Umbels Tall and Fair by Himring  

| | |

Fanwork Notes

Two photos of umbels taken by me; one of them set into the other, with a relevant quotation from The Book of Lost Tales added.

I am not entirely sure this is the cow parsley, which has been argued to be the hemlock that Luthien (and Edith Tolkien) danced among. But anyway, umbels.

The title is taken from Aragorn's song in The Lord of the Rings. I also looked at the history of that poem in The Collected Poems.

Fanwork Information

Description:

Umbels, such as those among which Luthien danced.

Canon Source: Lord of the Rings, Tolkien's Poetry

Major Characters:

Major Relationships:

Genre:

Type: Photography

Challenges:

Rating: General

Warnings:

Posted on Updated on

Umbels

Close-up of white flowering umbels with a ladybird sitting on the flowerets. Inset is a view of several such plants from farther away, with a title: "a great misty growth" in white lettering.

Comments on Umbels Tall and Fair

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.

Oh wow! Those are beautiful! We don't have hemlock here and I had no idea they looked like that.

I think my notes here may not have highlighted that enough: this is not hemlock, it is a look-alike plant that also has umbels!

I am not sure whether it is cow parsley or cow parsnip.

Here is an article discussing which umbelliferous plant Tolkien himself saw back in 2017 and was remembering, with photos:

https://eybirdwatching.blogspot.com/2014/06/a-hemlock-by-any-other-name.html

But whichever plant mine was, it was magical to see, even under the sun, rather than the moon, and I tried to capture that a bit.

I'm glad you like it!

 

Oh, that was just my utter lack of knowledge about these plants; I assumed cow parsley and cow parsnip were types of hemlock. I had a book as a child with a drawing of Queen Anne's Lace (which I thought so pretty!) and your photo had reminded me of it, and Ijust thought it must have been another type of hemlock. After reading through your link (thank you!) I see it's actually another name for cow parsley. (Which is such a sweet name, although kind of the opposite end from Quuen Anne's!) Thanks to your post I now also know what an umbel is.

And I love the ladybird, btw!

I am ao glad you mentioned about the trees! 

So, not having either plant here, when I read Tolkien’s description of Luthien dancing among the hemlock, I imagined the plants to be small flowering things on the forest floor. Years later another book described how the characters took shelter from the rain under the boughs of a hemlock, which naturally puzzled me. So I looked them up, only, I searched for "hemlock forest", which returned only photos of the conifer. So my imagining of Luthien (and Edith) dancing changed to an odd flowering form of conifer! After seeing your post, and the link, I thought I'd got muddled about the trees. I did search for "hemlock" again, this time without the "forest", and only the flowering plant came up. Très confusticating!😆 I am so glad to have this all sorted out now, and my image of Luthien's grove restored!

You know, I always quite liked the term umbel and imagined large flowers, but I never knew much about them until your images piqued my curiosity.  So, now I know that the term is from the Latin umbella, meaning parasol, which is what they look like.  I also didn't know the flowers are characteristic of the parsley and carrot family or about hemlock umbels.  Thank you!