New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Fell Fire: it was a strange name to give a prince of Noldor in the Noontide of the Blessed Realm. But, then, Eärwen of Alqualondë was known for her eccentricities. The Swanmaiden who would sooner dance naked in the waves with the common-folk than pin a chiton across her lovely shoulders and see to the duties attendant on Olwë’s eldest child; who preferred to set her strong hands to the cutting and shaping of wood and the building of great hulls than to the delicate and womanly work of sewing sails.
It was no doubt what drew my father to her.
Aikanáro, she called me.
Well: Eärwen was not a Noldo. The Swanmaiden was a strange woman. Perhaps she did not know.
Yes, that must be it. She simply did not know. Silly bird.
A princess of two peoples, no one dared tell her: not since Míriel had anyone placed fire in a child’s name.
They did not need to. My mother knew.
So did my father.
But oh, dear Mother, did you know that you had doomed me with that name?
It was not your name, child, that made you choose as you did.
I did not choose to be born, Mother.
A long silence.
You might at least have let me live in ignorance of who I am.
Your father would never have allowed it.
See? You, too, were powerless against the force of his will. Fire consumes, Mother. It takes all into itself.
Even so. You had a choice.
They were my brothers.
When your brothers chose to kill my kindred you stayed your hand. Why?
They were my kindred, too, Mother. Do you think me a monster?
He did. I was exiled at last from the love of my father and his children for choosing you and yours.
Are my children not your brethren also?
That they are, Mother. Your grandson even named his child for me: Artanáro.
Poor Artaresto. He did not know.
The Halls hum their everlasting hum. The last note of Creation, reverberating on and on and on; the first note of the Last Music, softly slumbering, awaiting the cue to resound.
At length, my mother speaks again.
They say you loved a mortal woman.
That I did.
And you will remain in the Halls forever in longing for her.
Is that what they say of me?
I would weep, if I had eyes to do so. Instead, my spirit rages; leaps, flares; for I am a spirit of wrath. A spirit of fire.
Forgive me, Andreth, dearest. I loved thee, but I loved thy freedom more. I loved thy Gift. It is unjust that thou shouldst be held the cause of my fate.
I swore.
Swore, child? What did you swear?
With Manwë and Varda as witness, by the One. To the Everlasting Darkness doom us, if our deed faileth. I took my father’s oath, Mother.
Humming.
Mother, do you understand?
I cannot return, even if I willed it.
But she is gone, if ever she was there.
Is it the fate of all Fëanor’s sons, I wonder, to endure their endless awaiting utterly alone? Or has the Doomsman set aside a special holding place for me, Fell Fire, ill-gotten and unloved?
This concept of Aegnor as a bastard child of Earwen and Feanor came from discussion with Melesta and Leethevix.