Gifts and Guilts by bunn  

| | |

Chapter 1


Gimli had been living on Tol Eressëa in the house of Celebrían for nearly a moon, and had almost got over the oddness of it. 

He woke in the morning, watching the sun reach golden bars across the pale wooden ceiling. Outside the low open window, gulls were crying, Elves were singing merrily, and there was a deep rolling sigh, almost beyond the edge of hearing, that was the sound of the sea. The red floor-tiles were oddly plain, though practical enough, and the simple rush-mat was the kind of thing that Legolas liked.

A strange place for a Dwarf of the House of Durin to find himself, here in the West beyond the Sea. Strange to be the only one of his people here. Strange to have left so much behind.

Still he had seen many worse places to wear out the end of a life. 

For one thing, the breakfasts were very good, and at his age, that was a great comfort. 

*****

When he and Legolas returned from their morning stroll along the harbour wall, he was surprised to find a visitor awaiting him. 

Celebrimbor of Hollin was even taller than most of the elves Gimli had encountered in the last month, and he was wearing austere dark clothing, very finely made with a subtle pattern of holly-leaves. If Gimli had known a great deal more about the far past than any Dwarf of his generation, he might have recognised the calf-length laced cotte as suggestive of a diplomatic mission, but as it was, he only thought it made Celebrimbor look even taller. Legolas looked almost short beside him. 

Gimli refused to be loomed over. He marched into the low whitewashed house into the hall, sat down firmly and waved Celebrimbor to a seat. “So you’re Celebrimbor of Hollin, are you? We saw your gate: very fine it was too.”

“Though we weren’t in the best place to admire it at the time,” Legolas added, settling across the table from Celebrimbor, and regarding him with a curious eye.

“So I heard from Mithrandir.” Celebrimbor’s voice was rather softer than Gimli had somehow expected. “It had outlived its purpose by many years, by then. Still, I was delighted to hear it still answered to the pass-word and opened for you. It would have been well over five thousand years old by then, and I doubt anyone had looked after it in quite some time.”

“We were even more delighted, at the time,” Legolas told him. “Did Mithrandir tell you of the Watcher in the Water?”

“He said there was some horror at the gate.” Celebrimbor frowned severely. “Difficult to imagine. I knew the place well in happier times.” 

Gimli frowned, remembering. “It was late in the year, and the gate-stream had been dammed to make a great pool. The water was deep and dark. It held a horror indeed: a thing of slime with many reaching arms, and it reached out first of all for the Ring-bearer.”

Celebrimbor winced. “And that brings me to my reason for coming to meet you,” he said, clearly uncomfortable. “I understand, Gimli, that you are a descendant of Durin the Last of Khazâd-dum, and knew Thráin, last Ringbearer of the Seven.” 

Gimli puffed out his breath in surprise. “No!  I never met Thráin the Unlucky,” he said. “My father did, but he was still young when Thráin died. He was a cousin of my grandfather, so yes, he was my kin. And yes, I believe he held the Ring of Khazad-dûm, though it was a great secret. Gandalf says it was taken from him by the Necromancer, though at the time everyone thought it had been lost to Durin’s Bane.”

“Yes,” Celebrimbor looked down at his hands, which, Gimli noted, were ringless. “Mithrandir told me that too. Your family kept it for a long time, Gimli. All through the long years of Khazad-dûm: all the long lives of Durin and his heirs.” 

Gimli nodded. “We kept it safe. Wasn’t that what you asked him, long ago? You came into Khazad-dûm, and you gave it to the King, and said: keep it safe. That’s how I was told the tale.” 

His eyes went from Celebrimbor’s solemn face to Legolas. “It’s odd enough, for me, when I recall that Legolas could have seen Moria before it fell,”

“Except that I had other things to occupy me,” Legolas laughed. 

Gimli refused to be distracted. He pointed at Celebrimbor. “But you! You’re a name on a doorway to a kingdom my people lost a thousand years ago. A story from the most ancient histories.” 

He waved a hand around the long room with its blue-patterned tile floor and the small windows that looked out over the sea, beyond which gulls were crying. 

“This place always feels, as Sam Gamgee says, as if it’s inside a song. But mostly it’s one of Legolas’s songs of wind and leaf and wave, or maybe one from Rivendell. Elvish songs, new and old. But Celebrimbor Ring-maker! That is a song of my own people I have fallen into, and a very old one, at that, one near-forgotten and full of doom and gloom. I am not sure what to do about it.” 

“It was good of you to see me,” Celebrimbor said, very tall and formal. “I see how odd it must be for you. I assure you: I don’t think of myself as any kind of legend. More as someone who made a number of very serious mistakes.” 

“Mistakes so very long ago,” Legolas said with a smile. “So long ago that there’s not an oak or even yew that would remember them. Gimli certainly doesn’t.” 

Celebrimbor frowned. “I wanted to speak with Gimli because... It was a mistake, to give that Ring to Durin. I should never have made it, and I should have known better than to give it to a friend. It was unforgiveably careless, and...” he hesitated, then plunged onward with an air of one getting the worst out of the way. “I fear that it took a part in the downfall of your house, Gimli. It was an astonishingly dangerous thing to carry around, with Sauron looking for it. I feel some responsibility for the other Six, but at least I didn’t hand those out as gifts. The first of the Seven Rings I gave to my friend, Durin. I should never have done it.” 

“And you can’t tell Durin, so you have come to tell me?” Gimli asked.

Celebrimbor nodded. His forehead was creased with worry. “And... He knew. Annatar... Sauron. He helped... he was part of making it.  He knew that I had given the first of the Seven to Durin. I thought at the time, it didn’t matter. Moria... Khazad-dûm was well defended, I thought. I was wrong.”

Legolas began to speak, but Gimli shook his head and held up a hand while he thought about it. He was well used to giving judgement. As Lord of the Glittering Caves, he had ruled on many disputes, though none had ever been brought to him so old and weighty as this. Legolas watched him with bright-eyed amusement. At least he was being quiet about it. 

“I see that this is indeed a matter for my House,” he said, having worked it out. “The line of Erebor is senior to mine, but Thorin Stonehelm is not here, and I am. 

“For all that your gift was well-intentioned, the effect was terrible. Thráin died in torment to protect your gift, and very likely he was not the first to do so. Yes. I see that my house might be said to have a claim against the House of Fëanor. Yet also, I believe you are a kinsman of Elrond, is that so?”

“It is so,” Celebrimbor agreed seriously. 

“Elrond has long been a friend of the House of Durin, and moreover, is my host. We owe him much. Furthermore, it seems to me that you laid no oath on Durin or any of his descendants to keep your ring. You asked their help, which they chose freely to give. You gave them a gift, which they chose to keep.”

He nodded to himself, satisfied that the decision was correct. “I judge that no grievance lies between us.” 

Celebrimbor rose and bowed, and Gimli did the same. 

“And now the judgement is out of the way,” Legolas said rather plaintively, “Perhaps we could find some wine?”

“Wine for you,” Gimli said cheerfully, “And cheese, and perhaps some of Bilbo’s seedy cake: didn't he say that he would be baking this morning?  But Celebrían’s cellar can probably run to ale for myself and Durin’s friend here. I hope you’ll tell me more about Durin, Celebrimbor. Very little has come down to us about my kinsmen in their great days.”

“Ale indeed,” Celebrimbor agreed and for the first time he smiled, and his face looked quite different smiling, as if a spark of joy had lit within him. “I will tell you all I can.” 


Chapter End Notes

I was struck with how very long the House of Durin hung onto that last Ring, the Seventh Ring that the Elves of Eregion gave them directly. All the long years of Moria, and then almost 900 after that, when they had lost home after home and were seriously poor, and yet they kept Celebrimbor's Ring when they had lost nearly everything else. Probably, doing that was why Thrain got snatched by the Necromancer.

I felt Celebrimbor would probably have Feelings about this, and Gimli, after all, is one of Durin's House, even if he's not quite Durin's Heir.

People in this story may occasionally refer to Khazad-dûm as Moria. Gimli does it because he walked through modern Moria, and feels that 'black pit' is an accurate description of the place nowadays. Celebrimbor does it half by accident and then corrects himself, because it was a kind of joke in his day, which is why Durin is called 'Lord of Moria' in the inscription on the doors.


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment