New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
-Part 3-
He lost himself in the push-and-pull, the back-and-forth, the give-and-take. He’d witnessed it before – in fighting, in dancing. This here was neither – or both; familiar and strange and new at once. At times they crested against each other, two waves building, forces clashing – only to divert around each other: binary stars slung around each other’s gravitational well. Opposed, but not antagonistic. No struggle for the upper hand, but a game, sometimes fighting for ground, sometimes ceding it.
At some point, Celebrimbor turned them around, and then he had Annatar up against the wall, one hand at the small of his back, the other bracing himself on the parapet as he buried his face in the crook of Annatar’s neck, kissing a trail of heat down his throat from below the ear to the collar. The Maia smelled of summer and warmth, fire and ozone, hot opals and something else that Celebrimbor could not pinpoint – something wholly strange, but ethereal, something which set his bones thrumming. When Celebrimbor slid his mouth lower, a pulse jumped under his lips and he suddenly, violently became aware of – This is real. Annatar had built this form from the ground up, but the imitation was perfect. The skin felt like skin, temperature, texture, and all, the same went for the clothing, the hair, down to minute movements like blinking, breathing, facial expressions that would be unwitting, instinctual on any Incarnate. A masterpiece, sublime in detail and precision. So easy was it to forget that it was, in fact, a creation.
Slowly, Celebrimbor pulled back. He lifted his gaze and his eyes met Annatar’s, this ancient, primordial gaze – a golden ring of fire around a black void, beautiful and dangerous like the corona of an eclipsed sun, as inescapable and ruinous as a star that had collapsed into infinite gravity, with matter swirling on a glowing accretion disc around its destructive centre.
“What are you?” Celebrimbor whispered.
Annatar just watched him, and again, there was that shadow of a smile on his lips – as if there was a secret jest to be found here, as if he knew something that Celebrimbor did not. Then he took Celebrimbor’s face between his hands once more and brought them together until their lips were only one breath apart.
“Yours,” he replied, his voice low and velvet-soft and spelling ruin for everything Celebrimbor had ever known of caution and wisdom and restraint. “If you want me.”
Celebrimbor held his gaze. A bated breath shuddered its way from his lungs.
What kind of fool desires to look directly at the sun?
The answer provided itself. Willingly, readily, almost self-ironically:
Me, apparently.
He tightened his grip around the small of Annatar’s back, until they were pressed against each other, collar to knee. He lowered his head, brushing his cheek against Annatar’s so he could speak into the Maia’s ear. “I want you,” he whispered. “I’ve wanted you for so long.”
He could feel Annatar smile against the side of his face. “Take me then,” he said. “Take what you want.” The Maia’s grasp around his neck tightened. “Take everything.”
Celebrimbor kissed him again, rougher this time, bending Annatar slightly backwards over the wall, while keeping their bodies flush against each other, his hand splayed between the Maia’s shoulder blades. Distantly, he was aware that he could not have moved Annatar so much as an inch if the Maia had not allowed it, and there something warm and dark and content pooled in his stomach at the realization that, yes, he wants this, too.
Annatar’s fingers were grasping his collar, pulling him in. When he shifted his stance, one of his thighs sliding between Celebrimbor’s legs, he sucked in a sharp breath, his fingers digging into Annatar’s shoulder blades.
“We should –” Celebrimbor rasped out, but Annatar had taken the notion from his mind before he had even finished speaking.
“We should,” he agreed and in the next instant, Annatar had twisted them around as if executing a turn in a dance, and when their revolution was complete, they were standing in Celebrimbor’s private rooms.
Celebrimbor instinctively side-stepped to catch his balance, but Annatar caught him and put a steadying hand against his back. “Careful.”
Celebrimbor exhaled. “That was – unexpected.” Other than supernatural perception, Annatar hardly ever made use any overt divine abilities. This demonstration of power was all the more startling for how offhanded it had been.
Annatar regarded him, his gaze searching. “Are you all right?”
“It’s fine,” Celebrimbor said, slightly out of breath. “It’s just – I was surprised. I have never done this before.”
“I would hope not,” Annatar said, hooking a finger through Celebrimbor’s belt and pulling him back in. “Otherwise I would have to ask what other Maia has spirited you away for a tryst in the past.”
Celebrimbor laid his arms over Annatar’s shoulders, leaning in until they were nearly nose to nose, while his fingers played with the hair at the back of the Maia’s head, twirling a silk-soft strand of hair around them. “Not to worry,” he said with a quiet smile, speaking into the air they were both breathing. “There has been no other god who’s taken an interest in me.”
Annatar smiled back, but it was showing far more teeth than usual. “Good,” he replied. “Because I have not been known to share.”
And with that, he pulled Celebrimbor in again. Out of the corner of his eye, he saw the Maia make a sharp gesture, and with a flick of his wrist, the door to Celebrimbor’s bedroom flew open.
“Inside, if you will, Tyelperinquar,” Annatar said, his voice low, and there was an undertone to those words, something rough lurking under smooth enunciation, that sent a shiver down Celebrimbor’s back.
He went, pulling Annatar along, reeling him in again. They came together like a collision. When their lips met, an electric thrill raced up Celebrimbor’s spine and then down into his stomach, where it curled and coiled, tighter, tighter, tighter. They inched their way into the bedroom, as they stepped back, around each other, circled each other, fought for the lead in this almost-dance, this not-quite-fight. Celebrimbor wound his fingers into soft, golden waves at the base of Annatar’s head, pulling his head back and kissing a line down the exposed throat. At the same time, he sensed a slight tug as Annatar’s hands came up to his collar. With a twist of his fingers, Celebrimbor felt the topmost button of his vest come undone.
His face buried in the crook of Annatar’s neck, he grinned. “Again?”
“Yes, again.” Annatar flicked open the second button.
“I’m beginning to think that you are taking issue with my attire.”
“I take no issue with your attire in general. I take issue with the fact that your attire is on you, instead of on the floor where it belongs,” Another twist of long, deft fingers. A third button came undone.
“Quite ironic that you of all people would say that,” Celebrimbor replied before kissing the Maia again. “Multiple layers, and all that.”
“Go and do something about it, if it bothers you.” Annatar nipped at his lower lip, teeth grazing skin. His voice was low and husky, and it went straight towards the coil of heat in Celebrimbor’s stomach. “No one is stopping you.”
It was as if another binding of restraint snapped inside him at those words. He wrapped his arms around Annatar, turned them around and pushed him up against the wall, before sliding both hands under the open front of the Maia’s white outer robe pushing up and shoving the fabric off Annatar’s shoulders. Below, he was wearing a silver-grey vest, which –
“Never complain to me about buttons again,” Celebrimbor remarked with a breathless exhale as he begun undoing the first button (of many) while pressing an open-mouthed kiss below Annatar’s ear.
Annatar threw him a devious smile. “Don’t you like your gifts beautifully wrapped, Tyelperinquar?”
The fire inside his chest flared.
Celebrimbor looked at the Maia, grey eyes meeting golden ones. “As a matter of fact, I prefer them unwrapped and laid bare to admire.”
Annatar laughed quietly. “Get to work, then.”
So he did.
Their dance resumed as they made their way across the room towards the bed, shedding robes, vests, shirts, trousers, boots along the way, never parting for longer than it took to draw breath. Celebrimbor’s heart was beating a frantic rhythm against the inside of his ribcage, and he burned, burned, burned.
Then they were at the bed, and the backs of Annatar’s knees were against the mattress, and Celebrimbor tipped them both over. They tumbled down in a rush of air and heat. Celebrimbor caught himself on his elbow, breaking his fall. His other arm was still slung around Annatar. The impact forced them together, and for a moment they were pressed up against each other along the entire length of their bodies in a line of heat and friction, hearts racing, chests heaving, before Celebrimbor pushed himself up.
He lifted his gaze to look at Annatar – and stilled.
The roar of the blaze within his mind was momentarily silenced. It was as if time had stopped, and the rush of blood in his ears was gone, and even his own heart had quietened its frantic beat. The world had gone still when he looked at Annatar, who was lying on his back below him. A god, older than the world, who had the universe itself sung into being. In his bed. In his arms. As shieldless and unveiled and bare as Celebrimbor had ever seen him.
Gone was the distant deity, the patient, knowledgeable, but reserved mentor, gone the meticulously curated appearance and just as meticulously curated distance. Gone were the beautiful, opaque layers Annatar had always cloaked himself in – ever catching the eye, but never truly letting him be seen. Gone was the absolute neatness of his appearance, gone was the iron control, of himself, and of his surroundings.
This here was someone else: someone just as radiant, but raw and wild and undone in a way that Celebrimbor had never seen before. There were spots of colour on Annatar’s cheeks, his lips reddened and swollen from kisses and soft bites. His chest was rising and falling against Celebrimbor’s own, the beat of an immortal heart pulsing under the skin of his throat where Celebrimbor’s lips had left their mark. His hair was a wild golden tumble, strands fallen across his forehead, over his shoulders, spread out underneath him and mingling with Celebrimbor’s long, black tresses that had cascaded around them like a curtain to shield them from the world. One of his hands was holding on to Celebrimbor’s shoulder, the other was resting next to his head, palm upwards, the fingers loosely curled.
In a world full of beautiful things, it was the most arresting thing Celebrimbor had ever seen.
Annatar was looking up at him, his expression open, unguarded, with a wry, slightly sly come-hither smile on his lips. He inclined his head, his locks sliding over the mattress, following the movement. “Is something the matter?”
Sudden affection filled Celebrimbor in a rush that that made his insides twist. There is a god in my arms, and he is mine.
The fire in his stomach flared, but just for this instant, its blaze was banked, and there was warmth more than scorching heat. On an impulse, he raised his own free hand and laid it above Annatar’s, interlacing their fingers, before he bent down and kissed him; long and deep and unhurried.
Annatar rose up to meet him. His hand slid from Celebrimbor’s shoulder to his chest and pressed up against it, and his palm was hot like an iron brand against Celebrimbor’s skin.
The flame rekindled, and with it, the hunger. Celebrimbor pushed into the burn, pushing down, until their bodies were once more flush against each other. He wound his fingers into Annatar’s hair and pulled slightly until the Maia tilted his head back, kissing along his jaw.
There was a hum under Annatar’s skin, and a preternatural, searing heat, as if his essence was straining outward, just barely contained by the form he had chosen for himself. Celebrimbor splayed hands on Annatar’s chest, running up his side, feeling the taut rise of muscles, the hard ridges of ribs, the sweep of the collarbone, the slight give of skin under pressure. Creation and attention to detail, brought to perfection.
How fitting, that the divine craftsman should have created his most sublime masterpiece in himself.
Celebrimbor kissed his way back upwards, until his lips were grazing Annatar’s again.
“How much of this you?” he whispered.
He felt Annatar go still. “What do you mean?”
“You are beautiful,” Celebrimbor responded, unhurriedly brushing the tips of their noses together, while his free hand ran up Annatar’s neck, gently pushing aside a lock of hair. “You made yourself so. How much of this is the vessel and how much of this is you?”
Annatar laughed quietly. “Now of all times is when you want to start a metaphysical discussion about the fanar of Ainur?”
“I assure you it is very pertinent to what we are doing.” Celebrimbor shifted and began another trail of kisses down Annatar’s throat, down to the dip between the collar bones.
“In what way?”
Celebrimbor bit him – carefully, but enough to serve as an admonition. “Answer the question.”
Annatar, who had almost flinched – the closest he had actually come to an instinctual, reflexive, truly incarnate reaction today – forced the tension back out of his body with a surge of will that was palpable like a hum in the air, which, again, was not very incarnate at all.
“I am here, if that is what you mean,” he said. “There isn’t the – ah – immediate, inextricable connection between a spirit and a body that you have. My body is not me in the way that yours is you. Think of water inside a glass. Contained within the same space, but separate. Discrete entities, discrete natures.”
Celebrimbor gave a thoughtful hum, brushing his lips over Annatar’s collar bones, while the Maia ran his fingers through his unbound hair.
“You do not sound like you approve,” Annatar stated.
“That would be because I don’t.” Celebrimbor said, his mouth sliding lower.
“You are truly something else, Tyelperinquar, do you know that? You must be the first mortal to deem a god’s nature insufficient and possess the cheek to say it aloud.” Annatar’s fingers in his hair went tighter, pulled.
“Not insufficient,” Celebrimbor said, his lips lightly tracing Annatar’s breastbone and following the line of where it dipped to his stomach. “Just not fit for what I want to do.”
Again, Annatar went very still. “What do you want to do? Aside from the obvious, I mean?”
Celebrimbor lifted his head and his eyes met those of Annatar over the expanse of his stomach, his chest. “I want to see you come apart,” he said, reaching behind him and sliding his fingers up Annatar’s leg, over the ankle, the calf, the knee, all the while holding the Maia’s gaze. “I want to see you come undone.” His hand slid into the hollow of Annatar’s knee and then he pulled, bringing them together at the hip, suppressing the shudder that threatened to wrack through him at the spark that shot down his legs straight to the soles of his feet. “But I want you to be here for it.”
“I am,” Annatar said, frowning, pushing himself up on his elbows.
Celebrimbor held his gaze. “In your entirety,” he clarified. “Just like me.”
He saw the exact split second when Annatar understood what he meant.
The Maia hesitated. “I am not sure –” He interrupted himself, uncharacteristically diffident. “I have not tried – ” He looked down, aside, his brows pulled together. “I do not know how that would go.”
Celebrimbor felt him withdraw in spirit before Annatar even moved, and he quickly moved to intercept it, anticipating the retreat before it could happen.
“Stay,” he said, wrapping harm more tightly around the Maia.
Annatar froze.
Celebrimbor pulled himself up towards Annatar, pulled them together, until they were sitting upright, nearly chest to chest.
“Tyelperinquar, I am not sure me incarnating would be – advisable,” Annatar said.
Celebrimbor heard the undercurrent of something else under the too-controlled tone, the too off-handed way the Maia leaned out of concrete discomfort and into abstracts like wise and unwise and advisable, carefully skirting around the question ‘for whom?’. He noticed how, while he had his arms around Annatar, Annatar had his hands on Celebrimbor’s chest, almost like a brace, almost as if getting something between them, ready to widen the distance.
“Then don’t do it yourself,” Celebrimbor said, gently pulling against Annatar’s subtle straining backwards. “Use me.”
Annatar’s resistance fizzed out like a spark doused in perplexity. “What do you mean?”
“We are both capable of osanwë,” Celebrimbor said, “you to a far greater extent than me, being a Maia. Don’t you think it would be possible to create a connection that goes beyond merely sharing thoughts in order to give you access to my senses and perceptions?”
Annatar seemed caught between apprehension and intrigue. “You do realize that this would equal possession of the mind and body. Your mind and body.”
“I trust you enough not to snuff out my mind when you are doing this.”
Annatar looked at him for a very long time. “The way you speak makes me think you do not realize the extent of what you are trusting me with.”
“Oh, believe me, I do,” Celebrimbor said. “It’s just that the scale of possible catastrophes that can occur when working with a Maia is so great that an order of magnitude more or less doesn’t really make a difference to me, believe it or not.” He looked at Annatar. “If you wanted to do me harm, you would. I couldn’t stop you one way or another. So why should I fear this more than creating the Rings with you? I’ve already thrown my lot in with you and decided to trust you. Why would I begin to have misgivings now?”
Annatar was silent. He didn’t look at Celebrimbor and there was a stiffness and reluctance to him that had not been there in a long time, perhaps not ever.
“Come,” Celebrimbor said, leaning forward with a teasing expression and a deliberate lightness to his tone. “Aren’t you curious whether it will work?”
A shadow of a smile flitted over Annatar’s lips, and he briefly glanced at Celebrimbor. “You really are something, Tyelperinquar, do you know that?”
“I must be, to have caught the interest of a Maia,” Celebrimbor said, still teasing. “I’m told I’m aggravating and interesting and utterly captivating. The question is, will it be enough? Can I convince him to do this with me?”
Annatar muttered something unflattering under his breath, which sounded distinctly like save Middle-earth from the spawn of Fëanor –
Then he straightened, and the standoffishness about him receded. He looked Celebrimbor in the eye.
“If you want to do this, you must open yourself to me completely. You cannot shy away or flee. The last thing either of us needs is for your spirit to be expulsed into the ether and losing its tether to your body. We must be One, and the circle cannot be disrupted before you are firmly anchored back within yourself. Understood?”
Celebrimbor nodded.
Their eyes met.
Grey and gold.
A golden ring around black, eclipsing everything else in the world.
What kind of fool desires to look directly at the sun?
He felt a sensation as if he had missed a step of stairs in the dark, and then he was tumbling forward and into the void.
For a moment Celebrimbor felt nothing, not even himself. He did not see, for he did not have eyes any longer. He did not feel any warmth or cold, nor the rushing wind of the fall, for he no longer had a body.
Then, though, he became aware of something beyond perception – a hidden force, unseen, unknowable, but nevertheless exacting the same dangerous pull as a collapsed star. Invisible, unfathomable, forever beyond sight, but pulling in matter and light and swallowing it forever.
In a moment of sheer, naked panic, Celebrimbor wanted to stop and pull back, but found himself bodiless in a non-space without axes and direction. Mathematical manifolds and vectors collapsed around him like towers. Vector space decomposed into orthogonal subspaces, veering away from each other. Then, though, Celebrimbor remembered –
Mind over matter.
You must not shy away.
Mind over matter.
— and mastered himself.
Something bloomed before him: it was fractal-like, spiralling outward in self-repeating patterns, logarithmic spirals, involutes, rising, expanding, folding outward, upward, and in was light and the hidden centre of gravity that he had been pulled towards. And only then did he notice that the curves were bending towards him, too – he had no body, but his presence alone was distorting the weave of his non-space. He became the origin point from which the isotropic lines of his own vector space originated, fanning forward and outward in a cone of all the colours of the light.
The fractal light approached him.
Celebrimbor pulled back, and at last, something like a sense of self returned to him.
Annatar, is that you?
For a moment, there was no answer.
Then –
Yes. As far as the concept of “I” and “you” can be applied here. Try not to cling to yourself. This is a space where the self dissolves. Do not be afraid. When the time comes, just let go.
Space condensed around them. Celebrimbor could see it in the flattening of the curves and fractals, which became ever more compressed. Somewhere, far off, he felt a tingle of something that someone with a body might have called apprehension, but then it was gone, vanished in the growing corona of fractured light that grew before him.
Their spirits approached each other, drawn to each other like other objects of great mass, slowly at first, but then faster, inexorably moving closer. Lines blurred. Space compressed. Time dilated. Although they both tried to hold back and slow the approach, they were picking up speed and then was beyond their control, and Celebrimbor could feel even Annatar slipping – and then their souls were a falling towards each other at the speed of light, a plunge, where space was reduced to zero and time became infinite. When they merged it was like the collision of two stars, a binary system crashing down into one and in a union of fire and brightness.
For a moment, they were both blind and deaf and numb. There was nothing around them and between them and for a moment, they were trapped inside a sphere where every possible direction pointed towards the centre, threatening to fall into a singularity of their own creation. But then Celebrimbor felt a mighty force, impossibly powerful, straining outward, outward, outward – and then the equilibrium broke, the hypersphere was folding its insides out, and Celebrimbor plummeted back into his body.
He was suddenly compressed from infinite dimensions into an infinitesimally small space, cramped and small and asphyxiating – and only then did Celebrimbor remember that he needed to breathe. He was choking – choked by his own physicality that was strangling him like a giant snake wrapped around his entire form. His heart would not beat, his lungs would not expand. With a gasp, he opened his mouth, and finally, finally, the air streamed back into his lungs. His heart was racing, and he took inhale after shuddering inhale. The world returned in increments, and he became aware of his surroundings again – his naked, sweat-slick body, the dryness of his mouth, the thundering of his heart against his ribs. For a while he just sat there, listening to himself breathing, and only after a few moments longer did he notice that Annatar was breathing with him – and in the synchrony of sound and motion became aware that he wasn’t only just in his own body anymore. And neither was Annatar.
Annatar had always been simultaneously repulsed and fascinated by the nature of Incarnation; this intimate and vulnerable unity of spirit and body, of being the flesh instead of wearing a form like just another gown. He was intrigued by the carelessness and ease with which the Incarnates moved through the world, even despite the fragility of their bodies, even though they had to fear destruction of something that was them at every turn. But while it made them vulnerable, there was an inimitable intimacy they shared with the world and everything in it. If they reached out, they were touching the world around them and it was touching them back, directly, immediately, without any veils drawn between them. The concept of thoughtlessly bringing one’s self into such direct contact with the world, let alone with other beings, had seemed incomprehensible to him; reckless, nearly obscene.
Ever since he had gotten to know Celebrimbor, though, had first taken his hands to guide him through the motions of manipulating molecular lattices, he had been drawn back again to that unfiltered immediacy, circling it – half-sceptical, half-intrigued – seeing it, for once, not as a limitation, but a boon, an improvement, a door open to Celebrimbor and his fellow Incarnates that was closed to him.
He was untouchable to the world, but it came at a price. Isolation: being close, but never being enmeshed, immersed, entangled in it. Always one step removed from everything, forever just out of reach. Granted, the theoretical possibility to fully incarnate existed, and it would allow him to reach through the veil that separated him from the world. But to close that broken loop for real, to enable himself to not only give, but to receive, would mean laying bare his fëa, open and raw like a flayed thing – a concept that made him recoil at the core of his being.
But then he had found himself growing more and more enticed by Celebrimbor, by his fire and the brilliance of his mind, had found himself drawn in close, closer than he had ever intended to get. And now, suddenly, there was the new and foreign notion that close was somehow not close enough – that the barrier he had curated so as not to get the world smeared onto him had turned into an obstacle that was to be surmounted or circumvented. He found himself returning to the confounding notion again and again, but never once truly considered vaulting this unsettling divide.
Until, of course, Tyelperinquar was before him – as bold and brilliant and beautiful as Annatar had ever seen him – his eyes shining bright with excitement and desire and something he could not put a name to – and offered himself up as a conduit.
It was a way out, a circumvention, a third option where only two solutions had appeared possible. It was unheard of, unthought of, daring, dauntless, ingenious, and utterly Tyelperinquar.
For a moment, Annatar was stunned. Then he had to rein in his anger, had to bite back a sharp, Do you even know what you are suggesting, you incorrigible fearnaught?
Because did this foolhardy, this reckless, this glorious, brilliant elf know nothing of danger and death, did he care so little for risk and ruin – to casually suggest an absolute, boundless entrance not only into his mind, but his entire being?
And one would have to be a fool to hand over the key to one’s entire being like this.
And yet Tyelperinquar had only shrugged, with a glint in his eyes and the casual nonchalance of one who had only a tired smile to spare for Death itself, and told him – again, so casually, so nonchalantly – that he did trust Annatar to the extent to hand over the key to his soul. A degree to which no one should trust anyone.
And –
Annatar should not have accepted.
He knew so much of caution and restraint. He had exercised them all his life while staying in the shadows and watching others get tangled up in webs of foolish desire and deception, while staying well clear of them himself.
But for once, he wanted.
Here there was a way to experience everything, without giving anything up in return, offered freely by one who could not possibly understand the greatness of the gift and trust he was offering. (Or one who knew, and cared not, and would do it anyway.)
And so Annatar opened both of their minds and drew them together and—
It was breathtaking. Literally and metaphorically.
In the first few seconds he did, truly, struggle for breath, his spirit coursing in an endless loop through not one, but two forms, one of them a real body, and just as much his now as it was Celebrimbor’s. More his than his own form had ever been.
On an instinct, he flung out his arm to catch a balance he had never lost before, the other hand going to his throat in an instinct that was foreign to his Maiarin nature.
And then something inside him settled – or his spirit – both their spirits stabilized their trajectories – and how different that was – a state of ongoing permutation, of constant change, without anything static, switching perspectives.
It reminded him of nothing so much as the Beginning, when he had not yet separated from the Great Consciousness that had given birth to all the Ainur, before they gained names, a sense of self, and personalities, and descended into the world.
He had never thought he would experience it again.
Annatar opened his eyes – their eyes – and came face to face with Celebrimbor.
The elf raised his head. When he opened his eyes to look back at Annatar, they were golden.
Annatar was looking at the elf, and at the same time looking back at himself out of Tyelperinquar’s eyes.
For once in his unfathomable existence, Annatar was rendered speechless.
He was face to face with Celebrimbor and he was Celebrimbor; he was at the same time audience and actor, experiencing everything twofold. He ran his fingers down what was at once the arm of the elf and his own, he felt the touching and the touch. The nerves in his fingertips were crackling with electric overcharge. Celebrimbor’s spirit surged, lapping into Annatar’s own fána and allowing it to feel what the elf’s incarnate body was feeling.
“This – is different,” the elf said.
Annatar pulled back, trying to momentarily disentangle their spirits and bodies from each other. It would not do to go forward with this if Celebrimbor’s mind was going to buckle under the strain. “Are you all right?”
“I am. It is … strange. A sense of displacement, kind of a double vision, but … Annatar, I can see so much more, perceive things I haven’t ever – ” He halted, considering, the look in his strange golden eyes suddenly far away as he noticeably shifted his perspective from his own eyes to those of Annatar. “Is that how you see me?”
Annatar froze, and suddenly felt a violent dread that he had given away too much, belatedly realizing the acute danger that there was in telling someone Dare to take everything, and having that someone do just that without reservation or hesitation. He should have known better with Tyelperinquar. One hundred thousand years of never having one’s expectations met, let alone exceeded, were no excuse after three hundred years of having known Celebrimbor.
Annatar quickly contained the notion before it could reach the elf and inquire about the reason for it. He would have to – compartmentalize, far more strictly and consistently than he had done up until this moment. Just because the elf saw no issue in opening his mind and his perceptions to Annatar, did not mean that the inverse was true, and some things – many things – were for no one but himself to see and know.
“That is … blindingly bright,” Celebrimbor said slowly, intrigued. “Is that light – refracted? The corona of colours reminds me of it. It’s beautiful – but where does the light come from? It seems to shine from inside of me, nearly through me ... Is this my fëa?” He paused thoughtfully. “Is this how you see living beings in general?”
Annatar was suddenly and intensely glad that they were alone. It would not do for Celebrimbor to find out the answer to those questions. It would be too much, to give him that.
Instead, he decided to go with the angle of explanation that the elf himself had provided. Which wasn’t wrong, per se, but—
“I see more than just the physical plane. A strong will and strong spirit will always outshine a mere physical vessel,” Annatar said.
Celebrimbor made an absent-minded noise, craning his head around, taking in the room as if he was seeing it for the first time. “It’s marvellous. You can see so much more than I do; everything looks so much brighter. I wish I had sight like that; I would love to try this out among people.” He looked back at Annatar, then his eyes widened. Annatar felt his shock and surprise as if they were his own. The sensation was so unfamiliar and intense that he very nearly recoiled.
“Your eyes,” Celebrimbor said. “Why are they grey?”
Ah. Well, that made sense.
“Our experiment was successful,” Annatar replied. “It seems there are side effects.”
Celebrimbor considered this. “Successful – does that mean – ?” His eyes focused on Annatar, and for a moment, he was piercingly, exclusively himself, looking at Annatar as if he had never seen him before. “It worked?”
Annatar nodded, the unfamiliar sensations of second-hand incarnation rushing through him and tingling under his skin. “It did.”
“You can feel –”
“ – everything you feel, yes.”
A smile spread over Tyelperinquar’s face, but it was a different expression than his usual, bright expression. His eyes turned a darker shade of gold, the sheen of his aura dimmed and veered from the perfect brilliant white of the synthesis of all colours to something dusky, like the last light of evening before nightfall.
When Celebrimbor reached for Annatar and pulled him in, Annatar drew in a sharp breath at the contact – involuntarily, a reflex that wasn’t his. It was a reflected sensation in his mind, just like the feeling of an electric spark shooting up his spinal column at the contact, but since he was Tyelperinquar, and since they were sharing both bodies and nervous systems, he felt it as sharply and immediately as if the feeling had been his own. In fact, Annatar was quite unable to distinguish where any sensation had its origin and where it radiated towards. Cause and effect seemed to have been undone or rendered moot, because any direction between them was at once beginning and end, origin and destination, their minds racing through the expanded space from Me to Us like the electrons arranging themselves into higher orbitals.
Celebrimbor kissed him, and for a split-second, Annatar’s expanded awareness shrunk to the point where their mouths met, condensed into wet heat, the texture of their lips and the fanning of warm breath. Desire rose, fire-like. A tremor coursed through his form that he could not control, and his next exhale came unsteady, shuddering. In response, the Tyelperinquar’s twilight-dusky contentment surged like a wave and rushed through them both.
They were merged like two bodies of water poured into the same vessel and if there was still a boundary between them it was arbitrary and merely upheld by habits and the gravitational pull to exist only in a single point of space and time at once. It was beyond anything he had ever experienced ever since he had separated from the shared consciousness of all Ainur into a discrete self.
The tidal wave of impressions and sensations nearly drowned him, but distantly, he was still able to marvel at what they had created, this unity of two beings merging into one and how every touch he gave returned to him, how he was giver and receiver at once as if Celebrimbor and he were nothing but part of the same circle, where beginning and end could not be determined and every action he took was reflected back to him in the same instant. And endless circle, a single closed circuit.
Their minds were one, and when they looked at each other, gold meeting grey, a flash of hungry possessiveness flashed through both of their minds, an echo of Mine, and he could not tell where it had originated, which of them it belonged to, but in the end it didn’t matter.
It was immediate. Intoxicating.
And then Celebrimbor reached for him, in body and in mind, and Annatar reached back.
One of them must have pushed the other back, their bodies falling towards each other like their minds had, straining towards each other, two fires melding and becoming a singular, great blaze.
It was creation and it was unmaking.
I want to see you come undone, Tyelperinquar had said, and then he set about doing just that, precisely, methodically, relentlessly.
The onslaught of sensations was torrential. Briefly, Annatar thought they had shunted themselves back to that extratemporal space they had barely escaped, because time seemed to skip and lunge –
But then again, it must have been something else, for both of them were here and one and together in every way possible, in every way that mattered. They were so firmly anchored in this circuit of shared awareness and physicality, and the proof was in every hot press of lips, of every graze of the back of a hand, every grip of fingers digging into pliant flesh and muscle, nails raking over skin, laboured breaths, urgent movement, arching backs – and in the next moment he knew, they were plunging, falling, as the world around them was devoured in all colours of the light, time unspooled like a loose thread, and at last they came apart – unmade, undone – and lost to time and the world, as they surged into each other and around each other, until they themselves were dissolved, atomized, dispersed, their wave functions collapsed—
—into a final state of perfect entropy.
Celebrimbor did not know when he had fallen asleep. The night had fallen out of time, and he had no notion of whether it had ever returned to the normal world, or simply remained in this chaotic dimension where minutes and hours expanded and contracted at will; a space without Time like the one Melian and Thingol must have inhabited after they had come together in the woods of Doriath.
He had no recollection of disentangling their shared minds and bodies, but when he woke to pale dawn light streaming in through the windows, his body and vision and mind were his own again.
For a moment, he felt strangely bereft. Reduced. His vision was back to the way it had been – muted, ordinary, with less colour and light – and his awareness was once more firmly contained in his own physical form. He felt cramped in a way that he had not heretofore known, and briefly he thought of a bird that had been allowed to stretch its wings and fly, once, before being put back into a cage.
He sat up and stretched, the blanket pooling in his lap, but it did little to remove the notion of being constricted. Perceiving everything around him had come so easily last night, as if his eyes had never been opened wider. Now he had to make a conscious effort to focus that seemed clumsy to him, and comparably strenuous.
Celebrimbor ran a hand through his hair and blinked. The bed next to him was empty, the mattress cool.
He lifted his gaze and there, in front of the oriel window, he could see Annatar’s silhouette against the slowly brightening, dove grey sky. The Maia had sat down on the deep sill, one knee pulled up and his arms loosely draped around it. He was dressed, though in contrast to his usual elaborate white robes, he was wearing a simple black shirt and trousers. He wore no ornaments or jewellery and his feet were left bare. There was something strikingly intimate and otherworldly about the quiet scene; a reduction to simplistic essentiality. The half-light seeping in through the window pane softened the Maia’s edges, while shadows clung to his dark clothing, like voiceless primordial things flocking towards him, sensing familiarity. Annatar had been looking outside, but turned his head when Celebrimbor threw the blanket aside and rose from the bed.
Golden eyes followed him as he padded across the room.
“Go back to bed, Tyelperinquar,” Annatar said softly. “It is early still.”
“It’s fine. I am awake.” He was. There was a growing restlessness in his limbs that made it impossible to stay still. He had to move. Celebrimbor walked closer, then halted about five pace away, caught by sudden uncertainty. Yesternight felt like a dream.
He knew it had happened, and the evidence was all over his body – purple lovebites on his neck, shoulder, and chest, bruises on his flank and thighs, the gentle burn of scratches on his back, the looseness in his limbs. And yet, for a moment he was not sure how to continue from here. Going to sleep had been a caesura; the world turning on without giving him time to adjust for the changes, and now he didn’t know how to proceed. Was there a wall between them, or wasn’t there? He longed to reach out, but he did not know whether he was allowed to do so.
For a few moments, Annatar and he simply looked at each other, unmoving.
“Are you ... are you well?” Celebrimbor asked tentatively.
Annatar made a small sound, halfway between amused and dismissive. “Of course I am. I should be asking you that. If I had known the extent of what we’ve done beforehand, I would have been more wary of subjecting your mind to it without preamble or precaution.”
“My mind is fine,” Celebrimbor said.
Annatar watched him intently for a few moments, the golden gaze roving over him from top to toe, then stopping at his eyes, searching, as if the Maia wanted to ascertain himself of the fact that Celebrimbor was speaking the truth and that there was no crack upon his mind or soul.
“Good,” he said, at last. Then, “I’m glad.”
Suddenly, a high-strung tension that Celebrimbor had not even noticed before seemed to go out of Annatar, and the Maia leaned back against the wall of the window bay behind him.
Celebrimbor hesitated. “You were worried about me.”
Annatar didn’t answer immediately, looking straight ahead at the opposite wall. “Of course I worried.” His eyes flitted back to Celebrimbor. “One of us has to.”
Celebrimbor exhaled softly, then attempted a smile. “I appreciate it. But you needn’t have. We Incarnates are not overwhelmed so easily as that.”
Annatar did not respond. Instead, after holding Celebrimbor’s gaze for a few more moments, he held out his hand. Startled, Celebrimbor reached out and took it.
Annatar’s palm was warm and dry when Celebrimbor laid his hand in his, only slightly above the temperature one would expect from a human or one of the Eldar. Everything about him seemed still and subdued in the grey dawn – not sad or regretful, but withdrawn and contemplative. Celebrimbor watched as the Maia regarded his hand, running his thumb over the its back, his fingers, and the thin scars that countless years of fighting and forge work had left him with, lighter against the tan of the unmarred skin. In the low dawn light, the hand was thrown into stark relief – shadows pooled between fingers and the ridges of the knuckles, painting dark smudges next to the rise of the sinews. Only the barest tint of colour shimmered through a world in grisaille.
Neither of them moved for an indefinite amount of time.
Then, slowly, nearly reluctantly, Annatar let Celebrimbor go – but not by pulling back or letting the elf’s hand fall. Instead, Annatar guided his hand downwards with a nearly imperceptible touch of his fingers, so light, so careful that it would have been more fit for handling a monomolecular glass sheet, until it was hanging at the Celebrimbor’s side once more, and only then did Annatar pull his own hand back.
“You should get dressed,” Annatar said. “The nights are getting cool already.”
“Hard as that may be to believe, but I hadn’t actually noticed.”
When Annatar looked up at him, he tried a grin. The Maia frowned, then shook his head. Any edge the expression might have held, however, was taken off by the exasperated smile hiding at the corners of his lips. “Go dress,” he said, shooing him off with a wave of his hand, but his tone was fond.
Celebrimbor went. He showered and dressed before returning to the window. He climbed up opposite of Annatar, pulling his knees towards himself, and gazed outside. The first bit of sunlight was creeping over the green-grey woods of Eregion, outlining the highest tree tops, the gentle slopes of hills and the eastern flanks of the three peaks of Khazad-Dûm in blazing gold. The sky was cloudless and turning from pink to blue. It would be another warm, wonderful day of late summer.
Our halcyon days, Celebrimbor thought, resting his head against the wall behind him.
They both watched in silence as colour crept back into the world. The sun crept over the horizon. The sky turned from washed-out water colours to cornflower blue. At some point they shifted their legs into an intertwined position, so they had more space to sit comfortably, their knees resting against each other. Celebrimbor felt the cold of the wall seep into his back where the stone pressed against the damp spots on his shirt where his wet hair had come to lie. The window was facing south-east, and eventually, the sun beams reached the window, and Celebrimbor, whose right hand was lying in a growing pool of sunlight, felt the air growing warmer there. Out of the corner of his eye, he noticed how the sunlight found Annatar’s hair – light drawn to light, gold to gold, fire to fire.
When he turned his head to look fully at Annatar, he found the Maia watching him.
“What is it?” Celebrimbor asked.
Annatar shook his head. “Nothing. I was merely ... lost in thought.”
Celebrimbor regarded him, puzzled, when something caught his notice. He looked at the long black trousers and the dark, long-sleeved shirt that hung slightly too loose around Annatar’s shoulders. “Are those my clothes?”
Annatar just smiled.
“How come you have taken to plundering my wardrobe now?” Celebrimbor asked, nudging Annatar’s knee with his own. “Surely you do not need to descend to wear cotton and linen when you can make your own divine robes that are way finer than that.”
“Certainly I don’t need to. But perhaps I like having something of yours on me,” Annatar replied, inclining his head to one side, still that small, almost secretive smile on his lips. The movement let the loose neckline slide aside where the shirt was too wide for him anyway, baring part of his left shoulder and collarbone, where the marks Celebrimbor had left on him were visible. The uncontrived, artless intimacy of the simple motion struck Celebrimbor like a hammer to the chest.
The dream-like hours of darkness had passed, but this was still the secret, private version of Annatar sitting across from him that only he had been allowed to see. Loose and easy, marked by the previous night in body and spirit: the bruises on his skin that he had not bothered (or wanted) to remove, the still loosely tousled hair that fell over his shoulders and made him seem untamed and fey in a way that reduced the similarities to the meticulous, closed-off personage of Aulë’s emissary to a mere passing resemblance.
Instinctively, Celebrimbor’s own hand came up to his neck, touching his own purpling marks. “You haven’t removed them.” It was half a question.
“As I said,” Annatar replied, his voice even, but still, ever so slightly smiling. “Perhaps I like having something of yours on me.”
The statement made Celebrimbor feel, for just a second, acute regret at just having showered, only to weigh it seriously against the idea of dismissing that fact and carrying the Maia back to bed anyway.
Annatar’s brow quirked up as if he had read Celebrimbor’s mind – which made the elf reconsider the uncontrivedness of it all.
He frowned. “Annatar, are you trying to seduce me?”
The Maia smiled wryly. “Implying there is anything left to be done on that front.”
Point in case.
Celebrimbor laughed. “Schemer.”
“Guilty as charged.”
“And I fell for it. Dear me.”
“Yes. You are, unfortunately, ensnared and caught in my web of machinations.”
“Oh no.”
“You may get on your knees and beg for mercy. I might consider your entreaties if I feel like it.”
“Oh, so you’re a schemer and a tyrant.” Celebrimbor inclined his head to one side and grinned. “Whatever have I gotten myself into with you?”
Annatar mirrored the movement, his eyes glittering, his tone nearly playful. “Has nobody ever told you that it is dangerous to tangle with the Powers, Tyelperinquar?” He shifted his leg, angling his foot so it grazed, feather-light, along the outside of Celebrimbor’s thigh.
Celebrimbor caught it and held it down, his thumb brushing over Annatar’s ankle down to the arch of the foot and back. “I am sure even the Powers can be swayed to lenience.”
“Perhaps, perhaps not. You can certainly try.”
“I can be convincing,” Celebrimbor said seriously. “And obstinate.”
Annatar laughed softly. “That much is for certain. The question remains whether that is going to save you or doom you.”
“I don’t know,” Celebrimbor replied, keeping eye contact, his thumb still circling Annatar’s ankle. “You tell me.”
Annatar considered this, then shook his head, looking like he was biting back a smile. “No, I don’t think so. I’d rather keep you on your toes. It gets less interesting if you know what’s about to come.”
Celebrimbor raised his eyebrows. “Should I be worried?”
“Very,” Annatar said solemnly.
Celebrimbor laughed. “I shudder to think of the nefarious plan you might devise. Are you going to keep stealing my clothes?”
“Maybe.”
Celebrimbor made an amused noise, then looked at the Maia. “Come to think of it, I’ve never seen you wear black before.”
Annatar’s smile slipped a bit. “It’s not my colour.”
Celebrimbor regarded him. “I don’t think so. It suits you. Black goes well with gold.”
Annatar looked away. “Perhaps. Still, I prefer others.”
“White?” Celebrimbor guessed. “Or the sum of all spectral colours?”
Annatar threw him a sideglance, then he laughed, but it was subdued, half-hearted. “Both and either, depending on the occasion.”
“Depending on whether you choose a humanoid form or a fractal.”
“Something like that.”
They fell quiet.
The sun rose higher. The golden squares on the windowsill expanded, flowed up their legs and chests. The air grew warm. Just then, in the silence of idle musings, a thought occurred to Celebrimbor and he suddenly leapt off the sill.
“Where are you going?” Annatar asked.
“Fetching something. Wait here.”
Celebrimbor walked out into his study and when he returned, he had the prototype Rings in his palm.
Annatar quirked up one eyebrow. “The Rings? Do you want to continue working right now?”
Celebrimbor stopped before the windowstill. “No. Not necessarily. But – well. When we were … ah, together, I was thinking of them.”
Annatar’s eyebrow climbed higher. “Your mind certainly does some interesting leaps.”
Celebrimbor gave him a long look. “You’re one to talk. Half the time your thoughts brushed mine they were full of flashes about quantum coherence and wave fields.”
Annatar elected not to respond to this. “What idea did you have?” he asked instead.
“Funnily enough, your thoughts about coherence were what made the idea fully take form.” Celebrimbor looked at the Rings, then at Annatar. “Do you think – do you think we could do it with them?”
He saw the Annatar’s face race through a range of expressions: from a frown to a slight lifting of the eyebrows when he understood, a subtle tensing of his entire frame when all the implications were mapped out –
Two-way connections between the Rings and through them, between the minds of their wearers, a reciprocal feedback loop –
“You want to connect them? Why?”
Celebrimbor looked up. He hesitated. “I grew up with osanwë, never questioning the fact that it existed or how it shaped my entire perception of the world, how I communicate with other Quendi. How I communicate with you. Not just yesterday, but whenever we work together – we hardly talk, Annatar. We open our minds and we understand each other on a level that would not have been possible otherwise. Imagine if – imagine if this was possible for more people. Leaders. Queens. Thanes. The Ealdorpeople of the Atani. Imagine if they had such a Ring as a communication device, paired with powers of protection. No more misunderstandings leading to conflicts. No more critical delays in relaying information. If one person needed aid, the other would know immediately. The powers of the Rings could be combined, even, each able to tap the others in the set, to draw on them in times of need. The Atani and Khazad could finally have something akin to osanwë. It is such a wonderful thing to have, an understanding on such a deep level – why should they not have access to a similar thing if it can be done with technological aid?”
Annatar regarded the Rings in Celebrimbor’s palm. He was very still.
“The powers required for such Rings would be immense,” he said eventually. “No bearer who isn’t a powerful sorcerer would be able to do anything with them. To achieve the effect you desired, the bearer would have to be one of the Powers themselves.”
Celebrimbor nodded, turning one of the Rings between his fingers.
“But what if …” he said, trailing off.
Out of the corner of his eye, he saw Annatar shifting, leaning forward. His thoughts were racing, they were a clear, glittering brook leaping down a mountainside in summer, so fast that it turned to white-water. The idea, as he now realized, had been at the back of his mind for some time now. It had only needed the right circumstance to crystallize into clarity.
“But what if the power didn’t come from the bearer?” he said. “What if we – what if we tried to connect the Rings to the world itself?”
Annatar had seen his thoughts and his eyes widened. “The primordial powers of Arda – harnessed and focused, and returned to her...”
Celebrimbor looked up at Annatar. He knew they were thinking of the same: the world, but different. A veil pulled away, the fundaments of Arda laid bare; a world in which where all the courses and connections of power became apparent in their endless circular, reciprocal nature –
Earth. Fire. Air.
All his life he had wondered how his grandfather had done it when he had created the Silmarils during the noontide of Valinor, and now –
A tremor ran through him from top to toe, his heart clenching with something powerful. “If we opened the Rings, to the bearer and the world alike –”
“Yes,” Annatar said immediately, sliding forward on the windowsill. “It would work. Tyelperinquar, it would address every problem related to power that we have run into –” He cut himself off.
“I was right,” he said, slowly.
Celebrimbor looked up at him.
Annatar looked back as if he was seeing him for the first time. “I was right in coming to you, right in what I saw in you…”
He slid off the sill, took Celebrimor’s face in his hands and then Annatar was kissing him - wild, elated, unrestrained, with a burning fervour that made the sun itself pale in comparison.
He had acted without thinking.
While he could persuade himself towards spontaneity at times, his was a mind that was cautious and wary, weighing options for their possible benefits before undertaking them. After millions of years of existence, few things could startle or surprise him anymore. Even fewer managed to impress him. And nearly none left him frozen, thunderstruck with astonishment, when paths were opened to him and ideas were presented to him that he would not have arrived at on his own.
But in this moment – when the brilliance of Tyelperinquar’s mind had become apparent like a myriad-faceted diamond suddenly held into the sun – he had no longer thought. A fire had flared up within him – not of the body, but of the mind, speaking of his deepest essence that made him himself, for it was this part that Celebrimbor had spoken to.
It was a visceral yearning for freedom, boundlessness, for higher, better, further – and he had always believed himself alone in this. In a universe full of powers next to which even he paled into insignificance, he had never met someone with the same vision, the same drive, the same hunger –
He had believed himself alone, and then it was as if he had stepped in front of a mirror turned window, and instead of his own reflection there was someone else looking back at him – different, but the same in all the ways that counted, someone who could understand, who could dream, who would reach out and take –
When Annatar released Tyelperinquar, he stepped back. He felt untethered, off-balance, but in a way that made him think of a hawk plunging into the endless blue of the sky.
Celebrimbor, too, looked taken aback – but whether it had been the impulsive kiss or the fact that he was slowly realizing the momentous scope of his vision was impossible to tell.
For a while, neither of them spoke. The air still, and there was no sound save for the heavy, sped-up beating of Tyelperinquar’s pulse.
Celebrimbor looked down at the Rings, and Annatar watched him as the sun, at last, rounded the walls to illuminate the window, watched as it turned the edge of his dark hair and lashes golden, as the light flowed water-like over his form and his hands – and set him ablaze in a brilliance that nonetheless paled in comparison to the brilliance of the mind his body housed.
“With the limits of power removed –” Celebrimbor spoke haltingly, his eyes fixed on the Rings.
“They could do anything.”
“Yes,” Annatar replied.
Silence enveloped them. Sunlight flooded the room, erased the walls, the floor, the stone around them in a white blaze, leaving them in a timeless place suspended in air and light.
“This will be the greatest work we will ever create,” the Celebrimbor said slowly.
“Yes,” Annatar said, but they were speaking of different things.
Then Celebrimbor looked up, and his eyes were bright, so full of wonder, hope, and incredulous joy. “This is it, isn’t it?” he asked. “This is how we change the world.”
Annatar looked back. “No,” he said softly. “This how we tear down the old world, and build a new one of our own.”
Changed.
Remade.
More beautiful than ever before.
It begins now.
WELL, WHATEVER COULD GO WRONG WITH THAT I WONDER.
A few things I realized while writing this:
- I cannot, for the life of me, write sex scenes. I tried and it devolved into maths.
- I cannot, I reiterate, write sex scenes, because on top of my own catastrophic ineptitude, trying to steer Celebrimbor and Annatar into something remotely sensual was like trying to herd cats. Writing the first part was like a permanent state of "yes, yes get on with it, oh you're talking again, okay, you done? now go on, now kiss. oh jfc you're talking again, wait, are you arguing?! don't you dare start an argument now - oh, well now we're into sort of math-y abstract territory, okay, I guess you're doing an experiment now that might or might not leave either of you dead or lobotomized or shunted out of your bodies or worse, what kind of weird concept of attraction do you even have, oh okay, if you want to be like that, be like that I guess"
- Celebrimbor can see maths. I don't know what you call that type of synesthesia, but he has it.
- The orbital Annatar was thinking of is 4fz3, because of course it is.
- The last part of the fic is either really sweet or really horrifying, depending on whether you assume Annatar is being genuine or not
- Except for the creation of Rings without any power cap, which is always and in any iteration, terrifying beyond belief
- It is factually impossible to write those two having a conversation without the conversation having at least three additional layers under the surface, including but not limited to a) statements that sound cute but are terrifying, b) statements that sound cute until you think about who's saying them, and then they're suddenly terrifying, c) foreshadowing, or d) the reader's power of hindsight, which, again, makes a lot of things terrifying.