For Unwittingly I Have Become Your Doom by Erdariel  

| | |

For Unwittingly I Have Become Your Doom


The cell stank of blood. Faintly somewhere in the back of their minds they were all beginning to understand that they would live the rest of their brief lives with that smell constantly in their noses. Finrod stared at the mangled corpse in the far corner of the cell. At least the head, limbs, and torso were all still attached to each other, torn and broken though they were. It was some small dignity, in a way.

For a long time none of them could bear to speak. They sat, mute with horror, each alone.

In the silence the sounds of their breathing were harsh. There was also the rattling of chains, not very loud but constant, an occasional harsher clang keeping it from being forgotten as background noise.

It was Beren. He sat a little apart, huddled with his knees drawn up to his chest, and shivered so that the chains that bound him rattled. He had been shivering, Finrod realized, since before the wolf had come for Lothdal, and had never stopped. The cold was getting to him again.

It was cold enough in the dungeons to be uncomfortable even to the elves; Finrod had found himself sleeping fitfully and dreaming of snow more often than he cared to admit. But it was still only a discomfort to him, no worse, and could be endured. It was not so harmless to mortals. The dungeon was cold enough to make a mortal man sick, given enough time. Maybe even cold enough to kill. Finrod had done his best to aid Beren against it, but he did not know how much time that could buy. All he could do was keep trying and hope it would be enough.

“Beren”, he called softly. “Beren!”

Beren lifted his head slowly and turned it in Finrod’s direction. He squinted at the darkness that was almost impenetrable to his eyes, but said nothing.

“Come here”, Finrod murmured, reaching out his hand in the darkness, though Beren could not see it.

Beren stood, movements slow and stiff. Sauron had had him out of the cell for a while earlier that day, and when he had come back he had not allowed Finrod or any other to see if anything could be done for his newest set of injuries. Finrod watched him carefully now, trying to guess which signs of pain in his movements told of some new hurt and which were old.

Edrahil was there before Beren had moved more than two steps, taking his hand, guiding him in the darkness so he did not step on anyone or trip on their tangled chains that lay all across the floor. A look of stung pride flashed across Beren’s face, but he swallowed it without a word and allowed himself to be led. Edrahil’s hands were sticky with blood; his own, trickling down from wounds the bonds had dug into his wrists when he had pulled at them in vain to go to Lothdal’s aid. Now it got all over Beren’s hands, but if the man noticed, he said nothing of it.

Beren sat down next to Finrod. This close, he could see something: the faint shape of the body, a hint of the gold-gleam of hair, the glow of light in Finrod’s eyes that neither Middle-Earth nor even Sauron’s darkness had wholly extinguished. Finrod, too, could see what darkness had obscured before. A thick band of bruises circled Beren’s neck. His hair was thoroughly damp, in places still wet enough to cling to his skin. Blood was soaking in patches through the back of his shirt.

The look Beren gave Finrod was tired, resigned, apologetic. His eyes were dull, the bold and proud fire of Bëor’s kin only smouldering now. Some wounds went soul-deep, and Sauron knew all too well how to inflict those.

“You are cold”, Finrod murmured, as he had done before, shifting closer to Beren, reaching his arm around his shoulder to bring him closer. “Let me…”

Beren turned his face away. He sat still as stone, refusing the invitation.

“Come now. What is it? What is wrong?”

“You should not… should not touch me.” Beren’s voice was quiet and very hoarse. “You… I do not deserve it.”

“You need the warmth.”

“I do not deserve it”, Beren repeated, trying to draw away from Finrod.

“What are you talking about?”

“You know why.”

“No, Beren, I do not understand. What do you mean?”

With a pained sound Beren shoved Finrod’s arm away. He collapsed into a heap on the floor, face buried in his arms.

“This… all because of me!” he choked as if the words burned not only his raw throat but also his soul. “Your doom..!”

“Beren, Beren—” Finrod’s hands hovered over the whipped back, the bruised neck, before finally one hand settled onto the tangled hair “—I was doomed from the moment my father turned back on the road and I did not. If you brought me to my doom, it was only as an instrument of that which was already inevitable; the doom was not of your making.”

“But you— this darkness, this torment… none of you would be here if I had not asked! I could have… I should have… so arrogant!”

“Look up, let me see your face”, Finrod murmured gently.

Beren rolled to his side and turned his head toward Finrod. Their eyes met, Beren’s instinctively fixing on the two points of light in the darkness. His face was drawn with anguish, but his eyes were dry; he was far beyond tears. Finrod traced a hand along the bony cheek, flushed hot with emotion even as Beren still shivered with cold.

“What did Sauron say to you, when you were alone? What did he put into your mind?” Finrod whispered. “Do not believe him. Whatever it was he told you, you know he is a liar! He only means to trick you or crush your will. Beren, do not give him that satisfaction!”

He drew Beren into his arms and held him against his chest. Beren did not resist, but he held himself stiffly, seeming to accept no comfort from the gesture.

“But it was not him. I knew, I always knew, even before I came to you I knew”, said Beren miserably. Behind his back, Edrahil’s eyes darkened, though he held his tongue. “I knew it could end in nothing but suffering. I should never— I should have gone to make my attempt alone! I do not know… maybe I thought— I hoped…” He laughed bitterly. “But when has hope ever availed?”

Finrod closed his eyes and fought against tears. Beren’s words were a knife in his guts. He would have cheerfully debated the philosophy of hope with Beren all day and all night once, over some good wine and sitting in a comfortable chair in Nargothrond, but now, here, it would be no comfort to either of them. All the words of theory, philosophy, even faith had now turned bitter and dry as ash in his mouth. Even the ones he yet believed in. Perhaps especially those.

“Beren”, he said slowly, after a time, “is there quarrel between the houses of Nolofinwë and Arafinwë?”

Beren blinked, seeming thrown off by the change in topic, and pulled back to look up at whatever he could see of Finrod’s face in the dark. “No, none that I have ever heard of.”

“There is none. Yet if Nolofinwë and his children had not followed Fëanor and his sons to Middle-Earth, neither would any of the house of Arafinwë have gone. It was following the house of Nolofinwë, and for love of them, that the children of Arafinwë put themselves under the Doom, to suffer on the Ice and meet with evil fates in Beleriand”, said Edrahil, ever quick to follow Finrod’s thoughts.

Finrod nodded, smiling sadly. “If I do not blame them, if I hold no bitterness against Fingolfin, Turgon, against my own brothers or sister who were all more eager to go, I think, than I was, for leading me to my doom — why then should I blame you?”

“But they were your kin”, Beren whispered hoarsely.

“They were, they are. And I went with them because I loved them. Likewise it was for love to you and your kin that I came with you, and not only because my oath bound me. And is that oath not itself wrought of love? Would your father have come to my aid if there was no love between us? Would I have bound myself in an oath to him and his kin, even for gratitude and life-debt, if I had no love for him?” Finrod gathered Beren’s ice-cold hands in his own and held them close to his breast. “But to return to the exile we Noldor took upon ourselves, and the Ice— you have known cold. You have known dark. They were endless, on the Ice. The cold, we knew, must have an end somewhere, eventually, but it becomes hard to have faith in that when you suffer it long enough, does it not? The dark, so far as we could then see, truly was to be endless. For we had no knowledge of the counsels of the Valar, having turned away from them, no knowledge of their work in making the Sun and the Moon which to you have ever been there and ever shall be.” He felt his shoulders grow tight, hunching against remembered cold much more than the present chill of the cell, but went on nonetheless. “I will not say none of us ever felt any bitterness against the house of Nolofinwë for leading us there. More blame was due to the house of Fëanor, of course, but they were far away. Fingolfin and his children were there with us. Nonetheless, whenever someone needed aid, or warmth, or comfort— we gave it. No matter whether the someone was of the house of Nolofinwë, or of that of Arafinwë, or of the folk in the following of one or another of us. It was needed, it was given. This is a matter beyond bitterness, beyond blame or guilt. Punishing yourself now will not aid any of us. There is little enough that I may do for you here, but what there is, please, let me do.”

“I will add this”, Edrahil said quietly. “At least do not charge yourself with more than your share. Even if we accept that you have brought Finrod to this end, it was not at your call that the rest of us came. It is for love of him that I, and the rest of us, too, followed him here when he called for those who still loved him to come, as it was for love of him that I crossed the Ice — whoever he was and is following, and whether I approved of the cause or no. Where he has gone, there have I gone, and where he is going, there will I go. For his sake. If you must hold someone guilty for bringing me, for bringing them, to this place, it is not you whom the guilt falls upon. But would you blame Finrod for our doom?”

“No! No more than I would blame my father for— for everyone. He was their lord, as Finrod is yours. It is a matter of loyalty, there can be no blame in that.”

“Except when the loyalty is to you?”

“I had no right!”

“My oath gave you every right”, said Finrod firmly.

Beren bowed his head. Some of the tension in his body began to ease, and he allowed Finrod to draw him closer again. He looked utterly worn out, and if he could still not release himself from his guilt, at least he was willing to accept the warmth and comfort he needed again. Finrod guided his head to rest against his chest, quietly stroking his hair.

After a moment Edrahil moved closer, pressing against Finrod’s side, putting one arm around Beren’s shoulders, adding his warmth to Finrod’s. The others followed him until they all were huddled together in a small pool of warmth in the middle of the cold, crushing darkness.

Slowly Beren’s eyes closed and sleep took him. Finrod listened as his breathing slowed. He said nothing, only moved enough to settle Beren into a more comfortable position on his lap. Time passed around them, drip by drip, slow and thick as tar. The others began to fall asleep too, using the little moment of peace for rest and escape in dreams.

At last only Finrod and Edrahil were awake, by some unspoken contract staying up to keep watch over the rest. Finrod turned his head to look at Edrahil.

“Tell me, do you blame me for dooming you?” he asked very quietly.

“No. Never”, Edrahil answered at once, likewise quiet to not wake anyone else. “I will own that a part of me should still like to blame him—” He nodded at Beren. “—but what would it help? And was he not oathbound to make his attempt at his quest, as you were to aid him?”

“He was. And he still is, and so am I.” Finrod shook his head. “If you would not blame me, do not blame him either. Or at least do not let him see that you do, I beg you. He suffers enough already!”

“I shall not. I resent him a little, yes, I am not so strong that I would not. But I pity him more. A pawn of doom, as you told him he was. Not only your doom, either, I now believe, but something greater that will come to rule the fates of many besides us.”

“And the doom has its claws in him yet. I do not think it is done with him. I tell you, Edrahil, if any of us lives to leave this place, it will be him.”

Edrahil lay his hand carefully over Beren’s hand, which was clutching at the hem of Finrod’s shirt. “Is fate so cruel? That might well break him, if the torture does not.”

Pain twisted Finrod’s mouth. Beren shifted and whined in his sleep as if sensing his distress. Finrod turned his attention back to him, stroking his hair, humming a melody under his breath. It was a while before Beren sank back into the depths of sleep again.

“I hope it shall not”, Finrod whispered, when Beren lay once more still and calm, “but even if it does… I must do what is in my power to try to save him. You know I cannot do otherwise.”

“I know. For my part, I forgive you for all you have done and all you might do. But I do not know whether he will forgive either you or himself, if he lives and you do not.”


Chapter End Notes

Thanks for reading! Hope you enjoyed (if enjoy is the right word to apply with this fic, haha) <3


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment