Better Than Talking by polutropos
Fanwork Notes
Originally posted to AO3 January 2026 for Silmarillion Stocking, in response to a prompt by unendingwanderlust.
- Fanwork Information
-
Summary:
Glorfindel finds his ex on the beach.
Major Characters: Glorfindel, Maglor
Major Relationships: Glorfindel/Maglor
Genre: Slash
Challenges:
Rating: Teens
Warnings: Sexual Content (Mild)
Chapters: 1 Word Count: 835 Posted on Updated on This fanwork is complete.
Better Than Talking
Read Better Than Talking
“I was on an errand to the Havens in any case,” says Glorfindel. “Looking for you was something to do. I was not made for peace times — terribly boring. Besides, you weren’t that hard to find.”
Maglor gives his shoulder a friendly punch. “That wasn’t what you said when you found me, dripping wet, hair like a sodden mop. What was it you shouted over the storm? ‘You fucking cryptid freak! Of course you would choose the most miserable, uninhabitable stretch of coastline!’” He pulls a long drag from his pipe, at which Glorfindel scoffs. Disgusting habit. Damn the wizard. “You might have packed something more resistant to the elements.”
“I did,” Glorfindel protests. “Only some trickster stole my pack.”
Maglor cackles uncharitably. “I told you not to take that personally. I do that to all travellers who cross my path. They almost always turn back when they’ve lost their belongings. You understand: I can’t risk being found by just anyone.”
“And it cannot hurt to acquire their small bounty, destitute as you are.”
Maglor ignores him. “You, of course, persisted against all sense.”
“Incorrect. I persisted because I have exceptional sense: the sense that my stolen pack meant someone else was near, and that someone did not fear to provoke the wrath of a great warrior.”
“Hm!” Maglor grunts. He sets his pipe on the log behind them. His expression turns thoughtful. They’ve bantered and bickered this way ever since recovering from the initial shock that first miserable night when Glorfindel finally discovered his hiding place in a crevice halfway up the cliffs. Where do you even begin, after five thousand years, one certain death, and another presumed?
“I admit you were the last person I expected my pursuer to be,” Maglor confides.
“Understandable, given that I was dead.”
Maglor shakes his head. “No, Olórin told me you were back.” Damn the wizard! Glorfindel thinks for the second time in as many minutes. He had not considered that Mithrandir’s information on the (general) whereabouts of his once-husband was knowledge shared by both parties. “I think he hoped I would go looking for you. Wanted me to make myself useful in the war or something of the sort. Told me of all your great deeds.”
“I am sure you were duly impressed.”
“Not at all.” Maglor tuts. “Typical Amanyarin stuff. But why did they only send one of you? They sent legions for Morgoth.”
“Because I was the only one who wanted to come. I had unfinished business in Middle-earth.” Glorfindel shifts a little, lets his hand fall onto the cool sand as an invitation. He turns a soft gaze Maglor’s way.
Maglor flinches and stares at him like a stupefied cat. “What? You did not come for me.”
“What if I told you I did?” Glorfindel leans closer.
“Stop. Don’t be ridiculous. You haven’t had a single affectionate thought about me since before the first Sunrise.”
“That’s true,” Glorfindel says, giving up the act.
Almost true: for a decade, give or take, after their final separation at Mithrim, Glorfindel hated his husband. For the ensuing lifetime, he all but forgot about him; he hated him again when word of Doriath’s fall reached Gondolin. Fortunately he didn’t live to witness the worst of his deeds, and by the time he was brought back, well: it was so long ago, and Glorfindel too enlightened by his time spent dead to succumb to such unhelpful emotions as anger. These past few days, though, he has felt a kind of affection for the ragged-edged remains of Maglor son of Fëanor.
“Did you ever think of me?” Glorfindel asks, and is surprised to hear himself say it.
“Sometimes,” says Maglor. “Mostly to compare my love for you to another.”
“Ouch,” says Glorfindel, who had done the same.
“I think we would have ended up estranged even if none of the rest of it had happened.” Glorfindel feels Maglor’s eyes on him, and turns to face him. “Strange, isn’t it? How tragedy only expedites that which would have come to pass regardless.”
Glorfindel isn’t sure he agrees with that sentiment. He isn’t sure he understands quite what it means. What he is sure of is that the sun is setting behind him, and the golden light on Maglor’s face, on the curve of his neck, on his forearms exposed by rolled-up sleeves, is adding heat to the stirrings of affection.
“Is that so?” Glorfindel asks, leaning in so close he can feel Maglor’s breath on his lips. “Do you think this would have come to pass regardless?”
“Oh, fuck you,” says Maglor, and yanks him even closer. Their thighs, stretched down the sand, press together.
“Please,” Glorfindel groans, and bites hungrily at Maglor’s lip. Ah, yes, he thinks, as the fog of pleasure closes around his mind: this is much better than talking about it.