Comments on Silmarillion Non-Con November 2026

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


DAMNN that was hot. 

Melkor trapping Mairon in an abusive and controlling situation by isolating him with false promises and then switching off was so good and in character!! This kind of situation was accurately realistic and I did feel sorry for Mairon!

Poor Maia, flew into a cage ❤️‍🩹

Not Sauron giving free endometriosis treatments more easily than modern doctors do 😭🙏🙏

Let's not say he has no heart. ❤️ 

Sublime work!!! I found the whole non-con body modification so interesting!! 

Very glad you liked that one! I had the idea and I just thought it would be so funny for him to do! I mean it's not a perfect treatment, she'll probably be forced to breed with his wolves after due to the exact nature of the transplant, but oh well! XD 

If you liked that then I know I have at least one other non-con body modification fic planned for this month! 

Thank you for these chapters, oh god you have no idea how these oneshots are keeping my mental sanity during this AO3 shutdown 🥹🙏🙏🙏

Also, both the Sauron/Maedhros and this Celegorm/Finrod... Damn they were hot

Oh god I needine a whole book about this OKAY!!

It was so hot (as always LOL, but I guess it was even HOTTER okay), especially the fact that Fëanor was drugged out of his mind and so he couldn't resist to Manwë's cuddling.

Also Manwe not being angry with him?? And that he's keeping him as he was a pet and giving him "pleasure for his own good" despite Fëanor not wanting all of this. Oh dear I'm so weak for that.

I wonder why/when did the Valar realize that he was "a gift"/special ugugdgdhsus need more about this

(Grinning like crazy reading such a nice comment, WOW)

I decided to add the drugs in halfway because it's Fëanor, right? That's surely the only way to get him to behave! XD

Of course Manwë would never be mad at him! He's so forgiving and of course the poor animal didn't know what it was doing, the whole thing was his fault really for not keeping an eye on him, at least that's what Manwë thinks! Ha!

Honestly Finwë probably kept telling people about it and how grateful he was, then eventually the Valar heard and took him. I'll be uploading these as seperate fics to AO3 when it's back and I'll probably continue quite a few when I feel like it, this being one of them! Thanks for reading and commenting again!!

DAMNNNNN that was so good and juicy.

The world building and the dynamic of this modern au are so interesting, and even the way you fit Silm events in a modern setting is genius!!

I low-key wish to read more of it, Mairon influencer got a certain charisma and I can see him doing vlogs with his new pet 🥹🥹

Also I wonder if Fëanor would do something to get his son back – or even better, if Fingon would do something to rescue him 👁️👁️

Tysm for reading and commenting! I'm so glad you liked the way I merged the two worlds, it's my first time trying to write a modern AU and I normally don't even like them.

Definitely more vlogs from mairn incoming! He was so fun to write. I actually had to go and watch a bunch of the most sickening unboxing videos I could find to write him properly, lmao! I was laughing at myself the whole time. 

As for a rescue and family reactions, well there's more planned with a certain singer at the heart! You're in luck for reading more because tomorrow's prompt is set in the same AU as a continuation, so look out for that! I'm having so much fun and this is looking like it could get quite long. <3

I hate how accurate influencer Mairon is LOL, it's truly his dream job in another life 

I'm loving the idea behind the elven pets in a box, I feel you could make this into it's own longfic and really build up an interesting world here, there's enough detail here to where I'm intrigued about the world outside of Mairon itself 

Thank you! He really is insufferable in the most hilarious way! XD 

I will likely be writing spin off fics within the same universe but with different characters, it's a world I really like. I can't take credit for most of the premise though since the "elves in a box" comes from the joint box boy universe fics on Tumblr. It's a shared AU where the corporation does exactly this and deals in a modern version of glorifed slavery. I've loved the fics for ages and most of them are OC stories set in the same world. 

Do you have any particular characters you'd like to see more of? 👀

What can I say other than how much I'm loving this au so far.

Maglor GO DIVA DON'T EVER SHUT UP ABOUT WHAT THEY DID TO YOUR BROTHER!! I love how much he's fighting to keep the attention on his brother's kidnapping, despite hurting his own carrier but who cares when your brother is being trafficked 😭 

The compulsive watching was so on point too!!

Maedhros gaining back a bit of consciousness is so juicy and how much distressed he was about the idea of taking a decision!! Okay you know I'm so sold out of this au and I normally don't like modern aus, I hope you'll continue it some way or another!!