Il y a longtemps, une nuit obscure, un monde perdu by Prackspoor
Fanwork Notes
So this was basically a super late entry for this year's Silvergifting Week. I initially intended to post it as part of As the Stars on AO3 but then the plot bunny got out of control and dragged me along into a rabbit hole not unlike Alice. The bunny was apparently eating well and thus grew to a very respectable size, which would have absolutely destroyed the flow and tone of Stars. Which, incidentally, is why it gets to be posted as a standalone story now.
The fic takes the Dark Academia prompt of Day 4 | August 13 as well as the Modern AU prompt of Day 7 | August 16 and goes absolutely crazy with them, which is how you end up with a mega-crossover of Silmarillion, Lord of the Rings, Fallen London, the ley system of the Nightmarked series, and ... You know what? Why do I go around, telling you things? Surely you totally know after finishing the fic.
Six fandoms in total, four are already listed. Perhaps you can find out the missing two.
On another note, this fic was totally an excuse to get the characters dressed up in trenchcoats and Oxfords, which is an absolutely profligate author's fantasy of mine.
What era is this fic set in? No idea. Might be Belle Époque/Fin de Siècle, might be the 1950s. Time is weird when the world is broken beyond repair. Everyone gets to wear cool clothing and walk around with canes, though, if they so wish. What more do you want.
I hope you enjoy this extremely weird, unanchored trip into a broken timeline, a doomed world, and the exploration of the terrifying power of stories.
- Fanwork Information
-
Summary:
Rain was driving down in sheets from the slate grey sky. The crocketed pinnacles of Merton college’s square chapel tower rose up like spears, as if they wanted to slice open the underside of the low-hanging storm clouds. It seemed not so unlikely, in this moment, that the clouds could open up and release a diluvial flood that would drown the world under a new ocean. Stranger things had happened before, in this world and another.
It was not hard to think of Beleriand.
Oxford, at least, was still here – for the moment, at least.
Canon Source: Lord of the Rings
Major Characters: Celebrimbor, Sauron, Frodo, Gandalf
Major Relationships: Celebrimbor/Sauron
Genre: Alternate Universe, Drama, Experimental, Folktales/Myths/Legends, Mystery
Challenges:
Rating: Teens
Warnings: Creator Chooses Not to Warn
Chapters: 1 Word Count: 11, 638 Posted on Updated on This fanwork is complete.
Il y a longtemps, une nuit obscure, un monde perdu
Read Il y a longtemps, une nuit obscure, un monde perdu
Rain was driving down in sheets from the slate-grey sky. The crocketed pinnacles of Merton college’s square chapel tower rose up like spears, as if they wanted to slice open the underside of the low-hanging storm clouds. It seemed not so unlikely, in this moment, that the clouds could open up and release a diluvial flood that would drown the world under a new ocean. Stranger things had happened before, in this world and another.
It was not hard to think of Beleriand.
Oxford, at least, was still here – for the moment, at least.
It was more than could be said for other cities – here and elsewhere.
“I think I could enjoy this more if the weather was less ominous. Then again, it seems like a fitting backdrop for the occasion.”
Celebrimbor turned around.
Frodo had flipped up the collar of his dark grey wool coat. Although they had momentarily found shelter from the weather in the arch connecting two quads, the rain had caught them. His flaxen curls were damp from the rain, and his hands were shoved deep into his pockets, despite the gloves he had not taken off. His face was only dimly visible in the gloom as his eyes traced the ribs in the vaulted ceiling portraying the zodiac signs. They snagged briefly on the Scorpio, which, frankly, looked more like some kind of sheep and told an interesting story about sculptors and working from imagination rather than knowledge. Frodo frowned, then his gaze slid over the dull, beaten-down green of the abandoned Fellows Quad, where purple liminal ley was a churning ghostly glow superimposed upon the grass, seemingly half water, half fog.
Frodo watched it with unease, before his eyes darted back across the front quad in the direction of the exit as they had done so many times before while they had been waiting. The entrance gates were closed, save for the smaller wicket gate, which allowed only a scant bit of grey light to filter into the entrance.
Celebrimbor resisted the impulse to turn around, walk towards the edge of the arch, and spy in the direction of the exit. The urge bored into his neck like the edge of a knife-blade, but stubborn pride refused to give in to the desire to press his back against the wall and keep watching the gate like a rabbit awaiting the arrival of the fox. With deliberate ease, he pushed himself off the wall and walked over towards Frodo – a bit closer to the quad, a bit further from Merton’s gates. The air was cold even in the passage, and the storm was driving in the rain and the wind. The air smelled of autumn and of wet, old stone. Nobody but them was out and about, neither students nor teachers. No lights were on in the windows looking out onto the quad – for all that it appeared, they could have been the only people in the entire world.
“It’s beautiful even in the rain,” Celebrimbor said, looking up at the college’s walls. The purple sheen of the ley lent it a ghostly, nearly otherworldly touch. “A gloomy sort of beauty, but beautiful nonetheless.”
Frodo smiled, but it was a pained expression. “I would prefer it in sunlight.” He hesitated. “The eerie glow reminds me of wraiths’ fortress, in a way.”
Celebrimbor supressed a shudder. He was glad for few things that had ended his first life, but never having had to lay eyes upon Minas Morgul was one of them. He threw Frodo a side glance, and once again there was the knife of guilt between his ribs.
He has suffered through things no living being should suffer through. If I had foreseen that the echoes of my folly would ring out across thousands of years, would I have seen sense before it was too late? Or would I—
Frodo’s heavy inhale cut off the thought before it could run off towards dangerous reaches where madness lurked like the gloaming in an old forest. “But I do not think the sun shines a lot in these parts, anymore,” he said, his tone quiet and flat.
“No, probably not,” Celebrimbor agreed. Or ever. If one believed the people here, this was how it had begun in London, as well. At first the sun had left. Then darkness had come. And after that darkness had opened its gullet … and swallowed.
“It makes you wonder, though, doesn’t it?” Frodo threw him a side glance. They were nearly of a height, and despite having arrived here more than two months ago, it was still jarring to see him like this – so very much changed from the halfling he had met on the green hills overlooking the White Shores. Then again, perhaps it simply took longer to get used to it. A body was not a shoe, after all, and even a new shoe took a few weeks before it was broken in.
“You mean the seeming deliberation behind it all?” Celebrimbor craned his head, taking in the gathering gloom, the driving rain, and the Gothic buildings against the darkening sky.
“Yes.” Frodo wasn’t looking at him, his shoulders consciously loose, but Celebrimbor could see his right hand tightening inside the pocket of his coat. “Writers seem to be able to do a lot more than we gave them credit for. Who’s to say that authorial intent doesn’t govern this world, too?”
Who indeed?
Celebrimbor crossed his arms.
Put it like that, and it did seem like about a dozen coincidences too many. Things should not align like this – the scene-setting weather, the plans and the backdrop, the irony and biting sarcasm of twists and turns of fate that fit just a little too neatly, a little too cruelly to have come about naturally. The fact alone that he was here with Frodo, of all people with him, and waiting for—
I wonder why I never saw it before.
Probably because no sane creature would ever consider fate being so pliant that it could be written in a book. Or that any sane being would write down fates like that. But, well. Sanity seemed like an overrated thing these days, when even reality was up for negotiation.
All in all, going along with it without thinking too much seemed the best course of action. Even if it was books all the way down, there was nothing that he could do about it.
“Do you have the time?” Frodo asked.
Celebrimbor shook back the sleeve of his own woollen coat, the other adjusting the scarf around his neck. The wind was bitingly cold, and the watch face was difficult to read in the low light.
“Almost three,” he said. “They should arrive soon.”
Frodo nodded, but this time he could not hide the tension in his shoulders. “I do hope he plans to invite us inside,” he said. “Night falls at four, I should not like to be outside after dark.”
“I’m sure he will. I cannot imagine anyone wanting to spend more time than necessary in this weather,” Celebrimbor said, but inwardly he agreed with Frodo. Oxford might be nearly four times the distance from Londonʼs centre as Harrow, but even so Celebrimbor would not want to be caught outside during a surge of abyssal ley – not with the liminal ley as unstable as it was. He threw a side glance into the quad where the ghostly haze of the rising ley was more visible than in the passage. Every now and then he thought he caught a glimpse of crimson in the midst of the purple haze. Celebrimbor very much hoped he was mistaken, but while he knew of self-suggestion, he also knew that he wasn’t very much inclined towards it.
Frodo seemed to have seen it, too, if his drawn expression was any indication.
It was in this moment that the sound of a lone engine grew louder on the street beyond the gates. Parking was not allowed anywhere near the colleges, but the driver clearly wasn't bothered by this, seeing how the engine cut off directly on the other side of the gates.
The knot in Celebrimborʼs stomach tightened. A fist closed around his ribs and squeezed.
Frodo had gone pale. His left hand was clutching his right one – both gloved. Celebrimbor couldn’t have said whether Frodoʼs stillness was iron composure or petrification.
Without speaking a word, they stepped closer to one another and turned towards the front quad.
A car door slammed, then another, audible even over the rain.
Only moments later, two figures emerged from the entrance passage, smudged into grey wraiths by curtains of fog and falling rain.
Celebrimbor’s throat was tight. He wanted to step back, but held his ground.
The two shades crossed the front quad with quick steps, the sound of shoes on the paved ground inaudible.
Next to him, Frodo’s shoulders tensed. His features were rigid, his pallor ghostly.
Then the first shadow stepped into the arched passage, briefly blacked out by the storm-grey backlight.
Then it was inside, and the twilight evened out around it, finer features rising in shades of grey from harsh, nuance-erasing chiaroscuro.
Amber-golden eyes caught his own.
Something inside Celebrimbor’s heart seized and he had to remind himself to breathe.
Sauron halted.
And it was him.
It was.
It was just that— it was—
Celebrimbor had seen him after the creation of the One. Remembered, still, through a haze of blood and pain, the flattened, two-dimensional creature that the once radiant god had fashioned himself into. The red in those eyes, the terrible hollowness of the gaze. The features – still beautiful, but statue-like. Frozen – in a type of rigor mortis that had come for one who knew no death, invited in and painted over his face through an act of reckless destruction of the self whose mere memory made Celebrimbor recoil even now.
He remembered Sauron. His body did – even though it was not the one Celebrimbor had worn before, even though every visible wound had been healed, every break restored. And yet. Every tendon, every muscle, every bone in Celebrimbor’s body knew Sauron, had been taken apart, rent asunder, atomized by the terrible force of a gaze of fire, a band of gold, hands that had held Celebrimbor’s heart in them, metaphorically before, literally, after—
But why—why in all the world did this Sauron look so much like the friend he remembered from before; ere one question too many, one revelation too terrible, had brought everything down upon their heads?
He looks like—he looks like—
“Tyelperinquar,” Frodo said quietly, his voice toneless, but surprisingly strong. His right hand grabbed Celebrimbor’s left. A strong grip, a grounding one – even though it was missing a finger.
Celebrimbor remembered to breathe.
As he inhaled, the spell that had lain upon the moment and frozen it in time broke. Sauron had not moved. His eyes were still fixed on Celebrimbor. Gold like gold, and gold like fire and flame, a ring around the pupil that reminded him of nothing so much as –
Celebrimbor took a step back, and wished for a wall – something he could put his hands against, because the floor seemed to list under his feet.
He looks like Annatar.
The white robes had been exchanged for a long, camel-coloured overcoat, belted at the waist, beige slacks, and brown Balmorals. But other than that – other than the strange window dressing that all of their appearances had been subjected to in this world, he was just the same. The same face, the same eyes, the same expression. Alive and three-dimensional, in a way that Sauron had never been after forging the One. His expression was blank, but it was a guarded blankness, not a void. Not the mockery of a higher power from which personality and dimensionality had been expunged with a branding iron.
Celebrimbor’s eyes snagged on the grey woollen scarf and the grey gloves. Wondered, if they, too, hid, like Frodo’s, the marks of a bygone age, a different world. Bite marks of a great hound. Another missing ring finger.
Celebrimbor’s body had been too thoroughly destroyed to be returned to Aman in any other state than healed of all physical wounds. Even so, he now felt the phantom pain of his chest and abdomen being slit open in the Y-incision of a seasoned pathologist. Felt the indescribable agony of having his ribcage prised open. The skin of his fingers burnt, as if the knife was once more under the epidermis, peeling back from layers of fascia and muscle; the terrible tearing at his nailbeds – the remembered pain of broken bones, the bizarre, nauseating feeling of air around his intestines—
Frodo’s hand squeezed his own a second time.
Celebrimbor forced himself to breathe in.
Sauron still had not moved.
I cannot do this, Celebrimbor thought. It was not a thought born from fear or panic, but a near-clinical self-observation as if he was watching himself from slightly above and two steps to the left. (Which, in itself, was probably a sign of how badly he was faring.)
I can’t. Not if the past clings to him like a noon-shadow, and is carved into the hollows of my bones. Not while everything reminds me of him; not while everything in me remembers him.
(Like Annatar.)
(Like Sauron.)
(Two incompatible halves of an irreconcilable whole.)
It was in this moment that the second shade stepped into the passage. Frodo tensed – but froze halfway through, as if one instinct had been overridden by another, faster than the conscious mind could process. “Gandalf?” he said, and his tone was uneven, a stumbling mix of confusion, and surprise.
The old man stepped around Sauron, shaking out his trilby from the rain, his cane clacking on the flagstones. He was tall and narrow, and clad in a long broad-belted tweed coat, but his gait was sure and quick as he came closer, the keen eyes under the bushy eyebrows fixed on Frodo.
“Gandalf,” Frodo repeated, and there was such relief in those words as if the old man had blasted open the oppressive stone of the arched passage above their heads, and allowed in the open sky, the howling wind, and the lashing grain.
Frodo took a step forward, and in the next instant, he and the old man were embracing.
Frodo clutched the old man tightly, full of disbelief and wonder, before stepping back, one of Gandalf’s hands remaining upon his shoulder as the wizard held him at arm’s length and looked him over.
“Frodo Baggins,” he said, and his eyes were dancing with old joy and fondness. “We meet again.”
Frodo stared at him. “What are you doing here?”
“Why, that is a question that is easier asked than answered in full,” Gandalf said. “As for what I have been doing and am doing right now—” His gaze darkened, as he turned around, throwing Sauron – who had remained standing at a distance, right where he had frozen when he had spotted Celebrimbor – a glare. “Why, right now I am keeping an eye on this miscreant and make sure that he stays where I can see him and does as he is told.
“As for what I have come here to do…” He turned back towards Frodo, and worry now mixed with the joy of the reunion. “It seems to me, my dear Frodo, that we are destined to meet in dire times of great darkness and difficult decisions. If I am not entirely wrong, which I rarely am, we must undertake another quest together, and soon – though where it may lead us, I cannot yet tell. Many paths lie in darkness here, and my eyes do not see as far as they saw in a world from which the shadow had been lifted.”
“So there is another shadow here, upon this world” Celebrimbor said. He did not – studiously did not allow his eyes to flit towards Sauron.
Gandalf turned to him. “There is, Curufinwë, as I am sure you already know. You have been in this world for a few weeks, as far as I know, and there is no escaping its darkening these days. As for how we are going to deal with it – that is a question that shall be discussed, and soon.”
“I am sure of it,” Celebrimbor said, taking a step closer. “For now, I am glad to finally meet Mithrandir, who Frodo has told me so much about.”
“Only good things, I should hope,” Gandalf said, throwing Frodo a look from under furrowed brows, but he was hiding a smile.
“There might have been mentions of threatening to throw Pippin down a well,” Frodo said. His answering smile was a pale, tense thing. His eyes kept sliding back towards Sauron.
“Are we human, then? All of us? Or do you retain your powers?”
“For now, we are,” Gandalf said. “So you need not worry about Sauron attempting anything untoward – for the moment at least. Besides, while I may not be a Wizard as we are speaking, I do retain my knowledge, and oft this has been the greatest power of all, even in the past when I still had my staff and steed.”
“Then I shall be all the gladder for it that you are here,” Frodo said. “I have an inkling as to why we have been brought here, but I do not know what we could possibly do or why it has to be us.” He crossed his arms as if he was cold.
“I, too, have my suspicions,” Gandalf confirmed. “I do not see the way yet, for I lack important information still to judge how to go about things. And as to why it has to be us – well, apparently it is us who can do something about this, of course.”
Frodo’s shoulders fell. “I still recall what you told me in the mines of Moria, Gandalf. And yet, again, I wish it had not needed to be us.”
“You remember then, what I said to you in response to that,” Gandalf said, but his voice was not unkind. His hand squeezed Frodo’s shoulder. “Even if we are destined to meet again at shadowed crossroads, then not all of this destiny must be of evil. History may repeat itself – or rhyme some of its verses – but that also means that while you must yet again walk a darkened road, you will not walk alone, for I shall accompany you once more.”
The ghost of a smile flitted over Frodo’s pale face – come and gone within an instant – but for the first time since they had arrived here, there was something akin to hope in his eyes.
“I would be glad for it, Gandalf,” he said quietly. “It is like the Journey of the Ring all over again. I do not even know which direction to walk in, let alone how to accomplish whatever quest is to be imparted upon us.”
“Neither do I. But it seems to me that we shall find out.” Gandalf stepped back and the three of them turned.
An old man was approaching them, small of stature, and bent with years. Under his brows, though, his eyes had a keen and sharp intelligence that reminded Celebrimbor a lot of the Istar standing next to them.
“Professor,” Gandalf said and English came to him with easy familiarity. Had he spent longer months here and Celebrimbor and Frodo had? He must have, to sound this accustomed to the language.
But when the old man answered, it was not in the foreign tongue.
“Welcome,” he said in Quenya. “To all of three you.” He ignored Sauron, who still had not moved.
“Ah, now I feel foolish,” Gandalf said. “We should have expected you to speak the High Tongue.”
The professor waved it off. “It is not of this world, and I myself feel strange speaking it here – though I must say it delights me to be able to use it with you – nearly as much as it does to see you here, dire as the circumstances may be.” A small smile tugged at his lips. “I am glad that you were able to make the journey here. The weather is dreadful, won’t you come in?”
The professor led them inside, Frodo and Celebrimbor following after him directly, while Gandalf and Sauron brought up the rear.
“I would show you the chapel and the Hall, but I am afraid we are rather pressed for time,” the old professor said as they walked down an abandoned hallway. “You’ll forgive me if we forgo the scenic route in favour of the direct road.”
“Oh, by all means,” Frodo said. “I’ve had enough of scenic routes to last me a lifetime.”
The old man hesitated for a brief moment, and when he looked back, his lined face was full of guilt. “For what it’s worth, Mr Baggins – and it may not be much – if I had known …”
His gaze slid to Celebrimbor, and if anything, his expression became even more despondent.
Celebrimbor looked away, afraid of what the old man might otherwise see on his face. Staring fixedly at his own shoes on the stone floors as they walked.
“You didn’t,” Frodo replied to his left, his tone carefully even.
“That is no excuse,” the old man said.
No, it isn’t.
“It’s fine,” Frodo said quietly. “Please, lead on.”
The old man brought them into a study crammed with desks and shelves full of books. Paper and pens were strewn on one desk. Stacked on the side Celebrimbor recognized a pile of essays, already cursorily annotated for the first time, waiting their turn for their second time to be read and marked for good. The room smelled of ink, paper, and parchment, and the memory of his own study in Eregion hit him like a blow to the breastbone.
One after the other, they filed in.
“Tea?” the professor asked.
“Why, yes,” Gandalf said, and somehow, he sounded very English doing so, even though he was still speaking Quenya.
Celebrimbor threw him a side glance, one eyebrow quirked up – and noticed that Sauron was doing the same, an expression of disbelieving scorn on his face. When their eyes met, Sauron’s face went blank.
Quickly, Celebrimbor looked away again. While the professor shuffled outside, likely to procure tea from some place that held fewer old books and manuscripts that could be endangered by water and open flame, he busied himself by walking up to Frodo’s side who had been studying the rows of bookshelves to their right, his hands buried in the pockets of his coat.
Celebrimbor followed, his gaze gliding over barely legible titles, embossed decades ago. The Edda. The Kalevala. Beowulf. The Iliad. The Odyssey.
Celebrimbor pulled the last book out and carefully opened the yellowed pages. The unfamiliar script curled itself across the page, not unlike tengwar. He had had a bit of time on his hands ever since coming here, but the shape and sound of the verses remained nebulous enough that he could only feel his way forward through the dactylic hexameter.
Ạndra moi ẹnnepe, Moụsa, polỵtropon, họs mala pọlla
plạnchthē, epeị Troiẹ̄s hierọn ptoliẹthron epẹrse—
“It is beautiful, isn’t it?” Frodo said quietly.
“The rhythm is quite something,” Celebrimbor replied in a low voice. “Though I would like it more if I understood the poetry of it better.”
“It is one of the foundational texts of the literary canon of these countries,” Frodo said. “An epic poem about a decade-long journey home of a man famed for his wits and accomplishments.”
“You know the story?” Celebrimbor gave him a surprised look.
“I read it rather soon after we had come here,” Frodo admitted, a weak smile on his face. “Something to pass the time.”
Outside, the rain had begun to fall in earnest, drumming against the windowpane. Frodo looked outside and when he spoke, the words seemed to come from somewhere else as he recited the beginning verses:
The man, O Muse, inform, that many a way
Wound with his wisdom to his wished stay;
That wander’d wondrous far, when he the town
Of sacred Troy had sack’d and shiver’d down;
The cities of a world of nations,
With all their manners, minds, and fashions,
He saw and knew; at sea felt many woes,
Much care sustain’d, to save from overthrows
Himself and friends in their retreat for home;
But so their fates he could not overcome,
Though much he thirsted it. O men unwise,
They perish’d by their own impieties!
That in their hunger’s rapine would not shun
The oxen of the lofty-going Sun,
Who therefore from their eyes the day bereft
Of safe return
Celebrimbor was staring at the open book in his hands. The words blurred in front of his eyes. The paper turned into white ships, the ink into a night-black sea running red. The golden lamplight in the grain of the page transformed into a fire that could be seen from the other end of the world.
But so their fates he could not overcome,
Though much he thirsted it. O men unwise,
They perish’d by their own impieties!
With a sudden motion, Celebrimbor snapped the book closed and put it back with rather more force than he had pulled it out. He turned away from the shelf, feeling Frodo’s gaze on his back.
Which brought him face to face with the room, and that meant face to face not only with Gandalf but with Sauron, both of whom had been watching him silently.
Sauron’s face was expressionless and he looked away as soon as Celebrimbor glanced in his direction, but Gandalf frowned.
Thankfully, the uncomfortable silence was broken by the return of the professor, who was carrying a tray of steaming cups. Four, Celebrimbor noted.
Doesn’t he drink tea himself?
But then the professor — and this time it was clear that it was neither coincidence nor mistake — handed Gandalf, Frodo, and Celebrimbor three cups, while taking the last one for himself. While he did this, he didn’t look at Sauron even once.
Celebrimbor stole another glance; and yes, Sauron was frowning. But once again, he held his silence. His arms were crossed, his brows pulled down and lips thinned with displeasure. It was an expression he had seen on Annatar – not often, but often enough to bring with it the pang of the familiar that should sooner be forgotten.
He hadn’t been careful enough. Annat—Sauron noticed his staring, and the amber eyes flitted up to meet his gaze. Celebrimbor looked away and took a sip of tea – and in his unthinking haste scalded his tongue. He turned away to hide his grimace of pain and swallowed the near-boiling liquid. The tea slid down his oesophagus like a white-hot iron brand and he suppressed a cough.
Thankfully, nobody else seemed to have noticed.
“Well,” the professor said, “I guess you are wondering why you are here.”
“We have a vague idea,” Frodo said. “But details would be …” He paused. “Appreciated.”
The professor nodded. “Yes, of course.” He gestured at the chairs that were standing in his study, looking rather like a dispersed herd of sheep that had gotten lost in the academic chaos of books, desks, and piles of paper. “Please, take a seat.”
They did – save for Sauron, who remained standing, even though intentionally or by coincidence, there would have been a chair available for him. He crossed his arms and leaned against the far wall of the study, watching the proceedings from the half-shadowed corner.
The professor threw him a glance that was at once displeased and full of unease, but then he returned his focus to Gandalf, Frodo, and Celebrimbor, who were sitting in a loose circle around his desk.
“You have heard of London by now, I assume,” the professor began.
Frodo and Celebrimbor shared a long look, and without speaking, both of their gazes went to the map of the British Isles that was hanging behind the professor, fixing on the black void that was yawning where the capital of the United Kingdom had been. Even as they were watching, tendrils of darkness wavered and crept outward, incrementally darkening more of the map. The “w” of Harrow, the upper edge of “Croydon” and the “Da” of Dagenham were already half-swallowed by the shifting shadows.
They returned their attention to the old man.
“We have,” Celebrimbor said.
The professor nodded. He had a pen in his hand, and he was turning it absent-mindedly between his fingers, as if mulling over how to go about his explanation.
“While there seems to be little debate about what has happened, the questions of how and why remain unanswered. If we ever want to have a chance of stopping and containing Londonʼs Fall, or even reverse it – if such a thing is at all possible – we need more information. More knowledge. And that is why you are here, I am afraid.”
“Is that also why you are here, Professor?”
At the sound of the voice Celebrimbor’s blood froze in his veins.
Everyone in the room turned their head.
It was the first time that Sauron had spoken. He was leaning against the wall in his twilit corner, arms crossed, and his golden eyes very bright in the shadow that fell across his face.
“For it seems to me that someone called forth a Darkness that bears a striking semblance to Ungoliant and is just as hungry to devour. One person in this room seems – shall I say – uniquely qualified to create such a thing – and has done so before. The number of gods in this room is quite small at the moment.”
The professor paled and for the first time, there was a shadow of anger on his face. “I refute this accusation! Had you any kind of decency and regard for the faiths of this world, you would abstain from drawing comparisons like that. And the darkness is most certainly not my doing!”
“Isn’t it?” Sauron asked, pushing off the wall and coming closer. His steps were languid, like that of a stalking big cat. Shadow and lamplight flowed over his form. “I wonder, then, why, in a world that is full to the brim with writers, it is you who is involved in all of this, and why it is us that are meant to be the foot-soldiers in a fight that was never ours.”
The professor’s pallor was ghostly now. He lowered his gaze. Ran his hand down his lined face, as he held a face over his mouth. “You are not here to undo my mistakes. I maintain that I have nothing to do with the Shadow. You are here because we need more than mere humans to save ourselves.”
“And you have no gods of your own to call upon?” Sauron asked, his tone acid.
“Not many. Not in this day and age. Like any other creation, their existence is dependent on having their stories told. And on belief.” The professor’s hand trembled. “Ours is a world that has lost the ability to tell stories – and more importantly to listen. The gods that remain to us are few and their strength is much diminished.”
“And, as I might mention, they are as of now entering into a dangerous, unstable alliance to uphold the equilibrium of this world,” Gandalf said. “There are few entities in this day and age that still hold any sway and power, not all of them benevolent. They are busy establishing nexus points and pillars to tighten the weave of this creation, to prevent other holes from being torn into it and other places from Falling.”
The professor nodded. “There are small entities, and they do have their pockets of power and belief, but their reach has become small. Belief is stretched thin, and over great spaces, with little to fuel it. The ley is barely controllable at this point, and ever more pockets of abyssal ley surface all over the world. It has not yet become bad enough to tear reality like it did in London, but there might not be much more time.”
Gandalf nodded gravely, his hands resting on the handle of his cane. “As of right now, the Nameless One, Ha-Nozri, and the Morningstar are the only ones holding together Europe, as well as big parts of the Americas and Near Asia, and to rely on the latter is a more dangerous bet than you can even imagine.”
Frodo and Celebrimbor shared a look. They knew too little of this world to estimate the extent of desperation to engage with certain entities, but they were all too familiar with the dangers of trusting the wrong people. It was a story that remained true across the boundaries of universes.
“As far as Yeshua told me, his ... half-brother seems to be willing to work alongside him for now,” Gandalf said. “But how long this cooperation will last is anyone’s guess. The Morningstar is the one most capable to control the abyssal ley, though, so we can hardly forgo his contribution. This world is short enough on powerful allies – even if there were ones that were more reliable and less dangerous.”
And don’t I know a thing or two about dangerous bedfellows, Celebrimbor thought. Here and now, in this world, they at least have the excuse of despair and necessity.
“The few powers that remain in this world will not be enough to surmount this crisis,” the professor said. “Parts of the world are still stable, East Asia, Oceania and parts of Africa chief among them. But the rest is crumbling, and fast. It is only a matter of time before the next place is going to be devoured.”
“Why is it happening? Does anyone know?” Frodo asked.
The professor shook his head. “We do not. All attempts, reasonable or otherwise, to explain the phenomenon have failed. Of course, one of the first courses of action was to send an expedition to London and find out what had happened. When it didn’t return, a rescue team was sent. When that, too, didn’t return, the plans of entering the site of former London were abandoned. Rescue and reconnaissance were relinquished; the expeditions given up for lost. The area was cordoned off from the public. Other so-called ‘helpers’ sprung up. You wouldn’t believe the tidal wave of missives that had come flooding in – clairvoyants, prophets, witches.” The professor scoffed, but it was a tired, exhausted sound. “In their desperation, they heard out everyone; but of course it was for naught. Darkness had claimed London. What the heart of this darkness was – as well as the knowledge of how it was made and how it could be unmade – remained a mystery. Our only chance, perhaps, to save us; and yet our every attempt to find it has failed.”
Silence followed in the wake of these words.
Celebrimbor shifted uneasily in his chair, his fingers drumming out a translated polynomial sequence on the armrest. “I understand that this world needs outside help. But I am still not clear on why you need to provide it. And why us?” he asked, unable to push aside the fact that he was falling in step with Sauron’s line of questioning, the difference in tone notwithstanding.
The professor looked pained. “With the resources and powers of this world exhausted, we needed help from other places. And I am the only one who could successfully provide it,” he whispered. “Other writers tried to call upon their works. Many. But as soon as the gates were opened and their creations called forth – they unravelled.”
“Their worlds were not as tightly woven,” Gandalf said slowly. “They did not survive the transition.”
The professor nodded, his hand still over his mouth. “We had ... many attempts. So many people tried to help, from all over the world. But there seems to be a weight to this world that threatens to flatten any subcreation that is called into it. A physicist compared it to a fabric like space-time that does not survive having a concentrated gravitational well above a certain limit dropped into it. The fabric – the weave of the subcreation ... it just rips under the weight of reality. It collapses into nothing.” The professor hesitated. “A dear friend of mine tried before I did. We had faith in him – his was a strong weave, the personage of his imagination vivid, the world elaborate and strong. He had one character especially that we hoped could save us.” His hands were trembling now. “He attempted to call it forth, eager and ready to put his work into the service of humanity in a time of great need. When he did – the story – everything in it –”
He broke off.
The silence in the room was oppressive.
“It did not work,” Gandalf said quietly.
The professor shook his head. “It did not,” he whispered. “And his subcreation was erased.” He lifted his head and when Celebrimbor turned to follow his gaze, it was fixed upon a gap in the bookshelf. Three, perhaps four thick tomes might have found a home there. “It was there. I still recall it – but only like one would recall the outline of a void and know that something is missing. Everything else ... is gone. I remember neither the title nor the characters, neither the plot nor the first sentence. It is gone. It has never been. The story has been purged from existence, and everything in it with it.” He lowered his head and for a moment it seemed as if he might weep.
There was a dark weight in Celebrimbor’s stomach now, and when he looked at Frodo, his face was pale and drawn.
“What of your friend?” Frodo said quietly.
The professor did not reply. His head was lowered, one hand was braced against the desk to support him. His hands were bony, flecked with age, the skin paper-like. Silence ticked by. On the mantelpiece of the fireplace, the ticking of a clock cut eternity into slices dropping away into oblivion. “He had poured too much of himself into his work.”
Celebrimbor nearly flinched. Before he could think to stop himself, he had turned around.
But Sauron was not looking at him this time. The golden eyes were fixed on the hunched, grieving old man. Sauronʼs gaze was unreadable. There was no pity or empathy in his features, but there was a shadow on his face that did not come from the lack of light in the room.
“I am sorry,” Frodo said.
The professor didn’t move.
“What of other myths?” Celebrimbor’s eyes flicked over to the shelf where the Odyssey stood. “Surely the old founding myths of your world have enough power to survive the transposition into the supracreation of this world.”
“Perhaps they would have,” the professor said. “But only the original writer himself can call forth what has been written. And many of the myths have been told and retold over generations, written and rewritten by a line of storytellers. It engrained these stories into our collective consciousness and made them strong, but the very process of myth-creation across centuries is what would have prevented any single writer from summoning Achilles, Beowulf, or Siegfried, even if they were alive to do so.”
The professor looked old and bent in the light of the lamps. Outside, night had fallen. The rain was steadily falling down. Inside the college, the blue surface ley lay like a peaceful shimmer over the floors, but outside the purple sheen of the liminal ley glowed like a dark portent, reflected back from Mertonʼs walls and the underside of the dark clouds that shrouded the night sky, moon, and stars.
“It was I who wrote Middle-earth into existence. And I created charac—people like you, who went on to enter the collective consciousness of this world in a way few other creations did. I held the key to my own world, and I had heroes at my disposition that I could call forth.” The old man looked pained. “And that is why it must be me – and that is also why it must be you.”
Seconds ticked away in silence.
“I don’t understand,” Frodo said. “A doom is hanging over your world, but how can we help resolve this? It does not seem like something that can be defeated either by strength of arms or wise counsel. What do you need us to do?”
The professor lowered his gaze. He looked very old now. The lines in his face were deep vales of shadow. “To find the heart of this darkness,” he said. “And to find out how to unmake it.”
For a moment, no one spoke.
“You mean to send us in there,” Frodo said. His voice was flat, toneless. “You mean for us to enter London – wherever and whatever it might be now.”
“You have found your path through dark places, Frodo Baggins,” the professor said softly. “You were created for it. If anyone has any hope at all to tread the lightless streets at the heart of darkness, and find his way, it would be you.”
“I have completed my journey,” Frodo said. “I have finished my quest. Why would you – why –” He broke off. His sentence snapped like a broken twig as he regarded the old man; this god with power over ink and paper, with utter alienation and incomprehension. Emotions battled on his face: despair, anger, disgust, fear – with none gaining the upper hand as Frodo stared at the shrunken form of the man who had created him – with so much love and yet so much pain, born from the ignorance of a god unaware of his own power and the consequences of his actions. It was worse to bear than cruelty. Cruelty, at least, you could understand and condemn. But this? This here wasn't cruelty or evil, and it shaped Frodoʼs anger into something that had nowhere to go. For how did you deal with someone who loved you so deeply, and yet had written you into a life of agony and unhealing scars?
“Because we cannot do it, Frodo. You are more capable of doing this than anyone else of this world.”
“You mean, we are expendable.”
Sauron’s voice cut through the silence like a knife.
Celebrimbor felt like someone should speak up and contradict him.
Nobody did.
The clock ticked away on the mantelpiece. What part of eternity remained to them suddenly seemed very short. The tail-end of time, the era of growing shadows.
Frodo rose from his seat. His face looked shadowed, bloodless. When he spoke, there was an edge to his voice that was betraying how close to despair he was. “Why us three, of all the people in your world? If you wished for a hero, why would you not call upon Elrond or Glorfindel, Beren and Lúthien, or Eärendil and Elwing? All of them are mightier and wiser and more powerful than – ” He broke off before the word me could escape him.
“Because we are important, dear Frodo. But we are not the keystone,” Gandalf said kindly, rising as well and laying a hand upon his shoulder.
Frodo looked between him and the professor. His gaze was hollow, but his brow creased in a frown.
Celebrimbor saw the exact moment when realization hit him, and it was the same moment when everything came together in his mind, too.
He closed his eyes and ran a hand down his face.
Of course.
There were not merely three of them.
When he opened his eyes again, the professor was no longer looking at his desk, but at a point over Celebrimbor’s shoulder.
This is not about the heroes.
“Above all else, we need power,” the professor said tiredly. “To a degree that neither Glorfindel in his glory days nor even Fëanor wielded. This is a crisis that is beyond mortals.”
“And beyond most immortals,” Gandalf added, “for you created us this way to serve the story you were building.”
“True, and there is little that I regret more – and have been, ever since I knew that you were...” The professor hesitated. “Alive. But I have not written you that way, and I can neither un-write you nor change you without undoing the essence of who and what you are. The story must remain stable, the framework must remain the same.”
Which is why—
Frodo had gone pale. His left hand was clenched tight around his gloved right. Celebrimbor could not fault him for it. He had feared this outcome ever since he had seen the terrible, familiar spectre prowling through the arch behind Gandalf, and yet...
Silence filled the study, save for the hum of the electric lights overhead. Their sheen appeared dimmed, though, and shadows pooled in the far corners of the room and between shelves.
“I do not appreciate,” Sauron said, his voice low and dangerous, “being reduced to a tool.” His golden eyes were bright in the shadows cloaking his face, there was a fire in them: a flame caught in opals hidden at the heart of mountains when the world was still young. Out of nowhere, verses of shadow, flame and darkened trees rose, unspoken and strange, only recently read in the small library of the lakeside house in Northern Italy where he and Frodo had spent so many weeks:
Tyger Tyger, burning bright,
In the forests of the night;
What immortal hand or eye,
Could frame thy fearful symmetry?
The professor’s gaze darkened. So did Gandalf’s.
“See it as fair turnabout for what you did,” the wizard said. “One might even say there is poetic justice in you assuming the role that you attempted to force onto everyone in Middle-earth under your rule.”
Sauron’s eyes narrowed.
In what distant deeps or skies.
Burnt the fire of thine eyes?
On what wings dare he aspire?
What the hand, dare seize the fire?
“You strike me as neither naïve nor particularly foolhardy, Professor,” Sauron said. “Which is why I wonder what makes you think that I will willingly go along with this.”
The professor regarded him, and his features were shadowed with distaste – but as to whether that was only directed at Sauron but at something else entirely, was impossible to tell. “Willing or not, but go you will,” he said, but it sounded like the words themselves pained him.
And Sauron understood.
“You would not dare,” he snarled.
What the hammer? what the chain,
In what furnace was thy brain?
What the anvil? what dread grasp.
Dare its deadly terrors clasp?
“I will, and I do,” the professor said tiredly. He reached into the pocket of his cable-knitted grey vest and pulled forth a small box of wood, at which Celebrimbor’s insides filled with ice.
He opened them and in the box lay four rings, two silver, bearing a pale sapphire and another white adamant. One golden, bearing a ruby. The last one golden, as well, but without any adornment. They were familiar, but in the way of a distorted dream image – just similar enough to be recognizable as what they were supposed to be, but off in that slight way that dreams were, strange and eerie in a way you could not point to anything specific.
As one, Frodo, Celebrimbor, and Sauron took a step backwards.
Gandalf alone remained standing where he was, an air of unsurprised resignation about him.
“You expect us to bear those?” Celebrimbor said. His throat was tight and he felt untethered, as if he was expecting the lose the ground beneath his feet at any moment. He had felt off ever since stepping into this strange world, but now it was more than that. He felt ill. His eyes were fixed on the simple gold band, and he felt phantom wounds opening up all over his body: pain remembered, never forgotten, even after so many years and being restored to a hale body, reborn.
The professor nodded. He, too, looked resigned and unhappy as he regarded the rings in the box, but he kept on speaking nonetheless. “Yes. For there is power to stories, and power to how they work. You were made from one, and at this point I dare not even claim that there isn’t a writer who is typing out the fate of our world, too. It is a burden, but one we can turn around and use to our advantage – you especially. There is power to numbers, like seven and three, in other stories, too. Strength to repeated themes, like a rope wound from ever more strands of hemp, thicker and stronger for every strand that is added. There is a power we can work with here – in tradition and tropes.”
All four of them regarded the old man, and the box in his hand.
Frodo looked on in abject horror. “Must it be Rings again?”
The professor inclined his head in agreement. “Yes. Rings have been imbued with power in your old story already. We must make use of that – but on our terms. Stories must remain within a certain framework to be come known and recognizable or even legend, but tropes and symbols, while kept and repeated throughout time, may be twisted or inverted. Three were the Rings that the One sought to master in your old story. Three Light, one Dark. Now they shall be remade, but this time, it will be three who will master the lone Ring, and its bearer. Three were the wardens of Light in Middle-earth, and now they shall be again. Frodo, the Ring-bearer and Path-Finder through the darkest of places. Mithrandir, the Wise Pilgrim, the Leader. Celebrimbor, the Creator of the Rings.” He fell silent.
And, of course, at the nexus point of it all – the sheer force and power of one who was written to command Darkness, and to be able to wield power able of subjugating an entire cosmos of ink and paper.
Tick-tock, went the clock on the mantelpiece. Lightning flashed outside, reflecting from the liminal ley and turning the night ink-black and ghostly purple.
The time was nearing midnight, and silence reigned in the office. Tea was cooling in abandoned cups.
At some point, the professor had lit the fireplace and flames were licking upwards, golden and orange, sending shadows dancing around the room.
Sauron had left hours ago, and had still not returned. Currently bereft of his powers as he was, Celebrimbor did not know where he would go in this darkness and weather, but he still found himself holding out a half-hearted hope (that he knew, in his heart of hearts, was in vain) that he would not come back.
Frodo had not spoken ever since the new Rings had been revealed. He was sitting in a chair near the fireplace, bent forward, his elbows on his knees and staring into the flames. Gandalf was sitting at the desk, quietly speaking to the professor.
Celebrimbor had been standing at the window, staring out into the night and the churning ley that turned redder towards the eastern horizon, letting his thoughts evaporate into hollow numbness, not watching for furtive movement on the quad below, or the lilac sheen of the ley catching on golden hair or golden eyes.
“... must have some theories, no?” Gandalf was saying.
“Of course I do, though I feel I am no more qualified than any other person to speak of my opinions, perhaps less so.” The rustle of paper filled the room.
“You mentioned that East Asia, Oceania and the African continent were holding up better,” Gandalf remarked.
“They are. The ley is more stable there, though the reason for that remains unclear.”
“You did mention a weakening of both belief and the power of stories in Europe and the Americas,” Gandalf said. “You must have considered that this is factoring into why some parts of the world are more affected than others.”
“I have. I am not as hubristic as to assume that we are the uppermost link in this chain of subcreations,” the professor replied. “It is the nature of a closed system that one cannot gaze outside it. So who’s to say that somewhere, someone is not taking pen to paper right now and writing the conversation we are having?”
Gandalf hummed in agreement.
“Which is another reason why I suggested adhering to the rules of storytelling in everything we do,” the professor said.
“Oh quite. I think it is the smart thing to do, given what we know. I will say that I am concerned about involving Sauron, though.”
“So am I. Believe me, I was loath to involve him, but he is tied to the rest of you, whether we like it or not. His story can be woven into yours, and I can give you ways to handle and subdue him. I dared not summon the Black Enemy himself – he is not bound, neither to the Rings nor to you three, and there is no way for you to control him. Under our specific circumstances, he might even have been the weaker choice.”
“I see your reasoning,” Gandalf said, “yet I don’t like it. If story has the power we must assume it has, we must brace ourselves for the inevitable betrayal. You gave us Rings, but I fear he might yet find a way to circumvent those fetters and unleash himself. Sauron has made many mistakes in his long existence and he has numerous faults, but a lack of cunning or craftiness was never one of them. I would have preferred Nienna or Vairë at our sides, but I see how their threads could not be woven into a tapestry along ours.”
“I understand. Believe me that I would not have called him into this world if I had seen any alternative. I regret it now – writing him as I did, tying him to your fates, and not giving you more power to oppose him.” The professor sighed. “And yet – who would have seen those ends, twenty years ago?”
“No one,” Gandalf responded. “And through no fault of the people of your world. Yet I must ask: have you considered the possibility of us failing?”
“More than once,” the professor said. “I gave my word that I would summon you and send you on your way, but I made it clear that it was a walk on a knife’s edge.”
Celebrimbor turned around. “The chances of success seem slim,” he said, an edge to his voice. “I see few possibilities for events to play out in a way where we succeed without even knowing what awaits us beyond the darkness. What will you do if we fail? Do you have contingency plans?”
The professor nodded tiredly. “We do, but as everything else, it is a measure of desperation and we have little hope that it would even work. And yet, in the absence of hope, despair must suffice, I suppose.” He ran a hand over his hair. “As we speak, Mademoiselle Alicia Dessendre is assembling the Painters in Paris. She proposed the idea of ... creating an exit door. We do not have time to write our way out – creating a story that would be stable enough to support entrance would take years – time that we do not have. But if there were painters skilled enough ... perhaps a window into another world might yet be created.”
Celebrimbor pulled up an eyebrow. “So you would attempt to escape into another subcreation? Who’s to say that it doesn’t depend on the upper chain links and collapse the moment this world is destroyed?”
The professor looked at him. “No one. But as I said, we must do without hope from here on out.”
It was in this moment that the door to the office flew open. It cracked against the wall and Frodo jumped in his seat. Celebrimbor, too, whirled around, his hand going for a sword that wasn’t there. Gandalf turned around, frowning.
“Oh, I am sorry,” Sauron said acridly, one eyebrow raised, “am I interrupting your plotting?” Both his hair as well as his coat were dry, as Celebrimbor noticed.
He cannot have gone far, then. Then, another thought: Has he been overhearing us?
It was unlikely, given how quietly Gandalf and the professor had spoken. Then again, it would hardly be the most notable feat that Ann—Sauron had proven himself capable of.
“Hardly,” Gandalf said, his bushy brows furrowed. “You left of your own volition. Excuse us if we do not wait until you deign to return from your sulking until we make plans.”
“Always so eager to put yourself on the leash of yet another master,” Sauron sneered, striding into the room. “Why, Olórin, some things never change, don’t they?”
“At least I am doing something constructive, you incorrigible hound,” Gandalf said, his voice veering distinctly towards annoyance. “Whereas I could ask where you have run off to in the meantime.”
Sauron bared his teeth in the caricature of a smile. “Oh, excuse me for not jumping at the chance to kneel in subservience to a master and a plan I have not chosen. We do not all of us have knees as durable as yours, Wizard.”
“Where were you?” Gandalf snapped.
Sauron scoffed, pulling off his scarf, before throwing himself into the second chair near the fireplace, ignoring Frodo’s flinch. Ignoring everyone in the room, in fact, save for the wizard. “Am I to be held accountable by you now? But if you must know: the library. It is no Bodleian, that much is for sure, but still I found the presence of dusty tomes and mites infinitely preferable to yours.”
“What were you doing there?” Gandalf’s eyes were full of suspicion.
“Why, Olórin, I was reading. That’s what people tend to do in libraries.” Sauron crossed one ankle over his knee, his mouth twisted in a derogatory mixture of snarl and smirk.
Gandalf fixed him with a dark look. “You are to remain here forthwith. Are we clear?”
“Make me, Wizard.”
“Oh, I will if you force me to.” Gandalf’s gaze dropped to Sauron’s left hand, where the band of gold was shimmering on the fourth finger of his hand.
Sauron’s gaze darkened. “Try me,” he said, voice low and dangerous. “Just try me, if you think a poor imitation of the Rings is going to be enough to protect yourself against me.”
The two Maiar looked at one another, not unlike two great beasts locked into a silent fight for the upper hand. At last, Gandalf huffed.
“You would hardly be here anymore if the Ring wasn’t enough to keep you. I am going to take my chances with you, lapdog of Morgoth.”
Sauron bared his teeth. “Careful, Olórin, the lapdog bites.”
Gandalf scoffed, then looked away.
Only to nearly be hit when something came flying only inches past him, and landed with a loud smack on the desk, whipping up papers and nearly upending a water glass.
The professor hissed in a breath and hurriedly bent forward to catch it, whereas Gandalf whirled around, an unpleasant exclamation on his lips and his expression dark with anger.
“By Manwë, if you do not learn to behave within the next minute, Sauron –”
“Hold your breath, Wizard, and stop to look and think before you get your feathers all ruffled,” Sauron drawled, unimpressed. “I know it’s not exactly your strong side, but do give it a try some time.”
Celebrimbor, who had very nearly leapt forward on instinct, to put himself between the two Maiar – and when would the day come when he would learn not to do this? – stopped and for the first time, looked at the object that had landed on the desk.
It was a book. Old, dusty, the pages yellowed.
On its cover, the title was stamped in faded gold lettering: The Weave of Words and Worlds, by Mortimer Folchart.
“I will not deign to make any comments about having hints and solutions right under your nose,” Sauron said sarcastically. “But I do wonder that there is a book whose contents are dealing with a proposed problem that is remarkably similar to ours.”
The professor leaned forward, putting on his glasses.
“Folchart...” he said. “Folchart. I am sure I have never read that name before.”
“They do demand that professors be able to read before hiring them, don’t they?”
The professor ignored the jab. “I am utmost certain that this book – this book ...”
“It did not exist before?” Celebrimbor asked.
Silence reigned supreme in the room; once again the ticking of the clock was the only sound.
Coincidences. Plot threads aligning. Threads interweaving. Courses being corrected. Hints being strewn. Foreshadowing and dissemination of information. Being in the right place at the right time. Are we being rewarded for adhering to the rules of storytelling?
“Quite an interesting read, from what I could glean within half an hour of skimming it,” Sauron said. “Almost suspiciously pertinent to your current little quandary. A lot on mythopoeia and subcreation. Of belief and the power of the written and spoken word. One could almost say it was made for storytellers with delusions of grandeur.”
For the first time, the professor did not react to the words. Nor did he regale Sauron with his attention, neutral, negative, or otherwise. He was carefully turning the old pages, eyes roving over the script.
“Curious...” he murmured. “Very curious indeed... I hesitate to call it a coincidence that this book should choose to appear now, of all times...”
“I don’t believe in coincidences,” Sauron said.
Celebrimbor, loath as he was to admit, was inclined to agree.
Frodo had risen from his chair and had come over to stand next to him, for the first time showing signs of liveliness again ever since he had put on the Ring of Fire, looking ill as he slipped the band onto his left hand.
Gandalf rumbled something undecipherable under his breath, but he, too, was bent over the book, reading along upside down.
The professor read on, his eyes gliding over the lines impossibly fast. He turned the page. Then another. The further he read, the paler he became.
The Spectres of Time and Silence loomed. Somewhere a hourglass was running low, nearly all the sand in the bottom of the glass.
Tick-tock, went the clock, splintering the stillness like glass.
Gandalf’s brows were furrowed.
Celebrimbor had his arms crossed. Frodo was grasping his beringed left, perhaps unconsciously, perhaps not.
When the old man of Merton College looked up, his face had lost all colour.
“An enlightening read, is it not?” Sauron leaned back in his chair, crossing one knee over the other. He pulled off the glove of his right hand, flexing the fingers. The fire shone through the gap of his missing fourth finger.
“Why, Professor,” he continued with a dark smile full of teeth, resembling nothing so much as the wolf out of a grim fairytale. “You know how to weave a world, you said as much. But how do you unweave a place so thoroughly that it separates from the whole and falls through the cracks of creation?”
In a belt of perdition that extended hundreds of metres around the Dark Frontier, the trees had withered and died. The grass had turned purplish-brown, and the abyssal ley was a thick red haze on the ground; so thick at times that Celebrimbor struggled to see his own feet. The air was still save for the wind; no birds flew here any longer.
Hayes & Harlington station lay abandoned. The concrete of the street and the platform had cracked. Thistly growths pushed up through stone and street. Thorny vines had grown and wrapped around lampposts, buildings, the tables announcing the schedules. The trains lay stranded on the rails, like great dead beasts – their innards hollow, their windows dark or broken. They, too, had been claimed by the vines, as if the train station had fallen back to nature thirty years instead of nine months ago. The clock above the platform had stopped at 4:14 some indeterminate time ago. It had, perhaps, gone backwards in the time Celebrimbor had not been looking, but he could not be entirely sure.
The winds were relentless out here, the clouds hanging low and heavy and slate-grey above their heads like a concrete ceiling about to come down any second. The air was cold, but oppressive.
They were standing on the train tracks.
Ahead of them, the tracks led out of the station and vanished into a wall of Darkness not a hundred metres away.
It was not true darkness, though. It was neither wispy like fog nor permeable like gazing into a sphere of night would have been. The world simply … stopped.
Gandalf looked at it, pensive, but with a worried furrow between his brows.
Frodo said nothing, his hands pushed deep inside the pockets of his coats. Another knife-sharp gust of wind raked across them. Celebrimbor grimaced and put up the collar of his coat, then adjusted his scarf. Whenever he moved his left hand, he could feel the ring like a chokehold around the first phalanx of his fourth finger.
The professor had not looked away once, his small form shrunken beneath layers and layers of cotton and wool. He shivered when the next storm gust hit them.
“I never thought I would see the like of the Void that I so thoughtlessly described,” he murmured. “By God, to write and to see are different things indeed.”
And perhaps this is how our gods will learn not to be so thoughtless with our fates, Celebrimbor thought, but there was no satisfaction in the idea.
“I cannot even imagine what had to happen here,” Frodo said quietly. “For a place to just … become erased like this.”
“Not entirely erased,” Gandalf said. “Fallen. Chances are, it is still somewhere.”
“But where?” Frodo asked. “And what of its people? I cannot even picture the horror one would feel when … Falling alongside a place like this.”
“Well, wherever London has gone, the screaming has largely stopped,” Sauron said dispassionately as he stepped up next to them. When Frodo made an instinctual step to the side, he pulled up an eyebrow. “Oh, pull yourself together, Baggins. You are going to meet other terrors than me before long.”
Frodo did not reply, but pointedly removed himself to the other end of their line. Which, unfortunately, left Celebrimbor standing next to Sauron.
A fact which both of them pointedly ignored.
Gandalf hummed unhappily. “Well then. No use in dithering. Walk we must, so walk we shall.” He threw the professor a look. “Our true natures shall be returned to us once we cross the threshold?”
The professor nodded. “Yes, that is how I wrote you out of the books. Any danger for this world is prevented –,” he did not look at Sauron as he spoke, “ – and you will have all your powers at your disposal on the other side.”
Frodo drew up his shoulders, not looking at the professor, but at the dark wall ahead of them. It went up as high as they could see.
If you look down upon the Earth from space – would you see an end to it? Or is this a pillar of Nothingness carved out of the universe, extending forever in this direction?
Celebrimbor took a deep breath and exhaled slowly. He was used to his mind suppressing the workings of his body, but he was nearing a point where the tension in his limbs overtook the mastery of the mind, where his focus narrowed down to a pinprick, and his own thoughts felt far removed, as if perceived through a veil.
Gandalf put his cane forward with a loud clack upon the concrete sleeper.
Next to Celebrimbor, Sauron suddenly barked out a humourless laugh. “You should see your faces! Is the time of grandstanding already over? One would think it wasn’t your own idea to come here and drag me along.” He looked at them. “Miserable wretches, all of you.” He scoffed. “Come! If we are to meet an ignominious death, we might as well do it with a bit of verve.”
And with another laugh like a knife, speaking very little of joy or sanity, he walked ahead, his beige coat whipped around his calves by the storm winds, and vanished into the darkness without a backward glance.
After a moment of hesitation, Celebrimbor followed.
Do not stop, he thought. Keep the momentum. Whatever you do, do not stop. And he didn’t.
Three steps, thirteen, thirty –
He felt more than heard Frodo and Gandalf on his heels, the professor closely behind.
Don’t stop.
And then the Void was there to swallow him, darkness closed over his head like an ocean; and the world was gone.
Chapter End Notes
The quotes in the fic are taken from the Greek original of the Odyssey. The English version was taken from George Chapman's 1616 translation. The Tyger belongs to William Blake.