The Fall of Arnor; Book One "Out of the Bree-land" by Diane Finnis-Robb
Fanwork Notes
This story was intended to deal with the major events of the fall of the kingdom of Arnor with the same level of detail and adventure as found in The Lord of the Rings. It introduces new characters and histories to the conflict without deviating from the Tolkien canon as we know it through academic study.
- Fanwork Information
-
Summary:
The first of six books covering the fall of the kingdom of Arnor
Major Characters: Gandalf, Pallando, Alatar, Glorfindel, Eärendur, Witch-king of Angmar, Black Númenóreans, Orcs
Major Relationships:
Genre: Adventure
Challenges:
Rating: General
Warnings: Character Death
Chapters: 11 Word Count: 132, 271 Posted on Updated on This fanwork is complete.
Introduction and Table of Contents
Read Introduction and Table of Contents
Introduction
The opportunity to create and play in the lush world of J. R. R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings has captivated artists for generations. I am no different in my love for that world and its stories than millions of other creators all over the world.
The story that you will find here began as a choose-your-own-adventure role-playing game for a select group of friends who seldom get the time for that kind of interaction any longer; it was meant simply a chance for us to gather, create, interact and discuss in this exciting universe with full fan freedom and none of the restrictions of editors, arguers and copyright attorneys. Most of the plans for that adventure were made in 2019, well before the Covid pandemic came along and upset plans for all our shared universes; cultural, political, social, physical and fictional.
In the year 2020, as the pandemic was at its worst, I found myself escaping to Middle-earth every day, building the small story that I had in mind for my friends and players into a novel. There were originally no plans in my mind for opening it to the public as I’m doing here; I simply wanted to share it with a handful of friends who had seen me develop the idea. But writing in such a rich and full world, my own or anyone else’s, has a way of taking an author into unexpected territories. There is so much more material here than I ever imagined creating and by the end of 2020 I began to revise much of the early story into a series of two or three novels. The plan was to mimick The Lord of the Rings in scope; to have six "books" of adventure story followed by an appedices of world-building material.
Set in the year 1975 of the Third Age of Middle-earth, some thousand years before the events of the War of the Ring, this story concerns the fall of the last remnants of the North Kingdom and the war with the Witch-king of Angmar. It is written entirely within the context of Tolkien’s work and not as an “alternative history.” I have tried at every step of the writing to stay true to the original source material and welcome any feedback on any of my mistakes. As a writer and artist I am painfully aware of how poor my skills are as a researcher; for artists collect information only to support their own purposes and too readily lose information which does not.
During the writing of this book I have made contact with many Tolkien fans who have contributed to its growth. Our conversations have played an enormous part in my work, my understanding of the material and my own mental and creative health over the past few years. I can’t thank you all enough for that. If, as I hope, this book brings you a small opportunity to delight in an extended world of Tolkien’s design as the writing of it has done for me, then you should know that it grew out of those very important conversations.
-D. F. R.
Contents
Book I
1) “A Meeting at the Four Greenfields”
2) “Fear, Fire, Foes”
3) “Questions Amid the Ashes”
4) “The Ways into the West”
5) “Gathering Concerns”
6) “Flight to the Foundations”
7) “The Bard’s Tale”
8) “As They Waited”
9) “The Worry of Rats, a Counsel of Stones and the Better Part of Our Nature”
10)“Two Ways Forward”
Chapter One; "A Meeting at the Four Greenfields"
-In which Many Important Folk are Drawn Together for a Chance Meeting
Read Chapter One; "A Meeting at the Four Greenfields"
Early springtime in the Bree-land1 had grown less bright. Traffic along the East-West Road had slowed for generations and the small community that lived between the Hill and the Crossroads saw fewer and fewer travelers these days. The Dwarves, who claim to have had a mighty hand in the Road’s construction, used it seldom now to travel from their homes in the Blue Mountains to their far-distant and more ancient halls in the Iron Hills. For at this time, or so the Breelanders had heard, Men and Elves, in their unceasing struggles with the Dark powers, had brought war once again to the North of Middle-earth and all the old paths east had become uncertain. So now fewer and fewer folk came across the fields into the Bree-land from a road so filled with dangers.
They went east still, the venerable Dwarf traders from the Blue Mountains who had formerly made the Breelanders prosperous, but by longer paths. Around the settlements west of the Baranduin where many of the Periannath (or Little People) who had left the area of the Hill some three hundred years before2 had built a pleasant home for themselves copying the peaceful (and, until recently, quite successful) Bree-land model. But the Little Folk in that land were not as open to strangers as the Breelanders had been, so Dwarven travelers went wide west of their settlements and crossed the mighty Baranduin at the South Crossing, some two-hundred and fifty miles southwest of the Bree-land and quite far enough to affect the trade.
Now just where the Dwarves went from there is uncertain and, for those outside of the Bree-land who may have reason to care for such things, it was still the subject of much debate. Khazad-dûm, great and prosperous hall of Durin through two ages of Middle-earth, still thrived of course, though the old Elvish kingdom of Hollin on its western face had been razed by war in an earlier age. The old gate there had been closed and the Dwarves of Khazad-dûm traveled only east and north to the Iron Hills now. They avoided the Men of Arnor, the sundered North Kingdom, for war had come into that land from the dark fortress of Angmar that was called Carn Dûm. The Dwarves were certainly no strangers to war, but they saw little profit in this conflict and kept their distance. And so it was that the Breelanders now saw no profit from Dwarven gems and gold and mithril as the Elves of the north and the Men to the east and south did.
Despite this slowing of trade the Hill and its surrounding villages, which folks more simply called “the Bree-land”, had remained quite calm and peaceful for many hundreds of years. The main village was on the southwest side of the Hill and quite pleasantly situated near to the crossing of the two Roads and surrounded by a wide and cultivated hedge of which the Breefolk were very proud. This settlement always had a large inn and stables to serve travelers and many other small businesses as well. There were perhaps fifty houses on the hillside and within the Hedge and they even had a small tower (though it might stretch the definition to call a forty foot building a tower) near the inn which held a great Clock.3
This device and its little tower had, in fact, predated the community there and had been built by the Sea-kings as their Road came south and the cornerstone was laid. It would be more accurate to say that the Bree-land had grown up around the Clock than to to say that it was theirs. But while the Clock had not functioned within the living memory of any Breelander such an unusual device was quite uncommon in that part of the world at this time, and so one should not be surprised at the pride which all the neighboring folk took in it; for the Clock, to their minds, made their village into a city and, to many other minds as well, a place of some importance. While they still had hourglasses and sundials and other such older tools to accurately judge the day’s time many Breelanders quite commonly would express it using the phrase “of the clock” as it sounded much more civilized and echoed back to the day when their land certainly had much greater importance.
Proud of their home and the peace that it had brought them, the Breefolk were an odd and isolated community,4 belonging to nobody but themselves (and more accustomed to dealing with hobbits, dwarves and other odd inhabitants of the world than most Big People were or are now). The Big People of the Bree-land were brown-faced, dark-haired, broad, shortish, cheerful and independent. But there were also, and particularly in the main village of the Bree-land, quite a large number of hobbits.
Through long centuries the war of the Northmen against the Witch-king of Angmar had remained many leagues still from the Breelander’s doorstep, even as the last throne of the Sea Kings5 at Fornost had fallen in the winter of the previous year. No news and no travelers came from that direction and the North Road became silent and forbidding, and grasses grew over its stones. Now, with the springtime, people came timidly into the Bree-land and cast their eyes warily that way as if expecting to see doom riding down it from the dark and unknown lands of the North.
‘And so there’s to be fewer folks heading north with all those troubles there,’ said old Tom Truetunnels on one auspicious night at the Four Greenfields.6 Tom and his family had been Breelanders for many generations and had been proud of the fact that they refused to move west with all those Marish-folk, Fallowhides and Stoors and other uprisers to their foolish experiment across the Brown River. But that was before war had come to the lands of Arnor, a war that the Kingdom of Men seemed to be losing, and some other of Tom’s neighbors were not quite so sure about their position and of the town’s safety as he purported to be.
‘And I say fewer’s the better for us here. No, let the troubles of those folk in the north stay in the north, I say, for it's not the business of a Breelander, and not from the makings of our own. No, it's Elvish folk and their Elvish ways which stirs up these troubles and make things unsafe for travelers. But it’s those travelers...’ he said with a gleam in his eyes upon making his rather polished point, ‘those travelers that bring their own troubles into our lands, do they not?’
And there was some approvals to this notion, for Tom was holding a small but very seriously concerned court of his neighbors in The Four Greenfields, the largest inn of the Bree-land and the closest to the Crossways. The Greenfields was, for generations, Bree-land’s most famous public house having been laid in the town’s west end and nearest to Tharangond,7 the crossing stone of where the East-West Road meets its younger North-South counterpart. This made it an ideal gathering spot in old days when the Road saw much more use of course, for it was the first inn to be found coming east through the Hedge-gate. An old stone building, unique for having two stories and a large stable, green window shutters and even paned glass to many of its windows. But now, in years of fewer travelers coming over the Road, it gained greater importance for being adjacent to the Clock- tower, the town’s greatest landmark. Many townsfolk were heard to say, “meet you under the Clock” which was, of course, a way of saying, “meet you at the Four Greenfields.”
Tom Truetunnels was perhaps playing on the feelings of his more frightened and doubtful neighbors in his comments. For present there that night, and throughout the Bree-land, the townsfolk, who were at the time comprised more of the ‘Little People’ than the ‘Big Folk’, held a certain healthy disapproval for the wars of Men. These wars had brought them nothing but suffering (if only in the commercial sense) for some six-hundred years or more. Many of his neighbors felt that if war had finally come then, much like their distant relatives west in the Shire, it might be time for them to leave.
But not all those people assembled at the Four Greenfields that night were Breelanders nor were they ready to accept the rather loudly stated opinions of old Tom Truetunnels. Towards the back of the public room where Tom spoke rather openly to his neighbors (and anyone else who might have half a mind to listen), back in the darkest and most removed spot available to travelers, three quite tall gentlemen sat in a rather curious and complete silence, huddled in large greycloaks as if they were keeping away the rain. Careful observers (and, if the truth be told, there were precious few of those at the Four Greenfields on this particular evening) might have been surprised by their company; for though no one could attest to just when it was they had arrived, not a single person in the room had heard them speak to one another as they sat there apart from the crowd. Occasionally one would look deeply, sharply even, at another, but no words were spoken by them which any Breelander had yet heard.
Until Old Tom Truetunnels spoke his piece and seemed to have gained the assent, if not the full out praise, of many people around him. Just until then.
‘Their troubles, you say?’ replied the tallest of the three. He stood up as he spoke, perhaps out of anger or perhaps out of the simple cordiality involved in joining Old Tom’s conversation (for that would be a regular courtesy in any publichouse at the time). Kindness might have been in his manner then, even if it could not exactly be found in his deep and resonant voice. There was some surprise caused by his approach and in his person and his demeanor, and all of the other folk listening to Tom would have trouble discussing the man clearly with their friends later (though , of course, being Breelanders and in considering the events which would come over the following week, they would indeed discuss him for a very, very long time thereafter). His cloak may have seemed old and tattered, but clearly this was not a regular traveler to the Bree-land, well certainly not of the kind that Tom Truetunnels might call ‘regular’, and many in the crowd found his outspokenness quite as surprising as his looks.
There was a fire in his eyes, deep and grey as they were, and a spark seemed to kindle under his brow as he spoke; ‘So the troubles of Men and Elves mean little to you over troubles of trade and a good harvest, do they?
‘And perhaps that is as it should be. Perhaps all of your perceived prosperity might best be measured in the number of pints this barman might sell,’ he said, cordially gesturing toward the proprietor at the center of the room and meeting his eye. ‘But where will you be when there is no one left to sell them to, I wonder?’ he said to the barman. ‘Where will you all be when the joys of this world mean nothing to those who have taken them from you?’ he said to the crowd.
‘For you and all the Peoples of the North, Halflings8 and Elves and Dwarves and Men, you now live in a time of choice. War will come. War, greater than what you know now, and even the broadest campaigns of this time will seem as skirmishes to tomorrow’s generals. How will you address it, I wonder? Now is your time to resolve yourselves and know your minds. Will the gossip and cautions of local shopmen and short-sighted farm-keepers guide your steps, or will the boldness of kings charge your hands?’
He paused here, looking back at the expressions of his companions as if he were somehow being scolded for having said too much. ‘Yes,’ he said quietly, sitting again, ‘I wonder how you will address it.’
Now old Tom Truetunnels was a builder like his father before him and not some shopman or farmer as the tall wassird seemed to suggest, but beyond that this talk didn’t sit with him; was he being called short-sighted by some stranger? Well, that just simply would not do.
‘We don’t know much about the ‘boldness of kings’ here-abouts, greymantle, but wars we have seen come and go, and far too many to suit us as a peaceable folk,’ Tom replied. ‘True, I suppose, that there’s a horrible land with a horrible Witch-king away to the north and the Big Folk of the Old Kingdoms will fight him to their deaths, so it seems. Sad and horrible,’ he said with genuine regret in his voice, ‘but far from us and in a cause not of our making,’ he added with reinforced conviction. ‘You say, whomever it is you may be, that their war is ours, but the Folk of the Bree-land have never seen it nor given into it in one way or the other; no, the Big Folk come up or down their road to the war, some fewer come back as those that goes, but no war has touched us here in the Bree-land since the Stone was first lain in the crossways and the Clock first built.’
Smiling then, and perhaps a bit too sure of himself and his opinion, he stood as the stranger had, cordially in that same way, but with the emphasis of his argument.
‘What would you say then, traveler, to that? Is it not peaceable for a folk to stay out of some war not of their making?’ Said Tom.
The quiet this discussion caused in the otherwise busy commonroom of the Four Greenfields was sudden and quite complete. And it may rightly be said that understanding this discussion goes a long way to understanding the times and the people assembled there at this most particular moment on an early spring day in the nineteen-hundred and seventy-fifth year of the Third Age of Middle-earth. For many people who were auspicious in the coming days of that Age were, by coincidence (if that is what you wish to call it), gathered here yet unbeknownst to one another and, though it would be to the great surprise of the rather straightforward if simple Tom Truetunnels, the arguments offered here went far to shape opinions of the Wise for many hundreds of years to come.
The three tall Men (if Men they were) continued to sit in locked silence, even if the previous speaker’s long and bushy eyebrows seemed to wrinkle at Tom’s question. He had, in Tom’s standing address, been rather specifically called to answer, and some tension fell amongst the room when he himself did not stand to respond; after all, old rules of a public debate still held sway even in provincial places like the Bree-land and standing-to in any publichouse carries a very ancient response of standing-back.
The grey old fellow did not stand. He did not need to, for the voice of the traveler, somber at first, held the attention of everyone in the common room.
‘Peaceable? Most certainly,’ he said. ‘And it is a wise and just folk who will seek peace when so much strife confronts them. Is it peaceable for rabbits to hide in their holes while predators are abroad? Peaceable indeed. And wise too, when the night seems so full of dread. But is it a want for peace or a healthy fear that guides them? And, moreover, is it wise, in fear or in the cause of peace, to disregard the plight of one’s neighbor for the security of one’s own fortune? Is it the wisdom and desire for peace that guides your lack of action, or a fear for your own safety?’
This rather direct assault on the bravery of Breelanders met with some immediate gasps of surprise and some grumblings of anger, but the old man continued without concern.
‘Now fear, it might be said, is also wise in these times. For the Witch-king that you speak of is very fearsome indeed and, if my own fears are correct, he is only one finger on the hand of a much greater Menace than you might imagine. If you do stay your hand in war out of fear then you should know that your fear is well warranted.
‘But fear will not stop the dark times that are coming to all the lands of the North. Fear will not stop the Witch-king and his creatures from riding through all the ‘peaceable’ lands of Middle-earth and destroying the lives and fortunes you have found here. Will you not resist your fear and instead find courage in allegiance? Will you not stand with those who would protect you? Is the Bree-land not part of the North Kingdom?’
Now this last bit of his argument, whether the speaker knew so or not, had been a debate in the Bree-land for many hundreds of years. For the town indeed had its origins with the Kings-out-of-the-Sea and the construction of their North-South Road long ages before. When the Tharangond was first set, the Clock-tower built and a sentry post laid at the meetings of the two great Roads it was certain that a town would quickly emerge. And it had, for the four fields at either quarter of the roads’ crossing were fertile as like an island in the empty lands around it. So it was that in those days they were inhabited by descendents of the first Men who had wandered there after the changing of the world. These early town-fathers were not servants of the Sea Kings and, at that time, paid them no allegiance. The Kings of Númenor came and they built their Road and their Clock-tower, but it was these others who benefited greatly from the trade there over many long years. And for many generations of men and kings no tariffs were levied, no taxes drawn, and the Breelanders were left free to govern themselves as long as the roads remained open.
And so the Road did remain open through many long troubles in other regions of the world. And here a thriving community grew in relative peace while turmoil besieged the greater realms. News was heard, bad news most often, but bad times themselves had stayed out of the Bree-land until quite recently.
While there was no official connection between the Bree-land and the Sea Kings the first townsfolk felt a certain loyalty to the Silver Crown which had later come into question. In the town’s earliest days there was one great Sea King and he and his sons had used the North-South Road to move their warriors against the Dark Lord in far-off Mordor. And that war had been won, but at great cost, for the old King had died and now the Númenóreans had split their lands between the two sons with a kingdom in the North, Arnor, and another, Gondor, away in the South. That first northern king, Isildur of Arnor, was by all accounts a very great hero, but he had never returned from his war with the Dark Lord. The Breelanders heard the tales of this Isildur for many long years and even took a certain pride in telling them to others. After all, everyone loves to tell stories of the heroes from their own lands and, perhaps by dying so far away and never bothering the Breelanders, he made for the most excellent model of a king that anyone might wish for. No Breelander ever doubted the lordship of Isildur, who had never really bothered them with his own troubles, and so to him all proper respect was given. But his death, many hundreds of years ago, slowed the travel of warriors along the North-South Road and people of the Bree-land lost interest in, or connections to, Isildur’s heirs. And still no taxes were ever drawn nor demands made upon the Breelanders, so business at the Crossways went on much as it had before. Breelanders believed in their king but felt and acted quite curiously free of any kingship. To many, this was the most excellent of arrangements.
It was an arrangement that continued for another eight hundred years and, while soldiers still came and went occasionally through the town, the Road in the direction of the South was not patrolled and went untended; the grass grew long on the paving stones and people began to call it the Greenway. Then, in the declining years of Eärendur, the last reigning king of Arnor who left no clear successor, the northern realm was split yet again into three parts by his sons.9 And so news was heard again in the Bree-land; bad news as usual, but for Breelanders it seemed more the worse, because the Crossways and the position of their small community, lay rather squarely at the boundary for each of these fledgling nations. Which created the question still much in debate today; claimed by three kings it had never known and paying taxes to no one throughout their long history, was the Bree-land truly part of any kingdom?
This had all happened some eleven-hundred very long years before the discussion at the Four Greenfields of course, and no reason had yet come about to resolve the issue. It is quite important to remember that questions like these seem to take many, many long generations to resolve, particularly when discussed in no place more official than a local publichouse.
But it should also be noted that this division of kingdoms occurred at a time when the population of the Bree-land began to change. As if three squabbling brother kings surrounding them were not distraction enough, trouble was brewing on the Eastern Road past the mountains and a dark Shadow had fallen on Greenwood the Great so that Men, returning from travel in that direction, began to call it Mirkwood. Trade to the east was all but abandoned. Old relationships between the First Men here in the western lands of the North and their old brethren to the east were forgotten. At this time the Common tongue of travelers began to grow (some proud Breelanders would suggest it happened here, at the Four Greenfields and the cornerstone of the Tharangarond, first10) and many Peoples, fearing the Darkness growing to the East, settled in Bree-land, tripling the town’s size within two generations. Most of these new people were hobbitlya, or so the First Men of old had called them, but here, as they came to the Bree-land about ten hundred years ago, they were simply referred to as ‘the Little People’, and they had very little interest in a king they had never met.
Tom Truetunnels, proud nineteenth scion of a grandsire who first walked into the Bree-land and made it his home during that time, was less than pleased with being compared to a rabbit and, of course, felt that he had great argument to give about the town’s allegiance to some king whose name he’d never come to know.
‘Well, we’re part of the North to be sure, but we’re that part which wants no part of any king, if you ask me,’ said Tom. ‘And why should we? We’ve seen nothing of any king here in the Bree-land for many lifetimes and have had quite enough nuisance from the squabbling of the Three Kings’ soldiers along our borders. Now those squabbles are over, their tall towers have tumbled down and all those soldiers lie in their mounds out West of here. I’m sorry for that, truly sorry, but, sad though that may be, their troubles, brought upon themselves, is ours no more. I’ve seen no Witch-king nor goblins here in the Bree-land and I’ll warrant we never shall.’
‘In that you might be wrong, sir,’ said a calm voice from near the fire. This came from one of the many Little Folk gathered there that night, though he seemed alone and stood apart from most of the rest. He was dressed in a peculiar fashion (for a hobbit of the Bree-land at least), all muted greens and browns, a supple leather waistcoat rather than the usual brightly dyed cloth, and an oddly triangle-shaped grey-green cap, which sat on his head and shaded his eyes.
‘For I’ve seen them in my rounds in the north of Chetwood. Orcs that is. Of a Witch-king, well, I can’t say anything about that other than they’ve got some kind of a king I’m sure, even if Breelanders do not,’ he said.
‘Now, Ben,’ said Tom, ‘save your long tales of the wild for those that buy your wares. I’ve seen the pelts you bring to market each month, but there’s not a Mammoth Wolf, giant batwing nor an Oliphant in the lot.’ This seemed to quiet the young hobbit, whether out of shyness or respect or simply because he chose not to argue. Either way, Tom Truetunnels was pleased with the results.
‘No, I say again, it's the Elves and the Sea Kings that have caused all their own troubles and, no matter who might tell us otherwise,’ he said, pausing to look back at the rather argumentative stranger in the corner, ‘those troubles will not touch us here. Leave well enough well alone, I say.’
And with that, and a rather long and self-congratulatory last gulp of his ale, he left them all to be the wiser.
*****
Nights like these at the Four Greenfields were the reason why Buttercup Blueburrow so very much loved her job. It was hard work of course, serving food and drink to thirsty customers, and the inn was uncommonly crowded for this time of year, making her chores run quite late into the evenings. But travelers here brought new life to the otherwise drab little town with their tales (and sometimes songs!) of far off lands. Stories of people and places that Buttercup herself had often imagined yet knew she would never see in her own lifetime. The townsfolk were largely boring to a girl of her age and (as her aunt had called it) her rather dreamy disposition. That old Tom Truetunnels, like most of his friends, was a gossipy sort and no one ever heard anything good or exciting in all of his talk (to which she was unwillingly treated on most nights of the week). But tonight, by whatever fortune, the inn was nearly full with all manner of travelers and the half-overheard conversations in the common room were proving quite a distraction from serving drinks and food to all these wonderful strangers.
The room itself (for she was certain it wasn’t due to the food served there) was the most popular gathering spot in the Bree-land and many people from the surrounding areas came there whenever business brought them to town. The townsfolk, lacking anything more exciting to do with their evenings, came there most nights as they always had in hope of hearing news from the world around them. But, being Breelanders, they preferred only good news or small gossip and expected that it should come from somewhere not too far from their very own doors.
Now there were three fireplaces in that room which made it an exceptional place for gathering. Two were lit but recently in this early hour of a spring evening and only with a low blaze, yet people still pulled tables around them and there were always loose chairs there which they huddled together for their more private conversations. Amidst all of that the room itself was still quite large and in its center Collum Gilleyfoil, the Four Greenfield’s proprietor, had built a great serving station filled with bottles and flasks and barrels of all of the drinking stock put plainly in sight for his guests. Then, piled around and about that collection of wares, he had arranged the majority of the house’s tankards and mugs and other vessels so that everyone assembled might be reminded that here, in the middle of their talking, was a place to drink. It became quite popular (as one might expect) therefore to do both in the commonroom and so, showing the initiative to improve on a good idea, the owner had built a long oval table surrounding this whole serving area so that customers might come for their drinks easier (but still be prohibited from nipping the odd drop or two for themselves). He jokingly, or at least in joking with Buttercup and her other co-workers, called it “the henhouse”; because in time this part of the room, perhaps more so than the fireplaces, became popular for the townspeople as a spot to gather where they might watch the coming-and-goings of travelers and other outliers, talking their gossip and giving their viewpoints to any who might listen. It was there Collum spent most of his nights, talking with guests while pouring out the drink, and so, being one of the Big Folk himself (and in fact quite taller than most in the town), he built the surrounding table of the Henhouse Man-size and to elbow’s height where someone of his own size might want to comfortably rest his drink. Many of the townsfolk were Little People of course, so they had taken the matter of the table’s height not as an insult and, quite matter-of-factly (as hobbits usually do) they had solved the problem on their own. Large stools were fashioned by the hobbits, taller than themselves but with ladder-like rungs, so that the smaller Breelanders might also have a spot in the room’s center. Given the shape of these round ladder-like stools, and as good natured jab at the owner’s name, this was called “sitting at the Column” and became the favored vantage point by many of the regulars.11
On this particular night there were only six or so of those regulars surrounding the Henhouse and the majority of the other tables in the room held an odd sampling of total strangers, local acquaintances, curious country folk and occasional visitors. There were a few nightly visitors like Bert Thistleberry, the town cooper and Harry Flownsey, the baker’s son. Tom Truetunnels and his cronies, who had been coming here for decades and felt it somehow undignified to “sit at the Column”, preferred to huddle nearer to the fireplaces no matter the weather and, as Tom’s own example had shown, cared little for the opinions of strangers in the room about them. Buttercup avoided Tom and his older friends as much as possible, mostly because she found them dull but also, as Collum himself had said, ‘their need to share their own opinion exceeds their need of drink and, remember, there’s no profit to be had from their opinion.’
Fern Sarnside and his friends were another small group she shied away from. Fern was a gangly, dark fellow from near the eastern gate of the village and he had a sneaky eye that a girl of Buttercup’s age knew well as a caution. He had some companions join him many nights this past month who were (if one could imagine it) much worse. Sallow-faced, oily-skinned and stern-looking, their clothing was always rugged and dark and they spied at every tankard or mug she brought them as if they might carry it off in their near empty satchels. They weren’t armed as travelers often are (and Collum certainly discouraged long blades here in the commonroom), but they had small, cunning knives on their belts; impractical for cutting meats and dark like their clothing. She did not like to think what uses they had for such blades and, distrusting Sarnside as she did, gave him, his friends, and his usual table over near the rear door, a wide berth. They went to Collum for their needs and he (or so she believed) trusted them even less.
Flomi was at his usual spot by the back as well, though, as ever, he needed little to no attention. He sat there most every night, drinking quite slowly, and working away at his little scraps of pelt and paper. He drank much more sparingly than the reputation of his race, but Buttercup had always found him to be very kind in his way, and this also did not live up to the stories she had heard of Dwarves. But he had lived here at the Four Greenfields for many long years and taking care of him and his little eccentricities was quite familiar to her by this point. Other Dwarves might, on rare occasions, come and go, but Flomi, and even his father before him it was said, were a steady fixture in this small community and, in all the years she had served him, he never offered tales of his past or his time in travel.
Ben Floxleaf was in tonight and he was quite another matter. Buttercup hoped to talk with him when she could, for Ben was the farthest traveled hobbit that any Breelander had ever heard of and, while he was not a braggart by any stretch, he knew much more of the goings-on around these lands than any merchant or wayfarer who had ever bothered to visit the Four Greenfields more than once. His folk had come out of the North many long years ago, with the first Hobbit settlers in the Bree-land, leading many of them over the mountains it was said, but they had never made a home here. He, and his fathers before him, roamed and tracked and hunted game through the lands north and directly around the Bree-land and brought such a steady trade of their catch here to town that most other hunters had put the practice aside. Ben, a favorite of Buttercup’s, was here in town for many long days in the summer, but this was a bit early in the year for her to see him and his funny cap show up in the commonroom. She had no time to greet him with more than a smile just yet however as business was so brisque that evening. He smiled back to her, although his smile, or so it seemed to her, looked quite sad.
There were also the three old gentlemen near the back who had just made such a stir by arguing with old Truetunnels. They had been shown the most of Buttercup’s attention that evening for they were, up until that point, clearly the most exotic travelers she had ever seen. Wassirds, as the townsfolk called them, came sometimes to the Bree-land, but none had ever been seen in Buttercup’s time here. One, the tallest one who had stood up to speak with that windbag Tom and towered so high above him, was clad in darker greys and his boots and his cloak looked very weathered and had seen many miles (or so she believed, though she had never strayed more than a league or so from town herself). His beard was as long as Tom Truetunnels was tall (thicker and cleaner-looking too) and she fancied that in earlier days it had been dark like her own hair but denser, fuller and grown rich in whatever distant land he came from. It was grey now, if not quite silver, and only his bushy eyebrows showed a hint of the rich color he might once have had.
‘Buttercup! Here, girl!’ called Collum from the corner of the serving station where she usually retrieved drinks for the guests. She promptly gathered up the loose plates from where she had been standing listening to the men talk and hurried over just as quick as can be.
‘Now, girl, no need to look as if you’re in haste, for I’m not cross with you,’ Collum said with an almost conspiratorial softness. ‘No, it's your sharp ears for listening to these folks that I need most at the moment.’ As he spoke he took three small and delicately wrought cups from the shelf high above the bar, wiping them carefully and eyeing them for any small imperfection. In the three years Buttercup had worked here at the inn she had never seen these particular vessels put into service, didn’t even know they had existed, and now she found herself quite enchanted by their elegant beauty which so differed from every other cup in the house.
‘But I’ll need you to listen carefully to me now, girl,’ Collum continued, ‘and to tell me everything you hear upon return.’
As he said this he reached into his own knapsack that lay on the floor beneath the counter. She was surprised again to see that it seemed mostly packed, as if ready for a very hasty exit. It was at this time she also noticed a sheathed longsword laying alongside the cudgel that Collum normally kept behind there for the threat of unruly guests or late-night squabblers. This kind of behaviour happened rarely enough, and talk of the cudgel, or “Collum’s Peacekeeper” as it had been called, amongst the townsfolk kept any troubles to a minimum. But the sword hidden there, and the loaded knapsack, indicated that the proprietor might be secretly prepared for a whole different level of business on this one particular evening.
From the bag’s center, sheltered there like a precious keepsake, he pulled a small drinking skin and doled out three portions of what looked like a golden wine into the three small vessels. He cautiously cupped his large hands over the whole procedure and she watched carefully as the wine seemed to capture the light of the candle more brilliantly than the polished metal of the cups.
‘Now,’ said Collum, speaking quite carefully as he poured out the wine, ‘you are to take these three drinks to our three wizened grandfathers over there. Have no fear of them, girl, though I’ll grant they look as stern as a set of statues off there in the snug by themselves.’
He put the cups on a tray and then, rather ceremoniously (if such a word was ever used to describe drink service at the Four Greenfields) he covered them with a fresh cloth napkin from his own pocket.
‘Put the tray on the table, Buttercup, and, before you reveal the drinks, you’ll need to say something quite strange so that these particular customers will receive what you’ve offered. I’ll teach it to you. You don’t mind learning a small smattering of an old language, do you, girl? I’m sure you’re up to the task.’
Buttercup was, she knew that she was, and was quite pleased to be asked to perform such a wonderful job and meet these three strange men from afar, but at just that moment she was interrupted as Collum’s quick brown eyes darted from her face to the doorway, uncharacteristically registering some surprise. She turned her own dark head to follow.
Now there were many travelers at the inn on this particular night and, as mentioned, many strange folk in the commonroom from various parts unknown. Like any publichouse in any small city, townsfolk and wayfarers are usually cordial to one another but mix only cautiously and, here in the Bree-land, this was still generally the rule. The Breelanders, with a population composed of both Little People and the Big Folk, were (quite unknown to themselves) perhaps the most diverse of communities in all of Middle-earth at this time. Many travelers used the Roads throughout the town’s long history and whether they were soldiers or merchants, hunters or thieves, Halflings or Men, Elves (so some say) or Dwarves (in happier times) they had all walked through the town’s streets since the Thangorond was first laid and the Clock first built. Yet still the farmers generally spent their time amongst other farmers, the shopkeepers and tradesmen held to their own company and so on, so travelers were either openly invited through the cordial nature of the regulars or they sat away in their own corners as the three tall gentlemen in the back had done for most of the night. It was quite uncommon then, quite uncommon indeed, to see two newcomers enter the inn that were so distinctly unlike one another as those two that now stood in the doorway as Collum, Buttercup and almost all the other folk present looked on in dumbfounded surprise.
The first, which is to say the largest, was a Man of great size and girth. His bare arms were massive as the limbs of an oak tree and the long staff he carried in one of them looked as if it had grown branchlike from his own bronzed skin. He wore a long, unsleeved garment of supple, stitched leather with a girdle of plaited straw and bullrushes held by a wide, tooled-leather belt which was graven with the crude images of many heroes and many beasts. At his unclad knees and chest and shoulders he was covered with a prickly hair of the color of a rich riverbed and this same hair grew in coarser patches to long braided plaits from beneath his stony chin and along the top of his broad head with great explosive bursts on his brow.12 He was not a young man if judged by the length of his beard but his eyes, even from across the room, showed a childlike innocence and wonder as if he was entering a publichouse for the very first time.
Despite the unusual dress and appearance of the man, it was his companion, different in every way imaginable, that caught the interest of everyone in the commonroom that night. For next to the broad man, half his height and quite as lean as his longstaff, stood an Elf-child.
An Elf! Here in the Bree-land! Such a thing had not been seen in the memory of any Breelander nor in the memories of their fathers. Elves were not entirely foreign to folks of the North at this time of course, and were not yet wholly estranged from Men. Travelers, and even some Bree-land outliers like brave Benbow Floxleaf, told stories of encountering them in far-away lands or in their hidden halls. Some of the best songs, and certainly some of Buttercup’s favorites, came from Elvish legend and some of their words still crept into the vocabulary of the soldiers who rode through the Bree-land in brighter days. Even the cornerstone, Thangorond, was said to be an old Elvish word. But no Elf had ever walked into the Four Greenfields, nor any other part of the Bree-land, that any of the townsfolk could recall. In another age perhaps, when the great kingdom of Hollin was in bloom and Elves still roamed freely in the west of Middle-earth, before the Sea-kings came and the North-South Road was built they might have gathered here and spoken many long stories to the First Men who had later settled this town. But remaining so long unseen, like Isildur, the Bree-landers’ truant king, Elves were certainly held in very high regard by all the town’s inhabitants. But no one ever really expected to see one walk through the door.
And this Elf, like his companion, was certainly not someone anyone at the inn this night would have imagined. He was a child apparently (though upon later discussion the more thoughtful Breelanders like Buttercup would come to realize that immortality and childhood presented them with a puzzle quite beyond their grasp), yet he stood with an authority and an assertiveness like that of a high lord. His golden hair was long and straight, as if untrimmed since birth. But to say that it reached the middle of his back would seem no great thing in a boy so small. His clothing was very fine, as if the dust from traveling would not dare to touch it, and his cloak had a rich grey-green color that was unusual in this part of the world. He stood very proudly and at his side was a long dagger with a bone handle. On his back there was an overly large wooden sword. But his eyes, his eyes were bright in that way which songs recall; so bright that Buttercup was quick to look away, her face oddly flushed. There was such beauty in that boy that she had never encountered before and knew, in some part of herself, it would be impossible to ever forget.
‘Oh, the fat’s in it now, my girl,’ Collum said quietly from behind the bar.
‘So, we need to do this thing now more than ever. Here we go!’ He snapped a quick sharp fingersnap before her face to regain her attention. ‘So you’ll take this tray, as I’ve said, and you’ll set it upon their table and then what?’
‘I’m not to take the napkin up before I say something to the old fellows?’ she replied.
‘Very good, dear girl. You’re the natural I’ve always thought you to be,’ Collum said. ‘Now we’ve not much time, so repeat after me; ‘La Kho...’
‘La Cho...’
‘Kho, Buttercup. It’s a hard sound.’
‘La Kho.’
‘Ka laad!’
‘Ka lad...’
‘No, with strength, with heart, with emphasis! It's an oath, girl. Calad!’
‘Ka Laad!’
‘Fine, girl. But the strength is on the ‘Ca-‘. Now the second part is simple and quick; Drego morn!’
‘Drego morn!’ she repeated loudly.
‘Oh, that’s fine, it is,’ Collum said, putting up his hands and returning to his conspiratorial tone as he looked cautiously about them. ‘Now repeat it all back to me without telling everyone in the room.’
‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’13 Buttercup said, as a keen and quite unexpected light came into her eyes.
She felt flush again, but in quite a different way then she had with the sight of the Elf-boy; warm to the sound of the words on her tongue in a way that she would never have expected and, then at least, still in her naive girlhood, had no way to understand. Were they Elvish words, she wondered? There was a harsher tone to them than she would think to find in Elf-talk, but there was no mistaking their beauty or the rallying feel that these words put in her belly. Had she done it right? Even before Collum smiled so broadly she knew that she had and those words had seemed to come from some distant place in her that only he could see. She couldn’t wait to speak them to the three old travelers and hear their response. It was like a blaze had been kindled by these words that only Collum and the three old gentlemen might help her understand.
‘As I thought, girl,’ Collum said with a sly smile. ‘You’re a natural.’
*****
Something was amiss here at the Four Greenfields, no disputing that, but Ben had only half a heart to give it his attention. He was comfortable here, well, comfortable enough for any town he’d ever seen from the inside anyways, and there were friends here from his father and even his fathers before that. Those venerable old Floxleafs were no true townsfolk either. They were outsiders as he himself was. Still it is said that all wanderers need a home somewhere and the Bree-land was the closest to a home that Benbow Floxleaf and his forefathers had ever known.
Probably he should be bothered by this talk tonight of no kingly allegiance. He had met the king’s men on more than one occasion in his travels and thought them to be both kind and just in wild places, a quality which Ben found very admirable indeed. Probably he should be bothered by such short-sightedness from his own people here in the Bree-land who ought to know better. He also knew (as the Breelanders did not) that very real threats lay just beyond the furthest farmhouse and it was only a matter of time before they came a-knocking. Perhaps he should tell them more about the Witch-king and the things he had seen on dark nights, not two day’s ride to the north of this inn.
But tonight his mind and his heart (which were never truly far apart) and his hopes and his prayers (which were essentially the same thing), went to worriting about his dear Rosie who lay outside with a fever.
It was Benbow’s usual custom to come into the town every month or so during the spring and early summer. Game was plentiful then and he could bring the pelts and meats to market easily, trading as he would to slowly build his winter stores. But while he liked the Four Greenfields well enough and some (though certainly not all) of the people he met there, he seldom stayed at the inn, preferring to make his camp outside the town with Rosie. Beds made him uncomfortable and towns made Rosie moreso. Usually they would camp in the valley of the Combe east of the Hill, alone and away from townsfolk at night and then come in to trade pelts on the weekends for provisions and to keep up on the news during the day.
In more prosperous times, as the travelers were more plentiful and while game was high, Ben would stay for a month or so and provision Collum Gilleyfoil, the inn’s proprietor, with fresh meats. He liked hunting close to the town and the Chetwood and some of the lands to the west were still dense enough so that he need never travel far for deer and rabbit and even wild boar for the more distinguishing guests at the Four Greenfields’ table. During these times he might bring Rosie to town overnight and ask Collum to look after her. And she grew to tolerate and perhaps even like the Big Man as she never did with others. Once he even overheard Collum speaking to her softly in the Elvish when he thought no one was listening. Ben didn’t know more than a few words in that language himself, so he had no idea what the Man had said, but it was clear the comfort Rosie took from the sound of it. Ben was glad for that and hoped Collum might help with her now, so he’d taken a room here at the Four Greenfields in the hope more Elvish talk might ease Rosie through her fever. Now he was patiently waiting for Collum to finish his business with Buttercup, the serving girl, so that he might enlist the man’s help.
But the arrival of a young Elf-lord here in the commonroom, well, that was something Benbow Floxleaf would never have expected. What might have brought him, and his wild giant of a companion, here into the Bree-land (other than Ben’s own good fortune) he could not have guessed. But Ben, whom the Breelanders believed to be half-wild himself, had some experience with the High People and he felt certain, given half the chance, he might be able to ask the lordling to help with Rosie.
*****
‘Beothalion, my dear friend,’ the Elf-child said calmly and scornfully in perfectly smooth Sindarin, ‘please close your gaping jaw. I fear that you are drawing the flies which are so abundant in this dreadful place.’
The big man looked immediately flushed with embarrassment, but could not keep his eyes from darting around the dimly lit room at all of the strange sights. Nor could he keep his nose from continually crinkling at the delightful new smells. ‘I will, I will indeed, Tawar,’ he responded in a more broken and guttural version of the same Elven tongue. ‘I will very happily close my jaw around some of the savory foods I’m smelling here. What a wonderful place you have brought us to!’
‘There are smells to be certain,’ his friend replied. ‘I have never encountered such a strange assortment of offenses. How do these people live in these horrid and close conditions?’
‘We should sit, brother,’ Beothalion said. ‘We draw attention to ourselves in the doorway and I look forward to hearing the speech of Men. And that of these other small creatures! Not Dwarves, certainly. What do you think they are?’
‘We call them i pheriain in the halls of my uncle, though they are very rarely spoken of and have no place in our songs,’ Tawarengil said as he motioned toward a small table near the door. ‘They have been gone from the Vale of Anduin for some time and I have never met any of my people who have encountered them or, if they have, must never have felt them worthy of report.’
‘Ah, but you and your folk are notoriously harsh in the valuing of others, or we should not be here,’ the man said as they both drew up to a small (and, for Beothalion, certainly too small) table. ‘But look on them with favour,’ he said, pointing to one of the small stools with his wooden staff. ‘At least they have provided you with accommodations suited to your stature!’ He said with a roaring laugh that the elf, try though he might, could not help but enjoy.
Only Beothalion, his true friend since his early childhood, could jibe Tawarengil in this way. Such inferences from any other person regarding his childlike appearance would make him quite lose his carefully checked temper. Though he was certainly unlike anyone Tawarengil had ever known, there was no question in the elf’s mind that the wild man loved and knew him best. They had met in the first years of Tawarengil’s life, in his first misled adventure (of the many) and even then the wild man (at that time a boy himself) had shown him trust and kindness that was rare among the Woodland Elves of Tawarengil’s home. Together at that first meeting, some fifty summers ago, they had saved one another from certain death and formed a friendship that none of Tawarengil’s family could understand (and of which they certainly did not approve).
Still, Tawarengil, while he looked very much like a boy, was not, and his friend, while he had grown well into his adulthood, was much more childlike in his own approach to the world. It may very well have been a mistake to bring him along on this adventure and Tawarengil, in private thoughts that even his friend could not guess, was fairly certain he would regret it.
‘Ale, I have heard of, Tawar,’ the man said, sitting uncomfortably but agreeably on the too small chair, ‘differing from the mead of my Fathers and as unlike from place to place as the very land around it. Imagine! A drink which reflects the very land and people who have made it! I am excited by ale,’ he said, looking around the room and sniffing to catch the aroma from any full cups at the tables near him.
‘And the herbs! I grill meats on occasion, though killing, as you know, sits uneasy with me. But the smells from these kitchens! As we came up the Road those smells have been quite irresistible. Where does this herblore come from?’
‘Well, from the Elves originally, of course,’ Tawarengil offered with his usual pride and disdain. ‘Long ages ago the Fathers of Men learned the art of herb-oils and of curing from my People and, while they seem to have fallen to crude use here, there is no denying that the cooking of game in this land holds some echo of those skills and even some attention to capturing the flavor of the land itself. That is as it should be. But,’ he said, looking contemptuously at the Men at the table next to them and sniffing rather loudly as he made a sad and sour face. ‘I cannot say that other of the lessons we taught their forefathers regarding odor have still held as fast.’
Beothalion, for his part, had never experienced Men other than the vague recollection that he had of his mother’s folk before and, at the age of six summers, the adoption by his Father. Men’s customs, like his Father’s customs (who died some few months after this adoption), were quite unfamiliar to the wild man and he had lived for the many long years of his life outside of their contact. While it was not the language of his Father he had a passably good understanding of the Man-speech, Westron, for Huandain, his loyal servant, knew many of their words and the other friends who visited his home also brought many insights into the strange behavior of Men they had encountered. Of course Huandain and the others could not really speak the words of Men, their throats were not fashioned for such sounds, but Tawarengil had done his best to refine his friend’s knowledge over the years and in their weeks together now upon the Road. Beothalion was now impatient and more than ready to try this ‘Common Speech’ in what seemed to him such a large cluster of people.
‘We should stop talking Elf, Tawar,’ he said carefully in his new and cautious tongue. ‘They see us as strange enough, but none will talk with us if we keep talking Elf. And I do wish to talk.’ He looked so comical then, this giant of a man sitting carefully on this small little chair with his eyes darting about the room at all the new faces. Tawarengil found himself wondering how many faces Beothalion had ever seen. Other than his stable of animal friends certainly not even a dozen. How different his quiet life was from Tawarengil’s own time within the Halls of Thranduil, his uncle. Now, at Tawrengil’s request, he was seeing a much larger world than he had ever been prepared for.
‘Soon enough, brother,’ he said, returning to their common Sindarin. ‘There are Dwarves here. I’m ambivalent towards Men, and while I’ve no particular feelings in regard to i pheriain, I am most rightly distrustful of Dwarves.’
‘Only one, by my nose,’ the big man said as he rather too overtly gestured to the Longbeard at a table far in the back of the commonroom, ‘and he seems rather too engaged in his own business to care much for ours.’
This was very true. Though traveling Dwarves were quite rare to the Bree-land in these days some few tradesmen had settled in these lands alongside the Men and Halflings many years ago, plying their skills as smiths and wrights and masons. Here, unlike many other settlements in the North, they were accepted (if not entirely welcomed) and their talents were valued (if not exactly embraced). For no Man nor Halfling of the Bree-land could cut stone like a Dwarf and the builders, those like bigoted old Tom Truetunnels himself, could not do their job half so well without Dwarvish hands to lay the proper foundations.
This particular Dwarf of note, and he was the only member of his race to be in attendance at the Four Greenfields on this particular and auspicious evening, sat where he usually did, at a small table away from the fire, and did as he usually did, writing curious marks on torn and irregular sheets of paper by candlelight. Beothalion was quite correct in his assessment that this Dwarf cared nothing for the conversations of the people in the commonroom on this night (or on any other night, for that matter).
What Beothalion could not know however, for he had never seen a Dwarf before in all of his lifetime, was just how rare it was to see one openly engaged in the act of writing. Certainly the Breelanders took no surprise at this regular behavior from their town mason for they were, on the subject of Dwarves, almost equally naive. But Tawarengil, though he also had never really seen a Dwarf himself, knew enough to see this as a behavior quite suspicious.
‘Try not to gesture so broadly, my brother,’ Tawarengil said quietly to his friend, returning to Sindarin. ‘There are many eyes on us here, as we both suspected, and I think it would serve best to let the curious come to us. Have you noticed the three tall travelers toward the back?’
‘Indeed,’ Beothalion said, more comfortable in the elvish language. ‘Are they Men? Certainly they are nothing like the other menfolk we have seen in this town; tall and, while coarsened by years, are yet lively beyond their age. They have no smell that I can read from here, but their eyes are bright like your own.’
‘Brighter, brother. For they have seen the Western shore that only a very few of my people have ever seen,’ Tawarengil said, with some uncharacteristic respect. ‘They are the Istari, if I am correct, and my folk have welcomed one of them into our halls before. But not one of these three. Beothalion, we must speak with them, but we must be cautious.’
*****
‘Wonderful!’ The grey gentleman said from under his bushy eyebrows, ‘a delight to weary ears. Girl, who taught you these words?’
‘My employer, sir,’ Buttercup responded, pleased that her recitation of the speech seemed to bring the old man such joy. ‘He bid me to say these words to you and then to present you with this!’
With a careful (but, perhaps, just a bit overstated) flourish, the serving girl removed the cloth napkin from the vessels. They shone brightly as they caught the light of a nearby lantern. Immediately there was a smell that came up with the raised napkin like Buttercup had never encountered before and had not, to her surprise, noticed when Collum was pouring out the liqueur; not a pungent or savory smell like most of the ales or dinner dishes she served here at the inn, but something much more, well, wholesome and refreshing she might call it, as if all the smells of springtime had been held under the cloth and were just waiting to burst forth. For a moment, until the voice of the old gentlemen awakened her, Buttercup felt the flavor of the aroma had awakened some memory of high towered cities and still waters which she had never seen or known before.
‘Now this is a most curious and unexpected delight, my dear,’ the old greybearded gentleman said interrupting her reverie, and he and his companions exchanged looks that sat somewhere between surprise and suspicion. ‘Most curious and unexpected indeed. And,’ he said, looking crossly at his still silent friends, ‘we shall certainly enjoy them and most graciously thank your master for such a generous gift.
‘But,’ he added softly, ‘perhaps you might stay a moment and tell us more of this employer of yours.’
*****
If Flomi the stone-mason did not notice the three old gentlemen nor their brief argument with Tom Truetunnels it would certainly come as no surprise to the inhabitants of the Bree-land. Though he was kind and cordial enough (for a Dwarf, anyway) in most of his daily business relations, the regulars at the Four Greenfields took Flomi for something of an oddball and a loner.
Now of course this judgement of their neighbor was not, strictly speaking, very fair. Not many of them, other than the innkeeper Collum Gilleyfoil or outliers like Benbow Foxleaf, had been treated to much more than a passing conversation with Dwarfish folk other than Flomi in these days when the East-West Road was less travelled. Perhaps his behavior was not very odd at all for a dwarf and he should not be taken so much as a loner but rather as a person sadly alone being the only one of his kind in their rather small and not-entirely-welcoming community. But whether his unique separateness was a predilection of Flomi’s own or a characteristic of his People, most Breelanders had come to realize, if not even respect, that Flomi the Dwarf was not someone who came to the common room of the Four Greenfields for conversation.
Yet they could, as a rule, count on his attendance there most nights. For thirty years or more Flomi had lived amongst the Breelanders as a stone-mason and for much of those same thirty years he had lived at this inn, back since Collum’s grandfather, Craidic Gilleyfoil, owned the place. He kept the same small room at the Four Greenfields during all this time, even though his business had grown well and his stone yard, just outside the town to the northwest, certainly provided him room and ample money for better lodgings. He ate most every night and early mornings here in the common room, he laundered his clothing and stabled his ponies here at the inn and each month, or so it was said, he left a small gemstone, worth far more than a monthly rate, for the proprietor. But this last part was very much in dispute by all of Flomi’s neighbors. For the stories of extravagant Dwarven wealth are, of course, complimented by the stories of their stinginess and the gossip-tenders of the Bree-land, not having taken much opportunity to know their neighbor any better, were not certain which of these legends to apply to Flomi.
If there was great wealth from the dwarf hidden somewhere here at the inn or away at his stoneyard, no one of the Bree-land had ever seen it. There was talk of an attempted burglary of his room at the inn some ten years ago or so, at about the time young Collum came to the town to run the Greenfields for his aged grandfather. But Collum had become quite friendly with the mason since (a probable cause or effect of this generous tip that the Breelanders gossip of), so no information could be gleaned from him regarding the incident. But the legend of the innkeeper’s cudgel, the Peacekeeper, also grew about this time and Collum certainly made all townsfolk and travelers aware that he was ready to use it to keep the peace here at the Four Greenfields and throughout the Bree-land for his honored guests.
Of the dwarf’s other odd habit, the curious writing and copying of marks on strangely-shaped pieces of paper, there was also some conjecture (though the subject itself was certainly not as interesting as the idea of a hidden trove of gems there within the publichouse). Very few Breelanders were lettered of course; it was hardly considered a useful talent amongst people living in such a small and close-knit community. But of those literate few who had seen Flomi at his work in the common room the general consensus was that this must be the language of Dwarves, for none of the characters of his writing were recognizable to Bree-land’s most learned. As such, they were completely indecipherable and therefore, among the most gossipy of Breelanders, they became the target of the wildest speculations; the most popular of which, as should come to no surprise, was that Flomi the mason was making a treasure map.
The Breelanders, who knew so very little of Dwarves, even of this one who had been their neighbor for decades, were, if one should give them some credit, at least half right.
*****
It was at this time that quite a number of things happened.
‘Tawarengil, my friend, what is that?’ Beothalion said as his wrinkling nose caught the scent of the liqueur Buttercup had revealed at the other side of the room. ‘What is that wonderful drink she gives them?’ And he stood to his full and quite obtrusive size looking over to the table where the serving girl and the three Istari were gathered.
‘Beothalion,’ the elf whispered sharply, ‘would you please sit down. I’ve asked you to be cautious here among all these-’
‘I will, I will, Tawar,’ said Beothalion. ‘Don’t worry. I will be very cautious indeed. But I must learn more about that wonderful aroma. I know! I shall go and ask the proprietor for it. You said we could purchase food and drink and such things here, but I never knew that there would be such wonderful drinks!’
He set his longstaff aside, for he rightly assumed that would be a most unfriendly way in which to approach a barman, and moved with anxious and long strides to the area at the center of the room where the proprietor still stood watching the girl and the three old men.
‘Beothalion-’ Tawarengil whispered between his teeth sharply.
‘Do not worry, brother,’ the big man said, only half turning around so that his nose might still face the direction of the liqueur’s aroma, ‘I will get one for you as well.’
Flomi the Dwarf, who looked up from his work to notice that his own drinking vessel was quite over-long in being refilled, let his eyes glance around the room for the serving girl. It was then at last that he caught sight of her and, much more importantly, the three old gentlemen to whom she was talking in the back corner of the common room. And then, to his much greater surprise, he also noticed the young Elf near the door.
He looked over to his friend Collum who was, uncharacteristically, ignoring this elf and his other customers as he kept his own eyes on the young mistress Buttercup. Noting the innkeeper’s wariness (something he had come to trust in their years together) Flomi hastily began to gather up his work on the table in preparation of an exit. He risked another glance over to Fern Sarnside and his suspicious-looking new companions. They were watching all of the same developments, but their attentions seemed more drawn to the elf on the other side of the room.
‘Oh, it is only three years that I’ve been here, sir,’ Buttercup told the old man, laughing coyly, ‘but many like yourself judge me a bit more mature for my experiences, and I thank you kindly. Now Collum, well, he was here at the inn since I was a child. Certainly a dozen summers or so by all accounts that I’ve heard. But as gentle a master as any girl in this town might wish for, by my own account at the least.’
‘Well that is favorable tidings indeed, girl, for any master who should put such trust in people as he has shown in you is deserving of praise. So,’ the old gentleman said as he raised his cup and motioned for his companions to do the same. ‘Mellon, eithel govannen!’14 he proclaimed in a rich voice that was just loud enough for anyone (including the proprietor) to hear. Then he took a deep draught of the cordial while his accusing eyes bid his friends to do the same. They did so, cautiously, but with the same oath (spoken much more quietly).
‘Oh, now that is lovely talk as well,’ said Buttercup. ‘Is it Elvish? For we don’t hear that talk here nowadays, though,’ and at this she drew closer to the grey gentleman who had treated her more cordially than these other more stand-offish friends of his. ‘I do hope that young Elf-lord near the door has something of it to say. I imagine that the sound of it might be lovely indeed...’ and at this her voice trailed off and her face became, quite beyond her control, embarrassingly flushed once again.
‘Yes, indeed,’ the old man said. ‘His arrival is certainly unlooked-for and might have something new to tell us all.’ At this the old man’s brow wrinkled and his thoughts seemed to darken.
‘But,’ he said, smiling up at the girl and turning his mind back to the subject at hand, ‘I should like to thank your master for this generous gift. And I find myself puzzled, though no longer suspicious given your wonderful recitation, that I know nothing about him. Perhaps you can tell me more before we meet?’
‘Oh, this is bad,’ Collum thought as he watched the girl talking with the old wizard. ‘I sent her to listen, but she’s already fallen into the trap of letting them ask all the questions. Well, it was a gamble showing my hand in this way but, if I learn nothing else, their toast tells me that my guess was aright. So probably the time has come.’ He then cautioned the quickest of glances toward Flomi and saw that the Dwarf was beginning to package up his own night’s work.
‘Wise fellow,’ he thought. ‘Didn’t think he even noticed they were there, but now he’s already getting ready for the long-expected trip. As I said, the fats in it now,’ and moving to the other side of the serving table where his longsword and knapsack lay hidden, he was startled to see the big woodsman who had so silently approached.
‘Beg your pardon, my lord, but do you mind if I ask, have you come West from the Homely House?’
Tawarengil, who had been quite preoccupied with his friend’s lack of wariness, had not even noticed the pheriainth approach (and, though he hadn’t thought of it at the time, he later came to realize that this quietness in itself marked him as a much more unusual creature than he had earlier credited). He was perhaps as startled by the approach as he was the question.
‘Nidhin mened, periain,'15 he replied, cautiously testing the listener.
‘I am sorry, my lord, but I’ve no gift for your language, though it is a pleasure to hear it spoken in these days. May we speak in Westron, as you did with your friend there, and if it’s no imposition to yourself?’
‘You have sharp ears, little one,’ Tawarengil said (though, in truth, the pheriainth was not so much shorter in stature than he), ‘to have overheard that brief exchange. I suppose we both should trust and welcome such a chance meeting... despite other distractions.’ He looked past the pheriainth towards Beothalion and his halting talk with the innkeeper, to the three Istari who seemed to be watching his friend, and then to the Dwarf who seemed to be, rather hastily, gathering up his possessions.
‘You are most courteous to a stranger to ask of familiar halls in strange places. And at a time when so many behaviors of Men seem so strange to me. Yet your question does surprise me. I had not heard of i pheriain knowing of Imladris.16 Will you join me and tell me of Master Elrond’s House and how you know it?’
‘The Dwarf, you say?’ the old man responded.
‘If there truly is anyone, sir, who knows him best, it would be he,’ Buttercup continued. ‘Collum knows and meets every traveller that comes through the Four Greenfields. He says, “it’s all part of the job and just the common sense of being cordial”. Still, he’s got less time for the townsfolk than even I do myself, though I might say he is much better at not showing it. But little Flomi there, who is our stonemason, is the only person I’ve ever known him to spend his idle hours with. Most say it is because he knew Collum’s grandfather, old Cradaic who owned the Greenfields before him. Though some there are, some that don’t know Collum so well I’d say, that think it's only because of the little fellow’s money.’
‘Well, that could explain it, I suppose, in either case,’ he said, drawing the girl to talk further. ‘Though it is surprising that such a man, in such a small town as this, has learned the old language, offers gifts from the Elven folk and yet has the friendship of Dwarves. Yes. He definitely seems a man worthy of meeting,’ and he looked to the others as he said this.
‘Oh, he even knows some Dwarfish talk, I’m sure,’ Buttercup said. ‘I’ve heard them on a time or two talking a few words none of us might understand. Coarser than the Elf-talk that I’ve heard, but pretty in its own way. Old sounding it was, and rumbling and fast and flowing, like a deep running well where the water is dark and unexpected but cool to the taste.’
The old grey traveler smiled then with a very kind smile and Buttercup felt her heart unexpectedly warmed just as she did a few minutes earlier when Collum had first taught her those strange and wonderful words to say. ‘You are a most observant girl. A “deep running well” indeed, and to be uncovered in the most dry-seeming of places. May you and your line be blessed with such incautious insights for many lives to come! Now, I should like to meet this employer of yours!’
‘Hello! Is this your house?’ The big man asked as he caught Collum’s eye. He had his hands open in front of him at waist height and a very odd smile on his face, as if he was trying to present himself in the very least threatening manner possible yet had little experience with how that might be done.
‘It is that, I suppose,’ Collum replied, opening his hands before him as well in the hope of making this stranger more comfortable, and then dropping them with a shrug of his shoulders, ‘or at least it is my responsibility to tend to those that come here. So one might say I belong to the house more than it belongs to me,’ he added with a broad smile. A long-played joke perhaps, but Collum always found it useful to greet new travelers, especially strange ones like this, with some small self-effacing humour.
It went nowhere.
The smile on the man’s face dropped quite suddenly and turned to bewilderment. ‘Do you mean it is long for you? It seems not so big,’ he said hesitatingly and looking absently around him. This drew some cautious laughter from the other townsfolk close enough to overhear their talk, but the slowness of the stranger’s speech made it clear to Collum that this was a man who had only a small understanding of the Common Tongue and, despite what these foolish townsfolk might think, a very full possession of his wits.
‘Does he speak the Elf-tongues, perhaps,’ Collum thought. At this he looked past the man’s broad shoulders to see that his traveling companion, the young Elf lord, was beginning a conversation with Ben Floxleaf. ‘Yet another surprise, those two talking, though Ben knows Elves better than most here and perhaps better than I. On a different day I might try the Elder Tongue with this fellow, but I’ve risked enough on this night of surprises already. This is no time to tip my hand further by speaking Sindarin to a stranger,’ he thought cautiously to himself.
‘Well, this place is only so long as it is storied, my friend, and, having a few stairs up and down, it is has just as much length and stories such that I can manage,’ he continued, keeping up the droll, joking character of his conversation for any townsfolk who might be listening. ‘But you are more long, and at least half again as wide, as most all of our beds. What might I manage for you?’
‘There,’ the wild man pointed with his arm off to the last place in all of the world that Collum would like to have attention drawn. ‘There they have something I would much like to have!’
‘Well, that’s our young girl Buttercup that is there,’ Collum deflected without looking, ‘and she can bring food and such to you and your young lordship presently. But if you are in a haste-of-thirst from travel then I am, indeed, your friend in need.’
‘Thirst! Yes! That is it. Tell me, Friend-in-need, what is that they thirst for?’
This brought more open laughter from the regulars and (while he was glad the distraction was working) some amazement from Collum; it was a very great surprise that this tremendously large and clearly dangerous individual showed no anger at the snickering and condescension of the Breelanders around him. ‘Quite a wonderful temper in one so large,’ he thought. ‘This is a person of some note and of some manner, despite his rough appearance.’ But the innkeeper’s ruse, for a while at least, needed to be maintained if Collum and his charge were to escape the town safely and without undue gossip. So he kept up the banter for the other Breelanders to hear and be comforted by.
‘I should think, that like many, they thirst for a comfortable bed and a reprieve from long hours on horseback,’ Collum said, ‘though the tall grey-clad one in their party seems to thirst for controversy, and that’s a dish we have very few requests for here at the Greenfields. All here thirst for comfort, my large friend, or at the least some time away from discomforting concerns. So, now, what can I provide that might give you either of these joys?’
‘Hum,’ the big man uttered in a deep note as he seemed to deeply ponder this longer speech and what it all might mean. ‘Bed I need not and horse I have not, for he stayed at our own home many days walk from here. ‘Controversy’ is new to me. I may ask of it later, but will not request it if that is something you have little to share. Green fields I have seen coming here, quite green indeed. They did comfort me much in my travel but, being a stranger, I did not concern myself with them much in the seeing. But yes, as you say, thirst I have—‘
‘Oh, this is no fool,’ thought Collum as the people around them began to laugh at the big man’s halting speech. ‘Innocence of the talk of Men can show much wisdom in the offing. But I am in need of more subterfuge now than bold innocence and must end this distracting talk quickly.’
‘Well, though I can’t solve the problems of your travels, friend,’ Collum broke in, ‘I can solve your problems of thirst. Allow me!’
And at this he grabbed an appropriately large tankard and turned toward a barrel of fairly good (which is to say, the best that his house had to offer) red wine for the stranger. And the barrel was conveniently located near his own hidden longsword.
‘Mostly we are called Hobbits, sir, though the people of the Bree-land here mostly just distinguish between the Big Folk and the Little Folk,’ Ben told the Elf. ‘They’ve all got quite a good relationship here in that way. ‘Halfling’ is something I’ve heard a time or two and, if I might say, I would be fine for me to not hear it again. But ‘Theree-ay-en- neth’ as you say it is something I’ve only heard at the Homely House. That’s what put it in my mind that you might come from there.’ At this Ben’s prepared speech had mostly run its course and, while he was encouraged that the Elf had asked that he join him, Ben could see his talk wasn’t holding the young lord’s attention. ‘You see, my Rosie, she’s from there. The Homely House, that is...’
As Ben spoke the Elf’s focus was on his large friend at the serving counter and, following his gaze, Ben saw that the tall old gentleman, the one who had talked of the Witch-king earlier, had also taken an interest in the two odd travelers. He was approaching Collum and the large man in conversation, but his eyes were set here.
‘It seems,’ the young Elf said as he rose from the table and picked up his companion’s heavy longstaff beside him, ‘that if we are to talk further we will need to join my friend Beothalion. He is quite naive in regard to public places and apt to become confused by the manners of townsfolk. Tell me, do you know the name of the grey-father there who joins my friend? For I would speak with him.’
The young Elf-lord did not wait for any answer and began to walk forward to the serving counter. Ben wasn’t certain what he should do; was he being asked to join them and to make introductions? He did not know the old man of course, though he did recognize the effect his speech seemed to have on Collum and a few other Breelanders. Certainly the man and his friends were no more ‘townsfolk’ than Ben, Collum or this Elf were. That was clear from a glance. A wassird he most likely was, though Ben knew little of these mysterious individuals beyond their name. But now the young hobbit felt himself being pulled along in the wake of this eventual meeting with no clear idea of what he was doing there; he just wanted some comfort or advice for his dear Rosie.
But this indeed was the trouble of chance-meetings, particularly where elves and wizards were involved. For matters which interest them are usually old and deep so that one’s own concerns often become enmeshed or overwhelmed in a much longer story.
Flomi tried to catch Collum’s eye for a brief instant as he exited through the back of the commonroom, but the man was engaged in serving the large woodsman and his back was to the Dwarf. Collum also did not see the wassird approaching from another corner of the bar. Certainly his friend knew who these old fathers were and what their arrival at the Four Greenfields must mean to their own endeavor.
‘So all has been made ready for our hasty departure. Good!’ He thought. ‘ I have grown long tired of this dwelling place of dimwits and dirt-grubbers and will be glad to prove my findings. Three decades of exile here serves five generations of debt when I’m proven aright.’
Much of what he would need to take with him was already hidden in their secret hoard and little other than a fresh change of clothing was left in his room here at the inn. They had prepared for this moment, he and his friend. So Flomi decided to go straight to the stables and check upon his ponies, and also Collum’s great grey mare, to have them fitted for a quiet exit within the next hour. He crossed out of the rear doors and down the darkened lane to the stables doing a mental inventory of the small items that would be left in his room for others to discover. Nothing too familiar here, but he must stop by the stoneyard for a few last important items and to remove other traces. ‘Collum will have much to say on this topic,’ he thought, ‘but I will not leave without stopping there.’
What the dwarf did not see nor consider in his abrupt exit was the dark, skulking figure who followed him out the backdoor of the inn and waited in the shadows, watching him and his urgent walk to the stables.
*****
‘It smells very fine, friend! Very rich. Like earth in the shadow of big hills and like fruit that is sweeter when hard to find. I will enjoy it with much thanks!’ Beothalion said, taking the offered tankard of wine and enjoying the laughter of the Breelanders gathered about him. ‘But, tell me,’ he said more quietly, pointing back to the table that Buttercup had just served, ‘how may I have some of what he was drinking?’ I will happily pay for my friend Tawarengil and myself.’
‘There is no coin you might produce, good fellow,’ a deep voice said behind Collum and to his left, ‘for the worth of that custom cannot be measured in such a way and greetings, like the one that was, are only freely given.’
Collum saw that the tallest of the three wizards, the one who spoke so openly about allegiance to the King, had left the others behind with Buttercup to follow the invitation. ‘Good,’ he thought, ‘but why is he engaging this stranger? Is it because of the young Elf-lord? Is he to play a part in this somehow? And if so, how do I get all these silly Breelanders out of here so that we might talk?’
‘That was well spoken, Master Wanderer,’ the young Elf-lord said as he approached from the other side, a shy-looking Ben Floxleaf silently dogging his steps.
‘There,’ Collum thought, ‘all the fat into the fire of it now. Watch as the sparks fly.’ And at this he risked a quick glance towards Flomi’s table to discover him gone. ‘Out the rear door, wisely,’ he thought. ‘It seems our time has come.’
Now for those Breelanders still scattered about the room, those townsfolk who had found the odd assemblage of foreigners quite satisfactory for an evening's entertainment, this now was really too much. Giant wildmen, outspoken and old wizened pilgrims and even Elves would be enough for them to discuss for many days throughout the springtime. But having such folk actually gather here, why the very idea of their own happy commonroom becoming a meeting place for such potential troublemakers, quite exceeded ‘interesting’ and began to border upon ‘disturbing’. They moved cautiously away from the gathering knot of strangers.
‘Mae l’ovannen,’17 the Elf continued in his own lovely, flowing (but, for the Breelanders, entirely incomprehensible and disconcerting) language. ‘Elen síla lúmenn’ omentielvo!’18
‘Le nathlam hí,’19 the old man responded. ‘Peditham hi sui vellya?’20
‘Yes!’ Beothalion said excitedly. ‘We should talk the Common Tongue here, my friends, and I should dearly love to learn it the more!’
‘You’ve a fine ear for it already, my friend,’ the old man said, ‘and I wonder of the tale in how you came to learn it last.’
‘O, I will tell you it gladly, friend. For I am excited to speak of-‘
‘I believe that might wait, Beothalion,’ said the Tawarengil in Westron, raising a slow but warning hand, ‘for it is somewhat long in the telling and I believe that introductions should come before tales, is that not so, Oldfather?’
Now the nearest Breelanders became quite dumbfounded at all this foreign talk and lordliness so that they quietly left their place “at the Column” for more comfortable corners of the room. Better to be amongst their own folk and away from whatever strangeness the Road had brought here to their hearth. Collum did his best to seem equally annoyed (for he knew that gossip might follow much faster than any fugitive might run on horseback), but he was finally quite happy that the arrival of these strangers might give him sufficient cover to end his vigilance here at the Four Greenfields.
‘Ben,’ he said innocently (and worrying for poor Ben at having to suffer it in his own much more genuine innocence), ‘do you know these folk?’
Ben thought for a moment, hard and cautious. Mostly, he thought just how he wished he’d never entered either this town nor this conversation with all these lordly gentlemen. He wondered more than a bit at Collum’s ruse, for clearly the man knew more about folk like this than he was willing to let on, more than Ben himself; but Collum had always been a mystery that Ben was comfortable to leave unsolved. Apparently Benbow Floxleaf, wanderer, outlier but a familiar face as he was, could now be used as foil so that Collum might keep his own mystery and his distance. Ben liked Collum well enough of course, but no one enjoys feeling used. And then he thought about his Rosie and how she suffered and how that had brought him here.
‘I do not, Collum,’ he said, ‘though I am happy to say that I’ve met the Elder Folk before,’ half-bowing toward the young-looking Elf, ‘and know them to be honorable beyond a question. And,’ gauging his voice a bit louder for the benefit of the Breelanders, ‘givers of gifts with quite spectacular, though sometimes worrisome, value. I’ve had little trade with them, if that’s to your question, but nothing but trust at every meeting.
‘As to these other gentlemen,’ and at this he somehow found it proper to bow just a bit lower towards the other old gentlemen still sitting quietly in the rear of the commonroom, ‘I’ve nothing much to say. They seem kind and well-spoken in dark times and, to my mind, that makes them a people worth knowing.’
And then he looked long into the eyes of the old grey-cloaked man before him, the one who had spoken up earlier when old Tom Truetunnels seemed to argue for timidity.
‘Still any fellow, stranger or no, who will speak openly for peace and freedom, and even courage in defending our own borders is deserving of my friendship. So, hello, sir!’ He said addressing the old man and bowing even lower. ‘I am called Benbow Floxleaf, son of Robow, hunter and tender in the realm of Arnor that is North of the Bree-land and an honest tenant of Arvedui, the King of the North Realm.’
Many townsfolk did not know Ben very much nor very deeply of course, but none had ever heard him talk in this, well, lordly kind of way. Another odd and complete silence followed. It seemed a night for these moments to happen. As the Breelanders backed away even further Collum started to believe that things might actually work out in his favor. Distractions had been created and liaisons had been formed. What that might mean for his own enterprise was still uncertain, but help had apparently come unlooked-for. And that was a reward of faith.
And then he thought of Flomi’s empty chair and, seeing that there was a missing companion at Fern Sarnside’s table, he began to worry.
‘Master Gilleyfoil!’ the old man said (so that others might hear), ‘may I ask for six tankards of that fine red wine to share with these fellow travelers here who are so graciously spoken in such times? Is there some sideroom to be had for our kindly conference? For while this lord,’ and at this he gestured to the woodsman and the Elf, ‘and his companion are very new to this land, I am quite certain wisdom comes with them. This hobbit, with his experience and his shrewdness, also has much to tell and,’ he said, looking sharply around at the townsfolk huddled about the room, ‘after my last attempt at discussion here, I and my friends would dearly like to learn better talk from sharper folk.’
Then, while he held their attention with such a brisque comment, he produced a small but very shiny coin and placed it upon the table near Collum’s hand. ‘Who knows?’ He said, ‘perhaps you yourself might even join us?
'Now come, friends,’ the old man said as Ben, Beothalion and the Elf-child joined them and Collum hastily picked up the offered coin, ‘let us share tales of our journeys and delight in this meeting unlooked-for. Chance, if you would call it that, should not go unanswered.’
End of Chapter One
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter One
Here at the end of each chapter I will collect some notes which may prove interesting to some of you or, at the very least, helpful to readers who may be newer to Tolkien. Some of these will be more personal, covering as they do my reasons for selecting certain names or locations, and others will be translations of the languages and key locations.
There are many excellent sources for the material of Tolkien’s world to be found online and I’m sorry to say that I have not kept careful enough track of these in my research; it would be impossible for me to go back and credit them accordingly now, but I will try to mention those that I can and a few of the best will be listed in my appendices. The majority of the information does come directly from the work of Tolkien and his son Christopher and my readings of all the official tales and notes for Middle-earth.
In addition there is an expanded appendix for this project which will appear in another document. It is mostly derived from the original sources at the end of LoTR and found in The Silmarillion though it accompanies my own histories for the new characters created in this story.
1) This, of course, is the old name for the land of Bree as found in LoTR. According to Tolkien, Bree means “hill” and has references to Celtic word bre for “hill”. No distinction is made between the town gathered there at the crossing of the roads and all the surrounding lands, so I have used this to create the idea of an undeclared territory of hill lands divided into four sections. The one here called “Bree-land” will eventually, by the time of the War of the Ring, simply be known as “Bree”.
2) This refers to the founding of the Shire in the western lands of old Arnor in 1601 of the Third Age. The Shire calendar is not used in the Bree-land at this time.
3) This is a much later addition to the manuscript. In the writing of Chapter Twenty, as more importance was becoming placed on the people of the Bree-land, I felt the need to give them a clocktower. Hobbits have pocket-watches by Bilbo’s time of course, so this is not as anachronistic as it might first seem. Clearly the technology would’ve been created outside of the Shire (possibly dwarvish?), but for hobbits to have it in the Shire it probably came to them from Bree. I doubt that there is a clock in Bree when Frodo first comes to the town; something may have happened to it and, indeed, something may happen to it while I am writing this story. But adding it here in the opening chapter sets up many possibilities that I will utilize later.
4) Some of the text here is rather freely cribbed from the Professor’s earliest descriptions of Bree found in The History of Middle-earth (which will later be referred to as HoME). This is the first instance in which I’m using rather more obscure passages from the earlier drafts as “Easter Eggs” for deep Tolkien fans but, I must confess, as this started out as role-playing game of sorts, this was intended as a device for keeping a sense of the Professor's language in my own writing and amusing the reader/player.
5) An older name given to the Númenóreans by other Men of Middle-earth.
6) This name, which works so well for describing the lands around the Crossroads, actually comes from the first bar I ever visited as an adult. It was in the suburbs of Detroit, near my old high school, and had the atmosphere of a cozy Irish pub. Utterly forgettable beyond that.
7) This name was originally for the cornerstone of the North-South Road where it crosses the older West-East. It is not a true Elvish name, but a bastardization of some Sindarin words. I’ve chosen to remove it from the crossroads, which I make to be some half mile or so from the Clocktower, but here it serves better as a founding stone of the town.
8) There was a curious choice made here in having Olórin (who we will discover this wizard to be) refer to hobbits as “Halflings.” This is, to my mind, among his earliest encounters with them as a people and story in which he first takes notice of some of their fine attributes. The beginning of his interest in “Hobbit-lore,” if you will.
9) The tale of Eärendur has always interested me and will wind its way into this story. His death was in 861 of the Third Age, so 1100 years before the events you will read of here.
10) I know of no other place mentioned for the origins of the Westron language so it seems appropriate to suggest it might be here. Certainly the Bree-folk have a tendency to take credit for many things in LoTR and, according to Tolkien, in some of those things they are quite deserving of such credit.
11) My own little play on the creation-theory of a bar within the history of Middle-earth, something I would also credit to the diverse community of Bree.
12) This bit is cribbed from James Joyce’s ULYSSES, my other great obsession. The description of “the Citizen” in Episode XII seemed just perfect for setting the mood of this character and I wanted some little Joycean Easter Eggs where I can manage them.
13) ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ “Flame light! Flee night!” the Battle cry of the Edain of the North. From the Gondorian Sindarin.
14) ‘Mellon, eithel govannen!’ "Friend, well met!"; Sindarin
15) ‘Nidhin mened, periain’ “It is my wish to go, Halfling"; Sindarin
16) Imladris is, of course, another name for Rivendell.
17) ‘Mae l’ovannen’ “You are well met!” (Reverential) Sindarin
18) ‘Elen síla lúmenn’ omentielvo!’ “A star shines on the hour of our meeting” This is a Quenya greeting, very old, and there is some proving of himself to be seen here in Tawarengil using it after a more colloquial Sindarin expression. He would expect the wizard to know it of course, but it shows himself to be more mature than his appearance.
19) ‘Le nathlam hí,’ “You are welcome here.” Olorin reples in Sindarin
20) ‘Peditham hi sui vellya?’ “May we speak as friends now?” also in Sindarin
Chapter Two; "Fear! Fire! Foes!"
-In which Some Introductions are Made, an Escape Occurs, and a Deadly Distraction serves to Unite the Purposes of the Party
Read Chapter Two; "Fear! Fire! Foes!"
Just six nights before the fire happened Flomi and Collum had made plans for their necessary departure from the Bree-land. ‘It won’t be easy, my slipping away,’ the tall man had said, ‘and it may very well be that you will have to go for a time ahead of me if we’re to travel far in safety. I do not like the look of Sarnside’s sallow-faced friends who have so recently arrived and, much worse, I do not recognize their accents.’
The man had an uncommonly good sense for trouble and Flomi, who was never much known for watchfulness himself, had come to trust it implicitly in the dozen or so years of their relationship. Old Cradaic Gilleyfoil, the man’s predecessor, had been much more talkative, much more friendly with Flomi and all the townsfolk, but that had nearly cost them everything and the great enterprise of their ancestors was almost undone at one time through an act of petty burglary precipitated by that man’s carelessness. So Collum became a greatly improved replacement in regard to their secret mission (though Flomi did sometimes wonder what happened to the kindly old Cradaic after he was removed from his post. Men, or so the Dwarf had learned, were sometimes more fixated on the usefulness and successes of their kin than they were respectful of their grandsires).
It was Collum who had expanded the rumor of Flomi’s wealth and his extravagant payment for services. This had, quite surprisingly, shielded them from scrutiny for the past years. ‘There’s not so many thieves to be found here amongst the Breelanders,’ the man had said, ‘for thieving comes from a blend of greed, desperation and nervous courage; ingredients these folk have only in small portions. So if there’s no need for us to fear their tendency toward crime, let us find some good means to utilize their love of rumour. Let the gossipy ones believe there is money, and they’ll tell us about all the other characters they encounter who might’ve heard likewise; all those coming through town who might inquire after you, all those we might need to watch for.’ It was a very peculiar plan (particularly from a Dwarf’s perspective), to indicate false wealth as an assurance of safety, but it had worked, and worked well, for many years. Collum had nodded and winked at all their foolish assumptions of a Dwarfish hoard of gold and gems while Flomi, for the first time in two decades, found himself shielded from the many prying questions and the probing small talk of these ridiculous townsfolk. In the meanwhile to Collum they had revealed every perceived threat, every mistrustful glance which they saw and all of their far-fetched ideas regarding suspicious strangers. A wise judge of character, Collum had succeeded in turning their interest away from the dwarf himself and outward to any who might threaten his well-being. And all at the cost of a few well-given drinks, knowing gestures and carefully-placed questions.
‘He was right, I am certain,’ thought Flomi as he moved hastily towards the stables, ‘the time of our departure has finally come and I am most heartily glad of it. Thirty years here amongst these dim-folk might dull any person’s brightness!’
‘Now when we go,’ Collum had said, ‘it must need subtlety. For now, through no desire of my own, I’ve grown too large a figure to all these small folk of the Bree-land. There must be a reason for my departure or it will become suspect. You and I leaving together, especially now, is even more dangerous.’
‘What do you then propose?’ Flomi had asked. ‘Many of the roads we would travel are uncertain since the fall of Fornost Erain.1 Our journey must go North, even if not from the first, and there is no safe haven to be found there any longer.’
‘True,’ Collum had said, ‘and to the North Fortress and Lake Evendim we cannot go alone. But other of my folk are gathering again beyond the Baranduin and I’ve heard some rumour of travelers we might confide in now coming along the road to the Bree-land. People of great wisdom.
‘But west or eastbound I do not know. Many forces are being marshaled there between the Brown River and the Lhûn to create a fresh defense,’ he paused for a few moments, deeply considering the options laid before him.
‘I believe that our road must lie West before North,’ he continued after some time. ‘But still we must hear more of who remains in Arthedain2 if we are to travel there and solve the Riddle. You cannot yet devise the place on Evendim that we seek, so we must hold a safe place for a time in which more clues might come to guide us.
‘The Baranduin and the lands west of it are safe and untampered with as yet, but the next strike will likely come there rather than here to the south. The Witch-king cannot allow the remaining forces of Arnor to regroup with the Elves of Mithlond3 or your own folk in the Blue Mountains. He will cross the Baranduin in force soon while the days of sunshine are still short. He will need to hold the Stonebows to cut the forces of the West from attacking. I believe his attack there will come soon. The Bree-land here, and these happily ignorant people, will likely remain safe for some time, while hobbits to the west, in their beloved and unprotected Shire, will see war. The west will be a dangerous direction for travel.
‘But we are watched here, Flomi, I know it if I know anything. These new and suspicious travelers, the disturbance at your stoneyard last month, and all these increased questions of your wealth, they surely point to something bigger than burglary. And those who watch you now are no mere thieves any more than I am an innkeeper.’
The inn of the Four Greenfields was shuttered now behind Flomi as he made his way down to the stables through the connecting alleyway. ‘And that wise innkeeper (who is indeed no innkeeper) owns these stables too,’ he thought, ‘though most of these foolish townspeople do not suspect it.’
Collum’s predecessor had no such head for business nor innate understanding of how a town works. For twenty years of his indenture here Flomi had taken money from his own purse to use these same stables. It was a necessary part of his rather superficial function as a stonemason and an explanation of his need to return here to the Four Greenfields for the real work of each day; translating text. In truth he was somewhat embittered toward the old man (charming though he was) for this expense. But Collum had removed this obstacle almost immediately upon hearing of it by quietly (and, to Flomi, quite surprisingly) purchasing the stables and installing his own people there. ‘My own engagement, rune-master, is to your well-being,’ he had said at the time, ‘but our shared safety relies upon knowing who comes and goes. As an innkeeper I can discover much when a traveler will sit to talk, but a stableman can also tell us much more with less conversation; for any traveler who sits, alone or in groups, for many days on his end, will meet a stableman first, telling him of all his troubles, revealing to him all of his wants, and asking him, as first contact in a new place, all of his questions. I’ll have them in their comfort of sitting, but a wise stablemaster will understand their needs better for meeting them in their long days after travel and discomfort.’
Flomi knew that the man was charming him with the small witticism and, not unremarkably, with the decreased personal expense he would need to make in the stables. He laughed at the joke, was pleased by the savings, but immediately knew this new manager of his was to have more resources and more concern for their shared enterprise than his predecessor. And this, more than anything personally dangerous to himself which may have brought Collum to the Bree-land, let Flomi know that they must be drawing much closer in their mission.
Now, as he approached the stables, Flomi was remembering their planning from six nights before. ‘In the best version of our story that I might construct,’ Collum had said to him then, ‘I would leave first, most suddenly and unexpectedly, and you would make a spectacle here in the town about how I had stolen from you and how you must storm out to find me. This is the story I’ve been building towards for years, my own mysterious character creating a plausible end to our created fiction.’
‘Ah! I hope you’ve written me a wonderful monologue,’ Flomi laughed, ‘ I raise my maddock high in the commonroom and swear some oath on my grandsires of well-deserved vengeance! Who, in this small-thinking town, could deny that?’
‘Yes, a good laugh in its way I suppose, and in its ability to play on their own joy of gossip. And for long I wished that you might have it. I believe you deserve the glory of such a grand exit to keep these dull-headed Breelanders talking of your departure for many years to come.
‘But we cannot do this, Flomi, for my role as information gatherer in this place has surpassed your own as the extravagant but wealthy miser. They have come to trust me, these Breelanders. Once, when we started out together perhaps this would do, but in these many years I am now seen more as a warden by the Bree-folk than a transient. None will believe that any thief who had been given this much trust would wait this long to strike.’
This was true. Collum had gained and cautiously manipulated their trust in these past dozen years. He had skillfully managed to minimize his own mysteriousness by letting others do the talking. Even the most cautious and quietly-guarded Breelanders had come to feel that they knew Collum well simply because of all the personal things that they had unwittingly told the man of themselves. Very few in town, if asked, might be able to tell you his second name, yet all were somehow certain of his trustworthiness because of conversations in which he had managed it so that they reveal themselves much more than he ever had. Flomi had watched this happen over the years with some amusement and, in truth, had fallen into the same easiness with the man. Collum was an attentive listener and had a keen way of understanding another person’s troubles. But when Flomi’s thought about it now, well, the days of Collum acting unscrupulous in the eyes of the Breefolk had somehow long slipped past them, and Flomi, a resident in the Bree-land for three decades, had now become the outsider while this, ethir4 (Dwarves had, of course, no word of their own for ‘spy’) had become the friend of every rumour-monger the town had to offer.
‘I’m sorry my friend,’ Collum had said, ‘but when the sign comes, as I believe it will within these next few days, you must go first. Go quickly to the safest spot we can devise, and wait there for me to resolve things in the Bree-land and join you. It will not be easy, for it may happen quite suddenly.’
The lantern in the stable was low when Flomi entered and old Guldir, the stablemaster, was nowhere in sight. Outsiders might have found this a bit unsettling, for the stable itself had many stalls and was, it seemed, quite prepared to service many travelers passing through the Bree-land; in this way it was much like the Four Greenfields, a way-point that was seldom left unattended. But while there were quite a few unexpected travelers in the town this evening it appeared that many had come on foot, for many of the stalls remained empty. ‘The old man has probably stepped out for his own bit of sup,’ thought Flomi, ‘but that might make my own work here just the easier, if done with haste.’
The three ponies Flomi owned had a respected spot near the front of the stalls as it was his custom to take one, two or the team of them each morning with him on his return to the stoneyard. They were directly across from Collum’s own tall mare, Caitelyn, who had her own reputation amongst the townsfolk. Collum’s saddle, well-worn from whatever his life may have truly been before the Bree-land, hung unsuspiciously behind the mare and had, for years, provided a hidden drop point for messages between them; for Collum was one of the only four living individuals who had learned Flomi’s secret written language. And, if they were successful in their enterprise, he would be the last Man to ever use it.
‘I must check there again for any message before I go,’ Flomi thought, ‘but do I dare leave a note for him? How much danger are we in?’
*****
Rosie heard a very curious sound as the dwarf entered the stable. She did not see him of course, for she hated this terrible little town and all of its gathered smells and noises and people. Only her love for Benbow Floxleaf could make her endure the place, so, at his bidding, she hid in a stall of this terrible covered building with no sight of the stars. At the least, the cool late shadows of the day had helped her endure her own fever. But, she still knew a dwarf by his smell. And she was glad that he did not see her as she hid behind the high walls and listened. Her eyes were cloudy these past few days as the fever started and she no longer trusted them as she once had, but she listened and she smelled just as sharp as ever and she knew with great certainty that a dwarf had come.
The old Man had left some time before and she was happy about that; he had been kind to her when she and Benbow Floxleaf had entered, but she did not much care for his smell despite his kindness. As anyone knows, Men can well seem kind in the first, but might change in a moment and without a bit of warning; one had to watch a Man carefully and might still never be certain of their intentions. And if, like Rosie, one relied on smell and hearing lately more than eyesight, men were a caution; for their smell was usually less than pleasing and their words were often no true indication of their intent.
But the noise she heard now was soft and muffled and came from just outside the door behind where the dwarf had entered. Were there more of his folk outside? There was no threat in the small and suspicious sound, and Rosie stood there quite still hoping for some other clue to help identify it. She strained her ears and her nose, and even considered peeking over the protecting wall with her eyes, to learn more. And perhaps she might have, and perhaps things might then have gone quite differently, if she had learned to trust dwarves just a bit more.
*****
Flomi hesitated and looked sharply around the empty stables. There was no one, but a low burning lamp implied that Guldir or some other stable-hand might return soon. ‘I’ve no time for a proper message if, as we both have agreed, the time has come. I must take the ponies and set out and be thankful that no one is here to see me.’
He went hastily to Collum’s saddle which they had wisely hung within easy reach of Flomi as he might pass it near to his own ponies. Placed there each day it had served them usefully over the past decade. He looked about and then reached up to the hidden pouch for any last message.
‘Nothing there,’ he thought. ‘But I must not get stuck here writing or waiting.’ He knew Collum would look here for some sign. He hastily took a small and, in this town, quite unique brush from his jacket and placed it within the saddle’s pocket.
Entering the other stall he threw his own smaller saddle on Corlar, his favorite and the fleetest of his three ponies, and attached to that the long reins of the other two animals. He made very few sounds as he led them out the forward doors of the stable and paused for a moment under the shadows to look at the lane before him. There was no one in sight, no danger that might be seen as the lane wound toward the Hedge-gate and then on to the Great Road. A still night in which Flomi’s senses were awakened. For a moment he looked behind him.
‘I must go, while the time is quiet,’ he thought. ‘But some foreboding yet stays me. Am I watched?’ he looked quickly about and then back into the stable, seeing nothing but the dark lanes of the Bree-land before him and long shadows of the stables to his rear.
‘I will ride you, friend,’ he said softly, stroking Corlar’s neck, ‘for if we are watched they will need your own fleetness to follow.’ And at this he drew himself high into the small pony’s saddle and left the shelter of the stable at a brisque and, or so he hoped, unsuspicious pace.
*****
‘That is the smell of blood,’ Rosie thought, ‘or I am no friend of a good hunter. It is not from the dwarf, and he neither seems to notice it nor fear it, but there’s fresh blood which follows behind him. And he leaves it there without concern. Does he run from it?’ she wondered.
With no sight of the stars and the smell of fresh blood in the air she felt even more confined, even more anxious for Benbow Floxleaf’s return. The dwarf had left and no person seemed to be in the stables, so Rosie, in her discomfort, her fear and her curiosity, did a very foolish thing and raised her gaze over the protecting wall that she might, despite her poor eyesight, look for danger.
There, back in the darkness to the place from which came the smell of fresh blood, a nearly silent man, dressed all in black, peered through the rear doorway back in the darkness just at the edge of Rosie’s eyesight.
And, as her head peeked over the wall, his own turned sharply. The black man, she was sure, saw Rosie, alone, in the stables, and knew that she had seen him.
*****
‘Masters and travelers,’ Collum said in a voice large enough for any listening Breelander who might be lingering at the edges of all these strange folk’s conversation, ‘it is good to have so many of you here with news from our neighbors in the wider world. We are, and have been, a place at the Crossroads and do often build our own entertainments off of your stories and reports.
‘Now many of my friendly folk here do indeed like ‘news from outside’ as we call it, while many more prefer the goings-on from just a few houses down; for our entertainments and our politics are simpler here than you might have encountered in your travels. And we Breelanders are quite comfortably accustomed to our simplicity.’
This drew a few favorable noises from the townsfolk who were always happy to let Collum do the talking. But the humour of it was not lost on his new guests.
‘Now you, sir,’ he said, indicating the tall old gentleman in grey who had asked about a separate room and given Collum a coin, ‘have put many of my patrons in mind more of their own business and that of their neighbours with your talk of kings and allegiance. While I can’t say that you’ve not piqued my own interests with these words, I cannot truthfully say that you will find much support here in the commonroom for such sentiments.’ At this there was much affirmative grumbling from the previously skittish patronage for they seemed, somehow, to feel as if Collum had eloquently defended not only their right to gossip but also that longstanding Bree-land tendency to remove themselves from controversy.
‘I’ve a room for you all, sirs,’ he continued, ‘where you might share such tales as are your right, as travelers all, without disturbing peaceable-minded folks here who do not wish for such sad stories.
‘But,’ he said lastly to the whole group of strangers, including Ben, ‘I myself should like to hear better and wider stories of the surrounding lands from such wise folk as yourselves and, if such an opportunity should arise on a busy evening, I will join you there shortly. Milo!’
He called loudly to a young Hobbit who came quite immediately from the other side of the room as if he had no other task there but to wait on his master’s call.
‘Take these six fine gentlemen to the outer hall,’ he said to the servant, ‘and bring them a cask of the winyard and board enough for all. This,’ he said just a bit more loudly as he held a large gold coin aloft for a moment and then hastily tucked it into his own belt, ‘shall pay for all and I will, myself, happily attend to whatever else you gentlemen might desire later.’
*****
There was a thing which happened there that few of the folk assembled noticed, though it did not escape the sharp eyes of Benbow Floxleaf; for that old man had not given Collum a gold coin just the moment earlier and Collum, quite clearly on his own, had decided to make the switch.
Ben was less than familiar with coins than most townsfolk certainly. A hunter and trapper in the Northern realm all his life, he dealt mostly in barter. But he was not naive enough to be unfamiliar with the differences between gold and copper. Had no one else seen Collum palm the old man’s coin so quickly and then offer this gold one in its place during all his talking? And why should an innkeeper create such a bold lie about a payment which was clearly not in his favor? Surely the old man knew the ruse that was happening, but did the young Elf-lord and his large companion catch the substitution? Why was Collum going so far out of his way to make excuses for all of these people that they should meet apart from the other Breelanders in the common room?
‘None of my own concern, I suppose, but curious enough for anyone to throw guesses at,’ he thought. And so, cautiously, for he did not have a good face for deceit, Ben looked quickly around to see if any others might have noticed the switch.
It was then, quite by accident, he noticed the three sallow-faced and dark-dressed Men near the rear door, huddled and watching. ‘There was another of them earlier, I remember,’ Ben thought. ‘Where’s he gone to?’
As a friend of Collum’s and a good judge of danger from his time in the wilds, it worried him. For he knew at a glance that these men were robbers or criminals from the way their eyes lighted upon that gold coin.
*****
Flomi left the town at a cautious but happy pace. ‘I shall never return here,’ he thought, ‘and that is a pleasant thing to know.’
It was still early in the evening and not many Breelanders were around to see him go. If they had been, not many would have bothered to speak with him or have remarked on his departure. He had remained an outsider to these people for many years and, other than in their stories, he would not be missed.
The ride to the stoneyard was not long and the ponies knew the ground along the way. Once he left the last group of houses to the west of the Bree-land near the Hedge-gate, he quickened Corlar’s pace, secure in the thought that none had seen him depart and that now his real flight should begin.
‘I cannot decide on our going west or north just yet,’ Collum had said six nights past. ‘Perhaps something will present itself to me before we are forced to leave. But I am certain we will need to leave separately and so must arrange a safe meeting place. But where is safe now as the North is overrun and Fornost has fallen?’
‘Should we go to Sarn Athrad?’5 Flomi had offered. ‘Many of my own people come that way now and a few might be empressed to our cause.’
‘That would seem safest, yes, but it is more than seventy leagues from here to the Southern Crossing, many long days of travel in what is certainly the opposite direction of our goal,’ Collum replied. ‘And much of it would be open country that I do not think you ought to travel through alone. No. We will need something closer. A waypoint from which we can plan our next move.
‘The way west of Bree-land is clear,’ he said, as if thinking aloud. ‘The Shirefolk keep the King’s bargain and still hold the Stonebows Bridge at the Baranduin safe in his name. But it is also two days' ride that you would need to venture on your own. I’ve no doubt that you might do this quickly and that even as a stranger you would find some safety there, but if the Witch-king pushes West to pursue the scattered men of Arthedain then our road north from the Shire will most certainly be blocked.’
‘Aye,’ Flomi said. ‘It is a safe haven, but also a snare against our greater purpose.
‘There are some small villages east along the Road, are there not, where we might meet? Smaller even than the Bree-land and further from the attentions of Angmar,’ Flomi asked.
‘A scattering of villages still remain open near the Weather Hills, yes,’ Collum replied, ‘but that area before is marshy and damp, and few travelers strange to those lands would choose to stop there. A lone Dwarf would draw much attention from the folk who live just beyond the Chetwood. And you might need to await my coming for as much as a week or more with no explanation of your purpose. You would certainly be noticed.
‘No, my friend,’ he said, after a long pause to consider. ‘There is still one better and well-hidden option to be utilized. It seems that you may get the peace and solitude among cold stone that you’ve wanted for these past years. While it is still revered by a small group of Edain and still quite secret amongst the most of my people, there is a tunnel not a day’s ride from here that might suit our purposes perfectly.’
*****
‘The hospitality of this innkeeper is astounding, Tawar,’ Beothalion said to his friend as they entered the much smaller outer hall, ‘I have spoken but a few words to him and been given drink, an offer of food and a chance for more of the Westron talk. This is a mighty greeting to give a stranger! Will there be coin expected at the end? Will we have enough to match the price?’
Despite his friend’s naive enthusiasm, the outer hall into which they were being led made much less of an impression on Tawarengil. ‘It is just another dingy and squarish structure in an asymmetrical maze of blandness,’ he thought. It seemed frequented less, so the stench compared with the previous hall was somewhat diminished, but two small windows looking on the alleyway and a tiny fireplace indicated that this was not a Greeting Hall as his people were accustomed to; no, this was a place suited more to conspiracy than poetry, and that is just not the kind of hall that Tawarengil and his people would ever call hospitable.
‘We have ample coin, brother,’ he responded in Sindarin, ‘for, good-natured as he seemed, he is still just a simple innkeeper, and this hovel is certainly nothing beyond our means or our deserves.’
‘Are we to continue in the Old Tongue then, my lord,’ The grey-clad Istari asked in Westron as his friends followed silently into the room, ‘or would you like to seem even more distrustful to these humble townsfolk?’
Benbow had been ushered to this outer hall with all the rest of them by Collum’s page and apprentice, Milo Fastknots. Milo was tall for a young hobbit and so, like Ben, fairly comfortable on a pony. It may be for that reason that the two had encountered one another many times in the past few years as Milo had often ridden back-and-forth to the kitchens of the Four Greenfields with fresh game when Ben would set up his spring hunt in the Chetwood. Milo was probably the least talkative hobbit that Ben had ever met (outside of his own father, of course) and he thought that beyond the young hobbits’ size this was likely the main reason that Collum had hired the boy. Whether the youngster was bored or dim Ben could not ever guess, but Milo had an oddly impenetrable nature that kept him apart from the other Breelanders and quite clearly apart from gossip; a quality most certainly to Collum’s liking. He had sandy brown hair and uncommonly large hands for hobbit and while he had a tendency to stare forward at the emptiness in any room around him, Ben had come to realize that Milo was quite a good listener.
As Milo lit the fire in the hall, Ben drew close to him and away from the others. If he was to be identified as ‘townsfolk’, as the old man had just said, then it might just be worth using that to get a message to Milo’s master.
‘This is as odd a collection of guests as I imagine you have ever seen here, Milo,’ Ben said, pitching his voice to a low, even conspiratorial tone. ‘I’ve seen some very queer and still very kind folk out in the Wild, but not many such cross the door of the Four Greenfields these days, I suppose.’
‘Some do maybe, Ben,’ the hobbit said cryptically, looking up as he kindled the small fire, ‘but not all at once and not so talkative as these ones here. How do you know them? Seen them in your travels, have you?’
Good, Ben thought. Even the normally distant young Milo was curious enough about these strangers to raise a question or two when the chance arose.
‘Never before this very hour,’ Ben said, drawing closer, ‘but your master’s offer of some wine and a bit of food only makes my own curiosity the wetter. And I’d dearly like some news of the troubles surrounding us, which these wise folks might just have. Still, if I was to speak caution to your master, I’d mention those troubling scoundrels at the rear of the commonroom. One of them disappeared quite suddenly and the others took too great an interest in that gold coin Collum held up for all to see.’
‘Sarnside’s fellows? They’re up to no good, that’s for certain, and certainer it is that my master knows of it. Still,’ Milo thought aloud, ‘I hadn’t seen one of them put off quietly. That might be something. I’ll look to it. Thanks.’
He made a soft nod to Ben and, the fire being lit, he then went quietly out on his other errands. Ben returned to the others.
‘I should like to talk the Westron-talk, Grey-stalker, and I thank you greatly for the opportunity,’ Beothalion said as he strode to the center of the small room, addressing the most outspoken of the three old wanderers. He put his tankard of wine on a table and placed his open hands out and then down in front of him in an offer of peaceful greeting.
‘My words in this talk may be rough and slow. I am sorry, for I am told it is the talk of many people and I wish that I knew it and all of them better.’
At this one of the other old travelers came forward. His beard was also quite long and bristling with grey though his eyes matched the brighter blue under his dirty traveling cloak, and he spoke to the Wildman in return.
‘You have a clouded practice of very old ways, young one,’ he said in a quiet, slow and rumbling voice, ‘and I welcome the memory it awakens.’ At this he lifted his flattened, upturned palms to his shoulders, let them drop slowly to his sides and then brought them forward and out to be seen before his own waist. In all, it looked to Ben like a more formal, more ceremonious, version of the Wildman’s greeting.6
‘I greet you, happily and peacefully on our Roads to the West,’ he said, in the Westron tongue, but with a certain implicit ceremony. Ben felt a strange flush in his own cheeks at this grand gesture and simple talk; there was deep sentiment here and he could immediately feel it. Though the words were quite common there was an undiscovered history in their speaking of how people, a civilized and kind people, should meet in strange lands and form fair company. There was, to Ben’s ear at least, a kindness in that statement that he would remember (and hope to use) in the rest of his days.
At this act of civility the Wildman was quite taken aback and, as he stammered for a fair-seeming response, his friend the young Elf stepped forward.
‘Lord and Oldfather,’ he said (but keeping to the Westron as the other old man had requested), ‘your ancient greeting is apt, for west my friend and I are now bound on a hopeful errand for the northlands. If your words are more than symbolic, may I hope that you also travel this way?’
‘I am no person’s lord, master elf,’ said the blue clad fellow, drawing himself up a bit at the inference. ‘But I thank your own cordiality in addressing me as such. We three folk are, despite what you may have heard of us, travelers only. We have come to meet and speak with and know the folk of Arda.’
‘And maybe help them to their own better purposes,’ the other grey fellow added.
‘Often we are more quiet in that regard,’ the other continued with a reproachful glance to his fellow, ‘and while we are caring, seldom would we wish to be lordly.
‘I, for it seems names shall be needed, am in this land called Alatar.7 I greet you, lord, and welcome your news from the Great Wood and the Halls of Thranduil.’
This was grand talk to be sure, no matter the language, and Ben had some time there puzzling it all out. ‘It seems that these old gents, quite deserving of lordliness on their own, are traveling as beggars and that this young Elf-lord -for surely he talks with lordliness on him well beyond a discernible number of years- he respects them very highly,’ Ben thought. ‘Elves calling someone else ‘lord’ is not a thing I have heard before. Most curious!’
It is true that this was a curious thing indeed, not so much because of Elvish pride (and Tawarengil’s own pride was indeed quite great at this time) but for reasons that Benbow Floxleaf, or any other inhabitant of the Bree-land for that matter, would not be expected to know. For these ‘travelers’ were quite unlike anyone else in Middle-earth and their presence, at this point in its history, was only understood by a very small number of the Wise. They had not, at least not yet, had much to do with the affairs of lands and kingdoms and few mortal folk had marked them as anything other than pilgrims or sorcerers of some kind. Not yet at least.
Tales of these odd old men (or others quite like them, for the tales went back some many hundred years) often came to the crossroads of the Bree-land from many sources. But as no respectable Breelander was himself such a source of these tales then, of course, no self-respecting Breelander would choose to believe them. But even the most doubtful of the Bree-folk came to accept that there was something quite different about the old ‘travelers’ who occasionally stopped in their town and so, accordingly, they kept them at a fairly wide distance. Tall they were, tall as any of the Sea-kings (not that many of those folk had come to the Bree-land in recent memory either), but these pilgrims were bent from advanced age and long years of wandering. Their clothing was always quite drab, mostly dull-colored cloaks, broad hats and dirty boots, and they were generally (or at least until the earlier part of this very evening) not given to idle conversation. But often they carried with them, as old men often do, a great walking stick or staff, and by this item the Breelanders had come to refer to them as ‘Wassir’,8 though no one ever made attempts to learn anything more about them.
Unlike the Bree-folk, Tawarengil, young immortal that he was, knew more of these travelers than anyone else at the Four Greenfields on this particular evening. But Tawarengil’s youth did not make him incautious and so he continued their conversation without offering further hints on the subject.
‘You are gracious, visitor,’ the Elf-lord said, bowing a bit and raising his empty hands at his sides. ‘I am called Tawarengil, and as you have correctly said, I come from Thranduil’s Hall, and of Oropher’s kin. I, like many of my Silvan folk, move West to join our people against the Witch-king.’
‘This is true,’ the wild man continued excitedly, ‘Together we are moving through lands unknown to meet the Elf army and then, together with what Men and others will join us, Tawar and I will push the Witch-king and his folk back to their cold mountains! We shall crush them completely and then they will never come down the roads or lanes to these pleasant green fields or to trouble these fine little folk again!’
‘My dear friend here,’ Tawarengil continued with a laugh to Ben and the others, ‘has great enthusiasm upon seeing his first great city, Master Perrianath! His folk live a rather solitary life between the western eaves of the Greatwood and the High Pass and very few tales of your splendor come to them there.’
‘Well, that is something to be heard!’ Ben replied, feeling a bit called upon. ‘I’ve never traveled over the Misty Mountains myself, though I’ve been many times in their morning shadow.’ At this he came forward from his place by the fire and offered his small hand to the towering Wildman.
‘Benbow Floxleaf is my name, sirs,’ he said somewhat shyly. ‘My own family has hunted in the lands between the Mountains and the Brown River long as we recall, and, while I’ve no great taste for cities myself, I should be glad to tell you any stories of this land that you might like to hear.’
The big man took his offered hand and then bent to one knee so that he might take a good look at Ben’s upturned face. There was a deep curiosity in the Wildman’s eye and Ben could almost see there a moment of recognition, a kind of kindling, as they turned from wonder to deep trust.
‘If little folk of this land are so generous to strangers it must be a great country indeed!’ Beothalion said. ‘Well met, little friend Benbow!’
‘If you know much of the lands toward the Baranduin, master Hobbit,’ the old man in grey said, ‘then it is indeed good that you have joined us. But I suspect this was, in some part, the plan of our host.’
‘Yes, it would seem,’ said Alatar, slowly, ‘speaking up as you did has played its part, Olórin, but the part of this innkeeper I cannot yet perceive. I cannot believe that Lord Elrond would employ such an agent.’
‘Elrond?’ Tawarengil said, ‘this is the second time within this hour that I have heard such unexpected reference to Imladris in such a queer place. Does the host of Elrond ride out? For that would be great news indeed!’
The three old men looked at one another a moment, silently considering this new information.
‘This we do not know, my lord,’ said the grey fellow, ‘but that is our hope also. Tell me,’ and at this he looked long into the Elf’s face, ‘in what other context did the innkeeper or his servants mention Imladris?’
‘Oh, it was not the innkeeper,’ Tawarengil said, ‘but this very Floxleaf here who wished to talk of it.’
*****
There was trouble here, and the smell of blood, yet still Rosie kept her calm. She had no business with any Man but the stablemaster and no Man had any business with her. She lowered her head and clung a bit closer to the protecting wall of the stall, her eyes now turned to its door.
The Man was very quiet and, by her experience, Men were seldom ever quiet. Even with her sharp ears she could only sense his location through his smell -it was strong, for Men never realized just how strong they smell, and his scent was particularly gamey and unwashed- and she could tell he was moving slowly into the large stable and slowly inspecting his surroundings. He moved to the building’s rear, away from Rosie and the large doors left open when the Dwarf departed. There he remained for some moments and no sound, not even a breath, came to Rosie’s attentive ears. Yet still she did not panic, for she was, despite her current illness, of very proud stock and would not disgrace her parentage with panic. So Rosie kept her calm.
Then, somewhat suddenly, the Man made a noise; the rumbling of some gate-door near the rear and a loose footfall as if he no longer cared to be quiet. Rosie thought, for a moment, this was a good sign and that perhaps he would now leave.
The next few minutes seemed to bear that out. She heard the opening of three gate-doors and the saddling of three horses -noisome and uncouth beasts, half-panicked (or darkly excited) by the still lingering smell of blood- and she heard the sounds of the Man leading them out toward the main stable doors that the Dwarf had left open. They passed in line that very stall in which Rosie herself stayed hidden and she drew herself quietly closer against the supporting wall as they did; but still she would not allow herself to panic. Not unless that Man opened her own gate- door and came to find her. Then, if that should happen, she would bolt quickly through the open door and make such sounds of alarm and such a flash of speed that her sires would be proud. But she would not panic.
But the Man and his horses passed her door without a pause, and she remained safe.
Then the Man stopped the horses at the doorway, just as the Dwarf had done with his ponies, and, pausing for a moment, she heard him say one small word, a Black Word, and though she did not know its meaning just the speaking of that language sent deep shivers through her body.
‘Gnash,’ the Man said.
And still she did not panic.
He came back towards her stall, and now the small light of the one lantern in the stables came with him. She remained still and ready should the gate-door open, but he did not come so far this time. He stopped at the stall of the great grey mare close to the front. The horse, wiser and of better breeding than any other Rosie had seen in this building with no sight of the stars, let out a loud braying as he approached.
‘None of that from you,’ the Man said, ‘for pretty as you are you won’t be under me and I won’t want you behind me. So, there it is. Sad it might be, but you’ve got to go, love.’
The horse was Wise. Rosie had not seen her but once or twice before here in Bree-land and knew she understood the language of Men. Even from her own stall many yards away Rosie could feel the mare’s body trembling at the danger this Man surely brought to all of them in this building.
‘Your a strong, proud girl, to be certain, but this is a gate you’ll not leave,’ the Man said, and then there were some noises of metals and latches, and Rosey knew that the mare’s gate had been secured beyond the simple latch that all the stall-doors held. Any Wise creature might normally escape if they so desired, but the Man had secured against that..
‘A waste of good horseflesh, but I shan’t be followed, and if your master tries he’ll now be doing it on foot.’ And at this there was a loud crash and the sounds of liquid sloshing around near the stable door. Then the mare began to cry out as the Man made his way hastily toward the three horses at the door.
And then the light in the room changed, even to Rosey’s failing eyes, and the smell of burning and panic came, and the mare let out a scream of terror that was echoed by all the other living animals in the stable. The Man swung quickly into the saddle of one horse and took the others in tow with him.
But Rosie did her sires proud and still, even still, she did not panic. She let out a loud and terrifying call for Benbow Floxleaf to hear and, raising up to her highest and strongest, hit her own gate-door (which had never been locked) with all of her strength. She left her (formerly) safe enclosure and went to the mare’s stall; towards the new burning fire.
The mare was roped in tight. Someone, maybe the Man, had taken her bridle and tied it to a turnbuckle. The Wise horse, frightened as she was, was chewing desperately at it in hope of escape. Behind her, in the straw corner of the stable and high up along the walls, the shattered lantern had started a small blaze that was catching all too quickly on the wood interior of this building with no sight of the stars.
Other beasts in the stable, feeling the fear and smelling the fire, started screaming. Their gate-doors were not locked, but they had no idea of how to escape them. Blood and fire and terror had seized all those who remained in the stable.
But still Rosie did not panic. She could not open all the gate-doors. She could not free the mare who stood so horribly close to the growing fire.
So she ran. Not in terror, but straight out of the open stable doors and toward help from Benbow Floxleaf or anyone else who might hear her call.
She remained calm and she did her sires proud. And she cried louder than she ever had, and she ran prancing through the streets of Bree-land, so that people might come.
*****
Flomi rode on to the stoneyard making a mental accounting of all he must gather and the time that he would allow himself there to do so. ‘Just a smattering of heirlooms. It will take little time out of my way. I shall not be leaving anything of value behind, for I value my life in that yard very little, and will want no memory of it after,’ he thought to himself, ‘but some things that I have acquired here cannot be neglected.’
After their decision to move quickly, Collum had ridden out the very next morning to scout the proposed meeting place. He returned to the Four Greenfields late that same evening with good news and firmer plans.
They had met late in the outer hall after all the other townsfolk had departed. ‘As I had hoped,’ Collum began, ‘the way is presently clear and the old entrance that I know of remains undiscovered. I placed some small provisions as I had there for you, but I will ride out again in a few hours with more ample supplies; for you may have to wait a week or more for me to join you.’
‘Weeks or months are no hardship for me if the place is anything as you have described,’ Flomi replied, ‘and my work can continue there uninterrupted.’
‘Yes, Collum said, ‘and I fear it now need go faster. But tomorrow you must have it packed and ready for transport. We will meet a mile or so west of the stoneyard at noon and take things to the Foundations together.’
Flomi, his curiosity and his sense of adventure now fully engaged, had done just that and rode out on Corlar to meet Collum at the appointed time four days ago. The man rode up to their meeting place along the Great Road on his grey mare at some haste and, at first, Flomi feared some trouble had already found them.
‘No, the way is yet free,’ Collum said, ‘but we must do this with some speed. I rode into Bree-land late last night and left again before light this morning. If I’m to avoid much suspicion it would do well for us to return to the Four Greenfields before nightfall.
‘I have left one of my beasts9 at the Foundations this morning. He is a good animal in a climb and does not seem to mind the confined spaces. I do not know how that might be with your own ponies, and we will have need of steady pack animals where we will be going. There is some good store of food there now and no lack of cool, fresh water. But you shall see! Let us go.’
He led them away from the Road on the northside and into a rolling region of low hills that were sparsely wooded. The day was bright and mild and Flomi, who was no experienced rider, found it a pleasant enough and surprisingly straight course, though the pace was a bit faster than he and Corlar the pony might have preferred. The land here was quiet and untended, but many of the trees (and Flomi was no experienced judge of trees either) seemed young and fresh, but resilient and hardy, even to the point of seeming aggressive.
‘How is it,’ the Dwarf asked as they rode, ‘that this land is so empty? The Bree-land grows and grows in the decades that I have been there and yet no one from that land will move north and west to what seems a perfect home for farmers and herdsmen.’
‘It is a rich land and, yes, sadly empty,’ the man replied, ‘and few travel into it now. Perhaps the sadness frightens them. Some enterprising Hobbits went further west of course, to set up their own community over the Baranduin, and there they found great resources that had been some of the oldest farmlands before the world was broken.10 It may be that we will see that land together before we finish our task, Flomi, and it is more lovely than any other land in which I have yet traveled.
‘We ride now through old town lands and fiefdoms that, while much younger than “the Shireland”, have more recently and more completely gone empty. Once this was the Southern Fields of Arnor, the Emyn Ubra,11 a province far in the outside of the great city of Annúminas that my people founded here in the North. These lands were once filled with estates of the great lords of Arnor who still had dealings with the Elves of the lands between the Misty Mountains and Greenwood the Great and traffic from your own People coming over the Road when Elendil first established the North Kingdom. In that time, before the Great War with Sauron, the Dúnedain of the North lived here in great numbers and one would only have to crest the nearest hill to greet their neighbour. Much of the old forest here was cleared in that time and some good roadways, the shadow of one which we now follow, still lay beneath.
‘But we of the North are fewer since the Great War and those lordly families have long since perished leaving this land desolate,’ Collum said sadly. ‘Perhaps these trees will regain it and the memory of Men will be lost in these hills. Who can say?’
‘The kingdoms of Men are fleeting things indeed,’ Flomi said, ‘unlike the halls of my own people that are carved in the very bones of the Earth. Many great cities and works of Men of which I have read are lost to time beneath sun, seas and wood while our own halls delve deeper to the unchanging roots of Middle-earth. It seems to me that your Princess was foresighted even among her people to seek the aid of Dwarves in a lasting hiding place for her great treasures.’
‘We are away from the Bree-land, Flomi,’ the man said sharply, ‘but we will talk no more of the task, or of her, in these open lands than we did in that town.’ His face grew dark at this and Flomi, who believed he had come to know the man better than any Breelander had, felt that this darkness was not solely out of anger. Sadness, a sadness of loss, had come on Collum as he talked of this land just the moment before and it seemed exacerbated by the mention of his Princess. Flomi did not, nor had his father before him, know anything of this Lady’s background even though their pact had gone back for many a century. He knew only that Collum served the Princess and that her will was aligned to, and had even determined, that of his own grandsires’ for many generations. But curiosity (a rare trait among Flomi's people) often got hold of him and he occasionally looked for opportunities to learn more of his mysterious benefactor.
‘As you will,’ he said, and they rode on for a while through those lonely hills in silence.
The stoneyard outside the Bree-land was a quiet place, decently apart from any outlying farms, and set into one of the longer limestone hills west of the town and north of the Road. There, for thirty years, Flomi had made a meager living doing a journeyman’s task of supplying the Breelanders with hard cut stone for foundations in their seemingly endless and (so he believed) largely purposeless building. Nothing more intricate than a keystone or a cornerstone was ever asked of him by his customers and the hill he inhabited gave up her bones for these small demands easily enough. For there was good stone here, nothing like the ore-enriched mountains of his birth of course, but good, simple stone for these simple people and it yielded itself readily, and most willingly, to Flomi’s deft hand.
Most of his service to the Bree-land builders could be fulfilled in a short time of the morning, and this left him free to puzzle out the mysteries of his real task after the noon hour. For want of privacy he only met with customers in town at nightfall or in the earliest morning for deliveries. He had purchased his first cart and team of ponies in the early days of his business, hoping that by bringing stone to town in a drawn wagon he could avoid the unwanted visitor often found in an unneeded customer. It had also created more reason for him to stay each night at the inn, which he found much more safe and favorable to his sense of comfort. This practice had continued and so the stoneyard, while known to all, had not seen a visitor (other than Collum) in some years, or so Flomi had believed.
It was but two hours gentle ride from the Hedge-gate of the Bree-land to the yard and Flomi and the ponies reached it without consequence while the moon was low. From his years in the Bree-land Flomi came to measure the day as they did, by their own unfunctional clock and thought it to be about ‘ten of the clock’ as he rode up the lane to his, and his father’s, old property. There was a deep cut into the hillside there on its southern face and there Flomi’s father had set up both yard and quarry. There was a low stable and a grounds-house built to serve the ponies and as a mason’s offices respectively. Some dozen or so years before those offices had been ransacked and looted and the thieves had searched through the mines believing there might be some great hoard found there. They found nothing of course, for Flomi was not often present at the stoneyard at the time and was no fool to leave the very real and important work of himself and his sires laying about. What thief could know or appreciate such subtle work if he had? But after this incident, and at Collum’s suggestion, he had abandoned the perception of having living quarters in the stoneyard and moved his regular residence to the Four Greenfields. This made it easier for Flomi and his work to come to the Bree-land each evening where he might remain under the man’s watchful eye. Nothing like that had happened again, but the buildings had been disturbed again near the end of Nénimë, just one month ago. There were signs of a large animal, a bear or even a great-wolf, rumbling through both the stable and offices, but there was no disturbance of any of his papers or theft of his goods, and so Flomi simply cleaned things up and did not pay it much concern. Collum, careful and suspicious as was his way, felt less certain.
Now, miles away on the night of the fire in the Bree-land stables, all of his discoveries of these past thirty years, based on the work of Flomi’s father and even his sires before that, treasures to his own people and to Collum’s Princess, had been removed to the Foundations in their desperate attempt to keep the great enterprise one step ahead of discovery.
‘I should not have returned here,’ Flomi thought as he dismounted and let the ponies walk freely outside the stable. Quietly but briskly he walked toward the low building which he used as an office. ‘Collum would certainly disapprove of my being here and rather that I went with all haste towards our meeting spot while the moon is still low. But there are some things I must not leave behind.’
As he entered the low building he did not see, hidden in the trees on a slope of the land in the direction from which he had come, a rider, dressed all in black, and slowly leading a dark horse behind him.
*****
‘That’s true enough, sirs,’ Benbow said as he looked into the questioning eyes of the three old gentlemen and the child-seeming Elf. ‘For I was lucky enough to have met the lord Elrond as a boy and, with my father, had even visited Rivendell on a time or two.’
‘This is surprising indeed,’ said Tawarengil with a hint of distrust, ‘for even my own Silvan folk, brethren though we are, have not been so carelessly welcomed into that valley for many long years.’
‘And, remember, you don’t know where it is, Tawar, or maybe we might have tried,’ Beothalion interrupted, looking earnestly at Benbow, ‘ Maybe this Little Benbow friend of ours knows the way and may tell us.’
‘Knowing the whereabouts of such a place,’ Alatar said, ‘and being welcomed there are two very different matters.’ At this, he approached Benbow with the same open-handed gesture he had given to the Wildman. ‘Lord Elrond has shown you great honor and it would be unwise for us not to trust him in this. It would seem that fortune more than this innkeeper has drawn us together, Master Floxleaf, and I greet you on our Roads to the West.’
Ben felt that flushed feeling again and tried to meet the tall Man with the same gesture (accompanied by an awkward bow, something his people were more familiar with in this kind of situation).
‘I agree,’ said the grey-clad man, ‘and greet you also, master Hobbit, lord Tawarengil and master Beothalion...’
‘Ho!’ said Beothalion with a laugh. ‘I am no master either, Grey-stalk, but I thank you for the courtesy.’
‘Well, names, as Alatar has reasoned, seem appropriate to our meeting,’ the old man continued, ‘so know that I am Olórin to some here and to others yet in the wider world. To some Men of the South, and also to some of the Elves, I am called Mithrandir. To others there who regard my counsel less I am called Incánus. But I am a “grey-stalker” here in the Northlands as you suggest,’ he said looking to Beothalion, ‘and that title too suits me well.
‘But I should still like to know more of that other missing person in our chance-meeting, this Innkeep-‘
‘Hold!’ Tawarengil interrupted, thrusting up his hand and moving towards the window. ‘There is a cry of terror outside. Have you horses?’
‘From the stables?’ Ben started, grabbing his bow. ‘ But I’ve left Rosie to wait for me there!’ he cried as he ran through the door.
Suddenly there was a flurry of action and the others followed quickly. The outer hall was at the edge of the building and there was another door there which led to the alleyway alongside the stables. They sped quickly this way and, coming into the narrow alley there between the inn and stables, smelled the smoke and caught the light of the blaze. About forty feet to the left and up this alleyway, there was another door leading into the stables (the same one that Flomi had used earlier), but the main entrance was closer and to the right. Now that he was outside Ben could clearly hear Rosie’s cries in that direction and, running towards them, he could feel the heat of the burning stables on his left side. Beothalion and Tawarengil were right at his heels, but only the Elf was small and quick enough to overtake him in the narrow alleyway.
‘Fire!’ Tawarengil heard someone call as he rounded the corner. There he saw a woman drawing back away from the new blaze and he also saw a terror-stricken fat white pony prancing back and forth near the stable’s entrance as the fire grew.
‘Go!’ Tawarengil called out in Westron as the woman saw him. ‘Alert the people of the inn! Fire! Awake!’
Ben rounded the turn just behind him and saw that Rosie was safe. Relieved, his eyes immediately turned to the job at hand. The posts and lintel of the stable’s entrance had already taken flame and he knew that the town’s main well, and the necessary number of buckets, were hundreds of yards away and too few to keep more of the building from catching. Then, to his amazement, he saw the young Elf-lord run straight into the stable through the blazing doorway. He heard beasts, pigs and ponies and horses calling in terror.
Beothalion saw this too. He had paused for a moment to comfort the panicked pony but, without another second lost he ran inside as well.
‘Glory!’ Ben thought, ‘they’re saving the other poor beasts. Well, don’t just stand here, you fool, help them!’ And he himself, showing the uncanny bravery that hobbits were too seldom noted for in his time, ran headlong into a burning building with people he had only just met.
*****
The inside of his offices were dark and, though Flomi’s eyes were quite accustomed to such darkness, he decided to light a lamp for his final look about the place. It had the characteristic orderliness of a dwarvish dwelling; to the rear, built into the hillside, there was a sitting area with a great drawing table, a small chair and smaller nook for the rare occasion when Flomi would sleep here at the stoneyard. Normally this area would be divided from the main room by a partition of some kind, but there wasn’t a need for such where almost no person ever came to disturb him. A small space to the left of this was allotted to cookery and a pantry, but no food was ever left here for in the past years as Flomi now spent his nights in the Bree-land and dined exclusively at the Four Greenfields. Closer to the door on that left side there was a small closet for traveling clothes and, beside it, a short, strong bow for hunting (a thing that Flomi had not done since he was beardless). The bow had been his father’s however, and no matter what came next, he must not leave it behind.
Collum and Flomi had not ridden long in their uncomfortable silence before the hills began to recede toward a long line of bushes that could be seen ahead; straight this was like the Greenway near the Bree-land, but heading northwest and away to the distant mountains of Emyn Uial and the Hills of Evendim. He knew these places only through his research, for Flomi and his sires had grown in the Blue Mountains to the southwest of Arnor and none of the Longbeards there traveled north to Ered Luin, their ancient homes beyond the Gulf of Lhûn from before the breaking of the world. Ice-drakes lived there now, it was said, and worse things that had fled the ending of the ancient world and lingered still in the cold, deep places of the earth. But Men, in their great days of power, had returned to the shores of Evendim and built their doomed kingdom nearby.
‘Is that a new road ahead,’ Flomi asked, breaking their awkward silence. ‘I have seen no map that suggests it.’
‘Nor shall you,’ Collum said, ‘unless, perhaps, we are lucky enough to complete our task and discover old histories. That is no road ahead, Flomi, but the remains of a very old border, the base of the Rammas Armaro,12 Arnor’s neighboring wall, and the ancient edge of the great domain of Annúminas and old border of the North Kingdom of Men.
‘It stretches, or did in its day, from the old Downlands to the South, across the Great Road, and then northwest to the feet of the Ered Luin. There it was built high indeed for, as your People well know, that is a dangerous land and it may be still that those ancient walls hold terrors of the old world at bay. I know no tales from that far North. But here, south of the Baranduin’s origins, the Kings of Arnor had great friends in the West so that the wall was low in these lands, a marker only, or perhaps a sign that here one might find safety. And that is just what we have come for!’ At this he rode a bit faster prompting Flomi to keep up.
What refuge might be found in a low barrier wall Flomi could not guess at. Collum had described their hiding place as a great cave or tunneling that the dwarf would feel comforted in, but the hills here had become much lower and the earth that he could see surrounding the wall looked soft and sometimes marshy; inhospitable to such dwellings. But he knew Collum to be a person of deep secrets and his own curiosity led him on to see just what the man might come up with next. ‘Probably no true hall after all,’ Flomi thought as he rode to catch up, ‘and like to be some niche or cellarway that Men had cut into this old fence as a guardhouse or even a tool shed. But he has never seen a true Dwarven home of course, so I should forgive him his naivety. Still, I do not relish the idea of a week, or even a day, spent in some crude stone bolt hole that Men have roughly fashioned.’
They came to the remains of the wall and turned with it towards the south. Through the hedge and trees that had grown up there Flomi saw great stones, each tall as a man, covered in ivy or brambles and other creepers as the land tried to scale the barrier and reclaim its mastery. Roughened though these stones were by weather, they had once been evenly cut and were of enormous weight, set two or sometimes three high in a very regular manner, straight and level still though the land around had done all it might to resist their orderliness. Their color was reddish, not like the native limestone of his own quarry or the hills he had seen between here and the Bree-land. Flomi had to admit that there was keen work here, even in its ruin, and in his head he began to reassess all of his beliefs about the lost works of the Númenóreans; for, as he had thought of Collum just a moment before, he had never visited them and should be forgiven for his naivety.
‘There is strong work here, indeed,’ he marveled to his friend. ‘And this stone is not native. They have been quarried far from here, I think, and traveled long to their new home.’
‘They are from the beginnings of the Rammas in the feet of Ered Luin, carved from those cliffs which border our land. Here the Rammas is low and wide, like a raised roadway towards Arnor’s ancestral burial places in the south. We are now about two leagues north of where it once crossed the Great Road and, it was said, a town much like the Bree-land had formed there in Elendil’s days before the North-South Road was built. If so, then that place is lost now and the forest has taken it.’
At this, Collum halted his great mare and dismounted, encouraging Flomi to do the same. It was at this time, and maybe for the first time, that Flomi’s sense of curiosity turned to an awareness of their peril; for Collum had brought his longsword, which he routinely kept hidden, and took it from the horse and fastened it on his belt. ‘We are close,’ he said, ‘and should proceed now on foot to leave less trail. Caitelyn knows this area well and can do with the rest,’ he said, brushing the horse’s nuzzle and giving her a carrot or some other treat he had held in his pocket. ‘She will watch after your own pony and there is water for them nearby. Come, I will help you carry your packages the remainder of our way.’
There were in fact not many bags for them to carry as Flomi had only brought the work that he was engaged with, as Collum had asked, and nothing yet of his own belongings. ‘Time enough,’ he had thought, ‘particularly if this bolt hole is as spare as I worry it may be. Though if he carries his sword it seems I shall be prudent in bringing my maddock along on the next time.’
They moved south through the land near the wall, avoiding small streams and occasional muddy passages where the land grew soft. It was still not long past noon and very few living creatures moved through the land or marked their passing.
‘It is quiet,’ Flomi said. ‘Quieter, I believe, than passage on the Road itself.’
‘We are inside the Rammas Armaro here, still within the old border,’ Collum said, returning to his history lesson, ‘and along the other side the trees have grown thicker for more than an age. Small beasts and birds move freely through the lands going east and north, but the forest is retaking the western face of the wall where larger animals might be found. To the south,’ he motioned far ahead in the very direction they were moving, ‘five leagues south of the Old Road to the edge of the old Kingdom, is the burial place of the Men of Arnor and it is both sacred and desolate. Little wildlife ventures there, and much of it is unwholesome.
‘If there had once been a town near where we now stand, and I believe it so, no name was it ever given. The building of the North-South Road, and the laying of the Tharangond, subsumed its usefulness. The Bree-land then became a place of commerce better located than this and my people, greatly diminished in number after the Great War, left these western parts and drew closer to Annúminas, Fornost Erain, and Arnor’s center. We grew in number again for a while, slowly, but there were never again enough people of the North to hold the lands claimed by Elendil when he came out of the Sea and founded the North Kingdom.’
He halted, pointing southwest towards the wall. A great stance of very old trees stood there, taller than all the others, with straight branches forming a sort of glade apart from the younger foliage closer to the barrier. They were birch, Flomi thought, not uncommon to this land, but seemed to have a nurtured shapeliness which quite separated them from the landscape; regular and even like the wall itself, as if they had been reared and tended once and were now resisting the chaos of growth surrounding them.
‘Mark this spot, Flomi,’ he said, ‘for you may well come here next on your own. Look then for those seven trees, older than the rest. They were planted, I should guess, when the Rammas was built. It is a sign to my people that a spot here is special, lasting, protected and should not be overlooked.’
‘Aye,’ the dwarf said, ‘there are many such indications, many such sevens, to be found in the histories which I have read. I am bristling with anticipation! Show me where these seven shall take us!’
Placing the lamp on the peg near the low ceiling, Flomi began to work quickly. Other than the bow, most of the small heirlooms of his father were already on his person; the writing implements and ink vessels his father had fashioned to their task, the pouch and clay bowl he had made here in the Bree-land for the smoking of pipe-weed (a habit Flomi himself had not yet fully adopted but still admired), and the very unique ocular device that he expected came not from his father but even further back from his sires. Also, in another pocket and still unused, he kept the pen which he had been given by the mysterious Rider some weeks before.
He now began to repack them gently among a warmer change of clothes in preparation of both hard goings and cooler weather that he expected in the North. He then immediately went to the small closet and gathered the last two items; a light green traveling cloak and, most surprising, a bright yellow waistcoat. The former Flomi knew well, for his earliest memories of his father saw him clothed in this hood and cloak and going on one of his numerous long walks away from their home. Flomi had never worn it, saving it for now, for the time he himself would leave the Bree-land behind and, in this small way, take his father with him.
The waistcoat was a bigger conundrum; who had ever heard of a dwarf in a waistcoat? Clearly this was a gift from someone, likely some hobbit, that his father had met here in the Bree-land and politeness (something Flomi credited his father with solely through rumour) must have obligated him to keep. Yet when Flomi arrived to take over the task from his father no other article of clothing (beside the aforementioned cloak) was left behind. Why had he saved such a garish and impractical item? Should Flomi do the same now?
There simply wasn’t time to decide. With a grumble and some haste he wadded the yellow material up and thrust it into his bag. Now, the heirlooms attended to, he focused his attention on the more practical matters of his departure.
There was no food here of course, but there was some cookware that might serve him well. He took it with him. Beside the change of clothing he took his own favorite bit of luxury, a second pair of boots. Extra quills and tools for grinding pigments from his work table. Blankets, of course. There would always be a need for blankets. And he had a small kit of medicinal herbs and bandages in the stable that he must remember. All in all, a very light pack for a dwarf of his hardiness.
His mental inventory now completely fulfilled and the time he had allotted for this trip nearly spent, Flomi took a last minute to look around the small garret where he had spent nearly thirty years of his life in the service of his family. He breathed slowly and loudly then for a moment; not as a sigh or any such outward expression of apprehension, for such was unbecoming to a Dwarf in even the most private of situations. He simply took a moment to look to where he had been rather than where he was going and while that might seem peculiarly sentimental it was certainly not uncommon to any of his People.
‘Thirty years amongst these dim folk...’ he said aloud to no one but himself.
He then put his father’s cloak around him, took up his father’s bow and small quiver, and slung it on his back and then, his maddock over his shoulder, he was ready, and happy, to finally depart.
But at the last, turning out the lamp, he halted for a moment. Near his work table there was a cut of limestone, small as an acorn, that some time before -years ago, surely- he had pulled from the bones of the hill and found pleasing for its color and its shape and porous texture. He stopped his departure and, moving quickly as if to make the act seem less important, took up the limestone and put it in his pocket.
Then he turned out the lamp and exited, turned his back on the stoneyard, and on the Bree-land, forever. Or so he hoped.
End of Chapter Two
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter Two
1) Fornost Erain is a Sindarin name, but used by the men of Arnor. It means "Northern Fortress (of the) Kings"; from forn "north" and ost "fortress", and erain is the plural of aran. It was translated as "Norbury of the Kings" (from supposedly Old English norð-burg, which represents its Westron name. That’s a lengthy description, but it shows how the interplay of where names come from is at the core of Tolkien studies.
2) Arthedain lay primarily between the Lhûn and the Brandywine in northwestern Eriador. However, it also claimed the land north of the Great East Road from the Brandywine Bridge to the Weather Hills. When the two other North Kingdoms of Rhudaur and Cardolan fell, Arthedain was the last realm of the Dúnedain of the North and it's great capital, Fornost Erain, fell late in the year of 1974 of the Third Age, a few months before these events.
3) Mithlond translates as "Grey Havens" in Sindarin (from mith "grey" and lond "harbour") Founded by the Elves of Lindon in S.A. 1, the Grey Havens were afterwards used by any of the Elves (whether Noldor, Sindar, or Silvan Elf) to leave Middle-earth for Valinor. But they are also a great link between the scattered people of Númenor and to their heritage and friendship with the Eldar.
4) Ethir is a Sindarin expression closely described as “spy”, though the Elves do not really embrace this term and it has more to do with military deployment. In the strictest sense it means “outwatcher”. Still, it says something of the depth of Flomi’s knowledge that he would know such a word.
5) Flomi is referring to Sarn Ford here, the crossing of the Branaduin that was at this time the southern border of the Shire. The name he uses is Sindarin for “stony-ford”, but there was some bastardization of the name there by the Hobbits which, of course, Flomi would not use. There is, of course, another Sarn Athrad in The Silmarillion which was the site of a great battle between the Elves and the Dwarves in the Elder Days. But the world has changed and that land is lost, so this would be the stony ford that dwarves of his day would know on their way south to Khazad-dûm.
6) This gesture is an invention of my own. This story will carry many threads from The Silmarillion into the Third Age and I wanted something in Beothalion’s lost history to connect with the Istari. It is used here as a derivation of the “open hand” that is used to meet new people and, perhaps, formalized in the first meetings of Elves and Men.
7) The appearance of Alatar (and Pallando) in this story does not necessarily break with Tolkien’s later reshaping of the histories. He had decided that the Blue Wizard came to Middle-earth later than Gandalf and Saruman, about 1600 of the Third Age, and went into the East to struggle with Sauron there. This is still possible within my tale (though I like the early version better) and simply means that they have not yet decided on that road.
8) The internet is a fickle place for research. In looking for an earlier form of the word wizard I came upon wassar as one who holds the staff of power. The website went on to draw some fairly fun connections between wassar and the Jedi from Star Wars and other internet culture, making fairly entertaining links between the staff of Osiris, lightsabers and wizard wands. But mostly I wanted to describe these characters, the Wizards, in a time when they would not have had enough contact with the world that “wizard” was as yet a popular expression. Bree-folk are, as I’ve mentioned, quite well regarded by Tolkien (and themselves) as starting everything, or at least everything good, so I like the idea of the word origin coming in here. I settled on the wassird spelling because it echoes wasir, the Turkish word which gives us vizier.
9) I can’t remember any instance of the word mule for pack animals in LoTR, though it is quite possible I’m wrong about this. It seems to me that ponies played out this role of smaller beasts of burden in Tolkien’s imaging of the world and so I’ve kept that up throughout this work. But the darker powers have different animals at their use, and some versions of mules may appear here later.
10) The Shire is to the east of Beleriand most of which fell into the sea when the world was changed. As Treebeard alludes to in The Two Towers, it sounds like a lovely place for the Ent-wives, so I have extrapolated here the idea that this was some of the first farmland in Middle-earth to survive since the world changed.
11) Close as I can come at this writing o fQuenya for “nearer hills”.
12) This is a continuation of the low wall that Frodo and his companions cross after leaving the Barrow-downs. Bombadil refers to it as the border of a great nation, but it seems clear to me that the divided kingdoms of Cardolan and Arthedain would never have been able to undertake such a great building, particularly in the West of their lands, while attacks came from the North and the East. The Númenóreans in the early years of Elendil would have the resources, but why build a wall in the direction of your allies? The “Wall of Friends” seems a good way of establishing the territorial boundaries of Annúminas from those lands in the west.
Chapter Three; "Questions Amid the Ashes"
-Wherein the People of the Bree-land are Aided by Strangers, Some Cautious Questions are Asked, Many Histories are Told, Careful Alliances of Purpose are Drawn and a Prancing Pony Saves the Day
Read Chapter Three; "Questions Amid the Ashes"
It was well past the middle of night and drawing towards the morning when the desperate work of saving the Bree- land stables came near to its end. Buttercup had hauled buckets and worked pumps1 alongside the other townsfolk in those first frantic hours and she was now dog tired. Collum had pulled her away from the hard labor of managing the blaze an hour before and sent her to the kitchens to help prepare whatever meal might be had for all who had turned out and battled the fire.
‘I’ve told the cooks to empty the stores if need be,’ he told her, ‘and I’d like you to make sure they’re not holding back. All of the people here, just like yourself, have done hard, hot work and if they’d not put their shoulders to it so fast we’d have lost the inn and possibly a good part of the town itself. The Little People will be hungry no matter what the hour, and I think it safe to say that all will be thirsty. Give them all that they may ask, and do not wait for me to begin.’
And with that he went running back to where the Big Folk like himself were busy using earth and tarps of hide, tamping down the last timbers which remained burning to ensure that no sparks might kindle anew.
‘He must be more done-in than any of us,’ she thought, ‘running from blaze to well and back again, managing the whole job. All with one friend dead and the other vanished! Thanks be for him and thanks be for Ben Floxleaf and his Rosie, too!’
Her aunt Pansey and the other maids and cooks had all worked hard under Collum’s orders as well. Too young or, like Pansey, too old to help much with the fire, they had laid out all the necessary support they might give during the past eight hours of the clock. All available water stores and large vessels at the inn had been used to fight the blaze of course, but compresses and rags to be used as breathing masks the women had soaked in beer for the men who worked closest to the flames and smoke. The Breelanders had been surprisingly fortunate with the wind that night as well. Although the stable was in some places only a pace from the eastern side of the inn, no flame had rushed through that narrow alleyway and spread to this larger, provisioned and occupied building. Once it was clear that the wooden roof of the inn was not also in danger of catching, Pansey and her girls had set up a camp of sorts under the Clock-tower on the inn’s west side. There they started laying out biscuits, cheeses, fruits and dried meats or any other cold dish they could think of (for everyone felt it bad luck indeed to start a cooking fire).
‘Well, there’s wisdom enough in that I suppose,’ Buttercup thought as she examined the foods being gathered, ‘but with the morning chill, these tired men will want something a bit more bracing. There’s fortified wines and meads stronger than beer still in the commonroom and I’m sure Collum will want to offer those as well.’
The room itself was abandoned in great haste when word of the fire was first heard, but some of Pansey’s girls must have come here in their early job of protecting the inn. The fireplaces had been smothered, the curtains and draperies removed from the windows and the shutters of the rear door pulled. Drinking vessels still sat on many tables where the customers had left them when all the folk that were present, Big and Little, had gone out to fight the blaze. A few stools were overturned and the little gate that separated Collum’s workspace from the rest of the patrons sat open. ‘The man must have rushed faster than most at the first sound of trouble,’ Buttercup thought admiringly. ‘But it's not like him to leave the Henhouse door lay open.’
She stepped into the enclosure and started to gather as many drinking vessels as she could carry, noticing that the three small delicate cups she had served the kind old gentlemen earlier were strangely missing. ‘Now that is curious,’ Buttercup said to herself. ‘I hope no thief has come here in all the confusion.’ It was then that she looked down to see that Collum’s pack, and his longsword, were now also gone.
*****
When Collum had first heard the noises coming from outside he suspected the worst. ‘Flomi has been followed, as I guessed, and while I’ve had to waste my time dealing with all these strangers he has met with some entanglements,’ he thought. Instinctively he reached toward his longsword, now prepared to shed his tired and troublesome guise as an innkeeper and follow his better nature as a soldier protecting his charge. But it was Milo that came bursting into the commonroom at just that instant, shouting, ‘Fire! Awake! The stables are afire!’
Collum saw the dumb-struck expression on the faces of the six or seven of the Big Folk still in the commonroom, yet the hobbits, to a man, lept to their feet immediately and were at the door even before he was. Bert Thistleberry, the cooper, and Ned Appledore, a farmer from just east of the Hedge, where right at their heels. ‘If this town, and even much of the North, is to be taken over by these rather silly, sturdy, but hard-working folk,’ Collum thought running after them, ‘well then, it could be in much worse hands.’
From the commonroom to the stables the fastest route was out to the street. Already there were people of the town (once again, mostly Hobbits) heading towards the trouble and calling loudly; ‘Fire! Awake! Fire! All awake!’ It was not so many hours past the sunset, but Collum could see many a sleepy shopkeeper of his unfortunate acquaintance standing in doorways scratching their heads and the more intimate creases of their bed-clothes while looking to see what was the trouble. Awakened suddenly and fully, they set down their lanterns or candles and ran headlong to help their neighbours. ‘I have talked poorly of these folk and, no matter what this trouble might turn out to be, it was likely our own enterprise which has brought it on the Breelanders. They deserve more goodness than I have shown them!’ he thought. And then they ran, Collum and his neighbours, headlong to the smoke and the flames and the danger while up this same street, in the other direction, braying and prancing and raising as much alarm as she might, a frightened white pony did her best to kick and neigh and alert the town.
*****
‘You should breathe, Little Benbow,’ Beothalion said, ‘just lay there and breathe!’
And the wildman was quite right of course, Ben could not deny that as a bit of sound advice. And he would certainly tell Beothalion so, if he could ever manage to stop coughing.
For over six hours Ben had worked side-by-side with his new companions and the other Breelanders trying to control what had looked like a rather hopeless situation; for the stables had caught fire unnaturally fast. When he had plunged through the burning entranceway (a brave act that Ben, choking now as he was, had come to think of as quite foolish) the hobbit had no idea what to expect. From the outside there had certainly been a great amount of smoke, but only one post and the lintel of that egress, which was rather broad so as to accommodate the occasional wagon, was on fire at that time. And the whole portal was quite high also, so that Ben had no trouble running in at the point furthest from the flames.
But the inside of the building was more perilous than he could have foreseen. To his right the entire wall of the first stall was engulfed in flame, rather high up in fact, so that the thatched roof had begun to catch and there the fire spread rapidly, filling the loft area with a thick, dark smoke. Inside the poor remaining animals were screaming with horrified voices and Ben could see Beothalion, whom he had followed into the conflagration, rushing to and fro across the row of carrels towards the back, throwing wide the gates of each stall as quickly as possible and shouting to the animals in a language Ben could not understand. The young Elf-lord, on the other hand, stood very near to the worst flames there at the first stall, speaking calm words to a great huge mare (Collum’s horse, if Ben’s memory was aright) and cutting some hard knot of her bridle so that she might escape certain death.
‘Sîdh, Beleg Heryn! Sîdh!’2 he said and, miraculously, the horse was quieting, shining up to the little Elf-prince who stood barely as high as the great beast’s haunches. Once the horse was freed, Tawarengil stepped lightly away from her and cried, ‘Noro lim, Beleg Heryn! Noro lim!’3 and with that she burst toward the open entrance and past Benbow, her eyes still bright with the terror of the fire but no longer panicked as all those other animals that were still trapped in their carrels.
‘Tawar!’ Beothalion cried from the gloom at the rear of the stables and over the roaring sound of the growing blaze, ‘there are other frightened beasts here who will not listen to me. We must help them!’ But the Elf had already come forward to do just that when he spotted Benbow.
‘You are brave, little Perian,4 but these poor beasts are too great for you,’ he said as he paused for only a moment to take Ben’s shoulder. He had looked very much like a child before, despite his high talk and his courteous posturing, ‘just some smart youngster playing at being a lord,’ Ben had thought before when they were all assembled in the outer hall. But now as Tawarengil stood before him Ben could see how very wrong that first perception had been. For the Elf now seemed completely without fear of the fire growing around them and his whole bearing, here and now in the midst of great peril, exuded a confidence unique to his kind that Ben had seen only a few times before in those High Lords at Rivendell. Tawarengil was no taller here than he had been before in the commonroom, not much taller than Ben himself in fact, but in the midst of danger he grew very great indeed and Ben had to wonder at the age of this ‘youngster.’
‘Leave this to Beothalion and myself and go amongst your own people,’ Tawarengil said. ‘You seem not only a great deal braver but some degree smarter. Lead yourself out and lead them to return with buckets!’ And with this he ran to the rear of the stables to help his friend.
Ben followed the advice and sped through the burning entrance way to see a good number of townsfolk (mostly hobbits) assembling and calling for shovels and buckets and pails. Collum was among them, the great grey mare at his side, as he gave orders and set up a line from the inn to the main area of the flame. He did not see Rosie, but was comforted in knowing she was safely away from the fire.
‘Milo!’ Collum shouted, ‘run door to door from here to the well calling for water and vessels, and shovels with hands to work them. Go, lad!’
Laying his eyes on Ben he called, “Floxleaf? Who else is in there? Did you see the stablemaster? Was Flomi...’ At this, and as if they had been called forth, Ben was nearly knocked to the ground as three great pigs came running and squealing from the blaze and into the street around him.
‘That great wildman and his Elf friend are freeing the animals,’ Ben replied, ‘but I saw no others.’
‘We are in their debt then, and I should like them to get out here where I might repay it,’ Collum replied. ‘Go, Ben, if you will, straight down to the well and get folks there to draw as much water from the pumps as they can. This fire grows fast and if the wind rises we will lose the inn and much more!’
*****
Tawarengil and Beothalion had managed to rescue the remaining livestock in a relatively short time; four other miserably terrified horses and three angry pigs had been discovered by the wildman and he could not handle them alone. They were dumb beasts all of them, not like the tall mare or that first pony they had seen, and they could not understand the old language when Beothalion spoke it to them. So terrified were they that the two companions had to take them one at time out of the burning building while their screaming continued; not the pigs of course. ‘Swine are more clever than the trained beasts of these people,’ Tawarengil thought, ‘and their sense of danger isn’t dulled by docility like these townsfolk.’ Once Beothalion had thrown up their gate near the rear of the building, the pigs went scampering for the front, following the hobbit Floxleaf to safety.
With the ponies now free the wildman and the Elf could see the townsfolk starting to gather, setting up a chain of buckets from wherever water could be had and bringing shovels and barrows to gather earth which might smother the flame. The innkeeper was among them, ordering the others about, and the great grey mare that Tawarengil had saved was standing near to him. The three Istari were nowhere to be seen.
‘The flame grows fast, Tawar,’ Beothalion said. ‘These Little Folk are brave to fight it. How can we help them?’
‘Find and follow the brave one named Floxleaf, brother,’ the Elf replied. ‘He and this innkeeper seem to be organizing things here. I go to talk to our other new acquaintances. They have their own means against disaster.’ At this, as he did with the perian, Tawarengil awaited no answer but sped off to see what had become of the others.
This haste and purpose during peril, a quality that Benbow had found quite brave in the Elf-lord just a few moments before, was indeed a characteristic of his personality, though it had not always served him well. Now, in the face of the unknown, it was more instinct for him than valour. Tawarengil had never seen a raging and uncontrolled fire before. Unlike inside the stables with the saving of the threatened creatures, he now had no practical idea of what to do or how to fight such a catastrophic blaze. ‘We do not burn things unnecessarily as the Orcs do, and our Halls in the Greatwood are carved into stone, unlike this place,’ he thought. ‘Water from handheld pails? Shovelfuls of new turned earth? How will that hold back this disaster? How do we keep this conflagration from overtaking the whole of this town?’ But he did not wish to show Beothalion, his friend of many years, how unprepared he was for this new situation and he did not wish to put himself in the position of following these townfolk whom he still considered feeble-minded. So he sought the advice of the Wise.
Leaving Beothalion and the rest behind, he had gone back around to the alley which ran between the stables and the inn. He was certain that the Istari had followed them that far before Tawarengil and Beothalion, alerted by the pony, had sped forward into the burning building. Where they had gone next, and why they weren’t among the others fighting this blaze he could not guess.
Rounding the turn into the alleyway he saw the dark figure of one of them framed against the growing light from the blaze. It was Alatar, the one he took to be their leader, standing still with a curled wand raised just a bit and muttering softly to himself, his eyes focused on the glowing flames. The most surprising thing for Tawarengil, who had studied the Old Tongue throughout his life, was that he did not recognize the words.5
‘Hláranyë ringa Formessúrë,
asúy' aldassen úlassië,
alussa olbalissë nornë,
alamya ve Nuru-nainië.
Formessúrë-yalmë quéla,
ar Númello holtan hwesta
nísima asúya ninna,
ar nainië ahya lírinna.'6
‘What is that he speaks? Did he say númen súrë?7 Does he call for favour of the Valar?’ Tawarengil thought. And he halted there beside the old man, ‘Old, yes, but much more than Man,’ and even with the blaze roaring beside them, he waited there in rare silence, bowing his head as if to join the Istari in his plea. For he did not know what else to do.
It was then that Tawarengil noticed the dead body laying just a few feet behind them.
*****
‘I shall never escape this town in time,’ Collum thought, ‘and now I am greatly needed elsewhere.’
As the townsfolk worked around the growing fire the body of Guldir, the stablemaster, was soon discovered. The Elf and one of the old travelers had found him there in the alleyway and gossip, much faster than wildfire on the tongues of Breelanders, had circulated very quickly that the man had been murdered. Collum had the body covered and removed to safety away from the fire and, seeing the cause of his death, his face grew grimmer.
‘Guldir was a good man in my charge and I fail him now by remaining here,’ Collum thought. But still he remained. There were questions left unsettled and he could not just yet abandon these townsfolk.
When the blaze was finally contained to the inner structure of the stables, Benbow Floxleaf, Beothalion and Collum had led most of the Men in town to beating and smothering the outer walls. Ben, who had done a wonderful job organizing the workers at the well, had returned on his own pony and insisted that Hobbits could do this work just as well as the Big Folk.
‘I’ve no love of roasted toes, mind you,’ he said to those around him, ‘but I can’t, kaff! stand on my own feet easily while others walk into dangers for me.’ And, to Collum’s joy and surprise, some other hobbits, upon hearing this, did likewise.
The Elf-child, whose name Collum had not yet heard, did not participate. He seemed unafraid of the flames, indeed, more unaffected by the heat and smoke than all the other people around him, yet he acted somehow aloof of the danger they still posed for the town. He had instead spent his time gathering and calming the nearby animals (and he had saved many of them, including Collum’s own horse Caitelyn), the whole time talking with the three travelers.
‘I know only a little more of wizards than any man may, and these woodland Elves are new to me,’ Collum thought. ‘But they remain here, watching, and I cannot but think their continued presence will cost me even more time in departing. But why are they here? What brings them to the Bree-land?’
He should, or so he thought many times within this past hour, depart now while all the attention is on the fire. Though he had no real assurance yet, his heart told him that Flomi had gone before the fire had started and perhaps this, though Flomi would never do such a thing himself, was just the diversion they both might use for their escape. As the Breelanders tamped down the remaining flames, Collum had sought for any evidence of the dwarf’s escape. His three ponies were surely gone as was the saddle and all other belongings in Flomi’s usual carrel. He saw the charred remnants of his own saddle, most likely where the fire had been started, and took a few concealed moments to examine it in the hopes of some remaining message. The fire had taken much, but the slow burning of the worn leather had indeed protected a small paint brush concealed in one of the pockets. ‘Better than a note,’ Collum thought, ‘for this was surely not here before. Flomi is gone then, and I must, with all possible haste, join him.’
He had even snuck back to the inn at one point to gather his sword and his pack, including the three small drinking vessels that were precious to him, stowing them somewhere that he might grab them quickly and escape while the confusion yet lasted. But Guldir’s murder, the finding of this brush, and the disappearance of one of Sarnside’s friends told him a cautionary tale; Flomi had escaped, as he believed, but was followed, and the murder and this fire were set to confuse the trail.
‘I should leave, this very instant,’ he thought, ‘for if he cannot reach the safety of the Foundations all of our work will be lost.’ He looked towards the Elf and the three wizards standing off to the side and thought about the questions they would have; wise questions that he would be hard-put to avoid. And then he looked to Ben Floxleaf who, coughing and ready to collapse from the smoke, was still bolstering Milo and a few of the hardiest hobbits to keep up with the dangerous task. And with him, Beothalion, the wildman who had never seen a community of people before and yet was so ready to help them fight this disaster.
‘I shall never escape this town in time,’ Collum said to himself. And then he ran forward with the others to quell the last flames that threatened the community of the Bree-land.
*****
Some hours before, unaware of the fire in town behind him or the peril that now watched him from just outside the gate, Flomi left his small house at the stoneyard never to return.
His provisions were light, easily carried from here to his meeting place with Collum, so he now had to give a thought to his ponies. ‘They have served me well, all three, but they are not all fit for the travels ahead,’ he thought to himself. ‘I shall take Corlar, stoutest and fleetest of the three, and leave the rest with provisions and room to wander. No doubt some inquisitive Breelander will be here in the next day or two and take them into his care.’
But when he left his mason’s house and went back to the place where they had been, he found that the ponies had all gone. His saddle lay nearby, just where he had left it after dismounting Corlar, but the beasts themselves had seemingly wandered off. He checked the outer building, a kind of tool shed that served as a stable to his ponies when the weather was harsh, but they were not to be found.
‘Now this is unusual,’ he thought, and gripped his maddock tighter as he looked around the stoneyard for some sign of what had occurred.
******
Just before the sunrise the strangers began to assemble again in the outer hall that they had left so suddenly at the start of their fellowship. Out in the main yard under the Clock and before the inn the townsfolk were eating and drinking, congratulating one another on their bravery and trying their best to understand just what had happened. None present blamed the strangers, not as yet, for certainly they too had worked bravely to stop the conflagration from spreading. But surely there were some Breelanders who believed that the coming of these odd people into their quiet little town was somehow near to the heart of the problem. ‘Trouble follows trouble, I’ve been told,’ old Tom Truetunnels, with a new audience and new flagon of free beer was quick to point out in the smoky pre-dawn light, ‘and I’ve never heard of Elves nor Wassirds who brought nought but troubles with them.’ But the tall grey-cloaked wassird who argued with him earlier was not there to debate with old Tom this time. He had much more pressing matters on his mind.
‘You should breathe, Little Benbow,’ Beothalion said, ‘just lay there and breathe!’
The hobbit had fought the flames bravely alongside his larger companions and had nearly succumbed to the smoke as they moved further into the wreck of the stables. Beothalion had swept him up and carried him out, that much Ben remembered, but how he had arrived here in the outer hall with a compress on his forehead was lost to him. He would ask, perhaps, if he could manage to stop coughing. Across the room the three old men and the Elf-lord were standing over the large body of a man who was now wrapped in a burial sheet.
‘This death is a decision,’ Olórin said to the others, ‘and not without purpose. A course of action and new measures were taken here with this man’s demise.’
‘Yes,’ said the third member of their group. ‘And this fire was started after, to cover another purpose beyond this murder.’
‘Fathers,’ said Tawarengil, ‘are these small troubles worthy of the Wise? A man is dead, yes, and a town was emperilled, but what does this mean as the Witch-king threatens all towns and all folk here in the North? When we stood in this room last it seems to me our talk was on weightier matters.
‘Beothalion and I travel west to join others from Greatwood who have answered Círdan’s call. It is said he will assemble a force in the westlands against Angmar. Are you not bound this way also? Will one small death remove you from your course?’
‘No death is too small in any matters, lord Tawarengil,’ Alatar said, ‘and our course within them is not set. As yet. No, I agree with Olórin that there is something occurring here which may change all of our courses.
‘That you plan to go west you have told us, and you have made your purposes there plain enough. I commend you for them. Círdan has indeed called upon all the just Peoples of this land to aid the exiled Númenórean king and repel this Witch-king who seems so terrible a threat. We have heard this, yes, though it is not principal to our own concerns for Arda,’ at this Alatar looked to Olórin, as if this was a continuance of some private debate between the two.
‘There is wisdom and bravery to be certain in such a venture, though it is yet uncertain how many of the North People, your own included, will rise to this calling,’ Alatar continued. ‘You say that “others from Greatwood” have gone forth, but you have not mentioned why you, a very young lord of some great lineage, travel so with only this man as your companion. This is also unusual and not beyond our wonder.
‘We three travelers,’ Alatar said, continuing quickly and indicating the other members of his order, ‘who have been parted for many, many long years, have met here in this same small town to decide our own paths and whether to participate in these actions against this Witch-king. Do you not find it peculiar that this should happen on the same day that you and your friend arrive? On the same day of this fire and of this man’s death? Nay, lord Tawarengil, these are no small incidents, and I should like my own time to measure their meanings.’
At the end of this speech Ben, being particularly polite in holding things in up until now, let off another series of loud coughs.
‘And we have not forgotten you, Master Floxleaf,’ said the grey-cloaked Olórin. ‘Meeting a brave hobbit who has also been welcomed in Rivendell on a day when we have considered traveling there ourselves is no mere chance- should you believe in such a thing. You, and your folk, have some part to play in all of this yet, I think...’
‘Perhaps this is true,’ said the third member of their party, ‘but I am continually interested in this innkeep-‘
As if on cue (though in fact he had been listening outside for some time and awaiting this very moment) the door to the small outer hall was thrown wide and Collum Gilleyfoil and Milo Fastknots stepped inside carrying a large jug, cups and a board filed with meats and cheeses.
‘Masters!’ he cried, ‘you have not joined the others outside in their late supper though you most certainly deserve our great thanks. Much that was accomplished this night is better through your assistance. Will you sup with us?’
‘We must talk, master Innkeeper,’ Alatar said, ‘and I do not think it can wait through any time for the niceties of feasting. You seem to stand at the center of many mysteries, this man’s death not being the least nor the last.’
‘Guldir was my friend for many years, Old Father, and none in this town knew him nor will mourn him as I do,’ Collum replied with some flash of a seriousness that Ben had not seen in the man before. ‘But you speak accurately when you say we must talk, and talk frankly now before the Sun rises. For much more is at stake in our meeting than a stable or even a town.’
At this he turned to Milo, his young servant, and gave him instructions to leave. ‘Go see to Caitelyn, Milo, and Benbow’s own pony as well, I think. If decent saddles can be found for each then pay whatever price is asked. But quietly, please. Make no show or talk of our leaving. Once this is done, take them out of town and away from sight beyond the hedge a league or so to the west and just north of the Road. Await us there.’
‘Yessir, I will,’ the young hobbit said, ‘and I’ll have another pony for me and some provisions ready as well.’
‘Not this time, my friend. You’ll be needed here and my own way looks long and uncertain,’ Collum replied with a smile to the youngster. ‘The Bree-land, and the Four Greenfields, will need a steady hand to watch things while I’m away. Tell no one where you are going, but have Buttercup attend us here with more drink and some paper after one hour is over.’
‘Yessir, I will, sir,’ Milo said in return as he hurried to the door. There, as if forgetting something, and blushing in a way that Ben had never seen the quiet young hobbit do before, he paused for a moment and looked back at the innkeeper. ‘You can count on me, sir. I’ll hold things down.’
‘I know it for certain,’ Collum said, and then Milo quickly hurried on his way.
‘Again we see that you have a gift for inspiring confidence, master Innkeeper,’ Olórin said as the hobbit left the room. ‘But it is said; Dolen pâd tur- still tul- estel na i lom bachor.’8
‘Ah! ”yet uncertain turns oft prove unwise”’9 Collum replied with a broad smile. ‘I am to be tested it seems. Very well. Pedathanc hi sui vellyn?10 This is just and wise, fathers, to ask that I know the Fair Speech, but I fear we shall have some time catching our friend Benbow up in this method. Though I suspect it might be easier for you, Beothalion,’ he said, turning to the wild man. ‘I apologize now for any insult I might have given you earlier in the commonroom, but the townsfolk here needed distraction for my own purposes and the arrival of you and your friend came at just that moment.’
Here he turned his attention to the Elf, bowing at the waist and touching his palms to his brow, saying, ‘And I greet you, lord Tawarengil, when earlier I had no chance to do so properly. Ai! Le nathlof hí!11 Happy am I to learn that the Silvan Lords of Greatwood join with my own people against our enemies.’
‘Mae g'ovannen!’ Tawarengil replied. ‘You are courteous beyond my estimation and so I hope that you will forgive my earlier comments as well. But it is certain that you are no simple innkeeper!’
It was Ben who now felt somewhat simple. He had known Collum for nearly a decade, had, after many long conversations, even come to think of him as a rare friend, but there was a change in the man’s manner now that seemed truer somehow than any behavior he had seen before. ‘I knew him to be keener than the rest of these Breelanders certainly, and more traveled too,’ Ben thought, ‘and he spoke some Elvish with my Rosie that one time, and had many long talks with that Dwarf who he looks after. Does he speak that Dwarvish talk as well? And now here he is as lordly as this young Elf or these old pilgrims. What is a man like that doing here in the Bree-land? And,’ Ben reminded himself, ‘more importantly, why did he send Milo for those saddles? One for each of us?’
‘Kaff! Kaff, kaff! Now excuse me for a fool, Collum,’ Ben interrupted, still coughing as he arose from the other side of the room to enter this very surprising conversation. ‘But I think- kaff, kaff! -I think I’d like an answer to that question more than most of these folks. Just who the blazes are you- kaff! -what is going on here, and just where do you think that you and I are going with that order for new saddles?’
*****
‘I’ve no time for truants,’ Flomi had muttered angrily as he wondered about the ponies. He was, it should be said, quite suspicious of their disappearance. But, having little time and the original intention of setting them loose anyway, he spent only a few moments looking for them.
‘I shall miss the opportunity to ride to the Foundations on such a long night,’ he thought to himself, ‘but they are likely more weary than I. Corlar, who I would take along, is smarter than most ponies and has probably hidden himself and his partners from further work.’
‘Very well then, my lazy friends,’ he said aloud into the night. ‘I wish you well with your new masters and, should you serve them more handily, I hope you will live long lives of less labor, that you will grow fat and old, and perhaps learn better obedience.’ At this he went back into the outer building and spread a good supply of feed into their open manger. He poured out fresh water into their troughs from the well and then, once more, went out into the yard to search for any sign of their appearance.
He saw nothing.
‘Ghrrm,’ he muttered loudly and, shouldering his maddock, walked forward to his front gate. The moon was not so high and he hoped to make good speed away from the Bree-land before midnight.
*****
Buttercup had seen Milo and Collum take food and drink to the outer hall and suspected that the other strangers were to be found there. ‘And Guldir,’ she thought. The women had taken poor Guldir there away from the street once they knew that the inn was safe. ‘His throat was cut, they say. Who in the Bree-land would do such a terrible thing to that kind man?’ she wondered.
That indeed was the very thought that most of the tired Breelanders were having as they sat in the street, eating and drinking and talking and watching as the sun came up through the smoke of their ruined stables. Collum, through Buttercup and the cooks of the Four Greenfields, had set out as much as the fire-fighters might need or call for, but now, with the danger over and the spectacle still to be commented on, many new faces joined in the occasion. And as word spread to the waking folk of the town and just outside it, as smoke and signs of calamity met with occasions for gossip and perhaps a free breakfast, the number of the attendees grew quite as large as the number of buckets carried against the fearsome blaze. For what citizen, Hobbit or Big Folk, could wake before the Sun (as most did in those early days of Astron,12 when there was much work to be done) look toward their town’s center and not be curious about the great cloud of smoke which lingered there in the dead winds of this morning. People drew from far around, like wraiths in the haze, to discover what had happened. Rather than question their involvement Buttercup did her master’s bidding and made sure that all were provided for who gathered there under the Clock as the smoke lingered. It was not a feast exactly, for no Breelanders were so rude as to see death and destruction as an occasion for feasting, but it now had certainly become a gathering. And any gathering in the Bree-land quickly became a feast for rumours.
Old Tom Truetunnels was back of course (though Buttercup saw no sign of soot nor ash on his face as she did many of the other younger hobbits), and he was ready as always to provide his own insights on the event. ‘I was not present myself, you see,’ said Tom, ‘for there is important work to be done at the well when fire comes and I’m one for that kind of work.’ (No one could quite recall Tom’s presence at the well during the night’s events, but few other than Buttercup seemed to think that should stand in the way of his venerable opinion.)
‘But some things seem clear to me even from the other side of town,’ he continued for all those who would listen. ‘The stable-master is murdered and his house set to flame. Who would do such a thing you may ask? Well, who was there last who is not here now? That’s what I’d be asking.’
All the townsfolk assembled knew, or (more exactly) they had heard, that Flomi, the Dwarf stonemason, and his ponies, had departed hastily just before the fire had begun. It did not take much more than this first suggestion by the old-timer Truetunnels to make the Breelanders, suspicious as they were of any outsiders, forget that Flomi had lived among them as, if not quite a friend, then certainly a neighbour for thirty years. Busy as she was calling for more provision, Buttercup heard this nasty proclamation and turned hotly on it. There was, after such a long and terrible night, an anger and a resolve in her that was quite newly awakened and much beyond her usually quieter nature.
‘Now that,’ Buttercup said to the old hobbit, fists balled at her sides, ‘is perhaps the most stupid and unkind thing that I have heard you say, Mr Truetunnels, in a long list of your stupid and unkind sayings!’
This was quite shocking to all those who heard it for Buttercup, favored by Collum as she was and by most accounts praised for her politeness, had never been known for speaking so hotly. She was tired, dog tired of course, and the death and the fire and the long hours of work and worry had taken much out of her patience and perhaps (as it seemed to her later) had left her with a different kind of energy than that which normally led her through long work days. Many long hours now she had kept herself working when fatigue or fear might have forced her away. ‘Because it is needed,’ she had kept telling herself, ‘not because it's my job or I need to do it, but because the work here in front of me needs doing and it would be wrong and selfish to walk away from it.’ And that feeling, more than the examples of Collum (whom she thought the bravest of Men) or Benbow (who had surprised her with the bravery of Hobbits), kept her going when she was tired and afraid or unsure of what might come next.
‘You are wrong and selfish to say such a thing,’ she continued, shaking with a bit of exhausted and indignant fury as she glared at Tom Truetunnels and the whole of the town seemed to be watching. ‘One neighbor who was our friend is dead, murdered it's been said, and another has gone missing, most probably in fear and flight. Just because he is gone you call him guilty? We, those of us who were here and close and worked hard against destruction, fought fire to save the town as neighbours do, or as they should do. Are you so in need of an opinion of things that you’ll forget Flomi was our neighbour as well?
‘I have listened to you long enough, Mr Truetunnels, and your meanness. I’m tired and scared for my friends here and all that we almost lost. And I’m scared for master Flomi, who was kinder than you have ever been and is now probably fleeing for his life from whoever tried to set this town to blaze. But, no matter Flomi’s fate, he is lucky to be gone from your own manner of meanness,’ she said, her rage subsiding, ‘a meanness that makes any folk doubt their neighbour, and makes the whole town all the poorer.’
It was at this point that Buttercup looked about and saw so many of her townsfolk staring back at her, many with their mouths and eyes open awaiting more. They were hanging on her words, shocked at first by her surprising impertinence but, exhausted as they themselves were, ready for more of her frankness. ‘This is what being Collum must feel like,’ she thought in the moment, and that thought both excited and embarrassed her, for she realized this was the quality she admired most about the man; his ability to make people listen to and respect him.
But she did not know what happened to Flomi of course, did not know how the fire at the stable had started, and did not have any idea about who might have killed poor gentle Guldir. Beyond scolding old Tom’s ignorance and malice in her own exhausted fury, she did not know what else to say to these people who sat waiting to hear more. And she would not do as old Truetunnells had done and offer empty opinions.
Yet they continued to wait. She saw Bert Thistleberry, covered in ash and rubbing a tired foot, look up to what she might say next. Youngsters Andwise Brockhouse and Mungo Gawkroger sat by the base of the Clock tower in midbite of their cold sandwiches, mouths agape at her telling off the venerable old Truetunnels and anxious for more. Even the usually distant Ned Appledore took notice of her bold redress and Geoff Mallow, Guldir's sometimes stable hand who had never seemed to notice her before, seemed to smile at her newfound boldness.
At the edge of her tired voice, holding her right hand aloft in a position that felt, well, accurate if not familiar, she cried out, ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ just as Collum had taught her earlier and that same warm flush returned to her body, quieting her rage and calming her in her tiredness amidst the stares of her neighbors.
But of course neither she, nor the very most of the Breelanders, had any idea what the words meant.
None perhaps except Fern Sarnside and his one darkly-dressed remaining companion who sat well outside the gathering and whispered to themselves after her saying it.
*****
‘I have been an innkeeper here, certainly, Ben,’ Collum said to all of them as he took a seat by the fireplace, ‘and in that respect true to you and others in this town for all the time I have spent here.’ At this point he paused briefly and his dark eyes seemed to land on the winding sheet of Guldir, the murdered stable-master.
‘And I have tried to be both neighbour and friend, proprietor and consul, to these Breelanders and yourself with all the integrity I might while keeping my other purposes apart from those duties,’ he continued, looking up again at Ben. ‘But innkeeper is my guise and not my true service and I am sorry for any mistrust this ruse now revealed might cause between us. Particularly tonight when you and your Rosie have risked and suffered so much in the face of troubles which my own work here may have wrought.
‘Masters,’ he continued, ‘my time here in the Bree-land is ended and I come to you now largely out of thankfulness but also with some small hope for further assistance. I will depart shortly, and in all likelihood never return, for I am charged with a task that cannot be long delayed as it moves away from this formerly quiet hiding spot and onto the open road. Yet this little town and its foolish, honest folk will remain dear to me and tonight much of it might have perished without your involvement. Perhaps we may have business together elsewhere, for your arrival here on this day suggests as much, but my purposes and my way forward must remain guarded for a time. I will not explain them idly nor directly.
‘Yet each of you deserve much, perhaps more than my oath allows, so I will afford one question from each of you before we part. This, and whatever other kindness the Four Greenfields can offer, are yours until I am no longer its master and when our hour together is finished.’
‘Oh, this is no mere innkeeper indeed!’ said Olórin with a mighty laugh. ‘He traps us in our own inquisitiveness. One question each, but he uses it to take our measure! I like these Breelanders, and their consuls and their gamesmen,’ he said nodding to Collum and Benbow with a smile, ‘much more than I had anticipated. A chance-meeting once again proves to be nonsuch!’
‘Ben, you have asked me first,’ the not-such-an-innkeeper continued with his smile open and friendly, ‘and though it was in fact two questions, I’ll answer both in favor of our friendship.
‘I am not called Collum by others outside this town and took that name here only to serve other purposes. My true name is Ohtar and, though you may have guessed it already, I am not of the Bree-land but a soldier of old Arnor.
‘As to where you and I shall go next, I will not give our most direct route, but I will say that I need a guide in the Wildlands and you are the best that I know of. I have many reasons to hope that you will help me, some based upon the urgency of my task, but mostly because I am in need and believe you to be a friend incapable of abandoning a friend in need.
‘Does this answer your questions?’ the man said.
‘No innkeeper indeed, as the elf-lord here has said -kaff! Kaff!’ Ben replied looking Collum long in the face, ‘but I know you’re no scoundrel as the man I’ve known. I will want for more answers later, but you’re a right judge of folks to know I’ll not -kaff!- deny a friend in need.’
*****
Some hours after leaving the stoneyard, Flomi had found and made surprisingly good time on the ancient pathway he had ridden with Collum just four days before. It ran on surprisingly even ground through the low hills and the trees on either side became younger and thicker as he moved westward. As the lane, if that is indeed what it had once been, went lower running down the fold of the hills there were many deep brakes of new grass on the rising slopes. If he could keep to it now that the moon had risen to light his way, he should make the glade of the Seven Birches by sunrise. Tree and stone were quiet all around him, his belly was full, and his pack was light. A dwarf such as he makes very good speed over open lands in these conditions and his need was great; for now that he was alone and in flight from danger, his mind grew wary and suspicious.
It may very well have been the appearance of the young Elf that evening which had set things into motion, but Collum had thought that some newcomers to the Bree-land earlier, friends of the very inquisitive Fern Sarnside, were folk to watch. To this, Flomi readily agreed; for he had never liked Sarnside and had on many occasions thought the man watched Flomi and his work a little too carefully.
‘This may be so,’ Collum had said in response. ‘He is certainly wealthier in his spending than a modest tanner should be in the springtime, and surprising wealth is often a cause for suspicion. But I am satisfied to know that he is unlettered and so can have no idea of your true work. I suspect he has watched you for many years before I came here to the Bree-land, and so I have watched him steadily since.
‘No, our troubles are more recent, Flomi,’ Collum had said, ‘and though I’ve little doubt that Sarnside is part of them, he at least is the part I can fully understand.
‘Do you remember that visitor to the Four Greenfields last month? The one Gildur told me of?’
‘Aye, I do,’ Flomi had replied. ‘As you well know for asking me so often.’
On the eleventh day of Rethe (March in our current calendars) the Bree-land had encountered a sudden and chilling rainstorm, one that all the Breelanders hoped was simply the last roar of a particularly harsh and dreadful winter. For in Blooting (which we call October) of the previous year the Witch-king had moved on Fornost and a rash of sharp winds, deep snows and crippling hailstorms had seemed to invade the North alongside him. In the early days of the new year, with Fornost overrun, the Breelanders then held their breath and waited to see what might come next.
But Solmath (our February) turned mild and no news came from the North. Surprisingly few Northmen fled south along the Fornost Road through the Bree-land. Some dwarves that Flomi spoke to at this time claimed that Arvedui, King of Arthedain, had fled further north and west when the city fell, and the Witch-king’s forces and his magics had turned that way in the fullness of his wrath, making the Great Road safe for them again. They brought some small trade and some brighter chances down the Road with them. But by any reasons, theories or accounts, that late month of winter and its milder days gave the Breelanders a little hope that a troubling time filled with the wars of Men might well be behind them.
Then, despite all hopes and with the beginning of Rethe a fierce mix of snow and stinging rain came out of the north and all the peoples surrounding Bree-hill hurriedly barred their doors against it. With the weather so hard, Flomi did not return to the stoneyard that morning as was his usual habit and stayed at the inn working beside the fire with a solid breakfast and, as the afternoon wore on, a good belly of wine.
Collum was away then, for he had ridden out a day earlier on one excuse or another. None but Flomi knew that the man left each month to gather information on their secret cause, and not even Flomi knew where these short trips took him; but each month, even through the dangers of this past winter, Collum rode out of town and returned a day or two later with some secret news or scrap of a clue for the dwarf to examine.
‘I have always thought it significant that such a man as this rider would come while I was away,’ Collum had said to him those six nights before Flomi’s departure from the Bree-land. ‘I should have arranged my trips with more care and less regularity, had I thought there was anyone in the Bree-land to notice.’
But on that particular day of the storm, as Collum was away and as Flomi was comfortably working beside the fire at the inn and all the rest of the Bree-land was shuttered against new troubles, a black rider had come to town.
*****
Buttercup, having said her piece, turned her back on Tom Truetunnels and her other neighbors to go back toward the inn. ‘Might as easily stop the Moon13 changing his shape as keep these folk from talking,’ she told herself, ‘but I’ll sleep easier tonight saying what I have said.’
Pansey and the other girls eyed her and smiled as she walked past and Buttercup could tell that they were surprised, and more than a little happy, for her outburst. At this she flushed again and it was then, exactly then, that she realized that their looks made her feel just the way Collum’s secret words had done. It was not like the flush of girlish desire (as when she first saw that young and beautiful Elf-lord), or an angry flush of righteous pride (for it certainly felt marvelous to speak her mind to mean old Mr Truetunnels), but something else entirely; something that she had no words for before tonight and was even now trying to put sense to.
‘What I said meant a thing,’ she concluded, ‘not just a thing to me, but to others. And in it being said other folks were with me, not just for me, but together with me and being together was...’ She didn’t have a word yet big enough for what that meant to her. ‘It was like being part of a song,’ she ventured, but even that did not quite feel deep enough.
As she reached the porch of the inn, Milo, from the shadows within the building, motioned her to enter.
‘Why are you lurking here, Milo?’ Buttercup said. ‘Don’t tell me that something else has happened, for I’ve not a scrap of strength left to do much about it. Where is Collum? Does he need something else for the Elf-lord and those other strangers?’
‘He told me to come find you, miss,’ Milo said in a low voice. Though he was actually more than a few years older than Buttercup, Milo had always referred to her graciously, as ‘miss’ or ‘mistress’ rather than by her own name. She found this behaviour sweet in the young hobbit. He did not talk to people much other than Collum, Pansey and herself, and treated all three with a special kind of dignity. ‘Our master wants you to come to him in the outer hall bringing more drink and some paper for him and Benbow and those five other worthies. After an hour of the clock has gone. Not before, mind you. They seem to have some private talk to be doing.
‘I’m to be off now and to be quiet about it,’ he continued, glancing around from his place in the shadowed doorway. ‘There is, as you put it, something else tonight, and our work is not over for many hours it seems. You’ll need to find more of that strength, mistress, for he has need of those that he can trust and we seem to be all the fewer this morning!’
*****
‘Thank you, Ben. I will answer all that I may when I may, but your friendship does me honor.
‘So one questioner is appeased,’ Collum said, taking up the mugs Milo had poured and passing them around to his guests. ‘And the morning rises. Would that you may rest after the night’s work, but Ben and I cannot tarry. We must leave when the hour is finished. Who,’ he said, taking a short drink of the wine, ‘shall ask the next question?’
None spoke immediately. The wizards seemed to engage one another again through long glances and the young Elf-lord, looking their way, seemed content to let them decide. It was the wild man, Beothalion, who broke the silence.
‘I would still very much like to know, Innkeeper,’ he said, ‘what drink those other three friends had earlier and where I might find some of it.’
At this Tawarengil scowled, Ben looked puzzled and the three wizards showed a calm hint of surprise (if that is something they ever truly felt). Collum could not help but laugh a little and smile broadly at the big man.
‘Do not think your friend has wasted a question, lord,’ he said to Tawarengil. ‘He speaks with haste and appetite, but his question falls near to the mark of what I suspect you yourself might ask.
‘For the thing he speaks of, that his surprisingly keen nose (and no doubt your own) noticed was indeed Miruvor, the cordial of Imladris, that hidden land which you were discussing. Fearing troubles earlier this evening and wondering at what strange turn of fate brought three wizards to the Bree-land amidst those troubles, I carefully used a small portion of that precious spirit to enlist their aid or, at the very least, their notice.’
‘That you certainly gained,’ replied Olórin, ‘for not lightly does the dew of that hidden valley come to be shared in the wider world.’ At this the grey-clad figure and Collum watched one another for a moment; each taking the measure of the other’s words.
But no question followed from the old man, so Collum, nodding his head at the subtlety, continued.
‘I apologize, my friend,’ he said as he returned his talk to Beothalion, ‘after your bravery tonight I would gladly offer you some of the cherished drink, but it is no longer with me here at the inn. It has been moved in preparation for my departure. But who can say? Perhaps we will have other chance-meetings?’
‘You have been very kind, innkeeper,’ the wild man said, ‘being as you are one of the first Men I have met on this side of the mountains. And,’ he said, lifting and smelling his mug, ‘your own wine is very pleasing on my dry throat. I should be glad to drink with you whenever we meet!’ At this he drained his vessel and Collum, raising his own in kind, did the same.
‘I myself should like to know how you came by such a treasure,’ Tawarengil asked in the moment after. ‘For not even in the halls of Thranduil do we have this elixir in store, though its property and its history is well-known to all the Elves. How is it that you, innkeeper or not, have gained such favor of the Lord of Imladris?’
‘Ah,’ Collum said, turning to the Elf but refilling his own drinking cup. ‘The third questioner speaks.’
*****
In the hazy dawn light, aided by some lingering smoke and the tired eyes of sleepless fire-fighters who were now busy with their breakfasts and their rumours, Milo Fastknots was able to quietly leave the inn and round up the animals. Caitelyn, his master’s horse, would not leave the nearness of the inn without Collum and, to his great luck, Ben’s own fat white pony had seemed to take a liking to the great grey mare. Coming out the door on the west side of the building he saw them standing there together, as if they had been summoned, on the northern side of the Clock tower and away from assembled townsfolk.
The Clock was rather close to the Hedge here as Breelanders were not entirely certain of the tower’s ownership. The Hedge came quite close to its western base and provided a kind of close shelter away from the smoke which the animals seemed to enjoy.
The pony, he knew from experience, was skittish of strangers, but Caitelyn knew Milo’s hand well and shinnied up to him as soon as he approached. She still wore her halter, and the hobbit could see where it had been chewed at and then eventually cut to save her from the fire. ‘Thanks be to that,’ he thought, ‘for she’s too great a creature for me to lead otherwise.’ He patted her great head as it came down to meet him, and he took the lead in his hand wondering now what to do about the pony.
‘She’s not saddled nor bridled and I don’t think she lets anyone but Ben ride her,’ he thought, looking hesitantly at the creature who, from what he could tell, looked him over with the same distrust.
‘You’re a lovely, great grey giant you are, Caitelyn, and I’m grateful to see you both saved from the fire,’ he said aloud to his master’s horse who stood by him willingly. ‘But how do we make your friend here trust me?’
‘Oh, she’s a smart one, there,’ a woman’s voice answered from behind him. He had not seen her earlier in all the haze and smoke, but she was resting against the tower base and also away from the gathering. She sat there calmly and breathing deeply, and Caitelyn seemed to stir gently at her voice. The woman’s dark hair was loose from long labor, her garments were black with soot and, while he was not sure of where he had seen her before in the town, Milo recognized her as the first person he had heard raise the alarm over the fire at the stable. She was an outlier perhaps, from the growing areas around the Chetwood and Archet, but she still had a familiar look on her that Milo could not quite place and he rubbed his tired, smoke-filled eyes in hope of remembering her better. But nothing came to his mind at that time.
‘She’s the one saved this town from the fire, should you ask me,’ the woman said, standing easily and looking quite taller than he had at first imagined. ‘Saw her burst from the stables prancing and shouting for all to come. She’s a smart one and knows your talk, for certain,’ she said, wiping her face and coughing quietly. ‘You just ask and see.’ And at this she left Milo and melted off into the haze towards the south side of the Clock tower.
‘Well, alright then,’ Milo said. He turned to speak to his master’s horse while pitching his voice for the pony to hear. ‘Caitelyn, we’re to be going. For your master has need of you and has sent me to do his will. So I’ll lead you now and I’d appreciate it much if you’d help me and tell your friend here likewise.’
At this he turned his eye back on Benbow’s pony and said, ‘and, if you’re truly listening, your master wants you as well, girl. Saving the town was good work, if that’s you what done it, but you’re needed for more. We three will not see much rest before the morning is long, but there’s work to be done. C’mon, now, if you’re listening!’
And at this he took Caitelyn’s reins and going wide west of the tower turned down the lane toward the Great Road and the Hedge-gate on the town’s western side. His back was sore and stiff but, as best he could manage, his posture was commanding. Milo was no horsemaster, but he knew that strength and resolution in manner, something his own master had such great supply of, was needed to lead anyone; horse or neighbour. He tried not to weaken and look back. Caitelyn came easily in his hand, letting off a loud neighing of complacency or, he hoped, some suggestion for the pony to follow.
Bravely continuing forward, Milo did not look back to see what the pony would do and walked many yards in this way not knowing if he had fulfilled his master’s wishes. But his ears were sharp as any hobbit’s, and he heard uncertain movement behind him.
As he turned from the lane into the Road he looked back to see Benbow Floxleaf’s white pony following, hesitantly, at her own proud distance.
‘Now to find those saddles,’ he thought, rubbing again his tired and smoke-filled eyes.
*****
‘I fear that my answer may be less fulfilling than you might wish for, Lord,’ Collum said to the Elf-child, ‘for it seems you have an interest in being guided to Rivendell and this I cannot do.
‘Do not mistake me,’ he continued, holding up his palm, ‘for I understand your need and your cause. But my own way lies elsewhere. And master Floxleaf has agreed to accompany me, so another potential guide has also abandoned you. Perhaps there are others you might beseech,’ and at this he looked again at Olórin, but the old wizard did not speak.
‘Yet it is my history with Rivendell which was your question and, I fear, that may also prove disappointing,’ he said. ‘Like Benbow, I have been to the Hidden Valley on two occasions in my life, on other business. It would not be accurate to say that I have “the favor of the Lord of Imladris” as you put it. More so that my family has enjoyed that distinction for many generations past. The Miruvor was given as a gift to the one I serve and my family has carried some portion of that gift for 245 years.’
At the mention of this amount of years, Collum’s gaze left the young Elf-lord and went again to the three wizards. If they made any notice of this certain date, they did not remark upon it to the others.
‘Moreover, though it is not specific to your question, Lord,’ Collum continued, addressing again the Elf with a grave manner, ‘I will offer something of my own insights on Rivendell;
‘Elrond will not ride out. He mourns the loss of Arnor, but has placed little trust in the North Kingdom since its sundering. Arvedui and Fornost and the kingdom of Arthedain are shadows to him of his former friendships and he views their loss with regret but, I fear, little involvement; he will not risk his own to protect a thing which he feels that Men have already abandoned. He is aware that this move by the Witch-king cuts him off from the Grey Havens, his people in Lhûn, and the way to the West. This he will look to remedy, and maybe the help of you and your Silvan kindred will aid in this. But he will not ride out as a defender of Man’s lost causes.
‘And who should?’ Collum said with a smile, taking another drink of the wine and offering more to his guests. ‘What other hope can we the folk of the North have,’ he said looking at Olórin, ‘unless others should come to our aid?’
*****
‘An hour to wait,’ Buttercup thought after her talk with Milo. ‘The way I feel now, I should be asleep if I stood in waiting that long. So. Busy hands are wakeful hands,’ she told herself and went back into the commonroom to see what quality stores she might still gather there for Collum and his guests.
The room was just as it had been, still a mess from folk who had left it in their haste to fight the fire, so she started by gathering up the drinking mugs and tidying things a bit. She raised the long stools that had been overturned. She threw open the shutters to allow the hazy light of morning on her work. She noticed again the missing pack and longsword from behind the counter and, thinking of Milo’s words, knew with a certainty that Collum must be leaving for a long time. That he had, in fact, been prepared to leave since midday before and well in advance of the fire.
‘It’s not just Guldir’s killer or Flomi’s flight that worries him,’ she now realized, ‘for he was packed and ready long before. And with a sword beside him! Will he tell where he’s going? Would he have told me before all of this fire and death had happened?’
She had no idea. Trusted though she may be, most of Collum’s ways were still as much a mystery to her as they were to the rest of the Breelanders. But she had given up on waiting for him to reveal them. Her job, for which she was grateful, was to keep a careful eye on his needs and manage to match them as she might.
There were still some bottles of Shire winyard she had not taken out to the Firefighter’s Feast of Tongue-wagging (for this is how she had come to think of the party outside that was now abusing her master’s neighborliness) and these could be easily brought to Collum and his guests in the outer hall. ‘Paper now,’ she thought, ‘Well, that’s a harder thing. There’s some in the front room, I think, but those are scraps for bills-of-sale and surely not fitting to any use with that Elf-lord or those three older gentlemen involved. I should think of a finer paper than that, and,’ she told herself rubbing her eyes to keep herself awake, ‘and I should find it now while I’ve the time and the sense to do it in.’
She rummaged through the shelves and stacks at Collum’s serving area first, for she felt she had more place there than in his own quarters. As she thought, there were but a few scraps of birch vellum to be found there, but not very suitable to the kind of finery that Elves and other lordly gentlemen might require.
‘Perhaps they are using it to draw some wonderful map for some very great errand or, even, imagine if they are recording some song or story on this paper before they depart. Oh, how wonderful that would be!’ She thought. ‘I can’t bring him scraps of rough barks for such finery.’
Collum had no other private space at the inn other than his quarters. Curious as she was about this room, Buttercup did not believe paper, paper like the kind she wanted, could be found there. Her master had never been seen to work on the inn’s accounting far from his serving area. She had a mind to visit his room on this pretext (serving her curiosity more than her task) but, sensing Collum’s impending departure, she worried that it would already be empty.
‘But Flomi has also gone hastily. Would his room be empty?’ she thought. ‘And I know where to find the key.’
None of the staff of the inn were allowed to visit and clean the stonemason’s room without Collum present. This was a long known (and greatly spoken-of) tradition at the Four Greenfields and it had gone some way in generating the rumour of the dwarf’s wealth. Collum himself had a key that was used to let in one of the maids when the room needed tending each week, but he promptly locked it as soon as the task was completed. None of the maids could attest to any store of gold and gems there, only that the room was a mess with books and, more to Buttercup’s immediate needs, a scattering of papers. If the key was kept somewhere other than in the innkeeper’s pocket, none could attest to that either.
Until last week, when Collum had suddenly ridden off on business for the day. Flomi was also out at first light, and it was Milo Fastknots who came to let the maid in to clean the room. As the story went among the inn’s employees there was some great confusion then, for Dilly Mugwort, the hobbit-girl to whom this task was usually given, saw that many of the books and chests were now gone, and she was worried that she would be blamed when her master returned.
‘“Now, don’t you have no worry of that,” he tells me,’ or so Dilly had recounted to all the other girls later that afternoon, imitating Milo’s quick and impatient way of speaking. ‘“What a Dwarf does with his things is no business of ours,” he says, and, “I’ll make sure the master knows you did your job and nothing more,” he says as well, and so I did.” Dilly had made this clear to Buttercup and the others. ‘I went in with clean sheets and a clean broom, a clean mop and clean pails with clear waters for washing. I came out with nothing but dirty sheets, dirty pails, dirty mops and dirty waters, and I showed them all to our young master Fastknots there at the doorway just to be certain.’
As to Dilly’s own great adventure, Buttercup had no interest whatsoever. But the idea that Collum had entrusted Milo with this very important key was much more interesting indeed. Later that same day, as Collum had not yet returned and Buttercup was preparing the commonroom for its usual collection of townsfolk, she saw Milo back in the service area, the top of his brown fuzzy head just over the counter and his hands beneath it.
‘Early yet for you to be at the barrels, Milo,’ she had said, ‘even if the master’s away.’
‘Oh! Heavens, not me, mistress,’ he said, looking quickly over the ledge and pulling his hands away, stammering just a bit like a boy caught in a lie. ‘I just... needed this... this knife here,’ he said, picking up a small paring knife that his eyes lit upon.
‘Well, then,’ she said, ‘just have it back before it's missed. Now go out! Collum’s still not back and I’ve much to do getting ready before folks start wanting more of this place than paring knives.’ He withdrew right away, without the knife, and she watched him go with a smile.
Now, standing behind the high counter where she had then stood talking with Milo a week ago, Buttercup bent down low and in the dim light of morning saw an iron key hanging on a small hook far to the back where no one would find it.
No one, of course, who did not know where to look.
*****
‘You give us many interesting things to consider, whether it comes from an innkeeper or a soldier,’ Tawarengil said, ‘But not so many answers. I welcome your opinion, and it matches with some of the thinking of my own People. But I do not see that there is much which you mean for us to learn by your responses nor advice to be taken in hearing them.’
‘Indeed?’ laughed Collum. ‘And this surprises you? Is it not said; go not to the Elves for counsel, for they will say both no and yes? Elves, and other wise folk that I have know, seldom give unguarded advice, for advice is a dangerous gift to both parties.14 No, I have answered each question fairly, lord, as I promised, and did I not say that I have not the liberty to reveal all my purposes?’
‘Aye, that is true, Tawar,’ Beothalion said. ‘You cannot blame the rain for small drops just because you are thirsty.’
‘So, fathers,’ Collum said, turning back to the three old men, ‘what would you who are so wise ask of me before we part?’
The three looked at one another for a moment and then Alatar, the taller of the two blue-clad figures, spoke up.
‘You have not told us much that we did not already surmise, Ohtar,’ he said, ‘other than that honorable name which you were given outside this guise. And I also would guess that it is your true name and so tells some people, some rare few, of your lineage. Your free revealing of such a name in these circumstances speaks well, very well indeed, of your intentions.
‘Of your use of the Old Tongue, of your knowledge of lord Elrond and of Imladris, these things too were not outside our reckoning. For, as you said, the sharing of miruvor in so strange a setting drew our attention if not quite our confidence.
‘Indeed, there is little that you have said thus far that served our purpose rather than did serve your own, should we examine the results; you have enlisted a guide that you needed,’ he said indicating Benbow, ‘made a peaceful connection with two strangers who might have reason to doubt you,’ at this gestured towards Tawarengil and Beothalion, ‘and drawn all six of us travelers together, trusting, into a room with you where we might each reveal our own courses.
‘So I commend you on your statecraft,’ he continued, ‘for it seems clear from more than just the serving girl’s oath-speaking that the blood of the Three Houses is strong in your line. No, there is but one thing you have said tonight that is news to me and that might precipitate a question with useful answers.’
‘I thank you for your kindnesses and commend your observations, Oldfather,’ Collum said. ‘But, unless my ears were too flattered by all of these, I have not yet heard a question.’
‘Hah!’ Olórin let out a quick laugh at this clever response.
‘You have named yourself as “a soldier of old Arnor”,’ Alatar continued without paying attention to his friend’s laughter. ‘And that is a kingdom long fallen. That you do not call yourself a “lord” or a “knight” or some other title intrigues me, for I have been told that there are few left who would claim allegiance to “old Arnor” who then do not hesitate to make some great proclamation of their worthiness. Certainly one can learn much from the histories of knights and lords as they are recorded in books and learned in song, but it seems to me that it takes a soldier’s perspective to know a battle, and its effects, all the better.
‘So,’ he said, pausing for a moment to let the seriousness of his question register on the man, ‘for my own purposes rather than yours, Ohtar, tell me how stands old Arnor these days for its People?’
Collum looked long on the old man for this and Benbow, quite stifled by all that earlier bit about lords and statecraft, felt the tension run out of the innkeeper’s body.
‘I thank you again, father, for allowing me words that I do not need to measure so carefully,’ he said. ‘And I hope that my insights can prove worthy to your purpose.
‘The condition of the North Kingdom at this time is sufficiently miserable.15 King Arvedui of Arthedain, the accepted descendent of Elendil the Tall, is absent and in exile from the land by the onslaught of the cruel and perfidious Witch-king in Angmar. Even the very place of this king’s exile is uncertain, and his fate but very imperfectly known to the generality of his subjects who are, in the meantime, a prey to every species of oppression.
‘Arvedui, amidst whatever other claims, is himself but a short breath in the lungs of the great house of Isildur, Elendil’s heir. Three sons Arvedui has who are as misguided without him as the North country has been for some time. For wherever this exiled king may now be he is also the fourteenth successor of Eärendur the Foolhardy, who, some 1100 years ago, fractured the kingdom among his own three sons, rather than steer a truer, older course of estate. At that time, with the lands mostly emptied by the Great War and the sundering from our own kin away to the south in Gondor, three new flags arose from Eärendur’s squabbling sons to further divide our unhappy people; Arthedain, under Amlaith (who is grandsire to this unfortunate Arvedui), Rhudaur under one of his brothers, Tarondor, and Cardolan under yet another who was named Valandor. Also at this time the numerous class of lawless resolutes, once lordly but now impoverished in substance and hardened in character, roamed between the kingships, selling their swords and their honor and placing their hopes of harvest in civil commotion.
‘To these causes of distress in those days must be added the number of outlaws who, driven to despair by oppression, banded together in large gangs and, keeping possession of the forests and the wastes of our once vital land, set at defiance of these petty kingships. So for generations the nobles themselves, each fortified within their own castles, played petty sovereign over all that was within their reach and each of these three kings held lesser and lesser control throughout their wider regions.
‘Under the various burdens imposed by this state of affairs, the Witch-king came full to power in Angmar,’ he said. At this a shadow came over him and the room was silent.
‘Would you still say more?’ Alatar asked.
‘I will, Oldfather, and I do not count this as a second question,’ Collum said, collecting his thoughts and smiling a bit slyly while taking another small sip of his wine. ‘For you have asked me of how the North Kingdom stands today and I have, as yet, only offered insights on histories that you may already know.’
‘The histories, yes,’ said Olórin, ‘but the insights are welcomed. For you talk of the land as divided yet still one, and this is refreshing to my ears.’
‘I have always seen it so,’ Collum replied, ‘though my neighbors here in the Bree-land would be surprised to hear it said. I have traveled much for my oath and my People, and I believe that we Northmen feel some kinship with the land that our brothers to the South do not share. Great cities and great buildings have Men wrought throughout Middle-earth, and we take great pleasure in these works of hearth and hand. Yet to a Man of Arnor Evendim, the Lake of Twilight, is long in our memories, recalling as it may different shores of our forgotten past. There Elendil, after his flight from the wrathful Sea and the fall of Númenor, built his majestic and brooding city of Annúminas overlooking the calm and pale waters. It has since been abandoned in our strife and as our People have dwindled since the Great War. Yet to a Northman the image of peace and restfulness is not found solely in that lost city but remains in our hearts as a scene of a clear sunrise over cold, still waters.
‘We shall not depart these lands, bitter though our plight becomes, for brighter halls as other Men might, nor shall we stand to see them long divided by kinstrife,’ he continued. ‘For to us the land itself is Man’s solace from long travels and many turmoils.
‘Yet we were too few to hold these open lands after Isildur’s time and we are fewer now. The grand halls of our great kings are now wasted, and if the sight of the land still gives us comfort it comes with a deeper remorse.’
‘We have visited some of these halls of the Númenóreans,’ Alatar said. ‘Their escutcheons have long since mouldered from the walls of their castles. Their castles themselves are but green mounds and shattered ruins: the places that once knew them, know them no more, and this is not unfamiliar- nay, many a race before theirs has died out and been forgotten in the very land which they occupied16 and if the land here echoes your remorse it gives little sign of compassion.’
‘But hard lands breed hardy folk, and not all of them wholesome,’ Collum continued. ‘If the forests and empty plains were given over to outlaws from desperate means in our decline it was, perhaps three hundred years after Eärendur, that the more embittered Men and Orcs and other creatures of evil inclination were, as if by some long-remembered and unexplained impulse, drawn to the northernmost peak of the Misty Mountains in the far desolate corner of Elendil’s old kingdom.
‘Then, strangely in the midst of hostility between kings who should be kin, the open lands became safe for any who might dwell in them and folk left the remaining large cities to better opportunities. Armies, once needed for protection of these fertile but formerly dangerous lands, became naught other than trains of extravagant display for braggart lords and the men of quality left their service of these three petty kings to protect old homelands which they had not visited in generations. Some, homeless but truer to their heart’s calling than most, wandered freely on solitary missions through the North to ensure that order was kept in an otherwise empty land where these petty kingships held no sway.
‘Yet the relative peace this seemed to bring only made matters worse for the North,’ he continued. ‘For as the three kingdoms squabbled, each trying to claim their own importance to an emptying land of farmers more in need of a local market than a high king, Arthedain, Cardolan and Rhudaur grew more separate from one another and likewise from the stability brought by intercourse with our kinfolk in Gondor. Grass began to grow long over the South Road and few in our land looked that way for commerce, friendship, or even tidings of the larger world.
‘This seeming calm lasted for a generation or so and the hearts of Men within the courts of these three nations were turned to greed and malice. Some in Rhudaur, it is said, fell into the practice of dark sorceries, old rituals which never came over the Sea with Elendil or his folk but were somehow learned again. It is believed that the Witch-king, having openly announced his presence at the edge of our old lands during the reign of Malvegil in Arthedain,17 had been infiltrating the neighboring courts of Rhudaur and Cardolan for many years, his agents sowing great dissent between these kingdoms and sponsoring skirmishes which would further set them at odds. When Malvegil died, his son took the old Adûnaic name of Argeleb, the Silver King, claiming again dominion of the old North Kingdom and offered open hostilities with Angmar and Rhudaur. He went with all force to the aid of neighboring Cardolan and saved many of those people so that some of the land was again united.’
‘Argeleb the First was indeed a brave king, if not far-sighted,’ Olórin said. ‘Many good folk of the North were emboldened by his example and drew forth to his banner. I was sad to hear of his fall in the Weather Hills, but he lacked the strength of numbers to assail Angmar.’
‘This is true, Oldfather,’ Collum replied, taking another small sip of the wine, ‘or so our histories report. He never saw his way to the gates of the Red Maw,18 but he did indeed kindle the spirit of the Northmen in ways that had not been done since Isildur’s days. His son Arveleg was wiser perhaps, and held much of the Northlands for fifty years before the Battle of Amon Sûl.’
‘Kaff! I’m sorry if I’m interrupting, Collum,’ Ben said, coughing now more for the chance to speak than out of other distress, ‘and I’ll ask this gentlemen here rather than risk another question of you if I must, but that old battle in the North Hills was five hundred years ago or more.’19 At this he turned toward Olórin and asked rather frankly, ‘what do you old gentlemen know of that and, well, just how old are you?’
Olórin smiled at this, whether from the frankness of the question or from the directness of the questioner or, perhaps, some older memory. Then, briskly, he said, ‘to answer your second question first, master Floxleaf, I am no older than my mission here makes me and none the younger for this lengthy night of inquiries. As to the first question, which is much more useful to our purposes, I had some personal involvement with Arveleg’s flight from Amon Sûl20 before I departed for the South. Perhaps,’ he said, looking toward Collum with a questioning eye but carefully not phrasing his statement in a questioning manner, ‘perhaps this is known to some in the North who have not had their heads in holes for those hundreds of years.’
‘Hah! Now that is harsh, father,’ Collum said with a laugh. ‘Ben and his sires are not like other hobbits and live on the open lands unlike the tunnelers and bolted-door shopkeepers of this town. And they have lived in these wider lands for many long years, just one quick and quiet step away from darkness and battles and plagues and much distrustfulness. Their memories may not be long, but their eyes have been more open than most.
‘Of your own involvement at Amon Sûl I was unaware,’ he continued, ‘though I doubt it not. Much was lost on that day, but much more and worse might have happened if fortune, or some other aid, had not interceded. For the Red Maw was opened for the first time then and all the great numbers of Angmar poured forth into our lands. Here were all the old enemies of the North that had collected there, and multiplied while we thought the lands were safe and as the petty kingdoms squabbled. Then our troubles came forth. Orcs and Wolf-riders, now in great strength of numbers, sorcerous Men and wild folk who had come to despise the legacy of Númenor, Trolls and even Drakes came forth under the banner of the Pale Sword as Carn Dûm was emptied and all of the North was set to be despoiled. Amon Sûl was razed and Cardolan ravaged and the Witch-king rode across all the land to a great siege at Fornost Erain. Arveleg died in this year and it seemed that the North would now be lost.
‘But Arveleg was a king wiser than most and had shown a gift of far-sightedness. Renewing old bonds, he had sent his son and heir, Araphor to the Havens to be reared by Cirdan. This act, and the boy’s own good nature, had much effect upon the Elves of Lindon. On word of his father’s death Araphor, still a boy of eighteen, rode out with a great Elf-host at his side and broke the siege at Fornost.’
‘Glorfindel himself led these armies, I have heard,’ Tawarengil added, ‘and it was a very great host indeed that retook those lands. But the greater force that set Angmar back came from Imladris and Elrond himself rode in the vanguard.’
‘Yes,’ Collum replied, ‘or so I have also heard. Rivendell, and even the Golden Kingdom21 recognized the threat and pushed the Witch-king back to his fortress in the Hithaeglir. Though no siege was possible, for the land is mightily cruel and desolate there. But for a time he was subdued. Silent, brooding perhaps on victories that eluded him, diminished, or so it seemed, but still the Witch-king was not broken. Halted, but still waiting.’
‘Is this Witch-king deathless, Tawar, as your People are?’ Beothalion asked.
‘I do not know, brother,’ the Elf replied. ‘It may be so. Often the great evils of the world are so, and this Carn Dûm rises at the very edge of the broken fortress of Arda’s oldest evil. Perhaps, as some old dark creature awake again from the Elder Days, he comes fresh into these lands from some deep pocket of shattered Thangorodrim to do terrible works of malice upon those who overthrew his Master. Perhaps this malice and vengeance have granted him many powers over age and diminishment. It is not known. But mortal, as you are brother, this enemy is not.’
‘Grace! But this is better talk for a brighter morning,’ Ben said, opening the shutters wider.
Collum sighed softly and continued. ‘There are as many theories of the Witch-king’s nature as there are foes of his actions. In this way many of us who might join to oppose him are conflicted. And by this conflict his powers grow wider.
‘The young king Araphor re-took much of the Northland and held it in peace for 180 years. Rhudaur was gone, and Cardolan was nearly empty, any claim of its lineage shattered, as so it became vassal-land to Arthedain. The North was Arnor again, even if they still lacked the political integrity and force of numbers to call it so. Araphor’s friendship with the Eldar brought trade and some relative safety from the lands surrounding Fornost and to the West towards Lindon. Dwarves walked the East-West Road again. The Elves, feeling their passage West safe for a time, returned to their meditations. Your own folk, Benbow,’ Collum said, ‘flourished well in this time in the North. So well in fact that they petitioned the King at Fornost for lands of their own across the Brown River. Peace returned and brought some hope with it. And still the Witch-king waited.
‘In 1636 the Dark Plague swept all the Western Lands. It was worse in the denser cities of the South, or so I have been told, but many of my People of old Arnor perished and the lands were further emptied. Here many of our hopes foundered. The folk of Cardolan vanished almost entirely and for over one hundred years Wights wandered the lonely hills from Tyrn Gorthad to the North Downs east of Fornost. Many feared to travel then, and even the Great East- West Road was vacant and grass began to overgrow some of its path. The North became silent and its People withdrew from their cities to lonely places. Even the Bree-land, quite usually resistant to such troubles, was nearly emptied. Fornost Erain, under Argeleb the Second and his son Arvegil, worsened the matter and shut their wide gate permitting no one, under penalty of death, for one hundred years. If the lands had been won back from the Witch-king in Araphor’s time then they were emptied, poisoned and neglected in the three generations which followed him. And still the power in Angmar waited.
‘Now as I have said,’ Collum continued, ‘hard lands breed hardy folk and many, other than the Dúnedain, have claimed this lonesome land for their own. The Hobbits are of stronger stuff than most credit them and the lands between the Baranduin and Mithlond, remaining peaceful as it did, sustained much of the North. The doors of Fornost were eventually opened again, trade resumed on the Roads and relations were opened once more with our kin to the South. In 1940 Arvedui of the North (if not exactly king of Arnor) wed Fíriel, daughter of Ondoher of Gondor and our future looked brighter for a time. ’
‘And now our tale shifts South it seems,’ said Olórin, interrupting their host, ‘and, if I’m any judge of accents through my travels, our Ohtar here, I should say, has spent much time there himself and there is much he might say about Arvedui and his claim of the Throne of Men.’
Collum looked at him gravely and said, ‘is that to be your question, Oldfather?’
‘Hold!’ the old man said quickly, raising his hand to Collum’s eager eye, ‘for I know this game too well! I simply mean to offer my observation to our fellows and do not give that as another question here. No, our time here together grows short, I think, and I’m not one to squander your useful tokens in haste, soldier. Of the failed bond between the North and South Kingdoms of Men I know much. For when Gondor’s king Ondoher and his sons died then Arvedui of the North Kingdom laid his claim and it was said, “Elendil had two sons, of whom Isildur was the elder and the heir of his father. We have heard that the name of Elendil stands to this day at the head of the line of Kings of Gondor, since he was accounted the high king of all lands of the Dúnedain. While Elendil still lived, the conjoint rule in the South was committed to his sons; but when Elendil fell, Isildur departed to take up the high kingship of his father, and committed the rule in the South in like manner to the son of his brother. He did not relinquish his royalty in Gondor, nor intend that the realm of Elendil should be divided forever.” But Gondor rejected this claim and answered by naming a king of their own.’
‘And it was also said,’ Collum replied, ‘“Moreover, in Númenor of old the sceptre descended to the eldest child of the king, whether man or woman. It is true that the law has not been observed in these lands of exile ever troubled by war; but such was the law of our people, to which we now refer, seeing that the sons of Ondoher died childless...”’
‘Hah! Wonderful news indeed!’ Olórin exclaimed, leaping to his feet with renewed energy and clapping his hands in a robust manner that the others found surprising, ‘I will now interrupt your history lesson if I may, Alatar.
‘My friends,’ he said, looking at his fellow travelers and the Elf and the wildman and even poor confused Benbow, ‘This is indeed a propitious meeting to be had on a day in which we all may have doubted our courses! This soldier of Arnor has much to conceal,’ he said, placing his hand on Collum’s shoulder, ‘but still much involvement in our own concerns. Ask him no more for the time, Pallando,’ he said, turning to his quietest companion, ‘for we will save that boon for a time when it may reward us all better through our better trust.
‘He may, given the opportunity, report much more than any other you might meet on the subject of Arvedui’s remaining forces. Perhaps he knows if the sons of the king have joined with Círdan yet or even have some plans of their own to rescue their father. For I believe that this man has eyes and ears at his service well beyond the Little Folk of this town and those who travel through it.’ Here he raised his own cup to the innkeeper, who watched him with a cool and wary expression.
‘In the meanwhile I will offer my own question to speed our fellowship;
‘Ohtar, son of Ohtar, servant of the secret lineage and riddle-solver and protector,’ he said, turning his frank, grey eyes upon the man’s face, ‘how might we aid you?’
*****
The door was ajar when Buttercup got there, and that was the most frightening thing she had encountered in all this long night of terrible surprises. She stood there staring at it for a moment; so odd a thing to see this so private a room left open to anyone with the only key that she knew of pressed in her own frightened hand. She was uncertain what to do next, and quieted herself, watching.
‘The bolt is not broken,’ she thought, looking at the small gap of the doorway. ‘Someone got in without forcing it. With another key? Is Flomi here and not fled as we all think?’ Every wisdom in her body, instincts of flight and fear that she’d learned to control or rely upon in her time here serving men at the inn, told her that there was danger in this open door and that she should flee immediately and seek help. But she had hoped to be better than her own fears and had, in fact, just spent a difficult time chastising her own neighbors for giving into them.
‘I should like to see what the fuss is in here,’ she thought, ‘and I should like to think I’m strong enough to see to it myself.’ So quietly, hesitantly, she stepped forward and placed her hand on the door. ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ She whispered under her breath as she opened the door and moved into the room.
*****
‘Lord Olórin,’ Tawarengil said, ‘I should not wish to suggest you are unwise, but my own errand is, I believe, of some importance. Do you suggest I stop it to align myself with this...’ and Tawarengil’s words, usually quite fluid and assured for someone of his boyish appearance, became cautious. ‘...this... innkeeper?’
‘I do not, my lord,’ the grey traveler replied, ‘your courses are your own to decide. But I do suggest that we all have stumbled upon things here this night that none of us would have expected. You might call it heren,22 governance that should guide your decisions and Men might call it amarthan,23 “to be fated”, but here we are together with much to learn. Shall we question the grace that has brought this meeting out of some stubbornness for our earlier plans?’
‘Oldfather,’ Collum said finally, speaking directly to the old grey wizard, ‘you do me great honor. If you have learned things about my quest beyond these histories I can only hope it is through your shrewdness and no fault of my own that something of my deeper purposes are revealed. “How can you aid me,” you ask?’ he said with a much longer pause.
He took one lasting drought of his wine and answered to the room, ‘Friends and lord and fathers, despite your offers of kindness, or your plans to meet with the Elves of Lindon or Rivendell,’ he said, motioning to Tawarengil and Beothalion, ‘I believe that the Northlands cannot at this time be regained; we are too few and the land too vast for those that remain. We fight not just the hard armies of the Witch-king, but also against our own dwindling. Our lands have become emptied and our People, few as they have become in the North, have no king of Argeleb’s stature to rally them.
‘Such a king might come, as many foresighted among my People still predict. Of this, I cannot say. But rescuing Arvedui will not, I believe, save the North Kingdom and the hope I hold for my People lies elsewhere-‘
As Collum spoke his quick eyes, and Benbow’s, caught a dark shape drop from the sky past their now open window just as a scream of terror came from the floor above them.
‘A woman’s cry for help!’ Tawarengil said, as he burst towards the door, faster than the others could react. Beothalion, dropping his cup and seizing his staff, was at his heels without hesitation. The old travelers had all come to their feet, but Ben and Collum had rushed to the window just as the cry from above had been heard. Nothing could be seen from their small vantage of where the figure had gone and the alleyway here was quite close to the ruin of the stables where the air there was still filled with a smoky haze. There was no direct exit here as there was in the commonroom, and they would have to go out to the hall door to see their way through to the alley, following behind the Elf and the wildman in their own haste to the stair.
‘More troubles still, and with my sword hidden far from my hand,’ Collum thought. ‘I shall never escape this town in time.’
Rushing out the door with the others, he went right towards the stairway (for the woman’s voice who cried for help was surely Buttercup’s) but he knew in his soldier’s heart that the trouble should be met left toward the alleyway and the figure fleeing there.
*****
The door was not open for a heartbeat, quick as her heart was in the moment, and Buttercup’s new oath was barely spoken, when she saw a black figure rise from the corner of the room, hissing loudly as if angered, or perhaps even wounded, by the words she spoke.
Light came in through the eastern window of Flomi’s room, and the trespasser was silhouetted there against it, staring at her, as if determining how fast he might close the distance between them and tear out her throat like some animal. Or at least this is how she felt, recounting it later, and she could only recall how dark he looked, dressed all in black and with the window behind him, and how frightened he made her feel. She could not, try as she later may, see his face in that moment.
She turned her back on the figure and fled, unwisely perhaps, for as a wolf he might be right behind her before she could reach the stair. Then she remembered to scream.
‘Aiiee! Foes! Robbers! Awake!’ she called at the top of her voice as she ran to the stairhead. ‘Foes! Awake!’ She plunged down the stairs not hesitating a moment to see if anyone was behind her.
The handsome young Elf lord suddenly was on the stair beneath her as she hurtled down. He caught her in arms that were surprisingly strong for someone who looked so young.
‘Where, girl?’ Tawarengil asked, looking into her frightened eyes. ‘What have you seen?’
‘A robber, sir, or a monster,’ Buttercup replied, catching her fear and looking back at the Elf. As she did, Beothalion, Collum and the others came to the bottom of the stair in front of her. ‘A man all in black in the Dwarf’s- Master Flomi’s room, which should be locked and wasn’t.’
‘Ben,’ Collum cried, instantly taking charge, ‘go with Beothalion out through the alley and give chase. That must be what we saw. Tawarengil and I-’
But the Elf had already bolted up the stair. All that Collum could do was follow. Buttercup was left with the three wizards who were coming up behind.
Clearing the landing, Collum saw Tawarengil at the top of the stairhead turn left towards Flomi’s room. ‘Perhaps they really can smell dwarves,’ he thought, and followed the fleet young figure just as fast as he could.
As he reached the open doorway he saw Tawarengil standing in the room’s center, a long knife in each hand, looking for an enemy. ‘If it was just the one,’ Collum said, ‘I think we saw him drop to the alley just as you heard the girl cry out.’ Before the sentence was even finished, Tawarengil rushed to the window, its shutters thrown wide open. He then leapt upon the sill, gazing down into the alleyway below.
‘It is a hard drop for a Man,’ Tawarengil said to Collum as the innkeeper joined him at the window. ‘Not many would risk it.’
‘And he ran quickly after,’ Collum replied. ‘Ben and I saw his shape fall, but could see no one in the alley from our window below.’
‘It would seem, master Innkeeper,’ said the deep voice of Alatar behind them, ‘that your house is filled with curiosities this night.’ Turning, Collum could see that the old traveler had followed with Buttercup beside him. ‘And, with this new occurrence, it also seems unlikely that you will now leave as quickly and as quietly as you had hoped.’
Buttercup, her eyes wide and startled, looked at the old men, and at the young Elf and at Collum, who she had trusted and cared for so long. ‘I will never escape this town in time,’24 he said, this time for all the rest to hear.
End of Chapter Three
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter Three
1) The subject of pumps and fire protection here brings up one of the most difficult aspects of writing fiction in Tolkien’s universe; just what kind of technology did common people have access to? The story here is some 1300 years before the War of the Ring, but I’ve decided to keep much of that same late Medieval technology employed in those books. Tolkien’s world, to my mind, seems to be one in which technology does not move forward. Instead it is a static and rarely changing fantasy of the Medieval in which old advances have been lost and are carefully protected by the Wise.
2) “Peace, Great Lady! Peace!” in Sindarin, or so my online translator app informs me. I’m doubtful about the overuse of this resource of course, and welcome any corrections.
3) “Run swift!” in Sindarin. Of this one, given its use in The Fellowship, I am certain.
4) I’m having some trouble, as of this writing, determining the singular form of Periannath, the Sindarin word for “Halflings”. Hopefully I’ll sort this out before the whole book is finished.
5) A study of The Silmarillion suggests that the Quenya which a young Elf of the Greatwood might know should be quite different than the original Noldorin form refined for the Elves in their contact with the Valar. I have entered a very lovely poem here found on the internet, but I would like to go into this passage at some later time (as I’m currently trying to study Quenya) and make something of my own. In any case, it seems reasonable that the Wizards here would speak a much more pure language than Tawarengil might find familiar.
6) It is my hope to eventually create a passage like this in Quenya, but I am only just learning the language and far too inexperienced at this writing. This poem comes to me through the language site I have been using and is credited to a poet named Tatyandacil using their own translations. It’s quite lovely and suited well to the situation as it includes a prayer to the wind. It is a bit longer, but I’m including here just the first two stanzas.
“Hláranyë ringa Formessúrë, (I hear the cold Northwind)
asúy' aldassen úlassië, (blowing through the leafless trees,)
alussa olbalissë nornë, (whispering in the twisted branches, )
alamya ve Nuru-nainië. (sounding like a Death-lament)
Formessúrë-yalmë quéla, (The clamour of the Northwind fades, )
ar Númello holtan hwesta (and from the West I smell a)
nísima asúya ninna, (fragrant Zephyr blowing towards me,)
ar nainië ahya lírinna. (and the lament changes to song.)
7) Númen súrë is “west wind” in Quenya.
8) “Hidden paths bring hope to weary travelers” or as close as I can get to it in Sindarin at this writing. I can find no direct translation as yet, so I apologize to those of you out there who undoubtedly know the language better than I. But if I wait to learn the language in full before beginning the story, well, I’ll certainly be too old to ever finish it.
9) To help enforce the idea of this exchange as a proverb, and to exhibit my own failing in the Sindarin tongue, I’ve decided to let Collum finish it in the Common Speech.
10) “May we speak as friends now?” in Sindarin (according to Google).
11) “Hail! We welcome you here!” in Sindarin.
12) “Astron” corresponds to the month of April (actually March 23rd to April 21 in our modern account) within the Shire-reckoning. The Shire calendar is based acutely on the Saxon calendar so I wanted to use it here in place of the modern date (April 12th, for those who are keeping track). This does hark back to the idea that most of the best developments in Hobbit society probably happened in Bree first, but the idea that Bree, during the time of this story, would have developed its own calendar apart from Númenor, seems very likely. The Saxon calendar seems particularly appropriate in this case, but in a supporting work, "In the Shire-reckoning", I comment on the more elegant naming of the months which the Shirefolk use.
13) In Middle-earth the Moon is considered male and the Sun female.
14) This is a paraphrase of the conversation between Gildor and Frodo in The Fellowship. I like that Frodo's response is in italics in the original, as if he was quoting from someone (Bilbo perhaps?). But it helps to create another link between this story as apocrypha and the idea that these sayings might have gone into things which Bilbo heard but did not write about.
15) This, and much of Collum’s description of his lost kingdom of Arnor, is cribbed from Sir Walter Scott’s Ivanhoe. It is the first direct inclusion of that text that I’ve used here, but there will be many more.
16) This, also, is unapologetically pulled from Ivanhoe.
17) This would put the date about 1300 of the Third Age. That Collum delineated some of these dates through reigning kings of Arthedain rather than the other nations will be relevant later.
18) It is not entirely certain, and some internet debate seems to be present, but this is, for my purposes, a useful translation of Carn Dûm, the Witch-king’s fortress in Angmar.
19) Six hundred really, but Ben’s knowledge of history is sketchy at best. Olórin and Collum are referring to Argeleb the First's last battle in the Weather Hills in 1356.
20) There is some conflict on the idea of whether Arveleg died at the taking of Amon Sûl. Since the notes in the appendix for LoTR do not indicate death in battle I default, as usual, to that original source. The Fall of Amon Sûl was in 1409.
21) A useful name for Lothlórien.
22) Quenya for “order”.
23) I was unable to find an Adûnaic translation for “fated” and originally went with umbarto which is also Quenya. But I did want this to be from the language known to Men and have defaulted to the Noldorin translation here, it being the closest to old Númenórean. The written Númenórean language itself is closer to Sindarin of course, but I need a greater distinction between Tawarengil’s language and Collum’s.
24) This often used expression was, for a time, a working title for the whole chapter. I never intended to spend this long in Bree-land and had quite hoped to get on with the adventure a bit by this point. But the history lesson here was needed, I feel, and I’ve fleshed out other characters who might have remained incidental as a way of giving the exposition some room; Milo and Buttercup, the yet-unnamed woman who witnessed the fire, even Collum’s horse, have been given much more attention through the writing of this chapter than I had ever planned and many new subplots have suggested themselves. This is just a byproduct of the pleasure of walking around in the universe and I try to remember that it took Tolkien more than seventy pages to get Frodo out of the Shire. In this way the chapter here echoes some of Fellowship’s second chapter “The Shadow of the Past”, which is likewise long on history and tone. But Collum is, in this case, a perfect “non-player character” for me as the author, for like him I can’t wait to get things moving.
Chapter Four; "The Ways into the West"
-Here Fellowships are Formed, Gifts are Given, Escapes are Made, Provisions are Sought After and the Science of Growing Mushrooms is Briefly Explained whilst the Visit of a Black Rider to the Bree-land is Recounted.
Read Chapter Four; "The Ways into the West"
‘It was just a spark and a startle! I saw no robbers or killers! I was tired and I was frightened by fire, so I was louder than the spark was important and now, staring into your faces, I very much regret alarming the rest of you as I was alarmed myself,’ Buttercup said to the assembled townsfolk on the porch of the Four Greenfields. ‘So, please, take my apologies back to your homes and let the rest of us here alone to clean up after a long night’s work!’ All the Breelanders (all those who were not otherwise preoccupied by feasting, of course) had come running to the door when she had screamed from the second floor and had become quite aggrieved by being told to stay out by two of those old pilgrims who had met them before she had. They did not necessarily believe these tall old, sour-faced men who told them that everything was fine, but the Breelanders had prudently backed down from the strangers’ firm manner and their harsh stares which had forbade them to enter the inn.
After Collum and the Elf-lord went charging up the stair Buttercup had gone back to Flomi’s room with one of the old men (their leader, perhaps?). She realized that she still did not know any of their names. But this taller one in paler blue (who had been much quieter earlier in the evening) had asked her many questions along the way that she could not answer. The questions had made her feel foolish. She could not describe who she saw. She could not say if she had seen him before. She did not think she would know him if she saw him again. She could not say if he held a weapon. It was “no” to all that he asked. All of these questions, and her conclusions upon them, made her feel terrible. Surely Collum, if she might live up to his example, would have had more information to give. But she did not. She was tired and frightened and she had gone into a place that she was not permitted to be. Her panic at seeing a threat (and she was beginning to realize from the grave expressions on these men’s faces just how great a threat she had encountered), now made her feel weak not out of fear (though that was certainly part of her feelings), but out of disappointment. She had disappointed Collum and these others somehow by not being more observant, and so disappointed herself as well.
‘Buttercup,’ Collum had said to her in a gentle tone as they stood with the Elf and the old man in Flomi’s room before the open window, ‘you have risked much tonight, girl, and worked hard as any, but you dared much more by coming in here.’ His voice was low and caring, but she still felt embarrassed by it, for she knew she was forbidden to be in this room and had not made a good account of herself regarding the thief she had seen here. She avoided his eyes, and those of the young Elf-lord, as he spoke to her.
‘But the long hard night is over, girl,’ he said, ‘and hope comes with the morning.
‘Go back to the door for a short time, please,’ he continued, ‘and rid the house of our troublesome neighbours. I fear our newfound friends are not as up to that task as you are and may set new buildings ablaze just to discourage nosey hobbits. I’ll need a few short minutes with Benbow and the others and then you and I will meet in the commonroom.
‘I’m sorry, Buttercup,’ he said, lifting her chin and looking into her eyes, ‘but I’ve not much time and more than a few things to say. Can you help me a bit further and bring some short peace to the Four Greenfields at the end of a long night?’
‘Yes, sir, I will go to the door now,’ she had said, trying to look brave and even smile a bit to seem daring, ‘I’ve got wine for you all, but only just came here seeking proper paper as you asked-‘
‘No time left for wine I fear, girl, and I’ve papers enough for what must be done,’ he replied, grabbing three random sheets off of Flomi’s bedside table. ‘Just give all those busybodies at the door a proper thank you and farewell and then you and I shall talk soon.’
And she had done this, not that those outside the door were too happy about it all. Many wanted Collum himself to come out and give an accounting. They wanted his answers for the recent cries from inside, the goings-on within the Four Greenfields and just who these tall strangers thought they were to prohibit good neighbours from entry (these opinions, Buttercup noticed, were only offered after the old gentlemen had gone back inside).
‘I should like to hear from Collum himself, miss,’ said Andy Brockhouse, one of the young hobbits, ‘why, for all we know them old wassirds have put some spell on him and the inn itself will be the next thing set to blazes.’ There was a general agreement on this from the others with the exception of some grumbling from a few of the closer neighbours who had seen the strangers fighting the fire. It seemed that any good services these gentlemen had offered through the long night were being swept away in an hour’s worth of rumour. Towards the back of the crowd Buttercup could see Tom Truetunnels sitting amongst his other friends and watching slyly as the crowd on the porch grew more agitated.
‘How are we to know,’ another said rather loudly, ‘that these strangers haven’t put a spell on you, girl? You seem to have been talking to them quite a bit, and talking very strangely to the rest of us I’d say, ever since they came to the Bree-land.’
‘That,’ Buttercup thought to herself, keeping her anger in check, ‘is really quite too much.’
‘If you find my talk strange, Tom Birchfield, it’s for want of rest and freedom from such silly questions. So, for want of patience, let me talk with all of you all the more frankly:
‘The very kind, and I should say very hospitable, owner of this inn and provider of your morning’s meal is my master,’ she said, raising her voice to be heard above the rest, but keeping her tone even and polite as possible, ‘and he has told me to come here and say to you how thankful he is that so many Breelanders came to the aid of their town last night and how happy he has been to feed and to show his respect for so many worthies.
‘But it has been a very long night for everyone,’ she continued, ‘and all of us here need to get back to work! The Four Greenfields, by order of your host and my good master, is now closed to all but our traveling guests and the rest of you must hold your continuing questions for some later time. Should you show the courtesy to wash or stack your plates before you go then you will make our jobs here all the much easier but, if you can not find the kindness to do that, we trust you will finish your breakfast and leave the plates and cups behind you. While we’ve too much work and therefore no time for so much gossip, we thank you for last night’s bravery and wish a gracious good morning to you all!’
At this rather stern pronouncement she turned and slammed the large oak door of the inn and loudly threw the bolt. She paused there for a moment, breathing calmly as she may and then walked briskly away thinking, ‘So it is with our neighbours and customers. The best of them will know they’re time at the table is up, finish the food we’ve provided, and go about their business. The worst of them will do us no worse than steal a few plates or tankards and then arrive early to supper with more questions than they have coins.’
*****
‘He landed hard there, just near our window,’ Benbow said as he and Beothalion rejoined the others in the small outer hall. ‘But he clearly made it to his feet quick as a coney and there were some tracks to follow away down the alley. We gave chase, but lost any sign of him in all the wreckage of the stables and on the street behind.’
‘Little Benbow and I were quick, my friends, but this fellow was quicker,’ the big man added. ‘And I could not catch any smell of him with all the smoke still in the air.’
‘This is very bad news. Is there nothing else your sharp eyes could see, Ben?’ Collum asked.
‘Well, most folks are out in front of the inn now, so the streets back behind were clear when we came to them. I think we must’ve followed pretty close but saw no one and no discernible sign from here to the Hedge. He would have to be quick indeed to get out of town that way. No,’ the hobbit said, taking off his unique three-cornered hat and scratching his shaggy head in thought, ‘I think he either doubled back to the festivities through the smoke or slipped inside one of the other buildings. Either would be a neat trick for a sneak; makes him sharper than most I’ve heard of.
‘But I didn’t see enough of him to know what to look for, Collum. He was one of the Big Folk certainly, long strides and the tracks we saw were made by boots with a heel, so that’s something maybe. I might recognize that track again while walking the ground behind him, but I wouldn’t know the fellow himself if he turned and I looked straight into his face.’
‘The girl has no better description,’ Alatar said. ‘Dark clothed and taller than she herself, but she is not certain of the face.’
‘Could we not have her search the crowd outside?’ Tawarengil suggested. ‘Perhaps she might recognize him there?’
‘I’ll not risk her in that way,’ Collum replied, looking over to the wrapped body of the murdered stable-master. ‘No, I have my suspicions as to who is involved and am reassured that my people at the inn, and these rather uncomplicated, bull-headed yet still-admirable townsfolk, are now safe from any troubles I may have brought them. So all of this just makes my task the more urgent.
‘Friends,’ he said, reaching for his abandoned wine mug and lifting it to them, looking long into each of their eyes as he handed them back their own cups, ‘Ben and I will leave now while the townsfolk are distracted. If any of you, through all that we have discussed, would deign to join us, we will be found a league west of town just north of the Great Road at dusk. We will not tarry long there and then our way will change. I would be honored by your company, but can afford no longer time for debate. If you should stay, you will have the hospitality of this tavern and its new innkeeper for as long you should like. This we will do as Northmen, in respect to your great efforts at saving a town that is too stubborn to know what is good for them. If you go elsewhere, I wish all the blessings of my own house on your travels and good ends to all your works. Na lû e-govaned vîn!’1
And at this he raised his mug, but the others in the room (besides Beothalion who began to but was halted by Tawarengil’s quick and harsh gaze) did not.
‘We thank you for your kindness, Ohtar,’ Alatar said, ‘but we will not drink a cup of parting. We have every intention of coming with you, for a time at least, and, I believe, all are ready to depart now.’
‘This is so,’ Tawarengil said. ‘I have unanswered questions and many reservations, but I will follow the Istari, and you, for some time as this road leads West to my own purposes.’
‘This is good, Tawarengil,’ Beothalion said, ‘for I rather like these new friends that we have found and would be happy to walk with them further. But,’ he said, looking rather pitifully at his mug of wine, ‘does this mean we should not drink now?’
‘Drink we shall!’ Collum said with excitement. ‘And joy be with you all for your offer. A more proper word of salute then and we shall be on our way; Amatúlië!’2
At this hearty blessing in the Old Tongue (which Beothalion and Benbow did not understand) all seven of those present lifted the remains of their wine and responded ‘Mae g'ovannen!’3 then drank to their newfound fellowship.
*****
Walking back into the commonroom Buttercup, hoping to put aside her anxiety with familiar industry, began again her earlier task of tidying things up. She righted the overturned stools and collected the abandoned drinking vessels on a tray for washing up later.
‘I’d do it now if there were only some fresh water,’ she thought to herself, ‘but it must wait until that crowd has lessened a bit. Collum will want the inn shut until dinner I imagine, yet I’ll want something to do if I’m to stay on my feet much longer.’
She had wiped down the tables and was beginning to sweep when Collum, dressed in an old hooded traveling cloak, entered the room.
‘Getting ready for a room full of boasters and inquirers, I see,’ he said to her with a smile.
‘Oh, I’ve had quite my full share of our neighbors and their questions for one day, sir,’ she replied, ‘I’m mostly just keeping myself ready, and awake, for whatever work’s to come next.’
‘Leave that work to others, Buttercup, for you’ll need some rest now and your wits about you for later tonight.
‘I suspect half the town will be at your door once it opens,’ he said, taking a seat at one of the tables and motioning for her to join him. ‘And by then their theories, and their rumours, will have turned into quite a tidy little mess for them to argue over.
‘That’s the biggest part of the job here, you see,’ he told her as she sat down on the stool opposite his own, ‘let them do the talking. And only invest enough of your own wit and personality, and precious little of your own opinion, as to make them keep doing so. They’re decent enough folk, your neighbors here in the Bree-land, we saw that last night as they worked bravely and tirelessly to save the town. That was indeed something to see. Don’t forget it when later you hear the things they’re likely to say about Flomi, myself or the others.’
‘After you leave,’ Buttercup said, looking him squarely in the eye. ‘You mean to say that you are leaving now and not coming back, don’t you?’
‘I do, girl. My time here in the Bree-land is done,’ he said, ‘and I will admit that I shall miss it more than I had expected. But surely you know by now that I have concerns beyond this little tavern? You’re far too sharp to have not seen that much by now.’
‘I have, sir, at least I think I have in these past few months,’ she replied. ‘Flomi and yourself have been closer than ever it seems, and then when all these strangers started coming-‘
‘Those old gentlemen that you have met,’ he interrupted, ‘as well as Benbow, the young Elf-lord and his companion, will go with me in search of Flomi. This much you can tell your neighbors tonight and I don’t doubt that they will be happy to hear it. Let them say what they will about the fire in the stables. Flomi would have a laugh at their presumptions. But you should know for yourself that he was not responsible for that, and certainly not responsible for Guldir’s murder. We, all of us, go to aid Flomi now while he is in danger.’
‘I couldn’t believe that kind of talk for a minute, sir,’ Buttercup eagerly replied. ‘Master Flomi, though stand-offish to some, was kind to everyone who knew him, and Guldir more than most. Did-‘ she hesitated here, looking around the room and lowering her voice, ‘do you think it was the thief I saw that killed poor Guldir?’
‘Perhaps,’ he said. ‘Or one like him. I believe that Guldir was slain and the stable set to blaze as a diversion. I believe that Flomi was being watched and is now being followed. I’ll remind you, there have been other strangers in the Bree-land over the past few months.’
‘Sarnside’s friends, you mean! They have been a curiosity I’d forgotten with all these new travelers about,’ she replied. ‘But what interest would they have with master Flomi?’
‘That I won’t say, if for no other reason than your safety,’ Collum answered. ‘But be wary of master Sarnside and his friends tonight, should you see them. Have a care to never be alone amongst them. Milo will be gone for the rest of the day, but I’ve set some other friends from town to help if it should be needed. My own suspicion is that Sarnside and the others have already left and so you, and our nosey little neighbours here in the Bree-land, will be quite safe for now. And the Breelanders will now, quite happily, have something to argue over for much time to come.
‘Let them talk, Buttercup. Learn to listen, not just to their stories and their grumbling, but also to their needs. Let them talk and learn to profit by it.’
‘Where will you go?’ she asked.
‘This I also will not say,’ Collum replied. ‘Once more for your safety as well as other reasons. But I was a soldier when I came here and I go to be one again.’
At this he stood up from the table and Buttercup thought that he looked taller, and grander somehow, than she had ever seen him look before. It was as if the easy-going, relaxed manners of the innkeeper had been completely washed away. Who he was now was in fact closer to how she had come to think of him in the past few months; confident, wise and capable beyond the reckoning of others. It made her glad (and proud) to see it; as if she was proven right about a thing that people around her had missed. But it made her sad also, for this more than anything made her believe that she would never see the man again.
‘But,’ he continued, as he left the table and walked to his old position behind the serving area, ‘these bothersome but well-deserving folk of the Bree-land will still need an innkeeper and,’ he said as he reached under the counter and placed his well-known cudgel on the surface between them, ‘this inn will need a Peacekeeper.
‘These I leave with you for Milo,’ he continued, taking a sealed note from his pocket and placing it alongside the weapon. ‘Big for his size perhaps, but I’ve no doubt he’ll come to handle it. Milo is a friend to be trusted, Buttercup, and you’ll learn that trusting him will bring him closer to your service. Like you, he has a talent for listening better than most, but of greater value is his talent for keeping what he hears to himself. This letter, signed and sealed, will make him the new stable-master once the place is rebuilt and also your most loyal confederate in times of need. Have him carry this little deterrent openly for a time,’ he said as he lifted the cudgel, ‘and people will know that order, of the kind I may have provided, still remains in the Bree-land.’
‘Yes, I will, sir,’ she said, ‘but with you gone and poor Guldir now dead, who shall run the inn, let alone rebuild the stables?’
‘Why, girl,’ Collum said with a grin as he took a second sealed letter from his pocket, ‘that’s to be your job, of course.’
*****
The six travelers, having left Collum behind to attend to his last bit of business in the Bree-land, now made their way quickly and quietly out of the town. Ben knew the streets quite well of course, and the Breelanders were still distracted enough by what remained of the morning’s victules and their own competing rumours so that none saw the six companions steal their way out the side door and through the maze of low buildings westward to the Hedge. Ben himself did not reckon time as the other Breefolk did, but the angle of the sun told him it was still before what they considered nine of the clock and he hoped to be clear of the town as soon as possible.
‘We’ll cut a bit north at town’s edge to keep out of sight from those closest to the western gate. The Hedge is still thin there,’ he told them, ‘high and sharp enough that a horse wouldn’t win through, but a Man, even one as big as Beothalion here, can manage it. Once we make the other side we’ll use it for a time as cover before striking west. There are a few farms to cross out that way, but I reckon those farmers close enough to have seen the fire’s smoke this morning will be in town.’
They were clad much as they had been before, though Ben had put on a long grey cloak to protect himself from the brambles he knew they’d be encountering in the Hedge. He had returned his long peaked cap to his head, pulling it low to provide shade for his keen eyes as he searched their surroundings for any witnesses. He still had his small pack with water, hunting knives and some other essentials, but much of his usual gear was now lost in the fire at the stables. He hoped that Milo had been able to secure provisions for just wherever it was Collum meant them to travel. But his bow was back at his side and he had a quiver full of good arrows. He’d gone into much wilder lands before and been just fine carrying much less.
Beothalion and Tawarengil had little more than the clothes on their backs. The big man carried a large water skin, a small waist pouch, his quarterstaff and nothing else; no sign of food, or bedroll or change of clothing could be seen among them. Ben might not have found that peculiar in Tawarengil’s case, for Elves (at least as he had seen) enjoyed but did not need such comforts. Yet Ben had never known a Man to travel in the open with so little as this big wanderer had clearly done. And for them to have come all the way over the Misty Mountains in this way seemed all the more incredible.
The elf-lord’s own gear Ben took notice of as well. The leather of his doublet and boots was brown-grey and supple, a hide or a curing process Ben was unfamiliar with had made them light as cloth though he was certain they were much much tougher. On his belt, a simple but bright white sash bound by a wooden clasp, hung two knives in leather scabbards. They were small to suit his stature, but Ben did not doubt that they were keen and that the young lording could be quite deadly with them. The fire and the flight into danger this morning had made him all the more curious about Tawarengil’s actual age. Now as in the stables he looked less like a boy and all the more like a warrior of some experience.
The most curious part of the elf-lord’s gear however, came as quite a surprise. From among Beothalion’s other gear he lifted a long wooden shaft, nearly as tall as Ben himself, and on a cord of some kind he wore it on his back. At first glance Ben thought it might be a bow and was glad to have another bowman in the group. But as Tawarengil turned to address the others Ben could see it was no bow at all but a great wooden training sword much too big for anyone of his stature.
‘What he’ll want with a thing like that is beyond me,’ Ben thought to himself, ‘but Elves have strange customs of course, and I doubt he’d like to hear me ask of it.’
The Istari (or so Ben began to call them, having heard it so often from the Elf-lord and thinking it a much more respectful word than wassird) also seemed to be comfortable on foot and with little need of provision. Olórin, the more talkative of the group, carried a rather tall staff, and a large well-worn knapsack of a tough-looking and grey-colored thick hide that Benbow had also never seen before. He wore the same dark grey traveling clothes as he had earlier, and a wide-brimmed, tall-pointed felt hat that shielded his eyes just as Benbow’s own did. His leather boots were high and showed the scars from long years of walking rough lands, leaving the hobbit to wonder at the age and contrasting hardiness of these grey-haired and wizened folk.
Alatar, who very much seemed to be the leader of the three odd gentlemen, had no other baggage than he did when Benbow first saw him the night before in the commonroom. No waterskin nor kitbag, no cap nor outer cloak. He held a short rod in his hand that Ben had not seen before; smooth and white with blunted ends, it looked as if it had been carved from some great horn, milky white, curling like a great braid.
The third wanderer, whose name Ben thought was ‘Pallandin’ or something like, had put on a large, dark grey traveling cloak that concealed his deep blue robes. He had produced it from the leather shoulder bag he carried and, at his hip, he now carried a longsword in a finely-tooled leather sheath. Where this weapon had come from Ben could not rightly say but, old as this wassird looked, it was comforting to have another armed companion with him on such a curious adventure as the one they were now beginning.
In the earliest days of the Bree-land, at the laying of Tharangond which was the crossing of the two roads, the surrounding countryside had been fertile but wild. The Kings had come out of the sea and built or fortified their great cities to the north and to the west, but here, around Bree-hill, the descendants of the First Men then still roamed freely through a great wood which filled the valley on either side of the Old Road. There was peace, if not full trust, between these two peoples at this time and, for many a year before the Great War in the South, much commerce. As traffic moved safely across the roads in the early days of the North Kingdom the valley was cleared for farmlands and the Bree-land became a center for trade. It was in this time, although the Breelanders had certainly forgotten it, that the Sea-kings had set the Clock into its short tower so that all travelers might see it from the Crossroads and know that here was a place of the King’s watch and the home of a peaceful and industrious folk.
But as the Bree-land grew and the Sea-kings diminished, as dark things roamed the lands to the North and to the East, and then particularly since the coming of the Little People like Tom Truetunnels’ own industrious grandsires, the town, recognizing no real lord or king, quartering no armies nor standing any organized militia, found that it had no real protection from the increasingly dangerous countryside. Many citizens at this time had proposed the building of a surrounding wall to ensure their safety. But, having no government and therefore (thankfully, to many a Breelander’s thinking) no taxes with which to begin such an enterprise, a wall was an expense quite beyond the scope of their agreements. The Hedge then became the best solution the simple farmfolk of the Bree-land had been able to manage and they began building it with tremendous seriousness.
A great furrow had been dug along the perimeter of the town and all of the surrounding farmers participated in a great planting and long tending of bramble bushes; the first real public work of these independent people. A rather surprisingly sophisticated system of irrigation (introduced by those same industrious Little Folk who gave the Truetunnels their family name) was then created and the Breelanders, who usually disagreed on much, all took an uncommon pride in their shared duty for the building and maintenance of this barrier. Now, many centuries since its planting, the Hedge, while by no means as formidable or as easily defended as a wall, was indeed the small town’s only outer defense and one of which they were the most proud.
As Benbow had described, the Hedge that the party now approached was as high as a man was tall and about ten or more paces (if regular paces could be made through it) in its depth. The thicket of bramble-thorns and dark foliage was an obstacle to any large assault from across the open farmlands, but was not impossible for earnest and experienced travelers (or particularly nimble-footed hobbits) to pass. As the party came to it they could see that the thicket was closer and more tangled than it had appeared from a distance. There were no paths visible in the undergrowth, and they found it encircled by a stream running down from the hills in a deeply dug bed with steep slippery sides overhung by brambles.4 One could not jump over the stream, nor indeed get across it at all without getting wet, scratched and muddy.
‘A rather fine parting courtesy from these townsfolk for all our service,’ said Tawarengil. ‘Is it meant to keep their enemies at bay or their guests and neighbors from leaving?’
‘In springtime the stream runs a bit faster,’ replied Benbow, ‘but it is not much deeper than my own knees are tall. It feeds the Hedge through the summer months and the water here is cool and clean.’
‘It is, little Benbow,’ Beothalion said, as he bent to take a long drink from the clear waters. ‘It is quite refreshing!’
‘I’m not sure what Collum has in mind for our travels, nor what provisions his Milo might have found sufficient to all of us,’ Ben said to the others. ‘So I suggest you fill your waterskins here. We’ll be in open lands in a few hours, and the day looks to be quite warm.’
The others took this advice and, indeed, Beothalion had already begun to do so. When the wildman’s great vessel was but a quarter filled, he handed it, in a most perfunctory manner, to Tawarengil who took a long satisfying draught and handed it back to be refilled. The Elf then turned his face up at the early morning sun and closed his eyes, looking quite refreshed.
‘Have you no drinking skin yourself, my lord?’ Benbow asked. ‘Or, perhaps, no need for one?’
‘Oh, he will drink, little Benbow,’ Beothalion replied with a hearty chuckle as he continued filling his water bag, ‘though he does not like to admit to needing it. He will drink from mine when the rare need is on him, and he is well pleased that I am strong enough to carry water for two.’
‘And thirsty enough to drink it for four,’ the young Elf-lord replied with a smile. ‘But it is true, Master Floxleaf, that my people of the Greatwood need little of such sustenance when we walk in the open lands under Sun and Stars and amid things green and growing. We do take delight in clear drink and hearty foods, of course. I do not know how it is with those you have met in the House of Elrond, but my people reserve feasting for our halls and allow calavénë, eleni and laicolassë5 to bring us strength during our travels.’
‘We hear that Sun and Stars grow dim in the South of Eyrn Galen these days, my lord,’ said Alatar, ‘and one of my brethren did accordingly set his watch upon the land there.’
‘This is true, lord,’ the Elf replied. ‘Radagast he is called among us, though we did not give him that name nor know its meaning.’
‘That name is old,’ Olórin said. ‘The First Men gave it to him long ago before they met the Elves and their language from that time is lost in these and all other lands. Perhaps he alone in the world still recalls it. But he remembers those First Men fondly. He uses that name again, I believe, in their honor, for he loved them more than any other folk on two legs in the Elder Days. But we three have not heard from him in many long years and are glad to hear he remains at his vigil.’ At this the grey wizard looked long at his companions as if in some assurance of a past discussion.
‘Radagast does not come to Authengroth,’6 Tawarengil replied, ‘or has not in my young lifetime, but many of my folk have met him in the Greatwood or at his home in Rhosgobel in the western eaves. He has a queer manner, some say. More apt to speak the languages of birds than the Ancient Speech in polite company, and more apt to screech warnings than to give judicious advice, say others. Thranduil accords him great honor, as he is certainly due, but asks from him no consul. This makes many of my folk sad as the Greatwood grows dark. We do not doubt his wisdom, but we do not understand his mind and are therefore wary of his assessments. We should welcome sage advice as the Wood grows dark but, alas, where shall it be found?’
‘Does Elrond offer no opinion on these matters?’ Alatar asked. ‘Or have relations become cold between your two houses?’
‘I do not know, lord,’ the young elf replied. ‘For while Thranduil is my uncle I am still counted as too young to be in his councils and know nothing more of Rivendell than is told in our songs. But few of my people ride forth from the Greatwood since the Last Alliance and fewer still of other houses come to speak with us.’
‘Surprising, then,’ suggested Olórin, as he looked westward through the Hedge, ‘that Thranduil should send forth a force now against a foe so far from his own borders.’
At this Tawarengil had no response. But after a moment’s pause, the old man continued speaking.
‘But the call of Círdan the Shipwright is, of course, no small urgency and I’m sure the lord of Authengroth knows this,’ the wizard said. ‘Hopefully many more of the Eldar will feel as you do, my lord, and answer it.
‘Now, Master Floxleaf,’ he said, smiling as he changed the conversation abruptly, ‘I believe we should be on our way.’
*****
An hour or two ahead of the company an impatient Milo Fastknots had made his way out past the Hedge-gate and onto the Dwarf Road. The small farmlands and rolling hills that surrounded the village of the Bree-land on its western side were quiet in the early morning light. A few stray Breelanders encountered him as they were coming toward the town, but of course they were more interested in news of the smoke than to have any suspicions of Milo and his master’s horse leaving the fire behind them. Those that Milo had met he sent quickly into town with the barest of information as he himself went steadily in the other direction. If people asked him only a few questions it was because Milo had acquired a reputation for giving very little in the way of answers and, in this case, that reputation served him well. During this whole time Benbow’s pony had lingered twenty to forty paces behind, keeping Milo and Caitelyn in sight, but refusing to be seen in their company.
Having passed the Hedge-gate, the Big Hill (itself called “Bree”) that defined the area sat at the north-east corner of the two Roads’ crossing and now lay behind him. Along the hill’s southern and eastern faces, opposite Milo’s path and to the other side of the town, the most populated parts of the Bree-land had developed; Staddle, the Combe, and Archet. There beside the Hill and bordering the Chetwood, Breelanders kept a watchful eye to the north yet lived still in great peace. West of the Hedge, as Flomi had noted in his travels some days before, the farms were fewer and the series of low running hills to the west of the Crossing were growing more wooded. There was a line of trees that indicated the North-south Road and Milo could see them clearly just half a mile ahead as he left the haze of the village.
‘That pony friend of yours is sticking with us still,’ he told Caitelyn, his master’s great grey mare that he led, ‘though she wants nothing to do with me. She must be half-smart, spending so much time with Benbow as she does, and a good judge of company.
‘Well, come along then,’ he said, half turning back to speak to the pony. ‘Your master wants you just like ours does, and it won’t do to keep either of them waiting for a time when you and I might become friends.’ He quickened the pace a bit then, partly out of a hope to speed the pony along and partly out of a desire to keep himself awake.
‘There’s much yet to do,’ he thought to himself, ‘before there’s to be any rest. I’m to meet Master Collum and Ben a league from here, and that much is easy. Providing for them both is another matter. Probably I might borrow some light stores from old Master Peoninny’s place up the Road there. He’s friendly enough to my master and won’t ask much in the way of questions.’
‘But a saddle for you,’ he said aloud, returning to his conversation with Collum’s horse, ‘now that will take some doing.’
Most hobbits, it should be known, were not quite comfortable even on the backs of small ponies and seldom would they ride for long distances. Some of those Shirefolk Milo had seen were known to come back into the Bree-land with ponies from time to time, and rumour told that they traveled quite some distance that way along the Dwarf Road. But like most of the Little Folk, they used their ponies mostly for provisions and only occasionally had Milo heard of them riding up into the town. Maybe they rode in saddles all the time out there past the Brown River. Shirefolk, it was said, had queer ways and Milo knew nothing about them and their behavior in their own lands. Milo had his own pony of course, and he was big enough to ride her at need whenever she was kind enough to allow it. But he had no saddle for her as a saddle for a pony seemed a right uncommon thing to own.
Ben was the only hobbit who Milo had known to ride in the saddle and this made him, and his pony, all the more unusual to the Breelanders. Saddles were not for ponies, as they saw it. Saddles were for horses and horses were for the Big Folk like his master. The problem was that not many of the Big Folk lived west of the town and Milo had not believed that setting out in any other direction would be possible, not if Ben’s irritable beast was expected to follow. So he decided to leave with the greatest haste and in the direction of least notice, taking his chance west along the Dwarf Road.
On this more direct path Milo knew of only one horse’s saddle between here and the Shire. For just past the North-South Road lived Motho Greenhands and, as Motho was happy to tell any who might listen, he was a rare hobbit to own a horse. And that horse had a saddle.
‘Any farmer worth his crop might own a pony,’ Motho would say to any neighbor who would listen, ‘And my own ponies are friendly souls that I’d never part with for nothing. But a horse, a good horse and one who knows who is his master, mind you, a horse like that is worth three or four ponies to a hard-working farmer.’
Now in the opinion of most Breelanders Motho was only barely a farmer, hard-working or otherwise, and his name, Greenhands, was the subject of some fairly unkind jests. For he had changed the family name recently, as many of the Little Folk did when they came into the Bree-land, and no doubt he saw this new one as an improvement in regard to his reputation as a well-to-do farmer. But his old name was known to be Brownbottom, so ‘old Bottom-to- Hand’ was what some of the townsfolk called him in their own talk. Seldom within his own hearing of course, for Motho Greenhands, odd in manner and eccentric in tastes though he may be, commanded that certain respect and snide disapproval that all people of a small town seemed to have for the wealthiest among them.
As to his farming abilities, Motho had a good sized field not a quarter mile west of the Crossing where he grew mushrooms almost exclusively. Mushrooms were always in great demand amongst the Little Folk of the Bree-land, but Motho had somehow wisely cornered the market with a relatively small plot of land here west of the Hedge as the crop did not grow nearly so well upon the eastern slope of the Hill. Others had tried of course, but Motho had bought or developed a very unique process for handling the crop and, if it had lasted much past his own life, this would’ve been a marvel to other farmers for many years to come.
Mushrooms grow in cool, dark places of course, requiring little maintenance and, if conditions are right, yield three to four good crops in a year. They’re often planted to grow wild alongside large groves of fruit trees; a kind of extra bounty of the deep shade in an orchard of apples or pears popular in the east of the Bree-land. When Motho purchased the land of his farm he did not invest in any other crop but mushrooms. He built (or, more precisely, had built for him) two long sheds made of stone and mortar, forty paces from end to end and not much taller inside than some of the taller men among the Breefolk. The building had unique coverings of living earth and grass, like tunnels that had been raised up out of the ground and then covered again for protection from the sun. Alongside the eastern edge of each of these buildings, or ‘vaults’ as he called them, large shade trees remained so that structures remained both hidden and cool throughout the day. Inside of each building there were three shelves filled with soil, of a ‘special blend’ Motho told all the other Breelanders, and this provided the excellent conditions of temperature and darkness that made his crop into a wealthy industry even in such a small town as the Bree-land.7
Just how Motho Greenhands, in his former days as Motho Brownbottom, had come upon such advanced and progressive farming techniques is still unknown. He had been known to talk with many travelers and merchants in his younger days, but had no true friends within the town who could recount his earlier experience through anything other than gossip. With his closeness to town, he did not need to tend to the farming much himself but trusted local hands while he himself spent more of his time in a mushroom specialty shop not far from the Four Greenfields. With the other shop owners and townsfolk there as his constant clients he had become one of the wealthiest of Breelanders; and this certainly had gone a long way toward why so many seemed to dislike or to gossip about him. For in the Bree-land too much success was usually a cause for suspicion, and the price for Motho’s mushrooms still ran a bit high for anyone’s sense of fairness.
The story of how Motho, a collector of many odd things from foreign parts, came into the ownership of a horse and saddle was also a bit unclear. There were many tales (mostly told by old Tom Truetunnels) which floated around the Four Greenfields of Motho meeting with foreigners and dwarves and other outliers whenever they came to town; of helmets and swords, scrolls and spices and other surprising things which he had purchased that no other Breelander could see any practical use for. ‘Oh, he loves the stories of those old warrior folk,’ Tom had been heard to say, ‘but what a mushroom vendor like Bottom-to-Hand needs of a tall and shiny helmet I can’t imagine. Maybe he dresses in high boots with stirrups and cuts those mushrooms with a sword in those long dark halls of his. Maybe he’s built a ladder, block and tackle to put him on that horse he brags so much about.’
One version of the horse’s origin was that it had belonged to one of the Big Folk in Archet, another competing mushroom farmer, who had lost the beast somehow in an outstanding debt. Maybe he was a failed business rival, some said. Or maybe, said others, he was some mushroom thief Motho had caught and sent running, wearing his helmet and hauberk, brandishing his frightful (but, in terms of the story, quite hilarious) sword. This much more heroic version was one Motho himself liked to suggest but never would attest to. ‘I’ve a very great horse, a warrior’s horse if there was one,’ he would say, ‘and I have taken him fairly,’ he would finish mysteriously.
Milo, however, doubted that any hobbit as short and overweight as old Bottom-to-Hand might be sending any of the Big Folk running and keeping the horse he rode in on for his own. That much seemed much less than true and much more about him building a big story.
Either way Milo had seen the horse led into town last harvest with a huge wagon coming behind him. He was a great red-colored fellow, a horse leading a wagon way too large for carting mushrooms. Since that day he’d heard Motho talking about this horse most every chance he got on nights at the Four Greenfields. Whether the farmer hoped to sell the horse or whether he was simply bragging about his ownership of it, Milo did not know. Perhaps the rumours of the horse’s origins just added to the price of mushrooms.
But none of that mattered to Milo now as he walked west down the Dwarf Road and considered how he might get the things that his master required.
For his own part Milo had no real opinion about Motho Greenhand and, if pressed on the matter, he did not really care much for mushrooms nor was he willing to dislike a merchant simply for his prices or personal eccentricities. His thoughts were much more direct and much more simple; his master needed a saddle (two, if another could be found for Ben’s unsociable pony) and the mushroom farm of Motho ‘Bottom-to-Hand’ presented the young hobbit with his first (and possibly only) chance to procure it quickly.
*****
The six travelers, one at a time and with Benbow going first, made their way across the stream and through the Hedge. Any clever path that the hobbit may have discovered through his small size and great agility was of little use to the others as Beothalion, coming second, simply lumbered through the thicket behind him breaking branch and limb and cursing each scrape. The others followed, each at their own pace, with Tawarengil bringing up the rear in his own relaxed manner.
‘Well, brother,’ he said to Beothalion with a smile, ‘you have quite made a mess of these poor folks’ outer fences. I might’ve ridden a good size pony through this hole you have put in their fortifications.’
There was, as Ben could see, very clear evidence of their passing for any curious eye to notice. ‘Well, I don’t believe there’s so much worry from that, my lord,’ Ben told the Elf. ‘The Breelanders won’t have any reason to follow us and are likely to be glad we’ve left them. Certainly that Hedge will mend itself fast enough in springtime so that this path we’ve cut will be no more than a good story for the Bree-folk by fall. But I would caution you all,’ he said, looking about at the others and trying to affect a tone of command, ‘to show some better care as we travel. I’ve no idea where it is Collum means for us to go, but I know him well enough to not doubt him that danger is involved.
‘And I should further remind you all that we’ve no idea what happened to that fellow Beothalion and I chased after’, he said looking at the wildman. ‘Likely it was he or one his comrades that cut the poor stable-master’s throat for little reason and he or they seem to have some purpose in all this trouble. I should not like to make our presence known to such murderous folk as we move into the open lands ahead.’
‘Wise consul, master Hobbit,’ said Olórin. ‘I believe we should all do well to follow your lead for a time.’
And so Benbow led them across the open farmlands and pastures surrounding the western edge of the Bree-land. It was still the early spring, so they were able to cut a mostly straight line through the small fields and low rolling hills. They walked along in silence and Ben found himself rather pleasantly surprised by just how quiet they all, most unexpectedly and especially the Wildman, could be. The trees here became sparse and the first thing that came to the travelers eyes as the ground began to level was the North-South Road.
From their vantage point, just a mile or so north of the crossing and still raised as they were by the Hill’s gradual slope, the “Fornost Road”, as the Breelanders called it, was a wonder to behold.
‘Tawar,’ Beothalion said in a quiet voice as they all stood for a moment in clear view of the opening lands before them, ‘what is that?’
‘It is the work of Men, brother,’ the young Elf answered, his own voice lowered with an uncharacteristic awe, ‘and I must confess that I have never seen its like.’
Benbow had seen it many times before of course, but he could still appreciate their wonder.
Here, in this part of the North, the landscape was not level as in some plains of the South of which Ben had heard. The land before them ran as far as the eye might see in low and undulating hill country. To the far west, and moreso away toward the north, the hills continued and some tips of mountain peaks were seen, the Emyn Muil, rising behind the distant hills and catching the light of the morning sun. Ben had not been to those mountains, for at this time in his life he had never gone west of the Brown River, but he knew those mountains were great and, so rumour told him, at the very edge of the world. To the north and away east he knew the land much better, and even now, behind Bree Hill, the Weather Hills and even the nearest faces of the Hithaeglir were familiar to his experience and from the stories of his fathers; for the Floxleafs had hunted and trapped for many generations in this rolling countryside below the snowy lands between the western river and the eastern mountains.
Ben had never gone south of the old Dwarf Road much, for the South Downs were said to be haunted and the forests of the lands there had been stripped and made bare long before the formation of the North Kingdom. Strange tales came up the Road from that direction in older days, but now, in Benbow’s time and on that spring morning, a haze lay beyond those furthest hills and the land there stretched forth into an unfathomable mystery. Looking there he wondered at something Olórin had suggested earlier; had Collum really come to the Bree-land out of the South? What stories had he to tell of lands there which Ben had only half-imagined?
Against all this massive and open country, here, in this part of the North that Benbow Floxleaf knew very well, the Fornost Road, untended as it was for many long years, ran straight as a pikestaff for as far as keen eyes could see, never yielding to nor interrupting the landscape which surrounded it. And nothing in the natural shape of the world could quite compare with the experience of its vast orderliness.
‘I do not understand it. Did the hills themselves obey these Men?’ Beothalion asked. ‘Do hills rise or fall for this thing, or is it perhaps older and deeper even than they are?’
‘Old to some eyes it may be, Beothalion, and I am glad to be here and see the wonder of it touch your young heart,’ said one of the Istari. This was the third and most silent of the group and Benbow, who was yet unsure of this quieter wassird’s name, was surprised by his sudden speaking and the soft frankness in his voice. There was a light, even a kind of sadness or joy, in the old man’s deep green-grey eyes as he looked at Beothalion which Ben had not yet seen in the others; as if he had somehow been kindled to the wildman by his wonderment.
‘And old it may seem,’ he continued, ‘but as brief as a bud in the flowering of these lands which surround it. For here you look upon one of the last great works of the Dúnedain that was laid in an earlier age of the world, in this their time of Redemption, but yet the hills make little notice of things which are so fleeting.
‘Great in learning were your People when they came up out of the Sea and, as the innkeeper has recounted, a great love of the land was in their hearts. They brought with them much of the wisdom and wonder that was to be found in the high tide of their realm, of which much is forgotten,8 and with these lost arts they could read many designs of the order of the world.’
‘My People?’ the wildman said with even greater surprise in his voice. ‘This cannot be so...’
‘I have walked this road many times in my days here,’ Olórin said, ‘and it stretches many more hundreds of miles than your own trip here from the Carrock, Beothalion. And for all that walking still I marvel at its scope. To build such a marvel and to so readily abandon it is a thing I cannot yet understand...’ And at this his voice trailed off as if he was lost in some deeper thought than he had meant to speak but chose to wait on.
‘And so it is with the works of Men,’ said Tawarengil. ‘And the Elves understand it no better.’
‘We’ll not be traveling by the Road,’ Ben told the others, ‘at least not unless Collum has some plan I can’t guess at, and its way north to Fornost is dangerous these days. But we’ll cross it straight on and then meet our friends about a league or so on the other side. Come, but have a care for noise as we approach the Road and keep a sharp eye for travelers!’
*****
Collum’s own way out of town was faster, if more clandestine, than that of his companions. He concluded his business with Buttercup as quickly as possible, leaving her to her astonishment and worry, as he departed through the same rear door of the common room that Flomi had used on the previous night.
‘Far too hastily,’ he thought. ‘I have watched her for many years and hoped to leave her ready for much. But we leave too hastily. I would, given time, have given her more.’
Buttercup would, he hoped, be fine with the two letters under his seal. ‘She and her kin will now own that wretched little inn for generations to come and, through her kindness and care, her neighbors might yet be happy despite the wars that would go on around them.’ He would have prepared her better, if he could, but his service here was not to the inn nor Buttercup nor the townsfolk. His service was to his Princess and to the task she had set him.
‘But the girl is strong in her quiet way. Stronger than most and perhaps she will find her better qualities without my guidance.’ He left hoping for Buttercup’s success, hoping for the continued safety of the whole silly little town of the Bree-land, but he left them all the same.
The haze was still fairly thick in the alleyway behind the inn from the fire’s smoke, and Collum went west out the door, away from the wreck of the stables and toward the Hedge-gate. Under a small cluster of overturned crates at this alley’s end he had hidden his pack and his longsword many hours earlier, when he had then hoped to use the fire as a distraction for his departure. Now he recovered them quickly and strapped the pack fairly low in front of him and the sword down the center of his back where it would not draw undue attention. He then threw his travel-worn cloak over the pack, the sword and himself, covering his head with the hood, stooping a bit and turning one shoulder higher than the other. He also took two of the largest crates from the pile and tied them to a makeshift yoke which he might carry across his broad but now slanted shoulders. Walking from the alley in this way he looked much like any of the other Big Folk who lived among the Breelanders carrying supplies home from town; his frame appearing to be a little bent by labor and his middle seeming a little thicker from long nights of peace spent among friendly neighbors.
In this manner he moved steadily, though not too quickly, toward the Hedge-gate, his eyes on the ground and his body exaggerating the weight of his burden so that no one would see his face. He would be seen by many but, as he had come to manage in his past dozen years of service, recognized by very few. Now his mind was burdened with what steps to take next.
‘I had not reckoned for such a large party to join me,’ Collum thought, ‘But how can I refuse such noble assistance? Is it even within my power to decide? More than chance seems to have put three wizards on my doorstep for the day of our departure. Still, I must not let their questions slow me.’
The grey wizard, Olórin, had surely guessed much from Collum’s talk earlier. He had also shown a certain closeness about his observations that made any further questioning easier for just now. But surely the others would begin to make these deeper inquiries about his mission; the young Elf-lord most of all. “How then shall I face such questions,’ he wondered. ‘My oath is clear, but they’re assistance may be vital. Shall our task then be finally revealed?’
He came to the Hedge-gate quickly enough and the few people he saw on the Road were intent on the smoke and still hovering around the town and their own conversations. A dark-haired woman stood there beside the Gate watching him, her clothes darkened by soot and her hair disheveled from a long night of fire-fighting. Collum, who was also Ohtar, knew her well but in his secrecy their eyes could not meet. He would think of this parting for many days on his own road ahead.
Soon, not ten minute from the gate, the Old Road curved right towards the north and he left it. He abandoned his yolk and his disguise in the first group of trees that provided him with cover. Putting the yoke down, he removed his cloak and his pack. At his feet there was a small reddish stone and he lifted it, but found nothing there. He drew the third of his morning’s letters from his pocket, folded it carefully and, drawing a small ring of bone from another pocket, placed them both beneath the stone. He then took the longsword from his back and righteously, for the first time in many years, buckled it gladly to the familiar spot on his left hip. He was now prepared for the road ahead and had given over the duty of his service for those behind him. He swung the pack over one shoulder and replaced his cloak, now with his hood pulled back that he might look long at the western lands which finally lay before him and his mission. Then, uncharacteristically, he spoke aloud when no one was there to hear him:
‘West now to serve. The innkeeper is gone and I am once again openly the son of my Fathers in the service of our line. ‘Voronwë siluva ep’ eleni’.9 At this he smiled, and went quickly, quietly into the wild lands west of the Hedge-gate to meet his comrades. If he ever looked back with longing for friends at the Hedge-gate this tale does not tell.
*****
Earlier in the night the stars were bright and the moon was high still behind him to light the way. There were bird sounds, or Flomi thought them birds at the time, but otherwise it was quiet and his way was easier. On both sides of Flomi the woods pressed on, thicker and growing denser as he had noted before; but northward he knew that the ground fell steeply and the tops of the dark trees, growing at the bottom of the slope, were from this vantage quite well below his feet. Beyond them, north, the lowlands of old Arnor lay dim and flat under the dawn and there, perhaps thirty leagues from where he now walked, lay the conquered city of Fornost Erain. Did the Witch-king himself now sit in the darkened halls of that mighty fortress, so perilously close? The dwarf quickened his pace at the very thought of it.
‘Guldir was certain that this rider was from the Enemy, Flomi,’ Collum had said just a week before, ‘and I trust his appraisal. He does not speak lightly of such things.’
Thinking of it now, Flomi felt foolish and, subsequently, angry. Many things were becoming much more clear to him on this journey through the night’s darkness. How had so many generations of his family’s toil come to this? How had he not heard Collum mention ‘the Enemy’ and not known the dire implications of his labours?
Twelve years ago, when there had been a burglary and Collum had come to town to serve as his new companion, Flomi had been excited; for the idea that burglars had come to take an interest in his work was a certain, albeit dubious, measure of his success. All dwarves hated burglars of course, but the rumour of wealth that good burglars have such an uncanny nose for was, to a young dwarf like Flomi, some assurance that his long and chiefly silent works were not made in vain. How someone had come to know of his research was frightening certainly, but that some burglar thought it worth investigating was (in the very least of Flomi’s estimation) reassuring and (if pressured to speak of his more fanciful assessment of the situation then) more than a bit exhilarating.
But the man who rode into the Bree-land on that stormy day in Rethe10 was no burglar. And if Collum’s suspicions were correct, then Flomi (and his sires) had become involved with Collum and his predecessors in something much more dangerous than he had previously believed; much more dangerous than treasure-hunting. Every dwarf, of course, knew the folly of Men; for Men were always aggressors, without learning the lessons of their own history. They were always engaged with the Darker forces of the Enemy. So often in fact that they believed their own better nature might only be evidenced in this ongoing struggle. Durin’s Folk (or so Flomi believed, though he had long been away from his own People) did not live in this way; they carved and they forged and they sung deep songs of pride for the work of their own hands and for the depth of their own voice and the glory they felt in their own connection to Middle-earth. Their honor, and it was a great part of their lives, was not formed out of some ancient battle within themselves to do right, as Men seemed so taken by, but out of a call to make greater works with the Gifts they had been given. Men were not like Dwarves, certainly. The Doom of Men in Flomi’s day was not, to his dwarvish mind, arrogance (as it had been said in ages past) but trial; for they chased not life nor art but only to measure their honor against the Enemy, and they let this chase define them.
Collum Gilleyfoil was the tallest, strongest Man that Flomi had ever known. He had a warrior’s bearing that made the dwarf feel safe from the moment he arrived at the Bree-land and an assurity in his nature that made him feel protected and at ease. In twelve years they had become friends, Man and Dwarf, and of that bond at least Flomi felt certain; Collum was a good man who gave him fair appraisal of their need for secrecy in their shared endeavor. But now, walking along the pathway to the Foundations and thinking back at his time in the small town, Flomi knew that Collum Gilleyfoil was not a man one sent to watch over a simple charge and he was certainly not a treasure-hunter. Collum was the kind of Man one sent to watch against the Enemy, and his coming, even as long as twelve years past, meant that the Enemy, not some simple burglar, knew of Flomi’s work.
And now, walking alone towards a fate that seemed suddenly much more dangerous, Flomi’s mind turned back to that day when a Black Rider came to the Bree-land.
*****
Ben’s eyes were sharp, but Tawarengil’s were much sharper.
‘A Man moves west ahead of us,’ he said as they both crested a low hill, ‘he has paused just past the Crossing. He is looking about, but also keeping to cover. I believe it is our innkeeper companion, yet the manner of his walking is much changed.’
Ben did not see him first and, despite his previous experience with Elves, this fact bothered him more than a little. Just a few hours into their journey and Ben already felt as if it was his responsibility to guide everyone and to read all the information on their road ahead.
‘I’d agree, my lord, and believe that it is indeed Collum away there,’ he said. ‘He may wait for us in a place near to the Road, for his knowledge of these lands west of Hedge-gate I can’t speak to.’
‘Your friend's knowledge of these lands is far greater than he lets on, Master Floxleaf,’ said the grey wizard. ‘If he waits it is because he is doubtful of our own. And Tawarengil is correct; he moves to find cover, I believe, and to suggest a spot for our company to meet.’
‘Yes,’ Tawarengil replied. ‘This seems so. He makes for a small cluster of young trees there below us, but out of view from the Road. Admirable woodcraft for an innkeeper, I would say.’
‘More than I’d have credited him for,’ Ben said, happy to be getting on with things. ‘But good. Maybe now, away from the ears of snooping Breelanders, we’ll get some answers.’
*****
The sleet and hail had poured against the windows of the commonroom on that afternoon six weeks ago in Flomi’s memory. He had just completed his usual large dinner menu as a well-looked-for and robust lunch; a bowl of the Greenfields’ famous fish chowder, a small salad (something that the other Breelanders found most peculiar for any patron, let alone a Dwarf, to order) and a great large pasty that he had taught the cook to make, stuffed with rich and earthy seasonal vegetables and spices quite unknown to the Men of this area. Had this been any other day and the weather more seasonable, he would have only returned from the stoneyard by late in the afternoon and, waiting to settle some few and local accounts that might help disguise his other greater purpose, only then would he be able to settle into this familiar and much-anticipated meal shortly before dusk. But with the weather so harsh on this early spring morning, Flomi had foregone his usual ride to the yard, indulged himself by sleeping unto a surprisingly late hour past the dawn, and treated himself to some drawing time before coming downstairs just shortly after noon.
Drawing is not, in the way we might think of such things, a habit nor a hobby for the Dwarves. Some folk and historians there are in the greater world, presupposing as they do to understand dwarves and their culture through the works that they have seen and traded or that now survive even to this day would, undoubtedly, be quite surprised to learn this fact. But drawing, which is to say the representation of scenes, designs or characters onto a two- dimensional surface, is not to a dwarf as it is to others; an acceptable handcraft useful for communication or trade or pleasure. Instead, to any dwarf and most particularly to one like Flomi, it is a great and private (and, to the outside world, wholly secret) passion.
The great Dwarven sculptors and architects knew the skill well of course, as their works, which have long outlived their People, certainly reveal to this day. But no drawings have ever been found, no plans, no prototypes nor models of their works have ever been known to exist so that the now popular opinion (if one can indeed settle upon such a thing as a “popular opinion” regarding the Dwarves) is that they fashioned their great works almost entirely by instinct and intuition; one brilliant hammer-stroke leading to another so that they formed halls the size of modern cities, statuary the size of hillsides, mechanisms of so intricate a nature and armor of so many varied and articulated pieces less out of plan than out of their natural kinship with stone and metal. But how can this be so?
Many fine tools and ornaments the Dwarves have also left us, and with them many reasons to suggest the cunning of design that we might, for any other of the known races, believe had come from years of drawing experience. Complex locks and devices, ornate structures of weaving and of machinery, of war devices and of delicate tools, the working of gears and the marvels of combustion that seemed incredible to other people of their time, and indeed to us today, should seem impossible to create and to pass down to others without plan, diagram or illustration.
Yet no drawings by Dwarves survive and no record (yet to be found) speaks of them. If the Dwarves did draw, as anyone would surmise from their other arts that they must have, then they left none of it for other people to see.
There are no paintings that survive the Dwarves either and no mention of that art in their histories. There are sculptures of course, and many in relief which evidence a great understanding for depicting three-dimensional space on a shallow plane. These lead us to believe that the dwarves had an aptitude for drawing that may have even exceeded that of the Elves, who we know regard the skill very highly. How is it possible then, that no dwarven drawings were ever seen?
The answer is quite simple; dwarves do not regard drawings as exceptional because all dwarves, from a very early age, draw exceptionally well. And dwarves do not ever reveal their drawings to others because, as in so many things, dwarves are exceptionally private.
So, with that solitary and very gratifying part of his morning complete and the heavy ballast of a good meal inside him, Flomi happily settled into his regular study many hours earlier than usual. With Collum still away gathering new material, the extra time, or so Flomi hoped, would prove useful; for many of the latest passages which he had received had proven incomprehensible when compared to earlier breakthroughs and Flomi had begun to doubt some of his own work in the translations.
The commonroom was quite pleasantly empty of nosey townsfolk so early in the afternoon as the fierceness of the storm seemed to keep even the hungriest and most inquisitive of these Breelanders shuttered up in their own homes. Buttercup, the serving girl, usually happy to talk to any strangers who happened to find their way into the Four Greenfields, seemed quite startled to see him walk into the open and empty room.
‘Well, hello and good day to you, Master Flomi,’ she said, ‘I did not know that you were here with us. Kept in by this blustery weather, I should think.’
‘I am no more bothered by a sudden storm than any other of my race,’ he replied with a smile, ‘but my gentle pack animals and, indeed it seems, my neighbours and your customers, certainly are. So I thought I should give us all a comfortable and unexpected day indoors. Is your master still away?’
‘He is, sir,’ she said, looking cautiously about and lowering her voice just a bit, ‘and I shouldn’t expect him soon. For I suspect it's only desperate and dark folk who travel the roads today.’
‘Well, then, leave them to sort their own ways and let us keep ours,’ Flomi said, smiling all the more broadly. ‘I shall be very glad for the quiet of this room, the coziness of its fire, and a chance to read. In fact, the only thing that might make me gladder is a tankard of your hearty red wine.’
The girl smiled back and went to fetch a drinking vessel as Flomi settled into a spot beside one of the large fireplaces. Even then, in the early afternoon of an early spring day, a small but steady blaze had been lit to stave off the unexpected storm and the wind could be heard roaring through the chimney. Flomi drew writing implements and paper from his satchel as Buttercup delivered the wine and, looking up briefly to thank her, he pulled out some of the latest, most troubling pages of translation and settled his brain into work.
The concentration powers of a dwarf at work are not a thing to be overestimated. As Flomi looked into the three lines of the puzzle that Collum had most recently recovered, the surroundings of the room and of the inn and even of the Bree-land itself became lost to him. The warmth of the fire or the taste of the wine (often forgotten by his attention to the work), even the movements of the serving girl and her coworkers, became distant comforts as Flomi’s mind became concentrated on his work.
The Adûniac on the latest pages was beyond dispute; Collum’s source seemed to be correct in placing the origin of the work in Rhudaur. It had the hints of an Eastern style to the language and the crude yet flourished script that he had seen in a few earlier fragments which had come from that fallen land. Rhudaur had been conquered and absorbed into the Witch-king’s realm nearly six centuries ago, so why would anyone in that dark and unwholesome land be writing in the language of Old Númenor?11 He did not know much of the Men of Angmar, doubtless there were few in Middle-earth who did, but they were said to have many private languages, little learning and only used the most basic elements of the Common Speech. To see the Lost Tongue of his own people translated into this version of Adûniac by such an unsavory person filled Flomi, perhaps for the first time, with the full danger of his task.
‘Pssst- Master, sir!’ someone then whispered loudly near his shoulder, quite startling the dwarf from his thoughts. ‘Psst- Sir!’
Young Milo, Collum’s readyman amongst the Breefolk, was bent beside the hearth, stoking the fire and trying to cautiously get Flomi’s attention. How long he had been there the dwarf could not say. Milo was a strange one amongst the other hobbits of this little town; quiet as a cheesemouse in his movements and quite uninterested in gab and gossip. If the hobbit had said three words to the dwarf in the last year beyond an obligatory, ‘good day, sir,’ Flomi could certainly not remember them. Yet he always seemed to appear whenever his master seemed to need him. ‘An excellent quality in the servant of a spy,’ Flomi had often thought, ‘at hand, at ready, and as unwilling to idyll speech as he is to unwanted questions.’
‘Boy,’ Flomi said, much louder than with a whisper and with some degree of briskness, ‘you quite startled me and have broken my concentration! I’m not sure if I am more angered by the trespass than surprised by this sudden change in your behaviour!’ He tried to smile at this to lessen the sharpness of his tone; Milo was a good sort after all and perhaps had important news of his master. It was at this time that Flomi noticed the commonroom was empty, dusk was coming on, and the hobbit was dressed in a wet cloak as if he had just come in from the storm. ‘Has your master returned then?’ Flomi asked.
‘No, sir, he has not,’ the boy said, ‘and the weather is still harsh. All of the townsfolk are shuttered into their homes, but...’, and at this the hobbit lowered his voice again and looked cautiously about the room, ‘but there are others come to the Bree-land who take no notice of ill-weather.’
‘Travelers, boy?’ Flomi asked. ‘Here at the inn? Is this not the purpose of your business? Surely a traveler is lucky to have found such a place on so harsh a day and I should think that the business of your master is lucky to have him. I’ve no idea why you have disturbed me with this...’
‘I’ve no desire to disturb you, sir,’ the hobbit interrupted, ‘but this traveler is surely not here on my master’s business. We have, well, that is to say mistress Buttercup has, thought of closing the commonroom for the night, if we may. Would you take dinner and more wine in your own room, sir?’
At this suggestion Flomi looked about the room again. It seems that only a few hours had passed since he began his work, but the time was truly hard to establish on such a dark day and he had a way of letting time slip aside when focused at his task. The tankard of wine at his side table was full, but the girl was well accustomed in the habit of seeing to this whenever it emptied. He was not remotely hungry, and the warmth of the fire beside him was more comforting than he had previously noticed. The wind still howled outside, more fiercely now perhaps, but the sleet had ceased and the rain now beat a steady rhythm on the shutters. He looked at the earnestness on Milo’s young face and, for a moment, he felt as if the hobbit was trying to tell him something quite beyond his ability to put into words.
Then, as if by chance, his eyes fell on the translation beside him and, while he regretted it greatly later, he quite neglected the caution that others of Collum’s people were instinctually heeding. ‘The Breelanders are not wise,’ he thought to himself a week later, walking the long dark road alone to the Foundations, ‘but they’ve a sharp sense of danger that I myself have lately been found to lack.’
‘Now, Milo,’ Flomi said politely then as he picked up his quill and unfastened his ink bottle, ‘it is indeed an unseasonable day with little prospect of a busier night. Your master is away, and I would not begrudge you or your fellows a chance to close the inn early to seek your own beds. I am quite content and will not, I promise, tell your master.
‘Let the kitchen know that I have enjoyed my regular meal and would forgo anything further. Perhaps a bit of cheese might be left here on the table for later? And Buttercup could leave me with some more wine, as well. I should be very happy of that. You have left ample wood here in the bin should the fire grow low.
‘Close the room to all and the inn to anyone else if you’d like. If your master should learn of it, then it shall not come from me. But I have now the rare chance for quiet and for study and here I will stay. You are a good and kind servant for asking,’ he said then, smiling dismissively and taking up his pen, ‘but I shall be quite comfortable here on my own.’
Milo, as was his way, said nothing further. He hovered at Flomi’s shoulder for an uncomfortable time and, when the dwarf looked up to wonder at this, he could see the hobbit’s mouth hung open as if he should say more. Their eyes caught for a long moment, but Milo said nothing until, eventually;
‘Yes, sir. As you will.’ The hobbit quickly left his place at the hearth and went to the front entrance of the commonroom. As Flomi’s eyes followed him, he saw Guldir, the stablemaster, waiting by the door. The two spoke quietly for a moment and then, looking back hesitantly, they both departed.
‘Finally,’ Flomi thought to himself on that unlucky day when thoughts of the dangers involved in his task had only just begun to enter his mind, ‘finally I shall be left alone for a while with my work!’
But, of course, he was not alone.
End of Chapter Four
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter Four
1) “Until next we meet” in Quenya.
2) Literally “Blessed arrival!” In Quenya.
3) Okay, now the fun begins; I’ve given you this translation before. Who’s keeping up?
4) This description is cribbed from Fellowship in the chapter “A Shortcut to Mushrooms”. I often try to sneak one or two of these into a chapter to keep my ear crisply attuned to the style.
5) “calavénë, eleni and laicolassë” translates to “sun, star and green leaf” in Quenya.
6) It was difficult determining a name for Thranduil’s halls in Mirkwood as there is some dispute on the matter.
7) This little discussion on the origins of Hobbit mushroom farming came quite unexpectedly and quite late into the writing of this book. I wanted Motho, who was a much more insignificant character early on in my design, to make a profit from mushrooms. But later chapters of the story return us to this farm and so forced me to look at it, and Motho himself, in greater detail. Mushroom farming itself is actually more of a 19th century invention and it became clear to me that for Motho to be successful he had to somehow be an innovator. This is probably the first really big instance in which the book was redesigned with its ending finally in sight.
8) This is a paraphrasing from The Akallabêth. Beothalion is not, as we will see, Númenórean, but Pallando seems to regard all Men as one People.
9) “Faith shines brighter than the stars” or as close to the Quenya of that as I can manage at this writing.
10) This is the name of the month that we call March from the Shire calendar. The name represents a modernization of the Old English name for the same period of the year, Hreþmōnaþ, meaning "rough-month”. I chose to use the Shire calendar here because Tolkien wrote no Dwarf calendar (though there are some interesting attempts by others online) and because it indicates Flomi’s attachment to life in the Bree-land.
11) It is something to wonder about regarding Middle-earth; how many lands or Peoples there would actually have their own written language? Rhudaur was part of Arnor and, as we see in Gondor, they preserve the Adûniac language but the writing of its histories is largely Sindarin. The languages of Angmar would be a mystery. But there’s going to be more on this later.
Chapter Five; "Gathering Concerns"
-Wherein a Newly Formed Fellowship Walks Westward in the Sunshine, Talking More Freely, and a Darker Meeting from Some Weeks Before is Likewise Recounted
Read Chapter Five; "Gathering Concerns"
Drowsily leaning upon his mound of morning acquisitions, Milo Fastknots waited for his master as the sun began a slow descent into the west behind him. ‘He had better come soon,’ Milo thought, ‘or this mad-eyed pony might have me for an afternoon meal.’ Twenty paces away, still keeping her cautious distance, Benbow’s fat white pony stood glaring at the young hobbit from out of the shade of an ash tree.
‘Yes, and I see you as well,’ Milo said to the pony in an aggrieved but, hopefully, compassionate voice. It wouldn’t do at all, he thought, to have this stubborn animal leave him now, here in the open when they had come so far together from the Hedge-gate and accomplished so much of his master’s wishes.
They had all stood together now in this glade waiting for two hours or better and he could see that the pony was growing restless. Milo had chosen this spot in which to meet the others not so much out of his master’s command but because he knew it was familiar to Benbow and the pony. His master had been vague as to a specific location, but Milo knew that Floxleaf would know exactly where to find them.
‘We’ve been here before, you and me,’ he told the pony. ‘Remember? Two and three times last summer when your master had his camp here. It was me came and saw him then. Why, I even brought you an apple that one time.’ And he had. If not last summer then in the fall. But at some time. Milo did not, as a rule, seek friendship with many folk, but he respected Benbow Floxleaf, a favorite of his master’s, and knew how much Floxleaf loved that pony. And anyone could see how that pony loved no one but Benbow Floxleaf.
Caitelyn, content to now be in the open lands after her trauma with the fire, grazed comfortably as an ambassador in the middle of the glade with her new friend somewhere between the Milo and the angry pony. She would not take sides in this open dispute, but seemed to be keeping a watchful eye on just what might happen next. Still Milo was certain that the mare’s trust in him was the only thing keeping the pony from leaving. ‘See her? Sure you do. She knows to wait for her master,’ he said. ‘And, like as not, that’s just what we’re all going to have to do.’
Hours before he and the horse and the pony had stopped at the first well-provisioned farm west of the town; Motho Greenhands’ prosperous mushroom plantation not more than a mile west of the Hedge. It was at that time but an hour or two past the dawn, no later than nine of the clock back in the Bree-land, and a few of the farmhands were about as Milo and his two charges came up the lane from the Road. Some others, he soon learned, had seen the smoke rising in the town in the evening and had set off to help. One of those that remained, Binto Fairbairns, knew Milo well and greeted him coming towards the small house shared by the workers. As Binto stood in the lane Milo could see behind him the two long buildings of Motho’s mushroom farm, the two-story barn and its little corral and, of course, the stone turret that had been built just beside the barn; a tower that no hobbit could see any purpose for having.
‘Hullo, Fastknots,’ Binto said, as the two hobbits came closer together, ‘what brings you here this morning with such sizable company beside and a fiery commotion behind you? That is your master’s horse, I see, but do you have another pony of your own these days to look after as well?’ he said, looking past Milo and the great grey mare to see the white pony coming cautiously up the lane behind, still at her distance.
Fairbairns was a young hobbit, of about Milo’s age, with sand-colored hair and brighter, wiser eyes than most of the townsfolk. Binto’s own family, the Fairbairns of the Sarn Fields, had worked the lands south of here long years before Greenhands had come into his wealth and it was something of disappointment that their son now had to work the newcomers' fields for his own livelihood. Binto, wise enough in his situation, had no great love for his employer but a careful tongue in the matter and that quality had earned him a position of authority on the farm whenever Greenhands himself was away. Milo liked Binto Fairbairns quite well, and respected him, but he would have to be careful with him. Binto was sharp, no one’s fool, and he made his own decisions, though those decisions were always in fairness to his master’s wishes, whether he liked the miserly mushroom merchant or not.
‘That pony there belongs to Ben Floxleaf,’ Milo replied. 'Do you know him?'
'Sure I do,' binto replied. 'But only enough to wish him a good day. He doesn't have much call to hunt around these parts.'
‘My master and Whodekin Ben1 have a great need to see both their mounts saddled and ready. Something I was hoping old Bottom-to-Hand might help with.’
‘Hmmmm, were you now?’ Binto said, cautiously. ‘Well, you’ll get no help from him in any hurry today. He’s been to the town these past four days and I suspect that big cloud of smoke we saw this morning behind you means he’ll be there a few more. What’s all the rumpus?’2
‘Fear and fire and, it seems, foes where we least expected,’ Milo replied. ‘Some person set fire to the stables last night and, worse even, murdered old Guldir, the stable-master, who never hurt no one.’
‘Murdered!’ Binto cried. ‘Stars in the sky, who would do such a thing as that here in the Bree-land?’
‘None in the Bree-land that I should know of, but that’s why my master and Ben are off to catch the culprits. Murdered he was, his throat cut wide and the great stables burned about him. We’d not have found the poor man if the killer hadn’t done it just outside the building. Then the whole of the place was set to oil and torch, livestock and whomsoever else still inside. The folk of the town, and maybe even old Bottom-to-Hand was amongst them, though I cannot say that I saw him myself, but the whole folk of the town worked through the night or the Four Greenfields and many other buildings would’ve caught in the blaze. Now this villain, or villains, have gone west, we hear, running before the Sun, and my master has sent me out while the timbers of the stables were still a-smoulder to ready his provisions. He will give chase and those villains will pay when he meets them.’
Binto, for all of his sharp mind and honest work, did not really make it into town that often so Guldir, the stable- master was unknown to him, but such a tale of fire and murder had a rather blood-curdling effect for any hobbit and a phrase such as as ‘running before the Sun’ put the fear of Goblins in the mind of any Northerner . Milo considered Binto to be a very likeable ‘country hobbit’, and while he told no lies, he knew that scare tactics, particularly in a time of need, were quite motivational with such folk. He could see the terror and interest in the young hobbit’s eyes, and, taking a cue from his master, closed in on how to use it.
‘Now Collum and the hunter Ben Floxleaf would give pursuit, but their own saddles and gear were lost in the blaze,’ Milo continued, seeing just how far he might go with his plea. ‘They’ll ride west to find these killers and burners, and I’m here to set their kip and speed them on their way.’
He paused here and, later, over the years in which other folk more social than Milo would come to tell the story, they would often wonder if he knew to pause on this moment of his own or if it had been as an instinct he had picked up from watching his master. But pause he did, and he looked long into Binto Fairbairn’s eyes to make his point.
‘I’d have a horse’s saddle, another saddle for a pony, what provisions you can spare for long travels and even your master’s great horse himself that he might speed my own master in keeping the town’s justice, Binto. You’d have the full promise that each and every aid you will give me my master will pay in full and at fair price. But I’ve no time to wait for sluggardly mushroom-lords like old Bottom-to-Hand nor a leisurely ride back into town to ask his permission. I’ve worked all night in a blazing barn and walked all morning guiding frightened beasts, so I’ve no vigor nor time to discuss matters much further. Will you aid my master and, if you’ve not understood already, all of the Bree-land in our hope of justice?’
It is doubted by most everyone who ever knew him that Milo Fastknots had ever spoken this much to any one person in all his previous life. But he would certainly come to speak many other long and quite rousing speeches in his future.
*****
When the company came up to the small grove of trees where Collum waited they saw him sharpening a longsword; a very bad omen to Ben’s mind. He had never seen the innkeeper carry such a blade before, but there was a sureness to the man’s behavior that showed he was most certainly no stranger to the weapon. Long, steady strokes of the wetstone against the steel made a quiet soft sound in the glade and, though barely noticed, it gave a fresh rhythm to the company’s approaching pace.
‘Any news from the Hedge-gate?’ Ben asked the man as they drew closer.
‘None. I slipped past unrecognized quite easily enough. I fear that my former neighbors haven’t yet given much thought about watching their door. Currently, or so I should think, it is still all of you and poor Flomi whom they blame.
'When they find that we’ve all slipped their vigilance the blame will assuredly be set. Perhaps then they will become more watchful.’
‘Though I have never encountered such a large group of these little folk before,’ Alatar commented, ‘‘watchful" is not how I should describe them.’ He nodded courteously toward Benbow at this. ‘With no offense meant to master Floxleaf, of course, who has proved a most cautious guide. He has taken us well west of the suspicious eyes of your townsfolk and now we wonder, each of us I should think, where you, Ohtar, would lead us next.’
‘This is just so, Dúnadan,’ Tawarengil said rather more curtly. ‘My curiosity over the events of the evening runs strong, and I would gladly lend aid where I may in answer to your hospitality, but my own way lies west to answer Círdan’s call. What is your destination and moreover, now that we are free of your bothersome neighbors, what will you tell us of yourself?’
The tall man sheathed his blade at these questions and at the open, wondering looks of Ben and the others. He then buckled the sword a bit higher upon his hip and reached down for his pack on the ground before him. Shouldering it he said, ‘my lord Tawarengil, oldfathers and young masters, my way does indeed go west for a time just as your own may. If you will walk with me here in the open lands then I will tell you more as we travel. I am glad of such company and happy for your assistance this past day, however, I must remind you, only Benbow here is under any plea bond to my cause. You all may part as you wish. Some of you, I am certain, will understand if that makes me slow to reveal all of my purposes.’
Ben saw him look here for a moment at Olórin, but the grey wizard said nothing. So Collum turned his back on the group and began walking in long deliberate strides out of the glade. But not too quickly that they could not follow.
‘Milo is some hours ahead of us and probably has provisions for Ben and I only, following the instruction I gave him,’ Collum said as the others came beside him.
‘He’s a sharp young fellow, your Milo,’ Ben said, ‘and I think I shall be able to catch him up. He knows many of my own campsites within a day’s ride, but won’t go too far off the road with my Rosie growing suspicious.’
‘Good, Ben,’ Collum replied. ‘Lead us then, if you will.’ He then turned a bit to the others who followed and began speaking to them more directly.
‘The day is bright,’ Collum said to his new companions, ‘and these lands west of Bree are still free. This may change soon as the Witch-king moves his war over all the North, but for now we are safe to speak more openly as we keep stride.
‘I was born to be given the name Ohtar, true, but as you wise fathers may well know, that name was one that meant only ‘soldier’ or ‘warrior’ in Old Adûnaic. Yet now that is the name of my house and I am the twenty-seventh in my line to carry it since my ancestor served King Isildur.’3
‘Yes,’ Alatar said, ‘we suspected as much from your earlier telling. It was your grandsire then who brought Narsil home to the North when Isildur fell.’
‘It was, Oldfather,’ Collum replied, ‘and my family has served beside the rightful heir of Arnor since that day. We are honored in this, called “setya ohtar”, but our service to Isildur’s line has been in secret for some generations.’
‘Since the reign of Eärendur,’ Alatar suggested, ‘or so we should gather from your telling.’
‘That is so,’ the man replied, ‘and your knowledge of our history is keen to have surmised it.’
‘But mine is not,’ the young Elf-lord interrupted abruptly. ‘The tales of Men and of the Kings of Men do not travel to the Greatwood, Ohtar, and of “King Sea-servant”4 or whomever I and my companion know nothing. Yet it may be that the Wise,’ he said, turning toward Alatar and the other Istari, ‘have guessed at some larger truth here through this lineage. Still, Beothalion and I at least remain blind to it and to this man’s purposes.’
‘Patience, my young lord,’ Olórin replied. ‘This story may be revealed in time, but we must let it come as it will. Patient is the step of wisdom.’
Tawarengil looked harshly at the old wizard then, and color, not of anger but of some other passion, came into the pale skin of his childlike face. Ben thought for a moment of the Elves of Rivendell whom he had met; how high and calm they had seemed, how separate their faces were from their inner thoughts. But those elves were tall and lordly, ancient to hear tell of it. He had never seen nor spoken with a young Elf-lord until last night and had never really considered the Elves as they may be in their youth. If Tawarengil felt some rebuke in Olórin’s comment, he said nothing of it and turned his face away to the path ahead.
‘It was after the reign of Eärendur, eleven centuries ago,’ Collum continued in a friendly way, addressing the question, ‘that the realm of Arnor was split, my lord Tawarengil, divided between his three sons. This is not in accordance with our traditions, but there was great turmoil in the North and a fragile peace was brokered by the arrangement.’ He paused here for some time as they continued walking, his eyes ahead to the way west as they came out of a copse and into the rolling and unsettled lands just beyond sight of the Road. Ben still had the lead, winding them easily through the uneven ground, for he knew the land better than Collum who, familiar in a wood as he was from many journeys, saw it still through the eyes of history.
For three or four leagues ahead the land appeared less hilly than it was behind them toward Bree-hill. It was dotted with other small clusters of trees that seemed to stretch toward one another and reclaim the fertile and less rocky ground from here to the south and then again as it broadened off toward the north and that wide expanse of open, harder lands. Some of these trees, as Ben and Collum certainly both knew, were of very great age indeed, part of the once mighty forest that was said to cover the landscape before the Kings out of the Sea came to take these territories as their own. In many places these few great relics of an ancient and mighty forest had been left standing through the long ages of Man’s incursion and they had (very recently indeed, by the tree’s own accounting of years) sired new growth in the now unpopulated lands; majestic and massive beech and oak, willow and hawksborne and hazel, birch and rowan and maple and fir -great trees that had once served as great landmarks of Arnor’s old estates and farmlands now long abandoned- were reaching out to one another with generations of their children, some many hundreds of years old now themselves, trying to restore the peace that the land once knew. Arnor’s hold over the land, the sculpting and design of her great cities, plazas and cultivated fields, its roads and mills and watchtowers still visible in Ohtar’s mind from the histories of his people was vanishing and the great trees were coming back as if Man’s dominance had never been. And the trees, out of their contempt or their mercy, seemed to barely notice Arnor’s passing.
The sun was high now, beginning to dip slowly towards the far-off mountains west at the edge of the world, and for all that distance ahead the lands became a vast and rich band of green. For it was springtime in the North, and peace had reigned in the western edge of Eriador that lay before them for most of that age. Collum stopped for a moment on some higher patch of ground to look as far west as his eyes might reveal, hoping to glimpse the ribbon of Baranduin, the brown river, as it ran through the lands to the west. But he could not see it from here, and the way ahead seemed to him the more uncertain.
‘I understand this desire for peace,’ he said at some length, as if there was some great report, or even some show of great fatigue and a quiet acceptance in the statement. The others paused in that moment sensing his unease. But as soon as their eyes fell on him he smiled slightly and continued with his walking and the telling of his tale.
‘Peace at the expense of custom did purchase time for the North. But now, with the fall of Fornost to the Witch-king this past winter, it seems as if this dearly-purchased time has ended and all of the lands of old Arnor will be overrun.
‘Yet our past and, I must still believe, our hope for the future, remains.
‘Eärendur was a mighty prince in his youth who came late into his kingship. Even in the time of his father our people in these lands had diminished greatly through the War and our trade with our neighbors and even our own kin to the South had grown sparse. We kept no ships and sent few caravans or messengers beyond our own borders. In isolation distrust of neighbors often will grow, and so it was in Eärendur’s time.
‘But great precautions had been set in Arnor to preserve our past. Many important histories and artifacts of our people were brought out of Númenor by Elendil and Isildur to be housed in Annúminas. But how safe were they as our people became so much the fewer? Holding the splendor and history of Isildur’s folk in the North became the chief concern for many of my people by Eärendur’s time.’
Olórin, with low and somber voice, interrupted. ‘Some might say, Ohtar, that this was a subject of contention between the realms of Gondor and Arnor and that the people of both lands had become covetous of the heirlooms of Númenor.’
‘This may be as you say, Wisefather,’ the man replied, ‘but I and my ancestors before me have been soldiers and as such take great care before questioning the motives of kings.’ He grew quiet again at this, not stopping in his motion forward as they followed Ben’s lead, but looking for a time over his left shoulder to the lands of the south.
‘So it is said that true men follow their own heart’s calling and hope that true kings will know their own heart’s wisdom. And so it was wished in the time of Eärendur and in the time of my grandsire Ohtar, the ninth of our name.
‘Great protectors of the realm and of its artifacts had laboured long years to ensure that the legacy of Elendil might survive the harrowing of the Northlands, the division of lands and the dwindling of its people. Before the kingdom was ever split many great items of Númenor were removed from Annúminas to be hidden and protected.’
‘One might say this was folly, Ohtar,’ Alatar offered, ‘that artifacts and history should never be separated and hidden from their people. For pride and learning are the true value to be found in these things. Therefore, what good is it to protect empty parcels if they can no longer advantage the people they were meant for?’
‘I have no answer for this, Oldfather,’ Collum said. ‘It is a wisdom and a question beyond my service and my duty as a soldier.’
‘Men, or so it seems to me, cling like misers to their history,’ Tawarengil replied casually. ‘Your love of your own stories will never alter the fragility and weakness found in your bodies.’
‘The Gifts of Ilúvatar cannot be understood by all, Tawarengil,’ said Pallando, the third and most withdrawn of the three wizards, ‘it would be unwise to question the traits which may seem to come along with such a Gift.’
Beothalion, uncharacteristically quiet all this time, spoke up. ‘I do not know of this gift, Tawar, but I am most certainly jealous of our friend, the innkeeper. To have such a knowledge of his history! How deep his stories go!’
Pallando smiled at this, saying, ‘the Men of Númenor are indeed fortunate to have a history that is richly written, young one. But the Men of Middle-earth have a history no less illustrious for it being secretly spoken only by the few who guard it. May you come to hear some of it in your time!’
Ben had been trying (with some difficulty) to sort all of this storytelling in his head. ‘Forgive me if I’m a bit slow here, Collum,’ he said, ‘but I don’t quite see what all of this old history has to do with poor Gildur or your missing dwarf stonemason.’
‘Then you have certainly been paying better attention to the trail than to the tale, master Floxleaf,’ said the grey wizard with what seemed to Ben like a blend of humor and impatience. ‘For surely this stonemason, as unlikely as it might seem, holds a key to all of this history.’
*****
‘Finally!’ thought Rosie as she caught the faint sound of Ben’s voice away to the east. ‘What a time he’s been!’ He was downwind and she could not yet catch his familiar scent, but her ears where still sharp through the fever and she knew he was not further than six or seven hundred rangar5 behind her, talking calmly as if there had been no fire and no smoke and no flight to trouble him in this long and terrifying time since they came to the town. She loved this about Ben, though it caused her much frustration; his voice was always calm and reassuring no matter what the distress and dangers of their life and travels together had brought to them.
She could hear two or more speakers with him, but could not yet hear their steps. She wanted to bolt off and meet him, to leave her new friends and this other scowling hobbit behind, but she was still too frightened by the fire last night and by the dark-figured Man who had set it.
So she backed further away from the sunlight of the glade and into the shadow of the trees. Her new friends were startled at this and raised their heads to listen, wise as they were. Even the scowling hobbit had the good sense to stop his talking and stood up noiselessly, taking a large stick and a rock to his hand to defend himself and his new possessions against any intruders.
******
‘The most troublesome thing are the runes,’6 Flomi thought to himself on that stormy afternoon five weeks before, ‘for the hand of them is like none I’ve ever seen, though they carry an indication of familiarity with the original.’
Now it should be said here that runes were not, by any means, a common thing in the West of Middle-earth in that Third Age of the world. The ways of the East were, as they should be, quite unknown to Flomi; he could not speak to what Men knew in those distant lands and he did not wish to learn more of them or of their ways; for the Dwarves had shunned the East since the breaking of the world and they have never once looked back.7
So it was that in all the known lands between the Blue Mountains and the Iron Hills, even south to the Bay of Belfalas (as far south as any dwarf had been said to travel), that Flomi and his grandsires were thought to be the among the last of the rune-masters. And, like many of the skills of his People, they shared this art with no one. For Dwarves make many secret languages, understand many mysteries and have many secret names for things, but they are cautious by nature and leave no written traces of all that they know.
How the Seer, Malbeth,8 whose work Flomi was currently translating, had come into his awareness of runes was still quite unknown. It was quite unnatural for a Man to write of them as he had over one hundred years before. ‘I should like to have met that man,’ Flomi had often thought, ‘for I have never seen his like amongst these silly Breelanders.’ The complex picture-language used by the Seer was not true rune-craft of course. But his writings had disclosed a set of picture symbols, dwarfish in their making, and so the great mystery of Flomi’s family, and of their involvement with the Men of Arnor, had been opened again during his father’s lifetime.
But this new set of runes which troubled Flomi so, like to but differing from the Seer’s own writings, were of course, not entirely derived from the Dwarvish. They were, without doubt, drawn from Malbeth’s work echoing rhyme and meter and therefore rooted in the work of Flomi’s own grandsire,9 but they incorporated some unique variation in style and they indicated, perhaps, that some other influence then Flomi or his father had formerly seen in Malbeth’s writing until this-
‘Might I join you by the fire, master Dwarf,’ a soft and well-mannered voice said, startling Flomi from his work. He looked up quickly and saw a man, as tall as Collum was himself, standing in the center of the dimly-lit commonroom. He wore a traveler's cloak, black as night and dirty from the road. His boots were tall, riding boots certainly, nearly as tall as a hobbit, and he held in his hands dark gloves which he appeared to have just removed. At his side there was a longsword, also dark and without ornament, but Flomi thought little of this, as the roads were less safe for travelers than they had been a year ago. He wore no other trappings that might make him out to be a soldier, but he had a soldier’s bearing even here in the empty commonroom, and his request carried as much command as it did formal courtesy.
He did not smile as he spoke; no smirk of authority that might make Flomi more cautious than he should be, but his face held the semblance of kindness and his manner was open. He was clean-shaven, unusual in the Men that Flomi had met here in the North, and his hair was a dark-brown as Collum’s own was, but lank and tied-back neatly from his face.
‘You had better, traveler,’ Flomi said to the man. ‘For it is an unseasonable night and I fear that the hostelers here may have left for the warmth of their beds and we, their guests, must fend for ourselves.’
Walking the lonely paths now to the Foundations, still well before the dawn of his first morning since leaving the Bree-land, and heading towards the safety that he and Collum had prepared for, Flomi regretted that act of courtesy; he had come to realize that this, and not the burglary twelve years past, was the moment when they had been discovered. But it was only now that he began to realize the full severity of his situation and the danger that his courteous gesture had put them in.
*****
The seven travelers were walking north of the Road through brief clusters of trees that gave them some cover from prying eyes, though they expected nothing as dangerous as that here in the open lands to the west of Bree-hill. Benbow was now leading them up a small incline toward another copse of trees, mostly ash and fir and older rowan.
As they came to the hill Tawarengil paused to look ahead and the rest of the party, already keyed to his instincts, stopped as well.
‘Your servant is there, Innkeeper,’ the young Elf-lord said pointing, ‘and this Floxleaf of ours has found him quickly enough. But there are still many questions I would ask you.’
‘Your questions come as no surprise, my lord,’ Collum said, ‘nor do Ben’s skills. But more talk must wait until we have sent my man Milo on his way. He’s a great keeper of secrets that one, but I will not see his life further imperiled with harmful knowledge.’
‘He’s a sharp one, Collum,’ Ben said, ‘and while I don’t quite understand this peril you're speaking of, I couldn’t agree more.
‘Ho! Youngster,’ Ben called loudly as they came up the short hill. ‘Your master and I bring guests, so put your throwing stones aside and keep your hands open for greetings.’
When they came into the glade atop the low hill Ben was in the front. Milo was standing beside a small heap of supplies and two great horses were in the shade behind him. A short fat pony came briskly walking, almost trotting, towards Benbow and nuzzled right up beside him.
‘Hello, Rosie, girl,’ the hobbit said to the pony as he smiled broadly and left the other travelers aside. ‘You look very fine now after last night’s scare! But you should keep out of this sunshine, girl.’ He pulled a small apple from his pocket and fed it to the delighted pony, looking into her eyes with great concern.
‘Well met, Milo,’ Collum said, walking towards his servant and looking at the pile of supplies and then over to the two horses. ‘You have done much better than expected, I see.’
‘I hope that’s so, sir,’ the young hobbit said, looking around to see all the other travelers. ‘I’ve tried to anticipate your needs without raising too much a stir. But I’d not thought there’d be so many of you...’
‘Nor had I,’ Collum said, ‘but one cannot always foresee what providence holds.’
‘As you say, sir,’ the hobbit replied. ‘I’d gone to Greenhands’ farm for the saddles, which seemed the safest and shortest path, sir. Motho himself was away, but I nudged his man Fairbairns into a loan of Greenhands’ great stallion, thinking you might like a second mount for greater speed.
‘There’s only the one saddle for a horse, I’m afraid,’ said Milo, looking around to the others, ‘but I’ve also got Greenhands’ own smaller fancy saddle that Benbow’s pony might take to. I’ve carried it myself as she won’t let me near enough to fit. There was even a man-sized walking stick, sir, though I’ve no idea how old Bottom-to-Hand came by such a thing. I’ve got us some water skins, some wine and blankets for cold nights and additional bags with salted meats. Even two small pots for cooking or the boiling of water in a pinch. A fair stock on short notice for a long journey in open lands.
‘And it will be a long journey, won’t it be, sir?’ Milo asked his master.
‘Yes, lad,’ he responded softly, smiling at the young hobbit and bending to place a hand on his shoulder. ‘And it will be up to you to keep watch over Buttercup and the inn, if not the whole town of the Bree-land, while I’m away. Are you feeling up to the task?’
Milo looked at his master quite seriously then. He saw the longsword at his belt and felt the change in the man, knowing as Buttercup had, that his master was finally, as he had always expected, going off to some fate or another and not coming back. Then he looked down at the ground, furrowing his brow with a sense of deep determination. The thoughtful pause was long, but those who knew Milo Fastknots were accustomed to such moments of silence.
‘Well, if the truth is to be told, sir, I’m a bit tired from such a long night as we’ve had and fretting over Benbow’s pony who looked like to eat me.’
Then he lifted his gaze, rubbed his eyes a bit, and straightened his back. ‘But this bit of sunshine here has been restful enough, and I’ve had some cool water back at the farmhouse. I’ll manage, sir,’ he said resolutely. ‘What would you have me do?’
Collum smiled at this and looked over to Ben and then to the three wizards traveling with them. If they heard, or remarked at the man’s exchange with the hobbit, there was little indication; except, perhaps, with Olórin, the grey wizard, who seemed to smile slightly to himself.
‘Then back to the Bree-land with you, my friend,’ Collum said with a smile. ‘I have left some instructions and some instruments for you in the care of Buttercup. She will be the new mistress at the Four Greenfields and, I expect, she should have great need of you by nightfall. Heed her well and give her careful counsel when you may. There will be plenty of money there for old Motho as payment for his horse and his provisions and your sound purchases there will dispel many wild rumors.
‘It’s my hope that we’ll draw all trouble out of the Bree-land for a short time, but trouble along the Roads returns quickly enough and I trust you to show the other Breelanders how to deal with it. There’s more strength in some there than any of them know, but it will take a quiet and strong voice like your own to awaken it.’
Milo smiled broadly at this praise and looked around at the others.
To Ben he said, ‘you take care of that smart pony now, master Benbow. She looks sharp and cross at most anyone but you yet, the way I hear it, it's your prancing pony which saved our town.’
‘I will indeed, Milo,’ Ben said, ‘and you take care of yourself as well. You're a brave hobbit to take on your master’s work, but just the one I’d want for the job.’
Milo looked very happy and more than a little embarrassed by this praise. Then he set his jaw and, without looking at the others, walked out of the glade and back towards the town.
‘Anar caluva tielyanna!’ Collum called to the young hobbit as he walked away. ‘The sun shall shine upon your path!’
*****
‘Oh, I do not concern myself much with bad weather,’ the dark traveler said as he came closer to the fire, ‘but I have far to travel and my mount is happy for the comforts of this town’s stables. I had heard the place was filled with Halflings, so you can imagine my surprise at seeing one of Durin’s Folk sitting here cozily by a fire. Are you a gentleman of the road?’
‘Acchh! Would that were so,’ Flomi said with a smile. ‘No, I came here some years past to serve in my father’s place. I am the town’s stonemason, and a quiet and uneventful life that work is in a town filled with hole-delvers; it provides ample enough raw employment, but requires little art or ambition.’
‘I see,’ the man replied, looking briefly over to Flomi’s table and the writings and notes scattered about him. He then settled his eyes on the small wine cask Milo had left there for Flomi’s refreshment.
‘May I offer you a drink, traveler?’ Flomi said. ‘As I have said, they seem to have closed the commonroom around us and gone off to early beds. But I am left with wine enough for the both of us. Allow me!’
At this he stood up and went to Collum’s serving station in the middle of the room. It was now well past sunset and Flomi found himself wondering yet again about how many hours had gone by since Milo had left him to concentrate on his work. If anyone had come in since that time he could not remember or had not heard and (most accurately) had not cared. The opportunity to focus on the current pieces of the translation had been, as always, foremost in his mind. He did not wish to be discourteous to this other guest but, in a way, he was growing angry at Buttercup and the others for leaving him to play the part of host. Perhaps he would have a word or two with their master after all about them abandoning their posts and leaving him as greeter.
But the commonroom was dark now, with no extra candles or unnecessary fires lit, no townsfolk hereabouts with their chattering and gossip, and it no doubt looked very discouraging for others to enter. It was a wonder that the stranger had found his way here on such an unusual night. ‘But a traveler on the road must be met with courtesy,’ Flomi thought to himself at the time. ‘That is an old and important custom, even if all these bothersome Breelanders have forgotten it.’
As he went behind the service station to fetch a cup from one of the lower shelves there, Flomi happened to look through the darkened doorway that opened into the hall. There he saw Gildur, the stable-master, standing quietly in the shadows with his eyes focused on the traveler. Flomi’s eyes, like any dwarf’s, were untroubled by shadows and it surprised him to see a sword buckled to the old man’s hip and his hand, calmly but carefully, resting upon the hilt.
Flomi quickly looked again to the man at the hearth. Suddenly he became terrified; he had walked away from his work and left a stranger within its reach! But the man casually stood there warming his hands, his face never leaving the blaze of the fire. If he was aware of the scrutiny of others he regarded it not at all and, more importantly, he gave the pages that Flomi had left out on the table not the slightest bit of his attention.
‘But the Breelanders clearly sense danger from the man,’ Flomi thought at the time, ‘and both Guldir and Milo have learned more than a few cautions from their master. I must in turn learn from their instincts.’
‘Will you tell me, traveler,’ Flomi said as he returned to the hearth and began to pour out wine for the guest, ‘some tales, perhaps, from the Road?’
‘Tales, master?’ the man said frankly. ‘No, I will tell no tales, for they are doubtful things in the best of times and slanted things when there is conflict about. No tales, but some news of the outside world I can bring you if you wish. Are there lands and peoples that you would like to hear of? Or have your years here amongst these Breefolk curbed your interest in the gathering concerns of broader realms?’ He took the wine Flomi offered him, lifting his cup in thanks (and a salute, that Flomi later thought rather perfunctory and military in fashion), but he offered no words of greeting as travelers usually do.
Flomi sat across from the man and took up his own cup in return. He tried to sound quite casual as he talked, but he also used the time to start gathering up his notes and returning them to the safety of his satchel.
‘Well, we have had fewer travelers at the inn than expected this springtime,’ he said, ‘but perhaps it is the trouble up north which makes it so. My own folk have given a wide berth to this part of the Great Road for some years. Have you seen many dwarves upon your travels? Can you tell me of them?’
The man sat back and away from the fire at this question, turning his chair to face Flomi’s while the dwarf busied himself with gathering up the pages spread about. His face was calm and relaxed, and he took another very small sip of his wine and looked deeply into the dwarf’s eyes before responding. ‘I can indeed, master Stonemason,’ he said calmly. ‘It would be my pleasure to share with you.
‘Of the Peoples of the Iron Hills I know very little,’ he said, ‘their lands are high and guarded and they have now, as ever, little traffic with Men. It is said that the dragons are stirring again in that part of the world. But these may be tales only and, as I have said, I offer no tales.
‘The dwarves of Khazad-dûm go abroad east of the Misty Mountains and still have great renown with my People for their smith-craft and especially for their ores.’ At this he paused for a moment and looked long into Flomi’s eyes. ‘But the true wealth of Hadhodrond is not measured in gold or gems and it is seldom seen in the wider world,’ he said flatly, letting his voice trail off. But Flomi said nothing.
‘Your kin of the Blue Mountains still travel wide with their goods,’ he continued in an easier fashion, ‘but they are as wary as ever. If they come but seldom to this spot of the world it is because they have little concern with its conflicts. Once, long ago, they involved themselves with the wars of Men and have learned to regret it. They make very great weapons still, or so it is said, but they keep them only for themselves and the guardianship of their homes.
‘I have heard that they make excursions into the north of Ered Luin now,’ he said. ‘What will they find there? Are Nogrod and Belegost truly gone? Do the ice-drakes roam and sleep atop the ancient riches of the Khazâd, or does something older and deeper wander those lost halls? Oh,’ he said, smiling in that broad and disarming way that Flomi had caught a glimpse of earlier, ‘it is an exciting time to be a dwarf in the wider world, master Stonemason.’
At the time Flomi was quite shocked by all of this information and, as he thought back upon it now he knew that this was the first step the black rider had taken toward drawing him out and, perhaps, to reading things in Flomi’s own background. How quickly the Man had decided that Flomi and his folk came from the Blue Mountains seemed remarkable now in the dark night as he fled from the potential danger in the Bree-land.
‘Your knowledge of the Dwarves is surprising, traveler,’ Flomi had said. His caution of the man was still high though he had stopped putting away his papers to better hear the news. ‘And your knowledge of our history all the moreso. May I ask how you have come by it? Are there dwarves in your party perhaps?’
‘No,’ the man said softly, ‘I travel alone more often than not. But I have met many of your folk along my way. And, like yourself, I feel history to be the most important of studies. Now, what else would you hear from my travels?’
‘Well,’ said Flomi, ‘any news of the North if you have it. For it may soon concern us here in the Bree-land, although these townsfolk wish to remain ignorant of it.’
At this the rider, taking on a more somber face, drew another sip of his wine saying, ‘I can speak of fallen Fornost, if you’d like, but it is a harrowing tale that many would forego on dreary nights beside a fire. The son-and-heir of Elendil in the North has fled and he will not come again. Word tells that he is already lost in the frozen wastes. His sons are spread to the lands west of here, but they fight among themselves about how to rally troops which they no longer have and how to sue for aid which none will give them. The North Kingdom of old has fallen, for there is no strength at its center and there has not been in many a century. It is sad, is it not? That the valor of the North was so easily spent in southern wars and family squabbles. Angmar is the true force in the lands north of here, and their might is not the might of Men.
‘How will this little hedgetown of pig farmers and rabbit-folk fare against the might of Angmar, you ask?’ the rider said darkly, his smile gone and his eyes lit in the fire’s blaze. ‘Not well, I should think, if anything should be here to draw the Witch-king’s attention. Is there? I wonder,’ but his voice traveled off at this, as if daring Flomi to question him further. Seeing that this did not happen, the rider quickly went on with his report.
‘Don’t mistake me. I am happy for the wine you’ve offered, the stable for my horse, and the chance to share a roaring fire on a cold night, but no one should think themselves safe here. In the months to come the open roads might be a better place.’
‘Is there no hope to be found in the Elves?’ Flomi asked fearfully. ‘It is said that they are rallied to the North-king’s aid and will ride out against Angmar’s host...’
‘Is this a third question, master?’ the rider asked, raising his brow a bit. ‘I have paid for my room here, and for my stable, but I have enjoyed your wine and your fire and I am now your guest. I would gladly give you my thoughts on this third matter,’ he said, pausing just a bit and meeting Flomi’s eyes directly again, ‘but I am a traveler who keeps the Old Customs of the Road.’
Flomi, thinking at the time that he knew the Old Customs better than most, let his curiosity (which is usually a quite rare, but often deep-running trait among dwarves) get the better of his caution (which is a quality that he now wished he had come by earlier) and said to the rider;
‘Please, Rider, for you seem quite learned and I hear only little from the few who pass this way. Tell me more, if you may.’
*****
Once Milo had left the other travelers began to gather around Collum as he began to look over their provisions. Ben, gently brushing his hand through Rosie’s hair, watched from a little distance.
‘You are part of quite an interesting People, Master Floxleaf,’ Olórin said, walking towards Ben and still looking off toward the other now-departed hobbit, ‘with an integrity found in some individuals that goes quite unnoticed in the larger groups.’
‘Oh, he’s a fine lad, Milo is, sir,’ Ben said, a bit surprised to be singled out for conversation while so much interest was (and clearly should be) directed at Collum. ‘But I shouldn’t judge all of us by the Breelanders, nor by Milo or myself; hobbits are just hobbits to themselves, alone or in groups, wise or simple or anywheres between.’
‘Ho, ho!’ Olórin said with a mighty laugh, that Ben had not expected from this serious-looking, wizened old man. The others turned their heads at this surprise as well and, for half of a moment, Ben thought he was perhaps being made sport of. But he looked into the wizard’s eye, saw the genuine delight there like a welcoming ray of morning sun, and knew this was not the case. ‘Wise or simple, indeed! Well, master Floxleaf,’ he said smiling, ‘I am very happy to learn from you that I do not in fact know the full meaning of either of these things after all!’
Rosie lifted her head at this and gave a long neighing sound as if she too found something Ben had said quite funny. At this, Beothalion, who seemed to be mostly standing around admiring the collection of goods which Milo had brought them, came walking over.
‘She is very happy with your new friends, little Benbow,’ the wildman said as he approached them, ‘and, yes,’ he said, addressing the pony, ‘I should be sorry for my lack of greeting. Goheno nin, cinnog mairo. Gi suilon. I eneth nîn Beothalion.’10
At this Rosie gave off a gentle, contented noise and lowered her head to the big man’s outreached hands.
‘You speak the Elfish!’ Benbow said most happily. ‘Thank you, Beothalion, for that kindness! Rosie was raised with the elf-folk, you see, and it brings her great joy to hear it spoke, but I’ve not the skill myself. It is a great comfort to the both of us now, for she has not been feeling well...’
‘Yes,’ Beothalion said, looking into the pony’s eyes and holding his finger, very gently, inside of her ear, ‘she has a... hotness?...fever. I thought it might just have been the fire. You did well to give her shade, but she needs... palátā glae ... I don’t know what you call it...’
‘“Palmarosa?”’ Olórin said. ‘Yes. Gingergrass, they call it here in the North. Yes. Well, I’m no great herb-master, but it should be quite plentiful here I should think.’
‘Gingergrass?’ Ben said, trying to keep up with all this new information (most of which concerned him much more greatly than any stories of Sea-kings, or Witch-kings or the lost wars of Men). ‘Why, it's fair common from here to the Brown River, to be sure. Thank you, masters, for you’ve wisdom regarding my poor Rosie that I’m too blind to see for myself.’
‘Oh, she is wise, little Benbow,’ the wildman said, ‘and sorry that you can not hear her. But she knows you mean her very well.’ And as he said this he kept stroking the pony under her jaw and smoothed the hair up between her ears.
‘Do you...’ Ben was wide-eyed as he seemed to be seeing the big wild man for the first time all over again, another surprise for him in a day filled with many. ‘Do you speak her language?’
‘Speak?’ Beothalion said with an almost comic wonderment to his face. ‘No, I can not speak her language, little Benbow. I have not the... mouth for that.’ At this Rosie let out another long neighing sound, one Benbow had always taken as a laugh, and she shook her head gently. ‘Haha!’ Beothalion said laughing with her. ‘No, she is wise and so she listens well, but speaks her way. And I listen to her better than you might, but,’ he said, keeping one hand on Rosie and placing another on Benbow’s head, ‘she might be wiser than us both! Haha!’
‘Is it not said that the birds of every district, nay almost every nest, speak unalike?’11 Olórin said.
‘I do not speak to birds, Greystalker,’ Beothalion said with great seriousness, ‘for only the Eagles can be trusted, and I have not met any eagles yet.’
‘“Wise and simple and anywheres in between” indeed!’ Olórin said with a laugh as he walked off to join the others.
*****
‘Círdan Nówë, doomsayer of Nargothrond, does indeed call the Peoples of the North,’ said the rider, ‘and perhaps I shall answer him myself. He was ever a friend to the Númenóreans and so holds some desire beyond hope to save Elendil’s heir-sons yet a third time.’ The rider turned towards the fire at this, but his eyes seemed blacker now than Flomi had noticed them before. The disarming manner that the dwarf had seen earlier now had vanished and, with this third question of their conversation, Flomi then felt a new openness in the black rider that he found to be... disconcerting. As he considered it now along his walk to safety, it quite nearly terrified him.
‘He is the Eldest of his folk to remain in Mortal Lands,’ the rider said as he gazed deeply into the hearth’s small blaze. ‘What would it be like to look into those eyes? I wonder.’ And there was deep silence between them now, on a cold day before a fire when the world seemed uncertain.
‘But this was not precisely your question, master Stonemason,’ the rider then said, turning his eyes back to Flomi and taking another longer drink of his wine. ‘“Is there no hope to be found in the Elves?” you asked me, and that is a very old question indeed. Very, very old.
‘Dwarves have never sought such help of course, so I can only imagine that you ask on behalf of your townsfolk, these men and hobbits, and that is a very neighborly position to take in this moment. Quite companionable. I commend you for it. Is there more wine?’ he said then, rather suddenly smiling.
‘Why, yes,’ Flomi said, ‘certainly, traveler. Allow me.’ He took the cup from the rider then and filled it again from the small cask by the table. But this time he did not turn his back on the man. ‘Here you are.’
‘I thank you, master,’ the rider said, ‘and I accept this kindness as freely given. Now, as to that third question,’ and at this he settled comfortably back into his seat, crossing his long leather-clad boots before him, and took another small sip of the wine.
‘Throughout the Onslaught of Angmar, the Elves of Lindon under Círdan supported the ragged remnants of old Arnor and its squabbling kings. They assisted Arveleg and the men of Cardolan to drive off the wild Hill-men and, for a time, diverted the wrathful tide flowing out of Carn Dûm, which Men call the Red Maw. And for a time that line held. For a time.
‘But Elves are fickle and caring little for the protection of Men, Elves make poor jailers. They wandered, as they will, back to their shores or into their forests. And so the onslaught came again and Arveleg was killed and Amon Sûl was thrown down and then the line was moved again. Later and with Círdan’s help again, Arveleg's young son, Araphor, drove Angmar's armies from Fornost and the North Downs. Combining forces with Rivendell, and the Galadhrim who joined them from beyond the Misty Mountains, they pushed forward and the line was moved again. And for a time Angmar was silent. For a time.’
‘For many hundred of years that was, rider,’ Flomi said, ‘a time only, yes, but a good measure of it in the lives of Men.’
‘And now I commend you on your knowledge of the history of my race, master Stonemason,’ the rider said with a wry smile, ‘long years it was but a poor time in the lives of Men indeed. Pestilence and famine ruled the land, not king nor Elf-lord. Wights then walked in open lands made desolate by drought and blight. Men survived by shutting themselves away from others. Your own people, heartier than most, saw this as an opportunity no doubt, for Dwarves have never placed much trust in Men and likely preferred the Roads free of them for a time. But where were the Eldar? They suffered not from Pestilence, but did they hold the line still?
‘And all that time Angmar waited. For the Witch-king is deathless as Círdan is, so what care should either have for the brief lives of Men? You ask of hope from Elves now, but what hope did they offer then? Again I ask you, is it not sad? That the valor of the North could be let to wither simply because there is no hand to tend it? And you ask if there is hope to be found in the Elves.’
The rider remained silent for a time, and Flomi did not interrupt that silence. Beside him on the table was his satchel, half-filled with the papers he had begun to put away, his open inkwell and three different brushes for marking. Flomi’s wine glass was in his hand, but he paid little notice of it as ever. In his other hand he held a small piece of carpenter’s plumbago,12 rarely used in his works, but he stroked it often, liking the familiar smoothness of its texture to his hand. He could feel the warmth of the fire beside them, but also a growing coldness around the stranger who sat before him. He thought to stoke the fire, to perhaps add another log, for now he noticed a chill in the room that he had not felt before. But he let the fire burn and he waited for the rider to finish.
‘Círdan offers hope,’ he said finally in a slow and deliberate voice, ‘and calls for the North People to stand. He sends his ships along the coast to Forochel in hope that Elendil’s heir Arvedui may be found and returned to a hopeful people. That is the “hope” he offers; the return of a defeated king, the questionable heir of a sundered line, to a routed folk who have no strongholds left, so that they might stand against all manner of dark men and creatures that pour forth from Angmar. That they might stand and hold a line that he and his own people have many times forsaken while they take their Long Retreat to Lands-Beyond-the-Seas. That is the only hope this town, and all the North, can expect from the Elves; that they will be used to block the tide so others might escape to lands from which we are forbidden.
‘I have said it before, master Stonemason,’ he said smiling and then taking another small sip of his wine, ‘it is an interesting time to be a Dwarf in the wider world, but it is a poor time to be a Man of the North.’
And so the coldness Flomi had felt in the room entered into his heart. He had been engrossed in the puzzle of the translation for most of his life, and certainly the quiet time he had spent here in the Bree-land had not made him think much of the larger world. But he could not deny the feeling of truth in the rider’s words nor could he ignore the fear they caused within him. He took another long drink of wine against the coldness.
‘Hope, nor tales filled with hope, I cannot bring to you, master Stonemason,’ the rider said. ‘Bards are a better cure than travelers for dark thoughts on cold nights, and I am no bard.
‘But,’ he said then with a smile, returning to the easier though commanding tone of voice, ‘I can offer you some small thing, if you’d like it, in answer to the fair wine and fire that you’ve offered me. A simple thing really, but you might find some use for it.’
At this he reached into a pocket on his breast and drew forth a small wooden rod with a metallic tip. He held it forward in his right hand for Flomi to see; the tube ended in a fluted nib made of brass, but formed into a shape and manner Flomi had not seen before. More peculiar, the rod itself seemed hollow yet natural, a wood that he had never seen before.
‘Is it a pen?’ he asked. Yet he did not take it from the rider’s hand.
‘Yes,’ the rider replied. ‘The wood is called Acidosasa I am told, and holds ink just as a well might do, feeding it into the nib as pressure demands. I’ve no hand for this kind of work, nor use for such fine implements myself,’ he said smiling, ‘and one seldom meets travelers in this bare land who have the skill. Will you take it,’ the rider asked, ‘as payment for the wine and the fire?’
Flomi reached forward and took the item from the rider’s open hand.
‘I thank you, traveler,’ he said without hesitation and what he believed to be proper graciousness, ‘it is a fascinating tool, and I look forward to trying it.’
At this they both raised their wine and drank deeply. After which the rider eased back into his chair, studying Flomi’s face intently. ‘Now,’ he said smiling, ‘ it is my turn for questioning, I believe.’
*****
‘The animals seem at ease here,’ Collum said to the others after seeing to Caitelyn and her new friend. Bingo Greenhands’ horse was a great roan gelding with a mixed coat of chestnut and white. If he had a name then, Milo had not shared it and Collum had not heard tell of it. But he seemed to be happy out here in the open land, in fact both the horses seemed content to stand off in the cool of the trees and munch on grasses; but Ben’s pony would not leave his side as the group of travelers settled into the glade to talk.
‘We have made better time than I hoped,’ the man said, ‘so now we can spare a little of it to talk more openly.’ He sat down on the saddle that Milo had left amongst the provisions and encouraged the others to do the same in that friendly way that Ben had become so accustomed to. The three old wizards, however, remained standing.
‘I think we should begin with your town’s stonemason, Ohtar,’ Alatar said, ‘for that seems to be who we are following. Tell us, what strange circumstance brings a Dwarven rune-master into such an unusual role?’
‘Flomi, and the other scribes of his family,’ Collum began, ‘have a long entanglement with the line of Isildur here in the North, Oldfather. Their contract to Arnor stretches back through many generations of my family, though how that may be measured against the lives of dwarves I cannot say. For much of that time they have worked on their own, as is their way, translating and deciphering text of secret matters from our heritage that others thought forgotten. But forty years ago some of those secrets became revealed suddenly and Trochi of the Blue Mountains, Flomi’s father and predecessor, came to the Bree-land to discover more. My family has protected them here ever since.’
‘A dwarf master of letters I might believe, Innkeeper,’ Tawarengil said, ‘for it said that the Naugrim have many secret skills and a love of history is among them. But a lore-master who spends his days cutting stone for farmers? This seems quite incredible!’
‘I don’t understand, Tawar,’ Beothalion said, sitting on the grass beside him. ‘I have heard of the dwarves, though I have not yet met one. But what are runes? Are they writing? You have shown me this thing, and it seems to be a marvel, but I have no head for writing. Is the dwarf a master of writing? Is this what they call runes?’
Pallando came forward again and replied to this. ‘No, young one, rune-craft is not the writing of signposts that you have seen nor even the recording of song that your friend here may have shown you. Many might mistake it as such. But runes are...’ he paused here for a long moment, closing his sea-green eyes in thought. ‘Tell me, young one, do you talk to the friends and ancestors that have been carved into your belt?’
At this idea Beothalion looked down to his waist and the belt, the only piece of ornament which he wore. Ben looked too, for he had noticed it before but had not wished to comment with so many other mysteries at hand. The belt appeared to be very old, much, much older than the wildman himself did, and the tooled-leather had an intricate design of crudely rendered animals and the faces of Men. ‘Ancestors’ the wizard had called them and now, noticing things this way, Ben saw a great likeness between these rough, hairy faces and that of the gentle wildman that he had come to know in the past day. They were stern, these graven faces, much sterner than Beothalion’s nature according to how Ben saw it, but they were clearly his People. It was at this moment, and for the very first (if not the last) time that Ben thought about the power he had seen in his new friend; and how he would very much not like to see him when he was angry.13
Beothalion thought for a long moment and even Tawarengil, who seemed very impatient with all of these stories which only stalled his original purpose, looked thoughtfully at his friend.
‘It is the belt of my fathers,’ he said, wrinkling his brow as if this question asked deeper questions that he himself had a mind to do. ‘And so I do talk to the faces there. In times. Alone. "Privately," you call it?’
‘Yes,’ Collum said, looking deeply at the wildman but with a care he had not shown openly before. ‘Privately is our word.’
‘Privately, then,’ Beothalion said, ‘But I think that the word I want would be... deeper somehow.14 But, yes, friend, I do talk with them, In times.’
‘And do they answer you when you speak? Do you hear their voices?’ Pallando asked.
‘No. They do not. Though I would wish it might happen,’ Beothalion said with an empty, almost sad, look to his eyes.
‘That is the difference between a rune and a writing, young one,’ Pallando said. ‘And I deeply hope for you that someday you should come to hear the voices of your ancestors.
‘But we speak of rune-craft now,’ he said, turning toward the others, ‘it is a much, much older art than many imagine and the Eldar and the Edain do not practice it in this age of the world. I am glad to hear that the Khazâd still do, toward whatever purpose.’
‘Well, certainly not to the purpose of the People of Arnor,’ Olórin said, ‘and it is certainly not something that they would practice nor reveal outside their own fortified halls. No, Pallando, I think that this dwarf’s skill with history and letters might be more important to Isildur’s heirs than his deeper knowledge of the Flame of Aulë.’15
‘And in this you would be right, Greyfather,’ Collum replied. ‘There are old texts, revealed again in our- or, I should say, mine own- lifetime which open deeper histories for my People. Flomi and his sires have been a part of that mystery since its beginnings.’
‘And he fled?’ Alatar said. ‘Before the killing at the stables, you believe. What was the cause of this?’
‘Many signs of gathered attention since Fornost fell,’ Collum said, ‘but, moreover, six weeks ago, while I was away, a black rider came to the Bree-land.’
*****
And now Flomi knew, finally, what the rider had meant by ‘keeping the Old Customs’; for he had offered his fire (meager and inconsequential in springtime as it seemed), he had offered his stock (the common and rather poor red winyard that was served as the house wine here at the Four Greenfields) and he had asked his questions to an unnamed traveler; he had shown kindness to the man, which was fair custom, but until now had not considered it as transactional. In accepting the gift of the writing implement Flomi had not considered the meaning; he had completed the transaction of materials. Now he must answer to the established transaction of the questions he had asked and allow the traveler three of his own. They had made a Bargain.
Now it should be said here that the Old Rules of Customs, much like the Importance of Threes themselves, was not something to be found recorded anywhere in the writings of Men, Dwarves, Elves or (though it might seem the more surprising) even Hobbits. No one could step back from an implied transaction, look at a document, and cite the conditions neatly nor could one establish their very relative and very often case-specific usage. No arbiters could argue scope or violation, no tribal-heads nor governors could complain about the limits of their jurisdiction, and, even more importantly, everyone who lived in the West of Middle-earth at this age of the world, knew they were bound by these Rules even if they could not, with any true certainty, recite them. It was not exactly correct to think of them as archaic or forgotten, because they lived very much inside the everyday cordiality of all the Peoples of that part of the world. But they were not a known equation, not a matter of historical record or law, and as such they were very important in their observance.
Flomi, who knew the histories and the laws of this part of the world better than most, did not need any such document; he knew that he was now bound to the rider. Flomi had given material gifts and asked three questions. Now, with the writing implement, he had taken a material gift in return and, again in return, he was indebted to answer three questions; a Bargain. It surprised him to be caught in this way and he knew, quite certainly, that there was danger here; for what else could be said of such a clever trap in such an unexpected place on such a dark and unseasonable night. But now, seeing with awake-eyes the danger that the other Breelanders had only sniffed at, Flomi felt ready to face it.
‘Ah. Yes. As it should be, rider,’ he said, hoping the resolute tone of his voice would make him appear bolder, ‘for Custom is important to chance-meetings like ours, is it not? But...’ Flomi paused here for a long moment to let the rider’s anticipation mount.
‘Yes?’ the rider said, his impatience showing for the first time.
‘Well, it seems that you set conditions on our talk from the first, offering to “tell me no tales.” Yes. Well, I thank you for that,’ Flomi said, ‘for you are correct; tales are untrustworthy things and your news of the world served me much better. But I live without news here in the Bree-land, and I also stand at a great distance from my People and their tales, as you may surmise. Yet I have a deep love of histories.
'So.
‘I can offer no news for your questions, having none of importance in such a small town, nor tell you no tales for your questions, for they would prove untrustworthy by your own esteem. So I will give you only histories in response.
‘It may seem weary and unfortunate to you, I’m afraid,’ Flomi said, ‘but I am also no bard nor traveler. I have only history to disclose.’ As the fire in the hearth burned low between them the two figures looked long to one another’s eyes; each unflinching.
‘Very well, master Stonemason,’ the black rider finally said. ‘Let us start with your history.’
*****
‘I was not present at this time,’ Collum continued, ‘for clues and evidence in our task often comes from far sources and I had established the habit of riding out of town monthly to discover any new information and meet with other folk of my kindred who were tasked in collecting it. So I did not see this man myself...’
His voice trailed off here for a moment, uncharacteristic of Collum, or so Ben thought, and he was uncertain as to what motivated it. But the moment did not last.
‘But I am certain,’ he said finally, ‘that this man was not an insignificant ruffian out of Angmar nor even some lieutenant who happened upon the Bree-land quite by mistake. No. His manner was wiser than that, his language, though I heard it not myself, more precise, and his cunning sharper than fine-honed steel. I have met men like this on the battlefield and, mighty as they may be, they are far more dangerous in conversations in commonrooms. No. I am convinced that the Black Númenóreans ride now openly in the North and they are aware of Flomi’s work.
‘That, my lord Tawarengil, is who follows my friend, who directed my other friend Guldir’s murder, and who called for the torch at our stables last night,’ Collum said, looking straight at the young Elf-lord’s eyes as if daring him to have a remark.
‘Fathers, masters,’ he said, looking to the others with an imploring face as the sun began to slide closer to the treetops in the west, ‘I am oath-bound, for eight generations of my family’s honor, to not disclose the story of Flomi’s work. Some of you, I think, guess at its importance. I may not, by word nor nod nor other gesture, confirm your guesses. But this I know; he is followed by no mere cutthroat nor arsonist. They have decided to come for him. It may be that the appearance of so many great peoples at our quiet little inn last night forced their hands. I had not expected any of you, yet in the week before I had prepared us both to leave quickly. Yet they have come fast for whatever reason, and right on our heels. I know in my heart that Flomi and his work are not safe and, when we have concluded with our talk, I must fly to his aid.
‘Any may join me and, certainly, those who do will learn more. Those who will not are forgiven for their curiosity if they will forgive me for my caution.’ And at this he looked straight toward Tawarengil, standing now to emphasize his point.
‘But I will tell you all,’ he said looking deeply into the Elf-lord’s eyes, ‘that Flomi, son of Trochi, holds the true hope of the north realm of Arnor in his hands, unexpected as that may sound. Círdan may call all the free-People, but will they come? If the Witch-king could be pushed back, if Fornost could be retaken, would it matter? Could we Men of the North hold these lands again? No.
‘Friends, I am a soldier from a line of soldiers and I believe that the North is lost and that our future is uncertain. It is our history that matters.
‘Will you help me to save it?’
*****
‘Accch! History is not personal, traveler,’ Flomi replied, almost chuckling at his having stymied the rider, ‘and the history of the Dwarves, as a learned man like yourself might already know, is a secret. So it must be the history of my time in this town that you wish. Very well.
‘I am still quite young as it goes with dwarves in the wider world, for I have seen only one hundred and thirteen moonrises.16 Most of my people do not venture forth at my early age. But I was precocious as a lad and remain that way even through today. I came to this town some three decades ago to continue my father’s work. He too was a stonemason.’
‘Indeed,’ the rider said, smiling. ‘Charming. I have seen very few works of stone in this little village, however. I should think two generations of stout dwarves might make a fortress of a place like this.’
‘Oh, there is good stone here in the neighboring hills for any of my People to find,’ Flomi said, ‘but the Big Folk of the Bree-land are not good builders and the Little Folk, while quite industrious in their way, are hole-dwellers and seldom need much from me. My work here for the town affords me a little income and all the comforts I might need, but with little effort nor cause for ambition. So,’ Flomi said, smiling to himself as if he thought he found a particularly useful response, ‘I turn my spare hours to histories, which I love, and even the collecting of tales, which you, admittedly, do not.’
‘From the comfort of a cozy fire and a roadside inn, tales might seem like histories, master Stonemason,’ the rider said, smiling back, ‘but travel in the wider world often disproves this and may disappoint.’
‘As you say,’ Flomi replied. ‘I am a rather more suspicious audience for tales than these Breelanders of course, and care little for their local histories. But do I hear a second question in that, rider?’ Flomi asked.
‘No, no,’ the rider said, ‘I will take your comfort here by the fire as answer enough. But,’ he said, getting up and drawing more wine from the cask in preparation of his next question and filling Flomi’s cup as well, ‘I would like more history, real or no, from this little niche of the North. Now the Nogothrim tell no histories of themselves, as you have said, but perhaps you have other histories of my own people in these lands that might amuse me?’ And at this he lifted his glass a bit inviting Flomi to do the same.
‘Acchhh,’ Flomi said, lifting his glass in return and, carefully, taking the very smallest sip of his wine without letting his eyes leave the rider’s, ‘the glories of these People have fallen, rider, just as you say. I know little, nor care little, for the sundered and squabbling kings of this land. And no dwarf, nor elf I should imagine, would feel otherwise; for they were nothing but sad relics of former glories to our eyes. Sad, yes, because they were great once indeed; the North Kingdom of Arnor before the Great War in the South brought a lasting peace to these lands that profited dwarf and elf and man.
‘You say that we saw opportunity in the Years of Plague, that we were happy to find less Men on the Road, but this is not so. Hardier we Dwarves are, true, and less imperiled by this pestilence than Man or Hobbit, but not as safe on our way as we had been when Elendil’s true heirs held sway in the North. In the days of my greatsires the people of the Blue Mountains and, aye, even of the distant Iron Hills which now seem so remote, traded openly with Men and even Elves (though our grievances there are older and might never be resolved). Before Hollin fell to the south we had trade with the Eldar, but Sauron destroyed that peaceful kingdom long ago, and our western gate became shut for more than an age. Histories tell it now remains so. But, through the Road we traveled again, while Men held it, and all three of the kindred held great relations together again.
‘For a time,’ Flomi said sadly. ‘While Men of the North held the Road.’
There was a long silence between the two then and each took another small sip of wine. After much time the rider spoke. ‘Sad, I say again, that the valor of the North could be left to wither so simply,’ but there was a darkness in his eyes as he said it, though they never left the fire, and his voice remained cold.
‘One last question then, master Stonemason,’ he said, ‘as you seemed to have taken much of the news that I gave to you and turned it to histories.’ At this he stood from his chair and drew closer to the fire, his ungloved left hand holding his goblet up and his right hooked in the center of his swordbelt. He smiled lightly to Flomi’s direction, but his eyes shot quickly towards the entrance to the commonroom and then back to the dwarf.
‘It has been a merry meeting and I hope that my reliance on the Old Customs has not proved too disarming on such an unseasonable night,’ he said, ‘for I have, truthfully, enjoyed our talk much more than I do this horrid wine.’ At this he tipped his mug a final time and smiled very broadly.
Flomi laughed at this, nervously perhaps, and then drank with him. And the rider asked his final question:
‘I travel north soon,’ he said, ‘and I seek... things of history. Old things of my People. Tell me, master, in all your histories of the North, have you heard of “The River Gliding which leaves these inland realms”?’17
Light had not yet come up in the eastern sky as Flomi neared the seven birch trees. Perhaps further behind him it had come to the hills and less wooded areas. He could hear birdsong back away in that direction and the stirrings of morning that these things might, on any other day, peacefully herald. The seven birches stood tall and white before him, so tall in fact that he doubted dawn was far from reaching their uppermost branches. He now knew, though he had not even guessed a week ago when first he had come here, that he was in terrible danger. He now knew that his father, and his greatsires before him and every dwarf in his family since they had first become involved with the Princess of Arnor, had been in a terrible danger that he had never foreseen. He knew what he should have guessed on that night six weeks before when the black rider had come to the Bree-land; that he was watched and measured by the Enemy. He was now certain that the work, which he had formerly found to be only challenging and amusing and a legacy of his family, was of grave importance to Great Powers.
‘So,’ he said to himself, ‘this is their war, Men. But it is our history. I should very much like to have known the truth of it earlier, but now I see how the concerns run deeper. Collum is stead-fast, a friend who will protect me, and our place of defense is secured. He will join me soon and, together, with full openness regarding the severity of the situation, we will, I am convinced, solve the puzzle of our ancestors.’
And then, aloud in the darkness, as if mustering himself, he said, ‘and woe be to those who will hinder us in this task!’
If the sound of his voice informed the hunters he did not know. He did not hear a cry of command or the snap of bowstring, or the wrishing of the air before the first arrow hit him full in the back.
End of Chapter Five
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter Five
1) This is a bastardization of the name “Hödekin (also spelled Hödeken, Hüdekin, and Hütchen)”, a kobold (house spirit) of German folklore. According to the legend recorded by folklorist Thomas Keightley in 1850, Hödekin always wore a felt hat down over his face and was a helpful little sprite; his name means "Little Hat". For reasons we’ll see later, this connection is important.
2) Oh, I couldn’t resist. “What’s the rumpus?” is, of course, a quote from the Coen Brothers' film MILLER’S CROSSING, but rumpus itself seems such a Tolkien word, such a Hobbit-like word, that I needed to work it in here somewhere.
3) The Númenóreans do not have surnames and were often given the names of respected predecessors. Men would be given the name of their fathers only if they were of a great lineage. My supposition here is that the man who returned Narsil and brought with him the tale of Isildur’s death was given great honor and the label of soldier indeed became a title carried by his sons.
4) Tawarengil is helping Ben and the rest of us here by translating Eärendur’s name. But he may just be showing off his Quenya.
5) For my purposes here Rosie should be recognizing Ben’s voice from about half a mile off. This would be about 800 ragnar. Measures of distance in most cases are converted as nearly as possible into modern terms within Tolkien’s work. "League" is used often because it was the longest measurement of distance: in Númenórean reckoning (which was decimal) five thousand rangar (full paces) made a lár, which was very nearly three of our miles. Lár meant "pause," because except in forced marches a brief halt was usually made after this distance had been covered. The Númenórean ranga, which comes from the Quenya word for “stride” was slightly longer than our yard, approximately thirty-eight inches, owing to their great stature. Therefore five thousand rangar would be almost exactly the equivalent of 5280 yards, our "league.”
6) Here it seems necessary to insert some discussion of runes as we think of them and how that might apply to Tolkien’s legendarium; for, rather simply put, I do not believe that the written languages of western Middle- earth (other than the secret language of the Dwarves) was runic. Indeed, in every Germanic language, the word “rune” (from Proto-Germanic runo) means both “letter” and “secret” or “mystery,” and its original meaning, which likely predated the adoption of the runic alphabet, may have been simply “(hushed) message.” I’ll deal with this later in the writing, but it should be clear to every Tolkien fan that most languages in the Second and Third Age, even the language of Mordor, used Elvish script and letters of an Elvish alphabet to convey messages. We see it even in the Black Speech on the Ring itself. So Flomi is speaking to some other part of the material that is more purely pictographic or runic. But, again, this will become more clear as we move the story forward.
7) This little aside about the Dwarves and the East is based on the idea, from The Silmarillion, that the “evil” Dwarf-lords of the First Age had come out of the East.
8) Malbeth can be found in the appendix for LoTR of course and was counselor to Araphant, the 14th king of Arthedain. He made two very significant prophesies regarding the North kingdom and his role in this story is somewhat expanded beyond those.
9) The term “grandsire” among the Dwarves is not to be confused with “grandfather” as is often the case with other races. In regard to Flomi’s family this goes many generations back, but also carries a more specific relationship that we will learn more about later.
10) “Forgive me, little horse. I greet you (informal). I am Beothalion.” -from Sindarin.
11) This quote can be found in the first book of The History of Middle-earth and comes from a passage of Tolkien’s earliest writings for the legendarium; a section linking "The Cottage of Lost Play" with "The Song of the Ainur."
12) An archaic name for graphite that, to my ears, sounds rather Dwarvish.
13) Yes, The Hulk TV show. But, again, this is fan-fic and I simply cannot not resist the occasional Easter Egg.
14) I’ve always been attracted to how Tolkien, as a devout Christian, handles the subject and practice of his faith in the Legendarium. This subject will, of course, come up again, but this seemed an appropriate spot to deal with it in regard to the customs of Beothalion’s people; those among him in the party seem to recognize the idea “prayer” in his talk of “private” conversation with his ancestors.
15) Rune-craft, as might be obvious to readers at this point, will play a large part in the story. But I refer to it here as a principle skill granted to the Dwarves by their maker.
16) We know from the Hobbit that the Dwarven Calendar is lunar based (like the Hebrew one). Unlike the Hebrew calendar, the Dwarven New Year starts on Durin’s Day, which is the day that begins the last cycle of the Moon. When on this day both the Sun and Moon may be seen in the sky together. That places Durin’s Day, anytime between about Oct. 7 and Nov. 6, on the last day before the astronomical new moon as the moon sets just before the sun.
17) This is a clue to our deeper mystery, so I will not say much. But, for those Tolkien detectives out there, it comes from a poem in "The Cottage of Lost Play" and can be found in the History of Middle-Earth Vol. I
Chapter Six; "Flight to the Foundations"
-In Which a Long Forgotten Passageway is Revealed and Harrowing Battle with Orcs Ensues
Read Chapter Six; "Flight to the Foundations"
The arrow hit high on the left side of his back and instantly Flomi heard the cry of many harsh voices. ‘Orcs!’ he said to himself. ‘Of course there would be orcs!’
How many he could not tell as he darted to the cover of the nearest tree. It was less than an hour or so before the dawn and he was just outside of the glade of Seven Birches. If he could reach it safely, he might hold the entranceway of the Foundations against many foes. Surely it was a small band from the sound of them. But looking back to the east, the way he had come, he could now see some of them rushing towards him in the pre-dawn light. They were still some eighty ranga off; too far for any orc-bow he had heard of. That meant there might be others about, hunters of that group, skulking amid the trees. There was some cover here, and solid ground on which he might make a good stand against more than a few of these horrid creatures; but he would have no defense against the archers once they had time to reposition. Drawing his maddock1 into his hand he decided to run for the entrance to the Foundations and make a proper stand there.
*****
When Flomi and Collum had first come to the glade six days ago there was brilliant sunshine and firm ground to ease their steps. Collum had been quite outspoken earlier, discussing the history of the land in ways that he never had at the inn. But Flomi’s mention of the Princess had clearly upset him. His mood had turned sullen and impatient. Walking into the Glade of Seven Birches on that bright day seemed to immediately refresh him. He gazed up at the tall, straight trunks of those great trees with a smile on his face and light in his eyes, as if wrapped in some fair memory. He drew a long breath and spoke words in the tongue of the Númenóreans which few remember;
‘Balîk hazad an-Nimruzîr azûlada...’2 he said. And returning out of his thoughts he looked back to Flomi, saying, ‘Come. Here to the center of this glade. Can you note this stone here?’
‘Yes, certainly,’ Flomi replied, ‘it is like to those on the wall. Ah! I begin to understand. Too small for a doorway I should think. Is it some kind of lock mechanism?’
‘Nothing so secure as that, I’m afraid,’ Collum said. ‘Remember, we are on this side of the wall and that is called Rammas Armaro, the “neighbour wall,” which is only a border between the interior of the realm of Arnor and the open, free lands between here and the Gulf of Lhûn. The wall was not built for defence here as it was away to the north, and the place to which we are going, though long forgotten by most, was never meant to be entirely secret.
‘Stand here,’ he continued, ‘at this sightingstone, and look due west through the glade.’
Flomi did as he was asked, and from that vantage he could see that the mighty trees, which seemed to form an otherwise perfect and cultivated circle around the glade, left a narrow opening that revealed the wall, now some thirty or forty paces from where he stood. Moreover, the boughs of the westernmost birch trees seemed to point directly toward a single spot on the face of the wall.
‘The entranceway is just there,’ Collum said, pointing with an outstretched hand. ‘At dawn the cast shadows of the trees mark it clearly, but one who knows what to look for can see it from here at any time of day. Remember that section of wall and make straight toward it from here.
‘I can show you this now,’ he continued, ‘for it is most likely that you will next come here alone, and not necessarily with the dawn. The door itself is cunningly hid, so none might find it who does not know where to look. Use this sightingstone when you come here again.’
*****
Making it to the sightingstone, let alone the protection of the entranceway, was still quite uncertain. At a glance Flomi had seen maybe four or five figures running towards him. He had no idea where the archer might be, and no clear idea whether or not he could open the door before they were all upon him. Orcs were said to be very quick at a run and Flomi had never been tested in this way against them. In point of fact, he had never been tested at all when it came to orcs or to fighting them. There had always been great animosity between the Dwarves and the Goblins, but the two had not, at this time in the Third Age, had any sustained nor open confrontations for many an years.3
All of Durin’s folk who go abroad in the world are extremely hardy in battle, but Flomi was younger than most who did, and not a seasoned warrior. Though it was long years since his skill with a bow had been tested he was quite well trained with the use of his maddock and, though he had never fought in such circumstances until this very moment, the fury of his people was on him.
‘Abrâfu shaikmashâz!’4 Flomi cried loudly into night as he broke from cover and sprinted through to the glade of Seven Birches. ‘Follow if you dare!' he cried. 'I shall show you the hardness of Dwarven steel.’
There was renewed noise at this, and Flomi knew there were more assailants now than the four or five he had seen; perhaps as many as a dozen. He could not take the time to look back however, for if he slowed his pace even for a step he risked another arrow. ‘I’ll likely have no time for mail nor helm even if I reach the entranceway, but that narrow hallway or inner door can be held. I must-‘ an arrow flew past him on the left and then, an instant afterwards, a second to his right.
‘Two archers, then, at the least,’ he now knew, ‘but they are firing in haste. To the wall!’
He came full into the center of the glade and, as his foot hit the sightingstone and with the moon still out and his memory of the last time still quite clear, Flomi pivoted to his right and due west through what he saw as the opening of the trees, fixing his eye on the spot Collum had shown him. There was another near miss from a bowshot and now he could see short, broad figures just outside the glade moving at great speed and without caution. He poured all of his strength into his running and shifted the maddock into his right hand. The wall was now but twenty or thirty paces ahead. Behind him he could hear the orc-band forming up into a line at the edge of the clearing, certain that their quarry was trapped.
‘Hah!’ Flomi thought to himself, ‘that strategy will cost them. For now if I can just get the door open quickly, I will—‘ It was at this point that the second arrow, accompanied by a searing pain, bit into the flesh of his lower leg.
*****
‘Here is the entranceway to a forgotten place,’ Collum had said as they stood together before the wall on that bright afternoon six days past. ‘Can you see it?’ he asked.
‘I confess that I cannot,’ Flomi said, finding himself surprised in this. ‘It is cunningly hidden indeed, even in a wall this ancient and in such disrepair...
‘Ah!’ he said after long minutes studying the area, ‘there is an edge here, I believe, but hidden in a way that I did not think Men knew of.’
Collum smiled at this. ‘Perhaps we no longer know it, my friend,’ he said, smiling, ‘but once we knew much that is now forgotten. This place was built some two thousand years ago, you should remember, and it was the craftsmen of Númenor who then fashioned it. Many of their secret ways have been lost to my People here in the North.’
‘Hmmmn,’ Flomi mouthed thoughtfully as he further examined the stonework and the area around it. ‘There is no indication of lock nor mechanism. Yes, this could easily sit untested for long years. Was it meant as a hiding place for arms or supplies?’
‘No,’ Collum said, ‘nothing so secretive. For it was, in the time of its use, a thing known to many but used only by a few. The hiding of its appearance was not meant as a secret but as a kindness. There may be written accounts of it, but I have heard nothing of them. Perhaps your work will tell us. Soldiers knew of it, and the soldiers who were my grandsires most specifically. It has been used by us from time to time since the old days of Arnor as a safe haven. But in Elendil’s time it was open to all of our people, though its need diminished when so many of our folk died in the War against Sauron.
‘And so it was forgotten by the Men of the North,’ he continued, ‘yet another relic of greater days.
‘The mechanism is somewhat high I’m afraid, for the folk of old Númenor were tall in stature, but it is here. Mark you!’
At this he raised his right arm above his head and placed it firmly on the cold stone of the wall. A small grinding noise was heard and slowly a small patch of the old stones divided and swung inward, inch by inch, until both doors lay against the inner walls. Through the opening a shadowy stair of many wide landings could be seen turning north and downward inside of the rock. Flomi starred in wonder.5
‘This is a door to the place we call Tauma, or the Foundations,’ Collum said. ‘It is a forgotten roadway of old Arnor used to move people or supplies rapidly as needed. I have not explored it deeply, nor has anyone that I know of for many generations. But here we will be safe and remain hidden for a time until I can best decide our next course of action.’
*****
The pain in his leg as the arrow struck was quite sudden and intense, causing Flomi to drop to one knee. This brought a great howling of laughter from the orcs.
‘Har!’ he could hear one of them cry above the others, ‘you might have hard sharp steel, little ratling, but weak legs for running! Better for roasting, wouldn’t you say, fellows?’
More howls and cheers behind him at this, spreading out now so that their quarry could not slip past. ‘Perhaps a dozen,’ Flomi thought. ‘I cannot fight them here.’ With a great effort he shut the pain from his mind and, using the maddock as a crutch, thrust himself up and towards the wall. ‘Less than twenty paces,’ he thought, centering himself on the task and the task alone just as any of his worthy sires might have done, ‘only that, and then we shall see.’
Now it should be said that very little of Dwarvish hardiness and ferocity was well known by the peoples of the North in this age of the world; not by orcs or hobbits or even well-traveled men like Collum Gilleyfoil. Perhaps the Elves remembered and respected them for it, but the history of Elves and Dwarves is complicated and not a thing which they share openly with others. Dwarves did not fight in the Last Alliance against Sauron and had shuttered the gates of their great halls for many thousands of years by this time. There were legends of their great military prowess certainly, but these were from long ages past and none had seen nor heard of a Dwarven army in many of the lives of men. If they had enemies far away in their mountain kingdoms, if they marched against dragons or trolls or other dark things in the earth, no one had ever made reports of it anywhere near the Bree-land.
For dwarves are not by their nature a warlike race as many have, now in our later days, come to regard them. No indeed. They are craftsmen at their heart and as such they have a smith’s appreciation for and a maker’s skillful use with the weapons of their own hands. For it was weapons, fabulously wrought and bearing great powers, that were very high in the art of those people and every dwarf who ever held a forgehammer knew well how to wield a sword; and, of course, there were very few dwarves who had not been raised to hold a forgehammer.
But who would know this in all of the Northlands at this time and in this age of the world? For so it was to most people of those days that dwarves were known as tradesmen and builders, travelers and peddlers (some called them quietly) along Roads that were now the home of Men. They were armed surely, and traveled together in groups more often than not, but they were aloof when seen and generally pleasant enough when spoken to. If they were troubled by bandits, well, no Breelanders had ever heard a bandit tell of besting a dwarf.
It would be many long years before the orcs of the North would fully realize the power and ferociousness of Dwarven armies united against them. But on this night, in this spot near the edge of the ancient wall of Arnor, this small and hapless orc-band would be given a glimpse of the power of the Khazâd at battle.
*****
Once the doors had opened Collum stepped forward into the entranceway. ‘There is another stone here,’ he said, ‘just to the right of the door and at the same height. It will close slowly but, I caution you, it is not a buttress. This place remains secret and I believe it will serve our purpose, but it is not built against attack.’
‘Yes, I see,’ Flomi replied as he continued to examine the ingenious concealment of the doors. ‘It has but a thin layer of stone over lighter wood frames to make the drawing smoother and the fit easier. It is quite clever!’
‘There is nothing here at this landing for defense,’ Collum said, continuing his overview of the place and its military potential, ‘but I placed some items down along the turn of the stair that might hold if we are pursued. As you can see, this is an open lane, meant for transport of men and baggage.’
‘Hmm, there is an inscription here,’ Flomi said, his eyes sharp in the darkness and attentive to such details. He was kneeling low where the inner door met the wall on the left side of the entranceway. ‘I cannot read it; it has the old script, but if the words are Númenórean they are beyond my learning. Still-’ He took a moment to reach into the bag he carried at his side and drew from it a slender roll of thin parchment about a foot in width. He spread this across the area, holding it in place deftly with one hand. Then, with the other hand, he produced from his breast pocket a stick of plumbago and ran it briskly over the surface of the parchment, making an impression of the letters.
‘I do not know these words either, nor their style,’ Collum said softly, his eyes now looking sharply at their surroundings, ‘and I have not noticed them before. They are low to the entrance and away in shadow. Men’s eyes do not adjust to shadow as rapidly as yours, my friend. They may have sat here many long years and gone unnoticed by many before me.’ At this he strode softly to the stair head, placing his hand upon his sword hilt and listening intently. ‘Or,’ he said, with the softest of whispers, ‘they may be recent.’
‘Oh! Certainly they are not,’ Flomi replied with half of a laugh at his friend’s caution. ‘No, no. There is dust settled here into the larger markings and, as you say, this is a language understood by very few folk in a thousand or more years. No, I thank you for your guardianship,’ Flomi said casually, ‘but this is only just another wonderful mystery of your hall. I look forward to solving it in the days ahead!’
And he would (with help unlooked for) solve it, given proper time (though the answer should prove more troubling than he had ever expected), but to do so he would need to reach the safety of that entranceway once again, wounded and with a small band of orcs at his naked back.
*****
‘Will he climb, lads?’ came the deep voice of an orc-captain behind him. ‘Or will the little ratling dig his way under that wall? Har! He’ll have troubles digging once we cut those dirty hands from his arms!’
Flomi heard this all with great clarity, for he was in deep concentration, moving his body forward against all pain and listening intently to discern the number and location of the voices behind him. They were still at a good distance, despite their taunts, but he could tell they were forming up around him as he closed the gap between himself and the wall. Why there had not been another arrow, for he was certain that there were two bowmen, remained a mystery. Flomi wore no armor. At any time a single bowshot could take him full in the neck or through the chest. Yet no second shot had come after the one which had struck his lower leg.
‘There will be no killing!’ a stronger, smoother voice called out above the howls and laughter of the orcs. ‘He is wanted alive and unspoiled, and you will all answer for your disobedience if he dies!’ The laughter of the orcs stopped at this and there was some grumbling that Flomi could hear.
‘That was no orc voice,’ he thought, ‘but a Man. So, I have been followed from the Bree-land. Of course. Well, now we see!’
He had, as his assailants laughed and squabbled, drawn himself limping to the wall. Certainly the orcs believed that now his run was over. ‘Fools!’ Flomi cried aloud with a mighty laugh. He bolted directly to the wall and turned his maddock up high, striking and holding a familiar spot on the wall that Collum had shown him not six days before. And then he turned, propping himself against the wall behind him and waiting for the opening of the doors. The pain was gone from his mind now and there was fire and darkness on his face; the radiance of forgelight and the smoke of cooling metals it seemed to be, a mark of his People and of their anger which few combatants had seen and lived to talk of. Some orcs there were, though not many in this small band, who were older than the others and more tested in battle. Some few who looked into that fell face of their quarry and, wisely, slowed their pace. Of the Man, or Men, driving them, Flomi heard and saw nothing.
‘Eleven I see,’ he thought to himself, ‘and at least two bowmen who have not shown themselves. Hmmm. Thirteen is an unlucky number, but this is an unlucky day.
‘Fine,’ he said aloud and with a steady harrowing graveness to his voice, ‘Come, Rakhās,6 and learn what I can show you of Dwarvish steel. But, I warn you,’ he said with his lips curling into a most terrifying and secretive smile, ‘you will share my teachings with no one.’
At this he stood the straighter, clutched his maddock all the tighter and watched the fear come into the eyes of his foes. But as he backed up a bit to touch the wall behind him he realized, with troubling certainty, that the doors had not opened yet.
*****
‘Caitelyn has come this way with me, and on many roads much harder,’ Collum said, ‘she will not be troubled when we come into the passage.’ They had reached the first turn of the stair now and Flomi could see that it was built wide to accommodate pack animals but, here at least, only one abreast. As they turned north the landing became a ramp which went down many strides into the darkness ahead.
‘Your own beasts may feel differently, so I have had a trusty pack animal brought along. Mostly we will walk on the road ahead,’ he said, bending low beside the landing to draw upon a torch set into a rack beside the ramp. ‘Torches I have left here,’ he said, ‘though they are supposedly in great supply at intervals in the lower causeway. Or so it is rumoured.’ He paused a moment, took a flint from his pocket and lit the torch.
‘But I have not travelled the causeway,’ he said gravely.
‘This is a marvelous surprise!’ Flomi said happily. ‘When you mentioned a hiding spot, well, I must confess that I had not thought Men capable of such construction. It smells of deep earth here, long untrodden, but carrying mighty secrets! Sadly, it lacks the ornament my People might have given it and it feels, well, forgive me, but rather cramped. But the bones here are deep and many of these rocks, mined from the oldest of mountains, hint at great mysteries! Why was this marvel abandoned?’
‘This “marvel” as you call it is our Dark Road, Flomi,’ Collum said in a voice more grave than before. ‘This is the othlonn nairëa, “the Path of Sorrow”7 and, in its original days, it extended many long miles from the north in Annúminas to our burial grounds in the south. Many sad folk brought their kin here to be delivered and many noble dead traveled this way towards their interment. Does it surprise you, then, that there should be so little ornament for such a purpose?’
‘Forgive me, my friend,’ Flomi said with the most sincere of voices. ‘For, by my own people’s regard, you have offered to shelter me in a place of great power and heritage and I have unwittingly criticized it for drabness. That was a terrible misunderstanding which I hope you will forgive.’
Flomi looked so solemn in this, so completely genuine in his unwillingness to offend that Collum, easy-going and friendly as he had been in all his earlier relations with the dwarf, could not help but smile.
‘It is a grave place, my friend,’ he said smiling, ‘and forgive my graveness about it. Few remember it and none who do come here lightly. This is no comfort road here where we might quarter and travel and drink at inns with fine company. I do not think we will walk this road. But those who have walked it in sorrow and in safety.’
*****
The four orcs came forward on Flomi’s left flank first. Hesitantly, for they were frightened by what he had said and by the light in his eyes. There were others upon his right he knew, but they held their place while many in the center made a great racket of howls and the banging of shields in their much slower approach. A ridiculous deception of course, but he dared not take his eyes off them for a closer inspection of the right flank. ‘Yes, eleven, I think,’ Flomi said to himself, ‘but the bowmen have yet to reveal themselves.’
The orcs to the center, whooping and calling to distract him, did not concern him. The bowmen, who he knew to be the real danger, had not let loose another shot. Apparently the need to take him alive was vital to these leaders and the others, these orcs approaching now, were just rabble to their cause.
‘Good. The rabble is often wasted while the quarry is still loose. They will spend these orcs to see what I will do. Very good. So I must draw these bowmen out,’ he thought, ‘I cannot chase. They must need to come to me and in tighter spaces.’
The orcs, those on the left who were now closest and (if it might be said of orcs) bravest amongst their kind, were not three paces off. He could fight them, but by doing so he could not escape the bowmen after. For this he needed the safety of the Foundations. So Flomi, untested in battle yet his blood high in the moment, ready as he was with all the terrible vengeance of his sires to engage the first foe that should step into range of his maddock, angered as he might be at this attack and all of the repercussions it might have upon many lifetimes of his family’s work, made the hardest decision that he had ever made to this point of his life; he turned his back on his foes.
High on the wall he struck again, with all his hope and energy, to catch again the mechanism of the door that Collum had shown him. With his leg disabled he must have missed it on his first attempt and could not wait and watch to see if the trick had worked and the door would open. So now he turned right just as he must to strike the correct spot, and then quickly turned back fully to the left so as not to hamper his footing. Just as he did the first brave (or foolish) orc was upon him, his curved short sword raised high and a sneer on his slobbering lips.
A maddock is not as precise a weapon as a sword, nor a bow or even an axe. From our much later and much more utilitarian perspective it is often seen as an indelicate mining tool; a long and two-handed shaft that had a great sharp pike on one end and a broadaxe of a wide but short crescent upon the other. Formidable, even dangerous to wield, but not immediately seen by many as the most practical tool of war. One could understand how others might see it as a simple thing, just a stonemason’s tool.
Quietly and in the darkness of his rage, Flomi thought back to that day six weeks ago when the Black Rider laughingly called him ‘master Stonemason.’ He remembered the man’s calm disdain then and wished, very much, that the rider was here now to see what might happen when this stonemason’s weapon was swung in open combat.
‘Baruk Khazâd!’ Flomi called as he spun left with the axe side of his weapon now forward towards a lethal strike. He took the rushing orc’s head off cleanly just above the jawline with a single stroke, bringing the tool up and around to face the next orc after, and the horrified look in that adversary's eyes. He did not pause his stroke as the weapon was raised high again. He was glad that he had not used the pick on his first stroke; equally deadly to be certain, but it might have slowed his recovery in facing the assailant now before him. But here, perhaps for show, he turned the weapon in his hand and, pike forward, it bit through the cheap buckler the second orc had raised in vain defense and the shoddy leather helm he wore. A spinning, deadly and devastating opening volley which left the bravest of the two dead at his feet. He did not look down to check his handiwork. He looked forward to the next unfortunate assailant. It would cost him a moment to draw the weapon loose and he needed to exploit whatever terror he may have caused.
Yet this was not the problem he imagined it to be. The other orcs, mere half-steps away, drew back and away at his boldness. They became silent when their first kinsmen fell so violently. Now the orc laughter near the Glade was quieted, the whooping voices and banging of shields ended and the others, near on Flomi’s left, halted; all seemed surprised that what they thought was sport had now become so deadly.
‘Come you simpletons, you chattel, ignorant as you are of real battle. You who skulk ‘round lost travelers and so many unfortunate and undefended caravans! Come, you broken, dispirited, dissolute and disregarded servants of the Enemy,’ he shouted. ‘Come, yes come, you fleabags and you hole-stealers. Come you misshapen, misbred, hapless creatures of no destiny. Let me show you what lessons a keen Dwarvish tool might teach you. Come!’
Flomi’s blood was on him now, and ready was he then for anything, arrows or swords, which his foes might bring. He planted his weak leg behind him and, at the end of his shouting, in the quiet it had caused among his foes, he heard the last of the soft grinding noise of the door-mechanism behind him. In his mind and in his awakened senses he felt the slow and soft motion of the doors behind him just as he felt the surprise of his assailants all around him.
‘Stop him!’ went a great cry from one of the Men, one of the bowmen, he had not yet seen. ‘Do not let him enter that door!’ There was another great harsh cry of orc-voices to accompany it and, maybe, possibly, mustering themselves, they rushed forward as ordered.
Flomi did not wait to see. He did not care for their orders or what courage they might assemble and moved only in accordance to his instincts. In his heightened sense of battle-readiness he had heard the grinding of the doors, felt the space opening behind him, and then suddenly (and one might think surprisingly so at the end of such a loud and violent challenge) he rolled backwards and away from his foes.
His maddock he drew up and into his chest, his legs, injured as they were, he tucked tightly into his body, and his head he also tucked this way deeply to his chest, beard-to-brow as it were. In this manner he rolled very many strides back into the space of the entranceway that had slowly opened before the orcs and other assailants before him.
There was much yelling and cursing and shouting from the orcs and from the Men who led them. Many attempts they made to bring order to the situation.
‘Form up on that door!’ he heard another Man call. ‘Do not let him escape or you will all suffer! Into that doorway, you maggots!’
Some orcs were, perhaps, reasonably slowed by Flomi’s quick dispatch of their kin outside the doors and some, perhaps, were still surprised by this rather new and unexpected development of a Dwarvish bolthole appearing so suddenly in a wall built by the ancient Sea-kings, an enemy that they knew, through legend, to be most deadly. And away behind them, still far below the horizon, the Sun was waking and before its face, or so Flomi had heard, any orc became distraught.
Yet if they had done as the Men had bidden, listened to those who must surely be their masters, if they had done as they were commanded, it might have certainly ended just there. Flomi would not have escaped, in his crazy, desperate, prostrate, wreckless and rolling defense. Unarmored as he was, any quick-footed orc with a scimitar or even a sharply curved dagger could have brought about his sure demise. Any act of petty bravery by these foul people (who were not known for bravery in this age or any other), might’ve ended Flomi and, with the door now open, stolen or desecrated the great work of his family. Most certainly that may have happened and Flomi knew this in those brief desperate tumbling moments of his escape. But that had not happened. There was no courage in folk like these, even with their numbers.
He rose quickly three paces or so inside the doors while the orcs feared to enter. As quickly as he might, for he was now certain that there was some unwholesomeness to the wound in his leg; a fire and a weakness burned there that the focus of his mind could not fully negate. But still he rose rapidly and strong on the other leg and ran deeper inside the entranceway.
‘Come, you lumps of Troll-dung,’ he cried loudly to the orcs behind him, ‘come and face Dwarven steel at home beneath hard and sheltering stone. Come, if you dare and I will teach you a lesson in these halls of the dead that you will share with no one!’ Flomi cried loudly and, without waiting for a reaction, he limped around the first turn of the stair.
*****
Beyond the first turn of the stair, which headed directly northward beneath the wall, the path was not so steep. The way was cut with a few stairs, more like a ramp, but shallow in grade to allow animals to tread it without undo fear, and culminating before them in a large landing some thirty feet below the level of the earth, or so it seemed from Flomi’s estimation.
‘There lies the real step, Flomi,’ Collum said, ‘the first landing that is the closest which this place has to a guardtower that I know of.’
And here the steps opened outward to reveal a broader space with a door cut to the right-hand side. Collum motioned Flomi that way and together they entered through the ancient wooden doorway.
Here there was a ramp down into a large open space that was filled with brief punctuations of sunlight brought in from narrow passages overhead. The floor was not rough stone, as Flomi had seen before in such spaces, but a delicate soft moss grew wild here fed by the sunshine and the moonlight. Mostly the broad room was like unto a great and open storehouse beneath the earth as dwarves had in large halls. But of those places he believed that Men were quite unaware and, to his quick examination, it lacked any trace of being a dwarvish copy. There were shrubs here of a kind which Flomi did not know, and the moss too was equally beyond his experience. It was much smaller than a dwarvish structure would be for all of its seemingly vast size after that first narrow passage, yet even Flomi, experienced in old Dwarven halls and their design, was still shocked by its breadth.
‘A grazing field!’ Flomi said with noticeable awe, ‘and a great one. Left unattended for so very long!’
‘Yes,’ Collum said, ‘that is its function, though any name we had for such a thing is long lost. But here is the place in which beasts were kept that might take riders swiftly along the Causeway and here, also is a spot that my grandfathers’ have used in their secrecy. Through clever drainage and planting there was much life here as a waystation in its day. Long, long centuries some who know of it have maintained much; and there is much sustenance for when a man must go hidden.
‘Look here first,’ he said, turning inside the door to a store of supplies, ‘for if a need to defend ourselves should happen in this place I have set some provision.’ And at this Flomi listened to a rather lengthy list of defenses from the man that, at the time, he never fully expected they would need. He was wrong of course, but now, as the orcs besieged him, he found his mind returning to every detail.
‘Below is the Grazing Field,’ Collum had said, pointing down the ramp to the moss covered floor below, ‘just as you call it. Horses and other beasts were kept in such places as this in their day, and were trained to move rapidly along the Causeway needing little light nor fearing very little of cramped spaces. Come, let me show you!’
As he said this there was a very loud braying sound in the chamber beneath them. Much like a pony, Flomi thought, but with a voice much harsher than he had ever heard from any pony. Collum laughed to see Flomi so startled; ‘Hah! Fear not! Come and meet your new ally!’ Collum said, leading him down the rampway.
*****
‘That door has surprised them, but they will come through it soon,’ Flomi thought, turning around at the landing and drawing his bow. Stringing it in haste as he heard the orcs yelling and snarling at the entranceway. ‘And with my leg hindered, I must teach them to come more slowly.’
Taking advantage of the darkness, he drew two arrows from his small quiver and spun back around the turn quickly. Aim was unimportant; his hope lay in making them fear bowmen from below. He let one shaft go blindly as he turned and then strung the second immediately, now aiming at the first shape he could see, but loosing the arrow quickly. There was a harsh cry, he had hit something at least, and he hastened down the remaining steps to the door on his right. ‘Here,’ he decided, ‘I will stand.’
He threw the door (which opened inward and offered little protection) aside and set the maddock to rest on its frame. Collum had left good precautions just inside and Flomi, who had paid them little heed before, was thankful that these resources were near to hand. He had brought decent protection for himself; a ringed hauberk and helm, but there was no time to don such equipment now.
There were three full quivers of arrows, a score in each at a glance, set wide in their holster for ease at hand. He grabbed for one of these with great haste. But the greater need was the spiked pavise just outside the door. Enormous it was, a Man’s weapon that dwarves did not favour, these large shields served as a portable battlement for archers.
‘Now is the time to test new devices and put trust in old skills,’ Flomi thought, as he quickly dragged one of these into place just near the door, but at a commanding position of the stair. The quiver he laid inside with him and the first of its arrows he nocked and waited. ‘Come, you foul things,’ he thought. ‘Let me teach you.’
The orcs above were now sufficiently terrorized and rather rightly upset. They had been following this stub of a stonemason for most of the night on the command of their unwelcome allies, these Northmen. If the orcs might’ve had their way, they would certainly have taken the poor fool hours ago in the empty lands, where he walked loudly, foolishly, unaware and undefended. Well before the whiteface of the Moon was even high. But, on command from these Men, they had followed him for hours and hours away from their own camp and now the more dreaded yellowface of the Sun was coming.
‘If he’s wanted, we want him now,’ their captain had said to the pastey-white commander just less than an hour before, ‘for if the Sun is on him soon, then we won’t be.’ There were many gnashing (yet not too overt) grunts of approval at this statement and the Men who had been driving them took a moment to consider. They spoke to one another in their mannish talk. The warriors paused with their ears high while the snufflers, nose low to ground, kept the dwarf’s trail.
‘He flees,’ the second, smaller Man-boss had said, ‘but soon he’ll make camp. He is soft; a townsfolk. He awaits some guidance from his fellows that should come to him and I’m surprised that he’s come this far. There must be some pre-arranged meeting for him to come this way. He is frightened, and I half expect him to turn back. We’ll have him soon,’ the man said.
‘We’ll have him before the yellowface comes,’ their captain said, speaking arrogantly because he had his boys behind him, ‘or me and my fellows will be off!’ There were low grumbles and grunts of approval at this. The Orc- captain had certainly stood up for the ideas they all had shared but, of course, this was not something they were accustomed to and no orc in this small band wanted to appear to be in the least bit a revolutionary. They were surprised to see the Men take a moment to consider the captain’s rash words rather than cut him down and appoint someone new to his place.
‘We will follow,’ the taller of the two said, ‘and in the hour before dawn falls on him we shall as well. But until then,’ he had said slowly, loudly so that all of the fighters could hear, ‘if you want your own wretched lives beyond that sunrise and respect the authority of our terrible masters as I do, you will follow this dwarf and you will only take him when you are told to do so.’
At this the grunts and the gnashing noises amongst the fighters stopped. No one cared what the snufflers thought, if they thought anything at all. The captain, clearly still displeased, eyed the Northmen suspiciously. ‘Aye,’ he said, ‘an hour before the dawn we’ll give it. But we’ll take him quickly then, or leave you to the job yourselfs. And you can tell our terrible masters that and where to find us when you fail.’
They came cautiously to the stair, quietly now; there was no more snarling and gnashing of teeth, no beating of shields to distract their prey and prove their potency. They feared that Flomi had allies in the cave. But at the command of their masters they came forward still into the unknown space and against unknown and unexpected foes.
Flomi could hear their breathing in the narrow space even before he could see their shadows at the top of the stairhead. They could go two abreast here, short and squat as they were, and there were perhaps fifty strides of shallow steps within his view from the low side of the great shield.
‘They will not all fall here if they make a charge,’ he thought to himself, ‘but I will teach a little caution to the wisest before they do.’
He let the first shaft go just as one orc’s belt line cleared the roof of the stair. While these arrows were still unfamiliar to him, he had the time now to aim well and place the shot where it might frighten them all the more. There was a high-keening scream from the orc. Flomi, pleased by his success, said nothing and quickly knocked the next arrow.
The orcs drew back a few steps. Perhaps he could frighten these miserable creatures into believing there were others down here, bowmen and swordsmen and a whole army of dangerous foes. But the Men that led them would not be so easily fooled. They would push the orcs rapidly down the stairs, demanding a dangerous charge that one solitary and out-of-practice bowman could not hope to face. He waited, arrow ready and bow cocked, for a moment to see how this would develop.
There was a rough shouting from the landing above; some argument in a tongue that even Flomi did not know the words of. Some of the shouting came from the Men and Flomi was surprised to hear that they knew the harsh language of northern orcs. Then there was a snarl, joined by other harsh voices, and then a quick clash of blades that was abruptly ended. Then the voices stopped. At this, Flomi knew how things had gone amongst the leadership of these wretched people.
‘Form in twos with shields low and up front!’ came the Man’s call from above. ‘Quick down that stair, you cowards, or I’ll drag you out under the awakening Sun and burn your miserable faces!’
Flomi knew there was no time left to him now for archery practice; one bow alone, even at the height of skill, could not hold the stair against so many. He darted back into the doorway, setting the bow down and picking up his maddock that lay there. He stepped left to the pantry and took the helm for his head at least, having no time for the hauberk. At an angle away from bowshot, but still giving him a picture of the charge that was to come, he waited. He would hold this door. He must, because there was no escape, no safe place to fall back to beyond it.
‘Let them come and receive my lesson,’ he said softly, waiting.
*****
‘When we depart this place and move on,’ Collum had said, ‘we know our way eventually lies north through wild and desolate lands. I’ve tried to prepare us for that.’ They were walking down a stone ramp from the door into the Grazing Field and Flomi was listening to his friend, but looking about at the construction of the place. The floor of the large area was about thirty feet below the door, and the ramp that they were on wrapped itself to the left and around the open space hugging the outer walls. The gradient was shallow, turning twice, and would bring them to the room’s floor at its other side, perhaps one hundred paces down and at the foot of a great doorway. Larger and more ornamented than anything he had seen yet in these halls was that door, and before it Flomi could see two simple fountains of clear running water. Then there was another loud cry from below and Flomi could now see the beast who was making it.
The creature moved forward out of the shadows below them and towards their position on the ramp. To say it was like to a pony would be to say that a hobbit was like to a dwarf; of similar size perhaps and, at first glance, bearing most of the same orientation of limbs and their number. The hide and hair of the beast, from what Flomi could see, was much the same as a pony’s, though shorter and different in color and coarseness. But this was, by any estimation, not a pony.
‘What is this creature...’ Flomi said.
‘This is a friend that I have brought you,’ Collum explained with a laugh. ‘I have come to call him Duncan,8 but you may call him what you like. He is my gift to you.’
‘I do not mean to sound like an ingrate, my friend, and I am thankful for all of your foresightedness. This place, and your preparedness, is well beyond my expectations, but what kind of a creature is that? Is it a beast of burden, or some delicacy that I am unfamiliar with?’
‘Well, it may be both at need,’ Collum said with a smile, ‘but I hope it shall not come to all of that.
‘This is a creature from the east,’ he continued as they walked the ramp. The whole of the time the lonely beast followed them, or their voices, never once looking up as it trailed them along the length of the room. ‘The Wainriders of Rhûn brought them west in the wars. They are great pack animals that can endure much. Many were taken by the men of Gondor since the Battle of the Camp9 and they have greatly improved the livestock in that land; they eat little, run quick, and bear many times their weight without complaint.
‘But they are ungentle and extremely willful. Perhaps it is because they were raised by unkind hands in the East, perhaps they are just more wild in heart and fearful of predators, but they do not love to be ordered or to be sent into danger. They will do a hard day’s work easier than a pony, but they will do mostly what they wish and it takes a firm hand to guide them.’
The beast stood about nine hands to its withers, perhaps a bit taller than Flomi’s pony Corlar, but was yellowish-brown in color and had a broad dorsal stripe of a bright white color. The eyes of the beast, though Flomi had seen them only briefly, were set further back on it’s broad head and outlined with bands of black and white that gave them a foolish-looking mask of elegance on such a strange creature. The nostrils were wider and flared and red in color as if touched by fire. But the ears of this creature! They flew out from deep in his head much longer than the length of a Man’s hand and pointed downward with great dark hair protruding from inside them.
‘And does this beast eat the hand not firm enough to guide him?’ Flomi asked, for he had not yet seen the animal’s teeth and had some concern.
*****
The orcs rushed down the stair, a great cry on their terrible voices, each one expecting to fall before the next arrow. None did of course, and their blind and violent momentum brought them straight into the pavise, ramming into it with their bodies, hacking and bashing at it with their crude curved swords and blunted cudgels. So hot were they in their anger and their fear that they quite demolished the great wooden and steel-rimmed barricade well before they realized that no one was behind it.
‘Here, you skittering fear-filled things,’ Flomi said coldly from inside the doorway to their right when their energy had run out. ‘Here is where I will teach you.’
There were eight. As they looked up to meet his voice Flomi saw the equal mixture of hatred, terror, dumbfoundedness and hopelessness that he would think of in every orc that he would ever meet from this time forward. He almost pitied them, but as they raised their weapons that brief occasion to pity soon passed.
Three there were, much shorter and more animal-like than the rest and having broader snouts, who were low to the ground and nearly went on four legs. With only knives and simple leather jerkins to protect them, they backed away from Flomi’s challenge. Two of these had short bows that might prove to be a problem but, for the present at least, Flomi thought they looked too fearful to use them.
The other five were larger by far, and darker complected. They held greater weapons, dangerous looking things of heavy wood and bronze mostly, and some had bucklers or small shields, yet little armor beyond crude horned caps and scattered pieces of hardened leather that was scarcely distributed on their bodies.
‘If there are five fighters only,’ Flomi thought, ‘things might go better than I had thought.’
‘Ailigheee!’
The first of these fighters charged the door at Flomi’s challenge, his rage and his terror still high after his mad dash down the stair. The orc had a great wide sword in his hand, one which had done terrible damage to the innocent pavise as Flomi had stood aside assessing.
So now Flomi stepped back half a pace to meet him. The foolish orc, in his arrogance, lunged forward through the narrow space of the door and Flomi, who could’ve blocked the blade, instead dodged its linear assault easily so that he might bring his own weapon down in response. Flomi took the orc’s arm, and his weapon, off at the elbow for such arrogance. The awkwardness of the brute’s own momentum then carried him over the edge of the landing and onto the floor of the Grazing Field some thirty feet below. This left the doorway clear for the next assailant.
This second orc was more wary. He stood outside of the door, shield high and advancing slowly. ‘So, you learn already,’ Flomi said to him, turning his maddock gently in his hands. ‘What shall be the next lesson I teach you?’
This orc was indeed smarter than his predecessors. He raised the shield higher and quickly tried to step forward and left through the doorway to open the path for his comrades and expose Flomi to attacks from more sides. It did not work however, for the moment he raised the shield Flomi swung low with the axehead of his weapon striking at knee-length and, with a howl, the orc collapsed just at the door’s edge, making the path inside more difficult for his comrades. Continuing in a fluid motion, Flomi then swung the maddock high and brought the pick side down into the crippled orc’s head. While drawing his weapon out of the crumpled form he looked up to the orc just behind him. ‘Four,’ he said, his eyes full of menace and a terrible softness to his voice. ‘Four I have instructed. Who of you would learn next?’
*****
As they came to the foot of the ramp Jack was there, at a cautious distance, to meet and to watch them both. The man’s voice he knew, but this other was different and Jack had never encountered his look nor his smell before. So he had walked the whole of the way with them, keeping his eyes down and his ears open, trying to sort it out; this one didn’t smell anything like a man and, somewhere, at the heart of his instinct, Jack knew that this should make him wary. But he waited long for the man to come back, waited bravely, and now that the man returned Jack wanted to remain brave as possible (for he found that he had rather come to like that quality of himself). So he came full around to where they stood and looked this new kind of man-creature right hard in the eye, bravely.
‘Hello,’ he thought. ‘What is this...’
To say that this creature was like unto a man was to say that mice were like rats. Perhaps they were, in some distant way, and perhaps that meant they talk with one another in a language that all other animals might not know. But rats were dangerous, resilient, avaricious and cunning in ways that mice were not. And while Jack smelled more rat than mouse off this new creature, he did not smell nor see any reason to fear it. He was very dangerous, Jack thought, his whole People no doubt were. But he brought no fear to Jack’s nose, and Jack prided himself on his bravery and his nose.
*****
The fear of Flomi’s assault was quite enough for two of the smaller orcs that had hung back. Flomi saw them turn and rush back up the stair with alarming speed. The third of their kind stood there frozen. But he had managed to draw his short bow.
‘Cowards!’ he heard one of the men say from higher up and then there was a scream from one of the little pig-like brutes. Flomi addressed the three remaining fighters.
‘Your masters show greater caution than your fallen friends have,’ he said to them. ‘Or perhaps they mean to spend you to tire me. I have fine steel in my grip and good stone around me. I will not tire. Come. Whether on their orders or on your courage, I care not. Come and I will teach you more.’
The three who stood at the door before him however, were not as terrified as the little bowman behind them. Each was quite doughty in their way, as broad in their backs as Flomi was himself and carrying dangerous weapons; a cudgel, a rather nasty-looking short sword that was broad and curved, and a two-handed hammer. The one with the hammer would take some time Flomi knew; he was the heartiest of his group, with great strong arms like timbers and a chest like a barrel. Their eyes met for a moment then, Flomi’s and this orc-veteran with his scarred face and sly eyes. He smiled in response to Flomi’s taunts, held his hammer all the tighter, and spat at the ground between them.
‘That one,’ Flomi thought, ‘will not falter. That one will be last.’
‘What are you waiting for?’ came the shout from the Men behind them. They had just come into view from the doorway and Flomi recognized them as two of Sarnside’s friends that Collum had warned him of earlier. One, the shorter of the two, still held a longbow in his hand, but the other, though he carried a bow, had drawn a longsword of surprisingly fine make. He did not ever know the names of these Men back in the Bree-land, but he recognized them now.
The orcs, hesitant until now, stirred at their command. They shuffled about before the doorway, but they did not attack. The little one in back, terrified more by these Men than by Flomi himself perhaps, finally found the courage to knock an arrow. From this angle Flomi would not be able to escape such a shot, but if he turned inside for cover of the doorway the bold fighters might charge through and he would have to face them all at once.
‘Put that bow up!’ one of the Men cried loudly. ‘He is to be taken alive and I won’t have your miserable pigling cowardice make it otherwise! Draw your blade and take that dwarf!’
And the first two came headlong at the door on this command.
The one wielding the cudgel was worthless in the door’s narrow space, but the other, with a large scuta and the only decent helmet amongst them, rushed forward with his curved blade behind him and his body tightly behind the cover of that shield. Flomi could not meet his headlong charge and hold the door and his only hope came from halting the attackers in this narrow space. So he pivoted back on his left leg, biting down at the pain this brought, and then instantly stepping into a swing to the right with the maddock. Using all of his force, he brought the pike side of the weapon straight through the shield’s center hoping to halt the momentum of his assailant. It hit so violently that the orc was stopped and brought to his knees right where Flomi had hoped, within the doorway itself.
But this also meant that the maddock was buried deep into the opponent’s shield and he might not have time to draw it forth before the next orc was upon him. He pulled hard at the weapon, but even as he did the orc he had struck, stunned as he was by Flomi’s onslaught to his shield, brought the dark curved blade to use.
Flomi felt the blade bite into his ribs on the left side in a long and desperate slash. Beneath the pain, he saw the halted and partially stunned orc try to rise and lift the blade for another, and far more deadly, thrust. He had no armor and no chance to parry such an attack. So Flomi let go of the maddock, buried hilt deep in his opponent’s shield, and struck the orc full in the face. If he was half-stunned before by Flomi’s onslaught, this new blow slowed the wretched creature entirely; he stared forward with a dazed expression on his sallow and desperate face, his blade still raised.
He could not take back the maddock fast enough, so he reached up and drew the curved short sword from this orc’s hand. There was little resistance. Flomi brought it straight-down from above the orc’s head and, remembering the helmet, drove it into the softness of his neck in the same fluidness he had shown these brutes earlier. The orc crumpled atop his comrade, and the way through the door became that much harder. Flomi placed the short sword on the floor behind him and drew his maddock again as the remaining orcs considered their next move.
*****
‘Here we might rest awhile at need,’ Collum had said as they came to the bottom of the ramp, ‘but if we’re to accomplish our task we will be leaving soon and Duncan here will be better than your own beasts for long travel.’ As they reached the floor, he pushed his hand back to Flomi’s and gave him a small carrot as he had given to his own horse. ‘Come,’ he said, ‘I will introduce you.’
Flomi took the carrot of course, but now on level ground with the strange creature he was less than certain about feeding it. The beast let out a cry louder than the last and now, from this angle, Flomi could see its great white champing teeth.
‘Ho, gentle!’ Collum said to the creature, ‘I have returned as promised, and with a friend. Here, Flomi, do not let his noise bother you. But stand clear of his rear legs!’ At this, almost as if on command, the beast shouted again and made a terrific kicking motion with both of his rear legs. Collum laughed to see it or perhaps he laughed to see the look it brought to Flomi’s face.
‘This is quite a beast!’ Flomi exclaimed, stepping back just a bit. ‘Do the men of the East breed even their pack animals for terror?’
‘So it may seem,’ Collum replied, ‘but Duncan here has come to accept, if not quite love, a kind hand.’ At this he took the animal's mane in hand and stroked it gently. ‘Here,’ he said, ‘bring your treat for him so that he might know you as a friend.’
Flomi approached slowly, holding the carrot out in his open palm. Duncan took it from him gladly and stepped forward to have a good smell of the dwarf, who kept his palms up and open. Deciding that there were no other hidden treats in other pockets he brayed loudly again and then turned away from the two comrades. Walking off he let go an enormous pile on the ground behind him.
‘Ha!’ Collum said. ‘It seems you have passed the muster!’
*****
‘It is just one dwarf, you dungheaps!’ the man called from behind, ‘Take him! Why can you not take him!?!’
But they could not. Flomi knew it by now and so did the orcs. There were only two fighters and one shy tracker left of this party that had followed him all night. The fighters had a cudgel and a hammer; bad weapons for narrow spaces, and they must come forward over the bodies of the slain and to great disadvantage to attack him. He could hold against them, but he would eventually fall to arrows here in the open doorway. He needed to remove the fighters and then make the Men come through the door to him.
‘Very well,’ Flomi said, looking back to the eyes of the hammer-wielding veteran, ‘come if you will.’ And at this he left the frame of the doorway.
The fighters would now need to come through. If they were smart, and Flomi was certain they were not smart, they would clear their fallen comrades to make the way through faster. He was correct in this of course, and the large orc with the cudgel nearly tripped in his haste to come through the doorway.
There was a level floor here before the ramp declined slowly; so Flomi was on equal ground for now, but this landing was not more than two paces across before falling steeply onto the Grazing Field below. The ramp itself was narrower and his maddock would be of less use so close to the wall. He took a moment to kick the fallen short sword from his previous adversary back behind him should he need to switch weapons.
But a cudgel and a great hammer as these orcs had would also fail in the narrow passage of the ramp. Here is where these fighters would need to make their stand.
The cudgel swung high as soon as the orc cleared the door. It was a massive, gnarled thing, but lighter than a maddock and the orc spun it with deadly speed. The space between the two opponents was wider than Flomi would prefer, giving the length of the cudgel the advantage. He would need to close and drop this assailant before the next could come in.
But the orc was not so forward thinking; instead of rushing Flomi with his swifter weapon and pushing him back to admit his comrades, he planted his feet and let out a terrible cry of malice.
This cry was then answered; from the unexpected braying of Duncan below, and the orc, his great club lifted high, was distracted by this new challenge from some unknown creature. He even took his eyes off of Flomi to look for this new threat.
Flomi rushed in and brought the maddock down in one long stroke. So devastating was the blow that the orc may well have been dead before his body hit the ground. There was now less room on the landing and another body for his adversaries to trip over.
Flomi almost thought to grab for the bow. If he could get ahead of the one with the hammer, if he could run quickly down the ramp, he might be able to hold the bowmen from places of cover in the Grazing Field below. He looked to see the bow and the remaining quivers just over his shoulder.
But the remaining orc, the veteran with the scar and the hammer, was too fast. He lept atop the body of his comrade in the instant that it fell, caring nothing for the fallen and still careful of his step. The whole of the time the eyes in that scarred face were focused on Flomi. His massive figure blocked the doorway, leaving Flomi safe from archers perhaps, but he held the higher ground and his weapon had the greater reach. Flomi stepped back two steps, now beyond the armaments in the pantry and onto the ramp, kicking the short sword down a bit further with him. To weaken the advantage of this great hammer he would need to make the orc come into the narrow space of the ramp.
‘You’ve led us a merry chase, little flea-catcher,’ the orc said calmly, ‘but now it's done. They want you whole and unspoiled, these Northmen. Surrender now and I’ll just take one stumpy hand as payment for all my fellows.’
As Flomi and the orc stood facing one another on the rampway there came a great roaring noise from up on the other side of the door. This orc, smarter and far more deadly than his fallen comrades, did not become distracted by it and charged with a ferocious downward swing of his hammer. ‘No fool indeed,’ Flomi thought, as he back-pedaled two more steps on his weakened leg. ‘He controls his swing and steps in quickly to gain the ground.’
One of the men, the one with the bright sword came near to the door for a moment. ‘Hold him!’ he yelled to the orc, ‘do not let him run and do not kill him until I return!’ He then darted out of the doorway and back into the hall. Some new commotion there which Flomi could not guess at might very well be his saving.
The orc-veteran did not look very happy with this order and spat again to show his contempt. But he held his ground and did not advance. Behind in the hallway Flomi could hear the sound of fighting and the roaring of some great deep voice in a language which he did not know. It was certainly no orc-speech; fair and rich it sounded and in its timbre not unlike that of his own folk.
He was now well past the bow and the store of arrows now. Too high yet on the ramp to jump to the ground below safely even had his leg not been injured. Much blood had been lost from the three wounds and he did not know if he could wait, or even stand, long enough for this new help to arrive. In other days he might’ve hoped to outrun his opponent and then meet him on more equal footing on the floor below. But he saw now how fast orcs were at a run and he dare not turn his back to try. He must take this foe now while he still had the power to do so.
There was a loud braying from Duncan below that Flomi, ever after, took as a show of support from a friend in arms. And it hardened him to the task.
‘My hand is it?’ he said to the orc as they stared at one another across the two paces of the rampway. ‘Such a small thing, you call it, and to be taken in recompense for all your fallen comrades. But more skill is there in my hand than in the whole of your worthless, brutish, unloving, unwanted and defiled people. You think to take the hand that has taught all your friends such lessons as a trophy? Why, I would sooner take the ugly heads of three-score like your friends than offer one discarded fingernail from such a marvelous thing as the hand of Flomi, son of Trochi. Come, you arrogant and insignificant lump, and learn my final lesson.’
This taunt had the desired effect. In order to strike boldly and with all of his rage in such a narrow space, he would have to raise the hammer high for another downward cut and step quickly so that his opponent could not back-pedal again. The orc would have to rely on his speed against that of a near crippled dwarf. Flomi watched his eyes, watched the rage grow there and, at the first flicker of movement in the orc’s hand, he dropped the maddock and fell to his left knee.
From this low spot on the floor he saw the orc’s leg begin to step forward and he took the curved shortsword of his earlier opponent up in his left hand. On one last push of strength he charged forward from his right leg, closing inside the hammer’s arc, and bringing the full momentum of his charge forward on the newly recovered blade. As it bit into the orc’s belly, he grabbed the hilt with his other hand as well and, standing as quickly as his injured legs would let him, tore the weapon upward, gutting his opponent like a trout.
The hammer clattered to the ground somewhere behind Flomi as he looked into the dying orc’s eyes. ‘And this is my lesson,’ he said.
*****
He took some greater pleasure in this death than the others of course, but also some relief; the greatest part of the challenge was behind him and his body was now recognizing all of the damage that, in his peril, he had told it to ignore. He was weak now and it took much for him to remember that the battle was not yet done.
The shortsword he left buried where it was. Looking behind him, he saw that the maddock had fallen over the edge of the ramp when he dropped it. Sounds of battle still rang in the hall outside, a deep voice in some unknown tongue seemed to be singing as they clashed. Flomi thought of the legends of his grandsires.
‘I am too spent for close work,’ he said aloud, to no one. Duncan however did answer from below.
‘I thank you for your kindness, my friend,’ he said loudly, as he stood to walk toward the pantry, ‘and your confidence is... uplifting...’ He took his father’s bow back to hand and the small quiver of arrows that he had also brought from the Stoneyard. Then his left leg collapsed and he could feel it know longer.
‘Uggh,’ Flomi said as he fell to his knee, ‘and it seems I am in need of uplifting just now.’ He chuckled a bit then as he dragged himself forward to the doorway.
In the room outside one of the Northmen had already fallen. The taller of the two, the one who had issued his last instructions to Flomi’s hammer-wielding opponent, was hot in battle with another Man. And this was the one who, when Flomi saw him, appeared to be singing:
‘laine ár gcroí,
‘Neart ár ngéag,
‘Beart de réir ár mbriathar.’10
The man sang, as he swung a great wooden knotted cudgel around his head and body, making it impossible for the Northman with the longsword to close in. The newcomer’s armor was sparse; thick leather it seemed, about his sleeves, banded upper arms and broadly padded on his forearms. There was a hooded cloak and a tunic of a soft forest grey, but his inner garments were linen with fine braided chain and he wore high wrapped stockings of an equally bright emerald green.
Flomi had some moments to wonder at this unexpected help as he crouched from his place within the doorframe behind the bodies of his opponents. But the pain in his leg, which was certainly caused by some form of poison, was now beyond his control, and he knew he had little time to help this unknown comrade. He knocked the arrow, holding the bow sideways as he could no longer stand to shoot, but would not release it in such a cowardly manner.
‘You are undone, Northman!’ Flomi cried loudly from the doorway, ‘for the heartiness of Dwarves is something you wretched people left unaccounted!’
He did not loose the arrow. He did not need to. The darkly clad Northman turned to hear Flomi’s taunt and the other man, the help unlooked-for, spun his cudgel widely at the villain’s turned head. He fell without a sound or a scream.
Flomi mustered all of the energy left to him that he might stand and meet his mysterious helper. It took a long minute, and probably would not have been possible had he not been able to use his father’s bow as a crutch. But he stood, despite all else.
‘Stranger,’ he said, ‘I thank you for-‘
It was then that the lone remaining orc, the hunter or tracker or whatever use he formerly had, the one crippled by terror of battle yet not so cowardly as to run from the worst of it, stepped forward out of shadows where he had hidden.
His short little arrow from his short little bow caught Flomi full in the chest and then he scampered, like a shot out of a shovel, full up the stair before anyone could stop him.
End of Chapter Six
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter Six
1) Some “word nerdery” here in the spelling that I’ve chosen for Flomi’s weapon. Generally speaking a pick axe style weapon like this is called a “mattock” but that is derived from its usage in Old English and, as such, seems a bit too modern to my eyes. The Scottish Gaelic word was “màdog”, with the much harder constant sounds that seem more appropriate to Tolkien’s world. I’ve found in this spelling a blend more acceptable to my own tastes.
2) “ships / seven / of Elendil / eastward” -from the Adûnaic, of which there is little written by Tolkien himself. It is unclear to me whether it was a spoken language in Middle-earth by anyone at this time, with only a few fragments from old tales still in the memory of some characters like Ohtar. The wording here of the peace Ohtar finds is meant to reflect Aragorn’s coming to Cerin Amroth in The Fellowship of the Ring.
3) The Great War of the Dwarves and the Orcs would not begin until 2793 of the Third Age, some eight- hundred years after this tale. But one can imagine that the two races were in a suspended state of rivalry throughout all of their history.
4) This excellent curse, “Abrâfu shaikmashâz!” or “(You) descendant of rats'“, comes from the Dwarrowscholar.com, a wonderful resource for Tolkien-sanctified forays into dwarf culture. It is highly suggested.
5) The language here is, of course, meant to echo the opening to the Dwarf-doors of Khazad-dûm in The Fellowship of the Ring. The scale of that is, obviously, much grander, but it is another favorite passage of mine and, as I said before, the great thing with fan-fic is getting to make all the quotes.
6) “Rakhās” is Khuzdul for orcs (plural)
7) And here is another case of fumbling with the language. “Nairëa” is a Quenya word for “of sorrow”, while “othlonn” is Sindarin meaning “a paved way”. There is definitely not enough Adûnaic in existence to build such a word and quite a lot of the language of Men comes from roots in Sindarin. Hopefully I will make some corrections to this as I learn more.
18) The beast in question is an onager, or wild Asiatic ass that is a cousin to the modern donkey. I wanted a more Anglicized name here from Collum that might still suggest a donkey.
9) This was in 1944 of the Third Age, very current events as it goes in the legendarium.
10) So, we will come to learn more of this later, but this is NOT a Tolkien language. I think that’s enough information for now.
Chapter Seven; "The Bard's Tale"
-Wherein the Party Meets a Helpful Stranger and Learns New and Important Information
Read Chapter Seven; "The Bard's Tale"
‘Lo! The North lords and their glory through splendid achievements we have heard of in our distant homes,’1 the stranger sang softly in the half-muddled daze of Flomi’s woundedness.
‘Of Westernesse and their far-off home now faded we have harkened,
‘How prince-sons of Sea-kings displayed their prowess-in-battle and their former fame we have heard of.
‘Elendil, their mighty king, in honor of whom my teachers often call them Elendilings, came forth from the Sea to bring Hope to the land. But what Hope he held is gone with his sundered line and what Hope he portends has not yet come,’ the man said, switching from the older language to a heavily accented version of the Common Tongue. ‘You may not know these words, traveler, but I would sing them to you to bring you hope. Will you listen?’
Here the singing grew lower and more rhythmic as the Man looked to Flomi’s wounds, wrapping and binding what he could and looking grievously on those which Flomi knew, even in his daze, to be poisoned.
‘Eärendur the Foolish is oft named and known,
‘By many Men who in their mead-benches have heard.
‘Of how first he found himself friendless and wretched,
‘In terror of age and of death, and forswearing the Gifts of Man.
‘Sea’s Servant who never sailed,
‘Last-great scion of those great Sea-kings,
‘Mighty and mad and failed,
‘Was father to three kingdoms,
‘And three failures he bred in hearth and state.’
The man put a cool rag on Flomi’s head at this, softly patted his chest, and looking rather quickly aside, went on, now singing:
‘This king had sons:
‘Small and no comfort he got from them,
‘And waxed ’neath the welkin, world-honor gained,
‘No safety but his sovereignty.’
‘“No safety had from his sovereignty...”’Flomi corrected him. He knew this phrase somehow, from somewhere, but in his current state he could not place it.
‘Hmmmn,’ the man said in his deep and resonant voice, a broad smile on his face as he paused in his ministrations to the wounded dwarf. ‘You speak the ancient tongue and have heard this tale? Mae-govannen! I do not speak this tongue openly except with my family, and that has been many years past. But should we sing the tale together? ’
‘No, no... I do not think so, my friend,’ Flomi replied drowsily in the easier common talk. ‘I should rest a bit...’
‘No, no, and I do not think so, my friend,’ the man replied, looking more serious. ‘You are gravely injured and you must stay wakeful or you will fade. So I will tell you this tale and we will talk of it as I do. I like the sound of your version, but it does not make sense of the tale as mine does. Where have you heard it?’
Flomi groaned at this; he felt the healing power of whatever this man had put on his leg and on his chest, was thankful for the coolness of the wet rag the man had placed on his brow, but he was far too tired for academic debate.
‘There was another... somewhere... I cannot remember,’ Flomi said as he started to drift off again.
‘Then I shall tell you the tale as I know it,’ the man said as he took more items from his pouch and placed them in the small pestle beside him.
‘His sons, high in their pride of parentage,
‘Had marked the misery with malice that their father’s fear had caused them,
‘So that reaved of their ruler they may come to glories of their own.’
‘“But another was born to him, daughter of Eärendur, an excellent heir by all accounts, who would be made famous...”’ Flomi said to the man, his eyes opening a bit more in the talking.
‘Yes, yes! But you rush the tale,’ the man said excitedly. Flomi could see that he was grinding with great care something in the small pestle he had produced, and halted the motion to look at the dwarf. ‘Tell me, my friend, can you remember this excellent heir’s name?’
‘The heir?' Flomi asked, trying to maintain his focus. Eärendur's heir was Amlaith. It signifies “up”... something... raised...’
‘I confess that I did not know the meaning in the name,’ the man said. ‘You are uncommonly gifted in tales! Are all your folk this way, I wonder?’
‘Moreso than most people expect,’ Flomi replied with a small and tired smile. ‘We are makers by our nature and as such appreciate great tales for their making. I myself...’ he found that he was drifting here, less aware of his surroundings than by memories of times that he could not quite recall, and his voice trailed off as if following his thoughts down darkened roads of an unknown past.
‘You yourself,’ the man said, returning to the delicate grinding of some herb in the small bowl with his pestle, ‘shall come to comfort and in time tell me these things you know of tales, and I myself will certainly rejoice to hear them.
‘But for now, my friend, I shall do the telling. Correct me when you will, for I delight to hear new songs, but your powers are better spent fighting the poisons. So, we return. Where? Ah! “An excellent heir”.
‘An excellent heir he had.
‘Sent late in Eärendur’s life was sent the sire as his solace.
‘Bold-minded, beautiful and bright, marked by all to be
‘An excellent “Elendiling!”
‘And three sons also, the first of whom was Amlaith.’
‘Yes,’ Flomi said softly, ‘“up” something. What is “laith”? I don’t think that I know this...’
‘At the hour that was fated,’ the man continued in his singing;
‘Elendur-king and father then departed,
‘For such is the Gift of Man,
‘And so then warlike they wend him,
‘Away then they bore him,
‘Through under-deeps, his fond-loving comrades carried,
‘For great forefathers he had been named and so should be return’d.’
‘Yes,” Flomi said softly. ‘Yes, yes, I do know this tale... and have bent my life to it. I will do my best to listen.’ Yet he found it increasingly hard to keep his eyes open.
*****
‘Patiently and cautiously I did watch the orcs for some hours, undecided about their importance, but unwilling to leave them to run and bring havok to the peace of open lands. My hatred toward these folks is high, but carefulness had been taught to me and all my People, and reckless wrath is not within me.
‘A small band it was, under a score of foes, yet too many that I might attack openly without some few escaping. And too near to my destination were they that they may be disregarded.
‘A rude camp they had made and that in my traveling I had discovered. In shaded wood and soft earth such lean-toes and short diggings they had laid down which save such debased folk from their fear and hatred for Sun and Light, sheltering them by day as they moved and destroyed only by night. Watchful of this camp I was, patient as my People have taught me, though as ever wrathful we are to all their orc-kind and all of their ways. A great burden it was to my heart to watch quietly and not slay these enemies of the woodlands with ready hands. But these are not the woodlands of my birth, and I am not their guardian. What brought this small band here, so near to my destination, so close to where my own cause had bidden? Hard-bought prudence bid me wait my vigil. I might move on, leaving behind what I had seen and alerting the townsfolk, but knowing the ways of these fearsome creatures, I would fain leave any orc alive in fair woods. So patiently and cautiously did I keep my watch as the night fell.
‘Perhaps in my hesitancy to travel to that other place, the town ahead, I held my hand and made to watch these orcs rather than slay them. Forbearance there I beg you grant me; for I had never, nor had my fathers, any cause to visit a town before this time. A courageous man may go heedless of peril into a wood by night, I think, and still pause before meeting the unknown men and the unknown customs of townsfolk.
‘But orcs I do know. They had camped close in that wood, closer than they preferred to come to the large dwellings of a goodly people and there they had remained so for some time. Certainly then there must be some dark purpose which stayed them.
‘“Such a dozen or so could not take a town,” I thought while watching. “Why do they wait here so?”
‘I would go to this town in time, for such was my determined course, but thought to know more of these foes first. Warnings I may bring, but news and proofs I would be the better for having.
‘Orcs in our open lands have their regular rhythms. Sleeping by day under any long shadow or rough encampment, quarreling raucously at dusk and stamping about impatiently by moonrise. Paralyzed as they were by fear of daylight, more anxious they were to run freely and rampage wildly with the night. No enemies nor victims had they for the distraction of their distemper yester eve and so when night fell their disquiet grew greater.
‘Patiently I watched and waited, doubting and deciding what to do about gorgûn in the green fields so near to the town.2
‘“The captain I might kill,” I thought, and the others of his folk so then might be caused to scurry. Trophy of him I might make to take before the townsfolk so that they should learn the peril of their position. This settled into my mind the more whilst watching.
‘So, I watched and awaited the opportunity of their captain.’
*****
‘Was then that this Eärendur, Servant of Seas namèd,
‘Renowned prince of north lands,
‘Bairn of the Elendilings, son to Elendur,
‘Belovèd Eärendur, for long-lasting seasons
‘Was famèd amid all his folk.
‘Once great-minded, twice madness-driven,
‘Four times fathered, four times betrayèd,
‘As last North-king, he graciously governed,
‘And grew grim-mooded, as agèd.
‘Four bairns of his body born in succession...'
‘Yes... there were four, yes,’ Flomi said from some deep corner of his mind. ‘There were four... though few now remember of it...’
‘The Unnórenean remember much, my friend,’ the man said to him from somewhere Flomi could not quite see. Above him he could see comforting cold stone, and light coming through it in narrow wells along a great cavern roof.
But he was finding it difficult to turn his head to follow the man’s movements and still keep enough of his wits to understand the tale that was being sung. Flomi knew the language well, having made long study of it, but had never heard anyone other than his father or Collum speak more than a few words. This man’s voice was rich and fair, but his manner of speaking was... confusing.
‘We remember more of the North-kings in our songs,’ the man said, ‘than they themselves do in their halls. And now they have no halls! I wonder, will they now heed our songs?
‘Four bairns of his body born in succession
‘Woke in the world, to a war-troops’ leader.
‘Tarondor and Valandor were last,
‘Twin-sons without title or virtue.
‘Amlaith, first-son, who was up-standing..’
‘Standing?’ Flomi said. ‘No... no I think laith may mean “laughing”...’3
‘I confess that I do not know this either,’ the man replied. But now Flomi realized that the man seemed behind him somewhere and he could, just slightly, feel the man’s touch on his back near the numbness of his left shoulder. It was then that Flomi realized he no longer faced the stone roof overhead but a great open space covered with moss and small shrubberies. He could not account for the time between his last look at the roof and now, nor could he account for how he came here. But he could feel the man tending to the wound in his back, that which was the first of so many that he had almost forgotten their number.
‘If it indeed means “laugh” then I feel the name is tragic,’ the man continued. As he said this there was a great and startling noise from above but near to Flomi’s ear:
‘Breaafu-oi-yananen-briare!’4 came the great sound. Flomi could see now, lying on his side and staring ahead into the open space, the yellowed hooves of the beast step tentatively forward.
‘Hoho!’ the man said, ‘I think your beast here laughs better than any soggy Sea-king! He rejoices to see you awake again. Tell me, my friend, do you have a name for this uncommon companion?’
Flomi felt the warm nuzzling of the creature against his brow and was comforted. He closed his eyes again, at peace in his pain, and sighed softly.
‘He was called Ducan when he was given to me,’ Flomi said, ‘and he shall probably answer well to you with that. But he is my friend now and...’ sleep was coming up on him again fast in his comfort, ‘I shall call him Inbar...’5
There was a soft wet exhalation from the creature at this, and Flomi drifted back to sleep.
*****
‘There was indeed a rather stout and fearsome leader to the small and unwholesome band of brigands. Taller than the others, as is often the case with their captains, and more clear-spoken than the others, which is also often so. He carried a great hammer and perhaps a greater wisdom than his fellows; for he seldom left his tent for anything other than the giving of discipline, and this he and his hammer delivered upon the others most readily and most harshly.
‘The trees near to these wandering ruffians welcomed a wise hand; they offered one with my woodcraft good canopy and high vantage over the rude encampment of the interlopers. I held my watch in high places all the day under strong cover and wanted for nothing other than a stout strong bow as I awaited the time. Had I a good bow in good wood like those I would need wait no longer. A dozen foul creatures as these might fall in less than an hour and I might have the captain’s head and well be on my way.
‘Having neither bow nor quiver I waited and I watched and I counted my patience as preciously spent.
‘When the blessed Sun fell low enough and the dusk-shadows grew long enough for their comfort these orcs became restless. It was their way. And so now the captain had become more active to keep them in some order whilst their nature told them to run and to pillage as they should in their regular humour. A Dark Will had put forth its power upon all of these folk to fill them with a lust for ruin and rampage, death and disorder.
‘Orcs stay only as they are told to do. They have no home and, moreover, hold no home to heart as other more wholesome folk may. It is said in some songs by my People that they live in long-lost palaces that were plundered from ancient races. So it may be that in the former tunnels and holes that were great halls to Elves and Dwarf-folk the greatest of these goblin-kings now sat on sumptuous mouldering caches of old conquests, like dragons and wraiths may do, and there they bred and they boasted of old victories by their valiant ancestors and so too, it may be, they schemed of future glories which they were themselves too timid to try. I do not know to a certainty. For in the forests of my birth we know nothing of Dwarf-holds and Elvish-kingdoms other than what old war songs will tell.
‘Orcs, however, came occasionally to our forest home, and there from a young age we learn to hate them and have been taught to stalk and slay them.
‘Not so many came as once did perhaps, but not so few as to be forgotten. Orcs came to the forest and they died in the forest, and the Minhiriathrim still long survived. The forests they protected survived, and the orcs ran back to their holes or their palaces or those other neglected places of Men and Elves and Dwarf-folk. Many of their ugly kind I have myself slain in youth and, if the Unnórenean of my blood did learn to fear them as greatly as the Minhiriathrim of my upbringing did learn to hate them, more overjoyed was I at their deaths. They were the foes of my People’s heart, the enemies in many of our songs, and I know them and know their ways.
‘Orcs do not break camp carefully as wise woodsmen do, but seldom do they keep it into night and beyond day’s need. They will go to ground by day and leave that same foul hole before moonrise, forgotten and undisguised. Any true tracker can follow any group of orcs for many nights through their untidiness and come upon them while they are weak, worried and sun-sickened by a fresh dawn. But now, as the evening awakened and the camp grew restless, the captain could be heard ordering his folk to dig all the deeper and to clear all the wider; as if they were there as a fore-mission of more and many yet to come.
‘This would make my waiting unwise. I knew I must take the captain soon and bring his head as a herald to the townspeople. If these foul folk were driven in their purpose to stay at whiles, something seldom seen in their behaviour, then another captain of their kind might soon take this one’s place and a stronger leader arise as reinforcements come. The bloodied head of this current captain might convince the townsfolk of their impending troubles, but I could not know when another’s may replace him. So it must then happen before the night grew long. And so I waited, patiently, cautiously, through their restlessness and their scurrying. Waited for the captain’s coming to discipline his own and for an opportunity of my own.
‘It did not come with the moonrise. The captain did not leave the camp nor the shelter of his lean-to as he barked and bellowed orders at his battalion. For their own part they were, as ever, unhappy as all their kind and answered back belligerently; but none so much as to draw the captain, and his heavy hammer, into the open for dispute. Out where I hoped a careful quoit from my sling might finish this work of waiting.
‘So still I waited all the more and all the more I counted my patience as precious.
‘Three hours after the nightfall, with the moon growing high in the east, the foul folk became unsettled. News, it seemed, came down to them on the winds which I could not discern. The small snufflers felt it first, but all the orc-folk were soon raised to some new reports that I knew not from my perch in the trees.
‘There was a cautious growling in the camp of many crass and guttural voices. I know not the language of orcs, if language it may be called, but could still hear the hatred it held within.
‘“Enough of that gnashing noise!” the orc captain cried as he came forth from his hiding. “You’ll keep yourselves in the line I gave you, boys, or your fallen limbs will paint a bloodier line for your brothers to follow! Back in lines, I say!”
‘He came forward, a great-hammer on his shoulder, head high and smelling the wind. Then, with a straightening of his back and cracking of his neck, he spat commandingly on the ground before him.
‘“O, aye, I smell him too, lads,” he told them, “but our bosses like that smell even if we do not. Let him in and let’s hope he’s some work for us beside sitting in open fields when there’s plunder so close by.”
‘There were many calls of acceptance at this and it was easy to see that this captain knew very well the avaricious mood of his company. A good leader for a brigade filled with bad intentions. This made him all the more dangerous, all the more despicable and all the better a target. Moving quietly, cautiously, patiently and silently, from one high branch to one lower and with better vantage, one of straighter stone-throw, I watched and loosened the sling which I held at my harness, placing an iron-clad stone into its carriage.
‘Toward the northwest I heard, and then saw, a man come riding openly toward the camp. A dark fellow on a dark horse, with lank dark hair and a yellowish face in the clear cool moonlight. The orcs snuffled, sneered and bayed at his coming, but let him on and in as one of their own. Straight toward the place of their hiding he rode, as if surely he knew it before times. Whether an Orc-master, race-traitor, co-conspirator or hapless underling, I marked the sallow-face of this stranger and knew well to hate him for his allegiance.
‘“Draw close and stand you ready,” the rider called to the orcs in a breathless voice of one who has run hard before riding fast. “We hunt tonight!”
‘There were commanding shouts and strong calls from the camp; they did not like this Man, or so it seemed, but the captain of orcs knew their passions and played them for his purpose.
‘“Do we?” cried the captain, quieting his comrades. “What? Should we go to on your call only, while we have waited so long here for some word from your master? More of my boys will come soon and then we’ll take your little town of rabbit-folk and pig-farmers. Why should I risk my men a-walking on your lead when we can march two or three nights from now to a greater plunder? What is the take of your hunt that I and these lads should care to go with you?”
‘“The dwarf is on the move,” the man called back coldly, “and that is who you and your charges were sent here to take... at our command.”
‘The captain paused in his step to hear this. The traitor-man dismounted, gathering now his breath. Knowing that he must command these unruly folk he stood straighter to the task.
‘“The dwarf goes, alone, west, in haste and quiet,” the man said, “having no idea of his peril, though my own comrade has dogged him at every step. We shall follow and meet my colleague and then take the dwarf alone tonight as he travels. The time is tonight,” this race-traitor called louder, looking around to the grey-yellow faces of the creatures around him. “My colleague goes and prepares our meeting. This dwarf went toward the Stoneyard first and now travels west in the open lands just north of the Great Road.”
‘“My brothers are not coming to join us from the West,” the captain sneered, “but hard from the North to flood and seize and devour these empty lands. I could wait here two days and have warriors enough to take a town. A town which was promised.
‘“Why should I, and my boys, stalk some stunted rat-dwarf for your pleasure?”
‘At this the lank-haired man grew quite strict, quite hard in his manner and, despite the obvious enmity, quite a bit larger in my estimation.
‘“Because you are bidden, foul folk, because you are commanded,” he called to them all.
‘“Think you that you have some choice in our Great Master’s plans? Fools! You are driven here to do the commandments of your superiors and I am driven to use you, cattle and goat, warrior and tracker, as is my wish. This is the way of our policy; a wheel which turns to great action and we are but the cogs.
‘“No, this is near but is wrong,” he said, pausing, a sneer not quite a smile now opening on his lips. “You are lesser than cogs. You and your wretched folk are, in fact, but the rough and worn hoop that is lowest to the dirt while a cog spins above you. There is a great action in play and, if you are useful tools, you will play the part and perhaps even rise for a short time. Or you will be rolled over by those which do.
‘“We hunt the dwarf tonight,” the man said louder and now addressing the group of fighters who had gathered round him rather than their captain. He stood tall here against the many of them and put a hand to his sword to show his seriousness.
‘“We leave immediately to take the dwarf,” he said firmly, “and I’ve an answer in my hand for any who believe that they are better than such commandments.”
‘This taller-than-most and clearer-speaking-than-most orc-captain held the traitor-man’s gaze for a time. The moment hung heavily between them.
‘There was silence from the other orcs as they awaited the decision of their captain. Things could certainly go differently with any movement, any action of disregard, from their leader. This was their way. They ever awaited leadership. And this too will ever be their downfall, for they never had any good of it.
‘"I could strike the captain's head here solidly with a stone. Maybe, but not surely, killing him with a single blow from my sling," I thought.
‘"I might also take the rider, this traitor-of-Men, with such a blow." That one had no helm, no sign of hidden breastplate, and a carefully slung iron quoit at this range might take the villain rightly and directly down to death.
‘But there would be no time for a second stone. My cover was sound before but thinner as I had moved to hear their debate, and I had counted three bowmen amongst the orcs. Their bows were short, but their eyesight at night was ever quite keen. I had no bow myself nor a strong place to hide once discovered. So I must, to keep within my plan, kill one of these leaders quickly and hope it caused the others to scurry. But the moment of that plan had changed. I knew that they would not scurry if they had another leader to follow. And while I had a few stones I was only one man with but one sling.
‘It seemed then that my best chance lay in leaving. I might reach the town by the dawn and awaken the folk there to all which I had witnessed. Would they believe me? I know nothing of townsfolk and had hoped for an orc-head as some official proof of my position.
‘As the foul captain and the traitor considered one another I also watched and considered; many fates were wound into those few moments.
‘Then the orc-captain spit on the ground before him and turned his back on the man, speaking to his folk. “Grab your gear and whet your blades, boys!” he said, “we’re going a-hunting tonight!”
‘There were shouts of strong approval throughout the camp, but the captain did not finish so quickly. He turned to walk towards the rider. Continuing to address his soldiers he said;
‘“Shagrach, Muzgash and Abendego!6 You boys will stay and ready this position for the threescore of our boys from the North. We’ll assemble here with them two nights from now once this rat-hunt is done.” Saying so he looked squarely at the rider, gripping his great hammer tightly and closing the paces between them.
‘“We are ordered to help you at your needs. We don’t care a bit for your needs, but we do understand our orders. One night and a dozen boys I will give you for this hunt,” he told the traitor-man, “not because you command it,” he said slowly, spitting again with all the authority of his kind, “but because I have no orders otherwise. But we’ll be back here in two nights and we will meet our brothers to take this foolish town. For those are the orders I have and that my boys care about.”
‘The traitor-man stood evenly to the challenge. “One night will indeed bring our quarry, but we must ride now. He walks a path to no destination that we know and we will need to track him in open lands. My comrade is on the trail, but we must pick it up again at the stoneyard. If we ride immediatel-’
‘The great hammer swung wide and hard before anyone could expect it happening. The rider’s horse, his head a bloodied mess, fell terrified to the ground screaming. No second blow of the hammer ended the mare’s misery and her cries of pain and astonishment made the orcs all the livelier. The cruel captain turned hotly back to face the horse’s master.
‘“We do not ride, weakling,” he said. “We run! We run fast and long under the dark skies and through these empty, open lands. We hunt and we run! We will find for you your dwarf-rat. But now, I think, you shall have to run with us. I hope you will keep up, for my boys have no patience for lackards.”
‘At this he placed his bloodied hammer lazily upon his shoulder and walked brazenly past the traitor-man.
‘The traitor-man, his hand on his sword hilt, did nothing.
‘Shagrach!’ he cried to the other lieutenant above the calls of his party, “there is now much meat for our threescore friends. Stew it and render it as you will to make things ready.”
*****
Flomi could see the lightwells of the roof again and suspected that it was late in the afternoon. Someone had turned him. He also knew that it was Inbar, or his bleating, that woke him. But throughout his drowsing and waking hours the Man’s song was running in his head.
‘...A numerous band. It burned in his spirit...
‘To urge his folk to found a great building...
‘A mead-hall grander than men of the era...’
And later, much, much later he thought, the singing roused him;
‘Then the work I find afar was assigned...
‘To many races in middle-earth’s regions...
‘To adorn the great folk-hall. In due time it happened
‘Early ’mong men, that ’twas finished entirely,
‘The greatest of hall-buildings; Eälenea she named it...’
‘What!?!’ Flomi cried out from his drowsiness. ‘No, this could not be so! Where have...’
He was startled by the memory, weakened and dizzying from trying to rise and, lying back, he was greatly surprised to see Collum at his side.
‘Ease, please ease yourself, my friend!’ he said, taking Flomi’s hand. There was grave concern on his face, but Flomi was joyed to see him come.
‘Collum?’ he called in his weakness. ‘Am I so far gone with fever, or are you here?’
‘We have come, yes, Flomi,’ he said and then tried his famously encouraging smile, ‘but you have left us little to do upon late arrival. Are these dozen kills of your doing? It was quite a mess you left us for your first day in our new home. ’
‘Dozen, you say? I... I thought, perhaps fourteen with the bowmen...’ Flomi said drowsily. ‘The bard here helped me...’
‘He did indeed and in many ways, Master Dwarf,’ another deeper voice said from above. Flomi saw a great wise face then with penetrating eyes, staring down at him over Collum’s shoulder.
‘He has surely saved you from greater injury than you yourself have bothered to care about and I should remind you to thank him for it. Once you have slept.’ At this the old man put his hand on Flomi’s brow.
‘Your eyes...’ Flomi said as he drifted off again, ‘they are like the sea...’
‘Have you seen the Sea, brave one?’ the greybeard said as Flomi’s eyes were closing.
‘No...’ he said slowly, drifting back into dreams. ‘But now I think I should like to...’
‘Sleep, brave one,’ he heard the voice gently speaking, ‘and dream of it if you will. For sometimes the Seas are gentle and sometimes they are caring...’
And if Flomi was comforted to hear this we do not know. For he went into a very deep and healing sleep as the words were spoken.
*****
‘They did indeed run fast in the open lands. Of this, their captain spoke in truth. I would have had trouble staying up with them if they were not so boisterous and disturbing of all the ground as they went. From their encampment to the Great Road was not far and so I knew that I might follow at some distance. I then watched as the dozen ruffians rumbled loudly down in that direction. I would follow in their wake after attending to other tasks; for I could not leave these other three stand to make camp for three-score like them.
‘So I waited in the trees as the main orc-party departed, that I might make example of these three and perhaps also discourage many more of their kind.
‘The orcs fell upon the horse-carcass immediately. I fell upon them shortly after. This was no great battle; quickly I dispatched them and after felt slighted by the task. The horse still lay screaming in her miseries and I ended those as quick as I may.
‘These were not the broad-backed warriors nor the short-legged snufflers. They were rank-folk, porters perhaps, or simple spear-carriers left behind because they had no greater skill than the following of orders. I slew them quickly as I may without unduly damaging their heads.
‘For this was the work of my new intention; three pikes with three orc-heads for the three-score of orc-warriors a-coming. Perhaps seeing this the new-comers would scurry and the town might still be saved. Doubtful, but the only course I might follow in short time.
‘I wondered how I may help the town except through this act. I might wait and stand against the three-score orcs that were coming myself. There might be great songs to hear of that encounter. Such an idea very much tempted my heart.
‘And I very well might take one of these ugly, unimpressive and unfortunate orc-heads to the town as previously planned. They, the townsfolk, may then believe me, perhaps, and then they may prudently send their own folk into the field to meet the three-score. I could not know, for I know nothing of townsfolk.
‘But of those others, the orc-captain and the traitor-man, the townsfolk would likely give little regard. And the dwarf they hunted would suffer mightily before help might ever come to him.
‘I have heard of dwarf-folk. Just as I have heard of oliphants, ungolianonnar, trolls and Taras, dwimmerlaik and dragons.7 They did not come into the histories of the Minhiriathrim but lived much in songs of their fancy. The Minhiriathrim love tales and songs from the outer world and seldom do they doubt them. Great Kingdoms of Tunnels, the songs bespoke, chiseled in the hard rock of all mountains and dwarves were the children of these rock and lords and makers of these vast mountain kingdoms. Fabled these halls were, like unto high-ceilinged mead halls filled with much wealth made bright in dark places by lighted lanterns of cunning design, well-secured with great arms and keenly-made comforts beyond the ken of the woodland men.
‘When they first spoke of the dwarf I thought, standing in the tree boughs as I watched the main group of orcs depart, that I should very much like to meet a dwarf. That would be wonderfully interesting. But, moreso, I knew that I could not abandon this dwarf or any lone traveler to such foul folk whose intent I knew only too well.
‘So, after finishing my work with the fresh orc-heads and the warning they might give to their new-coming comrades, I forsook my intended errand to the town and followed the others north and west through the night to the aid of this lone traveler. I would give what help that I may and, perhaps, hope that this was payment of my patience. For I would abandon no goodly traveler to goblins.
‘Closer I came to their party shortly after crossing the Great Road. Watching cautiously and listening sharply I moved quietly downwind to escape their attentions. They had, in their hungry clamour, become easy to follow.
‘And all the louder now this orc-band had become. Whatever cautiousness may have quieted them at the Road’s crossing was forgotten by their folk now. They barked and howled and rambled out of rank, the fighters restless once more and impatient for their hunter-folks to find the dwarfish scent. These snufflers went wide of the gaggle group of the ruffians, turning their rough talents, their noses and their keener night-eyes to the task. The wind was from the West, well-omened for us and all our People, and I worked down her8 way to walk up quietly as I might behind the orc-band. Close I might come in this manner, with the wind’s favour, and perhaps pull down some weary straggler or two from the pack.
‘The wood here was opening and the hills of the land were gently rolling. I had not traveled beyond the Great Road before and my heart was now somehow struck by the placid stillness of this place. Ancestral memory was awakened as my Unnórenean blood came here to the home of its abandoned birthright. Do you know this call? Can you understand it? I could not deny its power. Keeping my practiced quiet came quickly here, naturally and to my heart’s-blood, for the silence of the land was heavier in me here than in the greenwood din of Eryn Vorn, the happy, noisome safe-haven of my childhood.
‘Always it was the North which called to Unnórenean blood, beckoning us to come from the woodhaven safety of our birth to the north and east, to the hills and lands that should be the old-lands of our lost heritage. “Deeper than Song runs the blood of Unnórenain,” the Minhiriathrim often said, “and cold but commanding in their heart is the blood which beckons them home.” I think of that now as I walk in these northlands.
‘In Tyrn Goerthaid9 four years before I had heard this call of blood so very strongly. But that land was cursed and is a home now for no Man. Many of our folk once had their rest there. Many of my lineage were there laid down. And, as all my fathers had done, I had made pilgrimage to these downlands on my twentieth autumn to hear their ancestral voices. Many hopes I then had as a younger man to understand my heritage not only through the songs of my protectors but also through the death-practices of our ancestors. I was drawn, by my own heart’s blood, to have the Unnórenain understanding for what was lost. And to all who question loss, Tyrn Goerthaid, and its inhabitants, give quiet and dismal answers.
‘“Númenórean blood is ours,” these shades told me. These wights who now held those downlands, they who laid down in death so very long ago before that blood had dried or grown watered in life throughout the Northlands. Now their home and rest has darkened, their once green mounds become dire and desolate, turned to a twisted and blighted plague-place of angered memories. An empty land of perturbéd spirits who despised their own restlessness. Yet, as graveyards might, the land itself drew its own far-folk home to its desolate bosom to taste of ancient reverie. Tryn Goerthaid was no longer a land of honor-watch and of requiem for distant families of the Sea-kings as long stories of our folk had told me. Now it was a land to be lamented. Once precious, revered by our People, it would never be ours’ again. It has been taken and darkened. Now it is a land of waste and of wraiths, a past that has become pestilent, where requiescent honors given the dead become entrapments for the living.
‘All the men of my house made their journey-rite of manhood there. Is it the same in your house? For we believe that all Men must learn to resist the call of their disturbed dead kinsmen. But some, as I am, were drawn further by their Unnórenean blood’s old, cold calling.
‘The low and hazy hills had most immediately awakened my heart’s blood from the first moment I had come to Tyrn Goerthaid. Sadness had settled into my young heart then; the unnamed disquiet of finding home and knowing it to be broken long before my arrival. Perhaps this was the purpose my forefathers had in the pilgrimage; the knowing of what is lost may bring the vision to begin anew. Good sons do all that is bidden by great fathers. I saw to the spirits, resisted their dwimmer-talk, and stood my night’s vigil at their pillar. In the bleak, still morning afterward I returned again to Eryn Vorn and my family as I should. But I never lost the memory of this great call to my blood, this awakening to my homelands.
‘Now the land here above the Great Road called me deeper and its stillness makes my heart sound all the stronger. The orcs occupied my attentions, but the empty lands filled my heart’s-blood.’
‘I have not yet seen the Barrow-downs,’ Collum said to the bard, ‘but everything you say of them fills me with the same sadness I have felt in the Northlands.’
‘No, soldier,’ the bard replied, ‘these lands are emptied and lonely, but not haunted and bare. Take joy in how they thrive!
‘But I must return to the story.
‘Before I could come too close behind the party, there came a great rustle through their ranks and more loud gross sounds of their restlessness. Then came a call from the captain’s voice and they began to run again. They had found the scent.’
*****
Light fell upon Flomi’s face and his body quietly woke with its welcoming warmth.
‘... Light-hearted laughter loud in the building...’ Flomi began to say softly in Sindarin. Some memory stirred in him of music.
‘Greeted him daily; the dulcet harp-music,
‘Clear song of the singer...’ he returned, as if in a dream of reciting.
‘He is waking!’ a great voice said near him. Flomi turned his head a bit to this and saw an enormous man, with bristling red-brown hair and bare arms and a bright happy smile on his wide face.
‘You must lie still, little warrior,’ the man said, coming closer with open hands. ‘You have slept many hours but have many wounds. I have watched over you while the others have talked.’
There was a strange flavor to the man’s talk; halting at times, as if the Common Tongue was young in him, but robust in tone like the bard’s had been. But they were not the same. Flomi thought it unlikely that this was some countryman of the man who had aided him.
‘I should not have thought it likely,’ came another much clearer voice from nearby, ‘but to be surprised by a dwarf seems a little thing in these three days of surprises.’
The voice was young and bright and clear, but filled with sureness and some small measure of disdain. He then saw an Elf-child walk up next to the man and began to remember.
‘You two were at the Four Greenfields... on the night of my departure,’ Flomi said. ‘Have you come with Collum?’
‘Yes, yes, you are remembering well, rune-master,’ the Elf-child said, ‘Pallando and the Unnórenean will be well pleased.’
‘He woke to sing a song, Tawar,’ the giant wildman told the Elf-child, ‘and in the language of your own folk.’
‘Indeed?’ the Elf-child said, this time with genuine surprise. ‘Well, I should like to hear that! I have learned lately to respect the learning of rune-masters, but an Elfish song raised in the deep voice of the Naugrim? This intrigues me.’
‘No, no...’ Flomi said, ‘you misunderstand. It is not an Elfish song, but something from old Arnor that this bard... brings us. Something important to our cause. Is the bard still here?’ he asked urgently. ‘Collum must know!’ he tried rising but the strong yet gentle hand of the wild man, and the pain in his chest, quickly convinced him to lie back.
‘He knows, little warrior,’ the man said gently. ‘They talk now and my brother here has just come from their speaking.
‘Yes. Rest yourself, rune-master,’ the Elf-child said, ‘there is great counsel being taken about you and your enterprise and I have just come from there.’
‘Tell them, tell Collum,’ Flomi said as he lay back under the big man’s gentle hand, ‘the bard brings us clues... tell him we must hear his song...’
But if this Elf-child heeded him, or had any reasons of his own in the matter, Flomi could not tell. He drifted slowly back into sleep and, at the edge of his reason before slumber, thought he heard the soft music of a dulcet-harp playing within the cavern.
*****
‘After an hour's angry run the orcs paused again as they closed upon their quarry. A short valley they had come to and I watched them safely from the distance of a hilltop as their new courses were laid.
‘In the valley’s bottom they had come upon another Man, another race-traitor, who awaited their aid. I could not hear the exchange of their voices at so great a distance, but knew they had caught up to the other villain who had been stalking the dwarf.
‘This man was on horseback, as his comrade had been. He was taller than the other race-traitor perhaps, and also held both longbow and a sword at his side. Even from high on the hill I could see that this was a man more given to governance than his companion and who would well-master the orcs. Even at a distance this was a dangerous man.
‘From safe surrounding I watched a while as the orc-captain and the two traitor-men talked and a dozen warriors rustled aimlessly around. Harsh words were likely said, though I heard them not from that high place above the valley and over the harsh crashing of the restless orc-folk.
‘Suddenly, unexpectedly, this new leader shot his hand up and let a loud dark cry into the night. This was of a crass language, unknown to me, but dark and fearsome to all who heard it. The gnashing sounds of unhappy orcs were stifled by it, the restless and boisterous wandering of their usual behavior halted. With some rough voice in some Dark Tongue the traitor-man had mastered them and all were paused before it.
‘Short was the speech (though its barely heard rhythms echoed us quietly in my head), and the traitor-man raised his sword high upon giving it.
‘Finishing the Dark Talk he spun his blade quickly, mercilessly, to cut the throat of his own horse. Rather than see the beast suffer he brought the blade swiftly down to end its life. Then, walking boldly to the orc-captain, he took up the captain’s raiment in his hand and wiped the horse-blood from his blade. Sheathing it and looking into the captain's eyes, he called loudly to the orcs in his same Dark Language.
‘They fell, warrior and hunter, upon the fallen horse, tearing and rending for all they could get of the fresh meat still hot with life.
‘The orc-captain did not move. His hammer did not leave his shoulder. He looked to this new commander with a long and sharp eye. After a long moment he spit to the side and accepted the man’s leadership.
‘A dozen orcs ate all they might of the dead horse’s flesh quick as they may and then this dark man had them on the hunt again.’
*****
‘Flomi?’ a voice called. ‘You must wake awhile, my friend.’
It was Collum, of course, and the man’s voice drew him through the darkness. But waking made him feel stronger, and he was happy to answer.
‘I am here,’ he said softly, ‘though I marvel that you and so many others are here with me. Our place of hiding seems to have become a meeting-hall...’
Collum used his old and trusted soft smile; ‘well, my friend, it was you that left open the doors.’
‘True, that I did,’ Flomi replied. ‘But such a time I had in opening and defending them that little chance came to run back up the stair to see them shut. I trust that your ancestors will forgive me for this.’
‘Oh, of that I have no doubt,’ his friend said, ‘for they are indebted to you already. Here. I have brought some stew to give you strength. Can you manage it?’
‘Yes, I shall try,’ Flomi said, trying to rise up a bit, ‘I am rightly famished...’
‘Here, friend,’ Collum said, ‘I will help you.’
So he came beside the dwarf, helping him sit up a bit and placing his saddle, which lay nearby, behind him. Flomi took the bowl from him and, proudly, managed to feed himself from it. There was a long and awkward moment between them as he tried to accomplish this, and Collum smiled softly again to break the tension.
‘Four days, I should think,’ Flomi said slowly to his friend. ‘Four days’ rest and, if he will have me, I should be able to ride a bit on your friend Duncan there. If he will have me.’
‘Oh, he has taken a strong liking to you,’ Collum said, laughing in a reassuring way. ‘Moreso than he ever had with myself or poor Guldir. All this day and night he has stood cautiously by your side. If he will bear any rider I am sure it would be you.’
There was another pause between the two as Collum watched his friend painfully slurp at the bowl of stew. Flomi did not meet his gaze, though he felt its questions. Collum could see that the dwarf’s left arm shook weakly, but that he still needed the help of it to hold the small bowl aloft with his right. He could hear the depth of the dwarf’s breathing; so much better now than when he had arrived to find him last night, but shallow still and coming much more often than it had in his health. Collum had never served beside a dwarf before, though he had heard old stories of their hardiness; but he had also seen many harsh battles and many wounded soldiers. He was wondering if Flomi would survive.
In the awkwardness of the moment Flomi tried to look about the room. The wounds in his shoulder and chest made it hard to turn about, but he saw half a dozen other figures, and some of their beasts, in the Grazing Fields around them.
‘We have much help now, it seems,’ the dwarf said. ‘Have you brought some horde of comrades for me to meet? I fear...’ he coughed a hard and wet cough here that frightened them both, ‘I fear that I have been too drowsy to offer them my thanks. Tell me, what do they know of our enterprise?’
‘Ahh, that is still uncertain,’ Collum said, drawing closer and smiling his old familiar smile again. ‘Some are here who have wisdom deeper than Men may account for. Of those folk the little clues I have given to enlist their aid have, I think, revealed much without my saying. But they are enigmas themselves, these three, and I still do not know if they consider our goal worthy of their interest.
‘Others are here,’ he continued, ‘like your unlooked-for comrade, that are about business of their own; traveling west to the mustering that Círdan calls in Mithlond. They know less of course, but are anxious for their own journeys-‘
‘No!’ Flomi said, nearly spilling his stew-bowl, ‘the Bard must come with us, Collum! He has missing pieces of the puzzle. He sang a song that I have never heard that speaks specifically of our goal.’
‘How can this be?’ Collum replied, surprise showing on his face for the first time that Flomi could remember seeing it. ‘His folk are known to us, but mostly forgotten from the North. A song, you say?’
‘Yes,’ Flomi replied, ‘a very beautiful, very long song, in Sindarin of all things. I have many questions for him... though I will need more strength to ask them.’ He took a longer draw of his stew then and Collum noticed that his left hand shook less noticeably and that his gaze seemed sharper in its focus as he looked at the other travelers.
‘And,’ Flomi said slowly, regaining even breaths after his outburst, ‘though it pains me to admit it, we would be better equipped if we kept that elf among us. The Bard sings in Sindarin, but I cannot make out more than half of it.’
*****
‘The orcs returned to the hunt after their hot meal, long and straight through the night. They rushed less, making it easier for me to keep pace, for their way was more even now and their new commander had given them all they needed to track the dwarf-scent. There were pauses to their hunt, as if this new commander was curious to see where his quarry was bound, but the hunters had no such patience. Behind them the sun was soon to awaken. I made my own hidings more carefully, aware that the fear they felt from behind might disclose me.
‘They halted on a small rise of land as the night grew short. Many looked down to see their quarry ahead, but many also looked back to see the worrisome coming of dawn. In the deep protection of trees along the hillside I moved closer to hear their speech.
‘“...so if he’s wanted, we want him now,” their captain complained as his band stood beside him. “For if the Sun is on him soon, then we won’t be.”
‘Some rumbled, gnashed and growled in approval, but none of them too loudly.
‘The race-traitors then spoke to each other in some different tongue, yet another that I have never heard before, and considered their next steps with this band of ill-tempered gorgûn. The warriors paused with their ears high while the snufflers kept eyes averted from their masters and noses low to the ground on the dwarf’s trail.
‘“He flees,” the smaller race-traitor replied to the orc-captain, “but soon he’ll make camp. He is soft; a townsfolk. He awaits some guidance from his fellows that should come to him and I’m surprised that he’s come this far. There must be some pre-arranged meeting for him to come all this way through the night. He is frightened, and I half expect him to turn back. We’ll have him soon.”
‘“We’ll have him before the yellowface comes,” commanded their captain, encouraged by his companions at his back, “or me and my fellows will be off!”
‘Grumbles and grunts came from the band of fighters behind him. A slow and quiet silence followed.
‘“We will follow,” the other, stronger commander said coldly, “and in the hour before dawn falls on him we shall. But until then,” he had said slowly, but increasing the harshness in his voice so all nearby might hear, “if you want to keep your wretched lives beyond that sunrise and if you respect the authority of our terrible masters as I do, you will follow this dwarf and you will only take him when you are told to do so.”
‘Then the grunts and the gnashing noises amongst the fighters stopped. The captain spat at the ground again, though to the side of the traitor-commander, whom he eyed suspiciously.
‘“Aye,” he said, “an hour before the dawn we’ll give it. But we’ll take him quickly then, or leave you to the job yourselves. And you can tell our terrible masters that and where to find us when you fail.”
‘At this he raised his great hammer high and beckoned his boys forward. Then, fast again, but now quiet, for they would take their quarry soon and would not have him alerted.
‘The traitor-men, their command threatened, now ran to keep up.’
*****
Awakening under early dawn light, Flomi knew that he had once again lost the track of time. ‘How odd,’ he thought upon waking, ‘that a dwarf should lose time at rest in a cavern while others still know it by the rhythms of sunshine.’
‘Sunshine is their rhythm, rune-master,’ a voice said to him from somewhere that was not quite his hearing, ‘but it is not yours or that of your People. Men rise by Sun and till the land and work their arts. They build their worlds and dream of their futures with each new morning. Elves rise by Stars, but they till and they build no longer, preferring to lament their long lives in this Middle-earth that they once thought to be only their own.
‘The Children of Aulë harken not to Stars or Sun but to the firmament of Arda itself. You awaken as the world tells you,’ the voice said, ‘and there is much to be learned from that.’
Flomi looked about him to see where this voice had come from (for he seemed certain it was Dwarf-speech and unknown to any he had previously seen in the party) and found that the old man in the deep blue robes with the haunting eyes of the sea was seated here by his side.
‘Grandfather,’ he said respectfully, ‘do I know you? Twice now you have looked after me and brought me great peace. And now I feel you know much of my People that remains unspoken in the broader world.’
‘Perhaps,’ he said softly (and Flomi was here glad to see his mouth move and to know that it was the Common Tongue which he spoke with). ‘I know well the works of Mahal,10 your Maker, though I cannot pretend to know his purpose.
‘Of you, however,’ he said rising, ‘I can speak. You will live, Rune-master, though this battle was an untimely test of your mettle. Stone, they say, must be quarried to be measured, and you have done well in your time of rough-handling and severe measurement.
‘After such a trial Khazâd like yourself, though Rune-masters are seldom counted amongst the battle-folk, either die glorious deaths or lead good long lives of great prosperity as your Maker has willed it and as Ilúvatar has allowed.
‘Rest, son of Trochi,’ he said, laying again his gentle hand on Flomi’s brow, ‘and be well. Hold faith that you are not forgotten, and live justly and proudly in the Fire of Mahal.’
And again Flomi looked long into the deep color of the old man’s eyes and saw the sea that he heretofore had no reason to imagine. And, though questions swirled about his mind as the man touched his forehead, he felt a peace he had not felt in years and fell fast asleep.
In his dreams he heard a four-worded sound he had never heard before ‘seesoo, hrss, rsseeiss, ooors’11 and was happy. No great task lay before him, no crushing weight of his father’s work controlled him. He was free to live a long and prosperous life apart from responsibility.
But this, of course, was only the comfort of dreaming.
*****
‘I had taken no stragglers for there were none. They moved tightly now as a band, under their familiar orc-captain, excited with a clear and under-powered quarry before them. The traitor-men had held them in check well for a time, but they could not hold back the dawn. Their allies were restless for want of blood. Now as the Last Wall grew nearer in the dwarf’s flight they became concerned; had he some help awaiting on the other side?
‘So, as they had promised, the traitor-men determined to take him an hour before the dawn and within a mile of the westward wall. The men snuck to the fore of the party and then the bowman put an arrow into the runner’s back. From my place of cover behind the orc-band I saw as the arrow struck the lone figure and heard the orcs’ wild cries as they broke from cover to take their prey.
‘They were still some two hundred or so strides out and I, in my place of concealment, another fifty. With the orcs in full run I would not reach the dwarf until too late. I wondered what small help I might still be, and followed the orcs as hastily as I might.
‘From the trees ahead I heard a strong call. A voice deeper than any I have experienced. I heard this dwarf as he rumbled and cursed angrily through the night with a foreign music which stirred me.
‘“Abrâfu shaikmashâz!” came the cry and I could see the lone figure as he broke from cover, his weapon high. “Follow if you dare!” the dwarf challenged them all, “I shall show you the hardness of Dwarven steel.”
‘And at this he turned and ran to a glade some small distance away that was marked by seven white trees, well-omen of our People. The orcs cursed his challenge and followed him hotly. But the ground here was open before the glade and I had to pursue more cautiously to come up behind them unawares.
‘“I shall follow to see your steel shine, master dwarf,” I thought then, “and I will aid you as I can that I might hear the deep music of your language once more.”’
‘And we are greatly indebted that you did,’ Collum said to the Bard after hearing his long tale, ‘for though he fought mightily and conquered many, Flomi would not have survived his wounds without you. Even with Pallando’s aide, his hope is still doubtful.’
The two men stood outside beneath the wall, the hidden door now shut again behind them. Dawn was now nearing and for Collum it had been a long night of dire surprises and hasty consuls before hearing the Bard’s full tale.
‘Your kindness towards my friend has brought you to a most secret place, Unnórenean,’ Collum said to the man as he looked east to the gathering light, ‘but as I understand your history, it is a place for all our People. I am glad that you have helped to defend it and I trust you shall keep its secrets.
‘Our own paths ahead are uncertain until we know more of Flomi’s health,’ he continued. ‘Will you stay with us for a time?’
*****
Flomi awoke again, after some longer time, to the sound of gentle harping. The song itself did not wake him, in fact it had quite the opposite effect on his heart; intricate in its structure but altogether soothing in its melody, the song spoke to him of green meadows and of day’s last light, of long shadows and well-trodden roads to homes with lighted doorways and warm breezes out of the South. The early glimmering of the brightest stars in the darkening sky of a day’s work ended. Though these were not, he knew, the normal comforts of his own People, the song spoke to the comforts of his life as he knew it in the Bree-land and which he also knew he might never see again.
His wetted eyes, affected by the song, opened slowly as to not break the spell on his heart and he was not surprised to see that the Bard sat beside him, playing a harp of unique and marvelous design, leaning intently to his task.
He sat up just a little, quite quietly so as to not disturb the song, and looked about him as far as his injuries would allow.
Some ways off he saw Inbar and three other beasts. One was Caitelyn, Collum’s own great mare, with another horse and fat white pony. All three seemed calmed by the Bard’s music and even Inbar, standing a little apart from the rest, cocked his head and raised his great long ears to the sound.
Three old men (if Men they were) in robes of blue and grey sat in stillness on a bench near the fountains; relaxed they seemed, but unsleeping and unspeaking. They too were quieted by the song and sat unmoving beneath its spell.
A hobbit that he knew, the hunter Benbow Floxleaf of whom Collum had spoken so well, was curled up and asleep in a tuft of the grass which grew here in the Grazing Field. Flomi could see a great light in his face which at first shocked him. Then, and perhaps for the first time, he realized what he found so surprising and confounding in his time amongst these Breelanders; their ability to seek and to show the benefits of simple peace at the end of a good day’s work. In Floxleaf’s face he saw everything that he should ever miss of the Bree-land, and he was the happier for that memory throughout the remainder of his life.
Not far from him lay the great wildman he had met earlier, also deep in slumber, the heaving of his enormous chest slow and calmed and keeping some strange beat to the harping. Beside him stood the Elf-child, not much taller than Flomi himself was. He stood straight, but without rigidness, his eyes closed in green-dreaming (as Flomi had heard that they will do) and some small, half-surprised, expression of joy on his face. Whether this was for the harping or of his own green-dreaming Flomi could not know. Elves were a subject of some interest to his research but quite unfamiliar to him, and this one seemed more queer in ways than most. But the Elf-child was as much at peace as the others as the music played. This much anyone might see.
Collum sat closest of course. His great longsword lay beside him, his hand rested nearby it, but his head had also drooped in drowsiness. He was too much the soldier, too much the friend, to not stand vigil, but his weariness and the song’s power had, at last, gotten the better of his long watchfulness.
Lastly he turned his head again to the Bard, who looked at him now while still playing intently, beautifully. Flomi blinked his happy eyes, nodding, smiling, drowsing again, as if to thank the harper for his song. The man smiled back warmly, working his fingers freely over the curving instrument in his lap; plucking now more intently.
Flomi heard the call of green fields again at dusk, felt the long cool shadows of trees, knew again the very taste of red summer wine upon his lips. He thought of his father’s silly yellow waistcoat and was happy to have brought it. He decided that he should finally take up pipeweed. He wondered where he had put that small piece of limestone and very much wished to hold it again.
As he finally relented and slipped finally down into a healing slumber, small details of the stoneyard and of the Bree-land echoed through his head. He would never go there again, but for tonight the harp’s sad music gave his heart a fond memory of that last home for one final moment.
End of Chapter Seven
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter Seven
1) The italics for this song, and at some later points in the chapter, indicate that the words are being sung to Flomi in Sindarin. Not all italics within the chapter will be Sindarin, of course, as this was a common device in Tolkien for relating songs and any unfamiliar tongues. But for the scenes with Flomi and the Bard, the song here is always Sindarin. It is important to note that Sindarin, and not Adûnaic, was the “cultured and written” language of the Dúnedain in the Third Age and, as such, also principal in their histories. Moreover, readers should recognize that this song is rather freely appropriated from Beowulf. It has, from the beginning, been my intention to weave legends and stories that fit tightly into the Tolkien legendarium as Easter Eggs for readers. This chapter is an exercise in just that and, I hope, I should be forgiven by classics scholars who know the work so much better than I might. Like most artists of my age, I learn just enough of what I need to steal what I want to make the thing which I believe is my own best from what I know. Honest appropriation is a sad replacement for genuine research, but can be a sincere fuel for art.
2) Some here might take notice of “gorgûn” as the name for orcs amongst the Drúedain. There are (or may be) some links between the Drúedain, the Minhiriathrim and the Púkel-men that I hope to explore.
3) Unlike many of his predecessors, there is indeed no direct Sindarin translation for Amlaith’s name. Does this cast him as less legitimate? There are some unanswered questions here regarding the name.
4) I’ve got quite a lot of Joyce on me and so I looked hard and long to see if the sound of a donkey bray had been rendered by him or any other modern author. I found very little to my liking. So this noise, built with my fondest nod to Joyce, is the closest I can come at this time to the musicality of a bray.
5) Dwarves have their own language, which is secret, and their own names for fellows and loved-ones that also remains secret. Flomi will not use this name openly much, but he is groggy here and just thinking of it. “Inbar” means “horn” in Dwarfish and is given for the loud braying which saved his master’s life.
6) Reader’s here may note the similarity to the three characters in the Book of Daniel; Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego. There is no particular link intended here except that I find the sound of those names musically appropriate for orcs.
7) Of this list, “ oliphants, ungolianonnar, trolls and Taras, dwimmerlaik and dragons” a few items need mentioning. “Ungolianonnar” would mean “children of Ungoliant” as best I can manage. Oliphants and dwimmerlaik were chosen to indicate possible commonalities in the speech of the Rohirrim and of the Hobbits which Merry writes about some thousand years later. The geographic location of the Minhiriath makes it likely that smatterings of those older languages might have come there, much like the “gorgûn” mention in note #2. But “Taras” is a new thing within the list and is a reference to Mount Taras in Beleriand, lost in the changing of the world but somehow remembered in the songs of these old, old people.
8) Though Tolkien does not indicate genders for the four winds, I thought it might be something interesting to play with. The Minhiriathrim, in my construction, give characters, if not quite personifications, to the different winds, complete with names and stories. Winds of the west and of the south are all feminine and protecting, of the north and of the east, masculine and ill-favouring .
9) “Tyrn Goerthaid” is a more ancient name for the Barrow-Downs visited (unfortunately!) by Frodo and the other hobbits in his party. Tyrn Gorthad was the name in Sindarin. It is a compound of torn ("down") and gorthad ("of buried"). In one manuscript, the name Tyrn Goerthaid was used by Tolkien. Goerthaid seems to be the plural of gorthad with affected vowels.
10) “Mahal” or Maker, is the Dwarf word for Aulë. It is unclear how much the dwarves know of the Valar, but they know Mahal to be one of the many “Lords of the West” and that, unlike the other races of Middle-earth, they know he created them.
11) This onomatopoeic bit of sound is, again, from James Joyce, this time directly. It can be found in the “Proteus’ episode of ULYSSES and I think it does rather sound like the sea.
Chapter Eight; "As They Waited"
-In Which a Wizard Departs, a Peculiar Passage is Discovered, and Preparations are Made.
Read Chapter Eight; "As They Waited"
Ohtar hoped that Flomi would be well enough to take long counsel by the third sunrise1 since his battle with the orcs. But three days of waiting and confinement would be hard upon such uniquely self-directed and inquisitive folk as these others; there were Elves and Men here on their own missions, Wizards going about their mysterious business and one lone and quite baffled hobbit following along at Ohtar’s lead, but still always wondering about his friend’s secretive background and desperate request.
There were none in that small group who doubted for a moment that Flomi needed rest and healing before all of them might better benefit from longer counsel. They were all held there (with the possible exception of the hobbit) because they knew that something unique and powerful had drawn them to this moment and each felt that their way forward was less certain than it had been before their meeting.
Three days of wondering what might come next would weary a few of the party greatly and certainly make some of them anxious, make them question Ohtar about his mission and also make them very, very curious of one another’s intentions. They did try, each of them in their own way, to speak with one another and learn what they could about the concerns of the larger world on that first night since finding that Flomi had been attacked. The three wizards, who knew matters of the larger world best, were, quite unsurprisingly, the least likely to speak and seemed to be taking the measure of the other companions. It seemed that the wizards, despite their talk of the importance of patience, had quite settled their own arguments almost immediately on the idea of staying with the group. One left on the very first morning after their arrival and then, by the middle of that next long night, there would be other quite pressing matters that the party would attend to.
But throughout this time and with little interruption Flomi slept and slept deeply. Great care had been taken at first to not overburden the dwarf with unnecessary questions and great attempts were also made to force him to rest when the party had first arrived. To accomplish these things Ohtar had worked in his own quiet way to separate Flomi from the Bard as much as possible; for the Bard’s song had become a great fixation for his friend and Ohtar would rather see Flomi sleep and heal under the wizard’s powers than try to solve this new and most perplexing riddle.
*****
‘Crows will come,’ the Bard had said to the soldier on the night of their meeting. ‘But the wall is wide and they will have their feast on the other side without rumour of us here.’
‘Crows we will manage,’ the soldier said to him then in the dark hours as they had talked while moving the orc-bodies. The wall was taller here than where the Bard had known it in the south, but with the help of the giant forester, they had been able to move all the orc-bodies to a great heap on the other side.2
‘Crows should not be trusted, Collum Ohtar,’ the forester said gravely.
‘I shall remember that, my friend,’ the soldier had said with a smile, ‘but for now, I had rather be back inside where crows, and other eyes, may take no notice of us.’
This giant forester was uncommonly strong and had proven to be of great help in disposing of the bodies. He could not scale the wall as nimbly as the soldier or the Bard may, but he could throw orc-bodies easily to the top, and sometimes cleanly over the wall on his own. It had made short work of a very repugnant task.
‘Come now, Unnórenean,’ the soldier said, turning in his direction, ‘for I will share with you a great secret of our ancestors that has been forgotten by most and is entrusted to few in this age.’
The three then went to where the door lay open and the soldier, reaching up his arm, showed a small sign on the stone of the wall. ‘Just here,’ he said, ‘is the mechanism of the doorway to our Secret Path; to the place we call Tauma, or the Foundations. Mark it!’
‘Tauma...’ the Bard repeated slowly, his face alight with a wonder of the forgotten past.
‘Press your hand to the stone,’ the soldier commanded. ‘Your kindness towards our friend and your ancestry have brought you to this secret and now you must know how to keep it!’
He did as he was bidden, for he could tell that the soldier was a great commander of men, but also because he felt a great need within his blood to be part of this secret.3 The stone was cold but, how strange! it yielded to his hand and moved softly, very slightly beneath his palm. Then there was a quiet grinding like that of many small scraping knives as the two doors within the wall began to close without aid.
‘How is...’ the great forester said from behind him. Both of them stood in caution and great amazement as slowly the doors locked together before them, showing no stitch or division; a solid wall of ancient stone once again.
‘This is no spell, my friends, but the art of our ancient peoples of Númenor,’ the soldier assured them. ‘Long has this great skill of building been forgotten by our people in the North and I confess it is beyond my understanding as well. Dwarves are said to have such skill and even greater but, as you all will come to see, dwarves are great keepers of secrets.
‘A touch to the same exact spot, hidden from all except those few who know it, will open or close this passage. I will show you another such on the inside. There is no strange power to be feared in this, Beothalion,’ the soldier said, turning his gentle smile on the forester, ‘only the great learning of a once great people. You might touch the stone as we have and accomplish the same. But the Unnórenean and I are descended from those ancient builders,’ and at this he turned back to the Bard. ‘We have the very great responsibility to guard this Secret Path. For it leads to Tyrn Gorthad and the sacred halls of our mighty forefathers.’
‘I have stood my watch at Tyrn Goerthaid, Soldier,’ he responded. ‘I have heard their pleas and whispers and still keep the secrets of my grandsires. And I will keep this doorway you have shown me with the same care.’
‘This is good to hear, Oisín Na-Glirhuin,’ the soldier responded. Then, smiling smartly, he said, ‘and it is funny that you should mention standing a watch...’
*****
‘He seems to have a keen eye in a wood, that’s certain,’ Ben said of the Bard on the first morning of their waiting. ‘Scouting out the area is one thing, Collum, but do we need to leave him at watch? That door closes marvelously and none could find it that doesn’t know it’s here. Are we not safe without an outer guard?’
‘All that you have said is true, Ben, and should make us feel safe,’ he said in response. ‘But it seems that you have lost count in the story our new friend has told; one lone orc-tracker left this battle alive.’
Ben’s brow wrinkled at this news a bit. In his life as Collum Gilleyfoil, innkeeper, Ohtar had known this hobbit many years, and knew that he was now counting things out in his head and wishing it was possible to use his fingers and perhaps even his toes for the process.
‘Stars, but that’s so!’ he said after a moment. ‘And, to hear your man tell it, there may be three scores of these foul folk arriving soon after only one night’s run from here!’
‘Yes,’ Ohtar said without excitement. ‘He is to be trusted in that, I believe.’
‘And they’re to march on the Breefolk?’ Ben said.
‘It did sound this way,’ Ohtar replied, trying to keep any affect out of his voice so that he might hear Ben’s unsolicited thoughts all the better.
‘But... should we not ride to warn them? The troops would arrive tomorrow, or so I would reckon from his talking, and may come to the Bree-land as soon as the day after!’
‘Or..?’ he asked quite softly, turning his fingers almost theatrically to draw his friend out further.
Again Ben worked his brow for a bit. This hobbit led a strangely solitary life and was not experienced with strategies and war bands. But he was sharp, Ohtar knew, sharpest among any of the hobbits that he had met these past dozen years.
‘Or, if the other little hunter who has escaped comes to them, having really nowhere else he might go, those three score orcs...’
‘Yes.’ Ohtar encouraged him to make the assessment and waited for it to settle.
It didn’t take long.
‘So we can’t warn the Breelanders because we can’t lose folk in case the attack comes here?’
As they stood up near the top of the stair before the open doors talking, the sun was rising on the first morning since Flomi’s battle. From what Ohtar and Benbow had heard from the Bard, sixty orcs would arrive sometime on the following night southwest of the Bree-land with orders and intentions to take the town. Tomorrow or the next night at the latest. Either of them might ride now, ride quickly, and marshal those sleepy Breelanders against such a terrible force.
Or, knowing that an orc escaped yesterday’s battle and had no other place to run to, knowing that the slaughter of his band and the importance of the dwarf might weigh heavily on any new commander, there was quite an equal chance that the three-score war party would come here.
And those who held the doorway numbered but nine.
One of them might ride back now, hurriedly, and warn the townsfolk. But to do so would mean that the rider must stay and marshal everyone there against the orcs. Milo and Buttercup were not ready for such a great task on their own. Ben knew that if he or Collum went back, they would have to stay and lead the town in its defense.
‘Ben,’ Ohtar said quietly and slowly, ‘I will not constrain you with promises if you had rather go back. I will say again that I and Flomi are on a gravely important task which I hope to have your help with. But if your honor calls you back toward the Bree-land...’
‘My honor!’ Ben said with a growing anger now that he realized what might be at stake. ‘Well, that might seem a precious thing to some of these mighty folk here I suppose, but it's not been a thing I carry so closely. Honor be stoned, for it’s of no more use to a fellow like me than a chamberpot!’ he said.
‘But it’s my care those Breefolks have, Collum, my care and some friendship. How can I know what I know and not go to share it with friends, what few of them I might have leastwise, who are so emperilled?’
‘Do you suggest that I find this same decision easy?’ Ohtar said. It was, he knew, a bit unfair of him to say such a thing. For it required Ben to challenge his own decisions in the matter against his sense of Collum’s own loyalty; and they both knew that Collum’s attachment to the townsfolk, no matter what new information Ben had learned, was sincere and that his friendships there went much deeper than Ben’s own.
‘No,’ the hobbit said, screwing up his face again in thought, but this time his voice softened with respect, ‘no, it’s a proper, or even true I suppose, life which you made there and a hard decision to not ride back. I did not mean to suggest you were beyond care for the Breefolk.
‘But if I, or some other, should ride-’
‘I believe that it is I who shall ride, master Floxleaf,’ said a loud and deep voice behind them. Olórin had, they now saw, been noiselessly walking toward them up the stair while they were talking.
‘You’re own way, it seems,’ he said, smiling in that odd way that he had, ‘is to follow your friend here and learn some of the many things about him which he has chosen to keep hidden for many years,’ He then turned the same smile on Ohtar.
‘No simple innkeeper, indeed,’ he said, ‘but no less true in his friendship, I should think.
‘No,’ he said in a resolved and steady voice as he looked east towards the doorway, ‘I shall warn the town, if they will listen, and I shall, if time and the situation permits, deal with this orc-band myself.
‘But,’ he said looking back to Ohtar, ‘I will have far to travel quickly afterward and I’m afraid I must borrow a horse.’
*****
‘A most wonderful rest, Tawar!’ Beothalion said to his brother as he came to meet him near the well. ‘We have traveled far and slept in many wide spaces that I have enjoyed greatly. But I have never felt such peace and dreaming as I did last night under our new friend’s song. Such power there is in music!’
And at this he laughed loudly and plunged his head neck-deep into the trough of the clear-flowing well. The water was cool and bracing. He drank long of it, enjoying the wakefulness it brought to his body without forgetting the comfort that the night’s sleep had given.
Lifting his great head he shook it violently, casting cool water all about him, laughing loudly again as he did so. His great voice was, however, overwhelmed by the caterwauling of the strange beast, Duncan, who was the dwarf’s friend.
And even Tawarengil was laughing. ‘It seems, brother,’ he said with a broad smile on his still-young face, ‘that you have found a new supporter for your customs and wisdoms. This could help us greatly, if only an ass could be called to counsel.’
‘You should not call him that, Tawar,’ Beothalion said quite seriously in return. ‘The innkeeper tells us he is from the South- imagine that, brother, a land where winter never comes! They must have queer ways in the South and do not speak even the Old Tongues there.’
To Beothalion’s eyes the beast named Duncan (though he did not respond as if this was his real name) was yet another of the many wonders this trip had shown him. He was no pony certainly, and as different from horses as the Little Folk like Benbow Floxleaf were from Dwarves.
Perhaps that was wrong. Beothalion had really only seen the one Dwarf as yet and that one was too wounded to be judged rightly.
But certainly this Duncan was different. Louder than the horses he had known, but clearly of deeper and more ribald humour (for Beothalion had met many horses in the past weeks and generally, without seeming unkind for their offered friendship, found them to be much more boring than the Men and the Little Folk). Horses, other than Benbow’s wise pony, seldom seem to laugh in this wider world that he had seen lately. But the beast called Duncan laughed and champed and shat at everything he encountered whether he understood it or not.
If Duncan was an “ass” as Tawar called him, then Beothalion himself felt even simpler beside him.
*****
He had been made to wait. There was great comfort for him in coming out of the tunnel and into a wood again before dawn and he let his senses be filled with the joy of it; but he was not entirely unwise to statecraft and knew that he had been decidedly and singularly made to wait. And so, wise as he was, and in want of friendship, he accepted this assigned position, believing it came from a distrust that was born more of caution than disrespect. He had been made to wait and in his wisdom accepted this.
‘Orcs may come,’ he thought, ‘but not in this day or even this night. Tomorrow. Perhaps. Orcs may come, yes they may or even may not, before three more dawns. But not today in this full sunlight.
‘I have been asked to watch empty roads during warm sunlight, and it is a tiresome task,’ he thought. ‘But I have been mostly asked to stand outside while these great worthies talk. I have been made to wait.’
So he had settled himself to a place in the high branches in this birch grove, marveling at the shape and whiteness of these well-tended trees. He began to watch with his eyes while letting his mind sleep to the rhythms of the wind.
And, seeing no other way, he waited.
*****
As Collum and Olórin went outside to discuss the matter further, Ben, feeling more troubled than before, turned back down the shallow stairway leading toward their encampment.
‘Well so the worthies have gone off again,’ he thought rather glumly, ‘discussing their great plans just as they should. I’ve no complaint there, for I’ve had trouble enough keeping up with all of this high-talk and newness in a long four days of discoveries. But I do wish I was given the time to know Collum’s purpose. Each time I feel I’m closer to hearing it one of these high-folk takes him away to some new counsel.’
Ben very much would’ve preferred to be outside under the trees with the Bard whom Collum had deployed as a scout. Like his father, he was always more comfortable in an open wood than any other hobbit he had heard of.
‘What a queer place this is,’ he thought, ‘not that any hobbit has a trouble in a hole, but this is not, well, this is not any old hole built to comfort.
‘Oh, it is old, yes, greatly old I should say, but that’s not how I mean it,’ he thought as he walked quietly down the stair. ‘Hobbits that I know build holes for comfort and this seems like a hole built for... now what’s the opposite of comfort, I wonder....’
While not the direct opposite of comfort, "despair” was the word that Benbow would’ve liked to use here, but he could not. Perhaps that word had come into the Westron speech by this time. Perhaps many of the Northmen had used it, for they had come to know it so well in their ongoing conflict with Angmar. Despair was certainly not an unfamiliar feeling in the North at this time, and Benbow was widely traveled in the North-lands.
And despair would be a well-suited word for the feeling this place brought on; for though they only stood at the doorstep, this was the Tauma, the great Path of the Dead for Númenóreans of the North Kingdom and Men have ever despaired at the thought of death.
But there may be no specifically less-Hobbitlike word than “despair” and we can say with a great degree of certainty that Benbow would know nothing of it at this time of his life.
He would, having experienced the crushing weight of despair in his very near future, try very hard to describe this feeling without benefit of a broader vocabulary. He would say, ‘terrified-to-stillness’ and ‘stonified-by- worrisomeness’ but none of these were ever right and, of course, Benbow Floxleaf was never a wordsmith.
Hobbits, joyful as they were to receive the world’s rewards for a good day’s work, had no real place for "hope" in their language or as something separate from their lives. And then, therefore, there was no reason why anyone would ever want to describe its opposite feeling. In this condition, hobbits, and even very unusual hobbits like Benbow Floxleaf, live rare lives quite different from the concerns of Men.
As he came to the bottom of the stairway, Ben’s sharp hunter’s eye caught a quick, furtive movement towards the far corner of the landing; some small creature, he thought, that had snuck inside while the doors remained open. His bow lay inside the grazing area still, so he drew his knife and, on soft-padded feet, crept over to investigate.
The antechamber at the base of the long shallow stairway, where the shattered remnants of a pavise still lay strewn about, had just the one door on the right where Flomi had made his desperate battle. It was not a large space, maybe going ten or more strides along past the door and, like the rest of the stairway above, unadorned and low-ceilinged. As Ben moved silently towards the rear he saw a fairly large rat, or perhaps a chuck, standing still, its eyes fixed on the hunter. It was not a dangerous creature from what he could see, but Ben thought it very odd that a scavenger like a rat would find its way down here so quickly. The orc bodies had not lain here long and were moved many hours ago.
Their eyes remained locked for a moment more and then, with a quickness surprising for its size, the creature turned and ran straight toward the western wall of the chamber and abruptly disappeared.
Cautiously Ben followed it and saw the open seam there between floor and wall that had provided the creature’s escape; a regular slot in the construction two paces long and as high as Ben’s own hand.
‘Now I’m no hole-dweller,’ he said to himself aloud, ‘but this does not look comfortable to me.’
*****
‘In regard to the Bree-folk I can offer very little assurance,’ the old man said, ‘other than to say that I will aid them if they will listen. In some places of Middle-earth that offer should seem assurance enough.’
‘I doubt it not, wisefather,’ Ohtar replied as they walked out through the parted doors, ‘and I thank you for it. They are a sturdy enough folk in their own short-sighted way, but there is no guard or militia that you might call upon other than my own people at the inn whom you have met, and some others of my own kind who are still placed secretly within the town. I fear for their safety greatly, but they will, I do not doubt, answer your call.’
‘It may be that these orcs can be diverted,’ Olórin said, ‘but your folk at the inn shall be warned of them in any case.
‘Now then, of your main endeavor, if I have guessed it rightly, I have shared my thoughts with my brothers of the order and convinced them it is indeed of great importance. Pallando, I believe, shall accompany you. No!’ he said, holding his hand up and keeping the man from answering. ‘This was not a request nor another question that I need you to confirm nor deny. You have played your game of questions very well, Ohtar, and I commend you on it. If I have guessed wrongly and am simply granting our great aid to a simple graverobber, then the fault shall be mine.
‘Either way,’ he said with a small smile, ‘I will reserve my last question with you for some time when we meet again.’
‘I pray that it may be so, wisefather,’ Ohtar said, bowing respectfully with open hands at his side and a look of great hope on his face.
The day was still quite young and the sun had not yet topped the Glade of Seven Birches just east of where they stood at the gate of the Foundations. In the glade the Bard, Oisín, had taken his position of watch, but even Ohtar’s sharp eyes could not see him there amid the branches. If Olórin saw him he did not say, though he turned his conversation to this topic next.
‘Of the Unnórenean,’ he said, ‘I’m afraid I have little counsel to offer. I have heard of their people living in Eryn Vorn and have some suspicions regarding their deeper origins, but cannot foresee their role in the world at this time. Still,’ and at this he paused for a moment, focusing his eyes there to the east as they both had, before saying, ‘I do sense that some great purpose lay about him.’
‘Flomi, too, believes this is so. The song he sang is of great age and may, Flomi thinks, speak to our-’
‘He brings more than song, I am certain,’ Olórin said, cutting him off, ‘but his path and his purpose may lie another way. It will be upon all of you in your counsel to decide how these purposes are aligned.’
‘His people are known to us,’ Ohtar said. ‘Some of the great families of old Arnor had settled into the land that became Cardolan when the kingdom was split. When that land was overrun some 500 years ago a remnant of the Dúnedain of Cardolan held out in the Barrow-downs and the far forests. But we have heard nothing of them in many long years. To think that his fate could somehow bring him to aid Flomi at such an hour-’
‘Your mission and your path is not the only one, Ohtar,’ and again the soft kindness crept back into the old man’s voice. ‘I have read the signs of this occasion and I caution you to do the same. To have three of our order appear by what you may call a chance-meeting and discuss our future paths is a rare occurrence indeed. To then be served three glasses of Miruvor and introduced to such a diverse group of folk running in three different paths is no chance at all.
‘Some here may desire to go west yet to answer Círdan’s call. It is there that the great thrust to undo Angmar must gather and it may be that the Unnórenean will wish to join it.
‘Your path is still undetermined but, if I have guessed rightly, it must ultimately lead north,’ he paused there looking for any contrary gesture in Ohtar’s eyes or his manner. ‘Yes,’ he continued. ‘North to undiscovered places and great rewards.
‘I will take the farther path to the east,’ he continued, ‘and while it will lead me through the Bree-land and these orcs, I must quickly come before lord Elrond and petition him to join the fight against Angmar. To do this and still save the Bree-folk I will need a horse. How fortunate then that, quite beyond your orders or expectations, your young master Fastknots has provided us with a spare. Fastknots indeed! He has tied things up nicely without knowing!’
He laughed loudly at this, the very surprise and act of his laughter seeming to warm the grey of his whiskers and the color of his face. It lightened the heart of Ohtar, who had been listening so intently that he now felt foolish for his own seriousness. The laugh was sudden and large and a bit startling, but overhead he heard the songs of morning birds, who seemed not frightened at all but echoed the joy of his laughter. And so Ohtar found himself laughing as well to some new, lighter feeling of purpose, some secret pleasure of knowing that he did not completely understand, but that somehow, beyond all fear, warmed him still.4
*****
‘Yes. I see. Most discomforting indeed,’ Alatar said as he gazed at the narrow strip of escape that Benbow had shown him and the others. As he spoke his nostrils wrinkled ever so slightly and, even in the very dim antechamber, Ben thought he could see an eyebrow of the wizard being raised scornfully. It was hard to be certain. Ben had known him only a few days now and thought the scornful cast of the old wizard’s face might be his regular expression.
‘This chamber is nothing like my own home in Authengroth, of course,’ the elf-lord said as he came forward to examine the area, ‘and I am no expert of cave-making. Alas that our dwarf is still resting. But it does seem to me that the stone here above is different than the rest.’
‘Indeed it is, lord Tawarengil,’ Alatar responded flatly and without looking. His eyes instead had turned up to the ceiling and searched around the edges of the floor to each side of the slotted opening. ‘For it is a door. And not, I believe, of original construction.’
From the sleeve of his robe he then drew a small wand, long as a huntsman’s dagger, white as bone and curled like some braided rope. As Ben watched, the old man lightly touched the tip of this strange object, and a soft, blue light like moonshine came forth and surrounded his hand, lighting the darker corners of the room.
For all his years in the wild, Ben had never seen anything like this; the old man had done it so simply, in such an easy and commonplace manner as he stood just a foot or two away from the hobbit’s unblinking eyes. Ben looked around to the others to see if they had seen it too, to make sure that he was not in some strange waking dream. Tawarengil's young-looking face betrayed, or so Ben thought, a familiarity with such things; for he now looked at the wizard with grave seriousness as if the wonderment of captured moonlight suddenly transported into the cave had just made matters more interesting for the Elf-child. Beothalion, who had been lingering cautiously back from the place the wizard had been examining, now stood with his jaw open, his head tilted in disbelief, rubbing and blinking his eyes as he stared at the glowing wand. At the sight of this, Ben realized his own jaw hung open as well.
‘Does it not seem unusual to you that this antechamber is so large and has only the one door to the east?’ Alatar said as he looked carefully around the western wall of the room.
‘I know nothing of the designs of Men, wisefather,’ Tawarengil replied, ‘but it does seem impractical. Would the Innkeeper know more of this perhaps?’
‘Not of this place, I think,’ the wizard said. ‘The tales of the Foundations and its construction were lost even in king Eldacar’s time and, for some reason- and I believe it to be quite long ago- this door seems to have been added or repaired in secret. More troubling, perhaps,’ he said gravely as he paused, kneeling on the floor before the edge of the opening, ‘I can find no trigger for this portal; no mechanism, inscription or device.
‘Perhaps you are correct, lord Tawarengil, and our dwarf-friend inside may provide better investigation when his health has improved. Perhaps Olórin will know more of this, for I have not traveled so much as he in the realms of Men. And I am no lockpick.
‘But the troubling idea, it seems,’ and at this Ben could see the wizard’s nostril crinkling again and his eyebrows arching a bit more, showing a subtle distinction in his rather steady emotional state of disdain, ‘is that the door may be made to open from the other side.’
*****
The laughter of the wise one rang through the boughs, lifting the hearts of the birds and all the other creatures who felt it. He felt it himself, even at the glade’s edge where he slept peacefully among the branches, and it woke him with gladness and his joy was the joy of the morning before the dew is dry, when every leaf is green.5
It was the laughter of magick,6 of course. The Minhiriathrim spoke of it often; the power of the old Forest-folk7 to shape the seasons, halt the rivers and move the trees with their laughter. The men of his own family did not believe in it much, for the Minhiriathrim have many such old, old stories that seem to come from a world different in shape and manner than this one. The wuduwasa8 of those old stories had such laughter and it seemed that the old grandfathers, the wassirds, are like unto them.
Turning his eyes to the sound of it, he saw one of them, the one clad in dusky grey, standing with the Soldier before the doors. He came down from his high place in the trees to speak with them.
Stepping quickly through the morning light in the glade, he called, ‘Good morning to you, friends! I have done as you asked, Ohtar, and kept watch. The land has been quiet, and not even the crows have arrived yet to the feast we have left them. But now, Old One, the land and the trees feel the sound of your laughter. I have never witnessed such magicks before and it delights me now. Foul things will not come this way while such blessings echo!’
Ohtar had been feeling the same way; though exhausted by concern he was now relieved in spirit and hoped that the spell would carry over the doorway by which they stood long after the wizard had left.
‘Nîr tôl erin baded lîn,’9 he said to Olórin, though his eyes also looked to see if the Bard knew the Sindarin which he spoke.
‘Mas athradannech?’10 the Unnórenean said. And then, as he bowed to his two companions a bit, he said, ‘Sílo Anor bo men lín.’11 There was an uncomfortable quality to the action of which Ohtar’s keen eyes immediately took notice; he looked as if he had never done such a thing before, but had heard of the manner from others.
‘You are both too kind and indulgent of an old man’s sense of humour, and I thank you for it,’ Olórin said, still chuckling. Turning to the Bard he smiled a bit more and then took on a more serious and direct tone.
‘Master Harper,’ he said, ‘I feel that I have not had the opportunity to also thank you for the beauty of your playing last night. Many in our small party were sorely tired and care-worn from unexpected troubles. Your skill was a balm to our wearied hearts.’
‘I thank you, Great One, for your kindness,’ the Bard said, his eyes fairly beaming with happiness at this praise from one so lofty. From alongside them, Ohtar, wise in reading the small gestures of many men, watched as the wizard drew the eager and naive young man further out.
‘It is honestly given,’ he said. ‘You have a skill that I have rarely heard in many years of far wanderings.
‘And I am sorry that I shall not hear it again for some time,’ the old man continued, his face now taking a more grave aspect to further affect the seriousness. ‘For Ohtar and I have just taken counsel over the news that you have brought us. We are concerned for the people of the Bree-land, and it has been decided that I will ride now to warn them of the orcs that you have reported. I will need more information from you on the position of their camp.’
‘You shall have it, Great One,’ the Bard responded, ‘or, perhaps, if I do not offend in offering, I might accompany you? It may be that I was meant to find these orcs and, in doing so, be led further on my own path.’
At this comment Olórin looked briefly at Ohtar and, smiling, replied, ‘We were just speaking of that very subject, friend, and wondering, if we may, what destination your own path might lead you.’
‘Ah, this is an easy question, Great One,’ he said calmly, ‘for I go North, West, or even into the East to kill the Witch-king of Angmar.’
*****
There was a gathering then, not too many hours after the sunrise, as open light came through the cleverly laid holes in the earthen roof of the Grazing Field. All were present, but they kept their voices low and kept their distance from the sleeping dwarf, as so many discussions of their future relied on his speedy recovery.
‘He looks to be of very good stock, though somewhat thickened by his restfulness,’ Ohtar said to the wizard.
‘Oh, he is a great-heart, Ohtar,’ Beothalion said, nuzzling up against the horse with his own bearded face and touching him gently under the jaw, ‘he is not wise, and I cannot hear his real name, but he is- walna... gwal...’12
‘“Of anxious spirit,”’ Tawarengil finished. ‘Yes, I feel that in him too, brother, and confess that I feel much the same in this place. He will serve you well, Grey Wanderer, but perhaps not patiently.’
‘Let us all hope so,’ Olórin said, ‘for I’ve little time for horse-breaking and we shall have far to travel together. Still,’ he said as he moved forward to place a gentle hand on the beast’s brow, ‘I think you have chosen a name for him, Beothalion. “Awalna” will suit him well.’
At this sounding, Ben’s Rosey neighed gently and tipped her head. Ohtar’s own horse, Caitelyn, followed suit, and even Duncan, some distance apart from the others, whisked his head in agreement. If Awalna understood as much as they did, no one knew.
‘So, Olórin now has the agreement of these beasts and his own plan to move forward,’ Alatar said to the others. ‘In a few days we will each decide plans of our own. I will hear this bard’s tale in its fullness, and speak with Ohtar’s dwarf friend on the matter. We may hope in the likelihood that Olórin’s mission will keep the orc-band from coming here, but I believe this place is not so safe as it seems.’
‘Yes,’ Olórin said in thoughtful agreement. ‘I do not like that curious patch of doorway you have shown me.’
‘Nor do I,’ Ohtar said, ‘nor do I know any reasoning for its purpose. My own folk use this place rarely and only in time of need, for its history brings us no comfort. I know no rumour of this door, and can imagine nothing of its purpose.’
A moment passed then, one which Olórin would consider long into his time in Middle-earth.13 What he thought or felt in the reaction of his companions and their inquisitiveness can not be guessed, but Ben saw him look long into the eyes of Ohtar and then those of his fellow travelers. The old man considered a long moment and, with a ruffle of the whiskers around his mouth, looked as if he was about to speak. Then, lowering his head and pulling at his long eyebrows, he looked aside. The questions and needs of the others, it seemed, so troubled him that he looked away and busied his mind that they might not notice. Ben knew very few people well, wassird or no, and spent very little time among company other than his Rosie. But he thought then that he had seen grave concern in the old man’s eyes as well as the loneliness that he himself knew as a fellow outsider.
With renewed purpose Olórin walked over to the equipment which Milo had brought them, laid out and organized in the cavern by Benbow earlier in his impatience. There Olórin chose a bridle and a harness.
‘I hope you will be able to lend me this leader, Master Floxleaf,’ he said, ‘for I will have little time to fashion one of my own, and it might be best if Awalna here followed a familiar harness.
‘I’ve no need of a saddle. He seems wide enough to hold an old man easily.’ He said with a chuckle, ‘and that extra saddle might indeed serve you on the flatulent donkey, if any can put him to it.’ As he said this, he walked back to the horse he had chosen and gently put the bridle and lead around his head.
‘So Awalna I will lead, but the rest of you, I may not. In the question about this other doorway, I have no history to offer. I have spent time with many of Isildur’s heirs here in the North, but I’ve never been to this place until Ohtar led us yesterday. I should think that originally, back in the lost history of this site’s making, a “left-hand door” such as the one you have shown me would have been a storehouse or pantry, a space into which long provisions might have been kept and, perhaps, in the last years, arms against Angmar’s incursion to the south.’
Awalna answered well to the wizard’s gentle hand and the bridle was comfortably placed on his head. Olórin led the horse forward toward the ramp, and the other members of the party followed him as if they all wore leaders as well.
‘Why such a door would be refitted,’ he continued, ‘as this one surely has, is quite beyond my knowledge and also quite troubling. The stonework there is not so ancient as these halls, yet it is not recent either. I can think of no reason this should have been done and doubt very much it was done by the Edain who know this place.’
‘Then who could have found it and why have they left no sign?’ Ohtar said with a combination of anger and surprise.
‘I do not know, Ohtar,’ Olórin said gravely, pausing to look toward the others who also were following him in a long train up the ramp from the Grazing Field to the door, ‘but I do not like the smell of the door’s other side.’
‘Yes!’ Beothalion said loudly, as if someone had finally spoken to an idea he had earlier felt too uncomfortable to mention. ‘I smelled it also, and it is a foul, foul smell, grey stalker! I do not know this smell, but I do not want to go near it!’
‘I thought so too,’ Ben said quietly. ‘It has a troll smell.’
And all were quieted by this observation.
They had reached the top of the ramp and Olórin led his horse outside the doorway as the others looked to their right at the problem they were now discussing. In the gloomy distance of the antechamber, there was very little to be seen; a door was there, they knew this now, and it opened only from some secret on its other side. How it had come to be there was a mystery, but the danger it presented was obvious to everyone.
‘Trolls do not build, Master Floxleaf,” Olórin said, ‘but I do not doubt the wisdom of your senses. No, the more troubling thing is knowing that some other skilled hand did build this door long ago. Why? I cannot answer that. But I should caution you all to be wary in the face of this knowledge.
‘Now,’ he said briskly, turning his face toward the shallow stair, ‘I must go. I wish all of you well and hope against all outcomes that we shall see one another again. We have had a chance-meeting in peculiar circumstances and precious little time to know each other well. But my heart tells me some of us will meet again and I wish each of you wonderful opportunities in the days to come.’
At this he turned to each of the party individually, offering whatever words of advice that he may.
‘Lord Tawarengil, I pray that you will find all of the adventures you seek and so prove your mettle to your own self, even if no one else is watching. There are adventures to be found at every turn, my lord, but I would caution you to learn and exercise patience that you may grow to meet them in the way that you wish.
‘Beothalion here carries a heavy burden of your errantry. You are fortunate to have found such a brother as he. But he has another path, I think, and one of great discovery. Perhaps, lord Tawarengil, as you come into your own learning you will aid him in his.
‘Master Floxleaf here,’ he said, looking long into Ben’s face, ‘is a great surprise that I would caution all of you to appreciate; for many wonderful qualities can seemingly be found in hobbits if one takes more than a moment to look. I confess that I had not done that before, master Floxleaf, and I thank you greatly for making me reconsider. While my mind is quite occupied by more than a few problems at this time, I must say that hobbits like yourself make me hopeful in the most surprising of ways, and I will think of this surprise for some time into my future.
‘Ohtar I have spoken with,’ he said, turning towards the soldier. ‘There are many thoughts I have about your quest but, I remind you, the future of any people is only guided by their past and not ruled by it. The past can be a true and useful mirror, but the future moves forward whether a People recognize their reflection in that mirror or not.’
At this he turned to the Unnórenean. ‘Your past has been veiled, I think, but not entirely forgotten. You have been given a great goal, young one, and I am uncertain what counsel I would have which might serve it. Perhaps only that you should never let wisdom counsel against bravery, but remember that bravery often needs wisdom’s temperance.
‘Of we three,’ he said, turning to Alatar and Pallando, ‘my heart tells me that we shall not all meet on this shore again.’ The two wizards looked long toward him at this and some unspoken agreement seemed to pass between them all.
‘Our service draws us each away, but our greater goal remains between us. We shall never know the answers for all Peoples by standing in the same place and asking ourselves the same questions, and our separate roads present a greater hope for all. Finding the Enemy, I think, is not so important as helping others to find their own strength against him.’
‘You are bold as ever, Olórin,’ Alatar responded, but even Benbow could see that his face and brow were not drawn into their usual disdain at the comment, ‘but I have come to believe you are more far-sighted regarding these People in the North than I. Your wisdom and experience serve you well here, and you are well-suited to this disincorporated age; you wander through the lands touching the spirits of many folk without charting or demanding a way forward for any of them.’
‘Or,’ Pallando said then, in surprising disagreement, ‘you have been wisely learning their natures and kindling them together for the fire to come. For who among us knows what will be needed when that day does arrive?’
There was then a long silence that few felt any urge to break. Ben, normally very comfortable in long silences and certainly quite used to them, ended it quite abruptly.
‘I’ve no wisdom to lend to that, sirs,’ he said, ‘and I wish you all a chance to meet again, I suppose, if that is what you’d like, only...’
‘Yes, master Floxleaf,’ Alatar said, now raising that eyebrow again. ‘What is it?’
‘Well,’ Ben said shyly, ‘I’d like to know why the Bree-land is to be attacked, you see. If they came for master Flomi is one thing, and from the few things I’ve heard, that seems the way. But why are they taking the town? I guess that what I might ask is this, are they here for the dwarf or the plunder? It may be, knowing why they’d go there, tells us some purpose of that enemy you’re speaking of.’
‘Hah!’ Olórin said with a new light in his face. ‘I had not even thought that myself! Bravo, master Hobbit!
‘See there how unexpected these folk are! He makes a battle-savvy point we all have missed,’ Olórin said. ‘What exactly brings these orcs to the Bree-land? This dwarf may be uncommonly important for a reason we have glimpsed and that we believe the Enemy knows. But why send a force to the Bree-land when a small group of infiltrators might take the dwarf? Why should the quiet folk of the Bree-land fall?
‘I do not know this answer, master Floxleaf,’ Olórin continued, ‘but this is a question I will ask of the orcs.
‘Farewell, friends!’ Olórin said then as he gathered the reins of Alwana tighter in his hands and began his trek up the stairhead.
‘May we meet again in happier times! Or,’ he said, smiling to the others in the dim light of the cavern, ‘may better times draw us together to our happier meeting! I await good news of your greater fortunes!’
And at this Olórin turned his face from the others and strode quickly up the stairhead. And in his long, long time in Middle-earth he was seen by only four of them ever again.
*****
After the grey wizard had left the party new strategies were made. Benbow Floxleaf and Oisín Na-Glirhuin were sent out into the surrounding area to scout and gather provisions for the group beyond those which Milo had acquired. Ben would take whatever small game he might find here along the eastern side of the wall and Oisín would go over the wall and into the more deeply wooded area to its west. The discussion of trolls made the party worry that there might indeed be a cave in these nearby woods that had breached the other side of the mysterious door.Oisín would proceed with great caution in this search and also collect firewood and herbs they might need (he and Ben would also gather more gingergrass as it seemed to help greatly with Rosie’s fever). Both would return to the Glade of the Seven Birches within an hour of sunset.
In the meantime, uncertain as to what might come through this newly discovered doorway, fortifications were to be made within the antechamber and the Grazing Field. Beothalion and Tawarengil, using leather stripping from the old orc weapons and what other easily cast-off items they could find, devised a very keen net of alarm to surround the breach and its surrounding seam. In this way any movement from that direction would warn them all immediately.
Ohtar prepared the other door, the place of Flomi’s battle, for defense. The wood of the door was stout enough, but surely no guard against a troll or even a great-axe. The remaining pavise (two were still undamaged) were set below and at a raised angle in the Grazing Field to afford cover for archers. Some small store of bladed weapons (for they had salvaged what they could, even from the orcs) remained in the pantry at the top of the ramp, but the majority of better weapons and arrows were kept below. For if it came to desperate measures, they would need to defend the rampway at all costs. Ohtar had even taken some of the timbers from the grazing corrals below and used them to set brakes along the rampway which might slow down any large attack. Flomi and the beasts would need to be moved as well, but there was decent cover for them nearer to the Great Door and the fountains which surrounded it.
Alatar and Pallando, when not checking on Flomi, spent their own afternoon near to the Great Door on the grazing floor below, deliberating in their usual silent way.
*****
Decent hunting was found by Ben not so far from the wall and just north of the Glade (in those shallower lands where Flomi and Collum had left their own mounts to rest not a full week before), but Oisín had less luck. He gathered ample firewood, of course, for the trees were much older and thicker on the west of the wall, but no sign of caves or diggings could be found. He was unfamiliar with trolls through anything but the tales of his grandsires, but he could find no evidence of any large creature within a league of this part of the wall.
Together the two met Ohtar at the secret doorway and told him their news. ‘Both of you bring good tidings then,’ Ohtar said, ‘for no wolves or trolls about is as welcome to hear as those fresh rabbits Ben carries for our breakfast.’
They went inside and Ohtar again showed the Bard the trigger for closing the door. Then, as he pressed it and the door began to slowly shut, he was reminded of Flomi’s discovery and the rubbing the dwarf had made last week. His friend had not woken since last night, and Pallando had explained that his body was now in a deep state of healing. They all knew their best chance to leave this place came from the dwarf’s rest, his quick recovery, and his peaceful sleep, and no one had spoken with him since the previous evening. But now Ohtar felt that Flomi’s discovery, that carved inscription which he and no other man he knew had ever bent to notice, may be of some importance to their safety.
‘I would counsel now that this door remain shut until our own decisions have been made,’ Ohtar said as they began walking down the stairs. ‘I trust the grey wizard to divert the orcs from coming here, but even if he cannot this outer door will not be held against anyone who knows its secrets. The orc-scout might lead others here, but none of his folk would know how to open it.
‘You will see that we have set defenses to hold the Grazing Fields as Flomi himself did, though we are greater in number now and better prepared than he.’
‘It seems that one large rodent has set a flurry of concerns, Ohtar,’ the Bard said. ‘Though I trust your instincts, and Benbow Floxleaf’s nose, is all of this necessary?’
‘I cannot know, my friend,’ he said gently to Oisín, but Ben could sense Collum’s irritation at being second-guessed by someone he barely knew; he could see the corners of the man’s mouth curl into the old familiar and disarming smile he gave to many of the ignorant patrons of the Four Greenfields (and Ben, for just a moment, was shocked to realize that he himself had been treated to this same smile on a few occasions).
‘While you wait with worry,’ he said, ‘what is it that you do? Ben here hunts, and has done well in that. The Elf-lord, I can tell you, is very restless and anxious to move while his friend is quite content to sleep and eat moss and drink from the clear fountain waters. Of these wizards I cannot say, for if they show concern it seems quite unrelated to our own most pressing needs.
‘We two battle-ready men have just met, Oisín, and while that has been a fair thing so far, I do not know what you do when you are worried,’ he said as they came through the door to the Grazing Field, ‘but when I worry over a thing and have time for nothing else, I fortify and I prepare.’
Below them Ben could see the changes made in the great open space of the Grazing Fields. Cover was set. A great deportment of arms was stationed. Traps were laid in any easy path forward. While no veteran himself, Ben had lived long in the North and seen many a battlefield before and after a major skirmish. His eyes were sharp, of course, and his understanding quicker than most accounted for. He could see that the restructuring of the room looked much like an encampment preparing for a siege and, because he was a good judge of character in his own remote and isolated way, he could see the expressions of wonder and wariness on the others as they came into the room; they didn’t skulk behind cover, but they too had been prepared for attack.
‘Well, I don’t know much about battlements, Collum,’ Ben said loud enough for all the others to hear, ‘but I’ve brought us a fresh brace of conies large enough for all our breakfast in the next two days,’ he said, holding his catch aloft, ‘and I don’t know many travelers who would say no to that.’
A great ease went through the group then which everyone could feel. Beothalion laughed loudly, Rosie neighing with him, and Duncan shat again to show his own appreciation. The wizards held their quiet demeanor, but Ben imagined he saw a smile cross Pallando’s otherwise calm and placid face.
‘Thank you, Ben,’ Collum said softly as he started down the rampway. ‘You’re better at this than you know.’
*****
‘Rune-master, I do not mean to disturb you, but it seems I must ask you a question,’ the old wizened and pinched face said to Flomi as he came again out of dreams.
‘Hmmmrm,’ he said, rumbling deeply from a newfound hunger in his belly, ‘I have seen you. You are one of those who were at the inn the night I left.’
‘Yes, yes, that is so,’ the old man said impatiently, ‘and my brother Pallando has looked carefully toward your healing since we have come here-’
‘Yes,’ Flomi said sleepily, ‘he has the Eyes of the Sea... How do I know this? I do not know the sea...’
‘All who live in Arda harken to the call of Ulmo, Rune-master, though Aulë’s Children fear him greatly. The Sea is within all of you still,’ he said with some careful gentleness.
‘But I come to you now about stone, Rune-master,’ he continued, ‘and not the song of the Sea. I understand that you found an engraving near the door of this place when you first came here.’
‘Yes!’ Flomi said, his voice a bit clearer as he tried to sit up more at the question. ‘The script was the Tengwar script, surprisingly fluid and discreet for its carving, but the language was...,’ and he paused here, not through weariness or effort (even though he was still greatly wounded), but through a kind of embarrassment that he was formerly unfamiliar with. ‘The language was completely foreign to me,’ he said calmly.
‘And I understand that you have made a rubbing of this engraving?’ Alatar asked.
‘Indeed!’ Flomi responded, ‘it is, or should be, just there, within my bag. A small roll of parchment in a brown tie-string.’
Alatar, now being invited, searched the worn leather pack of notes that Flomi had kept by his side since the battle. The pack held many items of great curiosity, but the wizard extracted the scroll quickly and began to open it before them.
‘The rubbing was made in haste,’ Flomi said, ‘and I hope to get a better one once those stairs intimidate me less, but I think you will find...’
His talk stopped as the wizard had opened the roll, staring at the letters with a creased brow. Flomi did not know wizards before this day and had only met the two of them in a rather confused and feverish state, but he could sense the concern deepening in that old drawn face.
‘Do you know this language, Old One?’ he asked.
‘I know of it, yes, Rune-master,’ he said slowly, concentrating on the inscription, ‘but I do not speak it, if that is what you mean, nor do I suspect that any of the Wise here in the North do.
‘You are correct that it is written in the script of the Elves, but Elrond himself would be loath to see your little discovery,’ the wizard said, ‘for the words, of which I recognize only a few, are the Black Tongue of Mordor.’
End of Chapter Eight
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter Eight
1) Flomi’s defense of the Grazing Field took place shortly before dawn on April 13th (the 21st day of Chithing in the Bree-land calendar) and Collum and the others hoped that he would be ready to travel by the 16th.
2) The removal of the bodies of the orcs and assassins happened during the early evening of the 13th. This was not shown in the previous chapter, which focused on Flomi’s feverish view of events, but doubtlessly occurred before Flomi woke to meet Beothalion and Tawarengil.
3) The Unnórenain, “landless Men”, are of the blood of the Men of Númenor after all, and this place goes back to the ancient days of those people in the North before the division of Arnor. They are my own creation, of course, something I dreamed up specifically for this story, and while Collum seems to know of them at this point, I will be sharing more of their history as we go along.
4) It has been a singular joy of this experiment in fanfic for me to try and describe the power of Gandalf’s laugh. Thanks for getting this far with me.
5) This is a quote from The Silmarillion.
6) This is a tricky word to use. I very much like the idea that there is a supernatural in the Legendarium but that those who participate in it regularly, elves and wizards and such, treat it in a commonplace manner. Having Oisín (and Ben and Beothalion) encounter it for the first time is important to the storytelling, but it seems only a character like Oisín would have a ready expression for it. The “magick with a ‘K’” thing seems appropriate, but there is no direct link to it in Tolkien’s languages.
7) We will see more allusions to the relationship between the Minhiriathrim and their magical providers, the Pukel-men, in the future.
8) An early derivation of Tolkien’s “woses” and the Pukel-men.
9) ‘Nîr tôl erin baded lîn,’ “A tear/weeping comes on your going” -Sindarin
10) ‘Mas athradannech?’ “Where did you travel?” -Sindarin. Note here that the past tense use indicates Oisin’s poor grasp of the language for conversation. It is not used often among his people for anything other than stories.
11) ‘Sílo Anor bo men lín.’ “May the Sun shine on your road.” -Sindarin
12) The translation for “of anxious spirit” comes from many sources here, indicating Beothalion’s confusion of languages and mingled histories.
13) This proved to be the most difficult section to write in the chapter. I wanted some musing here from Gandalf on the other wizards, but could find no way to do it without giving access to his own interiority. Tolkien never gave us the interior mind of wizards (except on one strange occasion), so to do it with Gandalf would border on sacrilege. I hope I’ve found a decent answer to the problem.
Chapter Nine; "The Worry of Rats, a Counsel of Stones and the Better Part of Our Nature"
-Herein Some Answers are Given, Some Contingent Plans are Laid, a Great Threat is Faced, and the Truer Nature of Some of the Party is Revealed
Read Chapter Nine; "The Worry of Rats, a Counsel of Stones and the Better Part of Our Nature"
It was not long after middle-night that the rats came.
The alarms that Tawarengil and Beothalion had set by the Mysterious Door rang loudly and then went quickly silent, as if flooded by a deluge. The Elf-lord himself was on watch at the time and sprang quickly to the sound of action. They had set guard through the night at the stout wooden door to the Grazing Field and Tawarengil had shown, or so he believed, excellent patience in the knowledge that forces of the Enemy might be so nearby. He stood silently in the open frame of the solid wooden doorway, turning his great attention left up the stair to the outside world and right toward the deeper troubles that he predicted would come from the Mysterious Door.
He stood stone still on watch, unsleeping of course, his wooden sword planted before him in perfect accompaniment of balance to his legs, which had not moved for hours. His eyes were open but unfocused, for he needed them very little in this situation and so sent them dreaming into the Wood of his youth. His ears, however, were acutely fixed to the whole of the antechamber. The motions and the sleeping noises of his friends behind him were erased, but should a small waterbug or spider move in the space before him, Tawarengil would know of it instantly.
From behind him, however, he could smell the wholesome moss and flowing water of fountains that made this most uncommon Grazing Field so special, and these things sustained him throughout his watch. In this surrounding he could stand and wait for many long hours of night, more than any of his companions, and he had told the soldier this earlier as the watches were set.
‘I need no relief as others may, Ohtar,’ he had said, ‘for the green-smell of this chamber sustains me and the hope of activity excites me. I can stand throughout the night while others may rest.’
‘This may be so, my lord,’ the soldier responded, ‘but this is not how we shall protect one another if we are to travel together. I may not command you, but I would ask you to follow my wishes while we are safeguarding a hallowed place of my people. Wake me, please, at middle-night.’
Tawarengil had meant to do this. Through the events of these past days, he felt that the Innkeeper’s arguments had been wise enough, but too often contrary to his own observations. He had proven to be an exceptionally sharp Man whom they had discovered in the strangest of places, clearly a veteran soldier, but he was a Man nonetheless and Tawarengil doubted that any Man should lead while the Istari were among them. And this also puzzled him as he stood his watch; why had the Istari not taken charge of the company? Were they not Lords out of the West?
Tawarengil had heard rumour of the Istari throughout his life. He knew that when Radagast, one of their order, had come to settle in the Greenwood, Thranduil, Tawarengil’s lord and uncle, had been greatly disturbed. Many of the king’s soldiers and scouts were sent as ambassadors south-west to Rhosgobel to speak with Radagast regularly and to hear his wisdoms. Tawarengil had himself spoken with many of these ambassadors who had found Radagast’s ways peculiar and thought little of his wisdoms; some even thought him a little mad.1 But Thranduil discounted the observations of his ambassadors and would not hear them openly spoken in counsel. The Istari, peculiar as they may seem, had been sent to Arda for a purpose, Thranduil had believed. Tawarengil, in his strange fortune of meeting three of these great folk, had decided to harken to his uncle’s point of view on this matter. So he waited for them to take charge, to lead this party as he felt they should. Yet they gave no inclination towards leadership no matter how long he waited.
In his watch he did not consider these things of course; for that was not the way of the Elves. Meditations on such matters were reserved for wakeful time and woodland elves like him, while in the Greensleep, they turned their minds to things they loved and not to worldly concerns that they held, allowing their senses to heighten and remain open.
And so, deep in a memory of the Greatwood, Tawarengil heard a black wind rustling the trees around him, felt a chill he had never known in his true memory, and snapped his eyes open to hear the clanking of alarms and traps he had set only a few paces off to his right.
‘Arise! Arise and defend yourselves!’ he cried to the others.
Through the darkness of the antechamber (which affected the keenness of his eyes much less than it would the Innkeeper’s, he thought) came a great streaming flood of rats. Numberless. Overwhelming the web of nets and noisemakers that he and Beothalion had set there; the motion of them drowning the noise of the jangling metals placed as alarm.
Their noise was great, yet they were speechless in their flood; no squealing nor calling was heard from any and the black wind of Tawarengil’s dreaming was now the sound of hundreds upon hundreds of these creatures rushing under the gap of the Mysterious Door, climbing over one another, along walls and floors and anything else in their path, to reach his guardpost at the door to the Grazing Field.
*****
‘What does this mean?’ Ohtar had asked earlier that day, his surprise at this news unbridling his usual patience. ‘How came such vile speech to be written here and my own ancestors knew nothing of it?’
‘I have looked at the inscription and agree with your Rune-master,’ Alatar said calmly, ‘it was made many long years ago and there is no reason to believe that your own People, coming here so very infrequently as you describe, should have seen it. I am, perhaps, less of a scholar of the North Kingdom than my brother Olórin, but I should think this breach happened quite long ago, during the Great Plague2 perhaps, when this roadway was used less.
‘Was it ever used by the Enemy to some unknown purpose?’ he continued. ‘I cannot say for certain but am inclined to doubt. This very chamber, and the outer door above, have been left intact and are,’ he paused here and drew a long breath inward,3 ‘quite wholesome. There is something beyond that patched doorway that is decidedly unwholesome and now, it seems, we find evidence that they have come as far as the door and perhaps into this Grazing Field before. Long ago. Will they, or can they, come again? I cannot say.’
‘What then should we do, Great One?’ Tawarengil asked. ‘Surely such evidence suggests we are not safe here.’
‘No,’ Alatar said, wrinkling his brow in certainty. ‘No, we are not safe here.’
‘But not all are safe to leave,’ his companion, Pallando, said with equal gravity. ‘The dwarf needs time to heal, and even the stairway poses a grievous circumstance to one so sorely wounded. His folk heal best here, among stone and hall, better than they may in a wood and under pressure to move. No,’ he said, looking grimly at the other members of the party, ‘the best chance of survival for our friend is that he remain underground.’
‘Yes,’ Alatar said, ‘that is agreed. We may not flee this bit of news and yet hope to save the dwarf.’
‘Then flee if you will,’ Ohtar said, ‘for I may not. He is my friend and my charge. I will not risk his health over any threat made long ago in dark chambers.’
‘Hmm,’ Alatar said. ‘Dark Chambers. Perhaps, Ohtar, this is where your best hope lies.’
*****
Ben may have woken slower than the others, but he moved no less rapidly into position. His own watch would not come until late morning (an assignment that both relieved him and made him feel a bit insulted), but he had carefully chosen a sleeping place near the left pavise, where his bow lay waiting to be strung and his quiver was full. None of them could anticipate what kind of trouble might come, if any, but Ben’s skill with a bow was something Collum knew well and respected greatly. He was given a great supply of arrows and a strong position with which to hold the rampway.
He could see Collum, longsword already drawn, charging up the ramp as the Bard and Beothalion followed, each with weapons in their hands. The wizards, Ben noticed, were also quick to rise, but were moving to the rear of the chamber where Flomi lay beside the fountains at the Great Door.
‘Nâr!'4 Tawarengil cried as he slammed the wooden door behind him. ‘A great multitude of rats dense as a flood roars toward us through the dark passage! We must hold this door against them!’ Ohtar had contrived bolts for this door and the Elf-lord threw them now and, placing the wooden sword off to his left, drew his long knife. He then rushed to the pantry and drew out the long cudgel of one of the fallen orcs. Rushing back to the door he jammed it against the bottom just as two and three of the smaller rats began to force their way beneath it. Noises of their scraping and climbing and something like the sound of rolling, like wet and heavy leaves in a storm, could all be heard from without, but yet there was no sound or cry from any one of the creatures. He stabbed at the two who had cleared the door already and even in death they made no sound.
There was a short pause then in the noise beyond the door as these two were slain. Brief, the span of a breath perhaps, but Tawarengil’s keen ears caught it; as if all as one creature they now knew of him beyond the door and knew of his knife. And then the sound of their running and scraping stopped and the sound of them gnawing upon the wood of the door began.
*****
‘We have perhaps not considered all of the options open to us,’ Alatar said those hours before when they took their counsel. ‘The new and Mysterious Door and that Secret Door above which you have protected are not, after all, the only ways out from this place.’
All eyes fell on Collum here and Ben could tell he was uncomfortable with the proposal.
‘Our histories say that none have walked the length of that path since Eärendur’s time,’ he said calmly, ‘though it was once reported that a great many folk were brought out of Cardolan this way before it fell.’
‘My folk say this as well,’ Oisín added.
‘Some great refuge was made for an escape beneath the stones;
'...Rescued and descended together, till they saw the great last road,
'The well-fashioned wassail-hall wondrous and gleaming;
’Mid-worldfolk and kindreds that was widest reputed
'To halls under heaven North went, which heroes abode in;
'South went deadfolk, in all honors well-remember’d...’5
Ohtar looked with some surprise at this recitation, but quickly turned his conversation back to the wizards. ‘It is, in all cases among my folk, a very secret place,’ he said solemnly, ‘and none that I know have ever once opened the Great Door to the Foundations below.’
‘Yes,’ Alatar said, ‘I believe it has remained unopened for many generations of Men. And therefore it may remain the safest doorway. I do not know what darksome folk have come here, Ohtar, but I do know that at that portal your ancestors have wrought a gate which many unnatural creatures would fear to pass.’
‘And I fear it too, Wisefather,’ the soldier said. ‘To the south, since Cardolan’s fall, lie only the barrows and wights and despair. The Path to our barrow-houses is not meant to be a pathway of the living. This way goes north as well, I know, but if any exit there was ever known it may be lost to us now. It was meant as a road for the dead and their expediency. Should not the living fear to take it?’
‘Númenórean,’ Pallando said, stepping forward in his quiet and singular way of choosing an argument, ‘why are you so affixed on your dead?’
There was a longer pause here as Ohtar felt the weight of the wizard’s words.
‘You recount your history, dark as it has sometimes been, and overlook the opportunities afforded you by your accomplishments. Many many hundreds of years ago your people built a roadway here to carry their dead and their lamentations quickly and in all honor south to their barrow halls. Yet you know, and have heard,’ he said, drawing attention to the Bard and the story he had told, ‘of it being repurposed to save others of your own folk from disaster. It is not, at least not now, the darksome and solemn path it was designed for. In many years before our arrival here, it has been a road of hope for your People. You show it proper respect as a mortuary to your kinfolk and, it seems, you treat it with less respect as the salvation it has been to many others. Man, do you not see? A path to the barrow-houses is a path of acceptance, certainly. But a path that saved so many has turned into a path of the living! Can you not accept that? The sacredness you afford this road I respect, but you see this place only as a relic of former glories for your dead, when it might have better acclaim for the hope it once gave the living.
‘There is a doorway here which leads to your ancient causeway,’ Pallando said with even and keen speech as he pointed to the Great Door between the fountains, ‘It may be opened. We believe that it has been safe for many, many lifetimes of Men. The dark visitors who may have come to this cave before may know of it, but they most assuredly fear it. Will you forsake its more recent and hopeful history out of your own melancholia?'
****
Ohtar reached the top of the ramp first. The landing there before the door was only a pace or so in either direction, so he held back as he watched the childlike elf-lord use his foot to brace the cudgel against the door’s bottom while he also watched anxiously for any breach in the seams. At his feet, indeed, lay two smaller slain rats. As he stopped, with Oisín and Beothalion just paces behind him, he too heard the sound of the door’s wood being gnawed at; like how a swarm of bees might sound to a bear cub with his head stuck in a honeycomb, or the grinding of a thousands of acorns under an old and dry millstone. Ohtar moved them all quickly into action.
‘Beothalion!’ he cried, ‘relieve your friend and brace this door and the cudgel! Watch the seams! Ben!’ he called loudly. ‘There’s no work for your bow down there yet, my friend, but we can use your agile hand up here with a small blade. And bring that bow and a full quiver in case they weaken a spot!’
As Beothalion replaced him, Tawarengil took his place to the left of the doorway. He drew a second knife now and watched with readiness for any rat who might come near enough for its point.
‘Stay your position, my lord,’ Ohtar said to the elf, ‘hold this door as long as it lasts. Oisín!’ he said as he turned toward the Bard. ‘Your stout club and brave heart is of no use here against such a swarm. We must look to regroup and reinforce. Bring rope from below so that we might provide a quick escape for our comrades!’
The Bard did what he was asked, passing Ben on the narrow rampway. Looking quickly below, Ohtar could see Alatar gathering the beasts and moving them closer to the Great Door while Pallando was prepared the pallet they had fashioned to move Flomi.
‘I will not take that road until this door falls,’ he thought to himself. ‘I will not.’
*****
‘I will not take that road until hope fails,’ Collum had said hours earlier as he and Ben prepared new strategies for the encampment, ‘but it seems we must prepare against the possibility.’
‘Well, forgive me for being a ninnyhammer,6 Collum,’ Ben had said to him somewhat brusquely now that they were alone, ‘but I still don’t quite understand where that door goes to or why you seem to dislike it. That blue wassird, that Pallando he is, says it leads to a great accomplishment of your old folk in the North Realm, and I don't know why that wouldn’t be a safer road for your friend Flomi there. But, and I must say it here while I can, I just don’t know much about what’s going on and feel as if I’ve been told less than these other worthies might make such good guesses at.’
Collum stopped his work at this and looked long into Benbow’s face.
‘Ben, I have done your friendship a grievous wrong,’ he said. He sat down then, next to the hobbit in this place away from all the others and, for the first time ever, Benbow thought the man looked a little sad.
‘So many new things have happened so quickly,’ he said, ‘that I have not had time to think about your response. Perhaps worse, I have relied upon your friendship and your resilience with all these changes while offering nothing in return. You are a steadfast friend in hard times, and I have rewarded your trust unfairly. But now we wait, and time is ours. Come! Ask me all that you will.’
Ben was as surprised by this as he was thankful. He took a minute to look around the Grazing Fields and assure himself that now was indeed a good time for straight talk. The two of them were beside two large stones near the far end of the Grazing Field and away from the Great Door. On one of these stones Collum had seated himself, and the other he offered to Ben. All of their companions were busied with different tasks about the room; Beothalion and Tawarengil were fashioning a pallet to carry the dwarf, Oisín was seeing to the animals and the deployment of their equipment, Pallando was treating and examining further Flomi’s wounds, while Alatar was spending more time solving the riddle of opening the Great Door.
So Benbow looked upon the other stone and, after a moment, took a seat on it. The stones were of equal height but here, as Ben sat up straight as questioner and Collum looked down a bit as contrite confessor, both of them were of even standing, meeting together alone as they had not found time to do for these past three days.
Ben sat with his friend and, quietly, almost in secret, asked him the questions that had been bothering him most. They sat together on the two stones and, unlike all the discussions that had happened before in which folk had proved themselves to others or answered questions in regard to their own merit, Ben and Collum took the counsel of friends together, trusting, but knowingly faced with hard times.
‘So you’re not named Collum or Gilleyfoil and I suppose old Cradiac was not your grandfather?’
‘No,’ he said calmly. ‘And Cradiac was also no Gilleyfoil. It was an invented name to sound more, well, Bree-like. He was a man of my People, Númenóreans displaced here in the North Kingdom since Arnor fell into three separate states.’
‘But he was the innkeeper before you came here to keep the same inn,’ Ben said. ‘Not because of the inn, but because of Master Flomi there, the dwarf.’
‘Yes,’ Collum said frankly. ‘I was sent as guardian when Flomi’s work became more dangerous and we believed that he was, perhaps, being watched.’
‘By who?’
‘Ah. Then we did not know or even suspect,’ Collum said. ‘Burglars, perhaps? Maybe rumour had spread of a dwarf making maps. Folk who travel the road are always something more peculiar and dangerous than even the Breefolk realize, and so perhaps some would-be burglar may have noticed it first. Had rumour provoked a response? Dwarf-hoards are legendary and a map-making dwarf is a rare subject for great rumour. We did not know anything about this twelve years ago when I was sent for. But more we know now.’
‘These Black Númenóreans, you mean,’ Ben said softly.
‘Yes. But the certainty of that is only recent,’ Collum responded gravely. ‘Flomi did not suspect the depth of his danger until recently, but I had prepared more than a few friends against it. Guldir was such a friend and part of that trust. He was watchful with us all and I am sorry that I was not here as the Bard was to deliver vengeance for him.’
‘It was those two we found,’ Ben said, ‘Fern Sarnside’s friends from the Bree-land, then. They’re of those Black Númenóreans you’re speaking of.’
‘Certainly not!’ Collum responded quickly. ‘No, they were soldiers certainly, and I knew them as such when they arrived in the Bree-land early this month. One of them was of higher cunning than the others surely, but none were like the Old Foes of my people.7 I met some of those in a great battle to the south and they are deadly opponents and keen-minded! As I have told you, I believe Flomi met one last month, and it was that meeting which set a fresh watch on the Bree-land and sent these men as leaders for this orc-band and spies within the town. Guldir must’ve seen one of them following Flomi two nights ago and paid his life for it.’
‘He was a kind old man,’ Ben said softly, ‘and even my Rosie liked him. You served with him, I’d guess, for I know now that you’re a military man.’
‘Yes and no,’ he replied, ‘for he was a man of the North and my own wars were mainly in the south. But he served with my father and, in my youth, Guldir taught me many things about our lands here. He was with us on the day I was first shown these chambers. Ah! If he were alive now I wonder what he might say about our path ahead!’
‘Our path where, Collum?’ Ben asked. ‘You have told me nothing of why you need a guide in the northlands.’
Collum took some time with this response.
‘Ben,’ he said solemnly, ‘I serve the old lineage of Arnor, a sundered line that our history has forgotten but that our loyalty has not. I serve the direct line of Eärendur that, in his madness, was removed and disenfranchised. So, first, I need you to accept that this service of mine is correct and legitimate as I tell you more of my purpose.’
‘Stars and toadheels, Collum!’ Ben said with some frustration. ‘What should I be expected to know about the sundered line of kings? If I’m to trust you further, and I have very much trusted you in the past and the moreso recently, just tell me who you truly are and what you’re truly looking for!’
Collum paused a long while. He looked to his hands, he looked to the other folk going about their tasks far away from them and then, for a long minute, he looked into Benbow’s very frank eyes.
‘I am a soldier assigned to serve the heir of Isildur. I am a secret servant of the old lines of kingship. My family before me and I are stewards of the history of the North Kingdom.
‘And in the north somewhere,’ he said slowly, ‘some of the greatest artifacts of my People were hidden over eleven hundred years ago. My charge is to recover these, and the gravely wounded dwarf Rune-master here with us has the best chance of understanding how to do so. Now this bard, Oisín Na-Glirhuin, who is such a surprise, Flomi believes he holds a vital missing piece of the location we seek. I was uncertain at first, but now I agree.
‘I need to find this place and to recover these items. It has been the great plan of my People over the lifetimes of many of my ancestors. It seems that now, through chance or fortune, the possibility has fallen to me.
‘I will need your help, Ben,’ Collum said. ‘Flomi must live, the Bard’s song must be heard and then soon, perhaps sooner than I had planned, we must search the north. I trust no one to help with that as I do you.’
‘And you believe it's north we’re to go?’ Ben asked calmly.
‘Yes, I do,’ Collum said, ‘to the shores of Evendim.’
It was Ben’s turn to look down at his hands and pause and think just a bit. But the pause did not last long.
‘Getting to the lake was possible a few years back, Collum,’ he said gravely, ‘but it is a dangerous, even foolish path now. Your tower city is the home to trolls and bats and the like these days. With Norbury8 fallen this winter, and the king fleeing northwest, those open lands between will be watched.
‘We might try for the Shire and then move upstream along the Brown River,’ he continued.
‘I had thought that myself not long ago,’ Collum replied. ‘But it seems certain that conflict will move that way next. If the Witch-king is to be resisted a force will have to come over the Great Road. The Shirefolk are in more peril at this moment than they could imagine.’
‘I’d not thought of that,’ Ben said glumly. ‘More folk who should be warned, I think, and more who wouldn’t listen, I’d bet.
‘We might be safe to go there now,’ he continued, listing out their options, ‘but stuck like conies in a snare as we tried to move north.’
‘Yes,’ Collum said, with a small smile on his face, ‘I had thought as much myself.’
‘And you’re sure that the Stillwater9 is where we’re bound?’ Ben asked. ‘Because north of the Stonebows Bridge10 there won’t be any folks to aid us and no news but what we find. If there’s signs of war, I’ll spot them soon enough, but buried relics in or outside of the Grey-city are nothing I know of.’
‘Flomi has believed this for some years,’ Collum said. His face was earnest, but seemed to admit to Ben that he had no real way to be certain. ‘I have stalled him in this expedition as the Witch-king pressed forward, but now it seems our time of stalling has ended. Our purposes are certainly known and, to this location at least, Flomi has certainly been followed. I do not know what else they know.’
‘And there was that one orc who went uncounted,’ Ben said solemnly.
‘Yes. And only two of Sarnside’s suspicious friends were found here in the aftermath of battle. There were three that I knew of.’
‘Well, that’s more bad news I’d not looked for!’ Ben said rather loudly. ‘Bells in a hollow, Collum! What else should I know that you haven’t told me?’
*****
Benbow Floxleaf was sure at that moment that what he heard beyond the door was the most terrifying thing he had encountered in nearly forty years spent in the wild. His ears were very keen after all, and he had none of the quaint ideas of how rats behaved that city-folk might have. In the wild they seldom grouped in large numbers and fought with one another incessantly. They were a danger to be sure, but seldom would you encounter more than a dozen or so at a time. This was nothing like what he knew.
Close by Beothalion’s right side he crouched, his small hunting knife in one hand and bow in the other, listening and looking sharply for any indication of a breach. Beyond the sounds of so many teeth gnawing on the ancient wooden surface he could also hear the constant scurrying of the animals. A countless number. He could tell that they were climbing over one another’s backs to tear at as much of the raw wood as their teeth could find; he could hear their jaws grinding away beyond the door almost up to his own height.
But what alarmed him most was not just the ceaseless buzzing sound of their countless teeth on the wood, or the quieter rustling of their bodies as they trampled one another in their purpose. It was that he could hear them make no other sound. No cries of anger or excitement as any pack of animals he had known might make during an attack. All of their intent and all of their focus, many, many hundreds of them, it seemed, was directed upon the door.
‘Just how thick is this door?’ Ben wondered, and found that even with the other preparations they had made, he himself had never really looked at this area of defense carefully. He had trusted to Collum, yet again, on this part of their defense. ‘But no manner of military training prepares a soldier for this,’ Ben knew.
‘I am growing most... anxious here, little Benbow,’ Beothalion grumbled quietly from above. This anxiousness Ben could feel, and it scared him quite as greatly as the weakening of the door did.
This gentle and very giant wildman was holding the door against the weight and force of the unnumbered rat bodies with his great strong arms. The massive stock of his right leg and his leather-booted foot held a large orc cudgel in place at the door’s base so that no creature could press through that narrow space. He showed no sign of weakening in these extremities, and it seemed very doubtful to Ben that indeed he would while the door remained intact. But his head, and his eyes and his nose were all a flurry of small and worried motions compared to the rest of his body’s stillness; it looked to Ben as if his new friend was at the very edge of a frenzy that he could not manage, something very terrifying to himself and, as Ben’s old hunter’s sense told him, of enormous danger to all around him.
‘Sídh, gwador!’11 Tawarengil called to Beothalion in a calming voice. ‘You do not want our new friends to think you are reckless, do you? Poor master Floxleaf here has grown quite fond of your better nature, I think.’
Ben had seen the elf-child’s coolness under duress not two nights before and again it impressed him. But he felt less certainty in him now as their eyes met for a moment with the wildman frozen between them. Ben saw what he felt was a genuine concern coming from the Elf-lord, an unpredictability of what might happen next, and this made Ben all the more wary.
But as his eyes were turned he did not see another small rat at the bottom tear his way into the room through the door’s corner and near to his own foot.
‘Ben!” Collum cried.
And that was when Beothalion’s anxiousness got the better of him.
*****
‘I do not understand why everyone is so...gaer, Tawar,’ Beothalion said to his brother, ‘now that the stink of orc-blood is lifting, I think this a wonderful cave we have come to.’
‘I should not say they are ‘fearful’, brother,’ Tawarengil replied. ‘No, not even the little Periannath. He seems of much stouter stuff than I had expected. But they are growing anxious with all they are discovering here.’
The two had just finished fashioning a pallet for moving the dwarf and were now walking back to the area of last night’s rest. The Istari were still locked around the Great Door between the two fountains and Tawarengil felt it best to leave them to their deliberations; he wanted to look again at the store of weapons near the door. Looking that way, he could see the Unnórnean standing quiet watch in the still-open doorframe and, below him, little Floxleaf and the Innkeeper sitting on two old stones, talking. He was curious about their conversation, but felt he must take the time now to make his brother aware of some of the dangers that had been discussed.
The recent parting words of Olórin, the third Istari, weighed heavily on Tawarengil. Had he been reckless to bring his brother on this journey? He had no greater friend in the world and now, on the verge of what he felt was his first great adventure, Tawarengil felt with some sadness that he should have never asked Beothalion to join him. Things might become very dangerous for them all much sooner than he had imagined, and his brother, in his delightful innocence, seemed ignorant of that growing danger.
‘Brother,’ he said to Beothalion as he stopped and sat before him on the moss-covered floor, ‘tell me, do you feel anxious as they do?’
Beothalion seemed pleased to have the chance to sit and talk the common talk, so he dropped loudly to the ground beside his friend. Rolling his great body a bit into the ground for comfort, he took some dirt from below and pressed it to his forehead to cool his brow. He looked very thoughtful then, as if he were worried that Tawarengil was asking a question about some very important topic that he had somehow missed. And then, smiling with his usual honesty, he said;
‘I do not, Tawar. Oh, I do not like the smell of that other door, and my belief is that we should not go there. But that seems to be what all have decided. We will not go that way, surely.
‘I do not understand this new thing, the writing from a wall which frightens them, Tawar. But I do not understand writing. I will try to in time, for I see it has great power in this larger world that you have shown me, but I do not understand how it makes them... anxious, as you have said.’
Tawarengil thought hard on this for a moment.
‘It is the marking of an enemy, brother,’ he said, ‘perhaps a great Enemy who wishes to say that this place is their own. They may have made this mark long ago, indeed the Istari believe this is so, but they may know we have come here and they may come back before we can leave.’
‘I see,’ Beothalion said with great concern. ‘They smell the blood made here.’
Tawarengil himself had not thought about this before, nor had he heard the others speak of it openly. Ohtar had come here as recently as a week ago and left his peculiar Easterling animal in the Grazing Fields for that whole time, yet it had remained happy and unmolested. Why then, some amongst them might argue, would this place be unsafe now?
None among the party had offered that argument when the carving of the Black Speech had been found. Tawarengil, in his inexperience, was just now beginning to realize what the Istari might have already known; the danger of this place was greater now that blood had been spilled.
‘Yes, brother,’ Tawarengil replied, ‘I believe that you are right in this.’
‘I see, again,’ Beothalion said, still looking thoughtful and quite serious. ‘And we cannot take the Dwarf from this place and go back into the open lands?’
‘Not for more than a few days, or so I have heard,’ Tawarengil replied. ‘Pallando is a great healer, I am certain, and if he claims this time is needed for the dwarf, I do not doubt it. He will remain here by his charge. But tell me, brother, should we?’
Beothalion looked at him with a sharper eye. ‘Would we leave them?’
‘I do not know their path, brother,’ Tawarengil said, ‘and I don’t know if it is part of our own. We have gone far from our homes to a great gathering of force against Angmar. I hoped to see great legions of my people march as they had in ages long past and to be part of a great change in the northlands of this world. And I believe that we, quite unexpectedly, have had a rare chance-meeting with these others which my... spirit12 tells me to follow. But are we to stay and defend one wounded dwarf in a hall which has long ago fallen into darkness? Are we reckless to abandon our own plans for another’s? Brother, I do not know.’
‘Well, brother,’ Beothalion said, smiling, ‘I do not know your spirit better than you do, and I should not like to. I have not really spent time with Dwarfs, and can not speak to defending them. This one seems kindly, and I very much like his friends that we have traveled with these few days. But I do not wish to be reckless, Tawar. I am, as you know, a very ordered person.’
Tawarengil laughed richly at this and Beothalion, not really understanding the joke, laughed as well for the joy it brought them both. Over near the fountains Rosie and Ohtar’s strange animal laughed with them in a way that only the four of them fully understood.
‘Master Floxleaf’s friend would not forgive us for leaving just yet, it seems,’ Tawarengil said, ‘and that other creature could learn much, I think, from your better nature.’
‘Oh, you should not make sport of him,’ Beothalion said. ‘For he is happy in his way and cares little of your thoughts of banners and legions and “great changes in the northlands.” He laughs as we do, and shits and eats and sings to show his contentment. Perhaps that is the better nature he shows to us.’
Tawarengil smiled at this, happy for his brother’s gentle needling and quiet wisdom.
‘Well then,’ he said, ‘if you will not speak to what road you think we might take, brother, it seems I must content myself with the counsel of an ass. Wisdom, it is said, comes from unexpected sources in the wild country, and that creature is as unexpected and wild as I might ever imagine.’
*****
Ben was wrong about the sound of the rats; the sound of Beothalion’s distress terrified him more greatly, almost to that point of being ‘terrified-to-stillness’ he had wondered about earlier that day. No sound in all his many travels had struck him with such fear, and it came now from just beside him, from a gentle-seeming soul whom he had counted as a new friend.
There was a rat who breeched the door, a smaller one to be sure, but fast and darting toward Ben’s foot while his attention had been elsewhere. Collum’s warning had made him turn quickly and bring his little hunting knife across that way. Perhaps he would have defended himself against the rat, even as others piled into the breach behind him. Perhaps he could have kept pace with this small flood of foes who had found a way through this small corner of their defenses.
It was not worth wondering. For Beothalion had been roused then in his anxiousness.
And so there was a cry which echoed throughout the cavern and stilled every voice, every movement, and Ben was quite powerless against it.
‘Brüllllllllllennnnnnn!'13 the voice called.
And the sound was great and seemed to shake the very walls around the Grazing Field so that Ben and Collum and Tawarengil, so near to its source, found themselves seized by terror; vengeful and exultant the cry sounded, but poor Ben and the ageless elf-child and the veteran soldier could do nothing but draw their hands and their weapons up to guard their faces against it.
There was also, though Ben was too alarmed to understand it in the moment, a great answering cry which came from Rosie and Caitelyn and the queer Easterling animal, Duncan. They were filled with fear, yes, but if Ben had full account of his senses he might have noticed some hint in his Rosie’s voice of comfort; as if she sensed something greatly, very greatly, feared but long looked for.
And as the roaring cry rang out, the noise of the rats was quite suddenly stopped.
And, lifting his eyes slowly from behind his fingers, Ben saw the door between them all demolished, splintering and flying into a hundred wooden shards as Beothalion, or some great shape like he had been, went through it, stomping, thrashing and chomping at every rat in his path. And a new noise began: the sound of the rats’ voices in terror as they ran in every direction they could to escape this unexpected onslaught.
It took time for the comrades to regain themselves. Tawarengil was the first. He reached with his left hand to take hold of the wooden sword that he had laid by the door and, with a keen dagger in his right hand as accompaniment, he barreled through the sundered doorway to support his friend. Collum ran up next to Ben and cried, ‘We must hold them here should they regroup! Ben, stand by me! Oisín! Bring torches!’
Some few, fearful now as they had not seemed before and now screaming with terror undirected, tried to scurry through the doorframe to escape Beothalion’s wrath. Ben and Collum were quick to thwart them, and Oisín, now coming up the ramp after provisioning their escape, held two torches in one hand while brandishing his long, gnarled club in the other. The rats’ fear of fire, dagger, sword and bludgeon helped to hold what was left of the doorway.
But the main battlefield now was in the antechamber just beyond the doorway, and the sound of many rat voices could be heard as they fled in terror from the great dark shape of Beothalion in his rage.
‘Brüllllllllllennnnnnn!’ the cry came again, echoing throughout the whole of the cavern, and all the rats fled from it. From his place at the door Ben could see Beothalion (though he looked to have grown to an even more enormous size and appeared as a great dark and lumbering figure in the gloom of the antechamber) as he swept his long powerful arms right and left, sending debris of many rat bodies away with each great arc. Their former single-mindedness, such a strange thing in these creatures, was gone now and they wildly sought escape from the terror of the enemy they had found here. They fled everywhere and in all directions. As Collum and Ben and the Bard did all they could to safeguard the doorway, Tawarengil ran lightly, briskly, behind his friend out in the antechamber, sweeping away great clusters of the animals with long strokes of his wooden blade and deftly slaying them one and sometimes two at a time with quick thrusts from his agile dagger.
‘Glory,' Ben thought, ‘I took him for a child by his looks, but that one is a warrior I’ve not seen the like of. Look how his wooden blade and his shining knife spin through the dark!’
They struck hard at every rat body they saw. Oisín had wanted to take the fight outside the doorway where Beothalion and Tawarengil were engaged, but Collum held him back. ‘They come for us here, Oisín Na-Ghiliruin! We must hold them here and protect our friends!’ Each of the Men had now taken a torch in their off hands, holding them low to the edges of the door while Ben held secondline against any rat who bravely or in terror came through.
Beothalion, in his loud and terrifying rage, had reached the Mysterious Door. The rats fled before him, and he stomped them and mashed them and bent low to crush them in his powerful jaws, and all were terrified of his coming. They scattered as they could and many, many hundreds, fled back beneath the door’s opening. Behind him Tawarengil destroyed many, and the rats learned to fear the wooden sword as much as the dagger.
Beothalion began to hammer at the Mysterious Door, and the sound of it echoed throughout all of the cavern. The rats who dared scurried beneath his feet to the door’s other side, but many, many fled away and up the stairs looking for escape.
‘Brüllllllllllennnnnnn!’ his cry went, frightening all. Boom, Boom! Boom, Boom! His great fists went, hammering on the ancient and Mysterious Door that was the source of their trouble.
From his place behind, destroying every scurrying creature he might reach, Tawarengil spoke to his friend; ‘Brother! You’ve opened quite enough doors tonight, I think! Please calm yourself now and let that one be!’
If they'd had time to speak their own minds, Ben and Collum might well agree. But it was at that moment the great light of the Moon entered the chamber here under the earth.
*****
‘There are wards here upon this door,’ the old wizard explained, ‘which I can read. Many are meant to hold the door, as I believe it has been held for some time. But,’ Alatar finished, ‘among them there is also a ward which opens it.’
Ohtar and Ben, after their talk together, stood beside the two wizards at the Great Door between the two fountains. Water entered the chamber here on either side of the Door and filled two large scalloped stone basins at just above Ben’s own height. In them the constant, gentle sound of the flowing water had a calming effect within this chamber that they had called the Grazing Field; all were attracted to it. Once, shortly after they had arrived here and while Ben felt he had little to do but investigate his surroundings while the others talked their high talk, he had put his hand into the basin, just above his head, and been surprised by the coolness of the water. Drawing some out in his hand, he found that it tasted fresh and cool as a mountain stream. Wisely following his father’s advice, he had filled his drinking skin immediately.
By some contrivance or design he could not hope to understand, Ben saw that the water from these basins flowed into lower troughs on either side, moving farther away from the doors. These were not ornate as the basins were. Each trough was about two spans in length and, being but chest-high to a hobbit, were obviously meant for the watering of horses. Here they had led the animals and all had drunk delightedly from the unexpectedly cool water. But, by some other design Ben did not understand, the level in these troughs seemed to change very little, no matter how much Rosie, or the horses, or that other queer animal, that Duncan, might drink at a turn. Water flowed constantly from basin to trough and, so it seemed, down from there and out somewhere else into the chamber. ‘How else were these mosses and other plants fed so long?’ Ben thought.14 ‘The place is a marvel, that’s certain. Clever like the ruins I’ve seen to the north, for Men were clever in the days of the Old Kingdom. But these wells and doors and things are working still. A marvel that is, which I’ve not seen anywhere before.’
This was, of course, quite more true than he might understand. For Ben and the others stood here, before these rare doors, at the brink of one of the last preserved works of Númenórean builders from when they first came out of the Sea and into the northlands. While Ohtar and many of his grandfathers had called them ‘the Great Doors’ for many hundreds of years, this room, with its natural fountains and its sustainable field, with its secret entrance and its guarded one, were in fact of a humble and austere design as suited its purpose; the room and the doors and the fountains were not and had never been ‘great’ by the Númenórean aesthetic, no matter what later generations might call them. But now, and for being still functional while so much of Númenórean work had fallen into decay or legend, they hinted at a former greatness; so well-preserved as they were in time when so much of the North had so obviously fallen.
The height of this chamber did indeed seem great by contrast to the shallow low and narrow steps and antechamber which one used to access it. But the roof overhead was not much greater than eight ranga,15 and the Great Doors here between the fountains less than half that in height. Tall, yes, for the Númenóreans of old were a tall and doughty folk by all accounts, but as Ben considered it now, the doors themselves were not so much taller than the doors to the Bree-land stables. Yet they were not crafted of wood like the door above. These doors were fashioned of once-polished white stone (one he did not recall seeing before), and many letters and symbols were carved upon them that Ben did not understand (though he had seen many of these symbols in other places, but never much considered them).
‘You may open it, perhaps,’ Collum said to the wizard, ‘but may we close it again from the other side? If we open it to make ourselves safe will doing so then leave it unguarded to the enemy and to desecration? For this I cannot do. And,’ he said with great concern, ‘if we cannot come out again, where might we go? The two known ends of this roadway are lost. Are there others in either direction? None of my people have said and none living may know. Do you know better, Greatfather?’
‘I do not,’ Alatar said, and Ben, for the first time in days, thought he saw a hint of compassion cross the wizard’s knitted brow. ‘I do not know enough about the history of your people to guess at this. If the doors are opened, which I believe I can teach you to do, then you should be able to close them from the other side. Through all of its defenses, this is roadway for the Dúnedain and like the secret door above, you and your folk are meant to keep it.’
Ohtar looked long at the Great Doors, which held such mystery for him ever since he first came to this place many years ago. He saw this place in a way Ben could not; for he looked past the wonderment to the order and the precision of the design. Here, in a room he had hoped to use for solace and a brief hiding, he knew, as he had before bringing Flomi here, that they stood on the verge of something greater. This ‘watering hole’ that his folk had visited and kept secret for many long centuries Ohtar and many of his family knew for its deeper history. Here was the ordered waystation for the great mystery of Men. Here, beyond this place Flomi had casually named “the Grazing Field” was the Causeway, Tauma. It was the last road of kings and symbol of how his People both exalted and feared death. Ohtar had opened a secret door above in his need, but the fear of opening this Great Door below was an answer to his faith.
‘I may keep the way best, Wisefather, and keep best my faith and my Peoples’ history best as well,’ he said to the wizard, ‘by never bringing light into that doorway.’
*****
In an instant all of the rats within sight of the shattered doorway were suddenly blinded. This did not keep them from scurrying toward torches and blades and daggers, of course, but it made them much less dangerous in their frenzy. The light came like a hard rain across Ben’s back and into the antechamber. To call it ‘light’ felt wrong to Ben, for it was more like a heavy feeling, an almost physical sensation like a hailstorm without a wind as it stunned anyone caught looking at it.
‘Lacenítë!’16 The great voice called from behind Ben. He knew it was Alatar who had, during all the conflict, come behind the three door guards quite carefully on the narrow landing. Ben could not look back to be certain, as he felt the light emanating like an unexpected storm that had come out of the wizard, fallen across his own back, to go out and into the antechamber and blind all those who would look in their terror.
Many rats were destroyed by this light. They simply disappeared before Ben’s eyes as if they had never been. They were quite simply snuffed like smoke under a bucket of fresh water, and Ben wondered if they had truly been or, as unnatural beings, were they just now banished by some spell. Most of these vanished creatures were the ones with the greatest resolve, directly surrounding their position at the door. The hard rain of light hit them and left nothing in their place; not smell nor fire nor smoke nor carcass. They were abolished quite as clearly as if they had not existed.
Alatar strode past Ben and Collum and the Bard, tall and spry and agile despite his seeming age, and out into the antechamber, his form long and dark as if the silhouette of his body was a long shadow cast by the great light held in his hand. As he passed into Ben’s sight, the hobbit saw that there was a wand there; the curious, curling, bone-white one he had seen before now glowed again, but with a light brighter and more silver than if the Moon himself had come down and been carried into this small space. Around the wizard, all of this light seemed to gather, and the blue of his robes, the silver of his hair, and the paleness of his skin were like one great, soft, comforting but terrifying blue torch in the darkness. Living rats, those who still had their wits, blindly fled from the radiance of him. The others fell to their backs, afraid, conquered, and hoping for a mercy that their kind had never known.
He strode to the center of the antechamber and, with a great rolling voice he then called to Beothalion, ‘Leave that door and your anger behind you, Young One! What lies beyond is not for us this night and your friends have greater need of you than violence!’
Beothalion’s great arms let go one last harsh fury against the door, ‘Boom Boom! Boom!’ and then grew quiet. Ben could not see much in his position of second guard, but it seems that the Wildman became suddenly still, suddenly calm, and the shadow of his great hulking figure diminished there before the Mysterious Door just as the light from Alatar’s wand brought a quietness to the room.
‘I think we shall have no more out of that door for the evening,’ the wizard said calmly as the remaining rats, still hundreds of them, scurried or writhed in blind terror around him as the young Elf-lord, leaping and swinging and stabbing with his swift accuracy drew them further into panic. But beyond his two companions, beyond Beothalion’s still form, with the light still present but not as blinding in the antechamber, Ben could see that the gap in the Mysterious Door, formerly not much bigger than his own small hand, had opened and was now almost to his own height, and he wondered what might come from it next.
End of Chapter IX
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter Nine
1) Radagast is much less of a blank slate than the Blue Wizards featured in this story. I don’t care much for the comedic effect that he was given in The Hobbit movies, but Sylvester McCoy did bring a bit of eccentricism bordering on madness, which I like. I hope to convey him as a sort of a renegade from the other four Istari, more accustomed to beasts and growing things than to the societies of Elf or Man.
2) The Great Plague came into Gondor in about 1635 of the Third Age, about the same time that a Shadow fell on the Greatwood. This would be over 300 years before the time of this tale.
3) I’ve completely stolen this moment from the movie Flash Gordon where the scientist, Emil Zarkoff, walks off the spaceship, sniffs deeply and loudly, declaring; “Good. There is oxygen on this planet.”
4) While “nâr” is indeed Sindarin for “rat”, it is the singular form with "nair" being the plural. But for dramatic effect "nâr" sounds better.
5) This is not part of The Tale of Eärendur, a riff I’ve constructed over the scattered stones of Beowulf, but it does use some of the same meter.
6) An expression often used by Gaffer Gamgee, of course.
7) I think that most Númenóreans would see the followers of Sauron as their great enemy.
8) Fornost Erain in the Hobbit way of speaking.
9) I’ve chosen another hobbit-like name for Lake Evendim, this time of my own invention.
10) This, of course, is the Bywater Bridge in the Shire.
11) “Peace, brother!” In Sindarin.
12) Tawarengil pauses here because “fae”, which is Sindarin for “spirit or radiance” is not a word that he thinks would translate well into the Westron tongue. He’s kind of a snob that way.
13) This curious word is not from any of Tolkien’s invented languages and to reveal its source here might spoil later surprises. For those of you who are curious, it is German. See what that tells you.
14) One of the most interesting and sometimes difficult things to write in Middle-earth is a character’s encounter with a modern or mythical technology that is quite beyond them. It gives one the chance to describe something now commonplace with a sense of wonder, but it can often sound cheap and phony. I was going for the former here and apologize if I’ve hit upon the latter.
15) Again, this is a Númenórean stride, just a little over a yard by our standards, and the principal unit of measure still in the North.
16) This Quenya word means “blind or unseeing” but it is an adjective and will need to be changed later to a command.
Chapter Ten; "Two Ways Forward"
-Here at the Close of Book One Decisions are Made and Cup of Parting is Had by All.
Read Chapter Ten; "Two Ways Forward"
And nothing much else happened, all the rest of that night.1
There was work to be done still, for many panicked rats still scurried about in the antechamber and up the stair to the outside door. They were cornered, blinded and afraid, and Ben felt a pang of pity for them as he and Tawarengil and the Bard dispatched them mercifully and made a great sweep of their bodies down the stairway. Most, or so it seemed, had fled through the gap in the Mysterious Door and Ohtar had lit a small but steady fire there to keep them from returning. Now the bodies of their comrades were being swept in great heaps to this spot so they might further fill the span under the door. No noise could be heard beyond that Mysterious Door and, open much wider as it was, Ben thought the smell coming from it was much more distressing.
Alatar and Beothalion had returned to the Grazing Field, but neither said anything to their companions and walked wearily down the rampway, as if any energy for conversation had gone out of them and into the battle. Alatar had the same stern and grave set to his brow, but Beothalion looked quite vacant, as one walking in sleep.
Pallando had come to guard the old door frame in the battle’s aftermath and during the subsequent slaughter. Few of the rats approached this doorwarden even during all their terror and confusion. The wizard had unbuckled the long sword from his belt and stood relaxed with it, still in its scabbard, to bar their way; on instinct, or perhaps some other low and keen animal sense, no rat would go that way.
The cleansing of the stairway and antechamber took some few hours as all the bodies were swept to the Mysterious Door and a pyre was lit there. This was done on Ohtar’s insistence, as he would not suffer to have the remains of these creatures any nearer to the Grazing Field. Some arguments were made by the others about the smoke and the air within the chamber, but Ohtar would not hear of it.
Once the pyre was lit Ben could see all of the smoke from hundreds of burning rat carcasses flowing out beneath the Mysterious Door, almost as if drawn there with an unnatural force. The four comrades, Ben and Ohtar and Tawarengil and Oisín, stood for a long time before the blaze watching the uncommon behavior of flame and smoke and said nothing to one another. Eventually they turned aside and, still walking in silence, rejoined their other friends in the Grazing Field below.
*****
Flomi had not woken during the fray. This concerned Ohtar much at first, but Pallando reassured the soldier that his friend had entered a deep sleep of healing; to remove him from stone and hall now would be a great hurt to his recovery.
Beothalion also lay in heavy sleep near the watering trough to the left of the Great Door. Even now they could see the dampness in his hair and clothing; for he had plunged as much of himself as he could manage into the waters there to cool his body and scrub the blood of battle from his face and limbs. Now he lay snoring deeply beside the fountain and Ben’s Rosie stood beside him protectively, occasionally nuzzling his great wet beard and whisking her tail. Tawarengil went to him there and sat silently beside his brother. Where the Elf-lord’s thoughts went none could tell and his childlike face had a calm that the members of the party had not seen before.
Rosie then left the slumbering Wildman and came to Ben’s side, brushing the top of his head with her jaw as she did sometimes when they were far north in the wild country and she could feel his concern of that land’s dangers almost as surely as she could feel her own. This, as it had done in so many past travels, comforted them both greatly.
Oisín put up his cudgel and sat down with his harp, plucking gently, absently but confidently; and all those in the Grazing Field were greatly comforted by his song.
After checking on Flomi, Ohtar went directly to Alatar, who stood very still and in silence before the Great Doors. He did not speak to the wizard, for he would not disturb him in his thoughts, and the two stood like this for many long minutes as the others fell silently to rest and the Bard’s harp found its slow and sonorous way into song.
‘There is safety beyond this door, Ohtar,’ the wizard said finally. ‘I can open it for you or, more correctly, I believe I can teach you to open it yourself. What lies far beyond, in the haunted South or the forsaken North I cannot tell you. But I can teach you to open and to close this door, and the wards that protect it from what we have seen this night will remain undisturbed. I-’ At this he paused for a moment and looked a bit surprised by the words forming in his head. ‘I am- sorry, for I have no advice to give you in this matter and see little that might counsel you in the road ahead. And this-’ he paused again, but the surprised look that he had turned then to consternation, then to a flash of humour and then, with a slow weakening of that knitted brow, his whole expression lightened and he looked almost ready to laugh as Ohtar had seen Olórin do earlier that morning.
‘And this gives me much to consider,’ he said finally, though without laughing. ‘We have had an important meeting, I believe, and I would help you as I am able. But the decision, as always, is meant to be your own. Tell me, soldier, what would you do?’
Ohtar bowed softly in respect to these statements and lifted his eyes again to the Great Door. Many runes were written there; some he knew but most he could not discover. When he first came here with his father’s men the reading of these writings was meant to be a test of his understanding of the Old Tongue. But many things written here had been forgotten by the Men of the North and were cast in languages long lost before he or his father or his father’s father had come to read them. The Door was a secret, one of the great secrets of his heritage, and faith and awe for the larger mystery which lay behind it held sway over his heart.
But still it was but a door; a gate they might go through to find safety in their need. And tonight’s attack had shown him that their need was great.
His eyes left the door then and looked to the others, his comrades-through-chance in the room around him. His soldier’s mind knew their mood as well as it knew their resolve and their strengths; but they could not stay here four more nights while Flomi healed. They would not survive it. He wanted to respect the Great Door as all the generations of his fathers had, but they and he had all been soldiers coming here for a day’s rest and some acknowledgment of the past glories of their people. To his understanding, they had never been in the kind of danger that Ohtar had brought these comrades to now. He respected the mysteries that lie behind this door, but as a captain of soldiers, or so his father had taught him, he had to think of the needs of his men.
‘I am a soldier, Wisefather, and not a king,’ he said finally. ‘Without a king’s command I must speak to these good companions of ours and let that decide our way ahead.’
*****
‘And now the time has come for our last debate,'2 Ohtar said just a short time later. All were awake in the Grazing Field now, even Beothalion who sat quietly on the ground beside the fountain and spoke with no one.
‘You all have done such great service to me that I cannot hope to reward, but my own way forward is to protect my friend, Flomi son of Trochi, and so I may not leave this hall until he is well enough to travel.
‘Many of you have joined me out of our chance-meeting,’ here he gestured towards the Istari and Beotalion and Tawarengil, ‘others from old vows of friendship,’ and here he gestured with a smile toward Ben, who sat rather patiently outside of what he considered a circle of High-talkers, ‘and others have fallen into our adventure through turns both surprising and illuminating,’ and here he singled out Oisín by hand and eye.
‘I can ask none of you to go forward with me after what has occurred tonight, and would, for friendships’ sake, encourage you now to leave with first light.’ There was a stirring from many assembled there and Ohtar, who was also Collum and also an Innkeeper, knew well how to speak up over a grumbling room.
‘No, no, Ben,’ he said, ‘even you. For your pledge I hold dear and your help I might sorely need. But Flomi cannot be moved, and until he is well, here I must remain. I’ve no promise of what tomorrow brings and expect no vow. Another night here may prove deadly, yet I must stay.’
‘I do not know who cares about my judgment in such matters,’ Pallando said slowly, and all eyes looked upon him as he did, ‘but this is wise. If the dwarf is moved from here I believe he will die.’
‘And so I am pledged to remain,’ Ohtar said, ‘and all of you, even you brave Benbow, are free of any bond to remain with me. Therefore I entreat you, as a friend who has been glad for your kindness, that with the coming Sun you should quit this place and go forward to your own adventures.’
‘Well, I’ll not do that!’ Ben said from outside the circle. ‘I don’t have adventures to go on to as these other lords might, and I’ve said that I’ll follow and that I’ll help. I’ve said it,’ and here Ben’s public speaking, never a thing he was particularly keen on, faltered just a bit. ‘I’ve said I'll do, and so I'll do as I’ve said. Tomorrow night will come as it will, Collum, just as it does here and elsewhere. But you’ll not be facing it alone.’
There were smiles and calmed faces at this response but very few deep surprises. Many looked at Benbow, this small and rustic hobbit, and considered his bravery as they thought long on their own. More surprisingly, it was Pallando who was the next to speak;
‘I have taken this dwarf as my charge, Ohtar,’ he said with grave concern in his voice. ‘I and others of my order all agree that there is something worth our interest in your mission. That may still bear out. But, for now, that is not my principal concern. The dwarf is my charge now, as he is your own, and I will stay with him through his healing.’
‘Yes, this is for the best,’ Alatar said. He did not seem alarmed by this news as the others did. ‘It will be strange to be parted from you, my friend, but I agree. This is best.’
‘Then you will not remain with them, Wise One?’ Tawarengil asked.
‘No, I shall not,’ the wizard said. ‘Olórin has taken the East road to Rivendell. If any might counsel lord Elrond to come forth, he has the greatest chance.
‘But the road West must still be seen to. Arthedain’s forces are still gathering from their rout and lord Cirdan’s call must be answered. Olórin was correct. There is a grave threat here in the North. It is not our principal task, of course, but it must still be seen to.’
The two wizards looked at each other in a long moment. There were none there willing to break the silence of that moment or who knew the deeper seriousness of it.
‘Agreed,’ Pallando said.
‘Lord Tawarengil,’ Alatar continued, looking away from Pallando, ‘if you and your friend wish to travel with me and answer Círdan’s call, I would be happy to make introductions for the both of you to that great lord.’
Tawarengil looked at Beothalion for some response. The Wildman was awake now, but he had spoken very few words since the battle and still had a vacant look about him that no one there wished to disturb. Benbow had seen this look before on soldiers and refugees that he’d encountered in some of his more dangerous travels, and it made him sad to see it again here. In the short time he had known him, Bethalion had seemed to Ben one of the most joyful of all the men he’d ever met. Now, since the night’s attack, that lighthearted spirit seemed, well, gone and a strange wariness or surprise had come to replace it.
‘Your offer is kind, Great One,’ Tawarengil said in reply, ‘and I have greatly looked forward to seeing the banners of my people assembled as stories say they were in our past. I am still young amongst my folk and have no memories of those older days. I and my brother went forth hoping to make such memories for ourselves.
‘But, I wonder now,’ he continued while looking back at Beothalion, ‘is the road East closed to us? If Olórin is still in the Bree-land, if we could find him, might he take us with him? My brother would, I think, be happier being closer to his home and—’
‘I would not!’ Beothalion interrupted sharply. He did not raise his voice, but the suddenness of it silenced all others. ‘I do not want to leave these people and their troubles, or this great large world that I am seeing, Tawar. To be sent home! Like a child! I miss my home and I miss very much my friends there, brother, but I will not leave you, and these new friends because of things that I miss. I will go where you go, brother.’
‘That is very kind of you, young one,’ Pallando said, his voice low and rumbling, but gentle like the continuously running water of the fountains. ‘And you have brought us all great support already. Much greater than even you expected, I think. I hope that you will come to learn more about your own surprising nature. But Ohtar and master Floxleaf and I will be fine now. Behind this door there are greater protections for us than even you might provide.
‘And yes, you might catch up with Olórin, lord Tawarengil,’ he continued, his voice already calming the others, ‘if that is really your wish. Just as we have indicated since our first meeting, the choice is always your own to make. But answers lie in the West for all of the Eldar, my lord, and for your brother here as well. It is the Eldar in Mithlond who still hold many answers to a past most Men have overlooked. And of your People, young one, of all of the Children of Haleth,'3 he said looking compassionately into Beothalion’s battle-shocked eyes, ‘I believe Círdan may know more than even lord Elrond does.’
‘Come west with me if you will, the both of you,’ Alatar said, ‘or back east if that should be your choice. But it is a choice you must make quickly, for daylight, and the chance to depart is soon upon us.’
And this was so. No sunlight yet fell into the Grazing Field from the narrow and carefully hidden slots above, but all could feel that the nighttime was fading; it had an almost physical presence here since the attack of the rats and now, noticeable to almost everyone; the hold of night was releasing.
‘Oisín Na-Ghiliruin, Man of Númenór,’ Ohtar said, ‘you may also wish to depart with the dawn. I will not deter you and you are under no oath to myself or these my comrades. You have, I believe, saved my friend Flomi when the rest of us may have come too late and for that I cannot repay you. But from you still, Flomi and I have the greatest need.
‘You should know, as these other friends do,’ he continued, ‘that we are involved in a great undertaking for our People. Many great things were lost in the North well before Cardolan or Arthedain fell, and it has been the hope of my family, for many generations, to retrieve them. Flomi, though it may seem strange to hear, is the best chance of that hope and he believes that your song, your tale that was sung as he lay wounded, offers him clues to that great puzzle. I did not, at first, believe this to be other than the fever of his healing. But I have come to trust in Flomi’s judgment and, lately, I myself have heard you say things that might make me believe it.
‘You are under no bond to stay, singer,’ he said, ‘but your song is very important to my hopes. I entreat you to join us. I offer you the full protection of my arms, but also the freedom to follow your heart. My need is great, but it does not outstrip my thankfulness for all that you have done. Tell me, will you stay and teach us what we need or will you go on to your own adventures? You will have my respect and my great wishes of success in either choice. But I must prepare now for tomorrow.’
Oisín had, in fact, stood as he had been addressed. Ben thought it a bit odd, like some of the Bard’s other customs he’d seen in the past day, but it was, in fact, a long-standing tradition of Oisín’s people. They were not, after all, the rough men of the Minhiriathrim, not the men of Dark times who hid their counsels in caves and sheltered forests and hidden glades. The men of Cardolan who came to Eryn Vorn were, blood-through-blood, the Men of old Númenór, begotten of the old Sea-kings, and while they had learned to hide and protect themselves as the Minhiriathrim had shown them, they never did less than stand when called upon.
Oisín stared at the Great Door with tremendous fixation, much as he had shown earlier that day when they all discussed it, but now his eyes held another kind of longing look; more purposeful and more discerning.
‘I cannot yet say, Hothron,'4 he said softly. ‘I will need time to pray.’
*****
And so the dawn came soon after and the party made ready to meet it.
Before the first shafts of filtered sunlight could be felt within the cavern of the Grazing Field Flomi had been moved to the palette they had fashioned for him and all his gear was also assembled there.
Tawarengil and Beothalion had gone off together to discuss their own way forward, but the decision had come fairly quickly to them both.
‘I am very sorry, little Benbow,’ the Wildman said to Ben, coming to find him directly after his talk with the young Elf-lord. ‘My brother and I are going otherwheres. He would have us follow Alatar into the west, and it may be,’ he said somewhat sheepishly, ‘this is good for me as well. I still have much to learn, we think.’
‘Well, these are wise old fathers, I think,’ Ben said, craning his neck to look up and catch the big man’s eyes, ‘and they seem to know a lot more about this world than you or I do. It couldn’t hurt to take a little advice that is offered freely from any one of these three pilgrims, I should think.
‘They may have great things to show you, Beothalion, great castles and green lands and such wonderful things you’ve not had sight of before,’ he continued. ‘And I hope all of these make you happy as you were on that day you first saw the commonroom at the Four Greenfields. I will remember that, and remember the surprise and joy you found there in the simple lives of the Breefolk.
‘I myself don’t care much about banners and legions as your brother does, but there’s a wonder to be found in those things as well, or so I hear.
‘We’ll be just fine here ourselves, Collum and that mister Pallando and I,’ he said, gesturing at his fellows, clearly uncomfortable with such a long speech. ‘I don’t understand much of what happened last night, but I’m sure that you saved me and many of us. Just as you did the night of the fire in the Bree-land. You’re a friend to me now on the road, mister Beothalion, and while I regret our parting, I look forward to you having everything you want in the adventures of your future.’
Ben didn’t know quite what to do at the end of such a long speech (and, just like Milo Fastknots, it was a situation he had not found himself in very often before). So, rather sheepishly, he bowed.
Beothalion felt likewise constrained by his lack of polished courtly manners. He resorted to his old greeting of open hands forward, down to his side and then turned palm up, the one he had shown the wizards before, three nights ago at the inn where they all had met. Then he remembered that Benbow didn’t know that gesture, so he copied the hobbit’s low bow, but went to one knee after. This brought their eyes into contact again and, holding their serious expressions for only a moment, their faces together broke into laughter.
‘Oh, I shall miss you, little Benbow,’ the Wildman said, laughing.
And Ben laughed, and away to the corners of the Grazing Field Rosie laughed, and the other animals (though they did not fully understand why) laughed with her. Ben was the happiest then that he could remember in many years.
The two companions did not see one another for a very long time, and much misery came to each before their next happy greeting.
*****
‘These runes were not all set into the door at once,’ the wizard said, ‘and there are some rendered here by crude hands. These are the most easy to read, I should think, for the words are in the modern tongue of the North while the letters are in the older forms.’5
‘Yes, wisefather, these I know,’ Ohtar said as they studied the doors together. ‘This place was sometimes used as a test for my people, and even myself in youth, for an understanding of our old languages which may no longer be found since Arnor collapsed.
‘I know the Westron written here,’ he continued, ‘and I have learned some of the Elven tongue from this wall. Studying here I learned to write it properly. There is even Adûnaic here,’ he pointed then to high carvings on the lintel of the door, ‘and while I have some understanding of their sounds, I cannot, nor could my teachers, grasp their meaning.’
‘I cannot either,’ Alatar said, ‘for I held little congress with those people when that language was in flower, and there is only one of my order who knows it still.6
‘Tell me, Ohtar,’ he said softly, ‘is there anything else written here which has drawn your attention but stands unresolved?’
Ohtar looked long at the Great Door. He wondered how many times he had visited this spot, how young he was when first he came to the Foundations; never as a boy of course, for this was too secret and too sacred a spot for boys to know of, but certainly many times before he and his father had traveled south to Gondor. They came here to talk and to study and to prepare the younger Ohtar for the responsibilities he would carry and that had been carried by the twenty-six other Ohtars before him. He regretted how infrequently, even with his living in the Bree-land these past dozen years, he had been able to bring his own sons here.
‘If I am to guess, wisefather,’ Ohtar said reluctantly, but with a small grin that hinted at humour for being tested, ‘I would pick not one inscription, but two. Here, on the pedestals that support these basins, two matching inscriptions can be seen. The script is Tengwar, as the Men of Númenór used in Isildur’s day, and it is finely crafted; my own father believed it part of the original construction.’
‘It seems your father had much wisdom despite knowing little history, Ohtar,’ the wizard said, ‘for I also believe this to be the case. But he could not read the inscription here, I would guess. Few in the world of Men might.
‘It is written, as you say, in the letters Men learned from the Elves,’ Alatar continued, ‘but not in the language the Elves had taught them and that the faithful of Númenór so long maintained. No, this bit of amusing speech is in the old High Language of the Elves that only a very small number of Númenóreans had ever learned or kept. I doubt your Rune-master has ever come upon it or that our young lord Tawarengil has even recognized it. It was, I can say with all frankness, the most surprising thing that I and those of my order have been shown in these past few days of surprises.’
‘Can you understand and interpret the inscription, wisefather?’ Ohtar asked. ‘Does it have something to do with opening the Great Door here?’
‘Oh, most certainly,’ the wizard answered briskly, as if it was the silliest question he had heard in a long time. ‘And I can teach it to you. I shall teach it to you. But you made an excellent observation just a moment ago which seems to escape your mind now:
‘There are two pedestals with two matching inscriptions.’
*****
The Bard opened the door with carefully contained excitement. He did not enjoy this underground place, sacred as he knew it should be to him and to all of his people, but throughout the last night’s battle the lack of sky and open space had troubled him greatly. He and his people did not fight in mines and tunnels but in open lands and deep forests. He could not imagine how dwarves and elves and other folk lived and died in tunnels or such places, with no sky over their heads.
As the Secret Door swung in towards him, he saw the morning light, still way below the tree line, off to the distant east. As always, the light from that direction seemed cold and remote until, finally, the Sun burst forward to warm even that far-off, still-feared part of the world. Stepping forth onto the cool ground before the door, he could hear bird calls and other small sounds of wind and of living things as they awakened. He looked down at his feet and saw that even in the springtime of this land north of his own, frost had come to the small bushes and grasses growing near the wall. Frost came seldom to the Eryn Vorn, the land of his birth and his People’s exile; one must sometimes go high into the trees to find it. Now he looked up at the sky and saw that many of the stars were still out, still shining to light his way until the Sun may come.
Here, with the great sky above him and the sense of great life around him, he could not imagine living, fighting and dying in a tunnel or a hall, no matter how great or lordly such a hall might be, as dwarves and even some elves were said to do. As he and his new friends fought and may have died last night.
He could not imagine it but, truly, he had never before imagined his own dying very much.
‘Imagining one’s own death is a waste of imagination,’ he had thought then, and (being a collector of such witticisms) would joke about later.
He did not wish to join the soldier and the others back in the tunnel while the stars were overhead and there was dew on the grass and the Sun would soon rise to meet his face. He did not know if his way forward should lead under the ground when he felt so powerfully the joy of another morning.
‘But to imagine one’s own way forward without prayer is a waste of faith.’
As the world awakened around him, and with the anticipation of the Sun on his face, he went forward into the birch glade ahead. There he would climb the highest tree in the westernmost part of the ring, climb to the highest spot that would hold him, his face ready to meet the Sun, the blade of his fathers in his lap.
It would be a beautiful day in the springtime of this northern land. The dew would melt quickly, no clouds could be seen as yet, and the lands around him were awakening softly, peacefully.
He would feel the Sun on his face and on the land and hear within his heart the way forward.
*****
Tawarengil joined Ohtar and Alatar before the Great Door. ‘You will go forward then?’ he asked. ‘You will open this door and go further into these dark halls?’
‘Yes, my lord,’ Ohtar responded, ‘my way must lie there until Flomi has healed. It seems clear that our protection in this chamber, if truly we had much, has ended. So if I cannot take Flomi out, I must take him deeper in.’
Tawarengil took a moment to consider this. For Ohtar it was, in that moment of their last conversation together, a surprising thing to see the hesitancy on the elf-lord’s face.
Over the past three days, Ohtar had seldom seen such a moment as this happen. The lord Tawarengil he had seen was brusque; quick to action or speech in ways that, on those few occasions Ohtar had of speaking with other Elf-lords, seemed quite uncommon. It was sometimes difficult to address Tawarengil as an adult given that he looked so childlike, and perhaps that had something to do with the lord’s impatience. But Ohtar knew better than to be fooled by appearances concerning the fair folk, even if he knew little of their ways. From the start, he had treated the Elf-lord just as the Istari had done: respectfully but cautiously. For the elf was clearly of great lineage but seemed to have unrevealed purposes.
‘We will not go deeper,’ Tawarengil said resolutely after a few moments, with clear seriousness written over his childlike features. ‘Beothalion and I will go west to Círdan’s call as we had intended. We will ride out under the banners of my People to destroy the Witch-king. We will learn more, as we have sought from the start, learn more of ourselves and of our People. We will not go deeper into tunnels and mysteries which only distract us from that intention.
‘But making this decision fills me with some... uncertainty, Ohtar,’ the Elf-lord continued, ‘for I and my brother have grown interested in your own fate and he,’ Tawarengil paused here as a gentle smile showed us his face, ‘and I myself, do not leave our interests behind us lightly.
‘We can wish you well,’ he said then, turning to face Ohtar with some formality, ‘but we cannot join you further.
'Galu, Hothron. Boe i 'waen, im naer. Na lû e-govaned vîn, Sílo Anor bo men lín.’7
‘I am most grateful for your kindness, lord,’ Ohtar said in return as he bowed slightly in deference to Tawarengil’s graciousness and in respect for the lord’s stature. ‘And I can only thank you once again for all of the help you have given to my cause and to those short-sighted people of the Bree-land. I wish you well in your own roads to the West and am likewise saddened that my duties will not allow me to accompany you and see the lands of the North retaken by our united Peoples. I have been in wars, lord, and still my heart is stirred by banners and the ringing of silver trumpets as you speak of. Go to glory, lord Tawarengil, and, if fate permits, we shall meet again in the free lands of the North.’
And so they would meet again, after many miseries and unexpected hardships, after long battles and heart-shattering circumstances, and they would be glad for this meeting though the cost was high.
*****
‘But she must go with you!’ Benbow said. ‘I’ll not take her further into the dangers behind that door. I’ll not!’
‘And she will also not, little Benbow,’ Beothalion replied. ‘She is very wise, more than any other I have seen in my travels. She knows your mind and she knows her own. She will not leave you.’
Rosie responded by neighing loudly and rubbing her head against the top of Ben’s in that old reassuring way that she had.
‘Acccch! Rosie, girl,’ Ben said, reaching up to touch the pony’s jaw line and stroke the area around her cheek and below her ear in the way that she loved. ‘Rosie, if you can hear me as this friend of ours says that you can then, Rosie, my dear, you should not follow!’
There was another loud, disgruntled neighing at this comment and it was echoed by the braying sound of Duncan, the dwarf’s beast, further back in the field.
‘Oh, she hears you, but she will not leave you, little Benbow, the Wildman said. ‘Why should she leave? I do not know how to answer this.’
‘Why? Because I want her to be safe and to live long and happy away from dangers, of course. Why!’
‘Yes, I know this, my friend,’ Beothalion responded quietly, ‘but have you not wanted that for her always before?’
‘Well, yes, of course I have, but...’
‘I understand your feelings, Ben,’ Collum said, walking quietly up behind them. ‘It seems that Caitelyn, against my better wishes, will also join us in our journey. I had offered her to Alatar that he might take her far away from this troubled place. He was... unmoved. He claims to have no need of her on his travels.’
‘I will take charge of your friend, Collum Ohtar,’ Beothalion said, ‘though I do not ride.’ He thought for a moment about this and, looking around the chamber, said, ‘Perhaps my brother does.’
‘Now that would be a sight,’ Ben said, picturing the young Elf-lord, not many inches taller than Ben himself, astride Collum’s great grey mare, his wooden sword in hand. Sensing the joke, Collum also smiled.
‘You do me yet another favor, my friend,’ the man said, ‘and again I thank you. If you can see Caitelyn out of this harm and on your journey west it would ease my heart greatly. There are wonderful farmlands just beyond the Brown River that she knows well and might love to see again.
‘Now, Ben,’ he said, turning to the hobbit, ‘while I obviously agree with your desire for her safety, your Rosie is not a simple beast like Caitelyn or Duncan there. She was raised in Rivendell and has a keener understanding than either of us has accounted her for. And she has always been loyal to none but you. I do not think she will let you go without her.
‘I have never heard of any of my People who has gone beyond the Great Door, but I do know this: that way was prepared long ago for horses of much greater size than even Caitelyn. Rosie will be no more trapped there than any of us.’
‘I appreciate what you are saying, Collum,’ Ben replied, ‘even if I don’t find it at all reassuring.
‘Okay, Rosie, my girl,’ he said, looking lovingly into the pony's bright eyes, ‘it will be as it has been; you and me on new roads together.’ Rosie neighed softly and nuzzled against his head again. ‘We may not see open skies together for some time, girl. Let’s go see the morning Sun for a bit now.’
*****
Ohtar thought that this was an excellent idea and so Rosie and the other beasts were all taken up the ramp in the company of Ben, Beothalion and Tawarengil. Here they would be given an hour or two of morning light and air before the company was to become split and half of them would plunge further into darkness. Ohtar himself remained behind for a time to sort the provisions and to prepare Flomi’s litter. Alatar was still studying the workings of the Great Door.
‘Will he wake soon?’ Ohtar asked Pallando as he approached the wizard sitting there beside Flomi’s litter.
‘No,’ the wizard replied gravely as he touched two fingertips to Flomi’s brow. ‘No, he will remain at rest for a time, Ohtar. Their strength is like stone; growing greater in its immobility. They came forth in the days of the power of Melkor, these Children of Aulë, and so he made them strong that they might endure much. They are stone-hard in toil, stubborn in cause, fast in friendship and likewise in enmity. They suffer exhaustion and hunger and hurt of body quite as other peoples do but bear it more handily, as the stone around them, quietly resisting age and hurt. And they live long, far beyond the span of Men.
‘Yet not forever,’8 he continued. ‘He sleeps as stone sleeps now. In a healing sleep which his people have that I have helped him to find. I doubt that a dagger would awaken him-’ And the wizard stopped suddenly here to see the concern on Ohtar’s face. ‘Though I also doubt any daggers could trouble him here with good comrades at hand,’ he continued. ‘Touch him, Ohtar, and understand this! Feel it for yourself.’
Ohtar was, in his heart, greatly torn over Flomi’s condition. He had sent the dwarf here to what he believed was a safe place hardly a week before and now it seemed to be one of the deadliest places he had ever encountered. Impetuous and naive as he often seemed, Flomi had become Collum’s friend and Ohtar, who should have the goal of their quest most high in his mind and above any friendship, now found himself more concerned for Flomi than he was for the mission. Had they left a week ago, as he knew they should have, all might have been different.
The two friends had spoken a few times since Flomi’s battle; the dwarf had risen to consciousness in fits of determination and stubbornness during that first night. Pallando, the quieter of the two blue wizards, had changed that. He had spoken with Flomi, and had touched his wounds, and had said slow, unknown words over him so that the dwarf fell deep into a deathlike sleep; sitting near and listening closely, Ohtar could still hear the breathing of his friend. But nothing else; no moan or sigh, no flicker of eyelids or turn nor twitch of body could be seen in his slumber. So near death he seemed then that Ohtar was afraid what that death might mean to his Princess and how he had failed to protect his friend.
‘O, you Men!’ the wizard said, looking at him now and seeing Ohtar’s fear and wonder. ‘So involved as you are with death that you will not allow yourselves to notice how others face it differently. This dwarf, your friend as I take it, was grievously wounded. But he and his kind do not go so readily as Men might. Touch his skin! Do not fear what it will tell you!’
Ohtar, responding more to the power in the old man’s voice than through any decision of his own, bent beside his friend and reached out his hand to touch Flomi’s brow. It had been feverish earlier, on the night when they first came into the Grazing Field and saw the dwarf being cared for by Oisín. Now the skin that Ohtar touched was much cooler, not cold as he had at first feared, but cooler than his own. ‘Like a stone brought inside the house at the end of a summer’s day,’ he thought.
‘Yes,’ Pallando said, breaking his thoughts, ‘he is quite cool as he rests. There is a fire within these People that does not need Sun nor Stars to be kindled. That fire is now directed to the healing of his body, and the skin you feel beneath you contains it.’
Hearing this, Ohtar could feel the hardness of Flomi’s skin. Not the ruddy, leather-like quality he thought of when looking at him before, but a stony smoothness and resilience. He breathed, and he was warm still, unmoving and unaffected by Ohtar’s touch.
‘Yes, much like stone in his healing. And he will now be a good deal heavier,’ Pallando said. ‘We shall need that donkey of yours to bear his litter.’
*****
As they stood near the wall and felt the morning Sun on their faces, Ben’s quick eye caught quiet movement in the trees of the nearby glade. He saw the Bard drop silently to the ground there and come forward to meet them. Tawarengil and Beothalion had gone off a bit to the north with Caitelyn and the other queer beast, leaving just Ben and his Rosie to meet the man.
‘Looks to be a beautiful morning,’ Ben said to him amiably, ‘and Rosie and I have come to take our last bit of sunshine for a time.’
‘Aye, the Sun smiles for us today after our long night,’ the man said warmly, pausing to look back to the eastern sky, ‘and dawn is ever the hope of Men.
‘May I touch your beast?’ He asked cautiously, raising his open hand to Rosie.
‘Well,’ Ben said with equal caution, ‘if she lets you then it’s surely fine with me. But she doesn’t take to folk easily, my Rosie-’
Much to Ben’s surprise, the pony came and put her jaw right into the stranger’s outstretched hand. He rubbed under her chin, but cautiously still, like one who was unfamiliar with ponies.
‘Well, that is another surprise in a week of the same,’ Ben said, ‘she doesn’t usually take to strangers and, no insult meant, she doesn’t much care for the Big Folk.’
‘Do you mean the men of Númenor?’ he replied, petting Rosie and looking into her eyes.
‘Well, just Men, I’d guess,’ said Ben. ‘She’s seen some bad ones in her time. And it might have something to do with her being raised by the Elves. They’re fine suspicious of Men too, from what I’ve seen.’
‘We do not have such beasts where I come from,’ he said admiringly, ‘and not much kinship with them as I have seen here in the wider world. The people of Minhiriath, and those of my folk who have survived since Cardolan’s fall, are a forest People. We do not train nor keep beasts. We do not farm nor raise flocks as my ancestors of Cardolan once did. We are wanderers and hunters now.’
‘Well, we’ve certainly that in common then,’ Ben said smiling, ‘I and my fathers before me have wandered and hunted here in the North country for as long as anyone remembers.’ He patted Rosie’s side then, saying, ‘Though we’ve had good friends like Rosie here to help us in moving our feet forward.’
The Bard turned then and looked long into Benbow’s large brown eyes. He then did the same with Rosie, still gently stroking under her jawline.
‘Thank you, Benbow Floxleaf, and thank your friend... Rosie?’
‘“Roh-so-sin-dinn”9 as I’d first heard it said,’ Ben replied, ‘but she’s just simple Rosie to me.’
‘Not so simple at all, I think,’ he said, smiling broadly. ‘Thank you, “Rosie”,’ he told the pony very frankly, ‘What a tale we are in, aren’t we?’10
*****
The Bard came down the ramp into the Grazing Field and stood before Ohtar and Pallando as they prepared their way forward. An awkward silence fell between the two men, and Ohtar, the taller of the two, stood quietly waiting to see what would pass.
Oisín bent his knee and offered his open hands.
‘I will take you as my captain,’ he said, his head low, ‘for what time I may be useful to you. I will aid you as I can by song and story and force of arms. I will go into this sacred place with you,’ he said, indicating the doors before them, ‘for as long as it may serve you to have me as escort.
‘Yet I must also go forward when you will release me,’ he continued. Then he drew from behind his back a dagger, long, leaf-shaped and damasked with serpent forms in red and gold. It shone very brightly in the dim cavern, the light of the early sun red upon it. Its edge was hard and keen, and Ohtar knew it to be a work of old hands.11
‘I will take you as my captain for what time I may prove useful,’ the Bard said, ‘but I must, when possible, be released from your service to fulfill my vow. Then I will go to kill the Witch-king with this blade. But for now I shall swear by it.’
*****
And so the company was decided; Ohtar, Ben, Oisín and Pallando would go deeper into the mysteries behind the Great Door so that their friend would have time to heal. Perhaps this would be only a short way, for Flomi still needed four to five full days rest to recover, and then they might come out again into the Grazing Field in the morning when daylight would make it safe. If this were to happen they would then return as they came and depart this place with the skies over their heads and a yet undetermined way north. Or, perhaps, they would journey north through the passage; though no one knew what other exit lay ahead on that grim road. It went north, they knew, to the Silent City, Annúminas, on the shores of lake Evendim, and Ohtar and Flomi had both agreed that their mission must lead there. But Annúminas had long ago fallen into emptiness and despair, and none knew if that way yet remained open.
Alatar would take the others west to Mithlond to answer Cirdan’s call. Tawarengil and Beothalion (and even Caitelyn) would join him. Alatar believed that the forces of Elves and Men were gathering there and that his wisdom would be needed. Tawarengil wanted to see the banners of his people unfurled. Beothalion, for his part, followed his brother but also hoped to learn more of the world and of his own place in it.
All the provisions that Milo had brought were pulled out into the morning sun before the Secret Door and divided to the benefit of each party. This had been somewhat of a waste of energy, for no provisions would be needed for the travelers on the western road. The land between here and Mithlond was fertile and friendly with open skies and great patches of green hills and rolling rivers before one came to the Gulf of Lhûn, the mouth of the great Western Sea. Between here and Mithlond they would cross the Shire, a land of great plenty whose folk were still loyal to the King and kept the Road. They had little or no need for provisioning. Alatar and Tawarengil and Beothalion would take Caitelyn with them at Ohtar’s request. Alatar seemed unhappy about this decision regarding the horse, but the Elf-lord defended his brother’s position on the matter.
So the subterranean travelers were given the great share of the supplies. Rosie and Duncan, who seemed strangely receptive to going on despite the danger, would bear much of this as they moved forward. They could not yet be sure of their way, so large stores of mosses from the Grazing Field and skins of fresh water from the troughs were prepared for them should they take that unrecovered road North. Dried meats and fruits, wine and blankets, saddles and rope, all of what Milo Fastknots had gathered, were given to these folk as well.
All of these decisions were made rather quickly after Oisín had decided to follow the north party, and Ohtar then prepared quickly that they all might depart soon. He had gone to a crude pantry in the Grazing Field and found three drinking vessels which he knew of. He added these to the four others he had brought from the Bree-land: the delicately wrought cups he had shared with the wizards at that first meeting. He cleaned these all very thoroughly and, overturning a small storage container to use as a table in the Glade of Seven Birches, set them gently into a line. As his compatriots gathered and watched him prepare, he drew a lambskin canteen from his bag and slowly, with some solemnity, poured from it carefully, equally and evenly, into these seven cups.
‘Come, my friends, and we will drink a proper parting,’ he said.
The last of his remaining contents were set before him in the seven small cups on the crude, makeshift table. Ben, who still thought he knew some things about the man well, watched the regret fall on Collum’s face as the last of these ingredients was squeezed from the canteen and the supply was finally drained. Collum took a long moment to look at the depleted vessel before looking into the eyes of his friends.
‘So we will now,’ Ohtar said, ‘drink this cup of parting that we spoke of before. To Beothalion, I have promised this, but I also owe all you others greatly.
‘This,’ he said, raising one of the smaller crude drinking vessels above his brow line, ‘is Mirovur, the cordial of Imladris, of which my family has been given a rather special stewardship.
‘Three I served a few nights ago,’ he continued, ‘and seven I serve now. Nothing now remains of what I have carried in secret for over twenty years.’
‘Ohtar,’ Tawarengil said, ‘you should not do this! It is a rare gift indeed to carry the cordial of Imladris, but you should not give it carelessly to others!’
‘Do I, my lord?’ Ohtar said. ‘Is it careless to reward such friends as we have gathered here? I go into a great unknown. Shall I take such a treasure with me, or shall I share it out under the bright Sun with bold comrades, in celebration of glad times?
‘Here, my friends and comrades,’ he said, handing out the drinking vessels to all assembled. ‘We must part company, yet I am thankful to my last for the company we have shared. In some few hours we will go to our fortunes, but I would drink a cup of parting with you now before that moment comes.’
Collum, or Ohtar or whomever he may be called, then dropped his own vessel to the table, banging it there gently before he raised it again in celebration:12
‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ he called loudly.
The two wizards repeated his call and even Tawarengil repeated it slowly and sheepishly. All drank the offered cordial and all hearts were warmed by it.
Ben, even before he put the cup to his lips, felt, smelt, or dreamed almost immediately of the time, four years past, when he and his father rode into the hidden valley of Rivendell. He smelled again the birch and pine of the valley, remembered the roasting meats and roaring fires of the Homely House. He heard again, in beautiful memory, the singing and the laughing of happy voices in the air. There he had lost his father, but there he had been given Rosie by the most beautiful Elf-lady he had ever seen, and so the moment this draught brought to his mind was both happy and mournful. He welcomed it.
Tawarengil, from his first scent of the liquor as it was poured out, had quite expectantly fallen into a deep reverie. The woodland Elves of his people live deeply in the green and their dreamtime often sees them wander into familiar forest paths reliving details of the sunlit trees and starlit paths. He knew of Mirovur, as all his folk did, but he had never encountered it before now.
Oddly, it did not send his dreamingmind into a deep memory of the Greatwood in daytime and the world which he loved, but into an unfamiliar nighttime and a sky full of stars in lands that he had never seen. He felt, very acutely, the swaying of the birch trees near them in his nowtime. He felt those trees’ longing to grow and bend to the West and their commitment and faith to grow straight as their stewards had guided them in their youth. In his reverie those trees were not yet born and all the world was younger, younger than he had seen it in his small lifetime and clearer than any song had ever described. Clear and bright were the stars in these ancient times as Tawarengil saw them now. With the smell of Mirovur he dreamed beyond his own short experience of a young world which he had never known. It was night in that dreamworld and he walked alone and naked in the open and unsullied lands. The bright stars above put him farther west of the land he was in now, farther west than any skies he had imagined. But even then, in that distant world as in this present one, he felt the grass and the earth beneath his feet as it rolled westward, returning somehow in ways that the grasses could not speak of now and that he could feel only but not fully interpret.
Still in his trance and still in his comradeship with the others in this glade of white trees, as he took the treasured drink to his lips, his eyes were drawn upward again and, though it was early morning and bright sunshine was coming into the glade, he did not see the Sun as he drank the cup of parting.
Instead, his eyes beheld up above them the heaventree of all stars. A past which possibly had ceased to exist as a present before its probable spectators had entered actual present existence.13 He saw the moving of time and, young though he was, he felt the movement of all things West to their purpose.
And he heard, for the first time in that dream of then which put him far west of now, the roaring of seas. And he heard the call of the West. And he resisted it then as he did for many long years after.
Beothalion worked to contain his excitement as the liqueur was poured out. It was this smell of honey and sunshine and clear, cold flowing streams that first caught his attention three days before in the Bree-land as he was surrounded by so many very new smells and sights and sounds. It had drawn him out of his chair, away from his brother’s cautious guidance, and into his first conversation with people he did not know. The smell of its pouring, then and now, felt as a familiar thing in a very foreign world that he could not resist tasting.
But the taste of the cordial itself, in Beothalion’s mouth, brought something quite different. It rolled through his mouth and over his tongue and, at first, brought to his memory the smell of rain. Throughout the rain, he remembered that the small island had held, for seven days it held, but all around them the orcs had taken the shores of the river in impossible numbers. His father and his brother had already fallen trying to ride out to meet them. He must hold the line against the siege. He must keep his people alive and wary through the rain and the attack. He must hold the line.
Somewhere, unbidden though feeling very much like a memory found in the Mirovur’s taste, Beothalion thought, or remembered saying to himself, ‘The day will come when they will perish and I shall go back.’14
And there was a clear and undeniable pride which he felt in this memory, a willfulness uncharacteristic of his current nature that made him, in that very difficult and uncertain moment of his life, feel all the stronger. In all the long years of his life afterwards he never told anyone about this, not even his son, but he never forgot the road of discovery which the taste of that drought sent him on.
Ohtar had never tasted Mirovur. There was some part of him, some voice of his father’s, which made the cordial, and his stewardship of it, so important to his mind that partaking of it himself should feel unfaithful. But here he was at a great crossroads with a collection of people who may do better work in the larger world than he himself might do under it following his own current direction; they might become warriors of the North while he and his line had been relegated to being the custodians of their own very specific cause.
As he poured the liqueur into these assorted vessels, he resisted the compelling urge to let the aroma transport him to some memory of home; some glimpse of what his heart longed for. Memory and smell showed him fleeting glimpses of a tall, dark-haired woman and her wide but serious smile; of sons he had spent too little time with; of his father, who remained lost; and even of Guldir, now dead, who had helped him so much in younger days. But he rejected these flashes of smell’s memory and kept to the work of service. He knew this to be the trick of the potion, or so it had been called by his fathers: that it restores the heart and spirit with memories of all that it has longed for, but also reveals truths of the self that are sometimes uncomfortable.
Ohtar did not want to drink this most special and precious of draughts with the others, but custom dictated that he should.
Each time that he had poured this out (and he had done so three times in his lifetime before now) he had managed to avoid partaking with the others; to conserve the beverage perhaps, or, maybe, to avoid the thoughts or memories that it was purported to bring.
As the drink came into his mouth, the smells of the birch and rowan, of the fir and nettles of the area surrounding this special place left him, and he was once again in the northern marches of a fair land far south of where his feet stood now. A country of climbing woods and swift-falling streams (as the land was to the north of his feet as they stood here near the Tuama where it was early morning yet). But in his mind and his memory the night above him became fine under stars and a great round moon, and it seemed that the fragrance of the air grew as he and the company of soldiers rode forward. They rode quietly by night. All had swords at their sides, and were clad in green and brown of varied hues, the better to move unseen in the glades of Ithilien. Green gauntlets covered his hands then and his face was hooded.15
In Ithilien, thirty years before, he rode with the company of the Commander, Eärnil.16 He had the respect of this Commander and, though still quite young, he had a clear purpose, a known path, in the wars of Gondor and the preservation of the realms of Men. He was a soldier of Númenór then and he served a king of Gondor and a Commander he respected. As the day would open up in this memory, he and the Men riding beside him would go to the Battle of the Camps and turn the tide of war. He served faithfully then and he served well.
But even then, in a fond memory, he could not be totally honest and still be totally clear in his duty. For he was not Ohtar then but Telumehtar, just as he is not Collum now but Ohtar once again. There were always masks to cover his purpose. Then, and now, he served not the king of Gondor but a Princess of Arnor. His allegiance, like that of all his fathers before him, was to the true line of Elendil.
He had seen her only twice in all his years, but he had served her will all of his lifetime. He had known for long, even as he did when he had followed that great Commander in Gondor, or as he stood here before these new friends that would go to war in the North, that he was hers. He could never go to war again, never decide his own path, whilst he served the Princess of Arnor.
And as he drank the cordial with the others, as he felt the familiarity of the ground beneath him and smelled the memories of his past travels, it was the face of his Princess which the drink brought foremost to his mind. He shut his eyes to hold the memory longer.
Oisín Na-Glirhuin knew nothing of this custom or of drinking. The beverages of the Minhiriathrim were limited to fresh waters and animal milks found in the wild. They were nomadic hunters, so they raised no herds and made no wells. Some, and these were some whom Oisín seldom spoke with, made potions for healing and for fortune and sometimes, or so he had heard, these were to be drunk in some level of ceremony as he was seeing his new friends inact here. Perhaps. He had never been part of that sort of ceremony or spoken much with those who had followed these old ways.
But he had watched carefully and understood fully the solemnity the Soldier used in pouring out the liquid. He saw the frank faces of those other friends around him and set his own just so, so as not to seem ignorant or disrespectful in the ceremony. But in his own heart, he knew only that he did not know anything about what was going on.
But even in ignorance, his eyes were sharp. This was not spring water poured into these vessels and it was also not the murky slop that he had heard was given by the Wisewomen amongst the Minhiriath. The light of the risen sun behind him hit the arc of the liquid as it rolled slowly out through the skin that the Soldier held aloft so carefully, dealing it out so preciously. And the light which came off of it seemed bright and precious. He had not seen gold or gems or any of these precious things, but in the stories he knew they all glimmered as this drink did.
Was this another custom of his family, a thing which the Soldier knew but that his fathers living in the open lands had forgotten? Was this something that he might learn? He felt the weight, the seriousness it brought to the others and could not wait to understand more.
And then the smell of something new hit him and he was lost.
His feet were here. No one raised as he had been would ever forget where their feet were. He could still feel the strength of the tall birches behind him and, with their help, his feet were still here. He remembered the remnants of dew on the grass which he saw earlier that morning, remembered the last stars of day as they awaited the coming Sun and heard again the birdsong when he left the underground some few hours before, remembered the dew on the grass. But smelling and seeing this potion (if that is what it was) roll cleanly into the cups and then, putting one under his nose, took him elsewhere.
It seemed in that moment that innumerable birds chattered in the eaves: and some sang upon the treetops, while doves and pigeons circled in flights about his eyes' borders or swooped to settle and sun themselves upon the sward. All day long, for surely he spent many days in this vision, there went a hum of bees among the flowers: bees that fared about the roof of where he stood in dreamtime and along all the scented beds of the leafy mound before his house.17
His house? No, he had no such forest house. That was for the Minhiriathrim. They had saved his People, something his line had been grateful for for many generations, but the fate of the Minhiriathrim was not the same as the Unnonóreans'.
He pushed this idea from his mind, felt again the place where he now stood and then the Soldier raised the cup in his own hand. All raised their vessels and the Soldier cried, ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ and, putting the cup to his lips, Oisin was lost again.
He remembered now a great battle of which he had been told many times, but now with a clarity of detail that he had never before imagined.
‘Utúlie’n aurë! Aiya Eldalië ar Atanatári, utúlie’n aurë!’ he heard called then in the black and desolate North under skies clouded with ash. He stood then with his own fire-blackened axe and grey woolen cloak over leather armour while around him the light of the drawing of the swords of the Noldor was like a fire in a field of reeds and all the hearts of the many armies assembled were kindled.
But on that day fate was the more strong...
The day grew darker, and countless tears were shed as all the host of the Iron Prison swarmed against them. They fought their way back to the shadow of Ered Wethrin and all the valiant Men of that day about them were slain, the Orcs hewing their heads and piling them as a mound in the gold of sunset. He heard his captain’s call then, full in some memory’s ear, and his heart was again kindled.
And there in the place near the birches, just as he saw it in memory or imagination, he cried after his captain saying, ‘Aurë entuluva! Day shall come again!’18
‘Day shall come again!’ His new friends responded vigorously, and all hearts were kindled by this.
Just three nights past Alatar and Pallando had partaken of the Cordial of Imladris. That had not been their first time, and looking at one another now over upraised glasses, they wondered at this strange situation.
If the drought worked on them as it did upon the other, bringing comfortable memories and important moments, we shall never know. They drank quietly with the others and stared long at one another across the crude clay vessels. For they were about to parted from one another for the first time since the very making of the world.
End of Book One
Chapter End Notes
Notes on Chapter Ten
1) This is an almost direct quote from Bradbury’s Something Wicked This Way Comes, another favorite book of my boyhood. In Chapter 31 of Part Two, this one line, as the entire chapter, was something that taught me much about important pauses in fiction.
2) This, of course, is meant to echo Chapter Nine of The Return of the King. But also, in an introductory book of a bigger story, every writer is aware of how much expository speech is going on. There’s been some action, but mostly a lot of drinking, toasting, and discussing future plans. But between these seven individuals, this is truly their last debate.
3) Haleth, an unforgettable character from the First Age of Middle-earth, has something to do with Beothalion’s people. I’ll get to that. Promise.
4) Hothron is the Sindarin word for “captain,” and in using it, Oisín has elevated Ohtar a bit since the battle with the rats.
5) These writings that Alatar is describing are phrases in the Westron language but written in the Tengwar form as it was used in Númenor. The idea, as Ohtar discusses, is that this secret place also served as a kind of schoolroom for the few people of Arnor who knew of it.
6) Umm, Saruman, of course. What other wizard would know the language of the Fallen People?
7) “Good luck, captain. It is necessary that I go. I am sad/sorry. Until the time of our next meeting may the Sun shine upon your road.” -Sindarin
8) This part is largely a paraphrase from The Silmarillion. I wanted to place a reminder here of how different dwarves are, but from the perspective of a wizard. Old school language was therefore required.
9) This comes from two Sindarin words; “Rocco” -“meaning horse”, and “cindinn” - meaning “little one”. Frankly, Rosie is named after Rosinante, Don Quixote’s horse, and this construction is the closest I can come to that in my poor understanding of Sindarin. Ben is very likely mispronouncing the Elvish, of course.
10) A very obvious echo of Sam’s “What a tale we have been in, Mr. Frodo, haven’t we?” from Two Towers.
11) Oh, it is indeed a work of old hands. Most of the description here is appropriated from Aragorn’s description of the reforged Narsil and Merry’s Barrow-blade. Spoiler.
12) This is a rather peculiar drinking custom I’ve seen here in Philadelphia that I don’t remember from my younger days in Detroit. I’ve asked a few folks in bars just where it comes from and none seem to be certain. General consensus is that it has something to do with people who are no longer there. If so, it strikes me as a quaint and appropriate feeling for this moment.
13) This is another reference from my other passion, Joyce’s ULYSSES, found in the “Ithaca” episode.
14) Go find this one. You know it’s just at the edge of your memory. Anything else would be a pure spoiler.
15) These passages are, of course, some of the early descriptions of Ithilien where “the Battle of the Camps” was fought in 1944 of the Third Age. I’ve also layered in a description of the armor of Rangers of Ithilien because I felt it interesting that this major victory was also a sneak attack. Frankly, I would have put more of this in; this is one of my favorite chapters in the book specifically for its description of the land and how it revives the weary hobbits. But the story needs to move forward.
16) Eärnil became king of Gondor and currently reigns as such when this story is set, though those of the North dispute his claim. Ohtar’s memory capitalizes the title “Commander” here out of respect, but does not do so in regard to his predecessor , Ondoher, who he calls “a king”.
17) No, the house is not his. This layered quote is from The Cottage of Lost Play and many of Oisín’s deeper ideas, like Jungian archetypes, are housed in the primordial versions of Tolkien’s legendarium.
18) This bit of flashback is from The Silmarillion, of course, and I should probably take a moment to explain its connection here. I don’t intend these to be Shirley McLain-style past-life experiences unveiled through Mirovur. That’s schlocky and kind of too RPG skill-role related for my tastes. And it may well seem to experienced Tolkien readers that this goes a little beyond the results of Mirovur as a “kindling of spirits,” as we saw in Fellowship. That’s probably true. But what I wanted here was an agent for unlocking the kind of cosmological visions Frodo had in Bombadil’s house. My hope is that it will provide the right kind of enjoyment for fans who have the same attachment to those other books as I do and to show and still contain some wonderment for new readers who’ve not gone far past LoTR in their exploration of Middle-earth.