New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
“So really, all of this is Morgoth's doing. If not for him stealing the Silmarils, the Fëanorians would never have made their oath and come here, and even if they'd come anyway, they would never have attacked my people.”
Elurín was growing into a fine, strong youth, quick with his sword and quicker to lend a hand. Maeglin thought he was maturing faster than any Elvish child, but he had the shape and the bearing of an Elf, and some at least of Lúthien's beauty, though his hair was a moon-silver that must have come from his mother.
“It's impossible to say what would or wouldn't've happened if everything was different, but yes, that's the heart of the matter.” Maeglin thought carefully before what he said next. “They had great courage and protected all of Beleriand steadfastly for many years. I say this not to excuse what they did to your people; there could be no excuse for that, but you need to understand that they weren't always terrible monsters; they were people in a hard position who made terrible choices.”
“And anyone might end up the same way if they aren't careful and sure, I get it. But what would make someone change like that?”
“Well...I can't say for certain, but I have my ideas. After the Nirnaeth and the awful losses of that time...people were broken by it. People I knew, with less on their shoulders. Maedhros Fëanorion—I'm not sure if it was ever a formal marriage, but it was no secret he was as good as wed to King Fingon. Their love was the stuff of legend. And then Fingon died so horribly on the field, and Maedhros was the one who had pushed for the Union and was Lord Commander over all the armies, and he couldn't get to him in time. After that—I can understand how he might see no point left in anything. Or in holding back.”
“I suppose no one ever told him he shouldn't leave his husband to be his conscience?”
“I'm sure he did know better. It just wasn't enough in the end.”
“I hope I have someone around to stick a sword in me if I ever convince myself something like that is acceptable.” Elurín chewed on the end of his quill, mangling the tuft of untrimmed feather.
Maeglin wanted to reach across the table and pull it out of his mouth, but he reminded himself it wasn't worth fighting over things that didn't really hurt anyone. Courtly etiquette had never saved the people he loved.
“I still want to be the one to kill Maedhros,” Elurín concluded. “But I want to kill Morgoth too.”
“There's no fighting Melkor now,” Mairon interjected. “All the Elvish powers have been crushed. You'd just be throwing your life away, and we don't want that for you.”
“Things could change,” Elurín replied. “By the time I'm old enough, a lot could change.”
“I wouldn't bet on it,” said Mairon.
Elurín turned back to Maeglin. “You were there, weren't you? At the Nirnaeth? What was it like?”
“It was overwhelming. So loud. People everywhere, and if you don't keep track of who's around you, you're dead. It's hard work, heartbreaking work, and it just goes on and on. You can't stop fighting long enough to save your friends from bleeding out around you. You don't want to plunge your sword into your enemies, not at first, but you know there's no choice. Then after a while they stop seeming like people at all, just bodies you have to stab, and that feels worse. I hated every minute.”
“What about you, Mairon, were you there too?”
Mairon placed a marker in one of Eöl's tomes of metallurgy and set it down. “Mm. On the other side, of course.”
“I know that part. But what about the fighting?”
Mairon sighed.
“Please? I really want to hear.”
“Battle is exhilarating. It brings everything into the sharpest focus you'll ever know. The rest of the world falls away, and all that's around you becomes simple and clear. The glittering arc of a sword, the spurt of bright blood, the judder of a foe's dying gasp and they way they go limp on your blade—it's breathtakingly beautiful. You find yourself desperate to kill again and again just to feel it one more time. It's intoxicating, and it brings out the most feral side of you to revel in it. I miss it.”
He glanced between Maeglin and Elurín, taking in the boy's eager expression and Maeglin's sour one. “Anyway, you should listen to your uncle, not to me. We're not the same kind of beings at all.”
“I'm part Maia too.”
“And part Human,” Maeglin reminded him. “We don't know for sure what will happen if you die.”
Elurín shrugged. “As long as I finish what I mean to first, I won't care.”
“All the more reason not to run towards it recklessly,” Mairon warned.
“I know.”
*
The quiet susurration of rustling leaves and branches filled Maeglin's thoughts whenever he let it now. The forest had twined itself within him until he wasn't always sure anymore where he ended and it began. It comforted him to feel life buzzing through his veins, water and minerals rising from the soil, leaves breathing in and out as they sent sugars back to roots in return. The murmur of the forest's unending music was as unlike the noisy crowds of Gondolin as sweet, cool night from day, and he wondered at his child-self sometimes that he'd ever thought the busyness of an aboveground city would be preferable. But what else could he have done? He hadn't known then what he hadn't known.
He had spent the last hour or two hammering steel—a few wandering bands of Mannish traders had learned that good smithwork could be had in Nan Elmoth, though they carefully declined to step under her branches, and they paid wheat and barley, fabric and scrap metal, occasionally a small cask of wine in exchange for knives and swords, pots and kettles, wool combs and plowshares and horseshoes. Maeglin's hands were aching now, though Mairon had made him quit before he was ready, and he sat in the warming green glow of spring trying to massage away the pain, uncertain whether even the slight pressure he was using was making it worse instead. He paused again and lost himself in the slow-moving minds of the trees. It was easier when he could subsume himself in the million selves he was bound to, his hurting body but one among many, and feel what they felt until it drowned out his own senses.
“I see I was right.” Mairon settled beside him, wiping his sooty hands on his apron. “Next time I'll stop you sooner. You get too carried away with your work in there.”
Maeglin grumbled a half-hearted complaint and leaned against him.
Mairon wrapped an arm around him and kissed the top of his head. “What did you want to make with all those fiddleheads and wild garlic you picked this morning?”
“Some kind of soup? We could add some nettle leaves and send Elurín down to the creek for mussels.”
“Easy enough. After you've rested.”
“Bossy,” Maeglin muttered, but he nestled closer against Mairon. “Who said you could order me around?”
“Only when you really need it,” he smirked.
“Hmmph.” Mairon was warm and inviting against him, and Maeglin could think of nowhere he'd rather relax for a little while. He closed his eyes again and tried to put his pain out of his mind. Without any warning, a wave of protective concern bore him over.
We do not wish him to leave, he found himself thinking. No, it wasn't his thought. He shook his head, trying to disentangle it. He belongs to us; he should stay at home. Isn't that what we want? Some change was happening in the forest, and Maeglin felt it happen within him as easy as his breath. A moment's focus, and he knew what it was. Maeglin-part-of-many was bending paths to keep someone inside.
“Elurín?” he whispered.
“What about him?” Mairon asked, going sharp and alert as he did at any hint of strangeness.
Maeglin felt him almost as soon as he realized what he was looking for. The boy was walking along the edge where Nan Elmoth met Doriath, and Maeglin and the forest together were preventing him from crossing the boundary. He was singing quietly, a song of concealment, but it could not hide him from the forest's lord. Maeglin remembered well the helpless feeling of the path reshaping itself under his feet to his father's will and how much he'd hated it. He considered only a moment before he wrestled against the forest.
“No. He can go as he pleases.”
But he will be hurt if he strays. We must keep him safe. We must keep him here. Maeglin didn't like how much the thoughts sounded like his own.
“No. Guard his coming and going, but you will let him pass.”
The forest sighed and stretched like a great and petulant cat, and it opened a way for Elurín. Maeglin hoped with everything in him he hadn't made a huge mistake.
“Elurín just crossed into Doriath,” he told Mairon, who watched with concern. “The forest didn't want to let him go.”
“Should I go after him? I don't recall giving or being asked permission for that.”
“You know I don't like you crossing the border. We don't know how closely you're watched for. No. I'll have some words for him when he returns, but I'm not going to hold him here against his will. Not ever.”
*
Elurín slipped in quietly just as supper was laid ready.
"I believe you're in some trouble, young man," Mairon greeted him. Maeglin flipped the last flatbread on the griddlestone and, standing, dusted the flour off his hands. Elurín held his head high and his shoulders square.
"Let me speak for myself before you start into the long lecture about my safety, please?"
"Let's hear it, then," Maeglin told him. "What was so important you felt the need to leave without telling me?"
Elurin triumphantly brought out a handful of leaves and set them on the table. "I was looking for this herb. I haven't found it anywhere in Nan Elmoth, but it grows still in Doriath. My Grandmama used it when I was very young, when Grandda had headaches or his arm hurt. She said it was especially good against hurts that came from Angband. So I thought...you're always in so much pain. I wanted to help."
Maeglin held back the first words that leaped to his lips, thinking through the warring feelings in his chest. He'd long since given up any expectation of help for him, and Elurin's leaves woke more tired contempt than interest. But he couldn't be entirely angry with so much earnestness on the boy's face.
"I appreciate that you wanted to do something for me. But keeping you safe matters to me far more. I would be devastated if something were to happen to you out there where I could do nothing. What was your plan if you came upon a band of orcs? Your skill with the sword is growing, but one against many is not a gamble you should ever take."
Elurín sighed. "Everything was fine. I can practically disappear anywhere there's forest. Nothing could find me even if there were enemies around."
"You think that, right up until the moment you're surrounded and it's too late."
"If I'm the last heir of Doriath, shouldn't the forest itself help me? And don't I have some responsibility to it, like you do here?"
"I'm not sure there's much left in Doriath that can protect you, with Melian gone and her memory fading," Mairon said. "Nan Elmoth has more self-possession than most places. Don't base your understanding of other forests on what you know of her."
"Will you at least try the herb?"
"I will," Maeglin told him. "But regardless, I don't want you going back without asking me first. You can take up any responsibilities you bear when you're older. Is that clear?"
"Yes, uncle."
"If you were captured and not killed on the spot, you would put us all in danger," Mairon added. "You have to think beyond just yourself."
Maeglin shuddered at the reminder.
"But I was! I was thinking about Uncle Maeglin."
"It's not a risk I would have had you take," Maeglin insisted. "The mere possibility of my feeling better isn't worth anyone's life."
"That's why I didn't ask first," Elurín grumbled under his breath.
After supper, Elurín and Mairon conferred and set to brewing. A simple tea fit what Elurín remembered best, but Mairon took some of the broad, hairy leaves and began some other preparations that would take more time. When the kettle came to a boil, Elurín crushed a couple of leaves between his fingers and dropped them into a steaming mug. A sweet scent filled the room. It reminded Maeglin of a cold, crisp morning in the Ered Luin, piney and full of promise.
Mairon clapped a hand over his nose. "Void, that smells awful."
Elurín laughed. "I think it's nice."
"Are you certain you got the right plant?"
"I wouldn't ever forget what athelas looks like. Not any more than I'd mistake a dandelion. I learned that one when I was very young too."
Mairon held the cup, poring over it for a long moment before he relinquished it to Maeglin. "I don't perceive any of the toxins I'm familiar with. That's a peculiarly Elvish malodour. Might as well go ahead, if you can manage to get it down."
Maeglin smiled. "You seem to be the only one who doesn't like the smell."
Mairon's lip curled in scorn.
The taste was faint, a breath of mountain air and a resinous undertone, and Maeglin wondered if there was something to brewing it they'd missed, but he sipped at it slowly, stretching it out enough that any immediate ill effects should show up before he drank too much.
"Is anything happening?" Elurín asked.
"Oh, no. You're not going to hover and be a bother," Mairon told him firmly. "Off to bed with you."
"But it isn't even bedtime!"
"I am being far more lenient than I would prefer. You worried your uncle greatly today and put yourself at risk, and I don't take kindly to either. Bed, and be glad that's the end of it."
Elurín huffed but didn't argue further.
As soon as he'd gone, Mairon started cleaning up without looking at Maeglin. "He has to understand how serious this is. If you aren't going to keep him in bounds."
Maeglin pulled him into his arms. "I think you're doing fine."
*
The athelas tea did not make a huge difference in Maeglin's pain, but by the end of a week, he found it was helping a little. He never stopped hurting, but he spent less time trying to breathe without moving his ribs. He couldn't work much longer in the forge, but it didn't cost him as many days to recover when he did. He would never have imagined, in Gondolin when he was hale, that his current state would be worth any gladness, but even that slight improvement was precious to him.
Elurín had been optimistic enough to dig up a whole plant with the roots on his unsanctioned excursion, and he planted it where a little more sun came through the trees. There it grew and flourished, and all that summer moths came to its flowers. Elurín put himself in charge of tending it and harvesting the leaves, and Maeglin quietly observed the pride he took in his task with something that was almost like hope. He couldn't give him a life untouched by war, but maybe he could have more to care about than weapons and bloodshed.
Elurín had the sense to wait a couple of months before presenting Maeglin with his request. "Please, can I just cross over to start getting familiar with the land on the Doriath side? I have a plan to stay safe. I've thought and thought about it. I won't ever go so far that I can't sprint for Nan Elmoth. I'll scout really thoroughly from this side first, and I'll only go at noon on a sunny day, when orcs are least likely to move."
Maeglin set down the shirt he was mending and studied him. "What is it you feel such a need for? Is Nan Elmoth not big enough for you? You don't even have an excuse to go hunting over there this time."
"I just--it's my home, isn't it? Even if all the people I knew are gone and it's left empty...maybe I'll feel closer, where I know they used to be. Maybe...I...I don't know. But I need it."
Maeglin sighed. "I don't like it."
"I'll be so careful, I promise."
"You'll have to get Mairon to go with you to the edge. If he tells you not to cross, for any reason, you obey him."
"I will! Thank you, thank you, thank you!!"