The Sting of Salt and Pity by annarobots  

| | |

Fanwork Notes

This story was originally posted on AO3 on 22 May, 2026.

AO3 Tags: Ghost Stories, MerMay, First Age of Arda (Tolkien), Losgar, Nevrast (Tolkien), The Sindar (Tolkien), Legends, Folklore, Horror, Water Spirit, Bad Moms of Arda, Harm to Children, Additional Warnings In Author's Note

This is a ghost story. It contains material that may be upsetting in more than one respect.  I haven't found out how to put notes in a details-cut tag on SWG yet, but I will put detailed content notes in the Chapter End Notes of the story if you'd like to check before reading.

Fanwork Information

Summary:

I have never seen a foam-fay.  I have never known anybody who was taken by a spirit of the sea.  But the Sea itself is perilous.  And there are foul things that walk abroad, in the empty places of the enemy North.

To say nothing of the monsters that might live in one’s own home.

There is a man walking all alone along the beaches of Losgar.

Major Characters: Original Female Character(s)

Major Relationships:

Genre: Folktales/Myths/Legends, Horror

Challenges:

Rating: Adult

Warnings: Character Death, Check Notes for Warnings, Child Abuse, Mature Themes

Chapters: 1 Word Count: 1, 120
Posted on Updated on

This fanwork is complete.

The Sting of Salt and Pity

Read The Sting of Salt and Pity

“Mother!  I saw a stranger on the beach, walking in the water. His hair was red as the dawn.  I think he is a water-spirit.  A foam-fay!” 

My daughter has never known a day without a sunrise.  She was born after the flame-eyed Elves came from across the sea and drove the enemy to hide behind his gates.  She dreams in fairy-stories: beware the foam-fays, the water-spirits who take the shape of lost loved ones.  They will lure you to the water, they will lure you with fair songs.  They will enchant you, just like the fairy-queen enchanted Elu Thingol within the starlit wood.  Beware!  If you go too far, they will drag you under, laughing. 

I tell her these tales as warning, so that she might fear the many dangers of the world.  She has not learned her lesson.

“Did you speak to him? Tell the truth.” 

“No,” she lies.

I wait.

“Well.  I called to him, but he did not answer, or if he did, I did not hear.  My voice echoed all about the waste between the hills and the sea.”

The waste—

The crack of my wooden spoon on the backs of her hands is sharper than a knife.  “You cannot go so far.  Not alone!” 

“I did not go in the water! I am careful.  I am no child.”

My child has lived too long in peace. 

“There are worse things than water-spirits.  Real dangers. Evil, rotting things that stink and go cloaked in shadow.  You must not go so far.  If you see the skeletons of the swan-ships that burned, you must turn back.” 

I have never seen a foam-fay.  I have never known anyone taken by a spirit of the sea.  But the Sea itself is perilous.  And the monsters walk abroad in the empty places of the enemy North.

To say nothing of the monsters that might dwell in one’s home.

“He was not evil,” she argues.  “He did not stink.  He wore no cloak of shadow.  And no creature of the enemy can abide the water.”

“What kind of beast are you, to question your mother?  If he is not of the enemy, then he is a Noldo and a man, and thus not to be trusted.”

“No one should walk so long alone and friendless.  I wonder—”

“Enough!  Go and cut a switch.”

She pouts, but she minds. “As you wish.”

After she returns, switch in hand, it’s a firmer scolding, then straight to bed, no dinner but the heel of the day’s bread.

But it is strange—after night falls, when all is quiet but the waves against the cliffs, I lie awake, restless, my heart stinging with pity. 

Pity for the red-haired man who walks the beaches of Losgar alone.

My daughter, wrapped in woolen blankets, sleeps the heavy sleep of children.  At night, her fine hair lies loose and rippling, a half-shroud over her face.  Her tears have dried.  She looks sweet, in sleep.  I touch her soft cheek.  She does not stir when I rise and move about the cottage.  I take the cloak that was my father’s before he fell upon my knife when I saw him look at my daughter with the same vulgar stare that penetrated me. I take bread and cheese in a basket. I leave my daughter sleeping.

I carry a torch, though I need it not.  I am nearly as old as the stars, and long have I made my way by their light.  I can reach the firth and return home before the sun rises.  If nothing causes me delay. 

I hope the man is well. I do not want him to be cold.  No one should walk alone so long.

I take no weapon.  If an enemy comes near enough to strike with spear or sword, I must already be dead, for I am faster than any enemy that walks.  I go along the strand at the feet of the sea-hewn cliffs, careful of the black gleaming rocks, my left hand at the ever-changing sea.  I am no mariner.  I have never heard the conches; no longing for distant shores has ever gripped me by the throat.  The sea is only the sea: crashing waves, salt-spray, the smell of fish. 

As I come to the firth, great storm clouds blow in fast on a westerly wind.  They cloak the stars in shadow.  Thunder rumbles.  Now I go faster. 

A flash of many-branched lightning rends the heavens.

And then I see him. 

He would be tall for a man of my people, but perhaps he is not so tall for a Noldo.  His hair is lighter than burnished copper and red as the dawn.  He wades in the icy waters at the place where they came ashore, the Elves from across the sea.  He wanders among the burned ships.

I light my torch, for now I wish to be seen. 

Now I hail him.  I call friendly greetings in the tongue of his people.  The wailing wind swallows my words whole.  He does not hear.  He walks on. Another flash of lightning illuminates the side of his pale face, twisted in a misery that pierces my heart.

I will go to him.  I wade into the water, my feet splashing in the foam.  The wind drops, again I call out.  My voice echoes against the hills and returns, strange and terrible.  I think he hears.  He slows.

Now I wade farther into the shadowy waters, where the rocks grow treacherous beneath my feet.  The water splashes my thighs.  I am careless.  I slip.  Righting myself, I drop my torch.  The light goes out.

He stops.  He turns. 

I call out once more. The rain begins to fall.

Now I see his whole face. One side is terrible, a ruined hollow of naked bone where should be skin, and the other, fair and unmarred yet anguished. 

One lightless eye stares.

And then, from beneath the waves, something grabs me with the fingers of death. 

Oh, but my daughter, my daughter!  She sleeps in her bed. 

I kick, I fight, spitting salt, but the snaking arms are too many, and they slice at my skin, and the sea is too strong.  And though I cry for help, and my cries echo like the screams of Morgoth that shook the mountains, there is no one to hear.  The only soul to witness is the stranger, his red hair the last thing my living eyes see before the black water closes overhead and I am lost, lost to the great and greedy sea.


Chapter End Notes

Here are the detailed content warnings: This story contains physical punishment of a child that will likely be perceived as abusive by the modern reader. The adult narrator is implied to have experienced incestuous sexual abuse in her past, perpetrated by her father. Neither type of abuse is eroticized or excused by the narrative. The narrator leaves her child alone to investigate a ghost and, at the end of the story, she is killed, thereby orphaning the child.


Leave a Comment