New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Elurín stalked inside, tautness straining every line of his body, his hands clenched into fists. Maeglin and Mairon sat together in the window seat, calculating the ingredients for a steel alloy and talking of little matters of the forge. Maeglin fell silent as Elurín came to stand before them.
"Were you ever going to tell me?" he demanded. Fury and pain shone from his features, and the force of them hit Maeglin hard. "Did you think you could keep your perfidy from me forever?"
"What are you talking about?" Maeglin leaned forward in shock and concern, reaching for his nephew. Elurín had been walking in Doriath again, as he often did now, but he couldn't imagine how that could have led to this outburst.
Elurín pointedly ignored the proffered hand. "My brother was alive when you found us. You killed him. Murdered him. He was alive. You're kinslaying scum like all the rest of your people. Both of you."
Maeglin paled. Beside him Mairon stirred, and Maeglin laid a hand on him to still him. "How did you come by this knowledge?"
Elurín scoffed. "You do not even deny it?! What farce has this life together been?" He turned to Mairon with contempt. "I should never have granted you any name but Sauron. Did you calculate one child-servant was all you needed? Eluréd was unfortunate excess?!"
Maeglin tightened his fingers on Mairon's arm, but Mairon was watching him, awaiting his lead, and he remembered his words all those years ago. "I refuse to be your pet villain."
"Don't blame him," Maeglin insisted. "The decision was all mine." Surprise flickered in Mairon's eyes. "Will you hear the truth of it?"
Elurín fumed and gave a tight nod.
"We found you both on the threshold of death, at the end of what the forest could do to sustain you. It seemed to us that neither of you could survive waking. I decided the best thing we could do was give one of you all the chance we could, and so we took the last of your brother's strength and put it into you to give you life."
"And gave him death?!" Elurín growled lowly.
"Yes. And gave him death. I'm sorry. I chose that over letting you both die."
"You don't know that would have happened. You couldn't."
"It was by far the most likely outcome," Mairon interrupted, in the calmly neutral way he had of stating unwelcome facts. Maeglin knew, for so he'd been told himself in Gondolin, that to others it came across as cold and unfeeling.
"You don't know that! You should have given him life instead. Or let us go together if we must. How could you choose me over him! How could you?!"
"Elurín--I--"
"No!" Tears leapt to his eyes. "You murdered my brother! And then you lied to me! For years! Did you think the forest would hide your crimes? That Doriath would not whisper to my parents' heir? I found the place where we lay. You didn't even mark his grave! You never cared! The trees showed me everything. Don't speak to me. I hate you. I'm leaving. I won't abide under the roof of my brother's slayer." He kept his composure almost to the end, but his voice cracked on the last words, and he fled to his room rather than cry before Maeglin and Mairon. His sobs reverberated through the house nonetheless.
Maeglin didn't go after him. A cold, unmoored feeling was creeping over him, like every catastrophe in his life had been inevitable, and this one had come in the time allotted to it. He slumped into Mairon's arms numbly. "Everything I do turns to poison," he whimpered into Mairon's shoulder. "Every choice I make hurts everyone around me."
Mairon didn't answer, but he held Maeglin close, and Maeglin felt tears dripping into his hair.
"You need not permit him to leave," Mairon said into the emptiness at last. "If you think it best. He is a child still by your reckoning, is he not?"
Slowly Maeglin raised his head. "You will not tempt me thus. Every voice in the forest and the worst parts of myself will be screaming to keep him here, and you, of all people, will not add to my temptation."
"I am only thinking," he went on mildly. "You wouldn't let a child go off on his own, no matter how angry and upset."
"I'm not altogether sure he should be counted a child. He could easily pass for eighty or ninety. He's old enough to know his own mind. And I'd say he's capable of taking care of himself, if times weren't so dangerous. But that's true for everyone now."
"Still, he is young, and rash, and in some ways naive. You think he will not regret this a week hence?"
"He knows where to find us if he does. Mairon, I will constrain no one. He knows the forests well enough to travel alone; he's skilled with his sword. Anything else you say is only an excuse."
Mairon leaned forward so that their foreheads touched. "I don't want to see you hurt, sweetling."
"It was too late for that when we found him."
*
Maeglin was in the kitchen, preparing food by rote with no certainty he'd be able to stomach it, when he heard Elurín's feet on the stairs. Mairon waylaid him at the foot, and he heard their voices pitted at odds, though little of their words. He caught waves of Mairon's frustration and Elurín's stubborn ire, both felt so strongly that Maeglin could not have escaped them if he tried. Finally Mairon threw up his hands and stormed off. Elurín stepped into the kitchen, a pack tossed over his shoulder and uncertainty lining his face.
"I would take some food to journey on. I thought you would not begrudge me that much."
"I would begrudge you nothing," Maeglin answered quietly. He set aside the vegetables he'd been chopping and began to gather such dried foods as would be light to carry and easy to eat on the road. Behind him Elurín shifted.
"He insists you only did as he bade. That all the decision was his in truth, that he argued hard to convince you and you followed along unwillingly."
Maeglin stilled.
"I didn't think it sounded much like you, the way he puts it."
"He lies when he's scared."
"As you did together when you brought me here?" Elurín opened his pack and pushed around the things inside. "I figured most likely it was on you both. However much you say different things, you always move as one in the end."
"I am deeply sorry for causing you such grief. In truth, it seemed the only possible choice at the time."
"That doesn't give me Eluréd back."
Maeglin bowed his head and tied off a sack of hazelnuts, then pulled out the store of venison jerky.
"I would make of you one request, if you will listen but briefly to one who does love you, however badly I have failed you."
Elurín was silent for a time. "Speak, then."
"Elurín," he faltered, wishing for words he knew he would never find. "Dearheart. Do not go from us empty-handed, at least. There are gifts long in the planning that we had meant to have ready when you fully came of age. Wait some little time, so that we can send you forth well-prepared and well-armed. Accept them as weregild, if you will not have parting gifts from your family."
"You are no family of mine," Elurín said, his words like steel driving into Maeglin's heart. "But weregild I will have, if you won't tarry long about it."
*
"We won't have enough galvorn for a full suit of armor," Mairon informed Maeglin in the forge the next day as they took stock of their materials and the task they had set themselves.
"I know. If we use every old scrap and mix what ore we have into my pseudo-galvorn instead, I think we can manage a sword and either a helm or a breastplate."
"Helm," Mairon determined after brief consideration. "A good coat of steel mail does a fair enough job, but you can't be too careful about head wounds."
The furnace poured out smoke without ceasing for several days until they finished smelting the metals. Then the work of forging the sword and hammering out thin plate for the helm began. Maeglin directed the working of the galvorn and did as much as he could himself, though he was careful to limit his time. Better to take advantage of the hour he could manage in a day than to push too hard and be unable to hold a hammer for a week or more. Mairon spent every spare moment riveting rings into mail, and Maeglin thought it fitting for a prince. Mairon's mail was both supple and uncommonly strong, and Maeglin took note of his technique, though in the back of his mind he knew it would be too hard on his hands to work on such a thing himself.
All too soon they were ready. Elurín accepted them solemnly but without any sign of softening. In the few weeks he'd waited, he had kept to himself and relented none of his words. Maeglin had designed the black blade to fit his fighting style, and Elurín looked satisfied at least when he drew it and tested how it swung.
"I hope it will serve you well," Maeglin told him when he said nothing. Mairon had turned away, arms wrapped around himself.
Elurín nodded. "I..." He faltered and dropped his gaze. "I will wield it to defend those who need it."
"That's all I could ask."
"Yes. Well. I don't suppose I'll ever see you again, and I don't want to. I..." He swallowed hard. "Fuck." He dropped the sword, and taking two quick steps forward, seized Maeglin in a tight embrace. He glanced at Mairon, but he was still determinedly refusing to face them. Sheathing the sword at his hip and grabbing his pack, Elurín walked away.
Maeglin watched until he disappeared between the trees. Already he could feel Nan Elmoth beginning to rouse. It wouldn't take long for the forest to decide Elurín wasn't allowed to go anywhere. He sighed and fell to his knees, pressing his hands to the nearest roots. Mairon knelt before him and clasped his shoulders comfortingly, though his lips were pressed tightly in a thin line, and he did not speak.
Elurín would never know of the long and bitter battle Maeglin fought against the forest and his own heart. The forest's fury, as soon as it realized what was happening, was tangible, a taste of earth and iron on the back of Maeglin's tongue. Branches rattled overhead as if a storm was blowing in.
"He must not go from our eaves. The boy belongs here. We will not lose another heir."
The forest's voices shrieked in Maeglin's head. He took a deep, steadying breath. If he slipped for one moment and wished for Elurín to stay, he knew the paths would all close and turn him towards home. He could not allow that to happen. The forest's will pressed hard against him. It was stronger than him, and controlled only so far as their bargain allowed him control. If he hadn't believed it before, he would never doubt it again.
"It is my will that he go freely in and out," he murmured steadily, holding fast against the crashing plaints and protests. "I am lord here, and this is my will." Like he had when he'd demanded the wood allow his passage as barely more than a child with his mother, he knew he must hold absolute confidence in his own words. Mairon's presence, warm and solid, lent him strength. "He will go and come as he wills, and others may be yet to come, and I remain, and you will not be abandoned or alone again."
"It would be easy. We could make him want to stay. Give us back our heir!"
If the forest could be said to have fists, it was beating them against the doors of Maeglin's mind. He could feel tendrils of power trying to squeeze themselves into any chink and take him over, but they could find no purchase. Nan Elmoth had no words he had not thought of in the weeks of forging arms, and every time he'd come to the same conclusion. He held it like a talisman now.
"I will keep no one against their will. I will hold no one who does not wish to be held."
A glimpse of Idril was dragged before him. "You should have had her. You are lord, you should have all your desire. You have lost many. You should not lose the ones you have now."
Maeglin steeled himself against the tug of shame and want and bitterness. He couldn't allow it. Not the grief at her memory, not the squirming little voice that agreed with the forest and whispered what might have been. He thought of his mother with a fading bruise on her cheek and their mad flight to freedom. He pushed away all the little hopes he'd held for Elurín's future with them, the dreams of a lasting family.
"I am not my father," he whispered. "It is my will to let him go."
Nan Elmoth roared, but it was not wholly willing to defy him altogether. Maeglin felt Elurín step into the ford of the Celon. All at once, the tension snapped, the pressure released, and Maeglin crumpled to the ground. Every muscle in his body hurt. He wasn't certain he could move.
Gently Mairon gathered him up and carried him inside. Only when he was safely ensconced in bed with a mug of hot tea did Mairon break the silence. "That was a lot of power and a lot of struggle for something you didn't even want."
"I got exactly what I wanted." Maeglin's voice was hoarse and scraped at his throat as if he'd been screaming, though he'd never gone above a soft murmur.
Mairon made a frustrated sound. "I don't understand you."
"That's all right."
"You could have talked him around. It wouldn't have taken that much to convince him. You could have just commanded him; it would be within your rights as his lord and guardian."
Maeglin shrugged. "Do we have to pick it all apart? It's over. I did what I thought best."
Mairon huffed.
"I appreciated you not trying to change my mind these last weeks."
"You seemed pretty determined." Mairon cast himself onto the bed beside Maeglin, throwing his arm over his face. "Anyway, I don't need you or anyone saying, 'That's Sauron for you, he always does terrible things and gives wicked advice, what can you expect.' You didn't want to hear it."
"Have I ever done that to you?" Maeglin asked.
Mairon took a while to answer. "No. Not even when you should've, when it would have been greatly to your benefit, and probably Elurín's too. I'd have forgiven you if you had." He rolled onto his side and gently traced Maeglin's cheek, not quite daring to meet his eyes. "I'm not sure why you didn't, when blaming me might have fixed things. But...I'm glad."
"You asked me not to."
"I know. But I'm not used to that mattering."
Maeglin carefully slid closer. Nestling in Mairon's arms, he kissed him softly. "It does to me."
Very quietly Mairon asked, "Do you think it was wrong, what we did for Elurín when we found him?"
"I don't know," Maeglin sighed. "I think...I think if I had to make the choice again, I'd do the same."
"Even knowing he'd call you a murderer for it?"
"You would, wouldn't you?"
"I thought we were in agreement that my sense of what was right should never be trusted. Not when it comes to pleasing you Elves."
"Mmm."
"It's going to be so quiet around here," Mairon murmured, sounding defeated.