New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
“They laughed at me, Fëanáro.” Nerdanel wasn’t sure how to impress on him just how uncomfortable the party had been. He moved through the crowds of courtiers and their social and political intrigues like none of it could touch him, though she knew sometimes it did. He didn’t understand why she usually preferred to keep her thoughts to herself and watch.
“They found you charming, love.” He left the garden wall where he’d been sketching something into his notebook and settled beside her on the bench. “They were calling you Nerdanel the Wise by the time the Mingling was over.”
“I’m reasonably sure it wasn’t a compliment.”
“The Tanners’ Guild adopted your solution. That much at least was sincere.”
“I didn’t mean to be funny or wise,” Nerdanel insisted. “It seemed so simple and clear, and I didn’t think they would—I didn’t stop and think.”
“If it helps,” Fëanor shifted thoughtfully and leaned against her, “I think it was more the way you said it that surprised them, not that there was anything laughable about your idea. They want to wrap everything in flattery first, make sure they keep the advantage, or obscure it in layers of hints and hypotheticals so if they come out on the wrong side later, they can deny they ever suggested it. Nothing can ever be plain and straightforward.”
Nerdanel nodded. She knew what he meant; she had watched Fëanáro use words like a delicate blade to slice apart his opponents in perfect politeness, and it was both thrilling and disquieting at once. “So I sounded hopelessly naïve.”
“Please don’t let them get to you. I love the way you speak.”
Nerdanel sighed. “How do you put up with it all the time? Do you really stop and calculate every word for effect?”
“It gets quick with practice.” He flashed her a feral grin. “Trust me, they liked you. You haven’t spoiled anything.” His hands were alive with an energy he could not contain, fingers tapping an intricate rhythm on his thigh.
She could watch him for hours, Nerdanel thought yet again. His constant motion was difficult to capture in stone, and her first attempts had proven unsatisfactory, but she would never stand down from the challenge. She felt on the verge of grasping and mapping the beats his soul danced to, and when she had, it would be her finest sculpture yet.
“You only do that when you think no one notices.”
His hands immediately stilled and came to rest elegantly in his lap.
“I didn't mean you should stop.” She slid her fingers around his wrist, tracing the paths of muscle and ligament; down to his thumb, stained with ink; skated her fingertips over his knuckles to feel how they bumped. Maybe she was a little obsessed with his hands. “That one’s for when you’re having a good time. I like to see it.”
“No hiding from you, is there?” Fëanáro smiled wryly. “When I'm here, playing prince, I do have to look the part.” He did, regal and impossibly handsome, but Nerdanel thought about him waking beside her in a tent somewhere in the wilderness, all soft and rumpled and unguarded, as if he were truly comfortable in his skin for once, while the golden light of Laurelin slowly waxed and lit that spark in his eyes. She’d rather have him happy than princely.
Fëanáro watched as she studied him. “You know, when I’m with you…I feel like I don’t need to hide.” Casually, as if it took none of the effort she could see him making, now that it had been pointed out, he began tapping his fingertips against his thigh once more.
Nerdanel pressed a soft kiss to his cheek and felt him relax a little further. “Does it make you happy, all your careful intrigue at court? The things we talk about wanting…don’t you ever think about leaving it all for good? Have that big rambling house full of kids and laughter so far out in the countryside that Tirion news only reaches us when it’s weathered into bits of funny stories?”
“Hold me?” he murmured against her ear, and she pulled him close, nestling him against her chest and kissing the top of his head. He gave a little sigh. “I don’t think I can give it up. I need to be there, to have some say in decisions, to…to protect myself and the people I care about. I can’t let others have all that power over me and not know what’s going on.”
“Who are you afraid of, Fëanáro? Your own father?” She said it gently, but he flinched.
“You don’t know how quickly you can lose things. You don’t understand how fragile everything you love can be. Yes, even here.”
Too late, she remembered the name he was not speaking. “I’m sorry,” she murmured, and she wrapped him tighter in her arms as if she herself could shield him from grief.
“No. It’s better you don’t.” He slipped his hand around her and felt in her pocket until he found the lump of beeswax she carried for modeling sculpture ideas as they came to her. The warm wax molded easily in his nimble fingers, taking on shape after shape in quick succession: a calla lily, a lotus blossom, a rose. “If…I cannot give you everything you want…if I can't leave everything behind for you…will you still want me?” His voice had grown very small.
There was his fear again. It haunted him, spilling out into everything he did, fear of loss and pain he could not prevent however tightly he clung. She wished she knew how to relieve him. “I want you no matter what.” She felt his breath where their bodies met, harsh and tightly controlled. “We’ll work out a solution that’s good for us both. That's what everyone has to do, in the end.”
“Is it?” His smile was crooked, ready to turn sharp and defensive at a moment's notice, but a soft trust shone in his eyes that she treasured.
Nerdanel gently butted her forehead against his, and he slipped a kiss onto her temple. “A house just on the outskirts of town, maybe? We can still have a big garden for the children to play in. And space for separate studios.”
He nodded. “Separate studios are an absolute necessity. And it's not like we have to stay here year round, as long as I'm home for the most important court sessions. I will always want to go exploring with you.”
“See there? A compromise, no scheming or weeks of politicking required.”
Fëanáro laughed, a quiet sound of pure delight, nothing like the laughter that had been aimed at her at the party earlier. “Indeed.”
“It…isn't entirely that simple.” Nerdanel took a measured breath of her own. “If this has to be a big part of our life…I won’t play their games for you. I’ll accompany you when you need it, but I won’t be involved in your plots. I will be quiet when I please and I will say what I think in the words that please me. I don’t know another way to be, and I’m not going to pretend to be someone I’m not.”
“I would never ask it of you.” The soft silver light illumined his profile, and Nerdanel saw the solemnity of his steady gaze. “I would ruin something fair and precious if I asked you to change for me. I do not wish it.”
A peaceful warmth settled over her at his ready assurance. Even in the places they differed, he always met her with care. This was no exception, and she wasn’t sure why she’d worried it might be. “I did like the dancing.” She pictured it, all the bright gowns and jewels sparkling under gemlight and candles blurring together as she spun and spun in Fëanáro’s arms, the movement suffusing her until nothing existed but the two of them and delight.
“Dance with me again?” He stood and held out his hands to her, sweet with the smell of beeswax. He hummed a fragment of a tune as she followed him further into the silver-lit garden. “That’s the one you liked best, wasn’t it?” She felt him at the edges of her mind, and when she let him in, the fullness of the orchestra met her and bloomed between them as her memories of the music blended with his. They moved together under the flowering trees, whirling faster and faster in perfect step, his weight thrown into her arms with wild abandon as his strong hands supported her in turn, and she laughed as the pleasure of it filled her limbs and shivered down her spine.
“You show me joy,” he murmured as they swayed together, catching their breath. “I never knew what it was until I met you.”
His mind still rested comfortably against hers, so it was easy to open to him further and share without any words at all how he filled her with it, too.