Wherefore? by polutropos  

| | |

Fanwork Notes

Originally posted to AO3 September 2025.

Fanwork Information

Summary:

Fingolfin's body is brought to Turgon. Turgon asks why.

Major Characters: Turgon

Major Relationships: Fingolfin & Turgon

Genre: General

Challenges:

Rating: General

Warnings:

Chapters: 1 Word Count: 277
Posted on Updated on

This fanwork is complete.

Wherefore?

Read Wherefore?

“Why have you brought him here?” Turgon finds breath to speak at last, slumping towards his father’s body. But the bare rocks cannot answer, and Thorondor has long departed. There is no one to speak on behalf of the King of Arda, if this deed was even at Manwë’s behest. The servants of the Valar work in strange ways, even as their lords.

Maedhros was brought back maimed, but alive.

To Turgon Thorondor has brought Fingolfin’s mangled corpse.

“Wherefore?” Turgon’s hands shake as he gropes at the humid warmth of his father’s gambeson, fingers brushing the raised threads of embroidered flames. Once bright bursts of yellow, they are stained damp and dark with blood. Turgon chokes on his grief. A cloud of guilt bloats his chest.

It is well that he can say no more, for the questions that weigh upon his thoughts would blaspheme the Powers.

What was he to do? The Lord of Waters himself had commanded it. Build a city; take refuge. None shall see thy going. So he left them: father, brother, all. And now here is Fingolfin, face bloodied, jaw askew, to torment him. Could he have chosen otherwise?

How many more? How many more have fallen, whose bodies will find no lofty cairn in the Echoriath?

Does his brother live, and reign now alone?

Never again, Turgon swears. Morgoth has been cowed; his father has seen to it. But he will rise again, and when the assault comes — from the North or South — whether the Valar will it or no, Turgon will open the leaguer, and he will march forth to fight beside kin and people.


Leave a Comment