New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
The idea first came to him through Finrod, of all people. Finrod would probably be horrified if he knew.
Celebrimbor had a standing invitation to Finrod’s evening gatherings in Tirion, and rarely took him up on it. But Finduilas had mentioned she was going, with Galadriel, and that Orodreth, Edrahil and even young Gildor would be there too. Celebrimbor was overtaken by a wave of nostalgia for lost Nargothrond, and friendships formed when the world was young. Now, here he was, under the soft lights dotted artfully through the apple trees in the garden of Finrod’s house, watching Galadriel arm-wrestling with one of her Teleri uncles while Finrod filled him in on the latest news.
“They offered it to the Ringbearer first,” Finrod said, his nose wrinkled. “Terribly poor taste, I think. Frodo said no. So then they asked me if I would be interested. Me!” He shuddered and took a sip of his wine. “If there is one person in the whole of Middle-earth I have no interest in encountering again, in any form, at any time... No, thank you.”
“Did they ask Edrahil?” Celebrimbor enquired.
Finrod shook his head. “No, nor any of my Ten. My refusal was emphatic. I suppose it put them off enquiring further. I suppose they didn’t... they didn’t ask you?”
Celebrimbor shook his head. “The Valar prefer to ignore my existence. They always have, if you think about it.” He had seen Nienna, briefly, before he had left the Halls of Mandos, but they had not spoken for long.
He had half-hoped that Aulë, who he remembered vividly as a kind of shining extra grandfather, might still think of him, but from Aulë’s halls had come no word, and Celebrimbor was disinclined to go visiting and risk being turned away for his name and family, mostly because he did not want to force a breach between Aulë and Nerdanel’s family.
“Their loss,” Finrod said consolingly. “Let me get you another drink, and then you must tell me... Oh, she’s won! Well done, Galadriel.”
*****
The thought kept coming back to him now and then. He pushed it away as unhealthy. Unproductive. Really, just a terrible idea all round.
But then, he was of the House of Fëanor still. The star was the sign of his house, for better or ill. And that meant curiosity, a healthy dose of distrust in the will of the Valar to actually get a job done, and a certain reluctance to let go of a grudge.
He took a knapsack with sandwiches and a few essential tools, told his friends and concerned grandmother that he would be back in a week or so, and set off to the shining city of Valimar, looking for Eönwë, Herald of the Valar, who had at long last completed the task he had failed to complete at the end of the War of Wrath, and had brought Sauron into the West for judgement.
*****
Celebrimbor had expected to see a figure in chains, and had prepared himself for a face terribly marred: the missing finger and the expression of hatred. Or, perhaps, the essence of that figure caught somehow in gold and runes.
What Eönwë presented to him, with an expression of distaste on his handsome shining face, was neither of those.
It was a glass jar, smaller than he had expected, with what looked like a cloud of smoke swirling quietly inside it.
He took it, feeling awkward under Eönwë’s gaze, and pushed it into the knapsack without really looking at it.
*****
When he returned to Tirion, he found there were a few matters waiting that required his urgent attention. The knapsack, and the jar inside it were pushed haphazardly into a cupboard until he had time to consider them properly, which was not until the night was drawing on.
He set the jar on the sill and looked at it in the dim starlight. Somewhere inside, someone... or was it ‘something?’ looked back at him silently.
It was powerless, without voice or form.
After a long, long pause, Celebrimbor shuddered and got up.
Nobody knew how to make silima any more. Fëanor had made his unique form of crystal to hold the light of the Silmarils, unbreakable, unchanged by the passing of aeons or by the endless light contained within them, and he had not even told his beloved grandson its secrets.
But Celebrimbor knew how to make something that was close. And he did not feel inclined to sleep anywhere near that jar until it was safely enclosed in something unbreakable, both from without, and more importantly, from within.
*****
“Why did you feel this was something you needed to do?” Elrond asked, after he had taken a look at the jar, and turned back to Celebrimbor. He did not quite turn his back on it, which was understandable enough. Celebrimbor had taken some time before he had felt comfortable doing that himself.
“I felt that...” Celebrimbor reassessed the situation, and met Elrond’s dusk-grey eyes suspiciously. “Elrond, I am not one of your Edain patients.”
“Of course not.”
“I passed though death and the Halls of Awaiting, and now I am free, a prince of my own people in the West beyond all evil,” Celebrimbor explained, since he felt Elrond seemed to be oddly unclear on this matter.
“You are. And you are my considerably older kinsman, and here in Valinor beyond the world, we have all left behind the shadow of old ills. Nobody needs healing any more,” Elrond agreed, unruffled. “It is a great relief to me, that my skills are no longer needed here. So, do tell me, just to satisfy my curiosity, why you choose to keep what is left of Sauron, master of slaves, lord of torment, ruiner of wide lands, commander of unspoken horrors, Necromancer, and murderer of a great number of our kin, not least yourself, in a jar in your house?”
Celebrimbor took a breath to reply, and then, abruptly, laughed. “He isn’t any of those things any more.”
“Not currently. He would be again, if he could. Or do you believe he might do better, next time around?”
Celebrimbor considered this for some time, running his finger around the elaborate silver fluting on his wineglass, considering the runes worked through it, carrying a small enchantment to ensure the temperature was always perfectly to his taste.
“Probably not,” he admitted eventually. He picked up the jar, encased in a perfect crystal sphere of something was not quite silima, and turned it in his hands, feeling the small weight of the living spirit within shift in his hands as it moved, like a small bird. It did not seem to care for Elrond’s presence. He could see it glaring, with an eye that did not entirely exist. “I’m not sure that there’s anything much there now but an appetite for revenge.”
He placed the globe carefully on the table, in the shadow of a tall curving green vase that his grandmother had given him. It was filled, just now, with deep red, rather untidy roses, that cast scatters of fallen petals on the table and filled the air with a musky perfume. The roses reflected in the glossy sides of the vase, and also in the shadow-filled jar, giving Sauron’s smoky spirit a dappling of reflected rosepetals, and keeping it safely away from the long beam of late afternoon sunlight, that made a long warm stripe across the polished wood.
Celebrimbor had no taste for torture, and he knew the sunlight made his — guest? Prisoner? Pet? — unhappy.
“Does it eat?” Elrond leaned forward, his keen gaze fixed on the jar.
Celebrimbor shrugged. “Reflections. Shadows. No doubt it would like more... he always did. But I’ve learned a bitter lesson about indulging him.”
Elrond nodded. He was still watching the swirl of clotted smoke within the jar. Abruptly, he reached out and tapped it gently, just enough to make a faint ringing sound. The barely visible thing within flinched away from his fingers.
“Perhaps I can see why, after all,” he said. He picked up a delicate rose-petal and dropped it beside the sphere, watching the reflections shimmer and be lost. “At least this way, we know exactly where he is, and exactly what he is doing.”
“There’s comfort in that,” Celebrimbor agreed, and topped up Elrond’s glass with wine. The sunlight slanting through the glass made a delicate twist of dark red fire, as it sat in Elrond’s hand, and the near-non-existent eye inside the jar was no more than a faint echo of the Sun’s radiance as it shimmered, caught in the generous second life of the fruit of the vine.
I've included this in my Undying Lands series,though chronologically, it's probably a better fit in Return to Aman, in between Celebrimbor's return from Mandos, and the rest of his House. This is because Return to Aman has (however meandering) a closed and completed arc which is not primarily to do with Sauron or Celebrimbor, whereas Undying Lands has so far has not grown an arc of its own.