finis by polutropos
Fanwork Notes
Originally posted to AO3 November 2026 for Scribbles and Drabbles, inspired by art by vinyatar.
- Fanwork Information
-
Summary:
Elros and Elrond consider the curious fates of their parents. On the matter of their own fates, much remains unsaid.
Major Characters: Elrond, Elros
Major Relationships: Elrond & Elros
Genre: General
Challenges:
Rating: General
Warnings:
Chapters: 1 Word Count: 394 Posted on Updated on This fanwork is complete.
finis
Read finis
“I’m sorry I didn’t believe you,” says Elrond.
“About what?” Elros asks. They haven’t spoken in minutes, but his brother’s thought has been a dull hum besides him, wordless, but trembling with uncertainties. Elros has watched the starlings swoop and soar on the horizon, following the same paths they have always followed. War, peace: it is all one to them. The sky remains the same. The smoke always clears, in time.
It seems Elrond has been watching the flock, too.
“Mother. She became a bird.”
Elros hums. It’s not the sort of thing to which you respond, I told you so. Yes, our mother, whom we thought dead all these years, turned into a bird.
“Of course you didn’t believe it. You’ve always been cleverer than me. Dead mothers don’t turn into birds. They don’t come back from death. Not half-mortal ones, in any case,” he adds, recalling Lúthien. Elros hadn’t believed it either, not since he became old enough to distinguish what you wish to believe from what truly is.
“But you saw her. You must have.”
Elros shrugs. A pang of feeling pricks at his heart and he closes his ribs around it. “I am not sure. Perhaps I did. Perhaps it was only that Ulmo and I had the same idea.” He grins and chuckles. “Only Ulmo had the power to make it happen.”
Elrond doesn’t laugh. “I wish I had believed you.” A glimmer of light catches the tears in his eyes.
“What would it have changed?” asks Elros. Elrond is thinking. The silence drags on, and when he senses Elrond will not, cannot, answer, Elros says: “I think you were wise to let them go.” He means Eärendil, too, whose star will soon climb onto the horizon. “It does no one any good to cling to figments of hope.”
“But they live. They lived.”
And we will never see them again, Elros thinks, because, for him, all stories are better when they have an ending. His own will: he knew it the moment the choice was offered. Soon, he will have to find the strength to tell his brother this. Not now; now he finds Elrond’s hand on the grass and sets his own atop it. Watches the birds descend into the darkening hills.