Last week's newsletter went deep into Tolkien studies, so this one reverses course back to fanworks, fanworks, fanworks!

In terms of thinking about fanworks, we first have the next installment of Cultus Dispatches: an interview with the creator of the Silmarillion Headcanon Survey, Scedasticity. This recent sub-series of articles on fanon and other fan-generated theories really started when I was startled by data from the Tolkien Fanfiction Survey about the authority fanfiction writers give to other fans' ideas. We often think of fanons and headcanons as being rife with conflict (and sometimes they are!), but what survey data showed was the fans put a lot of stock in each other's ideas and wisdom—more than they do scholars, filmmakers, and even Christopher Tolkien—nudging me to look deeper at fanon and other fan-generated theories and how we the fanworks creators interact with those.

Scedasticity's survey—actually surveys, plural—do exactly that. She asks which of popular headcanons fans ascribe to. Over the years, she's amassed quite a list of surveys with varying levels of intensity, but the results are intriguing, and she was kind enough to talk to me about her experiences running the survey, the results that did (and didn't) surprise her, and where she sees the surveys going in the future. You can read my interview with Scedasticity here (and can view Silmarillion Headcanon Survey results and take the open surveys here).

In terms of making fanworks, we have a new challenge this month: Experimental. The title is not very experimental and the challenge really is what its title says: the opportunity to experiment with a new approach to making fanworks. The challenge moderators have compiled a list of fiction and art prompts ranging from mild (different medium) to wild (asemic writing, a term I did not even know until working on this challenge), or you can make your own prompt of something you've wanted to try in your work but haven't had the chance. Challenge prompts are good forever, but if you want the lovely stamps made by Independence1776 this month, your entry should be posted to the SWG archive no later than 15 November 2023. If you're new to our challenges, come join us! The full challenge guidelines are here.