New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
A narrow pass led across the rugged grey shoulder of Mount Rerir. It took them north away from the lake; fortunate, that, since it meant there was no need to risk passing the lakeside and the Watcher that lurked beneath the surface.
Elrohir found the steep ride more exhausting than he had hoped. Fëanor himself had spoken words over his bruises and broken rib, but healing did not seem to be one of his stronger abilities: Elrond would certainly have done a more thorough job. But then, Father would have insisted that he spend a few days “resting just in case,” which was always dull. Fortunately, that seemed to be an unfamiliar concept to Fëanor.
But despite the smooth pace of his horse, the rough ground was hard on Elrohir’s bruises. He was glad when they were done with the uneven path through the hills.
Fëanor dismounted, and Elrohir gratefully followed, sitting down on a reed-tussock to rest his aching ribs, while the High King took out his Silmaril and set it on his brow. The warm light from the jewel went shimmering like summer sun through birch leaves, and sparkled merrily upon the clear surface of the young stream that ran away south to become the great river Gelion.
One Silmaril lived with Elrohir’s grandfather Eärendil, sailing in the sky as a star, and the Silmaril that Maedhros had taken was still buried deep within the land. But this last gem had been flung by Maglor from the coast of Lindon. It had lain upon the sea-bed for many long years, and when Beleriand had risen again, it awaited its creator, shining still.
It seemed, as far as Elrohir was able to judge, happy with recent events, and brightened joyfully in Fëanor’s hand, as he had seen Eärendil’s gem brighten for him.
Elrohir glanced cautiously at Amras, who had been called the bloody-handed by the survivors of Doriath and the Havens. He wondered if the jewel would endure the hand of Amras as joyfully as it did Fëanor.
This Silmaril was the one that had burned Maglor so fiercely that his hand was still scarred. Amras had attacked the Havens too.
But that was all a very long time ago, and even if the Silmaril had not forgiven it, Elrohir had no inclination to bear a grudge that his father would certainly disapprove of. He would keep his grudges for the orcs. There was nothing complicated about orcs.
Fëanor, untroubled by such questions, beckoned Amras over to the stream. Amras made introductions, and after a moment, the River Gelion stepped up from her bed to greet them.
Here at her springs she took the form of a child, her small body shining bright as if with dew, though under the bright sheen there was a dark strength. The River’s hair was green and gold, and it flowed around her as if it felt a current in the air that no-one else could feel. She reached up wonderingly to the Silmaril with a glistening finger, and laughed as Fëanor knelt smiling to let her touch it and its light ran over her.
He held out a plain green stone, not faceted but smooth, with a faint golden fire set deep within it: a work of wonder by any measure. “A gift, to the River of the Land.”
"A joyous day blessed with light!” she exclaimed, and took the stone and looked into it for a moment, smiling, before she cast it into the water by her feet. Then she looked up, and caught Fëanor’s hand and Amras’s and whirled them both into a swift dance among the yellow buttercups. Fëanor reached out with his other hand to pull Nerdanel into the dance, and then all the Elves were dancing, forgetting grief in the endless music of the River.
Elrohir got up to join them, a little cautious of his ribs. It was worth a little stiffness for the joy of the moment lit by sun and the light of a Silmaril. Around them, the plume-eared long-legged hounds that followed Amras pranced joyfully, and the horses shook their long manes and tails.
Then the River broke away from the dance, and the dancers swirled to a stop as swiftly as they had begun.
“My children have advised me to seek your counsel on a strange matter,” Fëanor said, all at once intensely serious, and he described the matter that had brought them there.
The River listened in silence to his words. Then he called on Elrohir to speak of the Watcher that had guarded Moria, and of what he had seen and smelled in the lake. As he spoke, the River grew tall and strong, as if in spate, until she towered above the Elves before her, and her waters roiled, brown and strong now, and full of shining flecks.
“There are people like that who dwell far below the land,” she said, her face uneasy as the waters. “They live in the secret caverns where our waters dive deep into darkness. We remember their names, we, the rivers and the streams that carry tidings of the sunlit lands even to the uttermost depths. But their songs are not cruel or evil, though they never come up into the light of moon or star. It is not their place.”
“This one did,” Celebrimbor said, his sharp face, so much like his grandfather's, looking serious. “It came right to the surface and felt along the shoreline as far as it could reach.”
“It took hold of our boat and gripped it as if with a will of iron,” Fëanor said. “How can these... people... be fought?”
“Perhaps they can be fought,” Gelion said, frowning like a thunderstorm. “Perhaps. It is not a thing that I have ever had to do, not even when the Darkness came.... A bitter time.” She looked away along the valley into the south where the land widened and opened upon the endless plains of Beleriand. “Perhaps I and Helevorn could rise in flood in the lake and so dislodge it. But perhaps not. They are very strong. The lake is wide and deep: a bowl of strong stone. It might be that we would only bring ourselves to helpless shallows, and yet still it would cling to the rocks. We are not so able at war as the Elves,” she said and the shadow of old pain came into her eyes.
Amras took her hand, and she dwindled to face him. “You were an able ally in our great need,” he said meeting her eyes steadily. “We are grateful. I hoped only that you could aid us with knowledge, and you have done that. Is there more that we should know?”
She sparkled at him gratefully. “Such knowledge as I have I will give you freely. What can I say of the people of the Great Deeps? They do not see with eyes, they...” she made an expressive gesture with her hand.
“Hand-speech?” Celebrimbor suggested. “Like the iglishmêk of the Dwarves.”
“Yes! Hand-speech. Body-speech, you might say. And when the land is dry high above and the flow of the stream is gentle, they sleep long in their darkness, and murmur soft words to the water. But when the rain comes and the time comes for the rivers to dance in the wildest floods, they cling to their rocks and dance with us, as trees in the storm.” She shook her streaming head. “But who knows what this creature of the lake may do? If it is twisted and broken and turned from darkness to which it was born towards terror and Unlight... I do not know.”
“Sleep,” Fëanor said thoughtfully, and looked, for some reason, at Nerdanel. “They talk in their sleep? You asked before if it would be dangerous if not provoked, Nerdanel. I had thought of killing it, but now I wonder. If we could cast it into sleep at first, then perhaps Celegorm could speak with it.”
“It is a servant of the Enemy,” Elrohir pointed out, startled enough to interrupt. “They speak only lies, and their will is cruelty and torment. You can only flee them, or slay them. They will entrap you, if they can.”
Fëanor gave him a swift flame-fierce look, and Elrohir had to restrain himself from recoiling. But Elrohir had near two thousand years of fighting the Enemy in Middle-earth behind him, and Fëanor had had, perhaps a month. He met Fëanor’s eyes and did not flinch, and after a moment, Fëanor nodded.
“Yet Morgoth is gone, and Sauron is a voice on the wind, and his remaining servants scattered now, they say,” Fëanor said,and touched the Silmaril upon his brow for a moment, his narrow face stern with thought. “It seems a pity to lose this one chance to find out more about these people that live so far below the land, even if this individual is not at its best. Still, one thing at a time. We know that it can sleep, and is likely to be quiet when it does so. That gives us a first step, at least.”
Elrohir might have said something more, about whether Celegorm the Hasty was really the person most to be trusted in speaking with a servant of the Enemy, but he had won his main point, and that was enough for now. Giving public counsel to a king required a light hand, and Elrohir was very practiced at it.He had lost count of the kings of Middle-earth to whom he had brought news and counsel from Rivendell. Admittedly, few of those kings had been Elves. None of them had been at all like Fëanor.
“I came to ask your counsel in this matter,” Fëanor said now to the River. “Have you more to say of this water-beast — or water-person, if that is the correct way to speak of it? If we cast it into sleep, what path would you counsel me to take afterwards?”
The River looked over at Elrohir, a long cool deep look, with quiet reserves behind it like deep pools under willow-trees.
“I cannot tell,” she said. She looked away and trailed one foot in the stream behind her as if distracted, and rubbed at her left wrist with her right hand.
Fëanor looked down at her and frowned in puzzlement. Then he bundled his formal cloak behind him and sat down on the grass next to her, beckoning Nerdanel over with an abrupt jerk of the head, and dismissing the other elves with an equally abrupt wave of one hand.
Celebrimbor and Amras turned away as if this was entirely usual. “Come on,” Amras said to Elrohir. “They’ll be talking for a while, I expect. Let’s get some lunch.”
They had brought with them white bread, honey, cheese and apples: simple food but plenty of it, and the Elves that had come with Fëanor scattered in small groups along the bank and through the trees. Elrohir sat down beside Celebrimbor and Amras to eat.
“She was a captive of the Enemy herself,” Amras said quietly, when he saw Elrohir glance back curiously across at the River and her two guests. The River was now lying against a low shingle bank, having dwindled to the form of a small child. Fëanor was lounging on the bank, and Nerdanel, wearing a very serious expression, had taken her boots off, rolled up the bottom of her breeches and was dabbling her bare feet in the water.
Elrohir raised his eyebrows enquiringly. Even Sauron at his greatest had been wary of the powers of the waters.
“Ulmo’s power retreated from the rivers of Beleriand, at the end,” Celebrimbor said, glancing over at the small figure upon the shingle-shore. “Even the rivers were fouled, darkened and enthralled.”
Amras nodded. “A bitter time for her and all her sisters. Now the rivers and streams have woken again to life, but they have not forgotten. Easier for her to speak of it in private, than to many listening ears, I think.”
“Surely though, what happened to the rivers before Beleriand fell is very different to this Watcher in the Water?” Elrohir asked. “The Watcher of Moria was as much a thing of darkness as any orc, by all accounts.”
“I don’t know how to judge a water-beast that serves the Enemy, against a River fouled,” Amras said. He gave Elrohir an uncomfortably perceptive sideways look. “But then, there are probably those who would say I was next thing to an orc myself...It must be strange for you, Elrohir, to come among us kinslayers.”
“Oh, come on, Amras,” Celebrimbor said uncomfortably. “That’s all over long ago.”
“It was for us,” Amras said and gave his nephew an unrepentant grin. “I fought my war and waited long enough in the dreary halls of glum old Námo to pay for it. But Elrohir has only recently come from his war, and by all accounts, he was always on the side of right and the will of the Valar. Don’t you ever wonder what we look like from those sunlit confident uplands, Tyelpë?”
Celebrimbor shrugged uneasily, and did not reply.
It was the kind of thing that mortal cousins often said, as if the Elves of Rivendell and the Valar were entirely of one mind, and the war in Middle-earth entirely a matter of self-confident light against the darkness. Strange to hear Amras speak as if he were a younger cousin of the Dunedain.
“No-one in Rivendell would blame Celebrimbor for anything,” Elrohir said firmly. “I’ll admit your reputation is darker, Amras.” That might have been a little provocative, but after all, Amras had started this.
“Ambarussa, the butchers of Doriath, hunters of our own kin,” Amras said, not without a certain relish. “Perhaps the orcs have similar names for you, Elrohir.”
“Oh, they do,” Elrohir said, and smiled deliberately, since they seemed to be leaving tact and diplomacy behind in what was probably a thoroughly Fëanorian way of going about things. “The orcs began our fight, and they more than earned everything that we did to them.”
Celebrimbor winced and looked away. “Dear Celebrían. If there was anyone in Middle-earth who should not have had to endure anything like that, it was her.”
“Nobody should have to endure the attentions of orcs,” Elrohir said. “We were fighting to survive. That means drawing a clear line between friend and enemy, and the orcs were always very definitely on the wrong side of that, all of them. It wasn’t a line any of them would ever choose to cross.”
“I wonder,” Celebrimbor said quietly. “I would have agreed with that once, Elrohir, but now I wonder. They were terribly afraid of us.”
“But when you are struggling to survive at all, you do have to be careful who to trust,” Elrohir pointed out kindly. “Even when Eregion and Lindon were strong, the armies of the orcs were stronger. By the time that Angmar rose to power, Rivendell was balanced on a knife-edge.”
“I heard,” Celebrimbor said, and sighed. “And yet, there’s something very sad about a line drawn between friend and enemy. Once that’s done, you’re stuck with it.”
“True,” Elrohir admitted. He took a bite of apple and thought about it. “And it wasn’t always as simple as it was with the orcs. I don’t know what the opinion of the Valar would have been, when my cousins’ kingdom of Arnor fell apart around us. Rhudaur entered into alliance with Angmar on our very doorstep. The few that we thought we could probably still trust from Rhudaur fled to Rivendell for sanctuary, and then went on to Cardolan. It might be that there were wraiths among them, walking in borrowed bodies, or simply that there were those who were not friends as we hoped. Cardolan fell to the wraiths, later, you see.”
He shook his head and then shrugged. “ I don’t know myself if every choice we made in those days was right. If the Valar had opinions about it, they would have been most welcome to come and lend us a hand. ”
Amras laughed. “There’s a familiar feeling!”
Elrohir grinned at him. “I imagine it is... It doesn’t feel like you’re inevitably on the side of right and justice and the will of the Valar, when you find yourself in the middle of a civil war.”
He looked at Celebrimbor. “Three of the Nine Ringwraiths were our cousins, men of Númenor.”
Celebrimbor made a face. “That’s grim to think of.”
“Yes. But we all know that Númenor has not always been on the side of right, or justice... nor it did it always follow the will of the Valar. My father hoped for a long while that they might not be entirely lost... But there are some people who are set on a course that ends in darkness, and cannot be won back. Those who choose the wolfs-head and will not turn back must be hunted as wolves, before they take you by the throat.”
“Hmm,” Amras said, offering Elrohir a second apple from the bag, and throwing it over to him when he nodded. “I find myself very glad our wars did not overlap, Elrohir, or at least that we never found ourselves on opposite sides. But here’s a thought. When you are surrounded by enemies and darkness, there’s no choice but to hunt the wolf whenever you see him. It’s him or you. But in the light of peace, you might take the risk that the wolf cub might grow up and choose not to bite you.”
“I suppose you could,” Elrohir said, lying back on the grass, rather cautiously lest he should catch his bruises. “But why would you risk it?”
“Well, because the wolves too have their place. They are hunters, as we are. And they are beautiful,” Amras said with a smile. “There are wolves that run with Oromë, you know: you should get him to take you hunting, sometime. I... doubt I’ll get a chance to do that again myself: I’m not quite sure enough that Oromë would count me as one of the hunters and not as quarry. But you should try it.”
“Perhaps,” Elrohir said comfortably. “Though the game sounds somewhat risky. Perhaps I shall stick to hunting beside my kinsmen. You did a reasonable job distracting that bear.”
Amras waved a hand. “You’d have got him anyway if we’d hung on another moment or two. We could go salmon fishing, what do you think? Fishing beside an otter would be something new... Though I thought you were in a hurry to be off to Tasarinan to visit Artanis?”
“I was,” Elrohir said. “But no doubt the salmon will be here next year... unless the creature in the lake eats them all. I can’t see your brother Caranthir being too happy about leaving such a creature to roam his fishing grounds.”
“He’s bound to grumble,” Celebrimbor said, looking more cheerful. “He always grumbles. But if Grandfather makes the decision, he’ll carry it through, of course.”
“And you think that’s a good thing?” Elrohir asked.
Celebrimbor shrugged and looked sideways at Amras through narrowed eyes. “Perhaps not,” he said after a long assessing look. “But it’s not as if Grandfather doesn’t have people to argue with him and make him think twice. Grandmother. Me. You. Elrond. Turgon sends him long, complicated letters that are very well-researched, he loves them. They make him think. Then there’s Galadriel, of course. The Ents! He had a ten-day argument with old Fangorn when he arrived, did you know? I was somewhat worried, but nothing got singed and I think they both enjoyed it in the end. And then there’s good old great-auntie Lalwen, and his brothers... He’s a king, not a tyrant.”
Amras said, very quietly and unusually for him, very seriously. “Maglor. Maedhros.”
“Yes,” Celebrimbor said. “That, too. Though I hope we can avoid arguments there, it hurts them all far too much. Oh, it looks as though they’ve finished their private chat with the River. Shall we go and ask if they have come to any conclusions?”
***
The Feast of the Lighting of the Lamps was over at last, and Elrohir, now fully recovered from his bruises, was riding out on the horse that Amras had given him.
He had said his farewells, and was now heading South and East, on his way to the willow-meads of Tasarinan where Galadriel walked beside the rivers Narog and Sirion among the unfading trees — if she had not already set sail back to Tol Eressëa, or to visit her mother in Alqualondë. Elrohir had ended up staying in the Eastmarch considerably longer than he had intended.
If Galadriel had gone, then no matter. Elrohir had arranged to go hunting again with Amrod and Amras, next spring. He could visit his grandmother then.
There would be time enough to speak with her again in peace, and perhaps he would sail home for a while, and tell Mother what he had seen and done. It would be a fine thing to talk to her about the work that Nerdanel and Celebrimbor had begun. That was sure to interest her.
Beleriand was not quite Rivendell or Lórien, and nor was Tol Eressëa and nor was Aman, but it was a fine thing to have time to explore them all.
As he rode along the the lakeside road, he noticed Celegorm, who had arrived at Caranthir’s fort some days previously, reclining in the sunlit grass. One hand was trailing in the clear water.
“Away to visit Artanis?” Celegorm asked Elrohir as he checked his horse to greet him.
Elrohir nodded. “I had meant to travel there some time ago, but when I met your brothers, they invited me to attend the festival.” His eyes went to the water. “Is that...”
Celegorm nodded. “It reaches up from time to time and just touches my fingertips.” He looked up at Elrohir with eyes narrowed against the light of the sky, his long shining hair spread loose around his shoulders. “Of course, if I were you, I would be able to swim down and speak with it more easily.”
“The conversation I had with it was not a very amicable one,” Elrohir said wryly. “I prefer it half-asleep.”
“I can feel it dreaming,” Celegorm said. “Dark dreams, most of them, filled with cruelty, greed and malice. But not all of them are evil. There are dreams of sweet water bubbling cool over bright stone. Dreams of sunlight on green weed deep in the lake. Perhaps in time there may be more of them. I think it will be happier if there are.”
“I hope so,” Elrohir said, sincerely, and rode on.