Comments on always feel like home to me

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


I have this story and many of your other Maedhros and Fingon stories bookmarked on my Ao3 account, and with Ao3 down I've been so happy to find your stories here on the SWG archive. I've reviewed many of your stories before on Ao3, although often more briefly than they deserve. I'm usually reading on my phone and I find it challenging to leave feedback commensurate with what good stories deserve on my phone. 

This is one of my very favorites of your stories. I love how poignant and sweet it is. Maedhros' fears and determination not to try to renew his romance with Fingon for Fingon's own good is heart-breaking (you write this well in several of your stories as I recall). I love Fingon's kindness and persistence here (again, this is something you write well in many of your stories). 

I loved how Fingon hadn't realized that the reason Maedhros hadn't tried to resume their love affair was that Maedhros didn't believe he should, that Maedhros believed his body was ruined and that he wasn't worthy of Fingon, rather than that Maedhros hadn't taken any action to resume their love affair just because he didn't want to. It's an understandable misunderstanding for Fingon to have made. 

I loved how gently he pointed out that he'd already seen Maedhros' scars and injuries, and how he made it clear through his actions that he still loved Maedhros' body as well as his mind. I loved how Fingon kept asking “Do you not want to, or do you think that you ought not?”

Thank you so much for writing this and sharing it on more than one archive!