New Challenge: Title Track
Tolkien's titles range from epic to lyrical to metaphorical. This month's challenge selected 125 of them as prompts for fanworks.
Twenty years of SWG challenges has seen all kinds of use of the prompts that (mostly) moderators cook up each month to tempt and torment our challenge creators. Some challenges are worn thin with love. Others lie, untouched and growing dusty, in the attic of the SWG Challenge page. This month, in honor of twenty years of challenges, we are upcycling our old challenges and dusting them off for a second chance at life.
Jumble Sale prompts are created by SWG members using past challenges and prompts. For this challenge, you can choose your prompt from the list below. Each prompt is indicated by a "For Sale" and may include multiple elements. As always, we welcome creative interpretations of prompts and use of any part of the prompt.
Make sure to tag all challenges included in the prompt if you would like the stamps for them. Challenges from before 2017 do not have stamps, but there is a special stamp for creators who venture into the deepest, dustiest recesses of the SWG attic by creating for a prompt that uses a challenge from prior to 2017!
If you'd like to create prompts of your own but missed the original call, you're not too late! Submit Jumble Sale prompts here. Allow us forty-eight hours to update the website before querying.
Thank you to Varda delle Stelle for this month's stamps!
This challenge opened in .
Choose your prompt from the collection below.
Use the Breaking Boundaries challenge to show a meeting between characters of two or more different cultures. Add into this the Hanged Man prompt from Major Arcana (see below) and the following quote from Rise Above: "Science makes people reach selflessly for truth and objectivity; it teaches people to accept reality, with wonder and admiration, not to mention the deep awe and joy that the natural order of things brings to the true scientist." ~ Lise Meitner
|
XII. The Hanged Man
|
A man hanging upside-down by one foot. The figure is most often suspended from a wooden beam (as in a cross or gallows) or a tree. He is fully clothed and has his hands tied or hidden behind his back. Ambiguity results from the fact that the card itself may be viewed inverted. There is a halo burning brightly around the hanged man's head, signifying a higher learning or an enlightenment. The background is blank. In astrology, the Hanged Man card is associated with the planet Neptune and the Pisces zodiac sign. (Wikipedia) The Roman numeral XII is shown at the top of the card. Readings: |
Challenges to Tag: Breaking Boundaries, Jumble Sale, Major Arcana, Rise Above
Prompt Credit: AdmirableMonster
Use the April's Fool challenge in which a character plays a prank on another character. This one should be a pre-Ring War Third Age/Fourth Age fanwork or otherwise include the pairing Aragorn/Legolas. (If you're not sure if it's a Silmarillion fanwork, this FAQ can help.)
Challenges to Tag: April's Fool (pre-2017), Jumble Sale
Prompt Credit: an evil anonymous genius
Use a corny schmaltzy cheesy prompt from our Cheesy Corn Chips challenge and create a Faramir/Eowyn hurt/comfort story (likely located in the Fourth Age but if you can manage it elsewhere in the history of Arda and still meet our definition of Silmarillion fanworks, we'll knock half off the price and help you tie it to your car!)
Challenges to Tag: Cheesy Corn Chips, Jumble Sale
Prompt Credit: an evil anonymous genius
Use one of our anti-prompts from the Dark Matter prompt generator.
Challenges to Tag: Dark Matter, Jumble Sale
Prompt Credit: an evil anonymous genius
Using the March 27 prompt from the Birthday Bash challenge (see below), include one original character with a significant role.
March 27
In April 2011, the SWG opened its Dreamwidth community, the first new social media platform it would adopt, due to increased denial of service attacks on LiveJournal. This first small migratory foray would typify the 2010s, which were marked by multiple fandom platform upheavals, closures, and migrations.
Word: displaced
Poem:
Yesterday I lost a country.
I was in a hurry,
and didn't notice when it fell from me
like a broken branch from a forgetful tree.
I Was in a Hurry by Dunya Mikhail, translated by Elizabeth Winslow
Challenges to Tag: Birthday Bash, Jumble Sale
Prompt Credit: Himring
Create a fanwork set during the Second Age using any of the prompts from the bingo card "Plants that grow in Ithilien and elsewhere" (see below) from the Potluck Bingo challenge.
Prompts by Himring, Board by Polutropos
Plants That Grow in Ithilien and Elsewhere prompts:
B1 terebinth
B2 lebethron
B3 rose
B4 oak
B5 saxifrage
I1 eglantine
I2 anemone
I3 water-lily
I4 culumalda
I5 cypress
N1 marjoram
N2 lily
N3 (free space) beyond Sam's garden-lore
N4 tamarisk
N5 juniper
G1 parsley
G2 asphodel
G3 ash-tree
G4 stonecrop
G5 iris
O1 celandine
O2 cedar
O3 ilex
O4 thyme
O5 myrtle
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Potluck Bingo
Prompt Credit: Himring
Choose any two women from the "Original Female Character" bingo board from Potluck Bingo (see below) and have them interact in any way.
Board by Elleth
Original Female Character prompts:
Create an OFC who is...
B1 - important to the plot
B2 - queer
B3 - a Dwarf
B4 - a canon character's love interest
B5 - an antagonist
I1 - a queen or ruler
I2 - unimportant to canon characters
I3 - old
I4 - a Textual Ghost
I5 - a side or background character
N1 - a Mary Sue
N2 - a mother
N3 - FREE SPACE
N4 - unlikeable/flawed/imperfect
N5 - a non-humanoid creature
G1 - a canon character's friend
G2 - from a marginalized group
G3 - childless and/or unmarried
G4 - a Maia
G5 - a servant
O1 - an Orc
O2 - not defined by gender norms
O3 - a canon character's relative
O4 - a child
O5 - a trans woman
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Potluck Bingo
Prompt Credit: Himring
Combine prompts from the "Tell Her Story" and "Femslash & Lyrics" cards from Potluck Bingo (see below).
Board by Flora-lass B1 - Firiel of Gondor I1 - Morwen of Lossarnach N1 - Silmariën G1 - Elros’ wife O1 - Tar-Telperiën |
Board by Elleth B1 - Say that the wind won't change on us I1 - Towards your eyes, so full of paradise N1 - We did not give up on love today G1 - The cracks in the stained glass almost disappear O1 - Just don't waste it - this was not a mistake |
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Potluck Bingo
Prompt Credit: Himring
Create a fanwork about a king or queen you've never created a fanwork about before (see the Kings & Queens challenge for a list of kings and queens from The Silmarillion and The Lord of the Rings. Note that textual ghosts and original characters are welcome. If a character's royal status is questionable, they are a king or queen if you say they are.)
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Kings & Queens
Prompt Credit: Himring
Write a crossover using the Quiet Place franchise ("horror crossover" prompt from the Potluck Bingo Horror & Darkfic card) and featuring Maglor that includes a storm (literal or figurative, from the challenge When the Storm Breaks ...)
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Potluck Bingo, When the Storm Breaks ... (pre-2017)
Prompt Credit: Independence1776
Show characters plotting something (from The Plot Thickens challenge) using a prompt from Idiomatic and including an animal character.
Challenges to Tag: Idiomatic, Jumble Sale, Plot Thickens (pre-2017)
Prompt Credit: polutropos
Create a fanwork about heroes (for the Heroes challenge) in the Seventh Age (for Back to the Future) and including a named ship ... as in the boat, not the relationship.
Challenges to Tag: Back to the Future, Heroes (pre-2017), Jumble Sale
Prompt Credit: polutropos
Create an "academic pastiche" fanwork about or including numbers (from It's All in the Numbers) using a prompt from the Gnome Tome prompt generator.
Challenges to Tag: Gnome Tome, It's All in the Numbers (pre-2017), Jumble Sale
Prompt Credit: polutropos
Create a fanwork including a game (from Let the Games Begin) and about a group of characters not mentioned by Tolkien (from Companies, Clubs, and Cliques) that mentions Gondolin.
Challenges to Tag: Companies, Clubs, and Cliques (pre-2017); Jumble Sale; Let the Games Begin (pre-2017)
Prompt Credit: polutropos
Consider the statement, "But I won't do that," and what "that" is for your character and what happens when the inevitable happens and your character must, in fact, do that. The fanwork should focus on the laws and customs of Arda (from the challenge Laws and Customs) and should include Turgon.
Challenges to Tag: But I Won't Do That (pre-2017), Jumble Sale, Laws and Customs
Prompt Credit: polutropos
Create a fanwork about a birthday celebration or activity for one of the prompts from the Birthday Bash challenge and combine it with a prompt from the "Tell Her Story" or "Villains ... or are they?" bingo boards from Potluck Bingo (see below). Include a character from both cards and we'll throw in a free vintage Noldorin cheese grater!
Board by Flora-lass B1 - Firiel of Gondor I1 - Morwen of Lossarnach N1 - Silmariën G1 - Elros’ wife O1 - Tar-Telperiën |
Board by Grundy B1 - Gothmog I1 - Ulfang N1 - Morgoth G1 - Ancalagon O1 - the Great Goblin |
Challenges to Tag: Birthday Bash, Jumble Sale, Potluck Bingo
Combine a prompt from the Soap Opera prompt generator with one or more prompts from the Taboo challenge (see below).
B1: bad language
B2: violate Laws and Customs among the Eldar
B3: murder
B4: sexual deviance
B5: ethnocentrism and prejudice
I1: food taboos
I2: laws
I3: acceptance and change
I4: table manners
I5: culture shock
N1: [obscene] gestures
N2: unclean things
FREE SPACE
N4: stigma
N5: euphemism
G1: political correctness
G2: weddings and funerals
G3: curses
G4: ostracization and exile
G5: incest
O1: cannibalism
O2: etiquette
O3: consequences
O4: religious taboos
O5: found out
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Soap Opera, Taboo
Choose a song from Turgon's Rock Opera and any prompt from the Potluck Bingo "The Material World" board (see below). Your fanwork should prominently feature a female character.
Board by Grundy
The Material World prompts:
B1 - straw
B2 - reed
B3 - bark
B4 - wood
B5 - sod
I1 - wax
I2 - brick
I3 - stone
I4 - metal
I5 - glass
N1 - earth
N2 - air
N3 - FREE SPACE
N4 - fire
N5 - water
G1 - papyrus
G2 - paper
G3 - bamboo
G4 - leather
G5 - fur
O1 - hemp
O2 - flax
O3 - jute
O4 - cotton
O5 - wool
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Potluck Bingo, Turgon's Rock Opera
Create a fanwork about a character you've never created a fanwork for and who is included in our character biography collection (New Directions challenge). Use one or more squares from the Potluck Bingo "Eat, Drink, and Be Merry" board (see below). Your fanwork should be set at the beginning of a new age.
Board by Grundy
Eat, Drink, & Be Merry prompts:
(All prompts are mentioned in the legendarium.)
B1 - bread
B2 - butter
B3 - cheese
B4 - eggs
B5 - bacon
I1 - water
I2 - milk
I3 - tea
I4 - coffee
I5 - cream
N1 - salad
N2 - potatoes
N3 - FREE SPACE (photo of Merry Brandybuck)
N4 - mushrooms
N5 - green herbs
G1 - beer
G2 - ale
G3 - wine
G4 - porter
G5 - mead
O1 - seed-cake
O2 - scones
O3 - apple tart
O4 - biscuits
O5 - honey
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, New Directions, Potluck Bingo
Draw a card from Major Arcana, a prompt from the Dark Matter prompt generator, and a format or genre from In Rare Form.
Challenges to Tag: Major Arcana, Dark Matter, In Rare Form
Combine any prompt from the Bollywood challenge with the "Silm Smut (NSFW)" board from Potluck Bingo.
Challenges to Tag: Bollywood, Jumble Sale, Potluck Bingo
Combine the Tiffany Inkwell from the Middle-earth Museum challenge with the decade challenge of your choice (Roaring 20s, Swinging 40s, Funky 70s).
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Middle-earth Museum, decade challenge(s) you chose
Pick the Vintage prompt of your choice. Write a story in that style using X Marks The Spot.
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Vintage, X Marks the Spot
Combine a prompt from It Comes in Threes to solve a canon problem for the Solve a Problem challenge. (Note that there is an optional list of canon problems to solve on the challenge page, but you are not limited to these.)
Challenges to Tag: It Comes in Threes, Jumble Sale, Solve a Problem
Create your own Matryoshka challenge by having a friend pick you prompts from Soundtrack, the "Music of the Ainur" card from Potluck Bingo (see below), and Turgon's Rock Opera. (Note that if you do the easy level of the Matryoshka, you do not need to combine all three challenges.)
Board by Grundy
Music of the Ainur prompts:
Links go to videos of the song. Where possible, versions with lyrics or closed captions have been chosen.
B1 Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea
B2 What's Up Danger?
B3 Odds Are
B4 All Along The Watchtower
B5 Don't Stop Me Now
I1 On the Nature of Daylight
I2 A Midsummer Night's Dream
I3 Summertime
I4 Jupiter
I5 ‘Organ’ Symphony No.3
N1 Shut Up And Dance
N2 Love Me Now
N3 FREE SPACE
N4 Whenever, Wherever
N5 Can't Get You Out Of My Head
G1 Duel of the Fates
G2 The Bridge of Khazad-Dum
G3 Dies Irae
G4 O Fortuna
G5 Ode an die Freude
O1 A Sky Full of Stars
O2 All I Know So Far
O3 Stuck in a Moment You Can't Get Out Of
O4 Hold Each Other
O5 Love Don't Die
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Potluck Bingo, Soundtrack, Turgon's Rock Opera
Choose a prompt from one of Tolkien's non-Middle-earth works as part of the On a Different Page challenge and use it create a fanwork that includes Finrod.
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, On a Different Page
Prompt Credit: Quente
Create a whimsical fanwork that includes characters plotting (The Plot Thickens challenge) and that is about a king or queen you've never created a fanwork about before (see the Kings & Queens challenge for a list of kings and queens from The Silmarillion and The Lord of the Rings. Note that textual ghosts and original characters are welcome. If a character's royal status is questionable, they are a king or queen if you say they are.)
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Kings & Queens, Plot Thickens
Prompt Credit: Quente
Take a fanon you feel passionately about and turn it on its head (Fanon Inverted challenge). Then create a fanwork with your inverted fanon and that involves Morgoth.
Challenges to Tag: Fanon Inverted, Jumble Sale
Prompt Credit: Quente
Take on a meta Matryoshka! Choose at least one prompt from Analysing Arda and one from Tolkien Meta Week (and fill in additional prompts as needed as you want from both). Just like a Matryoshka challenge, the beginner level is two prompts, easy is three, medium is five, and difficult is seven. While prompts can be combined into a single meta piece, you can also do multiple unrelated and unconnected meta pieces if you prefer.
Challenges to Tag: Analysing Arda, Jumble Sale, Tolkien Meta Week
Using one of the prompts from the Experimental challenge, create a fanwork about the insignificant, unsavory, countercultural, and unwritten people of Middle-earth for the Arda Underground challenge.
Challenges to Tag: Arda Underground, Experimental, Jumble Sale
Use one of the slightly reworked advice columns from Dear Irmo but at least one character must be dead and your fanwork should explore the experience of death, afterlife, or rebirth per the Halls of Mystery challenge.
Challenges to Tag: Dear Irmo, Halls of Mystery (pre-2017), Jumble Sale
Choose one of the character groups or identities from the Middle-earth Is Multitudes prompt board and place a character of that identity in a leading role in your fanwork. That character must interact at some point with a setting-as-character (the Living Land challenge) in a way that explores the theme of nature vs. civilization.
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Living Land (pre-2017), Middle-earth Is Multitudes
Pick a major event in the history of Arda, then create a fanwork about a character who was not directly involved in that event and what that character was doing at the time (Behind the Scenes challenge). Use one of the Orctober prompts to shape your story of that character.
Challenges to Tag: Behind the Scenes, Jumble Sale, Orctober
The SWG's very first challenge was Strong Women. Pick a woman from the legendarium to write about. Textual ghosts and original characters are welcome. Combine with a second challenge based on the character group the woman belongs to (if she belongs to more than one, you can take your pick, or use them both and receive a 15% discount and a piece of hard candy from inside the cashbox!)
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Strong Women, third challenge based on the group the character belongs to (note that all are pre-2017)
Combine an Idiomatic prompt from a language you do not speak with the prompt of your choice from Laws & Customs.
Challenges to Tag: Idiomatic, Jumble Sale, Laws & Customs
Create a fanwork centered on an Edain or Númenórean woman, using the theme of exile (from the Song of Exile challenge), and incorporating this prompt from Dip the Ladle:
For this I weep all my days
and throughout my lifetime grieve
that I swam from my own lands
and came from familiar lands
towards these strange doors
to these foreign gates.
~ The Kalevala (Elias Lönnrot)
Challenges to Tag: Dip the Ladle, Jumble Sale, Song of Exile
As part of the Breaking Boundaries challenge, depict Easterling character(s) at the Havens of Sirion and/or in Túrin’s outlaw band.
Challenges to Tag: Breaking Boundaries, Jumble Sale
Create a fanwork that addresses the question of life, (im)mortality and reincarnation, or re-embodiment (Circle of Life challenge) focusing on characters from The Children of Húrin.
Challenges to Tag: Circle of Life (pre-2017), Jumble Sale
Create an AU fanwork where the story changes to allow a character who dies, departs, or otherwise leaves words unsaid to say those final words after all (Things We Never Said challenge) and focus on Túrin’s character.
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Things We Never Said (pre-2017)
Create a fanwork that shows the oral tradition (Traditions challege), uses a summer-focused prompt from the Gates of Summer challenge, and centers Edain and/or Mithrim traditions and celebrations.
Challenges to Tag: Gates of Summer, Jumble Sale, Traditions (pre-2017)
Create Silmarillion femslash for the pairing of your choice using the prompt from the Utopia/Dystopia challenge
But I don’t want comfort. I want God, I want poetry, I want real danger, I want freedom, I want goodness. I want sin.
~ Aldous Huxley, A Brave New World
and the song "Gravity" by Vienna Teng (video | lyrics) from the Just an Old-Fashioned Love Song challenge.
Challenges to Tag: Jumble Sale, Just an Old-Fashioned Love Song, Utopia/Dystopia
Prompt Credit: Elleth
Create Silmarillion femslash using the Tolkien Femslash Week Bingo "Four Words" card (below) and the B2MeM 2010: Passport to Middle-earth prompt for March 9 (also below).
Four Words Text Prompts:
B1: ancestor, fatal, culture, gloom
B2: homewards, hymn, collection, reverse
B3: bloom, devour, blinding, alliance
B4: thunder, fragrant, apple, arch
B5: knot, founder, intimate, aim
I1: below, ankle, invisible, glacier
I2: charade, amber, colony, moment
I3: firstborn, portrait, absent, dove
I4: humble, linear, comet, marble
I5: battalion, unsure, headstart, bliss
N1: antelope, pierce, tremor, honey
N2: silver, tangle, rainfall, dormant
N3: free space
N4: pattern, tongue, lantern, blush
N5: early, skyline, almost, mask
G1: promise, eastern, echo, cloud
G2: trial, naive, beacon, cloud
G3: berries, lively, ruby, scroll
G4: ocean, thousand, ceramic, fever
G5: crush, legion, bewitching, flame
O1: heartsick, infinite, settler, sudden
O2: heroes, recluse, ten, initial
O3: exile, hands, diversion, perception
O4: limit, daisies, cotton, hopeful
O5: proposal, drifting, lock, mortal
Photo courtesy of Menno Groenmen.
March 9: Nargothrond
Follow the footsteps of Finrod Felagund while spelunking through the underground realm of Nargothrond. Explore its riches and wealth and you will discover profound love for this underground city. If an active stay is not preferred, the Celegorm and Curufin Company can provide you in a theatrical tour named “Does she love me or will she betray us?” (a beany Huan will be included for the younger ones), where you can follow the footsteps of the illustrious trio of Celegorm, Curufin and Lúthien as they weave their web of desire, power and politics.
Today's Challenge:
Write a story or poem or create artwork where the characters have to decide between loyalty or betrayal.
Challenges to Tag: B2MeM 2011 (pre-2017), Jumble Sale, Tolkien Femslash Week Bingo (pre-2017)
Prompt Credit: Elleth
Create a fanwork including some unrecorded Fëanorian offspring that uses the "star poem" prompt from April 14 of the Birthday Bash challenge (below) combined with the Gnome Tome prompt generator prompt: "It cannot therefore be concluded from silence ... that any given person had no children."
night drapes
stars emit light
around the north star-fire
stars journey
in their wake
stories extend
star poem, translated from the Diné by Manny Loley
Challenges to Tag: Birthday Bash, Gnome Tome, Jumble Sale
Prompt Credit: Elleth

Araglas inherits the chieftainship of the Dunedain of Arnor upon his father's death. But Araglas has been living in Rivendell all this while. Meanwhile, his second cousin Arthiel has been acting as his father's right hand in the Angle.
Araglas comes up with a plan that stuns Arthiel and her lover.

On the day of Tuor and Idril's wedding, Maeglin and Voronwë find some common, unstable ground.

On a sunny day in spring, Frodo got the urge to go north and west, up into Arnor, which was still quite wild and uninhabited outside of newly-built Annúminas, and the slow trickle of work happening around the ruins of Fornost, which even the Dúnedain were still sometimes reluctant to visit. When he spoke of his plan, his dad told him to remember to pack enough food and not to forget a bit of rope, and his mother said not to forget his cloak. Most of his siblings were too young yet to be permitted to go along, but Elanor immediately asked if he wanted company.

Before the destruction of Gondolin, Glorfindel was forced to keep many parts of his life a secret. Much of this changed after his second coming to Middle Earth.
Featuring: Glorthelion, intersex!Glorfindel, mpreg, and queerplatonic Glorestor.

In the Third Age, a stranger arrives in the area between the Long Lake and the Lonely Mountain. He is not quite what he seems...

painting of the Tower of Pearl in the Western Isles

The land of Dor-Lómin welcomes a displaced Easterling woman after Nírnaeth Arnoediad. Theirs is a short-lived yet reverent kinship.
Written for the SWG Jumble Sale Challenge September 2025. Sold! One Headstrong rake!
The challenge was to have a character with an identity from Middle Earth is Multitudes interact with the setting-as-character as in Living Lands, in a way that explores nature vs civilization.

She had learned the way Elves married, she did not wish to be tied to him, or him to her. She knew she was a fleeting thing in his long life, and she had her pride.
Haleth brings her son to Thargelion, seeking answers.

Galadriel and Celeborn witness the end of the War of Wrath.

Míriel invents pants.

After the Fall of Gondolin, Maeglin's more than a little broken. Is there any hope for him?