Two Peredhil and an Elf in a Boat by bunn
Fanwork Notes
- Fanwork Information
-
Summary:
How many thousands of years does it take, to transform a distant sire into a kinsman and a friend?
Major Characters: Elrond, Gil-galad, Eärendil
Major Relationships:
Genre:
Challenges:
Rating: General
Warnings:
This fanwork belongs to the series
Chapters: 1 Word Count: 5, 139 Posted on Updated on This fanwork is complete.
Chapter 1
Read Chapter 1
Elrond looked doubtfully down at the clear green water, veined with fine white foam, and the small white boat floating at the bottom of the bronze-railed ladder, rising and falling with the gentle swell.
“I thought,” he said, surprised, “That you were bringing Vingilot.”
Eärendil grinned up at him from the deck of the little yacht. “I will take you up in Vingilot another time, if you wish. But I do spend a very great deal of time on board Vingilot. Now and again, on a fine sunny morning, it’s good to leave behind the ship that soars between the stars for white sails to run before the wind.”
A thought seemed to come to him, and Eärendil frowned in sudden concern, looking up at Elrond high above. “You do know how to sail a boat?”
Elrond considered the considerable expertise of the Mariner. “Imladris is many days ride from the Sea, and it has been long...” he began to excuse himself.
Gil-galad came up behind him, his simple blue tunic kilted to the knee, and a well-worn leather bag slung over his shoulder. He interrupted Elrond in mid-sentence.
“It’s true. It is a long, long ride to the Sea from his far-off mountain-valley,” he agreed, shaking his silver head at Eärendil, the picture of solemn sadness. “Really, Elrond is terribly unfamiliar with both ships and the Sea.”
Eärendil stared up at them both with wide shocked blue eyes for a brief moment. Then his eyes narrowed.
“You.” he said to the High King, an exclamation of amusement and annoyance all together.
Gil-galad laughed, “I nearly had you there. Come on Eärendil, he spent over a thousand years in Lindon with me and Cirdan, before ever he went near Imladris. Of course he knows how to sail.”
“It really has been a very long time,” Elrond protested, smiling. “That rigging is not of a kind that I have seen before, and of the three of us, I am certain I am the least skilled in this particular art. ”
Gil-galad said with a quicksilver grin: “Then, our chance to practise has come. I don’t know that form of rigging either. It could be that he discovered it from above, in some distant land far beyond the realms we know, but from the look of delighted explanation on his face, I’ll bet that he invented it.”
Eärendil grinned at them both. “Correct! Well, mostly correct. Come on board.The wind is set fair from the north-west, it will hold all of today, if I’m any judge. I’ll show you how it works.”
The boat ran light across translucent water rippled silver with shoals of small fish. Her white sail cast pale reflections on the water as they left the harbour with Eärendil’s sure hand upon the tiller. The wind freshened as they came out from the shelter of the Lonely Isle, and the small ship leaped forward more eagerly across the broad backs of the green waves, sending a sparkling foam splashing from her curving bows.
Behind them, the cliffs retreated purple and gold in the morning light, and far beyond them westward, the greater mountains of Valinor came faintly into view. But Eärendil’s hand was steady on the tiller, and the sails strained against the strange rigging. Ahead, the water darkened to a true ocean-blue, with not a sign of weed or rocks below them, though the sea was clear as a blue glass.
Gil-galad and Eärendil talked amiably of the positioning of boom mounting points and back stays, of the importance of flexibility in spars, and debated the efficiency of inverted bows.
Elrond could remember just enough of boat-craft to more or less understand the conversation, and to suspect that Gil-galad was probably making guesses in order to keep up.
Still, Eärendil — Father — seemed to be enjoying himself. He insisted that Elrond take the tiller, while he moved around the boat, showing off its various cunning devices proudly.
Elrond had little to add to the conversation as long as it ran on boats, but he listened carefully to the explanations and opinions, thinking that another time, he might suggest that Elrohir and Erestor come with them, and that if they did, it would not do for Elrond to look baffled by these matters when Eärendil — Father — spoke of them.
“So,” Father said after a while “Why Imladris, Elrond? I always wanted to ask you that. I was surprised when I heard that you’d left Lindon for good.”
“Because I asked him to,” Gil-galad replied, before Elrond had an answer.
“Well, that, too,” Elrond agreed. “When I left Lindon — well, you probably know about that?”
The wind was freshening, and the boat heeled over a little singing as she sailed, a small burbling music under the bow that Elrond had not heard for many lives of men.
“I’ve heard something of it,” Eärendil said. “There were stories that came back into the west with weary travellers coming home, that came to Elwing’s ears and so to me. And of course, I have spent a lot of time looking down on you, whenever I can. But why don’t you tell me anyway? I’d like to hear you tell it.”
There was something about Eärendil’s hopeful interest that hurt Elrond’s heart, and the hurt was for many things that had been lost, long before he had ever seen Imladris.
Still. Now they had time: time at last for the telling of tales.
Elrond smiled, and raised his voice a little, the better to be heard over the sounds of wind and water.
“Very well then, So: Celebrimbor had brought the three Rings to Gil-galad, with the news that Annatar was unmasked as Sauron himself, and would go to war.”
“Did you say ‘I told you so?” Eärendil enquired, with interest.
Gil-galad managed to frown at him in a kingly, serious manner at the question for almost long enough for Eärendil to be taken aback, then spoiled the effect by laughing. “I’ve said it to him since, but at the time...”
“It wasn’t the moment,” Elrond agreed. “And it’s not as though we’d been sure. We thought there was something odd about Annatar, but none of us had an idea who he really was.”
Unless Celebrimbor had known, and had taken a gamble that failed. Elrond had wondered about that. If so, Celebrimbor was silent on the subject, and Elrond was reluctant to push him about it.
Anyway, there was plenty more of the story without that. He surrendered the tiller to Gil-galad, and went on with the tale.
“Sauron’s legions were marching north, burning all in their path. Eregion was besieged. So Gil-galad here decided that we must send help. He sent me, with a host of everyone who could be spared without completely emptying Lindon.”
There had been so many of Elrond’s friends in Eregion, quite aside from Celebrimbor himself. Names and faces came to his thought.
“We rode out, without any great hope of success, for the rumour of Sauron’s armies made them even greater than they were. The land was dark and choking with the smoke of the burning forests that hid the sun and stars.”
Eärendil nodded. “I remember that. I could see nothing, looking down from Vingilot, but a great pall of black smoke.”
“I am sure it was planned so that his orcs and trolls could move freely. It made it harder for us to move swiftly. No doubt he planned that too. At any rate, by the time we had found our way through the vapours and smokes to the river-border of Eregion, it was too late. Sauron had already ruined Ost-in-Edhil, and he turned on us in fury.
“I picked up what survivors I could, and we fled north with all speed. The Dwarves struck at Sauron as we ran — not that I knew it at the time, but that gave us a slim chance, and we took it. Then we ran into Celeborn and his people.
“We couldn’t get back to Lindon: there were orc-legions west of us by then. So we looked for a refuge: anywhere we could hope to defend. And we found Imladris.”
“The valley of the Riven Dell,” Eärendil said. “I have looked down on it so many times, since then, but I remember, when first I heard that you were there, it was hard to make out at all.”
“The mountains and the cliffs hide it in their shadow,” Elrond said, thinking back to that first sight of the valley opening before them, the water falling white over the great blue-grey shadowed cliffs and the shining green of the river-meadows. “A useful stronghold, at first, and hard to attack if it is defended. That was why I settled there. Eregion was gone, we needed — Gil-galad needed someone further east to watch for signs of Sauron.”
“It didn’t have to be you,” Gil-galad pointed out. This was, Elrond thought privately, transparently untrue.
Eregion had three princes: Celebrimbor, Galadriel and Celeborn and had needed all three to hold the balance between Sindar and Noldor of Fëanorian, Fingolfinian and Arafinwëan allegiance, not to mention Men and dwarves.
With Celebrimbor fallen, Elrond had been the only possible captain. But the reasons for that were not ones that he wanted to explain to Eärendil. To his father.
“Well, the valley is beautiful,” he said, instead. “We were stuck there for a good while,so I had a chance to get to know the place. Sauron’s host held us besieged there for near-on three years: that is, my host, Celeborn’s people and the remnants of Eregion all together. Yet even knowing what lay beyond the cliff-walls, it felt ...safe. A strong, kind place, even in the worst times. That first winter, it was cold as the Enemy’s heart. Snow was on the ground for weeks, and the river ran deep under ice. We were hungry. And yet...all the slopes were coloured in shades of lilac and blue, and the trees were decked with shining snow, and the waterfalls all turned to green ice that caught the light at mid-day, if there was sunlight. In the evening, sometimes, you could look up and see the stars come out before the day was done.”
Elrond smiled, almost to himself, caught in a bright memory from a very long time ago. “And that was where I first met Celebrían, too. I’ll never forget that first sight of her. Like a vision in the sunlight under the waterfalls... She came to Imladris looking for her father, after the fleet of Númenor came and broke the siege.”
“Númenor,” Eärendil said, and sighed. He got up to adjust the sails a little; blunt, expert sailors’ hands on the silky grey ropes, that were very different to Elrond’s slender harpist’s hands.
“Númenor,” he said again. “ I was so proud of Númenor. For a while. And then...I still am not sure quite how it all went so wrong. There was a time when our family in Númenor felt so close. We saw them grow, I and Elwing, and build great peaceful cities, and then... it was as if there was a sickness that struck at the heart. We grew distant and unwelcome. Then... it was almost as if they had turned into something else entirely. ”
“I think you should still be proud,” Elrond told him firmly. He had thought about this so many times. He had talked of it with Elendil the Tall, with Arvedui Lastking, with Aragorn. The same discussion, with different faces, different tales and battles shaping the debate, along with the long shadows of all the Men he had spoken with before.
And now at last he had some time to speak of it with Eärendil, who was not a Man at all. “We can be proud of the good in it. I am glad, still, that Ciryatur came out of the West with his fleet and drove Sauron away into the East. It saved my life, and a good many others in Eriador. I am proud of the beauty of Númenor: the learning, and the making. And afterwards, too. There was greatness in Arnor and in Gondor. Light and wisdom to hold back the horror and the dark.”
“They felled the forests and took the people as slaves,” Eärendil said, very gently, as if he thought Elrond might not have noticed something that was visible even to the stars in the sky.
Gil-galad was watching Elrond without speaking. This was not the business of Elves.
“Not all of them,” Elrond replied quietly. “Not even at the end. I have watched them...” No, that was wrong. The Mariner too had watched it all. “We both watched them all go down into the dark: Númenor, Arnor, Rhudaur, Cardolan, Arthedain. And there were always many who deserved better. There were always those who Ionged for peace and light and learning, and turned away from the sword, or used it only because they had no choice. Even in Mordor, after Sauron fell. You can’t doubt that was a good deed well worth the pain, even though we lost so much.”
Gil-galad snorted. “I’m glad you feel my death was worth the price I paid for it.”
“It was,” Elrond said, unhesitating. He looked over at his sire, long-lost, now found but nearly a stranger. “And yours, too, Father. All you gave up, for those who planted and wrote and built and sang.”
The wind was rising. Gil-galad gave up the tiller to Eärendil, and went as he suggested to keep an eye on the fore-sail.
The sea around them was now a deep dark blue, and the white beaches of Aman were a misty line along the edge of sight. Great long rolling waves lifted them like hills and the white boat rode them like a bird. Overhead, the sky was now an overcast pale grey.
Gil-galad stood, his hand on the mast, looking out at the vast darkness of the Sea. “We’ve come a long way.”
Eärendil nodded, and he too stood, looking out, then he nudged the tiller to turn the boat a little away from the wind, though he had no map or compass or any other obvious way of determining a course. “We have reached the true Belegaer. The waters here are deep and cold.”
“And Ulmo moves through the waters, in the darkness beneath any light of sun or star,” Gil-galad said. He had to speak louder than usual above the sound of wind and water. The boat was leaping across the waves, her sails straining.
Elrond looked out at the great black hill of water they were climbing with disquiet. “Is the boat fit for these waves?”
“She’s stronger than she looks,” Eärendil replied, and said no more. Gil-galad moved his weight to balance the boat.
Elrond began to notice a faint cold mist in the air. He could no longer see any land, and the horizon was hazy with low cloud.
He thought of suggesting that it might be time to turn back, but “Not much further now,” Eärendil said, and his voice rang upon the great deeps as if in prophecy.
All around them, as if they had grown from the white foam, birds were flying, calling out in many voices.
The dark water was stilling, now only a gentle swell.
Ahead was a long low shape in the water, that as they came closer to it became a worn red rocky slope thrusting up from the great deeps. They were approaching on the sheltered side, and as they came closer, Elrond could see a faint green cap above the water.
An island, barely.
Around them, the water was thick with birds diving and preening in great floating rafts. The cliffs were white with them. Eärendil let out the sails,and the boat slowed as the rocks blocked the wind.
“Is this one of the Enchanted Isles?” Gil-galad asked. “I thought they had all been swept away long ago.”
Eärendil shook his head. “No. There are no Enchanted Isles, not since the Downfall. The mist we came through may be a remnant of them, but if so, it’s no more than memory. No, this is Númenor.”
Elrond stood up, one hand on a rope for balance, and stared at it: the dim hump of rock, the many birds, the black waters. “Surely we cannot have come so far in a morning’s sailing. All the records agree that you could barely see Aman from the peak of the Meneltarma, even on the clearest day, before the world was bent!”
“It was a fair wind,” Eärendil said, unsmiling. “We sail here beyond the world’s seas: west of West, on waters that have known many enchantments. And our House has Ulmo’s favour.”
“To the island where my brother died.”
Gil-galad reached out a hand as if in comfort for a grief out of the deeps of time, then let it fall as Elrond met his eyes.
“Yes. To the island where my son died,” Eärendil said to him, and there was something almost defiant in his voice.
“It was his choice,” Elrond said steadily. “And Arwen’s, too.”
“I wish I could have known Arwen. I watched her wedding from the skies.”
“Not the same as being there,” Gil-galad said with sympathy in his voice.
“No,” Elrond agreed, against the sound of deep cold water lapping.
“I heard,” Eärendil said cautiously, “That you said she could not wed, unless to the King of Gondor restored.”
“Yes,” Elrond said. Arwen was his only daughter. He had kept his children by him as long as he could endure, had protected all his children in every way he could, but there was no way to explain that to Eärendil.
“I wish,” Eärendil said, in something of a rush, “That I could know you better, Elrond.”
Elrond looked over at him, disquieted. “You do know me. We met today to go sailing. We’ve met a number of times.”
“As strangers might, who share a friend,” Eärendil glanced at Gil-galad. “You’re civil enough, yet I never know what you are thinking.”
Elrond hesitated, trying to read intent from Eärendil’s faded blue eyes, his slight frown.
Eärendil went on, as if trying to fill Elrond’s silence. “I... I have no right to complain. I left you and Elros, and I never came back.”
“For the best of reasons,” Gil-galad said quickly.
Eärendil shrugged. “If I could do it all again, I would do things differently.”
“Really? You’d doom all Middle-earth to save your children?” Elrond said, and wished he had softened the words.
“Why not?” Eärendil demanded. “I never asked to be a star. I’ve thought of this through so many nights, sailing the darkness in Vingilot. I could have taken all of you: Elwing, the Silmaril and my sons, and sailed to Valinor. I don’t know why I didn’t.”
“Perhaps my memory is clearer than yours, then,” Gil-galad said firmly. “You left them because you thought it safer. We all did. You thought you’d left them in safety in the Havens, while you took the difficult and dangerous way across the pathless seas.”
“This was all over so long ago,” Elrond said. “Does it still matter? Father.” he added, a fraction of a second too late.
“It hasn’t mattered since Elros died,” Eärendil said bluntly. “But now it does, because more than six thousand years after you were first invited, you have finally come into the West, and I have a son again. Or so Elwing says. I don’t know how you feel about it.”
Elrond frowned. “You wish then, that I would speak more openly? Very well then, I will. You have spent six thousand years a distant legend, a hero in the skies. But my path has been different. I have spent my life among Men, Elves, Dwarves and Hobbits. I have concerned with their lives and business: large and small. I have been foster-father to many orphans, advisor to many kings. I am ancient, Eärendil: only a few handfuls of years younger than you. Elros, when you knew him, was young. I am not.”
Eärendil bowed his head, but Elrond felt a sense of relief, as if he had laid a ghost.
“The three of us all have this in common,” Gil-galad said. “All three of us knew Elros. Knew him as a man, not a legend or a king, and remember him as a kinsman. Let us go up onto the Meneltarma, what’s left of it, and remember him.”
There was something wrong with that. “Is Númenor not counted as part of Middle-earth?” Elrond asked. “I thought you could not set foot there. Here, I mean.”
Eärendil gave him a brief, troubled smile. “That was true, once. But it’s been a long time since anyone was concerned with where this island is. I don’t think the Valar pay much attention to the charts kept in Alqualondë.” He smiled wryly. “For that matter, I don’t think they pay much attention any more to where I am. Or Elwing, either.”
They did not anchor the boat. At Eärendil’s command it slid through the dark waters up to the shore to let them alight, then like a great bird, retreated to rest on the patch of still sea in the shelter of the island.
Gil-galad, standing on the ruins of Númenor, turned to Elrond. “It was all such a long time ago,” he said sympathetically. “That’s the hardest thing about all of it,” he waved a hand to indicate the extent of all Númenor lost. “When I returned to life, I was burning to get back to it. To Middle-earth. But they told me no. My time for life in Middle-earth is over.”
“We could have used your strength,” Elrond said, thinking of the slow ruin of Isildur’s realm of Arnor, of the wights that had come to dwell in the graves of Cardolan. Then he took firm hold on the day. “No matter. The time has come for all of us to leave Middle-earth and all its woes behind us.”
*****
Elrond had never visited the Meneltarma, though he had heard so many descriptions from homesick Numenoreans, had read so many detailed accounts, that he felt as though he had.
He could see it in his mind: the great road spiralling to the very mountain peak in the heart of the island of Númenor, leading to the wide cup, vast enough to accommodate the people of a city, edged with a tall rim of rock, thousands of feet high above the plain below.
A huge, rocky, silent space where no animal or bird ever came, save only for the Eagles of Manwë, and where no word was ever spoken, save by the King.
Now, it was neither tall nor silent. It stood only a few feet above the water, and one side of the great stone cup had vanished into the depths of the sea, leaving a rough bouldered slope leading up to a level space like a half-moon, sheltered from the sea-winds by the worn remains of the rim. The boulders were sea-washed and smooth, and among them small ferns and grasses had taken a hold. In sheltered crevices, tiny blue flowers lifted their tousled heads.
Elrond turned right around, looking for some sign of Númenor-that-was. Perhaps a worn step or a stone that had once been shaped by tools.
There was nothing.
And everywhere there were birds, living and dead, calling wildly from their refuges among the rocks, or leaving small delicate traceries of bones that crunched underfoot. One end of the island was white with their droppings, though even in the shelter of the rocks there was enough of a sea-wind that the place smelled more of sea than bird.
And yet it was Númenor. The rocks, unshaped and sea-worn, still remembered the high and holy place that they had been: the long silence, the fire and wave that ended it.
Gil-galad scrambled up to the rocky lip on the windward side and stood there on the perilous lip, looking out, his silver hair catching in the sea-wind like a banner.
Elrond considered the slope, identified a couple of footholds and decided that if Gil-galad could climb up there, Elf though he was, then so could Elrond.
He had to let go of dignity and scrabble with his hands, but he made it, and turned in time to pull Eärendil up over a place where the rock had slipped under his foot.
The wind was fierce again up here, driving stinging droplets against their faces, and before them was the wild green emptiness of the open sea under a vast grey sky.
They looked out in silence, thinking their own thoughts.
Elrond thought of Elros as he had been as a boy in the Havens of Sirion, running and fighting with a reed-sword along the shore, paddling barefoot in the cold clear stream that ran down to the waters of Sirion.
He thought of Elros at war, growing into a leader of his people with Gil-galad’s guidance.
He thought of Elros as a man, choosing to take up kingship and take ship into the West with all his people. He thought of how Elros had named himself Tar-Minyatur, the High First Lord of his new land, and had decreed the silence of the Meneltarma.
Now all that Elros had built was lost, or at least, translated and changed into newer tongues, transformed beyond reckoning. All that Elrond had built, too, would be lost.
The Sea did not care for any of that.
It came to him that when talking to Eärendil, he had not spoken with the authority and experience of the Lord of Imladris, of the Herald of Gil-galad, or even Elros’s lieutenant.
No, he had looked at Eärendil, and had been troubled by the memory of two small boys whose father had sailed away, and left them in danger.
But it had been so very long since he had been one of those small boys, he was surprised at himself that the child was still there, could still colour his thought at all.
But it didn’t have to be like that. He could choose to be any of the many versions and colours of himself that he had taken on through the long long years. Here was a kinsman — an easier, more familiar word than father — and yet, Elrond had not asked him about himself, had no idea, even now, how life went for the Star who was a guardian of the Walls of the World.
Elrond smiled. Kind as summer, the Hobbits said, and that too was a choice.
******
Gil-galad started it, as he had so often, in that other life so long ago.
He turned to Elrond, one shoulder hunched against the blast, and lifted an eyebrow.
“No!” Elrond said. “You could turn an ankle on these...”
But it was too late. Gil-galad was leaping, and Elrond had a split second to be thankful he had not worn a long cloak, and then to think that this time, this time on Elenna the Isle of Gift, he was not going to allow Gil-galad to win.
Elrond leapt after him, and then both of them were running wildly over slipping stones and low tough grasses, down out of the wild wind into the shelter of the ancient rocks.
Birds were flying all around them, calling wildly. A long white wing caught Elrond on the cheek, and he almost slipped, had to jump off-balance onto a rough shelf.
Gil-galad turned in his headlong flight to see where Elrond had got to, and a smaller, slighter fair-haired figure raced past both of them to make it down to the brink of the black water, laughing.
“Victory to Eärendil!” Gil-galad called out, and the king’s voice echoed from the rock among the cries of the birds.
“I always could beat you,” Eärendil told him, and Elrond had a sudden vision of something he had never thought of before: the young High King and the half-elven heir to Gondolin racing along the shores of Sirion, like brothers. Had Gil-galad let Eärendil win? Surely he had.
******
The boat came gliding to Eärendil’s call. Elrond stepped on board and retrieved the bundle he had brought with him.
“Lunch.” he said firmly.
“O, excellent Elrond!” Gil-galad exclaimed, delighted, and rather to Elrond’s surprise. He had noticed that Gil-galad generally ate less, now, than he used to do.
“This is food in the style of Gondor,” he told them, producing, with a flourish, small, brightly-decorated pots of menemen, baba ganoush, tarator, olives with cheese and a bag of fresh simit bread with sesame seeds. “I made most of this myself. Well, apart from the bread. Celebrían made that: she always says I get it wrong.”
“I had thought of fishing,” Eärendil said, sitting down and taking a piece of bread with enthusiasm. “But this is better. I have never eaten the food of Gondor.”
“And I have not eaten it in an Age,” Gil-galad said. “I expect it has changed.”
“Oh, it has changed,” Elrond told him with a grin. “Particularly the cheese. Cheese only gets better with the centuries, I’ve found.”
“Does it?” Gil-galad said, considering with interest a soft white cheese with walnuts.
“Tell me what you’ve been doing all these long years,” Elrond said to Eärendil after a while. “You know a good deal about me, but all I know is that you’ve been up there... somewhere. I’d love to hear all about it.”