the cleaving by TheChasm  

| | |

Fanwork Notes

Written for Maedhros & Maglor Week 2024.

Fanwork Information

Summary:

Newly re-embodied, Maedhros stumbles through the business of living, until the news arrives that Maglor has sailed West.

Major Characters: Maedhros, Maglor

Major Relationships: Maedhros & Maglor

Genre: Drama, Family, General

Challenges:

Rating: General

Warnings:

Chapters: 1 Word Count: 7, 779
Posted on Updated on

This fanwork is complete.

Chapter One

Read Chapter One

It had taken some time for the very slightest of sensations to stop feeling like an assault upon Maedhros’ new-formed body. The sunlight – so much brighter here than it had ever been in Beleriand! – had nearly blinded him, first stepping out of the Halls of Mandos and into this strange second life. The very purity of the air stung his lungs, he whose last remembered inhalation was the smoke of his own incineration; his mother’s embrace was as sandpaper on his baby-soft skin.

He understood that such extreme discomfort was uncommon, if not unheard-of; most of the re-embodied adjusted physically within a few days, but Maedhros, dazed and disoriented, had dwelt in his mother’s house on the outskirts of Tirion for a full two weeks before he could master himself enough to hold a conversation without wincing, at the scrape of his voice in his throat and the clamour of sound in his ears. It had been many thousands of years since, despairing, he had cast himself into the flames – there was a great deal that must be explained to him about the current state of the world. Yet there was one point he kept returning to, insistent: “Where is Káno?”

They explained it to him very gently, first his mother and those of his younger brothers who were returned, and then Finrod his cousin, who had come to see him: Maglor was lost. They did not know where he was. He had never returned to Aman from Middle-earth; in fact Maedhros himself might be the last person ever to have laid eyes upon him.

Maedhros could not understand it, or could not believe it, perhaps. How could Maglor not be there, by his side? He had always been there. He had followed Maedhros, all the way to the bitter end, unquestioningly faithful – he must be there. They were merely mistaken, they had not searched hard enough, they had not questioned the Maiar of Mandos with sufficient vigour: Maglor was close by, he must be. Although Maedhros’ final memories were hazy he knew that Maglor, too, had held one of their father’s Silmarils in his hand, had understood that all they had done to gain the jewels had been in vain; and so he would emerge from Mandos soon, surely. Maedhros could wait for him. He had done so the first time they were born, after all.

In the meantime there was all the work of learning how to live to preoccupy him. Maedhros was not unaccustomed to being plucked unsuspecting from an ancient gaol, and thrust abruptly into a world he had forsaken. He bore with what patience he could muster all the tedium of choking down his meals, and going for short walks to strengthen his shaky colt-like legs, and remembering how to hold a civil conversation. It should not be so hard here, in the bliss of unsullied Aman, as it had been at Mithrim. But too often Maedhros found himself turning restlessly to his right and finding only empty space beside him, or leaving awkward gaps in conversations that were never gracefully filled, or lying awake late into the night waiting for some soothing tune to lull him to sleep.

He did think Maglor could stand to hurry a little. But his mother looked at him very sadly, when he dared express this.

“He is not coming, Nelyo,” Caranthir said later, more bluntly, cornering him in the library where he was attempting to catch up with thousands of years’ worth of history. “He is lost. Is that so hard to understand?”

Maedhros only blinked at him, then; but he found himself growing more frustrated over the days that followed, at the slow pace of his own recovery (for should return to life truly feel so much like a sickness?), and at the furtive pitying looks of his mother and brothers, and most of all at Maglor’s inexplicable absence.

“Where is Káno?” he would ask, again and again, each time receiving an answer that did not satisfy – until, one afternoon, perhaps a month after his return to life, Finrod had showed up all flustered at the door, and announced that the High King his father had received word from the Valar: Maglor had sailed West, and would land at Tol Eressëa the next day.

Maedhros was not sure he believed that, either, after all the half-truths. But he joined the delegation to the isle’s eastern shore anyway, and was watching when a makeshift little boat was sighted at last on the horizon. Maglor was there at its helm, guiding it; Maedhros knew it long before his brother was close enough to see. He would know Maglor anywhere.

There was a tall Elf-lord standing near them, with star-bright grey eyes and long glossy dark hair. Maedhros did not recognise him at first, but then he heard his mother address the stranger as Elrond, and say, in a hushed voice, “Do you think he will—” But then she noticed that Maedhros was listening, and stopped talking abruptly.

Maedhros walked away from them, unwilling to hear any doubtful speculation on whether Maglor was coming. It was the first thing he had felt certain of, in this bewildering second life: he would see his brother soon. He knew it in his new-made bones. And in his eagerness he found that he was standing at the very edge of the beach, the water lapping at his feet, by the time the boat docked at last in the harbour, and Maglor caught sight of the watchers on the beach.

The boat’s first occupant, another of the strange little creatures that Finrod spoke of so enthusiastically, leapt out onto the shore with a delighted cry, but Maglor stood frozen for a moment.

He looks so old, was Maedhros’ first coherent thought. Indeed there was something not entirely fleshly about Maglor, as though that bright spirit had worn away some of its outer casing over the long millennia. But his eyes – his eyes were very familiar, wide and dark and utterly focused on Maedhros.

“Oh,” he breathed. The next moment he was in Maedhros’ arms, the clean salt scent of his hair filling Maedhros’ nostrils, the sound of his breathing – tuneful, yet – rasping in Maedhros’ ears. It did not hurt, where every other sensation had been a torment. Maedhros only thought to be surprised by that later: of course Maglor’s touch could never hurt him. 

They did not say much to each other, that first day. There were others who wanted to touch Maglor, as though making sure he was more solid than he appeared: their mother, whose eyes were so very bright she might have been weeping, and Elrond, and their brothers too. The hobbit (for so that race was named) he had sailed with wished to introduce him to the two who already dwelt on the isle, and then once they had sailed back to the mainland Finarfin the King came himself to speak quietly and seriously with Maglor for a while. He looked rather overwhelmed, once it all was done.

So Maedhros did not speak to him, at first. He was assailed now by new memories, pushed aside perhaps until he was strong enough to cope with them – blood dripping from Maglor’s hand where it clutched the Silmaril. His face, drained of colour as he stared at Maedhros. The harsh awful scrape of his scream as Maedhros had stepped backwards into the chasm—

What had he done? What had he done?

Mandos had been good for Maedhros, although he only remembered it in fits and bursts. His fëa, so long unmoored, yet sat more comfortably in this remade form than it had in the one he had destroyed. He had been released, he understood, with the knowledge that if the Valar had forgiven his sins at last that did not mean that all the rest of the world was ready to do likewise, and that it was his now to make some measure of atonement for the destruction he had wrought. Once he had recovered sufficiently, Finrod had explained to him, his cousin would accompany him on a pilgrimage to Alqualondë, where he might start by making formal apologies to Olwë the King for the first of his slaughters, and pledging to make some form of reparations.

All this was very well, and Maedhros more than willing to try at it – but it was not, he realised now, where he must start.

“Káno,” he said, when Maglor appeared at breakfast the next morning, “wilt thou walk with me?”

Maglor looked at him a long moment before answering. He was dressed, Maedhros noticed, in the same ragged tunic and braies that he had been wearing when he landed, although there were any number of fine soft clothes packed into the chests of this house. Maedhros had heard murmurs from his brothers that Míriel the Broideress, who had been dead long before his own birth, now lived again, although he knew not whether to credit them; but whoever had woven these clothes, they were both lovely and comfortable, their touch very nearly bearable even against his sensitive skin. For a moment he wondered that Maglor had cast them aside – but then, Maglor’s return to the lands of his birth had been very different to Maedhros’ own. It seemed to Maedhros suddenly as though the gulf of years between them was a physical thing, a sea stretching wider than the very ocean Maglor had sailed; and of course Maglor would refuse him. He must refuse him, after what Maedhros had done. 

“Yes,” he said eventually, his eyes unreadable.

But it was easier when they were out of their mother’s house, and away from the weight of so many eyes upon them; then Maglor came without being called to Maedhros’ side, and tucked his left arm through Maedhros’ right, pressing against him as they walked. How strange that they should still fit together just so, although this raw unused body of Maedhros’ had only ever held his brother once.

Neither of them was willing to go to Alqualondë just yet; but Maglor, Maedhros thought, was restless without the Sea in sight. Maedhros had noticed the tension in his shoulders increase, the previous day, as they had come inland, and the steady rhythm of the waves had been replaced by the bustle of Tirion, and the ocean breeze had grown fainter and fainter. So he guided their steps through the Calacirya and then south along the cliffs of Eldamar, the salt spray stinging their faces as they went. Maedhros fancied there was something of Uinen’s wrath in it still, her small vengeance for the Teleri: but Maglor seemed not to mind it.

Maedhros kept meaning to start a conversation, and yet the words would fail in his throat again and again. Should he say, I am glad beyond words to see thee again, or Tell me what became of thee, these thousands of years, or simply Forgive me, forgive me? How could any of them be enough?

In the end the first thing he said was, simply, “Káno, I am tired – might we rest a while?”

“Oh!” said Maglor, who had been gazing out at the Sea, seemingly lost in thought. “Of course – I am sorry I did not think of it sooner. Thou hast not had this body very long, after all.”

The sound of his Quenya had changed over the long millennia, more liquid in its phrasing, the stresses subtly different – Maedhros thought he detected, in the slopes and valleys of his brother’s voice, the echoes of countries he would never see and people who had been dead so long only the Sea now remembered them. It made him shiver. But Maglor’s tone was yet familiar, the gentle scolding tone he had used whenever Maedhros would push himself too far. An odd sound, in these bright and peaceful lands.

Wordlessly, he sat down on the grass. Maglor settled beside him, and looked at him, less abstracted now, as though drinking in the sight of him. Then he would touch Maedhros’ cheek and jaw, and marvel at the even line of his shoulders – Maedhros realised with a jolt that the old deformity had not pained him once since his return – and most of all at the shapely right hand resting in Maedhros’ lap.

“All new-made,” said Maedhros, with a little grimace.

He had not liked his scars, in Middle-earth. Still they had been a part of him. And the missing hand had always been the easiest maiming of them all to bear, the mark that had proclaimed Fingon’s love for him. Fitting, he supposed, that it was gone now. He had been told that Fingon was returned to life, and dwelled in Tirion now; but he had not come to see Maedhros, and Maedhros was not sure he had yet the courage to go to him.

Maglor was easier. Maglor had seen him at his worst, and not forsaken him.

“I never dreamed of thee so,” he murmured now. “As if none of it had ever happened.”

Something hard and aching rose in Maedhros’ throat. “And didst thou dream of me, Káno?”

“Should I have not?” Maglor returned. He was staring still at Maedhros’ hand. “Should I have cast thee away, excised thee from my memory – said, I had no elder brother, he was not real, I do not think of him— would that have pleased thee?”

“Káno,” Maedhros breathed. Here, now, was what he had been dreading. What could he say? How could he fix this? “Dearest.”

“Do not call me that,” Maglor said. He looked away from Maedhros, out to the Sea. “Your deeds showed plainly enough that it was not true.”

Maedhros could not deny that.

“And yet now thou livest!” said Maglor. He looked at Maedhros again, and there was wonder in his eyes. “I never thought of it. Did not we swear ourselves to the Everlasting Darkness? But thou walk’st now in the Sun. How can it be?” He shivered, and wrapped his arms around himself.

How many times had he held himself so forlornly? Had it not been the chief of Maedhros’ duties, one he had learned as a toddling child, to soothe Maglor when he was distressed, and wipe away his tears, and hold him until the world seemed a little warmer? He had forgotten it, in the years before his death. Maglor’s weeping had not moved him to any elder-brotherly instinct to comfort. Maglor’s unhappy impassioned words had only ever provoked in him exasperation. Maedhros felt again that vague nausea at the twisted thing he had become, and leaned forward to draw his brother into his arms.

Maglor stiffened, for a moment, and then slumped into his embrace, leaning his weight against Maedhros’ chest. He was very thin. Maedhros had not noticed it before.

“They said it was forgiven,” he said, into Maglor’s hair. “Or perhaps that our Oath never bound us to any darkness beyond death in the first place. It was not for mere Eldar to cast themselves beyond the circles of the world for evermore, Mandos thought.”

He remembered little now of his interview with the Vala before he had been cast out blinking into the sunlight; yet he had the distinct impression that he had been upbraided for his arrogance.

“What was it like?” Maglor asked, his voice a little muffled by Maedhros’ tunic. “In the Halls?”

Maedhros thought for a while. “Lonely,” he said, eventually. But that had been the wrong thing to say, for Maglor tensed in his arms, and he hastened to add, “I did not mind it so much, I think. It is hard to remember now.”

Maglor pulled back enough to look at him again, his eyes scanning Maedhros’ face very carefully. “Thou look’st – well,” he said softly. “Much better than—”

What had Maglor read on Maedhros’ face, in the instants before he had jumped? With what final memory had Maedhros left his brother? He had not thought of such things, then, bent as he had been on his own destruction. He had imagined, perhaps, that the world would end when he did; but it had gone on growing and breathing and changing without him, as though all the blows he had dealt it amounted to no more than a freckle on its cheek.

And here was Maglor whom he had abandoned in his arms. With that he could not bring himself to be ungrateful.

“I am glad,” Maglor seemed to decide. He wrapped his arms around Maedhros, and clung to him in silence for a while.

Maedhros sat very still, and let himself be held. Eventually Maglor seemed to want to examine him again, as though he could not yet fix in his mind the fact of Maedhros’ existence (for which Maedhros could not blame him, for it seemed horribly uncertain to him too). He clutched at Maedhros’ new hand with his left, and raised the right to Maedhros’ cheek.

The skin of his palm was horribly rough. Without thinking, Maedhros jerked back.

“Nelyo?” Maglor sounded uncertain, and afraid. It was the first time he had called Maedhros by that old affectionate name.

“Thy hand,” Maedhros said, his heart beating fast. “Let me see it.”

Maglor presented his right hand, and Maedhros’ stomach turned over. Had he managed to choke down more than two mouthfuls of food that morning he might have vomited; as it was he could manage only a choked exhalation of horror. His brother’s hand was a ruin, black and withered and claw-like. There were open sores on his palm that wept clear fluid, and his gentle nimble fingers resembled nothing so much as sticks of charcoal, liable to snap clean off at any moment.

“Thy hand is burned,” Maedhros said, numbly.

Maglor shrugged, and withdrew it. Maedhros noticed now that he had kept it tucked into his pocket for most of the morning, perhaps thinking to spare Maedhros the sight of it. “Thou knowest what marks the judgement of Varda leaves.”

“But mine is fine,” said Maedhros. Blood was roaring in his ears. He held his own left hand out for examination, the skin as new and unmarred as an infant’s. “Mine is fine. There is no mark. There is no mark.”

“Well, yes,” said Maglor. There was a curious look in his eyes as he took in the white softness of Maedhros’ palm. As a warrior in Beleriand Maedhros might have laughed to see a hand like this one, uncalloused and unscarred; he felt ashamed, now, holding it out before this time-worn battle-scarred brother. “You got to heal,” Maglor said. “I did not.”

Maedhros had not wept yet, in this second life, but he choked on a sob now. “Do not – but they should have healed it – we will go to Lórien, they must heal it—”

“They will not,” said Maglor. “Nor do I wish it.”

“How can I be healed and thou not?” Maedhros cried. “How can I be forgiven the evil I led thee into while thou are marked still? How—”

He realised he was shaking, and when he had raised his voice Maglor had stiffened. He had been used to solitude for all these endless years, a solitude to which Maedhros had abandoned him; Maedhros could not bear it. He jerked to his feet and turned back the way they had come, ready to stumble back to Tirion rather than sit here with the mark of his failings another minute.

“Shall you walk away from me again?” Maglor asked. His voice was very low, and yet it cut through the roaring of the wind and the crash of the waves and the pulse hammering frantically in Maedhros’ ears, in the manner of a bright silver fish passing effortlessly through rough waters.

The question stopped Maedhros in his tracks. He looked back to his brother.

Maglor was sitting just where Maedhros had left him. He had not stirred when Maedhros rose. Indeed there was something of resignation in his eyes as he looked at Maedhros, as though he had only been waiting for the illusion to shatter, and Maedhros to abandon him. 

“Káno,” Maedhros said, “Káno.” And he came to sit beside Maglor again, noticing as he did so that he was light-headed.

Hesitantly, Maglor leaned a little of his weight against Maedhros’ shoulder.

Maedhros took Maglor’s burned hand in his, as gently as he could. “Does it hurt?” he asked.

“Yes,” said Maglor, his voice matter-of-fact. “There is no herb or remedy that will soothe it.”

The pain, Maedhros remembered with a shudder, had been worse than blinding. It had not been only his flesh that the Silmaril had seared, but the very spirit within it. Laughable, to imagine that some carefully-prepared paste or healing lotion might dull the burn.

“How canst thou bear it?” he breathed. He swallowed, and then added, “I could not bear it.”

Maglor looked at him with those wide sad eyes and said nothing.

“Káno,” Maedhros said again. He wrapped his arm around his brother’s thin frame, a gesture of restraint as much as of affection. Foolish, for it was not Maglor who had been the flight risk, after all.

“Thou knewest that,” Maglor said quietly, catching the thread of his thought. Strange that their minds yet found each other so effortlessly, strange that Maglor could still know him so entirely, when to Maedhros his brother seemed so very incomprehensible. “Thou knewest I would never leave thee.”

Maedhros swallowed. “I knew it.”

“Thou wert wrong,” Maglor said, tracing the fingers of Maedhros’ right hand with his left as he spoke. “Wrong not to hearken to Eönwë. Wrong to make another attempt on the Silmarils, when our deeds had proven us unworthy of them many times over. Wrong not to listen to me – when I had given thee all my faith for uncounted years! Dost thou concede it?”

“I do,” Maedhros said, his breath coming in something close to a sob. He had known all this at the time. It was why he had jumped.

“I was wrong, too,” Maglor said. The brush of his fingers on Maedhros’ palm was so very gentle. “I should have tried harder to convince thee, should have refused to accompany thee on thy fool’s errand. I could not bring myself to do it, at the time – could not bear to defy thee.” Maedhros’ breath caught, but Maglor continued, unyielding. “How I rued my cowardice, later! Perhaps thou wouldst have lived, had I only the courage to refuse thee.”

“Káno,” said Maedhros. It was the only word that remained to him. Had his brother lived all these long millennia blaming himself for Maedhros’ death? Maedhros had not thought of that. He had thought—

“It was not true, though,” Maglor continued. “There was no version of the tale where thou couldst live. I always knew I would lose thee.”

Maedhros inhaled sharply. “I – thou—”

“Thinkest thou that I did not notice,” Maglor said, his voice very dreamy, “how often thine eyes strayed to the edges of clifftops, long before thine end? With what envy thou wouldst gaze upon every fallen soldier – how carelessly thou wouldst carry thyself into every little skirmish we found! Wert thou hoping to make an honourable end of it, Nelyo? Thou wert hoping, I think, that Eönwë would slay us both. That would perhaps have been kinder; but we were too far gone for that mercy.”

“I did not think thou hadst noticed,” Maedhros said, blinking back tears. “I thought—”

“But I knew thee, Nelyo,” Maglor said quietly. “I knew thee.”

Maedhros put his arms around him, and held him, and held him, and held him. Any moment now Maglor might tire of his touch, who had not been embraced these past millennia. He might put Maedhros’ arms from him – gently, for even now Maedhros could not conceive of a Maglor whose hands were ungentle – and turn away towards the south, and walk away along the seashore, singing, without looking back towards his brother. Maedhros would deserve it.

But Maglor stayed within his arms, breathing.

“I am very angry with thee,” he murmured. Maedhros’ thoughts yet bled too freely towards the surface of his mind, easy to glean. Or else it was just, as Maglor said, that his brother knew him. “How many cruel speeches I have made thee in my thought, how often have I cried out all my bitterness and resentment to the waves and wished I could speak them to thee in truth! But I never thought I would. I never thought of this.” He looked searchingly at Maedhros, his eyes wide. “Shalt thou vanish again? Can I bear to hold on to my wrath, knowing it is possible?”

“It is not,” Maedhros said softly. “I am here, Káno. I am here and I will not leave thee again.”

“But you did leave me,” Maglor said, his voice sharpening. “I knew it was coming, do not mistake me! I knew the drift of your thoughts in those last years. I knew I was not enough to hold you here. But why, Nelyo? After all your insistence that we must not surrender – why did you jump?” He swallowed, and added roughly, “How could you, after everything? Had I not sworn myself to you, in both word and deed, many times over? Did it not matter – did I not matter?”

His eyes were bright now with tears. Maedhros marvelled at it, that a grief as ancient as this one could still move Maglor to weeping. He had always been so: as a child sad stories and romantic ones alike would bring him to tears, and the slightest of criticisms had left him blinking furiously, striving to master himself. After Thangorodrim Maedhros had woken, and felt his face bathed in saltwater, and known his brother was beside him.

Maedhros had often made him cry, too, in the last years, with a sullen word or a sharp one. It had satisfied some ugly part of him to know he still held that power over Maglor, that Maglor cared yet for Maedhros’ good opinion. He had not wept at the end, when he had yielded to Maedhros’ command and agreed at last to go after the Silmarils. Maedhros could yet remember the hollowness in his stomach, seeing his brother’s dry cheeks and bright glittering eyes.

What had he become?

“Káno,” he said. “Káno, I was so ill.”

“I knew that,” Maglor said. He had pulled back from Maedhros’ embrace; still close enough to touch, and yet Maedhros felt again that the distance between them might span oceans. “But I was there! Did that not count for anything with you?”

“It did, Káno,” Maedhros said unhappily. He was better than he had been, he knew. The old choking weight of despair was lifted from his shoulders; but he had grown used to the burden, cherished it almost, and in its absence he felt unbalanced. And it was still not an easy thing, to speak of his last days. “Thou must not believe I did not think of thee.” But what right had he to command Maglor now? What good would it do, after his brother had mourned him for thousands of years? “All thy faith thou hadst given me – and all thy loyalty too – and what had I done with it? Poured it out like so much water on the ground, wasted it, wasted thee, shackled thee to myself and my madness – led thee unwilling to thy ruin! I realised it. Dost thou think I did not realise it? I saw the burn on thy hand before I noticed my own. How could I live with myself, knowing what I’d made of thee?” 

“And was this better?” Maglor demanded. “Did you find your penance in the flames, Nelyo? Did it gladden you, to have left me behind at last?”

Maedhros choked on a sob. “No – no. I thought – I thought—”

But too often with Maglor had he wielded his words to cruel effect. He would keep his silence now.

“Thought what,” said Maglor. He looked sharply at Maedhros. “Am I not owed even the courtesy of an answer, after all these years?”

Maedhros closed his eyes. “Thou wilt not love me anymore, should I say it. Thou wilt walk away from me – and I cannot bear that.”

Maglor laughed. Long ago, if asked what he thought the loveliest sound in the world, Maedhros would have named Maglor’s laugh without hesitation – a lilting golden sound it had been, putting one in mind of sunlight on the green grasses of Lothlann and the delighted bubbling of a mountain spring, sweeter yet than the supple power of his song. But this laugh was bitter, and Maedhros flinched to hear it.

“You will bear it, Nelyo,” Maglor said. “Trust me: it is bearable.”

Maedhros opened his eyes and fixed Maglor with an anguished look. “I do not want – to hurt thee.”

“Too late,” said Maglor, unmoved.

Maedhros shuddered and closed his eyes again. “I thought thou wouldst follow me,” he said, all in a rush. “Thou hadst sworn thyself to me – promised me that thou wouldst follow me into anything, after Thangorodrim – even at the last I bent thee to my will – and it burned so, Káno, there was no living after that – I thought thou wouldst follow after me, thou hadst always cleaved to me, I thought thou wouldst jump when I did – and I reached for thee in the darkness and thou wert not there—”

The emptiness of it! Maedhros did not wonder, now, that he had been unable to grapple with the memory on his return to life. He had never been strong enough to bear Maglor’s absence, never truly set himself to the task of living without Maglor. He would have to learn that, now. Maglor would not stay with him now, after what he had confessed – could not love him, knowing that Maedhros had wanted him to die. Perhaps he had already walked away.

Maedhros found the courage to open his eyes. Maglor was still sitting before him, and he was weeping silently as he looked at Maedhros; but despite his tears there was an odd ironic smile on his face. “You always had to be right,” he murmured.  “Was it not so? Right to go after the jewels – right to despair – right to jump. There was no living after that, you say! How could anyone live, knowing what his very inheritance had named him?” He lifted his blackened hand, pointedly. 

Maedhros shuddered. “Don’t.”

“I thought of it,” Maglor said softly. “Of following thee, that is. Not only then, but many times, over the years. My brother and my liege-lord, the living mark of my guilt! Thrice over was I sworn to thee. Every bond of duty and of love demanded that I follow. And yet – and yet.” He drew a breath. “I cast the Silmaril into the waves just as the Sun was setting. Her light on the water was red and gold and violet all at once. I was so absorbed in its colours that I forgot even to mark the path the gem had taken to the deeps; and it would have been so very easy to follow it in, but for the thought in my mind that I should like to see how the sunrise on the water would look, the next morning. And that morning, and every morning after, I found that the world was very beautiful: and I was not willing to depart from it just yet.”

Maedhros drew him close again, and kissed the top of his head. He thought Maglor must flinch away from his touch, but he stayed where he was, as Maedhros held him and inhaled the salt scent of his hair. How terribly unfamiliar he was, this ancient creature, with the unhealed burn on his hand and the unhealed grief in his bright eyes. He had lived the span of Maedhros’ own years many times over. Perhaps Maedhros was little but a phantom from the days of his youth, to him, a memory so long-evaporated that it had ceased to hold any relevance at all.

Maedhros realised now that he had always been frightened of that. He had needed Maglor to love him best, always, to follow him even unto the fires of destruction. He had clung to that unshakeable devotion as all the certainties of his life had crumbled; by the end of it all he had not known himself, any longer, but he had known yet that Maglor loved him.

“And I did,” Maglor breathed. “I would have cleaved to thee, Nelyo. I would have forgiven it all, hadst thou stayed.”

Maedhros swallowed painfully. “And now?”

Maglor said nothing; but he did not pull away, either.

“It would have been better had I sent thee away,” Maedhros said miserably, clutching at Maglor. “Thou might’st have gone to seek out the children – thou wouldst have been happier, with them.”

“I could not have done so,” said Maglor, “whilst thou hadst need of me.” He tilted his head to look up at Maedhros, his dark eyes unreadable. “And thou wouldst not have allowed it, even had I wanted it.”

Maedhros could not deny it. How choking had been his envy, in those brief years they had held the sons of Elwing hostage; how deeply he had resented those unhappy children, for the claim they had on Maglor’s attention, the space they had carved into Maglor’s heart. Maglor had been all Maedhros’ world, by then, the chief sweetness of his days and the only rock to cling to on his tormented nights – but in the presence of those Sinda princelings he began to doubt that the reverse was true, that Maglor yet loved him above anyone.

When the Host of the West had come to Beleriand, bearing the news that the Silmaril in the sky was carried by Eärendil the Mariner, he had seen his chance. Send them away, he had told Maglor, lest the Oath make of us a blade to turn against them – if thou hast any love for them at all, send them away before one of us hurts them. Maglor had protested at first, and then yielded as he always did; and once Elros and Elrond had left them he had wept in Maedhros’ arms for hours, and Maedhros had been viciously glad.

Perhaps Maglor would go to them now, as he had not then, when he forsook Maedhros. Elrond had been there on Tol Eressëa, Maedhros recalled; he had not seen Elros.

“He is dead,” said Maglor. “He chose the Gift of Men, and departed this world long ago.”

“Oh,” Maedhros said, and then, belatedly, “I am sorry.”

“It was peaceful, by all accounts,” said Maglor. “He did not age, even when he had lived many times the lifespan of most mortals; and at the last he lay down with his hands folded over his chest and went to sleep.” He paused, and then added, “I was glad he chose as he did, for he could never bear to be bound too tightly to any thing; but I grieved thee anew on his passing. It was very different to thine own.”

“Káno,” Maedhros said.

“Thou didst not choose an easy death, Nelyo,” Maglor said quietly. “I suppose for thee it was swift at least, if not painless. For me it did not end.”

“I know,” Maedhros said, and began to weep in earnest, dripping yet more saltwater into Maglor’s hair. “Káno, I am sorry, I am sorry! It is not enough – I know it cannot be enough. Oh, there is no use in any of it – how might I begin to atone for any of my evils, when I cannot even make right what I did to thee whom I loved best? Was there anyone in the world I did not hurt with my cruelty and my selfishness? I knew what I had become: but I was yet too blind to realise what I’d done to thee, what I’d made of thee! And even in seeking some penance for that last of my sins I hurt thee, as ever I did. I cannot bear it. I will die again, I will go to Lórien and lay down my body as Míriel our grandmother did: I am not fit to dwell here in this land of peace, I will only bring it to its ruin.”

“Nelyo. Nelyo!” said Maglor. He raised his burned hand to Maedhros’ cheek and brushed away the tears, his touch very tender on Maedhros’ soft new skin for all that his palm was charred. The incongruity of it was enough to shock Maedhros into silence.

“Thou art not listening,” Maglor said. “Thou still dost not quite understand it, dost thou? My poor tragic brother, who suffered so, and caused so much suffering in turn!” His voice was gentle, although the words stung. “Were thy cruelties truly so singular, thy pain so very unparalleled? Was there anyone in the world thou didst not hurt, thou sayest! Many, Nelyo, many. The world is older by far than thee, and remembers villainy much greater than thine. The Noldolantë is a very long lament! But it is not the most famous of those songs now sung in Middle-earth.”

“How canst thou say so?” Maedhros asked, still weeping. “It was unforgivable, what I did – what we did. The very Bay of Balar ran red with blood when we departed Sirion! Time cannot heal the hurt we dealt, nor make right our evil deeds.”

“But we can,” Maglor said softly. “We can, Nelyo.”

Maedhros was not sure he believed that, for all the convincing power of Maglor’s voice. In truth it seemed to him very unfair indeed that he had been returned so rudely to life with all its attendant agonies. He had not chosen this world. He had turned his face from it.

“We were not so very important, in the end,” Maglor mused. “How tormented we fancied ourselves at the time! Only a youthful error, I might say, were it not for the bloodshed we caused in our vanity and our selfishness. Oh, the waves we saw crashing over the land in Beleriand’s last days seemed so very catastrophic – but they were nothing compared to the one that drowned Númenor.”

“Númenor?” Maedhros asked, wiping at his eyes.

Maglor smiled at him. “Elros’ legacy,” he said, “a fair kingdom of Men. The glory of the Second Age, while it lasted; but it was drowned in the Changing of the World, and now only the memory of its memory lives on in the East. In Gondor now there are few, I should think, who know the name of Maedhros son of Fëanor.”

“But thou didst,” Maedhros said, because he needed it to be true. “Thou remembered’st me.”

Maglor shrugged, and looked away from him, pulling free of his embrace. “What else could I do?” he asked. “All my faith and loyalty I gave thee, and watched thee pour it away – but what is a vessel without water, its cracks exposed to the glare of the Sun? Tending thee was all my purpose. In those final days my first task on waking was to check that thou wert risen too, my last at night to sing thee as best as I could to sleep. And I was glad! I was glad that thou hadst need of me. I knew that thou couldst not cast me away, that thou wouldst not survive the cleaving.” His voice grew flat and measured. “Well, I suppose you did not. But I did.”

“Káno,” said Maedhros.

“Do you know what you took from me?” Maglor asked, still not meeting Maedhros’ gaze. “Not only yourself, but more than half myself too. Can you imagine it – the emptiness?”

Maedhros could not. Maglor was right: Maedhros could not have lived, had Maglor been parted from him. He had stumbled blind and dazed through even this peaceful second life, until the very moment he had held his brother in his arms. The thought of a longer separation was intolerable. How had Maglor borne it?

“I remembered thee better than I did myself,” Maglor said softly. “I did not know who I was, without thee to follow. I did not know how to be, without thee to love.” He looked at Maedhros again, and the tears running silently down Maedhros’ cheeks. “Now I have made thee cry. In the old days I never would have done so.”

“I am more tender now than I was then,” Maedhros said, through his tears, “and more sensible of the hurt I have dealt thee, too. Káno, I am sorry – for what little it is worth, I am sorry.”

A faint, distant smile curved Maglor’s lips. “More than a little, I should think,” he murmured.

Maedhros swallowed. “How didst thou do it?” he asked. “How didst thou keep on living?”

“It was hard, at first,” Maglor said frankly. “And piece by piece it grew a little easier. I am very old, Nelyo. It has been two Ages of the World since last I saw thee. But dying never seemed to me to be the less painless choice. Perhaps that was cowardice.”

“No,” Maedhros said hastily. “I do not think so. And I am – glad – that thou lived’st. Thou wert braver than I, my Káno.” But he could not call Maglor that any longer. 

“It is true,” Maglor said, catching his thought, “that I am not thy Káno any more, or at least not the one thou knewest.” He put his arms around Maedhros, and leaned his head against Maedhros’ shoulder. “But I am still thine.”

“I do not deserve that,” Maedhros said, still weeping; “I did not deserve thy devotion then, and still less now.”

“But thou hast it anyway,” Maglor murmured. “Perhaps it is not always about deserving, Nelyo.” He twined their right hands together, his burned and Maedhros’ own still so very raw. How easily Maedhros’ fingers tangled with his brother’s, as though they were always meant to fit so, although the shape of the very world was changed since they had last clasped each other’s hands in this manner and all the rest of Maedhros’ body seemed little more than a clumsy marionette to him.

It was a grace past imagining. It was mercy yet harder to bear than that of the Valar when they had cast him out onto the green grass outside the Halls of Mandos. Would it be honesty, to explain to Maglor how mistaken he was, how foolish it would be to love one who had proven himself so very unworthy of it? Maedhros was not sure he was equal to the task; he could not cleave from Maglor a second time. But he had promised to atone, now that he was living again.

“I led thee to thy ruin,” he said, into Maglor’s hair, “and then I left thee there.”

“I am not ruined, Nelyo,” Maglor breathed against his neck. “I thought I was, for a long time. Bloodied and branded and cast aside at the last – and there are hurts I have dealt that shall never be undone, and scars I bear that shall never heal. But all the same it is a mighty world, and a beautiful one, and I am glad to live in it.”

“I am glad too,” Maedhros said hesitantly, and won for his efforts an approving smile. It was not quite the smile of Maglor’s youth – wryer, now, its edges harsher than they had been. Maedhros found that he loved it even so.

“And here thou art!” Maglor said softly. “The Marring of Arda is less complete than once it seemed, Nelyo.”

“But how can I undo it?” Maedhros asked. “How can I heal what I have done to thee?”

“Thou canst not,” said Maglor, matter-of-fact. He squeezed Maedhros’ hand with his burned one.  “Thou canst only live with it.”

“How?” Maedhros whispered. “Káno, I am afraid.”

“Look at the sky,” Maglor said. “Listen to the Sea! They are here, and they are beautiful! And I am here, too.” He was still clinging to Maedhros. “We have all the time in the world, now. We will do our best to make right what we can, as Mandos commanded thee. We will do it all better, this time.”

Maedhros managed a laugh, although it sounded half a sob. “Thou art grown very wise, little brother.”

“I have had a great deal of time to do nothing but think,” said Maglor, dreamily. “Is that wisdom? I know not. But I do know – I do know it need not have happened the way it did. We had a choice, even when we thought we did not. Look at thee!” He touched Maedhros’ face again, wondering. “Even the Everlasting Darkness does not last for ever; and we were never bound as deeply as we imagined. We should have done better. We will do better, now, thou and I.”

“Then – then thou wilt not turn from me?” Maedhros asked. “Even after—”

“Even after,” Maglor confirmed. “How angry I have been with thee! I have cherished my wrath all these years: but it is a cold companion beside thee, o best-loved of brothers, the first claim on my heart. I am glad thou art here. I am glad thou art returned to me, or I to thee.”

“As am I, dearest,” Maedhros breathed. “As am I.”

This time Maglor did not object to the endearment. He stayed nestled against Maedhros, warm and solid, his head tucked beneath Maedhros’ chin. It was not forgotten, Maedhros knew. He could not undo the hurt he had done Maglor, nor erase the ancient marks of grief in his face and eyes, any more than he could heal his blackened withered hand. But here was his brother in his arms, all the same, and the sound of his breathing rose and fell with the same steady cadence as the unending roar of the Sea.


Leave a Comment