New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
How does Elwing find her way to the gates of Mandos? On the wings of an albatross, of course. The very wings that had miraculously sprouted beneath the waves, even as the water poured into her lungs, to lift her up and away from this place. It has taken Elwing the lifetime of her mortal son to finally make her way to the Halls — and she arrives alive.
Heir of Lúthien she may be, but she is no more allowed to cross into the realm of the formless than any other who still inhabits a body — be it bird or woman. So the Maiar at the gates inform her, and she stretches her great wings and laughs in a resonant whine.
“I came not to visit the dead,” she says, taking woman’s form, “but to visit the galleries of Vairë.”
The waifish Maiar do not speak for a long while, staring ahead. No one has seen Elwing in so long that even the timeless Ainur are wary of her presence.
“You are welcome to walk through the galleries, lady,” one of them says at length. “But see that you do not gaze too long upon the tapestries of Time. All that has been is depicted there: the mundane, the joyful; and the dark, the evil—”
“I know that,” says Elwing. “Why do you think I have come?”
The Maia betrays no offence at the interruption. Together, both extend their long arms, and the rock face opens. Elwing steps through.
The door shuts behind and stifling heat enfolds her. Immediately she is in a maze of fabric, layers upon layers of textile suspended from a ceiling too high to see. She must clear a path ahead with her arms. History brushes against her with every step. When she has got her bearings, she stops to look at one of the long hangings. The embroidery is impossibly intricate, row upon row of miniature mountains, castles, ships, and people no larger than a pinprick. She must tip her head sideways to follow the story as it unfolds up towards the ceiling, where it disappears, too high for her eyes to follow.
She will never find what she seeks this way.
“Greetings,” she calls out. “I am Elwing, daughter of Dior Thingol’s heir. I come seeking the true knowledge of things that came to pass before my time. Is there any servant of Vairë able to show the wife of Eärendil to the answers she seeks?”
Surely the walls of fabric will swallow all sound. She should have known: the realms of the Valar are ever obscure. She remembers the dizzying circle of the Máhanaxar, the way the thrones of the Valar seemed to spin around them and blur in the haze that rose from the smooth glass floor. Elwing wipes the sweat from her brow and pushes onwards.
Not long after, a voice penetrates the heavy quiet: “Ah, there you are,” it says. “Welcome, child of Melian.” The woman emerges from the dense cascades of fabric, which force them into close proximity. Elwing shrinks into the tapestries and looks down at the smaller woman. “You should know better than to introduce yourself by the lineage of your fathers in the halls of Vairë,” the woman says. “We have no fathers here, nor sons.”
“Hello,” says Elwing. “Thank you for coming to my aid, my lady. May I know what to call you?”
The woman quirks her lips. “Know that I am a broideress. Those is the service of Vairë use no names.” The woman takes both Elwing’s hands in hers. They are small and delicate, scarce larger than a child’s. “Now, what answers do you seek, Elwing daughter of Nimloth?”
Elwing is taken aback. With a lineage as great as hers, she cannot recall ever being defined in relation to her mother. It opens new pathways in her mind. Now she is here, among all the history of Arda, with a guide, she wonders if there are not other stories she ought to seek. Lesser known histories, like her mother’s.
But she stays her course. “I wish to see the childhood of Fëanor.”
Her guide laughs, a little ruefully, and twists her head to the side. As she does, Elwing glimpses, trailing from beneath her headscarf, a long silver braid.
“Why, that history is well known!” the woman says. “The prodigy. The boy without a mother, whose father loved him overmuch. Marred by the death that marked his birth.” She pats Elwing’s hand reassuringly. “Look not so dismayed. Most who come here wish to revisit the well-trodden stories. I do not judge you for it. After all, they are the stories that time most distorts. Do you know, those who style themselves historians almost never visit these galleries? They might! They might freely peruse every moment, every detail, exactly as it fell out. But they think they know better. Ah, but their accounts are from direct observation, they say. If not their own, then another's who was there. The source of our knowledge is too intangible, too arcane. We do not operate in the realm of the real. Would they say aloud that they do not trust us? No, that would be blasphemy. But they do not come here, and that speaks loudly enough of their opinion of Vairë’s tapestries. So I praise you, Elwing, for coming here. You are a truer historian than many.”
“Thank you,” says Elwing. The woman’s bold and assured manner has rendered Elwing timid, a state unfamiliar to one who was forced to learn the habits of a queen from an early age. Her guide inhabits the space with such ease, speaks with such authority, that Elwing wonders if she is not Vairë herself in the guise of one of the Eldar.
“So, tell me,” says the woman, taking her by the hand and guiding her through the fabrics, “why do you wish to see the childhood of Fëanor? Do not tell me you hope to discover the secret of the fire that made him the greatest creator the Eldar shall ever know — you do not seem the type. You would not be the first, though.” The woman glances over her shoulder, smiling conspiratorially. “The historians don’t come here, but the craftsmen do. But there are some things not even the Valar know.”
“No,” Elwing confirms, “I have no interest in his craft.” The woman huffs. “Meaning no disrespect.” The inhabitants of Aman have strange and irreconcilable views on the legacy of Fëanor that Elwing has no interest in untangling. “I wish to know the origins of his discontent.”
“Arda Marred.” The woman stops abruptly, turning on her. Then she breaks into a rueful laugh. She clasps Elwing’s shoulders, slides cool fingers down her arms. The moment extends, heavy with unfamiliar feeling. “Wouldn’t you rather know how the tapestries depict your own choice?”
Elwing flinches. The woman’s small hand is unexpectedly strong, tightening as Elwing attempts to withdraw. “What?”
“You, too, left your children — and to a world far darker than the one in which I left my son.”
The defensive heat rising in answer to the first statement gives way to a rush of confusion, then embarrassment. “Broideress,” she whispers, then, “Míriel. I am sorry, I— I did not know. I did not remember that you— that you had returned.”
Míriel smiles. “It would not hurt to read some of the histories, dear. Though they make little of my second life. It mars the neatness of the tale somewhat, doesn’t it? I suppose we share that, too. Aman does not know what to do with mothers who dared to die. Did you choose to live in your tower, Elwing?”
“Yes, I chose it…” Elwing’s cheeks are hot with shame and something else. She swipes away tears she had not even realised were there. “But, Míriel: I do not think— I have never thought that you are to blame.”
“You lie,” says Míriel, but kindly. “You may speak truth to me, child, for I know it all already.” A whine of grief rises in Elwing’s throat. “Sh, sh,” Míriel consoles, and pulls her into an embrace. She strokes her hair, settling her palm at the nape of Elwing’s neck. Elwing sobs. The tapestries ripple in an impossible breeze, brushing at her back, her ankles, as though they, too, had hands with which to comfort.
At last, Míriel slips from Elwing’s clinging arms and takes her gently by the chin. “I do not think it is Fëanor you wish to see. Nor is it your own son, lately gone from the world. Elros suffered, yes, but Elros had great joy, also, and established a great kingdom of men. His descendants will reshape the world. The world suffered for Fëanor’s suffering, but from his discontent and his foreboding was the unsullied light preserved and the downfall of Morgoth achieved. You see? No moment of a life exists in isolation. No choice is altogether wrong, but nor is it altogether right.”
Elwing has fallen into astonished silence. Míriel reaches her neck high and touches her lips to Elwing’s “And some choices,” she whispers, “are not choices at all.” She lowers back to her heels, and Elwing’s skin prickles in the absence of her touch. “It is a heavy burden you carry, and one that does not belong to you. Come,” she takes her by the hand, “I will draw it from you.”
The storied curtains give way, fluttering and disappearing into the warp of time and space. A great circle shimmers into view on the floor. It appears solid, but Elwing knows: one step, and she would plunge through the surface, for it is a basin of water sunken in the ground. Reflecting its surrounds, it reveals nothing of its self. Elwing rocks onto her heels and reaches for Míriel’s hand. But the Broideress is gone.
“Míriel?” Elwing whimpers, and stifles the sound with a palm against her mouth. She turns, seeking. Her eyes catch on a ripple in the water’s surface, then white feet wading in.
“It is not deep,” Míriel’s voice reassures her. Elwing scans the length of her legs. Míriel, whose prior garments Elwing cannot recall, is dressed now in no more than a pale blue sash that slants down from one hip, exposing the bony curve of the other. Her stomach, by contrast, is soft and round, gathering in a small roll beneath her abdomen. Another length of fabric criss-crosses her chest and finishes in a knot behind her neck. The narrow strip of cloth leaves little to be imagined of her breasts, pendulous and exposed on either side of her sternum.
Elwing swallows. She has never been with a woman — only admired her own form, for Elwing’s most frequent lover has always been herself. She is not like Míriel: round hips where Míriel’s are square; a hard, flat stomach where Míriel’s curves; small, taut breasts where Míriel’s are ample and yielding; skin like brown sand sea-moistened, where Míriel’s glistens white. Elwing wonders if it burns, as bright things so often do.
“What is this place?” Elwing asks, after far too long a pause. Míriel is already thigh-deep in the water.
“My favourite feature of Vairë’s halls.” Míriel drags her fingertips across the water’s surface and looks to the ceiling.
“But won’t the water damage the textiles?” Elwing asks, rather stupidly, for why would anything decay in the home of a Valië?
Míriel laughs, but not with mockery. “Come into the water with me, Elwing. You are named for a fall of water, are you not?”
Of course Elwing need not answer, for Míriel knows all already; has received, in whatever way history transmits itself to the looms of Vairë, every moment of her life. The quotidian, the terrible, the shameful. The private, the intimate.
“What will I see there?”
“See?” Míriel’s brows arc up her forehead. Wisps of silver, freed from her braid, curl around her face in the humid warmth. “No, you will not see. You will become. Return to the water that made you. The story of the world lives in the water — yes, you understand now. That is how we hear it. Come in. Let the story see you.”
Still clothed, Elwing wades in. The hem of her skirt drags, pulling it taut against her body, and she feels herself exposed. Míriel’s eyes slide up and down, taking in her form; but Elwing sees no shade of possessiveness in her gaze, of the sort she has come to expect from nearly every man who looks upon her, even as they must have gazed upon her foremother; yes, even so did Beren look on Lúthien, and even so does Eärendil look on Elwing, and even if it excites her to see it in her husband’s eyes, it is there — but not so with Míriel. Míriel’s desire exudes compassion, and generosity. A twinge of grief tangles in Elwing’s throat: how she has needed this.
Míriel invites her to take off her garments, and Elwing does. As they fall away, she is aware of the fierce heat pooled between her thighs. She cups her own breasts on instinct, enjoying how they have swollen in answer to her arousal.
Míriel sighs appreciatively. “You are so beautiful.” She holds out her arms. “Come. Let me touch you. May I touch you?”
“Yes,” Elwing murmurs. She dives into the water and lets the momentum carry her into Míriel’s arms; to Míriel’s lips. She kisses her, warm and damp, and Elwing gasps into Míriel’s parted lips when their breasts collide beneath the water. How wonderful, the feeling of another woman’s body against hers. Míriel still wears the scarf about her chest, and Elwing pushes a hand beneath it, drawing it aside. She pulls back from nipping at Míriel’s lips to admire her, and dips down to kiss instead the full and heavy weight of Míriel’s tits.
“Ah!” Míriel sighs. Encouraged, Elwing flicks her tongue across the peak of a hardened nipple, and rolls her thumb over the other. She would have imagined it to be little different from touching herself, but oh, it is nothing like! Touching Míriel, being touched by her (for nimble fingers chase teasing pathways down Elwing’s spine), has all the excitement, all the pleasures both unexpected and familiar that Elwing experiences with Eärendil — yet more. For Míriel knows her in ways even he, her husband and friend from childhood, never can: as a woman, yes, but also as witness to her life’s story. Though they have not met until this day, Míriel has seen every moment of Elwing’s existence, knows her doubt and pain and regret — and desires her despite it.
She guides Elwing to the rim of the pool and buoys her up to sit in the shallows. The water laps against Elwing’s swelling sex.
“There, there,” Míriel soothes. With cupped palms she guides the water to tickle and tease. Elwing’s knees fall open, and Míriel spreads them wide so she can kneel between. She kisses Elwing’s mouth, butterfly-soft, trails over her chest, nipping at her breasts, ghosts over her stomach, and stirs the hairs between her legs with her breath.
Elwing cannot keep her hand from tangling in Míriel’s damp silver strands. Míriel seems not to mind: her tongue flicks at Elwing’s clit, brief but bright as a star that shoots across the sky. Elwing whimpers, thighs already trembling of their own accord. Míriel’s tongue reaches, circling where Elwing throbs beneath her folds, then flattens, broad and strong against the whole. She stays there, hands caressing Elwing’s calves and thighs, soothing the trembling from her muscles.
Elwing releases Míriel; leans back on her hands. Her head tips back; her eyes close. Her hips roll slow and deliberate against Míriel’s mouth. The cavernous room throws back her moans like music. No — there is music: bright, triumphant, admiring.
Míriel’s hand glides up Elwing’s wet body to fondle at her chest. Such clever hands, such a clever mouth. When Míriel hums appreciatively, Elwing is aware that she has uttered the praises aloud. And why not? She showers her with more, and feels them returned with every glide of Míriel’s mouth over her sex.
She is coming close, and tells Míriel so. So Míriel holds still, suckling gently at the sensitive bud where all her pleasure is gathered. Elwing’s body spasms, clenching towards that hot centre, clenching again. Míriel pops her mouth off, igniting a last burst of ecstasy, and Elwing’s elbows give out as she unravels.
When she gathers her breath, she finds Míriel’s body draped around hers, one hand pillowing the back of Elwing’s skull, the other cupping her breast. Her thigh rests across Elwing’s hips, and Elwing can feel the heat between her lover’s legs. She tilts her head, seeking her lips, and fumbles her hand between Míriel’s thighs.
With a shushing, Míriel gently deflects her hand, instead clasping it in her own and lifting it to point with her at the dark bowl overhead. A tapestry descends. Elwing watches entranced. As it falls nearer to the floor, Elwing untangles herself from Míriel to stand and walk towards it. She gasps at the image before her; tears prick the backs of her eyes and spill a blurry screen across her vision. It is her, naked and beautiful, resting upon a bed of clover and buttercup. Silver willow branches sway above her sleeping form.
Míriel has come up behind her and now circles arms about her waist. “What is it?”
“You, of course.” Míriel kisses her shoulder. “At rest.”
“But why?” Elwing studies the picture, scanning for details that might reveal its meaning to her.
“Because you have earned your rest, Elwing. And you desire it. I saw it in you.”
“No, no.” Elwing shakes her head, tensing in Míriel’s arms. “I chose the life of the Firstborn and I would not go back on my choice even if I could.”
“Dearest,” says Míriel, and guides her to turn and face her. “I am not inviting you to die. Only to rest.”
She kisses Elwing’s neck, gathering her once again in her arms, and the two women kiss before the portrait of Elwing at rest in the gardens of Lórien.