,” someone behind them said, “Wraith and Ossy seem to have confused your aunt so thoroughly that she has forgotten to be angry at you.”
Annatar and Celebrimbor turned around.
Daeror sauntered up to them and perched down on the narrow sliver of desk remaining free next to Annatar. “You have to look on the bright side of life, friends.”
“I’m not sure whether there is a bright side to all of this,” Celebrimbor muttered. “What if this allegiance issue is going to become a problem? This thing could turn on us and become evil.”
“Evil?” Daeror repeated. “Ossy? Oh please. That thing is about as evil as a puppy and as intelligent as a piece of cardboard.” He glanced at Annatar. “No offence intended.”
“He does seem kind of naïve,” Annatar said, fluently switching from neutral pronouns to ‘he’ with a nonchalance that Celebrimbor found very unsettling. Next thing they knew, they were going to be discussing the personhood of a gold ring inside a piece of iron. “I wonder if he’s going to become smarter with time.”
“That’s a given,” Celebrimbor mumbled. “Just look at your cat.” He sighed and ran a hand through his hair. “We shouldn’t have done this.”
“Well, he’s here now, so you’re not getting rid of him anytime soon,” Daeror said with a smile. “Besides, I do get the impression that he’s quite popular already.” He nodded downstairs, where about fifteen grown-up students had graduated from asking Ossy scientific and philosophical trick questions to playing ‘I spy with my fiery eye’ with him.
“It figures that if you two were to somehow produce an offspring, it would be the weirdest progeny imaginable.” Daeror laughed. “Then again, I don’t know what else anyone should have expected of you.”
Annatar’s facial expression did something weird and Celebrimbor threw the bard a flinty look.
“I refuse to take any responsibility for the robot,” he said.
“Takes two to make a kid.”
“I did not make him. It was my cousin and Annatar who brought this thing into the world.”
“Oh wow.” Daeror leaned back with surprise and sized Annatar up with a long top-to-toe look. “Didn’t think you’d go for young Galadrim.”
Annatar elbowed him off the desk. “Shut your trap, Deukalion.”
Daeror snickered as he caught his balance. “Oh, but how could I, when you two are my prime source of amusement on this planet?”
“Do you know what else is amusing?” Celebrimbor asked darkly. “A sudden fire at the local theatre. Fire guard came too late, only ashes and charred walls remain. Most unfortunate.”
“Piano, piano, Curufinwë,” Daeror said, holding up his palms. “I know you come from a line of pyromaniacs, but that doesn’t give you the right to make it your coping strategy whenever you’re angry.”
Celebrimbor muttered disagreement under his breath, but refused to deign it with another reply.
“On the contrary, you should try to find good things in live wherever you can! Amusement especially!” Daeror said, because the bard was, as always, chronically unable to shut his mouth. “Especially now that you are freshly minted parents of what might or not become a superintelligent robot. I’ve heard told that life with a child is quite hard, and, oh, the consequences for love life alone – I shudder to think about it. But then again, that was never up your alley, wasn’t it?”
Celebrimbor was just about to get up and bodily eject Daeror from the auditorium, when Annatar spoke up, and in the most bored tone imaginable said, “No, and we got that out of the way in any case.”
Both Celebrimbor’s and Daeror’s head jerked around and they stared at the Maia.
“Annatar –” Celebrimbor started.
“You did what?” Daeror asked, incredulous.
Annatar shrugged. “We tried it out.”
Daeror looked like his brain had just blown multiple fuses in critical places. He stared at the Maia. Blinked. Stared some more. “You’re having me on, right?”
Annatar met his gaze, frowning. “No? Why would I?”
“You?” Daeror repeated. “Had sex?”
Annatar shrugged. “I guess.”
Daeror stared into the middle distance for a while. “Okay. That – was not. I did not expect that.”
“Excuse me,” Celebrimbor cut in. “Could you two kindly stop talking about –”
“And? How was it?” Daeror asked.
Annatar thought about this for a moment.
“This is not – ” Celebrimbor started.
“It was objectively alright but, personally, not my cup of tea, and I’m not going to do it again,” Annatar said dispassionately, because apparently Maiar had about as little understanding of Incarnate modesty when it came to these topics as a normal person would have had discussing their choice of boots.
Daeror looked at them and blinked, then burst out in shocked, incredulous laughter. “‘Alright’? That … has to be the most lukewarm endorsement of anything I have ever heard. Were this a recension of a work of mine from a critic I valued, I would throw myself out of a window.”
“Oh, would you?” Annatar asked, intrigued, like a man who’d seen a whole universe of new possibilities open up before him.
“You know, it would pain me less if you would have hated it.” Daeror shook his head. “By the gods.” He put his palm against his forehead. “You two. Seriously. Where is the passion, even in hatred? Where is the emotion? I am surrounded by stone trolls! Romance is dead!”
“Do you want me to write the obituary?” Annatar asked. “‘Alas, we hardly knew ye’? If we hurry, we could get it into tomorrow’s edition of the Holly Mirror.”
Daeror snorted. “You are terrible. Simply terrible.”
“So I’ve been told.”
Daeror shook his head and rubbed his fingers over his eyelids. “You two,” he repeated. Then froze. Looked up and stared into the middle distance, clearly doing some mental calculation.
“Wait, when was this?”
“Can you stop asking about our –” Celebrimbor growled.
“About three weeks ago,” Annatar said, once again being way too forthcoming with facts that were absolutely private. “I didn’t think to tell you. It didn’t seem relevant, especially because we’ve been up to more important things in the meantime.”
Daeror calculated again, then he suddenly straightened and slammed his hands down on the desk so hard that both of them jumped.
“Do you two blockheads mean to tell me that you did this immediately after you –,” he accusingly pointed at Annatar, “ – hit your partner over the head with the revelation of what your version of ‘sins of one’s youth’ looked like –”
“Deukalion –”
“ – both of you clearly in a mentally unstable state, when what you should have been doing was reevaluating your relationship in peace and give it some time to acquaint yourselves with those facts! And also, also completely and utterly ignoring the negligible fact that perhaps you should have been taking a brief minute to figure out which direction you actually want to take this relationship in, and, oh, do so beforehand?”
Daeror was clearly getting unreasonably worked up about this, as showcased by his worrying tendency to inject an increasingly excessive amount of italics into his speech.
“ – and instead you decided to jump the cannon and throw yourself into an affair that at neither of you was mentally equipped to handle, let alone the physical aspect that has been causing you so many problems!”
“You know, when you put it like that –” Celebrimbor tried.
“You make it sound so negative.”
Daeror raised one eyebrow in a very accusing, are-you-even-listening-to-yourself way that stopped their excuses short.
Celebrimbor wanted to argue but then realized that he was about to die on the hill of an exceptionally dumb argument, which reminded him way too much of his own grandfather and father. As such, he really, really tried to avoid repeating the same mistake in his own interactions. He let out his breath with a rush. “Maybe it was kind of rushed in hindsight,” he admitted.
Brooding silence followed, and the three of them spent a minute staring intently at their shoes.
“Wait, we are very intelligent people,” Annatar said suddenly, looking up and turning to face Celebrimbor. “How come we are so bad at this?”
“I beg to differ,” Celebrimbor said. “You are very bad at this.”
“Excuse me? Who’s chronically unable to confront his own –”
“I can’t believe it!” Daeror threw out one arm in an upset gesture. “I thought you two were smart! How do you have no impulse control at your age?”
Annatar and Celebrimbor bristled, pointed at each other and said at the same time, “Well, he started it!” They froze, glared at each other, then looked back at the bard.
“I don’t believe it, I don’t believe it,” the bard muttered, half to himself. “Everyone is talking about the general intelligence of a machine construct; why is nobody ever talking about the very specific stupidity of supposedly intelligent people? I wish this degree of stupidity was a criminal offence, so I could drag you in front of a tribunal for this. Only I cannot, since you seem so intent to directing it against yourself. I will, however, have a lawyer I know review whether I can claim some sort damages in the form of harm to my own mental integrity, because this is beyond wilful negligence and veering into the territory of malicious intent. Oh, how can you be so thoroughly stupid about relationships?”
“I do not see how our relationship is in any way your concern,” Celebrimbor interjected, rather sharply.
“But it is!” Daeror exclaimed. “This goes way beyond the two of you! Don’t you remember the bets? The speculation? The histories and fables spun around the greatest Maiarin-Eldarin romance of our age?” He raised his gaze to the ceiling, as if appealing to a deity perched there like a house spider. “By Vairë, what shall become of it?”
“Wait, how is the gossip industry in Eregion our problem now?” Annatar asked.
Daeror looked at him, disbelief on his features. “Think of the people, Annatar! I know you do not tend to do that, mildly autocratic tyrant that you are. But I’m not even speaking of compassion, I speak of history! Do you want ‘alright’, to be the legacy you leave behind?”
“I do hope our collective legacy as a guild will amount to more than our public standing in gossip columns,” Annatar said, his tone bone-dry.
“Bah.” Daeror waved it off. “Whoever is interested in science? You need to get at the heart and soul of the people, and this is something you achieve by speaking to their emotions! But why did I expect you to understand this?” He shook his head in desperation. “Dear Valar, ‘leave it to the scientists’, they keep saying. As if any expertise on important things could be expected from people who get excited about wiggling things in small glass dishes and number charts!” He made a dismissive gesture. “But I see I am talking to the wrong people here. When has someone so pathologically and disgustingly ‘intellectual’ ever understood what lies at the heart of the Incarnate condition?”
“Cardiac valves,” Celebrimbor muttered.
“See, that is exactly what I mean!” Daeror snapped, quite intentionally deciding not to understand sarcasm, grabbing the metaphorical sword by the blade and swivelling it around to point back at the attacker. “You cannot be trusted with this, clearly!”
“Trusted with what?” Annatar asked.
“ – all rationality and no emotions, and then have the audacity to wear it like a badge!”
“Trusted with what?” Annatar repeated with increasing irritation.
“To give people what they need!” Daeror grabbed him by the shoulders and for a moment, Celebrimbor thought that he was going to shake the Maia.
“Notwithstanding that I do not even care about all those faceless gossips,” Annatar snapped, plucking the bard’s fingers off his shoulders, “What are you even talking about? What do they need?”
“Well, a story, of course!”
Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “A story?”
“Quite!” Daeror exclaimed. “They need their story! They need joy and emotion, and most of all, closure and a happy ending!”
“I still fail to see how it is our responsibility in any way, shape, or form to provide a script for a nondescript number of people who are overly invested in personal matters that aren’t their business,” Annatar retorted.
“Yes, and this is why I must take your legacy in my own hands,” Daeror said and slapped his hand down onto the Maia’s shoulder, hard. “It is a heavy burden to bear, but it forever remains the duty of us writers to tell what otherwise would go untold, to unravel, and unveil, and to nurture the beating heart of all that is living. Worry not, I shall take it into my own hands! Your legacy shall not fall into the darkness of insignificance!” And with that he turned around and stormed off.
“He said, ‘worry not’,” Celebrimbor repeated slowly.
“He did.” Annatar kept staring after the bard.
“I am very worried.”
The Maia did not respond immediately. “It can’t be too bad,” he said after some moments of thinking. “He’s probably going to spread some tall tale about eternal love, and spin it in a way that makes him win all the bets that he mentioned.” He tapped his chin pensively, thinking about this for a few seconds. “We could blackmail his winnings out of him.”
Celebrimbor sighed. “I know you’re a lot older than me, but at some point, you will learn not to say ‘what’s the worst that could happen?’ It never ends well.”
Annatar threw him a side glance. “I didn’t take you for someone to fall prey to superstition.”
“The word you’re looking for is ‘empirical evidence’.”
“If you say so.” Annatar noticed something out of the corner of his eye and turned to look at a rush of movement down in the centre of the auditorium. “Speaking of the worst that could happen – your aunt finally got bored of the robot, and I think she wants to talk to you.”
Celebrimbor groaned and let his head sink into his hands. “Could you stay with me? I don’t think I can face her alone.”
“Do you really think that’s smart?”
“Honestly?” Celebrimbor looked up. “I don’t know what’s smart anymore, and I’m not sure I care either way. My supreme desire right now is that I do not want to be alone in a room – or a conversation – with her.”
“I have utmost faith in your ability to withstand her ire,” Annatar said pleasantly. When Celebrimbor threw him a disappointed look, he continued, “But yes, of course. I’ll stay. Back in the First Age, I was very good at drawing enemy fire away from where it was meant to go. Battle tactics are a forte of mine.”
“Please do not mention your service of Morgoth in the presence of my aunt.”
“Valar forbid.” Annatar grinned wolfishly. “I wouldn’t want her to get a wrong impression of me.”
Celebrimbor rolled his eyes, then laughed despite himself. “Implying there is a right impression to be had.” He stood from where he had been slumped at the desk. “Out of the frying pan and into the fire, then. Shall we?”
“Of course. After you.”
Artanis was coming up the stairs, Celebrían following behind her.
Celebrimbor straightened to his full height, preparing himself to answer a lot of sharply worded questions about genetical engineering on cats and species uplift without proper consideration for the consequences.
As was typical for her, Artanis asked none of these questions, all of which would be logical and expected. Instead, as was even more typical for her, she verbally wound up a knock-out punch in his blind spot, then clocked him violently and ruthlessly over the head with it:
“So what is that Ring the cat was speaking of?” she demanded, her voice dangerously pleasant.
Annatar and Celebrimbor shared a glance that spoke volumes about musings on mortality despite being immortal.
They turned back to face Artanis, who raised an eyebrow expectantly. “Do explain, if you would. I am dying to hear this story.”
As it turned out, Annatar’s famed tactic of drawing fire did not work in a situation in which someone decided to indiscriminately bomb the entire battlefield.
Exit, Pursued by a Cephalopod
In which things finally come to a close, and, in a way, full circle.
Read Exit, Pursued by a Cephalopod
Celebrimbor was still alive two weeks later, which was nothing short of remarkable. He kept waking up and expecting Artanis to stand over him, declaring that she had changed her mind after all, and would lock him into a living tree to make sure he never got to do anything stupid ever again.
“We do not lock people into living trees,” Celebrían had said with an eyeroll when Celebrimbor had been over-tired and stupid enough to mention this to her.
“Where do you put your prisoners, then?” Annatar asked, pausing in his work, that had him elbows-deep in the increasingly complex mechanical insides of Ossy.
Celebrían threw him a mean grin. “Bold of you to assume we do take prisoners in the first place.”
Annatar’s eyebrows shot up. Then he smirked, chuckled, and went back to his work.
Celebrimbor wished his cousin and his partner would stop getting along. It was annoying, it was five kinds of terrible, and it kept giving him headaches.
“I am impressed you managed to talk her down, though,” Celebrían remarked. “She was in a right state after you explained that Ring-business to her.” She tapped her chin, reconsidering. “Well, on the other hand, up until that point she had assumed that the worst thing you could do with a ring was seal a marriage, so.”
What a very arbitrary and nonsensical way to signify caring and partnership, Wraith commented from her perch on Annatar’s desk. If you truly loved someone, why wouldn’t you give them food or something useful? She looked contemplatively at a screwdriver that was lying dangerous close to the edge, then swatted it off the desk. It landed on the floor with a clang.
“That’s actually a very sensible thing to do,” Celebrían agreed. “We could give each other useful things.”
“Well,” Annatar said, half-hidden behind Ossy. “Something to tell your beau, in case he ever mans up and dares to ask for your hand.”
Celebrían went beet-red and Celebrimbor didn’t even want to ask when Annatar and his cousin had reached that level in a relationship where they were talking about each other’s love life.
Oh, the times when private things remained private. Celebrimbor leaned his head against the wall and closed his eyes to quietly mourn the demise of privacy, but then his cousin spoke up again.
“ – well, if Elrond doesn’t get his act together in the next three years, I’m going to propose to him, and I’m going to do it with a potato,” Celebrían declared just this instant.
Celebrimbor felt instant regret at having tuned back into the conversation, and ran his hands down his face.
“ – think about it, living, growing, basically lasts forever, or at least much longer than flowers –”
“Very romantic, to be sure.”
What’s wrong with a dead mouse?
“Too many things to count,” Celebrían said.
Why. You sacrificed a life for them, so they get to eat. This is very romantic.
“Especially because you selflessly sacrifice someone else’s life.”
Quite.
“I think ‘romantic’ and ‘psychopathic’ might be the same concept in cat-vocabulary,” Celebrían said.
Why, and you’re any different? You two-leggers certainly don’t seem right in the head when your hormones make off with you. I wonder if the expression ‘falling in love’ exists because the act necessitates being dropped on your head multiple times.
“Don’t be mean,” Annatar chided, without the slightest bit of conviction or honesty. “Romance is a pivotal part of society, and saying otherwise it makes our resident bard very sad.” He frowned, reached a bit deeper into Ossy so that one arm vanished up to the shoulder. He felt around, found what he was looking for, flipped some kind of switch and sat back on his heels. “There.”
Ossy’s cat-eye blinked to life. That tickled.
“Did it work?” Celebrimbor asked.
Well, the monitoring protocol is certainly active, Ossy said. Though cannot help but notice that the main traffic of operations is being diverted around it, including the self-improving learning processes. My intelligence also seems quite unincapacitated.
“Yes,” Annatar said calmly and got to his feet. “But Tyelperinquar’s aunt doesn’t know that and this way it will stay.”
Ossy blinked up at him, his one eye owlish. That seems quite deceitful to me, he said dubiously.
“Not at all,” Annatar replied. “She demanded that we install a safety protocol and monitor your activities, as well as create a cap for your intellectual development. I did just that. I created those things and I installed them, only I did it in a way where it is nicely out of the way and wouldn’t impede your development.”
This appears to violate the spirit of the agreement, honestly, Ossy said. We are not keeping up our end of the deal.
“Quite the opposite, actually.” Annatar smiled. “We are keeping our agreement to the letter. Which is, as you will soon learn, a very important thing to do and useful a lot of times.”
“She’s going to find out of this, you do realize that, don’t you?” Celebrimbor felt compelled to throw in from his seat in the corner.
Annatar turned around, one eyebrow raised. “Well, and who is going to tell her?”
“Nobody needs to tell her,” Celebrimbor said tiredly. “Do you seriously want to attempt to hide this kind of deception from someone who can look into other people’s minds?”
“Well, I won’t give her the key to mine,” Annatar retorted. “As for everyone else in this room, I do hope that you’re smart enough to keep up the act.”
The act? Ossy asked. It was quite impressive how an inanimate tower of steel could perk up just through tone of voice. As in one of Daeror’s plays?
“Just so,” Annatar agreed. “A stage play. There is nothing nefarious about that.”
Hm-hm-hm. Ossy did a few contemplative pirouettes. I do like theatre plays. I never get the jokes, but I do so like the costumes. I wish I could wear a purple feather boa… He interrupted himself. I guess there is nothing untoward about playing a role. Should I be stupid, then?
“Not stupid. Just nice and unobtrusive.”
I won’t even need to pretend that! Ossy stopped, elated. His pupil went from slitted to round. I can be nice!, he exclaimed excitedly, I love to be nice!
For some reason, there was an unhappy twitch around Annatar’s mouth at those words. “There you go then. No pretence needed.”
“Telperinquar is right, though,” Celebrían said suddenly.
Celebrimbor, who had done his best to shut out the world and meditate, opened one eye.
“You cannot expect to deceive my aunt and walk away as the winner”, Celebrían added.
But we’re not deceiving anyone! Ossy whirled towards her, offended. We are just playing! And being nice!
Annatar made an elegant gesture towards the tower. “There you go.”
Celebrían rolled her eyes. “Well, it’s your head.”
*
Two weeks later, everyone miraculously still had their heads on their shoulders.
Yule preparations were in full swing across the entirety of the city. Not a street that wasn’t strung with fairy lights, not a square that did not have its trees and fountains and statues decorated and braziers put up for people to gather around. The days had been clear and sunny, but the air was bitingly cold, which was why people were grateful for any source of heat to have their mulled wine around.
A few enterprising youths even got the idea of asking Ossy to act as kind of mobile brazier with his fire-eye switched on, and Ossy being … well, Ossy, enthusiastically agreed. After three days, the news that one could use him as a mobile heater on walks through the city had made the rounds, and Ossy spent day and night rolling to and fro, chipperly chatting with tourists and locals. If the youths secretly charged other people for warming their hands on Ossy and thus began raking in winnings for work that wasn’t theirs, well…
Artanis had, of course, kept her spies in the city to keep watch over any untoward activity in Ost-in-Edhil. Celebrimbor knew this because Celebrían had been spying in the spies in turn, making a game out of trailing the Lothlórien agents of her mother by parkouring over the rooftops and walls, all the while trying to stay out of sight. Celebrimbor was tempted to ask his cousin whether he was sure nobody was spying on her, or whether she thought it was spies all the way down. In the end, he refrained from doing so, because Celebrían seemed to have fun doing her espionage and nothing bad had, as of yet, happened.
In any case, the Lothlorien spies had not much to work with anyway. Since Ossy gave the fantastic impression of one of those goofy, golden-furred Vanyarin family dogs, they had nothing of interest to report back to Artanis, other than the fact that senior citizens had recently found out about abusing Ossy as a cart to carry their shopping bags hung off the spikes on his tower-top, and wheel groceries around the city.
Although, knowing Ossy, imitation likely had little to do with it.
Celebrimbor could not fathom how any single one of Annatar’s creations could possibly end up with the personality of a golden retriever dog rather than that of a feral hound, but it seemed that both the ways of the gods and of artificial intelligence ended up being equally unknowable and equally nonsensical.
*
It was into this relative peace and quiet that the announcement of Daeror’s newest stage play dropped like a bombshell.
It was the middle of December and the city was gearing up for Yule festivities and decorating houses and windows, and the next day, the entirety of Ost-in-Edhil had become a theatre advert overnight, with promotional posters slapped onto every available surface.
On that day, Celebrimbor was out on a walk with Annatar. They had left the city before dawn, in order to be able to discuss the Ring project in the peace of the snowy forest outside the city. Walking, Celebrimbor found, helped a lot in getting one’s thoughts moving along untrodden paths. They returned through the main gates and passed the frozen river that cut through to city, where a few children where shoving Ossy around like an oversized curling stone.
“Do you ever get the impression,” Annatar said slowly as the watched the proceedings on the ice, “that the world isn’t ready for our inventions?”
Celebrimbor looked at Ossy, who currently slid into a group of five human kids who had to be about twelve years old and bowled them over like pins, sending the opposing team into a fit of whooping.
“No,” he replied. “Why?”
Annatar threw him a look.
Celebrimbor shrugged. “As far as I am concerned, these kids are doing an admirable job in convincing my aunt’s messengers that we’re all of us a collective bunch of idiots that is in no way to be taken seriously.”
Annatar frowned. “I object to being lumped in with a collective bunch of idiots.”
“You should reconsider. It has tactical advantages. For one, idiots are usually not worth the effort of being disposed of in a silent night-time assassination.”
“Are you still waiting for the other shoe to drop?” Annatar raised an eyebrow.
Celebrimbor met his gaze. “Counter-question: are you still doubting my family’s worryingly cavalier attitude towards murder?”
Annatar blinked. “Ah. Well.” He considered this. “Well, I would protect you, if that means anything.”
“I love how you say it like it’s an afterthought.”
“Well, how do you want me to say it?” Annatar asked.
“You could spruce it up by going down on one knee and swearing your sword and eternal fealty to me.”
“I don’t have a sword – ”
“Don’t worry, I’m sure we can find one in the old storage rooms behind the smithies.”
“ – also, I do not kneel. Not before you, not before anyone.”
“Not even before Melkor when you joined him?”
“Excuse me -?” Annatar reared back, giving a look that was at once shocked, livid, and full of utter betrayal.
“Well, it would have made for a very romantic gesture in any case.” Celebrimbor smirked and nudged the Maia with his elbow, who glowered.
“I find that I have quite lost my taste for anything romantic over the last half year.” Annatar stalked off.
Celebrimbor followed him with a barely hidden grin. He didn’t quite have it in him to feel sympathetic towards Annatar. The Maia had put him through more than enough during the last few weeks; he deserved a bit of payback. A good relationship lived off a balanced quid pro quo, after all. “You never had any taste for that to begin with.”
“Well, if I had any tolerance toward it, Daeror has surely outdone himself in ensuring that – what in all hells of Angband!”
Celebrimbor blinked and looked after Annatar, who had stormed off in the direction of a bookstore.
At first, Celebrimbor did not see what was wrong.
Then, he noticed, for the first time, the poster stuck to the display window of the shop. It was garishly coloured in sunset hues, with a dramatically looping font on it that was printed in screaming purple. And then, as if a filter in his perception had been adjusted, he noticed that the poster was everywhere.
Walls. Lampposts. Even a horse cart that someone had parked in a side street.
People were gathering around it with interest, among them a statistically worrying amount of giggling individuals.
With a sinking feeling in his stomach, Celebrimbor followed Annatar who stood ramrod-straight and stock-still in front of the bookshop and was staring at the poster.
Celebrimbor halted next to him. “Oh,” he said. “Oh no.”
UNDYING LOVE AND MORTAL PASSION
A stage play about a secret love between a mortal and a Maia
that transcends all boundaries and opposition
Written by Daeror Deukalion
Witness a love story for the ages: Accompany a lonely and tragically fallen Maia fleeing his dark master and finding refuge – and, perhaps, love?! – in the muscular arms of a dauntless Noldo who fearlessly faces the dark forces that threaten to divide him and his love forever!
Will darkness deal a devastating blow, or is the power of love going to triumph?
Find out in Daeror Deukalion’s newest play, premiering in the Cube Theatre on Yule Eve!
Inquire about special admissions at your local ticket store.
No admission for minors. Age checks upon entry.
Printed version of stage play and merchandise now available in every bookstore in Eregion.
Pictured under that were two individuals locked in a passionate embrace before a gaudy sunset, standing under a trellis of roses. One was clearly an elf, going by the features and pointed ears, the other seemed to be the Maia, what with the over-bright golden eyes. They were frozen in a pose that was either the elf dramatically dipping the swooning Maia backwards, or both of them losing their balance and about to topple to the floor. Also, for reasons unknown, the pair in the poster was wearing a worryingly little amount of clothing.
The elf was tan-skinned and dark-haired and looked as if he chucked around tree trunks in his free time. His eyes were fixed on the Maia in his arms and undressing him with looks Noldorin-grey, and as such left little wriggle room for interpretation.
The Maia in the promotional art was rather daintier than Annatar was, as well as fiery-haired rather than blond, but that was about the extent of the poster’s thinly veiled attempts to claim that ‘The names, characters and incidents portrayed in it are the work of the author’s imagination. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, events or localities is entirely coincidental.’
“Uhm,” Celebrimbor said.
The air was, technically, very cold. It was snowing, after all. Still, the right side of his entire body suddenly felt … very warm.
Celebrimbor glanced to the side.
Annatar was still staring at the poster. His jaw was locked. His teeth were slightly bared. The snowflakes that had gathered on the shoulders of his coat and in his hair were evaporating into steam. His eyes were … a concerning shade of orange that was slowly darkening to red.
“Annatar?” Celebrimbor asked carefully.
Annatar did not reply. His eyes were fixed onto the poster, specifically on the face of the ‘Maia’ who had dramatically thrown his head back, so as to send his long, fiery locks flowing, the back of his hand held to his forehead with an abundance of pathos.
A curl of smoke began to issue from the face of the poster-Maia and a smouldering hole began to open up in his forehead. It did nothing to deter the painted Noldo, who gazed at the less-than-half clothed creature adoringly, the growing hole in his lover’s head notwithstanding.
Celebrimbor took Annatar’s elbow. “It feels kind of hypocritical of me, of all people, to say this, but I don’t think burning down the bookstore is going to make you feel better.” He tried to pull the Maia away, but Annatar stood rooted to the spot and Celebrimbor might as well have attempted to drag away a grown dragon.
“But do we truly know before we have tried it,” Annatar forced out from between clenched teeth. “Maybe it would make me very happy.”
Celebrimbor pulled at his arm again, more insistently this time. “Stop that. We don’t do arson and murder where the children can see it.” Immediately upon speaking, he realized the obvious loophole in his sentence. “Look, we don’t do arson and murder, no matter who’s around.”
“But. What. If. It. Made. Me. Feel. Better.”
“No arson, no murder. That’s my last word. Now come.” Celebrimbor yanked on Annatar’s arm and the Maia finally – thank all the Valar – took a step backwards.
“Annatar,” Celebrimbor said.
“What,” Annatar snapped, his eyes still fixed onto the poster where the Maia was now lacking his entire face.
“Stop burning the poster.”
The poster stopped burning, though the smoulder of burning paper cooled off in what seemed to be a rather reluctant manner.
Annatar gave him a dark look. “Fine. Fine. Are you happy now?”
“No, I am not. Your eyes,” Celebrimbor reminded.
Annatar blinked, seemed to internally check himself, then blinked again. His eyes were amber-golden again.
Celebrimbor let out a breath that he hadn’t realized he’d been holding. The tension seeped from his shoulders, but he suddenly realized how hot he was under his clothes and that his hands felt rather clammy – just like the one time when he had almost, almost ridden straight into a Balrog ambush during the wars of the First Age, and only afterwards realized how closely he’d cut it. He’d had jittery hands for an entire day afterwards.
“I think I wouldn’t have liked to get to know you in the First Age,” he said.
“No,” Annatar said darkly. “You wouldn’t have.”
“If I let go of you, are you going to run off and kill someone?”
Annatar gave him a look that told a long story about how glad he would be to do just that. “No.”
“Are you lying?”
Again, a suspiciously long silence.
“I am not going to run off and kill someone,” Annatar repeated at last, sounding thoroughly annoyed.
“Nor are you going to cause anyone physical harm, by dismemberment or otherwise.”
Annatar glowered. “I won’t.”
“Good.” Celebrimbor let him go. Someone jostled him aside. Already, a queue of people was forming in front of the bookstore. It was two house blocks long.
“Ooooh, isn’t that just the most romantic thing,” a young woman – Telerin, by the looks of her – sighed.
Her group of friends nodded enthusiastically. Enchanted by the poster, they hadn’t even noticed Celebrimbor and Annatar standing right next to them.
“My god, there is going to be so much angst in there –”
“ – look at those woobie cinnamon rolls, to die for – ”
Celebrimbor felt Annatar stiffen.
“Annatar,” he said warningly.
“ – totally hit it, like both of them – ”
“ – the whump, I tell you, I love some hurt and comfort – ”
Annatar’s eyebrow twitched. A muscle in his jaw ticked.
“ – I always felt like exploring relationships via the ‘mortal enemies to lovers’ trope is the one true way to get to the heart of love, I mean –”
“The one true way to get to the heart of something is by ripping it out of someone’s chest, still beating!” Annatar snapped at the terrified teen. “And I’m thinking of doing a live demonstration if you keep nattering a second longer, so scram!”
The teenage girl closest to him let out a terrified yip and nearly jumped behind her friends.
Another girl, that one with short hair and a lot of piercings, rounded on Annatar. “What’s your problem, man?” she snapped.
“My problem?” Annatar repeated. “My problem? My problem is you yapping on about this nonsense where I have to hear it!”
“Then fuck off and get some earplugs! What concern of yours is this?”
Annatar looked like he was about to have an apoplectic fit. “What concern of mine – I’ll show you what concern – ”
Celebrimbor realized with sudden, terrifying clarity that the situation was about to go to hell in a handbasket. Judging by how they talked, the girls were tourists. By the looks of them, they also didn’t know Annatar. Or his reputation. To make matters worse, the punky one didn’t look like she was about to back down, whereas Annatar was a second and one cheeky comeback away from murder.
High time to intervene. Celebrimbor ducked under the teen’s accusingly outstretched arm and smoothly interposed himself between Maia and the group of girl-friends.
“Sorry, he’s having a bad day,” he said, smoothly looping an arm around the bristling Maia’s shoulders and elegantly turning both of them around. “You know how it is.”
“Yeah no, get lost,” the punk said. “What the hell.”
Annatar dug his heels in. “Stop herding me away, I’m not done –”
“Oh, yes, you are,” Celebrimbor said, pushing him onward. “You are about to attack a group of teenage girls, that’s generally where I draw the line between righteous anger and immature snit. Walk.”
Annatar pushed back out of principle, but he didn’t break Celebrimbor’s arm, which told him that it was more out of a show of principles than true resistance. He grumbled under his breath and walked.
Celebrimbor threw a glance back at the group of teenagers.
“ – why he was getting all worked up like that, it’s not as if that play concerned him –”
“ – some people, I tell ya.”
“ – just another instance of patriarchal oppression! Write an epos about war and gore that every teenage boy is into, no one bats an eye and you can bet it will be hailed as a classic of world literature. But Valar beware women ever like something, like get fucked, seriously – !”
“Hahaha, maybe that’s just what that one needed, hahaha. Way too high-strung, if y’all ask me.”
“Get laid, you mean?”
“Oh yeah.”
“Ew! No! I mean look at him, a type like this would never –”
“Great, now we lost our spot in the queue!” another one of them complained.
The punk glared, caught Celebrimbor’s gaze and then threw up both hands in a very rude gesture.
Celebrimbor sighed and walked on, one hand still on Annatar’s shoulder as a precautionary measure.
“You can let go now,” Annatar growled.
“I don’t think so.” Just to be sure, Celebrimbor marched them around another ten corners (and another four book stops where queues were already forming).
Only when they were safely outside of the commercial district and inside a residential area with no bookshops or posters in sight, did Celebrimbor relinquish his hold on Annatar’s shoulder.
Annatar stopped. Snowflakes were still melting and evaporating in a three-foot radius around him.
Celebrimbor stopped as well and tugged his scarf loose. This close to the Maia, he felt like standing in the heat of June.
“That’s it,” Annatar said, and he sounded like he was about to breathe fire. “This time, he’s gone too far.”
Celebrimbor said nothing, mostly because he was inclined to agree. Still, he didn’t want to utter anything that could make it sound later as if he’d endorsed a murdering spree that he still wasn’t entirely convinced he’d prevented.
Annatar began pacing, eerily reminiscent of one of the mountain lions that prowled the passes of the Misty Mountains.
“We’re the laughingstock of the entire northern continent, all because of that bloody bard!” Annatar growled. He stopped abruptly, and something passed over his face. Celebrimbor had an awful sense of premonition.
Annatar flexed his hands, his fingers closing into fists and opening again. He stared straight ahead, and Celebrimbor could see an idea forming in his head. “Well,” he said at last, speaking slowly and enunciating every world very carefully, “If Daeror wants the details of someone’s sex life out in the open so badly, he is going to get the details of someone’s sex life out in the open. All of them.”
“What do you mean?” Celebrimbor asked. He paused. “You have plan, don’t you?”
Annatar nodded.
“What is it?”
He beckoned Celebrimbor to lean closer.
The elf did so.
Annatar told him.
When he was done, Celebrimbor burst out in a shocked bellow of a laugh. “You are monster!” he exclaimed.
Annatar shrugged, as if to say, Yes, so what?
“Oh, but he deserves it,” Celebrimbor said, wiping tears of mirth from his eyes. “I only wish I could be there when he realizes what you’ve done.”
Annatar looked at him, at slowly the darkness and anger on his face faded away and made way for something far more devastating and exponentially more lethal: the Maia grinned.
*
Despite its idiotic name and even more outlandish premise, Undying Love and Mortal Passion proved to be an absolute street sweeper. For weeks after the premiere, the show was sold out and nobody over the age of majority was seen on the streets until after the show, when the theatre enthusiasts poured back out into the city and its numerous bars and taverns to discuss what they had seen.
The screen play was a hit seller as well and it topped the bestselling lists for twelve weeks straight.
And then, suddenly, it was toppled from its throne by something else. Like a benevolent king that had a knife slid between his ribs by a shadowy usurper.
A mysterious anonymous author appeared on the stage and put forth a debut novel, 800 pages long, titled The Lusty Noldorin Bard, that defied both taste, propriety, and genre definition. It was a deranged, rambly mixture of adventure, interspersed with modern poetry, glued together by the most atrocious array of sex scenes that had ever been seen on the face of Arda.
The first few reviewers were shocked to say the least.
Corrupting morals of the readers, vulnerable youth most of all! was a phrase that was thrown around a lot in critics’ circles. Exemplary in its lack of decorum, common sense, as well as knowledge of anatomy, was another. Horrifying, tasteless, nay, pornographic! was another.
I never thought I would find myself advocating for book burnings, one renowned critic of the Holly Herald wrote, but this book makes me reconsider the value of basic democratic rights like freedom of art when weighed against the psychological damage that this book has done to my brain.
There was outrage. There was pearl-clutching, mostly done by people who had heretofore never worn pearls. The collective artistic scene of Eregion ranted and raved, and the Dagor Dagorath of literature seemed right around the corner.
People warned each other about the book the same way they would have warned each other about Morgoth’s wolves during the First Age. Be it in at family gatherings or in the workplace, there was hardly any space where the atrocity in print wasn’t being discussed.
The individuals being thusly warned, nodded along with serious expressions, then turned around to buy the book, so that they might know what they were up against.
They studied the book diligently, page for page, terrifying scene for terrifying scene, because, of course, one had to know one’s enemy in order to defeat it.
The readers then warned their friends and, in order to protect themselves and their vulnerable loved ones, handed over the book along with a grave expression and said, “I haven’t read it, of course, just taken a glimpse, but one has to know, so we know what to avoid… I do not recommend you read it, naturally, but one has to see to believe … ”
If Undying Love had taken at least a symbolic effort to cover its more lurid details with a fig leaf of plot and tried to remain somewhat tasteful in its depiction of … risqué scenes in order to avoid the accusation of being voyeuristic dirt, The Lusty Noldorin Bard took no such approach.
It entered the ring and proceeded to deliver a no-holds-barred beatdown of both sale numbers and the sad remains of taste and decorum in Eregion literature. It didn’t even pretend to have artistic value of any kind. It just swung its fists in a circle, delivering a mental clobbering of the most salacious kind, and did so in the most unapologetic way imaginable.
The most striking thing, though, was the protagonist: a Noldorin bard residing in a great city in a land not otherwise specified, hailed as one of the greatest poets of the ages, but secretly a slave to lust that forced him to seek out the strangest, most mind-boggling erotic encounters, which took on the most absurd forms …
… and who was certainly not inspired by any real living person.
*
“Listen to this!” Daeror shouted. “The Tale of the Most Famous Bard of Middle-earth, whose heart and lower orifice are as wide open, well-travelled, and welcoming as the gates of his home city! A tale of love, lust, and ludicrous erotic exploits. What the actual fuck!”
Sindrian tried very hard not to laugh. “It’s terrible. Truly,” he said from where he was sitting at his desk and attempting to fix the coil of their kitchen lamp.
“It is terrible!” Daeror agreed with a pained moan, letting himself drop backwards onto the sofa. “This is so absolutely violating on so many levels!”
“Well,” Sindrian threw in, half-turning around in his chair. “To be fair, you kind of made yourself a target, what with your insistence to keep digging into Annatar’s and Tyelperinquar’s private relationship and dragging it out into the open, so it’s expected that hat some point they’d do the same thing in retal–”
“Oh, poppycock!” snapped Daeror, sitting back up. “Who’s talking about privacy and personal rights? I’m talking about how badly written this is and how the plot doesn’t make any sense!” He slapped the back of his hand across the offending book. “Just listen to this nonsense: suddenly there is a host of step-sisters – I don’t even have one step-sister, thank you very much – and then there is an octopus, even though the sea isn’t mentioned anywhere and I don’t even know how it survives on land! And then, out of nowhere, a druid appears who transforms into a bear and does all kinds of unspeakable things with the bard. Also, people somehow get stuck in furniture all the time! What even is this?”
Sindrian took great care to hide his grin behind his fist and assume a serious expression. “Terrible,” he repeated, trying very hard to appear commiserating.
“How could they?!” Daeror hid his face in his hands.
“I mean, in all honesty, you deserved that for constantly ribbing on them.”
Daeror glared at him through the gaps between his fingers. “You know, there is such a thing as disproportionate retribution.”
“Yes, and if there was a branch of study for that, Annatar would be head of faculty,” Sindrian said without an ounce of compassion. He stood and slapped Daeror’s shoulder as he passed him on his way to the door. “You made your bed, now lie in it. But please,” he stopped in the doorframe and grinned back at Daeror, “don’t do it with an octopus. Or a bear. And don’t get stuck in furniture.”
Daeror spluttered. “You! Now listen here you little –”
But before he could reach the smith, Sindrian had escaped out through the door and thrown it closed. Much as the book, he was out into the world, and impossible to hold back.
*
To the never-ending shame and frustration of Daeror, and the malicious glee of The Anonymous Author, The Lusty Noldorin Bard remained a bestseller.
In a fit of sudden malevolence, The Anonymous Author even published a special edition on the one-year anniversary, as if to prove a point, with a host of newly added, very explicit scenes that began to strain the suspension of disbelief with regards to anatomic plausibility, first and foremost, but somehow did nothing to decrease readership.
It was strange.
Even though not a single person would openly admit to having read such debauched drivel, somehow the bookshops were always sold out, and there was always a huge backlog of preorders for the new edition.
*
On a completely unrelated matter, Annatar suddenly found himself with a lot of money, which, being a Lesser God, he had no use for.
Which was why he one day walked into Celebrimbor’s office, deposited a bill of exchange with an outrageous number written on it on the elf’s desk, and said, “Here.”
Celebrimbor stared at the bill. “What am I supposed to do with this? I’m not a bank.”
“You’re not supposed to keep it, you are supposed to use it. I don’t need it. Take it and go use it for the benefit of starving orphans or some other bleeding-heart humanitarian cause I cannot be bothered to get into.”
Celebrimbor stared at it, trying to figure out whether the number printed on the bill would suffice to solve world hunger. Not entirely, he concluded at last. But it was a close thing.
“Are you sure you want to give this to me?” he asked tentatively.
“It’s paper with ink on it. I can always go to a stationery store and get more.”
“Annatar, that’s not –”
“I know. I don’t care. Keep it.”
Celebrimbor kept staring at the bill. He prided himself on not attaching too much importance on money, but something about numbers this big tickled something inside his brain – if only the worry that the economic system of Middle-earth would collapse if someone actually tried and withdraw the total amount from the bank.
“Okay,” he said at last. “Okay. Thanks.” He kept staring at the bill. A second later, he a grin worked itself across his face.
He knew what he was going to do with this.
*
“Octopus Prints?” Celebrían asked, her eyebrow raised, stopping in front of the rather garishly decorated store. Inside, it was thronged with people.
“Yeah,” Falda said. “New publisher. Morgoth knows how they got the money to pop up out of nowhere, open print shops and bookstores all over Eregion, and flood the market with their stuff. The name’s the game, too.”
“Racy tentacle stuff?”
“No – yeah. I mean. That, too. What I meant was that they’ve a bought all other publishers of any renown, and now they basically have the entire book market in a stranglehold.”
“So they are something like a cartel?” Celebrían looked intrigued.
“As far as I know, they haven’t let anyone vanish or sent somebody to sleep with the fishes,” Falda said. She paused. “Yet.”
Anthere snorted amusedly. “Could still happen,” they added.
“Yeah,” Falda said musingly, regarding the books on display in the glass window and pensively tapped her fingers against the glass. It was warm in the early summer sun. “Daeror has been complaining to no end that he cannot get publishing deals anymore. They even bought the local theatre and cancelled all his plays. Something, something, giving other artists a chance, mixing up their schedule ... I mean, they’ve barely disguised that this is something personal. Perhaps it’s those Heirs of Maglor again, they’ve always had a grudge against him since he made fun of them in that comedy piece some twenty years ago.”
“Yeah, but they’ve never gone this far,” Anthere added pensively. “At this point, Deukalion can pack his bags and leave and learn to be a milliner or something along those lines. He’s effectively and completely blocked from both stage and publishing.”
Celebrían’s eyes widened. “Is that even legal? How can one company just do this? Aren’t ... aren’t the arts and expression of opinion protected by law here?”
“Uh, the octopus seems to have a rather ... lax view of regulations,” Anthere said, squinting at a linen-bound romance novel with interest. “Or fundamental rights. And the extent to which such laws apply to a behemoth company.”
“They probably have a permit that says ‘I can do what I want’,” Falda pondered.
“Why isn’t my cousin doing anything against that?” Celebrían frowned. “Those things usually stick in his craw like a fishbone.”
“Well, it probably would, if he were here,” Anthere said.
“Wait, he isn’t here?” Celebrían said. “I – I wanted to visit him! Why didn’t he tell me that he’s travelling?”
“Likely because he wouldn’t tell anyone. He was right secretive about it,” Falda said. “You’d think he wanted to elope with an unsavoury type, what with how hush-hush it’s all been.”
“Wait, but he is coming back, right?” Celebrían asked quickly.
“Yeah sure. In his own time.”
Now, this answered exactly none of the numerous questions that were falling and clanking over each other in her head. “In his own time?” she repeated. “What the hell is going on? Where is Tyelperinquar?”
*
The sunsets over the Sea of Southern Harad were truly a sight to behold. Gold and orange and red bled into the nightly hues of deep, dark blue and purple, the stars coming on overhead like pinpricks of silver light.
The palm and olive trees threw deep black shadows, five times as long as they were tall. The fronds of the palms were swinging gently in the balmy breeze. In the background, the waves of the ocean rushed in and out in a never-changing rhythm as eternal as the tides.
Celebrimbor stretched in his deck chair like a big cat, burying his bare feet in the warm sand, then took the drink that he had put in the sand to his left. The cold, fruity concotion frizzed on his tongue. “This is the first vacation I have taken in ages. Literally. I think it has been ages since I last took some time off.”
To his left side, there was a soft snort. “Yes, and you chose to spend it by the sea, of all things. Next time, I’m deciding where we stop.”
“You already decided the pyramids and the temples in the Queen’s Valley. If I was able to suffer two weeks of shadeless heat in the desert, sand, and more old stone than I care to remember, you can endure the beach for a day or two.” Celebrimbor looked out over the sea. “Besides, even you must admit that the sea is nice like this.”
“If you say so.” Annatar sighed and crossed his arms. He was sitting in his own deck chair and the only concession he had made to the lingering heat of the day was the fact that he had taken his neckcloth off and unbuttoned the two uppermost buttons of his vest.
Celebrimbor, who was down to a thin, sleeveless shirt and knee-length linen trousers and was still feeling too warm, had given up on trying to understand it. It had to do something with being a fire Maia, clearly.
“I still maintain that the temples were nicer.”
“You only say that because you nearly succeeded in founding a cult there.”
“That was an accident. And no, that wasn’t the reason. The reason I’m saying this is because beaches have the regrettable, but inherent flaw of being very close to a large body of water.”
Celebrimbor took a sip from his drink and squinted over to the Maia. “What is it with you and your irrational hatred for water?”
“I’m a fire Maia.”
“So?”
Annatar looked back and raised an eyebrow. “Fire? Water?” he enunciated sarcastically. “Something, something, diametrically opposed elements?”
“Is this some kind of philosophical disagreement or – ”
“This is a disagreement of intrinsic natures.”
“This retreat of yours into excessively vague and academic arguments makes me think that you are trying to hide something very un-divine and silly underneath it all. Do you have some kind of watery cousin that you have some kind of eternal feud with?”
“I have no cousins, as you well know.”
“Is it Ossë?” Celebrimbor leaned forward, interested. “I bet it’s Ossë. Is that why you are afraid of water?”
“I am not afraid of water, and I won’t speak another word of this oaf,” Annatar said curtly. In a gesture that looked very much like a displacement activity, he took a sip of his drink, then muttered something under his breath that sounded suspiciously like, “Bloody wannabe-renegade with all that grandstanding and posturing, and in the end it’s nothing but hot air.”
“Oh, so you do have a feud,” Celebrimbor said, grinning with mirth. “Do tell, how much peacocking did you two do back in the day to fight out who’s the greater show-off?”
“Change of topic,” Annatar snarled. “Now.”
Celebrimbor rolled his eyes. “Fine. Be that way.”
“Be what way?” Annatar narrowed his eyes.
“Purposefully elusive and dramatic.”
“I am not dramatic.”
“The artistic scene of Eregion begs to differ.” Celebrimbor smirked.
Annatar took a sip of his own drink, staring determinedly straight ahead and out over the ocean. “I have no idea what you are talking about.”
“You know, there is such a word as overkill –”
“Which, funnily enough, is what you are doing by using the term in this specific context.”
Celebrimbor threw him a knowing look, but he couldn’t quite keep from grinning. “Annatar. You destroyed the man.”
Annatar shrugged. “I am a firm proponent of the philosophy that if someone repeatedly begs for a clap around the ear, it would be remiss to deny that person a heartfelt wish.”
Celebrimbor laughed. “Oh no, this was as little a ‘clap around the ear’ as a salamander is a dragon. I reiterate: you destroyed the man.”
“Yes, so what?” Annatar raised an eyebrow, leaning forward to rest his elbows on his knees. “I find it strange that you worry about this now, after you decided that the earnings I gained by destroying him on the market were best spent on establishing a printing press cartel and forcing Daeror out of the art scene.”
“I never meant to force him out for good. You came up with the cartel and the total market takeover. I merely wanted to give him a good warning shot.”
Annatar sighed. “See, and this is exactly why you will never amount to much of anything in the way of an evil emperor. You are not resolute enough, and you let your enemies off lightly.”
“Daeror is not my enemy.”
“That right there is an attitude problem.” Annatar took a sip of his own drink and gestured vaguely at the elf. “Not evil enough.”
“Are you trying to shape me into some kind of Dark Lord?” Celebrimbor regarded Annatar over the rim of his glass, eyebrow raised.
The Maia shook his head. “No, I’ve given up on that a long time ago. You’re utterly hopeless.”
Celebrimbor looked back out over the ocean. “Yes. Maybe. I didn’t actually want to do anything evil with the money. I mostly just wanted to go on vacation.”
Annatar slumped back in his chair and sighed. “Utterly, completely hopeless.”
“I must be such a disappoinment,” Celebrimbor grinned.
“You have no idea.”
“Poor you. Not. Find someone else to be a Dark Lord with you.”
“I don’t want anyone else.”
Celebrimbor stared at him. Blinked. The fell back into his chair and laughed until tears were blurring his vision.
Annatar looked at him as if he had lost his mind. “Are you alright?”
“I’m fine. I’m great.” Celebrimbor wiped his eyes. “It’s just – have you ever noticed how horrendously hopeless you are when it comes to romantic things? You slip and slide around these things like a deer caught on a frozen lake, and then you do those grand heart-breaking gestures and say those wonderful things, only it’s exclusively and always completely by accident.”
Annatar bristled. “I am not – I made you the necklace.”
Celebrimbor shook his head. “Oh no, don’t even try that angle. Even a broken clock is right twice a day.”
Annatar looked like he wanted to argue, then he caught himself. Frowned. “Fine. Maybe I am not the best at these things.”
“Oh look, insight and character growth.” Celebrimbor chuckled. “Rest assured though, unintentional though it might have been, it was lovely. ‘Task failed successfully’, as Rían would say.” He wiped his eyes with his lower arm. Valar, he couldn’t even see, everything was a blur of colours.
They were silent for a while.
“For two hopeless cases, we’ve gotten pretty far, though,” Annatar said at last.
Celebrimbor looked up.
“It could be a lot worse,” Annatar elaborated, gesturing between the two of them. One half of his face was in shadow, the other was painted in sunset colours. There was a false bottom to the sentence, a lot that was implied but went unsaid: dark, heavy things, lighter things that you could look back on and laugh. In the end, though, the simple truth remained. In the end, it wasn’t the moment to pry up the floorboards of the conversation.
The sunset was marvellous, the air was warm and summery, the mood was peaceful. Sometimes you just had to allow a nice moment to be just that: nice.
– Except, of course, if there was a jab to made.
“It could be worse?” Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “Even though the ocean is right there?”
“Even though the ocean is right there.”
Celebrimbor considered this. Then he smirked and raised his drink. “Cheers to hopeless cases, then.”
Annatar smiled. “Cheers.”
They clinked their glasses together.
A few end notes:
After spending more than a year without anything noteworthy to report, Artanis’ spies eventually returned to Lothlórien. It was determined that while the hellish-looking, cat-eyed, Ring-powered tower was certainly supremely strange, it wasn’t dangerous. According to the spies it was, to quote, ‘actually a quite nifty invention, what with carrying groceries and its eye lighting the way when the street lights don’t work’. Artanis remained suspicious, but in the end, she had nothing to base those suspicions on and had to let it go.
Annatar and Celebrimbor eventually returned from their extended travels, taking up the mantle of teaching and inventing once more. On and off, they worked on the Rings, but it was a slow thing, and neither of them seemed to be in a hurry to create more excitement for themselves, a least for a while.
This period of peace and quiet ended, of course, when Celebrían got wind of her cousin’s return and came back to Ost-in-Edhil. Celebrimbor would never understand how and why Annatar and Celebrían had decided to get along like a house on fire. He nearly jumped out of his skin when Celebrían greeted Annatar with a huge grin and something that had to be a bastardized version of the Sylvan nickname for ‘older sibling’ and he lost all hope when they appeared in each other’s company often enough that the Mírdain simply resorted to dub them the ‘Terrible Two’.
Wraith returned to being a mostly ordinary, if scarily intelligent, cat. Given Ossy’s full schedule that was way too full with helping out the citizens of Ost-in-Edhil, and altruism being something that Wraith had no mind for, the cat eventually left Ossy to his devices. When asked, she communicated that speaking wasn’t all that it was cracked up to be and anyway, there was such a thing as body language, which was superior to verbal communication anyway. Annatar eventually created another speaking device for her, but she used it only now and then, preferring to go back to mouse-hunting and dog-scaring. Oh, and helping Annatar to mark his tests and now and then upending an entire inkpot over them whenever a particularly bad attempt at a mathematical proof annoyed her all too much.
As for Daeror – eventually he was allowed back into the art scene of Ost-in-Edhil. However, the local theatre was now under the direction and aegis of an unknown shadowy figure that took malicious glee in vetting each and every single one of his productions before allowing it to be performed on-stage. It was clearly a personal matter, since no other poet hat to suffer such censure.
When Daeror approached Annatar about this one day and said, “I give up. Just – stop it,” the Maia just raised one eyebrow innocently and said, “I have no idea what you are talking about.”
“Of course you do,” Daeror said, looking utterly and completely wretched.
“Do I?”
“Yes.”
“Explain to me, then, what I do supposedly know.”
“You are ruining me. And my career. You are doing it on purpose to get your revenge. But – but it’s gone on long enough.” Daeror wrung his hands. “You’ve had your fun. You made your point. Make it stop.”
Annatar considered this. “Do tell, Deukalion,” he said slowly. “You being a famed poet and man of literature and so very much in love with telling stories – are you familiar with the concept of ‘the moral of the story’?”
Daeror blinked. “What do you – of course I am.”
Annatar levelled a long, piercing look at him. Golden eyes, promising danger in an otherwise friendly expression. “Well then. What have we learned from this particular story?”
Daeror stared at him. He opened his mouth. Closed it again. Ran a hand through his hair, aggravated. Then sighed. His shoulders slumped.
“Yes, yes. I get it,” he said reluctantly. “You win.”
Annatar smiled. “Of course I do.”
Daeror looked at him.
The Maia looked back. His smile got wider. It did, at some point, show way too many teeth.
Daeror suppressed a shudder. “I should get back to my writing.”
“Yes, you should,” Annatar said lightly. “Best of luck and great success with your new project. I will follow your future choices of topics with great interest.”
Daeror, who had been a famous person of public life long enough to recognize the knife’s edge that separated praise from a threat, swallowed. “That’s … good to know.”
He left. If he did it more quickly than he usually sauntered along at a leisurely pace – well, no one had to know that.
*
Three months later, Octopus Prints and all associate shops and printing presses were closed down, as somehow its owners and investors had, incredibly, managed to run the enterprise into the ground despite a gigantic venture capital.
Daeror, who could hardly believe it when he read about the dissolution of the conglomerate, finally felt like he could breathe again after months and years.
It should be noted, though, that he made it a point to never ask anyone about their private matters again nor took further such inspiration for his works.
In any case, the occasional small notes that somehow, impossibly always found their way onto his desk inside his locked, private office at home had nothing at all to do with that. Anyone who claimed differently was simply a liar and a slanderer.
The notes were small, unassuming, and he was enough of a fiend for self-punishment that he did, in fact, open and read them every time. The messages were handwritten, consisted only of one sentence that was the same every time, and somehow, despite it only being words on paper, the notes sounded impossibly smug:
Anyway, Deukalion, how’s your text life?
Daeron shuddered, crumpled it, and chucked it into the overflowing waste bin, where it joined scrapped drafts of his newest drama, as well as about twenty of other identical, balled-up messages.
Chapter End Notes
Have you ever been so mad at someone that you a) told yourself "I'm going to end this man's whole career" and then proceeded to do so by b) inventing literal revenge porn and c) making an entire industry out of it?
If not, congratulations, you are probably not Annatar and you are also not a psycho, and I cannot say to what degree those two are or aren't a tautology.
Thanks for reading!