The Fall of Arnor, Book Three; "The Shirefolk" by Diane Finnis-Robb
Fanwork Notes
This story was intended to cover the major events of the fall of the kingdom of Arnor with the same level of detail and adventure as in The Lord of the Rings. It introduces new characters and histories to the conflict without deviating from the Tolkien canon as we know it through academic study.
- Fanwork Information
-
Summary:
The third of six books covering the fall of the kingdom of Arnor
Major Characters: Gandalf, Pallando, Alatar, Círdan, Glorfindel, Witch-king of Angmar, Eärnur, Black Númenóreans, Orcs, Hobbits, Dwarves, Aranarth
Major Relationships:
Genre:
Challenges:
Rating: General
Warnings: Character Death
Chapters: 1 Word Count: 1, 561 Posted on Updated on This fanwork is a work in progress.
Introduction and Synopsis
Read Introduction and Synopsis
Introduction
A longer introduction to the history of this work may be found in the two preceding books, "Out of the Bree-land" and "Into the Mushroom Fields." Those books were begun more than six years ago and this third part of the story some time around the spring of 2023. But a great reconstruction of this book happened midway through its first draft. After months of writing Book Three and constantly battling the urge to go deeper into the lives and histories of Hobbits, I did, in early 2023, finally succumb to that urge and left this story of the final battle for Arnor to write a stand alone novel of that history called “In the Shire-reckoning.” That novel, set three hundred and seventy-five years earlier, was drawn from the backstory I had devised for the Shire and its pioneer hobbits. Much of the early material in that novel was drawn from the first draft of this story and does indeed complement this tale, but it is not directly part of the series.
It is a difficult thing to write an adventure story set in the Shire for that land is intended to be a rather idyllic and peaceful place where adventures should seldom happen. But it became clear to me in the crafting of this story that readers would be disappointed that my characters should travel through such famous territory and spend very little time there. So dramas were established, rivalries created and certain backstories came to mind which might fill that peaceful little realm with material interesting to readers (and myself). Enough material and backstory in fact that it altered my plans, and the title, of this third book of “The Fall of Arnor.” I have established a cast of well over one hundred fifty named hobbits over these past three years and it seems that here we may put to rest the idea of the involvement which Shirefolk had in the War against Angmar and their service to the king.
So, quite contrary to my initial plan, here is yet another book that quite heavily features hobbits.
Also new as of this writing, I have become a member of The Silmarillion Writers' Guild and have chosen it to be the main portal of distribution of my work in Tolkienian fiction. The membership here is supportive and smart, well-versed and well-intended, and quite gifted in their own work and in their educational goals. I am so intrigued and delighted by this new environment that I am going to try to release the work here in a serialized fashion, hoping for comments along the way. As someone who has worked for decades in the field of comics, this method is familiar and appealing to me. Much of this third book was already written three years ago, but now, in the second draft, it is all very new again.
-D. F. R.
Synopsis
Here begins the third book of The Fall of Arnor, a telling of events which occurred many years before the War of the Ring and relating many of the details of how the realms of the North faced the great challenge of the Witch-king of Angmar, won the day through great deeds at the Battle of Fornost Fields, yet eventually fell into dissolution.
The first part, Out of the Bree-land, told of the meeting of three wizards (Olórin, Alatar and Pallando) in a tavern in the chief city of the Bree-land. Chance, as some might call it, had also brought three other travelers to the tavern that night who were also of great significance in the coming years: Tawarengil, a young Elf-lord from Thranduil’s halls in the Greatwood; Beothalion, a tall Man from the Vale of Anduin who carried an inner strength; and finally, Benbow Floxleaf, a most peculiar hobbit who had roamed and hunted in the lands of the North for all his lifetime.
These six travelers caught the attention of Ohtar, a servant of the true heir of Elendil, who, through honesty and cleverness, drew the group together to serve plans of his own.
This unlikely meeting happened on an April evening in the nineteen hundred and seventy-fifth year of the Third Age of Middle-earth, a time when the fate of Elendil’s North Kingdom, Arnor as it was called of old, was very much in peril. Elendil and Isildur, his heir, had perished in the Great War with Sauron in the South nearly two thousand years before and since that time the people of Arnor had diminished. In the eight hundred and sixty-first year of that age king Eärendur, in a fit of madness, had divided the North Kingdom between his three sons, leading to generations of strife. Then, in the thirteen hundred and twenty-fifth year of that age, a new power arose in the north as The Witch-king declared himself openly in Angmar.
After six hundred and fifty years of wars with Angmar, after plagues and the destruction of many great cities, the North kingdom of the heirs of Elendil has been all but lost in the time of our story. The king, Arvedui, has fled into the North and cannot be found. A great council has been called by Círdan, lord of the Elves at Mithlond, to determine the fate of the North. Tawarengil and his brother Beothalion were traveling that way and the three wizards, on errands of their own, were debating this option as well.
But Ohtar, in revealing his own troubles, presents them with another plan. He and his companion, a dwarf rune-master named Flomi, are seeking a long-forgotten storehouse which is of great importance to the heir of Elendil. But Flomi and his research have been noticed by a Black Númenórean, a rider out of Angmar, and so they must flee the Bree-land. Flomi, following a pre-arranged plan, departs in advance of Ohtar and the others and is waylaid by a small band of orcs at the Tauma, an old Arnorian hiding place which he and Ohtar have prepared. He is gravely injured in battle with the orcs and, in the last, is aided by a new friend, Oisín, a wild Númenórean from the great woods to the south.
When the others choose to follow Ohtar west out of the Bree-land to learn more about his mission and to offer their aid, they encounter the wounded Flomi and his caretaker Oisín at the Tauma. There they learn that a band of three score orcs out of Angmar have been sent to attack the Bree-land. As the party is unable to travel without putting Flomi’s health at risk, Olórin chooses to go back to the Bree-land to stop the orcs. He aids in the muster of the Bree-land and advises them on the coming battle as is told in the second book of this tale, Into the Mushroom Fields.
But far more than three score enemies have come; a full three hundred and fifty orcs have ridden out of the north and their goal is the capture of Flomi as well as the utter destruction of the town. The Breefolk fight valiantly and take many losses. They meet the captain of that army, Sakalkhôr, a Black Númenórean, and from him Olórin learns that Arvedui, last king of the North Kingdoms, is dead.
Sakalkhôr and his forces are defeated with the help of Ohtar’s own people, though the Black Captain himself escapes. Olórin leaves the people of the Bree-land in relative safety and departs to bring his message to Rivendell and enlist the aid of Elrond.
But in the perceived safety of the Tauma all is not well for the party. On the morning of Olórin’s departure a small doorway is noticed in the antechamber. On that night an impossibly large horde of rats come through that door to attack the party. Beothalion, showing another side to his nature, and Alatar, revealing some hint of his own power, dispel them. It is decided that the place is no longer safe though Flomi must remain there for four more nights to heal from his wounds.
So the party is split once again. Ohtar, Flomi, Ben, Oisín, and the wizard Pallando go further into the Tauma behind a great door covered in many runes. But Alatar, Tawarengil, Beothalion and Ohtar’s horse Caitelyn will now travel west to answer Círdan’s call.
Three wizards met, by chance, in the most uncommon of places to discuss their wanderings and their secret mission. Chance revealed to them three different paths forward and, trusting to their understanding of the forces at play, they have followed each of these paths.
This third book, The Shirefolk, now tells of the two of these paths, north and west, and of the adventures had by the travelers since the sundering of their fellowship. Of what great things were discovered and of what mighty lords were met, of what tragedies occurred and what griefs were felt before the Great War with Angmar comes and the Witch-king himself is met, all of which is to be recounted in the last part of this story, At Fornost Fields.