New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Dear Maglor:
I received your request for “a volume on flora known to interact with the physical impulses of the Eldar”. I have not dispatched the requested reading material for two reasons.
The first: Your request lacks specificity. This is the House of the greatest master of herblore this side of Belegaer. It is not within my prescribed duties as his master of scrolls to winnow down compendious literature into reading lists for whomsoever should take an interest in this or that subject.
Second: Come get it yourself.
Yours to command no longer,
Erestor
Erestor:
Thank you for your prompt reply, albeit without the requested reading material. I can always trust you to be efficient, if not effective.
You know well why I cannot come to the House of Elrond myself. This is doubly so at this time, for I find myself afflicted with unruly passions and may prove true the people’s worst fears about me. I am a dangerous man.
Please just send the damn book.
In memory of our ancient friendship,
Maglor
Maglor:
I do not in fact know why you cannot come to the House of Elrond, given that Lord Elrond himself has, at least once a season for the past several centuries, invited you to occupy a room here. You alone insist upon your exile to a shack hanging upon the side of the cliffs.
As for your so-called affliction, I have no reason to believe this is not another of your elaborate excuses for benefiting from the peace of Imladris and yet contributing nothing to either its administration or defense.
No one here remembers or cares who you are. It is time you made yourself useful.
Final regards,
Erestor
In this later life, Daeron has made a point of undoing his poetic reputation as a haughty, tattling sneak. He wears his identity openly, owns the errors of his past, and conducts himself with humility in his dealings with all manner of peoples: elves, men, and dwarves of all stripes.
Thus it is quite against his character to be sneaking around the library of Imladris on a moonless night looking for a certain book of botanical knowledge.
Daeron, of course, has a wealth of knowledge about the flora of Middle-earth, as good as any true-born child of Beleriand and better, as a favourite disciple of Melian the Maia. He is quite confident he knows exactly which plant he has, miserably, come into contact with. How negligent not to have seen it! And in the presence of that rogue son of Fëanor! Even without this unfortunate wrinkle in the affair, Daeron knew from the outset that it was a grave error to agree to perform with him; but dear Arwen had been so set upon having the musics of both lines of her Eldarin heritage played at her coming-of-age. It would have been ungracious of Daeron not to agree. Who but he could better represent the music of the most musical tribe of the most musical of Ilúvatar’s creations? It was incumbent upon him.
A duet had not been communicated as part of the engagement. And such a wild, unweeded grove at the height of Stirring should never have been chosen as the setting. Well, to say ‘weed’ is unfair to this plant, or to any plant. Daeron, being well-attuned to the natural world, does not actually believe in weeds. All plants have their uses. And the pollen of this flower, when used deliberately and between willing parties, is a gift.
Daeron’s unruly cock stirs at memories from the deep past. Yes, the deep past: it is only the effects of the flower that bring to mind the alluring cut of Maglor’s robes, as he wore them at that concert. It is only on account of the flower that his body hums yet with the vibrations of Maglor’s voice; that his blood courses more quickly at the lingering scent-memory of… blackberry, sea-salt… and cardamom, perhaps?
Daeron curses under his breath and adjusts his nightclothes around the swelling. Unfortunately, the adjustment only increases his ardour, and he must rest his head against a shelf, breathing deeply. He will overcome this.
Eventually, despite the drainage of blood from his head, he finds just the book: not among the botanical collection, but on a high shelf among various volumes on erotic subjects: Yavanna’s Earthly Gifts: Flora for the Promotion of Procreative Behaviours. Daeron scoffs at the sanitized title. Procreative, indeed. Of course it is in Quenya, and antiquated at that.
No matter: plants change at a far slower pace than languages. It will do.
A rustling from the corridor causes Daeron to jump. He scurries from the library in the opposite direction, hastening to his chamber, where, with the free hand not tending to his affliction, he flips through the pages by the soft grey light of dawn.
By the time of his third orgasm, he scarcely needs the damning image of that flower to confirm his worst suspicions.
Maglor:
Think not that I am sending this book to you out of a sudden pang of compassion. Not for you, in any case. I am concerned about the well-being of whatever good resident of Imladris was responsible for its temporary disappearance and sudden reappearance.
The convergence of your request (and, knowing you, I should have known of what sort of ‘passion’ you spoke) and this surreptitious theft-by-night cannot be coincidence.
I suspect you may know who it was consulted it. And you, alas, may be the only hope of relief for them.
Please return the book promptly, and do not keep me informed on whatever befalls from the knowledge obtained therefrom. I do not want to know.
Be good.
Erestor
Irilótë
When inhaled, causes prolonged, insatiable lust. Untreated, symptoms persist from six weeks to twelve months following exposure, depending on the health and maturity of the plant. Following copulation with another exposed individual, active chemicals in the pollen will be neutralized and the hosts’ amorous inclinations should return to normal.
Exposed individuals do not typically experience sexual attraction towards non-exposed individuals, but as their persistent state of arousal may be a source of discomfort to both themselves and others, it is recommended that they remain isolated until recovered.
If seed fertilization via host copulation is not possible, bathing in cold water may relieve symptoms somewhat. No other cures have been identified.
Maglor sets the open book down on the table. He releases a long puff of air, absently runs his thumb down the length of his persistently half-hard cock, and gets up to make himself a cup of tea.
There are several choices before him:
1. Wait the six weeks to a year for the symptoms to resolve themselves.
After only three days of playing host to this flower’s seed, he has had to haul his laundry to the river to wash six times. It will soon be seven, given what has recently happened to his trousers. No, carrying on like this is out of the question.
2. Find a partner willing to expose themselves to the flower and copulate with him.
It is not that Maglor doubts he would be able to find such a person. On the rare occasions when he does make an appearance among other speaking peoples, he still draws eyes. He indulges now and then, invites the occasional itinerant into his bed; but this is more complicated. This involves explanations, and conversations, and cooperation. The sort of interactions that form ties between people, ties that twist into knots and must be untangled down the road. Maglor has had more than enough of that in his life, thank you.
Glorfindel would probably do it. But he is on some heroic and important mission of indeterminate length, and Maglor needs someone to fuck now.
3. Throw himself off the nearest cliff.
This is not a serious option. Maglor has had far too much success being a coward to stop now.
That leaves one, and the most obvious, choice:
4. Fuck Daeron.
Dear Daeron:
It was a great pleasure to share the sward with you at Arwen’s celebration. To think that we two, peers in our peerlessness, have never once in all these long ages drawn breath together in song. Never has my harp known fingers as lean and deft as my own, and yet yours upon your pipe kept pace as effortlessly as a hummingbird flits and shimmers from flower to flower.
As Ilúvatar brought the Ainur together for the Great Music, so perhaps time and chance have brought us together in Imladris to make music. Of lesser import, perhaps. Or perhaps not. Who better than we to heal at last the scars of our ancient wounds by joining in song?
Do come visit me sometime soon. My lodgings are modest, but the views are stunning and the acoustics even better.
With admiration,
Maglor
“I know you have not really invited me here to make music.” Daeron stands stiffly at the foot of the garden path, curling and uncurling his lovely long fingers at his sides.
“No music at all?” Maglor says, and takes long strides towards him. He smiles, genuinely. If he had to be placed in his current predicament, there are certainly worse partners than Daeron. Maglor will make him sing before they are through with this.
Daeron scowls. What lovely lips he has. “And there will be no healing of scars. Someone must carry the memory of your crimes in this forgetful age.”
“Oh, do not worry yourself about that. I have carried them through two ages and do not intend to put them down any time soon.”
Daeron’s face is flush and his breathing short, but Maglor does not think it is in anger.
Maglor extends a hand in invitation. “Won’t you come inside? Or do you wish to take care of this outdoors? That is the Sindarin custom, is it not?”
Daeron refuses the hand and makes to brush past him. Only, when his shoulder collides with Maglor’s chest, a spark ignites at the point of contact. He halts, spins on his heels, and seizes Maglor’s face in both hands to kiss him fiercely. Their hips meet without the slightest effort, and Maglor pulls him flush against the throbbing of his cock. Daeron matches his ardour, and they rut together in the garden.
Their first release happens within moments.
And does nothing to resolve either their lust or Maglor’s laundry problem.
Their second is more deliberate. Clearly, without skin-to-skin contact, they might as well have been rutting into their own hands.
“No,” Daeron insists, shuffling out of his leggings, “penetration is not necessary.”
“How would you know?” Maglor kisses down his chest. He is quite enjoying this.
“Because,” Daeron arches, squirming between Maglor’s hands held firmly around his ribcage, “this is not the first time I have inhaled the seed of Iruíloth.”
Maglor licks up the length of his cock. “It is not?” He takes the tip between his lips then drags his body forwards to kiss Daeron’s lips. Their mouths lock, tongues seeking. Breathlessly, Maglor pulls away, trailing fingertips down Daeron’s heaving chest. He tweaks a nipple and finds it is delightfully pierced through, a tiny pearl upon a silver ring. What other secrets does this bard conceal behind his austere countenance? Maglor takes the pearl between his teeth, twirls his tongue around the pebbled nipple. “Then you had better show me how it’s done.”
With unexpected, wiry strength, Daeron flips Maglor onto his back, landing neatly astride his hips. He stoops, aligning their cocks and squeezing his hand between their bodies to encompass both with long, strong fingers. Maglor groans involuntarily. How long since he has known such pleasure? He feels a pang of premature loss: he does not want this to end. Perhaps, if he can resist the urge to come, and keeps Daeron from doing the same, he can prolong the effects of the flower.
It is too hard. He is all white passion, all artless lust, and already warm, slick fluid is spurting and spreading over his stomach. So much of it that it drips down his side and onto the newly washed sheets.
They pant, side-by-side on the bed, glistening with sweat. Daeron’s sticky hand lies between them.
“Here,” says Maglor, tossing him a towel. Daeron snatches it in midair and wipes his hands.
They lay there in silence for some time. Blood returns to Maglor’s head for only the briefest of moments. Long enough for him to wonder why a current of heat still buzzes in the space between his and Daeron’s bodies. And then the blood is creeping back down. His cock twitches against his thigh. Determinedly, it rises, until it lies full and heavy against his stomach.
It is Daeron who breaks the silence. “Fuck. It didn’t work.”
Maglor, not realising he had been holding his breath, gulps a lungful of air. “No,” he exhales, “it did not.”
The preparation takes longer this time. Or, they take longer to prepare. At least, this third time, the lust is less acute, the passion less urgent. And Maglor finds Daeron willing to luxuriate in it, kissing and groping, both giving and receiving. Curious hands trail over taut muscle, soft hidden places, swollen lips, and even the ticklish soles of feet.
Maglor kisses his throat, licking the dip between his collarbones, and up to the bulge of his larynx, and Daeron sings indeed. Low at first, slow, then rising and sliding through perfect scales. As he sings, Maglor slips oil-slicked fingers between the cleft of his buttocks. He opens readily, welcoming a finger, which Maglor twists and strokes inside him, circling but deliberately not finding its mark.
When at last Maglor pushes into him, he too is singing, a low and dark harmony to Daeron’s bright, starlit notes. He rocks slowly, clutching Daeron’s wrists against the bed, nipping at his jaw, his ears, plunging his tongue into his mouth.
“I do not want this to end,” Daeron mutters when they pull apart, barely intelligible. He trains his eyes on Maglor’s, though they drift ever upwards, rolling back in bliss.
“Nor do I,” Maglor replies, but cannot keep his hips from rocking faster, from drawing longer and fiercer strokes in and out of Daeron’s willing body. He knows he’s found the mark when Daeron wails and arcs and curses and clutches Maglor’s buttocks, nails shaping stinging crescents in his flesh.
Maglor’s whole body rushes and churns towards a climax like a great heaving river cascading off… well, he thinks as the metaphor unravels into senseless bliss, it seems he is throwing himself from a cliff after all.
“That wasn’t so bad,” Maglor says, returning to the bed with a cup of water for his companion. He reclines, still nude, and scans the sinuous length of Daeron’s body.
Daeron shuffles to a seated position and pulls the sheet up to his waist. He gulps the water down, sets it on the floor with a shaky hand, and rapidly dresses himself.
Once dressed (save his undergarments, which he skipped over in his hurry and now clutches to his chest in a messy bundle), he turns to Maglor and announces: “That’s done, then. Goodbye.”
He makes to leave, but Maglor grabs his wrist as he passes. Heat, dulled to a simmer but undeniably present, blooms where their skin makes contact.
“You are leaving already?” Maglor gazes up at him with his most pleading eyes, but Daeron has clearly made his decision. “Very well.” Maglor rises and takes the few strides to his small dining table. “Return this book to the library for me, won’t you?”
Daeron snatches Yavanna’s Earthly Gifts from his hand. “Fine.” And again he says, “Goodbye.”
“Goodbye,” Maglor responds, and neither of them moves.
“Yes,” says Daeron, eyes penetrating and black. “I will leave now.”
“Go on, then,” says Maglor, and winks. When Daeron still does not move, he gives him a little pat on the rear.
This elicits a choked squeak, and with a jerk of his hips Daeron is off down the garden path. Maglor watches him with mixed regret, amusement, and something else he cannot place. Finally Daeron reaches a bend in the road, at which point Maglor catches sight of him breaking into a run just before he disappears.
Maglor sighs, and his heart fills with warmth.
Stirring gives way to Spring, and Daeron dreamily goes about his days in the House of Elrond. A creative energy like he has not experienced in an age possesses him. He is composing lays that have drifted formlessly in his mind for years; performing pieces of them in the Hall of Fire night after night to a captive audience. He is sociable, ebullient even.
He draws attention as he has not since Doriath-before-the-Sun. He receives offer after offer of secret trysts. Some he accepts. Soon people become jealous of his attentions and compete for the position of his most desired companion, each bringing more innovative pleasures to his bed than the last.
The only problem is that Daeron thinks only of Maglor. Maglor’s broad chest plastered to the backs of his lids as a handsome prince of this-or-that realm takes him so deep he chokes, then takes him deeper still. Maglor’s imagined fingertips on his spine, roughened palms groping. Maglor’s voice in his mind, groaning and rolling over him like the sea.
Something is wrong. Perhaps some of the flower remains, absorbed into his blood. Perhaps he cannot be cured. Or, perhaps… No. Daeron learned plant lore of Melian herself. He knows plants. He knows Iruíloth, intimately. He cannot have been wrong. There’s been some evolutionary change in its effects. It must be.
Finally, he decides to conduct an experiment. The plant will have stopped blooming now, and he can safely return to the grove and take a sample to study.
It looks very different with its flowers gone.
Too different. Back in the House of Elrond, he spreads the leaves he has gathered on a table and, with a sinking dread, opens Yavanna’s Earthly Gifts.
No sooner has he found the page than eager footsteps fall upon the flagstones, accompanied by a mirthful voice: “Oh, what do you have there?”
Daeron slams the book closed and flips it face down on the table.
Lord Elrond draws up behind him, excited as a child at the prospect of some impromptu botany. He holds a leaf up to the light. “Hmm, Echuirloth. A common flower. Known for protecting the soil around certain fruit-bearing trees before they bloom. What prompts you to study it?”
Daeron flushes. “I, uh..”
Elrond reaches for the book, and Daeron longs to fold himself into a ball and roll beneath the table.
When he sees the title, Elrond laughs. He laughs longer when he opens it to the page Daeron has foolishly bookmarked.
“Oh Daeron, you rascal! Do not tell me you went looking for this!” He points at the clearly different plant depicted in the drawing. “Not even my interventions can gentle the winters enough to invite warmth-loving Iruíloth into the valley. It grew in Doriath, I suppose?” Daeron is sick with embarrassment and at a loss for words. Elrond places a reassuring hand on his back. “Do not worry. It’s a common misidentification. Celebrían once thought the same.” He sighs and clicks his tongue. “Nevermind.” He pats Daeron’s shoulder and removes his hand. “If you want something similar, you need only ask.”
“Thank you, lord Elrond,” he manages, and shuffles away. “A generous offer, as always. Perhaps another time. Now I think I will return this book. Goodbye.”
“Hello,” says Maglor, peeling himself upright to swing his legs over the side of his hammock. “Funny, I was just thinking of you—”
“I have some bad news,” Daeron interrupts, and seats himself on a nearby stool.
“Oh?” Maglor asks. “That is also funny, because I had some good news to share with you, and was just thinking how to share it. That plant, you know, it was not—”
“I know,” says Daeron, and pierces him with those sharp eyes. “It was not correct. The information in that book. It has evolved.”
“What?” says Maglor, at first genuinely surprised; then, after a beat of reflection, entertained. “ Please.” He leans back. “Tell me more.”
Daeron answers in a rush, turning his head to the side and clutching the fabric of his creamy silk tunic where it bunches around his knees. “I did an experiment, you see, and the pollen has evolved so that even after copulation between two hosts it persists. In the bloodstream.”
“Really?” Maglor stretches his legs towards where Daeron sits.
“Yes. It persists.” He turns to face Maglor. “The effect is permanent.”
“Oh,” says Maglor. “Well, that explains a great deal!”
“Does it?” says Daeron, voice pitching upwards hopefully.
“Yes, it does. For I have been unable to stop thinking of you since our… copulation. Unceasingly. I pine for you as I have not pined for anyone in long ages.”
“You do?” Daeron says, breath quickening.
“Yes. I think only of how you sung so beautifully beneath me, of how well your body shaped itself to mine. I think of all the many things I could do with you, and where, and I even—” he chuckles, mock-shyly, “—I had a thought… no, I won’t tell you. It’s very silly.”
“Tell me,” Daeron demands, leaning forward in his seat.
“Oh, only that it might be pleasant to prop my harp between your thighs and solely with sound and vibration play you to a shuddering climax.”
Daeron rises from his seat. With unwise abandon, he launches himself at Maglor, tumbling into the hammock with him. Maglor laughs, delighted, as he shuffles his limbs back into the sagging fabric. The wood beams from which it hangs groan under the weight of both elves, but the weave finds a way to accommodate them both. The sides lift, shielding them from the curious eyes of birds and beasts.
But their soft cocoon does nothing to quiet the musical sounds of their pleasure, which bounce off every cliff in the valley, even down to the House of Elrond and the wide open windows of the library, where a certain librarian’s ears twitch in disgust.
“Oh for fuck’s sake,” says Erestor, and shuts the window.