New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
LAST TIME on The Mirror Crack'd: Malhof's identity was revealed, and Celegorm made lots of very good choices.
THIS TIME on The Mirror Crack'd: Celegorm's choices become even more interesting. Anniavas and co have an eerie experience at the borders of Doriath.
Further A/N:
well, we're back! Wasn't posting while AO3 was down because I didn't want to get unsynced in my crossposting.
chapter rated T (there really is, like, one or two explicit rated chapters in here but they're still a ways off)
chapter warning for brief horror, not much else
It was planning season in the gardens, with planting looming on the horizon. Anniavas was having to learn a whole new skill set, again. “Is there no end to the things I don’t know?” he exclaimed within two days of returning from Lake Helevorn.
“Is that strange to you?” Echeleb asked, sounding mildly curious.
“YES!” Anniavas exploded, and then went back to trying to understand all the interactions that lay behind the arcane rules and complicated maneuvers that seemed to go into laying out everything that was to be grown that year. Behind him, he heard Dernodhos cackle. “Oh, shut up,” he tossed over his shoulder at her.
Constantly feeling like a novice was not good for his self-esteem, but he knew that if he slowed down, the concern rooting somewhere low and uncomfortable would put out shoots and begin to grow. Celegorm had not only run off, he had disappeared. No one had spoken to him since he had struck Anniavas. Despite Maedhros’s clear confidence that his younger brother could take care of himself and repeated assurances from every friend Anniavas possessed that it was not his fault—including both Hemmoril and Maglor himself—he could not keep from worrying.
“You are not going to believe what’s happened!” Melweril announced, breezing down into the tea gardens with her usual high-handed lack of care for whatever conversation had been going on before she had arrived.
Dernodhos elbowed Anniavas, and he glanced over to see her signing, “We’re probably going to believe it. Who do you think has had a fight in the lower kitchens this time?”
“I saw that,” Melweril sniffed. “And it isn’t gossip. It’s news. About Lord Celegorm!”
Anniavas froze, hand trembling, and nearly dropped the cultivator he was holding.
“Dammit,” muttered Echeleb. “Melweril, are you sure this is something we want to hear? Anniavas—”
“I am fine,” Anniavas clipped out. “I’m not a fool or a coward, Echeleb, thank you.”
Echeleb raised their hands in a way that Anniavas understood to be something halfway between an apology and a washing-of-hands of the situation.
“Eirien overheard Lord Maedhros talking to Lord Maglor—”
“Wait,” Anniavas snapped. “Is this actually gossip that is meant to be conveyed? Will it—” He didn’t quite know how to say what he wanted to say. Would it be an insult to Maedhros? But Maedhros did not seem to be insulted by things that were said about him, at least not by the workers of Himring. Would it jeopardize the security of the fortress? But surely something so sensitive would not have been discussed by the Lords Maedhros and Maglor where anyone else could overhear. And yet—this damn fortress relied so thoroughly on trust that Anniavas did not know that they would think to avoid talking about something that might cause others to lose faith in them.
“Stop worrying, Anniavas,” Melweril said dismissively. Then, before he could object again, she went on. “There’s been a letter from Nargothrond. They have Lord Celegorm and are demanding that Himring exchange him for Finrod Felagund.”
“Who?” said Echeleb, before Anniavas could finish even processing this bombshell.
“The former ruler of Nargothrond?” Anniavas heard himself saying incredulously. “One of the lords of the Noldor—he nearly defeated Sauron in a contest of songs?”
“Well, good for him,” Echeleb said. “You know I pay little attention to the politics of the Noldor.”
“I know who he is,” Dernodhos signed with another cackle.
Anniavas huffed explosively. His body took itself to its feet and began to pace back and forth. This was unexpected. This would have political implications. There would of necessity be negotiations. “Stars and bone,” he said disgustedly. “What was Celegorm thinking? We have only just returned from Helevorn. If I must go Nargothrond next—”
He did not like the shudder of barely-suppressed panic that ran down his spine.
“You are only an apprentice undergardener, you know,” Melweril pointed out. She sounded almost amused. “I know you went to Lake Helevorn—”
“Where he was invaluable,” Echeleb pointed out dryly.
“I’m not saying he isn’t a good man to have at your side.” Melweril’s voice had gone a little gentler. Maybe she’d been spending more time with Eirien. “I’m saying he’s acting as if it’s his responsibility, when realistically—”
The door opened, and Lord Maedhros strode in. “Anniavas,” he said, in his usual steady, impassive voice. “May I speak with you?”
* * *
Enchantment lay heavy across the land. Just past noon, Anniavas had marked a change in the quality of the light as they traveled southwards. From the bright yellow-white of a spring afternoon, it had faded into a clear, pellucid blue, almost the light of twilight.
“Melian’s enchantment,” Maedhros had explained, indicating the line of dark trees along the northern skyline, which made Anniavas shiver for no discernible reason. No matter which direction they had chosen to go, they would have had to hew close to the boundary of Doriath to avoid losing time on their way to Nargothrond. Traveling to the North was more dangerous, Maedhros had explained, because in Nan Dungortheb the edges of the Girdle clashed with a remainder of the dark evil that had followed Morgoth and Ungoliant when they fled from Valinor. Anniavas found it difficult to imagine a more disturbing place than this one—the Aelin-uial, where the river Aros met the river Sirion and both of them broadened and stilled so that their mingling made a series of meres reflecting the terrifying twilit heavens so perfectly it felt as if they were walking between patches of sky and might at any time fall through into nothingness.
They had laid camp near the edge. By the next day, the Meres of Twilight would be behind them. Only Malhof—Finrod—seemed as perturbed as Anniavas felt. Limral—just old enough to accompany them with the wise wolf watching her—gamboled around happily, bowing and barking on her too-large paws to encourage someone to play with her. Maedhros showed no agitation, nor did any of the five advisors he had brought with him in addition to Anniavas. Finrod was subdued, uninterested in play, and lay with his nose on his crossed paws, ignoring Limral even when she began to worry at his ear. (It was hard to recall that he was an Elf, in truth; all his mannerisms were wolfish, if a little more sensitive, a little more attuned to the nuances of spoken communication.)
No one spoke much. It seemed difficult to speak, to break this silence. Maedhros was always quiet, particularly in a group, and Anniavas did not feel much like socializing with the other Elves, whom he did not know well, but earlier evenings around the fire had featured much lively debate and discussion among the others, at least. Anniavas could only assume that they, too, felt the oppressive, watchful presence from the north. Not a foraging predator, but a creature waiting and watching, perhaps in ambush. So a fly might feel a chill passing near the tunnel that housed a spider, even if it was too far away to attract the spider’s full attention.
Maedhros slept in his own tent. He owed no explanation, being the lord of Himring, but he gave one anyway: “I am not much of a bed partner, these days.” Anniavas, who was well aware of certain gossip surrounding sleeping arrangements involving Maedhros and the High King of the Noldor, wondered if this was strictly true, or if there were exceptions. It was none of his business, he reminded himself, who Maedhros did or did not sleep with, or around, or in the company of. Anniavas had requested that he be able to share with Finrod and Limral, who were generally calm in his company. He had prepared an explanation, himself, somewhat more detailed than, “I am not much of a bed partner these days,” since he was not important, and he had already demonstrated the ability to sleep among others in the dormitories, but, to his surprise, only the request was necessary. So the five advisors he did not know were sharing a large tent, Maedhros was in a slightly smaller one by himself, and Anniavas was in the smallest one of all, curled up against two warm furry bodies.
It was an excellent arrangement. He expected to sleep well.
* * *
White sunlight filled an azure sky from horizon to horizon. A cool, gentle breeze stroked his face. Beneath him rolled the landscape—forests of a luxurious, verdant viridian, and golden hills carpeted in waving, sparkling grasses. His wings caught at the air, beating in a steady pattern as he flew.
(Someone was crying.)
The day was almost dream-like in its beauty. Shimmers of enchantment wavered through the air in great dizzying whorls, loops of not-quite-there iridescence. Even in its destruction, a spell could be lovely. Indeed, many things were lovely in their death throes.
He dropped lower, straining against the unaccustomed heaviness. There was only so much weight that physical wings could take, and he seemed to be very tired, so it was taking all his energy to maintain the song that lofted him afloat. Beneath him, waves of darker green and lighter green chased one another across the tops of the forest.
(Someone was moving, wriggling, crying.)
He floated lower. Ahead he seemed to see a patch of sky in the ground, almost circular, a matte blue from this angle. It shimmered again, and now he was over it. Beneath him, he saw a terrible black-furred creature with multiple mismatched wings beating desperately at the air. There were holes torn in them, but somehow those ragged scraps were still keeping it aloft. Dozens of red eyes blinked on and off across its form, and held tight in its grotesque, scythe-like claws was a golden wolf, struggling and writhing.
Crying out, he plummeted like a stone. The sky—the mirror—became water, dark water, all around him. Anniavas was drowning. No, he realized in the next moment, he was not sinking beneath dark water, he was soaked in sweat and peeling his face off of a whimpering Finrod. A concerned Limral was pacing back and forth, making short little distressed yips.
“Here, girl,” Anniavas gasped, and she came to him. He held onto her gawky, half-grown form. “I’m all right,” he said to her. “I’m all right. It’s all right.”
He had not known it was possible for an incarnate form to sweat this much. He was shivering now, and he took deep breath after deep breath, petting Limral to keep her from panicking. “Good girl,” he told her helplessly. She licked his face.
Finrod was still asleep, still whimpering. “Finrod,” Anniavas said loudly, but the soft whimpering and kicking continued. Remembering his response to the soft humming made Anniavas uneasy of trying to waken him another way. It might be that it had been a general response to Song, but it might also have been a response to Anniavas, and a creature waking from a nightmare was vulnerable. Maedhros was his kinsman—Anniavas did not really know how close they were or had been, but Maedhros—Maedhros was skilled in handling this sort of distress.
Maedhros would know what to do.
He tried to tell Limral to stay, but she was having none of it, so instead he edged his way out of the tent with her dogging his flank. Outside of the close, sweat-scented tent, he had hoped to feel less claustrophobic, but he didn’t really. There was no Moon and no fire; the only light was the faint and silvery light of the stars, which seemed to be caught in a line behind the dark forest looming to the north.
With Limral following close behind and bumping her nose into his thigh, he stumbled his way through the eerily quiet darkness until he found the small tent where Maedhros was sleeping. There was a soft, low moaning sound coming from inside. Anniavas stooped and undid the tent flap, crawling in cautiously. Limral followed him, panting loudly.
“Maedhros,” Anniavas said, voice low, clear, and steady. “Maedhros, wake up.” He did not quite want to touch him, in case he was dreaming of something like the metal that Anniavas had removed from his chest.
The noise stopped. Maedhros’s eyes snapped open, twin bright lamps glittering gold-silver in the darkness. They stared at one another.
“Anniavas,” Maedhros said, distant and questioning.
“Yes,” Anniavas whispered.
“Ah.” He rolled up on one elbow and rubbed his face with his hand. His auburn hair, escaping from its customary braid, fell in plumed locks about his shoulders.
“I had nightmares,” Anniavas explained. “I think Finrod is having them too, but I could not wake him, so I came to find you.”
“It’s this enchantment,” Maedhros said, voice raw and rough with sleep. “Those whose fëar have been intruded upon by a Maia’s touch before may be more susceptible. Finrod and I—and you, I suspect—have all been exposed to Gorthaur’s.”
“You postulate an unusual connection—comparing Gorthaur and Melian.”
Maedhros sat up, rubbing his eyes. His scarred face was haunted. “Only in their enchantments,” he said, with a shake of his head. “Evil aside, Melian has lived among Elves and learned what it means to…” he trailed off, apparently searching for words.
“Exist as an incarnate?” Anniavas supplied.
“Mm.” Maedhros stretched and rose. “Let’s go to Finrod. I’ve woken enough young relatives from bad dreams.”
When they returned, Finrod was still asleep, his feet kicking and twitching slightly.
“I wonder…” Maedhros said softly. “If I remember correctly, he used to have foresight dreams. When he was a child, he would wake himself up screaming.” He frowned, gazing off somewhere in the middle distance. “No one really—understood.”
“Is there anything particular you have to be careful of when you’re waking someone up from a foresight dream?” Anniavas asked cautiously.
“Don’t know.” Maedhros’s eyes went distant again, a little unfocused. “Only one of the brothers who has much foresight is Amras.”
Amras did not reside at Himring, Anniavas knew. His mind also told him that there was some tragedy associated with the youngest brother, but he was unclear on the details. He decided not to push.
“It’s fine,” Maedhros said reassuringly, and he leaned forward and briskly shook Finrod’s shoulder.
Those great brown eyes snapped open—and should they not be lit from within as Maedhros’s were?—and the wolf surged upright, a vast golden wave of fur and claws, leaping—
Anniavas thought he made a noise, soft and afraid, and then he was on his back, with a canid’s weight on him, and—
(he heard rending flesh and snapping bone)
(someone was making a high, distressed noise like a pained animal)
—Finrod was nosing him, sniffing at his face, his throat, his shoulder. Anniavas’s mind explained, impatiently—not shaken at all, of course—that this was a response of concern from an animal searching for an injury. After a few more moment of inspection, Finrod began to lick his face all over. Anniavas wondered if he was breathing.
“Huh,” said Maedhros. “You okay, Anniavas?”
“Fine,” Anniavas said. His voice sounded a little strangled, even to him. Limral ran over and stuck her tongue in his ear, and he managed a weak rattle of laughter. “Fine,” he said again. “I’m fine.”
Maedhros watched all this with his usual expressionless countenance; then he sat down on Anniavas’s bedroll. “Can I sleep here?” he asked.
“What?” Anniavas said, which was probably rude.
“It’s all right if you don’t want me to, I take up a lot of bed, but we all seem to be having nightmares. I thrash—not a good bed partner, as I said before—but sometimes I sleep better with someone I trust.”
“Oh,” said Anniavas, in a small voice. He knew by now that he could quite easily say no to Maedhros. He had even done so, on certain occasions—that was not quite accurate, was it? He was permitted to say no to Maedhros. When he thought about it, he found that he had some difficulty actually doing so, perhaps because Maedhros only ever seemed to ask him for things he wanted. “You can sleep here,” he said. Perhaps this was too honest, too eager, but he was very tired, and, in any case, Finrod might sleep better with Maedhros here as well, mightn’t he?
“Right,” said Maedhros. He yawned and lay down. After a slightly nervous moment, Anniavas joined him. He had not bothered with a bedroll; it was overwarm in the tent with Finrod and Limral in any case, even with the queer artificial chill of the artifact sunk into Anniavas’s back. Maedhros, perhaps, agreed. Certainly, he did not comment on the lack. He seemed warm as well, Anniavas thought sleepily. He had first thought to arrange himself with his back to Maedhros, but this seemed unnecessarily rude, particularly with the sharp, cold edges of the artifact protruding, so he turned over to face him. After a moment, Limral and Finrod curled up near his head.
* * *
Again, Maedhros dreamed. The scorching heat of Angband, never far distant, burst upon his dreams like a volcanic eruption. If there was any redirection of those dreams after moving to Anniavas’s tent, it was not in the subject matter but perhaps in the emotional content.
The Mannish healers whispered that Elves did not grow ill, but Maedhros had, in Angband if never in Valinor. He dreamed of mounting fever, the way the walls elongated and distorted, the way his perceptions loosened and faded around the edges. Perhaps it was no illness, but a thwarted attempt to Fade, to escape in any manner that he could. Perhaps something else entirely.
In the dream, the memory was clearer to Maedhros than it had been when he was living it; almost, he could see himself stretched on a pallet, bundled up under blankets. Someone was with him, a shadow moving ceaselessly at his side. Water was poured down his throat, with hot, meaty porridge following. Two voices spoke, arguing.
He may be dying. One prisoner is not worth this effort.
I have my pride. Námo will not have this victory.
Song, brilliant, echoing, haunting. Maedhros’s head rang with effort.
You are not a healer.
I can keep him here!
Then Maedhros was staring into a pair of flame-gold eyes. Fight, damn you. Keep fighting.
Why should I? he remembered asking in a cracked and hollow voice, but this time, he said nothing. Instead, he reached out to tuck a strand of firelit hair behind one ear. He blinked, and Anniavas was standing on the other side of the darkened room, brewing a pot of tea.
“I can’t get the damn temperature right,” he said irritably. “Come taste.”
The tea tasted like the broth, like drinking the smell of fire. “Seems fine,” Maedhros told him.
He opened his eyes again, heavy eyelids protesting for an instant as the heavy weight of Melian’s enchantment tried to draw him back into the muddled dreams, and then he was lying on his back with a weight on his shoulder. Maglor, he thought—too light for Fingon, and the only other person who routinely shared his bed. When he looked down, it was Anniavas, breathing evened out in a heavy sleep, though Maedhros could not see if his eye was shut. Only the ruin of the left side of his face was visible; the rest was cradled in Maedhros’s shoulder. His body was pressed all along Maedhros’s right side, and Maedhros took a quick, sudden in-breath.
Before he could take any other action, Finrod’s golden head came up from the other side of Anniavas. The look on his face was very smug, for a wolf.
“Shut up,” Maedhros told him.
Finrod panted at him.
Maybe after they returned from Nargothrond, Maedhros thought in some consternation, he would need to send a letter to Fingon.