Myth by polutropos  

| | |

Fanwork Notes

Originally posted to AO3 June 2025.

Fanwork Information

Summary:

A woman becomes a bird, a man becomes a star, and the world is saved.

Or... not. An alternate history of Elwing and Eärendil.

Major Characters: Eärendil

Major Relationships: Eärendil/Elwing

Genre: General

Challenges:

Rating: General

Warnings:

Chapters: 1 Word Count: 238
Posted on Updated on

This fanwork is complete.

Myth

Read Myth

It’s a seal, Eärendil tells himself, absurdly, frantically, as Vingilot approaches the shoreline. A seal, serene and satiated, taking her repose on the rocks. But Sirion is in ruins, and something glows beneath the moveless form.

In leaden silence, Eärendil rolls his wife onto her back. The Silmaril washes his vision white, blinds him to her face. He yanks it from her neck and her head snaps forward with the force of it; lolls back lifeless. Eärendil screams: regret and rage and grief so grand it might swallow him.

When he stands at last, it is with a star upon his brow and vengeance burning in his breast. He sets a westward course.

Eärendil’s demand for recompense never reaches the ears of the Valar. For he dies alone in the empty streets of Tirion, feet scored and bloody from the diamond dusted streets no mortal was meant to tread.

The Silmaril has returned to the land of its creation. Eönwë bears it to the King and Queen of Arda.

Varda sets it to sail the skies; calls it a sign of hope.

In Endor, the armies of the West with their golden banners allow the lie to take root; myth spreads like wildflowers in a scorched land, and the hearts of the Exiles are lifted up.

And is it not right that it should be so? Have they not suffered enough?


Leave a Comment