A New Road or a Secret Gate by bunn  

| | |

Breakfast and Mortality


“Would you not prefer to stay in bed, Elrohir?”  Amras asked him the next morning in some concern, when Elrohir, arriving in the tall white room where Amrod, Amras and Celebrimbor were eating breakfast, declared his intention of joining the elves riding west to the river Gelion. “Or at least stay here and take things easy?”

“I feel a great deal better for the night’s rest, and anyway, it’s only a cracked rib and bruising.  The horse you lent me has a good smooth pace: it will be no trouble as long as I don’t ask him to trot,” Elrohir reassured him. “It won’t be the first time I’ve ridden with a few bruises. Is there any news of the beast in the lake, do you know?”

Celebrimbor shook his head and took a mouthful of dark rye bread.

Amrod turned and looked out of the window at the lake, shining tranquil in the morning light. The purple mountain-wall that enclosed it on two sides reflected in the water, white birch-trunks shimmering near the brink.  “Caranthir says there’s nothing new, but nobody has gone near the lake since we saw it. I shall be staying here, at any rate, as Caranthir’s second, in case he needs one.”

“I can stay, if you need my assistance,” Elrohir offered.

Surprised, Amrod laughed sharply.  “I think we can manage without you.”  He hesitated and added; “Though the offer is appreciated, of course. You have fought one battle on Father’s behalf already.  If you really want to insist on riding on down to Gelion only a day later with a broken rib, you will be leaving a well-equipped fortress behind you, and two not inexperienced commanders too.”

“Well, I did come to Beleriand seeking adventure,” Elrohir said, to make it clear that he had not intended any disrespect to his host’s abilities. “But it’s not every day one gets a chance to meet a River. I know the River Lune, who must be some relative of Gelion’s across the Mountains, I think.  Lune was a true friend and ally in our long battle against Angmar.”

He looked at Amras, and wondered if he had any idea where Angmar had been, or why they had been fighting at all.

“I don’t, really,” Amras admitted with a grin, catching his thought. “I have never crossed the Ered Luin, and I admit, my knowledge of Eriador is shaky at best.  But I gather they were servants of the Enemy?”

“They were. It was a kingdom North and East of Imladris — you know where Imladris lies?”

Amras screwed up his face in comical embarrassment.  “Somewhere near Celebrimbor’s city in Eregion?” he said, and laughed. “I’m guessing; you can probably tell.  Celebrimbor has told us a fair bit about Ost-in-Edhil and Eregion, but we had little news when we were in the Halls of Mandos.  What news we got second-hand was only what Fingon and Grandfather saw in the tapestries of Vairë and came to tell us later. Fingon had never been to Eriador either, and Grandfather was there only briefly long before the Sun rose, so the details were probably somewhat confused.”

“So I imagine,” Elrohir said politely.    

“Occasionally we’d hear they had seen Artanis — Galadriel, I mean. ” Amrod put in from the other side of the table, where he was spreading yellow butter thickly on fresh warm bread. “They spotted Maglor twice in six thousand years. Typical Maglor, that, he can slither out of anything.  And occasionally they would see someone who was probably Elrond. Neither of them had met your father, of course, and recognising someone you don’t know in the weavings of Vairë is difficult, I’m told, though they looked out for him particularly, because Maedhros always used to ask after Elrond, when he finally started talking properly again.  But details like exactly where he lived were not very clear.”

“I’ll draw you a map,” Celebrimbor said seriously, pulling out a notepad and a pencil.  “Here are the Blue Mountains, in the West, with the river Lune flowing down into the Gulf.   And then running north to south here on the other side of Eriador there are the Misty Mountains. Here’s Eregion, and the capital Ost-in-Edhil, near the mountain Caradhras and...”

“... Khazâd Dum,” Amrod and Amras said simultaneously, and laughed.  

Celebrimbor glared at them, and Elrohir quickly straightened his face into a polite listening expression.  “If you don’t want to know...” Celebrimbor said.

“Of course we do, Celebrimbor,” Amras said, and leant forward seriously to look at the map.

“So, Lindon is over here, West of the Blue Mountains,” Celebrimbor said, making neat notes with the pencil. “Here’s  where we are, which would be under the Sea in the Round World, of course, but there is some overlap, since a lot of the Blue Mountains are in both places at once. How that works with both Lindon and Thargelion and the Ered Luin being at once here in Beleriand Risen, and in the Round World, is an interesting mathematical problem...”

“Tyelpë,” Amrod said firmly.  “No interesting mathematical problems.  We are talking about strategy in Eriador.”

Celebrimbor sighed extravagantly and rolled his eyes at Elrohir.  “Yes, Uncle Ambarussa!” he said with considerable sarcasm.

“Hush, brats,” Amras said, assuming an air of enormous authority. “Pearls of knowledge will be wasted on us simple types, Tyelpë, you know that. Tell Father later, he’ll appreciate it.”

“Bah,” Celebrimbor said and smiled, an unexpectedly sweet and shy smile.  “He’s no fun to show off to. Far too hard to impress. Anyway, the rivers used to run roughly like this...”

“The courses of Greyflood and the lower Loudwater have moved north a little since then,” Elrohir said, pointing at Celebrimbor’s roughly sketched map across the table. “But Imladris is here, on the upper Loudwater, not far from the Road that goes from Mithlond over the mountains to Greenwood the Great.  Angmar lay here, to the North. About five days march from Imladris to the Ettenmoors, and another five to Carn Dûm the fortress of Angmar, near Mount Gundabad. That would be after Angmar had fallen, of course. When it was at its height you wouldn’t have got near the place unless with an army: it was crawling with orcs.”

“So near Mount Gundabad?” Celebrimbor said, and blinked in surprise at the map.  “But that’s a holy mountain of the Dwarves, the waking place of Durin himself. What did the priests do?”

Oh.

“I am afraid Mount Gundabad was overrun by orcs not long after...  after Eregion fell,” Elrohir said gently. “It has been a goblin stronghold all my life.  Long before the rise of Angmar, Gundabad was the home of orc-chieftains. My father thinks they escaped the fall of Angband and stayed hidden, breeding in the far north until Sauron began to stir again.”

Celebrimbor took a long breath and closed his eyes for a moment. Then he let the breath out explosively.  “I should have wrung his neck the first time I saw him,” he said furiously. “Gundabad was not a fortress.  It was at peace.”

“That doesn’t matter to them. Orcs take what they want, peace or no peace,” Elrohir said, then realised that of course, Celebrimbor must know that perfectly well.

“Every time I feel I’ve left him behind, there’s one more thing he’s smeared his filth over.” Celebrimbor’s hands were clenched and his shoulders bowed.  Amrod put an arm around him wordlessly for a moment.

“His Black Gate is broken, his Tower fallen and his Ring destroyed,” Elrohir said, wondering if Celebrimbor needed to take miruvor, and if so, where they kept it here. He put the vision of the Barad-dûr in ruins into the forefront of his mind.  “I saw it fall. He is only a voice on the wind now. Arda may be marred, but she is no less fair.”

Celebrimbor heaved a long sigh, and some of the tension went out of him.  “Yes. But I sometimes still desperately want to kick Sauron very hard. Right in his perfect teeth,” he admitted.

“Imladris stood against him with the help of the Ring you made, and so did Lothlorien. And Mithrandir rode out against him with the strength of your ring upon his finger.  Not a bad kick in the teeth, that.” The familiar feeling of Celebrimbor’s strength was even stronger than usual in the air now, and it reminded him sharply of the last few years at home, when Father’s strength that wrapped the valley round and kept it safely hidden from unfriendly eyes had been laced through with the strong clear sapphire sense of Vilya.  

“Tell us about Imladris,” Amras suggested, glancing briefly across the table at Celebrimbor.

“It’s a deep valley in the foothills of the Misty Mountains,” Elrohir said, and perhaps it was because Celebrimbor was there that he could see the path home ahead of him, clear in the morning light, and the resinous scent of the fir trees in the sun came back to him.

"There are several ways down from the high moors into Imladris, but all of them are narrow and steep, winding through sharp rocks and thin heather. It’s a good stronghold: if the enemy manages to pass the Ford of Bruinen to find the valley at all, they can send only a few people at a time down the paths.  On the upper valley side there are steep woods of dark fir-trees, and here and there along the valley-side there are waterfalls running white against the stone, filled with rainbow light as the sun catches in the spray...

“Everywhere in Imladris you hear the song of water falling, except in the coldest winters when the streams on the heights freeze into long icicles... In the valley-bottom the River runs clear and cold over golden stone with snow-melt from the mountains, singing to herself, and there beside the water are woods of oak and beech, apple-orchards bright with blossom in the spring-time, and rich green pastures that are filled with yellow flowers. We used to sing the night through among the beeches sometimes, in the days when there was peace, the stars tangled in the treetops and the enchantment of the Ring folded around the valley until you could almost not remember what was song, what was memory and what was here and now...  

"Then in the morning when the sunlight creeps above the valley side, you would cross the river on a narrow high-arched bridge, wide enough for only one horse to pass, and climb up singing to the House through the meadows, silver with a net of dew."

Elrohir sighed. "Dwarves and Men and Elves from across Middle-earth come there to rest on their journeys and take counsel... Or they used to, anyway. Some of the Dunedain still live there, so they probably still at least see visiting travellers.”

"It sounds very beautiful,” Nerdanel said from behind him. Elrohir started. Caught up in memory, he had not heard her come in. “And I think that is the most words I’ve ever heard you speak all in one go, too, Elrohir.  You must miss Imladris a great deal.”

“My Quenya is perhaps still a little unpolished,” Elrohir said apologetically. “I have to think what words to use.”

“Oh, not at all!  Your Quenya is very good, really!” Nerdanel exclaimed. “Fëanáro would say; better than mine, horror that he is when it comes to languages. I can just feel him wincing when I use slang.”

“To be fair,” Amrod said, leaning back in his chair, “You do wince at him quite a lot too.  And you call him a horror, which under the circumstances is not very tactful. He has been politely refraining from ever commenting on it.”

Nerdanel wrinkled her nose for a moment, looking annoyed. “Thank you Amrod, when I require commentary on the state of my marriage from my unmarried sons, I shall ask you for it.  Your father can stand up for himself, believe me.”

“Have some breakfast,” Amras suggested to his mother, and poured her a cup of tea. Nerdanel sat down and helped herself to rye bread and smoked salmon.  

Celebrimbor said hurriedly, “Imladris was where Elrond led the survivors of Eregion, wasn’t it, Elrohir?  I was very glad to hear that at least some of them had escaped.”

“I believe so. That was long before I was born, of course,” Elrohir said obligingly. “They were retreating north and stumbled on the valley by chance.  Father held it for almost three years until the Numenorean navy landed, relieved Lindon and marched inland to break the siege at last. The soil of the valley-floor is rich and there are many nut and fruit trees.  That was fortunate indeed, since my father had ridden out in haste and had not brought supplies for a long siege.”

They had ridden out in haste to the aid of Eregion, but still had come too late; Elrohir had grown up with the tale.  The army that had besieged Rivendell then had carried Celebrimbor’s broken body as their banner. Better not mention that, perhaps.  

“As I said, it’s very defensible.  Even when Angmar invaded Arnor, broke the tower of Amon Sûl and wrecked both the kingdoms of Rhudaur and Cardolan - that’s here, just North of Rivendell and here to the south and west — we were able to hold the valley itself.  Five hundred and sixty-six years that war lasted, and in the end all the kingdoms of the Edain around us had fallen and Rivendell was a refuge for the Dunedain who had not fled west as well as the Elves... Then at last Gondor came to our aid and Angmar was defeated. But it was too late to save the North-kingdom by then.”

“Was it not very strange, Elrohir, to have the Edain living beside you?”  Nerdanel asked him, with a wondering look.

“The Dunedain are my cousins,” Elrohir said, baffled. “My father’s brother’s children. Why should it be strange to live with them?”

“Well, they live such short lives.  A couple of hundred years, isn’t that right?  It must be... well, it must be terribly sad.”

“Oh, I see,” Elrohir said, and thought about it.  “Yes, I suppose it is. You see them born, and grow up, and you fight beside them and they are your friends, and they grow old and tired, and there is another cousin growing up, and you fight beside them instead.  That’s just how it is, in Middle-earth. We remember them, and they go on. I think it’s harder for them than it is for us. But it made it easier to choose, that we knew them so well, Elladan and Arwen and me. We knew that whether we chose to stay in Arda or go beyond it, we would have friends.”  

Amrod hunched his shoulders and screwed up his eyes for a moment in obvious discomfort. “It seems so strange to me, that you and your brother chose different paths.”  He looked at Amras and grinned at him deliberately, showing his teeth. “It’s not that I have never been tempted to drop him off a cliff, obviously, but still, to walk away knowing it was the last time...”

“Amrod,” Nerdanel said warningly, but Elrohir waved the objection away with a slice of rye bread.

“It is something of a tradition for us,” he pointed out. “You and Amras have been together always, isn’t that right? And you knew you probably always would be.  But Elladan and I grew up knowing always that we might choose different paths one day, as my father and my uncle did, and knowing that... Well. When we were very young, we spent a good deal of time with our cousin Eldacar.  He was often in Imladris. He taught us to ride, took us hunting, we went with him to visit his home, Annúminas, the city of the Kings of Men — it was here, beside Lake Nenuial, Celebrimbor. He was like the best older brother you could imagine.  But after two hundred years, he was gone forever. Unless we chose to follow him. Yet our mother is an elf and bound to Arda unto world’s end. The choice was not the same for us as it would be for you.”

“It’s still not a completely unfamiliar dilemma, as it happens,” Amras said.  He got up and stood behind his mother, with his arms loosely around her shoulders. “Even if it was not quite so long-lasting in the end.”   Nerdanel put up a hand and squeezed his arm.

“I don’t know whether to think Celebrían lucky or unlucky,” she said unhappily, and ran a hand through her thick hair, tugging at it distractedly.  “At least I got my children back in the end, but not one of them chose me when it counted. Still wouldn’t.”

Amrod got up abruptly, pushing his chair back so hard it scraped on the pale sandstone floor.  “Curvo’s right,” he said. “You are quite impossible when you are in this mood.”

“She has a point,” Amras said.  “And tell me honestly you never regretted it, and I’ll have to call you a liar.”

Amrod stood poised for a moment, still looking annoyed, and then abruptly he laughed. “All right!” he said.  “We all regretted it sometimes.”

“I certainly did,” Celebrimbor said with a wry grin.  “Making a list of occasions when I thought: I wish I’d stayed with grandmother! would take me quite some time.”

“But you’d still do it all again, if Fëanáro asked you,” Nerdanel said sceptically.

Celebrimbor made a face. “I’m glad I got to meet Elrond and Elros, and I’m glad I got to work with the Broadbeams and the Longbeards. I did my best in a number of battles, and who knows?  Perhaps I made a difference? I’m glad that the Rings I made helped. But... I don’t know. It’s a very hard question.”

Nerdanel sighed, wrapped wild red hair around her fingers and tugged.  “Yes.”

“Your hair will be like a doormat if you keep doing that to it,” Amrod said, pulling out a comb from the pouch on his belt.  “Let me sort it out.” Amras sat down again to give him room to comb Nerdanel’s spiralling curls.

“So, did you ever decide?” Amrod said to his mother as he combed, long rhythmic strokes that pulled the shining hair out to its full length before it sprang back.  “Which one of us should have been Umbarto the fated?”

She looked around at him, and then at Amras for a long moment before she replied, and her eyes were sad and tired.  “All of you, in the end,” she said. “All of you were fated. I saw your doom ahead when you were born — not the form of it, no, or I would have tried to change things, or warn you. But the darkness, yes. Each of my children one by one, I looked into your eyes, and saw you had been born to go under the shadow. It was only my last two, my sweet Ambarussa, where I thought there might be a chance, for one of you at least.  But Fëanáro would not choose either of you to be the fated one, and neither of you would turn aside. So in the end it was both.”

“That must have been very hard to live with,” Elrohir said, moved by her sadness.

“Yes,” she said. “And of course I wonder.  If I had not seen it, if I had known nothing, would anything have been different? Would I have loved them more, somehow, would I have said something different, would they have stayed.  Would I have gone with them.” She sighed. Amrod began twisting her hair into a wide plait.

“It’s all over now,” Amras said, but his voice sounded uncertain.

“I know what you should make next,” Celebrimbor said to her, and his voice had a strength and a confidence behind it, a power worn but undefeated that reminded Elrohir again forcefully of Imladris.  “It has just come to me, what you should make next, and I would work with you on this, if you agree.”

“Of course, Tyelpë,” Nerdanel said, eyebrows raised in surprise.  “You know I enjoy working with you. But what is this idea?”

“We should fold the Shadow into our art,” Celebrimbor said.  He got up, his eyes bright. “We should take what you have seen, what I... all of it, the darkness and the hate, the lies, the pain.  All he did to me, all we lost, the bitterness that came from it. We should make something with that.”

“Smoked glass and black marble, perhaps,” Nerdanel said thoughtfully.  

“And gold,” Celebrimbor told her firmly.  “Definitely gold.”

“Mmmm.  You might have something there, Tyelpë,” she said. “Where’s my sketchbook?”

“I expect it’s where you left it yesterday,” Amras said, with considerable amusement. “Stay there and let Amrod finish your hair, and I’ll go and find it.”

“Would you?  Thank you!” Nerdanel exclaimed.  “But don’t take ages. Fëanáro will be here soon. I left him furiously scribbling plans for a sort of giant spear thing.  The Teleri use them to hunt whales, apparently. But if we’re going over to the springs of Gelion today, we’d better get going soon.”


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment