Lord of Nan Elmoth by Harp_of_Gold  

| | |

Fanwork Notes

Fanwork Information

Summary:

Maeglin meets a strange Maia wandering in the mountains outside Gondolin. He meets him again in the depths of Angband. How can he find refuge with someone he never should have cared for, in a place to which he never wanted to return?

Major Characters: Maeglin, Sauron

Major Relationships: Maeglin/Sauron

Genre: Alternate Universe, Drama, Family, Horror, Hurt/Comfort, Romance, Slash

Challenges:

Rating: Adult

Warnings: Child Abuse, Domestic and Partner Violence, Mature Themes, Sexual Content (Graphic), Torture, Violence (Graphic)

Chapters: 19 Word Count: 55, 398
Posted on Updated on

This fanwork is a work in progress.

Chapter 1

Read Chapter 1

No one should’ve been there. Maeglin shouldn’t either, not really, but he was always careful not to roam so far into the mountains that he couldn’t see the eagles circling far above, and anyway, he’d go mad if he stayed forever within the tiny cage of Gondolin. The stranger was sitting on Maeglin’s favorite perch, an outcropping of weather-beaten marble streaked with serpentine. His bright red hair was a startling incongruence among the greys and browns of the rocky mountainside, and Maeglin pulled the hood of his cloak closer. He’d left behind the black he usually preferred in favor of silky grey wool that shifted and blended with his surroundings, but it wouldn’t keep him hidden if he were reckless.

As he watched, the stranger shook out his hair and looked straight at Maeglin. He didn’t move, but it was too late. The stranger raised a hand and beckoned. “What are you doing up here, all on your own?”

Maeglin bit his lip and stepped forward. “I might ask you the same. Often have I wandered here, and never seen another.” He hesitated. According to the mortal boys Turgon had sheltered, there were few people of any sort still living just north of Gondolin, aside from the Enemy’s servants. “I come here to be alone with my thoughts. And to look at the rocks.” That much, he thought, was safe to say. It could be perilous to reveal anything that might lead to suspicions of his true home.

A smile played upon the stranger’s lips, and Maeglin couldn’t tell if he were pleased or simply laughing at him. “You’d climb all this way and look at the rocks instead of that view?” He gestured to the pine forests of Dorthonion blanketing the slopes below them.

“I mean, that’s pleasant too. But...well, there’s a layer of limestone above the marble up here, and sometimes, where it’s worn away, you can find traces of shells and strange animals in the rock.” Maeglin was certain that, even if he wasn’t being quietly mocked before, he would be now, but the stranger had asked. “The Dwarves teach that in the earliest times, the Powers struggled with one another, and some lands were lifted up, and others cast down, and the heat and force from their battles transformed the stones, and so all the marble around us was limestone once too, and if you trace the line where the marble stops and limestone begins, you can see where it warps and shifts. I…I like to imagine what those battles must have been like, to push the stone into those shapes.”

“This was all undersea back then,” the stranger said quietly. Maeglin came nearer. “They were sea creatures, your stone traces.”

“You think so? Some of them look like huge snails, or roly-polies. Larger versions of what you’d find on the forest floor.”

“There are fish’s bones sometimes too, I’d wager.”

“I’ve only found parts of fish twice. More likely from some ancient riverbed; the molluscs would have lived there too.”

“I think I would know; I—” He cut himself off abruptly.

Maeglin stepped closer again and sat down on the bare mountainside, out of reach but within comfortable speaking distance. The stranger was not an elf as he had first assumed. When he was a little boy, Maeglin’s father had taken him to Doriath and presented him to the court. Well he remembered how Melian’s presence had filled the room and made everything seem to glimmer around the edges. This Maia was keeping himself closely contained, Maeglin suspected, but what he sensed felt like the hum of Dwarven machinery, the focused heat of a blowlamp’s blaze, a glimpse of unreachable perfection whispering on the horizon like a siren’s song. A hint of menace and of sadness echoed there too, and Maeglin backed off before he could be accused of prying into his mind.

“You were there? Is that what you were going to say?”

Golden eyes flashed upon him. “I’m not saying anything. Believe me or not, as you please.”

Maeglin laughed. “I won’t ask, then. But I still want to know what you’re doing on my usual seat.”

“Oh, is this rock yours? I never would have guessed.” He tucked his feet under him and spent a moment arranging himself more comfortably. He reminded Maeglin of his cat, when she turned round and round and kneaded her chosen spot, checking that he was watching, before she settled. “I just wanted to get away for a bit,” he finally admitted. “Not have all my responsibilities staring at me hungrily for a few hours.”

“Like they’re going to eat you up, and there’ll be nothing left of you in the end?”

The golden eyes lingered longer this time. “Aren’t you very young for an Elf?”

“I don’t see what age has to do with anything.”

The Maia shrugged. “When you’ve lived as long as I have, you’ll find that certain things are worth giving up your self for.”

Maeglin remembered the look in his mother’s tired eyes when she’d whispered to him that he was the only reason she stayed in this world, and he wondered if she’d thought the sacrifice truly worthwhile. “You just don’t sound very happy about it.”

The Maia seemed tense and prickly now. Maeglin had said too much, like he always did when he opened his mouth at all.

“I think it feels easier to breathe up here,” he offered, in case he could still salvage the conversation. There was something compelling about the Maia, even if it was simply that he didn’t stare at Maeglin with the uncomfortable mix of pity and distrust he got from so many in the city. “Not so hemmed in. No reminders that the person you love will never love you back.” That was too much to share, he knew, but he wasn’t sure he minded. He didn’t need to calculate the consequence of every word and expression on his reputation here, and if he felt like complaining to the stranger, it probably didn’t matter anyway.

“I wonder if it’s better or worse to never have their regard at all. I can tell you losing it hurts.”

Maeglin perked his ears. “Sounds like you have a story.”

The Maia threw a small pebble and watched it clack against the rock face. “I loved someone devotedly for long ages and thought they loved me in turn, but now it’s like they hardly notice I’m there. Nothing I do is enough anymore. You seem curious and clever. Don’t let your happiness rest on someone who doesn’t care.”

“It isn’t that simple. Else you’d do something to change things yourself.”

“Fair.”

Silence fell again, but a more peaceful one. Although the Sun was covered by clouds, which was why Maeglin had chosen today to venture out, it was warm enough where the rocks had absorbed the heat. He stretched out with one arm over his eyes.

“It’s strange for an Elf to learn his history from Dwarves.”

Maeglin had thought perhaps the Maia was bored of him already. “I suppose. I learned mining and smithwork from them, too. They were good teachers.”

“Maybe you’ll make better use of this than I will, then.” He tossed Maeglin a rock that held a small cluster of embedded garnets. “For bringing noise into your quiet place.”

“Oh. From the overhang back that way?”

The Maia nodded.

“I’ve found garnets there once or twice before. You don’t have to give me anything, though. It’s been nice. Having someone to talk to.”

“Well. I hardly have time anymore to play at jewel-making. My forge is all serious business, when I get to step inside at all. These days I spend more time managing others than working with my hands. I miss it.”

“It seems so frivolous, doesn’t it, to take any time for the things you love with the threat of war constantly in the distance? I experiment when I can, but so much of it is turning out the same things again and again.”

The Maia studied him thoughtfully. “Exactly. Nothing but swords and weapons, one after another without end, and anything else is wasted resources I can’t justify. So very tiresome. I suppose, for that matter, I should be getting back.”

If there had been a Maiarin mastersmith living somewhere in Dorthonion, or even the regions beyond, Maeglin thought he would have heard of him. His father would have said something, if only to curse him and denounce his work as inferior. But there was an ease to sitting here with him that Maeglin hadn’t often known. “Do you think we might meet again? I would like it.”

“You have not asked my name, nor have you given me yours.”

Maeglin smiled, a wistful little quirk of his lips. “I have a feeling if we shared our names, we’d be obliged to kill each other, and that would be a pity after such a lovely afternoon.”

“That would be a pity indeed.”

When they parted, Maeglin walked a circuitous route along the ridge, dipping sometimes into the trees, singing all the time a low, sleepy song of concealment, until he felt himself long alone, and even the solitary wolf that had watched him for a time had disappeared, and then he turned to fetch his pony and take the winding, narrow path back to Gondolin.

Weeks passed before Maeglin dared to slip away again. It was a risk he shouldn’t take; he was opening himself to the Enemy, and Turgon would kill him if he ever found out. Possibly literally. But he wanted to ask what sort of forging a Maia learned, and he wanted to be where no one would care if he let bitter words slip out, and the Maia had seemed lonely too. He’d be careful, and he’d guard his mind, and he’d walk all the way around the Echoriath if he must, to keep him from his trail. The Maia wasn’t there the first time he returned, nor the second, and he started to think the sense of meeting a kindred spirit had been as one-sided as his feelings for Idril. But when he went again, hoping for little more than a moment of peace, the Maia was already waiting.

*

“Is this your work?” The Maia lifted a hand towards the brooch that pinned Maeglin’s cloak, but he didn’t lean in close enough to touch it. Maeglin half wished he would, and then thoroughly squashed the notion.

“Yes. A new alloy I’ve been playing with.” He’d made sure to strip any signs of his House from his outfit, but this he’d thought safe enough. “Really it’s my father’s invention, but the materials for it are very hard to acquire, so I’ve been working out alternatives. A substitute version.”

“So you’re striving to surpass him.” His eyes gleamed. “Do you think you’re succeeding?”

Maeglin didn’t know how to answer. “Umm…I don’t think I can say that. It’s stronger and lighter than steel, but it can’t yet match the original.”

“But easier to produce? That’s important too. A metal is little use if you can’t get enough for your purpose.”

“Yes. And I suppose that’s true.”

“May I see?” He held out his hand.

Maeglin wasn’t sure how much information a Maia might obtain by touch alone, nor what position his friend might really hold, but he wasn’t going to have Orcs clad in pseudo-galvorn added to his long list of mistakes. “I don’t let anyone else handle it.”

“Proprietary secrets. Of course.” He withdrew a short distance, and Maeglin mourned the lost closeness.

“What of your own work, then?”

The Maia thought for a moment, then loosened a small knife from a sheath inside his boot and slid it over to Maeglin. It was curved like a claw with a frighteningly keen tip, a finely-crafted blade that bore the wear of much use, but what caught Maeglin’s notice was the metal adorning the mammoth-ivory handle; the weight of it as he hefted the knife, the gleaming pale sheen. “That’s platinum.” He hadn’t worked with it often, but he’d seen it, studied it enough times in Nogrod to be sure. “These are castings.”

“Yes.”

“How?! What kind of furnace…what kind of heat…? How is that even…”

The Maia held out his hand to take it back. “Proprietary secrets,” he said as his smirk broke into a sharp smile.

So it went between them, every fascinating discussion of metals and craft punctuated with quick retreats and veiled explanations that obscured more than they shared. Maeglin didn’t care. To the Maia he was neither prince nor lord, and he didn’t know to look for the ghost of Aredhel or of Eöl behind Maeglin’s eyes. The Maia never seemed to mind when he fell into long silences, and he didn’t sigh longsufferingly when Maeglin got excited about some rock and spoke faster and faster, tumbling over himself to explain, and though he never softened his blows when he disagreed, Maeglin thought he preferred that too.

He was cautious, he told himself when he returned to his wide, soft bed in the House of the Mole and lay awake wondering if he could ever excuse this blatant flouting of Turgon’s wishes. He didn’t talk about his work in Anghabar, the painstaking calculations he figured and refigured as he sought the best ways to support the developing mine shafts and keep his people safe, nor his experiments with Rog to improve the efficiency of the furnaces they used to smelt ores. He didn’t talk about the ways he’d been constructing blades to get a weapon that would neither snap in battle nor dull, and he did not mention the blue gleam that now alerted a sword’s bearer to nearby Orcs. Instead they devised clever cuts for gemstones, argued over methods for fusing gold granulation, traded signs to look for when hunting certain minerals. Things that couldn’t give either of them a real advantage, surely. That knowledge had no power to hurt, so it had to be all right. He let his mind wander to the words the Maia had taught him, names for all his stone creatures in a language from long ago that rumbled pleasantly in Maeglin’s mouth; trilobites and ammonites and crinoids and sea stars that looked like strange flowers. His last memory before he slipped into dreams was the bright, clear sound of the Maia’s laugh.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 2

Read Chapter 2

“You seem more cheerful lately,” Salgant told him over a cup of the delicate floral tea he favored. Between his time in the mountains and occupying himself with work, Maeglin had been neglecting their weekly afternoons together, and he’d decided it was time to make it up to him.

“I…met someone.”

Salgant beamed. “Maeglin, that’s excellent! When will you bring the young lady around? You have to introduce her; I can’t bear the suspense.”

“Oh. Umm. Not a young lady, actually.”

“Young man, then? Or not either?”

“Well…he’s—but I didn’t mean it that way. He’s…a friend. I think.” No one, not even Salgant, should imagine he could love someone other than Idril. It wasn’t like that at all.

“I’m as eager to meet a friend of yours as I am someone you have romantic feelings for; you know that, right? One’s not more important than the other.”

Maeglin stared into his teacup, blowing away the steam before taking a sip, a tiny smile on his lips. Salgant still managed to surprise him sometimes. “I don’t think he’d want to do that. Yet, anyway. He’s…very shy, and I don’t think he’d want…you know. Everything I do in public gets the scrutiny of the entire court.”

Salgant nodded understandingly. “I think you must make him feel very comfortable, if he makes that exception for your company. It can be a treasure, to find someone like that.”

That felt true enough, despite having given him the wrong reason to conclude it. “For both of us, I believe.” He finished his tea and let Salgant pour him another cup. “I have a new fossil for my collection.” He took a trilobite from his shoulder bag and unwrapped it as Salgant pulled his chair closer to see. “Look how big the eyes are on this one.” The Maia’s suggestion to use acid to eat away the surrounding rock had worked to great effect.

“Oh my. I wouldn’t want to step on that in the garden on a dark night.”

Maeglin grinned. “Actually, my friend suggests they were sea creatures. Do you know anyone who would know if something like that still lives?”

“I never saw such a thing in any of the fish markets in Nevrast or the Falas, but there are plenty who were fishers there. You could talk to Egalmoth; I think a fair number ended up in his House.”

Maeglin made his best pleading face.

“Or I could ask around, I suppose.”

“Would you? I’d appreciate it so much.” Salgant would weave it into the conversation and make it sound like a perfectly normal thing to wonder about, and however many times Maeglin watched him at work, he could never get his own words to come out right. Better to keep his silence, and save himself the strange looks and pointed laughter when he could.

Salgant adjourned to his harp where it sat near the wide window overlooking the gardens, and Maeglin got out his watercolors and began a sketch of the trilobite, careful to make note of all the features that stood out as different from his others. Salgant’s music was light and rippling today, meltingly sweet notes that skipped like a mountain brook, and as the hours passed in easy contentment, Maeglin wondered what it would be like to have his new friend there too, sprawled on the floor between them with his wolf furs cushioning his head and his red hair fanned over the pale rush mat. Making sarcastic remarks, most likely. He shook his head. It would never be possible, so he shouldn’t let himself hope for it. There were too many unfulfillable wishes already in his life.

*

Maeglin had brought honey cakes to share, and the Maia savored them, daintily licking the honey from his fingers before lighting a little flameburst in his palms to burn away the stickiness. Maeglin wondered whether such treats were rare for him or something he had at all, but he didn't ask. Questions about the places they lived tread close to the line, and Maeglin didn’t want to infringe. Perhaps he was important enough to get any luxury he wanted, and Maeglin’s offering meant little. He wasn’t sure he wanted to know, if that were the answer.

More than ever he needed the escape of the little haven they shared today, and he was content to relax together. The day was warm and bright, and Maeglin wore both a wide-brimmed hat and the dark lenses he’d kept on in public only once. Hearing that he must be half Orc to fear the Sun so had banished that idea. The Maia had tucked himself into a shadowed nook in the cliffside and pulled up his hood so the wolf fur ruff hung over his eyes.

“Days like this almost make me miss the forest where I grew up,” Maeglin said at last. “The Sun could barely peek through those trees.” He could feel the Maia’s gaze upon him more than see it.

“Only almost?” came his amused voice.

“Mm. I was miserable there. My father made me miserable.”

“And you’re happier now? Having left?”

Maeglin’s fingers tightened on the broken pebble he’d been playing with. “That’s not a fair question.”

“Really? It seems simple enough.”

“If I’d known what I’d lose—who I’d lose, in leaving…” One edge of the rock was jagged, though worn, and he pressed his thumb into it. “I don’t know. Maybe Naneth would rather have died than stayed. I think she might have chosen the same regardless. But I’m not sure I would. Anyway. I wouldn’t go back there. But I felt so very safe, under those trees as a child. Until I realized my father used them to trap us there as much as to protect us.”

“Not simple at all. I see what you mean.” The Maia hesitated. “It gets so tangled up, doesn’t it? Places and people you care about, and the way they treat you, and choices you can’t turn your back on, and everything slowly falling apart into things you never wanted…” He shook his head. “I can’t say enough to make sense. Let’s speak of something more cheerful. I’ve dragged you down by asking.”

“It’s all right.” He cast around for brighter thoughts, but a weariness had settled on him that he knew wouldn’t easily be dispersed. But if his mind would touch nothing but problems, he had enough of those. “Maybe you could help me with something. What would you do if someone who works for you keeps getting the same thing wrong and doesn’t seem to learn when you correct them?” Salgant’s advice had achieved nothing, and talking to Rog or worse, Turgon, felt like showing too much weakness. He couldn’t afford to look like his lordship was too much for him.

The Maia snorted. “You whip them soundly. Make sure it hurts enough that they won’t dare ignore you again.”

Maeglin looked up at his friend in astonishment and not a little dismay. “That…seems really harsh.”

“You have to be harsh to keep your people’s respect. Otherwise, they’ll walk all over you, and you’ll lose your place.”

He wanted to argue, to find some counterpoint, but words were fleeing him, and Maeglin could only think how much he’d feared and hated his father and his heavy belt beating welts into bare skin while he struggled not to scream and failed.

“Hey. Hey, I didn’t mean to upset you.” Tentatively the Maia reached for Maeglin’s shaking hands and took them between his own. The heat of his touch sent shivers through Maeglin that were far from unpleasant. “I can see you don’t have the stomach for it. But you’ll need to develop it, if you want to command others. That’s how rulership works, whether you like it or not.”

“That’s not…” How it works in Gondolin, he could not say. “I don’t want to live that way. I don’t think that’s the only way to make it work. Don’t you think…wouldn’t it be better if people followed you out of admiration and trust, not fear? Don’t you think making them fear you will ruin whatever trust you’ve earned?” He had never felt any desire to obey his father after the beatings had started, only cold necessity. He didn’t want that for anyone following him, even if Turgon would allow it for such minor conflicts.

The Maia shrugged. “You asked me; you got my answer. It’s never failed me so far.” His thumbs were drawing distracting circles over Maeglin’s palms, and as much as he liked the sensation, he couldn’t help remembering that the Maia belonged to a different world; one set ultimately on his own destruction. The warm afternoon felt suddenly bleak and cold. The Maia seemed to sense it; he tipped Maeglin’s chin up, and Maeglin was caught in his golden, cat-like gaze. “You’ll figure things out. There’s fire in you, even if you often push it down.”

“What do you mean by that?!”

“The way you carry yourself, like you want to be invisible. The way you swallow half of what you want to say—I know we’re both careful of what we reveal, but you…it’s a conscious decision you have to make, every time you share something, even the most harmless of things. I don’t think that’s just keeping private things private; I think it’s so habitual you don’t know how to stop. I could be wrong, though.”

Maeglin’s heart was in his throat. He didn’t like feeling so exposed, like a mole whose burrow had been ripped open, baring him to sunlight. What else did the Maia see too clearly? “People don’t like me when I say very much.”

“Then they don’t deserve you,” the Maia said fiercely.

“It’s not their fault. Not always. I just need to learn how to make myself into someone she’ll want.”

The Maia’s mouth twisted. “Ah. So it’s one person in particular you do this for.”

“I have to care about everyone’s opinion, but hers matters most.”

“Let me know if you ever find out the trick to that. You’ll have to teach me.”

“What happened to ‘they don’t deserve you’?”

“Some things are worth giving up your self for,” he said quietly.

*

Autumn was fading; the mountain slopes were a mosaic of red and gold, and Maeglin knew if the snows came early, this could be his last afternoon with his friend until spring. He’d left a sign for him to come on the first day of the new moon, and though it wouldn't be the first time their duties got in the way and kept them from meeting, it was disappointing to climb over the rise and not be greeted by a shock of red hair. He settled in with his sketchbook to wait anyway, and an hour or so later, the Maia appeared from the edge of the trees. A certain sharpness haunted his smile, and something about him seemed rushed and flustered, though his clothes looked as put-together as always.

“I haven’t much time—I have to check on my pets soon—but I didn’t want to abandon you,” he announced as he sat beside Maeglin. “Something big is afoot, and if I play everything just right—I may find my love very pleased with me.” The many rings glittering on his fingers clinked as he pulled his knees up and laced his hands around them. “If he would hold me again and give me one smile, I think everything else would fade away, and I would be content.”

The gleam in his eyes was dangerous and beautiful, and Maeglin felt vaguely sick. He didn’t know what “something big” could mean, but it couldn’t be anything good. He wondered if he should tell Turgon, though doing so without revealing his…indiscretion might well be impossible. It wouldn’t mean much to Gondolin anyway, and there was nothing they could do for those outside. That was the sacrifice Turgon had made.

“Come, don’t look at me like that.” The Maia clasped his shoulder, and Maeglin couldn’t help but lean closer. “I’ve brought you a little something. I don’t know if I’ll be nearby much longer—I hope not, in fact—but if I don’t see you again, I’ll miss you and these afternoons. You’ve made my life bearable, this last while.” The gift he pressed into Maeglin’s hands was an ammonite on a delicate silver chain, sliced in half and polished to show off the spiraling chambers inside, but where the ammonites Maeglin knew had turned to agate in their long ages underground, this one was sparkling pyrite.

“This isn’t from around here, is it? I’ve never seen any fossil like that. It would have to have formed where there was a lot of iron around it, but…”

“I found it farther north.”

North. North was Angband, but how could a thing of such beauty come from there? Plenty of land and rock stretched between them... The Maia comes from Angband too, and he’s going back as soon as he can. Maeglin tried to quiet the whispered thought. The Maia had only ever been kind to him, and it was likely ending soon anyway. “I’ll treasure it,” he said softly, and spent what time they had left basking in the Maia’s smile.

*

“We missed you at the council meeting.” Duilin was standing in front of a crackling fire in Maeglin’s study, and didn’t bother turning around. “Again.”

Maeglin cursed under his breath. He’d ridden hard to reach the plains before nightfall, and now it was late. He’d hoped to get inside without any interruptions and collapse straight into bed. “And just what requires my attention at this hour? I don’t generally go over minutes after midnight.”

Duilin tossed a packet onto Maeglin’s desk. “King Turgon sends his regards, since he sees so little of you. I’m sure those can wait for morning, as you say. I, on the other hand, want to know what exactly it is that takes you so often from your duties as a Lord.”

Maeglin dug his nails into his palm and pulled a practiced sneer onto his face. “Tell me, Duilin, are you still interested in that rather large order of arrowheads? Where, exactly, do you think they’re going to come from if I’m not out there dragging the ore from the ground?”

“I sent messengers to the forges and out to Anghabar when you didn’t show. You weren’t there.”

“Were you aware that veins of iron aren’t infinite? I was prospecting, not that it’s your business.”

“You know they say that’s what turned Eöl’s heart so dark. All that time he spent alone. It isn’t natural.”

“I wasn’t alone,” Maeglin wanted to say. Or maybe, “Shall I simply stay at the Princess’s side? Would you like that better?” Or even a solid “Fuck you.” He bit down hard on his lip instead. In his hurt and fury, he barely realized he was brushing against Duilin’s mind, and once there it was easy to pluck at the little threads he left hanging for anyone to see. One of the first thoughts to unravel at his touch was guilt. “Shouldn’t you be getting home? Wouldn’t want your wife getting ideas in all this time you’ve left her alone.”

Duilin’s minuscule flinch might have gone unremarked by anyone else, but Maeglin noted it with satisfaction. “And that’s none of your business,” he snapped. “Be at the next meeting.” He didn’t wait for a reply.

As soon as he’d gone, Maeglin let his trembling show. He hated how his body tried to betray him at the slightest conflict. It wasn’t fair. He thought about the comfort of a hot bath, but he didn’t want to rouse a servant just for that; he didn’t drag people from their beds to wait on his whims, and he wasn’t going to start now. He took a deep breath once he reached his room and started pulling off his clothes, not bothering to hang them up. The heavy curtains were drawn, and the murals with their dark painted trees enfolded him in his own private refuge where he could forget everything else. As he slipped between his sheets, he took off the ammonite and set it on the nightstand. He watched the candlelight flicker and reflect in its curves and wished he could live a different life.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 3

Read Chapter 3

A cry ricocheted through dark dreams, rousing Maeglin into sharp wakefulness with his heart pounding in his chest. “Help me! Please, I need you, you’re the only one I can ask. Please…”

Maeglin rubbed his eyes and shook his head. The burst of ósanwë was so loud that it hurt, and the beginnings of a migraine was throbbing behind his eye. He reached out tentatively to the Maia. At his touch, the pleading intensified.

“I know you don’t trust me. I’ll swear to anything you want. Please just come. You must be somewhere close. I think I’m dying.”

He was in the base camp for the mining operations at Anghabar, a couple hours’ climb from the mountaintop ridge where they always met. But far closer than if he’d been in Gondolin itself, and if he cut through a passage underground he could shorten it more… Hopefully it would be enough. He dressed as quickly as he could. “I’m coming. I need you to concentrate and tell me what’s happened and what you need.” He pulled on his boots.

“Hurt. Wounded. My throat…there’s so much blood.”

“All right. Where are you?” He shoved his first aid kit and all the bandages he could find into a bag, grabbed the pack he always had ready with food and water and supplies if he ever needed to run again, and quietly called to his horse. A jumbled picture of crashing through pine branches was all he got from his friend. Morincë whickered when she saw him step out.

“Hey, girl, I know it’s no fun waking up in the middle of the night.” Maeglin worked as fast as he could, strapping on his pack securely and speaking soothingly the whole time. “It’s important, I promise. We’ve got to be brave and fast tonight. I know you’ll do your best.”

He’d chosen her because she was nimble and sure-footed on rocky mountain slopes that held only the barest traces of trails, carved by the passing of deer and mountain goats that were often bolder than him. Morincë went through the old mine shaft without hesitation and climbed confidently in the dark, with Maeglin leaning over her neck to help her balance and urge her onward. They made excellent time, and when Maeglin reached the point where he usually left her to graze and took a steeper trail on foot, he pushed her on towards the dark pines. “Where are you?” he called again.

The pictures he received this time were more careful and composed, but the Maia’s thought felt wearier, as if it took great effort. “I’d hoped you were closer,” he managed.

“I'm close now. Hold on.” He had to dismount and lead his horse through the dense trees. The scent of blood hit him hard, and for the space of a blink he was swept back to his childhood, when his mother had come home from a hunt, laughing, her white clothes soaked in blood with a small deer slung over her shoulders, the light in her eyes wild and fey. Lómion had stopped short as he breathed in, then ran screaming from the smell and emptied his stomach on his bedroom floor. Eöl had cared for him with long-fingered, elegant hands that he hadn’t yet learned to fear, cleaning him up and tucking him into bed with a cup of warm tea and the big, soft toy moth whose silky wings he’d loved to stroke. Maeglin shook his head and tried to swallow down his nausea; he couldn’t let it get to him now.

A spatter of dark blood coated the pine needles under his feet. He spotted the Maia a moment later. He had dragged himself to a sheltered hollow under a pine and curled up in a fetal position, a wad of fabric held tightly to his throat. He was wrapped in a leathery cloak, and his hair was matted and wet with drying blood. Maeglin rushed to his side. “What happened?! What can I—here, don’t move—”

Kneeling at his friend’s side, he started to peel back the cloak, only for the material to shudder and twitch in his fingers. A great, bat-like wing tried to unfurl, then slumped. “Tell me if I hurt you,” Maeglin commanded. He was intensely conscious of how delicate the slender bones felt as he pushed the wing out of his way, carefully following the way they needed to fold. Starlight filtered through the trees and clearly illuminated the gash across the Maia’s throat. “It isn’t bleeding as much as I expected.”

“I’ve closed up as much as I can.”

“That’s good,” Maeglin answered aloud. “You’d likely have bled out by now if you hadn’t.”

“You’re incredibly comforting.”

“So I’ve been told.” It was a good sign, he thought, that the Maia could snipe at him. “You’re going to be fine.”

The Maia’s eyes widened, and he clutched at Maeglin’s arm. “Don’t leave me, please! I can’t—it took everything just to get here—please, I can’t lose this fána, I can’t make another, He’ll—” He abruptly cut himself off.

“I'm not leaving you! Don’t worry.” He wondered what sort of sore spot he’d hit, and what it meant. “I wouldn’t abandon you, not like this. Not when you need my help.” He’d started cleaning the wound, and he wasn’t sure what to do with it. The Maia’s neck was heavily bruised, and the skin looked more crushed than cut. Frowning, he poured water over it again, gently rubbing away more of the dried blood. “This is a bite.”

The Maia shivered and gave a small sob, which he immediately tried to squelch with a hand over his mouth.

“So…have you ever had a wound fester? Is that something that happens to Maiar?”

“How shh—” The Maia coughed and whimpered.

“Just lie still; don’t try to speak. I can hear your thoughts plenty clearly.” That prompted a wall of sudden and utter mental silence, and Maeglin rolled his eyes. Did the Maia think he’d been working only from vague feelings? “I’ve a little miruvor with me. I’d rather have you drink it, but if we’re worried about infection, it’s going on your wound.”

“I am not swallowing that Elvish rotgut.” He eyed Maeglin warily. “Who knows what that foul misbred mutt might’ve had on his teeth. I wouldn’t care if I hadn’t spent my strength, but…” He took a careful breath, and Maeglin could see how it pained him to move at all. “I can’t afford to lose this fána, and I can’t heal it any further.” The thought felt deeply reluctant, as though he’d have preferred almost anything to revealing it, but he had no recourse but to trust Maeglin.

"That's a yes, then." As Maeglin dabbed the clear liquid onto the bite, dripping it into the deeper punctures and tears, the Maia cursed roundly but silently. “So…you had a run-in with a dog?” Perhaps he’d seriously overestimated the threat his friend posed. And yet he’d been so certain of some great impending victory before…

The Maia snarled. “I should have killed him. It was his fate; he’s meant to die to the greatest of wolves, and who else could that mean? There is none greater than I.”

Maeglin thought of the wolf he’d noticed a few times trailing him through the edge of the woods and filed the information away. But the words that stood out to him were straight from one of his mother’s bedtime stories, the ones she told softly in Quenya when Eöl wasn’t near.

“You…don’t mean Huan?” It came out so quietly that anyone else would have made him repeat himself; he felt silly asking after his uncle’s hound from old tales. That was many years ago; he must be long dead, if he was ever more than a childhood entertainment. But every line of the Maia’s body tensed.

“What do you know of him?”

“Little more than a name, in truth.” He started wrapping a bandage around his friend’s throat; if any poison or foulness lingered in the wound, stitches would only make matters worse.

“He came with Melian’s little witch-girl. They took my tower.” The Maia growled aloud, his voice a dry croak. “They ruined everything!”

Maeglin recoiled from his friend’s bitter fury, but when he broke into sobs, Maeglin couldn’t help but try to soothe him, pulling him carefully into his lap, holding him and stroking his hair while he wept. He’s the enemy, Maeglin reminded himself, taking care to guard his mind. I should be glad of his defeat. I should be glad…

He wondered if the Maia meant Lúthien or Galadriel; both his kinswomen had been students of Melian’s enchantments when he visited Doriath. Galadriel had watched him from afar with a frown and furrowed brow, but Lúthien had knelt down beside him and told him funny little stories about all the courtiers until she finally got him to laugh. Eöl hadn’t gone back after that. When Maeglin had asked when they’d visit again, he’d scoffed, but not at Maeglin. “Thingol needed to know you’re my heir. He knows now.” Maeglin hoped, whichever it was, that she’d survived unhurt and accomplished what she sought. He wouldn’t mention them.

“We need to find you some shelter,” he told the Maia when he’d grown a little calmer. “I don’t think you should travel until that’s healed.”

“Where would I even go?” he lamented, lapsing into ósanwë again.

Maeglin didn’t try to answer that. He didn’t want to move the Maia far, but a quick look around revealed an overhang that was almost a small cave, and it would do better than a few pine boughs to keep him from the elements. The Maia had little strength, and Maeglin had to bear much of his weight, a few steps at a time with the Maia’s arm over his shoulders pressing him down. Somehow he made it without stumbling, and he spread his own cloak over the blanket roll from his escape bag and eased the Maia onto it.

When Maeglin started to rise, the Maia clutched his arm. “Please.”

“I’ll stay with you until morning. Then I’ll have to go back; I’ll be missed. I don’t want to make people worry. But I’ll come check on you, as much as I can.” He knew that would be less than ideal, but it was the best he could manage. It was too late in the year for long absences; he couldn’t risk being caught in snow in the mountains, and he couldn’t raise suspicion when everyone knew the weather should keep him at home. He’d tell his people he was inspecting the safety of the area around the mines; they wouldn’t question him or report him gone for a couple of days here or there.

Stretching out beside the Maia, his back to the winds outside, Maeglin put his arms around him for warmth and tried to rest. After a moment, the Maia tucked a wing over them both. He said nothing, but Maeglin could tell he didn’t sleep. When he heard his breath start to hitch, a tiny sound the Maia sought to cover, Maeglin silently dried his face with the edge of his sleeve, and the Maia burrowed closer against him. He felt so fragile lying there, nothing like the fearsome monster Maeglin knew he must be.

I could kill him, here, tonight. The thought rose unbidden. Perhaps it was even his duty. The Maia would not have hesitated to kill his cousin, had she proved the weaker. He remembered the stories Huor and Hurin had told, of fire and death and brutal destruction. Who could tell how many people he might save from future attacks by one quick act? Forget that he was defenseless; no quarter was ever given to Morgoth’s servants. They’d proven time and again they’d offer none themselves. He’d be a hero.

That’s what they’d all say in Gondolin. That’s what his father would have said. His mother too, he thought. He’d watched her once, near the margins of the forest, dispatch without mercy three orcs that had stumbled into a spider’s web while they begged in mangled Sindarin for their lives. She’d have reminded him, if she’d lived to see it, of his grandfather’s broken body. He pushed the image away. Maeglin couldn’t abide it. None of it mattered. He hugged the Maia tighter. This was his friend, who’d come to him for help, who’d trusted him with his life in his hour of need. Maeglin wouldn’t betray him. It wasn’t in him, whatever people would think.

*

“Little smith? Little smith. Hey. Elf!”

Maeglin blinked awake groggily and groaned.

“Sun’s about to rise. You said you needed to get back.” The Maia looked very pale and weary, but less like he was about to stand before Mandos.

“Yeah. Thanks. Let me change that bandage. I’ve some food and water to leave with you; I’ll bring more in a day or two.”

The Maia’s wound had fully stopped bleeding at last, and when Maeglin had cleaned it again and dressed it and made sure the Maia had everything he could give him for the moment, he called to his horse. The Maia reached up and caught his sleeve. “You’ve been good to me beyond anything I could expect. Thank you.”

Maeglin nodded. “You’re my friend. I do what I can.”

“Be careful.” He gestured vaguely towards the trees. “Out there.”

“I will. I’ll see you again soon.”

No wolf followed him this time, but the woods felt somehow less welcoming.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 4

Read Chapter 4

The image of the Maia lying alone, hurt and vulnerable and uncomfortably frail haunted Maeglin as he tended to his duties. The quality of the ores his House was mining at Anghabar had to be monitored and adjustments calculated for its smelting; he had transports to arrange and work crews to coordinate and preparations to make for winter. One of the lower shafts had been growing continually wetter, which meant they’d have to start pumping water out of it soon or abandon it entirely, and that was a headache he hadn’t begun to address. But however much he tried to focus, his thoughts kept returning to the mountainside where he’d left his friend, and the way his red hair spilled over his body like the coals of a fire, and how much he needed Maeglin right now, and sooner than was probably wise, he found himself setting it all aside.

His chief foreman entered as he was packing to go back out. “Escaping to the wilderness rather than deal with the lords?”

Maeglin paused. “I just need a few days alone.”

She raised one brow. “Oh, I get it. It’s your business, anyway. Before you disappear again, we’ve found silver in the easternmost shaft. Signs of it being a fairly substantial vein.”

“What type of ore?”

“It appears to be mostly ruby silver, with some traces of other silver-bearing minerals.”

“Arsenic heavy, then. I’ll want additional containment measures in place before we do any mining or processing of it. Let’s put that off until spring and focus work elsewhere. I need as much iron ore as can be had in these last few weeks of the season.”

“Are you sure that’s best? I’ve been hearing from some of the lords who are unhappy about how little precious metal is available.”

“I will have strong words for anyone giving you a hard time. Rôg says the city isn’t well-enough armed if we came under direct attack, and he thinks that’s a real risk this winter. He’s the one whose judgment I trust.”

“Why now more than any other year?”

“Birds whispering about lots of orc and wolf movements, from what I know.” It had occurred to him this might not be unrelated to his friend’s doings.

“Eh. Won’t matter so long as Lord Ulmo’s power keeps them from stumbling onto us. Don’t you find Rôg a bit paranoid?”

“Of course he is. If you ask me, the King’s servants could all stand to follow his example.” If Ecthelion had been more paranoid, my mother might yet live, he did not say, but he could tell from Nengil’s mental flinch it had occurred to her as well. Her feelings seldom reached her face though, and Maeglin was glad not to be met with visible pity or have to speak of it.

“I’ll pass your orders on.” She made a brief note on the papers she held and started to turn, but paused. “My lord? Whoever it is you’ve found out there, whoever you’re helping…we’ve got your back.”

Maeglin froze. “How do you know about that?” he whispered.

“Your horse was gone all night. Bandages missing from stores. No one in camp injured. I thought it was the most likely explanation.”

Maeglin covered his eyes and swore under his breath.

“I know you know how important Gondolin’s secrecy is. I know you’d never do anything to give it away. I’m not worried about that. It’s just—whatever you’re scared of, Turgon’s reaction, or how you think this person will be received—we’ll help you. No questions.”

“He’d be trapped here.”

“Like we all are?” Nengil shrugged. “I don’t know what’s left outside that’s any better, now. Think about it.”

“Mm.”

Nengil handed him a couple of the sticky, muslin-wrapped ration loaves kept in store for those working the mine. “We aren’t running short. These’ll get your rescue back on his feet.”

Maeglin added the loaves, sweet-smelling and studded with dried fruit and nuts, to his bag. “I hope you know how much I appreciate you.”

She nodded with a barely-there smile and left him to finish his packing.

*

Though evening was still far off when Maeglin reached the wood on the far side of the mountains, the light seemed unnaturally dim as he rode beneath the trees. It was not wholly unlike the gloom of Nan Elmoth he’d known as a child, but instead of the friendly roof of the dense oaks and beeches shielding him, it was as if some pall had fallen over the Sun. Something tugged at the edges of his mind, a presence he could sense but could not see, something watching him. He paused and listened, straining to catch some footfall, but there was only the wind. Morincë flicked her ears uneasily, and he pushed her to hurry.

The Maia hadn’t moved. He lay curled on his side in the crevice of the rock face and the shadow of the pines. Whatever stalked the forest, nothing had disturbed him. When Maeglin drew near, he could hear him whimpering, very quietly. He hurried over and laid a hand to the Maia’s sweaty brow. Gold eyes flickered open.

“Are you supposed to be so hot?”

“Didn’t think you’d come back,” the Maia murmured. His wings were still wrapped tightly around him. “He’s going to be so angry. He’s going to hurt me; I can’t, I can’t go back, not like this—” His words tumbled over themselves and turned into sobs.

“Who’s going to hurt you?” Maeglin feared he already knew the answer.

“My king. My lord, my love, my everything…” He allowed Maeglin to hold a waterskin to his lips and took a careful swallow. “It was going to be better. I had the perfect gift in my hands, and then it was all ripped from me…” His eyes were on the rock above them. “I deserve it,” he whispered. “I have to remember that. I failed him, and I deserve whatever he wants to do to me.”

“No.” Maeglin surprised himself with his vehemence. “People who love you aren’t supposed to hurt you, and you don’t deserve to be punished for honest mistakes.” He could hear the words as his mother had spoken them, and if it had often been hard to believe for himself, he found it wasn’t hard at all to believe it on the Maia’s behalf.

The Maia snorted, then winced at the movement. “Silly boy. Who told you the world works like that?” He wiped his eyes and straightened the corner of the blanket over his chest. “Love hurts. Service hurts. It’s a sacrifice to the one you hold dear, and you get up and you keep making it, because the world is empty without him. And I’m—I’m going—as soon as I’m well, I’ll…” He hid his face, but the way his voice broke gave away his tears. “I can’t face him. He’s going to destroy me.”

“You…don’t have to go back.”

“Did you not hear me? I love him. I would never abandon him.”

“You can love someone and still decide they’re bad for you,” Maeglin answered stubbornly. “You shouldn’t have to be afraid.”

“Is there no one you fear to disappoint, then?”

“I don’t…I mean…” He thought of Turgon’s face, frowning at him, of the endless fall from Caragdur where his father had cursed him to follow. “Yes. There is. But…I don’t think it’s the same.”

“Think what you like. You could never understand true loyalty.” The Maia turned his head away, and Maeglin’s heart sank.

I did it again. Said all the wrong things and made him angry. Maybe he’d assumed too much. Maybe he should just stop talking at all; it caused more problems than it had ever mended. He hesitated, but the Maia had no one else, so even if he wished he could make Maeglin leave, he probably didn’t want him to actually go. “Let me see to your throat.” It sounded harsher in his ears than he’d intended.

The Maia huffed and pulled his hair aside. Under the bandage, his skin was an angry red, and the fluid seeping from the edges of the tears was thick and yellowish. Maeglin winced.

“It hurts a lot,” the Maia whispered, watching him.

“Umm...I…I don’t think it’s supposed to look like that.”

“That bad already, hmm?” The Maia laughed, softly and bitterly. “You’ll have to wash it very thoroughly.”

Maeglin flooded the open bite with the water he’d brought, paying special attention to the punctures, though he pulled back every time the Maia groaned or cried, until he hissed furiously at Maeglin to just get it done already.

“I did bring some medicine,” Maeglin offered cautiously when he’d finished and his friend had curled up again, pulling the blanket to his chin. “Willow bark, for the pain. And some ointment; I use it on burns all the time in the forge. It’s meant to speed healing…”

The Maia opened one eye and peered up at him. “More effective than your miruvor, I hope. What’s in it?”

Maeglin listed off the herbs.

“That’s the best you have?” He sighed. “Better than nothing. Put it on.”

The moment the dollop of ointment met his skin, the Maia screeched like some cornered wild animal in its death throes.

“I’m sorry! I’m sorry!! You said it would be okay!!” He swiped at the medicine with a cloth, but spread more of it than he removed.

The Maia was breathing in short, sharp, pants. He reached out and squeezed Maeglin’s hand so tight that he suppressed a yelp. “Elves.” The string of unknown words that followed were grating and harsh. “Someone sang over it, didn’t they?”

“I guess so?” Maeglin was still trying to get it off the Maia’s skin without giving way to panic. Blisters had risen almost immediately where it touched.

“Stop that.”

“But…you…”

“This is good, actually. Listen. I need you to pack that stuff in everywhere the skin’s broken. Especially the deepest tears. I will scream, you will do it anyway.”

“No. That’s a terrible idea. It’ll only make it worse.”

The Maia rolled his eyes and slowed his speech as if he found Maeglin insufferably dim-witted. “I have spent all my strength, and I can’t fight back infection in my current state. Without something to help, it will keep getting worse until I die. If that happens, if I go crawling back after such a disaster without even a body, the punishment I fear will be as nothing beside the scorn and humiliation that would await me. So. Your Elvish stuff will hurt me, but it will also save me from what’s worse.”

Maeglin chewed his lip, considering.

“If you won’t help me, then give it here so I can do it myself.”

“No, I want to help, I won’t make you do that. I just… What will make this easier for you?”

“You are a scrawny little thing. If you could hold me down, though…” The hint of pleading in his gaze overcame Maeglin’s reluctance. Straddling the Maia’s waist, he took his outstretched wrists and pinned them above his head, carefully leaning a little weight on them. The Maia sighed and went limp.

“Better?” Maeglin whispered. The feel of his body beneath him was doing strange things to Maeglin, and he wasn’t sure he liked it.

At the Maia’s slight nod, Maeglin steeled himself and began to apply the medicine. The Maia’s wails were loud, but he did not struggle or try to throw him off as Maeglin feared. He only twitched a little and cried, as if Maeglin could actually render him helpless with a single hand. What that meant about his experiences Maeglin didn’t want to think. His slight twisting pushed him harder into Maeglin, and when he’d finished, he scrambled off his friend, hoping he was too distracted to notice Maeglin’s growing erection.

It’s just a physical reaction, he assured himself as he covered the Maia’s throat with clean bandages. But he wasn’t certain that was true. Part of him wanted to hold the Maia’s firm and slender body between his thighs again. I’m not interested in him like that. I love Idril. He shouldn’t be thinking how pretty the Maia was. Especially he shouldn’t be enjoying how pretty he was with tears filling his eyes and turning them to pools of gold; he should be horrified that his body could respond with arousal to someone in so much pain.

“Right, then. Willow bark.” The little reprieve of building up a fire and bringing water to boil was a welcome chance to collect himself. His stirrings were a strange fluke; he wouldn’t let a few stray thoughts make him act unworthily of his love.

*

The Maia kept turning and whining in his sleep, and the cool, damp cloth Maeglin draped over his burning forehead didn’t seem to ease him. “You need a real healer,” Maeglin muttered. “I could do so much more for you if you’d just let me.” He sighed. He couldn’t hide someone in the depths of his house forever. Turgon would hear of it, and he’d need to know everything, and Maeglin would be punished for keeping the presence of an outsider from him. He didn’t know how Turgon would react to the enemy brought directly before him. Would he execute the Maia without any chance of mercy? Without the Maia’s full cooperation, he couldn’t risk it. And the Maia had made his wishes very clear.

Maeglin pulled his cloak tighter around him and stirred up the little fire. It was getting darker and colder. Not far off, a howl sounded through the pine wood. Maeglin jumped and cursed. His bow was still tied to his saddle where he’d set it over a fallen log; he quickly fetched it and hoped the fire would be enough to discourage anything that hunted tonight.

“No, Master,” the Maia moaned. His eyes were closed, and he didn’t move when Maeglin took his hand. “I tried…please…”

Maeglin wasn’t sure if he should rouse him from his nightmares. The frantic begging sounded eerily like his own as a boy, whenever he’d proven a disappointment to his father, whether he’d gotten a lesson wrong or made an ill-timed jest or simply sounded too Noldorin. “Please—I tried—I’ll do better—please don’t—” His memories blurred with the Maia’s murmuring until he couldn’t take it anymore and laid his hand gently on the Maia’s cheek. He tensed, and Maeglin thought he might wake, but after a moment he nuzzled sleepily into Maeglin’s hand and settled into quieter dreams.

Resting beside him, Maeglin traced the curves of his face. Asleep like this, soft and relaxed, his plush lips barely parted, he looked innocent and far younger than his uncountable years. Maeglin had seen those lips curl in a sneer, but it was hard to imagine it now.

Again a howl echoed off the rocks, closer this time, and an answering howl sang back from the other direction. The Maia didn’t stir. Morincë was snorting and stamping her hoof. Maeglin went over to her and patted her neck. “Shh. It’s all right. Whatever they’re after, it’s probably not us.” Very reassuring, he told himself. Just what anyone wants to hear. Taking up his bow, he spent a long while choosing an arrow, rubbing his thumb along the smooth shaft and feeling a little silly. Naneth would say to be vigilant but not to fear. Most predators won’t mess with Elves, unless they’re Morgoth’s creatures. Or spiders. He wasn’t sure what chance he had of meeting wolves still free and wild.

He felt the glimmer of a presence, and when he snapped his face toward it, a pair of yellow eyes shone from the shadows. “Get away!” he shouted. The eyes disappeared, but a moment later they blinked at him again. He loosed an arrow and watched it pass straight through an eye without stopping. No satisfying thunk of shaft striking flesh. No flinch or faltering from the beast. But he knew he hadn’t missed. Grabbing another arrow, he let it fly, and another, but the eyes remained. A second pair joined them from across the little clearing. Maeglin stepped away from the fire and peered deep into the trees. The eyes were too many to count.

Fighting to keep his breath even, Maeglin stumbled back and struggled to think. The wolves were prowling closer; he could see silvery shapes slipping through the undergrowth. How many can there be?! He crouched and shook the Maia’s shoulder. “Hey. Wake up. Wake up, can’t you do something?!”

The Maia mumbled indistinctly and kept sleeping. He can’t help anyway; he’s exhausted and sick. There’s no one else but me. Naneth would have fought them off with sword and spear, but his arrows had left no mark, and even she might have despaired against so many. His father, though… In Nan Elmoth, as Eöl’s heir, Maeglin would have called on the trees, and they would have defended him. He didn’t know these trees, but maybe they would listen. Maybe they would take pity on one who had never raised iron to them, who knew the old forest songs. Songs he’d tried to forget.

The wolves were gathering at the edge of the firelight, taking his measure. There wasn’t time. Maeglin opened his mouth and sang. The first sound that came out was an awkward croak, but he cleared his throat and tried again. The notes grew stronger as he slid into the web of the forest. He sang of years of friendship; of nurturing roots and planting seeds; of hands against gigantic trunks; of sheltering branches overhead. He sang, his arms outstretched, until his fingers felt like twigs waving in the wind, until he stretched up toward the sky and down into the earth and found harmony with every trunk around him, their deep voices joining, singing of starlight and sweet waters and stirring sap. He turned his song to his request—I am a child of the forest. I have great need. Please keep me safe.

Roots rose and branches swayed, messages flitted through mushroom trails, and the forest answered. Yelps filled the night as the wolves fled, and Maeglin sank upon the loam whispering his gratitude.

Still the Maia slept.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 5

Read Chapter 5

Maeglin spent much of the day gathering firewood and wrapping the least bloody strips of old bandages around pine boughs to serve as torches. He hoped the wolves would be frightened enough not to return, but he couldn’t risk being unprepared. The trees had done him a great favor, but he was not of this wood, and there was no ancient pact binding him to it, and he could not expect them to protect him again. His miner’s lamp held less oil than he liked; the torches he soaked with it wouldn’t last long.

“Thuri? Thuri, are you there?” The Maia had kept mumbling in his sleep, but it sounded like he might at last be stirring.

“It’s just me,” Maeglin told him quietly. The Maia felt for Maeglin’s hand, and relaxed when he found it. “Your mountain friend.”

The Maia groaned and rubbed his eyes. “The forest sounds…restless. What—” He looked around, eyes widening as he took in the newly-dense line of pine trunks, jagged branches thrust into every empty space like a spear-wall. “What happened here?”

“I woke the trees. There was a pack of wolves—so many, I couldn’t think what else to do, I—”

The Maia was laughing, a chilling sound that started low and grew until he startled a flock of crows into flying off with loud complaining squawks. “Full of surprises, aren’t you? They aren’t a threat to you. Not really.”

“They certainly seemed interested and dangerous last night.”

“I should say, they can’t kill you. I suppose that’s not quite the same.”

Maeglin stared at him, unsure how else to impress upon him the seriousness of the situation.

“They’re all dead.” His laughter trailed away. “All of them. My wolves, my friends and my allies, my dear, clever Thuri…everyone I relied on and held closest…for what? All because I couldn’t handle an Elf and a dog.” He wiped tears from his cheeks. “Why are you helping me? You know enough of who I am.”

Maeglin wasn’t sure how to put words to the strange mix of feelings that welled up in him; he didn’t think he could explain to himself, much less to another all that the Maia had come to mean to him. He knew the Maia’s companionship had made him happy, and happiness was a rare prize not to be questioned too deeply. He knew their conversations made him feel curious and excited in a world that too often now seemed hopeless and dull. He knew the Maia’s golden eyes and laughing smirk lingered too much in his imagination, and that the pleasure he should be taking in his defeat was instead only a deep desire to comfort him. “You asked me to.”

“Hm.”

*

Evening came upon them sitting outside the little cave, the Maia bundled in a blanket, picking at a piece of bread. His throat was starting to look better, despite how Maeglin’s ointment had burned his skin, and Maeglin hoped that meant he was truly on the mend.

“They’re here,” the Maia murmured, nodding toward the edge of the trees. Spectral grey shapes slunk between the pines in the darkening twilight. He opened his arms and called to them, and though Maeglin tucked himself behind his friend, he didn’t retreat when the wolves came running up to them and nuzzled at the Maia’s hands and face.

“My babies,” the Maia whispered. “My darlings. You were so good, so loyal; you fought so hard, and I failed you…”

This close, Maeglin thought he could almost see through them, and in the firelight, they cast no shadow. Tentatively he held out a hand to the nearest wolf, and when it sniffed at him, appraising, and offered a little lick, he touched its head—or tried. He could tell something was there, but his hand passed through it with only a slight, cold drag.

“I told you they were dead,” the Maia said quietly.

“I didn’t understand.”

Tears glittered in the Maia’s eyes and streaked down his face. “They’re only spirits now. Strong spirits—strong enough to come looking for me—but you see,” he choked back a sob. “See how already they’re coming apart.”

Maeglin followed his gesture. Ragged lines showed along the wolves’ bodies where they seemed…thinner, beginning to separate like the pieces of a child’s toy where the stitching had worn loose. The Maia was pouring affection onto as many of them as he could reach at once, and beyond a glance or a nose pushed into his hands, they took little enough notice of Maeglin. He edged carefully forward.

As he watched, one wolf’s ear fell off, taking with it a chunk of fur, but instead of lying where it dropped, it morphed into a grinning wolf skull and winked out of existence, only to reappear perched in a tree, where it faded until only the smile full of teeth remained. Another wolf’s tail was drooping, and when it wagged too vigorously at the Maia’s touch, the seam gave way. One by one, shining like fireflies in the dusk, a flock of yellow eyes appeared above it and drifted along the forest floor, weeping blood tears as they fluttered together.

Maeglin stared, lost in the strangeness of it, but the Maia did not seem alarmed, only sad. “What’s happening to them?” he finally whispered. “Why would a spirit lose…pieces of itself?”

“They aren’t single spirits,” the Maia answered. “They are not wolves, but werewolves, forged at my own hands, and they are parts of many, pulled apart and rewoven to make them more powerful than any would have been on its own.”

“Parts of…?” Maeglin wasn’t sure he really wanted to know, and he felt sure he was about to hear “proprietary secrets” once more.

“The wolf, body and spirit, is the base,” the Maia explained, wiping his eyes. His teary voice grew steadier as he spoke. “Then pieces of other féar are combined with it—the mathematics involved is a bit complicated, but it’s a simple enough trick in practice. See, this one has a little of a Mannish spirit, just the part that governs speech. You can tell if you can hear its Song; human féar are distinctive…” He trailed off when he caught Maeglin’s horrified expression.

“And—what of the rest of it? That was…a person, and now…can it find Mandos like that? What…what’s left when you’ve pulled it to bits?”

“I…use most of it. There’s not much left when I’m done. I don’t think it’s anything you’d call a person anymore.”

“You’re telling me,” Maeglin pointed to the grinning teeth in the tree that had added a lolling tongue to themselves, “that whatever that is used to be a person, and that’s all that’s left. Forever. And you see nothing wrong with that?”

“That hound killed them. All of my dears. Else that would be part of a magnificent werewolf even now. That’s what’s wrong.” The Maia seemed half confused and half angry. “We all belong to one Master. If he wants me to use what’s his to make something better, I’m going to do it. And I’m going to excel. These were excellent creatures, and anyone should be proud to become part of such.”

“Would you be proud if it were you being torn apart?”

“I’m of much more use to him elsewhere. And I keep it that way.” He studied Maeglin. “It’s really very clever math.”

*

The night passed restlessly. Maeglin lay beside the Maia, wondering what it meant about him that he still felt so much desire to be close. His mind couldn’t reconcile caring for someone with the kind of deeds he’d related; the whole evening seemed unreal. Of course he knew the Maia served Morgoth; that meant he must be capable of all sorts of horrible things. But Maeglin couldn’t stop seeing the honest love and sorrow he’d shown for his werewolves, and he remembered his weariness when he’d spoken of his master on the mountaintop, and he thought again of what Nengil had said, of the offer of safe harbor. The Maia needed a way out if he were ever to take one. Maybe as much as his mother had.

Maeglin wished he had more time—time to consider, to gather his courage, to ask himself if he should be here at all. But as the few precious days he could spend with the Maia passed, the words kept burning in the back of his throat, and the more he tried to talk himself out of saying it, the more he thought he should at least give his friend the choice. The knowledge the choice was available to him.

Maeglin waited until he and the Maia were settled together by the fire, supper eaten and the Maia’s healing wounds freshly tended. “If you wanted…you could come home with me.”

The Maia laughed, a sharp but not unfriendly sound. “I wondered when you’d get around to asking. Forget that. Come with me to Angband.”

That name in its naked surety settled like a stone in the pit of Maeglin’s stomach. “As what? Your slave? Your pet?”

“As my honored and treasured servant. Would that be so bad a thing? Little smith, you have never been happy a day in your life.”

Maeglin started to protest, but the Maia shook his head. “No. I’ve heard enough to know it. Your childhood was tainted by misery and fear, and wherever home is to you now, it constantly makes you feel like you’re drowning. Tell me it isn’t so.”

“What makes you think I would ever turn against the people I care about?! Everything I did at your side would be to their harm!”

“Has it not occurred to you that’s exactly what you just asked of me?” A flash of irritation crossed his face.

“It’s not the same. Not when you were weeping for fear of your master.”

The Maia scoffed. “No. I serve the rightful ruler of all the world. It’s not the same, and that you think fear is something to be avoided simply shows the paucity of your existence.”

Maeglin turned his face away and hugged his knees to chest. He didn’t want to hear that from the Maia’s lips, and he didn’t know how to answer such a thought.

“You have a brilliant and curious mind. I could give you so much—I could teach you so much, and I have no doubt you’d have much of worth to share. This is an invitation I do not normally extend. You’d command others beneath me; I am not asking you to take a place lower than your due.”

“You could teach me among my people.”

“Do you not understand how utterly reviled I would be? It isn’t remotely tenable, and I wish you’d give it up.”

“I don’t even know your name,” Maeglin offered. “You could give yourself a new one. Be someone new. Imagine what we could do together, in a place where your beloved creations wouldn’t have to die for you.” That was perhaps the wrong thing to say, he thought as a faraway look came over the Maia. But the snarl he half-expected didn’t follow. “It would hardly matter what anyone else thought,” he continued. “We’d have each other.”

The Maia slowly smiled and leaned closer. “That would be true if you came with me as well.” He raised his fingers to Maeglin’s face and tucked a strand of loose hair behind his ear. His touch lingered, and Maeglin found himself wanting to push into it. “Is that what this is about, little smith? I’ve seen how you glance at me. I promise you’d get plenty of my attention.”

“I—what?” His cheeks were burning, whether at the implication or the Maia’s nearness, he wasn't sure.

“It’s only natural to be attracted to me. And—look, I wouldn’t have kept coming back if you didn’t intrigue me. I can see how fairly you’d keep growing, in craft and in skill and in my favor.”

“You’re just saying that. You’re trying to lure me into giving you what you want.”

“No, this is the part where everything goes on the table. What you want is to be wanted, and what I want is you.” The Maia’s eyes almost glowed as he said it.

Maeglin ran the tip of his tongue over his lips. “That isn’t...I just want you to be happy and safe.” The Maia’s declaration was making him warm and fluttery inside, and some part of his mind noted that could be dangerous.

“That’s really why you saved me, isn’t it?” the Maia purred. “Because you care for me.”

“I…I always help my friends…”

The Maia’s hand rested against his cheek, silken and powerful. Maeglin’s heartbeat pounded in his ears. He thought perhaps he should push his friend away, but he couldn’t summon the will to actually do it. The Maia filled his senses—his plush lips; his elegant nose; the spicy, smoky musk that clung to his hair. The intense, golden depths of the eyes staring back at him as if they looked upon something precious, too. Helplessly, like a moth drawn to a flame, Maeglin leaned forward, and their lips met, softly at first, but the Maia answered his hesitant kiss with fierceness and passion, and Maeglin was wholly overwhelmed.

He wanted to be closer, he wanted it to never end—this hungry exploration of mouths and tongues. The Maia bit down on his lip, and the bright, sharp pain felt exciting, and he wanted more; he wanted the Maia’s skin against his; he wanted to crawl inside him, and when his hand came up and tangled in the Maia’s hair and he returned the bite, taking soft flesh between his teeth and squeezing more than could possibly be right, until he knew it must hurt, the Maia moaned, and Maeglin thought he might explode from joy. He couldn’t remember ever feeling his cock so hard without a touch, and at the same time he was content to let it throb and ache; their kiss mattered so much more.

The Maia’s mind was resting against his, deep and shrouded like a labyrinth, and though Maeglin shielded his secrets and felt the Maia do the same, the verge where they met was warm and sweet and welcoming, with threads of desire and arousal spun around them, singing with pure want, and Maeglin could hardly tell what was his own and what was the Maia anymore. This was better than the meeting of their mouths, and he began to press deeper, but the Maia stilled him.

“Careful, little smith, unless it’s your wish to be wed so soon.” He was smiling; his hands had not ceased to hold Maeglin close. Their foreheads were together, and Maeglin found himself crying as he pulled away.

What am I doing? This isn’t what I want. He summoned a memory of Idril and focused on her, mourning as the feelings faded. He felt dirty. “I won’t go with you,” he told the Maia, and he fled.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 6

Read Chapter 6

“Salgant! Salgant!!” Maeglin banged on his door. Chances were good he wasn’t home, or even that he’d retired for an early night’s rest. The door swung open, and Salgant inspected him with concern.

“Maeglin. Is something wrong? You look like you’ve come straight from the hills.”

“I’m fine, I just…can I ask you something?”

“Of course, of course, come in!” He wrapped Maeglin in a warm hug as he pulled him inside. “I was packing my harp to head over to Idril’s little party, but I can go later; I always have time for you.”

“Idril…is having a party tonight?” His stomach twisted. He wasn’t even sure what he felt, except that it was uncomfortable.

“Oh, just a little poetry and music under the autumn moon. Not the sort of thing you tend to enjoy.”

He was right; Maeglin made himself appear at the most important of Gondolin’s gatherings, long enough to say a few words to the various people whose favor he needed to maintain, but he always slipped away as soon as he reasonably could. It was exhausting, trying to hold a vague smile on his face and come up with something appropriately friendly for person after person, and he never stayed longer than he had to. But for Idril… “Maybe I’m in a mood for poetry.”

Salgant eyed him dubiously. “Let’s get you something to take the chill off, and you can tell me what’s on your mind.”

Maeglin’s hands wanted to fidget with the hem of his tunic, to tap his thigh, anything to be in motion, but he arranged them elegant and still in his lap as his father had taught him. He must not let his princely appearance falter, not even here, however anxious and impatient he felt. Salgant called for hot water and a plate of cakes, and when his servant had set them out on the low parlor table, he measured out tea leaves and swirled the water over them with care and precision. Maeglin held his tongue. Salgant would have his little rituals; he only wished he could find the same calm in them. When he was finally presented with a cup and had taken three sips of the pale green liquid, barely registering the taste, he decided it was enough.

“What does it mean to have feelings for someone if you’re already in love with someone else? I thought that wasn’t the way of the Eldar. I thought we were meant to love only once, or at least a second time very rarely and only when the first is gone from the world. How do you know which one is real?!”

Salgant pushed the plate of cakes toward him. “Have you eaten today? I find these strong emotions can be much easier to deal with when you aren’t approaching them on an empty stomach.”

Maeglin started to answer crossly that it didn’t matter, but he realized he hadn’t. Not since that morning, before the Maia’s laughing demands and that kiss that still made his body tingle at the thought. He scowled and took a cake, a round confection of pumpkin and crystallized mountain ginger.

“I must ask, how much of your education on these matters comes solely from the Laws and Customs and from the romance novels you used to sneak from my library?”

Maeglin’s ear tips went red. He’d hoped that his friend simply hadn’t noticed his borrowings. “My mother had spoken to me of some things,” he mumbled.

“But you were still so young,” Salgant finished gently. “It’s nothing to be ashamed of, Maeglin.”

The corner ornaments carved into the stone ceiling had suddenly become very interesting. Maeglin kept his eyes trained upon them and raised his tea to his lips to hide the way his mouth quivered.

“It’s true that most of our people wed but once, and that many lie only with their spouse after their marriage. But attraction is not always so narrow and straightforward a thing. You have, I am sure, seen how many people have graced Lord Glorfindel’s arm over the years you’ve lived among us.”

“Sure, but he’s never pretended to be in love with them all; it’s just for enjoyment in the moment. I can understand that even if I don’t want to do it myself. He hasn’t found the right one to love yet.”

“Well. It’s not unusual to have a few youthful romances before finding the right person. And furthermore—despite what the loremasters would have you think, different people experience love differently. Some might never feel romantic love at all and never miss it. Some love deeply and immediately and never look at another, and they’re the ones we singers tend to dwell on. Not perhaps for the best.”

That’s me, thought Maeglin. I’ve always known that’s me. So why am I falling apart?

“But others take a long time to see their feelings develop. It can be a slow and gentle weaving of lives together; it isn’t all wild passion. Love is about the connection between two people. Feeling at home with each other. And truly, just as some people might find many others attractive, so too is it possible to have even that deep, spousal love several times over the course of a life. For some, at any rate. Back home, the Teleri, for instance, tended to be much more open to the idea. As are your father’s people, if I am not mistaken.”

“I wouldn’t know anything about that,” Maeglin said, as if the mention befouled his tongue. “He was far more concerned about keeping me from Naneth’s people than letting me meet his own. If any of them were even left.” For all that the royal family of Doriath were his kin, Eöl had never counted himself among the Sindarin. Maeglin wasn’t sure what names to ask about if he ever did want to learn more.

“There’s your great-grandfather Finwë, on your mother’s side.”

“Yes. The single example everyone knows, so rare the gods themselves had to make a special ruling for him.”

“I myself—well. Let us say there was a certain young man in Tirion with whom I spent many pleasant hours before I met—them.” Salgant’s voice wavered, and Maeglin felt a rush of regret for bringing up the subject at all. Salgant almost never spoke of his spouse. What Maeglin knew, he’d heard elsewhere—that Elehisë had crossed the Ice at Salgant’s side; that they had fallen in one of the first battles under the newly-risen moon. “We remained close; he even joined us both in bed a few times before…everything,” Salgant continued, trying to sound cheerful but only partially succeeding. “So you see, Finwë is certainly not the lone exception to tradition.”

Maeglin hesitated, not sure how to phrase his question without sounding hurtful. He wasn’t Finwë, and he didn’t need all those juvenile attempts when he’d devoted himself to Idril from almost the day he met her. “But still…you knew which you wanted to marry, right?”

Salgant looked like he wanted to say more, but he merely nodded. “Eventually.”

“There! That’s the part I need! How do you tell when it’s real love, and what do you do when it’s just…just feelings trying to pull you away?!”

“Maeglin…”

“What if it’s all some sorcery? I’ve never looked at anyone else. Not until him. I just don’t understand…I was certain, and now…now I don’t know what to think, or…what it means about who I am...”

Salgant took his hand and squeezed it gently. “I think it could be good for you to have some new experiences. To see what it is to care for someone and be cared for in return. This is the new friend you’ve been enjoying so much?”

“Yes. But he doesn’t want—he won’t—I mean…it’s never going to work out with him anyway.” He sighed. “I’m sorry. I’m wasting your evening.”

“You could never waste what I’m happy to give.” Salgant poured more tea, looking thoughtful. “To answer your question, it takes time. Time to get to know someone, to learn how you fit together.” He hesitated, and when he spoke again, it was with a soft, sad smile. “Elehisë used to say ‘Love should make you feel like more of yourself, not less.’”

Maeglin nodded sagely and refrained from rolling his eyes. No one wanted him to be more of himself. Salgant didn’t understand; he was likeable and friendly by nature, so he could afford to sit back and allow things to develop on their own. Maybe he was right though, about only truly knowing through being closer. Maeglin had hung back and longed in solitude all this time, hoping for any hint of encouragement, and it had gotten him nowhere. He said something appreciative and noncommittal to Salgant and nibbled at the array of sweets while Salgant talked of news in the city, until he judged enough time had passed.

“I shouldn’t keep you from that party any longer.” He widened his eyes, as if he’d only just thought of something. “I don’t suppose I could tag along? I think I could really use some company and cheer tonight.”

Salgant sighed, but his smile was fond. “I might believe that, from anyone else. You should go home and get some rest. Your head will feel clearer in the morning.”

“Please? I promise I won’t be a bother.”

“Maeglin, it’s not that. I just don’t think it’s a good idea. It isn’t going to make you feel any better.”

“Don’t I deserve to decide that for myself?”

“I—of course you do. Only—well…if you’re sure. We’ll have to get you into some decent clothes, though, and you know anything of mine would swallow you whole.”

*

Maeglin stepped out of a jasmine-scented bath just as Salgant’s messenger arrived back with the formal robes he’d sent for, black silk richly embroidered with silver. His housekeeper had chosen some jewels to go with them, and when he opened the bag they were in, the pyrite ammonite was neatly wrapped on top. Maeglin paused, wondering what twist of chance had brought it here, but he slipped it on all the same, remembering the pleased gleam in the Maia’s eyes when he’d worn it the first time. Something about it—the possibility of being desired, perhaps—made him feel bold.

The walk to the palace gardens passed in a blink. Maeglin wasn’t sure he had his words together, but it would have to do. Salgant was welcomed with broad smiles, while Maeglin got only puzzled, sidelong glances as he helped Salgant find a spot for his harp, but he didn’t care. He was at Idril’s party, and that was all he’d asked.

The golden center of the gathering was not hard to find. Maeglin timed his approach carefully, his fingers on the ammonite for courage. It would be rude to ignore his hostess too long without greeting, and rude to slink around, waiting and watching at the edges for her to notice him, but it would be equally rude to push himself in and interrupt the middle of someone’s story. It often felt like an impossible feat to get right, but somehow tonight everything fell naturally into place. As if it were fated.

Idril turned toward him as Maeglin approached and bowed. “Good evening to you, cousin. What a pleasant surprise to see you here.”

“And to you, my lady. It’s a lovely gathering you’ve put together.” You make it lovely. Was that too much? Maybe not. He had to speak if he wanted her to hear. “Lovelier still for having you at its heart.” There. He could perfect himself yet and be elegant for her.

Her smile was oddly twisted. “Thank you. I do hope you’ll enjoy yourself.”

“I was hoping to ask you something, actually.” The words flowed in a rush, before he could lose his moment in her attention.

“And what’s that?”

“I was hoping…we might see more of each other. In the coming days.”

“We’ll see each other at the council meeting next week. I’m sure you’ll be quite tired of me by the end!”

“I could never be tired of you,” he protested. He seemed to be gathering more eyes on him than were warranted or welcome. “I meant more just the two of us. Perhaps…perhaps you would favor me with lunch together?” He thought he heard snickering, but it was probably his imagination.

“I’m afraid my schedule’s quite full."

“Tea, then? It doesn’t have to be long. I know how it is to be so busy…” He trailed off as she stepped ominously closer and lowered her voice.

“Maeglin. I am trying to save you face. You are not helping, so I must speak plainly. I do not want to spend time with you. I am not your Melian to be stared at. I do not want your courtship. Is that clear enough for you?”

Mutely Maeglin nodded. Everything seemed frozen around him, as if trapped in a nightmare he could not wake from.

“Good. Enjoy the party. Cousin.” She walked away.

Those were definitely snickers he heard now. Even some outright laughter. Maeglin wanted to disappear, to never have been here at all. Failing that, he wanted to run away and hide. He wasn’t sure his body would obey him. His face burned, and a pit seemed to have opened in his stomach. Idril’s words kept repeating themselves in his head. Don’t just stand there! he silently shouted at himself. Don’t stand there, please… Out of the corner of his eye, he saw Pengolodh and Duilin whispering and smirking, and that was enough to set him in motion. He turned on his heel and strode towards the gate, holding his tears back and his head high.

Duilin caught up to him before he could escape. “Did the little mole prince think he’d catch a bright butterfly?” he murmured. “Better stick to your worms and dirt!”

Maeglin tried to snarl something back at him, but no sound would pass his lips. Duilin laughed again and let him go.

"Half-orc scum," he heard trailing behind him, but whether it was aloud or only Duilin's very loud thoughts, he could not tell.

Intent on getting as far away as he could, Maeglin did not stop until his faithful, weary horse had borne him out of Gondolin and into the silent mountains. Sunrise shone upon his tear-streaked face as he climbed the familiar rocks, but when he came to the camp where he’d spent the last few days, it was as if it had never existed. No sign could be seen of the fire; someone had scattered the ashes far away and dismantled the stone hearth where Maeglin had cooked and heated water. The overhang where he’d slept holding his friend in his arms was there, so he had not mistaken the place. He walked closer. Under the rock ledge, his cloak and his blanket were folded in perfect crisp squares, one stacked atop the other. Nothing else remained. The Maia had gone.

Years passed, lonely loveless years that felt emptier as each summer departed. Maeglin went less and less to their old meeting spot, though sometimes he’d get a strangely hopeful feeling in the dark of night and ride out the next day. The Maia was never there. Then tidings of war came, even unto Gondolin, and word was spoken of the Union of Maedhros and hope for Beleriand and Morgoth’s end. Maeglin insisted on leading his House at his uncle’s side. They fought for Fingon the High King, and Maeglin learned what it was to kill and to watch his followers cruelly cut down before him. He saw the true horrors of Angband unleashed upon the field, and watched Húrin and Húor, whom he still remembered as obnoxiously eager-to-please boys, lay down their lives for Gondolin’s retreat. When he came home he begged Turgon’s leave to build a seventh gate, the strongest of them all, and for a time he no longer ventured beyond Turgon’s bounds. If the Maia could willingly serve that, he was dead to him.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 7

Read Chapter 7

Maeglin took out his ammonite pendant and sat staring at it, watching the candlelight flicker on the pyrite crystals. He rarely wore it anymore; after the Nirnaeth it had felt like sacrilege to remember the Maia fondly. But he couldn't help still finding comfort in those windswept days in the mountains, in the nights when he’d tended the Maia’s hurts and held him close. In great need, he even allowed himself to think on the Maia’s kiss. Perhaps it was perverse. Perhaps the Gondolindrim spoke truly who said he had grown twisted in the dark of Nan Elmoth, that he was incapable of loving aright. But memories were all he had, all he would ever have, and he was desperate for comfort tonight.

He wished his feelings for Idril could be relegated to wistful memories as easily. It still hurt, like a poisoned knife twisting deep in his gut, every time he saw her smile so happily at Tuor or swing little Eärendil around while her son laughed for joy. He was never going to have that. He didn’t know how to accept that his bed would forever be empty and cold, that no one would sit with him over breakfast and make plans for the day, or nestle against him and share soft kisses by the fire at night. There would never be a child with his dark eyes and shining hair to tell stories and teach his craft to. His life would continue as bitterly as it had begun, and he wasn’t sure he saw the point of it anymore.

At least Eärendil had been excited about his little coat of mail. Maeglin had fashioned it of mithril for his seventh begetting day, making it large enough to fit him for several years to come. He’d insisted on putting it on immediately and had worn it for the rest of the day, until he’d been found curled up in the sofa pillows fast asleep and covered in cake.

Maeglin clutched the ammonite tighter. It had to be enough. He had a beautiful nephew who’d grinned broadly at him and given him a delighted hug that very day. His House relied upon him. Turgon listened to him more and more on matters of state, and he knew he should be proud of that. He sighed. It didn’t ease his loneliness. He’d spent all afternoon at his cousin’s celebration with her family, and every moment he had sharply felt how much of an outsider he was, peering in but never really a part of things.

Flopping back onto his bed, Maeglin closed his eyes and tried to remember what it was like to feel wanted. Not tolerated because of his status, not kept close as a relic of someone else who no longer lived, but wanted—desired, even—simply because his presence was enjoyed. He thought of golden eyes and blazing red hair, of a smirking laugh, of a silken voice whispering, “I would give you so much. Come with me, let me adore you.” He could almost envision being wrapped in that wolfish regard, that hunger that had spilled through their kiss and into his soul.

You know what was done to the Nargothrond prisoner, Maeglin reprimanded himself. He shouldn’t want that wicked Umaia, no more than he should want his very-happily-married cousin. You heard the captain who saw Gelmir mutilated on the field break down in hysterics giving his report. You watched brave men and women die.

But the Maia was long gone, and no danger could come of memories. Distracting himself with harmless fantasies had to be better than letting some stray thought slip through around Idril. He hated making her uncomfortable, and if he kept dwelling on her like he had been, it was bound to happen. Maybe I’ll visit our old meeting place again. Getting some distance and fresh air might help. With that hopeful idea, he finally managed to sleep.

*

Morincë was nearing her retirement, a venerable old mare with more grey in her mane than black, but it was she Maeglin chose to bear him once more into the mountains in search of solace. She knew the mountain pathways like no other, and her surefootedness had not waned. As they passed through the old mine shaft and emerged into the sunshine on the other side, Maeglin’s heart lightened. The air smelled of pine, and it filled him with sweet thoughts of long afternoons of forge-talk.

Anguirel bumped against his thigh as he remounted and nudged Morincë to head up the trail. The boy who could countenance riding out alone unarmed was no more, and perhaps that was for the best. He’d been so woefully naïve and willing to extend his trust, and it would have taken so little for the Maia to overwhelm him. But the Maia never had.

The woods were lightless and colder than seemed right, and as they passed through, he heard whispers of strange, garbled voices on the wind. Maeglin shivered. Reining in Morincë, he listened, still and silent. Again the sound came, an uncanny howl that wavered and split, becoming three tones, sixteen, then a single bare whimper. He considered simply turning back, but he didn’t want to lose the only little indulgence he’d given himself in years, and besides, they hadn’t hurt him before. “Hey there.” Maeglin spoke softly, comfortingly, as his mother had to her dogs. “Do you remember me? I’m your master’s friend. Don’t be afraid.”

A nose pressed itself into his hand, and when he glanced down and saw neither head nor body attached to it, he managed not to flinch. “Good wolf. That’s very good.” Somewhere he heard the sound of a thumping tail, but though he looked around, he couldn’t find it. “Very good wolves,” he said a little louder. “You’ll let us pass, won’t you?”

A little yip bounced among the trees, and Maeglin took that for agreement. He rode on, though he could hear them gamboling around Morincë’s hooves, and sometimes he felt one brush against him. He could see sunlight and the rocky slopes beyond when he remembered the food he’d stuck in his saddlebag in case of need.

“Would you like a treat?” he asked. “Can you eat something?” No answer was forthcoming, but he pulled out some strips of jerky and tossed them behind him. Morincë’s ears flicked back. A swarm of maggots had appeared from nowhere, and within moments the jerky was gone. Maeglin winced and looked away. “Thank you,” he called to whatever was listening.

Stepping out into the sun’s warmth was most welcome. Maeglin took a deep breath and let it out in a loud, relieved sigh. He wouldn’t have guessed the Maia’s wolves could still be found haunting the wood, but he thought he felt more sorrow for them than fear. It wasn’t their fault what they’d become.

The ground beneath Morincë’s hooves went from pine needles and loam to bare rock in short measure. Maeglin kept a careful eye out for loose scree that might prove too slippery for her. Not far off he saw the boulders where he’d often left her to climb farther up on foot. She snorted and tossed her head, prancing sideways. Maeglin patted her neck. “Feels a bit scary to walk on, doesn’t it? Just a little more, and then you can rest.”

He swung down, landing lightly despite his sword, and pulled the reins over her head to lead her. Morincë planted her feet and refused to move. “Come on, sweetheart, it’s all right.” At his insistent tug, she took a little step back.

“You didn’t mind all those ghosts of fallen-apart wolves, but a bit of rock is too much?” This stubbornness was unlike her. Maeglin glanced around, suddenly worried, but he was too late.

Orcs swarmed over the mountainside, coming from nowhere and everywhere around him all at once. He barely had time to draw his sword before he was lain flat on the ground, with many heavy bodies holding him prone.

“Remember, boys, the Lieutenant said not to put a mark on him.” Maeglin couldn’t see the speaker; his face was shoved into the dirt. Good luck with that, he thought. Blood was filling his mouth from a split lip, and he was sure he’d be covered with bruises. “Get him bound and loaded up. Be extra careful of his hands; if they’re damaged, the Lieutenant will have your head.”

Maeglin heard several grumbles of “Yes, boss” as his arms were jerked behind him and he was hauled to his knees. He tried to twist out of their hands, to do anything to fight back, but it was no use. They were stronger than him, and their fingers bit cruelly into his arms. One shoved a thick, dirt-covered thumb into his mouth and forced it open. A foul-tasting, bitter liquid was poured into his mouth, with his head tilted back so he had to swallow or choke. It burned going down. He vaguely registered being tossed over an animal’s back like a sack of flour, and then everything went black.

The trip was a long haze of pain, constant jostling, and darkness. Whenever he swam up to consciousness, his head pounding, every step of the warg beneath him sending daggers through his temples, the orcs drew him up and forced more of the vile liquid down his throat. It went on without end. All sense of time was destroyed, and when Maeglin finally awoke, bleary-eyed and dry-mouthed in a dark little room, he didn’t know if it had been days or weeks.

Carefully he took stock of his body. He was tied to a chair, and though he ached all over, he couldn’t find any real injuries. His head hurt fiercely, and he thought he might throw up, except he felt certain there were no fluids left anywhere in him to lose. He wondered what had become of Morincë. Most likely she'd been fed to the pack of wargs the orcs used as mounts. She'd deserved better; she deserved soft green pastures and having her mane braided with flowers, and he wished he'd never taken her for that last ride. Outside the door, he heard voices. Fear tightened his chest and set his heart racing.

“…just as you ordered, m’lord…lost a man in that horrid wood…whatever’s moved in there, it isn’t…”

“Thank you, captain, I’ll see that your men are rewarded for their hard work.”

The door swung open, and Maeglin stared up into the familiar golden eyes of his Maia. He could still see in them the traces of warmth and comfort he remembered, and somehow that horrified him more than anything. The part of his mind that wasn’t busy spitting curses took in the iron circlet adorning his brow and the elegant gold band that enclosed his throat. He was dressed in finely embroidered robes and carried himself with his old easy grace, but Maeglin thought he looked weary. A fading bruise purpled his cheek.

“Hello, little smith. Welcome to Angband.”

“You—” Maeglin croaked. He coughed and swallowed hard, wondering what would happen were he to ask for water. “You betrayed me.”

“Don’t think of it as betrayal,” the Maia answered airily. “I don’t. Everything in this world belongs by right to my Master. I’ve simply collected what is his.”

“You owe me your life,” Maeglin hissed.

“Yes. But as it is already owned by another, I’m afraid I cannot answer your claim.”

“Please. Please just let me go. For the sake of our friendship, if you ever truly cared for me.”

“Now, now, it’s a bit early for that, isn’t it? You only just got here, and it took a great deal of trouble to fetch you. I’ve had patrols waiting to extend my invitation for months. I was afraid you’d stopped visiting our favorite spots altogether.”

I’m sorry, uncle, Maeglin whispered in the depths of his heart. If I somehow escape this place, I will fall on my knees and beg your forgiveness for ever doubting you. “What do you want?”

“I’ve told you before what I want; that hasn’t changed. I want you in my service. I want your clever mind and to enjoy your companionship. But of course, that isn’t the main reason I invited you here.”

Maeglin really wished he’d stop saying that, as if he could erase the brutality of kidnapping and drugging him with mere words.

“No, the main reason is that I believe you have some information that is very important to my lord. I hope, for the sake of our friendship, you might choose to simply share it with me, thereby winning yourself great reward and me great honor. That would be far preferable to the alternative. I truly am fond of you, and I would hate for things between us to get…uncomfortable.”

Maeglin stared. His head was too foggy to sort through everything that was wrong with the Maia’s words, but he understood what was being threatened. How had he ever thought that little bright era in his life had been anything but a mirage? There was a knock at the door, and two orcs entered, carrying a small table with several rolls on it that wouldn’t have looked out of place in Maeglin’s forge. They clinked with every movement.

“Brought everything you commanded, m’lord.”

“Very good. Leave it there.”

They bowed and scurried away.

“So you are a lord in this place,” Maeglin said. His voice shook only a little.

“I am Lieutenant, in fact. My king’s right hand. You may call me Mairon. I won’t even require my title.” He began unrolling and laying out his tools, and Maeglin couldn’t suppress the desperate whimper that rose in his throat. He’d heard Mairon spoken of before, though his own people named him Sauron.

I’m going to die here, Maeglin realized. He knew it with crystal clarity, though none of this yet felt real. I will die here, alone and in terrible pain, and no one will know where I’ve gone. A quieter voice in the depths of his mind asked if anyone would actually care.

“I’d like to get this out of the way quickly, so you can get settled in and start acclimating to your new and better life with me. I’m eager to show you my workshops. But business must come first. So! Let’s talk about Gondolin.” Mairon’s smile, so like the ones Maeglin had dreamed of, sent chills down his spine.

Maeglin lifted his head. “No.”


Leave a Comment

Chapter 8

Read Chapter 8

Maeglin couldn’t stop crying, ragged, choking, panicked sobs that tore through his parched throat. He was bleeding from scores of tiny cuts, and every nerve in his body was screaming. It had gone on for what felt like hours of nightmarish intimacy as Mairon worked his way over every inch of his flesh with his collection of delicate blades and implements that lit deep pain wherever they passed. Maeglin had lost his capacity to speak long before the end; even if he’d wanted to betray his home, he couldn’t have done it then. Now he lay on a thin pallet in a different, equally dark and comfortless cell where Mairon had deposited him. Exhaustion and pain wore heavily upon him, and though he thought his fearful, jerky breathing would deny him rest, he sank at last into an uneasy sleep.

The Maia was sitting on the floor beside him watching when he woke. Maeglin shrank away until his back touched the wall and he hissed in pain.

“I’m sorry about that,” Mairon said softly. “I would have liked to give you more time to think it over, but I couldn’t afford to look too gentle. It might get you taken from me.”

Maeglin blinked up at him incredulously.

“I did warn you. You shouldn’t have made it necessary.”

“Give me water.” His throat hurt with the effort of speaking.

Mairon considered. “All right. But don’t get used to it. If you don’t decide to comply, you won’t be getting it often.”

Maeglin said no more, and after a moment Mairon rose and stepped outside. He returned with a cup in his hand, and he put an arm under Maeglin to help him sit and held the water to his lips. He wouldn’t let Maeglin gulp it down all at once the way he wanted, but made him take it in slow sips. This close, he could see the soft glow of the Maia’s eyes. When he emptied the cup, Mairon filled it again, and by the end of the second one, Maeglin was beginning to feel slightly less terrible.

“I loved you.” He didn’t think he could lie to himself here. Mairon held him and didn’t answer. “I loved you, and I saved your life.”

“And I’m very grateful for what you did for me.” Mairon sounded like he had on the mountainside. Sincere. Caring. Maeglin resolved not to be fooled by him. He couldn’t afford to trust him ever again. “But I can’t let my attachments get in the way of serving my lord. You have to understand that.” He moved back, careful not to jostle Maeglin’s aching body. “I would like nothing better than to shower you in favor and be your dear friend once more. But I can’t do that until you tell me what you know.”

“But I don’t know anything. I’ve never heard of that place—what did you call it?” His voice wavered annoyingly. It didn’t sound convincing, even to him.

Mairon laughed gently. “Oh no. You’ve already confirmed you’re who I need. People who really don’t know anything tend to start screaming that right away. They don’t summon up that beautiful defiance.”

Maeglin winced. He’d fucked up already, without even noticing.

“But truthfully…where else could you have come from? We’d driven the last bandits from Taur-nu-Fuin some years before.” He reached for Maeglin’s hands and clasped them soothingly, and Maeglin realized they were the only parts of him that didn’t hurt. “It’ll be all right,” Mairon continued. “I’m sure there must be a few people there you care about and don’t want to see harmed, but it will only be worse for them the longer this war is dragged out. Let me bring them under their rightful king, and you could reign as their prince, answering to me. You can help them. It doesn’t have to be the end of everything you know. It will be painful at first, but the world is going to be better for it.”

Maeglin shook his head. “What makes you think I would ever be willing to serve you after this?”

Mairon laid a warm hand on his cheek, and Maeglin found himself leaning into the touch. He shuddered, but didn’t pull away. “Love can survive a little pain. We’ll look back on this time and laugh someday. You’ll ask why you ever refused me.”

“I’m not going to help you destroy my home.”

“You realize I can’t allow you to say no.” The Maia’s voice turned cold and bitter, but Maeglin caught a frantic note that he tried to hide.

You’re afraid, he thought.

“I will have to change your mind, and you won’t enjoy it.”

Very carefully, Maeglin traced the edge of the bruise on Mairon’s face. “Did he hit you?”

Mairon jerked back. He couldn’t fully suppress his pained gasp at the sharp motion. “It’s none of your business.” He flexed his hand, tucked it behind him, then gave in and raised it to adjust the golden band around his neck.

A clarity Maeglin had rarely known was settling upon him, as if every step in an impenetrable dance were unfolding itself in sequence, and he had only to follow. He pressed closer. “I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to startle you. Is that hurting you?” He slipped a protective arm around the Maia and leaned in to inspect the gold. His breath froze. Inside the finely-wrought jewelry, sharp golden spikes pierced the Maia’s skin. Mairon had packed a strip of gauze underneath, where it couldn’t be seen, and it was crusted with his blood.

Mairon had stiffened against him, but he slowly relaxed and let himself be held. “Love can survive a little pain.” He murmured it like a well-worn litany, as though it was some kind of explanation.

“Why—what is that?!”

“My punishment.” Mairon seemed to grow in confidence as he spoke. “And one that was just. I lost my lord a Silmaril through my failures. I needed something to keep my attention on him and my duties, and away from…distractions. When I lay Gondolin at his feet, he will take it off.” He twisted out of Maeglin’s embrace and stared at him with gleaming, predatory eyes. “So you see, there is little I will quail from to obey him.”

“People who love you aren’t supposed to hurt you.” Maeglin was quiet but firm. “Not like that.”

“We’re here to discuss you and the secrets you’re going to tell me.”

“It doesn’t get better again, after he starts hitting you.”

“Have you ever seen what a whip can do to a person’s back?”

“You don’t deserve to be hurt like this.”

“Think about just how much pain you’re willing to bear for people who don’t care about you,” Mairon spat as he stood. “Think about it very hard before we speak next.” He shut the door loudly behind him, and Maeglin heard the lock click. He laid his head back against the wall and took long, slow breaths. The darkness closed in, so thick he could almost choke on it.

*

The light hurt his eyes. The orc who had come to fetch Maeglin jerked him roughly to his feet, paying no mind to the way he swore and tried to shield himself from the torch’s glare while his hands were bound behind him. Mairon met them at the flung-wide double doors of a vast smithy. Maeglin knew the smell of coal smoke before he set foot inside, and a wave of longing for his days in Dwarven cities tugged at him. No coal had been found in Gondolin’s mountains. Their forges burned charcoal made from coppiced hazel and willow, stands of cultivated trees whose fellings and regrowings ran on carefully calculated cycles of years. He hadn’t smelled a coal fire since his childhood, and he wished fiercely that he could close his eyes and be there again instead.

Mairon fell in beside him, but the orc did not release him, gripping Maeglin’s arm uncomfortably tight to propel him wherever Mairon chose. “All this and more will be yours to use as you please as soon as you’ve shared what I need,” Mairon said without further greeting. “Come, let me show you some of the equipment I’ve invented to speed my work.”

He acted as if the orc steering Maeglin were invisible, and Maeglin couldn’t shake the surreality of it. He stayed silent as Mairon explained his inventions and demonstrated each machine. Now that he knew what he was watching for, he could see how gingerly the Maia moved. He’d always been preternaturally graceful, but today every step and every gesture seemed calculated to keep the collar he wore from sliding or shifting on his neck. Maeglin wondered how he managed to forge with it on, or if every hammer stroke was an agony Mairon simply accepted. He remembered the time his father had struck him and knocked him into the anvil hard enough to break his rib, and how he’d been made to keep working anyway, each breath a fresh stab in his side.

“Are you listening to me at all?” Mairon demanded, pulling him from memories.

“Little hard to concentrate when I’m hungry, thirsty, and in fear for my life.”

“It’s your choice to suffer those things, and you can end them whenever you want.”

“That’s not a real choice.”

“You’re the only one I have who could truly appreciate this part of my work. No one else can understand the art of it, and my Master—” He shook his head. He looked so upset that Maeglin wanted to reach out and ask him to say it all again, but he quickly caught himself.

“You lost any right to my appreciation when you forced me here and tortured me.” It felt too easy still, this back and forth, despite his anger, despite the wrongness of what they discussed.

Mairon’s eyes narrowed. “Then I suppose there’s no point in dragging this out.”

With a wave of his hand, he gave an order, and the orc hauled Maeglin across the smithy and into a smaller room, where he stripped off Maeglin’s shirt and tied him to a waiting upright frame with his back bared to the open space. Maeglin heard Mairon’s familiar footsteps a few minutes later. He was shaking already, and he flinched when Mairon laid a hand on his shoulder.

“I don’t want you to be so afraid, my dear,” he murmured in Maeglin’s ear. “I don’t want you to need to be afraid. But this is a terrifying experience. It has to be. It’s going to be incredibly painful, and it would be untrue and against my purposes to let you think otherwise.”

A soft whimper slipped from Maeglin’s throat, and he bit down on his lip. Mairon’s touch was steadying, and he hated that it should feel so.

“All the comforts in my possession will be yours if you’ll let me end this.”

“I’m not stopping you,” Maeglin whispered. “And there is no comfort for betraying my people.”

Mairon sighed. He thoroughly checked over the restraints around Maeglin’s wrists, testing the tightness and the position, then ran the edge of his nail over Maeglin’s fingertips. “Can you feel that? With each finger?”

“Yes?”

“Good. We wouldn’t want anything going numb.”

Maeglin’s bemusement faded quickly when Mairon stepped away. He took a deep breath and tried to brace himself. The first lash cut across his back like a line of fire, and he couldn’t withhold a little cry. He’d thought it wouldn’t be so much worse than his father’s belt, but he’d been wrong. Or maybe he’d just gotten used to not being hurt.

“When my father married my mother, he told her she wouldn’t see the Sun again.” He spoke in gasps between blows, words he’d spent hours in the darkness crafting and rehearsing with the vision of the cruel band Mairon wore ever in his thoughts.

Mairon paused. “Are you ready to talk, then?”

“She thought he didn’t really mean it, and that it was an agreement she could live with for a while.”

“Is this leading up to Gondolin?”

“For a while, life was good, and he seemed caring and considerate. But he kept cutting off more and more of her world over the years. Tightening his control. The first time I know of that he hit her, I was sixteen and had slipped and said a Quenya name in front of him. Once he started though, it got easier, and he did it more. She begged, once, to come with us to Nogrod. He told her she wasn’t allowed out of the forest, because he didn’t trust her to be good.”

Maeglin swallowed hard. His mouth was dry, and it hurt to speak so much after days of silence. Squaring his shoulders, he drew on everything he’d learned in persuading Turgon’s council. “I realized, eventually, it was never going to get better. And I realized it was because when he looked at her, he didn’t see a partner, someone with whom he could exchange love and trust and care. He didn’t see a person, not really. He saw a thing. A possession. Something for him to control and use and mistreat when it didn’t do as he wanted. And it couldn’t get better, because as long as he saw us as possessions, he was never going to care about our opinions or our desires or our choices. He didn’t care whether she loved him as much as whether she obeyed. And he couldn’t love her the way she wanted to be loved, as a person, as someone he respected.”

“A sad story. I’m still waiting.”

“Are you a person to the master you love so much? Or are you one more thing he owns?”

Mairon didn’t answer, but he brought the whip down hard.

“I don’t think he sees you.”

Another searing agony.

“I don’t think he cares.”

Blood was running down his skin and drying in sticky trails.

“He isn’t ever going to return your love.”

The next strike wrapped around his ribs and caught the tender flesh over his side. Maeglin screamed, and whatever else he might have said fled his mind. He wanted it to stop. He needed it to stop. He wasn’t sure he could endure another moment, and it would be so easy to end it.

Maeglin pushed that thought away as hard as he could. He’d endured as a child, and if this was many times harsher, he was stronger now too. He’d prepared for this. A rhyme he’d often recited silently to himself to escape from a beating, if only in his mind, was there and ready for him, and he sang it under his breath, grabbing onto the words and the rhythm and focusing on them like a shield.

“Oak and beech whose branches sway

Where only starlight touches loam

Hear me, hide me, guide my way

Shelter me and bring me home.”

He reached the end and repeated it, letting the dark, comforting branches overhead and the sound of trees singing in the breeze fill his thoughts. Every blow now fell where his back already burned and throbbed, and he started to wonder how bad it would be if Gondolin were attacked. Plans for surviving a siege had been laid long ago, and were updated and stores maintained every few years. No no no. You can’t. You can’t even think it. He started one of his favorite songs from when he’d first come to the city, a ballad of Maedhros and Fingon he’d sung constantly during his work.

“Then Fingon rode from farthest West

The Sun shone brightly on his crest

Beloved of Manwë, archer fair

Golden ribbons in his hair

He came where Maedhros mourning hung

And to his bow an arrow strung

But greater mercy heard his prayer

Beyond the seas, above the air—

“Beyond the seas, above—above the…” He didn’t remember the rest. Nothing but pain existed anymore, and he hoped for nothing.

When Mairon finally released him, he stumbled and almost fell. Mairon held him up and brought him back to his cell himself, letting Maeglin lean against his side, still sobbing and barely aware of anything but how much he hurt. He stayed by Maeglin’s side, stroking his hair while he slowly calmed.

“Why do you sing of Maedhros, little smith? Do you really think anyone will show up to save you?”

Maeglin hazily gathered his scattered thoughts. Everything felt fuzzy and far away. Vaguely he wondered if it were possible to be drunk on pain. “Fingon came for him even though Maedhros betrayed and abandoned him.”

“No one’s coming for you.”

“No. I don’t expect they are. But I would carry you away if you’d let me.”

A complicated mix of emotions passed over Mairon’s face. “You’re not Fingon here.”

“I didn’t think so, back then. I used to…to dream of being Maedhros, when I was new in—” He cut himself off from the forbidden name. Too close. Too dangerous. “I dreamed someone who loved me would steal me away from my grief and scoop me into their arms and make everything better.” He coughed and wiped at his face. “I still want that. But I’m older and stronger now, and I think—I know if I could give that to someone else, I would be very happy.”

“Fingon died alone on a battlefield because of his ill-chosen devotion to Maedhros. That’s the reward for people like him. That’s what happens when you let feelings warp your judgment.”

Maeglin couldn’t quite parse what was wrong with his words. Maybe Mairon was right. Maybe it didn’t matter. “Are you going to kill me?”

“I don’t want to.” He twisted the rings on his fingers, red gems glittering in the light of Mairon’s lantern. “I can’t afford to fail him again,” he whispered.

“When’s the last time anyone touched you tenderly?” Maeglin softly asked. His Maia looked miserable, and he didn’t like it.

Mairon stared at him, wordless.

“Here.” He opened his arms, and the Maia hesitantly crawled into them. Maeglin cradled him close, careful of his neck, nestling Mairon against his chest. It was better like this; if nothing could save him, at least he could comfort his friend. Quietly the Maia began to weep. Maeglin pressed a gentle kiss to the top of his head and let his own tears fall on the Maia’s hair.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 9

Read Chapter 9

Maeglin told himself he hadn’t really expected anything to change because of the moments he’d shared with Mairon, clinging to each other as if their embrace could somehow release them from the misery they were trapped in, but he was furious all the same. He was stretched out on a cold stone floor, uneven edges pressing into his back and tearing at his unhealed welts, with his wrists and ankles chained down. Mairon arrived and stood nearby, watching intently as his servants laid a board flat on Maeglin’s chest and began piling lead ingots onto it.

“No. Move that one over,” he snapped. “I said to spread them evenly, did I not?”

The weight was already bearing Maeglin down until it was hard to breathe, and the orcs kept adding more. One of them dropped an ingot onto him from several feet. It felt like the time a horse had kicked him in the ribs. All the air was forced from his lungs, and as he gasped for breath, desperately wondering if this was how he would die, he heard the orc laughing.

In the span of a blink, Mairon grabbed the orc by the throat and slammed him against the wall. “That is the last time you disrespect me if you value your life.”

The orc slumped to his knees when Mairon released him. “Sorry, m’lord!” he spluttered. “Didn’t mean no offense!”

“Out. Both of you.” When they were gone, he knelt beside Maeglin and straightened the ingots into perfect rows. “Got your breath back? I don’t like that kind of sudden shock, not early on. It can get dangerous.”

Maeglin wanted to spit in his face, but he didn’t think he could spare the energy. “I hate you,” he whispered.

A shadow of something crossed Mairon’s face. Maeglin thought it might have been sorrow. “I know. It can’t be helped. Do you want to talk now and let me get this off of you?”

Maeglin shook his head minutely.

“I didn’t think so. All right. I believe you can handle a little more.” He laid another weight on the pile, stacking the lead with care. When Maeglin thought he would simply be crushed, Mairon sat back. “You can open your mind to me if you can’t manage speaking,” he said softly. “I’ll take it off as soon as you start.”

Maeglin could feel his ribs creaking. He had to fight for every scrap of air, and after every out-breath, he had to face the monumental task of breathing in again. The weight seemed to get heavier every time. He started testing how long he could wait between breaths, snatching them in shallow gasps when he couldn’t deny himself any longer.

“You’ll weaken faster that way,” Mairon murmured. “It’s better to make yourself breathe steadily, even though it hurts.”

“Fuck you,” he mouthed, but he had no strength to make a sound.

“You’re going to feel like you’re dying. You will die, if this goes on long enough. But it will take a very long time.”

Maeglin didn’t know if he could bring himself to die. It was one thing to ride into battle with his sword in hand. It was another to lie here helpless and wait to slowly suffocate, ignoring the way out that called ever louder. Tears slipped from his eyes, and though he tried not to let it ruin the careful rhythm of his breath, he soon broke into shaky, whimpering sobs. His chest hurt so much, and unlike the whipping he’d endured, there were no moments of rest, however short. Instinctively he reached for the Maia’s hand, but his arms were chained above his head, and his fingers could only curl uselessly towards him.

The Maia glanced toward his hand but did not move. “You can tell me. It’s going to be all right.”

People will die. I can’t let that happen. Maeglin thought of Idril, of little Eärendil. Of Salgant. Of all the people who followed him so loyally. He couldn’t trade his pain for theirs. Idril’s face filled his mind, and he pictured her smiling softly. If his love for her had ever meant anything at all, he would die for her.

“Who is that?” Mairon asked, and with horror Maeglin tightened his grip on his mind. He couldn’t let his thoughts bleed out so easily. “Is she the one you spoke of once? The one you love? I’ll give her to you. Anything. You only have to name what you want.”

“Run away with me,” Maeglin whispered. He closed his eyes and imagined instead Nan Elmoth and the trees he’d most loved to walk among. The dark was peaceful and cool where giant gnarled oaks and yew protected everything in their shadows. He wondered if his mother had known peace among them at times. He hoped so. Maybe he would see her soon. Maybe she could even be proud of him. He let his breaths slow and stopped trying so hard to push against the weight. Maybe it wouldn’t be so terrible to die. Maybe he would feel loved again in Naneth’s arms, somewhere in dark halls across the sea.

The Maia was swearing roundly. “No. No, fuck this. I’m not losing you, I’m not…”

All at once the weight was thrown off, and Maeglin gasped loudly. His head swam as he gulped in air. Mairon was unlocking the cuffs on his limbs and pulling him into his arms, and he had no resistance left.

“I can’t. I can’t let you die, I can’t lose you!”

Maeglin remained silent. He was angry and relieved and more than anything, numb. He let Mairon cradle him close and buried his face in the Maia’s hair, breathing in the familiar scent of smoke and spice. Slowly it sank in that he would live a little longer. He wasn’t sure he wanted to. When he was steadier, Mairon took him back to his cell and gave him water and a hunk of coarse-ground bread. He paced back and forth while Maeglin ate.

“What am I going to do?! I can’t disobey my lord. I have to deliver Gondolin to him somehow. If you’re not going to help me, and I clearly don’t have the stomach to do what needs to be done, then where does that leave us? He’ll take you away from me if I don’t get the information from you. He’ll take you, and he won’t care about not leaving permanent damage, and you’ll be dead or worse, and I’ll be punished. Why are you putting me in this impossible position?!”

Maeglin swallowed a big mouthful of the bread. Already he thought he felt stronger. “Why am I doing this to you? Don’t you dare. This was all your idea. You don’t get to blame me for your terrible plans not working. Why did you even bring me here? You could have gone right on leaving me alone.”

Mairon rounded on him. “Do you have any idea how long I did just that? Knowing all the time I had a viable lead on Gondolin I was intentionally ignoring? Do you know how long I’ve suffered this—” he pointed to his collar “—just to protect you?! You owe me gratitude for every year you’ve lived in peace since we met.”

“Well, you owe me your life, so maybe we’ll just call it even!”

Mairon fumed, and Maeglin reveled in his momentary place on top. “Why don’t you leave him?” he pushed.

“Because I love him.” Mairon resumed his pacing, twisting his rings back and forth. “I love him. He…he wasn’t always like this. He was magnificent, full of vision, full of creation. He could be harsh, but he had respect for those who served him well. He recognized excellence and cultivated it in me.” He settled beside Maeglin on the pallet. “He adored me, once.” Slumping, he hid his face in his elegant hands. “Where would I even go?”

“I have a place. The wood where I was born. I am my father’s heir, and heir to his power there. I could command the wood, and it would shield us.”

Mairon scoffed. “Like you wouldn’t immediately want to go home.”

“No. I wouldn’t ever go back. Too much risk that I’d be followed, even if you weren’t with me. I won’t bring danger upon them.”

“How very noble of you.”

“I shouldn’t have put them in danger in the first place.”

“There’s no way your little wood could stand against all the power of Angband. He’d come after me. I’d never be safe again.”

Maeglin shrugged. “You’re just going to torture me again tomorrow anyway.”

“Probably.”

“So what does it matter?”

“What do you mean?”

“What does anything outside of this room matter if we’re about to suffer and die regardless?” Maeglin didn’t know what mood had overtaken him, but it was something fey and wild.

Mairon laughed, sharp and bright. “You’re a strange little Noldo.”

“Only half Noldo.” Maeglin climbed astride his lap, moving gingerly to protect his aching ribs. If no future for him existed, he had nothing to lose. If every road led to death, he would take what he’d wanted and dreamed of all these years first. He grasped Mairon’s chin and studied his gleaming golden eyes, then very deliberately pressed his lips to Mairon’s. The Maia’s hands came up and pulled him closer, one cradling his neck and the other cupping and kneading his ass. Maeglin thought he liked it.

“I want one thing clear,” he said between vicious, demanding kisses.

“Oh?” Mairon sounded beautiful so breathless.

“I am not your friend.” He nipped Mairon’s lip and shoved his tongue into his mouth. Mairon opened to him eagerly. “I still hate you.” He kissed and bit his way down the Maia’s throat, drinking in every gasp and moan. The Maia was grinding his hips into Maeglin, and the feel of his hard cock pressing against him was intoxicating. “You…you’re the worst thing that…that ever happened to me—”

Mairon had worked his trousers open and closed his hand around Maeglin’s cock. “Shh. I know. Let me make you feel good instead.”

“As if that could ever make up for earlier.” He jerked Mairon’s robes out of the way and moaned as their bodies crashed together. His cock was leaking precome, and Mairon slicked it over them both. The silken drag of Mairon’s cock against his lit a pleasure that coursed hot through his veins, and he thought he would never tire of it. Mairon’s mouth was all over Maeglin’s chest and his neck as if he couldn’t get enough of him, and when Maeglin grabbed his hair and tugged his head back to taste him again, he looked up at him worshipfully. Maeglin rutted against him harder, rougher, almost enough to hurt. He hoped it hurt, Maeglin found himself thinking. He hoped Mairon would have bruises where Maeglin's knees held him pinned, where Maeglin's teeth marked his skin. But Mairon gave no sign of pulling away. He had melted in Maeglin's hands, meeting him stroke for stroke, little whines of pleasure falling from his lips, and that was even better. Maeglin wasn’t prepared when his orgasm hit him, harder, he thought, than he’d ever come before. Mairon followed with a few more thrusts, and they lay together, panting and sticky.

Drowsily Maeglin traced the scars on Mairon’s throat. Mairon caught his hand and kissed it before pulling his hair forward to hide the old wound. “Hideous; you don’t have to say it.”

“No. It’s the mark of what you survived.”

“It shows how far short I fell of what I ought to be.” He sighed. “If I ever get this collar off, I’ll have scars from it, too. So I’ll never forget how imperfect I was when my lord needed me.”

“Maybe you’re trying to be perfect at the wrong thing.” His eyes were closed, and nestled on top of Mairon, he was the warmest he’d been since he was brought to Angband.

“There has to be a way to make this work.”

“You’ll have to let go of something. You can’t have it all,” Maeglin murmured as he drifted off.

*

Maeglin woke with a start. He’d gotten to sleep for once without constantly waking shivering from the cold, and he was bitterly resentful of the rough hands hauling him up. Mairon’s outer robe slipped from his body as the orcs jerked him to his feet and forced him out the door. He was taken to a room with traces of blood on the walls and floor and strapped into a chair with his hands bound down on the table before him. Mairon entered, looking bored and mildly annoyed, and another Umaia filed in behind him. His gloating smile made Maeglin uneasy.

“Are you going to tell me what this is about, Langon? I don’t appreciate having my time wasted.”

“I hope, Lieutenant, that you don’t find any time a waste spent on my summons.” A deep, silky voice full of menace spoke, and Mairon sank to one knee, bowing his head.

“Of course not, my king.”

Maeglin’s blood chilled when Morgoth stepped into the room. His crown was too bright to look at, but the glimmer of the famed gems felt sickly somehow. Morgoth towered over his servants, and a terrible unlight seeped from him, as though anything that came too close within his orbit must wither and die. Maeglin wasn’t sure that his flesh was fully solid; it seemed to roil and warp beneath his skin, and though he leaned upon a cane, Maeglin had no doubt that a single blow from the Vala would obliterate him.

“This is the boy?” Morgoth glanced his way, and a wave of nauseating fear swept over Maeglin. That cold gaze seemed to pierce him, and every pain and grief and humiliation he had ever experienced flickered before his vision. With a dread certainty, he thought if Morgoth looked into his eyes and commanded it, he would scream out anything at all for the merest hope of getting away from his attention.

“Yes, my lord. A smith of Gondolin.”

“And have you gotten anything else out of him?”

“Not yet, lord, but I’m confident—”

“Langon has brought me the confirmed location of Gondolin. His spies are scouting its defenses as we speak.”

Mairon’s brows drew together in anger and confusion. “What? How?”

“Go ahead, Langon, take what you need.” Morgoth gestured toward Maeglin, and the Umaia glided forward and began studying him intently, grasping his chin with clawed fingers and turning his face this way and that.

“For all your great skill, little flame, you forget the simplest things.”

Langon laughed. “I took men into the mountains with the boy’s old nag. She led us straight to her stable.”

Morincë! Maeglin was torn between cursing and silently apologizing for ever bringing her into such evil dealings.

Langon straightened, and his features shifted as if Maeglin were staring into an eerie mirror. “What do you think? A good likeness?”

Morgoth looked straight at him, and Maeglin quailed. “Your name, boy?”

“Maeglin,” he found himself stammering. “Prince of Gondolin and Lord of the House of the Mole.”

“Imagine that, Langon. Now you’re a prince.” Morgoth’s laugh sounded like the clash of a battlefield, like nightmares Maeglin woke from screaming. “Go. Their prince mustn’t be away from home too long.”

Langon bowed with a flourish and left.

“Wait, don’t you want to see what else he can tell us?” Mairon asked. “It could be important for mimicking him well.”

“I have every confidence in Langon’s abilities. Yours, on the other hand, are still in need of fresh assurance. All this messing around with pretty tortures is fine on your own time, but you should have brought him to me sooner when he proved stubborn.”

“I thought he might be more useful to us afterward if the information were extracted with less…destruction, my lord.”

“What value is one slave against Gondolin? You’ve lost what could have been great honor, Mairon. Though I will grant half-credit for capturing the horse.”

Morgoth tilted Mairon’s face up, and tremulous hope bloomed in his eyes as Morgoth’s lips hovered over his.

“When you’ve done something worthy of reward, let me know.” He pushed Mairon away. Maeglin could hear the Maia’s little sob. “A smith, you say? Crush his hands and then have him fed slowly to the wargs, piece by piece. He’s defied me, and he’ll learn how foolish that was.”

Mairon bowed but did not move. Neither did Morgoth.

“Lieutenant? Don’t keep me waiting.”

“Forgive me, my lord. I was considering how to do it most painfully. He’s caused me great grief, and I want him to know the meaning of suffering before he dies.” As he spoke, he approached Maeglin and drew a knife, turning it around to wield the pommel.

“By all means.”

Maeglin watched, frozen in disbelief as he raised the pommel and brought it down hard on his right hand. The bone cracked audibly, and Maeglin shrieked.

“No!! No, you can’t!” Mairon moved slightly over and struck again, sharply and precisely. “Not my hands! Please, please!! What do you want? There’s seven gates. Please!! There’s seven gates! Don’t!!!”

Mairon didn’t stop. The pain was unbearable. Maeglin screamed and sobbed.

“You were too hesitant before,” Morgoth commented. “Take that to heart for next time.”

“Thank you, my lord. I will.” Mairon worked his way down each bone of Maeglin’s little finger. Maeglin didn’t notice the change in the air when Morgoth left. He didn’t notice anything but the awful pain and the knowledge that he wouldn’t use that hand again. Mairon broke every bone in his next two fingers and then hurled aside the knife.

“He’s gone now, dearest,” Mairon whispered in his ear. “I’m sorry. I’m so, so sorry. I will fix this, I swear.”

Maeglin couldn’t have stopped crying if he’d wanted to.

“You favor your left, don’t you? I thought that’s what I’d noticed. I hope that was right.” He bent over Maeglin’s hand. Maeglin flinched. “Try not to move, sweetheart. I’m going to set them.”

One by one he aligned each bone over Maeglin’s continued wails. “There we are,” Mairon murmured. “Nice clean breaks. Hardly any loose chips. Stay right where you are.”

“You’re a monster and I hate you,” Maeglin sobbed.

“I know.” Mairon took something from a shelf and returned. He opened a small jar and spread the salve inside over Maeglin’s hand. Maeglin thought he smelled arnica and horsetail. Resting his hands over Maeglin’s, Mairon began to sing, soft and low. Maeglin’s hand grew warm and started to itch deep inside. He bit down hard on his lip. The singing went on and on, and slowly the pain began to ebb.

Mairon was panting in exhaustion when he stopped. He looked half-ready to collapse, holding himself up by the table’s edge. “That’s the best I can do for now. It’s mended, but you mustn’t stress it; the bones are still weak. We’ll need to get you some decent food as well. Void, this is going to be tricky without any planning.”

“What is?”

“Our escape.”


Leave a Comment

Chapter 10

Read Chapter 10

Mairon pulled Maeglin to his feet, and Maeglin immediately bent over and retched. His stomach held little, and emptying it didn’t seem to help. The dizziness and nausea were too great to remain standing, and Maeglin felt a headache creeping in behind them. On top of that, his hand still hurt. He groaned.

“Lord Melkor has that effect on Elves sometimes. Get a hold of yourself; we need to move.”

Maeglin glared wearily up at Mairon. He didn’t have the energy to point out that the kind of pain he’d just inflicted might also have some effect. Mairon waited a moment or two, but when Maeglin made no effort to rise, he took his arm and hauled him toward the door.

“Mairon, I can’t, I’ll be sick again!” His legs felt like jelly, and the floor seemed to waver.

“Do you think this place cares? My lord is displeased with me and possibly suspicious. That means he’s likely to send someone to check on my obedience. And when you are not found hanging over a pit with several parts missing, we will have very little time left. Cry and scream if you will, but do not fight me.”

There was nothing else for it. Maeglin knew better than to trust him, but he had no chance of survival without Mairon’s help. He stumbled along, half-supported by Mairon’s bruising grip, miserable and cursing. Just like any other prisoner, he supposed. He wondered if this could be Mairon’s way of punishing him, giving him a glimpse of hope only to ruin him more thoroughly. What if he were following him to his death?

Mairon didn’t glance his way, only sighing and jerking him along when he tripped and nearly fell. He walked with a clipped, assured stride, and everyone they passed in the halls bowed their heads to him. He isn’t really going to leave this for me, Maeglin thought. Why would he? I’m nothing, an amusement. Even with Morgoth’s cruelty…he’s powerful here. Why throw that security away to be hunted by everyone? He had almost convinced himself it would be worthwhile to twist from Mairon’s hold and try to run when Mairon shoved him through a door and let him go.

“Lie down and catch your breath if you must,” Mairon told him over his shoulder. “Here’s your sword.” He tossed the sheathed blade onto the bed he’d pushed Maeglin toward. Maeglin sank onto it, cradling his hand, still wishing the world would stop spinning. He stared at Anguirel, wondering if he ought to run Mairon through. If he even could. The Lieutenant of Angband moved quickly and efficiently, stuffing clothing and supplies into two bags.

He glanced back at Maeglin. “Whatever you’re thinking, get it out of your system now. I’ve had enough of that look.”

“What look?”

Mairon sneered. “What look do you think? The one like you can’t decide if you’d rather punch my face or stab me in the back. Here, I’ll make this easy for you.” Tearing the scabbard from Anguirel, he pushed the hilt into Maeglin’s good hand, and raised the point to the hollow of his own throat. “Well? Isn’t this what you want?”

Maeglin held perfectly still. The Maia’s steady gaze was impenetrable, and Maeglin was certain he would see nothing Mairon did not want him to see. It frightened him to be seen so clearly himself.

“No?” He pressed forward until a single drop of blood shone on his golden-brown skin. “This is your chance. Take it now, or stop seeking ways to cross me. It’s distracting.”

Maeglin couldn’t tear his eyes from the blood. It sat below the collar Morgoth had bound upon him like a little red gem, and the wrongness of it made him want to scream and then wipe it away. Or kiss it away, and go on to soothe all the Maia’s hurts. He shook his head and lowered the sword.

“That’s what I thought. Take this and wrap yourself up. Make sure your face is hidden.” He handed Maeglin a pack and a cloak. Maeglin struggled with the clasp one-handed until Mairon sighed and fastened it for him. Anguirel was strapped to Mairon’s pack alongside his own blade, and Mairon paused with his hand on the doorlatch. “Keep your head down and stay right behind me. They’ll believe you’re my thrall.”

No one questioned them or seemed to notice anything strange about Mairon’s bearing, and Maeglin, hidden deep in his hood, focused on keeping his feet moving. Mairon was right; he couldn't bring himself to do anything but follow, and it was easier not to think at all. The smell of coal and iron brought him back to attention as they crossed the forges. He couldn’t help but peer at the tools they passed, wondering quietly if he’d ever get to hold such things again, when he caught sight of several large snips and shears hanging on a rack. He took a deep, cautious breath, considering. With a quick glance around the room, he confirmed they were alone.

“Wait,” Maeglin whispered, catching Mairon’s sleeve.

Mairon looked around himself, then jerked Maeglin into a corner. “What? It had better be important.”

I am a Lord of Gondolin, Maeglin reminded himself, as he had before so many council meetings. “Lay your head on the bench there and hold still.” He chose a heavy pair of nippers that ought to cut through even thick gold with ease. When he turned back, Mairon’s eyes were narrowed, and he hadn’t moved. “You aren’t leaving with that collar on.” He was proud of how little his voice wavered.

A shade of doubt and what Maeglin thought must be fear crossed Mairon’s eyes, but then he pulled his hair aside and lowered his head to the wood. Maeglin positioned the nippers carefully, wedging them against the benchtop for leverage while making sure the force of cutting would not drive the spikes inside deeper into Mairon’s neck. The Maia had closed his eyes, and his fingers gripped the edge of the bench tightly.

“It’s all right,” Maeglin murmured. “I won’t hurt you.”

“Shut up and get it over with,” Mairon hissed. He hadn’t seemed so vulnerable at the tip of Maeglin’s sword, but here, with Mairon bowed over the table and fighting with himself to stay calm, Maeglin felt that he held his life in his hands, delivered to him at his demand, and it felt precious. He slipped two fingers under the band beside the blade of the nippers and threw his weight onto the handle. With a solid thunk, the blades connected, and the golden collar gave way. Maeglin eased it off, trying not to scratch or cut, but some of the spikes had grown into Mairon's flesh, held tightly in place, and he had to pull hard to get them loose. He hurled the collar aside and staunched the Maia’s blood with the corner of his cloak. Mairon was silently weeping.

“I’m sorry. I’m so sorry; I know I said it wouldn’t hurt. I didn’t think—”

Mairon straightened, his lip curled in scorn. “That’s barely worth calling pain. Stop staring. You know nothing.”

Maeglin wanted to push, to ask what was wrong if that were true, but he didn’t dare. Mairon was quickly pulling himself together, drying his face and tucking his clothing around his neck so nothing would show, and in moments he appeared once more the immovable Lieutenant.

“Come along,” he snapped.

They emerged from dim passages into a sort of kennel. Wolves and wargs lounged upon rocky ledges. Dozens of golden eyes followed the newcomers with interest, and several rose and ran up to greet Mairon. He kept pausing to coo over them and pat their heads as they tussled over the privilege of being next to rub against his side and lick his hands. Maeglin hung close, trying not to look out of place, though he wasn’t certain how much fear a slave should show. He thought he felt a stir of moving air in the distance and smelled a slightly fresher breeze.

An orc approached and bowed low to Mairon. He waited attentively while Mairon inspected a half-grown pup, checking her newly-grown teeth and the brightness of her eyes.

Mairon brushed shed fur from his robes. “Is Gauleg well-rested? I want her saddled if she hasn’t been out today.”

“Ahh…well…it’s just, my lord, I-I have orders. From his Highness. He said if you came looking for a steed, we weren’t to prepare one, but tell you to report direct to Him.”

Mairon scowled. “What insolence is this? He sent no such word to me.”

“I’m sorry, my lord!” The orc cowered until Maeglin almost felt bad for him. “Please, I-I’m sorry, I’m only doing as I was told. Please don’t hurt me!”

“If this is someone’s idea of a prank, I will have your head.”

“Please, it’s straight from his Highness, I swear!!” The orc had thrown himself face down at Mairon’s feet. Mairon nudged him aside and stalked back the way they had come. Maeglin scurried to keep up.

“Not a good sign,” Mairon murmured once they were out of hearing. “This way. There’s a small side door that isn’t usually guarded.”

Maeglin flinched at every unexpected sound, but at last a rusty gate creaked open onto dark plains. Maeglin’s heartbeat was pounding so loud he wondered if Mairon could hear it. Freedom awaited mere feet away, and a desperate little noise rose in his throat as he lunged toward it.

Mairon threw his arm across the exit. “No. They’ll be on a solitary elf in moments.”

“What then?!” Maeglin wanted to demand, but he couldn’t get the words out. Was this the moment everything turned out to be one more elaborate torment?

Mairon handed him the pack with the swords, shrugging his shoulders and stretching his neck. Blood seeped from the punctures where the collar had been, but he didn’t seem to notice. “You’ll have to carry both. Lie flat on my back, and don’t fall off if you care for your life.” With no more explanation he became a huge wolf, golden-sable and the size of a small horse. For some reason Maeglin thought of the little golden adders whose venom his father had always warned him against. The color was the same. The wolf shook himself impatiently and sank down so that Maeglin could climb on.

*

The air was thick and foul with ash and smog. Maeglin clung to the wolf’s fur, burying his face in its coarse warmth as Mairon’s steady, unhurried trot carried them across the Anfauglith for hour after hour after hour. His hand ached unremittingly, and every time he shifted and pain flared through him, he thought maybe this would be the time he could hold on no longer, that his weary, abused body would drop at last to the lifeless plains and rise no more.

They came to a sluggish, ash-choked stream, and Mairon stepped into it with an unhappy whine. He walked along the creek bed, water sloshing around his paws. The quiet whines slipped faster from Mairon’s throat until they accompanied almost every breath.

“The water’s hurting you,” Maeglin realized, not daring to speak above a whisper. He remembered his mother’s teaching, that if he ever needed to escape from orcs, he should put running water between them if he could, that Morgoth’s foul servants would enter it only reluctantly.

“Ulmo hates me, and I hate him,” Mairon growled into his mind. “But it will hide our trail.”

Maeglin wanted to urge him to stop, to tell him not to suffer like this. Now that he knew, he noticed the hesitation with which Mairon set each paw down again. But if Mairon found it necessary… Maeglin wondered what would come behind them, and if anything could stop it. Maeglin had no strength left for fighting.

The sky was beginning to pale, and far off Maeglin thought he could see a different texture to the broken ground. He fell into an uneasy doze, jerking awake at every uneven step only to succumb again to exhaustion. When Mairon finally halted, the Sun was half visible at the edge of the world, a glaring orange smudge in the smoke-thick air, and sparse vegetation softened the earth. Maeglin slid from the wolf’s back with a groan.

“We’ll hide here for the day,” Mairon announced, taking his more familiar form and pulling Maeglin after him into a hollow where a long dead tree had been overturned. Enough dirt still clung to the jagged web of roots to shelter them underneath. “We’ll be too easy to spot by daylight. A couple more nights will have us off the plains, and then—I suppose the rest is up to you.” He looked uncertain and…lost, Maeglin thought, and he almost held out his arms to take him and tell him they would be all right, before his hand twinged sharply and reminded him who his Maia really was. He turned his face away.

“Do you…know where you want to go from here?” Mairon asked hesitantly. He dug a waterskin from their packs and took a small swallow, then passed it to Maeglin. His hands were red and irritated, and Maeglin told himself firmly he deserved it.

“Yes,” he answered. Part of him wanted desperately to turn towards Gondolin, to race the Umaia wearing his face and warn everyone of the danger they were in, but despite everything Mairon had done, he could not trust him with that secret. If everything had been a lie, if he were even now in the Enemy’s grasp, if this were some awful trick being played upon him, he could not lead them to Gondolin himself. It would be the sort of cleverness Mairon admired, to convince him he was on Maeglin’s side, was betraying his ancient loyalty for one who could have no real consequence in his eyes, only to use him to gain the knowledge he sought. Maeglin would not give it to him.

Mairon made a little impatient sound. “I need to know our heading. You don’t have to tell me anything else.”

“South. Towards the borders of Doriath.”

“You know there’s little left, if you thought to seek harbor there. Melian left this world when her Elf-king died, and her protection is no more. The Fëanorians destroyed her people soon after.”

Maeglin let his head fall back against the cool earth. “Oh. I…I didn’t know.” As little as he’d cared for his father, he had fond memories of his few visits to Menegroth and his kinsfolk there. “They’re all…gone? Dead? Or…?”

“My reports indicated some survivors fled,” Mairon said quietly. “They weren’t important enough to track further.”

Maeglin roughly brushed tears from his eyes. He had too much else to consider to spend grief on people he’d barely known.

“Does that change your plans?”

“No.”

“All right. Sleep, then, if you can. I’ll wake you when it’s time to go.”


Leave a Comment

Chapter 11

Read Chapter 11

Maeglin couldn’t stop thinking of the last time he’d fled an unbearable situation, riding towards a tenuous hope of safety with only the certainty that the malice left behind would catch up and claim him if it could. He remembered his mother, laughing into the wind as she urged their horses to run faster, and the look on her face when she realized Eöl’s poison was taking hold. In all the hours he’d spent at her bedside, weeping and begging her not to leave him, he’d never managed to speak the question that had filled his mind. Do you wish we’d never left?

He’d never shaken the feeling that all her suffering was his fault. It had been his idea to run. His idea to head for Gondolin, rather than any of the other places they might have found shelter. His inability to be the good son his father wanted that had made Eöl start hitting her in the first place. If not for him, Aredhel would still be alive and happy. Maeglin’s fingers clenched in the thick, warm fur of the golden wolf beneath him. Naneth wouldn’t have wanted him thinking those things. But then, it was his fault she was dead and couldn’t tell him they weren’t true. He wondered if his and Mairon’s track had yet been found and if he’d have to watch as everything happened over again. I won’t let it, he promised himself. I’m not a child to stand by and stare helplessly anymore.

No signs of pursuit that Maeglin could see appeared, but the great wolf Mairon had become kept glancing over his shoulder and scanning the skies, and when he found them shelter at the bottom of a rocky gully, he pulled away from Maeglin’s inquiring gaze. “If they’d found us, we would know it,” he said gruffly. “Rest. I’ll watch.”

“You watched yesterday. All I’ve done is ride; I can take a turn.” Maeglin took a piece of the dry waybread Mairon had packed and nibbled at it halfheartedly. Maybe it was bloodmeal that gave it that bruised color and faintly metallic taste? He wouldn’t be surprised.

Mairon grunted in reply, and Maeglin couldn’t tell if it was agreement or not. When he’d eaten as much as he could stomach, he gathered up his courage and went over to tuck a cloak around the Maia. Mairon absently pulled it tighter. He hardly seemed to notice Maeglin.

“Go on; you need to sleep,” Maeglin said.

“I don’t, actually.”

“You slept a lot when I was with you before.”

“That was…I was healing.” His fingertips went to the scar on his throat, as if to reassure himself it was closed, but when he brushed the wounds left by the collar, he shuddered. “It was different.”

“Maybe not sleep then, but at least rest.” Maeglin dared to touch his arm. “Please? I’m afraid of what happens if we’re caught and you’re not at your best.” It felt unfair, the way the words hit him like a blow and made the line of his mouth twist, but Maeglin knew he’d found his mark.

Mairon shrugged him off. “Fine. But just for an hour or two. I don’t want to be asleep if they come upon us.”

As soon as the Maia had curled up between the rocks, pulling his hood well down over his eyes, Maeglin set to work on the thorny problem of getting a message to his city. If Idril had ever simply let me in… Tentatively he stretched his mind towards Gondolin, seeking a certain bright gleam he thought he would recognize, no matter from how far. She was as powerful in osanwë as he was, equally as skilled in blocking him out as in stealing glimpses he hadn’t wanted her to see, and if there had ever been a moment of clear and open communication mind to mind between them, he could have traced those paths again. But all his probing found nothing. She was living; he could sense her presence in the world, but it was nebulous and distant, and no amount of trying could bridge the emptiness between them. Just as it had always been. She didn’t want him in her life or in her mind, and however he cast about to reach her, without some little willingness to hear him, there was nothing to grab hold of, only the yawning divide where he must drown.

Gasping with the effort, he came back to himself, wrung out and disoriented. A headache glimmered behind his temples. If we had a marriage bond… He shoved that old longing away hard. If he’d married her, he would never have left Gondolin in the first place, and he would be someone entirely different with a different set of problems, because Idril had never wanted Maeglin. He allowed himself a moment of wishing heartily that he was someone else, anyone else but the person who had ended up here, friendless and unmissed, tainted from birth with whatever it was about him that left him eternally shut out. Then he dragged himself back to the task at hand.

It was no use trying again. No one else he knew stood a chance of hearing him from here, so he’d have to use more physical means. Maeglin cut a narrow strip from his shirt, already dingy with the dust of his travels, wincing at the way his hand twinged. He thought he’d seen some softer earth among the waterworn rocks. The bottom of the gully was sand and gravel; Maeglin imagined the floods that must rip through it in the rain and stole a glance at the hazy sky. Everything in this country seemed ready to kill him. He’d just found a lump of hard yellowish clay that he pried from the steep banks when he heard the small sound of a hitched breath.

Mairon’s shoulders were shaking, and the little stifled sobs didn’t stop. He was awake, then. Maeglin disliked his own annoyance at the interruption. He felt torn between two realities, one where this was all an elaborate manipulation, and one where someone who cared for him and had sacrificed much was in need, and he still didn’t know which to trust. Hiding away his new writing supplies, he went over to Mairon and laid a hand on his shoulder.

“Hey,” he murmured. “Are you—” The Maia was not crying, he realized. He was laughing. Maeglin froze.

“Am I what? All right? Of course I’m fine. I’m brilliant. Why wouldn’t I be?” He laughed harder, pressing a fist to his mouth to contain the sound. “I just threw away thousands of years of service and devotion without a second thought. Without a plan. Without…without…” He rolled onto his back and stared up at Maeglin. His eyes held no mirth. “Do you know where I’m supposed to be right now? I had a meeting with Gothmog to go over weapons upgrades for mounted units. Then I was to deliver the summary of notable spy reports to my Master. Then meet with the heads of inventory and supplies. There was a discrepancy in the accounts, barrels of salt disappearing regularly. No one’s going to find and execute the culprit if I don’t.”

“Followed by another round of torturing me?” Maeglin didn’t know what had possessed him to say it. Mairon didn’t answer, but whimpered softly. Maeglin closed his eyes, sifting through all the possible words to follow. “Do you want to go back?” he finally asked.

“No.” Mairon’s voice was firm, and that was some relief. “I chose what I chose. I would choose it again. I just…” He shuddered, and tears were beginning to spill down his cheeks. “I betrayed him. Like it was nothing. I don’t…he’ll never forgive me for this.”

Maeglin remained silent while Mairon wiped his eyes and readjusted his cloak around him, quietly sniffling. “I don’t understand why you helped me at all.”

“He wanted me to kill you!”

“I’m hardly irreplaceable. I’m sure you’ve killed smiths more skilled than me.”

“That isn’t…” Mairon stared into his hands as if he could find answers there. “When I chose to follow him…I believed all the destruction was the means to an end. A worthy one. A world we would build together and rule, he and I, one in perfect order. I loved him, and I knew we might not see eye to eye on every detail, but I trusted his vision, and I trusted his commands. Transformation requires destruction, you see? Cutting a gem destroys the raw crystal. Building a city destroys the mountainside it’s quarried from. To create anything, you must destroy something else first. And…I enjoyed my work. I enjoyed being excellent at serving him. But then…he…I would never have left him for growing distant. Not after all he’s been through.”

Mairon rubbed at his neck and the angry marks that still showed where the collar had circled it. “I wouldn’t have left because of punishment. I’ve always accepted his will.” His voice had fallen to a whisper, as if he spoke to convince himself more than Maeglin. “It’s just…how can we build a perfect world if we ruin everything good and beautiful of the old one?” He ventured a glance toward Maeglin. “He wanted me to destroy you.”

Maeglin’s breath caught in his throat. No one had ever looked at him with that mix of hunger, anguish, and yearning.

“I don’t think you understand what a jewel you are.” Mairon hesitantly reached up, and when Maeglin didn’t flinch, he slid his fingers down the curve of Maeglin’s cheek. “And if he couldn’t see that either…What good is it, building a new order if I can’t have you in it? What world could possibly be worth that?” He paused and shook his head. “Maybe I’m being selfish. I don’t know anymore. I don’t know who I’m supposed to be without him. But—you were kind to me, and you made me happy for a little while, and I…I’m weak. A weak and traitorous wretch who couldn’t keep hurting you. That’s why.”

Mairon stood abruptly, while Maeglin was still turning over the tangled knot he’d been presented and trying to make some sense of it. “Sleep. I can’t.” He turned into a wolf and stalked away.

*

Every day that passed without being able to send his message filled Maeglin with dread, but finally they came to a place with a few spindly trees and water that ran almost clear. (“Don’t drink it,” Mairon warned him anyway.) He slipped away from Mairon when they stopped to rest. He’d seen a flash of feathers, and he waited, occasionally daring a whistled trill, until the bird reappeared. With tiny crumbs of waybread, he coaxed it to his hand, a sparrow that must be wandering far from home to have ended up here. He thought wistfully of the uncle he’d never gotten to meet, the one Aredhel swore could speak the tongue of any bird or beast. Maeglin would have to make do with whatever images a bird’s mind could comprehend. He fastened the note he’d scratched on the little scrap of linen to the bird’s leg and pictured the peaks of the Echoriath and Turgon’s tower as clearly as he could, pushing them carefully but urgently toward the bird, along with promises of the vast amounts of seeds she’d be rewarded with. The sparrow chirped agreeably, and Maeglin released her to the sky.

Mairon looked up when Maeglin returned, but he said nothing. He’d been surly and withdrawn since spilling his feelings, and Maeglin let him be. If it had been him sharing something so close, he didn’t think he could have faced the person he’d told for days. Not that he’d ever had the skill of striking up a conversation anyway. Glorfindel or Tuor might have drawn him out, dissipated the heavy tension and teased him into good cheer. Or Salgant, with his warmth and kindly humour. Maeglin wished he could have taken him up on his invitation and brought Mairon around to meet him. He wished any of this could be comfortably normal. He wondered if he’d ever see Salgant again.

“My hand hurts,” he announced.

“You’re using it too much.”

“You’re a little harder to sit on than a horse.”

“Believe me, I’m wishing for a saddle too.” Mairon took Maeglin’s hand, smoothing salve from the little tin he’d brought into his skin and singing over it softly. Warmth spread through him, and the pain eased. Mairon’s golden eyes seemed dull in the morning light, and he wouldn’t meet Maeglin’s gaze.

*

They had covered a dozen miles or so the next night when Mairon halted suddenly, lifting his nose and sniffing the air. Maeglin ducked down, shifting his cloak to hide him better. Without warning, Mairon transformed, dumping Maeglin on the ground. He scrambled to his feet.

“Mairon,” he hissed. “What the hell?”

Mairon pointed. A strange black bird was staring at them, head cocked to the side. It had four wings and an oily sheen to its dark feathers, and when it squawked and flapped heavily into the air, Maeglin saw its beak was full of teeth. But that wasn’t what held Mairon’s attention.

“I’m guessing that was yours?”

A smaller bird lay dead on the ground, barely recognizable except for the bits of feathers, its body split open from head to tail and its guts torn from its belly and spread around. Tied to its leg was a scrap of dirty fabric. Maeglin didn’t answer. Mairon scooped up the message and passed it to Maeglin without looking at it. “The skies aren’t safe either. Your best shot will be from within Taur nu Fuin. Though you risk giving us away.”

“We’re going through Taur nu Fuin rather than passing Himring?”

“Fewer orc patrols. Unless that takes us too far off our path?”

“No…no, that’s fine.”

Mairon nodded and turned away. Maeglin wished he would say something more, even if it were only to yell at him for putting them in greater danger, anything but this silence as if he was barely present.

“I’m sorry,” he offered as the wolf took Mairon’s place. Wolf-Mairon flicked his ears toward Maeglin, and when Maeglin approached, he pushed his nose into Maeglin’s hands. “I wasn’t thinking about the risk. I didn’t think it would be caught so easily.”

The wolf nuzzled his chin, and Maeglin leaned against him, forehead to forehead, breathing in the warm musky smell so like his mother’s hounds. “I understand there are things you value above our lives,” Mairon whispered into the edge of his mind. “Come. We must run.”


Leave a Comment

Chapter 12

Read Chapter 12

The land rose steadily as they climbed into the foothills of Ladros. Mairon was spending more and more time as a wolf. It seemed easier for him. As a wolf, he could be affectionate with Maeglin, even playful sometimes, leaning against him or curling up with his head in Maeglin’s lap, accepting pats and hugs and nuzzling Maeglin in return. In his more elflike form, he was aloof and burdened with a weight that Maeglin could never seem to lift or even get close enough to understand. It worried him, but the one time he dared to ask what was on Mairon’s mind, he was snapped at, so he contented himself with the wolf’s comfort and kept his questions to himself.

The air was sweeter here, more so as the forest deepened around them, and Maeglin filled his lungs with it gratefully. He hadn’t realized how much of the land north of Gondolin was too poisoned to sustain much life. Would it keep spreading until all of Beleriand was ruined? Surely even Morgoth could not be so callous towards the inevitable consequences? Nothing would be left for him to claim. He remembered Mairon’s words and wondered if he had any vision at all for what came after the destruction. Imagining dying lands in every direction made him heartsick, and he couldn't help thinking that even the dizzying heights of the Echoriath wouldn’t have protected Gondolin forever.

Mairon had caught a brace of rabbits, and though they’d passed into the edge of Taur-nu-Fuin, they were near enough to several Mannish homesteads sending up drifts of smoke that he allowed them a small fire. While he skinned the rabbits and set them to roast, Maeglin went in search of another bird. Fewer appeared than seemed right for the forested highlands; even after burning years ago and being logged in places since, he thought the land should hold more life. But maybe it didn’t return as easily as that. At length he found a robin who seemed to recognize the tower Maeglin showed him, and Maeglin sped him on the way with his warning. Maybe the robin would have better luck than the last bird. Maybe Gondolin still had hope. Maeglin wasn’t sure what it felt like anymore.

*

“So…” Mairon sat with his arms drawn around his knees, staring at the remnants of the fire still smouldering in the morning light. The rabbits were gone. He’d insisted on feeding most of them to Maeglin, taking only a small portion to pick at himself. Afterwards he’d cracked open the bones and sucked out the marrow with teeth more pointed than Maeglin remembered. “I’m not sure how far you expected me to go with you.”

Maeglin snapped to attention.

“I'll take you as far as you wish, of course. I want to know you'll be safe. But as soon as you no longer need me…just say the word, and I'll be out of your way.”

Maeglin's heart sank. It had been too much to assume the Maia would stay; he could see that now, but he’d thought…after the way Mairon had spoken about him, with so much fierce care…no matter. No one wanted Maeglin. That was how the world worked, and he should be used to it by now.

“Where will you go?” Please not back to Morgoth. Maeglin couldn’t bear to think of what he’d do to Mairon.

Mairon’s shoulders slumped. “I don’t know,” he whispered. He seemed so dejected, and yet his words had been cold and sure. His mind was a closed-off fortress, and Maeglin could catch no glimmer of meaning there.

I’m so little to you that you’ll leave without even having anything better? Maeglin struggled to swallow down his hurt. Should he even say anything more? If Mairon had made his choice…he had to respect it, didn’t he? Mairon knew Maeglin wanted him to make a home together. He’d told him so. He imagined asking again, begging, and the way Mairon’s mocking laughter would cut him open. “I appreciate all you’ve done for me. I won’t ask you to stay any longer if…” His voice was growing shaky, and he wasn’t sure he could steady it.

“As soon as I've brought you somewhere safe, then. Unless you want me to leave now.” Mairon had gone brusque and even colder, and Maeglin hated it.

“I don’t want you to leave at all!”

“You don’t want me here. You don’t want me near you.”

“What in Arda gave you that idea?!”

Mairon looked at him incredulously. “You hate me. You said so. I hurt you. I tortured you. You can't ever forgive that. I stole you away from everything you love, and am somehow responsible for the deaths of all your people, even though we both know my lord would have found them eventually. Those were your words. I told you I would fix it, but there’s no way I can fix all that. I’m giving you what I can, and that’s not having to look at me anymore.”

Maeglin didn’t know how to answer. None of it was wrong, exactly, but it wasn’t the whole truth either.

“Right. As I said. You don’t have to pretend anything to get the rest of what you need.” Mairon rose and kicked soil over the last coals of their fire, pulling his cloak around his shoulders. “I'll be back tonight.” As he stepped toward the forest depths, Maeglin drove himself to his feet.

“Wait! Mairon, don’t go. Please.” He caught the Maia’s wrist, but rather than face him, Mairon became the wolf. Desperately Maeglin grasped a handful of fur instead, and to his surprise, the wolf went easily when he tugged him back toward where they’d been sitting. Huffing, Mairon allowed Maeglin to haul him half into his lap and rest his forehead in Mairon’s ruff. “Please just let me figure out what I want to say before you run off?”

Mairon gave a long sigh and rested his chin on his paws, but he didn’t try to flee again.

“I…” Maeglin feared for a moment his words would dry up altogether. He combed his fingers through the wolf’s fur and tried again to gather his thoughts. “I am angry. I think I’ll be angry a long time. But I don’t…I can’t hate you. Not…the way I think you took it.” He dampened his lips. “It isn’t that simple. You brought me there, but you saved me too. I’m not sure what to make of it. They don’t erase each other.”

The wolf whined softly, his ears tucked back against his head.

“But there’s more between us than that, and it hasn’t disappeared either. Or at least there is for me. There’s…there’s caring, and friendship, and…and—but if you don’t feel that way, it’s all right; I only thought—”

Suddenly Mairon was sitting upright and very close, his gaze intense and his red hair tumbling about him, within the circle of Maeglin’s arms.

“I do want you,” Maeglin whispered. “I never stopped wanting you.”

“You’re trembling,” Mairon quietly observed. “You’re afraid of me.”

Maeglin laughed. “Not of you. Afraid of what you’ll say, maybe.”

“I didn’t want you to be afraid. I didn’t want to make you afraid.”

It wasn’t any kind of apology. None of what he’d said was. Maeglin thought he should probably care more about that. “I also told you I wanted to carry you away and make everything better. That hasn’t changed.”

Too late he realized it was the wrong thing to say. It sounded ridiculous and pitying here in the light of day, and he didn’t mean it to be, but Mairon wouldn’t know that; he’d be disgusted or contemptuous or both. Maeglin closed his eyes and waited for the blow to fall.

“I believe I’ve been doing all the carrying.”

Maeglin glanced up in time to see the little quirk of a smile form. The relief that flooded him seemed only to make him shakier, but he didn’t bother to hide it. He took Mairon’s hands hesitantly in his. “Then you’ll stay?”

“I’ll stay.” He stared down at their linked hands. “I’ll stay,” he whispered again, a promise almost too quiet to hear. Tears were gathering in his eyes, and the Maia hurriedly dashed them away. They didn't stop. Carefully, as if he wasn’t sure it could be permitted, he leaned against Maeglin, and when Maeglin wrapped him in his arms, he began to sob. “Sorry, I’ll get myself under control, I will. It’s only…I turned my back on my lord, and I thought you didn’t—that I’d ruined—I thought I was alone in the world.”

Maeglin squeezed him tighter. “You’re not.”

With his face pressed into Maeglin’s shoulder, Mairon drew breath as if to speak, once and then again, but he didn’t seem able to get the words out. Or perhaps he thought better of them; Maeglin knew the feeling. Too well. “I miss Him,” he murmured at last. “So much. I know you want it to be otherwise. But it hurts.”

Maeglin recalled nights in Gondolin when he’d cried himself to sleep, missing his father as well as his mother and wondering what was wrong with him that he could look back with longing on any memories of Aredhel’s murderer. He wasn’t sure he wanted to share any of that with the Umaia weeping in his arms.

“I shouldn’t have let you take my collar,” Mairon whispered. It sent a chill through Maeglin. “It was the last thing he ever gave me. I should’ve—I—” He shook his head and let his tears drown out the rest.

“No. He shouldn’t have hurt you like that.” He couldn’t keep his frustration from bleeding through, though he doubted it would help anything.

“It was his right. You don’t understand.”

“Did you like wearing it? Did you like his constant cruelty to you?”

Mairon’s reply was to shift back into a wolf. Maeglin cursed himself silently. At least he hadn’t driven him away. He should remember to stop talking sooner; unplanned words never ended well for him. Of course Mairon would have complicated feelings after long ages of devotion. How could he not? Somehow, Mairon didn’t object when he curled up against his side, so he rested his head on the wolf's chest and began stroking his fur. It seemed to soothe them both. Before long the steady rise and fall of his breath lulled Maeglin to sleep.

It was twilight already when he woke. He hadn’t meant to sleep long or so deeply, but the wolf lying warm against him exuded safety, and he’d spent too much time of late jolting awake at every slight rustle, so it was a welcome change. He felt fresher and more ready for action than he had in a while. “Mairon?”

The wolf stretched and yawned and became his familiar red-headed Maia, wholly unthreatening with bits of leaves in his hair and his eyes still drooping with sleep. “What?”

“Time to get moving.”

“Not yet.” His eyes closed again, and Maeglin could feel how quickly he was gone. Days of watching with little rest must have taken their toll on him, too.

With a little shy fondness he was quite sure Mairon didn’t deserve, Maeglin leaned down and pressed a soft, quick kiss to his temple, then rose and grabbed the waterskins. He could refill them in the spring nearby and get everything ready while Mairon slept a few more minutes. He hissed in pain when he pushed the skin under the stream’s surface; the cold ignited a deep biting ache everywhere his hand had been broken, and even switching hands and tucking it under his shirt to warm didn’t help. His chest ached too, and he rubbed it, wincing, when he straightened. He must have slept in the wrong position. It would be fine. He probably needed weeks of real rest to recover from all he’d endured, but they’d reach Nan Elmoth eventually, and he’d get it then. He’d be fine.

Steeling himself against the cold, he splashed some water on his face. He longed for a hot bath and clean hair, but washing even a bit of dirt and sweat off felt good. Maeglin stood, hefting the now-heavy waterskins over his shoulder, and turned back toward Mairon and their little camp. Through the trees he saw them. A troop of Orcs—five—no, six—were taking positions with loaded crossbow bolts trained upon him and Mairon. The Maia had seen them, too. He’d sat up, but made no further move. Their swords lay with their packs, out of Mairon’s reach and that much farther from Maeglin. Not that they would have helped much against crossbows.

The largest Orc stepped closer. “Lieutenant, our Lord commands your immediate return to Angband. Come along quietly, or we’ll kill the boy.”

Mairon didn’t answer immediately, but turned until he spotted Maeglin. His eyes were wide with fear.

A calm focus settled over Maeglin. If Mairon couldn’t save them, it was all on him. They were outnumbered. They were weaponless. But if they were deep enough into the forest, they might not be without allies. He remembered the way Mairon’s werewolf spirits had devoured his offering before, and he reached out with osánwë, sending his whispered words into the woods in every direction, hoping they could somehow hear. “Wolves, good wolves, your master needs you. Please, if you’re here, help us and destroy our foes.”

A rustling in the leaves around them was all Maeglin heard before the Orcs started screaming. Three of them appeared to be melting, a writhing mass of maggots gnawing away at their limbs. While the others stared in horror, Mairon leapt into motion, the great golden wolf ripping out their throats before they could take aim again. It was over in moments. An eerie howl went up, and Mairon threw back his head and joined in.

“You summoned my wolves?” Mairon asked as he shifted back and cleaned the Orc blood from his mouth. Maeglin turned away when he started licking it off his fingers. The thought of breakfast lost all appeal.

“I just—”

“I didn’t think you had it in you.” Mairon dragged his toe through scraps of metal and bone, all that remained of an Orc the ghostly wolves had eaten alive.

He had done that, Maeglin realized. He had known exactly how horribly they would die and had called the wolves on them anyway. He swallowed hard as his stomach threatened to empty itself. “It was the only thing I could think of.”

That was respect in the Maia’s eyes. He wasn’t sure if it made him feel better or worse. “They wouldn’t obey just anyone. Have you ever considered studying necromancy? I think you may find yourself well-suited.”

Maeglin shook his head, aghast, but Mairon didn’t seem to notice his distress.

A cluster of yellow eyes was floating near Mairon’s side, and he gave them a warm look. “Draugluin,” Mairon murmured. “You were always my strongest and best.” He sighed and beckoned to Maeglin. “We need to make haste. If they followed procedure, they’ll have sent a messenger to report our position before they approached. More will come before long.”


Leave a Comment

Chapter 13

Read Chapter 13

“We can’t go directly over the Ered Gorgoroth, not without a great deal of supplies and preparation, however much I might like to hide our trail there.” Mairon was scratching a rough map in the dirt, though Maeglin had a decent idea of the area. They’d pushed long into the daylight hours, putting as many miles as possible between themselves and their pursuers. “We might try the pass here, to the west—”

“It would be an excellent place to trap us,” Maeglin interrupted. It would take them so close to Gondolin, and if he were to slip away from Mairon there, he could reach the Gates, and be home. I won’t make Naneth’s error, he swore to himself. I am not leading enemies to the door. I am not giving them any more than they already took. Besides…I told Mairon he wouldn’t be alone.

“It is a risk,” Mairon agreed, watching him closely. “You would have us traverse the mountains where they’re lower in the east? I doubt it will be any easier to skirt Nan Dungortheb from that side.”

Maeglin took Mairon’s stick and drew the beginnings of his route. “We won’t have to follow its edges too long. We’ll come out closer…” He hesitated, his hand in the air above the depiction of Himlad. “Mairon? I do want you to come with me. I hope you will. But before I take you where I’m going…” He didn’t want to finish, didn’t want to have to say it at all, but he’d gone over the possibilities again and again, and he couldn’t see another way. I’m not my father, he reminded himself. That’s why I’m asking first.

“Well?”

Maeglin bit his lip and glanced nervously at the Maia, wishing he had a better idea of what would anger him. “I want you to be very sure this is what you want, because once you enter my lands and I take up my birthright, I won’t permit you to leave again. I can’t risk you changing your mind and running back to Morgoth and revealing the only safe place I have.” He closed his eyes. Turgon would be laughing at him if he could hear him now. So, surely, would his father.

When he looked up again, Mairon wore a mocking smile. “I don’t think you could actually stop me. But I’ll do as you wish. Really, you only had to say so.”

He should have known Mairon wouldn’t take him seriously. “Granted, I don’t know for certain that my forest wards will hold you. But I’m fairly confident they will. You won’t have a choice once you’re there.”

Mairon tilted his head. “I don’t think you understand. Set whatever bounds you wish; enforce them as you please. You can do whatever you want with me.”

“Why would you say that? I don't...own you. I don’t know why you would—”

“Maeglin.” His name dripped like honey from the Maia’s lips. “Don’t you get it? You won.”

“I don’t know what you mean.”

“Were those not the terms of our wager? If you had joined me in Angband, you would have been my servant. Yet here I am instead following you into the wilderness with nothing at all to my name; you won, and so I am yours. I will hold myself to our agreement as surely as I would have held you.”

It felt like some awful joke, but when Maeglin’s silence stretched too long, the Maia shrugged elegantly.

“I didn’t realize you needed it explained as if to a new-weaned child. Do you want me to swear to you or something?”

Maeglin scowled but didn’t acknowledge the insult. He’d accepted many vows of loyalty as Lord of his House, but to do so now felt dangerous and weighted with the sense of doom that had hung over him since his capture. “I’ll expect your word to suffice.”

Immediately he doubted his choice. What if Mairon knew no Finwëan would demand an oath, and he’d counted on that for a bluff? What if an oath was the only thing that might constrain him? Did swearing to one’s lord even fall into the same category? It would from him to me. It would have to. Not to mention Mairon was already breaking whatever vows he’d made to Morgoth. How many threads of fate might already be tangled around them?

Mairon nodded briefly and said no more. He seemed as uncomfortable as Maeglin was.

“We’re headed here.” Maeglin stabbed the spot in the dirt. “Nan Elmoth. It’s a very old forest, just across the river Celon.” He drew in the river and laid out the rest of their course.

“Nan Elmoth. That’s where Melian found her little…” He trailed off, glancing at Maeglin. “Ahh. You mean to bind me with the last scraps of her power.”

“You say that as if it were a fading memory, not something that lives and breathes and grows in every root and limb.”

“We could have taken the heart of Taur-nu-Fuin, where my power has seeped into the land.”

Maeglin noticed he didn’t mention the tower he’d held before the fight he lost with Huan. “Where we’ve already been nearly captured? How exactly would it hide us from Morgoth?”

“Stop calling him that,” Mairon grumbled. With the point of a nail he drew a spider in the borders of Nan Dungortheb. “Her power and mine have never played nicely together. This sounds most unpleasant.”

“You can still choose not to follow me. I’ll release you from my service. I’m not going to force you into a situation you don’t want.”

Mairon just looked at him. “So unpleasant. You can hardly imagine.”

*

They didn’t let themselves grow lax about keeping watch again, though the pace Mairon set was demanding, and they both wearied. Nightmares haunted Maeglin throughout their crossing of the mountains, and strange shapes flickered in the corners of his vision and whispered on the wind, but whenever Maeglin turned his head, he saw nothing.

“Don't stray from my sight,” was all Mairon would say when he mentioned them.

Huge webs choked the trees of Nan Dungortheb, and Maeglin couldn't shake the memories of his mother's steadying smile through the battles they fought there together on their desperate flight. Every time he closed his eyes he felt like he might open them again and see her just ahead, beckoning him on, and all that had happened since would disappear like a bad dream. But every time there was only Mairon, sniffing out the best trail or hacking through the dense tangle with his sword. He proved more practiced in the wiles of spiders than Maeglin would have guessed. Only one managed to creep upon them unawares, and it was quickly dispatched between a blast of flame from Mairon and Maeglin's black blade.

It was almost too easy, Maeglin thought as they descended towards the rolling foothills of Dor Dínen and the open country of Himlad beyond. Once across the river Aros, they'd be more exposed, but the few copses of trees and brush would hide them during daylight hours, and they'd travel swiftly by night until they reached the Celon and on its far banks, the safety of Nan Elmoth. That, at least, was their plan.

Maeglin recalled Himlad as a blur of painful light and the uncomfortable sensation that he might fall off the face of the earth into the vastness of the unbound sky. He had closed his eyes for long stretches and let his horse run after his mother's, until the motion made him sick to his stomach and he'd had to peek out again from the depths of his hood. By starlight the journey was easier, though the night was so radiantly clear Maeglin feared it gave little protection. Mairon kept pausing to sniff the air, though when Maeglin asked what he sought, he shook his head.

“Something doesn't feel right,” he said at last. “I don't know what it is. Be on guard.”

Maeglin loosened Anguirel in its sheath and scanned the horizons. They passed a flattened wallow in the grass where a herd of elk had been recently sleeping—Mairon claimed they'd been there less than an hour ago—but they must have awoken and fled. Maeglin wondered what could spook a full-grown elk in the dead of night. Nothing moved on the plains. In the distance an owl cried, breaking the eerie quiet, once, twice, and was suddenly cut off.

“How certain are you that nothing can follow us into Nan Elmoth? Can we risk having enemies on our tail?”

Maeglin answered as silently as he was asked. “Unless the Dark Foe himself besets us or they've brought an army, the forest will hide us.”

Mairon's ears twitched at the title. “Then we run for it?”

“We run.”

Mairon picked up his pace.

Dawn was nearing. Maeglin first noticed the red glare of flame kindled behind them. Pounding footsteps followed soon after and spurred them on. They’d been sighted. A Balrog rode toward them astride a massive steed, towering over the Orc wolf-riders around him. Stealing glances over his shoulder, Maeglin couldn't decide if the creature were more reptilian or some of kind of twisted bear. He supposed it wouldn’t matter which if he came in contact with its dagger-like claws. More Orcs kept swelling the pack as scattered riders caught up to the main force.

They were drawing inexorably closer, and the sunlight didn't seem to slow them. Mairon was wearying; though his paws flew faster than ever, his breath was ragged and harsh, and Maeglin didn't know how much he might have left. The Balrog was closing in. The heat of his body distorted the air, making everything around them shimmer. The Balrog’s whip cracked over them. Mairon jerked and cried out, but his steps did not falter. A black line was seared across his flank and hip. Maeglin clutched his sword tighter.

Ahead light glimmered on the water of the Celon. “There, that's the ford! We just have to get across.”

“I hope you’re right.” Somewhere Mairon found a little more speed. Maeglin lay flat against his neck, clinging with his knees and shifting his weight to where he would hinder Mairon the least. The whip cracked again, deafening, so close Maeglin could feel its flames. Mairon hurled himself over the river. It was a mighty leap, but he fell short of the far bank. He yelped sharply when his body hit the water, deeper than it had appeared, and he stumbled and went down. Red locks spilled around him, a wolf no longer. Maeglin had already found his footing, but Mairon couldn’t seem to get his head above the water. Every time he tried, the current pulled him back under.

“Come on, we’re almost there!” He got his shoulder under Mairon’s arm and heaved him up.

Mairon gasped a shuddery, pained breath and coughed up the water he’d inhaled.

“I’ve got you, hold on.” Wading was difficult with the Maia weighing him down, but their foes had stopped short at the river’s edge. Ignoring the sharp ache running from his hands into his arms, Maeglin dragged him up the bank over gnarled roots that held the earth and into the shadow of Nan Elmoth. Laying his palms to the roots around him, Maeglin struggled to calm himself enough to focus on the trees. “I need any time you can buy me.”

Mairon was still coughing, but he nodded and staggered to his feet. “Gothmog!” he shouted across the river. His voice was a hoarse croak, but Maeglin shuddered at the raw fury it held. “If our friendship was ever more to you than mere words, you will cease this chase and leave me be.”

Singing softly without words, Maeglin half listened while he nudged his mind against the trees on the riverbank. They were sluggish and sleepy and grew cross at his frantic attempts to rouse them. On the other bank, the Orcs were squabbling, reluctant to set foot in the water after it had nearly drowned their former Lieutenant.

“Mairon…I've ever been your friend. That hasn't changed.”

“The burn on my side suggests otherwise.”

“I'm sorry about that, but I have orders. They're what's best for you, too. Please. Just listen.”

“There is nothing left to say. I'm not going back.”

“I know things have been rough since…the Lúthien incident. I know. I've seen how he's treated you, and…it was a lot. But he’s hardest on you because he expects the most from you. Because he values you above anyone. Because he loves you, Mairon. How many times have you reminded me punishment is how you get the best out of people? You wouldn't want him to ask for less than your best.”

Mairon was shaking his head. “It's not about that.”

“It'll be hard, coming home, but I'll be there to help you get through it. I promise. And when you're restored to his favor, it will all be worth it. I'm here because he wants you back.”

“And what about where he stands in my favor? What then? When are the wrongs and the broken promises from him to me to be repaid?”

Maeglin sank deeper, finally past the sensations of rough bark and thorn that were all he could find at first. A heavy, despair-laden grief weighed upon him as if the air had turned to bitter syrup, slowing every movement and thought.

“He is gone. Our protector. Stir us not.”

Maeglin saw a figure who could only be his father, but instead of what he knew, harsh words and harsher strikes for any failure, in the trees’ memory he was a being of gentle hands, of nurture and of healing, of starlight sung down and sweet waters poured. The disjunction made him feel sick. “Please, I need your help. For his sake.”

“He left and never returned. There is nothing good in this world anymore. The airs and the waters are poison and our little ones do not grow. Why should we move for anyone?”

“Is it this…this pet you're so fond of?" Gothmog continued. "I'm sure it hurts to lose him, but I'll help you find another, just as soon as everything's calmed down again. You said he's a smith, yeah? We’ll have so much fine Noldorin stock to pick through once Gondolin’s taken, and his Majesty in a good mood again—”

“I'm not sure they're as interchangeable as all that.” Mairon's tone was cutting and dry, and he sounded in consummate control, but Maeglin could see the tremor in his hands from where he knelt, and he wondered how much longer the Maia would be able to stand.

“Look. For you, Mairon, if he means that much, I will pretend I never saw the boy. He's not here. Maybe he slipped from you in Angband, you only followed to recapture him, you never found him. Whatever story pleases you, that's what happened. He can live, orders be damned. That's the best I can do for you, but you'll have it.”

Maeglin tried not to listen to the little thrill of fear that wondered if such an offer would be enough. “I have returned. I am his son. The little one who played beneath your branches. I have sung to honor you and offered you my blood. I have come to take my place as his heir. I will make the little ones grow again.” It was a big promise, but if he couldn't keep it, the trees wouldn't have him anyway. He dug up every happy memory of his childhood he could find and shared them, all the times he'd stared up in awe and wonder at the ancient forest, every time his father had showed him how to strengthen his bond with their home. He found himself murmuring his familiar childhood rhyme,

“Oak and beech whose branches sway

Where only starlight touches loam

Hear me, hide me, guide my way

Shelter me and bring me home.”

He had no idea when he'd started singing it or how many times he'd repeated the words. It felt natural in his mouth, as if he were an elfling again, roaming the wood unafraid of any predator or straying Orc.

Mairon and Gothmog were arguing fiercely, but Maeglin didn't hear what they said. Gothmog began directing the Orcs into the water. It didn't matter now. Nan Elmoth’s recognition was sweeping through him, washing him in coolness and peace. “Sharp-eyed child of the forest. We remember. You've come home. You've come home.”

A thick mist rose on the river, obscuring all sight. Anyone who walked into it, Maeglin knew, would find their steps turned against them and their paths confused. With luck, their pursuers would forget they'd ever seen the place. He sighed in relief. It would hold a few days at least, and by then he could journey into the forest’s heart and claim his lordship.

“Come,” he told Mairon, hauling himself wearily upright. “We shouldn't rest until we've gone farther in.”


Leave a Comment

Chapter 14

Read Chapter 14

The house still stood deep in the middle of the forest, overgrown with ivy and moss. Some of the slates on the roof had been knocked loose, and the window sashes sagged. The door hung open, lopsided on its hinges, and Maeglin wondered if Eöl had left it that way in his haste to hunt them down. Surely Cwileg, who’d looked after the horses and helped Eöl in the forge, would have closed it up? Or Brôg, who’d burned charcoal from fallen limbs and taught him the names of mushrooms? They must have left long ago when Eöl never came home; Maeglin hadn’t expected to find Eöl's tiny handful of followers living here in isolation after so many years, so he wasn’t disappointed when he saw how thoroughly abandoned the place was. It was fine. They'd never so much as suggested to Eöl that perhaps he shouldn't hit his child, so Maeglin didn't miss them.

Maeglin set down his pack and carefully stretched. They’d slept beneath the dense, dark branches of a yew, in the hollow of its roots. Clad in wolf fur, Mairon had curled around Maeglin and kept him warm. He'd whimpered continually in his sleep, and Maeglin knew his wounds must hurt, though he said nothing of them. Maeglin himself had woken with his ribs aching so fiercely he could barely breathe, and his hands and arms had only gotten worse. It should probably be concerning, he thought, that his left hand, that had never been broken, hurt so much too, but he brushed it aside. They were safe now, and they both had time to heal.

As he walked around the cottage, Maeglin pulled aside the vines to peer into the mostly-intact windows and inspect the walls underneath. It seemed reasonably weatherproof, despite the passing of years.

“Aren't we going inside?” Mairon asked when he made no move to cross the threshold.

Maeglin sighed. He could put it off no longer, though he had little wish to gaze once more upon the stage where most of his worst memories had played out. Well. Perhaps he could allow Angband to vie for that honor. “I’d like to burn the whole place down.”

“Where else could we go? I can’t…I might get through the winter as a wolf, but I can't sustain us both, and—”

“No—I'm not going to do it. I just wish I could.” He swept the hanging cobwebs aside and shoved back the door. The hinges needed repair, but the wood was sound. “This house was so full of pain.”

“Are things of pain only fit to be cast away, then?” Mairon murmured.

Maeglin reached for his hand and squeezed it. “Sometimes they just need to be aired out and scrubbed well.”

Mairon's lips twisted into a smile, and he let Maeglin pull him inside. A thick layer of dust covered everything. It smelled musty and earthen, but no note lingered of the sharp metallic cologne Eöl had often worn. Maeglin breathed in deeply. He didn't know how he would have managed if the place still smelled like him. This, he could handle.

“How long's it been since you were here?” Mairon asked, eyeing the desiccated remnants of someone's last meal with distaste.

“About a hundred years. I was a child still when my mother and I fled, though I thought myself very wise and grown.”

A bird had built its nest in one of the bookshelves. Or several generations of birds, from the amount of dung heaped beneath it.

“Where’s a battalion of orcs when you need one?” Mairon grumbled. “Fire might be preferable to this much cleaning.”

“We don't have to do it all at once.” Maeglin peered into the kitchen, taking note of all the corners that might still hold preserved food. “We just need to make a little space habitable enough to start with.”

Heading up the stairs, he walked down the hall and opened the door to what had once been his bedroom. All was as he'd left it those many years ago, in one sense. Time had left its mark here too. He'd never made his bed the day they escaped, and the thrown-back covers were moth-eaten and shredded by mice that had made their home in his pillows. He lifted the edge of the mattress and dumped the mess on the floor. The mattress itself seemed intact, at least enough to work with.

The trunk at the foot of his bed was sealed, and when he lifted the lid, he found the enchantments had held. Digging through the contents, he found his thickly-woven winter coverlet, the colorful quilts he had helped his mother piece, lengths of fine wool fabric and pale green forest linen spun from nettles. He remembered the day Aredhel had tucked them away, teasingly swearing she wasn't cutting new clothes for him again until he finally stopped growing. He tried to breathe through the knot in his chest. She'd want him to have them now. Wouldn't she? Or would she be disappointed that he’d returned in the end, unable to escape the shadow of the trees that had bound her? At the bottom of the trunk, where he'd tucked it away when he decided he was too old to keep it on his bed, was the toy moth she'd stitched for him with embroidered silken wings. He took it out and sat back heavily. He was too big now to wrap himself in the wings like the whisper of her hug, but he held it against his heart and let his tears fall.

Mairon, who had stood in the doorway watching, approached quietly and sat beside him. He reached to take Maeglin's hand, but stopped when he flinched from the touch. Even that light pressure was too much.

“I'm sorry,” Maeglin murmured. “It just hurts. All the time. It's not you.”

“Don't. It's fine.” He put his arms around Maeglin instead, moving carefully, and though he seemed distant and uncertain, Maeglin found it comforting all the same. “Thought you didn't miss this place.”

“I miss her. My mother. I…miss the times we were happy. Before I learned what kind of person my father really was.” He thought of how the trees remembered Eöl, and the early mornings, before he had a name he could be called aloud, when his father had sat at his bedside, singing soft lullabies and telling him stories of forest creatures until he slept. “Sometimes I even miss him, and then I feel like a terrible person who's betraying my mother’s memory.”

“I think I know what you mean.” Mairon did not elaborate.

“He used to lock me in my room, right here, sometimes for nights at a time, when I'd displeased him. He threatened to put me in shackles if I ever tried to see my mother's family, and I never doubted for a moment he'd do it.” Maeglin didn't know why he told the Maia these things. After his first mistake or two, he never spoke of them in Gondolin; he'd learned quickly that much of his childhood horrified people, but then he’d be treated like some strange object of pity or told his father's deeds were bad enough without him making up more. To Mairon…it probably wasn't half of what he accepted as proper.

“There…are other rooms, are there not? You don't have to take your old one again if it makes you uncomfortable.”

Maeglin glanced up. Mairon's brow was furrowed in concentration and concern. Feeling lighter, he let himself lean back against Mairon's chest, knowing Mairon would hold him. “It was mine, though. And no one will ever lock me away again.”

Mairon pressed him closer. “No. Not while I live.”

Maeglin thought he could rest there forever, but the day wouldn't last. “We’ll fix up a place to sleep here, and then we'll clean out the kitchen and get the fireplace in working order. You can go through my parents’ room—the one at the end of the hall—and see what there is to salvage later if you want. I don't think I can go in there.”

Mairon nodded. “Let me see how you're healing.”

Maeglin held out his right hand, grateful for the gentleness of his touch. Out came the little tin of salve, and Mairon sang softly as he massaged it into Maeglin's skin.

“The bones are knitting together well,” he announced with a hint of forced brightness. “I did a good, clean job putting you back together. There's no swelling, no scarring. You've been under a lot of strain in the course of our journey, but I think you'll finish healing up swiftly now, and the pain should go away soon.”

“Thank you.” Maeglin said nothing of the pain in his left hand or his chest. That was probably the strain, too. “I would never have guessed you a healer.”

“You learn much in the course of reshaping living creatures.” Mairon shrugged as if the words did not bring visions of torture and vivisection to life in Maeglin's mind. “Plenty of healing required there. And…my master’s—Lord Melkor's—his hands were never well again, after the Silmarils. I spent a great deal of time on research to aid him, little use though it was.” He stared down, all of his put-on cheerfulness dropping away. “That was one of my great failures too. I haven't Estë's gifts; I can't restore what is destroyed. I can amplify and guide the effects of medicines; I can speed what the body would do on its own. That wasn’t enough for him. It wasn't…I wasn’t good enough. I've always wondered, if I could have spared him his pain…maybe I wouldn't have lost him.” He sighed and met Maeglin's eyes. “You’re an easier case, thankfully.”

“I did see how careful you were to protect my hands. I…I know you did what you did to get me out of there.” Mairon bore plenty of blame still, but he could recognize that much and be grateful.

Mairon raised Maeglin's hands to his lips and laid a delicate kiss to his fingertips. “Of course. You’re an artist.”

They spent the day sweeping and scrubbing the floor, wiping away the dust, tearing down tattered curtains, emptying the disintegrating feathers from Maeglin's mattress, washing the heavy cover, and gathering armfuls of hanging moss to dry for fresh stuffing. Maeglin was barely standing by the time they finished, but he didn't want to look like he was refusing his fair share of the work, so he forced himself to keep going. They had to have a clean place to sleep; everything else could wait, but he couldn't abide the smell of dust and mice coating his throat all night. By the time they started scrounging though the remains of the pantry, Maeglin's hands were shaky, and he was having a hard time focusing on Mairon's words.

“Sit,” Mairon told him sharply. “You've done enough. Tell me if there's anything likely to be worth looking through.”

“There should be.” Maeglin rubbed his eyes. When was the last time he’d actually eaten? Had it been before they reached the plains…? “Eöl was always afraid of being cut off from trade and kept under pressure from Angband. Or the Noldor. He had stores put up to last a long time. The…the stone tubs, at the base of the shelves.”

Mairon found them and pushed back a heavy lid. Sacks of glistening grains and nuts filled most of the space, with smaller amounts of other foods, dried or salted or cured tucked alongside. Mairon broke a chunk of maple sugar off a hardened slab and handed it to Maeglin. “Start with that.”

He remembered buckets after buckets and walking for miles with the weight of sap on his shoulders and songs around the fires that burned all night and day to boil the sugar down every winter’s end. He didn't know if he could do it on his own. “It will be hard to get more.”

“Yes. Eat it anyway.”

Maeglin didn't think anything had ever tasted so good. It revived him, if only a little, but Mairon insisted he stay put. Mairon ground enough barley to mix into some thin round cakes he baked on a flat stone outside, and they sat by the fire eating them with blackberry jam that was even more precious than the sugar, since Aredhel had made it the summer before she died. The night was loud with the song of crickets and cicadas. Nightingales had sung here once, but though Maeglin listened for them, he didn’t hear any now. Without them the woods felt hollow and queer. Soon enough, the year would fade, and they’d need to put up all the food they could before then. Eöl's old stores would sustain them for a while, but he didn't want to use them all and be left with nothing. There was the work of tending the forest, and he couldn't delay taking Eöl's place in it any longer; the trees wouldn’t sustain their goodwill long if he didn't do his part. At some point he'd have to open the forge and see what supplies there might be to work with, and find out if anyone was left alive to trade with in the wasteland Morgoth had made--

“What is it?” Mairon murmured. “You look horribly overwhelmed all of a sudden.”

“There's so much to do.” The thought of it made him immeasurably tired.

“We’ll get there. A little at a time, like you said.”

With the mattress taken apart and drying over several tree branches, they settled into a nest of blankets on the floor. Maeglin lay with his eyes wide open, staring up into the familiar rafters he'd thought he'd left forever. Part of him couldn't help listening for raised voices downstairs, despite knowing he wouldn't hear them unless it was in his dreams. Mairon was pressed comfortably against him, though Maeglin noticed how gingerly he positioned himself to protect the whip burn on his side. His hand slid under Maeglin's shirt. Maeglin sighed softly at the caress. It felt good just to be touched like this, as if it soothed some long-standing, desperate wound he hadn’t realised he carried. Distantly he marveled at how easily he let his torturer near him; surely he ought to shrink away in terror. Maybe there was something wrong with him. He'd always suspected it.

Mairon's hand dipped lower, under his waist band, and wrapped around his cock.

“Wait, what are you doing?!” His cock was already hardening, and the sharp arousal heating in him was not altogether pleasant or welcome. He put his hand over Mairon's to still him, but he didn't push him away.

“Shh, you don't have to do anything. Just let me please you.”

“I don't—I…” It wasn't that Mairon had become any less alluring or irresistible, but he hadn’t figured out quite how he felt about him, and they were both hurting and weary, and if he used the wrong words, Mairon would turn away, cold and rejected, and he didn’t want that—

“You need to relax and get to sleep. It'll help.”

“But…”

“I can use my mouth if you like,” he purred. “I’m very skilled; I'm certain you'll enjoy it.”

“Are you offering because you really want to, or because you think you need to please me?”

“Is there a difference?” He said it lightly, as if in jest, but Maeglin felt the puzzlement and irritation underneath.

“Yes. Yes, there is, and you need to understand it if we're going to do this. In the future, when we both actually feel up to it.” Gently he removed Mairon's hand and twined their fingers together instead.

They lapsed into awkward silence for a while. Maeglin’s body resented the loss of promised pleasure, and he half wished Mairon was elsewhere so he could take care of himself quickly and find oblivion, but the prospect of lying in the dark alone was worse than any thwarted desire.

“I don't know what you want from me,” Mairon murmured low and anguished against his cheek. “I don't know what you want me to be to you.”

“What do you want to be?”

“I don't know!” He rolled onto his back, putting a little distance between them. His golden eyes glowed softly in the darkness. “I've been his Lieutenant for so long. I don't think you need a Dread Lieutenant, Master of Torment, Lord of Werewolves, and Bringer of Order to the Pits of Despair.”

Maeglin's heart was in his throat. It had been easy to forget, in the course of traveling side by side, that his friend, petulant and caring in turns, was a preternatural being of such immense power, accustomed to unquestioned command. What was he thinking, asking him to be content with a life of bare survival in an abandoned house in the woods? He chose this, he reminded himself. He chose me. “I do not,” he answered carefully. “But I do need the companion who would argue smithcraft with me for hours. I need the brave and clever wolf who set me free and delivered me through many dangers. I hope I may have the friend who showed me his grief and pain and allowed me to help.”

Mairon made a small sound of disbelief at this, but he did not interrupt.

“I hope…” Maeglin wasn’t sure he could give voice to the next words. Setting himself so high could only lead to an equally great fall. But the darkness and the warmth of the Maia nestled at his side made him bold; hadn’t Mairon seen him at his most pathetic already, and had not turned away? “I hope I might have the one who treasured me enough to leave everything, and that I might treasure him in turn.”

“Oh, little sweetheart…” Mairon gently stroked his thumb along Maeglin's jaw.

“You are all those things already,” Maeglin whispered. “You don't have to be anything else. You don't have to be anything you aren't. I wouldn't ask it; I know how much it hurts—”

Mairon was leaning in, and Maeglin did not stop him as he closed the distance with a soft kiss.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 15

Read Chapter 15

When Maeglin woke up, he thought he was back in Angband. Only the dim greenish light filtering through the windows they'd uncovered assured him he wasn’t. Everything hurt. He wanted to cry, but that would tense up his chest and require deeper breaths than he could manage, and it would only make things worse. Mairon had already risen, so there was nothing for it but to lay still, making each breath as small as he could, unable to think of anything but pain.

Finally Mairon poked his head into the room. “Are you going to come down for breakfast? I've cleaned the chimney and gathered some firewood. Only fallen limbs, like you said.”

“I'm not…entirely…sure I want to move.” His voice was even more faint than usual. He waited for a cross demand that he speak up, but it seemed the Maia heard him well enough. Mairon crossed the room and sat beside him.

“What's wrong?”

“I hurt all over. It hurts to breathe.”

“Oh, is that it? I'm sure it's been a while since you've worked as hard as we did yesterday. You had me worried! We’ll take it easier for the next couple of days, all right?”

“I don't—”

“Come on, sore muscles will feel better once you're moving.” Mairon took Maeglin's hand to pull him up but dropped it at Maeglin's pained gasp.

Maeglin glared. “You think I've never overworked myself?” he hissed. “You think I don't know what a little soreness feels like? This is something else.”

Mairon was quiet for a long moment. “You've been through a lot these last weeks,” he said at last. “I don't think we should go jumping to conclusions.”

You're the one with conclusions, Maeglin thought, but he turned his face away and did not answer.

“I'm willing to wait on you if that's what you want, you know. You only had to say so.”

It wasn't merely the casual assumption that Maeglin must be exaggerating to get his way that filled him with rage. It was something in the smug assurance with which Mairon said it—as if he found the very idea both titillating and perverse.

“I didn't,” Maeglin snarled, and he tore himself up, ignoring how his body screamed. He stumbled on the stairs and caught himself sharply. Halfway down he had to stop and sit, his head spinning and his vision full of stars. He laid his head on his knees and waited for the dizziness to pass. Of course he couldn't expect real sympathy out of Mairon. The cure for whatever he was experiencing in Angband would surely be the whip. Maeglin wondered how long he would have survived in the place of someone like Lord Rog. Not very, he suspected. He'd never possessed that kind of strength. And yet he had survived, and Rog was probably going to die, along with everyone else he knew. The little he'd done to circumvent it was laughably insufficient when it was his fault for going outside the boundaries in the first place. He gave way to weeping at last and wished he hadn’t been right about how much it hurt.

A cold, wet nose pressed into the back of his neck. Maeglin turned and met wolf-Mairon's golden eyes. Mairon gently but insistently pushed his head under Maeglin’s arm until he got it around his neck. Sighing, Maeglin wiped his eyes and let Mairon help him up. Leaning on the wolf, he made it to the kitchen, where he found hot herbal tea and a bowl of porridge kept warm for him on the hearth. He nearly dropped the cup when he picked it up. Trying to hold back more tears, he cradled his hands against his chest. Massaging them didn't help; the pressure of his fingers on his skin only made the pain worse.

Tilting his head, the wolf huffed and transformed back. Mairon rummaged around until he found a smaller cup and poured some of the tea over. “Can you manage this one?”

Maeglin accepted it warily, but it was light enough to hold, if not quite comfortably. “Yes. Thanks.” The warmth was soothing, at least. He traced the old familiar patterns in the rough glaze.

“You're angry with me.”

“I—” Stars above, he couldn't afford to annoy him now. “I think I'm mostly scared.” It was true enough, and he didn't have to fight through an explanation of how dismissive Mairon’s words had felt.

Mairon nodded slowly. “Tell me what you want.”

For you not to make light of this, Maeglin thought. “I need you to help me into the forest today. I can't put off presenting myself if we want its protection to last.”

“I can do that.” Mairon's expression softened as he watched Maeglin struggle with his spoon. “As soon as you're ready, we can go.”

*

Maeglin clung to the back of the golden wolf, directing him between ancient, massive trees. He was thoroughly sick of riding, but he knew the walk was beyond him. Although he felt steadier after eating, holding himself upright took effort, and he ended up draping himself over Mairon's neck and resting his head in his fur. Evening had fallen when they set out, wending their way along a route Maeglin knew by heart. Mairon shuddered when branches brushed over him, but he didn't complain. They stopped at a little rill that welled up into a pool cut from the bedrock before trickling along its rocky path. A series of steps led down to its edge, hollowed by the tread of feet over many long-years. Maeglin knelt at the bottom and washed his hands and face in the cold clear water before drinking deeply of it. So had Eöl done every time he brought Maeglin to make his offerings.

Maeglin took a deep breath, observing how his ribs crackled and ached, and a quiet feeling settled over his shoulders. It wasn’t peace, he thought. Fate inescapable, perhaps, that could only be accepted. Whether he liked it or not, he followed his father's footsteps now. Rising, he dipped a cup into the water and rejoined Mairon. He walked the last short distance, with Mairon supporting his weight when he began to falter or paused to rest.

Long ago, a glade in the heart of Nan Elmoth had welcomed the starlight, but long ago still the trees had grown together over it, dense and dark and secretive above two lovers who stood entranced, and to this place Maeglin came. The boles of the trees were so vast that all the lords of Gondolin might not have reached around them. Maeglin laid his hands upon them one by one as he passed, whispering names his father had taught him as a child. Just ahead, a little space opened between the trees. As Maeglin stepped forward, Mairon sneezed. Maeglin glanced back. He sneezed again, and again, until he was tossing his head and pawing at his nose. Finally he gave up and changed shape, wiping his nose and his streaming eyes on the tail of his tunic. Maeglin reached up and thumbed away a trickle of blood from his upper lip.

“You don’t have to stay if it’s going to be uncomfortable,” he murmured. “I’ll let you know when I’m done here.”

Mairon held the back of his hand to his nose and frowned when it came away bloody. “Even now Melian will have her due. Ugh. It’s fine; I’d like to see how this goes. Unless you command me.”

Maeglin shook his head and leaned in to kiss his cheek. It took little effort to slip once more into the space where the trees filled his mind with their presence. He arranged himself in their midst with quiet care, on his knees between the roots of an ancient oak, a yew, and a beech where they grew intertwined. He poured the water he’d brought upon the earth, then took his knife and pricked his finger. Three drops of bright red blood followed, glistening as the dark earth drank them in. Softly he wove himself into the forest’s song. Nan Elmoth knew the child who had offered his blood so many times before, whispering prayers into tree bark and moving with silent grace through the dim twilight. Nan Elmoth welcomed him.

Maeglin sang of his father, not as he remembered in house and forge, but as he’d watched him silently under leaf and bough. He sang of his father’s love for the forest, for green nighttimes and the slow heartbeat of rising sap and spreading branches. He sang of responsibility, of protection, of nurture, of exchange. He sang of himself as his father’s heir, filling the place he’d left empty, taking up his promises. And the forest replied. Maeglin felt a rush of wind in the treetops and stirring roots underground. The forest sang of careful hands, of one whose heart beat in time with swelling buds and twining mycorrhizae. Of shelter. Of a guardian. Of one who was no longer separate, but dwelt within the forest and whom the forest dwelt within. And Maeglin opened himself, and sang yes.

It was as if his eyes and ears had been closed all his life, and only now opened. As simply as a candle being lit, his awareness extended to the edge of the forest and encompassed all within it. He could hear the rustle of every insect, the cry of every bird. He knew the path of each root that crept underground and the taste of the minerals they sipped as surely as if they were threaded within his body. He felt the weight of moonglow on a million leaves as if it were his skin it warmed. It was too much to take in, and yet it felt as natural, as inexorable as breathing. The forest breathed with him.

Maeglin didn't know how long he knelt there, his fingers sunk into soft loam, flooded with the beauty and immensity of all he perceived. Part of him laughed at the thought that the same spell that caught Melian and Thingol as they gazed into each other's eyes might hold him now in its grip, and he wondered if it would be such a bad thing to let long-years pass outside while he knew only rapture. Maybe time would bear his troubles away.

But Aredhel's son was not so lucky, and pain and weariness brought him back to himself before the night faded. Above his head a single nightingale flew, trilling its song, and disappeared into the thicket. Wincing, Maeglin rose, a bit unsteady and wholly overwhelmed. The forest had settled to a dull roar in the back of his mind. He stretched cautiously and rubbed his aching hands. Mairon stood watching. His eyes shone in the darkness. Turning to him, Maeglin dampened his lips. He wasn’t sure he remembered how to form words at all, much less what he ought to say after something like that.

Mairon had no such uncertainty. He dropped gracefully to one knee and bowed his head. “Little lord,” he breathed.

When he looked up again, Maeglin thought the force of the Maia’s regard was enough to overwhelm him too. He held out a hand, but Mairon hesitated before accepting it. His relief was immediate as Maeglin raised him up.

“I was a bit afraid I’d react badly to you now like I have the rest of the forest.”

“That would've been awful.”

“Yes.” Mairon wound a hand behind Maeglin's neck and brought their foreheads together. Maeglin's breath caught. “Yes, it would.” His lips traced delicately along the curve of Maeglin's ear, and when he pulled away, Maeglin let out a frustrated whimper. Mairon grinned. “Shall we be heading back?”

Maeglin stooped to examine a patch of aconite where Mairon had stood. Its leaves had become twisted and discolored in the time they’d been there. The moss underfoot was dead. “Do you think this whole place could become like Nan Dungortheb in time?”

“I don't know. I think that came about partly through both Melian and myself expending our powers to protect our lands, not just from our presence near each other. I think what you've done today and your welcome towards me should have an ameliorating effect. But it hasn't exactly been studied, so who can say?” He shifted into the wolf and crouched to help Maeglin onto his back. “Does it bother you, the possibility?”

Maeglin considered. No harm could come to him from the forest, and he thought any strange warping of what grew there could prove a useful deterrent. No one walked into Nan Dungortheb lightly, and no one should walk into his realm without his leave. “No, I don't think it does.”

Mairon's tail wagged, and he leaned his head back to lick Maeglin's face before climbing to his feet.

“There’s one thing I don’t understand,” Maeglin remarked as they drew near the house. He kept coming back to the thought like a sore tooth, poking at it again and again and finding that it still had not ceased to hurt. Mairon flicked an ear toward him. “My father was so loving and tender towards the forest. That's how it remembers him. Like I suppose a father ought to be. But he couldn't, even once, grant that same care to me?”

“Fathers are overrated. You start to show signs of wanting or being something even slightly beyond what they intended, and all of a sudden there's no more care, only blame for becoming your own person. You’re better off without one.”

Maeglin sighed. “I think it makes things worse, knowing he had that capacity and yet somehow I was never worthy of it.”

“He was a fool to think so,” Mairon answered, but there was a plaintive wistfulness to it, and neither spoke again.

*

“Were you really a prince in Gondolin? Can I ask about that now?”

Maeglin was tucked onto a tall-backed wooden bench Mairon had hastily cleaned off with blankets wrapped around him. Mairon sat nearby on the floor, restuffing their mattress with freshly dried moss, but his eyes kept drifting to the bookshelves with their thick tomes and stacks of dusty notes. “I don't see the harm in telling you about myself. But I was a prince, and a lord, and therefore much of what I might say touches on governance and the city itself, and I won't speak of those.”

“Your caution is admirable,” Mairon said with a wry smile. “We—I—Angband already knew there were twelve divisions on the field, if that simplifies matters for you.”

“Mm. I led one of them.”

“Lord of the House of the Mole, yes?” Mairon rolled the words over his tongue as if savoring the taste.

Maeglin shuddered. He couldn’t forget how he’d gasped out his titles before Morgoth.

“It isn’t what I would’ve guessed, you know.” His voice was light, but his searching glance showed he hadn’t missed Maeglin’s reaction. “I’d’ve said precocious young forgemaster, maybe some minor lordling. Not prince of all Gondolin.”

“Why not?”

“A prince shouldn’t want so badly to flee his kingdom.”

“No,” Maeglin murmured. “I suppose not.”

“So if your father was from the forest here…Fingolfin had a daughter, did he not?”

“Aredhel.”

“I remember her. She fought like a whirlwind in some of those earliest battles. I can see it; there’s some of her fierceness in you.”

Maeglin smiled softly. “You think?”

“Now let’s see…who in Gondolin could be miss golden-hair doesn’t-love-you-back? There was a beautiful golden lord fighting under a flower banner on the field of your Nirnaeth. Does he have a little sister, perchance?”

The ease and amusement he'd begun to feel evaporated. “It was Idril. And that's enough about her.”

“Aww, come now, shouldn’t I get to know who my competition is? Trying to move up in the world, were you?”

“She has a husband and a child. And you don't get to joke about them when—”

“Wait. Turgon's daughter has a child? That is the Idril we speak of?”

Shit. “Is that important?”

“They're in grave danger. She and the child both.”

“All of Gondolin is.” Because of you, he added silently, but from Mairon's little flinch, he thought he'd heard him anyway.

“Especially grave danger. Melkor will want the child dead. He fears Turgon's line…Langon will likely have orders to see to it himself. Did you get your message through?”

“I don't know.”

“You should try to make contact again, if you value them.”

*

Maeglin lay on the bed with Mairon curled warmly against his side and the power of Nan Elmoth buzzing under his skin. If he let his consciousness slip out into the approaching dawn, he was surrounded by a million voices—the deep notes of each tree, the fungi that flourished in their roots, the birds in their branches and the frogs singing in the ponds at their feet. A breath of his will was enough to draw on them and bolster him in whatever he chose to do. But that wasn't enough to overcome the distance between him and Idril; she'd closed that door to him firmly. It wasn't enough to grant him connections where he'd never been able to forge them; Turgon wouldn't hear him. He cast a thought toward Salgant, but despite his talent with poetry and words, his friend had never been able to manage much clarity mind to mind. Eärendil, though…Eärendil, who'd climbed in his lap and begged for stories, who jumped in delight every time Maeglin pulled a gemstone from his pocket to give him, Eärendil whose little heart was open to any and all—a six year old child could not be expected to carry a warning. But Maeglin could scare him away from the one who wore his likeness and meant his nephew harm.

Silently he stole into Eärendil’s dreams and began to craft. He brought together the darkest shadows of forests filled with lurking terrors and the sudden dread of finding something he trusted was not what it seemed. He touched the nightmare with the slightest hint of the fear and pain he'd known in Angband, he filled it with threats of horrors and perils to come, and he gave it his own face. He felt Eärendil wake screaming, and he was shoved violently from the boy's head. There would be no more entry. He gasped, coming back to his own surroundings, drained beyond measure. Maybe Idril would take it as a sign. Maybe it would save them all from the viper hiding in their midst. He couldn’t shake the sense that he'd done something he could never take back, though surely that line had been crossed long ago. Eärendil’s wails echoed in his ears. Mairon held him while he cried himself to sleep.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 16

Read Chapter 16

“You've had most of summer and fall.”

“I know.”

They had been preparing dinner together, but Maeglin couldn't finish stirring together the dumplings for the stew, and when he'd dropped the spoon in defeat and started gingerly massaging his aching hand, only to flinch from his own touch, Mairon had sighed and reached for him.

“It should be better by now. Even without my help.”

“I know!” Maeglin had improved, in some ways. His hands hurt a little less, he thought, and he no longer had sharp pains as he had at first. Instead it had mellowed and broadened, settling into a permanent deep ache that twinged around his joints and formed tender knots in his muscles. He felt the peculiar tingle of Mairon's mental probing and braced himself against the complaint he knew was coming.

“I can't find anything. There's nothing there to fix, there's nothing—”

“Don't you dare say nothing’s wrong,” Maeglin hissed.

Mairon glanced up, brimming with frustration, and Maeglin couldn't tell if it was with him or with himself. “It doesn't make sense. I've never seen anything like it.”

“Haven't you?” Maeglin murmured bitterly. He'd spent time of late thinking—or trying not to think—on the people he'd known of with pain that never went away, that no healer could amend. Angband-sickness, they’d whispered in Rog's forges.

“What do you mean by that?” Mairon demanded.

“Just—in all your time in Angband, you never saw this come upon a single thrall? Are you certain?”

Mairon huffed. “Most elves hold up fine. They get worn down and broken with time, sure, but you weren’t there for that long. I know it was a horrible experience, but you were treated fairly gently, as Angband welcomes go. Except for your hand, which I put back.”

Maeglin closed his eyes and bit off the things he wanted to scream. “What about the ones who aren’t fine?”

“There’s always a few who can’t handle it. The weak ones, who aren’t good for anything anyway. They can't keep up, and when they're punished for not working, they don't recover. It isn't worth the resources to nurse them along; they just need to be weeded out. They die in a few weeks or a couple of months at most, and then they're fed to the wolves or the dragons. If I had my records, I could tell you what the average percentage is, but mostly I expect a small amount of loss in any new batch.”

“So you never took the time to find out what happened to them. Or asked what those who lasted longer might be suffering.” Mairon didn't answer, and Maeglin wanted to grab his shoulders and shake him. “And. And you thought, solely because you liked me, respected me even, that I would survive torture with no ill effects? That because you saw me as worthy, there was no way I could be among the weak ones?”

“I…that’s not—” Mairon had at least the decency to look chagrined, but Maeglin was past caring. He turned away, tucking his hands protectively against his chest as if that could make them stop hurting. By the time he'd lived in Gondolin, Rog's folk, those who'd been thralls once, had been nigh three hundred years from their time in captivity or more, and still he remembered those who forged sitting down or who could manage only light work for an hour here or there. He remembered those who didn't show up for days at a time when they had a bad spell. What hope did he have if they were the ones who’d fared better?

After a moment Mairon crept forward and touched his shoulder. “Hey. Don't cry. It's going to be all right.”

“Is it?” He wasn’t crying. He wasn’t.

“At least let me help with your hands. I can do that much.”

Maeglin allowed him to clasp his hands between his palms and flood them with gentle heat. It was the only thing they'd found that helped much, and the effects wore off quickly. “Are you going to do that for everything? My arms, and my elbows, and my shoulders, and my ribs?” His hip had begun bothering him sometimes too; he thought maybe it had been wrenched when he was thrown around by the orcs who’d captured him, but he hated to add it to the list just yet.

“If you need me to.”

“We’ll be here all night,” Maeglin scoffed.

Mairon took a moment to spoon Maeglin's dumplings into the simmering stew, then continued working over his body without a word. Maeglin grew increasingly certain that he'd finally managed to really offend him. It would probably be funny if it weren't so frightening.

“You're different from those others,” Mairon offered quietly after a while.

Maeglin sighed. “Not really. They were people too.”

“I'm sure you just need more time.”

“Yeah.” But he didn’t really believe it, not anymore.

“Why don't we open the smithy tomorrow?” Mairon moved behind Maeglin and started on his shoulders and back, adding careful pressure. Sometimes Maeglin couldn't bear it, but tonight he leaned into the touch, and Mairon deepened it. “We have things in decent shape now; you won’t starve over winter if we spend a little time on something we both enjoy.”

Maeglin's stomach twisted. He shouldn't be having fun when he'd done so little. Gnawing guilt over how much he'd pushed onto Mairon and how much he was simply neglecting had been haunting him as it was. But the smithy might prove a source of income, if there was anyone left to trade with, and they'd need ironwork eventually anyway, so it wasn't wholly frivolous. “All right. I have no idea what might be left by now.”

*

In his dreams, Maeglin was on a battlefield, and an arrow had pierced his hand. Orcs surrounded him, but Mairon himself held the bow. He drew it back to shoot again, and Maeglin was readying himself for a fresh stab of pain when he woke. The pain didn't subside. He'd slept with his hand wedged awkwardly beneath him, and now it was throbbing fiercely. He cursed and rolled over, then glanced outside and cursed again. The sky was dark, and the Moon had already risen.

Maeglin felt sick. He’d slept the day away, after he’d given Mairon a promise. He was still so tired, and everything hurt, and the prospect of dragging himself out to the smithy now, with Mairon angry and annoyed instead of excited was hard to face. How long did he have before Mairon lost patience with him altogether? What happened when whatever spark of talent had drawn the Maia to him disappeared, buried in a grey morass of pain and uselessness? If he couldn't be a fitting lord or a brilliant smith, if he were nothing but an invalid forever, how long would it take for Mairon to cast him aside like all those weak slaves he'd spoken of so disdainfully?

Mairon was sitting at the kitchen table with one of Eöl's thick volumes of metal lore open before him. Maeglin paused in the doorway and watched him turn the parchment page with his fingertips, careful not to touch the lines of ink. He glanced up and back at the page, and Maeglin wished his mind wasn’t so thoroughly closed off.

“I'm sorry! I didn't mean to sleep so late; we can go out to the smithy now if you…”

Mairon waved a hand in dismissal. “Don't worry about it. You're not doing anything without eating first, and I didn't wait for you anyway.”

“You…didn't?”

“I'm sure you needed your rest. I persuaded the lock to open, but I didn't break it, so don't worry about that either.” He pushed a plate toward Maeglin.

“But…we were…” Maeglin choked down the viscous sense of wrongness. This isn't how it's supposed to go. It didn't matter; it didn't matter; it was just a minor change of plans. Rog would have shrugged his shoulders, spat in the dust, and gone on with his day. Salgant would have offered something beautifully poetic about scattered stones or rivers, and it wouldn't have helped, but at least he’d have tried. Maeglin smoothed his face. Mairon had done nothing he shouldn't; he didn't need to put up with Maeglin's discomfort. “I wanted to show you everything myself.”

“I still want to hear what you have to say. I didn't really…mmm. We can walk through it in a bit. But you might want to prepare yourself. It wasn't left in very good condition.”

“What do you mean?!” His father had always kept his forge immaculate.

“Well…maybe it's best to see for yourself. We’ll have some clean-up ahead of us, that's all.”

Apprehensiveness settled in his stomach, ruining what appetite he had left, and it only got worse when he took the smithy key from the nail above the door where it had hung untouched for decades. The lock turned smoothly; whatever Mairon had done to it must have removed any rust. He pushed the door open and froze.

Tools spilled over the floor; the anvil was thrown on its side. Bars and ingots of iron lay haphazardly in tangled piles. Maeglin couldn't breathe. He'd have to right the anvil—there wasn’t even space to stand; first he’d have to pick up—no, he should retrieve the chasing punches; it was no good stepping on them… The hammers, would their faces be marred? It could take days to polish them smooth, and—how would he ever—the metals had been so carefully arranged by size and hardness, and now—now they were—they—

“Hey.” Mairon's voice was in his ear, and Mairon's hands were on his shoulders, steering him outside where he didn't have to see the awful wreck. It was still there; his mind kept running through it, trying—“Hey. Maeglin. Little lord. He’s not here. He can't hurt you. It's all yours now; he can't ever hurt you or punish you again.” He guided Maeglin to sit against the wall and sat beside him, not touching him.

Maeglin’s chest ached. He hadn’t even thought of that, of Eöl—but of course it had been him, pulling and shoving, shouting and angry, and—

“Breathe for me, will you? Can you tell me what will help?”

Maeglin tried to say he didn't know, but only a half-hearted whimper came out.

“All right. It'll be all right. We’ll get it all put back. It won't take that long, really. Not the first time I've cleaned up after someone's temper tantrum; I've got a method now, you'll see. I'll fix it. No need to be so upset.”

Maeglin wanted to bite him. As if telling him he was feeling the wrong things would help! As if he didn't already know. But then the rest of his words filtered through. Maeglin’s throat still didn't seem to work, but he nudged a question toward Mairon. Melkor?

“Ah, it doesn't matter now.”

His hand wandered to the scars ringing his neck, and a flare of helpless fury rose in Maeglin. He wanted to tell him how wrong he was, but instead he laid his head on his shoulder, and when Mairon didn't push him away, he settled closer, wrapping his arms around his friend. Hesitantly Mairon's arms came around him too.

“Feeling better?” Mairon murmured after a while. “Your heartbeat’s slowed down.”

“Mmm.” He didn't want to look up and see what Mairon thought of his weakness. “Yeah. I'm fine. I'm sorry.”

“If you don't want to go back in there, I'll take care of it for you.”

“You can't. You don't know where any of it goes.”

“Are you going to obey your dear old Ada and put everything back the way he told you? Wouldn't you rather let me improve it?”

“Don't insult me. I know what I want in a smithy and it isn't what he had.”

Mairon's smile held a glint of sharp teeth, and Maeglin found it exhilarating. “You’d best get to showing me, then. Surely there's a few treasures in that junk pile.”

“More than a few, if they haven't rusted away.”

It was easier to go back in the second time, knowing what awaited and with Mairon's steadying presence ready to uphold him. Maeglin surveyed the wreck more thoughtfully. “Did he really think I didn't know where he kept Anguirel?” he wondered aloud. He could see what must have been thrown first upon Eöl's discovery of the missing blade and the progression of his rage as he'd searched for it.

Mairon made an inquiring noise.

“My sword. His finest work. He kept it out here under lock and key. I took it when I left with my mother. I took it as my inheritance. And to protect her, I fancied. He was away at the time, and when he realized we had left the forest…he must have come home first. To be sure. To take his sword with him to follow us. I wonder how much extra time he gave us because he simply couldn't believe it was gone.” It hadn’t mattered, in the end. Yet Maeglin found some satisfaction in the idea of his father stymied by his own possessive wrath. It hadn’t been enough to save her, but maybe his theft had allowed Aredhel to look upon her city in the sunlight one last time.

Mairon helped him set the anvil back upon its heavy stump and fasten down the chains that held it in place. Between the two of them, reorganizing and sorting through the piles went faster than Maeglin had expected. They moved racks and chests and laid tool after tool in neat rows. Most would need a good polish, but few were seriously damaged. Maeglin set aside the things that were deeply nicked or chipped. Some would be worth grinding down; others he would reforge or replace altogether. Several times he considered calling a halt and stopping to rest, but now that he was warm and moving, he didn't feel so bad. He could tune out the pain almost completely. Maybe he was better than he'd realized. Maybe Mairon was right, and his worries were groundless. A little more time was all he needed.

Working with Mairon was pleasant. The Maia lit up with irrepressible glee as the smithy began to emerge from chaos. He was quick and decisive, and though he argued more-or-less amiably about it the whole time, in the end he deferred to Maeglin’s vision of where things should go. Maeglin wasn’t sure at what point the atmosphere changed. A touch in passing that in hindsight was more wanting than friendly? A heated glance that Maeglin dismissed as intense focus? However it came to pass, one moment he was insisting that it made more sense to have various hammers grouped with the tools they were most often used with rather than all together, and the next—somehow he had Mairon pressed back against the workbench, the Maia’s deft and elegant fingers on his chin, directing him into a kiss. Had Mairon been flirting with him all this time?

“This is…far better appointed…than anything I expected,” Mairon gasped between kisses.

“I told you we’d have all we needed.” Maeglin pushed closer and bit down savagely on his lip, enjoying Mairon's whimpers and the feel of his hard cock beneath his clothes.

“I didn't think—you'll have to show me the working of your black metal, now that I’m yours.”

Maeglin loved the breathless way he said it. Yours. “I'll show you. And you'll show me what you know.” He was rutting against Mairon shamelessly, and Mairon grasped his hips in encouragement.

“Everything. Everything you want. We’ll do things we can't even imagine yet.” He plucked at Maeglin's belt, clumsy in his haste. “We’ll be unsurpassable, you and I.” He arched his neck as he said it, and Maeglin found himself drawn like a moth to that bared expanse, sucking marks into delicate flesh while the Maia moaned.

Maeglin suppressed a hiss when he grabbed at Mairon's waistband and his fingers screamed in protest. I am not losing this, he swore to himself, sinking his teeth into Mairon's shoulder and hiding his momentary weakness in the Maia’s loud pleasure. His hands were stiff, swollen, and throbbing with pain, but he was so sick of being sick, of giving up on everything. He could live with the pain tonight. It didn't matter. Mairon had his cock and was stroking him, just firmly enough to make him desperate for more.

“Do you remember when we were leaving Angband?” Mairon murmured against his cheek. “When you held me down on a bench and cut away my former master’s collar?”

Maeglin didn't think that was quite how it had happened. “I remember how unhappy you were about it.”

“Not the point. I was a lot of things. I was a mess.” He nipped at Maeglin’s earlobe, and that small, bright point of pain was not at all unpleasant. “Hold me down like that again and fuck me. Won't you?” Mairon couldn't seem to settle on commanding or pleading, and Maeglin wanted to laugh at how the two mingled in his voice. But he saw the naked longing in Mairon's gaze as well, and he held back his mirth.

“That's what you want?” He slid his hand up the Maia's neck, thumbing over his scars, caressing the line of his jaw. Mairon shuddered.

“Do I have to beg?”

“I won't make you,” Maeglin whispered against his lips, entranced by how still Mairon went when he grasped a handful of his hair. He tightened his hold at the nape of Mairon’s neck, and Mairon whimpered. Maeglin's cock ached with sudden need. Mairon didn't move until he pushed. He guided him down onto the workbench, wrenching his clothes out of the way. He thought he understood what Mairon meant. In that moment, Mairon had placed himself in Maeglin's hands, and the taste of power in the midst of his total helplessness had thrilled him to the core. What Mairon wanted to recapture must have been as compelling.

Impatient, Mairon pressed his ass against Maeglin, arching his spine and glancing back. Maeglin gasped at the touch of bare flesh. He'd never seen anything so filthy and so gorgeous. Before Mairon could say anything acerbic and ruin the moment, Maeglin shoved his head down harder. With too much force, he instantly worried, but Mairon grinned, so maybe it was just enough.

“Oh—oil. I need—I don't think there's—”

“Maeglin. Spit on your cock and push it in. It's fine.”

Maeglin blushed so hard he could feel his ears heat all the way to the tips. He wasn’t so inexperienced as he must look; after he'd given up on love and marriage, he'd occasionally traded quick, sloppy blowjobs and even been fucked himself a few times down in Anghabar's depths where his loyal miners would never tell tales on their companions or their lord. But in his heart he had always quietly reserved what he was about to do for Idril, as silly as the notion seemed now, and—well. A little tin of grease or balm or something had always appeared. He didn't know how comfortable this could be without it; he'd never been the one who had to think about what was needed. “Are you sure that’s enough?”

“Very sure. Hurry up.”

Maeglin swallowed his doubts and did as he was told. The Maia’s body accepted him with only a little initial resistance, and then Maeglin was sliding inside, watching his cock disappear into Mairon while he moaned and squirmed to take more of Maeglin faster. It felt incredibly good; the tightness, the heat, the way Mairon was clenching around him. Being so visibly and viscerally wanted. He rocked back and slid in again, and again, and then he was fucking into Mairon ferociously, his fingers gripping Mairon's shoulder like a vise as he threw himself into rising sensation. Mairon's little cries spurred him on. He seemed half gone in a haze of pleasure; Maeglin could feel it rolling off of him in waves as he met Maeglin’s thrusts. Mairon's hands were curled beside his head; though his fingers twitched, he made no move to touch himself.

I'm supposed to do that, Maeglin realized. I'm neglecting him. His position was a bit awkward, but he found if he leaned forward and wrapped his arm around Mairon, he could reach his cock. The sounds that tore from Mairon when he grasped it more than made up for the effort. Pain was creeping in around the edges again where his arousal had blocked it out, but he didn't care.

“You—oh—ohh…” Mairon sobbed and swore and came. Maeglin laid a soft, reverent kiss on his shoulderblade, enchanted and overcome in the wake of his partner's abandon. “Did you—” Mairon turned and met his lips. “Don't stop now,” he murmured. “Ridiculous boy.” He thrust back against him, moving on his cock with obscene grace until pleasure broke over Maeglin, and he slumped forward with a cry as Mairon wrung the last drops of orgasm from him.

*

Maeglin kept waking from restless slumber to his hands burning, his chest too tight to breathe, the weight of the covers unbearable on his shoulder. When he finally roused enough to take stock of himself, he was not surprised to find himself in the worst pain he’d had in weeks. I should've known better. I shouldn’t have let myself believe I could actually do anything. I just threw away whatever progress I’d made. Maybe it had been worth it, though? He ached to think of never having had last night at all. Was that what his future was to look like? Every scrap of joy bought with immense pain?

Mairon entered with a cat-like smile, but his face fell when he saw Maeglin. “Again?!”

“It's bad today,” Maeglin answered quietly. “I don't think I'm leaving bed.”

“No. You were fine last night.”

“No, I was pretending to be fine and ignoring every sign that I was pushing myself too hard.”

“You were fine,” Mairon growled. “You'd be fine if you'd stop dwelling on it so much. You’re making yourself worse coddling yourself like this. It's like you want to be sick.”

Maeglin's breath caught in his throat as shock turned into hurt and then disgust, even while some little voice inside him asked if perhaps it were true. He closed his eyes and tried his best to squash that voice. It sounded too much like Eöl. “Out of—of all the cruel things you could say, that drivel is what you come up with?” He realized he was shaking, and he hated it. Why did any hint of a fight have to strip away his dignity? “You’re only saying that because you can't stand feeling guilty.”

“Stop it.”

“I'm not getting any better, and you don't know how to fix me, and you hate the thought that you broke your newest toy.”

“Just stop!” Mairon snarled. “You can punish me if you want—strip the skin from my back, drive spikes through my flesh, whatever will make you feel better. Do it and be done with it, or shut your mouth and stop whining. I don't want to hear it anymore.”

Maeglin glared. Part of him was desperate to whisper a meek apology and promise his silence, but the rest of him was angry, and the more he thought about that desperate part, the angrier he grew. “What if I don't like either one?” he hissed. “What if I want you to have to think about what you've done? What if I want to be comforted and cared for and it's not about you at all?!”

Mairon was staring, and he realized how loud he'd gotten. He didn't apologize for that either. It was his house now, and he could be loud here if he wanted. Even if it did hurt his throat. Even if he trembled.

He didn't ask where Mairon was going as he stormed out. He could sense the disturbance of his presence as he made his way into the forest; if he focused—but that took energy he didn't have. He hadn’t even raised the layer of wards that would keep him confined to the forest yet. Every time he thought of it, disgust had taken hold of him, and he'd kept leaving it for later. He thought he could do it now, even from inside the house. His father's enchantment, that had bound his mother within Nan Elmoth's borders, was still there, quiescent in the forest’s roots. Maeglin had himself dismissed it when they fled. It had answered to him grudgingly then, for his father's will forbid their crossing, but the trees had favored their young lord in his need. They would answer him easily if he asked, and Mairon would find himself walking in circles he could not escape. He thought of his mother's tired eyes and the fingerprint bruises he'd left on Mairon unwitting last night, and how simple it would be to take the total command the Maia seemed to expect. He could see himself liking it. And what then? Had his mother died so he could become a copy of his father?

Maeglin clenched his fists until his nails bit crescent moons into his flesh. He couldn't do it. He couldn't. Let Mairon run back to his master. Let Mairon betray him again. There was no one else he could hurt now. If he were captured again, he'd make sure he died before he was brought back Angband. And what of everyone back home you sentenced to death or Angband by befriending him in the first place? Maybe it wouldn't come to that. He could not bear to think of little Eärendil suffering in those Valar-forsaken halls. He hoped if it came to that, someone would kill him before he ever had to look upon them.

Taking a few careful breaths, Maeglin dried his tears. He could do no more for his city, and crying over it wouldn't help. Gritting his teeth against the pain, he hauled himself up and waited for the wave of dizziness and nausea to pass. He gripped the stair-rail tightly as he crept down to the kitchen to find something he could manage to eat.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 17

Read Chapter 17

Maeglin dragged a pile of blankets and pillows down the stairs and made up a pallet by the kitchen hearth. Here the heat of the stones would keep him warmer than an empty bed could, long after the fire was only banked embers. Everything he'd need was at hand; unless the cistern ran dry, he'd rarely have to leave the room if he didn't feel up to it. They'd laid in some food during the plenty of early autumn, dried meats and berries and nuts, and with Eöl's old stores, he'd get through the winter alone. After that…he'd worry later. So he told himself when the house grew too haunted and silent.

On the third day, wolf fur against his skin pulled him from the brink of sleep. In the last vestiges of firelight, he saw Mairon’s form stretched out beside him, gleaming a poisonous shade of gold.

“I didn't really think you were coming back.”

Mairon licked Maeglin’s face and thumped his tail against the floor. Maeglin wound his fingers deep in his fur and breathed a little easier. When he woke next Mairon was gone again, only a few golden hairs on the blanket left to betray his presence. But as Maeglin blearily sat up and reached for wood to build up the fire, he noticed a fresh stack had been brought inside, and a pot of steaming tea sat on the hearth with a note scratched on birchbark beside it.

“Drink half a cup every four hours. Tell me if it helps.”

Maeglin sighed and wished he understood anything Mairon was thinking. He took the first dose with his breakfast. It was bitter and unpleasant and made no difference in how he felt that he could tell. Neither did the next brew a couple of days later, nor the one that numbed his tongue after that, nor the one Mairon instructed him to take for a week before reporting on. That one gave him a pounding headache, and he had to stop early.

Mairon was never around anymore, and he refused to show his face when he was. Maeglin would wake in the night to find the wolf curled snugly under the covers with him, but he always disappeared before morning. He thought Mairon must still be furious with him, but he couldn't bring himself to regret any of what he'd said, and when he gathered the courage to ask late one night, the wolf nuzzled under his chin and didn't speak.

It was a lonely existence. Maeglin had always needed more time to himself and his own thoughts than anyone he knew, but without a single friendly face to interrupt the long hours, with no companions to share his meals, without a sound to break the silence or a touch to comfort him, the dim house began to feel as if it was swallowing him whole. The first snows began to fall, earlier than Maeglin expected, covering the ground with a dusting of dirty white. Maeglin felt certain there hadn’t been so much ash and soot in the snow of his youth. Still Mairon spent his days roaming. It should be me out there walking the woods, Maeglin thought enviously. He ought to be relearning the lay of the land and finding out what work would need to be done come spring. He ought to be caring for the forest as its lord. But a little exertion in the biting air wore him out and left him clutching his chest for days, and the cold lit a bitter ache deep in his bones. The forest was patient; his work would have to wait. Maeglin settled in a corner of the hearth and made his life fit into the half-moon of its heat.

If he observed himself carefully enough and made himself stop and rest his hands every little while, Maeglin found he could sew a bit, though whenever he paused he could hear his father's voice scolding him for daydreaming and wasting time. He'd never looked kindly on any weakness. Maeglin shut out those thoughts the best he could. It took a far stricter discipline than Eöl could understand to keep his pain light enough to continue; if he stopped paying attention, if he neglected to rest, he wouldn't be able to cook for himself later or tend to the fire.

He was mending a heavy winter surcoat that had been his mother's; his own old clothes were small for him now, and he wouldn't touch Eöl's. It was moth-eaten and yellowed with age, but he didn't trust his rudimentary skills on the lovely fabric that had been preserved under enchantment. This would do for the cold months ahead. He'd shortened it to a more masculine length, though it was still cut fuller than anything he could have worn in Gondolin. Who was going to care here? As he stitched the last stretch of the new hem, he considered how best to fix the bigger holes. Maybe simple patchwork; he had matching fabric he'd trimmed from the bottom, and he wasn't sure he remembered Aredhel’s lessons in darning.

The little bell of the wind-up timer went off—a Dwarven trinket Maeglin had rediscovered in the back of a drawer—and he reluctantly stuck his needle into the edge of his work and laid it down. His hands only hurt a little right now, and it felt silly to stop and break his focus—surely a few more inches would be fine? But he'd tested that enough already to know how dangerous the temptation was. A smooth, round stone was heating in the coals of the fire. He pulled it out and wrapped a towel over it to warm his hands upon.

“My lord.” Mairon’s osanwë had a sharp edge. “Come find me quickly. There's something here you need to see.”

Maeglin tried to set aside for the moment the shock of being spoken to for the first time in weeks. He didn't immediately recognize the mental images of the area Mairon was pushing onto him, but between them and his sense of the forest, he thought it was near the border with Doriath. “I'm not sure I can walk that far,” he answered.

Mairon's impatience was palpable, and underneath it sat a hint of simmering…anger? Resentment? Something about it was strange in a way Maeglin couldn't quite put a finger on, but it made him uncomfortable. “I'll meet you half way and carry you. Just start towards me. It's important.”

Maeglin briefly considered refusing, or at least making Mairon explain himself, but he bundled up his sewing, banked the fire, wrapped himself in several layers of wool, and headed out into the forest. It was snowing again, lightly now, but the dead grey sky made him worry for the night to come. Many of the trees around him slumbered. He could feel the edges of their dreams as he passed; vast, slow, ponderous reveries full of the growth of buds and memories of warmth. He let his attention wander, filling his senses with the quiet life around him as much as possible instead of the cold air burning his lungs. He was beginning to wonder at what point the sensible thing would be to give up and turn back when his wolf appeared on silent footfalls. Mairon trotted up to him but took no time for greeting, simply nudging him onto his back.

“Where are we going?”

Mairon didn't answer.

“What's so urgent that you summoned me all the way out here?!”

Mairon huffed. “I found something. Children.”

“Alone? In this weather? Where would—”

“I don't know anything else.”

Mairon was clearly irritated, so Maeglin kept his questions to himself, but he couldn't help wondering why Mairon hadn’t simply brought them to the house. If they’d been lost in the snow long, every minute was risking their lives. Assuming they were alive… Mairon would have said if he meant children's corpses, wouldn't he?

Stopping suddenly, Mairon shrugged his shoulders and rolled Maeglin off in an ungraceful dismount. “Over there.”

Maeglin was almost annoyed enough himself to scold the wolf; he could have gotten down easily if Mairon had cared to ask. But there wasn't time for that. He started forward and realized Mairon wasn’t moving. “What now?! Aren't you coming with me?”

Mairon shifted smoothly and scowled. “If I'm not mistaken, this is the edge of your lands. Are you going to permit me to cross the border? I'm little minded to walk into your enchantments.”

“There…isn't one. I haven't—nothing’s stopping you.”

Fury flashed across his eyes, and his scowl deepened. Mairon stalked forward wordlessly. He brushed past Maeglin and led him to a little hollow in the ground between the stout roots of an ancient beech. Kneeling, he dug through dead leaves and snow. Maeglin stepped up beside him. Two boys lay hidden underneath. Maeglin reached for them; their faces were unnaturally still, their brown skin clammy and wan. Before he could touch them, Mairon yanked him back.

“Don't. Look.” He removed more leaves, this time with delicate precision. White threads of mycelium wound from the earth into their flesh, binding them together in a thick fungal web.

Maeglin gagged and turned away. “They’re dead. They've been dead some time.”

“No.”

“No? There are mushrooms growing in their bodies, Mairon!”

“And yet they smell distinctly alive. Come, look again.”

Maeglin steeled himself and knelt beside Mairon.

“Watch their chests,” Mairon told him. “See? It's very slight, but they’re breathing.”

“What do you think…?”

“What does the forest tell you?”

With a steadying breath, Maeglin focused on the slow thrum of life around him. “The forest remembers Melian,” he murmured. “Melian, Melian, Melian, the trees repeat to one another.” As the strength of that impression lessened, he began sorting through layers beneath it. “These boys are protected. They…the forest is feeding them? Keeping them in this…” They were like dormant roots waiting until they could grow, he thought, a rest more profound than sleep. Tiny droplets of water and nutrients were passed to them through the hyphae penetrating them, just as the older trees supported the young or injured.

“Their spirits are sitting very lightly in their bodies. Whatever the reason, they're being kept alive, but a little disturbance might prove their end.”

“We can't leave them here.”

“Yes. I guessed you would say that. It's why I interfered in what otherwise is no business of mine.”

Maeglin wondered if he should be upset at the implication that Mairon would leave children to die if not to please him. “It was very thoughtful of you. I appreciate it.”

A shadow of a smile broke Mairon's dour expression, but it was short-lived. “You aren't going to like the rest of my assessment.”

“Why not?”

“I don't think we can save them both.”

“Are you certain?”

Mairon sang softly to himself. Maeglin could make out no words, but the images his music conjured were all of death. He remembered bodies on the field of the Nirnaeth beginning to rot before their time. He saw the great lights winking out and darkness without stars spreading over all Middle-earth, and he shuddered.

“I'm certain,” Mairon said at last. “They've lain here too long. They have not enough…strength between them to sustain both. What they have is shared between them in this state, but as soon as they are woken, they will die. I believe I can pull that strength into whichever you choose, though. We can save one, or we can leave them both to their fate.”

“Whichever I choose? You’re part of this too.”

Mairon looked up at him. “I refuse to be your pet villain. I am not going to make this choice for you and then be told, no matter what I do, that it was evil and wrong. You're the lord here; the responsibility is yours.”

“Fine. I understand. Is one more likely to survive?”

Mairon shrugged.

Maeglin studied the boys more closely. At first he'd thought them alike, brothers or close kin, but the resemblance was more perfect than that; they were twins. Their ears were more rounded than an elf's but more pointed than a human's; not unlike little Eärendil's, he noted with a pang. How was he to sentence one to death? It's one or both, he reminded himself. One brother had pulled the other to his chest, his arms tight around him as if to defend him. Maeglin couldn't help thinking of how his mother had put herself between him and danger. She wouldn't have been pleased if he'd somehow managed to reverse her sacrifice and die in her stead.

“This one,” Maeglin said quietly, pointing to the brother being held. “Let's save this one.”

“I'll need you to sing with me. You untangle them from the forest, and I'll handle their spirits.”

After a quick but thorough discussion of how to proceed, Mairon sang the first note, and Maeglin joined his voice. Their harmonies twined together, dark and rich, and had the moment not been so grievous and weighty, Maeglin would have found it thrilling. Despite all his frustration with the Maia, despite all the ways he'd hurt Maeglin and all their disagreements, their minds at work fit together like they'd been made as one. Improvising against each other flowed as naturally as if they'd rehearsed a hundred times before. Every theme Maeglin introduced was taken up and woven into the tapestry of Mairon's song, and the structures Mairon presented him made such utter sense that Maeglin’s echoed counterpoint seemed inevitable.

As Maeglin sang of nurture, of spring, of restoration, the mycelial threads withdrew from the boys like so many fingers releasing them from the earth's embrace. He felt the surge of Mairon's funereal hymn at its height and sweetened it with ringing chords. One child’s eyes opened, and the other breathed a soft, final sigh, and his body crumbled into dust.


Leave a Comment

Chapter 18

Read Chapter 18

The choice was made; it could no longer be undone. A child was dead because of him—am I a kinslayer now? Maeglin wondered. He didn't see any better way this could have gone; he wasn’t sure that made it right. Mairon was coughing; flecks of blood appeared on the snow, but Maeglin couldn't see to him yet. The remaining child was stirring, and he waited, holding still so as not to frighten him. The boy looked from him to Mairon and back.

“Are you Fëanorians?” His voice shook, and he was scrambling backwards before he’d even managed to sit, but the wide tree trunk stopped him.

“No,” Maeglin said gently. “We're here to help you.”

“They killed Ada! They killed Nana too.” He started to cry, choking on his sobs. “They cut Ada's head off. It was rolling on the floor. I saw it!”

Maeglin swallowed down his horror and every protesting memory of his mother's childhood stories. “Hey, come here.” He held out his arm without moving any closer. “Can you tell me your name?”

“Elurín.”

“Elurín,” Maeglin repeated, not sure he'd heard it right through the boy's sniffles. “Elu…like Thingol?”

Elurín eyed him warily. “That’s Great-Grandda. He's gone too.”

“Yes. I'm sorry.”

“Dior’s son, then. Son of Lúthien and her pet human,” Mairon told him with silent venom.

Maeglin gave him a slight nod of acknowledgement. “You know what that makes us?” he said to Elurín. “My Adar was cousin to Thingol. That means we're family too. I'm your Uncle Maeglin.”

“Oh.” The boy started to approach, but hesitated and looked around.

“You never told me you were related to her.”

“You never asked? What have you got against Lúthien?”

“Oh, nothing.” He rested his hand on the scars on his throat that Maeglin had tended long ago. “She's the one who did this to me, but you know. Nothing that matters.”

“Mairon—”

“Where's Eluréd?” Elurín whimpered. “Where's my brother? He was right here! We have to find him; what if the Fëanorians—” He spotted the remnants of his brother's clothing where he had lain beside him. “WHERE IS HE?!” he screamed.

Maeglin scooped the wailing child into his arms. “I'm sorry,” he murmured into his hair. “I'm so sorry. He didn't make it. He…it's just you now. I'm going to take care of you. You're not alone.” Nothing he said did anything to stem the screaming, so he just held him, rocking back and forth.

Mairon watched impassively. He hadn’t moved.

“Is my cousin going to be a problem?” Maeglin demanded.

Mairon's pause was uncomfortably long, but when he answered, his mental touch was much softer. “No.”

Elurín coughed hard, and Maeglin thought he would start wailing again, but he got his breath back enough to manage whole words. “He can't be d—gone.” He tugged on Maeglin's shirt. “He can't be! He was right with me, I could feel him there, and then something was pulling him away—what did you do?! Did you let the Fëanorians take him?!”

Maeglin was scrambling after words, but Mairon was faster. “You've been here sleeping a long time. The Fëanorians are far away; they won't hurt you any more. I'm afraid your brother faded away and left this world long ago. See, weren’t these his things, just as he lay here? You were in a very special sleep, and it saved you, but he couldn't sleep so long.”

“No. No. I felt him. He was there…”

“Time does strange things in your dreams,” Mairon said with surprising gentleness. “I'm sure he's with your Ada and Nana now. But you're alive, and you're going to be okay.”

Elurín began to cry again, less frantically and more forlorn.

“You don't think he deserves the truth?” asked Maeglin.

“And how do you mean to explain it? Do you want him to run away and die in the woods alone? He has to trust us.”

Maeglin didn't like it, but he supposed Mairon was right. “Let's get you home,” he murmured. “We need to warm you up and get you something to eat.” He stood, hefting Elurín onto his hip, and wished heartily that the house wasn’t so far. Night was fast approaching, and they’d lingered too long in the cold already. He could envision it so clearly, the house nestled safe and sound in the dim little clearing, smoke trailing from the chimney. His clothes were damp from the snow and Elurín's tears, and he wouldn't be able to stave off his own pain and weariness much longer. Need filled him until he could almost taste it. “Mairon? You'll carry us?”

He gestured in the house’s direction, and the forest realigned. With a yawning groan and the tinkle of ice falling on snow, a path opened between the trees, and the house appeared a short distance away. Elurín’s quiet gasp stirred them to motion. Mairon was studying Maeglin intently; he shook it off, and as soon as Maeglin and Elurín were on his back, he trotted down the path, covering in mere steps what Maeglin knew should be miles.

Elurín held onto Maeglin tightly. “The forest back home would do that for Grandma when I was little,” he whispered.

Maeglin shivered and wondered just how much was possible that no one now living could show him. He thought of fine white threads of hyphae. “I've a feeling the forest will listen to you too, when you’re older.”

*

Elurín didn't stop sniffling all evening, but Maeglin got him through a bath and into an overlarge but clean and dry tunic without much difficulty. Mairon had offered to cook, more to avoid being asked to participate in any sort of direct childcare, Maeglin suspected, than anything else, but at least he hadn’t disappeared again. The silence felt awkward as he led Elurín to the kitchen table and they waited for Mairon to finish. Maeglin thought he should say something comforting, or at least make the child feel more welcome, but he had no idea what that might be. What comfort was there when you’d lost your whole world? With bitter fondness, he wondered if Turgon had felt the same way after Aredhel's death. They'd certainly shared plenty of silences. Would he have some great wisdom to offer if Maeglin asked him now, or would he admit his total helplessness?

Mairon handed the child a small bowl of what looked like particularly thin porridge. “Here. Try to eat slowly.”

Elurín took a bite and pushed it away. “Tastes awful.”

“You need to eat it anyway.”

Maeglin tasted it himself. Elurín wasn’t wrong. Was that a slight on him, or the child, or stinginess born of caution for the winter ahead? Or maybe he was simply exhausted too. “Mairon…?” He hurriedly reached for a lighter tone. “I think you forgot to taste this while you were cooking.” He began readying himself to stand and look for something to make it vaguely more edible, but he could tell moving was going to take effort, and it was going to hurt.

“I forgot nothing. He's been asleep without eating anything solid for something like three years. This is what he needs. Other food will make him sick. Trust me on this. It’s carefully optimized to restore an elf who’s been starved.” His smile was unpleasant. “You can ask me how I know if you want. You won't enjoy the answer.”

Elurín’s eyes were growing wider and wetter. “I'm not sick.”

Maeglin bit down on the reply he wanted to give Mairon.

“I'm not sick! Ada never made me eat nasty food when I was sick!”

“Mairon just wants to make sure you don't get sick,” Maeglin soothed. “What if we fix this with a little maple sugar?”

Mairon caught his wrist and took the jar from him. “A little. If it means you'll eat.”

Elurín looked doubtful, but he nodded once, and with some careful consideration, Mairon spooned out what seemed a paltry amount to Maeglin. It did the trick, though, and Maeglin resigned himself to his own bowl.

“I'll make you something else if you want,” Mairon offered silently.

“It’s fine,” Maeglin assured him. “I doubt he’ll keep eating if he sees me with something else.”

“Later?”

Maeglin shrugged and swallowed another spoonful. It wasn't so bad with the sugar. “Thank you,” he murmured aloud. “I wouldn't have known there was danger to avoid.”

Mairon poked half-heartedly at the fire.

“Is your throat all right? I saw you were coughing blood, earlier.”

“Too much of Melian. I'll be fine. It's more unpleasant than damaging.”

Maeglin wondered if that was entirely true, but he didn't push. He tucked Elurín into his own bed for the night; he hadn’t used it since his fight with Mairon. They could rearrange later. He was prepared to sit and keep Elurín company for a while, but the boy was asleep the moment he grew still. Such exhaustion was kinder, Maeglin thought, than lying awake with grief, and he was grateful for it for Elurín's sake. He pulled the blankets a little higher over him and blew out the rushlight. The Moon was glinting through the windows, and that was enough to find his way.

The aches he had tried to tune out all day were catching up to him as he made his way downstairs; his shoulders burned and every little movement set pain gnawing at his hands. At the bottom Mairon was pacing back and forth. He rounded on Maeglin immediately.

“You lied to me.”

Maeglin’s stomach twisted. He couldn't deal with this tonight. “About Lúthien? I didn't mean to hide it. You never brought her up.”

“Not that. The forest boundary. All this time, you had me believe you’d bound me.” He grabbed Maeglin’s arm and pulled him close, staring down at him with a predator’s eyes. “All this time I've tread so very carefully avoiding where I thought the borders might be, and it was for nothing.”

“Let go. That hurts.”

Mairon released him as quickly as a hot coal. Turning away, Maeglin rubbed at the imprint of Mairon's biting fingers and tried not to think of how desperately he’d wanted a different kind of reunion. “I'm sorry. I was going to, I just—I couldn't—I’m sorry.”

“Stop wilting away at the slightest push!” he growled. “If you're going to make choices for me, the least you can do is stand by them!”

Wearily Maeglin raised his eyes to meet Mairon’s. “I don't understand you tonight. I said I'm sorry. I'm going to bed.”

“What's even the point of all that power you hold if you don't have the balls to use it?”

Maeglin stopped. “I shouldn’t have to,” he said quietly. “I shouldn't have to enforce anything on you. It shouldn't matter whether you're bound or not. You offered me your obedience, and I told you not to leave my domain.”

Mairon's lips curled in a sneering grin. “So there is steel in there somewhere. I was starting to wonder if I'd imagined it all. You could be a proper little tyrant if you tried harder. Go on, then. Tell me how little my convenience matters. Tell me you don't care how angry I am.”

“But I do care. When you're angry it's terrifying and upsetting, and I'm not going to pretend otherwise for the sake of—whatever game this is.”

“Well, I'm not going to pretend not to be angry.” Mairon's teeth were bared, but the light in his eyes seemed more excitement than fury now. He leaned in. “So what are you going to do about it?”

“Is…that what you want? To…to be put in your place?”

Mairon’s threatening smile never slipped. “Or are you nothing but big words, princeling?”

“I won't.”

“Am I nothing to you?!” The Maia's tone turned frantic, and Maeglin wasn’t sure where he'd misstepped.

“Why would you think that?! What have I ever said or done—”

“Because it appears I have lost so much favor that I am not even worth the effort of punishment.”

“That isn't—”

“What do you want from me?! What are you waiting for?” Mairon started pacing again. “Am I supposed to grovel first? Is that it?” He turned to Maeglin. “You were right.” He spat the words with great distaste, but once they left him, they seemed to take all his rage with them, and he looked diminished; uncertain and fragile. “Does that satisfy you? You were right. Everything you said about me. I don't know what I'm doing. I can't fix things for you. I can't put you back and make you well again. I can't make things right, and you won't punish me. How are we supposed to live like that?!”

Maeglin hastily reconsidered everything he'd thought about the conversation. “And you couldn't just talk to me instead of picking a fight? Is that why you wouldn't stay home?”

“I don't deserve to be near you.” Mairon couldn't look at him. “You’re angry and you shouldn't have to deal with my failures. I knew that I wanted you, that you were unbelievably precious, and I hurt you anyway, and now your life and your body are ruined because of me and it's all my fault, and you won't even punish me!”

Maeglin reached for him tentatively, but he flinched from Maeglin’s touch.

“Is there no way back from failure with you?”

The question hurt Maeglin’s heart. He kept his silence. Too many words and feelings and thoughts were crowding his mind, and he didn't want to give way to the wrong ones. Mairon looked increasingly anxious, but he didn't push Maeglin to speak before he was ready, and that, more than anything, gave him courage. “Come with me,” he said at last. “I can't keep standing like this.”

Mairon padded after him into the kitchen. Maeglin sat upon the hearth and patted the stones beside him, but instead Mairon knelt before him. Gingerly Maeglin leaned back and stretched, wincing as his tight ribs creaked.

“You’ve been hurting all day again and pretending you don't?”

“You said it was important. And it was.”

Mairon sighed and bowed his head.

“I'm not refusing to punish you because I don't think you're good enough to bother with,” Maeglin said carefully. “That's what you assumed?”

“Why else?”

“I don't believe punishment is a terribly good solution most of the time. Especially not for someone you love and care about.” He very deliberately wasn't thinking of his father. He didn't need to add anything to the mess of his emotions.

“I know you're squeamish. I know you think my master was too harsh. It doesn't have to be bloody. There are other ways—”

“What ways? Sure, I've given extra duties to people who were making nuisances of themselves. Is that what you're after? You’re already doing far more than your portion of the work so we can survive here. You already are addressing what your actions brought about, which is all I'd ever demand. And…I would never want you to come to think of taking care of me as a punishment. That would…it would feel horrible. I couldn't abide it.” He studied Mairon and the thick tangle of shame and distress roiling around his mind. “No. You still meant pain.”

A morose little sound escaped Mairon, and his fingers tightened on his thighs.

“I have no desire to see you suffer. I don't want to be a person who hurts other people because I'm angry and disappointed. I don't think it would improve things.”

“So you are, then. Angry and disappointed. You don't get it. I'm suffering now, and punishing me would end it.”

“Dear one…”

Mairon shuddered.

A knot of dread was tying itself tighter in his stomach. “I'm not Melkor.”

“Believe me, I am very aware.”

“Do you want to…”

“Stop asking me that. Please,” Mairon said before he could finish.

“You have to stop asking me to be him,” Maeglin murmured almost too softly to hear. “You have to stop expecting it.”

“I don't know how to do this. If I can't help but fail, and I can't be punished for it—I—” Quietly, without moving to hide or stem his tears, Mairon began to cry. Threading his fingers into Mairon's hair, Maeglin gently pulled him down to lay his head in his lap. “How do I come back from that if you give me no way to pay my debts? How is anything supposed to be right between us ever again?”

He coughed, and Maeglin saw there was still blood. He stroked Mairon's hair and let his fingers trail down his back.

“It's been so long since I got anything right,” Mairon whispered through his tears. “I'm so tired. I'm tired of always failing. Of never being enough.”

“You left all that behind.”

Mairon scoffed. “I haven't done any better since. I did a shit job of rescuing you. You only needed to be rescued because of me. I had to rescue you from me.”

Maeglin couldn't argue with that.

“Tell me what to do. If you aren't willing to punish me, tell me how to make it right. Please.”

“I...I think…we both just have to take care of each other—and Elurín, now—and do our best to make each other's life happy and comfortable. I’m not sure there's any right left in the world beyond that. For us, anyway. That's all I ask. It's all I really want. That you're here with me. That you try.” He drew a careful breath, his fingers tightening in Mairon's hair. “Please don't leave me alone again.”

Mairon looked up in weary disbelief. “But you were angry.”

“You were being cruel and unfair.”

“Yes, that's not…” He sighed and hid his face again, mumbling into Maeglin's shirt. “He never wanted to see me when he was angry. Not until he was done punishing me. And you wouldn't.”

“I thought you'd decided I wasn’t worth being around anymore.”

Mairon surged upright and cupped Maeglin's face in both hands. “Stop that. Who taught you no one could want you?”

“Not many people ever really did. I’m not very pleasant to be around. Or so they say.”

“But they're wrong. I told you I'm yours, and I don't go back on that easily.”

Maeglin couldn't watch his earnest expression. “It's different now, though. You said yourself. I'm ruined.”

“Sweetling…”

“What if I can never manage a hammer again?” Maeglin pressed. “What if I can never go down a mine?”

Touching him with great care, Mairon raised Maeglin's fingers to his lips. “Then I'll be exceedingly sorry I took that away from you. It's not…I…” He paused. “Those aren't the only reasons I care for you. It…isn't all you are. My loyalty does not rest on your hammer skills. And if nothing changes…if you need it...I'll be your hands. There's work we can share that you don't have to carry out yourself. We’ll deal with it together.” He fell silent, searching Maeglin’s expression. “Will that be enough?”

Maeglin leaned forward and kissed him, soft and long. “Yes,” he whispered. “It will.”


Leave a Comment

Chapter 19

Read Chapter 19

Maeglin fell asleep beside the fire with an armful of warm, furry wolf pressed against him. When he woke, he'd been moved, thick stack of quilts and all, to a settle in the great hall. He tried to stretch, but his feet met the carved oak of the armrest. Slowly the day before came back to him. He had a child now. How was that supposed to work? How was he to care for someone so small and helpless and alone when he could barely take care of himself? His throat tightened at the immensity of it all.

Sounds drifted from the kitchen: voices he couldn't quite make out and the clink of silverware on dishes. Mairon was still there. He'd stayed, like he'd said he would. No. Sauron was there, the former lieutenant of Morgoth, and Maeglin had left him alone with a child. Just because he felt reasonably sure Mairon was no danger to him—He forced himself into motion, caught his breath with a pained whimper, and gingerly lowered himself back onto the settle. Bit by bit he adjusted his position until, if he focused on keeping his ribs still, he could breathe with only a little discomfort.

He'd have to leave Mairon to it, whether or not he deserved his trust. He reminded himself that Elurín wouldn't be there at all if not for Mairon. And hadn’t he sworn his loyalty? If he didn't believe it would extend to those under Maeglin’s protection, how much did it really mean? The hard back of the settle kept him from turning over, and the fierce ache in his hands was gnawing its way up his arms, but he nestled deeper under the blankets, and in moments he was once more asleep.

The next time he opened his eyes, Elurín was sitting on the floor, watching him intently. “You’re awake!”

Maeglin groaned and rubbed his eyes. The cast of the dim light told him it was past noon already, but he felt like he’d barely rested at all. “Sure.”

“Mairon said you were sick and I had to be very quiet until you woke up.”

“Nice of him. Nice of you.”

Elurín nodded. His eyes were red, but his face had been washed clean of any tears. Mairon’s patience must be exceptional today. “Are you a peredhel like me?”

“No, my parents were both Elves.”

“Oh. I thought Elves didn't get sick.”

“Not very often. But it can happen sometimes.”

“Did you know Mairon is in my Grandmama's and Grandda's story? He used to be Sauron, and he had Grandda locked up in his tower, and Grandmama came with Huan-the-hound-of-Oromë, and he turned into a wolf to fight Huan, but Huan grabbed him by the throat and held him down and shook him until he was crying like a little baby, and he had to give Grandmama his tower, and that's how she rescued Grandda.”

“He told you that?” Maeglin really ought to get the whole story sometime. He’d wondered last night how they would handle Mairon’s identity and promptly pushed the whole mess away to deal with later. He hadn’t expected Mairon to simply reveal himself.

“Well, no. That's how Ada told me. Mairon said that Morgoth captured him a long time ago and turned him into Sauron and made him do all sorts of bad things, and after Grandmama defeated him and took his tower away, Morgoth dragged him back to Angband and put him in chains, and then you came and snuck into Angband just like Grandmama and stole him away and set him free, and now he lives with you and never has to be Sauron or do bad things again. And that's what made you sick, because you went to Angband to save him.”

“Ah. I see.”

“Did you fight werewolves?!”

“Oh, no. The werewolves love Mairon, so they helped us. They even let me pet them. And then they ate up all the orcs who chased after us.”

Elurín leaned closer and whispered, though he wasn't actually much quieter. “Mairon let me pet him when he was still a wolf this morning. Did you know his ears are very soft?”

Maeglin smiled. “They are very soft.”

“Eluréd and me were going to get our own dog for our begetting day. A little one with soft, droopy ears like Nana's. But—but that was before…” His face crumpled, and broken sobs quickly followed his tears.

“Oh, sweetheart.” Maeglin eased himself upright, though pain still stole his breath. “Do you want me to hold you?”

After a moment, Elurín nodded and clambered into his lap. Maeglin kept him there until he ran out of tears.

*

“That's quite a story you told Elúrin.” Maeglin seated himself near the hearth where Mairon was preparing dinner.

For a moment, Mairon looked confused. “About how I came to be here? The child needed an explanation that would satisfy him and make him feel safe. So I gave him one.”

“I notice very little of it was true.”

Mairon scoffed. “Come, now. You were a lord of Elves and a councillor in the Hidden City. Don't pretend you don't understand what's required to manage people.”

“I didn’t generally rely on making things up completely.”

“Are you going to criticize every decision I make? What was I supposed to say? ‘Hello, small child, I'm the scary bad man from your bedtime stories?’ Pretend I'm someone else entirely and deal with the terror and betrayal when he starts asking too many questions? I thought you’d be glad I’d handled it.”

“No, I didn’t...that’s not where I meant this to go. Sorry. I am glad. I only…I would've liked to be consulted before gaining a whole new feat of bravery I could never actually live up to.”

Mairon pursed his lips as he added a handful of crumbled dry herbs to the thin soup he was stirring. They smelled distinctly medicinal. “You showed great bravery in my hands. And after. That took every bit as much as in the version I told.”

The quiet reply unsettled him. “I suppose you tell me what you want me to believe, too. Am I so easily managed?”

Setting down the ladle, Mairon finally turned to him. “There is little I could hide from you, Maeglin, if you ever put aside your qualms and turned your full gaze upon me.”

“I don't know what you mean. You keep your mind quite capably closed off.”

Mairon said nothing.

“It doesn't work like that!”

Turning back to his soup, Mairon tasted it and added a little salt. “This’ll be ready by the time we've dragged our new charge to the table.”

Maeglin considered arguing, but if the Maia was going to be stubborn, he decided there was little point. “I'll see where he's gotten to.”

It didn't take him long. With a moment's thought, he could feel the boy's presence like a spot of brightness against his eyelids. Elurín sat outside on the front stoop, next to the massive old yew growing against the side of the house, and the tree offered its senses to Maeglin readily. It knew the child for his and drew branches closer to shelter him. Maeglin opened the door and paused. Elúrin clutched a massive stick that must have been at least as tall as he was and stared intently into the forest. The yew was catching most of the snow before it could reach him, but a few flakes had collected in his hair.

“Elúrin?”

He jumped.

“Ah. Sorry to scare you.”

Elúrin looked up and scowled. “I didn't hear you!”

“I'm very quiet. An old habit.” He carefully lowered himself to the ground. “What are you up to out here?”

“Guarding.”

Maeglin’s heart twisted at that, but he tried not to reveal it. Perhaps that's what all children played at these days, with what the world had come to. “I see. I'm sure you’re doing a good job of it.”

“Not really. If you snuck up on me, so could something else.”

Maeglin considered the way Elúrin was huddled around his stick, the way his eyes flicked toward the lengthening shadows. “Mairon and I aren't going to let anything bad sneak up on you here.”

Elúrin sighed, but he allowed Maeglin to put an arm around him. “It doesn't matter,” he said quietly. “I should be dead too. I want to be dead. Then I'd be with my brother again. And Ada, and Nana, and little Elwing.”

Maeglin remembered the sharp wind on his face as he looked down from Caragdûr night after night after night, and how nothing Turgon said to him had ever felt anything but laughable. “They'll be waiting in Mandos a long, long time, and I think they'll be hoping you don't join them there too soon.”

“Not Eluréd. What will he do without me? He’ll be so lonely.”

“I'm sure he misses you horribly. But he’s got your Ada and Nana and…your little sister?”

Elúrin nodded.

“They'll all look after him and keep him company. And maybe he can see you sometimes in Vairë's tapestries.” Maeglin wondered if any of the stories were true, or if everyone simply repeated them as he was doing now, to dull a pain that could not be quenched.

“Will Ada have his head back?”

“I'm sure he will,” Maeglin lied.

“But what about me?” Elúrin whispered. His sniffles became outright sobs that shook him as he pressed himself into Maeglin's chest. “Maybe I could die of sadness like Grandmama. I bet I could if I tried.”

“Well. Maybe.” Maeglin had seen people die of grief, after the Nirnaeth. Some wasted away in a despondence they could not break. The determined ones went faster. “But even if you really want to, it doesn’t have to happen right away. You can always die later, you know? There's always next week, or next month, or next year, and maybe in the meantime you'll find something you want to stick around for. Just for a while.”

“I don't think there's anything.” He rubbed his face on Maeglin’s shirt while he thought. “But I guess I could wait. If it's just for a while.”

“Just for right now, you might feel a tiny bit better if we go have supper together. What do you think?”

Elúrin made a face. “Only if it's better supper than last night.”

“I'll make sure of it.”

*

Later that night, when he'd tucked Elurín into the bed Mairon had prepared for him in what had been a guest room long ago (though Maeglin couldn't remember any guests staying in it), he came back to the kitchen to finish washing up while Mairon swept the hearth and banked the fire to last the night.

“I would have taken care of that,” Mairon groused. “I don't need you making yourself worse.”

“I can manage this much. The hot water’s good for my hands, I think.”

“Good. Then you won't be needing me to warm them later.”

Maeglin contained the words that scrambled up his throat. He was beginning to suspect Mairon was at his most snappish when he was feeling panicky and insecure, but he pushed down the deep-seated need to leap to smooth things over and soothe him. He would not fear his Maia's moods.

“You've been unhappy all evening,” Mairon spat when Maeglin went on washing silently. “What have I done now?”

“I'm worried about Elurín,” Maeglin answered, a little proud of how steady and calm he kept his voice. “He told me earlier he wants to die.”

“Oh.” A chair was shoved into place under the table with more force than Maeglin could imagine was necessary. “Well that’s easily dealt with.”

“Is it?”

“We bind his fëa; I developed enchantments for that long ago. He can't slip away by grief or pain or distress then, and any injury will take longer to—but. There are some…deleterious effects. On the mind. And sense of independent will. Which is why I never used it on you. So…you probably don't want that.”

“It sounds like it wouldn't achieve what I'm looking for, no.”

In silence Mairon finished sweeping, then joined Maeglin at the sink, taking each dish from him and drying it. “I don't understand Elvish children well,” he said after a while. “But I have seen Elves survive things you wouldn’t believe out of sheer stubborn spite.” He chewed his lip. “I'll talk to him tomorrow, if you want.”

Maeglin hesitated—Sauron. I am talking about a child’s wellbeing to Sauron—then shrugged. “It can't be worse than the foolishness that was all I had for him.”

Mairon glanced at him with narrowed eyes, but said nothing. When the last dish was put away, he hung up his towel with perfect, even folds. Watching him filled Maeglin with the sort of quiet he usually only found underground. Sauron, he insisted again. The soft, settled feeling didn't leave, and it couldn't even be shaken by Mairon's prickliness. There was definitely something wrong with him.

“I didn't mean what I said about your hands,” Mairon offered without turning fully to meet him. “If you’re in pain, of course I'll—”

“I'm always in pain now,” Maeglin corrected. “But it isn't actually bad this moment. Thank you, all the same.”

A shadow crossed Mairon’s face, but he didn't argue. “Your bed upstairs is freshly made and ready for you. We did a lot of cleaning and rearranging while you slept, the child and I.”

“Thank you for that, too. I…Mairon—it means a lot, all you’re doing for me. I don't think I've said it enough. I'm very grateful.”

Mairon scoffed. “You expect too little.” But a redness lingered about his ears that Maeglin didn't think had been there before.

Maeglin started toward the stairs, but stopped when Mairon didn't follow. “Aren't you coming with me?” He held out his hand.

A terrible, aching hopefulness shone for a moment in his eyes before he snuffed it out. “You'll be plenty warm without me. I've imposed on you enough.”

“But I like having you there.”

“I'm going to find you your own wolf fur so you don't need mine.” His features began to lengthen as his fingers curved into paws.

“Mairon.” Maeglin couldn't see any farther into his mind, but he felt certain for once he was reading the Maia aright. “It's fine if you’re more comfortable that way. But you're welcome in my bed just as you are.”

The wolfishness retreated. He breathed a small “Oh,” and without another word, he took Maeglin’s hand and let him lead.

*

Maeglin never discovered exactly what Mairon said to Elurín, but they took up daily sword lessons together, in easy, short sessions at first. Mairon crafted him a wooden practice sword that balanced and swung like the finest of blades, and Elurín carried it everywhere. He seemed to grow stronger day by day, though he spent many hours in weeping, and soon Mairon declared him ready to eat whatever he liked and to train harder. Maeglin kept a close watch on Mairon’s teaching, but though he was at times both stern and demanding, he was never cruel, and his eyes often wandered to Maeglin's as if to confirm he had not crossed that line.

Maeglin tried to engage Elurín in lessons of his own, writing and sums and the scraps of Sindarin history and poetry he retained; all the things a young elf prince had a right to know. But Elurín's attention was only for the sword, and he could be convinced to sit and work at other things for mere moments at a time before he slipped away and took to wandering the cold hallways like a wraith again. Most days Maeglin let him. It didn't seem worth a fight, not when he knew what kind of pain the child bore and how all-consuming it could be, nor would he ever try to beat knowledge into another person in the same house where it had been done to him. Elurín could learn when he was ready.

So the winter days blurred together, piling one atop the next, none very different from the one before, while snow piled about the house and the world around them slept.


Leave a Comment