Recipes from Middle-earth by Harp_of_Gold  

| | |

Old Mrs. Butterbur's Chicken and Dumplings


Barliman Butterbur's mother is almost certainly not the first to serve up this soup in The Prancing Pony all throughout the winter, but she is the one remembered for it whenever it's made. A warming, filling meal to eat by a roaring fire on a cold night with good company and a few pints.

This is an old Appalachian recipe passed down through my family for several generations. Chicken thighs with the bone and skin work best, but any cut of chicken can be used. You can even use canned chicken for a quick, low effort meal. Also a great way to use up leftover holiday turkey or rotisserie chicken.

Ingredients:

3-4 bone-in, skin-on chicken thighs (or other chicken or turkey, about 1 lb)

1/2 yellow onion

water

salt

dried sage

for dumplings:

2 c all purpose flour (250 g)

2 tsp baking powder

1 tsp salt

pinch of sage 

1/4 c margarine or butter (2 oz/57 g)

3/4+ c buttermilk or milk with a splash of lemon juice (175+ ml)

Fill soup pot with enough water to cover chicken pieces. Simmer chicken until cooked through. If you don't have chicken with bones, add some bouillon or chicken stock.

While chicken is cooking, chop an onion and saute it in a little oil until translucent and starting to brown. Add to soup. (You can also add it uncooked at the start, but this adds flavor.)

Remove cooked chicken, pull from bones and shred, then return to pot. Add water if needed. Add salt to taste and a pinch of sage.

Make dumplings: Combine dry ingredients. Cut in butter until crumbs are pea-sized. Stir ín milk just until dough comes together. You may need a little more or less depending on your weather and humidity. The dough should be roughly the consistency of biscuit or scone dough, and just a tiny bit wetter.

Bring soup to a slow boil. Drop dough by the large spoonful into soup. 

Let cook for 10-12 minutes. Dumplings will puff and set. Grind fresh pepper on top to serve.


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment