Spared, But Not In Mercy by polutropos  

| | |

Fanwork Notes

Originally posted to AO3 January 2026 for Silmarillion Stocking, in response to a prompt by Lorinand_Lost.

Fanwork Information

Summary:

Alone and lost in the wilderness after the disastrous encounter with Glaurung, Mablung is desperate to find signs of life in she whom he has loved from afar.

Major Characters: Mablung, Nienor

Major Relationships: Mablung/Nienor

Genre: General, Het

Challenges:

Rating: Adult

Warnings: Rape/Nonconsensual Sex, Sexual Content (Graphic)

Chapters: 1 Word Count: 2, 280
Posted on Updated on

This fanwork is complete.

Spared, But Not In Mercy

Content warning clarification: The sex act in this fic takes place during Nienor's period of being unresponsive while under Glaurung's spell and therefore she is unable to consent. Mablung does not premeditate rape and does not use any coercion or violence.

Read Spared, But Not In Mercy

'Not for nothing did I dread this errand,' he said. 'For it will be my last, it seems. With this unlucky child of Men I shall perish in the wilderness, and my name shall be held in scorn in Doriath: if any tidings indeed are ever heard of our fate. All else doubtless are slain, and she alone spared, but not in mercy.'

“Won’t you rest?” Mablung said wearily, but with care. Nienor sat upon the damp ground, legs crossed, knees flat to the earth. He wondered that she held herself upright at all, for all strength seemed to have left her body.

Her hand lay limp in her lap; gently, Mablung lifted it. “Please.” She stared ahead, blinking only when the dryness of her eyes drew forth tears.

For three days, she had taken no food, no sleep. Water Mablung had to pour between her lips and close her jaw, else it would dribble, wasted, from her mouth. He did so now, and she gagged and thrashed as though she would choke. Mablung pat her back, a gesture that seemed to remind her body to swallow.

A desperate swell of pity stilled Mablung’s hand on her back. Strands of golden hair had come loose from her braid. One clung to the moisture on her lips and, unthinking, Mablung pulled it aside and tucked it behind an ear. He wound it loosely around his finger; as he drew it down, unravelling, his gloved knuckles grazed the tough canvas of the marchwarden’s tabard she still wore.

Abruptly, he fell back on his heels. He had no right to touch her so, who had no capacity to respond or speak. Worse that he loved her; had long loved her, in secret and from afar. Had he known she would join the company sent to follow after Morwen, he would have refused the errand, for honour.

Now they were alone, and like to perish together without Nienor ever knowing how he cared for her. Oh, that he had never kept his love from her! What was honour, what was it to love a second time when one’s spouse lingered, bodiless, in Halls inaccessible across the Sea; when doom widened, a great gaping hole, beneath one’s feet?

He might have brought joy to her sorrowful heart — or at the least he might have tried. Now, with death nigh, and hers forever, all that had kept him from revealing his heart to her seemed meaningless; selfish, even, to withhold such a depth of feeling from another, whether returned or not.

He could care for her. That, at least, he could do. He rocked forwards again, coming to kneel, and set his hands upon her shoulders, guided her to lie upon the ground. She went, pliant as a reed, and lay flat with legs still crossed. Clasping one ankle and then the other, Mablung unwound her limbs and stretched her out to rest. He spread a blanket on the ground beside her and, carefully, rolled her onto her side, away from himself, to lie upon it. Then he removed his cloak and draped it over her. Her eyes stared into the dark, still wide and unseeing. Should he guide her lids to cover them? Even so had he put to rest many a slain comrade. What if he shut her eyes and so they remained forever? A shiver he knew as the fear of death ran through him.

But would it not be a mercy?

Would it not be what she would want?

He could not know what she would want. So he left her, eyes wide open, seeing nothing — or perhaps seeing untold horrors placed in her mind by the worm of Morgoth. The dread voice of the dragon, his suffocating stench, yet stuck in Mablung’s memory, rising now and then as a bolt of terror so acute it were as though Glaurung were there again, breaking the tumbled stones of Nargothrond to shards with his mighty voice.

Mablung shuddered. He stretched out on the ground behind Nienor, and, for the first time since he had spent his nights beside her, he closed the space between them. All the weariness of the past days overcame him and he sank at once into a still and dreamless sleep.

Spreading heat stirred him awake. He thought he felt blood spilling from without and his heart drummed in horror; but he was leaden with the grip of sleep. He could scarcely drag himself upright from the ground. When he did, his thoughts assembling, he became aware that the heat flowed outward from his person; the blood rushed within, towards his centre. He was hard. Painfully so, like a youth first learning the functions of his form. He pressed his hand against the heat and throbbing, as though he could tamp it out, but it only quickened his arousal.

Nienor lay still where he had left her. Mablung scrambled away, clapping a hand over his eyes to keep them from straying to the curve of her hips. What had possessed him to lie so near! He cursed the betrayal of his flesh, fell to his knees and, lacking water, dragged fistfuls of pine needles and dirt across his face to scrape away the shame and lust heating his cheeks.

A hand was on his back — so gentle he did not even think to fear. He turned: there was Nienor kneeling, her expressionless face but a few inches from his own.

Forgetting for a moment the agony of his shame, Mablung rejoiced. She had moved! Of her own will, she had come to him! Then his gut twisted: for she had reached for him, and his flesh warmed where her fingertips brushed the bare skin of his neck. He took her by the wrist and guided her hand away.

But she knelt back, not taking her eyes from him, and lifted her tabard over her head. Then she worked the ties of her tunic. Mablung should have stopped her. But how? By force? She was no meek maiden. She was every bit the warrior in whose trappings she had disguised herself. Slowly, the swell of two full breasts emerged beneath her man’s clothing. Mablung’s breath caught.

“Nienor, no,” he begged.

She seemed not to hear him, and exposed herself fully to him. Her large brown nipples hardened to a peak in the cool air. As she bent forward onto hands in knees, her breasts hung like ripe fruit between her arms. She only had to crawl a foot or two before she was over his lap, winding her muscled legs around him, and grinding against his hardness.

His heart beat in his throat and pulsed in his cock. He could not have moved even if he had wanted to, so overcome was he with warring impulses: to seize, to flee, to fight. He breathed. This was best. To do nothing. To let her use him thus; to let her touch him as she willed. So long as he did not return her touch, he may yet be able to live to forgive himself. If he lived at all.

If they lived. Oh, what he would give to look into the dark pit of his doom and see what was written there. If they were to die by morning, were it not good that her brief life should end in pleasure? That his last hours in this corporeal form should be spent in ecstasy? But he did not know, and so he could not touch her.

She wrapped her arms tightly about his shoulders, pressing her breasts to his chest and rocking. Not a sound escaped her lips to confirm the pleasure suggested by the vigorous motion of her body. Then one hand snaked between their bodies to work at the fastenings of his breeches. She was a powerful woman, tall and strong, and her weight bearing down over Mablung’s thighs would have taken great force to cast off.

She freed him, closing a graceless fist around his cock. He felt a trickle of moisture gather on his collarbone, where she had lodged her head against his shoulder.

“Nienor…” he whispered. Forgetting his vow to keep from touching her, he hooked a hand under her chin and guided her face to where he could look upon her. She wept. At once tears sprang to his own eyes, seeing this certain sign of feeling in hers. His thoughts scrambled and sped off shrieking like a hundred birds scared from the branches of a tree. He kissed her, full upon the mouth. His parched lips chafed against hers, but they parted for him. Her tongue darted out, inviting him to answer. He did. His hand fell between their bodies, twining with hers around his shaft, and he bucked into the circle of their joined fingers. Fluid, slick and warm, leaked from his head and over his hand.

No, this was not right. It was she who ought to have her fill of pleasure. He broke their kiss, stooping to tongue at her breast, then suck upon her nipple as he made quick work of the laces on her breeches. He slid his hand through the thatch of her hair, until his fingertip came upon the slick pooled around her opening. He stopped himself. Had he become a beast? She had in nowise invited him here. So he pulled his hand from between her thighs, and rested back on his heels, panting. He had gone too far.

But Nienor mounted him. She shuffled her breeches down over the curve of her hips and settled above him. With her own hand, she lined him up to her entrance, and slid fluidly onto his cock. Mablung cried out; for it had been a thousand years or more since he had felt the tight, warm clutch of a woman’s body around his.

“Nienor, I love thee,” he moaned, revealing himself for the first time and mayhap the last. Let it be the last, he prayed, as she rode him, vigorous as a man in the fullness of his youth. Let me die in bliss and never wake to know a world after this, he thought, eyes fluttering shut. Mablung had known too much of sorrow and death. Let this be his last hour incarnate. Show mercy, Ilúvatar, on one who has suffered overmuch.

Nienor said no word in answer. Made no sound; only the slap of her flesh descending over Mablung’s thighs, the slick pop when she nearly slid off him in her body’s eagerness.

Pleasure bundled tight in Mablung’s loins, drawing up like a spring; and then burst, bright white, as his seed spilled into Nienor’s body. The shock of his pleasure rolled through him, a sharp bliss — and then nausea. The sickening realisation that Nienor’s body had gone limp around him, such that his seed dripped from her gaping hole. She sat over him, just as she had sat upon the ground before he lay her to rest. All pleasure was gone from her face, her body, if it had ever been there at all.

Mablung cried in agony, and threw her from him. She rolled into a heap on the ground like a lifeless doll.

“No!” Mablung tore at his hair. “What have I done? Oh, beloved Nienor, what have I done? I have defiled thee.” He crawled to her, afraid to touch her but unable to leave her so exposed. “I am monstrous.” He pulled her breeches up around her waist and tied her tunic closed over her chest. “I have killed thee,” he whispered. “I have killed thee.”

Whether by their crooked, corrupting union or by tarrying when the dragon ventured out of Nargothrond, he had ruined and destroyed he whom he loved. He would lay crime upon crime and slay himself, if he could. But Nienor breathed. Defiled and dumb as she was, she breathed. His heart was cold; he was too sick to weep. Numbly, he arranged his own clothing and stood.

“Come.” He stooped to clasp Nienor’s hand and pulled her to her feet. “No more rest will I find tonight. We will journey onwards.” Then, in a whisper: “May the darkness swallow us at last.”


Mablung collapsed with weariness, drawing Nienor down next to him, just as the sky was beginning to soften to grey.

There he was found by three of his comrades who had escaped the wrack and bewilderment of Glaurung. They shook him awake, rejoicing to find him and Nienor living. Their joy soon hollowed to see what had become of Morwen’s proud daughter.

Companionship on their travels kindled hope: they persevered. They were upon the borders of Doriath when the orcs surprised them. For the second time since her enspelling, Mablung witnessed life spring into Nienor’s limbs. Terrible, terrified: running, rending her clothes, and running, and running, faster than any child of Men ought to be able to run without the aid of some possessing power. And indeed, it was so. She ran, hot with the poison of Glaurung in whose wicked schemes Mablung had been ensnared.

Nay — not so. The dragon had but drawn the poison from a canker in Mablung’s soul; made him instrument of her destruction, but not innocent. She was gone, and he was disgraced.

Nonetheless Mablung would not rest, and with a small company he went into the wild and for three years wandered far, from Ered Wethrin even to the Mouths of Sirion, seeking for sign or tidings of the lost.
- The Children of Húrin


Leave a Comment