Atandil by Eilinel's Ghost
Fanwork Notes
- Fanwork Information
-
Summary:
If you ever wanted a longer than necessary slow burn of Finrod and Bëor trailblazing the elf-mortal love tragedy, I've got you covered.
(Originally posted as a series, but combined now into a chaptered fic here.)
Major Characters: Finrod Felagund, Balan, Bëor, Aegnor, Baran, Belen, Original Male Character(s), Original Female Character(s), Beren
Major Relationships: Bëor/Finrod
Genre: Drama, Family, Folktales/Myths/Legends, General, Romance
Challenges:
Rating: Teens
Warnings: Violence (Moderate)
This fanwork belongs to the series
Chapters: 26 Word Count: 240, 671 Posted on Updated on This fanwork is a work in progress.
1. Atandil
“I convinced myself the situations were different. I built labyrinths within my reason to justify the pretense, and in their twisting ways I wandered blind till faced with her grief—the tribute paid in pain, as thou hast named it. Till then I could contend that I suffered so thou might be spared; I grieved so that thou might hold love in memory untarnished. That I learned at the feet of Doom to thus keep its step from thine own neck, and so should goodness come of it. Eru forgive me, I was wrong.”
After his conversation with Andreth forces him to face his own rationalizations and hypocrisies, Finrod realizes he needs to come clean to Aegnor and confesses to him both the consequences of his former advice, as well as his own secret grief that motivated it.
Read 1. Atandil

409th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
The North Marches of Dorthonion, the Fortress of Aegnor
Finrod took a deep breath as he looked out over Ard-galen. Three months had passed since his sojourn in Ladros and the weight of deception lay heavy upon him. Tell him, she had charged at their parting and he gave his word, knowing full well that Andreth meant more than merely the admonition that followed. He was to tell his brother of all that had passed between them—of the hope unguessed, and of the bitter grief he could not now deny.
Yet here he found himself months later and still silence held rule of his tongue.
At first he judged it prudent to let some little time pass. It would be rash, he thought, to raise the conversation when they had quarreled already within the first day of his arrival, tempers still hot from the council at Barad Eithel. Aegnor had broken openly with him for the first time in that assembly, but neither had the chance to address it at the time, for messengers from Ladros arrived bearing word of Boron’s death and Finrod left at once to join Bëor’s house in their time of mourning.
The reality that their disagreement was rooted in commonality frustrated Finrod more than the conflict itself. Despite Aegnor’s accusations of complacency, they both sat uneasily under the prolonged siege, but where Aegnor’s valor was kindled to action by that threat, Finrod tended ever more toward caution in the growing conviction of its fragility. The unease had never fully left him since Aelin-uial, but of late it was becoming oppressive. Often he felt it as a tangible presence that intruded on the senses, a shadow at the edge of his sight, a pressure upon his lungs, a tinge of rot encroaching within his scent. In a way it reminded him of Valinor just before the Darkening, the vertigo of those days when there was always a third presence just out of sight, gone the moment you looked toward it but ever playing upon your peace. The vertigo was similar now, only the unsettling presence was an absence of presence: none of the others sensed it but he.
Turukáno would have felt it, he mused, or at any rate he would have heeded that Finrod did. But where Turgon was now, only Eru could say.
Eru and Ulmo, he corrected himself. He was certain now that he had not been the sole recipient of the Valar’s warnings and felt a fool for not considering that possibility sooner. Now those years were lost, years when they could have spoken of it while there was yet the chance or laid plans together perhaps that might have lightened the burden.
But Turgon had vanished and the other chieftains gave Felagund’s unease little heed besides a sympathetic nod, or a pointed jest from Maedhros about the badger cautioning from his den. And here upon the northern hills he could well understand his brother’s urgency and the High King’s counsel as he saw the shadow in the distance and tasted often, as he could tonight with the wind in the North, a mild, bitter tang upon the air. His own disquiet seemed indeed, as Aikanár had charged, little more than an excuse for inaction. Almost he feared that it too was a product of the Darkness, set upon him to leaden their feet and dull the chance of a definite victory.
But his heart was unconvinced of that, for he could trace its source beside the twilit waters. Neither could he shake the inexplicable certainty of heart, despite all urgency, that any preemptive assault would only hasten their destruction, not elude it. And thus Aegnor had spoken hotly against him among the gathered chieftains, and so again they had quarreled when Finrod returned from Ladros.
He shifted in the wind, feeling still the bite of that later argument. There had been no decorum of the High King’s court to restrain their tongues and both said much in their fury of which they later repented. But pardoned or no the sting remained, and hard on the heels of such a storm was hardly the time to press on into his own confession. For confession it must be if he was to hold his word to Andreth. He could no longer escape his own culpability, and in telling his brother of their conversation he knew he must answer for it. And that would necessitate a full honesty at which he had hitherto balked. It would mean baring the pain that guided every word of his earlier counsel, and that was a wound he guarded jealously from any watching eye.
That, if he was honest with himself, was the true reason for the delay. The same foreboding washed over him that he first felt in Ladros and he saw it again: the mingled blaze of a spirit’s flame and the fires of war, rising in annihilation. He will go forth before thee and he will not wish to return. It would be only a few short years, the remaining life of an adaneth and no longer, and then Aikanár too would be lost to him till Arda’s ending. Lost to him forever, if Arda remade was naught but his own mere flight in a dream. Could he risk turning those remaining years to ice?
Of his own pain Finrod had spoken only to Belen, and then to none at all once Belen followed his father in death. He carried it as his own private agony, bitter and beautiful, the last surviving intimacy.
Here again the regret reared its head. If he had been upfront with Aegnor from the start, it could have been a shared grief. There would be one other in Arda at least who knew the wound. Better even, one who understood it. And yet, was that not merely selfishness of another kind, to wish for camaraderie in suffering when the cost was his brother bearing the same anguish?
This was but the old reasoning reapplied. He shook his head to clear it. There was no longer even a shred of illusion to wrap about his eyes and show a path where he had the power to spare either of them. This doom was beyond him, beyond his power to circumvent and beyond his power to loose those it claimed.
A bell rang in the tower overhead and the sentinels stepped back from their posts, making way as a fresh line of soldiers ascended the walls to take their places. Finrod took another breath, then he too stepped away from the wall and looked after the departing sentries with a grimace. The bell may as well serve as his signal too. He removed a small scroll of parchment from where it lay tucked in his belt and contemplated it for a long moment, then turned his feet toward the fortress.
One thing about this unending war, he reflected darkly as he walked, was that it engendered a keen talent for flinging yourself at exactly that thing you longed to flee. Ten steps up, a short passage, an unembellished door. His feet followed the path as well-trained soldiers and crossed the threshold with only a muted protest. The rooms in this tower were less austere than the rest of the fortress. Aegnor was rigid in his principles and kept his dwellings in line with how he assessed their surroundings, a stronghold prepared for war and spare in the comforts and trappings of peace. But in this handful of rooms the severity eased and there was a simple, almost homely comfort to them that Finrod found restful.
Aegnor was there before him, his chair tilted back on one leg and balanced at a precarious angle, his feet resting absently against the corner of the table. Like all trappings in the room, the table was simple in its design, adorned only by the four carved wolfhounds serving as its legs. Finrod smiled as he glanced at the nearest and recalled the unruly group upon which they were modeled. His aunt had brought them as a gift after Nerwen’s birth: Taltar, Rómar, Capaiton, and Rempamo. “One to mark each of your own litter,” Lalwen said to her brother as she handed him the basket of pups, and seemed endlessly amused at each subsequent visit by the chaos of these four great, bounding brutes crashing through the decorum of Arafinwë’s household. It was Rempamo holding this nearest corner, his crooked ear waiting to bruise any negligent passer. Angrod had protested the haphazard ear when the three brothers were carving, but Aegnor was firm. Rempa without his cockeyed ear was not Rempa, after all.
Finrod ran his hand over the wooden muzzle as he moved further into the room. “Who was it that Taltar doused in wine?” he asked, pouring a glass of his own from the sideboard. “Was it Ingil?”
“Mm.” Aegnor turned over the page in his hand and his lips twitched up at the edges. “Seven years of tactful diplomacy to seat those five at the same table and the merry havocs brought it to wreckage before the second course.”
“Poor Rúno,” Finrod chuckled at the memory as he joined his brother at the table, setting the rolled parchment to the side. “Never have I known a more precise steward, and he never stood a chance against five stone’s weight of fur hurling itself at him in greeting. I rather believe he thought father would dismiss him on the spot. I grant him the fear, I too had never seen him so furious.”
“The only instance, in fact, in which I ever recall him employing profanity.” Aikanár’s smile drifted mischievous and he swung the chair’s legs and his own back to the floor with a resounding thud. He gripped each side of the table and loomed up as he delivered a striking imitation of Arafinwë’s uncharacteristic wrath in a low, dangerous voice.
“That,” Finrod said as his brother finished, “was accurate to the point of discomfort.”
“I never guessed he knew such phrases.”
Finrod raised an eyebrow as Aegnor crossed to refill his own glass of wine. “And where hadst thou the learning of them?”
“At the feet of the same teachers as thee, no doubt,” his brother retorted as he returned bearing the decanter along with him. “Who I suppose are also to answer for the vocabulary of atar aranya.”
“To the eloquence of uncles,” Finrod said as he raised his glass.
“The eloquence of uncles.” Aegnor returned the salute and sipped the wine, one luxury he did not temper, war or no. “He truly did appear ready to boil whoever set them loose.”
Finrod laughed despite himself. “Well do I remember it. It took me nearly a year to confess it was I who opened the door by mistake.” His smile faded as the words left his mouth and he drifted back into contemplation. The conscience had an uncanny way of holding you to task, he reflected as the slow minutes passed, and he settled his eyes on the wine glass in his hand. The stem was adorned with a tiny flock of cranes, their flight circling in a slow climb toward the rim, and he traced a finger along the delicate pattern. Nothing would be gained by delay. “On the topic of belated confessions, I should have told thee before that Belemir was my host in Ladros.” He felt the air go brittle between them. “He and his household.”
“I see.” Aegnor’s face remained unmoved, except for a slight tightening of the jaw. “And is she well?”
Finrod sought vainly for a response as he recalled the bitter despair pressing through each of Andreth’s words.
“Has she wedded another, then? Is that the meaning of thy silence?”
“Nay, she had no more inclination to that than thee.”
“Had.” Aegnor kept his voice level, but his fingers whitened against the table. “Ingoldo…”
“Nay, nay I would never keep that from thee. She lives, and is hale and strong yet.” He paused for a breath and then pressed ahead. “We spoke together during my stay, for many long hours and in great depth. She charged me to tell thee of it and, forgive me, till now I have not done so.”
“Why?”
“Because I feared the truth would anger thee, and I feared that through anger I might lose thee. But there is no explanation without the whole of it,” Finrod said as he reached for the parchment, “so I have written out the conversation. It seemed the simplest way, besides ensuring I recounted its entirety and was not tempted to overlook a detail in the telling. Though to speak truly, I believe I’d have recorded it regardless. What she told me of their traditions… Aikanár, it was a revelation—beyond anything I had imagined and my heart leapt at her words. I—” For a moment his enthusiasm had taken over and his eyes shone. Then he recalled himself to the conversation at hand and held out the pages with an apologetic grimace. Aegnor hesitated, then took them and spread them out on the table before him.
“What will I find here,” he asked, “besides your fascination with collected lore?”
“Clarity, I hope. “ Finrod’s voice was subdued again. “And honesty, though I fear not without its attendant pain.”
Aegnor’s face took on the cold impassivity of battle as he met his brother’s eye, then drew a breath and turned his eyes to the page.
Finrod lingered for several minutes, then rose and crossed to stand beside the window. His presence at the table felt suddenly intrusive, an unwelcome eavesdropper on an intimacy he had already violated as intermediary. But he knew his brother would not ask him to depart, especially when the words in question were written in his own hand. So instead he set the room’s width between them and fixed his attention outside the tower. It was a masquerade of privacy, at least.
The minutes dragged forward with only the sound of Aegnor’s fingers moving restlessly upon the table. Finrod retraced the memory as he looked out into the night and tried to gauge how quickly he might read, attempting to chart the pace and follow his progress through the debate. Would he move gradually over the words as the first echo of her voice since their parting? Or would he hurry past, a hand touching the iron as briefly as possible to gauge if it burned?
He glanced back and saw his brother outlined against the light of the hearth. Aikanár sat stiffly, the broad shoulders tense with resolve, one hand propped against his forehead, the other fidgeting over the grains and knots of the table, the golden hair burnished blood-red in the firelight. A fond smile tugged at the corners of Finrod’s lips as he took in the silhouette. The ever untamable hair danced a precarious balance of appearing both unkempt and immaculate. In its current state it was particularly striking, cropped severely these past four centuries to never allow a strand below the jawline as it declared its own silent rebuke of the Siege’s pride. The hair, the tower, the martial cut of every robe—the youngest lord of Dorthonion ensured you never forgot the war lying beyond the siege lines without ever uttering a word. And studying him now, his brother found he loved him all the more for it.
Finrod turned back toward the night air. He realized he had begun watching Aegnor these past months in the same manner he had watched Bëor as their years together drew on. Each time he caught sight of him he felt the pang of transience and gathered the image to him in deliberate preservation, solidifying it but turning the present into memory before its time.
It was a blade with no hilt, this foreknowledge of an ending, wounding the bearer more than it served as a tool.
He heard a rustle as his brother rolled the papers back together and set them on the table. A gentle sound, the wisp of a falling leaf, and as irrevocable. He stood frozen as the minutes stretched into a deafening silence, until at last he willed himself to action and turned away from the window. Aikanár’s eyes awaited him, burning.
“Was it necessary to tell me?”
“Better, I deemed, than to leave a deception between us.” Finrod’s voice faltered. “And I gave her my word.”
“Thy word could be excused with far less than this.”
“And thus ever after a fraud for binding to excuse and not integrity. Should I have lied to thee instead and kept this burden to myself?”
“A fair burden for thee to bear, I should say.”
Finrod was silent.
“Tell me—and tell me truly, Ingoldo. Knowing this, would thy former counsel have been otherwise?”
“There is only distortion in the mirror of woulds and mights.”
“Answer my question.” Aegnor’s voice was nearly a hiss. “Would thy counsel have been otherwise or was her pain always to be the tribute paid?”
“Canst thou think it of me? What I counseled was for her sake as well as thine. But had I known before…no, hanno, I know not. Perhaps. I think still I may have tried to spare thee.”
“To spare me!” Aegnor laughed bitterly and gestured at the scroll.
“Some agonies cannot be guessed until they are come.”
“And some are made no less bitter in the escape.”
“Nay hold thy anger until I’ve told thee all.” Finrod sought the ring on his left forefinger and seemed to draw courage from the iron band, sitting incongruously beside its fellows. “For many years I have been dishonest with thee. I found ways to ensure I never lied outright, but the omission itself has become a greater deception than I can bear. Especially with thee. Especially when…when the loss at the heart of it is a shared…” His voice broke at the crisis and he passed a hand over his face. The mask of serenity fell, leaving the pristine lines of his features drawn together in pain, and Aegnor had not seen his brother’s face so creased with exhaustion since their years on the ice. “I convinced myself the situations were different. I built labyrinths within my reason to justify the pretense, and in their twisting ways I wandered blind till faced with her grief—the tribute paid in pain, as thou hast named it. Till then I could contend that I suffered so thou might be spared; I grieved so that thou might hold love in memory untarnished. That I learned at the feet of Doom to thus keep its step from thine own neck, and so should goodness come of it. Eru forgive me, I was wrong.”
Aegnor watched him impassively. “Is this thy attempt to tell me of Bëor?”
The remaining composure drained from the king’s face and he stared at his brother.
“Findekáno guessed it years ago.”
“Findekáno!” The unexpectedness of this lifted Finrod’s reply higher than he intended and he was surprised by the note of panic in his own voice.
“Evidently it became clear when thou and he negotiated the northward migration with Aradan and Baran, and Bëor beside. He and Nelyo told it as rather a good joke between them—Atandil. I did not laugh,” he added as a spasm of pain crossed his brother’s face.
Finrod crossed to the table and emptied his wine glass, hesitated a moment, then filled it again. “How long ago did he tell thee?” he asked at last.
“A few years after Bëor’s death.” Aegnor’s expression softened and he added gently, “Before thy hair had regrown.”
“Ah.” Finrod’s attempt to laugh loosed a choked sob instead. “Yes, that was foolish of me.”
“It was mourning.”
“It was careless.” Another wave of grief tightened his jaw. He returned to his chair and rested heavily against the table.
“Did it matter so greatly whether it was known?”
“No, not on the face of it. But ask thyself, would the others have hearkened to a word of my counsel on the Atani were it known I was his lover? Aught I said would have been be dismissed out of hand.”
“And likely with fair cause. Thou wert hardly an impartial advisor already, even without one as the king’s kept favorite.”
“Lá!” Finrod flinched. “Must thou term it so crudely?
“Why, is ‘vassal’ considered more decent?”
The ensuing pause was frigid. “Now thou art deliberately cruel.”
“I am granted a cruelty or two, I think.” Aikanár rose and began pacing the length of the table and back to ease his fury. “But I will confess, knowing that of thee was what brought me to seek thy guidance.”
“And receive in return not even the courtesy of truth.” Finrod leaned his face against his hands. “What a hypocrite thou must think me.”
“I think thee many things,” Aegnor replied ambiguously. “But be at peace on this at least: I knew of thy grief before the counsel that led me to this road—and knew it was the cause.”
“Intentions do not absolve the deed. To say I meant well while driving a knife through thee is nevertheless to press a blade into thy flesh.”
“Yes. And I am angry with thee. But it is Anger held alongside her sister Sorrow, and tempered thus by the company.” Aegnor left off his pacing and came to stand once more at the head of the table, where he added in a practiced voice, “Temper we have named our bent to fury, and tempered it should be ere we let it flow forth. Else we are but ruled as the darkness would have us and creatures at the mercy of fury.”
“Father’s words.”
“I will not break with thee.”
Finrod could not bring himself to raise his eyes, but reached out and clasped his brother’s hand. The grip was returned and with it he felt the vice-hold upon his spirit loosen. The remaining years would not be ice, at least, and the relief of that flooded his heart. “Ask me, then,” he said as he gradually won back his composure, “whatever it is thou wouldst know.”
“And what should I wish to know but ‘why’?”
“Why indeed. And how can I answer it but to bring thee in full view of my own pretenses?” He clasped his hands together as he sought for the words to explain. Now that the conversation was upon him, Finrod found it was not the dread of revelation that brought the greatest difficulty, rather the most daunting task was admitting the intricate web of reasoning he’d fenced about himself this past century. He had not argued it to any save Bëor, and to speak it aloud now was to conjure that ghost alongside them. Almost he wished he was faced with the blunt anger of his brother’s fists instead. He fortified himself with another draft of wine. “To understand the reasons, thou must first know that I’ve believed I inflicted far greater pain through keeping him by me than had I turned away ere a deep bond took root. Remember, we knew little of the Secondborn in those days and every difference we discovered necessarily by degrees, one year at a time, until suddenly you found your hands were empty and the reckoning come. Of course I knew, even in those first months by Thalos, that they were transitory in ways we were not, but in my naivety I assumed it was after the manner of the casári and only learned my error when it was too late. By that time, I had already brought him to dwell with me in Nargothrond. It was placing a river’s fish within the brined waves and saying to it, ‘live and breathe!’ I watched while he withered, alone among our seemingly endless spring. To all around him he was the first of his kind and a curiosity, and thus every change in him was a discovery and a fascination, which only marked time’s passage the more sharply in his own senses. I saw the suffering it bred in him. Yet he stayed for love of me, and in my selfishness I kept him.”
His voice failed and he fell once more to twisting the plain, iron band around his finger. Aegnor watched him, but did not speak.
“I wanted to believe there was a right choice that would have prevented it,” Finrod continued at last. “I thought if I’d seen the danger earlier or shown greater control, that if I had broken with him at the start, then it might have ended differently. A brief pain, but bearable, and soon mended for each. That is what I hoped for thee. I thought if I could steer thee at the outset or warn thee soon enough, then it was within my power to spare the both of you. My failings in that regard,” he looked grimly at his brother and touched his hand to the parchment, “have been made abundantly clear, in at least half my aim.”
“In the whole of it,” Aikanár said sharply. The wine decanter was empty and he crossed to retrieve a second from the sideboard, each movement deliberate and drawing out the time. When he returned to the table, he filled both cups and then sat, facing his brother this time. “Tell me next, if thou wilt,” he said in a voice as brittle as etched glass, “how it is when it comes, the anguish unguessed?”
“The parting or what follows?”
“The parting. I can see well enough in thee what waits after.”
Finrod was quiet before answering, then drained his cup and turned to meet his brother’s eyes, letting the ósanwë move into the space between their words and expose what could not be articulated. “I was beside him when he died,” he said softly and Aegnor felt rather than heard the scream of anguish emanating from his brother’s fëa, not in memory only but a constant presence, a gaping wound ever cutting anew. “It was his that departed, but I felt my own soul tear at the severing, a searing sharper than flesh rending, and the powerless rush of free-fall. I am still falling,” he added hoarsely and pressed his palms against the table for equilibrium. “I caught hold of him and all my resolve to be steadfast at the end failed me. I pleaded by every name I knew for him to stay by me yet, to wait even an hour before the summons must be answered.” The light in his eyes dimmed as he spoke and his voice was hollow. “But I held a corpse.”
Aegnor reached out despite himself and rested a hand against his brother’s cheek.
“It is the emptiness, Aikanár. There is nothing in the wake. When we perish, there is at least the flicker at the edge of sense, the fëa held still within the same walls of time and creation. But there was nothing when he passed. There was only absence, only negation. He was beside me and then in the heart’s next beat he was utterly, irrevocably gone. Even estel shudders in the face of such,” he added in a flat voice and rose, crossing to stand once more beside the open window. He set his hand against the frame to ground himself and drew the night air into his lungs. The Valacirca had risen while they spoke and now it blazed before him in reprimand of his final words. He grimaced at the sky and turned away.
“Then hast thou naught but regret?” Aegnor’s voice drifted to him as though from a distance. “Or has any goodness remained as well?”
“Goodness?”
“In loving him. In choosing Bëor over prudence. Was it worth the cost?”
“Balan,” he corrected, and his voice was almost a caress in the intonation. “I never say his name now. I lose myself in the chorus of others’ voices and call him by the one he gave himself, the name he chose in contrariety.” He let his eyes drift back to the Sickle in the northern sky. “Yes, it was worth the cost.”
“In a time of war.”
“Even in a time of war.”
“And by what labyrinth didst thou justify it for thyself, since by such counsel I was reasoned from my own union?”
“Because there was no question of a child,” Finrod replied almost inaudibly, after a long hesitation. “And children are the foundation of that custom.”
The sharp trill of splintering glass cut through the air and Finrod spun around in alarm. But Aegnor sat motionless in the same position as before, his left hand clenching a fist so tight the nails drew blood, and the other loose upon the table where it fell after the sudden reflex hurled the wine glass from the table. The golden cranes lay in a huddled flock beside the wall while the wine bled out in a puddle around them.
“Aikanár?”
“The breadth of what thou hast taken from me…”
“Aikanáro…hanno…” Finrod crossed the space between them and knelt before the other’s chair, taking his brother’s face in his hands as he had when Aegnor was a child. “Ávatyara!”
“Forgive thee? What was thy wisdom in the end but a thief robed in compassion? I trusted thee.”
“And ever shall I rue the hurt it caused thee. I should have confessed all and instead I deceived thee, thinking in my pride that I had power to spare thee. I wronged thee.” He held for a brief moment, then the words escaped him. “But I did not command thee.”
“Do not dare,” Aegnor snarled, “do not dare speak reminders as though I’ve not impaled myself every hour since Aeluin upon my own complicity. I know this was my choice. But know also I would have chosen otherwise but for thee.”
Finrod withdrew as though struck and retreated to stand behind his own chair, his hands resting helplessly over the back. “Which nature would they inherit?” he asked at last, his voice heavy. “The father’s or the mother’s? And for which nature should one hope? For by the one inheritance a child would lose its mother ere it reached full maturity—with ever swifter passage for each successive offspring. Thus even in peacetime would the sundering we dread of war be achieved. Or should one hope instead for the alternate bequest? Would it be a kinder fate for the father to watch through ever gathering centuries as his children withered before him, his children’s children, and their children’s children—on through the endless years till he was nothing but a relic, fraught with pain?”
“Grant me the dignity of assuming I’d have pondered that before thy prompting.”
“I do. But how could I have counseled thee to it? I had watched Baran and Belen perish already by the time you came to me—little more than children when I met them and beloved to me as my own sons.”
“I know all of this.”
“I cradled Boron as an infant in my arms and you came to me mad with love for his grandchild. Four generations between my love and thine and yet you spoke to one whose grief was a new wound. And now I’ve buried that infant as the body of a feeble old man. As I buried his father. As I buried his father’s father. Believe me when I tell thee it cannot be imagined it until it is done—and what greater agony should thou face were it thine own flesh and blood.” His tears had held back for the whole of the exchange so far, but he felt them now stinging hot upon his cheeks. “Hanno, how could I counsel thee toward what yet bled within me?”
“And how could I choose, aranya, what was contrary to thy will?”
Finrod’s face crumpled at the title and a choked cry escaped his lips. “How I am paid in bitterness for the desires of my youth!” he cried. “Manwë take all kingdoms and powers from my hands, I want them not—if this is to be the cost. I spoke to thee as a brother, not a king. As do I now.”
“The twain cannot be divided. Thou art both to me.”
“And thus thou wouldst say I am never fully either?”
“I would.” And with that Aegnor’s wrath lay spent and weariness began to seep through his voice. “But on that count, at least, it is through no fault of thine own.”
“That I find increasingly difficult to believe,” Finrod filled his own glass and passed it to his brother in place of its shattered companion, “for ever the heart seeks to claim rule of its faults, that thereby it might have power to master them.”
“Stop trying to rule for one damned minute and perhaps our words may yet have profit.”
A smile split Finrod’s face despite himself. “A point scored.” He reached down and began removing his rings, first the decorative, then the signets, and finally the twined serpents, which he set to rest between them. “There, no more trappings while we speak. This only shall remain,” he said, lifting his left hand with the iron band still clasped about the forefinger, “for the sake of honestly, given over-late. And because king or farmhand, it constrains me till the uttermost end.”
“Might not time bring renewal? Thou art still free.”
“Nay. I swore the binding words in my passion.”
“As did our father’s father, and yet we walk this earth. Death without remission,” Aegnor said quietly, “was never accounted for in our customs.”
Finrod’s glance was skeptical and he made no reply beside.
“My turn now to play the hypocrite,” Aegnor said with a wry smile. “I counsel thee to inconstancy while thou knowest full well I shall never leave Námo’s halls once granted my residence.” He turned his focus to the glass before him and in mindless imitation traced his fingers along the golden wings. “Wilt thou?”
There was a long silence before his brother replied. “I know not. Nor shall I know, I think, until the choice is before me.”
“Always supposing one is yet granted us under the ban.”
“Always supposing that. I cannot see my way to it now, but it may be that in Námo’s halls there is healing, even for such hurts as ours.”
“It may be—if such healing is to be found within the bounds of Arda. But even were it offered, Ingoldo, I should not seek it. For me, the memory of possibility and the pain of forsaking it cannot be untwined. I will not heal from it, for I will not abandon her a second time. Not even in memory.”
“Would she wish that upon thee?”
“Yes.” Aegnor laughed and the sound was a strange mixture of bitterness and affection. “Yes, she would. And far be it from me to fault her. She bears it for all her remaining years, why not I for mine? That union I will not deny.”
“As ever, thou hast the greater courage between us.” Finrod smiled sadly. “Thy spirit quails not to face the Doom head on and accept the price: pain for love’s purchase, loss for what was found, grief the wages of bliss. Whereas I, in cowardice, sought to spare thee what thou didst not fear. I was wrong.”
Finrod rose and gathered his items from the table. He hesitated, then stepped toward his brother and with three fingers brushed the hair back from his forehead, then touched his lips first between the brows, then to the hairline. It was a gesture made by their father a thousand times and Aegnor recognized it in an instant, and felt a knot of emotion tangle in his throat.
“Forgive me, Ambaráto.”
Anger and sorrow struggled once again for mastery and Aegnor did not meet his brother’s eye until the receding footsteps had reached the door. “I will,” he managed at last as his brother laid his hand to the latch. “Only not quite yet.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
- The names of the four wolfhounds are roughly attempting to approximate: Taltar (unsteady/wobbling one), Rómar (horn/trumpet), Capaiton (one who leaps and bounds), Rempamo (crooked one)
- Atar aranya: [Quenya] “royal father”
- Hanno: [Quenya] “brother (diminutive)”
- Lá: [Quenya] interjection, “please”
- Casári: [Quenya] term for Dwarves, based on Khazad
- Ávatyara: [Quenya] “forgive (me)”
- Aranya: [Quenya] my king
- Ambaráto: Aegnor’s given name, meaning either “Champion of Doom” or “High Champion”
ADDITIONAL NOTES
- Per The Nature of Middle-earth, Felagund was "said traditionally to have meant "den-dweller," or specifically "brock, badger" and to have been given in its Sindarized form to Finrod by the sons of Fëanor at least partly in derision.
- Nelyo: shortened form of Nelyafinwë, Maedhros' father-name
2. Grief in All Her Guises
It was danger only if the goal was avoidance, and Balan had no desire to escape. The urge to laugh returned and his heart dared Estreth’s cautions to be true so he might find himself ensnared forever, held motionless on this hilltop, a statue cradled within the other’s hands till the world’s ending. If his soul was consumed in the process, then let it be so. It was a fair price.
A few months after Finrod discovered the Edain near Thalos, he continues to dwell with them and form friendships. Balan (Bëor) attempts to learn multiple languages, some old folktales of the Edain come up in conversation, and Balan and Finrod discuss grief with a side of constellations. Balan has a crush.
Read 2. Grief in All Her Guises

310th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
The Woods of Ossiriand, Near the River Thalos
“Alda…sírë…ondo…”
It was pleasantly hot in the late summer sunlight. The last several days had been sharp with autumn’s onset and Balan found it a relief to lie in the bright grass beside the riverbank, soaking in the warmth. He liked how these unwieldy words felt upon his tongue. Letting his eyes drift idly over the little glade, he tried to recall the names of what he saw, reciting each over and again to learn their shape.
“Anar…fána alma…vilya…lómi…lingwë…”
A butterfly was dipping back and forth over the mud and he frowned at it, prodding his memory. It was a childish sounding word. It had reminded him of his sons’ fumbling attempts at speech when they were young, the syllables each softened and rounded together. Wilwarin, that was it. It was the word that began these secondary lessons. A butterfly had landed on Nóm’s arm while they were working and he greeted it under his breath as it lingered, congenial, like a friend pausing to chat.
“That’s not what you’ve been teaching us,” Balan remarked as he caught bits of the murmured words.
Finrod looked up at him, surprised. “That was my own native tongue.”
“We’re not learning your tongue?”
He shook his head. “I have been teaching you the language of these lands. It will serve you far better—and earn friends in place of adversaries.”
“And what of your kin and people? Should we not learn yours as well?”
“The one is sufficient.”
Balan had found that unconvincing and said so.
“There is a good reason for it, Balan.”
“But you’ll not trust me with it?”
“One day I will. Naught good has ever come of its concealment.” Nóm returned to the pile of branches they were preparing for the huts and began stripping bark away with his knife. “But that is a tale for another time. For now, trust me that it is most expedient for your people to learn the language of your hosts. My tongue will do little good in these lands.”
“Nevertheless, I should like to learn it, useful or no.”
“Nay, you misunderstand me. It is not a question of usefulness. It is a disadvantage to speak it here, and a peril. Your people are far better served by Sindarin.”
“Good then,” Balan had replied. “You shall teach it to them.” He took the finished branch from the other’s hands and met his eye with a sidelong smile. “But you’ll teach me both.”
And so Balan had begun learning a double set of vocabulary, one alongside his people and a second that Nóm taught him quietly. He knew the language was commonplace for the Elf, but here away from any others of his kind the words were their own private dialect, a knowledge that only Balan shared.
“Wilwarin,” he murmured as the butterfly ventured out over the river and felt the shape of it move over his tongue.
“Gods save us, you’re alone.”
Balan started from his reverie, then leaned back against the bank as he recognized the newcomer. “Well,” he said with a wry twist of his lips, “I was.”
“Drowsing by the water when you’re meant to be drying yesterday’s catch,” Estreth kicked him amicably as she passed. “Uninvited company is no more than you deserve.” She set a basket beside the riverbank where several taught lines were strung between the trees, to which she began tying small fish from the basket to dry in the sun. “Well, where is he then?”
“Hm?”
“Your shadow.”
Balan rose as she finished the first fish and walked to where his own basket lay neglected beside a half-strung line. “With Meyla, I believe, teaching her some kind of meal. He learned the pottage and eisl from her yestereve and says he must repay the debt.”
Estreth snorted.
“Which I’m certain,” Balan added, “will be far more complicated than pottage and eisl.”
“I’ll eat a boot if it doesn’t involve some kind of singing.”
Balan chuckled, then improvised in a rough tune, “Pick five handwidths of farrely nettles, cut them with a silver knife. Bathe them well in summer’s moonlight, sing a melody o’er them thrice.” A wry smile tugged at the edge of his mouth. “Aggravatingly delicious, I’m sure.”
Estreth laughed at the juvenile sing-song. “I didn’t know you’d the constitution to mock him.”
“Mock him?” he said with feigned affront. “I wouldn’t dare.”
They fell into an amiable silence as they worked their slow way along the lines. Though Estreth had teased him for avoiding it, Balan enjoyed this kind of work. The simple repetition soothed him and it allowed his mind to wander where it would without risk to the task at hand. Besides that, he found a quiet satisfaction in the specificity of these knots, modeled and formed for this precise purpose and passed from mother to son, father to daughter as a tangible lore. Balan’s preoccupation with learning often left him isolated within his own mind, and he enjoyed these instances where knowledge was primarily physical. It grounded him in the tangible rather than the cerebral. A gust of wind sighed through the trees and Balan let it fill his lungs. The air was pleasant as it traveled in over the water and it lifted his hair in its passage, cooled the sweat on his neck.
“I wonder if it isn’t growing too mild to dry these,” he said, glancing toward the mountains where the slopes already showed the first blood of autumn.
“No, we’ve time for this catch at least. The spiders wove with the dawn this morning and the raven sang in five cries. The chill will come late this year.”
“Your portents.” Balan chuckled as he retrieved a loose line and lashed it back around the nearest sapling. “I’ve yet to see winter obey a raven, or spring the barking of a dog. But I’ll hope you’re right, for the sake of our morning’s work.”
“I am right.” Estreth pushed her basket further along the line. “Scorn our omens all you please, but you’ll remember it was my people guiding yours to early harvest during the hard winters. Our lore has kept us well for long enough to prove its usefulness.”
“True enough, and fairly chided.” Balan retrieved a fish that fell from his last knot and retied it. “I’ll doubt you as ever, but I’ll reform my ways and will not tease.”
“Good lad,” Estreth said with a sidelong smile. She carried her basket to the last line and worked for a time in silence, until Balan moved to join her. “You’re a keeper of lore,” she said quietly. “Did your people ever tell stories of the ghomennin?”
“Now and then, when they wished to keep children from straying too far from the encampment. I don’t recall many in recent years. There are true terrors enough on these paths that we’ve little need for invented ones. Why do you ask?”
“You don’t think the ghomennin are true terrors?”
“Creatures who rise from hillsides to trap you in a dance and consume your soul?” Balan laughed dismissively and continued with the work.
“Beautiful giants appearing without warning; ethereal beings who can ensnare you with their song…”
Balan glanced at her sharply. “That’s hardly a subtle insinuation.”
“It wasn’t meant to be subtle,” she retorted, then began chanting softly under her breath.
“Ghomennin gather, gather ‘round,
They dance a circle ‘pon the ground.
As serpents weaving mesmerize,
Ghomennin hold with shining eyes
The one unguarded in his ways
And bind to them his tale of days.”
“He’s not a demon.”
“Well, he’s the face of a pup and the eyes of a haunted old man,” Estreth said as she strung the last fish up on the line. “It’s all far too fay to be safe, if you ask me. And you’re half gone already. I’m surprised you aren’t perched by Meyla’s fire this very moment to not stray out of his sight.”
“As you said, there was yesterday’s catch to dry.” He tied the last fish to his line as well, then shouldered the basket and followed her back toward the encampment with a grin. “And I won’t shirk every duty in the name of hospitality.”
“Hospitality is one word for it.”
“Dare I ask what another is?”
“Whatever you’d call the creature a serpent transfixed.”
He grimaced at her, then walked ahead as Baran called his name from the camp.
❈ ❈ ❈
In the end, the new dish turned out to be little removed from the previous day’s pottage and eisl. It was a simple broth, scattered with various roots and vegetables, and bolstered with a fleet of doughy spheres.
“It’s some relief,” Estreth noted to Balan as they and Balan’s sons joined the meal, “that even he can’t produce dumplings in pristine globes. These are reassuringly knobbly.”
“And reassuringly substantive,” Baran added with a wink at his aunt.
“Oh gods all,” Balan mumbled irritably, “not you too.”
Baran laughed and then held up his cup as Belen and Nóm joined the group around the fire. “Mead, Bel?”
“Mm.” His brother leaned over and refilled the outstretched cup from the jug he carried, then glanced at Finrod. “Nóm, how do you ask for mead?”
“Annog nin i miruvor,” Finrod held out his own cup toward Belen. “Though to be precise, miruvor is not quite the same as your mead, but it’s my closest guess.”
“Annog nin i miruvor,” Belen repeated as he filled the cup, then set the jug on the ground between them as he turned to his soup.
“Nearly. Move the emphasis forward on your tongue when you say annog. Yes, like that,” Finrod smiled as the boy repeated the phrase, then he retrieved the jug from where Belen placed it and turned to fill Balan’s cup. “Ma nin antatyë i miruvórë.”
“Ma nin antatyë i miruvórë,” Balan repeated.
“Mára.” Finrod gave him a sidelong smile, then set the jug back in its place.
“And which would you favor, Nóm, given the choice?” Baran asked with a grin, “Mead or its translated cousin?”
“To answer that, tell me first what it is I would quench by the drink,” said the Elf with a matching grin, then relented as Baran looked at him in confusion. “Mead when I thirst,” he answered, lifting his cup in salute toward the other, “and miruvórë when I long for my youth.”
Balan broke into laughter at this and lifted his own drink in response. “An answer proving your affinity with us after all, Nóm. To treat with one’s nostalgia in the depths of a cup is quite Mannish of you.”
The laughter passed around the little group and then tapered off into various conversations as they settled into their meal. Balan leaned back and let his gaze drift around at each, the contented lethargy of the morning overtaking him once again. It was odd, he reflected, how often in these past months the feeling of completion arose. He felt it now, watching Baran finish his soup and walk back to tend the broken goat pens, or seeing Meyla’s daughter, a child of three or four, run eagerly to join the group, her little hands still woven into the formation she just learned. He felt it keenly watching Nóm move among them, speak their language, or seeing him follow attentively as Avina held her hands up to show him the newly acquired skill. Whatever it is he was, he had been missing and now he was here.
A smile split his face as Avina began her recitation in front of the Elf, holding her hands with the fingers still interlocked and pressed between her palms.
“Here I hold the lodge for meeting, here I build the doors of oak.” Avina turned her hands to show the thumbs held upright against the near side of the fingers, then spread them apart. “Open them to see the feasting, and hear the songs of merry folk!” She twisted her hands palm upward and the interlaced fingers danced as though seated along banquet tables.
Finrod laughed.
“No, no,” Belen interjected, “that isn’t how I was taught.”
“Mercy on your father, Bel,” Balan said with a chuckle, and drained the rest of his broth.
Belen grinned and held up his own hands, fingers laced across the outside instead. “Here I hold the lodge for meeting, here I build the doors of oak. Open them and where’s the feasting? Where are all the merry folk?” He had opened his hands to show the empty palms, then held one palm flat and flopped the other hand’s fingers loose over it. “Look about, you’ll find them sleeping. Listen and you’ll hear them snore,” he raised a hand to his ear, then turned it to a fist that arced down toward his palm once more. “As the morning comes a’reaping, they’re sleeping off the night before.” He marked this last with a particularly crude gesture hidden behind his hand where Avina could not see it.
“Balan!” Estreth struck Bel’s father jokingly as the group laughed and he dropped back on the ground in mock shame. “And you taught him that at Avina’s age, no doubt.”
“It’s no worse than the ghost tales you filled their heads with,” Balan retorted, pushing back up to rest on his elbows. “And a rude rhyme never kept them up in fright.”
“Nor did my tales.”
Belen looked sheepishly across the fire at his aunt. “I’ll confess there were one or two nightmares.”
“Those were instructive. They weren’t meant to frighten you.”
Balan glanced at her, an eyebrow cocked. “Like the ghomennin?”
Estreth tossed a lump of bread at him and it bounced off his chin.
“Eh!” He retrieved it from the ground and ate it. “And you the one who lectures me on thrift. Don’t waste perfectly good grain.”
Finrod laughed at their bickering, then turned back to Avina who was attempting to follow the conversation with a bewildered smile. “Shall I show you one I knew as a child?” He took hold of her hand as she nodded and closed it into a fist, then raised a finger for each line as he sang,
“Papa cooks the meal,
Mama sets bread to rise.
Brother sits a’harping
And Sister’s songs arise,
Baby sees noone looking
And gobbles up the pies.”
At the last line, he took her little finger and ran it pecking across her palm. She giggled and looked up at him, her eyes bright with laughter. “Again?” His face mirrored back her glee and he repeated the rhyme over and again until Meyla called for Avina from the hut. Then he raised each finger from the little fist, naming them as he went. “Papa, mama, brother, sister, baby. Gwinig,” he shifted into Sindarin as he tucked her little finger back down against her palm, then followed in reverse along the line, “nethig, honeg, emig, atheg.” He closed his hand over her fist with a squeeze and nodded toward the hut. “Go on, now. Your mother needs you.”
Avina ran to join Meyla and Balan looked up at Finrod expectantly.
“What,” Nóm said, laughing as he took the outstretched hands in his, “would you learn children’s rhymes as well?” He wrapped his hand about Balan’s fist to close it, then repeated the same game, only now he sang the rhyme quietly in Quenya as he lifted each finger.
Balan focused for a moment, then repeated back, “Atya, emya, hanno, nette, winimo.”
“Quétalyë mai, you speak well. But a poor friend I should be if I let you go about calling your fingers baby and papa.” A smile broke across Finrod’s face once again—like the dawn, Balan thought as the other released him and took hold of the left hand instead. His hand spread open against Balan’s, palm to palm, the slender fingers towering for a moment over the Adan’s before slipping down to match fingertips instead. “Nápo,” he pressed his thumb gently against Balan’s, then followed with each finger as he named them. “Lepetas, lepenel, lepekan, lepinke.” He slid his fingers over to wrap about Balan's thumb and forefinger. “And when these two are paired together, we name them nápat.”
“Nápat,” Estreth mimicked and pinched Balan’s arm with her thumb and forefinger. “That’s useful, at least.” She rose as she finished the soup and gathered the bowl and utensils.
Balan touched his finger to Finrod’s ring as their hands moved apart. “What does this signify?”
“It is the mark of my father’s house.” Finrod slipped it from his finger and held it out to Balan. “He fashioned it when I was a child, long ago, and gave it to my keeping when our paths parted. It is one of the things I treasure most in this life,” he added as Balan held it up to the sunlight and watched in wonder as the emerald eyes blazed out in green fire.
“Can I see it?” Belen asked and his father passed it into his hand.
“Madja, look at this.” Belen held up the ring as Estreth walked by him on her way back to the huts. “The leaves are smaller than grain.”
Estreth paused behind Belen and glanced at the ring in his hand. “It’s beautiful,” she said, reaching down and tracing her finger over the intricate curves, then she looked pointedly across at Balan with an eyebrow raised. “Serpents.”
Balan rolled his eyes, then grinned and mimicked a hiss.
“Reformed ways indeed,” she said with a chuckle, then walked back toward the center of the encampment.
Bel looked at his father in curiosity. “What are you two on about?”
“Your aunt,” Balan said, “thinks he’s one of the ghomennin.”
“What, Nóm?” Belen handed the ring back to Finrod. “That’s nonsense.”
Balan shrugged and took another sip from his cup. “So I told her.”
“She’s only saying it to aggravate you.” Bel grinned at him, then added as an aside to Finrod, “It’s a favorite familial pastime.”
“What are the ghomennin?” Finrod asked.
“Bel?” Balan looked to his son. “She told you and your brother more fables than I knew.”
“She did, though I remember them more from spook stories than from madja’s tales. When we were children, we’d tell them before daring one or the other to go ‘round a hill or through a nearby thicket. I think half of it we made up on the spot, if I’m honest. But generally speaking, they’re meant to be some kind of woodland spirits or demons—forgive me, lord—“ he added toward Finrod, “whose halls lie under the hills and who come out to snare those who stray in the woods. Madja would tell us of them when we were small so we’d stay near the camp and not wander too far afield. She taught us to leave jars of goat’s milk out each night and little bowls of hawthorn berries as signs of goodwill. As the stories go, if they’re not appeased they’ll come out from the hillsides and find wanderers in the woods or valleys, mesmerize them with a song, and…oh—” Belen broke off, suddenly uncomfortable, and looked over at his father.
Balan chuckled and shifted to sit more comfortably, then he picked up the explanation. “They enchant you with a song or trap you within their dance, then draw years from your soul to prolong their own life. It’s meant to be a tale of how our days are numbered,” he glanced at his friend apologetically, “though telling it to you now, it does sound rather like someone trying to make of you a horror.”
“Perhaps it is,” Finrod said simply. “If it is a tale held over from the dark years, then that is likely enough to be true.” He finished the last of his stew, then set the bowl aside and looked back at Balan with a glint of mischief in his eye. “I’ll confess to you, though ‘twould damn me in Estreth’s eye, my halls do lie hidden beneath the hills.”
“Beneath as in at the foot of?” Bel asked uneasily from across the fire.
“Beneath as in under.”
“Are you trying to frighten the lad?” Balan stood and began collecting the used bowls.
Finrod laughed. “Fortified caves, Bel, nothing sinister. And if it’s any comfort, know it is rare among my people. In fact,” he added with a grin mirroring Belen’s earlier aside, “teasing me for dwelling so is one of my own kin’s familial pastimes.”
Belen smiled in return, but the nervousness did not entirely leave his expression. Balan passed the pile of bowls and cups to his son. “Take these back to Meyla, would you? And help her till the washing up is done,” he added as Belen moved away with the load. “No slipping off to the woods, do you hear?”
“Aye, I hear. Ever your words my teachers and ne’er your deeds.”
His father feigned giving chase and Belen darted toward the huts with a laugh. Balan walked back to the fire, plucking a handful of hawthorn berries from the nearby tree as he passed and slipping a few into his mouth. He held out the rest toward Finrod as he moved to sit beside him on the trunk. “Appeasement, ghomenno?”
Finrod looked amused as he chose a few berries from Balan’s palm and held them in his own, lying like droplets of blood against his skin. “Do I prove my guilt by eating or refraining?”
“If it was a test, what’s proved by telling you first which way to choose?”
“That you believe me innocent,” he replied with a smile and ate the berries.
Balan laughed. “You know that already, or you’d have cast them back to the earth.” He ate a few more, then held out the remainder to the other. “What did you mean before, when you said it was likely the tale meant to cast you as a terror?”
“Ah, is that why you sent the boy away?”
“Something held you back and I flattered myself it was his presence and not mine.”
Finrod was silent as he finished the berries, then spat the seeds onto the ground and began in a quiet voice, “Long ago, when my people first awakened along the Eastern waters, the Darkness was already in the world. The Foe was aware of us before the Valar discovered our fathers walked beside Cuiviénen and he sent terrors and devils to haunt our steps. And because in those days Oromë the Mighty rode over Endor hunting the Foe’s fell beasts, the shadows took in mockery of him the shape of a hunter, the dark Rider upon his wild steed who devoured those of our folk who wandered. Long our fathers feared the sound of hooves, the specter of the Hunter, so that when Oromë did find them at last, many saw in him a terror, fled, and were lost to the darkness. Thus did the Morgoth poison our hearts toward goodness ere ever we had the sight of it."
“And you believe our tales of the ghomennin came also out of that darkness?”
“Perhaps. You can see for yourself the similarities. It was inevitable for Ilúvatar’s children to meet, whether in early years or later, and spreading division between us would ever be his preparation for that eventuality.” Finrod was quite for a moment, twisting a sprig of dried grass in his fingers. “Indeed, he has already made the attempt among my own people. I myself first heard of you through his whispers, though I knew not until long hence that such was their origin. Usurpers he named you in his slander and brought us to suspect the Valar held us in a gilded prison so as to pass Endor’s inheritance to the Secondborn, by restraint thus displacing the First. An easily controlled people, he murmured ever in our ears, dripping honey to feed our pride. Those the Valar might bend more readily to their will. A weaker race.” His voice had grown increasingly bitter as he spoke and he cast the dried grass into the fire with a vehemence that startled Balan. “Damn him to the Void,” he said quietly and his eyes burned with a fierce fire. “He set poison within the cup of friendship and turned to bitterness what should have been the wine of gladness.”
Balan was quiet as the implications of this took root. He watched his friend in disquiet. “You yourself have spoken with him?”
“Yes.” His face clouded and to Balan’s eyes it seemed for a moment lined with untold years. “But ask me not of it. I have answered your earlier questions, let that be enough.” He stood abruptly and gathered his outer tunic and bag from the ground.
“Forgive me if my words trespassed, lord. I meant no offense.”
Finrod paused, then turned back to rest his hand briefly on Balan’s shoulder. “Loth are we all to recall follies we’ve since disowned. If I have been brusque, my friend, know it is from my own shame and not from any displeasure with you. There was no offense.” He collected his sword as well and slung the looped belt over his shoulder. “I will return by nightfall,” he said and disappeared silently into the trees.
❈ ❈ ❈
Despite his words, it was past both nightfall and the evening meal before Finrod appeared again in the encampment. He had wandered the foothills for hours to clear his mind, bemused by how unsettled the conversation left him. There had been nothing unexpected about the exchange—it was a series of perfectly natural questions. Yet as he spoke he felt the same rush of adrenaline grip his throat as he had when Thingol denounced him for the bloodshed at Alqualondë. A strange comparison. It unsettled him that something this simple elicited the same response.
At first he considered it must be the shame of recounting lies to the one slandered. That had a thread of connection, at least. He recalled a similar look of distress upon Círdan’s face when he realized the origin of the rumors he passed on to Menegroth. Wittingly or unwittingly, being the conduit of Melkor’s lies was no easy place to sit. But that discomfort was not the source of this anxiety. Balan brought his own lies of the Darkness into the conversation and if anything it was a shared analysis of each’s experience. There was no judgment in that exchange.
No the true source, he realized as the sun sank over the plains, was his own reluctance to let his history encroach on these friendships. It had been a kind of intoxication dwelling here with them this past summer, being known only on his own merit without the negotiation of politics, without the spectre of rebellion and exile, or kinstrife and grievance as a lens for every action. That also was a thread of connection, he admitted, and a stronger one. It was the panic of the looming precipice, knowing the friendship built might not weather the truth of you.
Telling Balan of the days before the Darkening was edging perilously close to that sheer drop. It would be inevitable, he knew, but still he was surprised by how jealously his heart guarded this newfound companionship.
A smile creased his face as he moved through the camp and saw Balan and his elder son seated beside the central fire. “Mae govannen,” he said as he joined them, then smiled and added in Taliska, “Hello, Balan.”
Balan nodded in greeting, but made no reply. He sat stiffly beside the fire, his arms resting upon his knees and hands clasped tight together.
“You’ve been rather a time,” Baran said conversationally.
“I have, forgive me.” Finrod sat beside them and stretched his legs out before him. “I’m afraid I quite lost myself among the trees and hills. A forest in full grandeur is like a long draught of a mountain spring to the troubled spirit. I did not realize how long I had been absent.”
“Well, nothing’s eaten you, so that’s one concern mended.” Baran nodded toward his father. “He worries when anyone wanders. Quite two-faced of him since he’s the worst offender of us all.”
“Don’t drivel.” Balan’s voice was sharp and his son shrugged apologetically.
Estreth appeared from the shadows on the river’s side of the encampment, bearing two water skins slung over her shoulders. “Balan,” she called, “Eimet asked me to send you. He needs to know if the day’s work mends what’s needed.”
“Mm.” Balan made an affirmative sound, but did not budge.
“I’ll go,” Baran said, rising. “I know what’s required.”
“Is it the goat pens still?” Finrod asked after Baran retreated into the clearing where Estreth had emerged.
“Damned creatures will not stay put.” Balan frowned into the fire.
“As a fellow creature prone to wandering, I confess a modicum of sympathy for their plight.” He flashed a bright smile at the other in a vain attempt to ease the mood. “I think sometimes my steward would put up a pen to keep me within the bounds of my city, if given the chance.”
There was no reply and a cold silence spread over them as they sat, watching Estreth fill a bowl with herbs she brought back from the fields and shift a large cauldron to sit beside the fire. A muted cry rang through the camp and Balan stood abruptly, then disappeared beneath the trees.
Finrod watched him go, then turned hesitantly toward Estreth. “Have I insulted him in some way?”
“No, not to my knowledge.” Estreth poured one of water skins into the waiting pot. “It is only the circumstances in which you found him. Gelvira bears her child tonight.”
“Yes,” Finrod replied, smiling, “I passed Hathus as I entered the camp and he told me the tidings.”
“It often takes him this way. He’ll be gone till morning, most likely,” Estreth emptied the second skin into the cauldron and pushed it back over the fire. She sat, lifting the bowl of herbs into her lap and crushing them to a paste with a rough-hewn pestle, then glanced up at the Elf as his unspoken questions lingered between them. “His wife died giving birth,” she added by way of explanation.
The look of perplexity only increased.
“Esrid died in childbirth,” Estreth enunciated the Taliska sharply and met his eye to communicate the thought, assuming he was unfamiliar with the words.
But the confusion continued to deepen and his brows gathered in concern. “Do you mean that generation itself is a peril to your people?”
“Is it not to yours?”
“Nay, for us it—“ Finrod broke off as another cry rang through the camp and he looked back at Estreth, stricken. “Forgive me, I did not know; and I fear in my ignorance I spoke thoughtlessly. I’ve caused offense.”
“Not to me, lord.”
“Nay, but my glib festivity to Hathus must have appeared heartless, or premature at best to one who yet waits upon the precipice.”
“He wouldn’t reproach your goodwill, Nóm. You err if you suppose that fear and danger must overshadow any joy in the anticipation. With our people it’s ever the mingled fare. Our joys and sorrows are invariably hand in hand.”
“So I am learning.” He paced several lengths beside the fire in uncharacteristic restlessness, then turned back toward her. “What is there I can do? I would like to be of help.” He held out his hand toward the bowl of herbs. “I could assist with that.”
“No. We tend to each other in this,” Estreth said with a shake of her head. Then she softened. “But I will need more water. You could fetch two more skins from the river. Then, if you are earnest in your wish to help, go mind Balan. Make sure he doesn’t wander too far off.”
❈ ❈ ❈
Finrod reflected on the irony of his assignment as he passed through the darkened forest. He had deposited the water skins as directed and now wound his way soundlessly through the trees in search of the other. He was far more likely to join a friend in wandering than to usher them back from it, but he judged the responsibility Estreth delegated lay more in companionship than in herding. And that task he welcomed.
The night was nearly half gone before he found Balan at last, sitting atop a hillside out of earshot of the encampment. His back was to Finrod and he sat huddled together in a clump, his knees drawn up against his chest and arms wrapped tightly about them, his chin resting on his knees. It was like catching a glimpse of his childhood, Finrod thought as he saw him outlined in the moonlight, so small and vulnerable, a tiny figure alone against the mountains. He felt the urge to reach out and wrap an arm about the rigid shoulders and comfort the pain they fenced. He reached out toward the other’s mind instead, nudging a gentle awareness of his presence before he spoke so as not to startle him.
“I wondered if you would come find me,” Balan said without turning.
“Estreth sent me.” Finrod walked forward to stand where the other could see him. “I would have come on my own, but I feared that would be an intrusion.”
“No,” Balan said, his voice flat. “You’re not intruding.”
Finrod moved quietly to sit beside him. Now that he was near, he could see the reason for the huddled posture. Balan’s whole body was shaking and the grip about his legs tightened as each bout of shuddering came over him. “Are you chilled?” he asked, concerned.
“No.” Balan’s teeth chattered as he denied it and he shook his head in frustration. “I don’t know why it takes me like this, but I can’t control it. It’s why I go off alone, it worries Baran and Bel to see me this way.”
“Sorrow is always unpredictable. There is no shame in it.”
“Estreth bears it with more fortitude than I.” He felt the tension grip each limb again, holding back the urge to flight that rose whenever the memories surfaced.
“Estreth?”
“She's Esrid's sister. Hadn’t I told you?”
“No, I did not know that. I assumed she was yours.”
He shook his head. “She joined our people at Esrid’s marriage. It was unusual for either clan, but they wouldn’t be parted and our people were determined to press on on toward the mountains while theirs remained. They’d been orphans since childhood, you see, so each was all the other had. In truth, I believe my wife’s death rent Estreth’s heart in many ways that never touched mine—to my lasting shame. Yet in times like these when memory is the most brutal, Estreth remains, not just in the encampment but alongside them, present and attending despite all of it. Whereas I…” Balan let out his breath in a rush of exasperation and clenched his fists to still the trembling.
Finrod took the other’s hands in his own and pressed them gently between his palms, steadying them. “Grief meets us each in her myriad guises, Balan. There is not one embodiment of sorrow acceptable which leaves all others inferior. Nay, rather our varied griefs are each threads from which the tapestry of remembrance takes shape. Do not disparage how your body mourns; it is but your voice taking its place in the shared lament.” He watched him quietly as the long moments stretched on, then released his hands and shifted to face him. “But perhaps…”
The Elf reached out to rest his fingers upon Balan’s face, palms shrouding the eyes and thumbs pressing gently against the forehead. “Aia Nienna quanta nyérë,” his voice mingled with the wind whispering through the dry grasses around them, and Balan was immediately mesmerized by the sound. “Órava omessë lúmessë ya maurë…” It wrapped about him like water, the words rising and falling, waves passing through him. Perception slowed and all the teeming earth gathered in his thought. He was aware of the scuttling insects and the delving worms, the forest creatures and the mountain lions denning in distant ridges, the owl soaring overhead and all the forms unaccountable stirring beneath the night sky. He felt the presence of his people waiting in the valley below and gasped as the weight of their collective need bore in upon him. The gentle pressure on his forehead increased and a thread of warmth spread between his eyes. With his sight shrouded he could see it: a molten rivulet of gold traveling down his spine and spreading out through each fiber. Stillness fell where its tendrils touched and the melodic words followed in its wake, filling Balan’s senses like an incantation. The voice was inside him now, resonant in his bones, flowing through his blood, breath filling his lungs.
A prickling danger rose along the base of his scalp.
The ghomennin gather, gather ‘round,
They dance a circle ‘pon the ground.
But rather than recoil, he found himself near laughter as his memory called up Estreth’s rhyme. It was danger only if the goal was avoidance, and Balan had no desire to escape. The urge to laugh returned and his heart dared Estreth’s cautions to be true so he might find himself ensnared forever, held motionless on this hilltop, a statue cradled within the other’s hands till the world’s ending. If his soul was consumed in the process, then let it be so. It was a fair price.
Peace passed over him and quieted the fey mood; stillness that had evaded him since he was little more than a child, lonely and afraid and inheriting the clan’s headship well before his time. Again with eyes covered he watched as scorched embers lifted from each finger, from his arms, his legs, from his tongue, from his chest. The embers came together before him and coalesced into a whole, each piece returning like shards of a shattered vessel, and he felt the warmth and weight of it settle within his palms. He wrapped them gently about it and held the years of sorrow as a lovely, fragile thing, abstract and yet innate to him. The grief itself was not gone. It remained within his body, he could feel it distinctly, but it no longer overmastered him. He saw it glowing before him, warm and precious. And everything was stillness.
Then the voice too tapered into silence.
Finrod removed his hands and returned them to rest upon his own knees, while the humming of summer bugs rose once more to prominence in the night air. Slowly, Balan opened his eyes and looked about him, disoriented. Nothing had changed. They sat still upon the hillock, the grasses sighed with the same hush of nighttime, and his outstretched palms were empty.
“What did you do?” Balan turned his hands over in the moonlight, his voice tinged with awe, for the shaking was gone and his body at ease.
“Do you find it better or worse?”
“Better.” He took a deep breath and it was steady. “What did you do?”
Finrod laughed and lay back in the grass. “Ela!” he breathed as he looked up at the night sky and beckoned for Balan to join him. “Do you see him there?” he drew a pattern in the stars above them as Balan moved to lie beside him. “Menelmacar, the Swordsman of the Sky.”
“No, where are you pointing?”
“There.” He shifted so his line of sight was closer to Balan’s. “There are three stars a hand’s width over the tree-line, brighter than their sisters about them. Do you see?”
“I believe so.” Balan tried to focus as his mind still worked to grasp what he had experienced.
“Those are his belt. Now follow the furthest upwards and you’ll find his blade raised in charge.”
“Yes, I see it.”
“Then cross here and the curve of his shield wards the skies.”
“Mendelcar?”
“Menelmacar,” he corrected, “heaven’s warrior.” The finger moved further along the sky, itself luminous where it caught the moonlight, and Balan felt again the unsettling presence of a second thought within his own as the image of a dim huddle of stars rose ahead of the finger’s path to illumine what Finrod outlined. “This is Itseloktë.”
“Itselot—Itseloktë.” He turned the word over on his tongue and added it to the list of recitations. “Itseloktë. What does it mean?”
“It…how would you say it in your tongue…insects, perhaps? Gnats? Nay, flies would be nearer, I deem. The fly cluster.” He glanced over at Balan with a grin as the adan snorted despite himself. “Our Sindarin kin name it better. Remmirath they call it, the Netted Stars: a mesh of those jewels that alone are fit to crown the head of Tintallë.”
Balan recalled waking beside the embers and seeing the visions flowing out from Nóm’s song: among them was a woman measurelessly tall, strong beyond reckoning, wrapped in a mantle of twilit blue that reached beyond the horizon, that was the horizon. Light spilled out from her and he closed his eyes against the brilliance of the memory.
“Varda Elentári, our Lady of Light, who wove the stars into their celestial dance and set their steps in a sign of doom. Anarríma, Soronúmë, Telumendil, Wilwarin…”
“Butterfly.” Balan reflexively named the translation under his breath and Finrod laughed.
“Yes, the evening’s butterfly.” He pointed to a distant stretch of sky. “There he flits above the mountains: a wing here, another just there.”
“I see it.” Balan raised his hand toward the patterned stars and his finger rested lightly against the other’s. He lingered as long as he dared, then shifted their hands together toward the north. “And what of this one?” he asked as he dropped his arm back onto the grass. “Have you a name for it?”
“We do.”
“I’ve been drawn to it as long as I can remember, ever since I was a boy,” Balan continued as the other did not elaborate. “Some nights when I can’t sleep I’ll sit outside and follow it through the sky. It steadies me, I know not how.”
“It is the Valacirca,” Finrod said after a long silence, his voice quiet, “the Sickle of the Valar. It was set there in the heavens ere your people or mine awakened, as a sign of that truth which we hold in estel: it is Light that shall endure, not Darkness.” He turned his face toward the other and studied Balan’s profile outlined against the tangle of stars. “And I confess, my friend, it gladdens my heart to find this is shared between us as well: many of those nights when you watched its path, we would have kept vigil together. Ever have I looked to those same stars in times of despair to recall that all works of the Dark are for naught. That they will, as was said at the first Music, be but an instrument of things yet more wonderful than those it sought to destroy.”
“And that comforts you?”
“It does—to know we are creatures of the One who is Goodness, and from whose works must ultimately come joy, if not happiness. Lost on the ice before the sun’s first rising, when I came nearest to forsaking hope, even then I looked up through the bitter cold and behold! I saw the Seven Stars rise triumphant in the north, crowning the work of Eru to which Morgoth Bauglir shall never lay full claim, and over which he shall never triumph. In that hour I knew, as I answer you now,” he returned his finger briefly to Balan’s forehead in reminder of the question he addressed, “we are not abandoned.”
Balan’s eyes traced back over the constellations as the sound of his heart pounded hard in his ears. Something had awakened in him at the other’s touch that slept dormant for more years than he cared to count, and he felt as foolish and giddy as an infatuated youth. He knew his face burned red at the realization and was grateful for the wisp of cloud dimming the moon’s light. Then the flush spread to his ears as he reflected that the dark likely caused little hindrance to the other’s keener sight and every expression would be writ plain should Nóm look toward him once more. Balan turned his face toward the mountains.
He was increasingly aware of the hand resting inches from his head. He could still feel where the cool fingertips had rested behind his ears and would have paid any price to have his face cradled within them once again. Or more, to have those fingers tangled within his hair, pulling him in, pulling him down—
Utter foolishness. This weak-kneed devotion was for those of his sons’ years, it was laughable in a man his age. Half his life was spent and yet here he lay, a grey-templed chieftain, tracing stars and feeling the dizzy rush of adolescent desire. It was ludicrous. Then a worse thought struck him. A man of his years was but an adolescent to the creature beside him. He could live out all his days, he could outpace even the oldest of his ancestors, and yet still never surpass the span of a child in the Elf’s eyes. What was Balan’s half-century to one who remembered the dark before the sun’s first rising? Such insignificant creatures they would seem when, as soon he must, the other learned clearly of their transience. A little flock of sparrows, Balan thought bitterly. A cluster of flies.
“Would you tell me of her?” Finrod’s voice cut through the haze and pulled him back to the present.
“Of Esrid?”
“If you will. Memory can be both wound and balm.” He turned his face toward Balan once more and smiled. “Shared, I find it is more often a balm. Would it help you to speak of her?”
“Perhaps.” At the least it might ease this fevered confusion, though Balan balked at the thought after his realization. “What shall I tell you?”
“Anything you wish.” Finrod found his own cherished memories rising unbidden at the question—his grandfather’s hands lifting him as a child, his mother’s laugh, the particular crease over his father’s left eye whenever they debated. Then shifting, the thought of laughter melding with his own, of golden hair caught in the wind and covering his face as a voice sang next to him on a bright mountainside. No, that memory was not yet a balm. “Tell me of her voice,” he heard himself say.
Balan lay for a moment lost in thought. He most often recalled his life in single images, moments frozen in time rather than the embodied memory. But to think of Esrid’s voice was to remember in active engagement, and he had avoided that deliberately. If he only lifted up a moment from recollection, it could be catalogued and kept as an artifact alongside any other histories he learned. This, on the other hand, meant allowing himself back into the memory’s living presence and he felt the panic returning at the thought. He pictured the glowing orb in his palms once more and took a breath.
“It was low,” he said at last, his own voice gruff in the attempt to keep it steady, “like Estreth’s and with the same warmth of intonation. Deep and kind and quiet, unless she was laughing. Then you could hear her across the whole encampment. When Baran was a child, he and I would do the most ridiculous things to summon that laugh. He had the greatest knack for it and could draw it out better than any other. Though despite that, it’s Belen who inherited her laugh itself. You’ve heard him, Nóm, so you’ll know what I mean when I say it’s the kind of laugh that sets your soul to dancing.” He realized he was smiling at the recollection and turned to look at Finrod. “You were right. Gods only know how, but it is a balm and I’ve run from it all these years.”
“It is not until the time that it is,” Finrod said circuitously, “so rue not the years that have gone. They are not wasted.”
“A platitude I’ll grant you,” Balan said with a chuckle and rolled onto his stomach. “I’m far too glad at its comfort to tease you for the words.”
Finrod laughed. “Mock all you wish, I’ll be a willing subject. Tis a balm of its own for me to hear your mirth.” He turned to lie on his side where he could see the other’s face silhouetted against the moonlight. “But tell on, if you will. I’ll not tire.”
“A valiant promise, with the night already old,” Balan replied with a chuckle, but found his heart warmed by the assurance. He lay in silence for several minutes as the breeze whispered on through the dried grasses, then began in a quiet voice to recount his brief years with Esrid. He told of how the two clans sheltered together through a bitter winter and how Esrid and Geberic, a warrior of Balan’s people, grew close during that time. When the Spring came and Balan’s people wished to move onwards, Esrid and Geberic were wedded, and Estreth joined the migration to stay alongside her sister. It was only a year later that their company was ambushed and a bitter battle fought between the rivers. Geberic was slain, and many others of their folk, and Esrid left widowed and too far west now for the sisters to return to their own kin.
Balan had not known how best to care for them. In his clan’s custom, those from outside were bound into their number by a spouse or by the blood shared through a child of that union. With neither present, the position of both Esrid and Estreth was tenuous and rested entirely upon the charity of those around them. So when a few months had passed, Balan approached her and as a solution offered his own hand when the mourning period was ended, thus to secure both her place and Estreth’s within the community, Estreth being little more than a child at the time.
It was to be a union of expediency, but as the mourning year passed they began to find solace in each other’s company. Balan’s parents too had been slain when their village was attacked and burned, only a few years before his clan and Esrid’s met, and their shared grief became a point of kinship. Both had been left alone without warning to fend for themselves with little guidance, and both found comfort in the presence of another who understood that terror. They began to seek each other out as the days went on and by the time that year had ended, Balan loved her.
“She never loved me the way she had Geberic,” Balan said quietly to Finrod, “but the love that was there was enough. Eight years we had of it, days upon days of the blissful mundane. Baran was born, Belen was born. We were content, beyond what either of us expected or hoped. And then there was to be another child.” His voice trailed off and he could not continue for several long minutes. He pushed up to sit once more with his arms drawn tightly about his knees and looked out over the valley, his voice distant when he spoke again. “It came too soon. I knew we would lose the child, it was far too early. But I thought…” his voice broke and he took a breath to steady it. “In the end I lost them both, Esrid and our daughter. Alémi,” he added in a whisper, “Little Sparrow I named her in her mother’s tongue. She was impossibly tiny, Nóm, I could hold her almost in one hand. How it was possible that something so small and frail could take the lives of both of them, I have never been able to understand. Nor will I ever.”
Finrod shifted up to sit beside him, silent. Any words of comfort, he knew, would only show themselves hollow in the attempt. His own heart quailed merely at the retelling. What must it be to dwell with each moment of life and death so bound, caught intrinsically together at each turn?
“Baran was in his fifth summer, Belen his second. I remember very little of the ensuing year, but I know I left my wife and daughter buried on a hillside while we continued our march westward. I carried Bel on my back as we traveled, partly to comfort him, partly to comfort myself. It helped to have the living warmth of him against me and his little hands tugging my hair or my ears to keep me grounded. Estreth walked with Baran beside us and sang to keep us all moving forward.” A wan smile creased his face. “We became an unusual little family: lone-father, boys, and aunt-mother. But we all chose each other in that need and have ever been closer because of it.”
“I am so sorry, Balan.”
“Yes. Well. It has happened to countless others besides me. I’ve no idea why I cannot bear the weight of it when those others do.” Balan looked down wryly as his hands shook once again. “You’ve not cured me entirely, I see.”
“No,” Finrod took Balan’s hands in one of his own and reached out with the other to rest it gently against his face. “I only helped to settle it before. Grief does not have a cure, my friend. But that is not an evil, for if we did not grieve we did not love. And that is some comfort, I hope.” He moved his hand so the fingers rested once again on each side of Balan’s forehead, then drew it down slowly to close the other’s eyes with words whispered too quietly to discern.
A modicum of peace returned and Balan breathed deeply of the night air. All was confusion within him, grief and growing desire tangled together bearing somehow a seed of tranquility. Then through the stillness he heard a murmur rise from the valley below and his eyes shot open in trepidation. He rose to his feet. “Nóm? What is it?”
“Do you not hear?”
Balan shook his head and looked down at his friend, pleading and yet fearful of the answer.
“I hear an infant’s cry,” the Elf said softly, a gentle smile spreading over his face as he stood and took his friend by the arm to ensure he was steady. “And I hear voices raised in celebration. All is well, meldonya.”
"All is well," Balan echoed and in that moment, standing on a hilltop in this wide, new land, his arm burning with the other’s touch, he believed it with his whole soul. “All is well.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya
- Alda: [Q] tree
- Sírë: [Q] river
- Ondo: [Q] stone
- Anar: [Q] sun
- Fána alma: [Q] white flower
- Vilya: [Q] air, sky
- Lómi: [Q] clouds
- Lingwë: [Q] fish
- Meldonya: [Q] beloved friend
- Madja is an invented term for “aunt (mother’s sister)”, loosely inspired by Germanic-Gothic
MISC NOTES
- Some of the references to the ghomennin are loosely based on general descriptions of the Aos Sí.
3. Unfriends
Finrod felt the other’s panic strike his perception like a blow and was running even before Balan’s cry reached his ear. In a glance, his eyes took in the scene before him: the camp in sudden stillness, one of the Laiquendi staggering through the clearing, a limp body slung in his arms, Balan and Baran sprinting toward him.
It was Belen in his arms.
The Edain and the Laiquendi cross paths in the woods of Ossiriand and are faced with immediate conflict. Finrod and Estreth work to heal the damage, Balan (Bëor) tries to learn the communication of thought, and the Edain choose where their loyalty will abide.
Read 3. Unfriends

310th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
The Woods of Ossiriand, Near the River Thalos
Caught in a limb above the waterline were the remains of a deer skull, stripped clean by the air and water and bleached white in the summer sun. Belen stood transfixed by the sight of it. It hung like an omen suspended above the water of the tributary stream, dangling in a patch of light over the ripples like a god of bygone days. There had been many legends among his mother’s people of the deer folk and their lords, and he found himself drawn toward the skull as he had been to those tales in childhood. It was an exceptionally large skull and must have belonged to a great stag. It had, he confirmed as he set aside his spear and climbed out onto the trunk to examine the broken antlers. Even fractured as they were, the majesty remained. They must have been two or three times the length when they were whole.
“You were a right old patriarch…” he murmured to the bones as he untangled the points from the twigs and vines. “A grand king of summers.” He rinsed it in the stream, then held it up into the sunlight where it glistened, regal, as the water dripped from its edges. An image rose in his memory of the sheer cliffsides among the passes of the Ered Luin. Across their face had run a parade of rudimentary figures painted in various poses; warriors, children, hunters and healers, a figure carrying a babe in its arms, another run through with a spear, wild beasts with small figures clutched in their maws. But throughout the dance of paintings was one in particular that arrested Belen’s attention, an imposing figure that led each group through the tapering cleft, the recurring silhouette of a man’s body bearing a stag’s skull upon his head. He led the hunters, he stood among the ravaging beasts, he held out a hand to the figure bearing the infant, he bent over the healers at their work. Belen’s imagination had been captured by the skull man, as he dubbed him in juvenile shorthand, and he trailed behind their march to study the intricacies of the various depictions.
He felt a similar intrigue now at the tactile presence of the skull within his hands. He was overtaken by the impulse to enact those images himself, alone here in the woods with no brother to tease him for the frivolity or friends to laugh at his earnest fascination. He undid the leather band of his tunic and pulled it free, running it instead through gaps in the jawbone.
Belen lifted the skull and placed it on his own. It was large enough that it rested over his head rather than upon it and he shifted the position so he could peer out from the empty eyes. It was easier to see than he expected, little different from looking through the carved masks they wore during the longest night, or for celebrations at the turn of midsummer. He grinned as it stayed balanced when he removed his hands, then he tied the band firmly under his chin to hold it in place, retrieved his spear, and stepped forward, mimicking the movements of the painted figures.
Belen shifted his arms to carry the spear as the paintings had shown, his right arm extended parallel with the ground and crooked back so the lower end of the spear rested upon his upper arm while his hand braced just above, his left arm held up with the palm outward. He stepped forward slowly, easing the ball of his foot onto the pine carpet, lowering the heel deliberately to join it. It was a dance with the forest floor and with the trees about him and he moved faster with each step, surprised by how quietly he flew across the waiting ground, leaping over fallen branches and slipping between the clumps of bracken. He had become fleet as a deer, he thought wildly as he ran, he belonged to their folk.
Then suddenly he froze at the edge of a clearing. There before him in the sunlight was a young stag, tall and strong with antlers arching up in challenge. Belen was breathless as he watched. How he had managed to come this close without the creature fleeing was inexplicable. Perhaps that was why the skull man donned his helm of old, Belen mused. Estreth’s tales of the deer folk included myths of a hunter garbing himself in the herd’s hide and thus gaining his proximity unawares. If the skull man was of the deer folk as Belen’s father had surmised, then maybe what he saw on the cliff walls was this very practice.
Belen moved carefully behind the shadow of the tree beside him. He had never killed in a hunt. There had been several chances over the recent years, but ever he held back at the last moment and Baran or Hathus would take the kill. But crouched here he did not feel the creeping nausea that typically assailed him in these moments. Here, with his face shrouded behind the heavy skull, he was not quite himself. It was the skull man stalking this deer, he fancied, not Belen. It was the skull man who crouched gradually into a position where he had a clear line of sight to the grazing animal, the skull man who shifted the spear back to balance its weight in his hand. It was the skull man who lifted that spear, launched into a quick sprint, and pulled his throwing arm back into an arc as the deer’s head shot up at the approach.
It was Belen who felt a searing pain strike his side and fell senseless to the ground.
❈❈❈
Finrod retrieved another apple from the basket over his arm and held it out to the nearest donkey. Balan and his sons teased him relentlessly for having taken to tending to the little herd, but he found both the duties and the creatures a pleasant diversion. He had little exposure to them outside the few that accompanied casári trading caravans and discovered to his surprise that he quite enjoyed their company. They were affectionate and amiable souls. He smiled as this nearest one mimicked his step backward, then closed the gap between them again at his prompting and took the apple from his outstretched palm. “Yes, that one was not quite ripe, was it, little brother?” he mumbled to the beast in Quenya. “I promise thee I gleaned carefully, but the trees are withholding this season.”
The donkey snorted as it chewed the fruit and Finrod chuckled, reaching out to scratch its neck. He reached back into the basket and procured a ripe apple as it finished.
“Here. Not a word to thy brothers and sisters, but I owe thee another after that.”
A velvety tickle against his cheek announced that his own horse had meandered over at the prospect of apples and he reached up to run his hand over her nose in greeting. Ëassarië looked over the donkeys’ pens with something akin to pity, as she was allowed to graze unrestrained around the encampment and seemed to take this as a matter of course for all creatures. She nibbled at her master’s ear in protest for the delay and he held an apple out to her with a chuckle. “Glutton. Thou canst eat them from tree or fallen whenever it pleases thee and theirs must be brought by hand. Leave them their delicacies, Váya.” He ran his hands over her ears and stroked the dappled grey shoulder affectionately. Sea-stone he had named her after the shores of Alqualondë that filled his childhood, but Váya she was now after their years together, the stormy sea that carried him where it would.
Váya finished the apple and then rested her nose on his shoulder as he continued distributing fruit to the herd, nibbling his ear now and then to see if she could cajole him into another offering.
It was a pleasant way to pass the late afternoon. Finrod reflected once again how reluctant he was to leave this peaceful existence for the sharp dance of court. He could spend another season here, surely; perhaps even winter with them before it became necessary to send word to Barad Eithel of the discovery. They could be his own yet awhile before the grudges and feuds tangled about them as well and pulled them into its mire.
He took a deep breath to clear his thoughts. That future would come in its own time. For now there was the late summer sun, the golden evening, Váya’s breath against his ear, and the contentment of simple tasks.
A ripple in the air. There was a flicker of unease and then a sudden rush.
Balan.
Finrod felt the other’s panic strike his perception like a blow and was running even before Balan’s cry reached his ear. In a glance, his eyes took in the scene before him: the camp in sudden stillness, one of the Laiquendi staggering through the clearing, a limp body slung in his arms, Balan and Baran sprinting toward him.
It was Belen in his arms.
Finrod ran faster and heard Estreth cry out the boy’s name as she raced after them.
Balan reached the stranger first and caught hold of his son’s shoulders, sharing the weight between them, as Baran and Finrod arrived together and each took one of the legs. An arrow protruded at an ugly angle from the boy’s side and his eyes fluttered as Estreth cupped her hands beneath his head and they carried him back into the camp.
“Hathus!” Baran shouted, “Spears and surround the perimeter. Is it goblins?” he asked in a quieter voice, looking to his father as they laid Bel gently beside the fire.
“I don’t know.” Balan shook his head and grasped Belen’s face in his hands. “Belen, do you hear me?” He slapped the boy’s cheek when he did not respond, his voice urgent. “Belen!”
The eyes opened and he drew in a ragged gasp. “Vatta,” he whispered and caught a handful of his father’s shirt. “Vatta…”
“Hush, lad.” Balan wrapped his hand over Belen’s. “Don’t try to speak.”
“Lie back, Belen.” Estreth’s voice was a stern command and she pushed Baran aside to kneel and cut away the tunic with her knife.
“This is not an Orcish arrow,” Finrod spoke softly in Sindarin and looked up into the eyes of the Laiquendë opposite him. He recognized him now as he regarded the features. Orndaer, if he remembered aright, a young Elf distantly connected to the house of Lenwë. The fletching of the arrow matched the flock in his quiver. “What have you done?”
“It was a mistake.” Orndaer’s voice was laced with fear. “I had only a fleeting glance. I thought he was of the glamhoth.”
“Of the glamhoth!” The two Elves launched into a heated exchange and Balan could understand only the occasional word. But his eyes had followed Finrod’s and he too traced the mirrored fletching.
“Dagnir!” he hissed and leapt forward over his son.
“Balan!” Finrod caught him and dragged him back, shifting to place himself between the two of them. “It was a mistake. Do not make it a blood feud.” He pushed him back again as he fought against the restraint. “Balan!”
“He has killed my son…”
“Killed him? He—“ Finrod broke off as he recalled his previous misconceptions of their fragility and the color drained from his face. “Estreth?”
She shook her head as she examined the wound and her eyes moved to meet Balan’s. “It is rooted deep.”
Finrod knelt opposite her and moved his fingers gently over Belen’s abdomen as the boy whimpered and gritted his teeth. “Tell me the precise danger.”
“Blood loss, always,” Estreth murmured. “The lungs should be safe, it’s low enough, but it must have punctured the entrails. I can’t see how it wouldn’t, especially carried bent up as he was,” she added with a dark glance at Orndaer, who was now restrained by Baran. “If the gut is breached, there is little we can do. He will hemorrhage—or spared that, the wound will putrefy and a fever burn him away.”
“Madja…” Belen whispered and fear stood out among the drops of sweat on his face.
“Shh...” She smoothed the hair back from his forehead. “Stay still, little one. Nothing is certain.”
“I will tend to it,” Finrod said, pulling his outer tunic over his head and folding it up to set beneath Belen’s head. “I have some moderate skill in healing, and while there is much I’ve yet to learn of your kind, I can mend what you name.” He set his hand on the boy’s shoulder and met his gaze. “Have I your permission, Bel?” Belen nodded with an effort and Finrod looked up at his friend. “Balan?”
“Do what you will,” Balan’s voice was tight. “What choice have I else?”
“Build up the fire,” Estreth said, turning to Hathus, “and fetch water and any clean cloths you can lay to hand. I’ll be but a moment,” she added and sprinted back toward the huts as Balan moved to take her place beside his son.
Finrod rolled his sleeves and pulled his hair back in a swift motion. “Orndaer,” he said quietly, shifting to Sindarin once more as he wove the strands into a braid, “if I sent you to gather what I need, do I have your assurance that you would return and stay until his fate is known?”
“Yes, lord.” Orndaer did not hesitate. “I do not seek to flee. My deed was rash and I will abide by its consequences.”
“What’s he saying?” Baran asked in a gruff tone and his grip tightened about the Laiquendë’s arm.
“He answered what I asked. There are things I require and he knows what to seek.”
“No. Send someone else.”
“Baran—“
“I will not release him till I know my brother lives.”
“Nor I,” added his father. “Till that time, he is naught but my foe.”
“Then make of your foe a tool. Time is of the essence.”
“How do I know he’ll not run back to his own folk if we turn him loose?”
“If he wished Belen’s blood on his hands, he would have let him lie where he fell.”
“And if he wished peace from my hands, he’d have broken his arrow ere he nocked it.”
“Balan!” Finrod caught hold of his arm, his voice sharp. “There is no time for this. I have his word. He will return or you will hold me accountable, even to the death if you will have it so. I need assistance and he knows what to seek—and where.”
“Send him.” Estreth had returned, bearing a heavy satchel, and she dropped to her knees beside Balan. “Don’t be a fool. We need haste.”
Balan looked from one to the other, then swore under his breath as Belen gripped his hand tighter. “On your heads be it. Let him go free,” he said to Baran, then turned back to Finrod. “But I will not answer for his fate if my boy does not live out the night.”
“I hear you.” Finrod turned back to Orndaer and gave a series of instructions, speaking too quickly for Balan to understand more than a few words as he stroked his son’s hair and leaned down to kiss the burning forehead. Orndaer disappeared into the trees, fleet as the wind, and Finrod turned back to examine the wound. “Forgive me for this,” he said softly, then took the arrow in his fingers and shifted it ever so slightly.
Belen gave a muffled cry and Balan gripped his hand tighter.
“It moves freely,” Finrod said to Estreth, “which is some mercy.”
“Good.” She was quickly mashing a handful of leaves and honey in a bowl. “Then it’s not reached the spine. Balan, there is a pouch of willow bark in the bag—the plain pouch with the blue bead on its band. Take a few pieces and give it to him to chew, if he can.”
Finrod shook his head. “Nay, save that for when he wakes.”
“I am awake,” Belen’s voice rasped.
“I know you are, Bel.” Finrod smiled at him and retrieved a flask from the pouch at his side. He leaned over to lift Belen’s head, setting the flask to his lips. “Take a mouthful of this. Gently, now.” He set the flask aside and rested his hand over the boy’s forehead, then paused and looked up at Balan in question.
Balan nodded. Then, as it had on the hilltop beneath Menelmacar and the changeless Sickle, the other’s voice began to rise and fall with the wind, an invocation little more than a whisper, and gradually Belen’s eyes drooped shut as his breathing steadied.
“Balan…?” Estreth’s voice rose in alarm.
“It’s alright,” Balan replied, watching as Finrod leaned down and pressed his ear to Bel’s chest, listening.
“His heart is steady.” Finrod stood and motioned for Balan to take his place as he crossed to kneel beside Estreth. He produced a small, silver knife and tested it carefully against his finger before aligning it beside the arrow’s shaft. He paused and met Balan’s eyes over the prostrate form. “It is unlikely he’ll wake ere we are through, but hold him nevertheless, on the chance that he does.”
Balan slid his arm across his son’s chest and grasped the shoulder, bracing himself should the boy stir at the blade’s touch. He watched as Finrod traced a finger gently over the flesh to chart his path, then lifted the knife and cut.
❈❈❈
Night was dark within the low hut. Balan sat on the dirt floor beside the pallet, motionless, watching the slow rise and fall of his son’s chest through the gloom. The boy was alive yet. Balan marked each breath as sand through an hourglass, grains that drew the whole ever closer to its effect. Each rise of the lungs was another Belen had survived. Just one breath more, his father pleaded silently, just one more after that, and after that, and soon the night would be mastered.
He shuddered as the images rose again in his memory. It was a lucky placement, Estreth had said as she watched Nóm work, but Balan struggled to find any fortune in it. He had seen the ugly path it took through flesh and through viscera and felt his stomach turn again at the recollection. His tolerance was typically high and he assisted the healers at need, yet for his own son he found all his stoicism dissipate and he could only steal brief glances to know what passed while he held the boy’s shoulders pinned against the ground. And even those few left him dizzy as they loomed in memory: the soft pink of the organs, shining and naked in the sunlight, Nóm’s hands moving quickly about the wreckage, the deft fingers slipping through blood, Estreth passing a hot blade to stem the bleeding and Nóm shaking his head, stitching instead with strands of his own hair.
He lifted Belen’s hand from where it rested over the coverlet and pressed it to his forehead.
There was a rustle behind him and Balan felt the familiar brush of the Elf’s presence against his awareness. In the first weeks of their acquaintance, Balan had been easily startled when the other appeared beside him, the Elf’s movements indiscernible to his ears. So Finrod adopted the ritual of nudging the other’s mind as he neared to warn of his approach, and it had become a form of politeness between them. It was a gentle greeting, like fingertips brushing his arm, but it broke Balan’s reverie.
“I brought food,” Finrod said softly as he walked to join Balan beside the bed.
Balan shook his head. “I can’t eat.”
“Try a little. You’ve had naught since before midday and the night is half gone.” He crouched down beside Balan and held out a cup of broth in one hand and a chunk of bread in the other. “You may sit up all the night through sheer will, but sustenance will feed both will and body. You’ve had a shock,” he added gently, “but it is a fallacy to equate tending yourself with neglecting your son.”
Balan took the food reluctantly. Mostly he was unbothered when the other’s thought crossed into his, but now and then he found it deeply irritating to have his own perceptions articulated before he named them. Especially when they were those he had deliberately left unsaid.
“How do you do that?” Balan’s voice was a mix of curiosity and annoyance and he bit off a bite of bread with grudging acquiescence. “One moment it’s a simple enough exchange and the next you’re prodding about in my head. How do you break in there?”
“You allow me.” Finrod glanced at him with a sidelong smile as he moved to kneel beside the pallet. He shifted the blanket and inspected the poultice covering Belen’s wound. “Or at least you do not prevent me.”
“Can I?”
“Of course.” A look of chagrin creased his features. “I fear I’ve stumbled on yet another apology owed. I thought you knew it instinctually.”
“Perhaps I do,” Balan mused as he sipped from the broth. The flavor was unfamiliar and it occurred to him Nóm must have prepared it himself, a realization that began tempering his annoyance. “I’ve never tried.”
“No?” Finrod asked, setting a strip of clean linen over the poultice, then retrieving a vial from the pouch at his belt and soaking the linen through with the liquid it contained. It filled the hut with a bitter, herbal fragrance; sharp, but not unpleasant. “You may not have tried, but you’ve succeeded before now. You were quite angry, I think, when I questioned you on the origins of your people.”
“Yes,” the hint of a genuine grin spread over Balan’s face. “I was, rather. You were like a hunter’s hound who would not leave off the trail.”
“And you an intriguingly evasive creature. I tried to reach out then while we spoke and found not even a sliver of welcome.” He set a line of leaves over the linen and bound a second cloth over those. “You bristled like a porcupine when I came near at all.”
“Did I? I’d no notion of it.” Balan sipped the broth again and watched the other’s movements in apprehension. “How is it?” he asked as Finrod drew the coverlet back up to Belen’s chest.
“All appears as it should so far.” Finrod washed his hands in a basin beside the bed, then moved to sit beside Balan. “I have not tended one of your folk before, but from what I’ve seen, and from what Estreth has told me, I have every hope he’ll recover fully.”
Balan nodded and his eyes drifted back to his son’s face. He could still see the infant he held in the lines of those features and felt choked by his own helplessness in the face of Bel’s pain. He drank the last of the broth and set the cup aside. “This movement in and out of thoughts,” he said to distract himself, “if I can keep you from entering, does that mean I can look toward you as well?”
“All Mirröanwi—all incarnate creatures, I think you would say—can do so. The Eldar believe, as we were instructed, that all minds are equal in their standing, despite differences in how that aptitude or strength is manifested in each kind. But the capacity is there, regardless of surrounding constraints.”
“How?”
“It is like any natural process. Here,” he reached out and placed his hand against Balan’s cheek, “close your eyes and then set your hand over mine. Follow what happens within your mind as you do so.”
Balan hesitated for a moment, then let his eyes fall shut and raised his hand to rest tentatively over the Elf’s. He needed no injunction to note what passed within his thoughts and consequently sat in fear that the other might feel the pulse pounding through his skin.
“You did not need to look to place your hand. You knew where to meet my touch by instinct. By intuition, if you will. Now move your hand forward and follow my arm to my elbow.”
He did as instructed and let his fingers trace along the forearm, feeling the firm line of the radius beneath the fabric; a thin cloth, softer than any his people knew to weave, hardly a breath between the other’s skin and his. He focused to keep his breathing steady while attempting at once to observe whatever process of the mind he was meant to study.
“Good. You may open your eyes,” Finrod added with a smile and lowered his arm to rest once more across his lap. “The communication of thought is, in some sense, the same action. Your instinct directs you to the touch, your fëa—your spirit—knows to follow it as your fingers knew, sightless, how to mark the line of my arm without fumbling.” He pressed harder into the other’s thought than he would ordinarily. “Can you feel that touch? Or rather, do you see the image that I’ve set?”
“Yes,” Balan replied as the branches of a tall pear tree reared up through his perception with a surprising urgency. “I see a tree in flower with a low, white wall stretching behind it. The wind is blowing through its leaves.”
“That is placing your hand over mine. Now follow it back toward me, if you can.”
“How?”
“You have allowed me in already. And a door once opened, if there is willingness on each side, sets a path either may tread. Shift your focus and reach out with intent along that path. I will not bar the way.”
Balan concentrated on the gently moving branches. It was difficult to conceive of it as a path and not simply a foreign presence traipsing about his mind. Welcomed, yes, or at least not denied, but breaking in nonetheless. He focused once more and looked up into the other’s eyes, then reached out.
Finrod caught his breath. He thought he was familiar after these months of encountering each mind to glean their language, and yet having one reach out in return—having Balan reach out in return—sent an unexpected flood of sensations racing through his blood. There was an earthy rootededness in the brush of the other’s perception, a fumbling touch, at once rough and gentle. He had guessed through his own inspection that their hröar had a degree of prevalence, but this was something entirely different and beyond any framework he held in his own understanding. There was somehow a physicality even in encountering the other’s fëa and it took his breath away.
“Is this how it always is for you?” Balan’s voice was awed as he felt his way through the other’s thought. He could sense the restraint as well as the welcome and knew he was seeing only a small corner, a meticulously curated room laid out and fashioned for his viewing. But even that was overwhelming in its intimate vulnerability.
“It is,” Finrod replied, carefully holding his voice steady. “Openness is the natural state of any mind of the Mirröanwi, or rather it would be in an unmarred creation. Here, as we are, it is more often thus only between those who share affinity—kin, or those bonded in love and friendship.”
“This is uncanny,” Balan breathed as he looked about and Finrod felt again the fumbling touch within his mind. It reached the few memories he had selected and laid out, it passed through the curious fascination with these new creatures, his attempts to understand their ways, it grazed against the deep love he held for each of them, it paused.
Without warning, Finrod’s heart lodged in his throat. He had stopped breathing as Balan’s thought crossed the space of unique affection he occupied. A dear and fast friend, Finrod repeated to himself as he had each day, watching their companionship weave ever closer with dizzying speed, a brother unlooked for in the darkness. Yet even as he said it, he quietly closed off additional threads of his mind from the other’s view, unexpectedly timid in the face of inspection. Finrod was taken aback by this skittishness. It was he who had offered up these thoughts to the other’s gaze, after all. This was an entirely different experience, he reasoned, entrusting your mind to someone who was fundamentally other. The very presence itself left his equilibrium reeling. Balan must have seen the fear as well, because he made only a brief pause before turning to different aspects of the other’s thought, leaving that one in peace.
Another corridor opened, filled with knowledge Balan did not comprehend, yet laced throughout with the calm confidence of a task completed and understood, a conviction of danger eluded. Balan felt a firm pressure settle over his anxiety. It was the same sensation he had as a child when his father would kneel beside him after he woke from nightmares and wrap him tightly in a blanket, pinning him in a cocoon while the strong arms pressed him close against his father’s chest. Balan was soothed despite himself. So it was now as he felt Nóm’s quiet satisfaction with the tended wounds and the growing assurance of their efficacy. It wrapped about him like a blanket, pressed in upon him, quieted his dread. He allowed himself a long few minutes’ respite in that wash of calm, then returned to an earlier thread with a tracker’s zeal. He had crossed the remnants of a conversation with Orndaer in the other’s thought.
“You spoke with the other of your kind,” Balan said in a low voice, part question and part accusation. “Has he told you what happened?”
“Yes. Or at least I’ve learned more than we knew before, though I deem much will remain a mystery until your son wakes. He will wake, Balan,” Finrod added as the spasm of fear crossed the other’s face again.
Balan nodded and then turned his attention back toward the sleeping figure, taking his son’s hand once more in his own. But he did not, Finrod noticed with a small smile, retreat from the mingled thought, claiming without question his right to the openness due of love and friendship.
“Belen was stalking a deer,” Finrod continued gently, “and Orndaer came across him in a clearing. There have been more incursions of yrch, of goblins as you say, in recent months than his people have seen in many years. My own suspicion is that their trespass is bound to your arrival in these lands. If the Foe knew of your awakening, then the mountains would be watched so he would have forewarning if our kindreds should meet.”
“It was not a goblin arrow that felled my son.”
“No, it was Orndaer’s arrow and Orndaer’s hand that did so. He does not deny it.” Finrod was quiet before proceeding. “He mistook Belen for an orch when he saw him rise from the tree-shadow to cast his spear.”
“Nay, I do not understand it. I have seen goblins, Nóm, I have fought and killed them. Yet I am to believe that one with the keen eyes of your kindred mistook my boy for one of those tortured horrors?”
“He had bound a deer’s skull to his head, Balan. It covered his face. Yrch often wear the skulls of creatures when they venture out in sunlight for—“ he broke off as the other gave a choked cry. “Balan?”
Balan’s face was drawn with anguish, and he reached out to stroke the hair back from his son’s forehead. “The skull man…” he whispered hoarsely, “Oh Bel, my boy, fate’s amusements are cruel.”
Finrod felt the memories rush through Balan’s thought, mingled still with his own, of the painted cliffs and Belen’s childlike intrigue, Balan continually dropping behind the march to ensure his son did not fall too far back through his fascinated study. An image of Bel’s hand tracing over the rudimentary outlines, the soft flesh of his fingers contrasting with the sharp red paint and white skull that stood across the dark rock. Finrod knew Belen and his imagination well enough that the missing elements of the story formed quickly in his understanding and he swore under his breath. Tentatively he reached out to rest a hand between Balan’s shoulders in comfort.
The touch broke what remained of Balan’s restraint and he could no longer hold back his weeping. He bent double beside the pallet, pressing one hand to his face to stifle the choking sobs while the other clung still to his son’s. At first Finrod knelt motionless, his hand pressed to the other’s back in silent sympathy, then gradually he moved forward till his arm encircled Balan’s shoulders and drew him into an embrace. Balan turned his face in against the other’s shoulder and let himself be comforted like a child, his tears soaking through the tunic that still bore stains of his son’s blood. What was this new land, so full of hope only a few days past? What good had he done by leading them here?
The other’s hand moved gently over his back. There were no words this time, no whispered melody, no assurances or distractions. Nóm remained a still figure at Balan’s side, offering nothing but his presence in the face of the other’s pain, and was amazed to feel how swiftly the tempest calmed within his arms. He held him close as the sobs gave way to ragged gasps, which moved at length to an unsteady calm, an exhausted serenity lying muffled against his shoulder. He would have turned all the world on its head, he felt in that moment, to have his arms shield this frail, precious creature from any grief. Life and limb, he thought, soul and body to protect him. Was this what a father felt, Finrod wondered for a brief moment, were these Balan’s feelings toward the figure lying before them? He dismissed it immediately with a sudden distaste. There was something wrong in that concept, despite all the pieces lying as though they should align. It was in some way unthinkable.
“When he was born,” Balan’s voice drifted up, muted by the silken tunic, and broke the contemplation, “we dwelt on plains between the great forests. There were no trees for miles and I remember holding him with his tiny head cradled in my palms and telling him what forests were, and how one day I promised I would walk with him through their towering pillars and show him their majesty. I told him we would lie on the forest floor together and look up at the woven canopy, like lace over our heads.”
“And did you?” Finrod asked, his voice drifting softly through the other’s hair.
“Yes.” There was a smile in Balan’s voice as he answered. “We returned to the forests before a year had passed. I know not if it was my words that laid it in his heart from the beginning, but he has ever loved them, has ever wandered about them on our way.” His voice drifted to a whisper again. “How do I hold the bitterness that it led him here?”
There was no answer to this and Balan pulled away, moving to sit again beside the pallet and watching Bel’s face in the flickering light. Finrod shifted to sit beside him, quiet as before, and motionless as a carved image, save when he rose from time to time to check the poultice or to place a clean wrap over the wound. The stillness remained, and not a word passed between them as the night drew on, minutes stretching to an hour, and the hours stretching on as the candle guttered down toward its end.
“I will need to send word to my people, Balan,” Finrod said at last, as the weary dawn crept in upon their sleepless night. “Now that there has been conflict, I can no longer justify my prolonged silence. I am obligated now to send word to the High King, and to the other chieftains.”
Balan nodded, impassive. “What will that mean for my people?”
“I know not.” Finrod was quiet again. “It may mean little in the end, but it is more likely, I deem, to change much of the life you know. Some of my kin will be glad at the discovery of yours, many will be suspicious. To all you will be a curiosity.”
“You’ve accustomed us to that, at least,” Balan said with an attempted smile. “And what then, when the curiosity is satisfied?”
Finrod shook his head. “In this I have no foresight. But you find us in a time of war, and there are many jealous lords among us—myself not excluded. Allegiance of one kind or another will be asked, I have little doubt.”
“Then we will be sworn to you. And let us be so before your kin are upon us, that there may be no question of loyalty.”
“Be not rash in this,” Finrod felt the summer’s respite slipping through his fingers like sand, yet all the while something deep within him burst into fire at the thought of the other bound to him.
“Rash?” Balan smiled again and this time it reached his eyes as well. “We took you as a god when you first appeared and you forbade us that. Grant us the compromise of taking you as a king.”
“Balan—“
“I am yet chieftain of my folk,” he said and his voice grew uncharacteristically stern, “and I tell you I shall serve no lord else. If allegiance is required, then take us as your own or we will serve none of your kind.”
Finrod saw the resolve in the other’s eyes, felt it like steel across his thought. “So be it as you say.”
“Take then my oath in fealty, pledged to you as the head of my clan. Accept my loyalty and that of my people, bound in faithfulness and truth to you as our lord, to hold dear as you hold dear, to scorn what you disdain, to serve you in constancy all our days.” He slid the small knife from his belt and nicked his wrist with the point to draw a light flow of blood.
“Balan!” Finrod exclaimed, aghast, and grasped the knife hand’s wrist in his own to hold it away from its mate.
He looked up in surprise. “I only mark the oath, Nóm, it’s little harm.”
The expression of dismay eased, but did not retreat. Finrod took the bloodied wrist in his hand instead and set his fingers across the wound. “Then may healing mark its acceptance,” he said and Balan felt the bleeding taper, the skin adhere. When the fingers moved aside, the cut seemed a wound of several day’s healing. How often, Balan wondered as he stared down at his mended skin in fascination, would he unravel himself to watch the other knit him back together?
“May it be so,” he said and knew with a thrill that the utterance was irrevocable. Whatever might come, they were bound—his house and the Nómin—tied till the ending of all things.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya; S = Sindarin
- Glamhoth: [S] orcs, or the orc host
- Dagnir: [S] slayer, killer
- Orch/Yrch: [S] orc/orcs
- Váya: [Q] ocean, sea, ocean, (stormy) sea
- Ëassarië: [Q] pearl/sea stone (plus feminine name ending)
- Vatta is an invented term for “father”
- Madja is an invented term for “aunt (mother’s sister)”, loosely inspired by Germanic-Gothic
MISC NOTES
- Nómin: the name by which Bëor's people called the Ñoldor
4. Ye Shall Render Blood
In that moment he envied for the first time the mortality of Men. He coveted a death that came upon you softly, death that whispered and held out a hand and let you slip into his arms in sleep. Death that passed his fingers over your eyes and left a visage in peace. Balan’s death.
It's the Fen of Serech, more or less. An oath for an oath, blood for blood.
Read 4. Ye Shall Render Blood

455th YEAR OF THE SUN, WINTER
The Fen of Serech
He saw the blade pass through him, dark iron, stained darker with blood. His own blood.
He was falling.
The fen caught him, soft in its embrace, and the mud sucked at his wrists, his arms, as he flung them outward to break his collapse. It pulled him under. Finrod clawed at the matted weeds, dragging himself onto a solid patch and gasping for air as the battle reeled about him. Only shallow breaths, he learned quickly, the ribs were broken through and the wound in his side throbbed like fire.
He had been rash.
No, that was too generous. He had been a fool.
What madness was upon him to think in his urgency that he could outrun what had already been foreseen? He drove the host forward these past days in a frenzy of haste, focused only upon reaching Dorthonion before the fires left the approach impassable.
Angamaitë! Aikanáro!
Desperately his heart cried out to them still, though he knew full well they were gone now beyond his reach. He felt the gasp and flight of Angrod’s spirit as the host forded the Lithir more than a day past, then Aikanáro’s with a roar even as his own company was surrounded here in the wetlands.
Orodreth had been right. That was a bitter thought.
The host reached Tol Sirion as night fell, spent from the haste of their forced march. Finrod would have pressed on at once, but he could not deny their pressing need for rest, so instead he held back at the fortifications and set out at first light, taking but a quarter of the host to venture northward and determine whether the pass to Rivil’s Well could yet be forced. Orodreth argued fiercely against it. The hills had long since burned away, his father was dead, Aikanáro hemmed in between the ruins of Ladros and the fires of the highlands. “It is too late, uncle,” he had insisted. “Gorthaur led that assault and none could hold against him—the eastern side has been cut off for days. Better to relinquish the highlands than risk those who could instead hold the vale and stem this tide.”
“And Aikanáro? The remnants of Ladros?”
“What remnants? Dorthonion is naught but ash. Whatever corpses are left, you cannot reach them.”
And he had not. They were ambushed within miles of the pass and driven back into the fens, surrounded and outnumbered. They had held off the onslaught for hours without end, but by nightfall too many of his company were cut down and the line began to break. One by one they fell about him until only a handful remained. Gelmir alone endured of his guard and they had fought back to back as the sea of foes pressed an ever deeper wedge between their company and the remainder of the host.
A sudden onrush of smoke, noxious and fell, and Gelmir had stumbled from his side in the confusion. Finrod’s eyes burned in the haze and tears streamed down his face as his body tried to clear his sight. He could hear the battle all about him, but saw no further than the ends of his arms. “Gelmir!” he had cried into the choking mist. “Calano! Macildil!”
He heard their voices calling back, scattered and distant. Gelmir’s had been the least muted, he must yet be near. Finrod moved swiftly to his right, calling out for the other again as he tried to gauge his path.
The sense of danger had been immediate. He swung around, sword raised, but his speed was hindered by the shifting mud and a heavy mace crashed into his ribs. He felt them give way beneath the blow as he staggered to the side.
And that was when he saw the blade emerge from his own flesh and collapsed into the stagnant pool.
Face-down in the mud, he fumbled again for his sword in the water. His hand nicked against the blade, found the hilt. That was something, at least.
He grasped the weapon and thought of the deaths preceding him—his grandfather, alone barring the way against Darkness so the household could flee; his uncle, holding Balrogs at bay until his own fire consumed him at last; Arakáno, hurling himself headlong into the ambush to buy time for their lines to form. His own brothers, who had held the burning hills far longer than any thought possible.
And now he would perish here, a rat in a trap, choked in ankle deep water.
For blood ye shall render blood, and beyond Aman ye shall dwell in Death’s shadow. A fitting end, Finrod thought bitterly as he watched his own blood flow out, mingled in the icy streams of water. He was never a warrior. But that same sight kindled his pride anew and the valor of his people rose hot in his veins. It was blood of the house of Finwë. And he was not yet felled.
Stand. He clutched at the gaping wound with one hand and pushed up with the other. Fight. With all his will, he staggered a few steps forward, he cut down the Orc in his path.
A cry tore through the air only a short distance from him, muffled by the smoke, then there was a fumbling. A long scream of anguish.
“Gelmir!” He could not see him in the fray. He could see nothing but the burning fumes, the specter of movements within it. “Gelmir!” He shouted over the din, but the only reply was another Orc looming out from the haze before him, mace raised and laughing, blood upon his fingers. It was a brief fight. Finrod’s body moved without thought, the motions executed in reflex, and the Orc lay felled at his feet. He stumbled a few more steps, and then the earth reared up toward him and the water seemed to wrap itself about his vision like a cloak.
Too much blood, he thought fleetingly, and then felt his body crumple into the fetid reeds.
This was death, then.
Finrod drew in a ragged breath, choking on the reek. The rotting stench of the water. The metallic stench of blood. The dry, bitter stench of the burning hills beyond, carrying away his brothers within their smoke. In that moment he envied for the first time the mortality of Men. He coveted a death that came upon you softly, death that whispered and held out a hand and let you slip into his arms in sleep. Death that passed his fingers over your eyes and left a visage in peace. Balan’s death.
May peace ever lie down beside me
May you in wisdom’s arm’s find me
May valor not be denied me
And mercy’s temperance guide me
The memory of Balan’s voice rose vividly as though the song was new-sung beside him, rough and earthen and calming the tumult of his spirit, as ever it had. A death of peace may not be granted his kind, but he resolved that he would face his own as Balan had accepted his. In that, at least, death could meet them together. Finrod’s eyes settled on a trampled knot of sedges and he inched his arm over the ground till his fingers pulled loose a cluster of seeds. He drew these to his lips and set three upon his tongue, then his head dropped back into the mud and his gaze drifted up to rest on the thick clouds overhead.
There was something comforting in the knowledge that he and Aikanáro would enter Námo’s halls together. Arm in arm, pain alongside of pain, facing collectively what might daunt each alone. He was no longer afraid and a smile eased over his face even as the sounds of battle raged about him. He would rest at last.
Then he felt the Orc captain’s eye settle on him, he heard the laughter, the approaching step. The jangle of a chain. Eru, let it be death, let it be death.
A boot kicked his spine and another hot wave of blood oozed from his side. “Alive,” the voice growled from above him. “Put out his eyes and bind him with the others.” Nausea racked his body as he understood then what the earlier screams had signified and he fumbled uselessly for a weapon among the reeds.
And then through the darkness he heard it, sounding from the hills as though from his own delirious longing: the deep call of ox horns echoing over the marshes, the voices of Atani raised and shouting above the din, the war cry of the House of Bëor.
”Dweré ah sunda!” He heard the Taliska roar from his own throat as well. His hand found a knife lying where one of his guards had fallen and he grasped the hilt in renewed vigor, slicing through the sinews of the leg before him. The Orc fell with a shriek and he drove the blade into the skull, feeling the sickening crunch of bone as it passed through, the dizzying stab of kinship. He rolled to the side, reeling again from the lost blood, the earth rising and falling about him like the ocean’s waves. Another Orc fell beside him, run through with an Atani spear.
“Aran!”
It was Barahir’s voice.
“Aran nín!”
Barahir, who was the son of Bregor, who was the son of Boromir, who was the son of Boron, who was the son of Baran, who was the son of—“
“Nóm!” Barahir called him by name when he did not respond and caught him by the shoulders. “Do you hear me, Aran? Nóm!”
The affectionate name broke through the stupor and Finrod looked up to meet his eye. “Yonya…” he whispered and a cracked smile turned his lips. His son. What was blood in the end? In his soul he felt the sure knowledge—they were each of them his sons. Every scion of Balan, his own, beloved and beautiful. His children unbegotten.
“Nóm, keep your eyes on mine. Stay awake. Nóm, stay with me.”
“Yes,” he said. “I am with you.” And then the world fell away into darkness.
❈❈❈
Finrod woke beneath a pine. At first he stared up at the gaunt branches and thought himself on a journey with his father, wandering as they would for days on end through the forests of Valinórë. Something was not right in that, this tree was sickly, the needles sparse. And there was the murmur of voices about him, too many voices. Rough, mortal voices.
Of course, he was beside Thalos. There were pine thickets along the feet of the Ered Luin. He must have slept overlate if so many were moving about before him. Balan would tease him for it. He would tell him he was growing more Mannish by the day, that he would have a beard within the month if he was not careful. Finrod grinned as he thought up rejoinders and pushed up from the ground.
He fell back at once with a sharp gasp as burning pain shot through his side. The return of memory that followed was hardly less searing. All the world had changed since he last wandered with Arafinwë through the spruce groves of Aman. A century had gone since the earth turned Balan to soil and tree and flower—a hundred years to the day, he realized with a sinking grief, or at least it had been on the morning he set out from Tol Sirion.
The recollection of what had passed between that morning and this settled over him with another wave of anguish. It was well past dawn, he realized, despite the canopy of smoke and fumes. They must have carried him through the night, fighting their way free of the fens with his body a burden in their midst.
“Aran nín?” Barahir’s voice was gentle beside him and a hand reached out to rest on his shoulder. “Aran, can you drink?”
Finrod nodded and a water skin was placed against his lips. Barahir’s hand slipped under his head, tangling in the dried blood and grime, and lifted it, guiding him to the drink as tenderly as though he was a child.
“If you were one of us, I would give you something stronger to dull the pain,” Barahir said as he helped him to another drink and saw the sweat stand out on his forehead, “but I’ve no knowledge of how to tend your kind. Such would have slain us,” he gestured at the mangled side, “so I know not what might cause further harm or whether it would even be of help.”
“Give it to me,” Finrod said hoarsely with a nod of assurance, then took a deep draft from the flask Barahir held out to him. He hissed sharply as the liquor passed along his throat, parched from his hours in the burning fen, then took another mouthful and tried again to push himself up from the ground. “Nay, help me sit,” he said as the other tried to restrain him. “I need to see the world upright to still its whirling.”
“As you will.” Barahir glanced dubiously at the wound once again, then slid his arm under the king’s shoulders and helped shift him up by degrees until he could lean against the tree. “Have a care! You’ll set it flowing again.”
A muffled groan escaped Finrod’s lips and he gripped the flesh together as blood oozed once more through his fingers, his eyes closed against the pain. “You did warn me,” he mumbled as he leaned his head back against the bark.
“Your own folk are nearly here.” Barahir’s concern was palpable. “They will know what to do?”
“My folk?” This was hope unlooked for and his eyes opened, focusing on Barahir’s in a desperate plea. “Others survived, then?”
“Not from your company, lord,” he said gently and watched the despair crack lines across other’s features. “Forgive me. Any others were slain or taken ere we reached the battle. We found none but you—and even that was a bitter struggle. Their numbers were too great. We had not the strength to give chase.” He was quiet for a moment, allowing the king time to accept the news. “But the remainder of your host was driven back beyond the Rivil after you were sundered from them. I sent two men during the night to reach them and we have sighted their approach with a company of your people. They will be able to bear you back to Tol Sirion.”
“And thou?”
“We return to Dorthonion. Our number is small enough that we may yet find our way unhindered. We know many lesser trod paths through the hills to reach our aim.”
“That is a perilous path nonetheless. I caution thee now with the same counsel I scorned: the highlands have fallen. Go by thine hidden paths and gather what is left of thy people, then flee what is already lost. Bring them to Nargothrond, if thou wilt heed my advice. We’ve room and provision for many—for this very eventuality was it built. Or come at least to Minas Tirith where there are defenses to preserve thy folk.”
“Vandatar!” Barahir’s men had returned with the detachment from the Nargothrondrim host and they hastened across the clearing, Gildor sprinting ahead of them. He dropped to the ground beside Finrod and caught his hand in his own. “I thought thee dead until the messengers came.” His voice was held in strict composure now, but Finrod saw the dread lurking at the edges of his eyes, a lingering hint of the frightened child who cowered against him on the Helcaraxë.
“I live,” he said and returned the pressure to Gildor’s hand with a wan smile.
Two others knelt beside them and set to work inspecting the damage and tending what they could in the open woodland. Barahir’s men had gathered into a rough formation and stood ready at the edge of the meadow. They had tarried only on account of him, Finrod perceived, and now their eyes drifted impatiently toward the highlands. Would that the blade had ended him, he thought in uncharacteristic despondency, rather than leaving him lingering, a cause for further sacrifice. How many of Barahir’s folk had fallen cutting him out of that hell? How many of his own? He felt himself breaking apart as he thought upon it, shreds of himself feathering off like the ash drifting through the air about them. How many dead at Alqualondë? How many dead that he led upon the ice? How many? And those that endure shall grow wear of the world as with a great burden, and shall wane, and become as shadows of regret before the younger race. O Manwë, Varda, and all the holy, why had the blade not ended him?
“I take my leave, lord, now that I have seen you safely to your own people’s care.” Barahir bowed as he spoke, crossing hand and spear in the traditional salute. “May goodness keep you, aran nín, and mercy preserve you.”
“Wait.” Finrod shook free from his despair and called him back as he turned away. He drew a ring from his finger, holding it up toward Barahir in his open hand. “An oath once sworn to me in blood, returned in blood now to thee. Take this in token of my vow.” The twined serpents lay coiled upon his stained palm, their eyes shining up through the gloom. “Friendship thy people have ever had of me, but bound shalt thou have it now in troth. My aid is thine in every need, whether of thee or thy kin—if ever thou shalt call upon me, I shall answer.”
“Lord.” Barahir knelt beside him to take the ring from the outstretched hand and placed it upon his own, drenched yet with the other’s blood. “I hear thee in honor.”
“I but bind in word what has ever been true in heart.” He paused for air as his breathing caught in pain. “Thou goest now against my council, but nevertheless with the love that ever I have born for all thine house. My oath is thine, Barahir, shouldst thou ever find need of it. Do not forget it, and tarry not when the need is nigh. For truly I fear thy need shall be great.” Finrod reached out to grip the other’s arm. “My friend, go not forth. Death only awaits thee there.”
“Death is our lot, lord, meet us where it may.” Then Barahir’s voice faltered and he added in a softer tone, “And, lord, I have not yet found my son. Nor have I word of my wife since I left her fighting at his side. No shelter shall I seek from king or cavern till I know their fate.”
“Then go with my blessing as well.” Finrod released him and held up a hand in benediction. “And may the Valar guide thy feet and illumine the path of thy searching.” Then he paused, feeling once again the sinking certainty that this too would be a final parting, and his voice broke as he added in the Atani fashion, “May goodness keep thee, Barahir, Balanion, mellon nín, and mercy preserve thee.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin
- Aran: [S] king
- Aran nín: [S] my king
- Yonya: [Q] my son
- Vandatar: [Q] roughly “oath-father,” an approximation for “foster-father,” combining (oath, pledge, solemn promise) and atar (father).
- Balanion: [S] Balan’s son
- Dweré ah sunda is an invented phrase meaning “valor and truth”, loosely modeled after the Gothic language (Tolkien Estate publish the existing Taliska grammar and syntax challenge.)
5. A Shuddering in the Air
It was a custom done in scorn of death, Balan would tell Finrod later that night as they sat beside the fire in the hush of the midnight watch. He might come ever ravening among them, but they would scorn his maw. Even in their rotting they would lay claim to life.
Balan's people are on the road to Estolad. Finrod begins to suspect his own feelings, there is danger on the road, and we witness Atani burial rituals.
Read 5. A Shuddering in the Air

310th YEAR OF THE SUN, AUTUMN
The Woods of Ossiriand, Near the River Thalos
Balan woke again, restless. He had not slept a full night through since Belen was wounded, whether from the recurring dreams or by mere anxiety. It was becoming a consistent pattern, he noted with irritation. This was at least the fifth time tonight.
It was disorienting to wake under the open sky once again. They had been a migratory people as long as he could remember, but when they did set an encampment as they had at Thalos, they would remain for at least a year or more, often several.
It had all come apart so quickly.
Within a day of Belen’s injury, there had been messengers from Orndaer’s people, three grim envoys hovering like shadows at the edge of the encampment, watching every movement with sharp and wary eyes. They would speak to none but Nóm and hardly acknowledged the presence of any Atani who approached with him. Though in truth none would have spoken in return should they have been addressed. Only Balan and Belen had progressed far enough in the language to attempt dialectical differences, but Belen lay yet in a fitful slumber and Balan stood in stony silence before the kin of his son’s assailant, and his people set their mood by his.
In some ways it was like watching a stranger, Balan reflected as Nóm spoke with the emissaries at length. His entire demeanor had changed and there was an air of aloof command that he never adopted with the Atani. Balan found it deeply disorienting. There was a distance between them in those moments that pricked at his steadfast calm and he hovered behind the Elven king, sullen and quiet, nursing a simmering jealousy.
A faint light grew behind the mountains and Balan rose with a sigh. There was little point trying to sleep now that dawn had come. He wrapped the blanket about his shoulders and glanced at Belen, who lay curled in several spare rugs and was sleeping soundly beside him. It was a relief being freed from the compulsion to scrutinize his son’s breathing whenever he woke. The wound was healing with surprising speed, Estreth had informed him a few days prior, and Belen could even move about the encampment on his own for short stretches. Nóm had taken to watching him like a mother cat, which both amused and relieved the boy’s father, as it left him free to go about the caravan as needed without fear of anything befalling Belen in his absence. Balan was glad of the development as the herds had been nervous since the abrupt departure and his people needed to maintain a swift progress on their road. Wherever Nóm was leading them, it was imperative they reach it with time left to provision and shelter for the oncoming winter.
He shivered as he walked through the camp. Estreth’s portents or no, the frost was impending. He wrapped the blanket tighter about his shoulders and turned his steps toward the eastern side of the encampment where a figure sat outlined against the dim light, perched atop a boulder at the edge of the ravine.
It was Balan who reached out this time in greeting, a tentative touch, and he felt at once the warmth of welcome.
“Tis early yet for thee,” Finrod said in Quenya as the other neared. It was intoned as a statement, but Balan felt the question lift in his thought.
He shrugged as he looked up at the grey eyes smiling back at him. “Sleep is an fickle master,” he said with a wry grimace and turned his gaze back toward the mountains. “Or perhaps I am a restless vassal.” Balan glanced up at him with a quizzical expression. “Do you ever sleep?”
Finrod chuckled. “A few nights without will do little harm. Yes,” he added as Balan still eyed him dubiously, “I sleep.”
Balan walked around to the lower side of the boulder and hoisted himself up to sit beside the other. From that vantage he saw that Nóm held a thin branch in his hand, intricately carved all across its length, and was shaping it still with a small knife. Balan peered at the carvings in curiosity. “What is it?”
"Simpina.” Finrod blew over the surface to clear the shavings, then held it out to the other. “A flute. Rather crude, I’m afraid, but it was quick work.”
Balan took it in his hands and drew his fingers across the pattern. Even in their simplicity, the figures were compelling and precise, a line of hounds chasing merrily after a horseman who rounded the top, his raised horn tapering up to form the flute’s mouthpiece.
“I thought to give it to Belen—as a way to pass the time, confined as he is to the cart.” Finrod polished the knife against his cloak’s edge and Balan noticed with a shudder it was the same that had revealed the arrow’s path only a few weeks past.
“When did you do all of this?”
“Here, while the night passed. A task in hand keeps the senses alert.”
“You carved all this in a night? What,” he asked, glancing up at the moonless sky, “by feel?”
Finrod laughed. “You forget, my people lived long years with only the stars to guide us. Our eyes have no need of any illumination but theirs. Yours have known naught but the light of the sun,” he murmured softly, as though speaking to himself. He took the flute back in hand and turned the knife to refine the mouthpiece. “So of course, it is little wonder the night seems an impediment.”
“As does condescension.” Balan’s face was unreadable as he returned pointedly to Quenya.
“Condescension?” Finrod looked up in surprise and attended more closely to the other’s thought. “I purposed only to name as I found. But I see that angers thee as a presumed superiority, though I meant it not as such. What wouldst thou say instead?”
“I? I would tell thee we woke with the sun, and then the Darkness found us. We have been fleeing it ever since.” Balan glanced over at his companion and the sharpness eased into a boyish grin. “But sit easily, Nóm, I bristled only in jest.”
A laugh that sets your heart to dancing. Finrod recalled the other’s description of his wife’s laugh and thought the same could be said of Balan’s smile. It gathered a posy of lines at each corner of his eyes and lit the whole face with merriment. Joy rippled up from deep within him and the smile spread across to Finrod’s face as well. He huffed in mock offense and rapped the other’s head lightly with the flute.
Balan chuckled, then pulled his knees up onto the rock to wrap them within the blanket with a shiver. “Dawn it may be, but it’s no warmer yet.”
“Sit closer if the chill discomforts thee. Shared is twice the warmth.” Finrod moved his cloak aside as he spoke. Phrases from the Ice still sprang readily to his tongue, even after all these years. He lingered in silence as Balan moved nearer and rolled the flute about in his hands. “Balan, may I ask thee of it now without drawing ire?” He spoke still in Quenya, and his restless hands turned once more to refining the carved figures. “What was it that found you, there in the days ye will not recall?”
“Twas no lie when I told thee before I had little answer. Truly, Nóm, if I’d the knowledge, I would have given it thee.” He butted his shoulder lightly against the other’s in mild accusation. “I see I am believed now, at least.”
“I never disbelieved thee before.”
“Rot.” Balan relaxed into his own tongue once again. “You questioned me like an errant cub. Besides, if you’d believed me then, why return to it now?”
Finrod laughed. “Caught in a web of my own weaving. But truly, I thought only that I’d not earned your trust, not that you’d deliberately deceived me.” A gust of wind blew his hair down over his eyes and he tossed his head to clear it away. It fell again and Balan reached out, moving it aside and tucking it back behind his ear. It was a practical gesture, and one Finrod had seen him employ before with his sons, but the affection of it was intoxicating. The dancing smile again. Perhaps after all he had sat up too many nights; he was unaccountably dizzy.
Balan shifted his arm back under the blanket and returned the conversation to its main path. “I remember asking my father when I was a child—I was as curious as you—but we have few tales. And even those that we had, he was loth to tell me. What mattered, he said, was that we had chosen otherwise in these later days. ‘The path of penitence sets your wandering aright’.” He looked out at the growing dawn that sharpened the mountains to teeth against its light. “Whatever particularities are lost now, I tell you this at least: a darkness lies behind us, and we have turned our backs upon it, and we do not desire to return there even in thought. Westwards our hearts have been turned, and we believe that there we shall find Light.”
Finrod too looked out at the dawn and regret drifted into his voice. “Truly. Yet I fear that such Light is now further westwards than either your feet or mine may tread.”
An uneasy quiet settled over them and Balan found himself wondering at the change. He was unpracticed yet at interpreting the other’s thoughts, but he had felt the shift these past days. There was a tense wariness that had not been present before and a strand of apprehension wrapped about Balan’s own senses at that acknowledgment. “Do I want to know why you’ve been sitting up these past nights?” he asked at last, returning to the start of their words. “You didn’t do so before.”
“Orndaer’s words sit poorly with me. It bodes ill, I feel, that the Foe stirs again to venture his hand beyond our leaguer. Orndaer told me only of sorties, not any large force, but even a small raiding party when there are herds and children…” His voice trailed off.
“Yes, I’ve seen it.” Balan said quietly. “They’ve made for the herds and stores in the past. If we lose those, it is not merely the ones who fall by the sword. It means a starvation winter.”
“That you needn’t fear, at least. I would see you provisioned.”
“Nóm, we—“
“I accepted your oath, did I not? I’ll not have my people dead of cold or hunger, not if it is within my power to remedy.” He finished smoothing the flute’s mouthpiece and set the knife back in his belt, holding the instrument out to Balan. “There. Will it suffice?”
“Mm.” Balan traced the carvings again and chuckled. “You know he’ll be a right menace with this?”
“Good. A menace of joy to counter the menace of unease,” Finrod replied with an answering smile. “I will teach him to play it aright. It will do my heart good to have a merry task in hand.”
❈❈❈
“Gods all, Belen, if you play those same three notes again, you’ll find yourself killed yet—and by no stranger’s hand.”
Baran’s arms draped menacingly across the spear over his shoulders. The caravan had been underway for most of the morning and the last hour passed to the accompaniment of Belen’s fumbling piping, who grinned impishly at his brother from his perch in one of the baggage carts. He sat propped against various blankets and bedrolls and holding the offending instrument still poised against his lips. The remainder of the cart’s contents had been shifted onto the donkey who would otherwise have drawn it; while Váya, condescending to her master’s petition, allowed herself to be coupled to the modified harness and bore the cart’s burden instead.
“Change the pressure of your breath, Bel, and you gain notes.”
“Mm?”
“If you blow harder, the pitch will move higher and you will find more than the three.”
“Oh for everyone’s sake, Nóm, don’t tell him to make it any louder.”
Finrod laughed at Baran’s glance of helpless suffering and then winced as Belen forced a piercing screech from the pipe.
“No.” Baran stepped away from the line and shifted his spear down into his hand. “No more. Vatta, come along. I’m urged to kill something and it’s best for everyone if that’s provisions and not my brother.”
“Gladly.” Balan chuckled and turned to wink at his younger son. “Send for us when you’ve managed more of a bird and less of a stuck pig,” he said as he retrieved his spear from Belen’s cart and slung it over his shoulder by the strap.
“Mind any stray arrows,” Bel said glibly and Baran whooped with laughter as they broke off from the caravan.
“And you mind your flippancy.” Estreth shot an amused glance at her nephew.
“Laugh at fear and you spite his darts. Wasn’t that what you taught us?”
“Aye. Only you’ve you’ve taken it too literally to heart for my liking.”
Belen grinned and set the flute to his lips once more, letting out a long, shrill pitch.
“Gods of vengeance,” Estreth exclaimed with an accusatory glance at Finrod, “what possessed you?”
“I thought it would be a diversion,” Finrod said, trying to hold in the laughter as he grasped his hair in clumps between his fingers. “I’m paid in full for it.”
Belen leaned back with a laugh and held out the flute. “I surrender. I rely on both of you too entirely at the moment to dare risk a feud.”
Estreth snatched it from his hand before he could reconsider and moved back to walk ahead of the cart. “There, Váya, we’ll have some peace at last.” The mare snorted in response and nosed her arm affectionately. Estreth smiled and reached up to rest her hand alongside Váya’s head, her voice lowered to a murmur as she stroked her fingers over the silvery hair. “You’ve no business dragging him about like this, you know. You should never have let that one talk you ‘round to it. Lovely girl, you’re meant to soar unburdened, or with one alone upon your back.”
“Do you ride?” Finrod’s question was quiet, curious.
“I learned riding before I learned walking, Nóm,” Estreth said with a laugh, then her voice grew soft. ”My people kept horses—East, away over the mountains upon the rolling plains. When I was a child, Esrid and I would ride together upon our own mare. Chestnut brown she was, fleet in her pace, and watching the grass wheel away beneath us was as flight to the hawk.” She was silent for a long moment, then added, “Balan’s people keep no horses.”
Finrod knew the wistful mourning in her expression and looked upon her in compassion as they walked. “My mother’s people dwelt beside the sea,” he said after a time, his voice quiet. “As you upon the horse’s back, so my mother taught me to swim ere ever my father taught me use of my feet on land. It too was like unto flight. I remember hovering in the water, one arm grasped within my mother’s hands, the other held in my grandfather’s, and they drew me along between them on pinions soaring through the reflected sky.” His voice fell away for a long moment, then he added in a murmur, “I long for it still.”
“Do you no longer swim?”
“Nay, I swim,” he said with a laugh. “In rivers, streams, lakes…any bounded water. But the Sea will no longer have me. Not to ride upon her waves, not to perch upon the neck of a prow, not to know the flight of her waters. It is an ever present ache, that absence, is it not?”
“Yes.” Estreth did not meet his eye. “It is.”
“We shall reach the casári road ere nightfall, and from thence Sarn Athrad and the plains of East Beleriand. If you wished it,” he said after a long hesitation, “Váya would bear you over their rolling grasses.”
Estreth ran one hand along the dappled neck beside her, but made no reply. Rather, she turned her eyes back to the flute and studied the carved figures in greater detail. “It’s lovely for being such a thing of menace.” Her voice was quiet, but warned him back onto casual footing. “Is it a pattern only or something particular?”
“It is the Vala Oromë as he is shown in our traditions, riding with his hounds to the hunt. I think,” he added after a moment, glancing back to include Belen as well, “he may have been what you saw depicted among the mountain passes: leading the Great March of my own people across these lands.”
Belen shuddered. “I’m afraid I’ve rather gone off the fascination, Nóm. But tell on, I’d salvage it yet, if I may.”
“Valiant boy. What was it you said before, ‘laugh to spite fear’s darts’?”
“Aye, near enough.”
“Very well, then. If I can recall it, there was a rather crude song about the March that my cousin taught me when I was young.” Finrod looked back at Belen with a grin. “I’ll sing that, if you will, and see if we cannot bind amusement to those images rather than pain. Where’s your father hidden his harp?”
“Far side of the donkey,” Belen replied with an answering grin.
“And what passes for a rather crude song among your kind?” Estreth asked with amusement as Finrod ducked under Váya’s head and rummaged about among the donkey’s burdens.
“Well,” Finrod replied as he freed the instrument from the cords and began tuning it, “the March was delayed many centuries beyond the Valar’s plans from how often my people paused to beget new generations…” His words trailed off as he walked back to join them and his fingers lept across the strings with a mischievous smile. “So as crude as Eimet’s melodies, at any rate.” Then the clear, Elven voice rang out over the meadow, laughter and song woven together as he picked out the melody upon the harp, now strumming the strings, now drumming out a rhythm upon the wooden neck.
It was a simple song, relying more on play of words than any complex construction, and Finrod shifted it to Sindarin for Belen’s ease. By the second or third repetition, Belen had learned verses as well as chorus and they sang it out together, Estreth joining in for scattered lines and laughing at their merriment.
Then she broke off as the song began again and looked hard at the horizon. “Nóm, is that smoke over the tree line?”
Finrod fell silent and his eyes drifted toward the thickets to the northeast, discerning what Estreth’s sight could not: great birds rising and dipping again into the waving canopy. The lines of his face drew together intently.
“What is it?” Estreth asked, her voice low, an edge of wariness creeping into her tone as she saw his expression.
“Carrion fowl," Finrod replied in the same register. "There is a shuddering in the air, I like it not.”
Váya snorted and twitched as though a fly worried her, and Finrod laid a hand upon her shoulder, murmuring under his breath to settle her. She snorted again and then tossed her head in the air with an insistent nicker.
“Orqui.” Finrod turned swiftly to face the woods as the deep bellow of an ox horn reverberated from the eaves. “Goblins!”
“Baran’s horn!” Belen sat up swiftly and reached for his spear, then fell back with a sharp cry as the injury reasserted its mastery.
Hathus and a group of warriors were already sprinting toward the horn’s sounding while a larger group took up formations along the edges of the caravan. Finrod pulled his sword free from where it lay amidst the baggage. “You do not leave that cart,” he said sternly to Belen as he saw that Estreth was among those who had joined Hathus. “Not a foot outside of it, do you hear me?” Then he too was sprinting toward the woodland, his fëa reaching out frantically for any acknowledgment from Balan’s. Silence.
His feet moved ever faster over the greensward and he outpaced the others as he reached the forest, darting like a phantom beneath the trees with his hair streaming behind him, a trail of light. They could not be far now. He could hear the clash of weapons, he could scent the flow of blood. Balan! Place your hand over mine, Balan. Follow the line of my arm!
Finrod saw them then, spread out beneath the darkling trees. Thirty-five, he numbered swiftly, a small sortie just as Orndaer had recounted. Baran, Balan, and Eimet were scattered behind the nearer trees with several others, cut off each from the other in their flight back toward the meadow. The trail of bodies told of their path through the woods, battling for each tree, cutting their way to every step. Finrod’s heart fell as he recognized Atani bodies lying among the dead and a raw fury burned up from within him, white-hot, raging. He would end any who harmed these fírimar. He would tear them limb from limb.
“Anar caluva lyenna!” Finrod’s voice rang out through the timber and he flew headlong into the melee. The nearer Orcs wheeled about at his approach and drew into a new formation, shouting to each other as they shifted their attack. He was among them in an instant, the light of Aman spilling out with his fury, heedless of his own defense as he thought only to draw them away from Balan and the others.
”Dweré ah sunda!” Hathus and his warriors crashed through the trees, voices raised in their war cry, and did not halt until they had passed the beleaguered hunters. The company drew into a tight block, shields locked and spears bristling outwards, weaving Balan and his companions into the center to allow them a moment’s respite. Then they advanced together, every third step slammed against the ground with a shout. The Orcs turned once more and faced the new attack with ferocity.
“Nóm!” Balan saw the other still harrying the Orcs’ flank, biting into the side of their attack like a hawk—in, strike, down and about, sweep out of range before the return blow could land. “Nóm, pull back!”
Finrod’s wrath eased at the call of the other’s voice and he swung beneath the arc of his adversary’s blade. It nicked his cheek and he felt it cut through the flesh of his arm in the passage. But he was free of the rash ambush and he sprang back toward the shelter of the shield wall as a wave of short javelins rained out from the Atani line. The front column of Orcs faltered, re-formed.
“You rash devil!” Balan caught hold of Finrod’s tunic as he neared and pulled him roughly behind the hedge of shields. “What were you thinking?”
“I reached out for you and there was nothing.”
Balan looked up at him in surprise and caught a brief glimpse of unguarded thought. Fear, rage, an overwhelming rush of devotion that rushed helplessly to the brink. A bottomless, dizzying panic at the certainty of loss. The walls closed abruptly and Balan stood breathless, shaken. “I live,” he said hoarsely.
Finrod caught him by the shoulder, the fervor of his grip like steel, then turned to his place in the shield wall, Balan at his side.
❈❈❈
“Bring them out from the trees.” Finrod’s voice was weary. The Orcs had been outnumbered after the furor of Hathus’ advance, and many were felled in the surprise of that first rush. The remainder fought on beneath the trees, meeting fury with ferocity, valor with fortitude, and desperation withal. There was little joy in the victory, for it was hard won and seven of Balan’s warriors lay dead amid the bracken. But they had held the sortie to the woods and the caravan was spared.
“The yrch as well,” Finrod added to Hathus as he paused. “We burn the carcasses lest scavenging beasts sicken from their flesh.”
“You’re bleeding.” Balan joined him as Hathus departed and reached up to turn his face where he could survey the cut. It was already clotting and he turned his attention instead to the gash across Finrod’s arm. “This is deep,” he said and concern wove through his voice as he moved the torn sleeve aside. “Here, let me bind it.” He unwound the wide sash he wore about his waist, and cut a strip of cloth from its edge.
It was an unnecessary gesture. Finrod would wash and tend the wound when they returned to the camp, he would bind it after the manner of his people’s healers, and both knew it full well. But Balan stood beside him in the aftermath of battle and held still the sudden intimacy of thought, his heart pounding and within it the burning need to reach out, to meet him in some touch of tenderness. Instead he took the other’s arm within his hands and bound the flesh together, gently, wrapped about with his own torn vestments.
“There,” he said, struggling to find his voice as his fingers knotted the cloth. “That should keep your blood within you, at least.”
“Yes,” Finrod replied, and his voice was as gentle as Balan’s touch. “It should. Thank you.”
The Atani finished carrying the last of their fallen from the forest and had turned now to disposing of the remaining corpses. The disdain was clear upon their faces as they took hold of the legs and dragged them away, grasping with as little touch as possible.
Finrod watched them for a time in silence, then his eyes drifted over the remaining corpses.“Ámen apsenë nahtaremmar,” he murmured under his breath, “sív’ emmë apsenet tien i nahtarir emmen.”
“What was that you said?” Balan looked up at him curiously, the words too quiet for him to hear.
“A benediction, of a kind.” Finrod’s voice was strained. They watched together as Hathus and the warriors continued the process, dragging each out toward the eaves and the growing pile.
“What are they, Nóm?” Balan asked at last, his eyes passing over them in disquiet, the bodies looking vulnerable and exposed now that life had left them. “Do your people know?”
Finrod hesitated a long moment before answering. “I told you once of those who were taken by the Foe’s servants, in the early days of my people’s awakening.”
“You did,” Balan replied and felt a growing dread in the pit of his stomach.
“We know not with certainty from whence the orqui came, for by the time we encountered them, the Valar were not beside us to answer. But we can reason from knowledge already received, and from our own órë—I know not how to render it in your tongue. It is…the heart’s knowledge or conscience, the hand of Eru that guides the fëa.” He bent down to close the staring eyes before him and set the arms at rest upon the corpse. “There is kinship there that cannot be denied. They multiply as we do. They eat, sleep, and drink as we do. They die as we do.”
“They rape, pillage, and slaughter,” Balan added in a low voice, a ripple of fury.
“And they rape, pillage, and slaughter.” Finrod lingered a moment beside the body, then rose slowly. “Did you know they sing as well? When I first found you and heard your voices rising through the woodland, I feared it was a raid of their kind, slipped south past the defenses in the North. Then I saw you and learned better, of course. But they sing, Balan—and they sing as we do.” He was silent as he remembered his own voice lifted with Belen’s not even an hour past. It had shaken him deeply the first time he heard Orcs singing in the distance on the plains of Ard Galen. It was the first moment he had faced head-on the creeping horror of what that kinship entailed. He continued with an effort. “There are many philosophies among my people as to their origins. Some say they are naught but slime, creatures of mud and filth. It is easier, you see, to cut them down without scruple when you believe them naught but clay animated by some fell will; the Melkorohíni existing solely in opposition to the Eruhíni. Others believe that cannot be so, for were they such they would move of one will, in and of one purpose, propelled only by the thought of their maker. And yet we see for ourselves there is often strife among them, which could not be if they were but puppets of the Foe’s mind. Thus it is posited that they are rather those unhappy ones who fell into his hands ere we were led out from Cuiviénen, twisted or corrupted, tormented into enslavement and fear until their wills knew naught but his, their souls no hope but mastery.”
“And which do you believe, Nóm? Though I guess it already.”
“I? Neither and both,” he said with a wan smile. “Though if you pressed me I would say the latter. Yet there is a fracturing, a disjointedness that seems to dwell between their wills and their bodies that perplexes me. It is said that Gorthaur has at times imprisoned spirits within the bodies of fell beasts, and I confess I wonder whether some variant of that evil necromancy might not be at play. But I know not, Balan, it is all conjecture. What I see with my eyes is that they are twisted and evil. What I hear in my heart is kinship. Nay, that I see with my eyes as well. Look upon them,” he said softly, kneeling once again beside the body and turning the face toward them, “they heal from great hurt even as my own people, only with different tending.” The Orc’s face was missing the left side of his nose and scarred all across with deep gouges that had been left open to bind back as they might. Finrod studied this visage for a time, then turned the corpse to face away from them, hiding the face once more against the arm. “Most often I hate them, for I have seen the works of their hands and the foul deeds of their darkened wills. But ever and anon I find there is yet pity in me, and where that is, I must hearken to it. Else I too should begin yielding my soul to that same darkness. Mandos grant them release—and healing.”
“And grant my people vengeance,” Balan said quietly, then turned away.
❈❈❈
“You and I are over here, Nóm.” Estreth summoned him with a shake of her head as he had begun making his way toward the gathered crowd. The bodies of the fallen had been laid out upon the clean grass, washed and tended by the others and shrouded with thin blankets. “Only those within the clan take part.”
“Are you not?” he asked in surprise as he joined her.
“No. I would not be broken from my kin. Balan offered to scorn custom and take the blood bond without a renunciation, but I wouldn’t have it. I would sooner rely upon charity than belong to any but my own folk.” Her eyes followed Balan’s people as they ordered the bodies upon the grass. Each was now surrounded by an outline of gathered wildflowers: yellow, white, and pale blue. “It is a small stubbornness now, but one I cling to. For in all other ways I am more of their folk now than of my own. Still, I hold what ties I may.”
Finrod opened his mouth to reply, but a hush had fallen over the gathered company as Balan stepped out from their number. He had traded his usual overtunic for one of rich, dark red, embroidered across its length with an elaborate pattern of vines and beasts and blossoms. The intricacy and tone stood out against the dried bracken and he made a striking figure as he walked forward to stand before the fallen. He bore a spear laid flat across both palms, tipped with ceremonial gold and carved about the shaft with images of his people’s long wandering. This he held in stillness until all the throng had fallen silent, then he grasped it in his right hand and swung it upwards in a twisting arc, bringing the base down to strike against the earth. As the wood met the ground, Balan let out a great cry and Finrod’s breath caught in his throat at the sound. It was part wail, part lingering, one-noted song and it cut through the air as a blade of sorrow, before tapering again into silence. A hush. Then Finrod heard the intake of breath about him and his heart broke ahead of the coming sound; all the gathered people answered in kind, a deep, resonant keen echoing through the hollows until it too receded into stillness.
Balan stepped forward and knelt beside the first in the shrouded line, Thurbrand, a venerable warrior who had carried a spear since Balan’s childhood, and he folded the cloth back across the chest. He touched three fingers to each temple, to the valley between the eyes, to the chin. “Honor be upon you, my father,” he said softly, his voice intoning the practiced calm of a benediction. “Valor rest within you, my brother. Peace take you within her arms, my son.”
Baran knelt in the grass above the warrior’s head, his hands extended to hold a clay bowl, intricately painted and partitioned into three shallow sections, cupped within his palms. Balan reached out as he finished the invocation and took a seed from each segment. Gently, he opened Thurbrand’s mouth and set the seeds upon the tongue, closing the lips once again.
“From earth and from water were we ordered, from earth and from water were we formed. Return now to the soil that shaped us and from it grow again in life anew: grain for our sustenance, fruit for our delight, the oak tree tall for our shelter.” His hand rested for a long moment over Thurbrand’s face, then he stepped back a few paces from the prostrate form and knelt to one knee, his palms laid flat upon the ground and his head bowed. After a pause, he rose once more and moved to the next body, repeating the ritual again. “Honor be upon you, my mother. Valor rest within you, my sister. Peace take you within her arms, my daughter.”
It was a custom done in scorn of death, Balan would tell Finrod later that night as they sat beside the fire in the hush of the midnight watch. He might come ever ravening among them, but they would scorn his maw. Even in their rotting they would lay claim to life.
Balan moved down the line, until all seven had been tended. Then he stepped backwards, never turning his back to the line of bodies, until he stood foremost in the waiting line of warriors. Baran had moved now to stand at his side, and Finrod noted with a start that even Belen stood among them, leaning heavily upon his spear while his face was drawn with pain and determination.
Then they sang. Not even Makalaurë’s voice echoing through the darkened halls of Tirion had rent Finrod’s heart with the piercing ache of this lament, rough-sung and cried out in abandon. It began quietly, first with Balan’s voice alone, but soon it spread throughout the whole kindred, shifting in waves as the music passed from tongue to tongue. A rolling chant, the words layered each over the other, until the voices lifted once more in the long, wailing cry, while over them the line of warriors chanted in unison,
Death the destroyer, Death the slayer.
Death the coward, Death the betrayer.
Dead the makers, dead the life-givers.
Dead the valiant, dead the troth-keepers.
Living the memory, living the honor.
Living we hold you, deathless we make you.
And it was then Finrod realized he was weeping.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin
Simpina: [Q] flute, pipe
Orqui: [Q] orcs, plural
Anar calve lyenna: [Q] the sun shine upon you
Ámen apsenë (phrase): [Q] roughly: “forgive us our slaying as we forgive those who slay us” Cobbled together from this.
orë: [Q] heart (inner mind); warning, caution, (pre)monition, heart (inner mind), *conscience; warning, caution, (pre)monition
Melkorohíni: [Q] children of Melkor
Eruhíni: [Q] children of Eru
Fírimar: [Q] mortals, ones apt to die
- Vatta is an invented term for “father”
- Dweré ah sunda is an invented phrase meaning “valor and truth”, loosely modeled after the Gothic language
6. Here in Our Frailty
“Let us not perish here in the long darkness,” Balan said softly, crossing back to take one of the waiting wreaths and set it upon his own brow, “these creatures you chose to form. Remember us, here in our frailty.”
It is Yuletide. The Atani and Finrod celebrate throughout the night as they stay awake to greet the dawn after the Longest Night. Balan's people settle into Estolad, Atani traditions abound, and Finrod faces some memories.
Read 6. Here in Our Frailty

310th YEAR OF THE SUN, YULETIDE
Estolad
Estreth pulled another handful of meadow garlic from the cluster hanging beside her. It was always best to use one more than you thought you needed, especially when they had been hanging all this while. She set the handful with the rest upon the table and began to mince it.
It was lucky the winter had been mild so far. They made quick progress along the road and had reached the new encampment before the first frosts struck. But it needed swift work nonetheless to raise a village from the ground with time enough to prepare for the long, barren months ahead. Nóm’s people had been of help, of course. More help, Estreth could grudgingly admit alone here with the stores, than her expectations allowed. It was little time at all before they erected a low palisade around the perimeter—likely unnecessary, Nóm reassured her as they worked, but more convenient to have than to find wanting. And soon the huts too rose from the meadows; simple, one-roomed structures made of woven hazel branches and daub. Nóm’s people had been both repulsed and fascinated by that process; eying the paste of manure and mud with aversion, but admitting respect for the quick use of the materials to hand.
It had been strange to meet more of his kind. Estreth found them as disconcerting as she found Nóm in the early days of their acquaintance. His company, she noted with a wry twitch of her lips, was much improved by the comparison. Their demeanor held the same curiosity as his, but they remained aloof and distant, cautious observers rather than his ardent engagement. She had been relieved at their departure, though she hid that from Balan and his sons, who would gladly have urged them stay to on through the winter. Nóm alone had remained, which returned a semblance of normalcy to their days. He, at least, was becoming a known variable.
Estreth gathered the cut greens into a bowl with those already prepared and carried them out into the twilight. It was cold. No snow had yet fallen, but the ground and various tributaries of Celon had frozen over and the clouds were heavy. It would not be long now—Yuletide had come and the solstice was upon them. But they were provisioned well, far better than she feared when they left Thalos with such short warning. They had managed to carry much upon the road, and greater yet had been brought since by the Nómin. It would be a more plentiful winter than many these several years gone.
“Haelis, Estreth!” Nóm walked toward her from the edge of the village, a large basket under his arm. Estreth spoke his tongue as well as most others of Balan’s clan, but she still held firmly to Taliska—another of her small stubbornnesses. He greeted her ever in kind.
“Haelis, Nóm,” she replied, then glanced at his burden with a quick chuckle. “What has Balan set you to now?”
“Leaf seeking,” he said smiling. “Berry harvesting. Gathering Yavanna’s bounty to the halls of your dwelling.” He laughed at her look of skepticism and shifted the basket where she could see the contents. “He told me to fill this with holly sprigs.”
“That’s a fair harvest,” she glanced approvingly at the collected greenery.
“It is. It felt a pity to cut them, but the boughs are well laden still and should suffer no harm from the pruning.” He stood aside as Estreth entered Balan’s hut then followed after, ducking beneath the frame. Like all the quickly constructed village, it was a small structure; a single room serving every function, with bedrolls set along the edges, rope and board shelves lining the walls, and a circle of stones at the center to serve as a hearth. Baran sat on a bench beside this, twisting holly leaves into a circlet while Balan arranged various ingredients alongside a board on the earthen floor.
“Here.” Estreth set the bowl on a bench beside the doorway. “This should be the last of what you need for it.”
“Aye,” Balan glanced up with a smile. “Thank you. Ah, Nóm, you’re back as well. Take those over to Baran, would you?”
“Better yet,” Baran placed the finished circlet on his head as Finrod set the basket of holly beside him, “could you weave these instead? These two are not yet finished and I’ve promised Eimet to help build the night’s fires.”
“Just these two?”
“Aye. One for vatta and one for you, if you’ll wear it. I’ve done the rest.”
“Certainly.” Finrod took Baran’s place on the bench and reached into the basket of holly. “Are these a tradition of yours?”
“No tales,” Baran said sternly as he paused in the door, grinning back at them. “No lore. Once the two of you begin down that path there’s no telling how long it would be before he’s finished preparing the meat.”
“Insolent pup,” Balan chuckled at him, rising and moving toward the door. “Hand in the boar, then, if you’re so impatient.”
“Impatient?” Baran lifted a large pot from where it sat, preserved in the cold outside the door and passed it to his father. “I’m ravenous.” Then he followed Estreth back out to the village, the sound of merry songs drifting in behind them as he closed the door.
Balan returned to the fire once more and set the pot beside him. He removed a section of boar’s meat from the icy water and dried it with a cloth, then laid it out on the flat board before him and scored it with his knife.
“What do you call it?” Balan asked, nodding toward the holly in Finrod’s hands.
“Ereg,” he answered as he finished binding a sprig. Then he leaned forward and tucked another into Balan’s hair, securing it behind his ear. “Ercassë,” he added with a quick smile. The greenery stood out against the other’s hair, gleaming in the light of the fire, and the scarlet berries shone against the warmth of his skin.
“Ercassë,” Balan repeated. He finished mashing the herbs and salt into a thick paste, which he began spreading over the scored meat.
“What does it mean?” Finrod asked as he returned to his own task. “It has some significance to your people, I presume, given all of this.”
“Mm. Simply put, it does not die, nor does it lose its color through the cold of winter. So we bind it about when night is at its longest and hope scarcest. Defiance again, you see,” he said with a wink as he pulled a second slab of meat from the water and dried it. “I think you’ll find it the unifying thread in all our traditions. In this case we’ve an old tale as well,” he added, setting the meat beside the other upon the board, scoring it, and rubbing the remaining paste across its surface, “though I doubt it would interest you.”
Finrod glanced up in amusement and saw the mirth in Balan’s eyes. “You tease me,” he said, raising the circlet he was weaving to inspect it in the light.
“Aye.” Balan chuckled as he reached out for his cup and took a draft of ale. “Never have I met a pair of ears more eager for tales—and Belen is one of my sons.”
“And Baran your other. Shall we risk his censure?” Finrod asked with a sidelong smile as Balan retrieved the bowl of chopped meadow garlic Estreth left on the far bench.
Balan grinned and laid the bowl beside the other ingredients, setting a handful atop each cut of meat. “Aithan-hropit is its name in our tongue,” he said, indicating the holly in Finrod’s hand, “mother’s-cry. In the lore my own mother taught me, it’s said we suffered much in our early wanderings from prowling creatures who came among us in the dark of night to take or to kill. It became so dire that nearly every night there was a loss until, as one day drew to a close, a woman of our people fell upon the ground, wailing as the sun faded in the sky.”
He paused as he finished wrapping the prepared meat within cabbage leaves and tied them tightly with long grasses. Then he pulled handfuls of clay from the basket beside him and began working it down into a thick sheet upon the board. “As the tale goes, she had lost all children but one to these attacks, and that one remaining was an infant of less than a year. Night was drawing on. So she clutched the child to her breast and wailed out a desperate plea to the gods, reminding them that we had life but from their breath, and that by such breath they laid a promise within us—else they had created but to abandon and made life but for to watch its ravaging.”
Balan set the wrapped meat each upon its own section of clay and began folding it up around the parcels, pressing it together to cover the leaves. “Many were afraid at the boldness of her plea,” he continued, “and tried in vain to silence her, fearing that it would only bring further retribution upon our people. Yet seven times she cried out and at the seventh cry the sun dipped below the horizon. Night was upon them. But a single beam of light shone out through the clouds ere the sun departed and it fell upon a grove of holly, rimmed about the hilltop before them. It was the gods’ answer, the woman asserted in conviction unwavering, and she would not rest until her feet reached the grove. Seven days our people camped within the thicket and no evil dared venture through their boughs, nor for all the nights they remained in that place. And so it is said that for long years after we carried boughs of aithan-hropit as talismans upon our journeys to ward off those evils that dogged our early steps.”
Finrod had finished his weaving while listening to the other’s tale and two holly crowns sat beside him on the bench. He watched with fascination as Balan rubbed the last seams from the clay and sealed the meat within it.
“Now we mostly hang it only in remembrance during the Longest Night,” Balan continued as he rose to wash his hands in a basin and tapped his fingers to the greenery strung about the door frame. “And by that I mean we not only recall it in ourselves, but we hold it a remembrance for the gods as well, the bold plea of aithan-hropit, calling forth their own promise set with the breath of life. Let us not perish here in the long darkness,” he said softly, crossing back to take one of the waiting wreaths and set it upon his own brow, “these creatures you chose to form. Remember us, here in our frailty.”
He fell silent, then lifted the second wreath in his hand and held it out toward the other, a note of question in his gaze. Finrod held his eye for a long moment, then reached out and took the twined leaves from his outstretched palm. After all, he reasoned, was that not his own plea at every rising of the sun, every setting of the moon? “Remember us, here in our frailty,” he repeated, and set the aithan-hropit upon his brow.
Baran’s head dipped in through the doorway. “Vatta, nearly done? The fires are lit.”
“Aye.” Balan nodded down at the prepared slabs of meat, looking rather like bizarre, giant eggs upon the board. “They’re ready. And,” he added as his son retrieved the board and lifted it his arms, “we’ve managed the tale of aithan-hropit while we were about it—and do note, if you please, that the preparations are none the later for its telling.”
“Incurable, the both of you.” Baran shook his head with a laugh and carried the board out through the doorway, his father and Finrod following behind.
A line of fires ran down the center of the village, casting a warm luster over the huts and faces, and the sound of laughter rippled through the air. Hathus stood with a cluster of children about him and they watched in awe as he held two sturdy sticks in his hands, which he used to send a larger branch spinning through the air. The twirling branch was wrapped about with strips of cloth and ribbon and these billowed through the air as he tossed it whirling through the firelight and the children laughed in delight.
“Oy!” Baran exclaimed as Belen ran past, a carved mask over his face and chased closely by two friends bearing green boughs. “Mind your steps! You’ll have this over.”
“Skadus anek sá!” Belen shouted back over his shoulder with a laugh and ducked beneath the swing of a branch as he changed directions abruptly and leapt over the nearest fire.
“He’ll damage that wound yet if he’s not careful,” Balan muttered.
“Let him celebrate,” Estreth said with a chuckle as they joined her beside the fire. “It’s been knit together long enough now there’s little danger of that.”
“Little danger is still some danger.” Balan knelt beside his son as Baran set the board beside the fire. They lifted the clay-wrapped meat and set each within shallow holes dug at the edge of the fire, raking the soil and ash back over with their hands. “I wish he’d stay still.”
“He won’t mend if you keep him caged up in a hut either,” Baran retorted, lifting a spade and shifting the coals to cover the buried meat.
Balan snorted in response and cast a wary glance toward where Belen and his friends chased each other across the green.
“Nay, Balan, a little running puts him in no peril.” Finrod smiled as he shifted closer to the fire. “If Estreth has no concern, then neither have I. Allow that his spirit needs healing as well as his flesh.”
Balan rose and his features softened as he watched the activity about them. “It is good to see him joyful again,” he admitted grudgingly.
“So my words reach your ears when his tongue delivers them?” Estreth sipped from the cup of warm mead in her hand and looked at Balan under her brows.
“I heard them when you spoke,” Balan protested. “You’ll allow it needs several voices to still a father’s vigilance.” He leaned over the cauldron and ladled mead into two waiting cups.
“Yours, at least,” she laughed. “But he’s not a boy any longer, Balan. Let him err and learn for himself.”
“Nonsense.” Balan held out one cup to Finrod, then shrugged the fur-lined tunic further over his shoulders and sipped from his own. “He’s a babe in arms yet.”
“Aye. And you’ve not a grey hair to your head.”
Balan gave her a sidelong grin, then took another draft of his mead as he watched Belen through the glow. Preparations were already being laid for the feast to come and he saw the plate and chalice set at the head of the fires, garnished round with sprigs of aithan-hropit and left empty in remembrance of the dead. What a knife’s edge, he thought with the cold grip once more upon his gut, what a knife’s edge he had danced between watching his son dart through the firelight and marking him alongside all the others held in that empty seat. Esrid, Alémi, his father and mother…He shivered as Belen’s chase moved into the shadows and his eyes drifted instead to rest on Nóm, his profile sharp against the flames.
Finrod turned as the gaze reached him, sight itself a touch, and the warmth of his smile coursed through Balan’s veins like wine. He held out his musings of his son, offering them specifically, even though their thoughts now were ever twined. But Nóm had been more reserved since teaching him the technique. He realized then how often he trespassed in their early friendship and adopted in contrition a penitent politeness, holding ever a light touch of bond, but never drawing from that openness without invitation. The thought passed over into the mingled space and with it Balan pressed the ache of gratitude, and felt the smile grow upon his own lips in return.
More had joined the game now and children and adults alike darted in and out of the firelight, some masked, some barefaced, and shrieks of laughter filled the air. “What are the rules of it?” Finrod asked, nodding toward the chasing figures, then jumped back, smiling as a group of children nearly collided with him. “Merry chaos! Are there any?”
Balan laughed. “Few. The goal is to catch the masked creatures—the shadows of night. Their goal, in turn, is to subdue any of the maskless before that happens, which they do by stealing the aithan-hropit.” He reached up and tapped the woven crown about his brow. “If your holly is taken, you’ve till the count of twenty to catch the creature who stole it, or you’re counted dead.”
“And to catch the creatures?”
Balan bent down and lifted a thin evergreen branch from the pile beside him, tossing it to Finrod with a grin. “Knock them with a bough. Any contact will do. They’ve the same count from then to double back upon you, so it’s all agility and speed from there.”
“Alassëa sámalórië…” Finrod laughed quietly and shifted the stick in his hand to find a grip. Pine-scent filled his nostrils as the sap clung to his fingers; a wholesome fragrance, sharp and clean.
“Skadus anek sá!” Belen sprinted between them, his face shrouded by the bear’s visage he wore, and he snatched at Finrod’s circlet as he passed. He caught a handful of leaves, but Finrod ducked and clapped a hand over the crown before it could be taken.
“Ai!” He took off sprinting after the boy. “Brazen cub!”
Belen shouted in mirth and leapt over the low fire before them, Finrod following close at his heels. They wove through the crowd and about the scattered huts and he laughed as Belen evaded the path of the branch whenever he neared. The boy was surprisingly agile, Finrod noted, or perhaps it was that he himself dared not commit fully to the chase lest he push Belen beyond the limits of his healing. They rounded back into the light and Finrod darted forward, seeing his chance as the other slowed to avoid a pair of children. “Nahtan steiha!” he called in imitation of the others about him and swung the soft end of the branch in an arc toward Belen’s back.
The specter of a wolf loomed up from the shadows and Balan, masked, snatched the holly from the Elf’s head with a shout of triumph before the blow could land. “Skadus anek sá!” His voice flew back over his shoulder and he sprinted hard for the dark behind the village huts. Finrod flew after him in pursuit, caught up in their wild levity, and joy filled his heart near to bursting as he and the Atani ran laughing beneath the stars.
❈❈❈
“May goodness dwell in your household,” Balan’s voice echoed over the gathered kindred.
“And health be the drink at your lips.” The response rippled back as the voices gathered together, tapered down into quiet.
Carts had been hauled out and overturned as improvised tables, stools and casks dragged from the huts to provide seating for some while others made shift upon the trodden ground. Each family’s parcels of clay-baked boar were dug out from the cinders and the clustered groups ate merrily while they took turns rising to call out toasts, one to the other.
Finrod was captivated by the form these took. They reminded him of the naming ceremonies of his own people, of seeing a new vision of oneself rising to life through another’s eyes, being named into that which they saw you embody.
“Leader truly in spirit, as chieftain you shall be in blood.” Balan began the ritual, raising a carved cup of ale and speaking in blessing over his eldest son. “Courage as the heart of a bear. Warrior and minder. Kind as you are valiant, son of my wandering. Sama’nd sá.”
“Sama’nd sá,” Baran responded, echoing and receiving the benediction, then rising in turn to bestow his own, naming his brother gentleness and wise-heart, curious, beautiful and bold.
Finrod was strangely moved to hear them speak this way. He was transfixed as the hours drew on, drawn in by these half-familiar rituals, but set at once outside them by that same difference. Each knew their place in the dance while he sat alongside, quiet and watchful, gauging his motions ever by those about him.
This sensation bore him away from the warm firelight, till he stood in memory within the palace at Alqualondë, looking about at a flurry of activity. He was a child, not even the full height of his father’s leg, curious and small and shy in the face of such bustle. Lamps were strewn in clusters as far as he could see, intricately carved shells throwing light over the stone in myriad patterns. He could smell salt in the air as the sea wind drifted through the open halls, tousling his hair and brushing softly along his cheek, and he closed his eyes, comforted by the caress. ”Uinen’s greeting,” his mother would say whenever she saw the flaxen waves lift in the breeze, and would kneel beside him, setting her palm against his cheek, her smile warm as the sea air. “You see? She cherishes my boy as I do, winicë.”
Then a further memory—the same lamps, warm and fluttering, the same sea breeze ruffling his hair, grazing his skin. Only now he was grown, a prince tall and proud, and his steps carried him through the halls with hardly a trace of that timidity of his youth. He paused at a threshold off the main hall as he saw his father and grandfather wrapped in close conversation.
“…and they grow restless, Arafinwë,” his grandfather was saying. “Thou hast no wish to see it, I know. But we know it even here, more markedly perhaps than do thine own folk who have accustomed themselves by degrees, while we are met with the fresh shock of it at every encounter. There is danger in this disquiet.”
“I am not blind to it, atta.”
“Art thou not? My daughter has told me more yet of what she heard rumored in Tirion.” Olwë watched his son-in-law attentively and both were so engrossed in their converse that neither had noted Finrod’s arrival. “Of the hildor.”
“The Aftercomers.”
“Is this a true whisper or but the further spite of thy kin?”
“I know not. It must be true, I deem, at least in part, for the Valar deny it not.” Arafinwë’s fingers played distractedly over the chair before him. “Though I cannot believe such malice is in their nature, to keep us here from jealousy or avarice. If we are to relinquish Endórë to the Secondborn Children, then surely it is by the will of the One and no petty contempt.” He held quiet for a moment, then added, “Besides, what use have we for the shadows? Let the little race have Endórë—here we dwell in the Light.”
”Nay,” Olwë raised his hand reassuringly. “Save thy persuasion for thy father’s court. I entertain no belief that the Lords of the West would disinherit any of the Eruhín. But be wary, Arafinwë, lest thou scorn overmuch what thou knowest not. Long I lingered in those lands thou hast dismissed as darkness, and greatly did we love them. They are great and beautiful yet, despite—“ He broke off as he noticed his grandson at last, hovering uncertainly in the door’s shadow.
“Findaráto!” Arafinwë’s voice was uncharacteristically sharp in rebuke as he turned to follow Olwë’s gaze. “Hie hence! It is beneath thy blood to listen at doorways.”
Finrod felt shame burn anew in his heart, remembering the sensation of their eyes upon him as he fumbled for a reply. He could feel the gaze even now as he recalled it, eyes resting expectantly upon him as he faltered, the warmth of the firelight mingling with the flush of chagrin.
“May goodness dwell in your household,” Balan’s voice cut through his wandering thought. Finrod realized with a start that it was his gaze he felt resting upon him, and his heart leapt into his throat as he was called back from his brooding by the other’s blessing.
“And health be the drink at your lips.”
“Bearer of light. Restorer of my child. Wisdom and mercy.” Balan had lifted his cup toward the other with a smile. “Joy’s song that scatters our night. Sama’nd sá.”
“Sama’nd sá,” he managed in response and then felt his heart turn to water.
❈❈❈
They glided over the frozen stream. It was a sudden, unexpected rush of joy.
He had never yet set a willing foot upon ice in all the years since reaching Beleriand, except by unavoidable necessity. Too much was bound into the familiarity of that sensation and he could not bear feeling the slick treachery once again beneath his feet. But this…Finrod laughed as he chased after Baran and Eimet, their voices passing a simple ballad back and forth through the frigid air, and he felt alight with the abandon of it all.
The feasting had lasted late into the night, only dispersing when the food and ale dwindled and Baran emerged from one of the huts, carrying a basket of cattle bones under one arm and shouting, “nik’lénor!” which was met by a rousing cheer. It was customary, Balan had told him earlier, for the revelry to last throughout the night so that they might hail the rising sun and know the long darkness was past. Finrod had watched in curiosity as a large contingent headed off into the night, wondering what form this latest would take, and he followed them toward one of Celon’s frozen tributaries.
“You lash them to your feet,” Estreth had called to him as they reached the shore, depositing two bones and a tangle of leather bands into his arms before sprinting after the others toward the bank. Balan stood by, watching in amusement as Finrod held them up and tried to make sense of the flotsam. Each bone had been shaped and flattened along the top and bottom edges, and two holes were carved at each end. The leather thongs passed through one set of these, forming loops at the ends of each bone, then dangled loosely in the air as Finrod turned them over in his hands.
“Here, sit down and give me your foot. Like this,” Balan said with a chuckle and guided Finrod’s boot through a loop, setting one carved bone along the sole and bracing both foot and skate against his own thigh. He pulled the leather thong taut, then crossed it over top of the foot before threading it through the second hole, cinching, and wrapping it several times about the ankle to tie the strands securely in place. “You want it as snug as it goes so the bone doesn’t slip when you move. See?” He knocked his palm against the lashed skate to demonstrate, then flashed a brief grin before moving on to tie the second foot. “That way you don’t lose an ankle.”
“You go on the ice like this?”
“It’s simple enough,” Balan grinned at the incredulity on the other’s face and held out a hand to help him to his feet. “You slide across the surface on their edges rather than trying to walk as you would on dry ground. That way you use the nature of the ice in your movement rather than fighting against it by trying to walk. Come, I’ve no doubt you’ll soon enough put us all to shame.”
Finrod balked more at the thought of explaining his reticence to Balan than he did at the prospect of the ice itself, so he pressed down his unease and allowed Balan to lead him to the shoreline. Finrod watched as he selected two sturdy branches from the undergrowth and broke them under his foot so they were no higher than their waists. He trimmed one end of each into a rough point and handed one to Finrod, then stepped out onto the ice using the second to steady his own balance.
“Come along, then!”
Finrod glanced dubiously at the other Atani already bounding across the frozen river, then looked back at Balan. He stood only a few steps down the bank, hand outstretched and his features creased merrily in a smile. His brown skin was gilded silver in the moonlight and the circlet of aithan-hropit still rested askew about his brow. He laughed as he watched the other’s hesitation and Finrod felt the sound roll over him, an aching beauty in the bitter air as his feet clung fast to the shore.
“There’s naught to fear, Nóm, I’ll keep hold of you till you’ve mastered it,” he said as though coaxing a pup out from its mother’s den, then laughed again. “You’ll wait out the dawn there if you don’t make up your mind to it.”
“Go on then, eagerness,” Finrod retorted as he moved a step further down the bank, “and I’ll come after thee when I’ve seen it done.”
Balan shook his head with another grin and raised his hand higher toward the other. Finrod forced his gaze up to meet Balan’s eyes and then set his hand tentatively within the outstretched palm. Balan’s grip was firm as his fingers closed around the other’s, steady as Finrod allowed himself at last to be led out over the frozen water.
“No, don’t take steps. Push off with the sides, one to the other, and use the branch to keep balance. Like this.”
His palm was warm as it pressed against the other’s skin and Finrod found his misgivings eased by the touch. His own grip tightened as they moved into the center of the tributary, holding fast to that reassurance, though he already moved confidently on the rudimentary skates. He had hardly touched the bracing pole to the ice and would have outpaced Balan easily were they not bound still hand in hand.
He laughed as they picked up speed and followed the others. It was absurd that something as ordinary as a cow’s bone could entirely remake his perception. The ice was marvelous, a thing of beauty. Its treachery had shifted to moderate control, and consequently seemed no longer vengeful, no longer loose or untamable. Finrod glided over the river’s surface, releasing Balan’s hand at last, and his eyes drifted up to the stars as he grew accustomed to the equilibrium of this new motion. Menelmacar, Wilwarin, Itseloktë, Valacirca…their promise blazed bright above him as he laughed upon the ice with these children of the Sun. “Órava omessë,” he whispered into the night sky, “remember us, here in our frailty.”
He lost count of time as they skimmed about on the river, first racing hither and thither, then dabbling through a variety of games. He and Baran fell to Balan and Estreth in one complicated undertaking involving a sash rolled up and tied together as a ball, the poles they carried, and an inexplicable muddle of improvised wrestling. Finrod protested the loss, insisting that Balan and Baran had told such conflicting summaries of the rules that it was impossible to know if they were all playing the same game. Which, Baran mumbled as he set a chunk of ice gingerly against the bruise on his forehead, was entirely the point.
“Carrying the cub from the den was the point,” Balan remarked as he tossed and caught the rolled sash to flaunt their victory.
“Gaitch,” Baran swore at him with an affectionate grimace.
“Less conventions for the next, I think,” Estreth retrieved a flat stone from the bank and balanced it carefully atop her head. “Your mother and I played this when we were young, Ran. It’s merely whoever holds theirs for the longest distance.” She glanced back at her nephew as she glided in a circle. “The beauty of it is having no rules to bicker over when you’ve had more ale than you hold…”
“Did you and Esrid do that often as children?” Balan grinned as he lifted rocks from the river’s edge and passed them to Finrod and Baran.
“Gaitch,” Estreth swore at him in turn. “Go back and sleep, you’re terrible company.”
Balan balanced the rock on his head and began skating along the river, his voice lifted in one of Eimet’s drinking songs,
“O come! Be merry, my lad, there’s drink to be had,
there’s mead and ale in good measure.
Aye there, lass, fetch us some! And when you’ve so done
then we’ll beg too to drink of your—“
He broke off with a muffled snort as the rolled sash struck his face and knocked the rock from his head.
“That’s quite enough of that,” Estreth said with a laugh. “And you’ve lost already.”
“I haven’t,” Balan said with a show of affronted dignity, replacing the stone and moving back to stand beside the others in a line. “A game not begun cannot be lost.”
“And by that reasoning will never be started,” Baran retorted, then pushed off across the ice. “Hrava!” he called and made his way back along the stream toward where the rest of the group was clustered.
Estreth followed close behind him, then Finrod and Balan after her. The night was quiet apart from the distant sounds of laughter on the breeze, and Finrod felt the well of joy rise once more within him. He sang, using the pole now to push himself along the ice, and his voice echoed over the frozen water as he gathered each moment close in his memory, hallowing these little snatches of simplicity.
“A Elentári Tintallë
tyelpë pendas mírilya
menelo alcar elerrimbë!
Hairanna palan-tírienwa
Endórellon—"
A sound like a branch snapping. An unearthly echo, wobbling, resonant.
Before his sight could note the other’s movement, Balan felt arms about him like steel, the rush of air as he was pulled to the side, staggering together into the bracken on the riverbank. The drumbeat of the other’s heart pounded against his ear as Finrod held him clutched against his chest.
“Nóm?” he gasped, shaken. His own heart was pounding as well and his breath fled at the close crush of the other’s embrace.
The grip loosened as Finrod’s eyes darted back over the ice and took in the unblemished surface. It was whole. He moved back, breathing fast as embarrassment rose hot through his blood, but he did not release his hold.
“Nóm, what happened?”
“My apologies.” Finrod shook his head dismissively, but his voice shook. “I must have imagined it.”
“It was the ice shifting.” Balan’s voice was quiet, reassuring, and he looked up in concern at the drawn lines of the other’s face.
“Yes, so it was.” Finrod’s knuckles were white as he gripped Balan’s arms. A pause. Then his voice again, hoarse and unlike any tone Balan had heard in it before, “I thought it would take thee.”
“Nóm…”
“Forgive me. I am behaving foolishly.” Finrod released him abruptly and turned away. He was overwhelmed by the urge to run, to flee far from the vision that arose with the ice’s cry. It stabbed—violating, thieving, a fracturing thing between each of their words. He clenched his hands into fists to keep them from reaching out for the other once more. “Please go on,” he managed and forced a smile over his lips, then stumbled up the bank.
“Nóm!”
But he was gone, pausing not even to remove the skates from his feet before disappearing beneath the darkened trees.
❈❈❈
Balan returned to the others on the ice, but found little jollity was left in him. He could not shake the image of the other’s face hovering before him, drawn and fearful, or the way his hands trembled as he caught hold of him. It had unnerved him to see the transformation, not least because he had never yet seen such fear upon Nóm’s features—concern, fury, grief certainly, but nothing near the abject terror that had poured from his eyes as he clutched Balan close against him. He had looked through him, not at him, and this too was jarring. Balan had grown accustomed to the piercing gaze, noting both face and spirit and by that sight solidifying them together into a unified whole. The lack of it now left him disoriented, disjointed.
What was there in that eerie, frozen cry to cause such fracturing between them?
His worry set him on edge, even more than the distraction of remembering the other’s touch, the thrill of finding himself wrapped within Nóm’s arms. He drew apart from the others again and stood lost in thought upon the bank where they parted. Balan rarely attempted to reach out toward the other’s thought, finding it a far greater task to seek than to welcome—and rarely had he the need, for Nóm was ever resting patiently at the door, needing only his invitation. But there was no hovering touch now, and that too heightened Balan’s concern. He filled his lungs and stared hard into the distance, lifting up the image of a flowering tree—set your hand over mine—the gentle brush of warmth, a caress behind his eyes—move your hand forward and follow my arm—soft, golden light—I will not bar the way—then a wall of ice, frigid and impassable. Sharp at every edge.
Balan drew back as though slapped.
Then he shook his head and strode up the bank, unlashing the bones from his feet as he reached the top and dropping them into the waiting basket. He moved quickly toward the trees. I thought it would take thee. He heard the other’s voice over and again in his mind and could not escape the pain in it. Whatever difference lay between the causes was irrelevant—he recognized the fear at the root as his own constant companion, and he would not leave the other alone with such demons of grief. The Elf might close him out in thought, but he would seek him out in body, as he too had sought Balan upon the hills of Ossiriand when he sat frozen beneath the summer’s night.
He reached the village in short order and found Meyla and Belen beside the fires, teaching Avina to roast apples and cheese over the twinkling embers. He smiled despite himself at the sight, recalling how eagerly Belen devoured those delicacies as a child and watching now as he showed Avina how to draw them off the long twigs with fresh slices of bread.
“You’ve given up too, vatta?” Belen flashed a welcoming smile as his father joined them beside the flames.
“Aye, it grew cold for my old bones.” Balan accepted the proffered apple and held its warmth awhile within his hands before blowing on the edge and taking a bite, savoring the sweet crunch of the apple, the sharp tang of the cheese. “Has Nóm returned, then?”
“Mm.” Belen nodded toward their hut. “Slipped in without a word, not an hour past.” He speared another portion of apple and cheese onto the stick and passed it back to Avina. “All well?”
Balan’s nod was noncommittal and he moved away toward the thatched hut.
Finrod was seated on the floor when he entered. He had built up the hearth fire again and sat in front of the wooden benches, staring down into the flickering embers. The firelight illuminated his face in sharp relief against the shadows behind him and Balan’s heart contracted to see the features haggard and drawn.
“Nóm?”
“Balan.” He looked up at the sound of the other’s voice and tried in vane to shift his lips into a smile.
“I was troubled for you.” Balan removed his hat as he entered, heavy and lined with thick fur, and set it aside.
“Yes. You reached out and I struck you away,” he said as Balan crossed to open a chest beside his bedroll and removed a squat, clay bottle, sealed across the top with wax. “I apologize. I am glad you came despite it.”
Balan collected two cups from a shelf and walked back to sit beside the other, setting a cup before each of them, and gripping Finrod’s shoulder briefly before turning to the clay bottle. “We keep a portion of this held over whenever we set out upon a new journey,” he said, drawing his knife and working it about the top to loosen the wax, “to salute the sun when she rises after this longest night.” He pried the remaining wax from the mouth of the bottle and wiped away the loose flecks, then poured a large splash into the bottom of each cup. “I think on this occasion we will bring it out sooner. You look as though you could use something stronger than mead.” He lifted his cup with a wry grin at Finrod. “Sama’nd sá.”
“Sama’nd sá,” Finrod echoed and raised his cup toward the other, then drank. He gasped as the liquor cleared his throat and looked back at Balan in surprise, his eyes watering. “Miru-na-naur!” he coughed, laughing despite himself. “What is it?”
“Hrögemetheilit.” He tried not to laugh at the look of comic betrayal on the Elf’s face.
“Hrögeme—what does that mean?”
“Nothing at all,” Balan replied with a chuckle. “My father’s jest was we named it a nonsense jumble because that’s all you manage once it’s been downed.” He drained what was left in his own cup, then added with a sidelong grin, “Estreth says it’s self preservation—the name’s long enough that you can only ask for more of it when you’ve had naught of it.”
Finrod took another sip and shook his head with a grimace. “True enough.” The shock of the hrögemetheilit had eased his memories for a moment, but soon despair began creeping back about the edges. He was cold, as he had not been in centuries, and felt himself shivering as he moved even closer to the fire. He realized he must have sat upon the ground instinctively after lighting it. There were no benches upon the Ice, you simply sat as close to the warmth as possible. “Forgive me,” he murmured at last. “I’ve disrupted your time of celebration.”
Balan reached out and took Finrod’s hands in his own. “Do not disparage how thy body mourns,” he said quietly, reciting the other’s words back to him in his own tongue. “I judge thee not for it. Only would I comfort thee, if I can.”
Finrod’s face twitched dismissively. The words fell hollow and trite when turned upon his own ears. What right had he to mourn, regardless of the manner, he who had led them thence to the fate he grieved? He could hear yet the wind howling over the fissures, roaring up from the sea in bitter gusts. He had felt Uinen’s greeting there as well, but that sea wind slashed stinging cuts across his skin and no caresses. The Swan Maiden’s boy disowned and not cherished, and far now from Eärwen’s solace as well, her warmth and loyalty forsaken upon the stained docks when he chose the forward path.
The cracking, the muttering echoed again in his ears. “Racië!” Warning cries tore like howls through the evernight. He flinched as the vision rose once more before his eyes: a shattered berg, sagging under its weight. Pounding, relentless. Taking and dragging and crushing.
But it was Balan’s face he saw, lifeless and suspended beneath new-forming ice—how swiftly it always leapt over the exposed water when one had fallen—and blood seeped across his features as it had over Elenwë’s. It had spun a bright and binding web through her hair as he and Fingon dragged Turgon, screaming, from the crumbling edge. Beautiful and appalling.
“Nóm?” Balan’s voice cut through the dark and he turned towards it, grasping his hands. They were warm upon his skin and steadied him, pulled him back. They were born with the Sun, he thought incoherently, warm as the Sun. “Nóm, are you well?”
“I owe you an explanation.” Finrod’s voice trickled out at last.
“Only should it ease you to speak of it.” Balan’s face was lined with concern as he watched the other move in and out of memory. “You owe me naught.”
“Nay, you’ve earned the truth of me long since. It is only fear that stayed my tongue.” He pulled the cloak tighter about his shoulders. “Only help me begin…” He lapsed again into his own tongue as he stirred up the fire with an iron. “Tell me, from our time together, what hast thou understood of that which brought my people from the West?”
Balan rose and retrieved another log for the fire, choosing his words slowly. “The Foe assailed the land of thy dwelling and destroyed the Light that was, stealing then that which remained. Thy people followed him hence to seek vengeance.”
“And how dost thou believe we made our way to these shores?”
Balan thought for a moment, then shook his head. “I know not. I have not contemplated it, strange though that seems.”
“Then I shall give thee an accounting.” Finrod drew his knees down to sit cross-legged before the hearth and rested his hands, one upon each, in the posture of a storyteller. Then, slowly, he began to tell of the Silmarils, of the death of the Trees and the tangible Dark, the fear and the agony of that ever increasing loss. He told of the flight of his people and their fire for vengeance, of the strife in Araman and the breaking of the host, the burning of the ships at Losgar, the specter of the grinding ice unrelenting before their feet. Then at last he fell silent and Balan saw his knuckles were white where they gripped his knees. “Alas, my words catch and tangle on my tongue. Never have I spoken it to another, Balan, and I find I fall short at the need.”
“Then let it fall short, Nóm.”
“Nay, I need thee to know of it. For thy goodwill, Balan, I find I cannot hold by half measures. I would have thee know the whole of me, to take or leave what thou findest. Let me tell thee all and then thou shalt decide—and, if thou wilt, I shall release thee from thy bond. I would not have thee sworn blind.” He turned at last from the fire to face the other, his eyes hard with determination. “What I have not said to thee, what I have hidden in silence of my omissions, is that we left Valinórë against the will and counsel of the Valar. Losgar, Araman, all that followed…it was the firstfruits of our rebellion and the blood already upon our hands.”
Balan felt the soft touch against his mind, questioning, asking for the simplest way forward, and he opened to him without a moment’s hesitation, glad for a way to ease the other’s distress. Then the images rushed in like a gale, stone piers, raging water, the screams of battle. A sickening horror of carnage, warm and red, glistening in the lamplight—no not lamplight, it was fire amid the city, raging fire all about the quays. Feet slipping helpless in the blood. A piercing, bitter keen echoing between the cliffs, both song and scream, like the death-cry of seabirds.
Memories, Balan realized as he gasped for breath, these were memories, these flashes of agony and horror. He clung to the other’s hands as the waves of images lashed forward.
“We did not have ships when we set out.” Finrod’s words moved through Balan’s ears, muffled as though he spoke from a great distance. “Only my mother’s people knew the making of those, and they would have no part in our madness.”
Two women upon the dockings, hair of gold, hair of silver, blood upon their raiment, blood upon the blades they swung.
“Amil! Artanis!” Nóm’s voice seemed to cry out from Balan’s own chest as he saw through the other’s eyes.
A rain of arrows. The roaring sea.
“The greater part of us came upon the battle after it was begun. They had butchered the mariners, taken the ships.”
Nóm’s hands now, covered in blood, desperately holding together the chest of another Elf, bones exposed and organs slipping loose. The weight of the body resting within his arms.
“But we did not turn back. Fear, pride, duty…name it what thou wilt, but it held our course.”
A dark coast, a stinging wind. Far and tiny upon the horizon, a flicking line of red.
“We chose the ice over turning back.”
The eerie groaning, a crack, howling, a sickening ripple of snapping. Blind mist. A scream in the darkness. Again the moaning ice; a great, resonant thudding. Through the mist, figures are running, tying cloaks into ropes. He is running, slipping, leaping into the water. Cold like a knife, every fiber screaming, no breath, no breath. Dragging at phantom shapes in the water. A child in his arms, pulling her free from the wedge of ice. Arms atop the ice, hauling her up. Turn back, turn back, he is still there. “Turukáno!” Nóm’s hands again, catching hold of a tunic, a handful of dark hair. A second pair beside him. “Hanno, she is gone!” Crashing, wailing, the wall crumbling.
“We chose death over turning back.”
A still pool in a crack of ice. A brief moment of starlight through the mist. The Valacirca. Nóm’s reflection beside it in the water, gaunt and hollow, lips cracked open and the bleeding frozen over, eyes haunted, dim.
The memories seeped back from his thought and Balan gradually became aware of his own weeping, his breath catching in great gasps as they sat yet beside the hearth. He had reached out to clasp his hand behind Finrod’s neck, holding fast as though he might slip away into the memory, foreheads pressed together as his tears fell onto the other’s tunic.
“Balan…” Finrod took hold of his shoulders, holding him gently and his voice was laced with concern. “Balan, forgive me. I should have found the words rather. That was too much to ask of thee.”
“Nay, it was not.” He pulled back, shifting his hand to rest along Finrod’s face and tracing his eyes over the features to still the memory of that haggard reflection. It had been a death’s head in comparison to this golden visage against his palm, vibrant and radiating life. He could not shake the image. “I wanted to share in it, lord,” he said, and a wan smile turned the edges of his lips as he included the honorific, claiming again that bond. “Bound in faithfulness and truth, I told thee, to hold dear as thou holdest dear, to mourn as thou dost mourn.” He let his hand fall back to his lap and added, “I would never have coaxed thee out upon it had I known.”
“I know. And I deemed my fear of treading it was less than my fear of telling thee.” He smiled and this time it reached his eyes as well. “The greater fool, I.”
Finrod was quiet for a time, then plucked a dried leaf from where it clung to the hem of his cloak, turning it over in his hands and tracing a finger along the edges. “When our feet reached Endórë’s soil at last, cold tundra though it was, we sang as we had not for long years behind us. Broken music of weeping, greeting the soil and grime. And with our voices Isil too rose through the firmament, brimming with silver to end our long darkness.” He set the point of the leaf against the fire and watched it burst into flame. Carefully he lifted it, music rippling under his breath as the flames consumed the papery tendrils until only the light remained suspended, hovering above his palm. “And as we marched renewed toward the fortress of our Enemy, hope unlooked for burst forth at our backs. Anar rising, breaking the sky with a light we thought lost forever. Only the work of the Valar could have wrought such,” he murmured as the light over his own palm dwindled and faded. “A sign that we did not lie forgotten, here in our exile.” Finrod turned to look at him and the warmth of his smile set Balan’s heart alight. “And so ye awakened then as well, children of that same remembrance.”
Long Balan held his eye in silence before his heart released its grip on his throat. “Ever have I learned of our genesis in darkness,” he said at last, “understanding my kind always as creatures brought forth into shadow and peril. Never till in thine eyes have I envisioned us born of light.”
“You are of Light as we are of Light, children beautiful and intended, reflecting each in its various ways as the cut edge of a gem.” Finrod’s voice caught and he paused. “Dismiss my words if thou wilt, but in thy people—in thee, Balan—I have seen the mystery of the Song enfleshed, I have known the beauty of the ever-faceted thought of the One more vividly in thy presence than in the many centuries I’ve spent afore.”
A log cracked in the fire as he spoke and the flame leapt up as though in answer, the sudden glow hovering warm and bright between them, mirroring the reflection each upon each.
“My mother had a saying,” Balan’s voice was quiet as he reached out and held Finrod’s hands cupped open within his own. “Presence is the greatest solace.” He smiled across at him, then took his tenuous courage in hand and bent his head to kiss first one palm, then the other. “One for comfort,” he said quietly, as his mother had done so often to still his tears, “and one for company.” He set the hands back together, clasped within his own, and held them firm and steady. “I have no wish to be released from what I swore to thee.”
“Nor truly have I to release thee.” Finrod’s voice was little more than a breath. Estreth had told of the ghomennin transfixing their quarries, yet he it was now held motionless, mesmerized within the other’s gaze.
“Then come,” Balan said, rising and holding out his hand. “The sun is near to rising. Let us greet her together, thou and I, here after the long darkness.”
“Yes,” Finrod said, and took the hand within his own.
❈❈❈
The tendrils of morning stretched up from the horizon. All the kindred had gathered about the village edge and huddled in little groups, children rubbing their faces against their parents’ legs or curled and drowsing in their arms as each traded yawns through the crowd. Bottles of hrögemetheilit were passed from hand to hand until all stood with cups to the ready, turned toward the waking sun. The heavens blushed, quickened, spread wide with color until Anar lifted above the rolling hills and a stab of light blazed out over the frosted ground.
“Nahtan steiha!” Balan cried at the head of his people, lifting his cup toward the brilliant gold.
“Nahtan steiha!” they echoed in return, and all lifted the toast to their lips, drinking and calling out weary cheers as the night was ended at last.
“Nai lye hiruva airea amanar, Balan.” Finrod said quietly after drinking from his cup, looking down with affection at the man beside him. “Nahtan steiha.”
“Nahtan steiha,” Balan replied and knocked his empty cup against the other’s, smiling.
“And this then for thee,” Finrod said and raised his cup once more, half the amber liquid yet remaining. “May goodness dwell in your household.”
“And health be the drink at your lips.”
“Balan, meldonya, dearest friend of my heart. Truth-namer. Steadfast as the ancient oak. By sorrow’s knife marked, by sorrow’s mark carved to beauty. Anarinya—gift unforeseen in the darkness. Sama’nd sá.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin, T = Telerin
Ereg: [S] holly
Ercassë: [Q] holly
Winicë: [T] little-one, baby
Atta: [T] father
Hildor: [Q] followers
órava omessë: [Q] have mercy on us
“A Elentári Tintallë…”: [Q] rendering of the Hymn to Elbereth in Quenya
Miru-na-naur: [S] wine of fire
Racië: [Q] it is breaking
Amil: [Q] mother
Hanno: [Q] brother
Nai lye hiruva airea amanar: [Q] roughly “may you find a blessed Amanar [sun’s returning]”
Anarinya: [Q] my sun
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic:
Haelis: hello, greetings
Vatta: father
aithan-hropit: mother’s cry
skadus anek sá: shadow upon you
nahtan steiha: night is ended
Sama’nd sá: good/abundant life be unto you
nik’lénor: ice run
gaitch: swine
hrava: start
MISC NOTES
- Nómin: “the wise,” name given by the Atani to Finrod’s people
- Fun fact: Vikings used bone ice skates and that is what the nik’lénor scene draws from as its source.
- For some absolutely haunting sounds of shifting/cracking ice, see this Jonna Jinton recording
- Artanis: “noble woman,” the given name of Galadriel
7. A Heady Fragrance of Honey
That it was returned, he did not question. He could look back now and see everything arranged in its full image, he could trace the careful dance they both wound through this past year; every word, every silence, every touch ringing through with that steady truth. How had he been so blind?
Springtime has come to Estolad. Finrod is struck with a realization he has been avoiding and faces the decisions that lie in its wake.
Read 7. A Heady Fragrance of Honey

311th YEAR OF THE SUN, LATE SPRING
Estolad
It was pleasantly warm in the sun along the riverbank.
Balan smiled as the light illuminated a mosaic through his eyelids. Anar’s touch was hot upon his skin, moving in and out of the clouds and thawing at last the frigid ache of winter. The months had stretched long and bitter since Yuletide, and Spring came over-late and feeble in her charge. But at last the chill subsided, the clammy air grew mild, the birdsong returned.
And like a dam breaking, they spent every waking hour in the warmth, children careening through the fields with shrieks of laughter, the grown hardly more dignified as they were set loose at last to begin repairs about the village. There was much to remedy after the long winter and much yet to be built, and they sang as they worked. Most often these were simple melodies, a call and response falling into beat with the stroke of mallet or axe or plow or shearing blades, and Finrod learned them quickly as he worked alongside them.
The Casári too had sung while they delved the halls of his city and Finrod was reminded of that long work, hoisted up on wooden planks that dangled from a system of ropes and pulleys, the low, resonant voices echoing in time with their hammers, songs drawing tune and substance from the rocks about them. Indeed, he had become convinced the rocks themselves sang in kind as they progressed ever further. The Casári teased him for idleness, so often had his own chisel fallen silent as he listened rapt to the music that swelled around him. Gundin, their chief craftsman, had at last reprimanded him as Finrod swung suspended beside the wall, his hands hovering motionless in the midst of a half-completed carving. It is the work of every hand which makes the music, Felak-gundu. If you lay the one to rest, the other falters as well. After that, he had managed better, merging the two into one action and finding his own work all the better for it. Even now, two centuries later, he heard their song whenever he walked his halls, footfalls awakening the melody once more to echo in his ears: the sonorous bass of Dwarven voices a heartbeat through the caverns, the percussive chime of the chisels and picks, his own voice wandering through the midst, starkly out of place and yet woven perfectly into the whole.
If the Casári songs were stone, then the Atani’s were earth. Course, rich, filled with that bright, burning, ferocity that infused every aspect of their lives. Every morning Finrod was awed by their capacity for it, every evening dazed by how brightly they had burned. At night he would look on, mystified, as they slumbered in a deeper oblivion than his own kind knew. Some nights he would sit at rest in the hut and watch over Balan and his sons while they slept, his heart straining between a piercing joy and the terror of death’s foretaste. They were so still in those moments, so lost to the world around them, but he could not look away from their resting visages. Belen, who always looked younger than his eighteen years, could be mistaken for a child yet as he lay curled against his father’s back with his legs drawn up beside his stomach. Baran’s face too lost the firm resolve it bore throughout the day—a leader born and not made, as his father had named him—and his youth peered through as he slept. Even Balan seemed little older than his sons as he slept at their sides, his face relaxed into a near mirror of his eldest. The only apparent mark of age showed in the brush of grey at his temples and scattered throughout his beard. The rest of his face had eased into a childlike vulnerability, no longer creased with the cares and tension the days had folded into his skin. In these clandestine studies, Finrod caught a glimpse of what he must have been as a young man and was stung with regret that he never knew him as such.
He carried those visions with him throughout the days and saw the Atani ever with that vulnerability lingering behind their expressions, even as they frowned and sang and heaved new beams into the burgeoning village. How he loved them, these perplexing, fragile creatures.
The village had begun taking shape as the springtime moved forward. Additional huts filled the space within the palisade and rows of thick wall posts had been planted at one end, forming the skeleton of what would become the Hall. Fields had been tilled, lambing and kidding were mostly finished, and several donkeys had foaled. Finrod was delighted by these tiny additions to his charges and lavished even more attention on the herd than before, until Baran shooed him away, protesting that he would ruin them for all usefulness with such coddling.
As the urgency of tasks lessened, he and Balan fell into the routine of ending each afternoon beside the Celon, stretched at ease among the new grasses and heather, talking aimlessly or lying in companionable silence. Every day they lay closer, as though by accident, until they were accustomed to take their places side by side, arms touching lightly as the golden light washed through the meadows, dancing a mosaic through Balan’s closed eyes.
“Gods all, I’m hungry.”
“Thou art ever hungry.” Finrod’s laugh rippled quietly through the grass.
“I’ve lived a winter through on dried herring and roots.” Balan stretched his arms up to rest under his head. “Of course I am.”
“And salt pork, and preserved cheese, and the bread of my people, and—”
“And the fields do not yet yield, and I tire of what lives kept in barrels or hung from the beams.” Balan opened one eye to squint at him through the sun’s glare. “I’m an irascible old man, Nóm. Indulge me in my complaints.”
“The fields yield.” Finrod rolled to the side, grinning as he rummaged through the grasses and uprooted a flowering plant. “Only thou art petulant in thy choosing, vinyamo.” He drew out his knife and shaved away the outer rind from the tuber, then cut it free from the stalk and held it out to the other.
“More roots.” Balan feigned distaste, but took it and ate. The flavor was clean and peppery, refreshing in the afternoon sun, and he enjoyed it despite his grumbling.
Finrod turned back, shifting the grasses aside in search of a second, and instead found a little cluster of snowdrops. “Nieninquë!” he exclaimed and drew his fingers over the tiny, white petals. “I thought these had all gone for the season. When I was young, I would lie full days amid their first blossoms in the hills and meadows of Valinórë, nigh intoxicated upon their scent…” He plucked one flower from the cluster and turned back, drawing it down over Balan’s face to rest beneath his nose. “Like a heady fragrance of honey…”
“It is rather.” Balan smiled and his face twitched as the leaves tickled against his skin. “It reminds me of wildflowers in mead. We’ll add yarrow and lavender to it in the summer months—you’ll like that, I think.”
“Mm.” Finrod lay back in the long grass and set the snowdrop to his own face as he watched the clouds drift overhead. He breathed deeply and his senses filled with the fragrance of life; the flower resting beneath his nostrils, damp earth fresh and teeming with the new season’s vigor, heather plants crowning a nearby hilltop, the scent of the man lying beside him. He smelled of sweat and of sunlight upon skin, a sweet aroma mingling with the snowdrop blossom and the memory of golden springtimes.
It was a pleasant scent, earthy and homey. He was embarrassed now to recall how off-putting he found it only the summer before, even as his own kin clearly did now. They are passable company, certainly, once you’ve passed the pungency. The Ambarussar had found their quip nearly as amusing as the seething glare it earned from their cousin when they visited in the midwinter. Very well. They needn’t lie in the bright sun with the warmth of him against their arm, watching the sun in her merry dance through the heavens or feeling the silken nieninquë upon their skin. These were his pleasures. Finrod smiled at the thought and basked in the warmth of it, content.
“What are you grinning about?” Balan asked, watching with amusement as the various expressions moved over the other’s face.
“Is there not reason enough? The world is warm, Yavanna’s song abounds in the soil, in the grasses of the fields, and thou art beside me—the threads of friendship woven together despite all purpose of the Dark. Of course I smile.” Finrod shifted his arm to rest across his forehead, shielding the glare and dangling the snowdrop between his eyes and the sun, the light playing through the petals.
“Norolinda pirucendëa,
lendë tanna Nieliccilis,
sana wendë nieninquëa,
yan i wilyar antar miquelis.
I oromandi tanna lendë,
ar wingildi wilwarindië,
Losselië telerinwa,
táli lantalasselingië.”
The melody moved slowly, each note drawn out and varied into a songbird’s warble, and his voice seemed to split and counter itself, becoming both principal and accompaniment in a way that defied Balan’s grasp. Nóm had sung much throughout the winter to ease the long hours, but never yet had Balan heard this manner of music from his lips. It was both joyous and melancholy, spilling over with deep, unsated longing.
The words ran together so that Balan could not discern them, but neither did he ask for any translation. He preferred it this way, the syllables new and strange again as they brushed over him in the other’s voice, once more the mystery and promise of discovery.
Finrod’s voice wrapped about the song like a caress. He had learned it as a child when Lalwendë would fetch him and bear him west of the Pelóri, dowsing him in the Trees as she dubbed those excursions. For seeming thyself a sprig of Laurelin, thy son is kept far too much in the twilight. The chide was tossed at Arafinwë half in jest when Lalwen first collected her nephew from Alqualondë, setting him before her on the stallion and carrying him back the way she had come. Finrod remembered how the wind streamed through their hair as they galloped and the distinct feeling, passing through the Calacirya, that the Light too rushed in upon them with that same vigor. She would lift him down from the horse’s back and sing of Niéle as they walked through the valleys beneath Tirion and he perched upon her shoulders, his tiny hands playing in her hair, raven black and echoing with a golden sheen.
Ever after those wanderings with Lalwen, the melody sprang unsummoned from his tongue whenever his feet passed through the meadows about Túna. Amarië teased him for it on the times she joined him—was he a child yet? And so he sang it all the more, teasing in return, and greeted her at every meeting with “Norolinda pirucendëa lendë tanna Nieliccilis” until the opening notes of Niéle were nearly an epessë between them.
He realized with a start, here in this distant field far from the meadows of Aman or the jests of those once beloved, that he had not sung it since the day of darkness, lifting both voice and goblet in greeting when Amarië joined them at the banqueting tables, clad in flowing white and green, a twist of flowers woven into her hair. The song had been too bound in that pain, of the dark and of loss, that his tongue had foresworn it till now. Now, when once again it tripped from his lips without thought and ran dancing through the sunlight. “Ar wingildi wilwarindië…” he sang again.
“Foam-fay?” Balan at last let his mind trace the pattern of the words as well as the music of them and his voice cut in through Finrod’s meditations.
“A water nymph.” Finrod rolled onto his stomach and looked down at Balan where he lay beside him. “It was also one of the names my father’s folk had for my mother’s people—and he for her.” Then he laughed and looked out over the rippling water. “He called her wingildi; she called him pánë. Páni are a kind of sea birds that fly far across the waves and the mariners of Alqualondë would tell how they fluttered along in the wake of returning vessels, weary too from their own journeys. My mother teased that he followed her the way a pánë would trail the swan ships. And so he said she was the beacon guiding his way back to land, the steady point in the tossing sea.”
Balan was quiet as he looked up at the other’s profile, the sun’s light spilling through the mussed hair. The ache, grown familiar over the winter months, pressed again at his heart, beauty and longing mingling and threatening to spill over into words. He took a breath and allowed a small transgression. “I think thou art very like her.”
“I?” Finrod looked over at him with an eyebrow lifted and he laughed again. “Nay, I am the image of my father, though for good or ill will yet be seen. I’ve long since lost what beacon might have called me back as he.”
“Nay, thou art the beacon.” Balan held his eye for a moment longer, then his courage wavered and he shifted his gaze once more to the clouds. “So I see thee, at least.”
Finrod watched him for a long moment, his expression unreadable, then he reached out and traced the snowdrop gently along Balan’s face from hairline to chin and he smiled. “Have a care, then, where thou art led. Thou hast seen already where my wandering brought me.”
“And I have seen thy remorse.” He shifted so the other’s shoulders blocked the sun and looked up at him, reciting as his own father had, “The path of penitence sets thy wandering aright.”
“Mm. But I am not penitent.” A smile of mischief split Finrod’s lips. “Not when exile has led me to thy people—to thee. How can I regret that, melotornonya?”
“Melotorno?”
“One very dear to the heart, deeply loved,” Finrod said quietly and hope sprang in Balan’s heart as the grey eyes looked down at him with affection. “I think in your tongue its meaning would be ‘one whom love has made a brother’.”
“I see.” Balan tried to keep his face from falling at the added words.
“It is an approximation. I have no word for what thou art to me.”
“Hast thou not?”
“None. Thou art a new thing, strange and utterly indescribable. I’ve no language yet for thee.” He tossed the snowdrop down onto Balan’s face and leapt nimbly to his feet. “All this talk of páni and ships has left me longing for water.” He slipped his feet from his boots and ran toward the river, calling back over his shoulder, “Come along then, thy beacon is a backward sort and will lead thee from the shore and not toward it!”
Balan rolled onto his stomach and watched incredulously as the other disappeared down the bank. “Wingildi!” he called after him, laughing. “It’s hardly been thawed a month, you fey creature!” He pulled off his own shoes when naught but a splash came in answer and made his way down the bank. The rocks beside the shore were reassuringly hot and he set his tunic upon them, resting it beside the other’s garments where they lay cast aside in the sun. Shirt, breeches, rings, belt…Balan felt his heart lurch as it was all accounted for.
He had seen him once before by accident, when they dwelt in Ossiriand beside the banks of Thalos. Balan had risen in the night to relieve himself and while walking back to the encampment saw the other lit by starlight through the trees before him. Nóm had waded into the river till it reached his thighs and held a bowl in his hand, ladling water over his outstretched arm with solemn precision. As he filled it again and poured it out over his hand, over each finger, Balan could hear bits of his voice drifting over the water in a gentle, somber rite. It must be a ritual of his people, Balan realized, and retreated as quietly as possible, never certain whether the Elf had been aware of his presence or if he passed unmarked. But he had lain awake the remainder of the night, hounded by the memory of the other’s skin, burnished silver beneath the stars; the sound of his song rippling slow and solemn over the water; his own growing desire that left him dizzy and hopeless.
The voice came to him again across the waves, only now it startled Balan from his meditation rather than summoning him to it. He sang a comic tune Bel used for working, shuffling the words about to fit his purpose, and Balan laughed as he watched him glide through the water.
“O, why do you tarry?
The water is merry,
the earth has awakened!
O, still you are waiting—
are your feet made of clay?
Balan, come, come away!
O, why do you tarry?
The water is merry!”
And with that last, he dove beneath the surface and let himself twist weightless through the swift current. Balan had been right, it was almost unpleasantly frigid. But it reminded him of the Pools of Ivrin after winter’s passage, swollen with the snow-melt and fresh rain, and plunging into their depths had been a yearly mark of Spring’s return. The Celon, he reflected, would serve instead this year.
By the time he surfaced, Balan stood waist-deep in the water, watching him as though he were a madman. “It may as well be ice!” he called out and Finrod saw the gooseflesh standing across his skin.
He grinned and swam back toward him. “Step in further, thy body will accustom itself. Tis only the first shock that accosts thee. There, now another. And one more, just here to the right.”
Balan moved forward as directed, but on the last step the ground fell away beneath him and he plunged down into the full depth of the river with a yelp. He surfaced and a steady stream of profanity rushed out of his mouth as Finrod laughed beside him, hovering in the water, his eyes alight with mischief. “Gaitch,” Balan spluttered at last and lunged at him, catching hold of his shoulders and shoving him down beneath the surface. He felt him slip away even as he submerged and looked in vain at the water about him to chart the other’s path.
“Here!” Finrod emerged behind him, hardly a sound as he broke the surface, and Balan twisted around in time to feel the hands grasp his shoulders and plunge him beneath the waves once more. He emerged several yards distant, laughing now, and Finrod slipped away as he lunged after him, intent still on vengeance. It was like chasing a minnow without a net, Balan thought while he kicked through the water, always just out of reach and darting at impossible angles whenever he neared.
They splashed and shouted like children as the chase continued, and Finrod felt light with a joy he had known seldom since the Darkening. The water welcomed him in her embrace and enfolded Balan too at his side, the pair of them wrapped together in weightless flight through Uinen’s tresses. It was bliss.
He caught Balan about the waist and pulled him down, as he had done countless times when chasing his brothers or cousins in the waters of Alqualondë, and it was the very disjointedness of that juxtaposition which at last shattered the illusion. Truth crashed across his senses like a blow and he reeled as it rushed over him with the river’s current, inescapable in the intimacy of skin pressed hard against skin, a tangle of limbs, the sudden illumination of desire pounding through every vein. He froze beneath the water, his face caught against Balan’s chest, his own chest resting against the other’s abdomen, the bare hips; arms twined about him yet in the snare. No, in the embrace…
Finrod felt the other struggle against him with an increased urgency and it dawned on him he had no notion how long he had held him beneath the water. He released his grip abruptly and surfaced, spluttering.
“I might have known thou wert half fish as well.” Balan’s voice greeted him, caught between laughter and gasping for breath. “Nearly drowned me.” He sent a handful of water cascading into Finrod’s face and moved back, treading water just out of reach.
Finrod managed a laugh as he shook off the water, though it sounded forced and discordant in his own ears. He could not take his eyes from the other and stared at him as though learning his face anew. The dark hair, nearly black, glistened in the sunlight and unkempt waves had begun rising again through its length it as he bobbed above the water. A smile split his face, merry as a boy’s, and laughter lines sprang out across his skin, honey-brown and shining, deep and rich as a ripe acorn. He longed to reach out and trace his fingers over the beauty of that flesh, to set his lips to the tip of the cheekbone, along the length of the clavicle.
“Nóm?”
Finrod started from his reverie and shook his head. “Forgive me,” he said with a strained smile, “thou didst judge aright and I heeded thee not—it is too cold yet for this.”
Balan watched in surprise as he turned abruptly and swam back toward the shore. It must have been the water, he mused as he followed him toward the rocks. He should not have jested of drowning. They were not far from the tributary where the memories accosted him at the Longest Night and perhaps this was another of the same making. He pulled himself out onto the shoreline, shivering as the breeze heightened the water’s ice, and dressed quickly as the other had done. Balan had sacrificed his tunic as a towel, but it was a relief to wrap even the thin cloth of his undershirt and breeches back about himself, tempering the chill. He crossed the few steps to stand beside the other.
“I’ll leave thee in peace,” he said, reaching out to rest his hand on Finrod’s shoulder, “to quiet whatever memory it is that accosts thee.”
Finrod looked up at him in surprise, and his blood flowed down like fire from the other’s touch.
“Only promise thou wilt reach for me,” Balan added, “should company be a solace.”
“I will,” he managed as Balan pressed his shoulder briefly, then retreated back up the bank.
Finrod sat frozen on the crag, the river chuckling as it ran along beside him.
He was a fool. How had it gone unseen for so long? All the elements had been there for months, only he must have deliberately held them fractured to avoid acknowledging the picture they formed. How had he deceived himself so thoroughly that it needed the shock of nakedness to break apart his own ignorance?
He felt the hot rush down his spine again at the recollection.
That it was returned, he did not question. He could look back now and see everything arranged in its full image, he could trace the careful dance they both wound through this past year; every word, every silence, every touch ringing through with that steady truth. How had he been so blind?
A man with a wife. His mind reeled at this. No, he corrected himself, a man with a dead wife. Mortality must alter even that bond since that very wife had been another’s first. Esrid was gone, not returning, and Balan clearly did not consider himself bound. It was no different than his own grandfather, he reasoned wildly. Unremitting death must nullify the union and leave each party unyoked.
Unremitting death.
He was suddenly dizzy. The same mortality that set him free set Balan also on the far edge of a chasm, and Finrod dared not look toward its depths. He felt the precipice yawn out before him and his own precarious balance, his mind racing. It was impossible. Oh Eru, why have you sundered your Children? It must be impossible.
He reached down and filled his palms with water, dousing his face to still the reeling thoughts. Not enough. He knelt beside the bank, fetching one handful after another to wash over his eyes, red with unwonted tears, to cool his cheeks, burning under this knew knowledge. Then he faltered, paused. He leaned down and submerged his face once again, lingering beneath the surface as his mind flew back to the discovery, the touch of Balan’s skin, the press of his arms about him, his leg hooked behind Finrod’s knee.
He pulled his face from the water with a gasp, then his lips moved against its surface in a kiss, all desperation and passion.
Had there been no looming difference of kind, he knew he would have scorned all propriety and cast himself to the other’s mercy, even there upon the sunlit riverbank, bound one to the other upon the ground amid the lingering nieninquë. And in his mind, the taste of Balan’s skin was as the fragrance of snowdrops crushed beneath him, sunlight and honey, dizzy and intoxicating.
“Holy Manwë, save me…” Finrod’s voice tore a hoarse whisper through the birdsong and he gripped his face within his hands. “I am lost…”
And then without hesitation, his memory brought him again to the meadows of Tirion and the blossoming nieninquë, only this time it was his father who walked beside him.
“Love is choosing,” Arafinwë had said, a stern undercurrent to his words. “A marriage is for the life of Arda, my son, it is not a thing of whim or fancy, nor yet always of passion. It is chosen companionship and chosen partnership. Thou art fond of her?”
“I am. Of course I am.”
“Then be bound knowing that, and the rest will come in its time. It is a good match, Findaráto.”
“I know it is. And there is love, atar, only…” Finrod’s voice had trailed off as he realized he could not possibly articulate to his father this gnawing doubt that made him hesitate. Since his youngest days, he had known little of what it meant to be a prince of the House of Finwë. All his childhood was passed in the carefree twilight of Alqualondë, excepting the occasional formality of court, or when they joined his kin for the First Gathering of Fruits. He had been shy and reserved on those visits, fearing the inevitable teasing from his cousins when he spoke out of turn or was ignorant of a custom. Cullingwincë, they called him. Little goldfish. It was not until Turukáno befriended him that he felt part of the royal house, and not until Angaráto was born that he had the courage to assert it—ensuring his brother never felt the same uncertainty of place as he.
Ever after that early friendship, he had imitated Turukáno in everything. It was a way of passing for competence until he gained his own, of knowing the ways of Tirion before he dwelt there in his adolescence. Torn between his father’s expectation of distance and Tirion’s expectation of knowledge and poise, he mimicked first the one and then the other till each was pleased with his performance. He followed his cousin’s studies, learning swordsmanship alongside Turvo’s intrigue for the art and dance of it, he studied architecture, learned the planning of cities, mastered the dialogue and form of court. Then alone in the night he would read philosophy, he would slip out on quiet days to wander through the hills and greet the fauna and new growth, he would sing beside the streams and laugh as he watched children chase and play. Then he returned to Alqualondë and donned the old facade, taking up the mantle of his father’s mediation, the calm analysis of ethics and theology, and the light banter of Olwë’s court.
So engrained in this pattern had he become that when Turukáno courted Elenwë, Finrod found himself quickly following suit and setting his own attentions on her sister. It came naturally enough—she had been a student of philosophy and he was drawn immediately to the conversations they shared, discussions and theoreticals that bored his cousin when he tried to engage him. But Amarië was versed in all of these and her mind sharp and eager, finding the same intrigue and challenge in these debates that drew him ever back to the study. It was not long before they sought each other out independently of Turvo and Elenwë’s visits, and soon the expectations of all around them were clear.
But this had brought the crisis. Finrod had followed in his cousin’s steps for so many years that he was left wondering whether he loved Amarië indeed or whether he merely enjoyed her company and had moved forward in imitation of Turvo’s marriage. Would he have chosen this for himself without his cousin’s leading? Or was this little Cullingwincë flittering again after the other’s example?
“I will wait yet awhile,” Finrod had said at last, his eyes straying to the far mountains to avoid his father’s gaze. “That I might know with certainty.”
“There is never certainty, Ingo.” Arafinwë’s voice was gentler now and he smiled at his son as he lapsed into the affectionate address. “But that is not a fault. Tarry in pursuit of it and thou wilt wait all thy days.”
Finrod had tarried, and so he had lost.
But he sat now, an exile beside a far off river, and felt in his bones a certainty he had not known hitherto. There was no question anywhere in his soul as to the veracity of his affection. He loved him, this strange and unexpected mortal, with a ferocity and passion that left him shaken.
He had been governed all these years by the expectations around him, seeing himself ever through that lens alone, till all others saw him through the same. Until Balan, new and baffling and utterly other, had shattered through the mirage and handed his own self back to him through another’s eyes. May goodness dwell in your household.
“And health be the drink at thy lips,” he whispered to the water.
“Nóm!”
“Nóm, there are horses!”
“We’re to fetch you back!”
Avina and a cluster of children came tumbling down the bank, breathless and bright-eyed as they clambered toward him.
“There are so many horses, Nóm!”
“Can we ride them? Like when you took us on Váya?”
“I want to ride on my own!”
“You can’t ride on your own, Avi, you’re as small as the rest of us.”
“I’m taller than half of you, and stronger than all of you.”
“Vatta said none of us could ride without—”
“One at a time,” Finrod interrupted, laughing. “I cannot follow a word of it till you tell me what has happened. Are my kinsmen here?”
“With a whole host of horses!” Avina stepped forward as the self-appointed representative. “Why have they brought horses? Are these your shoes?” She held up the discarded boots they had collected from the top of the bank.
“Yes, thank you.” Finrod smiled as he took them from her and slipped them onto his feet. “The horses are a gift.”
“A present!”
“Who are they for?”
“Do we get horses?”
Finrod laughed again and lifted Avina up onto his shoulders. “Come along and you shall see.”
❈❈❈
It was a dozen horses, not a host; and the Ambarussa had sent them by two young grooms rather than attending to it in person. The Atani had gathered in a murmuring cluster about the little herd, though they kept a distance between them and eyed the proud creatures with wariness. Balan broke off as Finrod came into sight and jogged toward him.
“Nóm!”
Finrod felt a flash of adrenaline at the other’s approach and distracted himself by lifting Avina from his shoulders and setting her loose upon the ground. “They’ve traveled with better time than I expected. Ilcamo, Ravandë!” He lifted his hand in greeting and walked toward them with a welcoming smile, Balan trailing beside him.
“Heru Findaráto.” Ravandë greeted him with a formal bow and proceeded at once into a swift exchange as she presented Finrod with a sealed scroll.
Balan attempted to follow the Quenya, but it was a transactional conversation filled with etiquette and technical negotiations, neither of which he had learned in the past year’s study. He contented himself with standing at the other’s elbow, stealing glances at the restless creatures as they shifted about beside the skeleton beams of the Hall. They were magnificent. He had become accustomed to horses during their sojourn with Esrid and Estreth’s people years before, but these were of another kind entirely, sleek and majestic and nimble in every movement. It was nearly a mirror, Balan mused as he watched them, little particulars in these creatures that set them apart from their kindred in the East even as Nóm and his people were set apart from Balan’s own.
“I thought this must be your doing,” he said as he walked with Finrod toward the waiting horses after the formalities concluded. He had shifted back to Taliska in the presence of strangers and was smiling, though utterly baffled. “What are they for?”
“For you,” Finrod replied in the same, and then wondered once again how he had remained oblivious for so long. The gift was extravagant. “Is it not the joy of a liege to provide gifts to his people?”
Balan’s laugh was incredulous. “Aye, it may be, but…” he broke off as they reached the foremost and his voice was awed. “Gods all…look at them!”
Finrod reached out and ran his hand over the nose of the nearest, a shining black stallion standing a full hand above the others. “Aiya, Elmorë, cenital mára ná.” Elmorë whickered in reply and Finrod smiled, guiding the horse’s head toward Balan.
He reached out tentatively and mimicked how Finrod ran his hand along the jawline, smiling in surprise as the horse took a step toward him and nosed at his shirt.
“His name is Elmorë,” Finrod said quietly, “star-night. See how his coat glistens as he turns? Tintallë herself might have kindled it for all its beauty. I remembered him from my brief stay with my cousins ere I found you and thought you would find him a good companion.”
“Nóm…” Balan’s voice was husky as he held back the full emotion while others were gathered close. “He is beautiful beyond words.” Then he looked about the little herd again with incredulity. “They all are and this is a kingly gift. But, Nóm, I’ve not the first idea what to do with them.”
“Estreth will teach you,” Finrod said and nodded toward where she stood at the edge of the gathered crowd, her face unreadable as she watched the horses shift about. “She has that knowledge in her bones, I believe. Which brings to mind…” He trailed off and slipped through the animals until he found the one he sought.
Balan watched as a chestnut mare followed him away from her companions to stand before Estreth. He could not hear what passed between them, but he saw Estreth’s eyes and remembered the stories his wife had told him of their childhood on the plains. How Nóm had come to know of it he was uncertain, but it was the first time in these sixteen years since Esrid’s death that he had seen full, unreserved joy on his kinswoman’s face.
He turned back toward Ilcamo and Ravandë, his hands held palm upward in the custom Finrod had taught. “Please convey to your lords the deep gratitude of my people,” he said in Sindarin. Their converse with Finrod had been in Quenya, but as a condition of learning Balan had sworn not to use it with any others lest his people too fall under the judgment of Thingol’s ban. “We are indebted for this kindness.”
“Your words are honorable, hildor,” Ilcamo replied, “but it was a purchased exchange, not a benevolence. The lord Felagund paid for the herd in full. Your debt lies with him.”
Balan dipped his head in acknowledgment. “I thank you nonetheless,” he said, then returned his attention to Elmorë.
“A dear price it was, if I heard aright,” Ilcamo added to his companion, shifting to Quenya for supposed privacy. “The stallion alone was a king’s ransom.”
“As he should be,” Ravandë’s voice was curt. “Elmorë is a noble creature and I chafe to see him passed to uncouth keeping.”
Balan held back a smile as he marveled again at the creature before him. “You won’t resent me, will you, night sky?” he murmured in his own tongue as he stroked the velvety nose. “Uncouth as I am?” Then there was a rumble of hooves and he looked up to see Estreth ride past, galloping out toward the meadows, hair streaming behind her and her face lit with delight. A group of children ran behind her calling out cheers and pleas to be carried along until she passed beyond earshot, and then they lingered in a little line at the edge of the village, watching her in awe.
“I doubt a gift has ever brought such joy as that,” Balan said to Finrod as the other returned to stand again at his side. “I’ve never seen such happiness about her.”
“I feared it was a presumption on my part,” he replied, then laughed quietly. “It was, she told me in no uncertain terms; but of my many, the one she would find easiest to forgive.”
Balan laughed in turn and ran his hand once again along Elmorë’s head. “Aye, easy indeed.”
Finrod looked over as he stood in the sunset’s flush and his heart ached with the sight of him. He could not take his eyes from those hands, so sturdy and gentle as they passed over the horse’s coat. Oh to take them in his own, to kiss the palms as Balan had kissed his in the dead of winter, only his lips would burn now with that confession he hid even from his own insight. To let those hands move across his own face, the fingers tracing a line, firm and steady, beneath his jaw as they did to this creature he bestowed. Let me bear thee as well, he longed to say, come to my arms and let me hold the tide at bay.
It was impossible. He could not shelter him any more than he could hold waters back from the shores. The doom would come despite any love and it break whatever grip was laid. It would unmake them.
Love is choosing. His father’s voice echoed in his ear and with it he felt his heart shatter.
“Balan,” he said at last, and his voice seemed to come from outside himself, “I must return to my own people.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
Casári: [Q] dwarves
vinyamo: [Q] youngster, young one
nieninquë: [Q] snowdrop
epessë: [Q] after-name or nickname
pánë: [T] small gull, petrel
melotornonya: [Q] “love-brother” (meletorno + -nya)
Airë Manwë, rehtië nín: [Q] “Holy Manwë, save me”
vanwa nányë: [Q] I am lost
atar: [Q] father
cullingwincë: [Q] little goldfish
Aiya, Elmorë, cenital mára ná [Q] Hail, Elmorë, it is good to see thee.
heru: [Q] lord, master
hildor: [Q] term for the Men: after-comers, followers
The Nieninque song is a poem from “A Secret Vice” that Tolkien wrote in 1931:
Tripping lightly on the point of her toes,
thither came little Niéle,
that maiden like a snowdrop,
to whom the air gives soft kisses.
The mountain dwellers came thither,
and the foam-fays like butterflies,
the white people of the shores of Elfland,
with feet like the music of falling leaves.
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
- gaitch: swine
- Vatta: father
MISC NOTES
- Turvo: likely nickname for Turukáno, based off the ones we’re given canonically for the sons of Fëanor.
8. In Memory Untarnished
Finrod had felt the cold creep over him at his brother’s words. It was come, then, as he knew it would from the moment he saw Aikanáro’s eyes across the great hall at Ladros, struck through in a single moment with the shock, the gulf, the sudden rush of illumination and despair.
Aegnor comes to Tol Sirion seeking his brother’s advice as he navigates the complexities of his love for Andreth.
Read 8. In Memory Untarnished

384th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
The Tower of Minas Tirith, Tol Sirion
Finrod stood motionless before the window in his chambers, letting the warm breeze wash over his face as he waited for his brother to join him. Aikanáro had arrived in the mid-afternoon, striding in with his traveling cloak wrapped about him, the mud speckled upon its hem in a stark contrast to the formality of the other gathered lords.
Hanno, I have need of thy counsel.
Finrod had felt the cold creep over him at his brother’s words. It was come, then, as he knew it would from the moment he saw Aikanáro’s eyes across the great hall at Ladros, struck through in a single moment with the shock, the gulf, the sudden rush of illumination and despair. It had been months now, but his brother’s face was as vivid before him yet as in the moment. Finrod’s heart had lurched at the sight as his body recalled the revelation within his own veins and he felt the bond between hröa and fëa shudder, falter. Oh Aikanáro…little Sátinwë, no… With trepidation, he followed his brother’s gaze across the room to rest on Andreth where she stood beside Bregor, her hair falling loose from the braid that swung at her back. She had just released his brother after teaching him one of their dances, leading him careening through the lines with Beril and Bregor close behind, and now stood laughing with the fire’s glow full upon her face.
He remembered when Bëor taught him that dance, and he too laughed watching Finrod’s careful adherence to the whirl of steps and clapping. “Too precise!” he had called as they came up at the end of the lines. “It’s not meant to be beautiful, Nóm, it’s meant to be loud.”
Andreth’s eyes held that same mirth as she looked back at his brother, the same amused affection that noted all his ritual etiquette and laughed it away in a glance. “Leave thy marching for the siege lines, Náro, this is dancing not soldiering.”
Finrod’s breath caught in his throat. He watched Aikanáro step forward and take Andreth’s outstretched hands, his brother’s face as one caught between dream and waking. “Again!” she called and they leapt back into the mayhem, Aegnor’s cropped hair hovering about his head, gilded like the sun by the room’s firelight; hers unraveling from the braid into a rush of night, wrapping about him as they spun. It will snuff him out, Finrod thought wildly, airë Valaron, he will be lost. The room wavered before him and he swayed, stepped back.
“Come outside, Nóm.”
Belen’s voice. Cracked and roughened with age, but Belen’s voice nonetheless.
“Thou and I both could do with the balm of night air in our lungs.”
Finrod nodded wordlessly and took the back of his chair, wheeling him out toward the open door. He was steadied by the press of solid wood against his palms and the rhythmic creaking of the wheels. It had been a gift from Gildor, a decade or more past, when Belen’s old injury began to show its toll. The two had become fast friends during Belen’s time in Nargothrond and Gildor took it upon himself to design and craft the chair when he saw his friend’s persistent suffering. Belen was delighted by the gift, at first using it only when the pain grew dire, then within a few years he came to rely on it fully. “It needs only Váya to draw it,” he teased Finrod when Gildor first pushed him across the village square, “and we’ll have me back to the cart I arrived in.”
Finrod blinked back tears as he wheeled his friend out into the night air. How was that bright, daydreaming boy the man before him now, already old and grey as his father and brother before him? He had grown increasingly feeble of late and Finrod saw the little glances of farewell when Belen took in the world about him. He had not known it for what it was when Bëor’s eyes began that pattern, but he recognized it now as the herald he feared. It would not be long. Finrod brought the chair to rest at the edge of a low wall and moved to sit upon the stone at Belen’s side.
“You saw, then.” Finrod fell back into Taliska without a thought, the rush of memories carrying his tongue along with them.
“Aye.” Belen watched him quietly and there was sympathy in the dark wells of his eyes, so like his father’s. “You must have known you would never be the only ones to face it.”
“I should have, I grant you.” Finrod passed his hands over his face and his voice was tired. “But then, there are many things I should have known.”
“And many you could not till our peoples learned the way of each other. Wise you may be, Nóm,” he added with a creased smile that still carried the roguish mirth of his youth, “but you are not clairvoyant.” They sat in silence until Belen reached out and rested a hand on Finrod’s shoulder. “There were none to tell you the map of grief when you found him. Your brother needn’t walk blind as you did.”
Finrod could still feel the weight of his hand as he stood in his chambers before the open window, and he dashed the tears from his cheeks. Belen was gone. He answered the summons only a few weeks after that final conversation, the last remnant of Thalos, and the grief of it had settled upon Finrod like a winter’s mantle.
“Ingoldo?”
The air in the room shifted as his brother entered and Finrod pressed aside his grief. He could not allow it to guide his tongue. Any admission of his own weakness in this would mark a precedent, and that would serve only to set his brother on the same path to anguish. Silence would be the cost of his former cowardice.
“Aikanáro.” Finrod walked toward him, arms outstretched, and managed a welcoming smile. “Hanno. I am glad to see thee.”
“And I thee,” Aegnor replied as he embraced him. He lingered as he had in childhood, when he would fly to the safety his brother’s arms and nestle against the strong neck, the willowy shoulders, and feel his pain dissipate against the steady heartbeat. Empty comfort now, he thought bitterly. What were the griefs of Valinor—a scraped knee, a cousin’s insult…
“Sátinwë.” Finrod too had been reminded of the impetuous child he once held and he called him by his old nickname, taking him gently by the shoulders as his face softened in compassion. “Come,” he said and led him toward the hearth. “Sit and we will speak till thy burden is eased.”
Aikanáro lowered himself into one of the chairs and watched as Finrod crossed to a small cabinet and retrieved a decanter and two glasses, which he set on the table before the fire. The wine shone like ruby against the flames, the tint dancing over Finrod’s hands as it was poured. As our blood that holds me tied, came the maudlin thought at once, then he reached out and took the cup Finrod offered.
“Now then,” Finrod said and settled into his chair, attempting to minimize the anxious set of his shoulders within its folds. “Tell me what troubles thee.”
Aikanáro sipped from the wine and fixed his eyes on the fire. He had ridden like a gale from the eastern marches of Dorthonion, overcome with the conviction that this tempest within him would ease, if only he could bare it to his brother. Each night the conflict raged as he lay in the dark, each morning the decision remained postponed. He was in two minds at all hours, neither having mastery of the other, until the ground itself felt as rolling waves beneath his feet, and ever his anger grew at his own indecision. Bitterly, he recalled Findekáno’s laugh as Maitimo retorted ask Atandil to his cousin’s crude jest. The three of them had been deep in wine then, relating half-muddled rumors of what their people imagined were the anatomical differences between First and Secondborn. He burned with shame to think of it now—how childish it seemed in retrospect. But “ask Atandil” had lodged in his thought and he lit upon it as his salvation. If any would hear him without laughter, it would be he. And if any would counsel from understanding and not prejudice, surely it would be Ingo, who already had loved and lost and must know the tearing indecision that wracked his heart.
But Aegnor had seen the brief flash of terror in his brother’s eyes when he arrived and declared his need for counsel, the deepening lines that lingered on Ingoldo’s face even after the eyes regained their merry welcome, and he hesitated now with the moment upon him. He had not considered in his mad rush what pain he would delve in the other by his plea. His brother’s eyes were upon him again and he felt the concern growing with each moment the silence drew on. He focused on the dancing fire and carefully, tentatively let the question slip out.
“If…love was to arise between one of the Quendi and one of the Atani, what should be done?”
It was Finrod now who hesitated, mirroring his brother’s earlier motion and sipping from his cup to gain a moment. The question was at once more direct and more distanced than he had expected, and he met it on its own grounds. “By the pair in question or by the lord whose permission they sought?”
“I would find interest in the answers to both,” came the reply, Aegnor still not meeting the other’s eye.
“Then I shall give thee one which serves the twain.” Finrod breathed a silent plea to Manwë, to Nienna, to any Vala who would hearken that they might lend him what strength he had not possessed in his own time of trial, that his brother would not follow after him from the same waiting precipice. “They should part, as soon as may be, ere a bond is knit that cannot be unknit. Naught but doubled grief lies in crossing such a gulf and less pain should there be for both in a swift ending, voluntary and not sundered by what is beyond our power to alter.” The old wound ached anew as he felt the pain seep out from his brother. “Is it a love confessed or merely suspected?”
“It is known,” Aikanáro said; a short, sharp whisper, his heart in free-fall. “Though not yet spoken.”
“That is some mercy, then.”
“It is merciful to abandon? Thou spoke otherwise in Araman.”
Another glimpse of childhood, the tiny fists lashing against him while he soothed the tears, falling hot and angry upon his tunic. Finrod took the blow in silence, even as he had then. “Mercy seeks to spare the other pain—mercy and love,” he said after a long pause. “Is there not as much love, more perhaps, in choosing for the other’s good, though it means a loss for thine own desire?”
Aegnor’s glance was sharp, questioning as he met his brother’s eye at last and saw there only sorrow and compassion.
“Didst thou think it hidden?” Finrod asked gently. “Nay, dear one, I too was there amid the dancing of Bregor’s wedding feast. I saw thee then with the doom writ upon thy face, and I saw her too—bright and eager and the firelight upon her hair. I have known, Aikanáro. I have grieved for thee.”
“Is it certain to be grief, then?”
“What else should come of a union between those whose fates are thus sundered?”
“Surely some joy could be salvaged in what years there would be. She is young yet, even by the measure of her kind.”
“As thou art by thine.” A wave of jealousy rose with the calculation—nearly twice the years they might have to what Balan had lived at his side. He tasted the bitterness like copper on his tongue, fouling the pity it spoke only a moment before, then he shook the feeling away. What would those years have brought save a greater rending at the loss? “There would be joy,” he continued at last. “For a day, an hour…and what then, hanno? Their years are swift as the meadow’s blossoms, passing as quickly as they appeared, and thou left widowed for all the ages of Arda.”
“And yet we do not love flowers the less for their brevity, nor scorn to hold their memory sacred through the months that follow.”
“For we know they will grow anew when the seasons turn.” A spasm of pain crossed his features as his mind leapt to the image of snowdrops in a golden meadow. “There is no returning springtime when they have passed, no thaw to the frost that would settle over thee. It would be loss irreconcilable, beyond even the ending of the world. I cannot wish it upon thee.”
Aikanáro fell silent, turning the wine glass in his hand, and he felt his anger growing as the conversation drew on. This was no different than his own nightly wrestling. Why did his brother say it not? Surely he must realize that others had known. How could they speak till his burden was eased if the very place where their burdens met remained unacknowledged? “What is it like,” he asked at last, turning his eyes intently upon the other, “that sundering?”
Finrod’s knuckles whitened against the cup he held. He shook his head, his face a mask of composure. “I cannot tell thee how it would be.”
“Canst thou not? I thought if any, thou wouldst know.”
“I?”
“Hast thou not taken them as thine own? Did not Bëor dwell long years with thee in close friendship—in thine own household even? If any could tell me…”
“I know not. Long years indeed there must be ere the toll of that cost would be known. How can any of us say?”
Aegnor saw again the flash of anguish in his brother’s eyes, the weary grief of one who contemplates an ever mounting pain, and he faltered in his attack. “Canst thou not guess?” he asked, and his voice eased into a plea.
“What fruit is there in guessing? We may reason this way or that, but it is a pain that cannot be known until it is upon thee. So I deem, at least.”
“That hurt I would bear gladly, that her life might be spent in joy.”
Finrod felt the echo of that heady devotion within him, the memory of its fervor reverberating through his bones, and he was drawn back in an instant. He saw the dark eyes looking up into his own, radiating delight as he pressed in against him, the contentment of the sturdy hand slipping into his, that same hand sprawled lazily across the linens of his bed while Finrod traced each finger with his lips, marking the lines of home, of peace. Indeed, there was no questioning then, only conviction and light and longing. There was only Balan beneath him, Balan tangled in his arms, the sharp gasp that set his own soul on fire, igniting a deep, burning need to give, to love, to offer up the world in nourishment for this strange heart beating within his own. Then, as with every memory now, the hand shriveled as he watched, fell limp, the linens drew up in a shroud. He shuddered and stood, crossing to stand before the fire.
“Gladly thou thinkest now,” his voice was little more than a whisper as he watched the dancing flames, “but thou hast not yet felt her slip each hour from thy grasp, nor watched as new creases appeared upon her face, new lines across her hands, marking every year that draws her relentlessly from thee. Thou hast not yet known her eyes dimmed or her voice cracked and roughened, nor yet felt the steady hands quaver, frail within thine own. Nor hast thou wrapped her in ever thicker blankets because the chill of age would not relent.” Finrod’s voice broke and he gripped the mantle’s edge before him. He was treading too near. “I have seen it in all those first friends I loved, each one gone now beyond the bounds of Arda, and naught I do can ease the loss of them. But still thou wilt say this pain thou wouldst bear willingly, and I confess I too see the draw of such reasoning. But know that she would bear it as well. Men were not made to dwell so, with their fate set thus starkly alongside our own so that it must appear only an ill in the comparison. What trials would weigh upon her should she live at thy side and see only herself slipping away, while all eyes were upon her marking the speed of her years? She is proud and self-reliant, Aikanáro, as are all the line of Bëor. Would she not suffer to find herself an object of our judgment and pity?”
“We could flee.” The light in Aegnor’s eyes had taken on a fevered intensity. “South, east…there are wide lands yet beyond the scope of our leaguer.”
“And return to that which her people fled? Where death’s shadow lies yet more heavily? It would but lessen her years at thy side, to say nothing of those you would leave behind in your flight. And being bound so, dost thou imagine thine own grief could be concealed? She would know it each day thou marked a change in her and would feel every instance a new wound in her heart.” Finrod’s face grew brittle as he spoke. “And when she is gone, memory would make a mockery of thy joy, each moment bound ever in the knowledge of its ending.”
“She would not be memory only.” Aegnor spoke softly, hesitant now to tear at the unacknowledged wound. “She would be carried too in the eyes of any children. Surely that is a balm worth the cost.”
“I know not,” Finrod said and he was reminded again of that last conversation with Belen, loss compounding loss. “We’ve no certainty yet whether a child would be possible from such a union. And were it so—“
“Ingo!”
“And were it so,” he pressed forward, holding up his hand to quiet his brother, “which I do believe to be the case, remember where thou art. Wouldst thou bring a child, fragile and first of its kind, into the knife’s edge of war? The dam is ready to burst.” He gestured toward Aikanáro’s cropped hair. “Or is thy demeanor mere habit and no longer conviction?”
“Thy words are harsh.”
“War is harsh. The sundering is harsh.” Then his voice softened as he looked on his brother. “I would not have thee think otherwise.”
“Tell me, then,” Aegnor said, and his voice was tight, deadened, “what is thy edict?”
Finrod was silent. Then at length he crossed to kneel beside him and took his brother’s face gently within his palms, turning it to meet his eyes. Their faces shone together in the firelight, the kinship leaping across and grief mirroring each upon each. “There is no edict, Sátinwë,” he said at last, using again the childhood name of affection. “Thine is the choice before thee. But know this, dear one: love is not negated by sacrifice, nor is its beauty dimmed by restraint. There is pain before thee on either path, and upon both there lies a parting that will far too soon bare its teeth.” Tears pooled against his hands and Finrod wept as well to see his brother’s misery, its counterpoint throbbing yet within his own heart. “But thou hast asked my counsel, hanno, and it is this: take thy parting now while it is a choice thou canst make willingly. So may at least some of the pain be spared for you both, and you may hold memory untarnished, joy preserved rather than watching each as the gulf takes its wages while ye are powerless to hold time in check.” Finrod smoothed his brother’s hair back as the face crumpled before him and his own voice broke to a whisper. “If it was within our power to bridge that chasm, to knit together that gulf so that our fates were shared, we children of the One…dear kindred heart, I would have done so long hence.”
Aegnor’s last restraint broke at these words, the nearest admission he knew he would receive, and he slid from the chair as his brothers arms wrapped about him—and Sátinwë wept unhidden upon the safety of his shoulders. But there was no comfort now in the rolling heartbeat, only the steady sound of slipping time.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
Sátinwë: [Q] fire-spark, from sá and tinwë
Airë Valaron: holy Valar (pl)
Hanno: Quenya. “brother (diminutive)”
9. Vassal
“I would give everything to thee, but not as a stray once smiled upon who ever after limps hopefully at thy heels; to be some brittle leaf, wind-tossed and in its delusion of flight thinking it might reach the sun. Nay, there is no choosing for me, Nóm, thou knowest my choice already—writ as plain upon my face as in the thoughts I know thou hast seen. I do not ask thee to make my choice, I ask thee to make thine own.”
But when a year had passed Felagund wished to return to his own country, Bëor begged leave to come with him
Read 9. Vassal

311th YEAR OF THE SUN, LATE SPRING
Estolad
The scent of fresh timber rose sharp and warm through the breeze. Balan shifted the wedge further down the trunk and swung the heavy mallet against it, watching in satisfaction as the crack cascaded along the length of the wood. It eased him to send his anger shivering through the log’s veins, splitting it open instead of tracing the growing fissure within himself. He shifted the wedge again, lifted the mallet, swung.
The others had left off the task hours ago and he was quickly losing light as well. But it was a relief to work alone. With none about, it mattered little if he let his mind lie blank, filled only with the rhythm of splitting and shaping wood. It dulled the helpless despair that had clutched at him this past fortnight, ever since Nóm announced his imminent departure. Besides, working alone meant any task he completed lay free from that tangle of memories, gathered now like thorns about the whole of Estolad. How was he to live on here in peace when every hut, every clod of earth, every lintel and hearth stone bore the memory of Nóm’s presence? When every pillar of the growing hall pulsed still with his touch?
Here was the sheep pen he built with Baran, the hazel branches curved between the posts where he wove them in supple patterns. There was the boulder beside the well, shaped in the image of Eimet’s hound. Hathus joked that it had a similar profile when the hound rested beside it one day and Nóm had carved it into the likeness, mouth hanging open in a canine smile and the tongue lolling out toward the water trough, much to the amusement of the children who now quibbled for turns riding upon the stone back. Even the shirt he wore now bore its own hoard of memories. It was overlarge and thus had been passed to Nóm after the Orc skirmish, until his could be mended or replaced. This same cloth that rasped Balan’s skin had pulled taught across the other’s shoulders; the embroidered hems, gold and red against the fading blue, had felt the soft touch of his fingers as he explored their intricate motifs. Now it hung loose over Balan’s frame, the patterns rolled up above his elbows, the only touch his clinging sweat.
The blows fell with increased furor as he tried again to drown out the riot of thought. But the weariness of the day had grown heavy and his stroke fell akilter, knocking the wedge loose to strike against his shin. He swore and dropped the mallet, reaching down to rub the bruise as he murmured imprecations at log and tools alike.
“Vatta.” Baran had approached quietly and now stood just across from him in the shadow of the rising Hall. He had scrubbed himself of the day’s labor and appeared irritatingly fresh and cool in his clean tunic and britches. “Come away, you’ve worked long enough.”
“Nay, I’ll finish this last.”
“Vatta.” His son reached out and grasped the haft of the mallet as Balan moved to lift it again. “It’s enough. Let it lie for the night.”
“I said I’ll finish it.”
It needed only a light tug for Baran to pull it free of his father’s grip. “If you were any other, I’d have ordered you off the work entirely. You’ve driven yourself past exhaustion in pursuit of it—and for what? There is no urgency to raising the Hall, and it would bring only hardship upon our people were you needlessly injured, or worse.”
Balan glowered at his son, wiping away the sweat that dripped into his eyes. “I’m in no danger.”
“You sleep poorly, you eat less. Then you spend every hour driving yourself to the brink here in order to begin it over again the next morn.” Baran set the mallet aside with the other tools, then turned back toward his father. His voice lost its air of authority and became quiet, almost boyish. “You think we don’t notice, but we’re all keenly aware. We’re worried for you, Bel and I—and madja too.”
Balan looked up as though seeing him for the first time in their conversation, and was chastened to note the lines of concern running through his features. “I’m sorry,” he said at last, stepping back from the half-split timber. “I’ll leave off. I’ve no wish to cause you grief.”
Baran nodded and dug the toe of his shoe into the loose dirt, turning over little furrows in distraction. “Whatever it is that’s gone awry,” he added after a long hesitation, not meeting the other’s eye, “resolve it ere he’s gone. We need more than the ghost of you.”
His father’s brows drew together in surprise, but Baran had turned and made his way back toward the village before Balan knew what to reply.
Others could see it too, then. He looked down at the little pattern of lines his son had left in the soil and admitted there was some comfort in knowing the distance was not merely the invention of his own private worry. Yet that comfort came at the cost of confirming that his fear was grounded. Something had gone awry.
He reached the well and dragged the cover from its mouth, lifted the bucket from the hook beneath the thatch, let it fall into the dark.
A pause.
The distorted splash, echoing up to wash through his ears.
Every action was slow and deadened, as though he sat outside himself, observing his body in its accustomed patterns. It seemed to move apart from his own thought in a way that both mesmerized and disturbed him. He watched as his hands grasped the rope, passing one over the other in a lethargic ritual, until the bucket reached the top and he grasped its handle, pulling it to rest on the stone ledge. His eyes fixed on the water rippling within its bounds and it took a conscious act of will to move forward and dip his hands under the surface. This was what awaited. A life with his soul broken out from his body, his body a muscle memory of what once impelled it. He was fractured already, he realized. From the moment his spirit leapt out toward Nóm’s, it had never fully returned to him. Some burning, vital part of himself was caught within the other’s breast, and he had little heeded the absence while some bit of Nóm’s spirit had lodged too within his own, making up the difference. But the loss of him brought the loss of that as well and Balan felt a crack opening in his very being.
He plunged his face into the bucket to clear the haze, splashing water over his neck and running the drenched fingers back through his hair. He was a coward. For nearly a year he had burned with this certainty of devotion, the settled tranquility of love, but never a word of it had crossed his lips. And now he stood silent still while his heart’s desire had closed him out, and would within a few short days be gone beyond any hope of retrieval.
“Fool,” Balan spat at his reflection. “Spineless sheep.”
The mirror image looked back at him, rippled and distorted, the haggard features mocking his passion. The very thought was laughable. Vigorously, he scrubbed his arms in the water to break apart the likeness. What would a confession have gained but to turn Nóm from him even sooner at the shock such a ludicrous notion? He could not bear to see the disappointment wash over the other’s face, as surely it would, a blended pity and offense as he took in the presumption. Then Balan felt his gut go cold. Of course, that was precisely what had already occurred. The mingled thought, Balan’s increasingly transparent affection, his unguarded flirtation amid the snowdrop blossoms…how had he imagined there was anything left to confess? Nóm had seen it all and had closed him off in disgust. Here was the fault line of their rupture, and it was all of his own doing.
The mortification bore down upon him and he wished in panic that the other’s departure was at once rather than several days hence, that he might never have need to face him with this knowledge burning shame through every fiber.
But no, Baran was right. To let Nóm depart with this unresolved would leave an open wound till his last years were spent. He must know the truth of what caused their breach or he would ever wonder if it had been naught but his imagination.
He drew the cover back over the well and set off for the woods, knowing without question where the other would be found. When Nóm began avoiding their afternoons along the riverside, Balan had at first joined him on the little bluff overlooking the flax fields. But the distance had grown palpable, their silence no longer held companionship, and Balan found it a greater pain to trace that rift together than to avoid those times alone entirely. Which, in turn, had led to the furious productivity that now filled his days.
He saw the clearing through the trees ahead and drew a breath to steady himself. The dizzy fire still ran through his veins whenever he neared the other, and approaching now with his intent in mind set it burning through his gut as well—sharp, tickling adrenaline that brushed nausea along the base of his stomach. He neglected the customary nudge of thought as he crossed into the fading twilight. Nóm too had eschewed the practice these past weeks, instead making his approach deliberately audible so as to render it unnecessary. The absence of this was the final blow that convinced Balan his fears were grounded and there had indeed been some rupture between them. Never since Nóm’s arrival had he been without that steady presence at the edge of his mind, dipping in and out with a familiar intimacy that Balan coveted. And then when it had gone, he felt the world crumbling in upon him, the blank despair of a life stretching ahead without any remission to the solitude.
His heart ached as he neared and saw the other silhouetted against the sky. Nóm sat upon a broken crag, his knees drawn up before him and arms wrapped loosely about them. He was still as a carved image looking out over the valley below, the occasional ripple of wind through his hair the only sign of movement. Balan was breathless at the beauty of him; breathless too at the helpless dread that he would never again come upon him like this, vulnerable in the intimacy of this year’s camaraderie, and his eyes traced over the other’s form, gleaning every detail for the winter’s famine. Only he gathered now with no hope of spring.
Nóm turned as the gaze passed over him and, despite Balan’s fear, there was warmth in his weary smile. “Glad am I to see thee, meldonya,” he said, then his brows drew together in concern. “What is it, Balan? Thy face is a portent of woe.”
“Tis plain enough, I’ll grant thee, but surely not so ill-featured as that,” Balan retorted, unable to hold back the wry quip.
“Aye, and thy tongue a blithe fiend ever parrying my concern.” A wash of mirth eased Finrod’s features, but the disquiet did not leave his eyes. “I’ll not be diverted. What weighs upon thee?”
Balan hesitated. The momentary relief of their easy exchange had dulled his anxiety and he wondered again if it was not all of his own imagining. Then he recalled his son’s words and forced himself to meet the other’s eye. “Lord,” he said quietly, “have I offended you in some way?”
Finrod’s face fell, stung by the formal address. “Offended me? Nay never, Balan. Not in word or in deed.”
“I am eased to hear it." Balan traced the toe of his shoe through the loose soil in an echo of Baran’s earlier gesture. “Nevertheless, I cannot but fear something has gone amiss between us. You were my dearest friend, closer than any other I have known. You knew my heart ere I uttered it, understood it ere I laid it bare. You see me with a clarity I could scarce imagine and by such have drawn me out into the fullness of myself, whole beyond hope, joyful beyond measure.” The pointed formality failed him and he fell back into the intimate address. “Yet now thou hast fenced me out. We speak in trivialities, as acquaintances meeting in the day’s tasks, passing naught of consequence between us. I see thee shy away from our earlier points of friendship, I enter and thou soon wilt find cause to depart, I speak to thee and I feel the doors tighten. What wrong have I done thee, lord? Tell me—where is the hurt or what have I broken? Name it, I beg thee, so that in knowing I might see some road to mending it ere thou art gone from me.”
Finrod had grown increasingly distressed as he listened. “Ai, Balan, this is my doing,” he broke in as the other finished, his voice wrung with regret. “There is no hurt, my dearest friend—at least none of thy causing. Naught hast thou broken; indeed, if any have done so, it is I. I too have treasured thy companionship above all others, for as thou hast named, so too thou hast done: in thine eyes I am seen with a discernment that brings me near to healing. Bless thee for it, Balan, never have I felt such till in thy company. And forgive me—I thought to lessen the pain and instead I have furthered it.”
”To lessen it?” Balan’s voice was incredulous. “By what conjurings didst thou imagine distance should cause aught but heartache?”
“By a gradual tapering…it was a selfish assessment.” Finrod looked down at his hands as he spoke. He had been turning a twig about in his fingers and he fixed his gaze on its smooth surface, his voice quiet. “Keenly shall I feel the loss of thee—and coward that I am, I sought to ease the parting by degrees, not thinking how that might seem to thee. I have hurt thee, whom above all I would spare from grief, and I am sorry for it.” His voice faltered and he squeezed the twig hard within his fist until the wood bit the flesh. “More sorry than I can say, to have thus squandered our remaining hours.”
Balan felt the barriers crack, a brush of warmth, the familiar touch behind his eyes. The other’s remorse rippled over him, and with that intimacy he felt his own heartbeat return. The world about him lived and breathed and had form once again through the rewoven thought. Beyond Nóm’s head he saw the stars glimmer through the oncoming twilight: Anarríma, Soronúmë, Telumendil, Wilwarin, the Valacirca…his heart faltered. Their hope was cold, their comfort lost. What was it Nóm had said upon that other hilltop, all those months and leagues ago? The Seven Stars triumphant in the north, proclaiming we are not abandoned. How then could he—the only semblance of a messenger the Valar deigned to send them—sit here now, bright against the evening sky, his head crowned with that same silver sickle, and speak level words of his own coming desertion?
It was not desertion. Balan forced himself back from his own passion to reason once again as a chieftain. For Nóm to remain with them would be the true act of abandonment, choosing leisure and joy when his obligation lay bound to his people. They were neither of them free, and thus there was no avoiding a break. The only choosing was where it should fracture.
Finrod shifted aside to make room upon the outcropping, a tentative smile offered in contrition. “Wilt thou join me now, late as is my asking? Or is it thy preference to remain the brooding presence at my back?”
His voice drifted through the other’s musings and Balan heard the smile within it. His heart kindled his resolve and any hesitation burned away.
“I will join thee,” he said and walked forward to stand before the king. “If thou wilt grant me leave. Let me return with thee.”
“To Nargothrond?”
“Yes.” Balan’s courage melted away at the stunned tone. His mouth turned dry and he felt the carefully practiced words cleave to his tongue. “Let me be sworn to thee,” he managed hoarsely and held out his hands, pressed palm to palm, as he knelt. “As whatever thou wilt—servant, soldier, stable keep…”
“Stable keep!” Finrod hesitated for a moment, then reached out and moved Balan’s hands apart, holding them open upon his own. “Balan, I would have thee as a friend, not a servant.”
“I would follow thee as either, lord, only send me not from thy side.”
“Loth indeed am I to do so. But how can I accept any further troth? It is owed to thy people, and tis not mine to claim what is theirs by right. Should sheep be robbed of their shepherd just as they are set within a new pasture?”
“Baran will lead them.”
There was a long silence as Finrod considered. His heart had leapt into fire at the thought that the parting might yet be forestalled, that there could be years more in the solace of his company, in the warmth, the— He shook his head to clear it and focused on the other’s words. Baran had hardly crossed into manhood, this was a daydream not a solution. “He is young for that yet, is he not?”
“Not for our folk.” Balan shifted uncomfortably at the half truth, then shrugged. “Well, perhaps more than is usual. But he is older than I when I took it up, and already the better leader. I promised to bring my people through the passes, to find for them a land where they might prosper, and I have fulfilled that bond. Why should I now keep my son from flourishing only because I refused to relinquish what never suited me from the start?”
“Balan…”
“I am made to follow, Nóm. I understand this of myself as truly as I know the sun brings warmth and water may both quench and suffocate. All these years I’ve led not from my own nature but from necessity, and now that I may, I would set it aside. Baran is ready.”
“And so thou wouldst follow me.”
“I would.”
“To dwell among my people.”
“Aye.” Then he added, as though in justification,“Thou hast dwelt among mine.”
Finrod nodded, his eyes darting over the hilltop as he sorted the racing thoughts. “It is very different from this.”
“So I’d surmised.” Then a sinking thought crossed Balan’s mind and his face clouded. “Or is it my difference that concerns thee? That thy people wouldst think thee shamed by uncouth company?”
“No!” The lines of his face stood out in sharp disapproval. “Thou hast heeded overmuch the discourtesies of my cousins’ folk. Thy company is ever a balm, ever my joy—indeed the greatest I have known.” He reached out to cup his hand against Balan’s cheek, and the prickle of beard against palm sent lightening dancing down Finrod’s spine. “But I fear to draw thee away from thy folk, or to set thee isolated in a strange kingdom, caught beneath the hills like the ghomennin’s prey.” A wan smile split his lips at this last and he withdrew his hand, moving it back to rest against the crag once more.
“Thou hast my soul already, ghomenno,” Balan murmured, halfway between jest and confession. “What more is there to take?”
Finrod looked up at him and for a moment he wavered. All, all, all, he longed to whisper into the tangled midnight of his hair, to gasp across the curve of his lips, every remaining day of thee; soul, body, heart... It was only by an iron clamp of will that he held back from falling to his knees before the other, that he might set his cheek once more in the valley above his hip and feel the arms twined again, tight vines about his shoulders—only this time he would beg never to be released.
Instead he gripped the rock beneath him and sought strength from its rigor, cold against his palms. There was only anguish upon the road he desired. An hour’s joy, a moment’s ecstasy, and then the long march of grief in its wake. Any love would surely be drowned in those bitter waters. Nay, it was better to be as this bedrock, solid and immovable, a sure foundation over which the years passed as wind through the meadow. Let the will be stone and not fire, for stone could yet be carved into beauty, a lasting remembrance of untasted love.
“Thy joy,” Finrod answered at last, “thy peace and contentment would be taken. Dearest Balan, I fear thou wouldst but resent me in the end, should I yield to my own wish—and thine, and grant thee leave to ride at my side. Thy place is here, thy peace is here.”
“My peace? What peace should I have save at thy side? Anarinya thou didst name me, there in the deeps of winter. And elenya thou art to me, the light that binds me to hope, which holds my eyes in the night, which steadies me in the darkness. Do not take that hope from me.” His eyes were bright, pleading, and he knelt again on the crumbling limestone. “I would not be parted from thee.”
“Nor I from thee.”
“Then lord,” Balan held out the clasped hands again, an edge of desperation creeping into his voice, “wilt thou not accept my service?”
Finrod hesitated as the hands hovered before him and grew dizzy with his own vacillation. After all, could he not maintain their current stasis in Nargothrond as well as here? Let him be sworn as a servant and lean on that boundary where resolve alone might fail. There would be grief still, of course, but surely…Finrod reached out and took Balan’s hands within his own. They pulsed warm against his palms, the honeyed brown vibrant within his own pale fingers, and he knew himself close to acquiescence. Then a shadow passed over his face and he moved them back toward the other and released his hold. “I dare not.”
Balan crumpled before him. “Then tell me!” he cried. “Tell me what thou wouldst have me do.”
“How can I? Counsel I may give thee, yes, but to judge for thee? No creature may do that for another without compromising the integrity of both.”
“Counsel? Thy counsel is to speak yea from one side of thy mouth and nay from the other. Be not parted, but remain not too near. Go forth, but remain ever in my place. How is this counsel?” Balan had risen to his feet as he spoke and flung out his arms in resignation. “Tell me. What is it thou wouldst have of me?”
“Ask me not!” Finrod did not meet his eye. “I know not, even for myself.”
Balan’s laugh rang out, bitter and unnaturally bright. He turned away.
“It is no lie. All my thoughts are in confusion, my senses run scattered when I would lay hand to them. I know not how to discern my own wish, much less distinguish upon which road lies the wiser path.” Finrod's eyes darted over the grass and his hands rested clenched upon his knees. “My heart tells me this truly, at least: I want thy friendship.”
Balan’s shoulders stiffened as he remained looking out over the precipice.
“Nay, Balan, hear it not coldly in the crossed understanding of tongues. Companionship lies nearer, I deem.”
“But ever from afar.”
“I would not have it so.”
“Wouldst thou not?” Balan turned back at last, his face wrung with feeling. “Then bid me stay by thee. I would follow thee anywhere, dost thou understand me? I would give up everything, leave all of this if only to walk beside thee for one day—yea, for one hour longer. But I cannot choose it if thou wilt not accept it.” He passed a hand over his face and his voice caught as he continued. “I would give everything to thee, but not as a stray once smiled upon who ever after limps hopefully at thine heels; to be some brittle leaf, wind-tossed and in its delusion of flight thinking it might reach the sun. Nay, there is no choosing for me, Nóm, thou knowest my choice already—writ as plain upon my face as in the thoughts thou hast so lately scorned. I do not ask thee to make my choice, I ask thee to make thine own.”
The air was thick with the responding silence. Finrod sat motionless, his eyes fixed on Balan’s, his lips parted in anticipation of speech that would not come.
“I see.”
“Balan…”
“Yes is a simple enough word.” Balan’s face was etched with the fury of his grief. “Athon. Sá. Nai, even. But I see thee instead pondering how to explain without wounding me. No matter. It is the blow struck in silence that fells the swiftest. I take my leave.” He turned abruptly and walked back toward the village.
“Balan, wait. Balan!” Finrod watched him fade into the trees, but sat frozen in place upon the stone. “Melmenya…” his voice cracked as he whispered the last, long after Balan was beyond earshot. And then his own despair crashed upon him.
❈❈❈
It was deep night by the time Finrod returned to the village. At first he could not, for the wave of misery left him weeping incoherently on the hilltop, his hands pressed to the grass and rock where Balan had knelt. Then he dared not, for he feared to face the other again in the aftermath of their quarrel. He would not meet forgiveness there, for he had seen Balan’s eyes and knew that cutting glance well enough to expect little quarter from its fury, and to cross him again in anger was equally unthinkable. So he lingered long hours on the unyielding rock until he knew all would long since have sought their beds. Then his feet led him by hesitant and winding paths back toward the sleeping village.
It was peaceful in this little wood, beneath the blanket of night. The aroma of wet earth and burgeoning leaves washed through his senses and he let his mind run loose among the sounds of skittering creatures and the cries of night birds in the branches above. It reminded him of his former wanderings, the early days of their arrival in Beleriand when he meandered for leagues upon leagues, every leaf a new discovery, every call a song unheard, every light through the trees the possibility of revelation. His heart caught in his throat once again. Could he ever again wander light-hearted and free through Endorë’s forests, when each clearing held the memory of Atani fires?
As if in answer to his pondering, he reached the edge of the thicket and looked down into the village below. His judgement had been wrong—a fire burned yet upon the common green, marking that not all were abed, and a single figure sat hunched beside its coals. Finrod’s keen sight sought out the face.
Balan, awake and waiting yet, keeping vigil with the embers.
A pang of tenderness stabbed through him at the sight and he caught his breath, reaching out to steady his hand against a nearby tree. It was even as he first saw him, peering through the trees, the fire’s glow sharpening each feature, the warmth of him radiating out through the night. How his heart had leapt at that first glimpse, and at the sound of Balan’s voice that drifted toward him in song, both music and features plain but pleasant and captivating him in an instant. Finrod had loved him even then, he realized as he watched him anew through the branches.
“Holy Manwë,” he whispered into the midnight air, “have pity upon us. Guide me now, I beg of you. Grant me wisdom in my great need, ere my feet falter in this confusion and set all amiss.” But he was not Findekáno, and no eagle flew either to stay or to speed him. Only a sleepy sparrow, disturbed from slumber, flitted from her nest to his arm and chirped at him in drowsy confusion. Alémi, he recalled Balan’s words as he watched the bird hop along his arm and fly back to settle on the branch above, Little Sparrow I named her in her mother’s tongue.
Oh Balan, Anarinya, beloved…what a life of loss. And now he too would add one more to that ever-growing tally, compounding that grief which he longed only to comfort. Balan, Anarinya…
Finrod stepped forward from the trees, crossing the distance to the dying fire as though walking in a dream. Balan did not look up as he reached the light, nor even as he crossed to stand before him, to sit at his side with their arms touching lightly as they had in the golden afternoons beside the Celon.
He did not look up until Nóm’s voice drifted through him, sound and caress, word and action.
“Yes.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
Anarinya: [Q] my sun
Elenya: [Q] my star
Athon: [S] yes, I will
Sá: [Q[ yes
Nai: [Q] perhaps
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
- Vatta: father
- Madja: aunt (mother’s sister)
MISC NOTES
- For an explanation of the ghomennin, see chapter 2, Grief in All Her Guises.
10. A Shifting Mirage
“I have felt this role devour me, each year it has claimed; and as I watch you now I see its echo—the years it is kept from you devouring you in the same way. Why should I hold from you, my son, that which destroys me and would prosper you?”
Finrod and Balan say farewell to Estolad and begin the long road to Nargothrond.
Read 10. A Shifting Mirage

311th YEAR OF THE SUN, LATE SPRING
Estolad
“What does this mean?” Baran held the chieftain’s torque resting across his palms where his father laid it. His brows furrowed as he considered the twisted bronze and his voice was perplexed, laced with a vague unease.
“Nóm departs for his lands the morrow after next.” Balan kept his tone measured, but in the hushed mist amid the Hall’s framework it seemed to reverberate at twice its accustomed volume. “I intend to set forth with him.”
A tangle of expressions crowded over Baran’s face and for a long moment he stared at his father in silence. Then he gripped the torque in a fist and held it back toward him. “No,” he said at last. “I am not ready.”
“You’ve held more than half my duties since well before we walked the mountain passes—and all of them this past fortnight or more.” Balan set his hands behind his back, refusing the returned circlet. “You have long been ready, my son, and will make a far better chieftain than I.”
“The morrow after next…”
“It was decided over-late, I know.”
“I asked you to find resolution so that we might have you whole, not that we might lose you utterly.”
“It is not utterly, Baran. We will have need of an emissary among them as we settle, as Marach’s people and the Haladin make their way over the mountains; and I have his trust, I speak their tongue more than do any of our folk—save Belen perhaps, but I’ll not send him away so young. Please hear me when I tell you I choose this path because of my duty, not so I might shirk it.”
“You choose this path because you cannot lace your own boots without him there to smile upon it.”
Balan fell silent, stung by his son’s unexpected vehemence. He shifted his weight from one leg to the other and looked about at the skeleton beams of the Hall. They were unearthly in the morning mist, rising in sharp reprimand as though fingers of his ancestors had reached from the ground to point in accusation. It was a morbid thought and he shivered in its wake, shaking off the creeping unease that nested between his shoulder blades. “I know what it is to receive this without warning,” he said at last, his voice subdued. “I too was given headship of the clan long ere I expected it, and with as little warning as you. And for that I do beg your forgiveness. The suddenness of this shall ever be my regret. But I have felt this role devour me, each year it has claimed; and as I watch you now I see its echo—the years it is kept from you devouring you in the same way. Why should I hold from you, my son, that which destroys me and would prosper you?”
Baran made no reply. His jaw clenched against the warring emotions and his father watched as the face gradually hardened to steel, and felt his heart sink. It was the same expression he recalled from Baran’s childhood, shoring his tiny strength against the loss of his mother and taking up far more than his six years should bear. Balan felt his own determination waver at the thought of leaving him once more to navigate a new wash of responsibilities, billowing out from another parent’s loss. Was this after all a selfish indulgence?
But then he remembered Esrid’s voice as she held their son, rocking him gently while he slept against her shoulder, a boy of three summers worn out from a tempest of will. She had smiled up at Balan when he entered and murmured, weary and amused, “A will of iron, this one. He will be a good heir for your people, though I fear he must chafe at the waiting.”
She had seen it even then, and Balan could not deny the truth of her foresight. If he remained now, weary and burdened as he was, they would grow at odds as the years drew on. Baran had a clear vision for their people’s future in this land, and vision should be paired with action in one hand rather than divided between the two; with one dragging the other forward by reluctant degrees. Their people would flourish under his leadership, this Balan knew without a doubt, and a clean transition here at the start would give him the best foundation to bring that about.
“I know you’ve little wish to hear my reasoning in this moment,” he said gently, and reached out to lay his hand along Baran’s cheek, “but know that I do not choose this on a whim. I feel the conviction in my very soul: this is the path laid before me. I would follow it for our people, Baran, and serve them in the best way I might, that they too may have the chance to prosper—and you with them.”
“Cannot Nóm advocate for us himself? He has knowledge enough.”
“He will. But there is much yet for him to learn, customs and needs he would never think to consider. Our ways are as strange yet to them as theirs to us, and I could not abide our people falling at odds through misunderstanding if it lay within my power to dispel it.” Balan’s heart ached as he looked upon his son’s profile, outlined against the dissipating mist. In so many ways the face was his own, recalled from the water’s reflection of his youth, yet the mouth was Esrid’s, the eyes as well, and both were set now in a mirror of her resolve that he had never dared to cross. Yet he too bore stubbornness in his blood and his own certainty here was unshakable. He drew his hand back from the caress and held it extended toward his son. “I am determined in this, Baran, and I shall go, both for your sake and for the sake of our people. Only, if I may, I would go with your blessing.”
Baran’s face softened at this, but still he did not meet his father’s eye.“My love remains, as you are my father; and my duty you have, as I am your son. I give you my permission also, for I see you are set on this road and I do hear the reason in what you propose, much as my heart quails to think on it. But blessing sticks in my throat, vatta. Forgive me, but I cannot give it.”
His father kept his poise with an effort and the outstretched hand fell back at his side. “That is a fair concession,” he said heavily. “More indeed than I had hoped. And both love and permission shall I treasure through every step hence.” But his voice caught as he turned and his steps were slow to bear him back toward the village.
“It will break Belen, I fear.” Baran’s voice slipped after him, a quiet lash as he reached the Hall’s perimeter, and it dogged him through the remaining days.
His fear was grounded, Balan reflected as he stood watching them, his few chosen possessions stowed in the pack and saddle bags, and Elmorë lingering with Váya at the ready. Baran stood sullen and quiet, his shoulders set and the torque polished now and gleaming about his neck, while Belen hovered beside him, eyes red-rimmed and puffy. The past two days had been a whirl of preparations and discussions, and then the long draw of pointed silence as the specter of absence edged near. Balan’s resolve had nearly failed in the face of the parting, but he pressed down the growing dread and held steady; until at last he stood before them, lingering on the threshold of departure and unsure what farewell might be welcome.
Belen had not begged him to stay his departure, and that was perhaps the hardest to bear. If he had, Balan knew he could not have held his course. But Belen had been quiet when his father confessed his intent, nearly frozen—a fawn who felt the lion’s eye. “I understand,” were his only words, and then he left the hut to wander through the meadows, keeping company with the bay mare he had chosen from the herd.
“Carry this for luck.” Bel stepped forward from Baran’s side and pressed a pebble into his father’s hand. “For safety, rather,” he added, and Balan looked down at the stone upon his palm. It was shaped as the talismans of Esrid’s people and bore a thin line of characters carved about its circumference. He remembered finding a nearly identical charm tucked into the folds of Geberic’s tunic; placed there by Esrid’s fingers in the dawn light, only to be retrieved by Balan’s when evening came and he carried her husband’s body back from the field of battle. He felt his heart contract as Esrid’s son bestowed a twin talisman now at his own venturing forth and he reached out impulsively to gather Belen in his arms.
“You will let me follow, won’t you?” Belen’s voice was muffled against his father’s shoulder and his embrace clung tight. “One day you will send for me?”
“I would bring you with me now if I knew aught of where I was going,” Balan whispered against the thick nest of hair. “But your brother will have need of you, wise heart. And so too shall our people. But yes, my dear one,” he added as he held him close, “I will send for you when I may.” He cupped Belen’s face within his hands and drew it up till he could set his lips in blessing between his son’s eyes. “May goodness keep you, Belen, and mercy preserve you.”
Then he stepped back and turned toward his elder son, crossing hands over chest and dipping his head in salute as he stood before him. “May goodness keep you, Dar Baran, and mercy preserve you.”
“And the gods’ favor grant you sure steps and a swift homecoming.”
Finrod waited beside the horses, watching as Balan moved through the formalities of departure. First his sons, then Hathus, and on to the others who stood as elders among the clan. It held an air of unreality as he observed each rite and farewell. He saw the motions, he heard their words, but he could not yet envision Balan lifted out from among them and grafted instead at his side. It was a dream, surely; and he shuddered to think what waking would hold.
“So then, you will snare him from his people after all?” Estreth’s voice rose up in accusation beside him, quiet and fell.
“It is his wish.”
“And what is his duty?”
Finrod hesitated, then shook his head. “That is for Balan to discern.”
“Has he not sworn us to you? Are you not our lord to command him in his duty?”
“In some things, yes. But not in the rule of his people, nor yet in when he chooses to lay it by.”
“It is a poor king who holds not his vassals to their bonds.” She turned away. “Look to your own duty, Felagund.”
The unexpectedness of the epessë struck any rebuttal from his tongue and he watched with consternation as she strode back to her hut and closed the door. He knew he should not be surprised at her vitriol—of all the Atani her trust had been the hardest to win—but the bitterness of such a farewell left him heartsick. He thought back to the winter’s laughter, the five of them huddled together around Balan’s fire to thwart chill with company, and trading stories over the cracking embers. He had recounted many tales from his childhood as they passed the endless hours and spoke often of his own sister whom, he added with a grin, Estreth’s bright stubbornness brought ever to his mind. Fitting, she retorted, since his tediousness recalled Balan without fail in her own. It was friendship at last, however grudgingly.
A bitter farewell indeed.
“Her anger is with me, Nóm,” Balan had crossed to join him as he stood lost in thought. “It may strike at thee, but I am the offender. Let not that blame weigh upon thy departure.”
“It lies with me as well, and rightly so. I could command thee to stay.”
Balan cast a glance over his shoulder as he lifted a last bag onto Elmorë’s back, part challenge and part defiance.
A smile escaped Finrod’s lips despite himself. “No indeed, I would not have dared.” He watched as Balan secured the bag to the saddle bow, then stepped forward and unfastened Elmorë’s reins from the halter, looping them into a coil and passing them to Balan. “We will walk to start, I think. An easy pace and a chance also to bid farewell to the land.”
“Aye,” Balan said and stored the coil amongst the other baggage, little hiding the relief that passed over his features. “As thou wilt.”
“Thou art ready?” The question was soft, the voice brushing through him as the other’s hand rested upon his shoulder.
“No.” Balan shook his head, his expression resolute. “But if I linger any longer my feet will never find the road.”
Finrod nodded and gripped his shoulder. “Then come, Anarinya,” he said, releasing him and stepping forward, “for I would have thee at my side.”
“For all my days,” came the answer, then he followed as Finrod led them out through the opened palisade, not daring to look back lest his resolve falter at the last.
❈❈❈
“At some point I will need to teach thee.”
They sat at ease on the banks of the Celon, eating fresh bread and goat’s cheese while the horses grazed nearby. Meyla had set the parcel in Finrod’s hands that morning with a murmured blessing, then turned away before her tears could show. When, come midday, he opened it at the riverside, he felt his own heart twinge at the contents. The cheese was carefully wrapped within a square of beeswaxed cloth, tied with braided switchgrass, and drizzled inside with honey and herbs. It had been one of his favorites during the many meals he helped her prepare and the gift was bittersweet. He smeared another portion over the bread in his hand and glanced at Balan, who sat eying Elmorë’s height with wary appraisal.
“Sooner rather than later,” Finrod added, an amused glint in his eyes, “if we’re not to walk all the leagues of Beleriand.”
“Aye, fair enough.”
This time Finrod laughed outright at his look of apprehension. “He is a good-hearted creature, Balan, he’ll do thee no harm.”
Balan made a noncommittal sound and slipped the last chunk of bread into his mouth to avoid further comment.
“Hast thou truly never ridden? Even in thy time with Estreth’s people?”
“A donkey now and then, when I was a lad,” Balan mumbled around the mouthful, then paused till he had swallowed and washed it down with a draught of mead. “But never anything so imposing. I recall Esrid teaching Geberic before they were wed, but we were long gone from her people and their herds ere she and I had friendship enough for the learning.”
“By that measure I should have taught thee months ago upon Váya.” Finrod wrapped the cheese within its cloth and tied it once more with the braided grass. “I have been remiss.”
“By which measure is that, lord?” Balan’s voice was innocent, but the lines about his eyes crinkled in mischief as he finished the last of the mead and brushed breadcrumbs from his lap. From the corner of his eye, he was amused to note the color rise in the other’s cheeks and a grin escaped his own lips at the sight. He had understood nearly at once that Nóm’s yes was one of fellowship accepted, admitting nothing further; but the desperate grief of their quarrel had been confession enough to rekindle his hope, and Balan found it left him strangely emboldened. Whereas before he would have doubted these accidental slips, now he accentuated them. Where once he feared the affectionate banter would unmask his ardor, now he savored the possibility of exposure. What had he to fear from truth? Confessed or not, they belonged to each other, Nóm and he. They were formed of the same clay, he would have said had the other been of his own people’s tradition, and all their lives till now but one long endeavor to return each to the other.
Balan stood and broke the other’s hesitation with a smile, beaming down with the noonday sun. He held out a hand. “Teach me now, ere I lose the nerve?”
Finrod laughed as he let Balan pull him to his feet. “I knew not that it had been found.”
“Gaitch.”
His fingers lingered a moment beyond decorum, held lightly within Balan’s. The palm was warm, pleasantly calloused, slightly sticky from the mead’s residue and the honeyed cheese. Lightly, it pressed against his own in return as he tarried, then slipped from him as Balan moved aside to kneel at the riverbank and clean his hands.
They had not sat together beside the Celon since their afternoon amid the snowdrop blossoms and Finrod felt his heartbeat rise to see him beside the water once more. What madness had taken him, he wondered as he watched the ripples shift Balan’s skin to a mirage. All his reason had told him go, fly from the beckoning edge, pull back ere the precipice claimed him, and yet in his very flight he had clasped danger to his breast. He edged nearer the sheer drop, not back from it, and with each step tested his balance, poised as he was on the cusp of the fall. Where now was the defense in quitting Estolad when what he purposed to flee walked yet at his side, imbued since their outburst with an equanimity he had not born hitherto? Balan moved with the easy confidence of one who saw and knew his belonging beyond a doubt; quiet, assured, and his boldness took Finrod’s breath away. It both frightened and intoxicated him to be thus claimed in secret. Knowledge gleamed beneath the surface—affection, devotion, desire too, and it hovered warm and constant between them, the ever-possibility, never named and always known. A shifting mirage undergirding every movement, even as Balan’s skin beneath the dancing eddies.
As if in answer to the other’s musings, Balan stood and shook the water from his hands. He dried them on the edge of his tunic as he walked back and chuckled at Finrod’s expression of solemn introspection. “What is it I’ve done now to set thee pondering some new riddle?”
“Naught.” The laugh mirrored out from Finrod’s lips as well. “Only thou art as thou art, and I am very glad of thy company.” He reached out and took Balan’s hand within his own, walking beside him toward Váya and Elmorë where they grazed in the open grass. He could flout the line of friendship as well as the other, he thought with his own spark of mischief, his veins afire as their fingers twined together. Here through the long leagues they could tease fate, knowing the foretaste if never the consummation, beautiful and perfect in its unbroken potential.
Finrod released him as they reached the horses and stowed the remaining food in Váya’s saddlebags alongside the bundle of tokens he carried out from Estolad. There was the food Meyla had given, a set of carved bone skates from Baran, a warrior’s arm ring presented by Hathus. Eimet had given him a hollow wooden block, marked with various designs across its surface, and played with three carved finger-caps that drummed out rhythms upon the outlined notes. Belen had bestowed a similar pebble to that which he gave his father, only when he set it in Nóm’s hand he tried to explain it dispassionately as an artifact of curiosity, a tangible sampling of lore to carry along with him. This Finrod carried in the pouch at his side, cherished near his person even as Belen’s father kept his own. There was also the garland of braided clover blossoms that Avina had set about his neck, and he wore it still, the white petals nestled in sharp contrast against the deep blue of his tunic.
Both tunic and garland fluttered in the breeze as he retrieved the reins and fastened a pair once more to each horse’s halter, beginning an explanation as he went. “We do not use a bit, as I’ve heard Estreth describe it. These are for converse between you, not for domination or control, and they may be set aside entirely at need. It is trust between creatures, a bond of mutual dependence and respect, that must ever lie at the heart of horse and rider.”
“And how is that achieved?” Balan asked, reaching out tentatively as he approached.
“Thou hast his affection already,” Finrod replied as Elmorë stepped toward Balan’s outstretched hand. “He has followed thee without question all through the morning, despite thine avoidance this past fortnight. The rest will come with time.”
“That was not spite, night sky,” Balan murmured, falling gently into Taliska as his palm met the warm velvet of Elmorë’s nose. “You were the arrival of his departure, do you see? It is hard to befriend the herald of loss.” He ran his hand along the gleaming coat, scratching beneath the jawbones as Elmorë nickered and nudged his head in against his chest. Balan laughed and ran his other hand down along the neck, a gentle caress. “Forgiven, then?”
Finrod smiled as Balan murmured to the creature before him. He was reminded of watching Hathus hold his newborn daughter in their camp along the Thalos. Hathus, ever gruff and solid with his blacksmith’s arms and warrior’s gait, would soften in an instant whenever the tiny bundle nestled in his arms. The broad shoulders curved in protectively, his voice shifted to a soothing rumble, and his hands with their iron grip traced lines down the tiny nose, across the rosy cheeks. So too Balan’s movements were modulated as he drew his hands along Elmorë’s neck, scratched beneath the forelock; his voice low and quiet. Finrod felt his own ear twitch as Balan’s hands passed over Elmorë’s and, not for the last time, he found himself wishing he could spend an hour in the horse’s place, receiving that tenderness with no thought of fate or propriety, doom or duty.
Balan, uncanny creature, seemed to sense his mood and reached out to brush his hand affectionately over Finrod’s forearm where it rested upon Elmorë’s saddle. “Well?” he said, moving to stand beside him and taking the reins from the other’s hand. “Tell me how I manage this.”
Finrod laughed. “By trusting Elmorë to manage it for thee. But here,” he said, stepping aside so Balan had a path to the saddle, “keep the reins loose in that hand, then one foot here in the stirrup and on up as thou hast seen me do. Settle thy balance with the saddle if thou hast the need, but hold to it lightly and do not haul thyself up. Push rather, for it is the duty of legs, not arms, to seat thee.”
Balan nodded and steadied himself with a breath, then swung up into the saddle. Elmorë took a step forward as he settled into the new burden and Balan clutched at his mane in reflex. Balanced atop the shifting creature, he was even more grateful that Nóm had seen his earlier unease and spared him the ordeal of riding out from Estolad with all his gathered kindred looking on.
“Do not pinch with thy knees.” Finrod’s voice cut through the apprehension and he tapped his palm gently against Balan’s shin as he shortened the stirrup length, then ducked beneath Elmorë’s neck to adjust the other. “Relax into his movement rather than fighting to avoid it. If he consents to bear thee, he will not let thee fall.”
“And how am I to know if he’s consented?”
Finrod glanced up at him, baffled but amused. “He would never have allowed thee upon his back otherwise. Rest down into the saddle,” he added as he moved to stand again at the side, placing one hand on the small of Balan’s back, “and do not clutch at the top like that. Thou and he should move as one creature together, not he a rushing wave with thou perched helpless atop the crest. Bring thy leg back,” he set the other hand upon Balan’s thigh and pressed lightly until it shifted down under his touch. “There. Thou shouldst hold a line from thy crown through to thy shoulder, thine hip, thine heel.” He touched his finger in illustration to each he named.
“Rest into the saddle thou sayest, then sit stiff as a pole. Thou art an ever constant paradox.”
“Nay, they are not in conflict.” Finrod grinned and rested his hand once more upon the other’s leg. “It is finding the balance in walking together as thou hast by nature upon thine own feet. Imagine for a moment that Elmorë vanished beneath thee. Thou shouldst fall on foot not flank, and find thy landing sure.”
“By which you mean don’t fall on my arse,” Balan retorted in his own tongue, then gripped tighter with his legs. “Is he likely to do that?”
Finrod chuckled at this, but did not dignify it with an answer.
“Scoff if thou wilt,” Balan retorted, “but I’ve known thee to disappear amid the trees ere my eye had left thee. How then should I guess but that all creatures of thy company might be fay as thou?”
“He is flesh and blood as I am flesh and blood,” Finrod replied with amusement, “as thou art flesh and blood. He will not vanish from under thee.” He stepped away and swung up onto Váya’s back in an easy motion. “Hold the reins so,” he raised his own hands in example and turned each where Balan could see. “Lightly—and do not use them as a rope to hold thee. Remember, they are for converse, not control. Hold with thy legs.”
“My legs, but not my knees; steer, but do not control…aye, aye, my paradox, and I suppose I shall fly next and yet have no wings to lift me.”
“Aye indeed,” Finrod said, flashing a merry smile over his shoulder, “as Estreth before thee. Padra,” he called to Elmorë and Balan’s heart leapt to feel the stallion step forward, like the earth shifting beneath him. And then they were moving together—he, Nóm, these marvelous creatures—a steady current through the waving grass.
❈❈❈
It was on the third night out from Estolad that the weight of the parting settled over Balan.
They were camped for the night beside the confluence of Celon and Aros, and Nóm had left him with the horses while he ventured into the woods to supplement their fare with foraging. Balan sat with his feet dangled into the current, listening to the chattering song as Aros danced through a course of rocks to merge with his brother’s path. They had ridden late into the evening, for Nóm wished to reach this mark before they ended the day’s travel, and night had fallen ere they stopped to rest. Balan stretched his legs as they bobbed in the water and a hissed grunt escaped him at the twinge through his muscles. The soreness had begun to ease as the first days passed, but he yearned for the dismount long hours before evening arrived, and every morning he woke anew to freshly stiffened limbs and a deep, incapacitating ache.
The first morning after their departure he had fallen back onto his bedroll as soon as he tried to rise, a sharp string of profanity drifting up from the rumpled blankets. Nóm had looked over at him first in concern, then in mild amusement as he identified the malady.
“I did warn thee,” he had said with a sympathetic smile and crossed to sit beside him, “but thou wouldst ride the whole afternoon through despite it.”
“I did not wish thee to think me faint.”
Finrod laughed. “Little fool,” he murmured affectionately and eased him over onto his stomach. He pressed his palm firmly against the offending muscles, drawing it up in a slow path from lumbar to ribs; then along the opposite side and back once more, humming words in his own tongue that Balan could not quite decipher. The ache receded by degrees and he found after a short time that he could sit again in passable comfort.
These moments of impulsive tenderness left Balan flushed and light-headed. The last weeks’ distance had evaporated almost at once in the sound of Nóm’s yes echoing through the midnight air, and in its place appeared an easy intimacy, settled and fierce, as natural as drawing breath.
An owl called out through the twilight, mournful and curious. A fish leapt in the waters before him. He was reminded of a verse he chanted to Baran when his son was a boy of only a few summers. He would climb up to ride on Balan’s back as they walked and ask for it over and again until Balan could recite the lines with hardly a thought for what his lips formed. He found his tongue still remembered the pattern and the words hummed from his lips as he looked out over the water.
“Why do you swim, asked the boy of the fish of the riverbed?
I swim for in water lies the way of my kind. Why do you ask?
I ask for in questioning lies the way of my kind.
Why do you leap, asked the fish of the fox of the field?
I leap for agility is the way of my kind.
Why do you run, asked the fox of the deer of the wilderlands?
I run for in fleetness lies the way of my kind.
Why do you hunt, asked the deer of the wolf of the ravaging?
I hunt for to hunger is the way of my kind.
Why do you soar, asked the wolf of the hawk of the firmament?
I soar for in flight lies the way of my kind.
Why do you go, asked the hawk of the Man walking under him?
I go, said the Man, for in wandering lies ever the way of my kind.”
Balan’s voice broke at this last and he stood abruptly, the storm looming over the edge of his senses. Why do you go…Baran’s own words on the morning of his departure and he had not placed them until now. Balan stumbled blindly toward where he left the saddlebags, nestled under the protection of a willow tree, and rummaged through their folds until his fingers found what they sought. A lump of wood, smaller than the width of his palm, shaped into the likeness of a curled otter. He carved it for Baran when he was hardly past infancy and he could still remember the little hands grasping at it with fumbling fingers, the toothless smile gumming over the curved tail. But Baran had pressed it into his father’s hand at their parting and met his eyes with a gaze of steel. “Remember who you are,” Baran said to close their farewell, the otter’s feet marking dents in Balan’s palm as his son turned away.
He held the little figurine to his lips as the wave rushed over him. The days since his decision had been so filled with preparation and possibility that only now had the full barrage of grief struck him down.
He had left them, his beautiful boys.
He had set them fatherless as well as motherless and given them hardly a moment’s warning before he too was taken from them. The gods only knew when he might ever hold them again. He was weeping aloud now in great gasping sobs, supported against the tree with one palm pressed to the bark and the other clutching the little otter to his breast.
There was a flicker of concern, a warmth trickling through his thought, and it was no surprise when Nóm appeared behind him after a few minutes’ time. He took hold of Balan’s arm and eased him back from the tree, turning him gently until he rested instead against his chest, wrapping his arms about the trembling shoulders. Balan leaned into him, letting his grief run loose, and slowly, haltingly, he inched his arms forward to wrap around Nóm’s waist in return.
Finrod passed his hand over Balan’s head, moving his fingers along the scalp in steady strokes—fingertips together at the forehead, spread wide across the crown, drawn together again at the nape of the neck, as his grandfather had comforted each child in turn in the twilit years beside the sea. “Dear heart,” he murmured into the shroud of hair, his heart rent by the other’s grief, rent too as he spoke what he feared would mend it. “We will go back. I will take thee to them. I judge thee not that thy path leads from me, now the parting has unmasked its toll.” His hand traced down Balan’s back, gently following the arc of his spine where it dipped between his shoulders. “I yield thee.”
“Nay,” Balan shook his head against the other’s chest, gradually regaining mastery of his voice. “It forms as our feet move upon it—the path before us. And mine shall never lead me from thee, not until it leads no further.” He felt the arms tighten about him at this last and leaned in against the warmth of him. “I do not regret the choice, Nóm. It is only that I have never been from them, not even for a night, and I parted from Baran in conflict. With hardly two day’s warning—and what is that but a mere handful of hours—I left him to hold all that I forsook, to be both father and brother in my absence. I dare not hope he will ever forgive me.”
“He may,” Finrod said, shifting to cup Balan’s face within his palms and drawing him back to meet his eye. “He will, I believe.”
“I have little confidence in it.”
“Then lean upon mine.” He brushed his lips briefly against the top of Balan’s head as he leaned once more against Finrod’s shoulder. “I know well the anger he carries, how it stings and seethes through heart and vein. And I know too the bitterness of yearning for authority, only to receive it in such a way that but cold comfort is found in the acquisition.”
Balan was reminded then of the rush of memories passed through the dark on the Longest Night: the bitter desolation of the ice, the last glimpse of those who turned back—another father leaving his burden for a son to bear. “Does it ever ease?” he asked after a pause, setting his eyes on the carved figurine once more in fear of what answer he might read in the other’s gaze.
“It does. Though every feud is different.” Finrod’s hand drifted to the twined serpents about his finger, turning the ring absently as his eyes followed Balan’s to the toy resting upon his palm. After a moment, he slid the ring loose and set it upon his own outstretched hand. “I told thee once that I treasured this above all other possessions. But long I carried it in spite, donning it each day as a point of pride and private reprimand toward the one I wished bore it yet in my place. I was angry with my father for many years, Balan. My ire burned toward him for his actions, toward myself for my regret. We had never spoken so to each other until that moment, there in the frozen wastes with scourges and not tongues between our teeth—and those the final words that passed between us.” He paused, sliding the ring back onto his finger, then added. “Indeed the last that shall ever pass between us, unless Námo should relent and the Doom release us. If I may confess it, Balan, knowing thee now upon this road is a balm I knew not was wanting. I never saw my father’s grief at the parting, only his anger and the hostility of our break, but in thy mourning I can believe his. And through that I find the forgiveness I’ve admitted rings more easily now in my heart.” He reached out to set his hand alongside Balan’s neck, the thumb tracing the line of his jaw. “Baran loves thee, Anarinya. And his love, I deem, bears a greater hold than his anger, long yet though that may burn. He will forgive thee in time.”
Balan shook his head with a scoff, his voice unsteady once again. “We are both stubborn, he and I. I dare not hold such certainty.”
“Then I shall hold it for thee.” Finrod drew him once more into an embrace and Balan breathed deep, calmed by the scent of him, comforted by his warmth, steadied by the solidity of the arms woven about him. In his palm he felt still the bite of the otter’s paws where his grief pressed them into bruises, and he held that soreness fast, an anchor binding him when all else shifted illusive. Remember who you are.
❈❈❈
In retrospect, Balan recalled these weeks as a long progression of heady contentment—each day spent in laughter or music, tale or silence; each evening passed to the sound of Nóm’s song, silver and bright as the star sheen; each night lulled into slumber by the sighing of willow boughs and the solace of the other’s arms draped lightly about him. In the aftermath of his belated grief, Balan found sleep an elusive quarry and he lay restless beside the water, fighting down the tears that threatened to overwhelm him once again. He had felt Nóm’s gaze for nearly an hour before there was a rustle in the grass beside him, a questioning nudge against his thought, an arm eased about him and the warmth of the other’s body along his back. Sleep came quickly after that, and so every night since they followed the same pattern and Nóm would lie the night at his side, an arm draped over him, the pain of loss eased by degrees as the other’s presence steadied the tempest.
They followed the path of Aros until he ended in the Fens of Sirion, riding through meadow and thicket, hill and flatland; the days passing with a dreamlike fluidity in their cascade of images. The lands rolled out before them, bright and wide, and Balan saw each plant and creature anew with the clarity of the other’s vision. Everything around him grew fiercely, pulsingly alive and he was reminded once more of the night beneath Menelmacar in the hills of Ossiriand, when the other’s voice flowed through him and brought every living thing into his awareness—overwhelming and utterly beautiful.
Tall birch trees danced in the wind, silver leaves and silver arms raised through the sunlight, their dusting of color forming waves across the thickets.
Water laughed beside them as it raced between tight corridors or eased out in wide, lazy pools meandering through the meadows.
The chirping trills of frogs swelled through the wetlands as they neared the marshes, their call passing between them in a ceaseless chorus, filling the night.
A white heron, wings tipped with gold by the evening sun, it’s throaty call echoing amid the grasses as it passed through the willow trees. The willows themselves, with hair billowing loose, creating a labyrinth of secret rooms draped about with walls of fine lace.
Balan watched Nóm move through them, the fronds trailing across his shoulders as he passed, and he recalled the beaded doorways of Esrid’s people. They would hang these as partitions between their rooms and Balan could still hear the rustle of their movement, wooden beads shifting together like the whisper of dried leaves in wind. Esrid threaded one for their hut after Baran’s birth and she had strung little bells amid several of the strands. He remembered the tinkle of the beads moving aside, his wife materializing from the far room in portions, an illusion solidifying into flesh before him.
Nóm glanced back as he passed through the willow’s lace, smiling, the uncanny light drifting out from his eyes.
He was an illusion that did not solidify, Balan reflected, but moved ever as the wind or water, shimmering and shifting, beckoning and elusive. He followed him through the fronds and felt himself dissolve as well, spread out among the trills of the frogs, the whispers of leaves, the glimmer of Nóm’s hair through the draping willow wands.
This was Aelin Uial, he told Balan as night drew on and they lay to sleep beside the shimmering meres, a land woven through with enchantment and the memory of the first Song. “I have slept here once before,” he said, and his voice drifted like a prayer amid the reeds, “and ever after has its memory driven me…on toward some dread fate I cannot see. I fear it, Balan,” he added after a long hesitation, “though it drew me to thee as well; the same voice beckoning me through the wash of Gelion, the laughter of Thalos’ eddies. Heavy here lies the will of the Lord of Waters.”
They crossed the fens before dawn. A pair of ferries shunted them through the clinging mists, soundless and smooth across the water’s mirror. These were maneuvered by three Elves stationed upon each—one at the stern and one at the prow, one last guiding the quant pole from fore to aft. Balan had greeted them in their own language when they appeared from the mist, materializing with eerie speed in response to Nóm’s whistle, and they had answered him, brief and polite. But aside from that greeting they replied little to any of his conversation and at last he lapsed into silence as they glided forward through the fog.
Balan stood with one hand resting atop Elmorë’s shoulder, his fingers scratching lightly over the withers, and watched the foremost in curiosity. He stood a head taller than the others and his hair, waist-long and plaited in an intricate web, gleamed silver in the growing light. Nóm had been surprised at his presence when they reached the ferries and greeted him with cheer, jesting that he must have fallen foul of court to be so relegated to minding the crossing.
“Nay, thy sister bade me come and see thee well.” His face had remained stoic, but the edge of his lips twitched in amusement.
He stood now at the head of the ferry, only a few feet away, and Balan found his gaze returning continuously to that silhouette, the broad, martial stance holding vigil at the prow. Often he felt the dizziness of age when Nóm spoke of his own life, but never had the sheer weight of years born down upon him as it did here in the presence of this stranger. Beside him, Nóm seemed almost a child, merry and young as the sunrise, and Balan was awed at the shift.
“You are of the eboennin?” The voice drifted over the space between them, low and resonant.
“Yes.” Balan found his own voice thin by contrast. “I am Balan son of Beldar, until late the chieftain of my kindred. Though many other kindreds there are as well.”
“So I have heard tell. Angolodh sent word of much concerning your kind. I know of your name, Balan son of Beldar, I know the number of your people and the land of your dwelling. And much beside.” He looked over with the hint of a smile. “Yet I have been curious to make the acquaintance for myself.”
“Angolodh?”
“Ingoldo. Felagund. What name has he used among your people?”
“Nóm—for such we gave him. Its meaning is wisdom in our tongue.”
The other chuckled quietly. ”Then you have but named him as his mother did before you. Angolodh too is wisdom, and Ingoldo the same. Let us hope both, you and I, that it is a name proven in truth, for my lord is little pleased to find yet new strangers planted along his borders.”
The ferry drew up to the far bank and he stepped from prow to shore in a light motion, drawing the rope taught about the mooring post with hardly a pause. “I am Beleg,” he said as Balan led Elmorë out from the boat, “Marchwarden of Elu Thingol, lord of Beleriand. I count it an honor to greet you on behalf of my people, abonnen.”
“And I to greet you as herald of mine.” Balan crossed his hands and dipped his head in salute. “May goodness dwell in your household, Beleg, thane of the king.”
“And Elbereth’s light guide your coming and going,” Beleg replied, then stepped aside to bind the second ferry as it glided to rest against the moorings.
❈❈❈
It was past midday before they found themselves clear of the wetlands. The mists had clung heavily through the morning and their progress was slow till the sun climbed and cleared the air about them. They sat atop a low swell to eat their noontide meal—a collection of tart blackberries, a piece of salt pork divided between them, a few handfuls of nuts, the last of the mead they carried out from Estolad. It was a lazy hour spent stretched amid the sun and clover, and Balan felt the fog’s chill dissipate at last from his joints. It was glorious to lie here at ease under the weight of Anar’s heat, tucked down about him like a blanket after the morning’s eerie start. He half wished they could forego the remainder of the day’s leagues and lie here as they had in the meadows beside the Celon, counting little of journeys or plans and reckoning only these hours together at rest.
“Anarinya,” Finrod’s voice drifted into his ears, “sit a moment and look.”
Balan stretched his arms with a groan, then pushed up on his elbows to look where the other was pointing. The rainclouds had dwindled as the day drew on and the plain before them lay revealed under the brilliant sun.
“Look,” Nóm said as he traced his finger along the horizon, “canst thou see it now that the clouds are lifted?”
“See what? Thy sight is twice mine.”
“Nay, tis not so far. The highlands there, beyond the plain.”
“Aye,” Balan pulled himself up to sit beside him and followed where he pointed, shielding his eyes from the glare. “It holds the haze yet, but I can make out hills…bare-topped but wooded about their shoulders. Why?”
Finrod merely smiled in reply and returned his attention to eating the clover petals in his hand.
“Thine hills, ghomenno?”
He laughed as he finished the clover. “My hills,” he replied, then stood and looked out over the rolling lands before them. “This is Talath Dirnen, the Guarded Plain: all that lies between the arms of Narog and Teiglin. And beyond it the highlands, the Hills of the Hunters. Taur-en-Faroth. These are my lands, Balan.” His voice trailed off and a shadoESFEw of reticence passed over his features. For all those final weeks in Estolad he had dreaded reaching this view, facing out across the expanse that named him king. Duty, crown, the ever-looming siege…every trapping staring back in mockery as he would return alone with half his soul abandoned beside the riverbank. His spirit soared to see it spread before him now.
Finrod turned back with his heart pounding and looked on Balan at his side, draped in the golden light and smiling up at him, and he held out his hand. “Come, Anarinya,” he said at last. “Let us go home.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
padra: [S] walk
anarinya: [Q] my sun
eboennin/abonnen: [S] After-born
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
- vatta: father
- Dar: lord, master
- gaitch: swine
MISC NOTES
- For an explanation of the ghomennin, see chapter 2, Grief in All Her Guises.
11. Many A Dreadful Path
“You ask only such? To place the road to torment within thy palms and send thee forth, dear son of dear sons, unto a death of agony, alone and friendless? Only such!” Nóm’s eyes blazed out in the vehemence of his words. “I cannot, Beren. I will not."
Beren arrives in Nargothrond and both he and Finrod navigate a swath of memories as they determine the path forward.
Read 11. Many A Dreadful Path

465th YEAR OF THE SUN, AUTUMN
Nargothrond
Beren remembered his father telling him of the Bëorian apartments in Nargothrond. He would describe them with a laugh: very pleasant, very Atani—had you lived a century or so past. “You cannot be aught but upright there, Beren lad,” he would say with a grin, “not when it feels as though you’ve all the line since Bëor hanging about the corners, looking on to ensure you behave. An exceedingly comfortable mausoleum.”
“It’s a shrine,” Emeldir had corrected as she walked past, drawing her hand along Barahir’s shoulders. “And don’t be cruel.”
He found he agreed with both assessments as he sat now in the midst of the bed, looking about through the dim light that trickled in from the courtyard. The garden was an uncanny sight in the midst of the city, formed within the perimeter of a sinkhole that had long ago fallen through the shoulders of the hill and opened a sunlit bowl within the caverns. It was around this that the royal quarter was constructed and onto this that the Bëorian apartments looked out.
They were three rooms, set amid the king’s lodgings—a large chamber holding both sitting area and bed, a small study branching off from one corner, and a last room, smaller than the library, which sat two steps down along the far side. Within this stood a bath, carved from the trunk of a tree and twice the size of any Beren recalled among his own folk. It had been relief beyond measure to slip into its depths the previous night, both dirt and chill shearing off into the water’s warmth; and after it he slept all the night through, untroubled for the first time since Doriath by dreams or waking fears.
Though to think back on it now, all the night before seemed a dream in itself, sleeping or no. It had been a week of traveling with his guides through the dark until at last the Doors of Felagund reared up, gigantic and eerie in the gloom beneath the hillside. His senses reeled as they materialized from the trees with the precarious corporality of sleep. He had seen them before. No, there were three here, the lintels straight and not curved, and these doors were hewn of stone. He passed a hand over his bleary eyes and looked again at the apparition before him. No, he did not stand before Menegroth and Lúthien’s hand did not lie cool within his own to guide him on through the darkness. He shivered.
His passage from thence to the halls of the king remained a blur in his memory. The darkness of the gates, the echoing footsteps, a wash of golden light as the inner doors opened and the wide entrance chamber spread before him, tall beyond reckoning, bright as the evening sun, teeming with plants and trees. Many of these latter had been wrought cleverly from the living stone, with leaves of emerald and jade set within their branches. But other plants there were that grew indeed, and in surprising abundance—nocturnal ivy weaving its way along the flowstone, binding about stalagmites and pillars. There was one flower that sprouted throughout the halls; akin to the morning glory blossoms Beren knew from the meadows of Ladros, only the petals of this shone with a rich silver and it blossomed rather as the light faded than with the dawn’s waking.
They led him on through the winding passages, dim after the golden light of the first hall, until he could no longer tell one from the other in the long maze of stone and star-hued lamplight. Beren walked in a daze and his steps faltered as they passed ever deeper into the labyrinth, but a hand was always at his elbow to catch and hold him steady. He remembered little of how they arrived at last, only the shape of the door before him, carved in a vivid likeness of two swans looking back over their wings, their ebony gaze fixed on any who approached. And above them at the crest of the arch wound the same serpents he had known these past five years, twined in their supple dance about his own finger.
He was no longer accompanied by the sentinels who shepherded him from the Guarded Plain. A new warder stood at his side, tall, unmistakably Elven, his shroud of hair hovering in sable waves about his shoulders, his raiment intricate and bearing the mark of the king’s household. He had paused before the threshold, awaiting some signal beyond Beren’s perception, then he pressed his hand to the stile and the great beams swung soundlessly inward.
The room opened out before him and Beren caught his breath at the sight. In many ways it was akin to the halls he passed in Menegroth, but the winding stone forests were merged here with the fashion of the Dwarves—co-authors and not solely executors of another’s design—and wrought throughout with the high craftsmanship of the Ñoldor. Beren could not discern where the natural formations ended and the carvings began, each woven seamlessly into the movement of the other; trees, vines, a rolling sea of hewn waves across the far wall with lithe water birds rising in flight about the circumference of the room. A great hearth cast light across the chamber, but the walls were lined too with a further collection of the lamps Beren saw throughout the caverns, only these threw their dancing light in tones of gold rather than the starlight of the passageways, and this fell full upon the table amid the chamber.
Had Beren not known him already by sight, the image before him would have left no question. The lamplight illuminated all seated at the table, but it gathered and danced about the central figure. It swam within his hair and the golden strands cast it back again in a prism of light, filling the room with hues of his own presence, and Beren felt peace ease through his limbs as he entered and found himself wrapped too within the lamplight’s embrace. Here, then, was the lord of Nargothrond.
“I beg you will pardon the interruption, aran nin.” The Elf at Beren’s side bent in a quick, formal bow. “I judged you would wish him brought straightaway.”
The king froze. The grey eyes had already darted up to meet Beren’s before the first of the other’s words left his mouth, and they held upon him, bright and unsettling as he recalled from his youth among the Ñoldor of Dorthonion. Then a sudden querying wave broke upon his thought, a shock of recognition that cried out in hope, then was pulled back at once with the same immediacy. Beren saw the spasm that crossed the king’s face, the slip of his hand as it returned a goblet to the table, narrowly holding it back from toppling. Then he was on his feet, rushing toward him with his arms outstretched.
“Beren!”
He should kneel. He willed his legs to bend, though knew in the same instant that once he reached the ground he would be unable to rise again. The weariness trembled through every muscle and his descent quickly turned to collapse rather than salutation. But then the king was before him, dropping to his own knees as he reached him, and clasping him in a tight embrace.
“You live.”
At once Beren was a child again, lifted from the heath beside Aeluin where he had fallen, his ankle broken by the rabbit warren that gave way beneath him as he played. He had dragged himself on hands and knees until his strength gave out and the pain overwhelmed him, then lay helpless amid the gorse till night fell, unable to keep from crying as he shivered and tried not to think of the wolves roaming the highlands, the bears that lumbered through the wooded slopes. And then Nóm found him. He, with Emeldir and Barahir and all the folk of Ladros had spread across the heath until Nóm’s eyes at last sighted the boy where he lay. He was at Beren’s side in an instant, lifting him gently into his arms where the child found himself surrounded by warmth and wrapped in the scent of heather blossoms. “Beren! You live.”
Again the clear music of Nóm’s voice, again these same words exclaimed through his hair, again the scent of heather and meadowsweet washing through his senses. A sob escaped Beren’s throat and he clung to the king despite decorum.
“There, my child, you are safe. You are welcomed here, Balanion.”
Beren had not heard his own tongue since his father’s jesting farewell, there too in the gorse beside Tarn Aeluin. To hear it now, an Elven voice with the words and accent of his own people, to be sheltered and not hunted, greeted and not condemned...All the anguish he had held at bay tore loose and the tears came without recourse as he leaned his face in upon the king’s shoulder and wept against him in silent grief.
“Gawarthi, albe vët.” Finrod’s voice drifted down over him, repeating the words of comfort until the tumult stilled. “Gawarthi, sunus eil.”
Gradually Beren’s pride had reasserted itself and he raised his face from the king’s shoulder, subduing the torrent beneath several steady breaths. There were two dark splotches marring the draped silk, the imprint of his own face, and for a long moment Beren could not take his eyes from the sight: his grief made tangible, his pain embraced. Then he dipped his head in deference. “Forgive me, lord,” he managed in a hoarse voice, “I knew not where else to turn.”
“Forgive thee? Beren, my heart is lifted up to see thee safe.” Finrod stood and raised him to his feet. “Indeed, it is beyond hope that I greet thee—“ his voice broke off as Beren met his eyes and he saw there the yawning dark, deadened and hopeless, and his grip tightened about the other’s elbow.
He nearly told the king all in that moment, but he had become increasingly aware of the others’ eyes resting upon them. There were eleven of them yet seated about the table, seemingly forgotten by the king when he rushed forward, and Beren felt the curiosity and evaluation growing in their gaze. He had held his silence and listened as Nóm gave directions for his lodging and care—the Bëorian apartments, a fresh supply of clothing, food and drink brought to his rooms so he need not bear the strain of conversation, no disturbances until at least mid-morning, rest.
Mid-morning had come and gone, to judge by the tone of light, and Beren shifted the bedclothes aside and rose. The thick rugs muted the chill of the stone floor and his feet sank into their depths as he crossed the room. It was bliss after the weeks of travel. A set of clothes had been laid out on the low table beside the window and he retrieved the breeches from this and pulled them on under the linen nightshirt. They were of Mannish cut and Beren chuckled as he remembered his father’s jesting, very pleasant, very Atani—had you lived a century or so past. The assessment was apt. These were clearly from years gone and were fashioned still after the manner of Bëor’s generation, long and loose, binding in about the ankles and waist. He wrapped the long ties about his hips to secure them, then washed his face in the waiting basin and turned to look about the room.
A mausoleum Barahir had called it, and Beren had thus imagined it would be cold and dim, damp as the caverns he knew from the hills about Ladros. But in truth the apartments were lined with comfort, unexpectedly airy, filled with a surprising rush of daylight. Various plates of polished metal had been worked into the stone arches or along the shelves that lined the walls and these caught and reflected the light from within the sinkhole garden, leaving the room nearly as bright as though it sat above the ground. A hearth had been delved in the meeting point of the three rooms, opening out onto each, and a low fire crackled still within its bowl. Beren wondered in passing whether Elven fires carried on longer without tending or whether he had slept in such oblivion that a servant could have entered without his notice and built it up once more after the night. However it came about, he was glad of the flames that danced through the stonework and tempered the caverns’ chill.
He meandered about the room, looking now with curiosity at the shelves which had received only his passing glance in the haze of midnight. They held the expected assortment of scrolls and books—a sampling compared to the collection in the adjoining room—but Beren’s eyes were drawn to the other items laid out in careful arrangement. A shrine, just as his mother had said.
He drew his fingers down the edge of this nearest as he walked along its length. There was an old Atani spearhead, of the sort they used in the long migration, an ox horn, a hrögemetheilit crock—empty, Beren noted with a chuckle as he tipped it and lifted the cork, but marked with the sign of his house traced into the clay. A small portion of wood lay beside it, carved into the likeness of Iuthap, the sun goddess, arms wrapped about her and hair splayed out in rays behind her head. Beside this lay a book, carefully bound and set out in its own place of honor. With a pang, Beren recognized it as the twin of one Emeldir had kept similarly displayed in the hall at Ladros, an heirloom of Belen’s line. She would hold him upon her lap as a boy and read pages from it when the winter’s rain and snow kept them sheltering inside. “It is a fool who heeds not his past, Beren,” she would say at each reading. “Know the path your forefathers set so that in such grounding you may see where your own should diverge.” Beren reached out to touch the binding and longing overwhelmed his heart for the child he had been, the home that was ash, the mother whose fate he never knew.
His eyes drifted to the box beside it. It was the size of his hands placed side by side, and all about its surface were cut rough etchings depicting scenes from his people’s history and legends. His hand moved to the latch, then hesitated as he felt the abrupt conviction of a trespasser setting eyes where none were invited. But the ache in his heart reached out nonetheless, eased by the solace of these familiar designs, this long lacking sense of home. He slid the latch free and opened the lid.
He was intruding. It was apparent at once that this was a personal collection, a little stash of odds and ends that meant nothing to any save their keeper. There was a sprig of dried holly leaves, an Elven glass vial filled with sand, a pebble with early Atani runes scratched about the edges, several other stones of varying sizes, a carved otter toy, a palm-sized piece of a broken mirror, a gold wristband of Elven make, the necklace of an Atani woman.
Beren closed the lid. Then he caught his breath as he looked at the shelf above and saw the instrument sitting before him. The harp was smaller than he thought it would be, intended to rest in the crook of one arm, and constructed from two bent branches lashed each to the other and fastened to a hollow base covered with taut hide. The catgut strings were still wound tight about the pegs, but a wide crack had split through the base and left the instrument unusable. He ran the tips of his fingers along the arms, the wood coarse and rough-hewn. It was Bëor’s harp, he knew at once, carried over the mountains from their wandering and laid aside in the woods of Ossiriand, lifted in Nóm’s hands to summon Beren’s ancestors out from their slumbering.
The floor seemed to buck beneath him and he swayed, reaching out to steady himself against the stone shelves. Know the path of your forefathers, Emeldir’s voice recited again—for he too had awakened in the greenwood, called back from death unto life by an Elven song drifting through the branches. The tendrils of despair coiled and dragged once more at his chest, and he fought against them, forcing breath back into his lungs. But what hope now, when that which brought him back from the deadened haze was sundered beyond that very wall of darkness? Beren stood frozen in memory, one hand gripping the shelf’s edge, the other resting still upon the bowed arms of the ancient harp.
So he stood yet when the king found him, his footsteps moving soundlessly over the threshold from the sunken garden.
Finrod’s own breath faltered to see him outlined against the familiar backdrop. The ache shuddered across the jagged edge of his soul, even as it had mere hours before when he looked up from his cup to see Balan’s phantom hovering in the doorway before him. After the initial shock of recognition, he found he could trace the dissimilarities as well, Boron’s ears, not Bëor’s; Emeldir’s nose, which of course had first been Belen’s; the three lines playing between his brows which were Andreth’s—oh Manwë there was no comfort there, only a second wound to prod. But the set of the shoulders, the unruly waves in his hair, the line of the jaw and the curve of his lips, those hands resting upon the same stone shelves, upon the harp his own hands had not touched in more than a century.
How many mornings had he watched Balan linger even there beside the arch of the doorway, the light brushing across his wrists as it did upon Beren’s now and calling out the deep amber of his skin. Sixteen thousand, three-hundred and forty one, Finrod’s mind supplied in agile distraction. Nay, that was the tally of days between the midnight at Thalos’ springs and that second midnight he forced ever from his mind. The number of mornings in this room, then, must be—
“My lord,” Beren’s voice brought him back from the reverie. “Forgive me, I did not hear you enter.”
“My own fault.” Finrod smiled as Beren crossed toward him and the faraway look clouded his eyes once more. “I lost myself to memory, seeing you there. There is so very much of your forefathers wrought together in you.”
A spasm crossed Beren’s face at this and his fingers dug into the opposite wrist, ballast against the threatening flood. “It is a balm, lord,” he managed at last, “to be in the company of one who remembers them with love.”
“Orro, meldonya,” Finrod said softly, laying a hand upon the other’s shoulder, and Beren felt near to weeping once more at the kindliness of the touch. “Come and tell me all, if thou wilt. Much already can I guess from thy demeanor; but come, sit beside me and let it be a burden shared.”
Beren nodded and allowed himself to be led to the long bench before the hearth. Like the bath in the adjoining room, this too had been carved whole from the trunk of a tree, the seat and backrest following along the bending grain of the wood. Cushions were piled along its length in a motley assortment, some of fine Elven silk, others adorned with the vibrant embroidery of his own people. He sat upon the far side and lifted one of these latter into his lap, absentmindedly wrapping his arms about it for comfort. The king took a place near him and though he did not gather up a pillow of his own, his fingers traced over a line of needleworked bears in the same pursuit of solace. Beren saw the grey eyes rest upon his father’s ring for a long moment before they moved up to meet his own, grief resonant in their depths.
“He is gone, then?”
Beren nodded as he searched for his voice. “Five years past.” His voice was little more than a whisper, and he watched the lines etch deeper in the other’s face. It was strange, he thought, to see grief mark the Elven features like age.
“This is loss beyond words,” the king said in a hollow tone, then matched conduct to speech and let silence rest between them, his hand shifting from the embroidered bears to press absently against his side. The quiet drifted through Beren’s heart and he felt the ice-hold on his spirit ease to share in lament with one who too had known and loved what was gone. For unlike Lúthien who mourned indeed at his side, Nóm shared the grief through his own loss, a personal lament too and not solely on behalf of Beren’s own.
He knew not how long they sat thus, two mourners in a long belated rite, but the fire burned low before the king spoke again. And when he did, he seemed to know by instinct what would comfort the man before him, and set his words gently in the tongue Bëor’s folk brought over the mountains. “Little news and late came to us from Dorthonion. I never knew what became of him after our ways parted and he left in search of you. Truly, I believed you all dead till I heard tell of your own deeds—and those only by conflicting rumor.” Shame rippled over Finrod’s face. He had left him abandoned in the charred highlands, this son of his savior, alone in the anguish and solitude. It was little wonder he had not recognized Beren the night before. The face before him was lined with care, the temples and beard touched with grey, a far greater change from the child he knew than time’s passage would account. “I thought often in the intervening years to send a company that might seek you out, but ever I held back lest it draw the eye of the Dark more keenly upon the highlands and bring yet greater adversity than what assailed you already. And then too I knew not whether you lived in truth or if the rumors themselves were but phantoms set to draw us thither. Bitterly now do I regret my inaction.”
“Little would have been gained by open battle,” Beren replied, “for naught but corpses and shadows remained. Yet do not reproach yourself, lord! Even had you sent your soldiers to retrieve me, I would not have been coaxed thence by any promise of shelter. For as my father was, so too am I—it is beyond us to set aside any task once given its charge.” A smile crossed his lips at this, but there was no mirth in it and almost at once he let his face fall back to impassivity. “Death only I wished. And for death I prayed in the bitter nights, looking up at cold Menelmacar in his march over the heath, pleading that he might in mercy set his sword through my breast.” His fingers caught at the twined serpents, twisting them round and back, round and back again, and Finrod saw the callous standing out against his finger, numbering the hours of this restless practice. “Years were gone before I could weep. Four winters before my body would let me mourn. It was Gorlim who gave up our camp at last. Thû laid a trap amid the old village and lured his heart with phantoms—not wrong were you, lord, to suspect such trickery. He saw his wife, he thought, and so was taken, and so put to torment, and so broken at last to treachery. I returned too late. I found only their corpses.”
“Oh, my friend…”
“Death is our lot, my father would jest at each sally against our land’s marauders—wry ever his humor—let us see if he hunts.” Beren crushed the cushion within his arms, staring deep into the hearth’s embers. “Prey were we all—father, comrades, mother, sister…I alone am left of my people.”
“Nay, Beren, knew you not?” Finrod’s face lit with the thought of bringing some hope to the man before him. “They live! Emeldir led them out—through what trials I cannot imagine—but they reached Brethil, and there they dwell yet with the people of Haleth.”
“They live…” The cushion fell to the ground and Beren gripped the king’s arm impulsively. “Nóm, you know this in certainty?”
“I do.” Finrod set a hand on Beren’s arm in return, the ghost of a smile tugging his lips at the affectionate name. How like was his to his father’s voice, how like to Baran’s, to Balan’s…he pulled his mind back. “I sent word urging them to shelter here, but your mother would not tread a league further than need demanded. Yet be assured, as late as the height of Iavas I had word from Elu’s emissaries that she and your sister dwelt yet in safety, and—Beren, is aught amiss?”
Beren’s face had undergone a rapid series of expressions and he held the king’s eye now with a look of thunder. “Thingol knew they lived? And in Brethil—upon his very borders?”
“Aye,” Finrod replied, though he hesitated now and cast his mind back to the exchange. “Or rather the messengers who greeted me had word of it for Beleg Cúthalion is held in friendship with the Haladin. But there is naught gleaned by Thingol’s marchwardens that does not soon pass to his knowledge as well. I have little doubt that he knew. Why? Beren, art thou ill? What is it I’ve said?”
Beren had risen and was pacing before the hearth, his hands clenching open and shut, then dragging through his hair, gripping behind his neck. “If all that passed besides had not been bitterness enough…here, here is his final cruelty. All the while he knew them living and yet he named me spy, creeping snake, broodless pup…” He came up abruptly before the mantel and slammed his palms against the stone wall to emphasize this last, his arms shaking with fury as he held himself in place.
Finrod watched at first in bewilderment, then rose and crossed to rest his hand between the other’s shoulders. “Beren,” he said gently, and felt him flinch at the touch, then the set shoulders crumpled beneath his palm and heaved as he wept in ragged sobs against the stonework. Finrod did not turn him from this, but passed an arm about him for support, all the while fighting to hold his own perceptions firmly in the moment.
Memory had folded in upon itself at the sight of Beren’s face the night before, aged beyond his years into a mirror’s replica of six generations gone, and Nóm struggled to hold the strands of time apart. Beren weeping here against the wall, Balan in his arms beside this same hearth, Beren’s voice crying out his fury, Balan’s thrown back against him as they argued near to breaking, Beren’s hand pressed against the stone—they were the same hands, the shape of the knuckles, the vein patterns across the sinews, the fingers strong and compact—Balan’s hand pressed down against his chest, the weight of Beren supported by his arm, the weight of Balan as he lifted him in his age…ai Valar, hold the thread, find the stillness.
“Beren,” he said again, naming his thought into the present, “Beren. Mellon nín, I know not by what evil paths thy way led thee to such insult, nor indeed how twas possible that thine and my kinsman’s road overlaid—truly that is a great curiosity to me—but it was cruelly said and badly done. From my share in kinship to the house of Elwë, please take these apologies of—”
“Nay, lord, let me tell you first the cause ere your regrets are offered. For I confess, even now I tremble lest you too should perceive it an offense and turn me away.”
“Speak, then, and lay that fear aside. Long years have I known thy people, Beren, and goodly ever have been their ways. So too the integrity of thine own heart is not hidden from me. Naught would induce me to scorn thee, offense or no. But speak it, I entreat thee, for I feel a weight rising about my limbs that I cannot discern, and I dread that specter in the dark. Give it name that I might see it and know its hold. What was it brought thee foul of Thingol’s wrath?”
Beren turned at last from the wall and met the king’s eye, his features drawn with resolve, with sorrow, and these lit within by a bitter joy. In shock, Finrod felt the rough touch of the other’s thought collide with his own, ungainly in its fierce solidity, achingly familiar, and yet approaching with more nimbleness than ever Bëor had achieved. Balan, Balan, canst thou reach out still? Find me, I am here! How had this boy learned so seamlessly? He felt the gasp catch in his throat as Beren’s memory held out an image of summer meadows, of Neldoreth—how well he knew those glades from wandering lighthearted with Artanis ere the winter of sorrow—and he watched as snowdrops spread in waves throughout the grasses. His fingers tightened upon Beren’s arm and the tears tickled as ran down beneath his chin.
“I held out in hope these limbs of death toward that which lives undying,” Beren spoke at last and his voice was clear, resonant, and yet passing barely the distance from lips to ear. “Thingol’s daughter did I meet beneath the glimmering stars in Neldoreth, in summer’s joy, and in the solace of her song my heart was healed—hers the star that called me again to life, and hope found me amid the long darkness.”
The room was reeling.
A rage of jealousy burned through him to hear Balan’s voice speak those words of another. Beren’s voice, he corrected again in growing frustration and fought back the envy. Hold the thread, number the years, bind reason to the present.
“There beneath the starlight she set my hand in hers, she led me out from anguish, broke me free from the long death of isolation…Nóm, I never knew life till in her song, nor myself till her eyes called me forth.” Beren’s voice broke and the light about him faltered. “Lord, who am I now without? And what? What am I to do?”
They stood in the mingled light of hearth and sun, each grasping the other’s arms, each frozen in memory, mirrored rivers upon their cheeks. The long minutes passed.
“Elu knows of this?” Finrod’s voice trickled out at last, a hoarse whisper through the stillness.
“The minstrel told him.” Beren shook his head apologetically. “Forgive me, I mean no offense, I do not know his name.”
“Daeron, I would suppose. Long has his heart turned toward her in fruitless devotion.”
“Daeron. He watched our meetings. We were careless; I from weariness and awe, she from the certain conviction of our love: that it was of the Light and thus unquestioned Good. The king swore to her he would not harm me,” Beren smiled bitterly, “and truly not a single wound did he mete upon my body. But here the dread doom lies, my lord, and here I deem is where I name the specter’s weight. The purchase of life and love is this—a trifling thing, a little thing, a paltry price…” A cheerless laugh escaped his lips at this, unnatural and too swift. “The worth of his daughter, a Silmaril.”
It came upon Finrod in an instant, the sudden crystal stillness when the air falls deadened before the onrushing gale. He had sat here upon that selfsame carved oak, years past when these rooms were yet intended as a dwelling for his sister, and she reclined against the far cushions where Beren sat now, a sharp smile on her lips that warned him the strike was coming. He had readied the apartments in anticipation of her arrival, believing it her homecoming and not a passing sojourn, and his weeks were filled with glad yearning for her laughter to be again the sound of home, her quick understanding once more the balm at his side.
Nerwen’s laughter arrived indeed, but it was at Ingoldo’s assumption that she would trade one cavern for another, when Menegroth held every longing—Melian, the idol of his sister’s ambition and of whose teaching she had not yet drunk her fill; and moreover Celeborn who had, to the great astonishment of all, caught the golden princess of the Ñoldor within a net of stolid affection. Stung by the loss, her brother had shifted paternal and they bickered. His pride lectured rather than pleaded and he pressed that swiftness should end only in heartbreak: certainty was the work of time. Remove for awhile and govern Nargothrond alongside him, discern here whether the attraction yet held or whether it was a mere fascination of novelty, there away from her own. Should she not know with surety ere bonds were tied that could not be undone? And thus it came as he countermanded her autonomy, the flash of her eyes, the sharp smile, the strike. “Then why, Ingoldo, sits there no queen at thy side?”
He had opened his mouth for the retort, but even as it did now, the void opened like a crevasse on the Ice, gaping at his feet, and it held his voice. He saw the darkness rise before him, the specter rumbled behind his sight. An oath I too shall swear… Where had Nerwen stood when Beren was summoned before Singolo’s throne? Had she watched this unfold upon that eerie stage? Did she seen their father’s ring upon that hand and know, as he did now, where their kinsman’s knife would find its mark?
“So he thinks to strike thee down, without ever laying hand to thee,” Finrod whispered to gain a moment’s time, his eyes tracing again over those lost features, living yet in Beren’s face. He steeled himself with their presence, girded his courage with their memory.
“And fain will I take that ending, Nóm. Sooner should I be spent seeking the price of hope than spend all my days a stranger unknown even unto myself. What life remains for me if I am to be sundered from her presence? Nay, let me rather fall to Thingol’s doom than face that living death. I will not be swayed from the attempt.”
“Yet such doom goes beyond his purpose and Elwë prods to life that greater which dogs us all. More oaths are there at work, son of Barahir, than that which I owe to thee.” He was silent for a time, then turned to pace the length of the room, his agitation palpable. “Fool! Vain, stubborn fool! Does he not know that even naming such price is to call it down upon all our heads? Or is that his aim, a vengeance long deferred and set upon us by our own hands? Then he shall find himself caught within his own retribution, for the sons of Fëanor would lay all kingdoms in ruin—yea his own as well as ours—ere they suffered any but their line to win its purchase. This is madness.” He held back his steps as he saw the growing anxiety in Beren’s own features and strove to measure his voice. “Celegorm and Curufin dwell even now within my hall, they were among our company when Edrahil brought thee before me in the night, and with them came a great multitude of their people to shelter. But any friendship between us would be set at naught if thy quest were known to them. Indeed I would change from asylum to adversary in that very moment, unless I handed thee over as fodder to that doom which drives them. Yet my own oath holds, and my love moreover; and thus we are all ensnared.”
Remorse worked its way through Beren’s features. He watched the king drift across the room and linger before the shelves, the grey eyes wandering over the little collection. In his despair and haste Beren had not reckoned with ramifications of his arrival, with what the mere knowledge of his charge would entail for the king. "I should not have come,” he murmured. “It is not yet too late, lord. Turn me from the gates ere they put that choice before you. I have set more in jeopardy than I knew.”
“Nay, it was right of thee to come.” Finrod glanced back at him and shifted again to Taliska. He smiled, but Beren saw the weary resignation within its lines. “To whom could you have turned else? You may not understand it, Beren, but long have I loved your fathers and mothers—long have I loved you—as those children of my heart that I have not of blood. I am glad you turned to me in your need, dire as is any choice now before us.” Finrod reached out to rest his hand upon the box with its mural of etchings. His expression was unreadable and when he spoke again, his voice drifted toward Beren as though an echo of itself. “What is it you would have of me, oath-bearer?”
“I know not, lord.” Beren had given little thought to what lay beyond his flight to Nargothrond. Nóm would have an answer. If he could once reach the hidden doors, then wisdom would guide him. Nóm would set his path aright. Yet now he stood before the king and found himself utterly at a loss, queried by that gentle voice and instead of directed, and he cast about in confusion. “Provisions…or perhaps if there are maps I might study? Or guidance in any way…” Beren’s voice faltered. What aid could there be for such a journey? He felt the absurdity of his words and his voice trailed to a murmur. “If the tales are told aright, my lord, then do you not know at least the ways by which I might find the gates?”
Finrod’s fingers tightened upon the wooden box. Madness, madness all of it. Willful, futile madness. The old anger rose again as he saw it stretch before him, the tenuous thread that remained of the siege snapping in an instant, the bonds of blood drowned, the slumbering Doom summoned out with dripping maw opened wide—and for what? So that Thingol might hoard his daughter with the same jealous frenzy that drove Fëanor to rebellion and exile. So that he might keep from her that fleeting joy, frail and precious, bitter and beautiful and, he could admit at last, worthy of any price it required. Do you not know at least the ways by which I might find the gates? Ever they saw it with more clarity than he, these hearts of the Atani. Beren had set off stumbling toward the reek, pressing on with eager hope toward a death of anguish from the sure conviction of his love’s goodness, knowing not even the path to find the gates. Beren, dear heart, standing here before him and looking up in appeal with Balan’s own eyes, this child he had once carried through the heather and rain.
“Yes,” he said at last, “I know that road. But long years lie between where we sit now and when I beat my fist upon the doors of hell—all the years of thy people, Beren—and much will have changed in the slag and fire. Nevertheless, what knowledge I have is yours. But if I may offer counsel…” Finrod’s voice caught and he saw Aikanáro’s face hovering hopefully in the firelight at Tol Sirion. No, he had lost any right to counsel. “Forgive me, if I may offer a question instead. Would there not be life for thee yet in the woods of Brethil? Could not the comfort thy company would afford to mother and sister revive peace within thy breast?”
“It is kindly said, lord, and my heart warms to know you think so well of me as this. But what comfort would it be to return to them a hollow shell, a son and brother wandering yet from them as a ghost beneath the trees? Brethil! There upon the very eaves of Neldoreth…Nay let them have the comfort of memory and know me only as I was—unless beyond hope I should return with my joy in hand. Only further grief should I bring them were I to return as I am.”
“Faint thou dost count their love to deem it so easily conquered, but I perceive the intent of thine heart in this—and I confess mine would lie similarly if found in such a straight.” Finrod turned from the shelf at last and met Beren’s eye. “Thou art determined in this?”
“I am.”
“Then aid I shall grant thee.”
“Lord—“
“Only give me first thy word to remain here till the start of Firith ere pressing onward and allow me time to write to my kinsman to see whether he might not yet be turned from this decree. If thou wilt permit it, I will stand as lord and father in Barahir’s absence and offer any price he names, short only of my kingdom itself.”
“Lord, I would permit it gladly, and with a depth of gratitude I can never hope to express for love shown this friendless wretch upon your hearth. But knowing the lord of Doriath as you must, can you truly believe he would be induced to alter his course once set?”
“It is unlikely, I grant thee. But allow me at least the trial of it.”
“To what end? That your own allegiance might lie jeopardized by offering needlessly that which he will never accept? While I linger behind the futile words, dear hours spent on this false hope of my own conjured phantoms. Should I not rather lay my path at once toward that which is my only surety—a prayer to win thus in secret passage what the raging armies may not glimpse? Death is my lot, let me see if he hunts. The shelter and care you have granted already I count in appeasement of your oath: knowledge only do I beg of you in further fulfillment—knowledge and food, supplies.”
“You ask only such? To place the road to torment within thy palms and send thee forth, dear son of dear sons, unto a death of agony, alone and friendless? Only such!” Nóm’s eyes blazed out in the vehemence of his words. “I cannot, Beren. I will not. For love of those who went before thee, if thou wilt not accept it on thine own behalf, let me try to loose thee from this price.”
Beren faltered at the pain cracking through the clear, Elven voice. So too had Lúthien’s rung in his ears as she caught hold of him before the court of Menegroth, his retort to her father ringing yet through the carven chamber. “Stubborn fool, I would have fled with thee to whatever end, and thou hast bound us now to his vengeance, condemned my heart to send thee forth to death. Would I not have followed thee through wood and dale? Our bower set amid the willows, wed with trees our witnesses and the wild berries and herbs our wedding feast?” Ai Lúthien, Lúthien…
Then another presence, faint and looming, ancient and familiar, rising up through his own veins to mumble another chorus. Let pride sit awhile. Let him try the course. Let your heart be steadfast as the oak, patient as the owl.
Beren shivered. What was it his father had quipped…all the line since Bëor hanging about the corners. And did Barahir now linger with them in the shadows of these walls? Or had his blood spoken in a yet more distant voice?
“You have my permission, vatta,” he said at last, yielding to the steady beat, and named the other in token of his resignation. “And may your worth find favor where mine has failed.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
aran nin: [S] my king
Balanion: [Q] & [S] son of Balan
orro: [Q] alas
Meldonya: [Q] my friend
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
- Gawarthi albe vët: peace, little one
- Gawarthi sunus eil: peace, my son
MISC NOTES
- For an explanation of hrögemetheilit, see Here in Our Frailty.
- Iavas: the Sindarin name for the season of early autumn (Aug 10 - Oct 3)
- Firith: the Sindarin name for the season of mid-Autumn (Oct 7 - Nov 30)
- Thû: the name Men called Sauron
12. Children of the Sun
Finrod and Bëor arrive in Nargothrond and navigate what this new context means for each of them.
Read 12. Children of the Sun

311th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
Nargothrond
It was raining when they crossed the Narog. Five hours of damp progress and it was raining still, drenching through every thread of cloth upon them. Drenching through his bones as well, Balan thought cheerlessly as the drizzle turned once again to a downpour and Nóm gave no sign of halting. He and Váya slipped through the strands of water like a shimmering reflection. The rain had deepened Váya’s coat to the same hue as the storm clouds overhead, while Nóm seemed to hover upon her back, perched between cloud and cloud, some god of water or air. The flaxen hair turned molten in the deluge and it poured down over the lines of his head, the angles of his shoulders—golden filigree upon the simple, green tunic.
Balan had at first mistaken him for Satheweis in the dark midnight of Thalos, when he woke and beheld him sitting with harp in hand, the god of song beside their dying fire. Watching him now, he decided that Nóm was instead the image of Guënid, god of rivers, of seas, of all water. He had knelt on the far bank of the Narog that morning, reaching out to rest his palm upon the current where it rushed past, swollen and swift with the spring rains. “You are restless, my friend,” he had murmured over the din. “But it is only I and no dread or trespassing feet. Will you let us pass?” The torrent eased by degrees and Balan had been awed to see the ford emerge, newly passable in the wake of Nóm’s words; then full and raging once more as Váya and Elmorë’s feet reached the far shore. Guënid, Balan thought again as he looked at the figure riding ahead, for rain turned to light as it reached him, shimmering from his skin and glancing off the complex braids wrapping about his head. Balan had not seen him weave those through his hair since the early days in Ossiriand and was surprised to wake and find him engrossed in the process that morning.
Balan’s own shirt clung about him with a sodden chill and the fabric of his breeches had begun chafing along the thighs. If he was any god, he was the god of affliction. Here on his throne of wet saddle cloth, aching muscles his offerings, midges his supplicant worshippers. A wry grin slipped out at that last image and he pushed the hair back from his eyes, rainwater trailing over his ears. A lesser god certainly, but gods together, Nóm and he.
It was only three days past when he had felt that divinity in earnest—the rush of awe, the world gliding away, a heady mix of risk and invincibility. They had descended the low swell where they lunched above the Talath Dirnen and the horses set an easy pace across the grasslands. It stretched for leagues, rolling prairie dotted in the distance with hills and woods, but the eastern quarter lay flat and open before them. Balan was overwhelmed by the abundance of sky, nearly drowning in it as he looked up at the expanse, filling his lungs with the west wind while Elmorë trotted through the grass beneath him and the scent of meadowsweet washed through the air.
He heard Finrod’s laugh ahead of him. “How now, lost to the Aiwenórë already? And I’ve not yet taught thee flight.”
“Hmm?” Balan looked down with a bemused smile, then his brow arched at the merry glint in the other’s eye. “I fear to ask the meaning of that.”
Finrod laughed again and Váya’s trot quickened, Elmorë following her pace. “Remember what I told thee yestereve: shift forward onto the joints of thy feet, let thy weight be rooted low. Rise up from the saddle as he gains speed and take the movement in thy legs. He will not let thee fall.”
“Nóm…” All Balan’s fear returned in an instant and he watched in alarm as Váya sprang forward across the plain.
“Tolo, Elmorë!” Finrod’s voice flew back over his shoulder, music and challenge. “Noro lim!”
Balan felt the creature beneath him leap forward in pursuit. He caught his breath with a gasp and for a moment forgot all Nóm’s guidance and clutched at the saddle in panic. Elmorë’s muscles bunched and released beneath him as he gained speed and the ground rushed away, the wind roaring up through his ears. He would fall. Nóm was too far ahead and could not pull him back from the brink. He would fall—he was falling. His knuckles whitened and he leaned down against the horse’s neck.
Then came a low whinny, a twitch of the raven ears, a gentle calm rising from the shoulders beneath him. Whatever the connection was between these uncanny creatures and their riders, Elmorë understood it even if Balan did not, and the comfort of that steadied his fear. He will not let thee fall. Nóm’s words trickled back into his awareness and gradually he eased his grip, pushing up from his huddled position and shifting the reins into his fingers, allowing his arms to fall in with the neck’s movement. Elmorë’s calm confidence rippled back through the leather and Balan felt his own courage return at the sense of it. He took a breath and shifted his weight forward.
The next moment Elmorë seemed to drop out from under him and a wash of adrenaline shot through his stomach. But he felt the stirrups firm beneath the balls of his feet, the reins pressing into his hands, he felt Elmorë’s muscles yet rolling beneath him and the drumbeat of his striking hooves.
And all at once he was laughing. It was flight, as Esrid had ever told him. Imagine seeing from the hawk’s eyes, Bal. You soar low over the grass and it’s rushing away beneath your wings—you hovering within its motion, suspended between the sky and earth. The old ache rose amidst his jubilation. How Esrid’s eyes would have danced to see him like this, poised as her hawk in the firmament, he and this magnificent beast flying as one creature through the billowing grass. How his own heart would have burned to be seen.
Balan squinted as he drew his gaze up from the blurring grass, blinking back tears as his eyes watered in the wind. The plain was rolling past around him, golden and green in the afternoon’s heat. And golden and green too was Nóm ahead of him, brilliant in the unveiled sun. His hair and shirt streamed behind him with Váya’s speed and his head was turned back over his shoulder, keeping the other ever within his sight till he knew how he fared. And how Balan’s heart burned to be seen.
“Come then, night sky,” he called hoarsely into the wind, his voice thrown back into his throat with their speed. “Let us catch them.”
He felt the intoxication of it still as they plodded now along the Narog. The rain was falling harder, straight sheets through the still air, and Balan gave up any attempt to keep the hair from streaming down over his eyes. He numbered Elmorë’s footfalls in tens as he would his own steps during his people’s wandering, passing time in distraction and steeling his endurance by shares. It must end eventually. Surely even Nóm’s people could not travel on like this without ending.
The illusion rode ahead of him as before, shining golden and green along the riverside as he had upon the plain, and once again he looked over his shoulder. The bright laugh that followed did little to improve Balan’s humor.
“Ai, Anarinya!” The laugh turned penitent as Finrod took in the bedraggled spectacle on the horse behind him. “I’ve quite drowned thee. But take heart, soon the boughs grant us a full canopy and from there the going is easy.”
“Soon by thy measure is little comfort.” Balan shook his hair from his eyes and grimaced. “I’ll forgive thee when I’m dry.”
Finrod laughed again at this and turned back in the saddle. He began humming a traveling song, an Atani melody they had taught him while Estolad was raised from the fields. Then it was Balan who led the rolling chant, calling out the melody lines to the beat of hammer and axe, his people echoing in the double percussion of the response. Now Nóm’s voice held the call, and Balan’s it was that drummed the measure.
Ever onward
we go
Though the land is
fallow
And the daylight
falls low
We wander ever
oh
Over field and
barrow
We pass the hill and
hollow
Where the thorn bush
sharp grows
We wander ever
oh
Hear the rook and
grey crow
There running fly the
swift does
They flee the wolf and
his woe
We wander ever
oh
On roads that seldom
we know
We set our feet and
follow
The path we’ve forged and
then lo!
We wander ever
oh
Our feet may tire and
fall slow
Yet moon must wane and
fall low
Until to rest we
may go
We wander ever
oh
❈❈❈
It was night when they reached the gates at last. The rain had lessened when they passed through the foothills of the Faroth, riding in among them till Ringwil ran still enough to ford. From there they led the horses on foot between tree and crag, a complex and winding track that Nóm walked with surety and of which Balan never saw a trace. As dusk turned to dark, he gradually became aware that the shifting shadows within the wildwood were not tricks of the changing light, but figures following their progress, flanking them along each side. They were there in the corner of his eye, gone when he turned toward them; appearing once more when his eyes returned to the path, then melting again into the twilight whenever his gaze sought their forms.
“They have been with us since we crossed onto the plains.” Nóm had dropped back to walk beside him as the way widened and he sensed Balan’s unease. “Hadst thou not sight of them before?”
Balan shook his head. “Nay, not a whit. Have they kept pace all this while on foot?”
“There are more than these alone. The Talath Dirnen is woven throughout with eyes and defenses, and those have guarded us in turns from the moment we left Elu’s land and entered my own.” He glanced at Balan with a smile. “Though they will not approach without my summons.”
The shades continued to melt in and out of the brush. Now that he had seen them, Balan wondered how he had been heedless of them till now. Their presence rippled through the woods like a scent, the prickling tang after the lightening’s blaze. It was unmistakable.
They followed the Ringwil until he dove headlong into the gorge, tumbling over a jagged fall of boulders where his roaring foam mingled with the rapids below. They turned to the south as they neared the edge and passed through a cleft in the rock face. A passage opened out before them, just wide enough for a horse to pass unhindered, within which a sloping path had been cut with skill to imitate a natural stair in the limestone. It was hidden on the eastern side by a line of crags, and on the west by sheer cliffs rising to the highlands above.
Balan’s senses swam as they descended. There was no light within but the pale stars overhead and he followed Nóm more by guess than by sight, muttering charms of luck under his breath that the gods might preserve him from a false step and a fall in the dark. The strike of their horses’ hooves echoed along the corridor, ricocheting up narrow walls to punctuate the thunder of river and falls.
It was not a long stair, the Ringwil entered the gorge from one of the lower hills, and soon Balan saw the glint ahead of him—Váya’s sheen and Nóm’s gold illuminated once more in the moonlight. Another few steps and he too emerged from the passage to find himself amidst a small crop of ash trees growing clustered against the foot of the bluffs. A wide terrace spread out beyond these, bounded by the tree-lined cliffs and a sheer drop into the river channel. Nóm shifted to walk alongside him again as they followed Narog’s course south and Balan noticed a growing uncertainty in his demeanor. He was uncharacteristically quiet, his gaze fixed straight ahead, his steps slower than they had been throughout the day.
“All well, Nóm?”
“Yes.” A smile broke through and he was himself as he glanced down at Balan, the merry light dancing again in his eyes. “All is well, Anarinya,” Finrod said as he reached out to clasp the other’s hand in his own, impulsive and fervent, lingering as they walked shrouded between the horses. “We are nearly there.”
Then with a hiss of intaken breath, he released him and stepped forward ahead of Váya, tall and fierce and imbued in an instant with the sharp air of command Balan so rarely saw him employ. Now it radiated from him like light, like warmth, alarming and beautiful, and he watched the transformation in awe.
For a moment the king glanced back, a brief smile handed through the dark, a quick brush of thought. Then he turned and stepped into the overgrown copse of maple and ash obscuring the cliff face and disappeared beneath their boughs. Swiftly, Balan plunged after him, steps faltering as his eyes adjusted to the tree shroud, and with that slow acclimation came the image of two great doors, set within a stone-linteled archway and towering up through the rock wall before him. He gasped despite himself and felt the old fear of his people recoil within his breast, and only by sheer force of will—his own and Nóm’s holding like steel throughout it—did he keep himself from fleeing back toward the river. Elmorë’s breath snuffed hot against his ear and he reached up to rest a hand along his jaw, taking comfort from the living warmth of the creature beside him. For the doors had begun turning soundlessly inward.
It was dark within.
Ghomennin gather, gather ‘round
Pitch black behind the yawning archway.
They dance a circle ‘pon the ground
Balan realized he was breathing fast and had stepped back against Elmorë. He could not. Not even for love of Nóm could he enter that gaping hole in the cliffside. How could the creature at his side dwell here, he who was all light and goodness and golden merriment?
“Trust me, Anarinya.” Balan could not discern whether the voice reached him as a whisper or in the brush of the other’s thought, wrapped full about his own—warmth and comfort, reassurance and command. “Come and we will summon the light.”
Nóm’s hand rested gently at the nape of his neck and Balan turned all his attention upon that touch, fixing his senses on the palm across his spine, the fingertips atop his shoulders, the light pressure on each side of his neck, that he might not feel the movement of his own feet as he allowed the other to lead him forward into the abyss. A blanket of night dropped over them as they passed through the gate and his eyes strained against the dark. There was the clop of hooves on stone, the tentative shuffling of his own feet, his shaking breath, the muted thud of stone doors closing behind them.
And then light sprang up before the doors’ echo had faded, and Balan flinched back against Finrod in shock. A line of ten guards flanked the walls, a newly unveiled lamp suspended from the stone above each, and the light shone down and multiplied as it leaped from their burnished armor, from the wide, golden spearheads. They stood at attention as Finrod stepped forward, leading Balan still at his side.
“Galdol, aran nin!” Four figures stood before a second gate, a stone’s throw ahead with doors carved of oak, and the foremost of these bowed in greeting as they approached. “Glad indeed were the tidings that you returned.”
“Edrahil.” Finrod smiled and stepped ahead of Balan to clasp the other’s shoulder. “And glad is the hour I greet thee.”
It was an entrance chamber, Balan determined as he looked about. The walls had been carved out in careful symmetry, twice as long as it was wide, bearing great doors at each end and an arched ceiling between. Four horses could ride abreast through the gates and the chamber’s height would allow spears and banners to be born upon them. Nóm’s hand returned to his shoulders and once again he was centered by the touch.
“Balan Beldarion i eneth dîn.”
Balan pulled his attention from the hewn rock to focus on the conversation before him. He was passably conversant now, but not adept enough to follow an exchange without direct focus. It was an introduction, he assessed quickly, and Nóm had turned towards him now.
“Balan, this is Edrahil, the captain of my own guard.”
He crossed his arms and bowed. “In goodness our paths have crossed,” Balan said after the fashion of his own people, “in peace may their journeys lead.”
“Fair are your greetings, son of Beldar. I count it an honor to be of the first to welcome you to our city.”
Balan felt the heightened attentiveness pulsing in Nóm’s palm, the tension prickling across his thought. Had he said something wrong? Had the other? But the smile on Finrod’s face was genuine when Balan glanced over in concern, and his anxiety eased at the sight. It was a careful line to tread, here among the unfamiliar.
Edrahil had moved back toward the second gate which, like the first, had begun turning inward without a sound on its hidden pivots. The gatehouse opened out into a large chamber, the crossroads of the main and two additional passages, which tapered together into a corridor running down through the rock ahead of them. Finrod led the way along this, guiding Balan firmly at his side, while the captain and one guard fell into step behind them, and the two remaining led Váya and Elmorë at the rear.
The walls were patterned along their length with a series of alcoves, delved into the rock face on alternating sides. These arched up from the floor to meet in a tapered point, from which a lamp hung suspended over a guard’s head, echoing the configuration of the entrance chamber, only here there were no shrouds to disrupt the light. A guard stood within each, and each alcove was lined throughout with polished bronze or steel, mirroring the lamplight in prisms of gold and silver. Standing within their niches, the soldiers gave the appearance of uncanny statues lining the way; an impression only broken when each shifted to sharp attention as the king passed by. Balan watched this with fascination and felt a mix of awe and disorientation to see Nóm in this manner. Nay, even to think of him as Nóm within these vaulted passages felt somehow disjointed and strange. Nóm was the familiar companion of woods and fields—somber and fay, merry and quiet—a comfortable spirit who sat smiling beside Balan’s hearth. Here he was a formidable presence. He wore the simplest attire of any they passed, clothed still in the traveling hose and loose, green tunic of two days gone, but he radiated a dignity and command that merged with the very light of the halls. Balan was breathless as he watched him from the corner of his eye. He knew not even how to name him.
“There are three gates that open onto the gorge,” Finrod said in explanation as they walked, and it was Nóm’s voice again, drifting through the vision, “and all meet together in the passage behind us. We entered through the central of these—the main gate, or what we call Annon Aearon: the gate of the sea. Each of the doors we have graven for a promise of the Valar, in the hope that their memory may yet keep us in safety: Annon Anor a Ithil, the gate of the sun and moon that marks the light of our remembrance in exile; Annon Elen, the gate of the stars; and Annon Aearon, for the Lord of Waters who laid it upon my heart to delve this city.”
Balan nodded as he listened, his eyes darting over the passage while they continued their descent, still unnerved by the new intensity of the soul at his side. Ando Eären, he translated to himself, lips silently forming the words as they walked, Ando Anar Isilyë, Ando Elen. He felt the warmth leap toward him from the other’s thought, and the corners of Balan’s lips twitched upward in response. Yes, these were the names Nóm had given them as well.
They reached a crossroads at the bottom of the passage and the guards veered off along the right fork with Váya and Elmorë, while Finrod led Balan forward through an archway with a relief of vines and flowers. “Sin mardenya,” he breathed as they stepped out onto a landing and the roof and floor fell away.
The cavern was vast. It stretched like an open valley before them, the floor of it lined with interwoven structures, great stone formations carved and wound into these, a market—quiet now in the time of rest—and a trail of gardens running throughout. A great stair descended from the terrace where they stood, and about it the stone flowed down like water to the cavern beneath. Their landing continued about the length of the cavern, doors and windows opening out onto it from the living rock. It was one of many, Balan realized as his eyes lifted upwards. The roads terraced up and down the walls, climbing amidst a myriad of dwellings delved into the rock face. Light poured out through the cave, golden light drifting like evening’s caress over the flora and stone, and defying all Balan’s senses. He swore under his breath and stood transfixed, lips parted and eyes wide.
“This is the First Hall,” Finrod’s voice drifted in through the haze, “one of seven that serve as the primary living quarters for the city.”
“There are more than this?”
“Yes.” The king laughed to hear his breathless shock and the hand about Balan’s shoulder gripped tighter in reassurance. “Far more besides. I will show it all to thee,” he added in a near-whisper, and for a moment he was Nóm again—fervent and earnest and spilling over with joy. “Come.”
Balan followed after him in a daze. Nóm’s hand slipped from his shoulder as they moved along the road and the king walked a step ahead of him now, tall and radiant in the cavern’s light. Balan still could not determine from whence the light originated, but it caught within Finrod’s hair as though it too was the burnished metal of the guard’s alcoves, sending it dancing and tripping out from him as refracted sunlight.
“Vandatar!” A group emerged from around a corner, a young Elf striding at the head of them with his arms held open in greeting. He was tall, nearly as tall as the king, sharp featured and raven haired, and grey eyes dancing as he walked towards them. For a brief instant, Balan felt the frigid bile of jealousy as the king folded him into his arms with a glad cry and held him in a warm embrace. Then his mind attended through the weariness and he marked the greeting. Vandatar, oath-father. This was Gildor, he realized with shamefaced relief, the friend’s son orphaned on the Ice, taken on as the king’s own. In the wake of his quick envy, Balan felt a trespasser’s guilt to know the other’s suffering before ever acquaintance was shared, to have seen through Nóm’s memory the frightened eyes, the terror and heartbreak of the child waking alone between two parents who would not wake again. To know the memory of those desperate arms clinging about Finrod’s neck as he set him on his knee, weeping too as he named him his fosterling and brought him into his household. Balan pulled himself back to the present.
“Hinya.” The king’s voice was soft as he held the other close. “Glad am I to see thy face.”
“And I to see thee safely returned.”
Finrod grasped him by the arms as Gildor drew back, smiling. “I should have sent for thee,” he said with chagrin in his voice. “Forgive me that I did not realize ’twould be thy wish till now.”
“Nay, there is naught to forgive.” Gildor shook his head dismissively and Balan saw there was a sheen to the sable locks, silver and gold they stood together in the unaccountable light. “Only I am glad of thy return, vandatar.”
The king smiled in answer, then reached out to lay his hand behind Balan’s shoulders once more. “Balan, I have told thee oft of Gildor—my son in all but blood.”
“Goodness go with you, Gildor Inglorion,” Balan said, before realizing the name might bear more pain than respect. But the responding smile was warm, the sharp eyes welcoming. “It is both honor and joy to make your acquaintance.”
“And yours, lord of the Hildor. May Elbereth smile upon our hour of meeting.” Then Gildor turned back to the king with an apologetic glance. “Forgive me for drawing thee at once to matters of state, but Arminas is in the city with reports from Dorthonion. I have taken them down, but if thou hadst wish to speak with him as well, it should be ere aught else. He departs with the dawn.”
“Yes, I wish it. I have messages in turn for my brothers, and would send word to Orodreth also if he returns by way of Tol Sirion.”
“He does.”
“Then we will go to him straight away.”
Balan felt a wave of despair at the realization that sleep was yet far from his reach. The day had taken its toll and his eyes were heavy, his limbs aching through every joint.
The king sensed it in an instant and looked down at him, stricken. “Ai, Balan, the night is half gone and I’ve little heeded your rest.”
“I am well, lord,” he replied, attempting to set conviction in his voice, unsure whether this was to persuade the king or himself.
“You are weary.” Finrod’s hand was at his elbow. “And my hospitality is poor. The rooms were prepared as directed?” He turned toward Edrahil in query.
“Yes, lord. Shall I guide him thence?”
“With my gratitude. Balan, are you amenable? I may be long with Arminas.”
“As you wish, lord. I’ll not deny the road weighs heavily on me.”
“Aye,” Nóm slipped back to Taliska with a penitent’s smile, “I led you with little heed for aught but to arrive on the day I named.”
“As determined as a donkey who’s scented home.” Balan looked up at him with a quick grin, then added, “Baran did warn you were spending too much time with the little beasts.”
Finrod laughed at this and the sound ran like music over the flowering rock. “Aye, and how I shall miss them.” He set his hand briefly on Balan’s shoulder in parting, then with a smile he followed Gildor back the way they had come.
❈❈❈
Balan dreamed he was in the village where he spent his adolescence, wandering through the common green and setting his hand to stones and trees he had long since forgotten. There in his sleep he recalled the buttercup flowers running through the grasses, the rickety frame about the well, the shale his mother set into the ground before their door, the ash tree behind the hut and the clay figurine beneath it—his grandmother’s shrine to Melishk, the goddess of earth. Every part of it was empty. The houses, the green, the wide, shallow bend of the river where the women beat out laundry and children ran splashing and shrieking in the sun. Everything was draped in silence. He was searching, he realized, searching desperately for something he could not recall, all the while knowing it would slip away if he could not lay hand to it. Again he rounded the front of his family’s hut and where the dark shale had been empty a moment before, there lay now a clay jar of goat’s milk, a little bowl of hawthorn berries.
He woke with a start, disoriented. Above him the stone was smoothed into gentle vaults, set over in a pigment of midnight blue and decorated with a winding pattern of vines and golden flowers. Branches spread out above him in the morning light and he stared in confusion for a long moment. Why was there such an amount of sunlight? For it was clearly sunlight, not the evening glow of the cavern lamps, and Balan once again felt the eerie sensation of hovering in the midst of impossibility. He rubbed his hands over his face and pushed up to sit cross legged on the bed.
The bed was large, much longer than his height required, and bounded by a carved tree at each corner, reaching up to meet over the top in a twist of mingled branches. It was meticulous work, each tree unique and so closely mimicking their living counterparts that Balan at first thought they were planted within the floor. There was a hearth directly in front of him, unlit in the mild air; a curving wall of shelves delved into the stone, empty but for a basin of floating lilies and the few items he had carried outside his bags. They looked a scant little collection on the long shelves, huddled together on one end.
The source of the light was clear at once. There was a line of doors along the near wall, delicately carved with latticework along their length, through which the sunlight spilled into the room. A pair of them had been left open and from this a fresh breeze flowed into the chamber, ruffling the hair across Balan’s forehead. He leaned forward to peer through the opening and saw a wide, untamed garden, on the far side of which the rock face rose in sheer walls extending beyond his sight. That would be for a later study. He turned his eyes back to the apartments themselves.
Where the ceiling had been painted in elaborate patterns, the walls of the chamber were left in their natural colors. Various portions had been polished or highlighted in the shaping, the beauty of the stone washing through the room like a meadow in bloom, an autumn forest.
Balan drew his hands down over his face, a yawn splitting across his features. He managed a few hours’ sleep, he guessed. It had been well past midnight when Edrahil guided him to these chambers, a full hour after that ere he had bathed and settled, overwhelmed by the grandeur and comfort. He was afraid to touch a thing when he entered and stood nearly frozen in the midst of the room. Edrahil noticed at once and beckoned him forward to show where his belongings had been housed, reorienting him by leading first to the one point of familiarity. He then began noting each aspect of the room as he moved about, casually explaining functions and use as though such was included in any guest’s welcome—turning back the bedclothes, adjusting the glow of the lamps, demonstrating how the intricate contrivances worked to send cool water cascading into the bath, the system of pulleys to draw hot from the springs below.
Once abed, Balan found sleep was no closer than when he stood swaying in the First Hall. The mattresses he had known were of straw and grass, an improvement on the bare ground but nothing comparable to whatever was now beneath him. It was bliss. But still he shifted and turned, cold despite the warmth of the bath and the abundant blankets, restless despite his ease. He had not slept alone, he realized in a moment of epiphany, since before his marriage. First Esrid had been at his side, her warmth and presence alleviating the insomnia that plagued him since his parents’ loss. And when she in turn was gone, his sons shifted close: Baran curled against his back, Belen warm and small and wrapped safely within his arms. In all the years following, they slept still side by side and found comfort in the knowledge that each was near at hand. When that solace was forsaken, it was Nóm who lay beside him throughout the long leagues from Estolad, quiet and constant; Balan the one held now in the safety of another’s arms.
He ached with the lack of him. The bed was too large—he was lost within it and the sea of linen accentuated his solitude in stark contrast. It was the same insomnia upon him again, alone and frightened by the unknown, confronting the sudden loss of all he held constant. He wanted Nóm’s arms about him. Or he wanted Belen curled with his back against his own and the even sound of Baran’s breathing beyond, the steady cadence that lulled him to sleep these many years. He wanted Esrid. At last he had wrapped his own arms about himself, curling into the pillows, and slipped into an unsettled slumber.
Balan rubbed his fingers over his eyelids to clear the fog, then rose and wandered about the room. His own possessions had been set beside a tall chest and remained still in their bags where he carried them. Edrahil noted this in passing the night before; he had given directions for only the loose items to be set out on the shelves, unsure whether unpacking another’s bags would be counted an offense among Balan’s people.
He smiled at the recollection and retrieved the clean set of clothes he kept unused throughout the journey, dressing himself in the breeches and linen shirt, then setting the rest aside on the bed. The tunic was embroidered along each hem in a bright, geometric pattern that stood out against the dark wool. It was Belen’s work, a gift from before they began the mountain crossing, and Balan’s heart contracted as he traced his fingers along his son’s artistry. He would carry Belen with him throughout the day, here in these stitches. How alight his boy’s eyes would be to wander through these halls! Soon, Balan reassured himself. He would settle and learn the ways of the place, then send for him before the year was out.
He crossed to the other side of the chest where a small table stood against the wall and looked over the various items set along its length. There were a few small boxes, a carafe of water and a basin, a comb, a phial or two of oil. Balan opened one of these last in curiosity and was met with the aroma of heather blossoms and wild meadowsweet. It pulled him back at once to the foothills in Ossiriand when Nóm was yet a new and strange apparition. This was the scent of him in those first days amid the trees and Balan was amused to stumble so haphazardly upon how it was achieved. He chuckled as he set the lid back in place and returned the phial to the table alongside the others. He had assumed he merely grew accustomed to Nóm as he dwelt among them, no longer noticing the smaller differences, but it was far simpler than that: the supply had run out. Flesh and blood after all, he thought, and found these little discoveries grounding. His eyes drifted up to the wall before him.
Balan’s breath drew in with a sharp hiss. There upon the rock face hung a smooth pane, rimmed about with a gold pattern of ivy leaves, its surface clearer than a still pool. His face looked back at him and he returned the gaze, stunned.
He knew his reflection from the water, of course. He knew it too from seeing his face in the obsidian mirrors of Esrid’s people. But what lay before him now was a sharper image than any he had yet beheld, and the face staring back was no longer that youth conjured up from the obsidian’s shadows. You fool, you fool, this is what walks before his eyes.
It was a passable face, he decided as he pressed down his anxious contempt and tried to observe the features dispassionately. Pleasant enough. The eyes were weary—that was little surprise—dark and set beneath a pair of heavy brows. The nose was snub, slightly crooked in the middle from the remnants of an old injury, the lips thin but decisive. The light brown skin was set off to advantage in the morning light, but he was confronted for the first time with the faint lines scattered all across its surface; a cluster at the corner of each eye, two deep furrows between his brows, several parallel creases running the length of his forehead. He was pleased to see the hair remained darker than he assumed, cut roughly above his shoulders with the winter brushing only around his temples. The rest of the tousled waves hovered about his head, unkempt from the restless night, and could nearly pass as a match for Baran’s. But the grey leapt in grim accusation from his beard, scattered throughout, unavoidable.
Well, that at least could be remedied. He stooped again to the bags beside him and retrieved his knife and a whetstone, honing the edge until it would serve. He poured water into the basin, looked back at the reflection once again, then took a steadying breath and set to work.
❈❈❈
The swans were sharp in the lamplight, sinuous necks curved back and arched in proud elegance across the panels. A single eye of each fixed any who approached, holding them in watchful attention, and Balan’s own gaze was captivated in turn as he walked beside Edrahil. He had seen them before, he was sure of it. There was something in the supple curve of the wings, in the light dip of their backs that rested like a word on the tip of his tongue.
The captain paused before the entrance and Balan waited alongside him, his eyes moving over the details of the feathers, the tilted heads, the serpents winding together at the top of the arch. Both father and mother, he mused as they waited, for Nóm had said these were a symbol of his mother’s people, had he not? They kept watch here together, swans and serpents.
The ships. It struck his recollection with a cold rush as Edrahil laid hand to stile and stepped forward. The burning quays, the mad confusion, these same silhouettes cutting through the raging sea. Nóm had placed their creaturely likeness here guarding the doors where he sat in council and, as they swung open before him, Balan knew with certainty the other’s intent—that these might ever serve as warning and reminder to what governance passed within. If the gates of the city had been graven in the hope of faithfulness, these were carved in remembrance of treachery; that its memory might preserve them from recapitulation.
“Ah, mellon nin!” The king’s voice greeted him as Balan passed through the archway, and at once he was walking towards him, an arm outstretched in greeting.
Balan froze at the sight. He had been startled by the previous night’s transformation, but it had not prepared him for the apparition that moved toward him now. He felt again that awe of waking amidst the midnight song and seeing him there beside the embers, unknown, indescribable, achingly beautiful. Lord, are you a god come among us? But even then he had been attired for hunting, finely clad but in simple design. Whereas here he was a king in his own dominion, glorious and radiant, and as he had beside the fire in Ossiriand, Balan looked upon him and at once loved and despaired. He dropped to his knee.
“Don’t be a fool.” It was Nóm’s voice, the Taliska spilling warm and familiar from his lips, and it recentered Balan as he was pulled to his feet. “I am your friend yet, am I not?” Then the king’s laugh rippled out as he took in the features before him and set his palm against the bare cheek. “What have you done here?”
Balan’s expression fell at the mirth in the other’s eyes. “I…it seemed to be the custom,” he said, abashed.
Regret sprang across Finrod’s face in an instant. “Forgive me—I spoke in surprise, not mockery, but I’ve given offense. It was thoughtless of me.” He let his hand fall back to his side, but his eyes did not leave the other’s face and his voice warmed. “I am glad to know your countenance.”
For the first time, Balan noticed there were others seated behind the king, gathered at a long table on the far side of the room, and he was suddenly glad their exchange remained in his own tongue. “A portent of woe you called it once,” he said with a wry twist of his lips, “and yet I’ve dogged your steps for leagues. I’m not so easily offended.”
“And for that I am fortunate,” Nóm’s eyes glimmered with self-deprecation and he took Balan by the arm. “But it is nature, not custom, you know,” he added, and a sidelong smile flashed between them. “Yours is a rare skill here.”
Balan snorted in response and followed the king across to the table. He was becoming accustomed now to the unending dance of introductions and could follow the cadence nearly without thought. The difficulty, he fretted to himself, was affixing this influx of names to the equally manifold faces. He had begun resorting to tricks of memory, guessing meaning from his moderate understanding and tying this as best he could to the visages before him.
Brenoril, Noldorin heritage, one of the chief advisers. She who survived, Balan approximated as he exchanged the usual formalities. A long scar ran from above her ear to the tip of her chin. This he would remember without trouble.
Faelon, Sindarin heritage, the second of the king’s chief counselors. Just or generous. This was less apparent. Then Faelon smiled, wide and gregarious as he greeted the newcomer, and Balan was enveloped in the warmth of his welcome. Generosity indeed. This too he would not forget.
Gildor was next. There was no difficulty here. After his first misassumption, he kept Gildor’s face firmly in mind. There was something of Belen about him, the eager curiosity in his glance, the quick smile, and Balan held him dear at once on that merit.
Guilin now, seated beside him. He was dark as Gildor, but where the sharpness of Gildor’s features conjured a merry fledgling, these were set in stoicism. Balan fumbled for a translation as Finrod continued the introduction. Gui…gui…he could not place it. Cui was life, he knew, lin…pool or mere, perhaps? Song? He tried not to laugh at the thought of “life’s song” denoting this dower visage, but at least he had committed it to memory. Oh gods all, he had missed the title. Lord of some domain or other—he would ask Nóm later.
Then the last at the table, seated beside the king’s place. As with the marchwarden at the fen crossings, Balan felt the weight of years as a tangible presence about her. She was tall, her silver hair drawn back in a single braid between the shoulders, her eyes deep brown, wells of kindness and sorrow. Balan bowed as Nóm introduced her—Meril, besain, an elder of their people and chief among the king’s household.
“Goodness go with you, lady,” he said quietly, as awestruck by her presence as he had been to see the king in his splendor.
“And wisdom mark your coming and going, aphadon. Bitter the road, but glad is the welcome when children of the One meet in friendship.”
“May your words be as light to name the path we set.”
Meril inclined her head in acknowledgment and a smile broke like morning across her face. “Manwë grant it may be so.”
Finrod shifted the second chair at his side and motioned Balan toward it. “Come,” he said, “sit and join us. We have been long hours at council already and I shall be glad of new ears to refresh my mind. Indeed you arrived as though conjured—we had begun discussing the arrival of your people.”
“I was conjured, lord,” Balan said with a quick smile, taking his place at the table, “but twas by thine own summoning.” He had fallen into the informal from habit and faltered as he realized his presumption amid the gathered council. But Nóm laughed.
“True, true—expedience and no riddle. Ever thou wilt disabuse my feigned mysteries.” He too shifted his address and met Balan’s eyes in mirth, a quick brush of reassurance along the other’s thought. Then he returned his attention to the map spread over the table. “Estolad is here,” he said, reaching out to draw a finger along the Celon, “tucked in the bend of the river south of Nan Elmoth. The greater part reside within the encampment itself—we erected a village and palisade with aid from the Ambarussar—but there are fields and pastures in the leagues about it and many of the people have scattered throughout these. All told, I would estimate two thousand, perhaps? Is that accurate, Balan?”
“Near enough,” he replied with a nod. “Baran could make a full accounting if you wish a precise number.”
“Nay, I see no need for that yet.”
“Is this the full tale of your people?” Guilin’s voice was warm and musical, despite his guarded features. Perhaps after all, Balan thought, his translations had not been so far from the mark. “Or are there others yet following?”
“Of my own yes, this is the entirety. The Haladin, a people from whom we are sundered in speech, are still in the valleys on the eastern slopes, awaiting tidings before they venture further. There are yet other Men, whose tongue is more like to ours, with whom we have had dealings at times. They were before us on the westward march, but we passed them; for they are a numerous people, and yet keep together and move slowly, being all ruled by one chieftain whom they call Marach.”
“Have you knowledge of their numbers?” Faelon spoke now, his eyes keen as he studied Balan’s features.
“Of that I am less certain. The people of Marach travel in two hosts—I would think each is comparable to my own people, or rather they were when we last met east of the mountains. Of the Haladin, I know little. They travel in small parties, scattered about the land. But if pressed for a number, I would think they are more than we.”
“Eight to ten thousand, then, at a minimum.”
“Estolad and the surrounding lands can hold the number, if my cousins remain amenable.” Finrod leaned back in his chair and met Meril’s eye. “So far there has been no friction.”
“And with Elu?” Meril held his gaze, her own unreadable.
“He is ill pleased. But he concedes the land lies within what was granted us.”
“His humor will not soften when the number is twice doubled.”
“I have little doubt of it. But I sent word with Beleg at the crossings to prepare him for that eventuality, and perhaps with warning the ire may be eased. Does Tediel remain in residence?”
“She does.”
“The Iathrim emissary,” Nóm added in an aside to Balan. “I will speak with her ere the week is out and see whether we might yet bend my kinsman’s realm to hospitality.”
“There is objection beyond Thingol’s borders, aran.” Brenoril’s voice held a hesitancy it had not hitherto and Balan saw the king’s jaw twitch in response.
“The High King is displeased that I sent word overlate.”
“That may be, lord, but I spoke not of it.”
Balan saw the sharp glance, the look of questioning, and realized it was his own presence that held the conversation arrested. “Please,” he interjected quietly, “do not let fear of insult hinder your speech. I’ve led my people long enough to know that caution is not condemnation. I will take no offense.”
Brenoril inclined her head toward him in gratitude, then turned back to the king. “There is discontent among your own people as well. The rumors of Tirion are not wholly forgotten.”
“Lies of the Shadow,” Finrod’s voice was sharp. “Have we not reaped its rancid fruit long enough to know it is foul?”
“Twas ever a seed of truth around which he wove the lies, Findaráto.” Meril spoke quietly, but at the sound of her words Balan saw Finrod bite back the rebuke he had begun. “And so were we snared. Such deception is long in the shedding.”
The king nodded, then sat for a time in silence before he spoke again. “What course would you advise, then, having heard the nature of this disquiet?”
“It is but variations on the old unrest.” Guilin took up the thread, seeing Brenoril hesitate. “The Secondborn are found and some say it is as we were warned—they are not content to hold lands in the east, but have come seeking too these that we purchase with our life and blood. The lesser children reach for the inheritance of the first, even as Fëanor spoke in Tirion. What has our siege bought, they murmur, but to leave us pinned between the abonnen and the Sea.” He paused as the king took this in, then continued in a measured tone. “I would advise moving quickly to reassure them against these rumors. Establish these first venturers as sworn allies, subject to your command if they will have it. Present them as comrades in the long struggle and not beneficiaries only. It will not end the rumors, but it may disperse them and mitigate their harm.”
“They are established as such already,” Finrod’s finger traveled absently over the map, moving through the forests of Ossiriand, “in oath and in purpose.”
“Then let that be known. Have him swear fealty before the court that such loyalty may be seen in evidence.” Guilin turned toward Balan in afterthought, “If you are willing to do so.”
Finrod’s voice cut through before Balan could respond. “No. He shall not be bandied about in this. He has given me his oath already. Requiring anything further says naught but that his word is doubted.”
“A public profession would instill trust, vandatar.” Gildor’s glance at the king was apologetic. “They have not the knowledge of your months among the Edain.”
“Then let them look to my discernment and trust what I have welcomed.”
“I am willing, lord.” Balan’s voice was quiet and steady beside him.
“Balan—“
“What is it to me to speak the words again? If it sets thy people at ease, then I am glad to do it. It is no loss to my pride.”
“Is the oath yours to give, Beldarion?” Meril turned toward him and Balan felt again the daunting weight of her attention. “If I understand it aright, you have passed that office to another. Is it your son we should approach instead with this request?”
“Nay, it is within my right. Baran accepted my role as emissary and as such I have authority to speak on his behalf. He knows the oath I swore and holds himself sworn to the same. You may consider my words his own on this.”
Finrod remained silent and his gaze drifted again to the map, lingering over the twisting line of the Celon. “Thou art certain in this?” he asked at last.
“I am. Through long years we have wandered, seeking to escape the dominion of the Dark Lord and his Shadow, only to find him here before us. I will not serve him in this land or in any other, whether by deed or omission. Let me aid where I may.”
The king nodded and looked up at Guilin. “I concede the wisdom of it, and if Balan is willing then I am amenable. Only I ask that I might take council with him alone ere I give my full assent.”
“As you wish, lord.” Guilin rose in deference and the others followed in swift succession. “You know better than we the complexities of their culture—and as well as we the rancor of whispered venom. We will uphold your judgement in this.”
“Thank you, Guilin, it is kindly spoken. And my thanks to you all,” Finrod added as he swept the others into his gaze with a smile. “I have kept you an inexcusable length to sate my desire for tidings. Go with my gratitude and be free of any such demands till the morrow.”
Balan felt his old anxiety return as he watched the others depart. The silence remained heavy between them well after the room emptied—even Edrahil had withdrawn, presumably to take up his same position on the far side of the door—and the only sound amid the stillness was Balan’s own breathing. There was a panorama of images across the walls, he noted as he sought to divert his unease; lifelike in their detail. There were trees and vines winding across this near wall, tossing waves rising upon the further, the foam upon them wrought from natural formations in the rock. A flock of sea birds soared out from above these and Balan wondered in a brief flash of recognition whether these were the páni Nóm had described, following their vessels home from the sea. Beside these, a cascade of stone poured down in draping folds, reminding him of the underside of a mushroom, or of Nóm’s hair when they swam, ribboned in wet strands across his shoulders. Longing strained within him for those meadows and banks, the mundanes of Estolad, pristine and beloved now in their absence.
“There are other ways to solve this.” Nóm’s voice cracked the silence at last, eyes fixed still upon the map and one long finger tracing along the table’s grain. “Thou art under no obligation to let them parade thee as a pawn in our politics. Not for such did I grant thee leave at my side.”
“Twas diplomacy that I told my sons in reason,” Balan said with a shrug and a lopsided smile, unnerved by the other’s agitation and fumbling for a remedy. “It may as well be true in this. Let me swear whatever will lay peace between our peoples.”
“Thou hast sworn it already.”
“Aye, and so I understand thee not. What difference should the repetition make? Thou hadst no opposition to my word in Ossiriand.”
“No, for then I had not—” Finrod cut himself off and leaned forward, his hands pressed flat upon the table.
Balan watched in consternation, feeling the distance of the past day tighten about him. Then in trial, he hazarded the intimacy of their journey, his voice low, fervent. “I would give any oath of thine asking, Elenya.”
A spasm crossed the other’s face and for a moment Nóm’s voice too broke out unguarded. “Only one would I have of thee, and that I cannot ask.”
“Name it and it is thine.” Balan’s blood was fire as the other looked up and held his eye, for courage and desperation had mingled and he cast aside any barrier to his thought, laying it exposed for Nóm’s study. Let him see each burning strand of devotion, Balan thought recklessly, surely there was naught left by now that had not been guessed already. The candle flickered on the table as they held motionless, thought bound to thought, pulse pounding in time with pulse, transfixed.
It was Finrod who broke away first, flinching back from the fierce honesty of Balan’s gaze. He turned to the wood grain once more, but his hand trembled now as it traced the pattern and he breathed as one who had been sprinting.
“Nay,” he managed with a forced lightness, “naught will I take of thee beyond what was sworn already.” Then his hand darted out to catch the other’s wrist, his fingertips resting against the site of the blood bond. “It was enough.”
“Then let it be enough still, only with witnesses to hold it true.” Balan moved his free hand to rest upon the other’s, beginning at last to understand the reticence behind his words. “Not a word more, Nóm. I will not bind myself beyond that obligation without thy will.”
“Not a word more,” Finrod repeated, his eyes averted yet, but the fingers encircling Balan’s wrist gripped nearly to the point of pain. “Promise me.”
“Any oath of thine asking, Elenya. It is thine.”
Finrod nodded and drew in a deep breath, steadied his voice. “As thou wilt, then.” He turned back at last and managed a weary smile. “Thou art in the right, of course. I am being foolish, but I will not deny thy good sense. Come,” he said, standing, “we shall tell Guilin he has my assent.”
Balan rose to follow him, but Nóm turned back as if in afterthought, setting his hand once more to the other’s face. “Thou wilt always stand out among us, Balan,” he said softly, drawing his thumb along the cheekbone, and Balan shivered beneath his caress, the touch of palm to fresh skin running as lightning through his senses. “But that is not an ill.”
Then his hand fell back to his side once again and he turned away, leading them out past the swans’ gaze, only now Balan felt it prickle along his scalp in accusation.
❈❈❈
Finrod walked through the garden, a carefully folded bundle tucked beneath one arm, and he filled his lungs with the breeze that wafted down the rock walls. He had been giddy as a child when the chief Casári craftsman led him through the caverns to emerge blinking in the midst of a wide sinkhole. The positioning of the precipice on the hills above left the approach inaccessible and Gundin had described with precision how they could carve the royal quarter looking out upon it, filling those halls with daylight while maintaining a defensive integrity. Finrod never tired of it, the uncanny riot of life burgeoning up from the midst of stone passages, a glad song amid the caution.
He crossed it now with quick steps and paused before the doors to Balan’s chambers. He had intended them for Artanis when the city was delved, and placed them thus a stone’s thrown from his own—he and Nerwen could meander in and out as they had in childhood, each thought half-formed until known by the other. Hesitating on the threshold now, he realized it was the first time he had approached these rooms without feeling the pang of their emptiness.
Balan stood beside the line of shelves, illuminated in the afternoon light, and he hummed a quiet melody as he worked. He had at last begun settling into the chambers, nearly a week after their arrival, and Finrod smiled to see the care with which he placed each item upon the stone. It was a sparse collection, but it warmed the room with the familiarity of Estolad.
“I know you’re there.” The amused voice drifted back to him, the Taliska too tinting the air with comfort, and Finrod laughed.
“Betrayed by my own instruction,” he said, moving into the room, and he smiled as Balan turned toward him. He was clad simply in loose breeches and a plain linen shirt, the latter provided by Finrod’s attendant when Balan’s own were taken to be cleaned of the journey’s wear. It was overlarge, but he had kept it after those were returned, for he found the Elven fabric light and breathable in the summer’s warmth. Finrod decided it suited him. Taken together with his bare feet, the rolled sleeves and dropped shoulders gave him a boyish look amid the formality of the chambers, and the king found it an effort of will not to reach out and bury his fingers in the tousled hair.
An answering flicker danced from Balan’s eyes. In contrast to the other, Finrod had donned the greater part of his ceremonial robes, for Guilin’s proposed rite was a few hours hence. It was vain of him, he knew, but he took a distinct delight in the awed admiration that leapt across Balan’s features whenever he appeared in court attire. And consequently, Finrod admitted to himself with faint chagrin, he had dressed with more formality since their arrival than any of the occasions necessitated.
“You’ve decided to stay, then?” he asked in jest, glancing at the shelved items.
“Aye,” Balan grinned in return and reached down to retrieve another from the bags beside him. “Well, the return seemed tedious—and you keep good wine.” He rested a wooden box beside the others, opening it briefly to set Baran’s carved otter inside, then he shifted it into place on the shelf.
Finrod remembered that box from the long winter in Estolad. Balan had shown him the contents as they passed the hours one evening, lifting each item with a quiet reverence as he told of its significance. Within it lay his mother’s ring, an amulet from his father, a necklace that belonged to Esrid, a lock of hair from both Baran and Belen’s childhood. As Balan added the carved otter, Finrod’s quick glance noted a sprig of holly had been added to the contents as well, and he recognized it as the same he tucked behind Balan’s ear while they prepared for the Longest Night. His heart contracted.
“It felt out of place at first,” Balan shifted back from Taliska as he placed the last of the items on the shelf, “my things displayed in the midst of this splendor. But I thought it would be preferable to the emptiness, and now I find they center both place and comfort.” He stepped back and his eyes were warm as he surveyed his work. “I am glad of them.”
“And I,” Finrod said quietly as he moved to stand beside him, looking at the little collection. “It is joy unexpected to see them so merrily at home.”
They remained quiet for a long moment, then Balan glanced over with a chuckle. “Well then, what is it?” he asked with a nod at the bundle Finrod held tucked beneath his arm. “A cat in cream thou art, and hiding it poorly. What hast thou brought?”
“A presumption, I fear.” Finrod’s tone was sheepish, but his eyes danced as he held it out toward the other.
“Too small to be horses, at least,” Balan observed in amusement as he set it on the bed and loosed the ribbon binding it closed. The outer cloth fell away and he caught his breath in a gasp. There were three long tunics folded within it, each wrought from the same rich fabric that robed the king, and Balan saw at once from the crossed necklines and clasps that they were designed after the fashion of his own people. “Nóm…” His voice was husky as he lifted each from the linen wrapping. This first was green, deep as pine needles, and set about in gold with an interlacing pattern of birds and vines and snowdrop flowers. Midnight blue followed, with Elbereth’s artistry woven in silver across its length. Menelmacar raised his sword over the right shoulder. Then came red, sharp as fire, twelve-pointed suns worked across its folds in golden thread. He stared at this last, speechless.
“There is no need for thee to wear them, shouldst thou find more comfort in thine own.” Finrod’s voice rushed out in a torrent as he watched Balan draw his hand along the shimmering embroidery. “Thine are more than suited for any needs at court and I would not have thee think this is meant in disparagement. Only I wished to give thee something of beauty—beauty that is of thine own—and so I had Sídhon take their measure while he cleaned the others, and I gave direction from there. I hope I have not recounted any element in error.”
“Twas four days past when Sídhon came for them…”
“They worked swiftly.” Finrod’s quick smile carried an air of embarrassment. “But canst thou see here? It is patterned in vines, but tis the same motif that repeats across thine own. Here the loop and the turn, the lines crossed and bordered, again here and ‘round about the cuff. It is the same too on these others, only on this it is marked in seed pearls and about the dawn it carries in gold.” He glanced across at Balan, beaming, then faltered as he took in the stunned incredulity. “Forgive me, I am dwelling on whims. The other three should be completed within another enquië.”
“Another three!”
“Nay, chide me not, tis no excess. A full set is six. Thou canst judge then whether they suit or no.”
“Whether they suit?” Balan fell into his own tongue in wonderment and he laughed. “You daft creature, they are more beautiful than aught I’ve ever owned.” He traced a finger over the central sun and his face reflected its warmth, a smile casting lines from each eye, the gathered rays of his mirth springing forth. “Nahtan steiha,” he murmured as his hand came to rest over the gold.
”So that all might see thee as through my gaze, Anarinya.” Finrod felt his own honesty leap unbidden to his eyes and he looked away quickly, turning his face toward the embroidered light. “Hope unforeseen in the darkness.”
❈❈❈
Balan was avenged, came the first thought.
The doors of the great hall had parted and Finrod's breath fled as he watched the other step through the archway, flanked on each side by one of the king’s own guards and robed in Anar’s fire. He had instructed the artisans to weave the patterned suns from thread used in his own robes, wrought with elven skill so that it fell into harmony with the cavern lamps, holding their light within its sheen and seeming itself luminous in effect.
Balan was a blaze of light, beautiful as the dawn, and Finrod could not take his eyes from him.
“Nahtan steiha,” he whispered in echo of Balan’s exclamation, and felt Meril’s eyes shift toward him, questioning. She was first among the lords who flanked the throne, eight upon each side, and held the seat of honor at his right. He had often felt her pondering gaze since his return and knew that if any, she would be the first to see through any pretense and note at once what he had hidden from his own sight. But he held his mind tight and set his face in the firm lines of sovereignty, his thumb pressed against the carved throne so that a leaf’s point held his composure steady. For as the king watched his heart move toward him across the hall’s expanse, he felt the same awe threaten his own features that had drowned Balan’s when he fell to his knees before the gathered council. He was indeed paid back in kind.
They reached the foot of the dais, Calano and Canneth turning sharply to stand at attention on each side of the aisle’s end, and Balan remaining alone in the open space between them. He looked up to meet the king’s eye, tall and proud amid the gathered assembly, undaunted now by the grandeur about him. He knelt.
“Balan son of Beldar of the Edain,” Finrod’s voice rang out over the hall as he delivered the inquiries of service, “have you come as herald of your kindred, an emissary of those people you name the Wrotenne?”
“Lord, I have.” Balan’s voice too carried over the rock face, deep and earthen beside the king’s.
“And as envoy of such, are you granted authority to speak on behalf of them, to bind oaths in your lord’s name, to forge such ties as you see fit?”
“I am so granted.”
“And in that authority, is it your intent to ally your people in bonds of fealty and service to my house and to this crown?”
“It is my intent and that of my people, willingly offered.” Balan rose once more and stood at the base of the steps, his hands held open before him, and called out the answering challenges. “King of Nargothrond and lord of the third house of the Ñoldor, are you granted authority by the High King of your people to accept the fealty offered?”
“I am so granted.”
“And in that authority is it your intent to accept my people as your own subjects? To hold us in love and obligation as our lord, rendering such aid and protection as befits the bonds of duty, upholding justice and mercy in all your judgements?”
“Such is my intent and my vow.”
Balan laid his hands crossed upon his chest and bowed, then ascended the three steps of the dais and knelt before the king.
“As I swore to you once, so I offer my pledge now in the sight of witnesses, that my words may be held true and the fealty of my people marked in remembrance.” He set his hands palm to palm and held them out before the king.
“Take then my oath in fealty, pledged to you on behalf of the chieftain of my clan. Accept my loyalty and that of my people, bound in faithfulness and truth to you as our lord, to hold dear as you hold dear, to scorn what you disdain, to serve you in constancy all our days.”
Finrod took the outstretched hands within his own, and at once felt the far off wind from a bluff overlooking fields of flax. As whatever thou wilt…only send me not from thy side. He held tight as he looked down at the other and this time he did not draw the hands apart.
“So is it heard,” Nóm replied, his voice lifted with an effort, “and so it is accepted.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
Aiwenórë: [Q] "Birdland" or the lower air
Tolo: [S] come!
Noro lim: [S] run swift
Galdol, aran nin: [S] Welcome, my king!
Balan Beldarion i eneth dîn: [S] His name is Balan son of Beldar.
Sin mardenya: [Q] this is my home
Vandatar: [Q] roughly “oath-father,” an approximation for “foster-father,” combining vanda (oath, pledge, solemn promise) and atar (father).
Mellon nin: [S] my friend
Besain: [S] the Lady, breadgiver
Aphadon: [S] Sindarin form of Hildor: Men/Followers
enquië: [Q] Eldarin six-day week
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
- nahtan steiha: night is ended
- Wrotenne: (archaic) wandering folk
MISC NOTES
- For an explanation of the ghomennin, see chapter 2, Grief in All Her Guises.
- In the context of this series, it is held that Meril is a matriarch of Nargpthrond. Given her role as the massánië or besain, a historian once misidentified her as the queen, as such often fills the place of massánië.
13. And Still the Light Returns
Belen was near. He had passed the Narog that morning and must be well within the highlands by now. Any moment, he would appear from the trees, shifting from longing to presence through the twilit shadows. The parting would be mended, his son was coming home.
Now settled in Nargothrond, Balan looks forward to welcoming his younger son to join him there. But each has changed in the months since Balan’s departure and they navigate these distances in past and present, home and journey, presence and absence.
Read 13. And Still the Light Returns

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, WINTER
Nargothrond
Once again, Finrod caught sight of him through the trees. He was poised beside the Ringwil this time, one shoulder hitched against an ash tree, and his profile sharp in the evening light. He must have kept vigil at the ford for at least an hour now, despite Finrod’s assurance that there was time enough to reach the crossing once word came of their approach. At first Balan had allowed himself to be placated. But as the day drew on, the restlessness only increased and at last he set out alone. By now he could recognize the imperceptible marks of the High Faroth’s trail and from the gates to the ford, at least, he could find his way unguided. The walk would allow him to shift impatience to exertion, he had said with a rogue’s grin, and that would be a welcome respite for all. A smile tugged at Finrod’s lips as he looked upon him now, eyes fixed on the far bank and anxious impatience prickling off of him like sparks.
It was three weeks past that Gildor had departed with the messengers bound for Estolad, and the sentries at last sent word that the return party had reached the Narog. Four Elves, they reported, and one of the Atani. Finrod felt Balan’s heart sink at this last, despite the warm smile he summoned. The invitation had included Baran and Estreth as well, but only Belen had ridden forth. Balan should have expected such a course, he confessed to Finrod once the sentries had gone, the summer’s parting had hardly been warm.
Finrod tried to reassure him that refusal needn’t indicate bitterness. It would be a high cost for Baran to depart so soon after taking up his role, whereas Belen was unbound and free to go at will. It was duty, not denouncement. Balan had nodded and thanked him, but Finrod saw the pain lingering in the lines of his smile, and alongside it the determination not to cause the king worry.
It had been nearly two months since Balan was brought down by the long fever that plagued his people, and still Finrod could not shake the undercurrent of watchful fear which lingered well after his recovery. It had come on during the night, but none were aware till the following afternoon when Finrod wandered into his apartments and found him shaking and delirious, clinging desperately to every blanket on the bed. He shuddered even now as he recalled the ragged breathing and the shock of Balan’s skin beneath his palm, burning hot and clammy with sweat. It was only the memory of Estreth tending others through the previous winter that kept him from falling into a helpless panic as he cried out for Sídhon and began pulling the blankets aside. Balan had fought against this, grasping feebly at the linen and wool as they were dragged back, then curling into himself when that failed, shivering uncontrollably.
Finrod had stroked the damp hair back from his forehead and tried to recall Estreth’s techniques as all throughout the next days he and Sídhon worked in tandem, setting cold compresses to cool the flesh, carrying him to and from the lukewarm baths, cleaning the vomit from the bedside basin. He had witnessed illness during his time in Estolad, this was no new revelation, but nonetheless his heart contracted in fear whenever Balan doubled over and retched, or lay trembling and weak in the aftermath. The fragility was inescapable in these moments, the spirit’s hold like gossamer. Naught could induce the king to leave his side and he spent each sleepless night beside Balan’s bed, changing out the compresses or sitting motionless with the other’s hand clasped within his own, till he too was near collapse.
Celiel had attempted to shift him after the third night. As chief among the healers, she said, it was incumbent upon her to learn the maladies and treatment of the Secondborn, now that one dwelt here among them. It was incumbent upon her too, she had added, to advise the king that his own wellbeing should not be discarded in concern for the other. This last was shrugged aside, but Celiel kept vigil alongside him for the remaining nights. It was helpful, he found, to have the distraction of handing his small knowledge into her keeping. He told her every practice he gleaned from watching Estreth’s work, each detail he had learned while tending Belen the year before. It eased the dread to discuss it abstractly, and the sound of his voice seemed to soothe Balan’s restless slumber.
Finrod breathed deep of the winter air as he moved forward through the trees. His heart strained at every sight of him now, here and whole, living and vibrant and himself once again. Balan was wrapped in the same fur-lined coat he had worn in Estolad, bound about the waist with a heavy belt, and his toe scuffed patterns in the frosted pine needles carpeting the bank.
”Haelis, Balan!” Thought and voice reached out together, and Balan turned toward him in the same.
“Haelis, Nóm.” His eyes crinkled in amusement. “I concede—thy patience had the measure of it. I’ve gained naught but a cold hour.”
“Art thou chilled? We should have awaited them at the gates.” A flicker of concern crossed Finrod’s brow and he reached out in reflex to touch the back of his fingers to the other’s forehead.
“I’m cold, not endangered.” Balan twitched away with a chuckle. “And thou shouldst leave off ere Belen is here or I’ll have the both of you surveilling my every breath and never a moment’s folly permitted. It has been weeks, Nóm, I’m hale as I’ve ever been.” He cast a quick grin back at the king, then his eyes darted again to the far side of the Ringwil. Belen was near. He had passed the Narog that morning and must be well within the highlands by now. Any moment, he would appear from the trees, shifting from longing to presence through the twilit shadows. The parting would be mended, his son was coming home. “Besides,” Balan added as he tried not to pace, “I’ll not have him dragged through that specter of a gate on his own. It tried even my resolve, and I had begged thee to bring me hither.”
Finrod glanced down at him in chagrin. “That was rather unforgivable of me. In my vanity, I thought to awe thee by the surprise, and gave little heed to the fright it would conjure. But bear no fear on thy son’s behalf—Gildor would not have indulged such conceit. Ai!” he smiled and pointed into the trees, “They have come!”
“Where?” Balan stepped forward to the edge of the shore, his sight straining into the twilight. “A plague upon these eyes, I see them not. Where are they?”
“There.” Finrod pointed again and laughed as he caught hold of Balan’s arm, keeping him from charging through the ford in his impatience. “At the edge of the clearing, where the day’s light yet lingers.”
Balan saw him then, crossing into the speckled gold, nimble on the back of his bay mare as he rode side by side with Gildor through the waving boughs. Belen! Had he been so tall when they parted? He looked a man now, despite the short months between them. His hair had grown to his shoulders and his poise was natural and self-possessed upon the horse’s back, and his father stood speechless upon the hither bank as he watched him move through the clearing. Only once had he seen Esrid ride, long ago upon those far plains east of the mountains. She and Geberic returned to her village one evening, galloping through the hay meadow where Balan wandered, and even then he had been arrested by her presence, thundering past upon that imposing creature, her own form powerful and sure.
And her son, riding toward him now in the dappled sunlight, was the very image of her.
“Vatta!” Belen had sighted them as well and at once his horse broke into a swift trot. He was to the ford within moments and water dashed up from the hooves as he urged the mare forward through the crossing.
“Belen!” He found his voice at last as his son leapt from the saddle and flew into his arms. And oh, he was the same yet, not so much changed—the same warmth, the same sharp line of his shoulders, the same arms wrapping about his neck, the same scent of home. He clutched him tight against his chest and breathed him in. “Ai, Bel, my boy, my boy…Here, let me see you.” Balan took him by the shoulders and drew him back into his sight, laughing despite the tears on his cheeks. “How I have missed you!” He laughed again and cupped his son’s face within his hands. “And how well you look! You’ve grown a year’s worth in a mere season. Where is the boy I left in the summer?”
“Here before you, the same as you last saw him.” Belen’s smile filled his face. “And you, you are well?”
“Aye,” Balan said, brushing his hand over Belen’s hair, “I am well.”
“Gildor told me you’ve been ill?”
“Naught but the usual fever.”
“He said it was grave.”
“It was no worse than the winter ere we crossed the mountains.” Balan waved away his concern, then glanced toward Finrod in amusement. “They do not know illness, so every cough is a cause to fret.”
“Yet even you will grant a near fortnight abed is justified concern,” Finrod retorted with an answering grin, then turned toward Belen and his smile shifted into warm welcome. “Haelis, Belen. Your coming has been awaited with great joy—and it is a glad hour in which I greet you again!”
“Goodness go with you, Nóm,” Belen replied, then the bright grin broke across his face once more and he threw his arms about the king in the same warm greeting. “You have been missed.”
“As have you, Bel.” Finrod laughed as he embraced him in turn, then the mirth mirrored onto his own features. “And how are my donkeys?”
Belen laughed. “Not half so indulged, and thus are far more diligent vassals.” He glanced up at him as he stepped back, the grin shining yet. “Though I still bring them apples on your behalf. Honeg waits at the edge of the fold each evening—looking for you, I’d guess—and I pass him an extra when the others aren’t looking.”
“Dear Honeg…” Finrod smiled. “I shall bring him a basket full of them when next I visit, and a halter fit for the little lord of his kind.”
There was a series of splashes as Gildor and his companions reached the ford and joined them on the hither side.
“Suil, vandatar.”
“Na vedui!” Finrod crossed with a smile and embraced him in greeting. “The journey was smooth?”
“Yes, all peaceful. We had no trouble.”
“Good. And the crossings?”
“Civil.” There had been a brief hesitation before the answer, and Finrod’s responding glance held a sharp query. But Gildor shook his head imperceptibly and turned to retrieve his horse’s reins. “We made quick time once we reached the Talath Dirnen. Your son is a swift rider,” he added to Balan with a smile.
“Aye, and a swift study,” Balan replied, pride radiating from his smile. “Though this is in his blood. His mother sat a horse with rare skill.” Then he turned to his son with a quick smile. “You ride very like her, Bel.”
“Madja said the same.” Belen’s eyes were wistful, but pleased.
“Mm. I’m sure she did. And how does she fare?” Balan indicated the path as he and Belen led the way back toward the gorge of the Narog. “Has she forgiven me yet?”
“I don’t think there’s a child left in Estolad whom she hasn’t taught to hold their own upon a horse,” Belen replied with a chuckle, stepping about the question. “She’s set out plans already to turn these we have into a full herd. We’ll be a riding people within another generation if her schemes all come to fruition.”
“Good,” Balan let the question fall away and did not press. “It’s a shift long overdue, and negligence on my part that I did not see to it while we lived alongside their people.”
Finrod and Gildor walked together, dropping several horse-lengths behind to allow the two men space for their reunion. “Elu’s reticence has not softened, then.”
“It has not. There was no open animosity, but they were sharp with the boy and the mood at the crossings was cold. I relayed thy correspondence on the road east, but there was no answer awaiting upon the return journey. The news of additional incursions has not eased his frustration.”
“No, it would not. Mitigation was all I hoped, but even that seems like to be a naive intention.” Finrod’s eyes drifted along with Balan and Belen ahead of them, marking the lightened set of Balan’s shoulders, the laugh drifting back, the eyes that sought his son more often than the path ahead, and he felt his own heart filled with the other’s joy. “And what of his other son?” he asked with an undercurrent of trepidation. “Has he sent word or is the absence his response?”
“Both,” Gildor replied, his voice lowered to a breath. “He said he would not set aside the duty of his position for personal leisure. Nor could he countenance leaving his people leaderless in the first winter as their chieftain.”
“A concise and polite rebuke.”
“I believe he said more to Belen, and with less diplomacy, but I’ll not relay it if Belen does not.” Gildor shifted his cloak from the angle he wore while riding and wrapped it about his arms. “The intervening time has done little to alleviate the break, I fear. Rather, it has but ripened from hurt to anger. Certainly that is the case for the boys’ aunt. Though I confess,” he added with a twitch of his lips, “her candor was refreshingly blunt.”
Something near a laugh escaped Finrod’s lips at the thought of his shy foster-son confronted with the sardonic clip of Estreth’s tongue. Well, the boy seemed unscathed.
“Thy gifts were well received,” Gildor continued as Finrod’s eyes drifted again to the pair ahead of them, “and all asked of thee. They hoped I brought tidings of when they might find thee again among them. I said I knew not, but would tell thee thy welcome is ever held in gladness.”
❈❈❈
It was just as Balan imagined it, walking these familiar passages with Belen at his side. All his son’s new gravity fell away as they passed through the gatehouse and he took in the grandeur, his eyes wide with boyish wonder. Balan was amused to recognize the excitement in his own voice as he pointed out each facet and cavern, the intricacies about them, the innovations they passed. It was his arrival reprised, only now he played the part of Nóm, giddy and earnest, while the king walked behind them and the warmth of his joy wrapped through Balan’s every thought.
“I’ve had a full meal laid out here,” Balan said as they reached his apartments. The king had parted from them as they reached the royal quarter, that they might have time uninterrupted, and Balan felt a sheepish pride as he ushered his son into his own chambers. “Selfish of me, perhaps, but I wished to have you to myself this first evening. Tomorrow will suit for dinners and introductions. And besides,” he added as he closed the door and took Belen’s coat, setting it aside with his own, “formalities are a poor companion to rest, and you’ve had a long journey.”
“This is all yours?”
“Aye.” Balan chuckled and glanced at his son with a sidelong smile. “Unconscionably large, hm?”
Belen’s responding laugh was incredulous and he drifted further into the room, drawing one hand along the wall, the polished rock gliding against his palm. “It’s beautiful, vatta.” His voice whispered over the carved walls, entranced. “How have they done it? The stone is a song almost.”
“Even so. The carving was a kind of music, to hear Nóm tell it.” Balan could not take his eyes from Belen’s face, warm in the glow of the hearth, flesh and no phantom. “They sang as they worked the stone, keeping time with pick and hammer as we do in our own work. He says you can hear it still in the echoes of the passages, but I’ve never yet found aught but footsteps.”
“Nóm would hear a song in anything.” The boy’s grin flashed out in quick mirth. “It probably was naught but footsteps, only he turned it to music somehow. Do you remember the cart wheels on the road to Estolad? ’Tis a rare music beneath you, Belen—tree and earth and living creature in chorus together—drum and descant in one’.” Belen chuckled again and knelt down in front of the fire to warm himself. “I’m glad to see him again too. I’ve missed the both of you.” Then his eyes caught sight of the other openings connected into the hearth and he craned his neck about in curiosity. “Are there more rooms than this?”
“Two others. Come see.” He caught Belen’s hand and pulled him to his feet. “Here is the most absurd bath you’ve ever seen,” he chuckled as he opened the first door and the light shone in to illuminate the carved tree trunk. “Though it’s also the most blissful thing I’ve ever known, so you’ve not heard a word of mockery from my lips, lest they think I scorn it and take it away in courtesy. And here,” he crossed to the far side of the hearth where the library door stood open already, “is the one I like best. A room whose sole purpose, as far as I can tell, is thought and study.”
The wonder spread once again across Belen’s features as he stepped through the archway and saw the walls lined with scrolls and books.
“Look,” his father said as he drew a book from the nearest wall, “they bind it together into one block, do you see? Here along the edge, they’ve stitched it like a garment. And each of these is filled with tales or history or lore…knowledge, Bel, leaves upon leaves of knowledge.”
“Each one of these?” Belen ran his fingers along the spines on the shelf before him.
“Aye. And this is only what was housed here. There is a small cavern full of them as well—the library of the king—and this is a mere acorn of that.” Balan reached out to shift a pile of loose parchment upon the table and Belen could see many were scrawled across with halting characters, sections of script repeated over and again. Balan indicated these with a self-deprecating grimace and the quick glance at his son was both embarrassed and proud. “He is teaching me to write it, and to read it. I’m afraid I’m a rather slow study. Language itself has ever come to me quickly, but I feel a child again attempting the writing of it.” Then his face lit up with potential and he looked back at Belen with a broad smile. “He can teach you as well, now that you’re here. You would learn it easily, I’m sure of it. You have ever been quick with patterns and signs.”
“Aye, perhaps!” Belen’s smile was noncommittal, but he looked down at the character charts and trial phrases with interest.
“Only if you wish it.” Balan ran a hand back through his hair, upended by his own anxiety and feeling as though he was stumbling through conversations that were once second nature. He returned the pages to the table, then reached out to rest his hand behind Belen’s neck—a gesture of affection he had used since the boy’s childhood—and was relieved to feel him lean into the caress. “I am so very glad to have you here, Bel.”
Belen nodded as he shifted the parchment about on the table, but his eyes were distant and not attending to the figures before him. Then a little choked sound escaped his lips and he turned abruptly, wrapping his arms about his father and clinging to him as fiercely as at their parting in Estolad.
Balan gathered him close in surprise, stroking the hair back from Belen’s head where it lay buried against him, the slight shoulders trembling as his tears ran down his father’s neck. “There, my boy,” he murmured and held him close, “I am here.” Balan’s composure broke then too, and he leaned his face in against Belen’s hair and wept as he clutched him in his arms. “Oh my son,” he whispered into the dark curls, “I have missed you more than I could bear.”
“He said you’d been unwell,” Belen’s voice was muffled as much by emotion as by his father’s shoulder, and he gripped handfuls of Balan’s tunic within his fists as though he might slip away. “And all I could think was I might have lost you and never known till word made its way. Or that you might still go ere I reached you.”
“Ai, Belen…Hfaskebel…” He smoothed the hair back from his son’s eyes and cradled the damp cheeks within his palms. Esrid had given him the nickname—hedgehog—when he was naught more than an infant, laughing at how he curled his arms and legs together when he slumbered, like a tiny ball within his sleeping basket. “I am here. You have not lost me.”
Belen nodded as his father’s hands moved to rest on his shoulders, and he tried to steady his breathing. “He didn’t mean to worry me,” he said, his voice still rough with emotion, “only when he told me, it sounded…” He trailed off again and wiped the heel of his hand against his eyes in a futile attempt to stem the tears.
“Gildor had not seen a fever before. He’d nothing to compare it to, so he gauged by the king’s manner, and Nóm was worried—of course he was, he never attended to one of us alone, much less with the closest aid from our folk nearly a fortnight distant.” Balan squeezed his son’s shoulder in comfort and his face creased with mirth. “He’s been at my heel like a sheepdog ever since.”
“Aye,” Belen laughed at last through the lingering tears, “I know that well enough. That was all the road to Estolad, and months beyond too. Does he insist you rest every hour?”
“And always wear a layer more than is comfortable.”
“And keeps a count somehow of everything you’ve eaten in a day.”
“And if you say a word of tiredness or discomfort—”
“You find yourself seated before you’d any notion you moved and then assigned an hour at leisure whether you’d like it or no.” Belen’s laugh was unhindered now and he grinned up at his father. “I’ve missed you, vatta.”
Balan smiled in return and felt his heart overflowing with his presence. “I cannot tell you how good it is to hear your laugh in these rooms. How empty they have seemed without it!” He felt the lump growing in his throat once more, so he tousled the boy’s hair and led the way back into the main chamber. “Come, there’s food ready and you’ve had a long journey, but here I am keeping you from it with books and scrolls.”
“I don’t mind.” He followed his father back through the archway and to a small table that had been set before the fire, shaking his head once again as he sat and looked about the chamber. “I still can’t believe all this is yours…”
“Yours are hardly less.” Balan shifted the cloths that covered the various dishes and folded them as he spoke. “I thought to have you here, but Nóm insisted you have your own. They’re not far—just above these—and they too look out on the garden. I’ll show you once you’ve eaten.”
“My own?” His son looked startled as he settled himself at the table.
“He said it would be poor hospitality else.” Balan chuckled and portioned the meat between their plates, setting the greater part upon Belen’s.
“How many empty rooms does he keep lying about?”
“Many. It’s intended as a refuge, so they delved far more than need required. There’s room to house at least twice the number dwelling here now, if necessary. Go slowly with that,” he added as Belen took a long draught of wine. “It’s stronger than our mead or ale.”
“Learned by error, I take it?”
Balan offered only a grin in answer and sipped from his own glass before shifting his attention to the sliced fruit and bread. He managed several bites of these before lapsing into introspection, prodding a berry about his plate as he summoned the courage to voice the question. “How is your brother?”
“Insufferable.” The lines of Belen’s face tightened in apprehension, though he kept his tone light. “He’s horridly capable and knows it full well. You should see him manage an arbitration. It’s like watching madja’s whirling-dance at midsummer—you can’t see how it’s done, but it dizzies you just looking on.” A smile tugged at his lips and he reached for another handful of berries. “I am very proud of him.”
“And I to hear tell of it.”
“He’ll marry Sabil, I think,” Belen mumbled around a mouthful of cheese and bread, and seemed amused by the quick lift of his father’s brows. “Sometime before midsummer if I was to guess at it. It’s all but arranged now.”
“Good.” Balan took another drink from his cup and chuckled as he set it back onto the table. “He’s been long enough about it. I’ve expected that since well ere we crossed the mountains.”
“A force of nature as a chieftain. Utterly useless for his own interests.”
“He is well, though?”
“Aye. He sends his love,” Belen added, then shifted uncomfortably at the second half of the message and kept his eyes on his plate. “But he said to tell you he must decline the honor of the king’s summons, for surely you have not forgotten how much is required of him while our people settle in their new lands.”
“I see.” Balan forced a halfhearted smile and tried to hold the strain from his voice. “Very right and proper of him. I’m afraid I thought only of how I missed you both and did not stop to reason as he must.”
“I’m sure he knows that, vatta.”
“Aye, of course.” Balan refilled his glass and leaned back in the chair, picking absentmindedly at his meal. “And how fare the new lands? Word from the king’s messengers was that the harvest came in full.”
“It did. Greater even than the years we spent at the shores of Andanahti-marei.” Belen’s eyes took on a bright eagerness as he spoke and Balan was surprised at the shift from only a few months before. “It’s a marvel, vatta—the earth yields willingly, almost benevolently, and even in a brief year I’ve felt roots spreading as I never knew before. We are no longer wandering. We are home.”
For a long moment, Balan could not find the voice to answer. He knew well the sense his son had named. He had felt it first at Estolad, and like Belen he assumed it was the land embracing them, a sense of place stilling at last the compulsion to roam. But it had been Nóm, he realized when the earth’s welcome held empty comfort in the face of the other’s departure, and so he had chased that grounding across all the leagues of Beleriand, he had followed it deep below the earth. And there his own roots had grasped and taken and spread out in rest beneath the hills. Would his son feel that too, now that it was his home as well? Or would he feel only the loss of it? “I feel it too, Belen,” he managed at last, “though long was the road that carried us hence. Beyond hope, we have found its ending.”
“Aye, and its beginning too.” Belen was quiet as he finished the last of his food and his eyes lingered on the plate before him. “It was strange to pass the Longest Night without you,” he said as the time drew on. “You were gone, but I could not mark you as I mark aitha in the empty setting for the dead—which of course was a blessing, but it left only absence with naught to hold it.”
“Belen…” His father reached out to take hold of his hand across the table.
“Strange that it was easier to mark the dead than the living.” Belen’s laugh was short, tight with his trammeled emotion, and he held fast to his father’s grip. “I do not remember her, so all I’ve ever known is the lack. When you said today that I was the image of her riding, my heart leapt for it is some new way to know her, here within myself. But of you I’d known only an abundance. And I am glad of that, vatta, but I’ve known not where to place my grief.”
“Oh Bel, my boy…” Balan’s voice broke and he caught his son’s hand in both of his own now, unable to hold back the new tears that threatened.
“No, vatta, please, I didn’t mean…” He shook his head and his face furrowed in concern. “Damn this wine, I meant only that it is good to be by you again, that I have missed you dearly. Please, vatta, I meant it not in accusation.”
“I know, lad.” Balan tried to stay his tears and nodded in assurance. “I know. The accusation is my own. Not a day has gone that I do not blame myself for leaving you and your brother.” He wiped roughly at his eyes and managed a smile to ease his son’s remorse. “But tell me more of what all has passed. The king’s emissaries are well and good, but they never tell the things one wishes to hear.”
Belen laughed and the conversation was at ease again. He told of the long summer, stretching even later than the previous, of harvest and their merry scramble to store all the bounty, the onset of winter and the feasting at the Longest Night held now within the nearly-completed Hall.
They had marked it here in Nargothrond as well, and the memory of that quiet celebration lingered about the edges of Balan’s thought as he listened to his son’s tales. It had been just on the heels of his illness and he had nearly missed noting the day, still weak in his recovery and lingering within his own rooms. Nóm had arrived with the late-afternoon twilight, a basket of holly slung upon one arm and another holding all the settings for a meal. He had bound the circlets as he had the year before, while Balan recited again the tale of aithan-hropit and watched the nimble fingers weaving in the firelight. The table was laid with pork rather than the traditional boar, but it had been made with meadow garlic and seasoned with the same herbs Balan knew since childhood. Nóm had set them in mind after one meal and recalled them now without instruction. He had placed three settings—one for himself and one for Balan. The third, he said, was set for Esrid and for Alémi, and for his own dead gone before him. And in the deep night ere the dawn, Nóm had taken the roughened hands within his own and set his lips to each palm in turn. I feared night would take thee, yet still thine hands are warm, and still the light returns.
As Balan heard the rise and fall of his son’s voice, bearing these morsels of that life he had left, he too felt the fervor of warmth returned. Belen’s laugh again beside him. Belen’s words conjuring images of the home he too had loved. Belen’s voice raised in song as he carried Eimet’s new melodies here to his father’s ears—two for reaping, one that raised a fumbling rush of color to the boy’s cheeks. He’d not have sung it but for the wine, he mumbled, and had it not been made to aggravate Baran, and the emissaries would surely have been remiss on that.
And so the hours went by, filled with laughter and reminiscence, until Belen yawned and his father broke off in chagrin as he saw how low the fire had burned. “Gods all, Bel, you’ve let me keep you here talking half the night and you’re worn through from the journey.”
“No, I’m just as culpable.” His son’s eyes were bleary with fatigue, but he smiled. “I’d no wish to leave off.”
“Aye, well there’s plenty of time for that now you’re here. Come,” Balan stood and retrieved his son’s coat, then shepherded him out toward the garden courtyard, “yours are up the stair here—up and then back around to the right, just over mine.” He paused at the base of the steps as he watched Belen climb ahead of him. He had felt every league between them since they parted in Estolad and now he could see him with waking sight, his own dear boy, only a stair’s length now separating them. Balan shook his head and ascended after him. Too much wine again—he was growing maudlin. “This way,” he said as he reached the top and passed him, leading Belen to a similar set of latticework doors.
The room inside was slightly smaller than the main chamber of Balan’s apartments, and set in a near inverse. The bed faced the garden and the hearth was set in the opposite corner, venting out onto the sinkhole. But the other elements were similar—a set of seats about the fire, a cabinet to hold his clothing, a small writing desk.
Balan crossed at once to the lamp beside the bed and adjusted it to illuminate the full room. “These are quite simple,” he said as he moved to another and increased its light as well. “You’ll soon grow accustomed to them. They’re as good as daylight when you use them well, at least when compared to the rushlights we’ve relied on.” He turned back toward Belen and saw his son had paused before the side of the cabinet and was staring, transfixed, into the mirror hanging from its side. He chuckled. “Aye, startling isn’t it?” He crossed to stand behind the boy and rested a hand on his shoulder. “They still unnerve me, especially when I come upon one unexpectedly.”
“It looks as though he might step out and speak with me—as though I might step out and speak with me, I suppose I mean.”
“They never do,” Balan replied with a wry laugh, then tousled his son’s hair. His own reflection watched him over the boy’s shoulder and he eyed it with indifference. The beard had regrown during his illness and lingered still, for his interest in cutting it back had fallen away with his recovery. It was a comfort to have it, he realized as he looked on the face hovering beside his son’s, and found a new appreciation for Estreth’s small stubbornnesses. It was grounding to hold fast to his otherness. That was a bond that distance could not sever.
He squeezed Belen’s shoulder in quick affection, then turned toward the small pile of bags resting alongside the cabinet. “You’ve brought little,” he remarked as he lifted one and began transferring the belongings to their new home. Belen had never been a light traveler. So consistently had he hoarded little odds and ends that it became a running joke between Baran and Estreth to place bets on how many unique rocks or carved branches he would attempt to carry along on each new journey. But only a scant two bags had accompanied him on this latest, and his father glanced back at him in amusement.
“Aye.”
A stab of cold pierced Balan’s gut as he saw the apprehension wash over his son’s features and felt the hesitation, heard the crack in his voice.
“But Baran had wagered his good hunting knife and madja’s been coveting it for years, so I had to prove him wrong.” Belen’s tone held a forced lightness and he turned toward the second bag so he need not meet his father’s eye as he added, “and besides, it’s only to carry me through till the spring. I’ve told Baran I’ll be home in time for the sowing.”
❈❈❈
“Balan?”
Nóm’s voice drifted into the haze. It had been past midnight when Bel was settled in the rooms above, and it must have been at least another hour since—nay, several. But night still reached in from the shrouded doors, so at least he had not sat up till the dawn, which was some small mercy. Balan felt the king’s gaze resting upon him, heavy with concern, and he pulled his eyes away from the hearth and looked up. “You’ve heard, then.”
“Aye. Gildor told me as we walked.” Finrod bent down to add another pair of logs to the fire and prodded the embers back into life, then turned to watch the other once more, his eyes filled with pity. “I am so sorry, Balan.”
“You will let me follow—that was what he said, it was how we parted, and I’ve clung to it in all the days since. I would learn what kind of place it was I’d chosen, I thought, I would see things settled here and then I would send for him. And my boy would come back to me. He would come home. Foolish of me.”
“Hope is not foolish, melotornonya.”
Balan snorted in response. The affectionate term rankled beneath his skin like a splinter, at once distance and intimacy, and it burned frustration through his every fiber. There too was but another blind, foolish hope.
The king crossed to sit beside him and reached out for Balan’s hand, then he clasped it quickly within his own at the chill touch. “Ai! Cold as winter thou art,” he exclaimed, lapsing out of Taliska as he retrieved a woolen blanket from the far edge and drew it up around Balan’s shoulders. “How long hast thou sat here with the fire lying idle?”
“Leave off, I’m not a child,” Balan growled, and pushed him away as he shrugged the blanket loose. He wrapped his own arms about his chest instead and glared into the fire, the keen awareness of his own petulance only stoking his irritation.
Nóm had flinched at the sharp tone and now he drew back, chastised. “Forgive me,” he managed, “I meant no trespass.”
Remorse was quick, its fingers working up from his gut and prying through the annoyance. It was concern not condescension, he knew this. There was a clouded memory that lingered from the worst days of his fever, an image of Nóm silhouetted against the firelight, motionless at his side; of his own delirium and the sound of his voice muttering, pleading for Esrid in a hoarse whisper. And Nóm there beside him had not corrected him, had not reminded him that she was gone beyond his call; rather, he had held Balan’s hand clasped within his own and stroked the hair back from his face, and murmured comfort in the other’s own tongue. You are safe, Balan. You are here with me. I will not leave you. Now he shifted away and moved as though to depart.
“Don’t be a fool.” Balan reached out to catch hold of the other’s wrist and held him back from rising. “It was not a trespass. I am tired and heartsick, but I needn’t strike thee with the brunt of it. It is no fault of thine.”
“Twas I was brought thee hither.”
“Mm. To humor the creature against thy better judgment.” This time it was Balan who winced at his own acerbity and he wiped his hands over his face, as though clearing away a grime. “I’m sorry,” he added with a wry attempt at a smile, then shifted the blanket back around his shoulders where Finrod had placed it. “The trouble is that I’m proud of him for it—it breaks me apart and all the while fills my heart to bursting. He has found his place, he sees his value. They are a perfect compliment in so many ways, he and his brother: Baran’s the will that fires them, Bel’s the water that tempers.” He fell quiet for a long moment, then turned at last to meet the other’s eye and Finrod felt the knot about his lungs loosen, the chill between them ease. “He said as much when we spoke of it, and reminded me that I had as well, there by the palisade where we parted. His brother would have need of him, those were my very words. Only I overlooked in my grief that he too would have need of his brother.”
“They are a credit to thee, Balan—and to thy long and lonesome work.”
“They are a credit to each other.” His eyes were distant as he sat, still half-lingering within the earlier conversation. “He told me one foot yearns to stay, while the other is bound already to this home beyond hope they have raised amid the flax fields and barley. We have never been a settled people, Nóm. Never have we dwelt where each root and tree was known, where the earth too was friend and companion. Yet such have we found in the land of thy leading, and for Belen it is treasure beyond words. He has ever loved each village and camp, and would befriend the grasses and flowers, the copses and streams, then mourn come Spring at every departure. He is his mother’s child in many ways, and in this most of all. His is a heart of staying. And Estolad has won his love. He misses it already, I deem, short though his absence has been.”
“And thou?” A quick flash of smile as Balan’s brow furrowed in question. “Thine heart too was not made to wander.”
“Was it not?” The wry grin was genuine at last and the firelight glinted across Balan's eye. “Nay, I confess it, I too miss the golden fields and the riverside. But if I returned thither, I should miss the cool stone and the lamplight more; thy voice too, and the taste of thy wine.”
Finrod laughed at this last and glanced toward the table with its empty decanters. “Hadst thy fill?”
“Mm.” Balan drew his hands roughly down his face again and grimaced. “And more. I should have ended with Bel, but I’ve come back here and finished the lot.”
“Ai…” Finrod chuckled as he glanced over Balan in quick evaluation. “And still upright!”
“Still slouched and sulking,” he corrected and wrapped the blanket closer about his shoulders, “and in no state to entertain a king. Go on, Nóm, there’s no need for thee to pander to my foul mood. Thine own rest awaits and I’m a poor bondsman to keep thee from it.”
“And a poor lord I to desert thee in melancholy. Thou keepst me from naught—nay, leave off, you mad creature!” His hand shot out and intercepted the chalice Balan had raised once more to his lips, and the king drew it back into his own grasp. “Here, I’ll spare thee from thyself,” he added with a laugh and downed the remaining wine before Balan could protest. Then he reached out to draw the other toward him “Now come nearer. Thou art chilled through—chide me not, I see thy shivering—and I’ll have thee warm at least ere thou canst dismiss me.”
Balan gave a protesting snort, but allowed himself to be collected in against the warmth. It was a relief to be held, regardless of the reason, and his head soon drooped to rest upon the other’s shoulder. How steady it was, lithe but strong, the beating pulse keeping time with his own, calming him. Here then my home, the sound of thine heart now the rhythm of my wandering. He pressed his lips together lest he utter it aloud and thought again of Belen, sleeping in the chamber above. Only a stair’s length now, ever a farewell’s distance.
“He tells me it is for Estolad that he stays,” Balan heard his voice murmur against the fine wool of the king’s tunic and he was surprised by its blank resignation, “for place, for home and purpose. But what it is…what it is is that Baran has come to depend upon him in these short months, and he cannot bear to forsake him in my footsteps. And that is the truth of it.”
❈❈❈
The dinner was held in the cavern with the swan doors. Balan had taken it for a council chamber when he first arrived, but in the intervening months he learned that the room served various purposes: councils, festivities, functions of court, a makeshift theater once at the turn of Lairë, and—as was the case on this evening—the smaller dinners of the king’s household.
He sat in his customary place opposite Finrod, and Belen sat beside him, engrossed in conversation with Gildor, who held the seat across the table at the king’s right. The long table had been drawn out before the hearth and laden with a full ceremonial feast. The extravagance was to mark the midpoint of Hrívë, Nóm told Belen as they walked through the halls, but Balan had overheard his instructions to Sídhon and Gildor. It had been laid out in honor of Belen.
He watched his son move through the dance of introductions and courtesies, and his pride welled up at the sight. Belen was at ease despite his awe, bright and self-assured amid the golden lamplight and courtiers. Whence came this confidence in the time since their parting? Again as it had at the riverside, the change leapt out from the familiar lines of his son’s face, from the warm music of his laugh, and Balan found himself wondering whether he was similarly altered in Belen’s sight. And would the change ring so at every meeting now, scattered as they must be across the months and distance? Each glad reunion ever further from its origin, each conversation less natural than the last.
The laughter came again and Balan pulled himself back from contemplation. They were telling a story, Gildor and Belen, and Finrod was attending with the delight and fascination that ever drew Balan’s memory to Thalos and Estolad, and tales handed back and forth around the fires. It was some exploit from their journey and Balan picked up the thread in snatches. A faun, born out of season, had been caught in the rapids where the Celon and Aros merged, and Belen darted out across the rocks to intercept it, unable to bear its distress. He had slipped on the ice and plunged in as well, though he managed to catch hold of the faun in his descent and keep it from breaking its legs against the rocks as they crashed through the current. Gildor had leapt after them, his own balance sure as he darted from stone to stone, and in the end he hauled both of them back to shore, bruised and shivering, but whole.
“The lecturing once he had me to the bank!” Belen glanced at the king with a grin. “It was as though you were among us again, Nóm, and still chiding me for any attempt to leave that cart.”
“And rightly so,” his father interjected at last, features severe but amusement dancing in his eyes. “Twould have killed thee most like, had Gildor not been there to fish thee out. Reckless cub,” he added with a chuckle and turned to refill his goblet.
“That’s rather two-faced of thee, vatta.” Belen’s expression turned impish at the snort of protest from his father. “How if it had been a duck?”
Balan laughed fully at this, one brow raised as he glanced over at his son. “Sons are meant to learn from their fathers’ follies, not repeat them.”
“And yet from an acorn grows an oak tree.”
“Thy jests are in riddles, Belen.” Finrod’s eyes were bright as he watched them banter. How he had missed their easy camaraderie, the rough, wry jests and parries. And how too he would feel that loss cut again when springtime came and they bade the boy farewell—Balan’s bitter grief would also be his own. He shook away the gloom and looked at Belen with a sidelong smile. “Make tales of them that we might all be merry.”
“Have none told you of the duck, Nóm?”
“Mercy, Bel. At the first dinner?”
Belen laughed and took a sip of wine, then leaned back in his chair and grinned across at the king. “It was east of the mountains still, during a particularly bitter winter. The river where we camped had frozen over in patches and some unwary duck became lodged in one of those till the ice froze around him and left him trapped. So vatta promptly set out to—”
“Promptly? Bel, the creature was caught there the better part of a day. We could hear it crying out for hours.”
“Vatta belatedly set out to free it,” Belen corrected, “and he and Masci found a path along the various chunks.”
“Then learning thou hadst from that, at least,” Gildor interjected with a laugh. “Twas naught belated in thine advance.”
“The duck was still. The fawn was careening.”
“And the folly a steady current between the twain.” Balan muttered affectionately as he spooned a decadently spiced fruit and cream onto his son’s plate. “Try this, Bel. Twould be to thy liking, I think.”
“What became of the duck?” Finrod was watching them in amusement, his elbow propped against the arm of the chair, forefinger resting across his lips and dividing his smile in two. Belen looked up askance, silenced by a mouthful of fruit, and Finrod’s eyes turned to Balan in query.
“We found our way to him and broke the ice apart with a pair of branches.” Balan turned his glass about on the table as he spoke, a small smile playing at his lips despite the abashed tone. “He was well and hale by spring.”
“Because vatta tended to it as though it were a babe in arms,” Belen finished the bite and glanced across at the king. “He carried it back tucked in his tunic, and it spent the rest of the winter in our hut.”
“I could hardly turn him out after that.”
“No indeed. That duck was like a brother to me.”
Balan tousled his son’s hair in faux annoyance and Bel ducked aside, laughing. “We tended him till the new season,” Balan continued, resuming his explanation to the king, “and then he returned to his kin for their yearly migration—as we too set about ours. I confess I missed him once he’d gone.” A quick smile flashed out. “He’d followed me about for so long I’d grown quite fond of the company. He was a friendly little creature.”
“They called him father duck for years after that,” Belen mumbled to Gildor with a grin.
“Vatta’nd anuths,” Balan chuckled. “And still do, I don’t doubt.”
“Nay, mostly Dar Bëor now.” Belen blanched as the words left his mouth, catching himself too late amid the laughter and wine.
Balan snorted. “Lord Vassal—an archaic form,” he translated in an aside to Finrod, then grinned at his son and shifted to Taliska. “I scent your aunt’s humor in that.”
Belen looked chagrined and turned to fiddled with the edge of his plate.
“Ah. I see.”
“He doesn’t mean anything by it,” Belen said quickly, then faltered at the obvious untruth. “Or rather, he does but…What I mean is his anger is only for the moment. It won’t last.”
“Your brother is as stubborn as I am, Bel. It will not pass in a hurry.” Then the tired smile turned contrarian and he leaned back in his chair. “Nay rather, tell him not to leave off, for I’ll not scorn a name once given. Send my greetings to Baran Balanion, first lord of the House of Bëor.” He lifted his glass pointedly and sipped. “Sama’nd sá.”
“Sama’nd sá,” Belen repeated quietly as he too drank for the toast, though the laughter had fallen away from his face.
It was an uncomfortable silence that followed, and Finrod watched the two of them in concern. He had seen the hurt ripple across Balan’s features at the boy’s unguarded jest, bitter and unexpected, and watched it solidify the previous night’s despair. But Balan’s thought bristled against any attempted comfort, and Finrod dared not reach out through touch instead. Regret was already seeping through the quiet. Balan’s eyes were fixed on the centerpiece; Belen prodded the spiced fruit about his plate. Gildor reached tentatively for his glass and took a long sip of wine.
“How is Hathus?” Finrod asked at last, easing the silence with an encouraging smile. “I hear few personal details from those who come and go between us, and oft have I longed for word of you all. And how is little Fina?”
“They are well,” Belen answered with a grateful glance at the king. “Fina’s become a right little menace, running about as she does. And she talks more than any child I’ve known. Gelvira says that comes from the blessing you spoke over them at Alna’s birth, but Hathus says that caused her love of sneaking into the sheep pens rather.”
Finrod laughed and raised his glass. “Gladly would I be credited with either.”
“I take her riding on Kaseis most days. She’s a fearless little creature.”
“As befits a daughter of Hathus.”
“Truly,” Balan chimed in, his voice softened from its earlier ire, “and with his strength too. She had the fiercest grip of any infant I’ve known.”
Belen’s smile returned as he looked back at his father. “Do you remember Weiv calling her little blacksmith all that first year?”
“I do—and the tiny anvil Eimet carved for her in jest.” His eyes had grown wistful as they reminisced and he hesitated a long moment before asking the question that lingered on his tongue. “And how does old Weiv fare? He had grown feeble ere I left and Hathus worried over him during the last winter.”
“Aye, and continued so. He passed just ere Yuletide—peacefully, in his sleep.”
A low sound of grief slipped from Balan’s lips. “May he rest in the arms of Melishk,” he murmured after a moment, falling back on the customary benediction as sorrow and solemnity knit between his brows. “May he be held long in remembrance.”
“I’m sorry, vatta. I know he was dear to you.”
Balan nodded. “He was the last of my father’s close friends. It is a strange feeling, Bel, when there are no elders left who knew you well in childhood.” Then he sighed and pressed a smile across his lips, determined to keep the conversation from falling once more to grief. “But I am grateful for the years there were. He had a long life—and well lived.”
“So Hathus said as well. A full bounty of years, brimming over…”
A sudden apprehension reared up and Balan’s breath caught in his throat as he turned. “Bel—“
“Nearly eighty-seven, was he not?”
Nóm’s helpless shock struck Balan’s mind like a blow, racing blind through each sense. The room was swimming before his eyes—or was it before Nóm’s eyes—and he pressed his palm flat upon the table for equilibrium. No, his hands were clasped yet within his lap, it was the king’s fingers holding fast to the table top. This must be his dizziness too, then—or nay, was it Balan’s own, mingled as it seemed with his pulse pounding through his ears? Whose then was the nausea, this rising suffocation, the—
“Aye,” Balan choked out through the muddle, his gaze fixed on Belen’s so that he might not meet Nóm’s eyes across the table and falter before the panic enfleshed; that he might not know if the breaking had come. “Aye,” he managed more clearly this time, “a full bounty indeed.”
❈❈❈
“Eighty-seven years.”
The words drifted across the table, little more than a whisper breaking through the quiet. The others had taken their leave, dwindling out till only Balan and Nóm lingered along the empty table. The king had kept his composure throughout the remainder of the meal, carrying the conversation and smiling despite his racing dread, ignoring the precipice that gaped once more before his feet. It was deeper now, sharper, and the edge would claim him should he pause for a moment to acknowledge its new depths. But the others had gone now; there was naught holding him back and he was falling, plummeting downward as he lingered with Balan in the guttering light.
“Is that usual?”
”More or less.” Balan focused his attention on the curved edge of a leaf under his finger, tracing the carving as he continued to avoid the other’s eye. “But more often less, I’ll not deceive thee.”
The silence returned again. Balan stood behind his earlier seat, hands resting upon the crest rail, and was uncomfortably aware of his own fingers moving over the intricate patterns, restless and uneasy. The king, by contrast, remained all the while in near perfect stillness, as though he was another graven image for the troubled fingers to trace.
“Didst thou truly know it not?”
Finrod too did not meet the other’s eye, but gazed rather down the length of the table. Fourscore years, a few more beyond if they were fortunate. He felt them rushing by him like a gust of wind, these Atani, each dear friend, every beautiful infant, Balan… His soul raged in denial and he shook his head. “It was deliberate ignorance, I deem. I knew the Casári too were not as we and so I thought—nay, I let myself think—that ye were of a similar making. That there would be a century or two at least before—“ His voice faltered and broke off.
Balan’s heart ached as he forced himself to look up at last. Nóm sat frozen before him, the grief etched upon his face and his eyes dim, unfocused. This is how he would age, Balan thought in a flash of illusion. The lines of wrinkles would form here where these gossamer webs spread across his brow, where they reached down his features, winding about to catch the pattern of his smile. Yes, time’s knife would mark him even thus—if ever they had moved along his path in tandem. But this was anguish not age, and Balan stumbled before the remorse. He had guessed at the other’s assumptions, even in the early days beside Thalos, yet ever he told himself to let it lie. It was only conjecture. Nóm had not spoken of it, and it would be rude to correct an error presumed and not known. If Nóm asked, then he would explain it, of course. But there was no need to enlighten till then, for might that knowledge not drive him away? And so he continued through the months, looking aside as his reasoning spilled over into obfuscation, as his silence shifted to concealment. This grief was his doing.
“Balan,” Nóm said at last and his voice was laced with hollow trepidation, “I have never asked thee thine age.”
The carved blossoms bit into his palms. “Forty-nine, lord.”
There was no change to the king’s stillness, except perhaps a slight whitening of the knuckles where they pressed against the unyielding wood, yet Balan found himself at once struggling for breath. He saw the quick calculation, he felt the measure of it in his own heart, and the scant decades rose before him with a menace they had not held hitherto. Often enough he wished for longer years as his own drifted past, but never till Nóm’s presence had he craved for years unending. Nor ever till now had he felt himself so imminently on the edge of his own passing, faced with the other’s shock, the other’s dread.
Once more he saw himself through Nóm’s eyes, only now it was a vision of fleeting frailty, and he bristled against that image of inconsequence.
“I am as you find me, Nóm,” he said in pointed Taliska, “and I will not grieve that I am of my kind. We are not lesser, no matter how swift our path.”
“Balan!” The reticence was broken and Finrod turned toward him in protest. “Never did I think it. Never would I think it.”
“And so I will return with Belen, lord, if you wish me to do so.”
“Anarinya…” Nóm’s hand darted out to catch Balan’s within its grasp, working it loose from the crest rail to press instead against his own flesh. “Dearest friend of my heart. If your full tale was a year only, still you would have my love.” He gripped Balan’s hand as his voice caught, then drew it in till the other’s fingers rested against his brow and he leaned over them in a penitent’s prayer. “Please,” the whisper drifted up, hoarse and broken, “do not go.”
Balan’s grief broke at this and he reached out to cup the other’s head within his palm. “Elenya,” he breathed as his fingers passed through the silken gold, stroking it back from his face, and then Nóm’s arms were about his waist, the king’s face buried against his chest, and Balan held him as the last candle burned out and they remained alone in the hearthlight. “I will not.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
Honeg: [S] little brother
Suil: [S] greetings
Vandatar: [Q] oath-father
Na vedui!: [S] at last!
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
- Haelis: hello, greetings
- Vatta: father
- Hfaskebel: hedgehog (needle-mouse)
- madja: aunt, mother’s sister
- Andanahti-marei: evening/twilight-lake
- Aitha: mother
- vatta’nd anuths: father duck (or in the literal: father unto duck(s))
- dar: lord, master
- Bëor: vassal
MISC NOTES
- Lairë is the Quenya term for summer, lasting roughly from June 1 through August 9.
- Hrívë is the Quenya term for winter, lasting roughly from December 1 through February 10.
14. In These Holy Waters
His voice was hoarse as the weight of his helpless ardor bore down upon him and the water’s one epiphany flowed through his heart with bitter clarity: it was inescapable now, the truth and the reckoning.
It is Yestarë, the first day of spring, and Balan joins Finrod and a small company in their yearly pilgrimage to Ivrin, and to the holy spring in the hills above. Finrod is haunted still by his recent discovery of the Atani's lifespans, while Balan finds he can no longer keep a confession from his lips.
Read 14. In These Holy Waters

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, SPRING
The Pools of Ivrin
Finrod’s dive cut through the surface, hardly leaving a splash as he slipped beneath Ivrin’s mere. The water was ice, as ever in these first days of spring when the falls roared down from the heights, filling the basin with snowmelt from the shoulders of the Ered Wethrin. It was a cleansing draught that woke the long slumber, winter shearing away through the glass and light.
Once, any cold plunge had borne his thought back to Yestarë and this yearly pilgrimage to Ulmo’s Well. But as he glided through the current, it was the waters of Ivrin shifting into a remembrance of that other reverence—Celon, with his wide, easy movement; Celon with his ice and his burning knowledge.
Finrod drew his mind back with an effort. He was in Ivrin’s lake, fed by the holy well, the current alive with the presence of the Lord of Waters, the brilliance encircling him. He was home.
Balan had told him once, when their dead were buried on the road from Ossiriand, of his own people’s tradition—the world had been formed from the goddess of earth, from the god of water. Each poured themselves throughout its making and each, therefore, was bound till the end of time within the rock and earth, the ice and rivers. No forms did they reveal beyond these elements, for none could they take on without drawing their sustaining presence out from the world. Thus through the ceremonial washing, the fallen were wrapped in Guënid’s embrace. In burial, they returned to the arms of Melishk.
So it was here, Finrod thought as he surfaced and the air refilled his lungs. The Sea would not have him, Ossë would rage if ever he drew boat from shore, Uinen would turn her face aside. The Valar no longer walked beside them in raiment of flesh, but here in these holy waters he was held again as in the sea-brine of Belegaer, and his heart sang in exultation with the hymns of his mother’s people. The melody spilled out from his lips, bright as the shimmering water, and as its echoes rippled over him from the surrounding stone, he plunged once more beneath the surface.
There through the water he felt the others suspended too within that chorus. Canneth and Lithui, Edrahil’s dive twisting round in a great loop, weightless. Sídhon wading carefully from the shore and young Gwindor hurled laughing from his brother’s arms. Gildor—dear, beloved boy—soaring through the water with abandon, hands outstretched and grasping after some elusive kinship with his father’s heritage. Each of them woven through the waves, each wrapped in Ulmo’s embrace.
The water whispered nothing of Balan. Had he not yet followed them into the lake? Or, dread thought, was this judgment rather—a reprimand, a holy reminder of that gulf he must never tempt? Finrod twisted through the current and surfaced once more, casting about for the other. There he sat, perched on a low outcropping—merely ashore, then, and no rebuke from the water’s lord—cross-legged and watching the swimmers with a quiet contentment.
“Ai!” Finrod's voice danced over the waves, merry in his relief. “Tarrying yet?”
“The bank is warm,” Balan called back in amusement, “and moreover dry.”
Nóm laughed and dove once again, piercing a swift line through the water, a golden dart beneath the still glass. The lake was deep along the shore where Balan sat, the rock jutting out over a sheer edge of the basin, and Finrod emerged a less than a stone’s throw away. “How now, father duck,” he said as he closed the distance to hover within arm’s reach, grinning, the sunlight glinting from hair and water alike, “no love for the streams and meres?”
Balan snorted. “I’ve love enough, only little inclination to be a curiosity.” His glance drifted briefly to the other swimmers as he leaned back on his arms. It was one thing to splash after Nóm bare as birth, it was another matter entirely to plunge in amid the king’s guard, kin, and counselors. Ever since his arrival, he had sensed their intrigue as a thread running through every interaction, marking each difference with fascination; never unfriendly, but he squirmed nonetheless beneath the scrutiny. And his spine crawled at the thought of facing it stripped within the sheer water. Nóm’s thought brushed across this strand of abstraction and Balan flinched at his immediate concern, but did not push him away. “They mean no malice,” he added with a wry grimace. “And besides, I’ve learned well enough not to follow thee into the springtime torrents. Twas a week ere I felt my toes after thy last convincing.”
“Aye, but that was not hallowed water,” Nóm said, as he reached up to hold himself by the stone, and his teasing was warm in Balan’s own tongue, “and here the King of the Sea would surely spare your limbs.”
“Hm.” Balan shifted forward till his legs hung over the edge. “Would he? I shall test him first and learn whether he is merciful ere I try him with the whole.” He held his toes suspended over the water and looked down at the other with an impish grin. “Shall it be mercy, then, my lord of the water?”
“Blasphemy, Balan, is a precarious place to sit.”
And then in a swift motion Nóm launched up, leveraged by his grip on the rock, and caught the other about the waist with his free arm. He had found a foothold on the basin’s edge and pushed off at once to send them plunging together into the shimmering waves. For a brief moment they were suspended beneath the water, another tangled embrace, and Finrod felt his heart pounding at the reprisal. Perhaps he had done it deliberately, muttered the shrewd afterthought as the mirror of that first embrace coursed through him like wine. But this time he released Balan at once, and the water drew them apart as they rose in tandem to the surface.
And as before, Balan laughed as they emerged and shook the hair from his eyes. “Do you drown your impious, then?” he asked with wry grin, catching his breath.
“Not generally.” Mirth danced impish through Finrod’s eyes, then there was a flash of consternation and his hand slipped beneath Balan’s arm. “Thou canst swim with the added weight?”
“As insulting as Bel, thou art, thinking me ever half-returned to the clay.” He pushed off toward the center of the lake, a quick grin over his shoulder and a brush of affection against Nóm’s thought. “I can swim clothed without risking the grave, wingildi.”
Fire rushed through Finrod’s veins as the name tripped toward him across the water, wrapped in Balan’s voice—and like the páni of those long lost harbors, he followed after him through the waves. Harbors and seabirds and Balan; each passing, elusive and fleeting before the edge of his grasp. His hands stretched out as Gildor’s had done, reaching open and desperate into the cold before him as he raced forward in pursuit. The water’s song held Balan now as well as the others, but it was a fleeting melody, a stranger’s greeting, a father’s dirge. It whispered comfort too, and sympathy for his own heart, but he closed his ears in fury and swam faster. Consolation ere the wound was an insult, naught but a reminder of where the strike would fall.
“Can you drown in hallowed water?” Balan asked dubiously as they reached the midpoint, and his voice drew Finrod back from his meditations. He was treading in place a few lengths ahead with his shirt billowing about him, a cloud of deep green swelling through the crystal water. The sun’s glint had turned his hair to onyx, polished and shining, and the droplets within it glistened like uncut diamonds. He was breathtaking—and Finrod felt the melancholy give way before his presence, this tangible, living joy.
“I confess I have never tried,” he replied and the laughter was once more woven through his voice. A quick smile flashed across the water. Then his breath rushed in and he dropped without warning beneath the mere.
“Nóm?” Balan peered after him, first in bewilderment and then in unease. He could see the figure hovering below him, only an arm’s length or two he guessed, but it gave no sign of rising. He held another moment, attempting to gauge the depth, then filled his own lungs and plunged after him.
The cold pressed in at his ears as he heaved himself downwards. Nóm had not seemed far down, he calculated, the water thrumming around him, and his own descent was swift. He must have come nearly level with the other by now. His arms reached out through the current, slowing his motion, and he opened his eyes.
It was pristine. Light flooded down from the noontide sun and pierced deep into the basin. He could see all the way to the shore, the crags where he had perched only a few minutes before shining crisp and vivid through the water. And there to his right—Nóm dazzling in the midst of it. A cloud of gold, his hair floating about him; his body suspended as though caught in glass with the shimmering light cascading along its facets.
Balan’s heart was pounding. He drifted, caught too within the glimmering pane; frozen as he stared with eyes transfixed and veins burning. Each line lay traced against the radiance, the muscles curved in gentle knots about his figure, the sinews taut, the limbs lithe and strong. Balan was abashed at the hunger of his own gaze, but neither could he draw it from the porcelain figure hovering before him, naked and flawless and all his desire. He was pinned by the sight—like the serpent’s prey, Estreth’s voice whispered through his memory—even when the other’s eyes opened to meet his and the quick smile drew a new surge of warmth through Balan’s blood.
Air. It was the sudden panic of suffocation that at last broke the trance, and he launched toward the surface, gasping as he broke through into the breeze. Nóm emerged beside him a moment later, laughing and unwinded.
“Not drowned, then?”
“Not thou, at least.” Balan sent a cascade of water into the other’s face. “Impossible creature. I’d think thee gilled if I knew no better.
“Gained from a youth of idleness beside the sea, or so my uncle and cousins would tell thee. They may be craftsmen fine of gold and steel, silver and gem; but I and mine have wrought of the water’s motion and of light too. Yet dissemblers are they all, for tis our supposed idleness that fetches for them their pearls.” Another quick flash of mirth, and with it his youth leapt out again, startling and sunlit as it had been at the fen crossings, or when placed alongside Meril at feast or council. “In this, at least, I am my mother’s child. Did you hear the water singing?”
“No.” Balan laughed as he looked on him, hair slick as silk along his scalp, and tendrils of its gold snaking now about his own shoulders as well. The heat burned yet within his blood, and he felt the pulse throbbing through his ears, his teeth. “I begin to think Bel had the right of it—thou wilt ever turn a song where none is sung.”
“It sings of thee, Balan, and thou hast heard it not?”
“Nay, I’ve told thee. Naught but the muffled rumble—a lake, Nóm, and no more.”
Finrod hovered before him, perplexed and fascinated, then stretched out his hand. “Come,” he said at last, “I’ve a way to show thee, I deem.”
Balan reached out in mute acquiescence, shivering as he set his hand within the other’s palm and his met that flesh which he coveted only a short moment past.
“Bother not with sight; I shall lead thee. Only listen well, and let thy thought lie open.” With a quick smile he moved forward, drawing Balan at his side. And then, as they slipped once more beneath the still surface, Balan felt the other’s presence wash over him as well—bright as ever, but lit now with the crystal clarity of the mere about them, spreading through his thought with the rolling strength of a current. And with it, to Balan’s surprise, the water’s murmur shifted as they swam and it too became pristine and discernible, tangible as the facets of light piercing the glass about them. Music it was indeed, but not in any way he had supposed. He was listening through Nóm’s ears, the cadence ebbing and flowing, and within it danced pitches that his own senses never perceived, tones beyond his comprehension. He hovered, dizzy with it, leaving off his own strokes as he listened in awe and Finrod towed him in his wake beneath the water.
Nóm had raised him to the surface by the time Balan found he was again short of breath. He had the measure of him now, Balan thought with warmth, slipping within his mind as Esrid had once slipped into his coat, sliding her arms through the sleeves alongside his own so that they moved together, each motion in concert, laughing in the cold. So Nóm’s thought too spread within his mind, formless limbs aligned together, tendrils of perception moving as one—and Balan’s senses reeled with its intimacy.
Again they dipped beneath the surface, and again the song passed from Finrod’s ears to Balan’s discernment, and he attended more closely now to what he heard. He had expected words within its music, but like their woven minds, this too spoke by intuition and presence. Sensations rolled through his spirit like the waters themselves. Seeing. Knowing. Awe and recognition. Grief and wonder.
He was wrapped at first in the warmth of it—the water sang of him, it sang of his people. They were known after all, children beautiful and intended as Nóm had said. Beloved and whole, even in their frailty. But why then could he not hear it with his own ears? Why did Nóm’s Valar sing of them, but only in a melody they could never perceive? If Nóm could learn Balan’s tongue in such short measure, surely his gods would be of no lesser skill.
They broke through the surface once again and Balan felt his bitterness choke as he met the other’s eyes, eager wells of joy sparkling above the water. How beautiful he was in his delight! The guess had been hazarded and proven true, and the intoxication of sharing it poured from him like warmth. And Balan could not deny him. He clasped the hand more tightly within his own and returned Nóm’s gaze with mirrored joy. Then with a laugh they slipped again beneath the glass and he followed Nóm forward through the chorus.
❈❈❈
By midday, they lay in a scattered cluster upon the grass. It was a sunlit cove, jutting off in a divot from the main water, sand lining the shoreline with freshets of new grass encroaching about its edges. A restful clearing, filled with the laughter of the falls and wind whispering through the beech leaves.
Balan had borne up longer than expected in the icy current, but at last he broke from the group splashing beneath the falls and swam back to the sun-baked rocks, the day’s heat as unseasonable as it was welcome. He had stripped at once, no longer abashed in his urgency to be warm, and layered a heavy tunic over his fresh shirt and breeches. With his teeth still chattering, he decided that was not sufficient and pilfered a fur-lined cloak from where it lay draped over the king’s saddle bags, then returned with it to the bright sunlight beside the shore.
Sídhon was the first to join him. He rose from the shallows and shuddered in the breeze, a sleek hound shaking water from its fur, and laughed to see Balan huddled beneath the heavy cloak and tucked against a warm boulder.
“The light smiles upon you, Anorhín,” he said as he dried himself and retrieved his own clothes from the bank.
“Smile or frown I’ll welcome equally,” Balan replied with a snort, “so long as it thaws me. I’m frozen through.”
“So you appear.” Sídhon dressed, then procured a flask and filled the cap with a mouthful of liquor, clear and fragrant. “Drink this,” he said as he passed it to him. “My lord would hold it poor hospitality were I to leave a guest in discomfort when remedy was to hand.”
“Awiluth.” His thanks fell without thought into his own tongue as he raised the drink to his lips. He had been drawn back to the winter in Estolad by the familiar scent, when they huddled, numb and shivering, around the fire in his hut. He and Baran had worked through the night to keep the animals from freezing amid the snowstorm, and in the early hours of the morning Nóm produced a similar flask, dispensing a splash into each of their cups. The old ache rose with the memory and his heart lashed out at the absence of his sons, drawing up his remorse to darken the midday.
Balan had shut himself in his apartments for three days after Belen returned to Estolad and his brother’s side, speaking to none and permitting not even the king to break his solitude. He huddled alone with his grief and anger, and stoked his shame with their persistent company. But at length the storm subsided and he emerged, wan and quiet, to drift through the sunken atrium in the morning light. Nóm spied him through the latticework of his own rooms and crossed at once, gathering him within his arms and drawing him back into the shadowed cloister to hold him tucked beneath his chin; and Balan had clutched him desperately in return and sworn out a bitter torrent upon his shoulder till the grief lay spent and shaking against the other’s heartbeat.
Nóm had believed it was sorrow that drove him to isolation—and Balan did not correct him, for in part it was true. But heartache he could face in the other’s company, indeed he was eased by it, whereas it was the furnace of self-loathing that demanded solitude. And such it was that came upon him again at the winter’s remembrance. He shoved it aside and downed the liquor in a quick motion, hoping for some improbable cleansing in its dregs. But it merely coursed through him as it had in Estolad, cascading warmth through his heart and easing the tight chill that stiffened every sinew. It was enough, Balan decided as he leaned back against the boulder—mitigating the cold was a very passable balm for the moment’s ills. He let his eyes fall shut and basked in the heat of the sun on his face, the lull of the falls, the sounds of preparations about him as the long minutes ran together.
“Have I driven thee to theft, Bëorinya?” The king’s voice drifted over him, affectionate and amused, and Balan started awake at the sound. Most of the swimmers had returned while he dozed. Gildor and Edrahil sat on the grass nearby and Nóm stood half-dressed before him, shirt in hand and a grin dancing upon his lips.
“Nay, my liege, I would be dry on the rocks yet hadst thou judged with mercy.” His own grin mirrored back in kind, eyes alight and teasing. “This is but a weregild for my warmth and leisure.”
“Held in negligence of my vows already!” Finrod laughed and toweled his hair with the shirt. “The cloak is a just recompense—I cede it to thee.”
“I accept this restitution,” the other answered in a magnanimous tone, shifting to lie stretched upon the grass with the prize bundled about him. “My vengeance is assuaged.”
“And my reign mercifully intact,” the king retorted as he moved to take Balan’s place against the boulder. He reached out after a moment and touched his fingers to the other’s cheek, testing his warmth. “Truly, though, I’ve not set thee to harm by it?”
“And if I say thou hast?” Balan chuckled at the instant rush of concern, then drew the hand to his lips and kissed the twined serpents in a show of penitence. “That was churlish of me. I’m flesh, not glass, Nóm. I should not tease thee so.”
Finrod let out a breath in mock affront, but his gaze was warm as he looked down at the other, resting amid the snowdrops and spring violets. “Impudence,” he said, and a smile eased across his features. He plucked a handful from the riot of flowers and began braiding them absently into his hair as his eyes drifted over Sídhon and Gelmir preparing the midday meal, Edrahil and Gildor weaving their own wildflowers into chains and circlets beside him, Gwindor standing quiet at the water’s edge and watching the light play over the surface. As ever, he was struck with the incongruity of these lands. To have his heart lift in such joy while the Siege lay only a few days’ ride to the north seemed an irreverence almost, an affront to those who yet held the lines of battle. By what privilege did he rest here beside the wandering mere while his brothers patrolled the highlands, while Maedhros sat in vigilance atop cold Himring and his uncle gazed unflinching across Ard Galen toward the gathering gloom? Again he felt his confidence falter, again the nagging doubt prodded his shame—was it foresight or cowardice that had laid the hidden refuge upon his heart?
The gradually, Gildor’s voice drifted through his musings. He sang a simple melody, slow and quiet, the words a blended murmur as he wove flower stems in and out of the growing chain.
O child, O child, make wary your wandering.
O child, O child, mind what waters you seek.
O child, O child, look not in the brook or the riverbed
when all is still, and the starlight chill.
O mother, O mother, beware the mud slithering.
O mother, O mother, heed the river-song.
O mother, O mother, wade not in the mere or the mountain spring
when dark the hill, and the raven shrill.
Finrod’s hands stilled in their work as he listened to his foster-son’s voice, reaching out like a ghost of the past. He and Inglor had learned it together on the cliffs above Alqualondë, flashes of silver and gold darting through the sea-grass while Meril sang as she looked out over the rolling waves. The melody was one she had carried with her from Cuiviénen, a relic of those fears and traditions, and Inglor would ask her to sing it whenever they came across her amid their play. She sat often upon the cliff-tops in those days, perched upon the same ledge with her eyes fixed upon the east, and as a child Finrod had been both fascinated and unnerved by the ritual, each day marking a past that was gone beyond reach, a home that no one believed she should miss. His heart ached now at the remembrance, as it did too to look across at Inglor’s son and see the echo of his friend’s profile against the waving beeches, to hear the same mild voice drifting through the air. He realized his own voice had lifted up in response, and it too seemed a phantom as it joined in the song.
O father, O father, mark well the riverbank.
O father, O father, make your guide the current strong.
O father, O father, swim not through the stagnant stream
when frogs trill, and the reed-pools fill.
O lover, O lover, come dance in the meadow-lands.
O lover, O lover, the waters are bright!
O lover, O lover, we will sing by the waterside
when bold the will, and the senses thrill.
“Tis long years since I’ve heard that sung,” Edrahil remarked as they finished.
“You know it?” Gildor looked over at him in interest.
“Mm. In my youth, I sang it often with my lord and your father.”
“Did you learn it from Merillë, Hilyo?” Finrod asked. “Or did we teach you later in Tirion?”
“In Tirion. I knew her little before the journey.”
“What is it?” Balan asked curiously from the ground. “It reminds me of some of our own.”
“It is from the days of our own awakening,” Finrod answered, “away in the east, long ago ere the earth was broken and Cuiviénen lost. There were many warning songs in those days. The Foe’s servants were not idle and even those things we loved were oft turned to our fears. This that we sang was of my mother’s people—Gildor’s father’s people—and warns of wraiths in the waters.”
“It was one of the explanations for those who went missing,” Gildor added as he gathered another handful of cinquefoil. “There was the Hunter, turning the Valar to fear. The jealous Watchman who stole those gifted in skill, and turned the joy of making to danger. And there were the water wraiths, drawing the unwary down through the dark.”
“Water wraiths, you say?” Balan glanced over at Nóm with an arched brow. “Attacking the unwary?”
“Thou hadst warning aplenty,” he retorted, reaching out with a chuckle to poke a violet into the other’s beard, “and heeded it not.”
“Haven’t your people a tale of this sort, Bëor?” Gildor shifted to make room as Gwindor joined them from the waterside.
“Of wraiths in the water?” Balan frowned for a moment in thought. “Do you mean Aelthes and the atna-ahma?”
“Yes, ’twas such I had in mind.”
“Aye, it is similar in some ways. I’m surprised you know of it—I’ve no recollection of telling it to Nóm, but I suppose there were fables aplenty in the long winter and it’s like enough I’ve forgotten their full number.”
“Nay, Belen it was who told me. We passed many an hour with tales on the road from Estolad.” He passed a handful of flowers to Gwindor, then glanced back toward Balan with a quick smile. “Though I knew many from Ingo’s telling already, so he was hard pressed to find ground untrodden. It is little wonder he resorted to those less recounted.”
“It’s true, we do not often tell it.”
“But thou wilt tell us, surely?” The pale foot nudged his leg and Finrod’s eyes were upon him, jest and curiosity vying in equal measure.
“Aye, you glutton,” Balan replied in his own tongue, laughing as he looked back at him. “I’ll see you have your day’s fill of legendries.” He pushed up from the ground to sit cross-legged beside the king, shifting the cloak to rest about his shoulders now that the worst of the chill was mitigated, and plucking the flower loose from his beard.
“In the days ere our wandering,” he began, shifting to Sindarin and the lyric chant of his peoples’ scops, “in the days when light was young and clay new-wrought, there dwelt in the land of our waking a chieftain tall and proud, and with him his daughter who was wise in heart, strong in arm, and loveliest of all her people. Now Aelthes the chieftain’s daughter was pledged to Oelthes the fisher’s son. Great was the love that bode between them and great too the wedding feast their people laid, there in the glades beside the river, there in the meadow beside the banks. And in the midday sun amid the suevin blossoms, they were wed in the heat of Iuthap’s smile.”
Balan paused for a moment, turning the flower within his fingers and watching its petals twirl in the sun. “Now Aelthes grew tired from the sun and dancing and she withdrew to the riverside to sate her thirst. There in the still water she saw her face reflected, crowned with lilies and evening vines, and flushed with the warmth of all her joy. Then to her surprise the reflection wavered and shook, and from the cool water it rose before her, her likeness rippling and fluid in the air. And she knew at once with dread foreboding that she looked upon an atna-ahma. A water sprite,” he added in rough translation, “or a river imp, I think you’d say. Our legends hold that the gods of earth and water came together and from that clay all things were formed. But we’ve held too that in the places where they continue to mingle, in the beds of lakes, along the shores of rivers, other things form still by chance—unthought creatures, formless spirits lingering in the waterways or fens. The atna-ahma.”
He lifted the flower to hold it level with his face. “As the specter rose before her, Aelthes found she could neither move nor flee. She felt her flesh twitch and shudder, she saw the reflection cohere and bind. Long have I watched the fisher’s boy in the river. It was her own voice dripping from the apparition’s lips and Aelthes tried in vain to scream for help. He was mine when he paddled there as a child and he is mine now when he passes through my waters. He shall be mine ever, foolish child of dirt, for I will have him by that form you flaunted in my reflection, and you the one formless, unbounded from your kin. It passed her by, Aelthes the chieftain’s daughter, it retraced her steps to the dancing and the sun. It took the fisher’s son by the hand amid the feasting, it took Aelthes’ husband in the quiet of the night. While she knelt yet by the water and saw a new reflection set within the waves—withered and frail, spent and broken. Cursed by the atna-ahma to age and grow dim.”
Balan’s voice fell away as he spoke this last, and his attention seemed focused on stacking a little pile of rocks at his feet.
“Twas so far that Belen told me ere we were interrupted,” Gildor observed with a smile. “He said it goes on from there, but I’ve no notion whether it ends well or poorly for the chieftain’s daughter. Does the fisher’s boy discover that he was deceived?”
“Aye, in time. But Aelthes spends long years alone in the wilderness. The atna-ahma left her without a voice, you see, so she could not tell any of what befell, nor prove her person to those she had known. She wanders for years until at last she finds her way to the sacred valley where water and earth first mingled. There the goddess of earth speaks from the loam and tells her to spread clay over her body, then to climb to the head of the valley and seek Guënid’s spring. If she bathes there, then drinks of the holy waters, she will be wrought anew and restored to her own form. So she does this, through various trials, and when at last she sips from the spring, death falls away from her and she sees her reflection looking back once more from the water and knows the impostor too has been restored to its unordered form. And so she returns after the lost years and is reconciled to her kin. But death had been in the atna-ahma, unsustained by Luftu’s breath, and death it had passed to the children it bore Oelthes, and so its curse lingered yet among their people, and so death was brought to dwell among our kind.” He slipped the flower into the top of the pebble pile, then chuckled in dismissal, though his tone was forced. “Or so this tale says. We’ve many of the like—ever a new way to explain our nature, never an answer.”
“Aelthes and Oelthes,” Finrod murmured as he bound another bloom into the chain. “Understanding and knowledge?”
“Aye, tis so.” Balan glanced at him with a sidelong grin. “We’ve little regard for subtlety in our tellings.”
“Or you’ve a purpose to the transparency.”
“Indeed, lord,” he added with a sardonic twitch of his lips. “I believe such was the intent.”
Finrod smiled and flicked a flower at him. “Tripping me into pedantry once again.”
“Merely leading where thy footsteps tend.”
Gildor’s laugh broke out at this and he leaned back on his elbows. “Here is one to keep thee humble, Ingo—unbeguiled are the wits of the Edain.”
“And dulled not by proprieties,” Edrahil added, meeting Balan’s eye in amusement. Then he glanced back out at the foothills surrounding the mere. “Had we not such certainty your people remained in the east till your crossing, I’d have hazarded your sacred valley was even this in which we sit.”
“Hm?” Balan followed his gaze, then shook his head. “Nay, the cliffs would be of shale were it so, and clay the valley floor.”
“But there is a holy spring,” the captain added as he set the completed circlet about his brow, a stray cornflower drooping comically into his eyes, “and surely those are not in ready supply.”
“Is there, in truth?”
“There is.” Finrod retrieved the flower from the pile of pebbles and wove it in amidst the others. “Above the upper falls where the streams of the Ered Wethrin gather, there is a pool set deep in the rock. Ulmo’s Well, we name it, for ever have we felt his presence there even in these times of sundering.” He tied the last stem into the circlet he had woven and reached over to set it upon young Gwindor’s head. “It is said to be a source of healing, and that drinking from its waters brings restoration to both body and soul—much like the spring in thine own tale.”
“Is it far?”
“Nay, a short climb. There, amid the thicket by the rock fall,” he pointed toward a dark cluster of trees looking out over the valley.
Balan was quiet, his face unreadable as Sídhon and Gelmir approached and began laying out the midday meal upon the grass. “I should like to look on it,” he said at last, “if thou wilt tell me the way.”
“Gladly. Or if thou art willing, I will lead thee thither.”
“Aye. I confess I would sooner go in company than alone.”
“Then eat,” Finrod said and leaned forward to pluck the cloak further around Balan’s shoulders, “and we will go when the meal is done.”
❈❈❈
It was Thalos again as they climbed toward the summit of the falls. Nóm slipped through the trees before him and the old eeriness pricked once more at the nape of Balan’s neck. Even before Estreth’s hints of the ghomennin, he felt half enchanted, half in danger whenever he followed him through those pine groves and foothills—at once light and phantom, solid and elusive, and Balan had trailed behind him through Ossiriand in the dizziness of a dream.
Nóm wound now through a new set of trees, beeches instead of pines, passing sleek as a doe beneath their branches. And Balan drifted still in his wake, but it was longing now that dizzied his steps, and he felt his restraint slipping.
The climb from the glade where they lunched to the crest of the upper falls was not arduous. Despite the jagged appearance, the ascent wove gently between the crags and they came in short order to the top, hardly winded. The vale spread out before them as they paused beside the rushing water and Balan caught his breath at the beauty of it. The forest draped in a thick blanket across the foothills and in the midst of it the mere glistened in the sunlight—a blue opal strung from the silver band of the Narog.
“I remember the first time I saw it thus.” Nóm’s voice beside him was quiet, pensive. “There was a great feast in the first years we dwelt in Endorë. We thought to unite the scattered folk—our own kin as well as those who took not the Great Journey—to set aside the quarrels and pain, here beside these waters as though waking anew beside another Cuiviénen. It could never be so simple, of course. Looking back, it was at once naive and arrogant to imagine it might be achieved in such a way. Where is the goodness in feasting if such sits in place of reparations? If shouts of ’almien!’ echo instead of repentance? For in those days we still spoke not of all that befell, and what is not named cannot be redressed.” He fell quiet for a time and his eyes grew distant. “Turvo and I climbed here amid the singing and dance, that we might look out over the joy of it and see the hope in its potential. It was beautiful, then as it is now—the lake and the headwaters and the riot of the laughing Narog. I felt the pull then too, the lord of waters whispering, murmuring…singing of what might be built together, I thought, not the foretaste of a warning that would set us sundered.”
Finrod’s voice drifted into silence. He would remember this as well, he realized with a sinking dread, another companion beside the falls, another memory marked by its absence. He clenched his hands as he looked over the mist and spray, tucking his fingers into fists that he might not reach out and draw Balan in against him while they stood yet side by side.
“Come,” he said at last, his voice tight, “the spring is not far.”
He led them along the branching streams till one broke off and darted beneath the eaves of an alder grove. This they followed through the thicket to its source, tumbling down from the steep rocks to gather in a pool at the base of the hill, where it rippled and chuckled amid a deep, stone basin before slipping out into the rushing tributary that fed the falls. Crags of rock rose all about its circumference, barring approach save for a gap on one side that opened onto the water. In one wall of this, an alcoved shelf had been carved into the stone and it was toward this that Finrod guided him. A large cockle shell rested within it, carefully polished but unadorned, and Nóm drew this out and carried it to the water’s edge.
“Aiya Ulmo, heru ëari,” he murmured as he knelt and filled the shell. ”Na airë esselya, mendenya ná mendelya.” Then in reverence, he lifted it to his lips and drank, and Balan found himself mesmerized by a droplet running over the edge to trickle along the sharp jawline. How often had he longed to trace that same path with the tip of his thumb, or still better with the brush of his lips. The heat rose up through his ears at the thought and he was certain the color burned on him as the king rose, turning back with a smile and holding out the shell. “There is no obligation, of course, but know thou art welcome to it.”
“Aye, I will drink,” Balan said, taking the shell from the other’s hand. It was a fool’s logic to make the comparison. This was not Guënid’s well, he was not Aelthes—and false hope was a bitter draught. He thrust the tale from his thought as he moved forward and knelt in the gap between the stones. The spring was as clear as the lake below, yet its depths faded to obscurity as he peered into them, cascading down from the edges till they blended into shadow. It was no wonder they named it a well. He could not gauge its depth. “Navá Guënidan, rimis ah sothe’ei,” he whispered as he dipped the cockle shell into the basin. “Navá Guënidan, ananiujan tagas eil.” The water was cold upon his tongue as he drank of it, his lips resting where Nóm’s had lain, and it was naught but a common draught to quench his thirst. The bitterness rose again, bruised and helpless. What gods had ever spoken to him? And in what folly had his heart hoped despite reason that it would differ here with Nóm to intercede? Balan filled the shell once more and watched as the water ran back into the spring. “He speaks to thy people through the running waters, does he not—your heru ëari?”
“He does. Alone of the Valar, his voice has remained with us, reaching unseen through the firths and rivers, singing in the rapids and eddies.”
“Even as Guënid weaves veins through the earth…” Balan’s voice was flat as he stared into the well. Its cadence filled the air, mingled with the wind and the rustling dance of alder leaves, but the song was disjointed in his ears. “Might they not be the same, Nóm? The gods of my people and those of thine?”
“They are stewards, the ones of my knowing, not gods.”
“Yes, I’ve heard thy corrections often enough. But remember we thought thee a god—and if they too came upon us in the early days of our wandering, how much more so would they have seemed to our eyes?” Balan was quiet as he crouched beside the water and when he continued at last, his voice was nearly a plea. “Might they not have been what we named gods in the years ere thy tales? Could they not have reached out to us as well, lost children though we were?”
Finrod shifted to sit upon an outcropping boulder and his heart was heavy with the weariness beneath the other’s words. “I do not doubt,” he said after a long pause, “that the Valar have sought you in some way, though I know not whether they lie at the roots of your myths. However I can tell thee with surety that they have not crossed to these lands in raiment visible since long ere the sun arose—and in that, I fear, I and my people have played a heavy role. But, meldonya, whether in visible form or no, whether the genesis of thy legends or as some whisper yet unknowable, I tell thee that the lords of the West have indeed sought your people; for in the waters of Thalos I heard the same voice that called to my heart beside Aelin-uial, the same voice that we heard together in the valley below. It sang to thee, Balan, yet thou couldst hear it not. Might it not be that they have called to you indeed throughout these years, only speaking with a tongue you could not discern?”
“That absolves them little. They must have known we would have no such understanding.”
“Only the One is all-knowing. And thy people have ever been a mystery; even in Aman ye were a thing of speculation and great wonder—to us and to the Valar alike.”
“We are not a riddle, we are a people.” His voice was sharp. “And it is little kindness to puzzle over us ere our birth, then forsake us once life’s breath is laid.”
“Have a care, Balan, lest thy sorrow slip to blasphemy.”
A wry laugh escaped his lips at this and he stood. “To blasphemy? How can I blaspheme that which claims me not? The water sang of me—but only to thee. The rivers call out in summons—but only for thy people. Your gods or stewards sought out your kind, yea and rent the very earth to bring you to them and hold you safe. We were given over to the dark, Nóm. No messengers came for us. No gods chained the shadow that we might have life.”
“And yet of all in Arda, ye alone may shape your lives amid the tides of this world, unbound by that Music which holds all else in fate—I and my people included. Canst thou not see thine own freedom? The Darkness has tainted it, Balan, and named evil that which is good; but we shall all of us envy it, this gift ye bear, when the weary years press in upon us. Thou sayest there were no summons from the Valar, and this I grant in truth—for it is the One himself who summons you and calls you forth, released and not bound to watch a beloved world fade before you, to move in ever-growing sorrow toward its inescapable loss.”
“And yet those Valar have left us in ignorance of that very hope thou wouldst have me claim.”
“Unless it was ordained that we discern it together, Firstborn and Secondborn, and by such learn the fullness of our own being—each naming in the other that which our nature allows us to see, and each made greater thereby.” Finrod watched him as he stood beside the spring, defiant and weary, arms crossed and one foot scuffing lines along the moss-covered rocks. It was inconceivable that he would ever be gone. “Sama’nd sá,” he added, half-whispered, and his voice trailed off into the water.
A twinge crossed Balan’s face at the words of blessing, but his gaze did not shift from the far edge of the spring. “Aye,” he managed at last, his own voice hoarse. “If any messenger was sent, twas thee—and so to thee rather is all my reverence given.”
Finrod fell silent, surprised by the intensity of his own response, for his heart was stirred at the mere thought of it. Was it possible that his was the joy of Oromë? That, rebellion not withstanding, he had found favor as an emissary? Another hunter stumbling in happenstance upon that which he sought unknowing—voices through the twilit forest, faces warm in the firelight, their gradual awakening and Balan’s eyes opening to meet his own. Balan whose worship was his, Balan who had left all to follow in pilgrimage at his heels, Balan who…Balan who was more precious to him than any deference, more beloved than any dominion. Balan who deserved a worthy envoy and no charlatan. His heart might burn with the thought of it, but it knew too that he could never claim it. He shook his head. “I am an exile, Balan, not a messenger.”
“And how if thou art both?”
Finrod traced his finger along the rock’s striations and the line of his shoulders grew subdued and weary. “Elwë’s people believed we came as messengers when we returned to these shores, marching as we did with the new light of day, Anar risen to lay waste to the Dark. We bore Námo’s doom upon our shoulders, yet we let our friends think we too came as a sign of remembrance, that we marched to their aid—at the behest of the Valar and not against their command. We had power from their assumption, so we held to it and encouraged it and did not undeceive them. All that it wrought in the end was greater pain, a conflict deferred and not evaded, and division has it sown where there should be fellowship.” The image of Thingol’s fury loomed in his memory, eyes sharp as blades across the feasting table—an eerie reflection of his last glimpse of Eärwen amid the fire and blood, and his heart faltered. “If none else, then thou at least I would have see me truly, a wandering prodigal and no savior. Clothe me not, I beg thee, with virtues I’ve little earned.”
Balan was quiet, then knelt once more beside the well and trailed his fingers through the eddies. He cupped a palmful in his hand, lifting it level with his face, and his lips twitched at last into a smile as he watched it glisten within his hand. “What say you, babbling omniscience?” he asked of it, teasing in his voice while the water trickled down between his fingers. “Goodness has he, yet owns it not. Virtue, yet chides me for to name it. What shall I call him, then? A holy rogue? A blessed villain?”
“A lucky wanderer.” The smile echoed from Finrod’s lips and there was levity once more in the tone of his voice.
“A beacon.” Balan glanced back to meet his eye, then felt the burning flush as he realized the thought had slipped out aloud, infused with all the heat of a far, golden afternoon. At once his mouth was dry and he stumbled on his own words. “For thou didst come bearing light, Nóm, the very light we’ve sought all our days and through every step of our wandering.” He rose and returned the shell to its alcove, lingering for a long moment with one hand resting upon the ledge, then he felt the words fall from his lips and echo within the hollow rock. “But now the only light I seek is thee.”
“Speak not so. I too am a creature of flesh.”
“I know it.” Balan’s throat tightened, remembering again that flesh caught up in sunlight and glass before him, and he turned back toward the spring to hide his face from the other. “Oh gods all, I know it.” His voice was hoarse as the weight of his helpless ardor bore down upon him and the water’s one epiphany flowed through his heart with bitter clarity: it was inescapable now, the truth and the reckoning. For his silence held its own lies and an intimacy gained by false pretense was a mockery and no consolation. His eyes smarted with the sunlight’s reflection upon the water. He would be ever-fractured, a stranger to himself if he turned away and denied a confession here at the crisis. Fervor leapt racing through his veins, swift as the leaping spring beside him, and dizzy with the force of it, he could no longer hold back the flood. “Thy wish, I deem, is for all to remain unspoken.“
”Balan—”
"No." He held up his hand, determined now, and pressed forward over the king's protest. “I need to speak it, at least once. I need to know beyond guesses or assumptions that thou hast the true measure of it, or ever shall I fear I stand at thy side only because the truth was unthinkable and therefore unguessed.” His voice faltered and he kept his sight fixed on the twisting water, knowing his nerve would fail if he met the other’s eyes. “And the truth is that I love thee. I have ever loved thee, since I woke in that far midnight and thou wert there before me, beautiful as a god—and I pierced where I lay with the weight of thy gaze. Thou…thou the lost light of my wandering. And I have loved thee every hour since, not as the liege I am sworn to—nay, nor even as my dearest friend. I love thee utterly, and utterly without hope.” Balan turned at last, his own eyes lit with the mirror of the other’s sheen, bold and bright with abandon. “But thou wilt know of it, lord. I will have it so. For in that, at least, my own convictions may yet determine their sovereignty.”
Finrod’s knuckles whitened against the rock. The muted sunlight was suddenly blinding, birdsong and the chattering water mingled and deafening amid the stretching silence. How desperately had he longed for this, how fiercely had he dreaded it—with all his desire bound up in the fragile life before him, and all his fear gathered before its loss. His heart strained at the sight of him by the water’s edge, shoulders set and face lifted in challenge, while the sun brushed gold across the amber skin and he held the king’s gaze, unwavering. And Finrod stared back in awe, his resolve foundering before the reckless beauty of him.
Yet even as he marveled, he saw despair begin to seep through the other’s eyes and Finrod’s remorse leapt up in accusation. It was his own stunned silence causing the wound, the words slipping and fumbling from his grasp, and all the while he felt Balan breaking apart before him. He burned again with the revelation of Celon’s waters, and again his racing thought held any confession captive beneath it. Speak, you fool! Honesty was no transgression, why could he not say aloud that he too…he too… “Thou knowest it is neither unthinkable nor unguessed,” he fumbled out at last, his mouth dry and the words sticking to his tongue, “yet ever the boldness of thy courage astounds me.”
A cold rush as Balan’s thought pulled back from his, sharp and guarded once more. His face had hardened at the king’s words and there was defiance now in the set of his jaw. “I have offended you, lord, and spoken where I had no right.”
“Balan…” Finrod’s voice was little more than a breath, halting and bewildered, and he stumbled to his feet. “Nay, Balan, you mistake me. Turn not away!” The sharp tone had broken through his stupor at last and before reason could halt him, he crossed the distance and caught Balan by the arms. “Dear, bold heart, I know. I have known. Truly, I brought thee out from Estolad with this knowledge as certain in my heart as the day’s rising. Anarinya! I would not have thee from my side.”
It was Balan now who stood transfixed and his pulse pounded against the other’s palms. “Wouldst thou not?”
“Never.” It was with an effort that Finrod kept his hands steady and did not reach up to draw him in, to kiss him there beside the holy spring till all doubt and grief were drowned. “I would tear down every stone of Arda, were it within my power—cast it to ruin and build it anew from the dust if in so doing I might unbind my fate and loose thee from thine.” One hand had slipped free despite his resolve and reached out to cup Balan’s face within its palm. “Valar spare me,” he breathed as his thumb traced along the cheekbone, “I would forswear all to hold thee ever by me. Not my beacon, but my anchor, beautiful and steadfast, thy soul the still point that moors me amid the foundering.”
The glade was spinning. Balan forced himself not to look away, for he could see his own passion blazing back from the other’s gaze, ardent and desperate, and his breath fled before the force of it. Did he sleep still? Had he awakened indeed or was he slumbering yet beside the boulder in the sun? He reached out to brush a strand of hair from Nóm’s face, his movements slow and muddled as though caught in the dream he feared, but the touch shattered his uncertainty and he caught him behind the neck instead, pulling him forward till their heads rested together and the mingled breath passed like a kiss between their lips. “Elenya…” he whispered, hoarse and fervent, and felt the other’s hold tighten.
“Freithe eil!” He reached up to cradle Balan’s face in both hands now, fingertips shrouded in his hair and palms alight with the rasp of beard against skin. “Light of my heart…” The words slipped from him and he faltered, breathing fast. Balan’s palm was warm in the valley beneath his ear, the fingers strong and gentle as they traced along the base of his head, marked the lines of his neck. “Balan…” he whispered again and his breath caught in a sharp gasp as Balan’s free arm slipped behind his back and drew him in. The touch turned his flesh to fire, pressed close against the other, and his pulse pounded a drumbeat in his ears to feel the fingers moving along his neck, the brief brush of Balan’s lips against his own. His senses reeled. “We cannot,” he whispered with a great effort, then pulled away.
“Why?” Balan searched his eyes, not loosening his hold. “It needn’t be a scandal. I can be discreet.”
“Oh beloved, it is not that.” Finrod’s hands drifted over the other’s face, memorizing every line—the cheekbone beneath his thumb, the jawline passing along his fingers, the living warmth of the forehead to which he pressed his lips. He was growing intoxicated by the nearness of him, his resolve faltering as he breathed him in and all his passion poured into the lingering caress. “It is not that. I would wed thee in full sight of all—set thee at my side and proclaim that here, here is all my love and here all my desire.”
“And mine…Elenya!”
“I cannot, Balan. Everything would I give to thee—but it cannot be so.”
There was a pause as Balan watched him, perplexed, and he stepped back as Finrod's hands released him. “Wed me not, then, if it seems so dire,” he said at last. His features eased as he spoke and his tone was quiet, resolved. “I’ve no pretensions to it. The king’s vaen-hlaiba is contentment enough for me.”
Finrod looked over at him, startled. “What?”
“I’d not love thee the less for it.”
”Vaen-hlaiba?”
“Freithen-hlaiba, rather,” Balan corrected with a quick grin. “I was being coarse. It is…it means an intimate companion. I’ve not yet learned the word for it in thy tongue.”
“It is not what we mean by melotornonya, thou and I?”
“Nay, it—” Balan broke off. The king’s thought had reached into his own, curious as in their early friendship when each was yet a stranger to the other’s speech; and as he had then, Balan held out his intent without guile and at once felt his blood run cold at Nóm’s bewildered surprise. Humiliation pounded in his ears and his mouth was dry as he tried to speak, his hands trembling.
“I see.”
Nóm’s voice was gentle, but Balan could not look toward him. He had transgressed after all, passion and presumption overreaching, and he was brazen, uncouth in the other’s eye. He wanted to run.
“In this our people are different as well, it seems.” Finrod spoke quietly, as though coaxing a frightened creature back to his hand, but Balan had already drawn away.
“I am a fool,” he muttered as he staggered back from the water’s edge, and turned toward the wooded slope where he could escape and have no need to meet the pitying eyes, nor face the embarrassment, the sure affront—
“Nay, Balan!” Nóm caught him before he managed three steps and at once he was within his arms again, embraced in earnest now with his face cradled against Finrod’s neck and the long fingers threaded tenderly through his hair; and despite himself, Balan clung to him in return. “Melmenya…” Nóm’s voice murmured against his ear and Balan’s heart turned to water at the sound. “Melmenya, it was not folly. We have no word for it because for us the twain are one—the act of love and the bond. By such are we wed, and by such are we held till the ending of Arda, soul bound to soul in union irrevocable.” He felt the other tense within his arms.
“It is otherwise with us.”
“I see that." He rested his lips against the other's hair. "And fain would I follow thee, but I know not whether the way of thy people or of mine would rule us in the attempt.” He drew his hand along Balan’s back, marking the sharp line of the shoulder blades, charting the vertebrae up to his neck. “Perilous is the chasm that lies between us, beloved. It would consume us both, should we dare defy it and bind ourselves across its depths. Nay, please, I mean it not in scorn!”
Balan had pulled away at the words, insult and grief looming together through his mind, yet open and unguarded before the other.
“Loved I thee less, I would not hesitate.” Finrod felt his color rise as he continued. “Loved I thee less, I would find compromises to ease my heart and sate desire. But it would be to constrain the whole of me, to withhold from thee that which my love demands in fulfillment: both hröanya and fëanya. It would make of thee a plaything and still I would not be satisfied. What I want…what I want is the whole of thee, Balan, and to give thee less in return would be the breaking of me.” He moved close again, but did not reach out, fearing lest touch should shatter what faint resolve he still held. “I have been bent and fractured all these long years—from doubt, from regret, from my own pride and ignorance…With thee I am knit together. I am whole. Seen and known and named, as thou alone in all of Arda can name me. I cannot strike a fault line within that, nor set my love for thee at naught.”
Balan was silent. How had his heart leapt beyond hope only a few moments past? Where now was that boundless joy, that exultation? He was drowning in earnest, despair lapping up his chest, pressing about his throat as the spring gurgled unchanging beside him, its promise of healing a mockery of his pain. “Then can there be no love,” he asked at last, his voice nearly lost amid the water’s chatter, “if thou art unwilling to hold it in bond?”
“Not unwilling, Balan—constrained.”
“If thou art constrained, it is by thine own choosing.”
“It is by my own nature.”
“Thy nature is of cold dispassion?” The words lashed from him like a blade, no longer caring where he struck so long as he could wound in return.
“Canst thou not see what this asks of me?” Finrod’s voice burst out in unexpected anguish. “Thou hast assumed a strength that I have not. To let myself love thee is to live ever with the lack of thee. To know always the loss of thee.”
“And what shall I know, then? Hidden the fate of my people may be, but if thou art sundered from me by its outworking, then so too am I sundered from thee. Dost thou imagine I shall rest in any life or oblivion that awaits, when through it I am rent from thy side? Force not that division before its time!” Balan broke off, anger and grief vying still across his features. Then at length he looked up once more and met Finrod’s eye, shifting to his own tongue with a fading defiance. “You say I am unbound by that Music which impels you.” He reached out to take the other’s hand in his. “Can I not then shape my life as I will? Or were your words of hope but flattery to stem my anger?”
“They were not flattery, melmenya.” Finrod gripped his hand in return and the grief broke through his voice. ”You are free in ways that I am not.”
“And if you were bound to me? If I held you in union irrevocable, as you name it, would not your soul too be mine to shape beyond the Song and sorrow?”
“I know not.” Finrod felt the tears stinging in his eyes and he shook his head. “I know not. But my heart tells me it could not be so. It would rend us rather, bound across a gulf we cannot fill.” His voice broke then and he wept unhidden, reaching out to draw Balan into his arms. “Let us hold fast to that joy we are granted,” he whispered, slipping back to his own tongue amid his grief, “and of its bright memory weave a tapestry to bear with us whole, as we tread each our lonely road. For love is not diminished by restraint, Balanya, nor is friendship of a lesser worth.” He cupped Balan’s face within his palms and brushed away the tears that ran too from the other’s eyes. “Let me remember thee ever as this, here in the light and the water’s music, here with the words still half-upon thy tongue. This I would hold ever in memory.” He drew his fingers down the length of Balan’s jaw and let his thumb trace along the soft ridge of his lips. They parted beneath the touch, and his heart raced as he felt the other tremble against him. Or no, it was his own shiver at the close press of their bodies, his own breath fast and ragged, his lips bending down of their own will to seek the other’s.
“No.” Balan gripped the other’s arms, unsure whether he was holding him at arm’s length or clutching him that he might not draw away. “Not if it is only the once. Open not a wound thou wilt not bind.”
“I would…ai, Balan!” Finrod held himself back with an effort. “But were I to bind it thus, I would but bind thee unto thine own destruction—bind thee too unto my exile, unto my people’s fate. Heavy is the doom that rests upon us!”
“And upon us, I deem,” Balan countered, unfazed. “Else why should we run fleeing from the memory of our own beginnings?” He gestured toward the hills about him with a bitter laugh. “We whither as the grass of the field, Nóm. What doom canst thou give me worse than that?”
“There are many ways to die, melmenya,” Finrod said quietly and the light in his eyes dimmed, tarnished. “Some even as you live.” Then he felt Balan’s hand upon his cheek and he turned into the touch, pressing his lips feverishly to the palm in kiss after kiss, all desperation and ardor, until Balan took his face in both hands and turned him back to meet his eye.
“I would die any death for thee.”
A spasm crossed Finrod’s face at the hoarse whisper. “Too bright are the eyes of the Sun, too scorching her heat.” His lips were nearly against Balan’s and he was dizzy with the the nearness of him, the touch of him. Almost the taste of him. “It would consume us, Anarinya.”
“And scorching too are the stars, are they not? They too were woven of such light. But should not Light treat with Light, Elenya, and find itself only brighter in the mingling?”
“Or bring a double fire, burning all that dared near it.”
“Take me then,” he said, “and if I burn, I burn.”
Finrod’s fingers were tangled in his hair, Balan’s breath passing between his own lips. They were the same flesh surely, broken halves of a gem brought together, found beyond hope in the tumble of time and wandering…he was falling now, slipping from the edge, he could not hold. Body and soul. Body and soul and let me break—
A peal tore through the air above them and Finrod pulled free with a sharp hiss. An eagle was circling over the foothills, its cry echoing across the rock face, and his eyes followed it in trepidation through the breaks in the canopy.
“Nóm?”
His gaze remained on the sky, sharp and wary. “A servant of the Elder King…”
“Many eagles dwell in the mountains. They are not each a portent.”
“Not idly do the messengers of Manwë send forth their cries.” Finrod glanced back at the path they ascended and shifted quickly to set a distance between them. “Someone is coming.”
Balan shook his head as he watched him and a bitter laugh tore from his lips as the sinking certainty smothered his hope. He slammed his palm against the rock face.
“Hilyo.” Finrod lifted a hand in greeting as the captain came into sight through the trees. “Something is amiss?”
“A line of smoke to the north-east.” He joined them in the clearing and gestured toward the far hills. “It is small, but the source is unclear—it could be naught, or it could be a raiding party. They have grown bold of late and in small numbers manage far within the leaguer.”
“Mm.”
“I thought it best to find you.”
Finrod’s fingers fiddled with the signet upon his finger and he tried not to glance toward where Balan stood glaring out at the spring, his anger prickling through the air.
“Arto?”
He looked back with an apologetic smile. “Yes, you did right. We will ride on today and not wait for the morning—we should not linger.”
“As you will.” Edrahil dipped his head in quick i, then turned back into the woods, leaving them alone once more.
The silence was heavy.
Balan remained beside the rocks, unmoving since they had broken apart, and Finrod watched him long in turmoil. Yes, he longed to say, as he had beside the embers in Estolad when courage faltered before desire. Yes. He felt it on his tongue, it pressed against his lips. Then at last he steeled himself and stepped forward.
Then Nóm’s kiss rested gently against his forehead and the bitter draught was poured.
“Forgive me,” the king whispered, then turned and followed the water back the way they had come.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
atto quá [Q] father duck
páni: [T] small gull
anorhín: [S] sun’s child
almien: [Q] cheers, (lit.) to good fortune
Aiya Ulmo, heru ëari. Na airë esselya, mendenya ná mendelya: [Q] Hail Ulmo, lord of the seas. Your name is holy, my will is your will.
meldonya: [Q] my friend
melotornonya: [Q] “my brother from love” (meletorno + -nya)
melmenya: [Q] my love
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
- awiluth: thanks (to you)
- Navá Guënidan, rimis ah sothe’ei: Water of Guënid, rest and sustain me.
- Navá Guënidan, ananiujan tagas eil: Water of Guënid, renew my days.
- freithe eil: my love
- vaen-hlaiba: paramour, slang (lit.) bed-companion
- freithen-hlaiba: paramour, (lit.) love’s companion
MISC NOTES
- Yestarë is the first day of the year in Elven calendars, also the first day of spring.
- All credit for the “Hilyo” nickname goes to Song of Sirion, the wonderful fic that welcoming_disaster wrote to go along with my TRSB art. If you haven’t read it yet, go add it to your list. It’s so lovely!
- For the “beacon” reference in the scene at the holy well, see A Heady Fragrance of Honey.
15. Darkly the Sundering Flood
Here too the king’s presence was distant. Permeable almost, as though he stood half in the glade and half out of time—another wraith, Beren thought with affinity, drifting through the wood.
At the Pools of Ivrin on their road nothwards, Finrod, Beren, and their ten companions rest for one final day of safety before setting out toward the Pass of Sirion.
Read 15. Darkly the Sundering Flood
“Darkly the sundering flood rolls past!
To this my long way comes at last—
a hunger and a loneliness,
enchanted waters pitiless.”
—The Lay of Leithian, Canto III

1465th YEAR OF THE SUN, AUTUMN
The Pools of Ivrin
“There is a line of smoke to the north-east.”
Finrod’s scalp prickled at the words. It was a strange thing, how time could double back upon itself in an instant. A glance, a smell, an ordinary phrase and the threads of memory looped around to meet amid the weaving. And certainly there was comfort to be found within these plaited moments, echoing outward with the passing years. But memory was a bitter thing now, both solace and wound, fracture and support. He would never discard it and he could not escape it.
He joined Edrahil atop the boulder where the captain sat watch and peered out at the foothills he indicated. “Ours or the enemy’s?”
Edrahil shook his head. “I’ve no certainty. I suspect the enemy, for our folk would not move openly this far to the north. Unless it may be that some of Galdor’s people are passing through the mountains—Húrin’s people, I should say. They know many routes through the Ered Wethrin that we have ventured not.”
“Little reason would they have to wander so far with wolves and Orcs roaming.”
“Indeed.” Edrahil drew the cloak from his shoulders and bundled it to the side. The sun had risen above the tree line and doused the basin in a pleasant warmth. “Thus of the enemy lies my guess.”
“You’ve the right of it, I deem.” Finrod squinted as he watched the smoke twist against the bright mid-morning. It was distant yet, more than a day’s journey. “But whether foe or friend, they are too far to reach us ere nightfall—nor would they yet dare the Eithel Ivrin unless they have grown very bold of late. We may rest still awhile.”
“We, says my lord, and yet here he sits awake beyond his watch.”
“Mm. Two-faced of him, is it not?” The hint of a smile twitched at Finrod’s lips and he drew his legs up upon the rock. “Sleep is an elusive quarry today.”
“And the day before, and the day before that.” Edrahil’s glance held a mild reprimand, but he stooped to retrieve a thin cake of waybread from his pack, breaking it along the middle and passing half to the king.
Finrod took it with a nod of thanks and bit off a corner as his eyes drifted over the mere before them. In the dark of Araman, he had sat alone amid the grief and fury of his father’s departure, his back turned pointedly towards Aman until the fading line of the returning passed beyond sight. He would not look back, he told himself. Never again would he allow his eyes to dart behind at what was forsaken—nay, his bitterness cried out, at what had forsaken him—till their road was followed and the journey complete. He would face the dark, he would face the Ice, and walk headlong into their doom with never another glance of regret. Or so, at least, he had purposed in his grief.
It was Meril who sought him out at last and found him with the angry tears still hot upon his cheeks. She had stood before him then, a tall specter amid the clinging mists, and placed a wafer of lembas upon his palm. Rise, herunya, for these that remain are thine.
He bit again from the edge of this new waybread, savoring the mild sweetness on his tongue. It fortified his resolve even as that first had done, this too bestowed from Meril’s hand; once again a blessing and an edict. All doors had been closed as they made their silent way through the city, all windows shuttered. But Meril was there awaiting them at the Annon Aearon, tall and silver against the dark passage, and she held the provisions before her in open defiance. “Go now, herunya,” she had kissed his forehead and placed the parcel in his empty hands, “in folly perhaps, but not in dishonor. And may the bread of our people’s Great Journey hold thee sustained now through the steps of thine own.”
It had been bitter comfort at the time, for she would offer no wisdom for their road and jealously did he covet such counsel. Meril had ever been at his side—from the break in Araman to the founding of his kingdom, to its governance and keeping, and thence to its loss. Even in that hour she had held, grim and quiet at his right while the storm rose about him and drowned every word from his lips.
It was strange to think back on it. The whole affair lurked as a half-formed memory along the edges of his mind—seared upon him, yet scattering before his grasp whenever he sought it. He held snatches of imagery, the rolling roar of the assembly, the revelation of his own impotence, but it all passed before him as though viewed through another’s eyes, helpless and blurred. Indeed, he remembered seeing their reflection in the polished shield of one of his guards—it was Medlineth, third from the right—Celegorm poised like an adder, Curufin a half step behind, the murmuring lords who lingered yet, his own figure braced against the gale and distorted in the curving pane. His downfall mirrored back to him, a feckless observer.
There had been a child near the front of the gathering, seated on the floor at her father’s feet and galloping a toy horse to and fro across the stone. She was tiny yet, born just before the Bragollach, and Finrod’s eyes rested on her with an eerie sense of juxtaposition. He knew those wooden hooves and each intricacy of the flowing mane. His own hands had carved it, his own hands bestowed it—a gift and the king’s blessing upon the birth of the marshal's child, four months before the fires came. She sat now in the lamplight, watching the uproar with the same wide, curious eyes that had peered into his while he spoke the benediction over her, nai amanya onnalya ter coivierya. May your child be blessed…She had cowered against her father’s leg as the shouting grew. What use was the king’s blessing when it was the king’s word that bound them all to the crisis?
But they were his people too, Beren’s folk—sworn and bound in fealty as he too was bound by the lord’s vow in return, long before his word to Barahir. They were his, in love and obligation. And Thingol had, with damnable flippancy, condemned one of the few survivors of Ladros to torment and death without a even a word in courtesy to Beren’s liege. Beren, last son of that beloved line, whose every remnant was more dear to him than any treasure. His wrath rose again at the thought.
That it had been a jest, Finrod had little doubt. He knew Elwë well enough to hear the bite beneath the words, the dry parry giving vent to his fury. The scorn carefully masking his fear. But Beren, borne down by desperation and grief, had taken him at his word and named it back to him in challenge. He would see it done. And Thingol—here lay the bent of Finrod’s own fury—had not disabused him, but rather sat by while Beren stumbled forth to seek an end of anguish and despair. Folly, he had shouted at Edrahil when the final letter from Doriath was read and hurled upon the table in rage, senseless, arrogant folly!
But in truth, what better were his own actions? His intercession had served only to anchor Thingol’s purpose—assume a jape if you will, kinsman, but it is the mortal’s sworn word, and to his word I shall hold him—jest turned to edict, mockery to steadfast purpose. Nor had his hospitality achieved aught but to lead his guest before another stone-hewn court where Beren’s worth and integrity were once again cast in derision. And what would his own aid offer in the end but to stumble beside him into the gaping maw?
Tol Sirion had been his promise. With all the host of Nargothrond united, they could repel what the defenders alone could not withstand; they would cast out the festering evil and cleanse the isle. It would but drive Gorthaur into Taur-nu-Fuin till a new assault came, but it would be enough: sufficient time to re-garrison the tower and time too for Findekáno to send strength from Hithlum, for Húrin to cross from Dor-lómin. They would come. Surely, they would come. The loss of Sirion was an ever mounting blow and regaining the pass was beyond value if there was to be any hope of rebuilding the Siege. And if they did not and the tower fell once more, still it would not be in vain. For if the Foe’s eyes were drawn to a renewed offensive, a small detachment might achieve through stealth that which seemed beyond the—
He took a sharp breath to break the circling thought. There was no host, there would be no renewed assault. Even this had been twisted into the blade that unkinged him, the strategy proof of his fickle loyalty, the tower’s worth counted only when measuring Atani interests—else why had he not ridden out when Gorthaur came, why only now was the offensive drawn? It had been Orodreth’s question too, indignant when he was brought overlate to join Finrod and Edrahil in their calculations. Why only now did he seek to stay its fall?
The waybread was bitter upon his tongue. Meril had sent him forth with its benediction, but it passed down his throat as a talisman of accusation: the life-bread granted to sustain the road of death. How quickly his hands had been emptied! How quickly the reckoning had come. He felt the whisper echoing again through every fiber, Curufin’s voice a breath as he passed amid the growing turmoil, “A king is he that can hold his own, Cullingwincë.”
The sound of rasping metal drew Finrod back to the present. Edrahil had begun sharpening his sword and the steady rhythm drifted like a heartbeat through the glade. Ivrin was ever a place out of time, still and glad and filled yet with Anar’s warmth. An island within the gathering shadow. His eyes drifted to rest on the upper falls, full from the recent rains and roaring down to push the waterline high above the basin. He dreaded passing their torrent, as he knew he would ere the day was done, for his feet would be summoned irresistibly to the ascent and the view across the valley, to the bitter outlook where he would draw memory’s specter against his side, embraced in cold communion. Turgon who was gone, Balan who was gone, he who soon would be gone—and still the water flowed laughing while they passed like wraiths before its cadence.
“Why did you hold, Hilyo?” Finrod’s voice was nearly covered by the sound of the whetstone. “Gwindor’s anger was rightly placed—I whose last folly cost his brother’s life, pleading once more for that trust I’ve no right to claim. Yet Sídhon was bound to Gelmir and that loss was his as well, and the Fen cost you nigh the whole of the guard. I have earned your ire—and Sídhon’s—as much as Gwindor’s.”
For a long moment Edrahil was silent and his hands fell still in their work. “Perhaps,” he said at last. “But I it was who saw you half-dead where Barahir’s men had dragged you, and Sídhon who tended you through all the long road back. No blame could we place upon you greater than what you placed upon yourself.”
Finrod’s hand moved reflexively to rest against his side. It had been years since the scar pained him, but still the ache reached along its puckered tendrils whenever the massacre rose in his mind. It was the soul’s wound, he thought with morbid fascination, prodding its counterpart to waking once more. Long it had festered in the nightmare months following the Fen; its mending so slow that the healers grew concerned and whispered hushed fears of new poisons, venoms of the blade as yet unlearned, some new devilry pouring forth with the dragons’ fire. But he had languished in the shadow of their concern while the smell of smoke permeated every inch of the tower, harsh and bitter and burning his lungs with the ash of the dead. His malady was no new poison, he knew—it was the waking horror of living on while all those who followed him were lost.
“I too owe a debt to Barahir.” Edrahil's voice cut through his thoughts. He had turned back to the whetstone and once again the water’s meter was punctuated by the steady rasp. “My duty it is to preserve the king’s life, and I watched over a sea of foes while you were driven from me to a certain end amid the mires. And so it would have been, had he not fulfilled my own duty and drawn you back, alive beyond hope.” He turned the sword to its other edge. “I would follow you upon any road, aranya. And gladly too will I give my life for his son.”
A shiver ran along Finrod’s spine. Well did he remember the meadow and the charred pine grove, the haunted look in Edrahil’s eyes as he stood near, watching Gildor hold him down while Celiel cleaned the filth from the wound and bound it against the journey back. He had nearly bitten through the stick Gildor slid between his teeth, and he could taste still the bitter sap oozing over his tongue with the force of his pain. They were too near the enemy yet to risk a cry, and the wound had been deep, the Fen’s mud foul. Edrahil had not spoken through all those hours but hovered, haggard and weary with his hair shorn already in mourning, and never once shifted from his side.
And now it was Guilin’s voice echoing through his thought, cold and quiet amid the gathered council when Finrod took them into his confidence only a fortnight past. With respect, my lord, this is not the first time you have pressed forward in folly—yes, I say in folly—to serve the few who are already doomed over those who might yet live; as this Beren can surely attest, for it cost his father great losses to bear you forth from the last result. The knife slipped in and twisted, as though that guilt did not plague him through every waking moment, or haunt every sleepless night.
The wind sighed through the valley and Finrod filled his lungs in tandem with its movement. It was done now, and no reappraisal would change its course. “I was a good king once,” he said at last, his voice nearly lost amid the water.
“Arto. Thou wert ever a good king.” There was only a slight hitch as Edrahil continued drawing the whetstone along the blade. “And I am proud to stand by thee yet.”
A wry chuckle escaped Finrod’s lips. “Thy king still, thy fool also? Both kind and tactful.” He fell quiet for a long moment and his gaze drifted out over Ivrin’s waters. “Far better than this didst thou deserve, Hilyo.”
“True enough.” It was Edrahil whose dry laugh echoed now, a quick grin handed between them like the shared waybread. “But it will come for each of us, our stalking Doom. Better to meet it by willing choice than to flee before it till the hounds have outlasted you—and better too to determine in what cause you bear your neck to its bite.” He set the whetstone aside and ran a cloth over the blade, its edge glinting in the sunlight as he held it up to inspect the bevel.
Celegorm’s blade had flashed even so in the lamplight of the great hall, sharp and deadly as his eyes, and both trained upon Beren. Finrod flinched again despite the distance of memory. He was between them in an instant and the light ping of metal striking gemstone rippled still in his ears—the point of his kinsman’s sword against the Dwarven necklace. He had donned it in defiance, he realized later, the gems of Valinor carried forth to spite his uncle’s words and displayed now in tangible memory of what cost had already been paid that rival Oath. Even so, he had nearly faltered when the point rested against his breast and Edrahil stepped forward, his hand upon his own sword.
But Beren was there behind him, clothed in a tunic of midnight blue with Menelmacar’s sword reaching over the right shoulder—a ghost of the past holding him anchored still.
He was bound—by oath, and oath, and oath. He was no longer his own. Indeed, he had not been his own since he lay beneath a summer’s night and guided Balan’s hand along the woven stars, the touch of his skin still new and unfamiliar. Nay, he had not been his own since he looked through the trees and saw them, strange and beautiful, and knew against all reason that he belonged here among these perplexing creatures. He was home when he ran through the green woods with Balan keeping pace at his side. Home, when Baran’s sharp teasing drew out his smile, when Estreth watched him with half-affectionate suspicion. Home, when Balan loosed his blood and swore that they would ever be his, there in the long watch beside Belen’s prostrate form. How young the boy had been, so eager and earnest; how impossible it seemed still that any could mistake him for an Orc with naught but a skull obscuring his face...
The thought trailed off and his eyes shifted back to the distant smoke. There was only one fire, he was sure of it. Two at most. It would be a small company that made such a camp, not a force seeking battle. Twenty, thirty perhaps. “The roaming bands that come down from the pass, how many are in their number?”
Edrahil frowned as he stood and returned the sword to its sheath. “They vary greatly. Some are a hundred or more, others less than ten swords among them. Sedril has said the small bands venture furthest, similar to what we saw in the days of the Long Peace when raiding parties would slip through the leaguer.”
Finrod was quiet for a moment, then nodded toward the rising tendrils. “The company there—would you deem there are few enough for us to overcome?”
“Perhaps.” The captain peered again into the distance, then shook his head. “No more than fifty, certainly. At a guess, I would say fewer even. If they were unguarded and taken by surprise, we would have little trouble.”
“Good,” Finrod said, “so I thought as well.” He peered again into the distance and set the last bite of waybread upon his tongue.
❈❈❈
Beren woke, disoriented, to sunlight streaming through the branches. He had dreamt of Ladros for the first time in months—not as the charred house of haunts that so often stalked his rest, but as he remembered it from his youth. The rolling grasses along the slopes, the wind in the spruce grove, his father’s garden meandering down from their door. He could smell the herbs as he traced the well-known steps, he heard his mother’s laughter on the breeze and drew his fingers over the mead crocks, the clay rough against his skin. His sister’s hound came bounding through the green and the familiar bay washed through Beren’s heart with a deep, insatiable ache.
Ash. The green meadows, the open window. Barahir’s herbs too, the hyssop and thyme, the golden calendula blossoms, all ash in the wind.
He sat abruptly and rubbed the sleep from his eyes, looking out over the glade. Most of the others were sleeping still and lay clustered in a haphazard formation along the rocks. As too should he be, Beren thought ruefully, for it was hardly mid-afternoon. But instead, he brushed the leaves from his cloak and rolled it, tucking it beside his pack, then rose and made his way toward the shore. Sleep was past.
It was a short walk to the clearing by the mere’s edge. Their guard was loosened here beside the crystal waters, inviolate yet in the quiet of the valley, but nevertheless they slept within sight of the watch. Beren filled his lungs as he passed between the trees and felt his heart lift despite the melancholy. The day was bright, infused with the surprising warmth that rallied ever after the first frost; and as he walked, he found he was glad after all to have wakened. They would lie concealed through every daylit hour once east of the Narog. Who knew when he might walk again unhindered beneath the sun?
He hesitated at the edge of the trees. His hope had been to find the king on watch duty; or barring that, to come across Edrahil. They had grown close during his weeks in Nargothrond—Beren, the captain, and the king—for they were closeted long hours disputing the merit of each grim strategy while they awaited Thingol’s dispatches. It was intelligence gathering, they explained to any who queried: gleaning every detail Beren recalled from Dorthonion that they might equip the lords of the Ñoldor toward any future campaign. This had been true, of course, but anything of note had been documented within the first days, and more besides.
But Beren had passed Edrahil as he moved toward the shore, curled among those resting in the glade, and Finrod was nowhere in sight.
Sídhon it was who knelt along the shoreline as sentry, laying out berries and nuts upon a flat boulder in the grass. His ear twitched at the sensed approach and he looked up, poised and wary till he sighted Beren at the edge of the tree line. Then his features eased into a smile and he beckoned him forward.
“Haelis!” he said as he retrieved a small collection of apples and added them to the stone.
“Haelis,” Beren responded in kind then crossed to join him, lingering a few steps away lest his presence was an intrusion.
But Sídhon’s smile was warm and he held out an apple. “You took the first watch already, anorhín, and there are many hours yet till sundown.”
“Aye, and many past since sunrise. I’ve had rest enough.”
Sídhon watched as he leaned back against a tree and began polishing the apple on his shirt. What a change there was from the merry child he remembered in the hills of Ladros. That boy had been a riot of laughter, quick and bright and darting each way with an exuberance that spread to all around him. He was missing a tooth the last time Sídhon saw him, second from the center, and they had all laughed at the roguish air it lent that otherwise innocent face. But his manner was reserved since arriving in Nargothrond; quiet, his smile scarce. It was little surprise given all that passed between, but it grieved Sídhon nonetheless to see those cheerful eyes darkened, to find the child’s laughter stilled. And then, once the betrayal was full wrought and their course chosen, that reservation had shifted to despair. Beren was withdrawn through the brief preparations, silent through their departure. The self-reproach hung heavy upon him and he had spoken little on the road so far.
Sídhon selected a few berries from the pile and turned them about on his palm. “I remember your father well.”
Beren glanced up in surprise. The other’s voice drifted toward him with unexpected warmth, the Taliska easy upon his tongue.
“I knew him during his three years’ service in Nargothrond, of course—both he and his brother—but I remember him most vividly in Ladros. We danced on the lea when he wed your mother, a merry riot with all your folk singing through the late watches of the night.”
“Aye, she told us of it often—that the king rode from Sirion to Ladros for no reason other than to give a blessing and witness the oaths.” A smile twitched at Beren’s lips as he remembered Emeldir recounting the story and he moved to sit alongside the other. “My father held it over my uncle for years.”
Sídhon chuckled. “Your uncle’s marriage was at the time of the High King’s council else I doubt not he would have received the same.” He transferred half the berries and nuts to a wide leaf and slid it across the stone where Beren could reach them. “It took much for my lord to decline the rite, for dearly does he hold the honor. Truly,” he added after a pause, “one cannot hold it otherwise.”
“Have you stood as a witness also, then?” Beren asked, hearing the catch in his voice.
“Aye, I have.”
“I knew not that any but the king had done so—of your folk, that is.” He leaned against the boulder behind him and for a moment the old grin creased his face, and his eyes lightened. “I am glad to hear of it. Was it for one of my kin?”
“It was.” Sídhon met the smile with his own as he raised a handful of berries to his lips. “But I’ll say no more than that.” Beren laughed despite himself and Sídhon was pleased to see the guarded posture loosen, the pained lines ease. The right edge of his smile was a scant breadth higher than the left, even as his forefather’s had been when he leaned against that same rock more than a century past and sipped miruvórë in the sun, his wry laugh drifting on the breeze.
Beren finished the apple and threw the core into the thicket. “Do all of you speak our tongue, then?”
“Nay, most do not. Of our company here, only Edrahil and I—and my lord, of course. Hilyo was oft with the king when he rode to Estolad.”
“Yes, I remember him in Ladros when I was a child.” Beren glanced at the other in curiosity. “When did you learn?”
“I have been the king’s attendant since ere the sun first sailed,” Sídhon replied, sorting the dried nuts into various arrangements, “and I assisted Bëor as well when he dwelt among us. It seemed only courteous to do so in his own tongue.”
“That was kindly of you.”
“Not overmuch.” Sídhon drew a packet of waybread from the bag beside him, a tinge of embarrassment in his smile. “Languages are a delight of my people, and my own particular interest. His offered a fascinating study.” He lifted a cake from its wrapping and broke it, holding out a chunk to Beren. “He was a good and dear friend. Bitterly did we all feel his loss.”
Beren took the lembas and turned it over on his palm, his eyes distant as he traced a finger over the stamped design.“When my sister and I were children, we would carry dried honey cakes up Alaf Hill. Our aunt—our father’s aunt, rather—said our people were forbidden the Elven bread, so we would pretend my mother’s cakes were our own lembas, bestowed by special edict and carried through all our play, till we ate them in solemn ritual upon the hilltop.”
“Apportion it not to the Secondborn, lest through its sustenance they find weariness where gift was laid, and among the Firstborn long to dwell. Yes, I’ve heard it said.” Sídhon chuckled as he recited the maxim, then glanced at Beren with a brow lifted. “Little danger here, I think.”
“When I’ve the malady already?” He laughed and broke off a bite. “Aye, fair enough. Naught here that bread can worsen.”
“Felagund would tell you it’s nonsense—proverbs invented by those who’ve never spent a full day among Men.” Sídhon finished his own mouthful and the quick smile flashed out once more. “Few things are more certain to raise his disdain than willful ignorance of your people.” He watched as Beren progressed through the waybread, each bite broken off with the childhood reverence he described, and slowly his mirth drifted quiet.
Does he go to his own kind in Dor-lómin? Celegorm’s voice had torn through the great hall, his sword bright as blood in the lamplight—bringing with it the dread sensation of standing once more upon Túna amid the dark. Nay, it is to us that he comes, to our strength that he appeals in lust’s whim. Shall it be our blood poured out in satiation? Let the apanónar look to the lands they were given and reach not for our own to spend, nor seek to purchase their debts through the price of our birthright.
The king’s wrath was an instant fire. He had been calm till then, measured and steady against the onslaught, but the brothers knew too well where the armor’s weakness lay. His fury lashed out in defense, the show of preference was twisted round his neck, the crown hurled upon the stone. Sídhon raged still at the memory. What knew Celegorm of mortals or their love, that bitter beauty, precious and fleeting, so dear to his lord? What knew Curufin of an oath sworn from devotion and not vengeance?
Beren had finished his portion of lembas while Sídhon’s thoughts wandered, and now was collecting the crumbs with his finger, lifting each carefully to his lips. He took nothing lightly, this boy. Every kindness was held with warmth, every gift received with quiet solemnity.
They had feared for his life throughout the one night they tarried in Nargothrond, uncertain whether the brothers were content to hold the quest as executioner, or whether their Oath demanded a more immediate satisfaction. Every corridor was heavy with fear. Peril seeped like perspiration from the stone. But Beren had thanked the king quietly and retired to his chambers without alarm—Death may hunt me if he will, he had quipped with a mirthless twist of his lips. No door of mine is barred to him. Nevertheless, they had watched the Bëorian apartments throughout the dark hours: the king sitting guard at one door, Edrahil at the other.
“Where is he?” Beren’s voice broke through the patchwork of recollections. “He was not among those resting in the thicket. I thought I might find him here.”
“So he was when I took my watch, but he departed to climb the upper falls an hour or two past.” Sídhon gestured toward the tumult behind him. “The summit commands a fair view of the valley and the lands north of the river. He wished to examine our road while the sun is yet above the hills.”
Beren nodded and glanced up toward the crest of the falls, their spray blinding with the refracted sunlight. “Then I may join him—I too would glimpse our road ere we hazard its passage. Unless it is solitude he seeks as well?”
“Aye, doubtless.” Sídhon reached for another berry. “But he would not count your presence an interruption. Rotavva Wrotenni,” he added with a smile and his voice was nearly lost amid the roar of the falls. “Ever has he loved your people, more than many understand.”
❈ ❈ ❈
He found his way easily enough. The foot of the path was just as Sídhon described and he followed its track between pines and beeches, winding gently up the hillside. In some places steps had been shaped within the stone, worn now and smooth against his feet—a far contrast from the crumbling rocks that shifted and gave way when he clambered over the Falls of Sirion and sighted the highlands through the rain, a last fragment of hope.
Those hills lay beyond his sight now, nothing but a haze along the horizon when he gazed from the crest of these falls. The valley and headwaters of the Narog were spread before him in somber array and he shivered as he looked out over their expanse, at the forest draping a shroud across the foothills, the river a winding line of steel. It was beautiful—and foreboding spilled over every edge. Even Anar touched the land with suspicion, shifting the autumn leaves of the valley to fire but leaving the plain beyond in shadow.
And there at the edge of his sight: Brethil.
Brethil, whose fingers reached the Esgalduin. Brethil, whose boughs might gaze across the Mindeb and glimpse the twilight of Neldoreth, whose leaves danced in the same wind that carried Tinúviel’s song.
Tinúviel! Tinúviel! His heart faltered. The roaring falls beckoned with a siren’s voice. The plummet reached out to him, slender arms twining about his shoulders, drawing him down as Lúthien drew him to her side beneath the stars, beneath the boughs…and all his longing was to slip forward into that embrace, to tumble down in flight through the singing air and meet oblivion in the memory of her arms.
Beren caught his breath and staggered back, dizzy. For in that moment he had felt it there behind him, the light amid the air and the whispered song, the stillness potent and teeming—the tone of Neldoreth. Irresistible, it drew him from the precipice and he followed it without hesitation, drifting along the branching streams till he passed the eaves of an alder grove and a heavy quiet fell through the boughs. The stream babbled on. But the sound had clarified and sharpened, alive in the same way the light about him was alive, each threaded through with motion, with vibrance, with unmeasured thought.
He was at once lost in the familiarity and muddled by the difference. Beeches there were amid the alder trees, but they grew in snatches rather than the standing multitude where Lúthien had danced. Did she dance there still? Would she seek his memory among those boughs as he clung to hers here beneath this blood-red canopy, swathed in gold? Listlessness overtook him as his steps moved along the bank, for they were the same dull rhythm of the previous autumn, marking hours between the trees, losing days beneath the boughs. A wraith longing only for a fleeting glimpse of her beauty.
As if in answer, there was a flicker at the edge of his sight and he turned toward it in reflex, his heart pounding. Only now it was the king’s form he saw through the slender trunks, bright against the crags from which the stream’s source poured. The same rush of enchantment dizzied Beren’s senses—there before him, beautiful and fay, an apparition beneath the trees. But Lúthien had danced as starlight incarnate, whereas the figure before him was a creature of day, all golden sunlight cascading through the branches.
Finrod was still as the stone about him, a graven image in the gap between the rocks; one hand propped loosely against his lips, the other folded across his abdomen, and his eyes followed the water as one in a dream. He was no longer shrouded in the grey uniform of the Silent Guard, but had laid that tunic aside to reveal a faded blue shirt, frayed at the edges and embroidered in patterns of red and gold. Even from this vantage, Beren recognized the Atani designs—and here too, as in the apartments in Nargothrond, their form was of more than a century gone.
And here too the king’s presence was distant. Permeable almost, as though he stood half in the glade and half out of time—another wraith, Beren thought with affinity, drifting through the wood. Guilt passed over him with the recognition, for he knew that he watched uninvited and eavesdropped on the other’s solitude. It was the same conviction he recalled from the night his grandfather passed—he woke in the midnight hours and saw his father across the Hall, bent double in mourning, his mother’s hand set lightly against his neck. It was a simple gesture, and ordinary, but he had felt a voyeur to look on the quiet intimacy without their knowledge.
Beren stepped forward, rustling the leaves beneath his feet as he moved into the clearing, and the king turned sharply at the sound. For a moment his expression froze, a tangled mix of discovery and hope, then recognition settled and and his features eased into the familiar welcome.
“Beren,” he said, and though he smiled his voice was rough, “forgive my surprise, I did not hear your approach.”
“Nay, lord, the apology is mine. I’ve broken your solitude.”
Finrod dismissed this with a wave of his hand and moved to sit on a low boulder. “A welcome diversion,” he said, motioning for Beren to join him by the water. “I am always glad of your company.”
Beren crossed the clearing and his scalp prickled as he neared the water. “What is this place?”
“Ulmo’s Well it is called—a place of reverence. I believe your traditions would name it a holy spring.” Finrod felt his heart falter as Beren crouched down in the gap between the stones and dipped his fingers beneath the water. He could mark the differences easily enough after these weeks in Beren’s company, but still at times the resemblance would leap up without warning and bind a knot through all his senses. Navá Guënidan, ananiujan tagas eil… “Then in the water, Aelthes washed,” he murmured without thought. “And of the water Aelthes drank. A healing draught, a cleansing balm. And the withering fell from her like scales…”
Beren looked back at the king in surprise. “It is long since I’ve heard that recited,” he said, and a smile eased his features. “Few tell the tales any longer, but my mother would read them aloud each night by the fire in the Hall. ‘Know the path your forefathers set,’ she would tell me. And ‘it is a fool who heeds not his past.’ It was an old book handed down through her line—it held all these tales we’ve come near to forgetting.”
“Yes, I remember it.” Finrod’s fingers sought the iron band about his forefinger, turning it absently as he spoke. “Long years he spent in its making, and glad indeed would he be to know it held these back from loss.”
“Of course,” Beren’s voice was stunned as the stark difference reared its head once more. “You were there in the margins…” He knew it well enough in reason, that this who sat beside him had walked the world ere the sun, that his own love had walked it longer still, and would walk on till its ending. But ever he was dizzied by the tangible marks—those treasured items on the shelves in Nargothrond, these same eyes that rested upon him had shone in the woods where his forebears were found, his own history a recent memory. Beren shivered. “Is this Guënid’s spring, then?”
“Nay, if such was more than myth, it lay far to the east, beyond the Ered Lindon.” There was a forced lightness to his tone and he trailed into silence, his fingers falling still against the ring.
Beren rose and let the breeze fill his lungs. His senses were awash in the scent of leaves, the sun upon his face, the wind sighing like water through the branches. “It reminds me of Neldoreth,” he breathed, stepping away from the water, and in his memory Lúthien’s arms were about his waist, her voice against his ear summoning him forward, drawing him into the whirling dance.
“That is the presence of an Ainu’s spirit.” It was Finrod’s voice that met him in reply, and this too was warm and golden, dawn instead of twilight. “Here the lord of waters reaches through the stream, through every pool, sustaining and guiding each eddy and growing bough. In the far woods it was Melian’s power you felt, the life-blood of Doriath.”
“The life-blood, aye—and Lúthien the heartbeat, each season held in time by her dance.” Beren’s murmur was worshipful, and a smile slipped out despite himself. “She drew me to its rhythm too,” he added, glancing toward the king with a lightened face. Come! dance now, Beren, dance with me! The lines of care had eased and for a moment his youth shone through. “I would sit and watch her weave those steps, all joy in the beholding, while she chided till I rose and joined her. ‘Woo more nimbly, Beren, the deer and squirrels out-pace thy dancing!’”
Finrod’s laugh rippled out, clear as the spring beside them. “Even so,” he said, and mirth was alight once more in his eyes. “I remember my first visit to Menegroth. I was out of place and hesitant amid the unfamiliar customs, and she slipped from the dancing to hover before me, laughing at my reticence. ‘Ye Noldor are strange creatures, coz—limbed of stone, ‘twould seem. How long wilt thou watch in study to learn the joy ere thou wilt join it?’ Then she took me by the arm and pulled me into the dance before I could protest.”
Beren smiled again, but he turned to look into the grove and weariness seeped back into his features.
“After that, I would bring stories with each visit,” the king continued with a smile, “tales of what lay beyond the forest borders. I told her of your people, of Estolad and the plains, of Ladros.”
A choked sound escaped Beren at this and his fingers sought the callous where his father’s ring once rested. He had returned it to Finrod on their last night in Nargothrond, when they lingered weary and shaken from the fury of the great hall. Thine oath paid is now mine own debt to carry. But still his hands fiddled in their restless habit and he clasped them now to stay their movement. “I wondered,” he said at last. “She knew my home ere I described it—and a balm unlooked for that was, for I could not then recall any form but its ash.” Again he saw the slopes with their smoldering wreckage, the skeletons of homes and hall sprawled like a stripped carcass along the ridge, and the knot strangled in his throat.
Lúthien held him beneath the starlight when at last his grief was loosed; and he had wept against her in breathless sobs till she drew him down upon her lap and sang, long and low, her fingers trailing paths through his hair. Within her voice was the lament he could not speak, and within her song the memory of life, of those same beams planted and raised, his people’s voices singing in time with their labor. She had built it anew in the cadence of that music—from Finrod’s stories he realized now—and returned to him what the darkness had stolen.
“I know it sounds folly to find home in the glance of a stranger’s eye, but I have never known such joy as those months, Nóm.” Beren’s voice was hoarse as he held back the renewed wave of grief. “I was a hunted thing, helpless and wretched, but she sought me out night after night and in her gaze I dwelt without suspicion.”
“Seen and known and named, as only one can name you.” Finrod’s words were quiet. He had risen and stepped into the gap between the crags, and he reached out to rest his hand upon the stone. “And made whole thereby.”
“Yes.” There was a new note in the king’s voice and Beren looked back at him in curiosity.
“We’ve each of us our Neldoreth,” Finrod murmured, answering the question in the other’s gaze rather than his words. A distant smile tugged at his lips and his eyes were warm, unguarded. “Though to speak truly, mine was upon other foothills, amid the pines and not alder trees. But here was it spoken.”
And then, as though a haze had lifted, Beren saw the king’s arm caught in the sunlight against the rock and the pigment etched above his wrist. A vertical stroke, crossed at its midpoint, a dot on each side of the intersecting line. Emeldir and Barahir had each born a similar mark, as had his mother’s father, his aunt. By what illusion had he not seen it till now? His breath drew in with sharp surprise—the king was wed, and to one of Beren’s own people. His thoughts spun as the realization settled upon him. “Who?” he blurted out, attempting too late to restrain the stunned query and felt the color leap across his features. “Forgive me, lord, that was a presumption.”
“Nay, thou hast more right than any to ask—dear son of dear sons, as I’ve named thee before. Dear son of his sons.” Finrod’s voice caught and for a moment his knuckles whitened against the stone. Then a laugh slipped from his lips and he looked back at Beren with a wry grin. “‘Know the path your forefathers set,’ was that not the phrase? Ever keen, thy mother’s words.”
The knowledge shifted together like a mirage once neared. The king before him in the frayed and faded shirt, the patterns of the long wandering marked about its hems. Each pointed insinuation that had lurked beneath his cousins’ accusations. A shrine of items upon the stone shelves, each piece a herald of that first generation. The cracked harp and the spare clothes. Nóm’s voice greeting him with the language of his own people, naming him son as he clasped him within his arms. And throughout all, a faded scrawl in Emeldir’s book of lore, Whom among us can resist the draw of Light? Forgive me, Bel, I heeded not the cry of the raven. Yet neither can I find it in me to regret.
“Bëor,” he heard himself say, then flinched at the incredulity in his tone.
“Balan.” The king’s smile was weary now and his thumb turned the iron ring round and about his finger. “Brief it was and foolish, and bitter in the ending—as all such barters must be. But of all my years, his shall ever be the center.”
“But was he not—” This time Beren cut himself off in time, yet nevertheless felt Finrod’s eyes resting on him in amusement.
“Was he not wed to another?”
“I…forgive me, again I have spoken out of turn.”
“And again I correct thee—ask as thou wilt, there is no offense.” Finrod turned back toward the gleaming waters, the old grief and the old jealousies rising together with the question. “Yes, he was wed, some years before; but Esrid’s death was long ere thy people crossed the mountains. Of that suspicion at least thou canst absolve us. Nay, he was unbound—weary and alone when we met beneath the pines of Thalos’ spring.” He chuckled as he glanced back toward Beren. “And no doubt he would tell thee the same of me. We recognized each other at once, in some way, there across the dying embers. He was the first of them to wake.” Balan had ever been a light sleeper, poised and half-ready for the crisis, unless he held him gathered close. Then the breathing would slow, the tucked arms ease, and the solid warmth of him lie loose and heavy within Finrod’s embrace. He had held him every night in his age, for otherwise sleep came only in restless snatches, strewn throughout the hours—and Balan needed the warmth then too, of course. The emptiness ached in his arms. “It was the first time I’d looked in the eyes of your people,” he managed after a long pause, “the first time I saw that depth and fire, the vibrance and despair. I can see that moment still—the embers gleaming like gems amid the ash, the many sleeping bundles scattered about the clearing, then one of them stirring and his face lifted and looking up over his shoulder, Isil’s light washing him with silver…” His words trailed off, then after a moment he laughed and met Beren’s eye, teasing once more dancing through his voice. “No footing have I to fault devotion to a stranger singing in the woods.”
“No indeed,” Beren replied, the other’s laughter crossing to his own lips, “not when thou wert the songbird.”
“Ah, but twas I saw him first you know. I watched them for hours from the shadow of the trees and could not take my eyes from him as he sang beside the fire. Mind you,” he added with another flash of mirth, “he had not the voice of a nightingale.”
Beren laughed again, then felt the wave of incredulity rising once more, dizzying his senses.
It had been a crude punchline among the older boys in his youth, something contradicted with indignation, not anything he gave a moment’s credence—the cause of his first fight. Pretty as a peach, that mouth. Little wonder they say old Bëor chased after him to those caves. Hávar had muttered it in his ear as they watched the king’s guard ride out toward the plains, chuckling as he glanced toward Bregolas’ sons. On the lookout for a new bedfellow, do you think? And Beren had leapt on him, small fists flying, till Barahir hauled him back with nose bloodied and a split lip.
A jest. And yet here the king stood, a widow’s grief etched within the smile Beren had known since childhood. Nóm was a fixed point through all his memories before the burning—laughing at his grandfather’s jests, his voice raised in a funeral lament for the same, or flitting from note to note with the childish ballads he taught them. He would sit by the Hall’s fire in midwinter and carve toys while Beren and the other children gathered around him in a brood, watching the intricate precision of his knife in fascination. He danced alongside them at midsummer or in the reels of wedding celebrations—Sídhon had spoken truly in that, the king would appear over the ridge of Ladros for a surprising number of these. He had spoken blessings over each child of Bëor’s house in turn, his palm laid gently upon their tiny heads. Beren remembered the king murmuring those words over his sister when she was an infant of sleepless nights, then cradling her in his arms and tucking her against the embroidered silk, singing through the long hours while Barahir and Emeldir slept.
And throughout all, Beren realized, there flowed a river of grief—where each new life must have marked the loss anew, each death recalled the pain of that first. Yet Nóm was a spirit of joy in all these memories, his laughter ever-present and the generations of Beren’s people knit together in his song. How had he borne it?
His mother’s words rose through the tangle of memory. Emeldir’s hand had rested upon her son’s shoulder while the king sang a lament over the elder Beren’s body, his death early and unexpected amid the cruel winter. Know this of your king, little one: ever has he held us in honor. From our earliest days he marked our people with dignity, even in our passing. And then as though in afterthought, it is said he arrived in full mourning for the forefather of our House.
A new revelation struck and Beren felt his blood run hot with fury. “Is this what he meant?”
“Who?”
“The lord Curufin. Before the assembly when he spoke of duties and allegiance.”
“Ah.” A muscle twitched along Finrod’s jaw and he looked away. “Shorn like a widow for some usurper?” His voice was tight as he repeated his cousin’s words. “Yes. This is what he meant.”
Beren’s anger smoldered anew. He could see the king’s pale face in the lamplight still, frozen in an instant to a mask of its usual poise, eyes bewildered and in pain as they rested on his cousin. The abrupt stillness had been jarring in the wake of his impassioned retorts to Curufin’s brother. The accusations from Celegorm, he murmured to Beren in the aftermath, had been expected. It was the personal he did not anticipate—the cold, measured calculation of it. The cruelty. Beren had not pressed further at the time, but now his fists clenched as he watched Finrod shift forward to stand at the water’s edge and saw a tremor ripple along his shoulders. Brittle as glass, he thought, then without warning was plunged into a vision of Lúthien, hovering before him in the light. She too stood beside a shoreline, only it was Esgalduin’s waters that brushed against her feet and starlight that lit her features, that glistened within her hair. But the same tremor shivered through her frame and Beren felt a choking dread as she turned and walked into the shadow of the trees.
He started after her and the vision dissolved, leaving him once more forsaken in the woods beside the shore, stumbling to a halt and breathing fast. The hunger and the loneliness threatened to overwhelm him. This time she had been so near he was certain he could have touched her arm, had he reached out in time.
“Tell me truly, Nóm,” he managed at last in a cracked whisper, “to what pain am I leaving her?” Again he thought of the shelves in Nargothrond, their shabby collection held in preservation amid the long-empty apartments. “Do you regret it?”
For long Finrod was silent, then he took a deep breath and turned back to meet Beren’s gaze. “I did,” he said quietly. “In that first pain of parting, yea and for many years following, I believed I had chosen wrongly—from weakness, from foolishness.” A dry laugh escaped him and he shifted his shoulders as though shrugging a garment loose. “I found many words to castigate then, many reasons I should have held my course, or parted at once, or sent him back to Estolad when I knew my resolve could not hold. I buried my grief within regret, berated myself that I might see it as wisdom gained, to judge thus with prudence through its dear-bought insight. And, Valar forgive me, I gave counsel from that belief.” A spasm crossed his face and for a moment he faltered, then the breeze lifted once more and a smile spread gradually over his lips. “But I would not wish away a single breath of the time I was his. The memory of him dwells ever in my breast—the wound of him, I would have named it to thee only a handful of years ago. But in truth it is a balm and not a blade, a physic that soothes the long ache and that which binds the wound together, as he himself once told me. As he wrote in that same book thy mother read to thee. He holds me still, my anchor amid the grief of this passing world, and ever shall I hold him in return. Every moment of him I carry with me, forever undimmed till the ending of Arda.” Balan’s hand had rested against this stone, Finrod recalled as his own pressed against its rough chill. He had watched him slam it against this same outcropping in fury, and with such force that Finrod feared he must have broken it. “Nay,” he added quietly as his fingers traced over the calcite veins, “my only regret is that I tarried. Precious time was lost while I stumbled in fetters I bound upon myself, when I should have done as Lúthien—set my hand in his and walked out from these woods in joyful defiance.”
Her hand had been cool when she reached for Beren under the sighing boughs, his own trembling as his palm met the corporality of her skin. Even after he caught her in his arms, he still half-believed she would be revealed as one more mirage upon that shadowed road of phantoms—beauty come to torment now instead of clinging horror. But her hand wrapped about his and her pulse flowed between their fingers, grounding him, every fiber of him more vibrantly alive than he had ever known. “Why did you hesitate?” he asked, and clasped his hands together that he might not feel their emptiness.
Finrod’s fingers continued to follow the calcite, its path branching like rivers along the rock face. “The doom of my people, the fate of thine, the danger of souls bound across that distance, the ever-present Siege and the conviction that I had transgressed already by desiring that with which I was entrusted…” He shuddered and passed his hands over his face. “Fear,” he said with bitter precision. “Nothing more than that. I was afraid of the pain, I was afraid of drowning, of the loneliness of years. I spun reasons aplenty from the threads we held—and their philosophies were not wrong, but the convictions restrained me not once fear’s grip had loosed me. But for a century and more I have watched his sons grow and flourish, I have held their daughters and their sons, and the sons and daughters of these. Ever new and ever brimming over in wonder. I have lived surrounded by the fierce beauty of your people and never could I have guessed at such a joy, to see the echo of him travel down the lengthening generations…Yes, there was grief. And there was joy too—there is joy." He glanced across at Beren with affection, then slipped without thought into Taliska. “You are an echo very like him.”
“Am I?” Beren’s voice was bright with surprise.
“In face and voice. Only somewhat in demeanor.” A small smile played at Finrod’s lips as he strayed back through memory. “He was not a warrior.”
Beren’s brow lifted in amused skepticism. “He chose Dorthonion for his people, did he not?”
Finrod chuckled. “Nay, he left all that to Baran. He and I both chose scrolls over swords whenever the chance allowed. Book mice, Bel called us, scurrying ever back to our scribes’ larder. Yes,” he added in response to the other’s querying glance, “his sons knew. Belen dwelt alongside us for a time in Nargothrond.” His thumb moved across the mark on his wrist and his eyes grew distant. “Indeed, he stood as one witness.”
“The effigy in Ladros was not a likeness then.” There was mischief in Beren’s quick grin and he was rewarded with a full laugh from the king.
“Nay, not a likeness. That too was more of Baran than his father—though there is little surprise in that. Through Baran’s youth their similarity was striking and in the intervening years we always spoke of them as such. When Belegor shaped the Hall’s carvings, he knew only Baran’s visage and drew up the likeness from there. A tall chieftain, fierce and strong, with spear brandished and all your people’s brash valor shining from his face…” His lips twitched in amused affection. “You are very like him as well.” Finrod’s eyes drifted again to the gap between the crags with its sloping moss lining the path to the water. “Mistake me not, though,” he added quietly, “Bëor was no coward. He had more courage than many I’ve known—a steadfast courage, fixed and level, stubbornly so. It centered me. Truly, it holds me grounded still.”
Beren watched him long in silence. What of his own self would Lúthien bear forward through the years? Of courage he had shown little but the rash bravado in her father’s court. Of constancy, of dedication at least he had given more evidence. In that she had the memory of his footsteps seeking after her through the seasons. But would she remember that with joy? Or would that desperate chase too become mired in the grief of their sundering, tangled with her father’s fury and her own parting words. Stubborn fool, I would have fled with thee…How would she speak of him when a century had passed? When an Age was gone? Would he be wound or balm?
“We are ever taught to honor our forefathers,” he said at last, and there was strain in his voice, “and thus he has been a relic to my mind, separated by time and reverence, static as the figure in Belegor’s woodcarving. I wish now that I could have met him.”
“And I that he could meet you.” Finrod smiled still, but the lines of weariness had returned at the edges of his lips. “I confess that has shadowed my joy in these years among your people, that I have the chance to know you and he does not—how he would have loved each one of you.” Then illumination rushed over his face and his eyes were bright once more. “That I cannot remedy, but I can show thee a better likeness than Belegor’s rendering.”
He rose and retrieved a shell from the niche cut into the stone, then crossed to the waterfront and cast about till he found a wide divot within one of the lower crags. Beren watched as he filled the shell from the spring and poured it over the stone, repeating the process until the hollow was filled to its edges.
“This I learned of my sister,” Finrod murmured as he crouched beside the rock and glanced up at Beren with a quick smile, “who in turn learned it of the lady of Doriath.” He took a breath and let it pass over the water, sending ripples traveling out across its surface, then he sat back on his heels and watched while they settled once more into stillness. ”Many things may be gleaned of the water’s eye, both knowledge and mystery, guidance and obscurity. Perilous it is to set a course through its wisdom, for past and present may appear together without distinction, intermingled as well with those things whose time has not come. But in this it is a tool well-suited: I will show thee memory, if thou wilt look upon it.”
“Memory?” Beren moved across the glade, mesmerized by the silken veneer pooling upon the rock.
“My own. It will show as I command for such a purpose—and I am willing, shouldst thou wish to know his face.”
Finrod’s hand had shifted to rest upon the edge of the boulder and Beren was captivated by the serpents lying side by side with the iron band. There had been a crest in the first leaf of his mother’s book, the Bëorian sigil painted in bright, Elven ink, the twin serpents wrapped in embrace about its edges and their crown markedly absent. The four-point set in the center was filled with the colors of the king’s house…gods all, had they been blind? It was here all along, in the heirlooms of their line, in the heraldry they painted yet on shield and helm. In his bones, even. He knelt beside the king and set his own palm upon the rock. “I will look, lord,” he said. “I would know the one whose path I tread.”
There was a flicker of gratitude in the king’s eyes and he shifted to make room as Beren bent forward over the makeshift basin. The water was still, unnaturally so with the autumn breeze rising yet through the clearing, and upon that plane the leaves above were mirrored, bright as dancing flames. The hair along his neck prickled as he noticed that his own reflection was absent, and the heartbeat grew louder in his ears. Then abruptly the pool went dark, flat and without any reflection, as though looking out into the night.
Which, Beren realized as his eyes grew accustomed, was exactly what he was doing. There were leaves still, grey now amid the darkness, moving with the breath of a gentler wind. Slender trunks passed on each side of his vision as though he moved between them, gliding forward through the night air. There was a brush of orange through the boughs and for a moment Beren thought the reflection was returning, but it took the form of fire instead, its light spilling out between the trees. There were figures seated around the edge, others milling about through the clearing in familiar tasks. And then with a brush of the other’s thought, it seemed to him that he heard voices singing.
And here in earth beneath our feet
the flesh of gods, the steady beat
of Melishk’s heart will mark our way.
Here at last the rooted clay,
the darkness left, the waking day.
It was his own tongue, the singer’s voice pleasant and rough, the tune a hymn they had since preserved through each new generation—Bëor chanting to mark the mountains safe passage. Beren could see him beside the fire in glimpses stolen between the boughs. Middling height, his profile sharp against the flames, laughing as he traded the melody with the man beside him. Even from the distance, he recognized this second as the visage carved into the Hall at Ladros; though young here, younger than Beren, and his eyes lit with mirth rather than the fire of battle.
The same clearing again, only it was daylight now. There were huts scattered throughout the trees, some half-built, donkeys and sheep penned within woven hawthorn boughs. A group sat in another circle, perched on various logs and stools, but a bowl had been placed in the center and each took turns dropping a pebble and attempting to strike it into the vessel mid-air with the sticks they held. Hallus’n aurkeis—stone in the pot—Beren knew it well. They had played it beside Tarn Aeluin throughout the dark winters and young Hathaldir was nearly unbested. In the water’s vision another youth struck a pebble with the same twist of his wrist, the stone fell into the vessel with the same precision. Laughter ran through the group as he twirled the stick in victory and the nearest figure, whose dark nest of hair had blocked half the vision so far, glanced over his shoulder, grinning. Beren’s breath caught as the image met his eye. Smile lines were scattered across his features, crinkled along the ridge of his nose, and his lips were parted mid-laugh. The dark eyes looked directly into his own, but in the warmth of their glance, the intimacy of that quick affection, he knew at once his own intrusion.
The water too seemed to sense the trespass, for it shifted at once to the caverns, vast and many-pillared, lit with lamps of gold. The great hall of Nargothrond, Beren noted without hesitation—fixed as it was within his memory, within his guilt. A figure moved toward him along the same aisle he had walked at the king’s side, and the light hung about him as a garment. Indeed, it was caught within his robes, dancing from him as the lamplight had refracted from the king when Beren arrived, weary and stumbling before his table. Yet Beren recognized him at once—it was the same cloud of waving hair, the same ease of presence, the dark eyes once more meeting his in challenge and devotion as he knelt. Then a brief image of the king’s hand reaching out and resting against the other’s cheek.
Memory flinched away from this as well, or rather flinched into what followed, seeming to leap against its will to hover before the rocks where Beren knelt. Bëor stood in the gap between them, his chin thrown back as if braced against a coming blow, and the same shirt the king wore now hung loose about his shoulders. Nearly at once the vision faltered and became fluid as the water that held it, images rippling one into the other—Bëor’s face cupped within the king’s hands, the same again with tears streaming from his eyes, the spring rushing past, Bëor turning away in fury, the cockle shell filled with water. The vista of the upper falls with Bëor’s profile sharp against the sunlight.
Nargothrond again, memory had retreated. The image was of the chambers Beren knew from his own stay, looking back from the hearthside toward the principal room. Bëor sat sprawled upon the bed with a book propped against his knee. He was clad in the same shirt, rolled to his elbows and worn unbound over a pair of loose breeches, boyish somehow despite the steel grey of his hair. He held a trimmed quill between his teeth as he turned the page, then retrieved it and dipped it in an inkwell before jotting a note along the margin.
For a long moment, the water held steady upon this image of his face, each detail pristine in recollection. How different he was to what Beren had imagined—Bëor the Old, wizened and dignified, a sage presence and not this man with a sardonic smile creased into the lines of his face, glancing at the king with teasing and challenge.
The memory faltered. Then the reflection showed the same view, only it rushed now toward the bed in a mad scramble and there was a brief image of Bëor’s face, lined and frail now, set unmistakably in that final stillness.
Finrod’s hand struck the water with a choked exclamation and the vision scattered.
The puddle fell dark and Beren was startled to see his own reflection return, wobbling along the surface as the ripples coursed through the basin.
“Nóm?” he whispered and looked up in concern. The king’s face was still as marble, his eyes fixed yet on the gathered water, and his expression an unreadable mask, save only for the tears tricking down his cheeks.
But Finrod shook his head and smiled when their eyes met, and there was peace within his own. “I am well,” he murmured. “Truly.”
Beren nodded, but could not find any words in reply. His thoughts were reeling, caught between the revelation’s initial shock and the eerie fascination of having looked into his ancestor’s eyes. And more, of having looked into those eyes and seen himself there. “We have always named him the Old,” he said at last, his voice distant, contemplative. “I never thought to imagine him merry.” Then a smile broke over his own face as he heard Finrod’s chuckle in response, and he glanced back at the king in warm gratitude. “Thank you. I am glad to know his face.”
“And a balm it was to show thee.” Finrod looked down as he dried his hand on the hem of his shirt. “It has eased my heart—and I am grateful.”
Once again the pattern drew Beren’s fascination. Those lines had danced too on the robe he wore before the great hall, trailing in seed pearls along the sleeves and hems. “Was his the tunic you lent me?” he asked, knowing already the answer, for its cut too matched those he had seen in the water’s eye.
“It was. I wanted to remind them—for them to think of him when told of thy need. Most would have remembered him before that same hall, swearing your people to ours; they would have remembered the countless feasts, or their children who called him uncle and sat at his feet to hear tales of those lands beyond the Lindon. I wanted them to remember.” A muscle twitched along his jaw and he stood, turning away toward the spring. “But those children have long since grown, and none of them are among our number. Do any remember but I?”
Beren was silent. It was eerie to hear the same question from the king’s lips that his own had roared at the blackened stones of Ladros. The land had forgotten, the beasts had forgotten, the stars overhead shone on without pity—they too bore little of his people in mind. Only in his own memory did they live on in remembrance, only in his were they mourned, or so he had believed at the time. “Heavy it is,” he said at last, “to carry the dead alone.” His voice was tight with feeling and he rose to stand beside the king. “And those of us who must bear it know better than any the worth of its bitter joy.”
Finrod nodded, not drawing his gaze from the chattering waters. “In goodness our paths have crossed,” he murmured in the Atani fashion. “In parting, the same dust carries upon our feet.” His voice trailed off, then he turned toward Beren and met his eye with a smile. “So you see, my son, I would have sought to aid thee regardless—for thy sake alone, but also for his. And, this to my further shame, for the sake of one whose own bitter joy I denied by my counsel.” Beren’s silence once again pressed forward in query and Finrod fidgeted with the iron band as he answered. “It was my brother’s wish to wed thy kinswoman—and my word that dissuaded him.”
Another facet shifted, the hints and asides took on meaning, tales from Dorthonion’s fall fell into place. “That is why she walked out onto the heath.”
“Who?”
“Madjatta,” Beren replied in a breath. “Saelind—amid the Bragollach.”
“I know not thy meaning.” Finrod’s posture took on a wariness, tensed for a new wound. “What was it she did?”
“When the lord Aegnor was slain...” Beren looked at him in surprise. “Have none told you?”
“No.” Finrod shook his head and the eagerness in his eyes was mingled with dread. “Exiles there were of Angrod’s folk, but none came to us from the eastern highlands. I could learn naught but what I knew already from my own spirit—he was gone, and the fires took what was left.”
“Aye, so it was.” He shifted his weight from one leg to the other and thought back on the ragged group that found them amid the ash. His own sister had been among them, Hathaldir as well and Radhruin beside them. Hathaldir and Radhruin had been side by side again at Aeluin, and amid the blood and wreckage Beren could hardly tell the brothers apart. He shuddered. “More can I tell you, lord, though I fear it may be of little comfort.”
“Yet where truth lies, fear knows its measure. I would hear the tale if thou wilt tell it. Indeed, I would beg it of thee.”
Beren was quiet for a moment, then nodded. “The assault made first for Ladros instead of the central defenses, for the pass was easier to breach, and moreover they believed our kind to be weak. We were, of course, against such a number. But we sold our lives dearly and fled only when the land was burned from under us, and then the retreat broke in every direction. I and my mother found ourselves in the hills east of Aeluin—of my father you know. Another large contingent fled to Barad Tirnen to shelter with the lord Aegnor. Within a day it too was cut off by fire and foe, with no hope of aid from the western marches. But there were passages through the rock and secret ways along the hills that could still be passed if only a few dared them at a time. Many of those exiles found their way to us, and so we learned of what befell. My sister was one, and among the last to flee the tower.” Beren broke off for a long moment, then recollected himself and pressed forward. “She told me all I know of it. It was there that Bregolas fell and many of our warriors beside him. But till the last, lord, your brother held the gate, and nearly all our folk were able to flee. Hiril saw the breach while they hid among the hills. The enemy bore in like a sea and by then he had been wounded. He was surrounded and forced out from the gate, but still they could not take him alive, and he fell at last with a spear through his chest, his sword broken. They pulled back from him then and set a line of archers.” He faltered again as he saw the tears streaming from the king’s eyes and he shook his head. “Lord, forgive me, I’ve brought only greater hurt—”
“Please.” Finrod’s voice was a whisper, taut and brittle. “Let me hear till the end.”
“They needed only one round of arrows, Hiril said. That, at least, was merciful.” Beren’s own voice was choked with tears as he relayed his sister’s words. “And here is what I never understood till now: Andreth walked out from the gate when he had fallen, slow with age, but tall yet and proud. She carried no weapon, but knelt where he lay and took the body within her arms. My sister and two others watched till the full dark of night shrouded her from their sight, but while they watched, no Orc dared approach, so great was the fury of her spirit.”
Beren’s voice tapered into silence. The king’s eyes remained fixed on the spring, palm pressed against his lips and shoulders shaking with mute sobs. For long neither spoke and once again the only sound was water, and the sighing wind through the trees. Leaves drifted down into the current and were captured by its swirling eddies, spun round and back again to roll against the shore, lapping in layers against the stone. Beren saw fire in this as well—the motion of the flames, the dance of its varied hues. Fire was in everything now, the scent of smoke always half-upon his senses.
“I am sorry, Nóm,” he said at last, heavy with the sorrow, and found with surprise that he was desperately weary despite the day’s rest. “Again I have brought you naught but sorrow.”
Finrod steadied his composure, then turned back toward him, shaking his head. “Nay, think not so.” He reached out to rest a hand along the other’s face. The touch was gentle and the quiet tenderness of it called up the old ache within Beren’s heart, the memory of Barahir’s own hand tousling his hair, the calloused palm brushing his cheek. “It is strange comfort, but comfort nonetheless to know the grief in full. In truth, my heart is eased—for a known sorrow is a kinder thing. Every horror I would imagine, and in the uncertainty every horror was true.” A wan smile broke through the lines of grief and he let his hand fall back to his side. “Thy words have laid those to rest, Beren, and I am at peace now in my mourning. Do not offer apologies.”
The king bent to retrieve the polished shell and crossed once more to kneel beside the water. Beren watched as he lifted it and drank, and felt his own grief brimming over, tired and hopeless. There were only speculated ways before them now, he reflected darkly. And while one sorrow he may have eased, a thousand new he brought to take its place. There was no comfort on the road he asked of them.
His house had been built with Nóm at its root, half-upholding the foundation from the start, and ever constant. Bëor had held him bound in love, the new generations followed in faithfulness, Barahir drew him back from death’s maw. And Beren, the last of Bëor’s sons, had wound all of them into a noose about his neck. Shame clawed at his resolve.
Had he known that it would end thus, Beren wondered? Had he known when he saw their faces flickering through the trees? When he sang beside their dying fire?
The king knelt still beside the shore, his fingers trailing in the current, weariness showing through every feature as the sharp line of his shoulders slackened.
“Aiya Ulmo, heru ëari.” Nóm’s voice drifted back from the water, a breath amid the rustling wind. “My will falters, I know not thine.”
❈❈❈
A last apple clung to the tree, suspended like a bauble of gold from the hoary fingers. It caught the fading sun within its skin and threw it back into the twilight, glistening and uncanny. An echo of Laurelin, Finrod mused as he watched it shift in the breeze, one final golden fruit offered from the dead branches.
That was a cheerless thought. There would be despair enough upon the journey without such a beginning. Nay, shift the image to promise, for was not Arien’s vessel wrought from that selfsame offering? And this too had grown from death, from a fruit fallen and buried, wrapped within the dark of the earth. Return now to the soil that shaped us, and from it grow again in life anew. They were ever in mind, those words he had whispered over Balan in the darkest grief, when his fingers traced their last path along the still face. Grain for our sustenance, fruit for our delight, the oak tree tall for our shelter.
Gildor had tossed an apple core aside during one of their pilgrimages at Yestarë. He and Bëor were deep in conversation—what was the debate…some opinion Gildor had drawn from Belen that Belen’s father was keen to disabuse—laughing and quibbling over the divergent details. Balan had tossed his own apple shortly thereafter, and Finrod could still see the sharp flick of his wrist as he sent it arcing across the clearing. Truly, this tree could have grown from those very seeds, for they were near this glade if he remembered aright. Or had it been beside the cove? Balan’s hair was grey in the memory, so it was not in those early years with their heady dives beneath the water, when each new spring recalled the intoxication of the first, and the long afternoons were spent stretched in the sun. In later years they sat more often beneath the boughs and watched while others swam, their own hands seeking each other through the long grass, quiet and content. Perhaps it was indeed this clearing and his feet had returned hither of their own longing.
Balan had slept in his arms that night, tucked behind a cluster of boulders—there, even those where Canneth sat contemplating the woods—and the memory of his steady breathing still pulsed in Finrod’s ears, an aching echo.
He reached out and loosed the apple from its branch. It was far more likely this was an unrelated fruit, a tree spawned from squirrel’s plunder or some wayward badger’s meal. His amusement flickered briefly at the thought. The wayward badger was he, the apple his own passing feast—the last of the tree’s yield, and the last of his tasting perhaps. Few fruit trees would linger yet between the Talath Dirnen and the pass, and none at all once they were through.
It was crisp and sweet as he bit into it, something of cinnamon and honey to the juice that ran over his tongue. He was reminded of slipping into Yavanna’s orchards as a child, or of the apples they roasted with cheese in Estolad during the Longest Night—but no, those had been tart. It was the fruit in Ossiriand he had in mind, when he would perch upon the low oak branch and pass them to Honeg and the rest of the herd, indulging alongside them throughout the slow afternoons.
He took another bite. It was comforting to think of this as Balan’s tree or Gildor’s; to eat from the fruit of that gladness, even here amid the growing dark. Gildor! Would word now have reached the havens? The one balm amidst the treachery had been that his foster-son sat in Eglarest when the oath came due, safely out of reach of the reckoning. But how bitter the loss of that farewell—and how bitter too the betrayal when Gildor should learn of what befell and find himself new-orphaned, by choice now and not mischance. Meril had sworn to hold the news as long as she was able, but even she could not stem gossip indefinitely, and it could easily have passed on through merchant or messenger to the coast. Would he have ridden out when he learned of it? Galloped back to seek out their trail? He would have received Finrod’s letter if he passed through Nargothrond on his return, and surely he would have honored that last plea—stay and do not follow, lend Orodreth support in his need. Or would he have renounced it all in anger—debt, errand, and oath-father alike—and remained in fury beside the Sea?
Finrod filled his lungs and turned back to watch the preparations. There was an air of ritual to their motions, measured and precise, unhurried. Blankets had been rolled and provisions re-sorted. Additional weapons were drawn out from the packs and placed in readiness, hair twisted into tight braids. He could feel the intricate patterns of his own cascading down his shoulders. Sídhon had stopped him when he began to braid it, moving Finrod’s hands aside and taking the golden strands within his own, singing softly as he turned them through his fingers. Finrod had shivered when he recognized the deft motions and knew that it was the funerary form he wove—a lord of the Ñoldor laid out for burial. One more preparation for the road ahead.
Another melody drifted through the air now, Canneth humming as she went about her work. It was a dancing song, one of Maglor’s creations that had echoed in this same valley throughout the Feast of Reuniting, and Finrod’s heart stung at the recollection. They had danced here for days on end, scattered between the feasting and the song and the hours fallen in respite upon the grass. He had been half-intoxicated from the joy alone, from the measureless bounty of each brimming life. He remembered Edrahil laughing beside the water with Satya living yet and caught within his arms, Celiel deep in conversation with a healer of Círdan’s people, Canneth dancing with her brothers amid the spring flowers.
Now Canneth sat with two knives laid across her lap and her brothers had spat upon the ground when she followed Edrahil to the king’s side.
How had he led them to this?
Edrahil’s voice joined now, weaving lyrics into the harmony, and Finrod let the music wrap through his senses, steadying him, staying him. Sídhon reappeared through the trees with water skins freshly filled and carried them across the clearing. His feet fell at once into time with the music and he danced a quick series of steps as he set the skins aside. Then without a pause he turned back toward the open glade and swung into the dance in earnest, a smile spilling out as his feet flew over the grass. He might have danced still amid the court of Nargothrond, whirling in nimble patterns with his every movement elegant and precise. Finrod laughed despite himself.
Then, to his surprise, he found that his own feet were leaping forward onto the green alongside the other. He let the apple fly from his grip as he spun into the dance, spirit burning to loose himself in joy and rage, sorrow and abandon. To feel the burial braids pull tight against his scalp as he whirled beneath the boughs.
They were all dancing now, he realized as he came around again to the near side of the glade, Canneth and Celiel, Edrahil and the others—reeling silently through the twilight and laughing as the quiet melody passed between them.
He had danced with Balan to this music as well, only then it echoed through the vaulted caverns amid the feasts of Yávië. Finrod had drawn him out abruptly when he found the melody matched an Atani dance meter and pulled him merrily into the fray. He knew the steps poorly then and Balan had laughed at the attempt. But his dark eyes were alight as he joined the king alongside the courtiers and took the other’s hand in his, the palm rough against Finrod’s own, and guided him through the steps.
Beren stood yet at the edge of the clearing with his shoulder hitched against a gnarled beech. He wore the same smile as Balan had that night, an onlooker engrossed in the dance before him, and Finrod slowed. With hardly a thought his posture shifted, his legs sought their weight, arms fell loose at his side. The singers reached the chorus again and his right boot stamped the earth behind him, his palms met. He knew the steps by nature now and his feet beat out the rhythm on the grass while Beren watched in surprise to see the familiar motions bound in tandem with the Elvish melody.
“Laiksa!” Nóm called, holding out his hand, and Beren shook his head incredulously.
Then the fey mood took him as well and he pushed away from the tree, grinning as his feet joined the pattern and danced toward the king. Finrod laughed and led him backward by degrees until they neared the center of the clearing. Then he shifted his motion once more, only now the Elven dance wove around and with the Atani pattern, meeting and circling, song and its beaten time, the king’s steps holding both in harmony.
It was Beren who laughed now as he found himself the center point in the whirling figures. The Atani dance was well suited to it, a varied sequence of steps all held within a box of eight points, and Finrod’s steps darted in and out of these, striking the first point as Beren shifted to the fourth, curving round to the fifth as Beren’s feet struck the second and seventh. Wheeling and darting, laughing an apology as his hair grazed the other’s cheek with the speed of his passage, leaping by instinct through the waving grass. Finrod could no longer tell their motions apart—his own, Beren’s, the other Elves’ about him. They danced as wild, careless things beneath the twilight; time doubled back upon itself and every step cast in abandon, every turn a farewell flung into the night.
He knew not how long they continued on thus, but darkness was full upon them when at last the song faded. One by one their steps began to slow, one by one they drifted from the clearing to don their darkened armor and drink from the hallowed waters, until only Sídhon remained, whirling alone at the center of the glade once more.
At last even his steps fell still.
And then, as though this was the final herald they awaited, the twelve lifted their burdens from the dim grass and without a word passed soundless into the trees.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
herunya: [Q] my lord
Annon Aearon: [Q] Gate of the Sea
nai amanya onnalya ter coivierya: [Q] may your (sg.) child be blessed throughout his/her life
cullingwincë: [Q] little goldfish
anorhín: [S] sun’s child
onya: [Q] my child
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
- Haelis: hello, greetings
- Rotavva wrotenni: and onward, the Wandering People
- Navá Guënidan, ananiujan tagas eil: Water of Guënid, renew my days.
- hallus’n aurkeis: stone-in-pot
- Madjatta: great-aunt, specifically “aunt of father”
- Laiksa: dance (verb form)
MISC NOTES
- Re Curufin’s line (“for some usurper”): The Atani they were named by the Eldar, the Second People; but they called them also Hildor, the Followers, and many other names: Apanónar, the After-born, Engwar, the Sickly, and Firimar, the Mortals; and they named them the Usurpers, the Strangers, and the Inscrutable, the Self-cursed, the Heavy-handed, the Night-fearers, the Children of the Sun. The Silmarillion, Chapter 12: “Of Men"
- Belegor: the second son of Boron and the grandson of Baran.
- Yestarë is the first day of the year in Elven calendars, also the first day of spring. See chapter 14 In These Holy Waters for the reference.
16. No Gentler Pain
In the aftermath of their conversation at Ivrin, Finrod and Balan stumble through the new distance between them. Memory, jealousy, and the ghosts of each follow them throughout.
Read 16. No Gentler Pain

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, SPRING
Tol Sirion
She was there when he looked out over the river. His eyes traced the line of the highlands, but it was Esrid’s form hovering before him. In his mind, she sat as she would each night, one leg curled under her, the other drawn up with her arm propped upon the knee, half-resting as she prodded the fire or ran a ladle through the hanging pot. Her long braid draped over one shoulder, stray strands of hair hanging loose after the day's work.
When they were first wed, he would steal glances while she sat engrossed in a task or lulled by the fire’s dance. Balan had been wary then that his affection would be a trespass, an intruder where Geberic’s ardor should lie, and so his gaze was furtive, his own passion carefully veiled.
In the end, it had fallen from his lips unthinking. I love you—a hoarse gasp as her legs wrapped about him and drew him in, pinned between her thighs. He had frozen at the admission, apprehension clouding his face, but Esrid laughed and reached up to run her fingers through his hair. My dear one. He could still feel the weight of her palm as she pushed him onto his back and shifted over him, her eyes warm and looking down with amusement into his own. I know. When Baran was an infant, she had said it in turn, handed back to him haphazardly as his own confession had been. He had bound the child in a sling across his chest to walk through the morning haze—the boy would sleep then, lulled by the movement, and Esrid too could rest in the reprieve. The murmur of her voice had trailed after him through the door. You do know I love you, Bal? He had nodded and smiled as he tucked the infant closer, but in truth the words rang through him in wonder. Till then it was enough to be named dear, to hear her laugh echo each night through his own hut—through their hut—and know that he had drawn it out, to feel her arms slip about him, her hands find him in the dark, to know the sound of her sharp breath in his ear—
His own breath drew in with a hiss and he dashed the tears from his face. Gods all, why could he not shake this? She was twenty years gone and he had mourned these moments long since. They had no right to appear as fresh phantoms now. But he could feel her lips still, the touch fresh and warm upon his own as though she lay yet within his arms, not beneath a hillside he no longer recalled. He could taste her kiss, the sweat upon her skin.
Balan passed a hand over his eyes once more and shuddered. If he continued on like this he would never be fit to rejoin the others and there was only so long he could hide away here on the rocks before his absence was marked. No, it was not hiding, he corrected himself in irritation. It was a respite, a chance for his thoughts to clear. All the road from Ivrin had been passed in constant company, and all the hours since their arrival were a flurry of activity. Even the night held naught but oblivion, for he fell into the bed still half-dressed from travel and knew nothing more till the dawn. He could not recall when he had last been so weary.
And so he slipped out after the ceremony of the Guard and scrambled down to a ledge on the eastern face of the isle, where he sat tucked behind an outcropping and safely out of the tower’s view.
Solitude was an immediate relief. Yet perched alone on the head of the island he was isolated too from those distractions which had held his thoughts at bay, and at once the heartache of Ivrin reared up like a wave crashing through the pass. But it was the memory of Esrid that broke over him and left him gasping, breathless in its wake. It was the touch of her hands, not Nóm’s, that lingered upon his cheeks; the ghost of her lips he felt upon his own, not the fleeting brush of the king’s. Tears were running loose once more and he pressed his palm over his mouth, stifling the sobs as his shoulders shook helplessly, grief pouring from him like the river that swept each side of the isle.
There was tall grass on the hillside. That at least he could recall. It had billowed under the breeze like water’s motion and left him dizzy in its midst, for the ground seemed already to buckle beneath his feet as he carried the bier up the slope. He held one end of a pole, Estreth the other, Masci and Weiv supported the remaining. Baran gripped the branch just behind his father, insisting with all the stubbornness of his six years that he too should be among the bearers, and Balan had choked back a sob each time he felt the little arms drawing weight from his own hands. But at last they reached the grave and she was laid out upon the grass.
He had traced the clay along her palms, from forehead to chin, set seeds within her mouth and cradled the infant’s tiny body within the curve of her arm. Estreth knelt and cut two of the thin, dark braids from her sister’s hair. Later, she would weave these into kessela, the mourning strands her people wore in remembrance of the dead—one for herself, one each for Balan and his sons. He had watched her trim the strands and felt somewhere in his heart it should sting to see them severed, but all that rose was a keening ache that he had claimed no such token ere his parents were laid beneath the earth. But what relic could he have salvaged, he reflected bitterly while he laid his wife within the hillside, the raiders had thrown torches as they departed and the village and slain were burned alike in its ravaging. Of his father they found only charred bones. His mother’s body they knew from the jewelry, the earrings fallen beside her upon the flagstone path.
It was ever so, Balan thought as he drew a ragged breath from Sirion’s wind, at each loss it was the prior grief he mourned. After Esrid’s death, he had paced each night with Belen in his arms, the boy pushing away as he wailed wilwa aifa, wilwa aifa! and Balan had rocked him and walked, weeping too as he tried to console him. But it had been the memory of his own mother that drew his tears, there amidst the strangling grief. He would pat the tiny back and sing choked melodies and long, like Belen, to cry out for his mother and find her there when he turned, for her to take his hands and kiss his palms and murmur, presence, Balan, is the greatest solace.
And now he sat on the jagged edge of the isle, fresh from the grief of Nóm’s refusal kissed upon his brow, and it was the memory of Esrid’s mouth that haunted him, the little twisting line that ran across the tip of her chin. She had fallen from a horse as a child and split the skin against a rock, and the resulting scar splayed out in tendrils fine as milkweed floss. Balan had found it oddly bewitching and would pause as he ran his lips down the line of her jaw to linger over its mark, his tongue brushing the divot it left. Esrid laughed each time and teased him for the fascination—a strange obeisance to keep with such piety.
Often in those moments he would find himself wondering whether Geberic had loved these same features, the milkweed scar, the hairs straying from their braid, the soft folds of her belly against his palms. Had he too known the sidelong glances over the fire and the crinkle between her brows where laughter began? Had these been his worship as well? Or was this yet another difference between them—one chosen, one a necessity; one beloved, one whose love was learned; one dead, the other who led him to it. He had known him little ere he was cut down, the husband of her choosing, for they had been acquaintances and not friends. But later, when Geberic’s widow was his wife, he would wish in morbid reflection that they had been close, that he might know where to trace the line of jealousy.
Balan shook his head and drew his thoughts back to the present. Comparison gained nothing—not when Esrid lived and not now amid these new-festering wounds. It was the same thread, he reasoned bitterly, fond but never chosen.
He had thought to leave after Ivrin. They had ridden till well after dark that day and all the while he brooded over how to bid the most searing farewell. They would reach Teiglin on the morrow and, from Finrod’s explanations of various maps, he knew he could find his way alone from those shores. Follow the river till it reached the forest, then on along the tree-line until you found the fen crossings, bargain with the marchwardens to let you cross. And from there Aros and Celon would lead him home. But that would mean abandoning his possessions in Nargothrond, and Baran’s otter was there, as were his mother’s earrings, his father’s old dice. Esrid’s necklace too, and Bel’s carved stone…he had balked at the thought of losing those, so he hesitated and rode on still through the next day. They crossed the Glithui. They crossed the Malduin and his eyes strayed ever to the southeast. There was the great road yet, from Tol Sirion down across the Talath Dirnen, and if he took his leave when they reached the Lithir, he would have lost only a few days by following its course instead of Teiglin’s. They would camp on the southern shore that night, then he would break from them with the dawn.
You remain my king, Felagund, in bond and in love, but I’ll be the stray at your heels no longer. He would declare it in his own tongue. He would name him with the epessë he had never spoken, and in the utterance an ending would be marked—formal and final. He would turn to the east and he would not look back.
But he had woken often through the night, and on each occasion saw Nóm standing beside the water, a quiet sentinel with his back propped against a beech tree, his eyes fixed on the current. Not a muscle stirred between the glimpses, but Balan had felt the other’s thought ripple at each waking, instantly alert and, to his surprise, tensed with fear.
They had hardly spoken since Edrahil found them beside the holy well, but traveled instead in uncharacteristic silence, Finrod at the front of the company and Balan trailing near the rear. He had fenced his mind in fury as well, bristling as he rode in a cloud of gloom—let Nóm be met with ice if he chose to scorn the fire. But all the while he felt the other’s thought hovering beside him, never pressing but ever present, waiting. He had bristled all the more at this and glowered at the passing trees until Sídhon shifted to ride beside him and distracted his ire with linguistics. He was no fool, that one. A wry chuckle escaped him now as he recalled the hours passed in conversation with the king’s attendant. Sídhon’s words were carefully light, steering them from vocabulary and grammar to the history of Balan’s language, and thence to word play and jests. By evening, Balan had laughed despite his brooding and parried quip for quip as the sun retreated behind the Ered Wethrin.
But to the king his words remained cold, short and expedient, not a syllable more than need required. His mind too offered only sharp edges toward the brush of the other’s thought, tentative though it was. It was clear Nóm knew what it was he intended, and in truth Balan was not surprised. Who else had so known the intricacies of his spirit or lived, as they had these past years, with minds ever half within the other’s? Nóm slipped within his heart as limbs into a garment; and like those limbs, he knew the tenor of its motion even when he wore it not. Little wonder, then, that the king had gleaned his purpose and discerned without apprisal the bent of his heart.
And yet Balan knew with equal certainty that Finrod would do naught to hinder him, and in the end it was this resignation that broke his resolve. He had risen with the dawn, gathered each possession with methodical care, folded the fur-lined cloak and carried it to stand before him at the river’s edge. “I thank you for the use of it.” His voice was rough as he held out the bundle. “But I no longer bear the touch of those waters and so I need it not.”
The lines of Finrod’s face had been drawn with apprehension, but he shook his head and summoned a smile. “Twas a willing forfeit and no loan,” he said, shifting his arms behind his back. “Thine ever, if thou wilt.”
“Nevertheless—” Balan’s voice faltered. The practiced words choked in his throat and he dug his fingers deeper into the cloth, frustration seething through every fiber. You remain my king, Felagund…to what end had he recited them all the long hours of the night if their utterance was to fail here at the crisis? But Nóm’s eyes had been laced with pain and his spirit’s dread hung heavy in the air between them. Not my beacon, but my anchor. The other’s voice pounded through Balan’s memory like a heartbeat and the heady devotion rushed once more through his blood—thy soul the still point that moors me amid the foundering.
His feet could never willingly bear him from Nóm’s side. The knowledge came upon him with a settled certainty and this easy breach of resolve set his pride writhing. A dozen words, he thought with humiliation, a dozen words from the other’s tongue and his purpose collapsed about him like ash. He drew the bundle back under his arm. “As you wish, then,” he had replied, his tone just shy of a growl. “I’ll carry it yet if you’ll not claim it.”
“I am glad of it.” Once again, Finrod’s smile flickered mask-like along his features, then his eyes drifted toward Balan’s pack and his breath grew shallow, uneven. “I see thou art readied, then?”
“Aye.” Balan’s demeanor had turned sullen in self-reproach and he shifted from one leg to the other, his own gaze fixed pointedly on the river bank. “I saw no reason to wait,” he said and felt trepidation shudder along the other’s presence. For a moment he took a bitter satisfaction from it—Nóm too should know the sting of denial—but his ire relented the moment it rose and he glanced up in a ghost of penitence. “We will reach your isle by sundown?”
“By midday,” Finrod replied, and the force of his relief had been a torrent, nearly drowning the other in its wild rush.
Balan hunched back against the rock as he remembered it. He was weary to his bones. The reeling thoughts would not be quieted, each careening into the other and racing out in every direction, tangling behind his eyes till his temples ached. He half-longed to plunge into the current below, that the chill might break this endless pattern and cleanse his mind while he cut a path through the waves. He peered over the edge. No. He would hold his mind here. He would think of Nóm and he would grieve, so that he could carry a conversation and stay at his side, so that he could manage through the dinner that yet awaited. Oh gods all, a full dinner. Conversation and pleasantries, the expected smiles, the merriment…
Gravel struck the rock beside him and he turned sharply as a rain of dirt followed, then a quick scrabbling, a flash of gold, a tumble of limbs. The tiny figure righted itself at once and stood poised at the far end of the ledge—startled, but looking over him in cool evaluation. Balan returned the stare in kind, his own surprise more pronounced as he took in the apparition before him: an elf-child, standing no higher than his ribs, a cloth bundle clutched in one hand and a pastry held between her teeth. An incongruous sight. She wore a formal robe from the afternoon’s ceremonies but the skirt had been bound up about her waist, uncovering a pair of hose, and the front of both hose and robe were now clouded with limestone dust. Her free hand retrieved the pastry and she drew herself up, chin lifted in command.
It was Nóm’s chin, as were the cheekbones, the line of the mouth—almost an uncanny resemblance, Balan thought, and then recognition dawned on him. Her hair had been woven in patterned braids when he saw her last, the intricate strands reaching nearly to her hips and laced through with silver and gems. Now it was a shock of gold, cropped sometime in the last hour to hover unevenly about her jaws.
“My lady,” he said, dipping his head in deference.
The defensiveness in Finduilas’ bearing eased and she studied him curiously. “You are the Secondborn who follows my uncle.”
“So I am.” He barely held back a snort at her description and his features crinkled into a grin. “I am called Bëor.”
“Yes, I know.” She took a step or two closer and glanced up at the crest of the bluff, then back at the man before her. “Why are you here?”
“On the cliff-side where you’ve tumbled?” Balan chuckled, but found the jest slipped away from him as he met the solemn eyes. “Finding an hour to grieve,” he answered instead, and flinched at the blunt honesty. “What of yourself?”
“You’ve wept,” the child’s tone was matter-of-fact as she took in his reddened eyes and moved to sit beside him against the rock face. “Sometimes I come here for such. The tower has no view of it, you see, so father cannot worry—and the river’s music is a kind comforter.”
“Is it?” He tried to keep his voice light and free of the cynicism that flooded over him, but her quick glance was shrewd.
“You do not find it so?”
“I find the water holds many melodies.” Balan chose his words slowly and tried not to think of Ivrin’s chorus. “I am glad it sings to you of kindness.”
“Adatheg tells me sometimes of the aearlinnas, the Sea-songs. The mariners would chant them in Aman while children made boats of wood or paper and set them upon the waves. Ossë and Uinen would gather them, he says, and he would watch while the little boats danced through the water’s tresses and the lords of the Sea wove their song with ours.” A quick grin flashed out. “With theirs—I have never sung the aearlinnas, though my mother tells me her people have similar traditions. Only they do not sing them so far from the Sea and I have yet to see Belegaer the Great.”
Her percipience should be unnerving, Balan reflected as he glanced at the figure beside him. She looked little older than Avina, six or seven at most, but her eyes were sharp and canny, their gravity disconcerting amidst the childish features. Instead, he found her presence oddly comforting. “I too have never known the Sea,” he said, and smiled down at her as he would his own sons, “though your uncle has told me of it often enough. And there were gulls too in the land of my birth.”
“Were you born far from here?”
“Aye, tis far. Away over those mountains where my lord met us, and on again over the leagues to other ranges, in a valley between the rivers.” He drifted into silence. His mother had sat beside the water and held him suspended in the dip of her skirt, the sound of gulls overhead mingling with his own giggling while she called him her little bird, curled in a nest. He must have been quite small to fit in the cloth between her knees, he realized as he turned the memory over in his mind. He was surprised he recalled it at all.
Finduilas had shifted the parcel to rest on her own knees and Balan watched with curiosity as she balanced the pastry along its edge.
“What do you carry in the bundle?”
She glanced up at him and her brows twitched in suspicion. “You’ll tell adatheg.”
“I will not.” Balan chuckled and felt the weight upon his chest loosen. He leaned in conspiratorially. “I too am hiding from him—and I am no talebearer.”
“Are you not?”
“Nay, not unless you’ve killed a man or made off with the king’s signet and silver—” he broke off with laughter as Finduilas shifted the cloth aside and an elegant chalice, adorned with etchings of seabirds and stars, lay revealed upon her lap. “Gods all, child, you have taken the silver. What use have you for the king’s goblet?”
“Teaching Gwindor not to brag. And besides,” she said, lifting it free of the wrapping, “the cup is my father’s, not the king’s.”
“And what, pray, has your father’s tableware to do with young Gwindor’s pride?”
“He thinks himself already half-trained for the Guard by naught more than following his brother’s lessons—going on about how he could pass the trials or slip through any corridor without drawing notice. I told him that was a rare skill and he should retrieve my father’s cup ere it was laid for the feast, that we might see how ’twas done.” She set the chalice on the ledge beside her where it glistened in the sun and her eyes gleamed too with a matching light, impish and pleased. “He means to come up through the cellars, I deem. I saw him slip into the upper caves and they meet the store rooms under the Hall.”
“And from thence to the larders and kitchens where I perceive there will no longer be a cup awaiting his prowess.” Balan shook his head with a grin. “And by what rare skill has it come into your possession, my lady?”
“Not skill,” she said, turning her attention to the purple clover growing between the rocks, “cleverness. He set off to slink through stores and shelves. I donned a page’s tunic and entered through the main passage.”
This, then, was the mystery of her new-cropped hair—a page’s garb was well and good, but any member of her father’s retinue would know her in an instant with the cascading gold draped about her. A quick moment with the shears and none would give her a second glance, passing in and out with the other attendants. “Cleverness indeed.” Balan was laughing aloud now and he leaned his head back against the rock. “Gods save me from ever falling foul of your ire.”
“Father will be displeased.” Her voice was half-regretful, half-bored, and she plucked petals from the blossoms, lifting them to her lips to chew them thoughtfully. “But like as not that will pass by the morrow. Why are you hiding from the king?"
Once again the childlike bluntness caught him off guard, paired as it was with her depth of bearing, and left him uncertain whether she was more child or peer. Nóm had said, had he not, that the girl was little younger than Belen? But for all that, she looked no older than Baran at Esrid’s passing and Balan found it hard to hold the twain in harmony. “My heart is weary,” he said at last, settling on the same honesty he had used with his sons, “and this grief I could not weather beside him without drawing his concern.”
Finduilas nodded and plucked another head of clover, then glanced at him with a quick smile. “Thou in flight from uncle’s concern, I from father’s worry—we make a fitting company. Yet I am sorry,” she added as guilt drew in upon her features, “to have broken thy solitude.”
“I mind it not.” Balan’s heart warmed at her shift to the informal and he smiled. “Quite the opposite—I find the weariness eased by thy presence.” His eyes drifted out over Sirion’s swift waters, lingering on the eddies swirling at the foot of the precipice where they passed through the island’s caves. “I had a daughter once,” he said after a long pause, and his voice was quiet. “Dark as thou art fair, frail as thou art full of life…truly in all ways thine opposite, but speaking here with thee has drawn her near once more in my heart. I thank thee for it.”
“Does she remain in Estolad with the others?”
“Nay. Nay, she followed the fate of my people. Long ago now, nearly—” He broke off with a wry chuckle. “Well not so long in thy people’s reckoning. She would have been of a similar age to thee.”
“Was she born in the land of the gulls?”
Balan shook his head. “Away west of there—west and north, though I cannot tell you where it lies, for we have wandered long years since then and much has been lost to time’s weathering.” He paused, captivated as a small bird perched beside them on the ledge and Finduilas held a hand out toward it as though in greeting. “Her name was Alémi,” he whispered as he watched it hop toward her, then flutter up to rest within her palm, “little sparrow.”
Finduilas stroked a finger along its feathers. “In our tongue it is aew,” she said and smiled as the bird settled in her hand.
“Alémi was a name of her mother’s people. In my own, sparrow would be ötiokit. Like its call,” he added.
“Ötiokit,” she warbled to the sparrow, then raised her hand so the tiny black eye met her own. “Have you come on purpose then, little friend?” The bird tipped its head, trilling in reply, and Finduilas echoed its tune. Then her lips twitched up in a smile and she whispered under her breath. Her words held a rhythm too, a hint of the same melody, and the sparrow paused only for a moment before fluttering from her palm to perch instead atop Balan’s knee, where it sent out another trill, looking at him expectantly. The child took hold of his wrist and drew it upward. “Offer her thine hand.”
His glance was incredulous, but he turned his palm upward and let her guide it carefully toward his knee. Again the sparrow hesitated, but Finduilas reached out, running a calming finger along its back until it chirped once more and hopped from knee to outstretched palm. Balan caught his breath.
“Less than a twig’s weight thou art,” he breathed. The bird was tiny, not even the full width of his hand, and she shifted nervously when he cupped his fingers about her. “Gawarthi, gawarthi’nd sá.”
“Sparrows are shy creatures.” Finduilas’ voice was pleased. “It speaks well of thine heart that she judges thee kindly.”
“And of thine that she hearkens to thee.” He laughed as the sparrow’s feet wrapped around his finger and it cocked its head, peering up at him in curiosity. “Aye, little one, I’ll be but a branch. I mean thee no harm.”
There was another series of chirruping notes and his face creased in a smile.
“Ötiokit,” Balan answered in the same cadence and the bird hopped from his fingers to his wrist, ruffling her feathers and looking about. “Quite brave now, hm?”
She seemed to take this as a challenge and skipped along his arm till she neared his shoulder, then gave another trill and fluttered to perch on his head. Balan froze.
It was Finduilas who laughed now, her chin resting on her knees as she watched him. “And the word for tree in thy tongue?”
“Bamnds,” he said, grinning, then flinched as the sparrow’s claws pricked against his scalp. “Ach, sharp as a porcupine thou art, for all thy smallness. Tread gently.”
The sparrow paid this little heed and continued to root about in his hair, till suddenly she gave a trill of greeting and leapt into the air. Balan turned to watch her go and his own breath drew in with a hiss, for there on the crest of the bluff stood the familiar silhouette, tall and striking against the sky, his hair a stream of sunlight upon the wind, and the sparrow soared up to meet him. He held out his hand as she neared and she fluttered to rest within his palm.
“Tis thou harboring our fugitive, then.”
The voice had regained its warmth and teasing hovered once more beneath its cadence. Here was the friend of foothills and fields, the companion of the long road from Estolad, and for the first time since Ivrin, Balan longed to be near him. The ice began to falter and he felt the other there waiting, penitent and chagrined, and his own heart nearly rushed headlong to bury itself within that comfort. His smile held as he met Nóm’s eye and raised a brow. “Fearsome fugitives we must be,” he said to Finduilas in a mock-whisper, “that the king himself comes in search of us.”
She glanced up at the ridge, unconcerned. “He’ll not climb down. Not in formal robes.”
Balan laughed and through the cracks in his defenses he felt Nóm’s spirit leap, for it was genuine mirth at last, such as he had not loosed since their lunch beside Ivrin’s mere. “Aye,” he said, his eye still holding the king’s, “but he may send the Guard against us. Shall we surrender?”
Her glance was an eloquent reprimand as she retrieved the sweet from the folded cloth. “Not till the spoils are hidden,” she said and broke it in two.
He chuckled and took the half she offered. “Awiluth,” he said with a dip of his head and bit from the delicacy. It was a variety he knew from Nargothrond’s feasts, the pastry golden-brown and shining, formed into delicate leaves along the top, and spread inside with spiced fruit.
“Awiluth?”
“A word of thanks. The full saying is sán wiluthid eil, or roughly ‘my gratitude is yours,’ but that we keep for formal use—or when our thanksgiving carries the greatest weight.”
“Sán wiluthid eil.” She repeated it several times. “Do I say it aright?”
“Aye, and with an accent as precise as thine uncle’s.” Once more he glanced toward the figure on the bluff’s edge. The child was right, he thought with amusement, the king was clothed still in the robes of state, draped about him in abundant swaths, with his forearm resting casually upon the sword at his side. It was an ornate thing, the hilt formed from gwilwileth vines and twined serpents, the pommel a cluster of flowers overlaid with gold. But unlike the crest, these serpents did not uphold the blossoms; rather each held their head back in readiness for the strike, their necks forming the cross-bar with fangs bared toward the blade. A ceremonial weapon, the steel’s bent to cleave vassals and not flesh, and it had glistened in the sun when Gelmir took his oaths with palm laid upon the flat of its blade. It hung still at the king’s side and, like the cascading robes, imbued him with a sense of awe—and the corners of Balan’s mouth twitched at the thought of him attempting the climb.
Nóm’s lips returned the smile as their eyes met and the rush of elation was incongruous in Balan’s breast—for he should be ice yet, he should keep his pride and hold the distance. He should not long to fall in worship at his feet. He should wish to strike him rather.
Gods all, he was lovely.
“Finduilas Orodrethiel,” Finrod said, shifting his gaze to rest on his niece; and though his tone was stern, amusement danced about its edges. “They found young Gwindor locked in the wine cellar.”
“The wine cellar?” She had winced at the formal address, but now craned her neck about and looked up at him with barely hidden laughter. “How came he there?”
“It seems that in climbing through the caves, he discovered one of the smaller passages opens upon the store’s ceiling. He dropped down through this only to learn that the door was kept locked and by then his own entry lay far out of reach.” The king’s tone grew pointed. “Though what purpose he had in such exploration he refuses to say.”
“Indeed, that is a curious thing.”
“It is. As was the concurrent disappearance of the warden’s daughter.”
“I have not disappeared. I have been here with Ornon.”
Finrod’s brows lifted and Balan laughed as the king’s gaze shifted back to him in query.
“Nay, I’ve given my word. You’ll learn no tales of me.”
“Negligent vassal,” he replied with a chuckle, then turned back to Finduilas. “Much I can guess from the evidence around me, but conjecture is not confession—and Gwindor’s silence has not eased thy father’s worry.”
“Naught is there that should worry him.” Her eyes flickered as she looked up at him, shoulders set and defiant, and the stillness stretched into long minutes as neither stirred.
“Even so,” the king said at last, and Balan realized a full converse must have passed between them in the silence, “thy father is warden of this tower, and through that charge has granted hospitality to those who sojourn here. Gelmir is a guest of honor, for it is his oath-taking that we mark, and likewise his father and brother are held the same. It is a poor welcome for Guilin’s child to be shamed by the warden’s own—as innocent or understandable the cause—and a poor reflection too upon thy father’s governance.”
“Is boasting then a noble reflection upon the lord Guilin?”
Finrod’s lips twitched, but he held the smile at bay. “Indeed it is not. And no doubt young Gwindor is gaining a full knowledge of that truth as we speak. But thou wilt ever be held to a higher account for those things others do with impunity, and it is fitting that it should be so. For if we will set ourselves as wardens or stewards—“
“Or kings.”
“Or kings,” he added with a grin, “then we must set ourselves too as willing students of humility, lest responsibility shift to control or benevolence fester into vanity.”
“I am not a warden,” she retorted. “Nor am I a king. Gwindor’s was the vanity—let him be answerable for it.”
The king’s brow lifted in amusement while he held her eye, poised and motionless atop the bluff’s edge, and mirth played at the corners of his mouth. “Courage is of many kinds,” he said, and lifted his hand as the sparrow launched out over the river, “and the brash courage of our kin thou hast received in abundance. But there is a quiet courage too, Finduilas, of word and principle, and such thou hast as well. Laugh if thou wilt, but even in thy pride I can see it clearly—for is it courage to do a deed if thou wilt own it not? Thy principles will hold thee to confession, even where thy pique would let it lie.”
The obstinance held for another moment, then she glanced at Balan with a sigh of resignation. He had retrieved the chalice from the ledge and held it out to her with solemnity, though he winked as she met his gaze and the smile lingered still in the lines of his eyes.
“Very well,” she said at last. “Shall we surrender?”
“As you see fit, my lady Aeweth.” He rose to stand beside her and chuckled at her puzzled expression. “If I am to be Ornon, then Aeweth thou shalt be.”
The bright grin flashed up at him once more as she took the cup from his hand, then turned and retraced her steps, leaping nimbly from stone to stone along the precipice. Perhaps a mountain lion rather than a bird, Balan mused as he watched her ascend—she scaled the bluff with hardly a pause and reached the crest within moments.
“I shall best Gwindor in this as well,” Finduilas announced to her uncle when he drew her up over the edge, “for I will speak it unabashed, even if he will not.”
Finrod reached out and ruffled her hair, then chuckled as he saw the jagged edges. “Clever thy scheming may be, but thy skill in pruning remains wanting. Go first to Sídhon,” he added, turning the golden head one way and then the other. “He’ll set this aright ere thy father sees thee.”
“Twas thy council to own my deeds, was it not?”
“Imp.” He laughed and directed her toward the fortress with a gentle shove. “Go on—Sídhon thou wilt find in the tower, and Guilin and his son wait in the hall. I will tell thy father thou art found.”
She twitched her head free of his hand and crinkled her nose in objection, but turned nevertheless and made her way back toward the gatehouse.
“Deftly managed.” Balan had clambered up the bank while they spoke and now stood beside the king, brushing dirt and stone residue from his attire. He was dressed simply in a variation of the Guard’s livery and Finrod watched him with affection.
“I confess ’twas was a wrench to hold her to account for it,” he said as Balan resigned himself to the streaks of dust and gave up the task. “It was cleverly done—and no doubt the boy was due a humbling of some form or another.” A quick grin as Balan met his eye, another brush of thought through the cracked barricade. “But already Guilin holds little trust in her father as warden of the Pass and this will do little to bolster his faith.”
“Do you? Believe him suited to the task, that is.” Balan held back for a moment, then added with an apologetic twist of his lips, “His disposition seems hardly warlike.”
“Nay, be not deceived. Artaresto has no less courage than I. He is formidable, for all he would rather wander free among the mountains, or sit in peace before a scribe’s board—as would we all, I deem, should our lots allow for it.”
“Aye, true enough.”
A hesitation then, an unsettled pause as the last days’ distance reasserted its claim, and Finrod’s eyes drifted out over Sirion, brushing the rapids, the fields bordering each bank, the sheer heights of the highlands, till they came at last to rest on the pass. There was a murk on the horizon beyond the valley’s head, a cloud hovering at the edge of sight, and Balan followed the other’s eyes with disquiet. He had not grasped how near the siege lines lay till Edrahil gestured toward that haze in the morning hours and named it for what it was—the reek of Thangorodrim, with Angband beyond. A shiver prickled again down the nape of his neck. Indeed, he thought, who would not prefer the respite of hill or library to this vista of lurking threat?
“All look to him to prove himself,” the king continued at last, his voice pensive, “while I, by mere virtue of birth, was never questioned in this charge, nor yet in that greater I now hold. He knew little of his place among our kin or of where to find his role in this labyrinth, and I saw him falter before that doubt as I in my own youth. In this, you see, I may grant him a place to stand and see that his heritage finds him well.” The king’s fingers began to play over the filigree serpents at his side. “But yes, to answer thy question…yes, I trust him.”
Balan nodded, his eyes caught by the restless fidgeting. A silver arm band, shaped as a swan’s neck, wound its way from the king’s forearm to wrist, its head resting across the back of his hand, beak tucked just above the thumb. He remembered well the feel of that arm beneath his own fingers in the dark of Thalos when he first traced along its length, and for a brief moment he imagined himself that intricate waterbird, draping about the pale skin that lay shining and exposed in the sunlight. How he would hold himself tight against that warmth, press his lips to the valley between thumb and forefinger…
Silence had settled over them once more, lying heavy upon their exchange as the gloom upon the horizon clouded the air. He would have wrestled forward in any previous quarrel, would have sought the lingering thread and from it drawn again that easy intimacy, as natural as thought or the drawing of breath.
Instead, he turned away and moved to depart.
“Anarinya.”
The hand that caught his own was trembling and fire leapt through his veins with the hoarse whisper. He froze.
“Anarinya,” Nóm breathed again, desperate and fervent. “Balan…”
He realized he had leaned into the caress by reflex and felt the other’s fingers tighten in response. In the days since Ivrin, the king had tread a careful dance through every interaction, composed and smiling, polite, yet all the while scrupulously avoiding even the slightest touch. They both had, if Balan was honest in his assessment, and the shift was jarring. For in the months preceding, they had grown increasingly careless in their affection—Balan’s palm upon Nóm’s back, the king catching his elbow as they passed through the crowd, a casual embrace, Nóm reclining against him in jest, the warm weight of his head upon his lap and the cascading gold a river running over him…he had nearly drowned in the sudden lack of it. And now the king’s thumb was once more tracing a line along his forearm, and Balan’s breath quickened.
“I have earned thine ire, I know, and deservedly so.” He did not meet Balan’s eye, but watched the path of his fingers as though the shifting cloth held all his attention—down over the radius, the sharp valleys of the wrist, back along the muscle and sinew. “But I know not how to bear it.”
“If I cannot see my way to bearing my own anguish, how am I to instruct you in yours?” The words were from him before he knew he had spoken and Balan felt the other flinch at the bitterness of his tone.
“Forgive me,” Finrod murmured and released him in chagrin. “I should not have spoken.”
The silence returned at once and Balan’s fury rose against it, hovering thick and oppressive between his own soul and Nóm’s. He had a sudden, childish urge to stamp his feet on the ground, to beat his fists against this unseen barrier, tear it loose with nails or teeth if he must, to clasp the other to him and turn his fists upon Nóm as well—whether to break through to acquiescence or in rage at the refusal, he knew not. Grief and pride tangled in his breast and for a moment he thought he must surely break before it as he had on the cliffside, but the other’s presence steadied him yet, and despite himself he felt the storm ease.
He drew an unsteady breath, he took the other’s hand. “I will not be ever angry with thee,” he said at last, discarding formality for the first time since he pleaded beside Ulmo’s Well, and felt hope kindle where his thought brushed the other’s. “I am now, but it will not linger.”
Nóm was motionless as the fingers wrapped about his own, then he raised his other hand to join the first so that Balan’s hand lay pressed between his palms.
“Sán wiluthid eil,” he said, then released him.
❈❈❈
Finrod reached across to fill Guilin’s chalice. It was the regret that surprised him, he mused as he watched ripples spread over the surface of the wine. Grief he had expected, for it was so with any desired path not taken, but he looked across the hall and a bitter jealousy rose through his breast.
Bëor had risen as soon as the meal was finished and left his place near the king, moving instead to join a cluster of others gathered along the far wall. The sunset fell upon him through the line of arched windows, rose-red and golden, and he laughed at some quip of Sídhon’s, he sipped from the carved cup in his hand.
And Finrod was glad to see him merry—of course he was. It was childish to feel envy that his own words had not called it out, childish too to feel a reprimand in the lines of the other’s attire. For Balan had arrived to the celebration clad not in the woven sun or stars’ patterns, but in his own traditional tunic. The deep red was jarring beside the other fabrics in the hall, its hue blood-red rather than the rising sun of the king’s gift, and the vines and beasts of Belen’s embroidery danced across its length. His hand rested casually on the knife at his belt and that too was jarring, for it was the custom of the Nargothrondrim to bear no weapons in the halls of feasting, and to this Balan adhered in all the months he dwelt among them. But he had returned to the custom of his own people this night and carried Beldar’s knife folded ceremonially into his sash.
It was a deliberate choice. Sídhon would have laid out one of the usual garments—if not the sunrise, then the stars or the snowdrops or any other of the formal set—not this that Balan wore only rarely. And certainly not the accompanying braid with its intricate loops bound about the right hand. Finrod had known it at once when Balan took his place at the table and the woven hair glistened in the lamplight. Her hair. Obsidian black and shining, it had been threaded into a fine sequence of braids, each impossibly delicate and twisting together to form a spiral of lace-like intricacy.
Finrod first saw it on Balan’s wrist during the Longest Night and marked it little then, for similar bands adorned the boys’ wrists and Estreth’s. But Balan had worn it again in the early spring and then it twined around each finger, it twisted along his palm and up over the small bones to bind again about the wrist, impeding the hand’s motion. It was to mark the day of her death, he learned later, a tradition Estreth carried over from her own people. She, Baran, and Belen each bore a kessela as well, but it was Balan’s role to bind it thus on the days of high mourning—for it was the part of a spouse to render one hand unusable, holding the dead in remembrance as a missing part of the self.
In the months following, Finrod had learned quickly which were the days of grief. He marked each in his memory that he might know them when the year turned its dance and drew them ‘round again, that he might approach those hours with ready comfort, with the tasks of the day set to anticipate the ritual.
And so he knew that this night was not of their number.
The silken hair shimmered beneath the lamps. It wrapped possessively around Bëor’s hand, coiling between his fingers and guarding that palm which only days before had rested in the valley beneath his own ear, had cupped Finrod’s face within its warmth and drawn him near in invitation.
He could have walked down from the Falls with that hand clasped in his own and set Balan at his side before the gathered feast. He could have yielded beneath the warmth of those palms. But he had clasped his hands together throughout that silent descent, he had choked back grief and smiled in welcome when Balan returned to the seat of an honored vassal, hand in hand with the memory of another’s love.
“Would you have agreed to it, lord?”
“Hm?” Finrod was recalled to the conversation with a start.
“Had it indeed been wrought to such a purpose, that is.” Aechenon’s smile was both amused and curious, and he looked toward the king in expectation.
A quick surge of ósanwë from Orodreth. They spoke of Artanis—Artanis and Celeborn—apparently an ongoing debate on the isle whether it was a diplomatic arrangement or a match of affinity. Nonsense of course and best to set that gossip to rest at once. Or hold, Orodreth had disabused the notion already. His own part, then…
“I?” Finrod laughed. “Artanis would little pause to consult my approval.” He paused to sip from his chalice, then smiled as he returned it to the table and met Aechenon’s eye once more. “But had I such jurisdiction? Nay, I would not offer my sister in surety for any cause, however expedient. Though truly ‘twould be of little advantage in this particular instance,” he added with a chuckle, “for the match binds us no nearer than blood holds us already.”
“Yet twice tied is double the strength,” Guilin interjected, “and thin is the cord that binds Menegroth’s allegiance. Every strand added is a boon.”
“That I’ll not deny. And in Celeborn we gain a sound and steady kinsman.”
“Even so.” Aechenon sought to mask his smirk with another draught of wine.
“You scoff,” the king said, “but it is both mast and mainstay that weather the gale. And a ship with no anchor is at the tide’s mercy.” His eyes drifted again to the figure beside the window. The evening sun had decorated the floor about him with patterns from the leaded glass and Finrod fought down the image of light dancing through alder leaves. “Such difference would sharpen a keen edge, I deem, not blunt it.”
“Perhaps.”
“You’ll find Aechenon little convinced by the Sea’s wisdom, uncle.” Orodreth’s wife was of Círdan’s people and she glanced across the table with a spark of teasing in her eye. “His love is all for the highlands and the mountain winds.”
Aechenon returned the smile. “But the Elder King and the Lord of Waters are ever allied, are they not? Their wisdom will not fall out of harmony.” He retrieved the decanter and filled first Tuilann’s cup and then his own. “And yet a swift steed may drag its picket, for all the anchor was driven deep.”
The musicians had finished tuning as they spoke and now snatches of melody tripped and tangled through the air. Balan was laughing again. He and Sídhon had shifted back towards the wall with the rest of the crowd, clearing the center of the hall, and lingered in conversation while the music rose around them. Sidhon stood a full head above him, the silver and green of his tunic dazzling, a tall poplar amid the murmuring throng. Finrod tried not to speculate—what business was it of his what they discussed?—but his eyes followed each gesture nonetheless, traced the movements of their speech. It was Taliska, he noted from the shape of Balan’s mouth, and spoken swiftly too. It had been thoughtful of Sídhon to take it on with such diligence. He was nearly fluent already and surely it was a comfort for Balan to have another learn his native tongue—till now there had been none but Finrod who could meet him in that place of familiarity. It was a good thing, a kind thing. Balan’s laugh rose once more over the viols and pipes and Finrod’s ears strained for a hint of their banter.
“They await thee, uncle.” Another nudge against his thought, sharper now. Orodreth was growing frustrated, he realized, and perplexed by the king’s ongoing distraction.
“Yes, of course—forgive me.” Finrod raised his chalice to the chief minstrel with a nod, then cast a sheepish smile toward his nephew. “I fear it is my thought in need of an anchor. Come,” he said, rising, “let us join the revels.”
Gelmir had stepped forward as the king and his retinue dispersed into the crowd. It was for him to begin the celebrations, for the feast marked his ascension to the Guard and such was one of the attendant honors. He reached the center of the hall and for a moment he seemed to falter, then he squared his shoulders and strode forward as the music coalesced until he drew up facing Balan—nay facing Sídhon—and held out his hand. The ensuing pause was heavy with intention. But Sídhon held his eye, a smile playing at his lips, and he set his hand upon the waiting palm.
Balan had been right, then. Shame trickled through Finrod’s veins at his immediate relief, for it was uncharitable to have allowed any such misgiving from a mere exchange of laughter. Balan would never be so fickle, Sídhon never so presumptuous where it was clear his lord’s favor lay. His ears burned too at this admission. He had been unguarded, that was undeniable, but still had allowed himself the illusion that none but he held suspicion of the truth. Folly, of course. Indeed, the same folly that told him naught would change once the words had been spoken, that they could go on in the same contented stasis, ever unfinished and thus ever unended.
A twinge passed over Finrod’s face as he watched the pair move to the center of the hall, hand in hand, and stand poised while the music gathered speed—and he was glad for their joy. Truly. Of course it was not customary for the King’s Guard to marry, especially not with Gelmir only just sworn to their number. But neither, he mused, was it forbidden. After all, was it not the begetting of children that lay at the foundation of that wartime precept? Why then should these be denied their bliss when the only loss risked was each of each—and no gentler pain would that be for a bond deferred.
He would see it countenanced. Indeed, he would sanction it ere the day was done.
The music crested and the pair swung into the dance. It was a swift thing, half-martial and precise, with limbs weaving in and out of the other’s motion and every strike passing just shy of touch.
And each movement was a claiming, reckless and bold with all the gathered hall looking on.
Jealousy needled down the length of his spine. How simple it was, this unhidden devotion. One hand set within the other, no subterfuge or fear where the only barrier was a provisional custom. He moved forward without thinking and found himself wending a path through the crowd, bearing ever toward the westward windows, the luster of the setting sun, for Balan stood yet within its glow, smiling as he watched the dance with his arms crossed before him and the lines of mirth once more springing across his face.
They climbed the High Faroth the previous autumn and he had stood even thus, looking out toward the Falls of Sirion with the same half-smile playing at his lips and the same rays of joy folded into the corners of his eyes. Amid the crags and sighing pines, the king had longed to lean down and brush his lips against those creases, to trace the tip of his finger along their path. And so he yearned now, slipping through the gathered throng to emerge at the other’s side—for the crowd pressed him near, nearer than since they departed the holy spring, and Finrod felt the warmth of him kindle along his skin.
Three days past he would have brushed against him in the approach, he would have leaned into that warmth and nudged Balan’s shoulder with a pretense of accident, and Balan would have glanced up as though he had not sensed the approach already, and alongside the feigned surprise there would be affection in the quick touch of his gaze.
Instead, Finrod took his place with all the precision of the dance they watched, and like Sídhon’s arm or Gelmir’s darting leap he carefully evaded any touch. “Thy guess was in the right it seems,” he said in greeting, a smile playing at his lips despite the melancholy, and he glanced at the other in amusement. “Ever shrewdly do thine eyes perceive us.”
Balan chuckled. “Twas no clairvoyance in that,” he said, and Finrod’s heart leapt to have drawn out his mirth. “I saw them embrace in the woods ere we crossed the Narog.”
“Didst thou indeed.” Teasing rippled once more through Nóm’s voice, for there had been affection after all within the glance, warmth in the tenor of Balan’s words. “Careless of them where any might see.”
At once he felt his color rise and the misstep burned across his cheeks. Had not Edrahil nearly discovered him in his own compromising embrace? Who was he to critique a tryst beneath the boughs? The king’s vaen-hlaiba is contentment enough for me. Finrod’s blood ran hot at the memory. Could he not have been wrong to assume the attempt was futile? If Balan’s people were not bound as his, then surely this was of nature and not merely a flouted custom—and if it was nature then this should be the key consideration, for the limits of one soul must ever determine the reach of the twain. Even now he could change course, he could brush his arm against the other’s, twine their fingers together within the folds of his own robes. He could lean in while all were distracted by the whirling figures and murmur acquiescence in his ear. Follow me when the dancing is done. Anarinya, my own, I would have thee yet.
The kessela glared in accusation from the other’s hand. Balan was not a loophole, nor his love some strategy to slip past custom. If he was to yield, Finrod knew he would kindle like dried grass before the wildfire, and any intention to make trial of an affair would burn away at once in the press of the other’s skin, the taste of his lips. Oh Valar, how was he to hold when all his desire was to be consumed in the blaze?
“I am glad for them.” Balan’s voice was quiet, but it shivered through Nóm’s flesh.
“And I. Long years has Sídhon dwelt in solitude and my heart rejoices to see him so at peace.” Finrod clasped his hands against the previous impulse and focused on the intricate patterns of the dance, that he might not dwell on the warmth of the other’s eyes, the scent of cedarwood oil that hung about him. “You look well,” he allowed himself at last, shifting to the other’s tongue.
“Do I?” The resulting laugh was mirthless and there was a brief flash of fury as Balan’s glance met his own. “Then I’ve more guile than I’ve been told.”
Finrod flinched. It was no less than he deserved, surely, but each retort stung like a lash across his spirit and left an ugly weal throbbing in its wake. He had taken their ease as a matter of course, a natural thing arriving hand in hand with the first glimpse across the embers, and there had never been a moment since Thalos in which he had not staid himself by the other’s presence. The rift left him reeling. He could feel it deepen with each word that faltered between them and the more frantically he grasped, the further Balan slipped from his reach. The distance gaped from every movement, it taunted him from every fold and stitch of the tunic, scorned him from each knot of the kessela, the intricate artistry of Estreth’s people adorning the gulf that held them asunder.
Estreth’s people. So he ever spoke of them, but it was Esrid’s remembrance, Esrid’s locks forming the fine sequence of braids—and still his thought balked at naming her even in description. It had not always been so, surely. Elbereth, what a vile jealousy to arise thus at the marks of bereavement! And how dared his heart presume to envy when of his own choice he had spurned the remedy? Guilt’s condemnation was swift.
Sídhon turned as Gelmir’s arm passed above him, his own arm swinging round into the same motion, then catching the other by the waist as together they turned in sequence with the melody. It was mesmerizing—Sídhon in particular, he was ever beautiful to watch. Each step was an art, every movement fluid and precise, each pass of his arm the whisper of another skill. Well did Finrod recall his awe at first witnessing him in combat, hunting those beasts of the Dark which lingered on the Ice, then in earnest amid the ambush at Lammoth. It was unfamiliar then, the practice of battle, and yet Sídhon’s every motion was swift, exacting, deadly. And so too here, for the dance was a mirror image of combat, as were most in these days of Exile, and as much an exhibition of prowess as a mark of celebration. For a brief moment the melody tapered as the pair slowed in the center of the hall, then it rushed once more in a crescendo as others streamed out to join the dance. He should be among them, he knew. He should lead the revels and honor the new guardsman, he should be the king merry amongst his people. But he could not will himself from the other’s side.
“I love you. I’ll not recant it.”
Finrod’s breath caught with a hiss as the words broke through his reverie. Balan’s voice was low, holding still to the tongue of his own people, and his eyes followed the wheeling fray.
“I have tried to turn it to fury, but I cannot; to bury it in disdain, but it will not hold. I am yours, Elenya, whether you will have me or no—whether I will it or no.”
“Beloved…”
“If I am to remain, know that I stay for love of you. Not for duty, not friendship, but because I do not know myself when you are from me.”
“Nor I my own self without yours to call it forth.” A choked sound escaped him and he shifted nearer despite himself, arms touching at last, and clasped the other’s hand within the shroud of his sleeve. “I cannot bear to have you half a stranger.”
There was a brief hesitation. Then Balan’s fingers closed over his—and Finrod’s heart sang at the touch, for this too was a claiming, reckless and fervent, daring the gathered crowd to see. And with that grasp he felt the final barriers crumble, and Balan’s thought lay once more bare before his own. Ai Valar, these bruises were of his making, these jagged rents…they had not been there when last he rested here, and how well he knew the shape. He traced their echo within his own spirit and gripped the other’s hand all the more tightly.
“Ornon!”
Finrod released him at once. Finduilas was bounding toward them through the crowd and the king turned, clasping his hands behind him as he smiled down at her in strict composure.
But she ignored him and fixed Balan with a frown of accusation. “You are not dancing.”
Balan managed a grin. The fervent press of Nóm’s hand was gone, but his thought held all the closer for that absence; and despite his anger, Balan found himself comforted by the familiar touch. He dipped his head in greeting. “I am ill equipped, my lady. I fear it lies far beyond my skill.”
“There is no dancing among your people?”
“Aye, we manage well enough amongst ourselves.” A laugh slipped out as he looked at the earnest set of her features. “But this is of another sort altogether—I’d be toppled at once in the attempt.”
“Dátheg!” Her reprimand was turned now upon the king. “A full year.”
Finrod laughed. “Have I been negligent in his instruction?”
“Nay,” Balan cut in with a chuckle as Finduilas began a retort, “there are more pressing duties for a king than teaching his vassals to caper.”
“Yet few so pleasant.” The king’s tone was light in response, but the lingering thought had trembled, pressed closer to Balan’s own. “I have been remiss.”
Balan was suddenly aware of the frailty of the other’s balance. He could have him over in an instant, he realized, sent careening from the edge with hardly a push. If he called to him now, if he trailed after him when the feasting was done, caught hold of him in the hushed dark of the island’s corridors…If he kissed him now, all Ivrin’s objection would crumple into his arms.
“No matter.” Once again Finduilas’ voice drew him back to the present with a start. “I wished to dance with Ornon, but since thou art to blame, I shall make do with thee instead.” She glanced up at her uncle with a puckish grin, then seized him by the wrist and pulled him after her into the center of the hall.
Why had he been allowed to see it? Each facet of the other’s thought was curated, chosen with care ere Balan touched it. Why had Nóm shown him that glimpse of frailty? Did he wish to fall?
Or no, it was trust rather—that Balan would never trespass, would never wield his weakness in coercion. His heart sank.
“I hope my daughter’s exuberance does not offend you.” Orodreth had moved to join them in Finduilas’ wake and now drew up beside Balan with an apologetic smile.
“Quite the contrary. It puts me in mind of my own sons when they were boys—a welcome reminder, for I miss them dearly.” Balan tamped down his racing thoughts and returned the smile. “Though I believe your daughter is nearly the age of my youngest.”
“And he is no longer a boy?”
“By my people’s reckoning, he came of age more than a year past.” Balan’s smile had grown brittle and he shifted his eyes back to the celebrations. Finduilas and the king whirled through the midst of the dancers, their motions clearly half-improvised and laughter rolling out from them as they spun, and Balan felt his bitterness ease at the sight. “Truly, I am grateful for her friendship. Though,” he added with a chuckle, “I confess myself bewildered that she’s taken to me.”
Orodreth smiled. “I find little surprise in that. She has ever been fond of a curiosity.”
A snort of laughter escaped before Balan could suppress it. “Much like the king?” he asked with a wry grin.
Chagrin washed over the warden’s face as he realized the gaffe. “I expressed that poorly, I beg pardon.”
Balan dismissed it with a wave of his hand. “Nay, nay, I took no offense. They are kindred spirits in this—finding fascination in the unknown and not mistrust. I am grateful for it in the both of them.” The pair spun past as they spoke and he stepped back with a laugh, narrowly avoiding a collision with the younger, who called a merry apology over her shoulder. “My lord has spoken often of her in the time I’ve known him,” he said, feeling the ripples of joy brush against him from Nóm’s thought. “He is very fond of her, I think.”
“Yes, and she of him.” Orodreth’s voice grew quiet as he watched his daughter lifted in an arc through the dance. “I am glad of it. The solitude wears on him, for all he leads our merriment and pours the festal wine, and she and young Gildor are a balm. Gildor especially. He has been a son to him these years and that is a mercy, for great delight would he have taken from fatherhood—more is the pity.”
“Might he not still?” Embarrassment burned hot along Balan’s neck. Was he being warned away? Surely Nóm would not have told when the only fruit of such knowledge was Balan’s pride laid in sacrifice.
But Orodreth shook his head and his voice remained friendly. “My people do not wed in times of war, nor do we bear any child while there is such risk. Or rather,” he glanced toward Balan with a self-deprecating smile, “we are not meant to do so. My uncle was adamant against my own disregard for the custom, fond as he is of Finduilas now, for this peace is a passing thing and he trusts it not. He would never make such a compromise for himself, of that I am certain.”
“No, he is not one to break with a principle.” It was with an effort that Balan kept the bitterness from his voice.
“Indeed. Of course, I do not mean to say that Gildor’s bereavement was a mercy, only that they have been a blessing, each to the other—Gildor orphaned by the sundering and adatheg childless by it.”
“How do you mean?”
“Mm? Ah, forgive me, I forgot to whom I spoke and have been spinning riddles unwittingly. His betrothed chose otherwise when we left Aman, and thus for her sake he does not wed—or so my father says. Loyalty or heartbreak, or some fool’s hope that the Valar may yet relent.”
Ice ran in tendrils from Balan’s gut. Two years of intimacy, of thoughts interwoven, hearts inseparable, and never a single word or hint? For her sake he does not wed…The music had dulled, as though filtered through wool, and dizziness began to overtake him. His betrothed. “What was she like?” he heard himself ask, his voice carefully measured, though it too sounded muffled in his own ears. “Did you know her?”
“I did. Not well, for I was quite young then, but she was always kind to me and brought scrolls from the great libraries whenever she visited. She and dátheg were both students of philosophy and she knew I took an interest in it as well. But mostly I remember them dancing—at the lord Turgon’s marriage or at the high feasts atop Ezellohar. Gold and gold they were, tripping like light itself beneath Laurelin’s boughs, and brimming over with gladness. All was whole then, when we still knew not the Dark.” His face was inscrutable as he watched his uncle and daughter whirl through the dance’s conclusion, their own laughter and light spilling out through the hall. “What was Amarië like? She was the beauty of Valinor incarnate, light and wisdom, innocence and joy. But so are they all in my memory, those we abandoned. Each of them the Light that is gone.”
“I see.” His mouth had turned to sand and it was an increasing strugle to keep the threat of nausea at bay. Fool. Fool! “It is ever so, is it not, with those we have lost?” His nails dug into his palm and he focused his thought upon that sensation, centered his balance by its sting. Where had they gone? The crowd had drifted about them as the music ended and he had lost them amid his own confusion. Nay, there was Finduilas darting in again from the far edge, Gildor now in tow. His eyes scanned each group for the telltale gold.
“A grave accusation was leveled against me.”
“Gods all!” Balan spun round with a start as Finrod’s voice drifted over his shoulder, and only then did he notice the nudge of thought that should have alerted him to the other’s presence.
“Wary as a rabbit, thou art,” the king laughed, his eyes bright with amusement. “I am only a penitent, come before thee in contrition.”
“In contrition, forsooth?”
“Even so. Am I doubted? I have been accused of negligence, Bëor, and I will see it right.” The familiar smile played at his lips and he held out his hand toward the other. “Come! It is overlate, but I will teach thee now in recompense.”
Balan set his hand upon the outstretched palm, pressing his agitation into a skeptical frown. “I’ll grant thee trial of it, but thou art no more likely to have success in it than I am to grow wings by thy command.”
“Canst thou not? I was certain such lay within my purview.” He clasped Balan’s hand with a grin and led him out from the crowd. His smile turned giddy as they reached the open floor, and in his thought Balan could feel the mirth and longing tangled, exultant. Finrod pressed the other’s hand fervently within his own. “I would have given half my kingdom to dance with thee,” he murmured as he drew him into position.
“Only half?”
For a moment Finrod feared the acerbity had returned, but there was amusement glinting in the other’s eyes when he glanced down, and he laughed in relief. “Aye,” he said, shifting back to Taliska as he guided Balan forward in the dance’s motion. “The whole I would give could Fate be purchased.”
Then his thought slipped full within the other’s and laid each step before Balan’s feet. They turned, and turned again through the fluid motions as the minstrels sent a new chord echoing from the stones. It was less urgent than the first, a simple melody, but it filled Balan’s heart with yearning and he was amazed to feel the ease with which the other matched him to his own motion. Formed of the same clay, he found himself thinking once again, surely they had been bound since the making; there was no break between Nóm’s motion and his, no break between that spirit and his.
Gold and gold, Orodreth had said, whirling light. What a contrast there must be in this. It was gold and dun wheeling before him now, the grey of winter marring the flow of light.
And was this how he had danced with her? Did his hand rest even so, firm against the palm, light as it brushed his shoulder, turned him beneath his arm? Nay, she would have needed no such guidance. She was a creature of that same light, nimble and sure—as she was wisdom, as she was joy. An equal match.
Her image rose in vivid detail before his imagination, radiant, pristine; and despite the madness of his envy, he was drawn irresistibly to the warmth of her eyes. For there was kinship in their depths. She too had known the sharp edge of those principles, they had each fallen second when faced with his choice. Surely they should be yokefellows and not adversaries.
What was it Nóm had said beside the Celon when he sang of Niéle and traced a snowdrop along the ridge of Balan’s nose…I’ve long since lost what beacon might have called me back.
Were they each of these to him, then? Amarië the beacon, Balan the anchor, Nóm the ship at the Sea’s mercy between?
The king’s hand brushed against the kessela as he guided him through the steps, and with that touch a stab of conviction pierced Balan’s heart. He had hidden away on a cliff-ledge and wept like a boy for his own first love—a wife, indeed, and no mere betrothal—and yet he could harbor this vicious envy within a few short hours? Even now the memory of her lingered at his side, keeping step with them through every turn.
What of it if Nóm too had loved before? Balan’s own devotion was no less now for having been another’s first. Who was he to spurn another’s ghost?
Balan caught the other’s hand as they crossed in the dance, he let the arm pass about him, turned and ducked and stepped in time. He brushed against Nóm as though by accident and met his eye in quick affection, he felt the warmth rush through him from the other’s thought.
Crumbs, after all, were better than starvation.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
epessë: [Q] after-name or nickname
adatheg: [S] father-brother, an approximation for uncle (used loosely in this case)
Orodrethiel: [S] daughter of Orodreth
Ornon [S] tree + masculine suffix
gwilwileth: [S] butterfly
Aeweth: [S] little bird + feminine suffix
dátheg: [S] uncle, diminutive
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
wilwa aifa (toddler’s attempt to say wiljan aitha): I want mama
gawarthi’nd sá: peace unto you
vaen-hlaiba: paramour, slang (lit.) bed-companion. See In These Holy Waters
17. These Echoes We Have Left
If the airna’akran had not lingered upon his tongue, if its taste had not brought the memory of all he abandoned, if self-loathing had not rekindled his envy…
Ghosts of the past rise up between them. Balan must face his jealousy, and Finrod the possibility of losing him—as well as reckon with what he is willing to sacrifice to keep the other beside him.
Read 17. These Echoes We Have Left

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, SPRING
Dorthonion
If it had not been for the berries, his temper would have held.
Half the glade was filled with them, red as garnet and shining between the grasses and primrose blossoms. He had not tasted them since he wandered with Baran through the hills above Andanahti-marei returning at the end of each evening with mouths stained and laughing, grinning sheepishly at Estreth and Belen while they handed over baskets that should have been full.
He and Nóm had stumbled upon the trove by accident, strolling through the highlands to ease their legs after the day’s ride, and found the glade brimming over with wildflowers and the tiny, laden stalks.
“Airna’akran!” Balan had darted forward, all the delight of childhood in his laughter as he bent down and loosed a handful of berries from the nearest cluster. He had not seen them since crossing into Ossiriand, and till now believed they grew only east of the mountains. He plucked them free of the stems and held out a handful to the other, grinning as he told how his mother would bake them into bread or how he and Baran would lie full evenings on the hillsides amid the berry patches, eating them from the stalks as the sun fell below the horizon. Nóm had taken the offering from his outstretched palm, then followed Balan along the slope, smiling as he searched out the red berries from the green, collecting a meager stash in the front of his shirt.
Even the red berries were tart, early as it was in the season, but they feasted on them nonetheless; stretched on their backs amid the waving grasses and watching the clouds dance in gold and lavender as the sun passed into the west.
It had begun with laughter, of course, somewhere between flirtation and feigned insult, vying for the last of the little harvest. “When Bel was first learning to eat,” Balan had said with a chuckle, slipping a berry onto the tip of his index finger, “he needed to be coaxed for every bite, so each berry would be a hat upon a dancer, singing a little song until he laughed hard enough I could slip one into his mouth.”
“And that was successful?”
“Of course.” He hummed a melody and bobbed his finger back and forth with a grin. “Does it not persuade thee?”
Nóm shifted in a swift motion and caught the finger in his mouth, retrieving the berry before Balan could pull it away. “It does,” he mumbled around the fruit, dropping back onto the grass with a mirrored grin. “But then I have no opposition to berries.”
“Gaitch!” Balan rolled over in mock offense. “That was my last.”
“Shouldst not have made it dance, then.”
“Another three thou hast!” He nodded toward the other’s palm, then lunged after them as Finrod closed his hand and held it out of reach. “Nay, give it here, I’ll have them off thee in recompense.”
It was a muddle from there, tangled limbs and grappling fingers, the crushed flowers filling his senses like wine, and laughter tumbling through the glade. Nóm’s palm pressed him back, Balan rolled to pin the arm in place. Balan launched toward the clenched fingers, Nóm’s legs wove through his and tripped him downward instead. The hand about his wrist, his leg hooked behind the other’s, the warmth of him, half-sparring, half-embracing, Nóm’s grip resting now upon his waist.
They rolled back into the trillium and Balan scrambled atop him at last, pinning his arms to the ground and grinning down at him in triumph. “Bested,” he gasped, laughing still as he caught his breath and tightened his grip about the other’s wrists, eyes glinting. “Loose thine hand, I’ll have my vengeance.”
But the other lay frozen, a sea of gold splayed about his head, and his eyes were fixed on Balan’s, unblinking. And again, as amid the dancing at Tol Sirion, Balan knew he might have him if he wished. The king lay at his mercy here within the trillium and violets, marked with the grass’ long shadows falling sharp against the golden light. He would yield. Balan could bend down now and press his lips to the other’s, stained bright with the berries’ dye, and no resistance would meet him. He could slip a hand behind his neck and draw him in, taste the tart fruit upon the other’s mouth and feel him fall away beneath his touch. And he had been dizzy with the knowledge of his own power.
“Open your hand,” he had said again, in his own tongue now, and obediently Nóm’s fingers parted. The airna’akran glistened in the sunlight, bright as blood against his skin. They had been crushed in the struggle, but held at least somewhat intact, and Balan shifted up slowly to gather them in his mouth. “There is a saying amongst my people—the nectar of justice is as honey upon the tongue.” His lips brushed the other’s palm and amusement rumbled through his voice. “But these you’ve left me are tart as gooseberries.” A trickle of juice had run down along the wrist and he set his lips to this in turn, little bothering to disguise the kiss as he lingered, the other’s pulse pounding against his mouth. It pounded too against his palms where they held Nóm’s arms pinned in the grass beside his head, and Balan hesitated for a moment, then let his lips brush along the other’s forearm as he drew back to meet the grey eyes once more. “A creature of flesh after all, ghomenno?”
“Never anything other.” Nóm’s voice had been scarcely a breath, shivering as it drifted up to meet him.
He had felt the fear then, trembling through the other’s thought, the desperate clutch of trust, and with it he felt his own insistence falter. The other’s heart pounded still within his grasp as he pressed him into the trampled flowers, and Balan had bent down till his lips hovered a scarce breadth from the other’s. “It needs but a word from thee,” he breathed and felt the other shudder beneath him.
It was Balan who shuddered now at the recollection. Fool, why had he done it? What did he expect would come of it but a further quarrel, with each more bitter than the last? They had found an uneasy peace these last weeks and on a moment’s whim he had shattered it.
If the airna’akran had not lingered upon his tongue, if its taste had not brought the memory of all he abandoned, if self-loathing had not rekindled his envy…
If, if. He kicked furiously at the nearest patch, crushing the berries to pulp beneath his boot. What was it his mother had said? Search not for succor in the ifs and mights, nothing but distortion dwells within that valley. And yet Balan had ever delved there hungrily. If Esrid had lived. If he had not pressed his people on in their wandering. If Geberic had not been slain. If Balan had stayed by his sons, or abandoned the search for the mountain passes. If he had never met Nóm, never been lured awake by his song.
Only hours ere that midnight he was full of joy, sitting beside the fire with the hymn to Melishk passing between Baran’s voice and his own, no shadow of torn loyalties between them, laughing as they greeted the new land with hope. Baran, whose laugh he had not heard for nigh a year, whose sharp wit had been turned instead to name his father anew.
Lord Vassal. His fingers dragged through his hair and gripped it in handfuls. Nóm had never pretended anything but the truth—love was dear indeed, but principle dearer. What complaint could Balan bring? After all, it was he who had begged to follow the king from Estolad, he again who could not manage to break with him on the road from Ivrin.
And it was Balan too whose bruised pride hammered at the patient serenity till he could see the crack shatter along its length. Guilt stung him to recall it. Nóm had never been sharp with him till now, even in the desperation of Ivrin his outbursts were all of grief, and Balan was ashamed to have goaded him to it at last. Yet even as he bristled against the words, the truth of them scraped raw furrows across his anger. He wanted to push it far from his mind, to wall it over or shroud it that he need not see his reflection there.
There was a rustle in the clearing behind him.
His remorse prickled into frustration once more. It was Balan who had been cruel, but Nóm who had retraced his steps, who once again came back to him with gentle penitence and an apology he had no reason to give. He wanted to shake him and force him again to that biting honesty where Balan could press his own self-loathing into the other’s voice.
A stick cracked beneath the other’s step. Then a cold rush of bile as the realization struck him like a blow: Nóm’s approaches had ever been silent.
Balan’s heart pounded as he heard the steps continue, then pause, and he shifted to rest his hand on the knife at his belt, palm sweaty against the ox horn haft.
Turn. Better to know the threat than wait frozen for the blow.
Turn.
There were three of them at the edge of the tree-line. Two lingered in the deep shadows beneath the boughs, only noticeable in the brief glint of hair. The third stood at the boundary of the shade, pale eyes trained on Balan, with a wide-bladed dagger gripped in each hand.
Goblins. Orqui, his mind translated in frantic distraction, from the root urco: prowling creature, a thing that brings fear.
Another rustle, this time from the bracken to his left, and he spun round with a hiss. There were four now, either that or one of the hindmost had circled back without his notice.
This newest stood less than a stone’s throw from him. Other than corpses, he had never seen one so near outside the muddle of battle, and despite himself the curiosity held him transfixed. It was the hair that caught his eye at once, its variation of bone-white and colorless strands striking against the dark woods. Red ochre had been rubbed in strips throughout its length, along with some other pigment of burnt black, and these had been woven with the untinted hair into a series of patterns, some matching between the individuals so that Balan wondered whether they stood as a signifier—rank or kin or some other category of Angband that he guessed not. In contrast, the skin was pallid and nearly translucent about the surface, so that hues of muscle and sinew leaked into sight—a sickly pink, like chicken flesh or the salted trout Esrid’s people had taught his to preserve—and the eyes that lingered on him were cloudy, their irises dark as jet.
But it was the lines of the face that captured him, more familiar in movement than they had been through death’s mask, for here they yet held an echo of some bygone beauty. I told you once of those who were taken by the Foe’s servants... Nóm’s voice echoed in his memory and with it Balan’s fear overmastered him at last and he broke away, sprinting hard for the opposite tree-line.
For a moment he thought they might let him go. Perhaps they bothered little yet with Men, or he was inconsequential enough to be counted no more than a rabbit, a spooked deer. But then he felt them through the dim twilight, keeping pace easily as he crashed through the bracken. They flickered at the edge of his sight with the same illusion as the Silent Guard, melting in and out of the brush as those shades of the Talath Dirnen when he and Nóm first approached the hidden city. What was he thinking? The dusk was dark as night beneath the pine boughs and these creatures thrived in the sun’s absence. Why had he left the glade?
“Nóm!” The cry tore from him before his pride could hold it back, but the sound fell stifled amid the pines, deadened by the carpet of needles. He scrambled down a ravine, half falling in his haste, and doubled back toward where they had left the Guard setting camp earlier that evening. At least it should be this direction—or no was it behind him? Damn these pines, which way was the sun?
Another Orc appeared around the bend before him. This one had lost an eye, it was not of the original four. Balan swore and sprinted back the way he had come, passing the others as they followed his path down the bank. There were six now in that group.
Gods all, how many more were lurking in the wood?
Nóm. He fumbled frantically for the other’s thought as he ran. An pear tree. White flowers in the wind. The other’s arm beneath his fingers. Nóm! He had found him, but the barrier was ice yet, sharp and hostile to his touch. He leaned in against the king’s anger, pleading, and felt the jagged edges falter.
Three more Orcs. They had scaled the ravine ahead of him and fanned out as they approached, blocking the way. The bank behind him was rock, sheer and not sloped.
He was trapped.
Trapped. With a sharp gasp he pulled his thought back from Nóm’s and barricaded it before the other could reach toward him in return. Clever they are, Edrahil had said when they first rode north along the Narog, and well served to be so. Tis a mighty bounty the Foe sets on the princes of our people—a fair price for a head, but a fortune should one be snared living.
Balan had tripped the snare and fallen into another’s net, this ambush was not meant for him. Very well, then. He shifted into a ready stance and loosed the dagger from his belt. He raised it as the first Orc neared.
His head they could have if they wished it. But he would not be bait.
❈❈❈
Finrod dipped his hand into the stream and drew up a palmful of water. Strange, he thought as he lifted it to his lips, how an argument clouded everything in its wake. The shades of evening were heavy and oppressive, the water bitter—even the birdsong seemed discordant and wrong.
His heart was out of joint.
Every fiber of him was restless.
He swore and splashed another handful over his face. They had been giddy only a short hour ago, caught once again in that same, familiar mirage. It had been like the days before Ivrin. Nay, like the road from Estolad where each heady hour was filled with contentment, laughter flowing without thought or effort and every moment threaded through with the warmth of the other’s presence. They had fallen back to it ere that first dance was done and moved through all the hours since with the same ease. And so, once again, he had let himself grow unguarded.
He could still feel the other’s weight atop him, the scent of crushed grass in his nose, the wilderberries stinging tart upon his tongue. The press of Balan’s palms against his wrists, almost painful as they held him pinned within the flowering grass.
Aikanáro had kept a collection when he was a boy—butterflies and moths and beetles, honeybees and the oversized dragonflies that whirred through the hills above the white harbors, their glassy wings like the patterned glass of Tirion’s palace. He would collect them from the fields or courtyards where they had fallen and preserve each upon the walls of his chambers, caught with pins scarce the breadth of a hair.
Why should they be held unlovely because they have died? He would glare at Findekáno when his cousin teased him for the morbid fascination and the unruly hair seemed to bristle further in his indignation. They too bear the Song, even in these echoes they’ve left.
Finrod had tumbled down amid the crushed violets and found himself transfixed like one of Náro’s dragonflies; and he too could not shift a muscle to free himself while this echo caressed his palm, kissed the berry remnants from his wrist. It had been his own desire that pierced his breast and held him pinned beneath the other’s touch. Ai Valar, he could feel it still—his arm alight with the rough tickle of Balan’s beard, the breath upon his lips. It needs but a word from thee.
And his own voice had been little more than a whisper against the other’s mouth. “Don’t be cruel.”
“I?” Balan had laughed at first, sharp and mirthless, then drew away in indignation and the mirage shattered as he stood. “Tis thou who wilt speak love and in the same breath scorn it.”
“Balan…” The sudden shift from intimacy to wrath left his senses reeling, and his heart pounded as he pushed up from the bracken in protest. “That is neither kind nor just.”
“What has justice to do with aught between us? Is it just for thee to count me unequal because ye hold the gods’ favor and we do not?”
“Beloved.” Finrod rose and the crushed flowers clung still within his hair as he crossed the distance between them. “I do not think it.” He reached out to brush a burr from Balan’s hair, tucked the strand behind his ear in a lingering caress. “But speak not so, even in jest.”
The other snorted. “Why, will they damn me not if I blaspheme in heart only?”
There had been nothing to say to this, of course. Finrod dashed a second handful of water across his face as though to clear the memory and turned to follow the river’s path down the hill. Were they ever to drive the knife by happenstance? There was a brief fumble of the other’s thought against his own and he shoved it to the side, bristling. Let Balan sit alone in the shade of his accusations, they were unearned, baseless. Finrod’s steps beat a furious pace along the bank and he seethed at his own folly. He had learned naught, it seemed. Again these past weeks he welcomed denial, bundled warm and unwary within its fleece; and so again he had taken the venom unknowing. He was at a loss when it struck, the taste of his own laughter still fresh upon his tongue while he apologized and sought to soothe, murmured affection and plucked a new berry to dance upon his own finger with a tentative smile. But Balan remained tense and brittle before him and a restless silence had settled over the clearing.
“What is it thou wouldst have of me?” Balan had asked at last, fixing his gaze on the far trees rather than meeting the king’s eye. “Friendship thou sayest, and yet will dance with half thy soul wound within mine own. There must be naught between us, yet thou wilt hold me here in thine arms, take my hand, speak to me with all the cadence of a lover.” His voice trailed off and he pressed his palms against his face, then after a moment he drew them down and shook his head. “Take me or leave me, Nóm. Do not hold me here half-claimed.”
Finrod’s smile had faltered and he let the berry fall back to the ground. “I never intended to grieve thee so.”
“Then what was thine intent?” The empty air hovered between them; and when no answer came, Balan had laughed at the silence. “And still thine own mind lies a mystery to thee! Dost thou see it not? We are no further than Estolad—unparted but never too near, chasing at thine heel but ever in my place. Ever in my place, but ever out of joint in it.” The bitter mirth melted away and his voice grew sharp. “Thou wouldst have the petals and leave the pith.”
“I would have the whole.”
“Then have it. Or if thou wilt not, leave me to make peace with vassalage and do not taunt me with what I may not presume.”
“How taunt thee!”
“Every touch, every false hope, every brush of thy lips—“
“I’ve done naught more than was ever our way.”
“And naught thou hast done is without consequence.”
“Truly! And didst thou never sleep in my arms upon the long road? Didst thou never take my hand or draw me near—or set thine own lips to my brow?”
“Do not shift blame.”
“I shift it not, it is shared between us. Didst thou not follow me from the encampment and set thy feet upon my path?”
“Aye, and the greater fool I—that I did not choose instead as those before me.” Balan’s eyes blazed and he turned away, the line of his shoulders hardening into resignation. “How many shall we be in the end,” he asked at last, “those abandoned in thy trail?”
Finrod’s brows furrowed and a vague disquiet warned at the back of his senses. “Speak plainly, I take not thy meaning.”
“My meaning, it seems, is to serve my lord as a passing amusement while he waits for the gods to relent—that his heart might return to its true desire.”
“Its true desire?” He attempted to laugh at this, but the sound was forced and uneasy. “Come now, who has been gossiping to thee?”
“There was no gossip.”
“Truly!” An edge crept into his voice. “And so I am to understand this accusation was woven from air of thine own volition?”
“Thou hast not denied it.”
“I do deny it.” Finrod’s chest tightened. The other’s silhouette was sharp against the oncoming sunset, poised as it had been at Ivrin in anticipation of the blow, and again Finrod faltered before the sight. “Light of my heart…” He scorned prudence and strode toward him, cupping Balan’s face within his palms. “Light of my heart, I told thee. Did I not speak it even thus? All my love, and all my desire.” He let his thumb drift once more over the ridge of the other’s cheekbone, the curve of his lips, and for a moment Balan had lingered, his eyes falling shut at the touch. But they opened a short moment after and he pulled free of the other’s hold. “Balan—” Finrod reached for the other’s arm and flinched as he drew further away. “Canst thou think me false?”
“Is it faith to speak devotion if thou wilt own it not?”
His own words to Finduilas turned and molded, his own principle a knife’s blade against him. The silence returned, stretching so long that Finrod feared it was to be his answer, empty and final. But Balan spoke again.
“I think,” he said, returning to the other’s question, “that I have shared everything with thee. My heart thou knowest. The days of my wandering I have not hidden. My grief too I opened to thee, as I have not to any other, and yet all the while—“ His voice caught and Finrod felt the anger rippling from him, tamped down and tethered as he held himself in check. “Two years of whatever we have been to one another and thou couldst be all the while betrothed to another? Without so much as a word to me?”
For a long moment Finrod stared in stunned silence. “Betrothed to another?” he managed at last.
“Aye, so I said.”
“But I am not,” he stammered, reaching out again. “I am not.”
Once more there had been bitter laughter upon Balan’s lips as he glanced up at the other’s eyes. “Now I do think thee a liar,” he said and turned away.
“What reason would I have to lie to thee?”
“More, surely, than he who named it.”
“Who was it?” Finrod’s mind flew over every possibility. Hilyo would have no cause to invent rumor, nor surely would any of the Guard. Sídhon would never be so indiscreet. Guilin? Would Finduilas have relayed mismatched fragments of old gossip? Artaresto. He saw them again in his mind’s eye at the edge of the dance, Balan’s face set in an unreadable mask, Artaresto’s distant and wistful. “Was it Orodreth?”
“It matters only that it was not thee.”
“Yet thou wilt believe him over my own word.”
“Over what word? Thou hast said nary a one to me.” Balan’s gaze turned on him in an instant and Finrod felt the force of his anger strike like an opened furnace. “And what am I to take from that, save thou wouldst hold it in secrecy? And what from secrecy save that there was something to conceal?”
“There was nothing I meant to keep from thee.”
“Then why speak it not?”
“I…” He trailed off. Why had he not? He had thought of her often enough throughout their conversations, when Balan told him of Esrid, when they had lain amid the snowdrop blossoms, but each time some reluctance had stayed his tongue. Dread dropped through his stomach still at the thought of telling Balan, there beside the banks of the Celon, that he had sung so to another first, or that these were not the first features he had traced with the snow-white petals.
“Because if thou hadst spoken,” Balan answered in his place, “if I knew of her, then I would understand thy refusal was a simple thing: thou wouldst not risk any bond of soul that might leave thee shackled should thy gods call back their prodigal children.”
“It is not true.” The protest fell from his lips in hoarse entreaty. “Anarinya…”
“Do not call me that.” Balan’s eyes flashed as he turned back on the other. “What use to me are hollow endearments? I believed I held thy trust, as I have ever trusted thee.”
“So much, in fact, that thou wilt assign the most unworthy of intentions the moment doubt is sown? Short have been the years of our friendship by my people’s measure, Balan. I did not think it kept from thee, only not yet spoken.”
“And that is meant to absolve thee? It was no less deliberate. Untold hours have we spent in conversation over this or that, grave or merry—I know the name of the songbird who lodged in thy nursery window and yet hers I’ve learned by happenstance. You may dress a billy in merchant’s robes, but it remains a goat.”
“Or damn the butcher with mutton in your mouth. Thou hadst a wife.” He regretted the words as soon as they were from his lips. The sting of them blanched across Balan’s face like a slap and Finrod felt him recoil at once behind his fury—all edges and corners, sharp to the touch.
“My wife is dead.” The other’s voice was low, choked and dangerous. ”And not once did I hide her from thee.”
It was true, Finrod could not deny it. How well he had learned her features in the years at Balan’s side. How keenly he knew where the other’s eye would linger upon each, for he had gleaned intemperately from those memories and charted the shape of his jealousy through their rows. The texture of her hair, the three freckles beneath her left ear, the scar upon her chin, the echo of her laugh—Belen’s laugh, bright and clean, like bells in the morning air. Even now he felt the flicker in the other’s thought where the lingering taste of airna’akran had summoned her, reclining beside a basket, laughter spilling out while the boys darted to and fro along the hillside, mouths as berry-stained as his own.
The ache of longing bled through to Finrod’s heart; then anger rippled in its wake and Balan’s mind tightened against the intrusion, pressed him out, gathered all hints of her behind a wall and far from his touch. “That is not thine,” he snarled, and shame leapt hot across the other’s cheeks to be so reprimanded. “On false surety did I let thee go a’thieving in my thoughts. Thou hast taken me from them, leave their memory be.”
“That is falsely charged, and full well dost thou know it.” Finrod’s shame bristled to indignation at the accusation in the other’s tone. “I have never promised thee aught I could not keep, never offered what I could not give. There were no pretenses.”
“None? Thou wouldst not make of me a plaything—or so thou didst protest—and yet here I dwell as my lord’s entertainment, an amusement to pass the brief hours.”
“That is a lie.”
“And what of the place at thy side thou didst promise, knowing full well what was in my heart?”
“Servant, soldier, stable keep…I too remember thy words.”
“Craft thine own blade if thou hast wish to wound!” Balan’s voice was stripped with pain, the lines of his face drawn and desperate. “I was to be something of use. Not the king’s tame curiosity, dressed like a doll in his largess and paraded for the praise of courtiers. How generous his lordship! How benevolent is he! See how kindly he smiles upon these lesser children.”
“Castigate me not with thine own self-pity. This path thou didst beg of me, and against my wisdom I granted it.”
“Against his bountiful wisdom even! Aye, ever glad to take what I give, never owning thine own part in it.”
“I sought to spare thee. In the same hour I knew the truth of my heart I told thee the parting was nigh.”
“A truly noble sacrifice.” Balan’s accompanying grin was mirthless. “For thee I abandoned all I knew. I left my own children.”
“I asked it not of thee.”
Silence had frozen between them in an instant. Balan’s face contorted in fury, his hands clenched into fists at his side, and his eyes flashed in the fading light. “Ego!” he hissed at last, sharp as a blade.
And Finrod had sworn in turn, wheeled round and disappeared beneath the boughs without another word.
He drew up now at the bottom of the fell, breathing hard, both from the speed of his descent and the lingering fury, and he gripped a young sapling to steady himself. Shame wrapped about him like strangling ivy, gripping every surface, finding every crevice and clinging tight. Balan’s rage had been of grief, his jealousy too but a further guise of loss. Why had he let himself strike back? The answer was simple, but he quailed before its mirror. He had wished to cause pain, to wound in return, and remorse choked his breath. It disturbed him that he would turn so quickly to this sooner than see blame rest upon his own wounded pride.
Steady, faithful Balan…never had Finrod’s rage burned so fiercely against him.
“Aranya!” Sídhon’s voice broke through the haze. “Blessed Manwë, we thought you lost.”
“Lost?” It was with an effort that he wound the customary poise into his voice. “Did Gelmir not tell thee we had gone?”
“He did, but twas to the north he said.”
“So it was, but we drifted west as we walked. I thought to watch Anar’s descent from the tor above Rivil’s Well.”
“Then it was a merciful fortune that brought you down ere you had. They were climbing the western slope when we sighted them—even here where we stand. Ten Canneth counted,” he added in answer to the king’s querying glance, “though there may be more.”
“Orqui?”
Sídhon nodded. “A raiding band, most like. Though they’ve not up come through the pass, else we would have marked their signs ere now. They must have other ways yet, delved or hidden.”
Finrod’s blood had turned to ice, and fear lodged within his chest, nearly stopping his breath. The western slope led to the berry glade—and Balan would not have left it, not with memory pressing in so close. “When?” he choked out, catching the other by the arm. “How long since you spied them? How far upon the fell?”
“Perhaps a third of the ascent, less than an hour past.”
Finrod had spun around before the other finished and was sprinting back up the slope.“Go!” he cried over his shoulder, “find Edrahil and follow after me!”
“Arto, wait.” Sídhon gave chase without a moment’s pause. “I cannot—”
“Bring the Guard,” he shouted. And then again when the other made no sign of turning back, “That is not a request. Go!”
“Damned of the Void!” Sídhon swore in frustration, but he left off the pursuit and ran hard for the northern shoulder of the fell, a swift shadow in the twilight.
Finrod sped up the incline, leaping between crags in his haste to reach the glade. Had it taken so long to descend? Arien drew her ship beneath the horizon in the time it had taken already to reach this height and night wrapped its tendrils about him. He scrambled over moss and bracken, cursing the clinging brambles that caught about his legs, and at last shifted back to the waterside—it was the longer route, but he could run here upon the rocky bank or through the shallows when the shore was impassable. A third of the ascent, less than an hour past…he drove himself harder. Every moment lost sharpened the knife.
“Holy Manwë, Lord of the Air,” he gasped, prayers pouring from his lips as he raced beneath the trees, whispered and fervent, hoarse with fear, “grant me speed as the winds of heaven. Lord of the Waters, holy and wise, guide my steps, guard his way…”
There at last, just ahead. The fallen pine with its uncanny row of new growth. The oak with its blanket of ivy.
The empty clearing.
For a moment he drew up, frozen in the midst of it with the wildflowers soft and muted in the night air, and his eyes darted over the clearing for any sign of Balan. Here was the trampled patch where they had lain, fragrant yet where the blossoms were crushed beneath them. Beyond it, the marks of his own departure sliced away toward the downward slope, their earlier approach wide and easy beside it. And here—here was a new track where he had left Balan in his fury, branching off through the fern; a turned scuff of dirt, a patch of airna’akran smashed into the ground, another trail, breaking away beyond the berries, thin and straight with speed. He sprinted down its length and felt a new dread overtake him as three paths converged upon the first. It was a deer’s flight before the wolf-pack, frantic and desperate.
Then a new realization dawned on him with sinking horror; Balan had reached for him as he fled. Oh Valar, Balan had reached for him and he had pushed him away, met him with fury as he ran before the hunters. He called up the urgency of that brief touch in his memory and now he could discern it, the terror and the fleeting hope—that Nóm would hear him, that even now he would not be abandoned.
Balan! Finrod plunged beneath the still darkness of the pines and cast his thought wide in search of the other. He was here. He must be here. It was the king’s heart pleading now, fumbling for the other in the dark, pressing down the panic that only emptiness would meet him.
Warmth, a sudden clutch of relief, the rough solidity of Balan’s mind against his own, and Finrod cried out in relief. He was alive. But the consolation was short-lived, for it was only a moment before the touch turned sharp again, jagged and unreachable, and forced him out.
Finrod swore and scrambled down the bank at his side where a deep furrow had cut through the pine needles. It was fresh, the uncovered earth still damp, and here, here! Footprints at the base—the iron-shod tread of an Orc, the familiar shape of Balan’s boot. Finrod doubled back along the ravine, sprinting hard after their tracks.
“Holy Manwë, Lord of the Air,” he began again, “blessed Varda, lady of light—“ A choked cry broke through his prayer and he drew up before the far bank. The ground along the base of the cliffside was trodden and muddied, rent with all the signs of a struggle.
And blood stained the boulder at his feet.
He was on his knees in an instant, fingers running over the stone to measure the extent of the loss. It had collected in a few of the divots, only here upon the near side, surely not enough to be fatal? It had not been fatal, reason pressed through the haze to correct him. Of course it had not. Balan was there when he reached for him, and strong enough yet to force him out.
Balan. Finrod pressed once more against the wall of the other’s mind, but not even a crevice would yield. Balan!
Then he slammed his hand against the rock in frustration and rose, eyes scanning the tracks to learn which was the latest passage. The blood had been sticky still, they could not be far. A glint of metal caught his eye and he skirted the boulder, crossing to where it lay haphazardly beside the cliff—dropped or kicked aside.
A short blade, slightly curved. An ox horn hilt, polished with use.
The struggle had been fierce here, the ground marked with Orc blood as well as Balan’s, a hand print caught in the soft earth beside the bank. There was another impression beside it, long and heavy, dwindling into a taper where something had been dragged northward along the ravine.
Fury rose hot in Finrod’s breast as he bent to retrieve Balan’s knife from the dirt and clasped it against his own palm.
“Blessed Varda,” he hissed as he sprinted in pursuit, “Queen of the Stars, kindle me after Menelmacar’s form. Great Oromë, Master of the Hunt, set your holy wrath within my blade.”
❈❈❈
It was growing difficult to keep him out. The king’s presence leaned against his own, unrelenting and precise, seeking ever for where he knew the cracks should lie, and Balan’s will had begun to falter. At first it was simple to shut his mind and set defenses, as though raising them about Nóm himself, but fear was overmastering his resolve and he knew not how much longer he could hold.
They were swift. More swift than Balan had anticipated and he stumbled as he tried to keep on his feet. Each time he fell, he had been dragged a few paces until his minder turned back and pulled him upright again, caught by his collar like a pup by the scruff of its neck.
“Soil of Melishk,” he whispered as he slipped on a patch of wet moss, “Rain of Guënid. Earth bear me, river sustain me…” The rope cut into his wrists and he narrowly avoided another fall, earning him a barked reprimand from the Orc ahead of him.
They had planned to kill him, he knew, when they pinned him at last against the cliff. Two had held him, his arms stretched out against the stone and hand bashed upon it until his grip failed and the knife fell from his hold. It was only the scabbard at his side that spared him when the strike was nigh. There was a decorative ring about it, flat and gold, a clasp upon one side and the king’s device upon the other—Nóm had offered it to him in the midwinter when the original binding gave way—and it was the sight of this sigil that stayed the Orc’s hand.
“Danwedh,” she had growled, striking him across the face instead of drawing the dagger through his throat, and Balan had been stunned to recognize Elven words scattered within their speech. They had bound him then, knocking him to the ground and dragging him forward until speed became a more pressing desire than sport.
The leading Orc disappeared into a thin corridor branching off from the ravine. The banks had lowered as they moved northward up the fell, and here it reached no more than twice Balan’s height. The passage was thin, tapering in until only two or three could walk abreast, and it was swallowed nearly at once in the darkness beyond. Panic took him as the last of them entered. It was the same that had come over him before the gates of Nargothrond, only here he knew with certainty there was no light awaiting him beyond the looming stone. Balan dug his heels into the dirt and flung himself backwards, thrashing against the cord like a goat led in at slaughter. But the Orc’s grip held tight, turning the rope about her waist and knotting it securely, so that any hope of pulling it free was gone.
“Nóm!” Resolve gave way before the darkness and he cried out, desperate, while the rope cut deep into his skin and he wedged his foot against the stone. All unavailing. The Orc surged ahead and Balan’s legs buckled beneath him, collapsing once more into the mud where he was dragged haphazardly at the end of their line. “Nóm!” He fumbled at the rope, gripping as much as he was able to ease the strain against his wrists. His shoulder struck a rock. A broken stone left a cut along his shin. The sound of footsteps began to shift, to echo, and he craned his neck about in trepidation.
The passage ended in a shoulder of rock, rearing up into the line of the fell. Slim and nearly hidden, a crevice yawned beside it and the Orcs had begun passing through this, one at a time, and slipping away into the dark. “Earth bear me,” Balan whispered again, his voice shaking with terror as he was dragged toward it, “river sustain me…”
A shadow dropped before him. A quick glimpse of gold. A gurgle and a faint rasp.
The Orc who bound him fell to the ground, eyes unseeing and blood streaming from her throat.
And then it was Nóm’s face before him, Nóm’s hands running over his arms, working quickly at the cord about his wrists. Nóm’s heart steady and determined against his own.
Holy god of fire, do not let it be a trap…
An Orc had swung about. He must have glanced behind before passing through the cleft and was now rushing toward them, blade raised. “There!” Balan croaked, his voice hoarse with pain. “Nóm!”
The king plunged into his thought in an instant, and Balan reeled as the other’s presence surged behind his eyes. Nóm was drawing on both lines of sight, he realized, a quick mirror of what lay behind him, and turned with precision below the oncoming blade. The Orc stumbled and in a quick flash Balan saw a knife—his own knife—pierce the gut, sweep up, open the throat.
But this kill was not as swift. The Orc had time to cry out before the blade severed his voice and any hope of a silent escape fled with the sound. Footsteps echoed against the rock, sprinting, and Finrod leapt forward before they could gain more than a few steps beyond the cleft. He loosed his own knife as he ran and met them with one brandished in each hand, wheeling and striking like a wildcat.
If he could keep them cornered in this narrow end, Balan reasoned frantically, if Nóm could use the passage to his advantage and never face more than two at a time…A third Orc fell and another was immediately in their place. There were three upon him now, a fourth just out of reach, and Balan could no longer discern each stroke and parry, so swiftly did they fall.
It was like watching a wild animal, cornered and vicious. The speed of his movements, the blind fury of the attack. The king’s thought remained open against his own and Balan fought down nausea, his head spinning as he worked to free himself from the fallen Orc, dizzy with the other’s frenzy coursing through his veins. He fumbled at the knotted rope, fingers clumsy and half-numb from the bonds. Where were the others? Where was the Guard?
There was a sickening crack and Balan looked up in time to see the nearest Orc stagger to the side, one knee clearly broken, and fall into the arc of Nóm’s return swing, the hilt shattering the back of their skull. That was four already. If he kept on in this way—
Gods all, it was capture, not death that they sought. The realization dawned on him with horror as he watched Nóm hew away a hand that dragged him back—they were toying with him, hemming him in, waiting for him to wear himself out in the fray. But the responding epiphany came in the same instant: Nóm was toying with them in turn. He played into the trap one moment, luring them with a feint of easy prey, then struck out in the next; wounding, slowing, breaking their pattern, ever a step out of the net. Balan found himself reminded of Tol Sirion and the dancers whirling through the center of the hall, for Nóm moved with the same precision as Gelmir’s steps, dodged with the same grace as Sídhon’s responding turns.
An Orc loomed up from the darkness where she had scaled the sheer embankment, perched above the king and leaning out with dagger outstretched, poised for the leap.
“Nóm!” The cry tore from Balan’s throat in terror and Finrod twisted away just as the Orc sprang, taking the strike in his shoulder and driving Balan’s knife through her chest with the weight of her own fall. Yet the impact had forced him to the side and another Orc stood waiting to catch him by the injured shoulder, twisting him round and breaking his balance.
He fell.
Balan cried out again, unintelligible in his fury, and tore at the rope. It was tangled beneath the Orc’s body still, but the knot about the waist was on the near side and easier to reach than these about his wrists. He could grasp a rock with hands still bound, if he could only be free of the corpse, and he would bludgeon them till his last breath sooner than stand by while Nóm was dragged into that yawning crevice. His fingers slipped again and he swore.
They were in a tangle now, Nóm upon his knees, half-pinned by three Orcs and fighting as one possessed. The one-handed Orc lay dead at his feet, he had driven his knife into the thigh of another, cut through the cheek of a third. He would be taken. Or he would be slain—however high the price on his head, they would have none of it in death. Soon, Balan’s fear insisted, soon they would turn to the kill.
The rope was shifting. It was almost loose.
Nóm had regained his feet, blades flashing like teeth in the moonlight and tearing into the limbs that clutched at his shoulders, his legs. He slammed his elbow into a windpipe, stabbed and turned, twisted out of reach. Another Orc fell as the knot came loose in Balan’s hands and Finrod wheeled around towards the next blow. But the lead Orc caught him by the braid as he turned, pulling his head back with a snap, and he cried out, staggered sideways. A second Orc was upon him at once, pinning him down against the rock while the third saw Balan pulling the rope free and strode toward him, knife raised for the kill.
He felt Nóm’s fury rising like a gale. Light spilled out—white light, blinding and brilliant—and the king’s voice tore through the gully in wordless rage. One arm wrenched free and he sliced through the braid, the Elven blade cleaving his hair like water, then launched up in the brief moment this gained to hurl his knife forward, and the third Orc fell gasping, the blade protruding from his neck.
The second was dead in an instant—fingers through the eyes, neck snapped, body heaved aside as the last leapt upon him. She had stumbled back when he severed the hair, but surged forward nearly at once and bore him to the ground with a snarl, teeth sinking into his shoulder, fingers clawing at his throat.
Balan dragged himself forward and wrenched the knife from the Orc’s neck, staggering to his feet with blade in hand.
But it was over.
The body lay torn upon the ground and Nóm stood gasping in the midst of the wreckage, Balan’s knife still clutched within his grip. Hand and blade alike were stained dark with blood, his own blood streaming from a gash above the eyebrow, from the mangled shoulder, from the side of his leg.
And oh gods, the beauty of him was jarring—tall and pristine amid the carnage with the remains of his hair hovering like light about his face, wild fire still flashing from his eyes and his chest heaving as he tried to catch his breath.
Balan too was suddenly fighting for air. He was trembling, shaking uncontrollably now that they stood free and the full horror pressed in upon him, the narrowness of escape clenching in a vice-hold about his lungs. His grip upon the knife hilt faltered, he let it fall.
And then the king was striding towards him. He was taking him in his arms, stumbling back with him against the stone. He was kissing him with a passion Balan had never dared imagine, clasping Balan’s face within his hands and marking him with blood.
“You live.” The Taliska was hoarse, a whisper gasped against his mouth. “You live. Oh Valar, you live.”
“Aye, I live,” Balan choked out in echo as Nóm’s fingers tangled in his hair. The world was buckling around him and he would have fallen had the other’s hold been looser, or had he not been caught fast against the rock. Still he clung to the other’s shirt like a drowning man, dazed and foundering, suspended between extremes—the rough abrasion of the stone against his back, the soft tongue slipping into his mouth; the sharp pain of his split lip and burning wrists, the mad fervor in every vein.
“I never understood.” The words slipped out between breaths as Finrod clutched Balan’s face within his palms and kissed him feverishly upon his eyes, the crest of his cheekbone, his forehead, his lips. “He was ready to kill him where he hung and I never understood how…”
“Who?”
“It matters not.” He pressed him back and kissed him again, long and fierce, and Balan could taste the echo of airna’akran lingering still upon his tongue. “I’d have killed you with my own hands sooner than let them drag you alive to the bowels of hell.”
“Stop talking.” Balan took the other’s lip between his own, his tongue running along its edge. He tasted of berries, of honey and the warm afternoon, of sweat, of blood.
Balan was burning, fire kindling across his skin as Nóm pulled him closer, arms about him now and palm pressed upon the small of his back. Balan’s senses reeled and he crumpled in against his warmth, kissed him deeper.
But a hiss escaped him as the rope pulled tight about his wrists, the skin swollen where the coarse strands had cut in, and the king drew back with a sharp exclamation.
“A fool I am—I’ve left thee bound.” Finrod retrieved his knife and cut him loose in a swift motion. “Here,” he murmured gently as he eased the cords away from the broken skin, “beloved…” He cupped the bruised hands within his own and would have set each palm to his lips, kissed the marks of captivity in penitence, but Balan caught him behind the head as soon as his hands were free and pulled him in, ardor met and doubled in the returning.
“Gods all,” he breathed, heady and fervent against the king’s lips. “Elenya…” His fingers wove through the shorn hair, grasping it in handfuls as he kissed him in long stifled worship, fevered and desperate. He was like wine, Balan thought incoherently, like summer mead, like the sharp liquor of midwinter’s dawn.
His hands slipped down to cradle behind Nóm’s jaw, breath quickening at the drumming pulse, and he pushed up onto his toes to draw nearer the other’s height. A twinge had run along his neck and Balan found himself fighting the urge to laugh aloud. It was an anchor, growing ever sharper, his neck cramped only because he stood here upon the uneven earth with his face tipped up to meet Nóm’s lips.
It was only a moment, for the other’s shoulders had stiffened, his lips grew hesitant, and Balan clung tighter as he began to pull away. “No,” he breathed, pleading, “do not do this.”
But Finrod had already stepped back, his face gaunt with remorse. “Oh Valar…” He released him and shook his head helplessly. “Forgive me. I should not—I should not have…”
The king’s words trailed off and then Balan did laugh aloud, collapsing against the limestone and sliding down till he rested upon the ground, tears streaming from his eyes and his laughter high and unnatural.
“Balan...?” Finrod watched him first in surprise, and then in growing consternation when the barrage showed no signs of slackening. “Balan, you are hurt,” he exclaimed, shifting once more to Taliska; then again, more doubtfully as he knelt to run his hands along the other’s arms, his neck, his ribs, “are you hurt?”
Balan could only shake his head in response as the storm wracked over him, somewhere between laughter and sobbing.
“Of course you are.” His eyes found the torn wrists, noted the right hand turning purple where it had been battered against the stone, and he took it gently within his own. “Your thought was closed against me—why did you close me out? I would have found you ere this!”
“I was bait.” Balan was laughing at his own laughter now, nearly giggling as he tried to reign in the attack. “Bait, I thought—to draw thee out.”
“And would I not sooner fall with thee than know thee taken on my behalf?” The laughter was growing frantic now and Finrod clasped the other’s face in fear. “Look at me,” he said, forcing his head up till he met his eyes. “Balan, look at me.”
“I know not.” The mirth had given way to hiccups as it began to spend at last, and he wiped furiously at his eyes. “I know not what thou wouldst have, lord.” And then he was weeping in earnest, shoulders shaking and breath heaving in great gasps. “I know not, I know not, I know not.”
“Balan!” Finrod drew him into his arms, aghast, and held him cradled against his chest. His own tears were running loose as well, mingling upon the other’s face as he smoothed the matted hair from Balan’s forehead, kissed along the line of his scalp. “Oh beloved, beloved, I have thee. They are gone, it is done. I have thee.”
And at last, the sound of hoofbeats echoed against the stone.
❈❈❈
Thunder threaded its murmur through the morning air. It had begun with the dawn, first in a downpour beating against the tiles, then easing to a spring rain, steady and soft—which now lulled Finrod’s senses as he leaned against the parapet and looked out over the fells. It was one of many watch towers, the Cened Beraid, that lay scattered throughout the highlands, particularly here along their northern marches. They were small and spare, shooting up like the thin spruces that surrounded them, and placed at measured intervals along the fells, so that where one tower’s vigilance ended, the next began. It had been Angaráto’s innovation—or was it Eldalótë’s? The two of them together, most like. One was never certain from which an idea had sprung, so closely were their counsels entwined.
Finrod was glad of it now, whencesoever it came. They had ridden hard for the nearest of the Cened Beraid as soon as the Guard found them collapsed against the stone bank in the dark. Sídhon’s hounds had pressed in at once, snuffling in concern until Edrahil dismissed them with a shout and caught the king by the arms, looking him over in furious evaluation. Finrod nearly smiled at the recollection—he might have been a pup himself for all the reproach in Edrahil’s lecture. He had been rash, he had been foolish. He was the king, not a foot soldier without command, and yet he had flung himself headlong into an ambush with nary a thought for his own defense. Was he mad? He was, he must be, surely, to rush in so heedless of all but his blind rage.
It was rare that the captain forgot rank or decorum, but he had cast off both in his relief to find them alive and chastised the king as soundly as an errant child, binding his wounds with brusk efficiency all the while. Finrod could hardly blame him. It had been foolhardy at best to give chase, alone and knowingly outnumbered. Indeed, a grave breach of his own duty. But when he thought of the crevice at the end of the gully, jagged-edged and dark as pitch…nay, he could not manage a single regret for his folly.
Finrod flinched as water struck his face and startled him out of contemplation. The wind had shifted to the northwest while he was lost in thought and now a steady rainfall drifted into the alcove where he tarried. It would have been pleasant on another day, the mist gentle and cool, the air fragrant with damp earth and rain. But the binding about his shoulder was long in the securing and Celiel had been adamant it should remain dry and undisturbed till nightfall, when it would be cleaned and bound anew. He lingered a moment longer, then sighed and drew back from the parapet. Enough trouble had he caused already without needlessly undoing her work.
The Cened Beraid were built in mirrored pieces, there should be another battlement on the far side—one flight down, if he remembered correctly, and nearly opposite, looking out over the heart of Dorthonion—and there the tower would block the rain.
He ducked back into the corridor and started down the stair, grimacing whenever his left leg bore weight. That wound he had hardly noticed at the time and the depth of it astonished him when Celiel cleaned and packed it in the small hours of the night. It throbbed as he reached the end of the descent, a bone deep ache that gritted his teeth and made him long for the seed-cordial of the Sindar. More fool he—Celiel had offered it ere she cleaned the wounds and he refused. Better to have his wits about him, he had reasoned, better to be alert, should Balan wake and have need of him. He took several slow breaths, steadying his senses before continuing down the passage. A wishful delusion. He had betrayed his trust, Balan would not call for him.
The king had been ushered at once to the healer’s rooms when they arrived, and by the time his own wounds were cleansed and set, Balan had long since given over to sleep. At first, Finrod had lingered in the doorway and watched his slumbering by the faint light of the hearth. He was curled on his side, the blanket bunched around one arm, his other draped over a mound of dark fur—one of Sídhon’s hounds. Greweg, the smallest of the pack. He had been a frail and helpless little creature, Finrod recalled, nearly lost amid the squirming riot of his siblings. Sídhon had plucked him out of their number after the first day and carried him about, tucked within the front of his robe and tended carefully through feast and council, much to the amusement of the rest of the king’s household. Finrod too had cradled the pup upon his lap in the long autumn evenings and he and Sídhon took it in turns spooning milk through a hollowed cow’s horn to keep him fed. Greweg they had called him, little bear, and he had grown at last to match his siblings—the smallest still, but filled with bumbling affection. He had taken to Balan at once when Finrod returned from Estolad and was ever trotting after him through the stone halls or curled at his feet beside the hearth. And since the Guard found them the night before, Greweg had refused to leave his side.
Like as not Finrod would have remained lost in the solace of that vision, had Sídhon not found him and sent him firmly back to his own chambers to take what rest was left in the night. It was well that he had, the king reflected as he passed through the lower corridor and neared the eastern bend of the tower, he had slept nearly as soon as his head touched the pillow and not risen till half the morning was gone.
The scent of rain grew stronger as he rounded the corner, green and fresh, and he thought again how pleasant it was to fill his lungs with spring’s vigor. It was a strong tonic, this artistry of Ulmo and Manwë and Yavanna, mingled together in air, and the ache of his wounds eased before it.
There, just as he surmised. It was indeed a mirror of the floor above and he passed into the battlement with only a few steps. The downfall drifted outward across the highlands, draping like strands of diamond where the sun broke through the clouds and lit the hills in an uncanny contrast.
And Balan was there before him.
His heart tripped from its rhythm to see him standing at the end of the alcove, one hand resting upon the stone, the other scratching absently behind Greweg’s ears. Living and whole. For a moment, the sun had reached beneath the overhang and bathed his face in her caress—and the king’s breath must have caught at the sight, for Balan glanced back at once and his brows lifted to find the other there agape.
“Forgive me, I did not intend to disturb thee.”
“Don’t be a fool.”
Already Balan had turned back toward the fells, but there was warmth in his voice and Finrod was surprised to find his mind unguarded, welcoming. “A caution over-late, I fear.”
Balan’s lips twitched. “I am not angry with thee,” he said, shifting to make room as the other approached. “Leastwise not enough to wish thee gone.”
Finrod managed a smile as he ran a hand along Greweg’s muzzle in greeting, then leaned against the parapet and rested his arms beside the other’s upon the stone. Near, but not too near. Close, but do not touch. His mouth burned with the memory of Balan’s lips; his tongue tasted him still, berries and earth, sunlight and sweat and the lingering scent of cedar oil within his beard. Blood. Balan’s blood or his own?
He pulled his mind back with an effort. Balan was here. He was safe. He was little harmed.
“May I?” he asked at last, indicating the bandaged wrists, then lifted the left in his hands when Balan nodded acquiescence. He found himself reminded abruptly of the road to Estolad, of Balan’s fingers binding the sash to staunch his blood, of his own shiver at the touch, and he realized with a start that he too was grasping after any tenderness that might be permitted. Gently, he unwound the linen binding as he cradled the hand within his own.
The skin beneath was worn raw, marked with deeper ruts where the cord had pulled tightest—beneath the thumb’s base, along the outer bend, across the small bones of the hand. Fury clawed at Finrod’s breast once more and he frowned as he turned the wrist carefully in the light. He should be glad of it, he told himself. These were the marks of Balan’s life spared.
“Hast thou no trust in thine own healers?”
The wry teasing had returned to Balan’s tongue and Finrod’s anger dissipated before it like mist. “I do,” he said, and the hint of a smile played again at his lips. Of course he trusted them. But nonetheless they knew little here of the Secondborn. What if they applied a salve that caused festering instead of mending? What if the draughts that granted relief to his kind were poison to Balan’s? What if…He wrapped the linen about the wound once more and returned it to rest upon the stone. “It has been well tended.”
The rain had heightened while they spoke and wrapped in grey sheets about the tower, whispering along the leaves below, through the sodden pines. Balan watched it with a faraway expression and in the flicker of his thought Finrod felt a stab of joy, pained and marveling—to see the world yet, when leaving it had been a certainty.
“And thou?”
Finrod smiled at the question and shifted his weight against the parapet. “I am well. Thou art living,” he added when the other peered at him skeptically. “I am well.”
Balan reached out and laid his palm along the other’s cheek, turning it to bring the left side into the light. A dark bruise lay along one cheekbone, another above the king’s eye where the gash had been carefully stitched closed, a scab ran across his chin. Balan traced his thumb along this last and there was concern in his eyes despite the sardonic twist of his brow.
“I will mend. It was no great harm.”
Balan’s laugh slipped out despite himself and for a moment Finrod feared it was the former panic returning, but this mirth was genuine—and his heart strained at the sound. How near he had come to losing it, how certain he was only a handful of hours before that its last echo was gone.
The kind of laugh that sets your soul to dancing.
Nay, that was Esrid. That was Belen. Balan’s laugh was Finrod’s own treasure, rough and wry and kindling a heady warmth within him.
And it echoed beside him still. Oh, merciful Valar…
“I could understand them.” Balan’s gaze settled on a raven gliding over the ridge, his voice quiet now that the mirth had passed. “Not everything, but enough that I could follow their intent. They said danwedh. They spoke your tongue.”
“Yes. Fragments of it.” Finrod too fixed his eyes upon the raven and focused on each beat of its wings. He could still hear the last Orc’s voice in his ear—otheidior! otheidior! It had taken his full weight to push through her grip for the kill and she held his eye all the while, hissing condemnation as the knife drove slowly into her chest. He shuddered. “They draw from other tongues, borrowing and shifting as it suits, but there is not one cohesive form among them—or none that we have been able to discern.”
“I believed thee not when thou didst speak of them as rooted from thine own kind.” The raven passed out of sight and Balan shivered, moving nearer in reflex. “I saw it in these. Perhaps because they are the first I’ve faced since dwelling among you, but there was familiarity. I could see their beauty still.”
Their arms had shifted together upon the stone and Finrod grounded himself in the touch, setting his center-point in the warmth of their meeting. “We were ambushed the first time I killed, wandering and half-starved from the Ice when Orcs fell upon us.” There had been horror in Balan’s stare when Finrod rose from the carnage the night before, stark and unmistakable amid the relief. He tried to press the memory aside. “He was young, I think, a hand’s breadth taller than I, with a face of my father’s shape. My knife pierced his skull like a chisel.” He broke off for a long moment and when he began again, his voice was flat. “I retched when the battle was done, over and again on the bloodied ground until naught was left but my own horror shivering within me. It was years ere I could work in stone, so close was its strike and give to my blade against his bone.” His fingers pressed hard against the parapet as though holding himself to the present and he trembled with the force of his grip. “And now I have killed ten of their number and say to thee with ease that I took no great harm. Little wonder we seek to believe them formed of mud and malice. How can we reckon with our own deeds else?”
“Deeds are not weights on a scale,” Balan’s pulse was a steady measure against the other’s arm, “and in truth I know not how to reckon thee. But I know thine heart, and I know I would have been dead ere now—dead, or maimed, or strung up in some devil’s ransom.”
“Yea, doubtless. And thus I cannot see my way to regret. They stumbled by chance upon the weightiest leverage they might hold: crown and life alike would I have given for the price of thy release.” Finrod passed his hands along his face and shook his head, weariness cutting lines along his features. “Hilyo was right to upbraid me. I forsook every duty in my weakness—and indeed would do so again wert thou new-taken from me.”
“Elenya...”
“I should not have left thee.”
“Aye, perhaps. But lay it not overmuch at the feet of thy guilt—I would have gone hadst thou remained. I was in a rare fury.”
“Well do I know it.” The rain was driving harder now and its rise and fall reminded him Belegaer’s sighs against the far coastlines. He had brought Amarië to Alqualondë once, eager as a boy to show her the crags and hills he loved, the gem-strewn beaches where he paddled as a child, and she had smiled as he pointed out each well-loved landmark—the alcoves where he would hide from consequences, the line of flat rocks in the sand that he had called his own palace, the slope with its waving grasses where he would slip away with scrolls and bound leaves, the high cliff where Meril would sit and sing over the waters. She had smiled at each of these and laughed when he told her of the mischief he and Angaráto would wreak, but her presence had been distant, unsettled. It was only later when they returned to Tirion that she confessed the Sea had filled her with dread, its dark unknowable depths stretching away beyond comprehension. That memory had dogged him through Araman and upon the Ice, when the Sea was all fury and vengeance, when the dread was his own. “I did conceal her from thee,” he said at last, and was surprised to hear the hoarse grief within his tone. “I know not why. Shame, perhaps, or fear that thou shouldst think less of me.”
“And why would I think less of thee were it spoken? I who once had a wife, as thy wit was quick to remind me.”
Finrod blenched and his knuckles whitened where his hands lay clasped together. “That was cruel of me.”
Balan dismissed this with a faint shrug. “I am little proud of my own barbs,” he said, reaching down when Greweg whined and scratching him again behind the ears. “We neither of us spoke in kindness—let it lie. Wilt thou tell me of her now?”
“Yes, shouldst thou wish it.”
“I do.” The words seemed to come from him with a struggle and he turned to rest his back against the parapet, occupying himself with the hound. “I would know thee, Nóm, in any way thou wilt grant me.”
Finrod’s arm twitched as he caught himself mid-motion. He had nearly drawn Balan into his arms, nearly lost his resolve already at the tremor of devotion in other’s voice. He closed his eyes and breathed in the rain-scented air. One breath, two, speak on the third. “It was half true, what he told thee—Orodreth, was it not?”
Balan nodded. “He meant no harm by it.”
“No, he would not. He was the least eager of us to go and thus his memory lingers ever upon those we lost through our choice.” Finrod faltered and again he trained all his thought upon the brush of the other’s arm, his blood flowing like fire from the touch and anchoring his purpose. “We were never betrothed,” he continued at last, “though most assumed it to be so, and I did not disabuse them. I could not decide for myself whether our affinity lay in love or in friendship, and I dreaded above all that I would choose in a moment of false surety and learn not the error until it was done. She was my elder by several years and had studied under Manyarë, an eminent master of philosophy and one whose work I had long admired, and so our conversations at first were all of my eagerness to learn what she might tell me. Friendship grew quickly after that, for each of us found a reprieve from pretense in the other’s company and we sought each other often, whether in Tirion or in Valimar. All our kin believed it a love beyond friendship—and perhaps it was. Nay, there again I shy from it in the speaking. I did love her. But I could never discern my own heart and so I tarried, and I tarried, and I tarried; and then the Darkness was upon us and the madness and the haste of our vengeance. She would have none of it. We were each of us convinced in our own perception of duty, each sure in the soundness of our principles and the rightness of our intent, and we argued—bitterly. And we broke. She named me faithless, I named her haughty, cold. Though we were both of us blinded by pride, I as much as she; moreso perhaps. ‘Go in thy folly,’ she told me at the last, ‘and carry not even my memory to warm the road beside thee.’ “
Balan’s hand had formed a looping pattern about Greweg’s head: scratch behind the ears, scoop around and rub beneath the collar, pass up and scratch the chin. He repeated it in a steady rhythm as he listened and his jaw was set, his face unreadable.
“And so I went. Turvo had taken her younger sister to wife, and Elenwë’s heart chose exile sooner than parting, despite her sister’s ire; and I walked into the wasteland in envy beside them. But my bitterness was short-lived.” He let a brush of memory touch Balan’s thought—the crack in the ice, Turgon’s cry as he leapt from its edge, his own desperate dive after them. “Turvo and I walked side by side through the remainder of the Ice, passing his daughter from one to the other with envy hovering in a truce between us.” Finrod’s fingers traced a pattern along the sandstone and his voice had grown quiet, distant. “I did not speak of her after Elenwë fell. At first it was to spare Turvo, but ere long it became a matter of habit. And silence too was a simpler thing than speaking, for to speak a grief I understood not seemed a pernicious falsehood. Did I grieve in love or in friendship? Did I wish still for either?” He turned at last to face the other and withdrew his hands from the stone, setting aside his fidgeting in surrender. “And in that lies the truth of my silence to thee, I deem. For how could I speak of it in the same air that held thine own grief? A presumption it seemed and an insult to thy trust to say I too have loved and lost when my own heart could not discern the truth of it.”
“I would not have seen it so.” Balan murmured after a long pause, his eyes resting still upon Greweg, who yawned, sated, and lowered himself to stretch across the floor. “I would sooner have known thy sorrow, faceted and contrary as all sorrows must be.” He fell quiet again, worrying his tongue along the split in his lip. “He said she was the beauty of Valinor incarnate,” he added as though in afterthought, “light and wisdom, innocence and joy.”
“And so she was. But for all that, I could never find certainty.” He broke with restraint at last and reached out to cup Balan’s cheek within his palm, turning the other’s face to meet his gaze. “Dear one,” he breathed and his caress moved along Balan’s neck, “thou hast no rival there. Never have I been more certain than of my love for thee.”
“A strange way thou hast of showing it.” He leaned into the other’s touch, the ghost of a smile tugging at the edges of his mouth, and Finrod’s heart turned to water at the sight.
“Anarinya…” he whispered, and heard his voice break as it left his lips.
“Beloved.” Balan’s eyes did not waver now and they burned with all the fervor of Ivrin. “I would choose it again—to follow thee. I would beg thee as fervently still as I did above the flax fields and barley.” He lifted his hand to rest upon Finrod’s chest, his touch steady and firm despite the dark bruises. “Let me be thine, lord, as whatever thou wilt.”
And then he was in his arms, tucked close beneath the king’s chin, arms twined about each other and neither sure which had drawn the other in. Finrod’s shoulder throbbed with the sudden movement, but he pressed it aside and clung tighter still, burying his face in Balan’s hair, breathing him in. “Might we not be this instead? Lovers in soul if not…” his voice faltered and he felt Balan’s arms tighten impulsively about him. “Thou art more to me than any other. I cannot pretend to thee it is otherwise.”
“Nor I.” Balan’s face rested against the king’s neck, the soft prickle of his beard drawing fire through the other’s veins, and for long they remained thus: unmoving and poised as though outside of time, the minutes or hours passing over them, oblivious. “Sometimes,” Balan murmured at last, his voice muffled still against the other’s skin, “sometimes I think I have wandered all my days seeking only for thee—that thine was the whisper in the midnight, the hunger ever in my heart. I am home, Nóm, here in thine arms with the sound of thine heart setting my own. Here I am at rest.”
Finrod was silent, holding him close as he drew his fingers through the dark waves, set his lips to the edge of Balan’s forehead. “Light of my heart,” he whispered at last, calling back once more to the holy waters and the alder trees, “to what am I to turn on the day I do lose thee? When I cannot scream and strike at Death, when no force or love or fury can keep thee in my arms?”
“I will rest within thee yet, deathless in thine heart as my people have held all those who went before us.”
“A rolling echo, chasing me through the years. A remnant only and never the sounding.”
“Nóm…”
He buried his face once more in the other’s hair, savoring his warmth, memorizing the touch of his hair, the scent of his skin, the tangible weight of his thought resting against Finrod’s own. Then he drew back at last and smiled, cupping the other’s face within his palms and he kissed him between the eyes. “Heed me not, I am being foolish. Thou art weary, freithe eil—nay, I feel it in thee, do not feign it is otherwise. Go now. Laugh and rest and be at peace.”
“I cannot not leave thee so unwell.”
“I am well. Truly, Balan. That day is not this whose dawn we’ve passed; thou art living, thou art whole before me.” He let one hand linger upon the other’s cheek and warmth reached his smile at last. “How could I not be well?”
Balan held his eye for a long moment, then nodded and set his lips briefly to the hand at his cheek. “As thou wilt, then. I am weary, as thou sayest. Weary to my bones.” He stepped toward the corridor and Greweg rose at once to pad after him.
“Anarinya.” Finrod did not turn, but kept his eyes fixed on the stone where the hound had lain. “I am sorry.”
“Mm?”
“Open not that wound I cannot bind—twas all thou didst ask of me. And I have transgressed it ere a season has passed.”
Balan paused, then turned and closed the distance between them, slipping his hand behind Nóm’s head. “Then I shall transgress as well,” he said, and he kissed him, soft and lingering, and felt the king’s strength fall away into his arms. But Balan pulled back a moment later and his hand shifted to rest against lightly against the other’s jaw, holding him back as he pressed forward still. “And now the scales are leveled,” he breathed. Then he smiled, a brief flash of mirth, turned again, and was gone.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
ego!: [S] “be off!” Seemingly the nearest Elvish equivalent to “fuck off”. Per The War of the Jewels (p 365), “to say to anyone ‘ego!’ was indeed the gravest eithad [insult].”
orqui: [Q] orcs
danwedh: [S] ransom
Cened Beraid: [S] Looking/seeing towers
Greweg: [S] Little-bear
otheidior: [S] usurper
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
Andanahti-marei: evening/twilight-lake
Airna’akran: jewel-fruit
gaitch: swine
freithe eil: my love
MISC NOTES
- Special thanks to the linguistics channel in the SWG discord for Greweg’s name and for all the wrangling needed to construct otheidior! You were all an invaluable help!
18. The Warning Sounds Too Late
“Blessed was the joining of your forbearers’ souls, and blessed are we by the fruit of their labor.” Eldalótë stood at one corner of the table with a slim chalice raised in salute, first to the king at her left, then to her husband at the foot of the table. “May joy be upon what joy hath wrought!”
Shortly after Finrod and Balan's encounter with the Orc ambush, members of the family have gathered in Dorthonion to celebrate the begetting days of both Finrod and Angrod.
Read 18. The Warning Sounds Too Late

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, SPRING
The North Marches of Dorthonion; Barad Belaith, the Tower of Angrod
“Blessed was the joining of your forbearers’ souls, and blessed are we by the fruit of their labor.” Eldalótë stood at one corner of the table with a slim chalice raised in salute, first to the king at her left, then to her husband at the foot of the table. “May joy be upon what joy hath wrought!”
“And may Elbereth make light to shine upon you!” came the echo along the length of the table, the clinking of glasses, the laughter rippling like a brook.
Balan sipped from his cup and let his eyes drift over the little assembly. They were strange, these feasting customs of the Nómin—the ritual washing each of another’s hands, the bread broken and passed to the guest at one’s side, the form of the toasts, indeed the gathering itself.
“Do you celebrate birth’s remembrance among your kind?” he had asked once in Estolad, curiosity piqued as Nóm watched the merriment of Belen’s feast with rapt fascination. “Or does the counting become too cumbersome?”
“Nay,” Nóm had flashed a sidelong grin, “tis the day of begetting that we celebrate.”
And Balan had laughed, thinking him in jest, till the king’s look of earnest confusion told him otherwise, and then he laughed still more in bemusement. It was the crude term Nóm had used in his assertion—the trouble, Balan teased him later, that came of learning a language through prodding about in another’s head. The vocabulary thus gleaned was only as respectable as the mind he plumbed.
His lips twitched in the attempt to suppress a chuckle and he glanced again toward the head of the table. Nóm reclined in the foremost chair, laughter spilling out like music while the golden light of the courtyard draped about him, his cropped hair hovering about his jawline.
Finduilas had been gleeful when she met them at the gate that afternoon. “Adatheg!” She had grinned up at the king as Váya slowed to a halt beside the green, and the light in her eyes was mischievous as she took in his hair. “How then! Hast thou gone a’thieving as well?”
Their similarity was even more pronounced with the shorn gold mirrored between them and the same impish mirth had danced along Nóm’s features. “Aye,” he replied as he slid stiffly from the saddle, “a’wandering and a’thieving over hill and dale.”
“And what spoils hast thou brought me?”
“Ornon,” he retorted, teasing in return, and had laughed at the perplexed furrow of her brow. Then he moved near enough for her to leap into his arms in greeting, and his breath had caught in a hiss as she collided with his shoulder. “Gently, little fiend! I am not unscathed.”
Finduilas sat nearly adjacent to Balan now, nestled between Gildor and Eldalótë, and was taking in all that passed, her brown eyes sharp and canny. She had interrogated him at length following Nóm’s admission and insisted on hearing the tale thrice over ere she would accept he had not neglected any details of note. Then she had set upon the king in turn, he believed, having heard Sídhon shoo her along the passage after they dispersed to wash and dress for the meal. But when they reconvened in the courtyard that evening, Balan noted with amusement that the attendant’s efforts must not have been entirely effective, for the same pattern of braided pearls had been woven through both Nóm’s hair and hers—Sídhon’s work—and she had arrived at the king’s side, arm in arm and laughing together at some shared jest.
“May Elbereth make light to shine upon you!” The acclamation echoed again as Tuilann finished the next toast, tipping a dash of her wine into Orodreth’s chalice; who in turn passed a portion of his to Balan, and on around the table as before—the praise shared among the assembly so that each drank together of the same blessing.
“As Yavanna’s orchard was the tree of your parents’ union.” Orodreth stood, lifting his cup in benediction first to his father, then again toward the king. “Blessed the branch which grew from it, and blessed be the fruit born therefrom.”
“And may Elbereth make light to shine upon you!” The clink of glass, the wine passed again, the blessing drunk.
Finduilas’ eyes sparkled as her father returned to his seat. “I fear the fruit must be overripe that drinks to its own praise, ada,” she said, mischief dancing through her voice, and her lips twitched into a grin when Orodreth glanced up at her in surprise. But he laughed at once and held out his palms in a show of penitence.
“Sharp-tongued little fox.” Gildor bumped her shoulder affectionately. “We’ll none of us dare to formality in thy presence.”
“Nay, Elinkë,” Finrod glanced at his foster-son with amusement, “thou hast forgotten: the fox it is who defends the fruit of the orchard, not the one who mocks it.”
“Well shouldst thou know it.” Aegnor chuckled from the far side of the table and laughter scattered back through the group.
Fingon lifted his glass toward the king with a grin. “Blessed indeed was the fruit borne therefrom.”
“And sharp too the fox,” Finrod retorted.
“What, a grudge still?” Mischief spread along his features and he leaned forward to catch Balan’s eye. “Bëor, fortune has set you in ignorance of our familial strife—come, you shall be our arbiter. Let us suppose you had a brother, a younger brother, who had a particular fondness for apples. Now let us further suppose that in your youth, you had a cousin who knew a way to obtain the choicest apples there were, and in his benevolence he shared this knowledge with your brother—”
“He baited your brother with a dare—”
Fingon held up a hand and cut in over his cousin’s words, “—and when your brother set out to retrieve those delicacies and your cousin warned him of the foxes guarding these orchards—”
“Shouted it in afterthought,” Angrod interjected in turn, “when I was already over the wall—”
“—you then chose to launch yourself after him into the forbidden groves.” Fingon concluded, then spread his hands in innocent appeal. “Now, if you were bitten on your, er, flank as a result of your own reckless pursuit, would the fault lie with your cousin for being free with his knowledge or with yourself for choosing to leap forewarned into the path of the foxes’ teeth?”
Balan hesitated, his hand resting upon the base of his own cup and turning it by degrees. “I fear my lord forgets that I am the father of two sons,” he replied at last, a smile playing at the corners of his mouth. “I have set more than one broken bone gotten by the benevolence of shared knowledge.”
Finrod’s grin was triumphant as he raised a chalice toward his cousin, but Fingon’s gaze remained on Balan, one brow cocked, teasing and curious. “Then you would rest blame at the feet of knowledge?”
“I would rest blame at the feet of he who set the foxes.”
“She who set the foxes.” Maedhros spoke for the first time, his voice low and amused. “Twas Yavanna’s orchard they plundered.”
“Was it truly?” Balan chuckled and broke off a piece of bread from his plate. “Then as a loyal bondsman, I shall add the foxes to my tally of grievances.”
For a moment the silence was sharp, but it was broken at once by the rough sound of Maedhros’ mirth. “Would you say then, adan, that the Valar err in keeping their sacred groves?”
Balan refilled his cup and paused to watch the ripples settle before answering. “I would say—forgive me, lord—” He glanced at Finrod with faint contrition. “I would say do not invite a guest and then take offense when he eats from your board.”
Maedhros’ laugh broke out in full at this, gravelly and half-abrasive in the quiet of the courtyard. “Almien,” he murmured, touching his cup briefly to the other’s and taking a quick sip. “Spoken indeed as a pupil of exiles.”
“Almien.” Balan returned the salute and drank from his own. “But my lord would tell me such words are perilous folly, and so in honor of his celebration I recant.” His eyes drifted back to meet the king’s, and a smile eased his features as he found the brush of Nóm’s thought warm despite the twinge of concern. “All of which recalls to me,” he added as he rose, “that I alone tarry yet with a benediction ungiven. I am poorly versed in the customs of your people, but I will speak blessing as we do among my own folk, if it is permitted.” The king dipped his head in acquiescence and Balan held out his hands before him, pressed palm to palm. “Earth rejoiced in your making and water poured blessing on the hour of your birth. Fire leapt with gladness when your soul felt its kindling and wind soared triumphant as your breath joined with hers. The burning sun smiled when light touched your visage and song broke loose at the sound of your name. May Melishk set your dwelling firm beneath you, may Guënid’s water mark your path. May Fon’s heart warm and keep and guide you, may Luftu’s breath sustain your own. May Iuathap ever walk before you, and Satheweis bring joy to dwell within your house.” He laid his arms over his chest and bowed, first to Angrod at one end of the table, then to the king who sat with hands stretched palm-upward before him.
“May blessing rest with thee as thou hast blessed,” Nóm answered in the Atani fashion, bringing his palms together to mirror Balan’s earlier gesture, then drew them up to his lips in a sign of acceptance. “Sama’nd sá.”
“Sama’nd sá.” Balan lifted his cup from the table and raised it as those before him had done, tipping a splash into Maedhros’ cup, then Orodreth’s as the toast moved once more around the table and the prayer to Elbereth echoed again.
Then a cheerful murmur arose, for Sídhon had passed through the surrounding peristyle bearing a round loaf on a polished, wooden platter before him. It was intricate, set with latticework from which sugared flowers sprang, as though each plait was a green and laden vine, and the scent of honey wafted through the courtyard as he placed it at the head of the table. Balan was surprised to see that it was quite small for such a gathering; the whole of the loaf was fitted snugly within a circlet of flowers no larger than the width of his head.
“We call it lumas,” explained Orodreth at his side, “for it too, like its cousin lembas, is waybread—the waybread of time, marking joy in each year’s flowering and sustaining us as we journey onward, bearing the ever-growing weight of memory’s burden.”
“Quite a festive despair, that sounds.”
He heard the king’s chuckle from along the table, but Orodreth’s brows furrowed in concern. “Nay, Bëor, it is the task and calling of the Eldar to persevere in memory, to hold it ever-sacred and ever-present as Arda wanes. Weariness there shall be, of course, but we do it gladly and do not treat with despair.”
“Do we not?” Maglor glanced at him in amusement, then waved a hand through the air in dismissal. “Nay, nay, be not offended. Thou art the righteous among us, Artaresto. Allow that we flippant twigs may tease the boughs for their steadfastness, being but envious creatures ourselves.”
“And so does the knife tease the sword for its sharpness,” Angrod added beside him with a grin. “Thou art no more apostate than I.”
Maglor opened his mouth in retort, but it was Eldalótë’s voice that rang out along the stone.
“Vána, blessed and ever-young,” she said, drawing a knife through the glistening crust, “cast your glance upon this gathering that these we celebrate might flourish as those flowers which spring in new life before your passage, that their souls might sing with the joy of your blessing.” She had divided it evenly into twelve pieces, each with a flower in its midst, and leaned forward now to set the whole in the center of the board.
“The will of the Valar shall be done.” Hands darted forward with the prayer, bumping together in their haste to claim the portion each had in mind, laughing and jostling till the platter lay empty, save for the circlet of flowers and a single slice of lumas. Balan reached out and claimed this last, shifting it to his own plate as they all began to break off bites and eat.
“There is a fig baked into the loaf,” Finrod explained, his eyes merry as he watched Balan’s confusion amidst the revelry. “The one who finds it in their portion is said to bear forth the blessing of Vána into the coming year, and thus we name them—”
“Lord of the feast!” Finduilas crowed, snatching the circlet from the platter and planting it firmly upon Gildor’s head. “He’s hidden it here behind a radish,” she added and grinned at him in triumph, his face reddening as he sought to evade the attention. “Thou shalt have thy good fortune, coz, agreeable or no.”
“Hail, the lord of the feast!” Finrod lifted a chalice and the sound of his laugh danced through the air as the others joined him, echoing the salute.
“Vána favors thy line, Elaráto,” Angrod quipped after they had all drunk his fortune. “Thy father too was crowned by nearly every lumas, if I remember aright.”
“He was indeed,” the king glanced at his foster-son with a quick smile, “and was as bashful as thou art at the honor. Do you remember Thadhril?” he asked then, turning toward Fingon and Angrod and shifting the conversation deftly from Gildor’s embarrassment. “She once ate the fig whole before any knew where it lodged. Though whether that was from shyness or a desire to wreak havoc upon the proceedings, I still could not say.”
“The latter, with certainty.” Fingon chuckled, refilling his wine.
“Which is Thadhril?” Maedhros glanced at him in query.
“She apprenticed with Curvo in Aman,” he answered. “Middling height, dark, I believe she is one of his lieutenants still.”
“Friendly with the envoy from Belegost,” Maglor added with a quick smile at his brother.
“Ah. I know the one.”
“Unparalleled is thy skill in leaving the unsaid ringing louder than thy words.” Fingon leaned back in his chair and grinned as he set his eyes on Maglor. “Tell the tale.”
“Hearsay and gossip, Finno,” Maglor retorted, “and beneath thy dignity.” Then he laughed when the other did not relent and leaned back in his chair. “As thou wilt. There was a young envoy from the lord of Belegost, golden-bearded and jovial, and for the duration of his stay one did not find him without Thadhril’s company, nor Thadhril without his. And as thou hast said, twas not the eloquence of what we encountered that raised a tale, but the loudness of what we did not. All nonsense, of course,” he added as Fingon’s face shifted from amusement to concern. “Though he did petition to remain in permanent residence and I am told there was a heated conversation between the lieutenant and her lord after it was denied. Whatever the truth of it, there is a new envoy in place and Thadhril grants him scarce more than politeness.”
“Hearsay and gossip, as thou hast said.” Fingon drank deeply from his wine, then shook his head, perplexed. “Truly, I cannot imagine how there would be any appeal between naug and eledh.”
“Perhaps for the logistical challenge.” Aegnor mumbled into his chalice, earning a snort from Gildor at his left.
“It is an interesting question, certainly,” Orodreth mused, passing over his uncle’s quip. “How close should we understand the kinship between Eru’s Children and Aulë’s?”
“There is no distinction,” the king countered. “Did not the One adopt Aulë’s children as his own?”
“Thou wouldst hold such a pairing to be permissible, then?”
“I said not so.”
“And yet,” Fingon leaned forward, “if thou wilt say there is no distinction, then surely that position can be inferred?”
“I hold there is no distinction in the place of each as Children of the One. It is true that Aulë formed the cadhadrim, but it was Eru who breathed their spirit into being—as he did ours, as he did the Secondborn.”
“And being thus of the same breath, the Children could also be of one spirit...” Eldalótë finished the last of her lumas, and her brows furrowed in thought. “A possibility, of course.”
“But is not all of Eä sustained by the breath of the One? And we do not consider ourselves akin to the mice and mushrooms.”
“Come now, Finno,” Aegnor cut in, “we needn’t all predicate pairing upon kinship.”
Fingon flicked a cherry pit across the table and his cousin dodged it with a grin. “But we might upon a shred of commonality. There is as much difference between eledh and naug as between mouse and mushroom, surely.”
“Nay, that is more uncharitable than thy meaning,” Angrod protested. “One a breathing creature and one a fungus?”
“Gold and iron, then,” Fingon conceded. “Oil and water. Some set of elements that cannot mingle.”
“Thou wouldst set the measure to meet thy purpose,” Finrod said with a grin, “but gold and iron may weave together in beauty, as there within the bracelet on thy wrist.”
“They may be woven, true—braided in friendship and respect. But seek to make of them one metal and it is a brittle blade you hold.”
“That may be so. But as yet I’ve heard no reason from thee but prejudice.”
“Is it prejudice when a thing is mutually distasteful? Bëor,” Fingon leaned forward and appealed to him a second time, “surely you would agree were it your own people in question.”
Balan hesitated for a moment and lifted the cup to his lips before answering. “Being near to iron myself, lord, I fear I’ve not the objectivity to judge your own mettle.”
Fingon laughed and raised his own glass toward the other in concession. “A point deftly scored.”
“All this quibbling brings to mind the jewel smith and the craftsman of Nogrod.” Maedhros glanced at Balan with an amused flicker in his eye. “Do you know the tale?”
“I do not.” Balan shook his head. “What craftsman is this?”
“Mercy, Bëor,” Aegnor snorted, his words half-obscured with mirth, “encourage him not.”
“Come now, be gracious, coz.” Maedhros reached for the decanter and refilled his cup. “Twas thy brother in defense of such cultural exchange not a moment past, and thou disparaged him not.”
Aegnor confiscated the decanter with a laugh and gestured in resignation.
“So, then. There was once a young smith of our people who, as the story goes, grew enamored of one of the masters of Nogrod. Now this naug was a—”
“Cadhad,” Finrod corrected over the rim of his chalice.
“Cadhad, an thou wilt. This cadhad was a craftsman of great renown, a master of filigree and fine ornamentation, and rumor of him spread from the eastern wilds to the feet of the Ered Wethrin. Upon hearing tell of his prowess, the smith set out at once for the city of the Naugr—of the Cadhodrim, and indeed so gratifying did he find the craftsman’s work that he returned each season, till at last his steward exclaimed in frustration, ‘why, O lord, do you journey so often to the mountain forges?’ ‘Ah, tis quite simple,’ said our smith. ‘Anarimaitë i tanoron lamba.’“
Balan choked into his wine as he tried to hold back a snort. Luck had brought the chalice to his lips as the jest unfolded, for Maedhros had shifted the final phrase into Quenya to play the double meaning and it was a moment ere Balan noticed the change. The others were laughing around him; all except Tuilann, who understood nothing of the forbidden tongue, whether genuinely or on principle, and Finduilas who—gods all, he had made the mistake of meeting her eye. She too was attempting to feign ignorance of the wordplay and his own laughter nearly won out at the sight. She stuffed a bite of pheasant in her mouth and looked away at once, holding her composure with far greater skill than he. He hid his face behind another long draught of wine.
Maglor was grinning at the far corner of the table, parrying quips with Aegnor and Fingon. “Truly,” he exclaimed in feigned shock at Aegnor’s latest insinuation, “twould be an unexpected explanation for Curvo’s ties to the Smith’s Guild.”
“Nay, Káno, surely not unexpected.” The king broke into the conversation, sipping from his wine to hide the laughter already weaving through his voice. “Did he not tell thee Telchar was their finest member?”
“Valar save us!” Fingon’s laughter rolled along the table. “And from Arto even!”
Maglor threw up his hands in resignation, though his quick staccato mingled now with the others’ mirth and his eyes were bright with merriment. “Come, Bëor,” he said, turning toward him with palms spread in plea, “give us a tale of your people and draw us back to virtue.”
“Shall I, my lord?” There was an amused edge to Balan’s voice as he paused to refill his cup. “You’ve a flattering confidence our tales would serve for such.”
“Wallow with us in vulgarity, then. I mind it little—save that you set your tale in song, if you will. Ingoldo’s letters are illuminating specimens, but in this I find them lacking: How has the One tuned your voices? By what steps do they dance through the Song?”
“By many, lord; some fumbling, some sure. My own is a poor staff with which to judge the whole.”
“But a note sounding amongst them, surely.”
“Aye, as you say.” He sipped from the wine to gain a moment in thought, then his eyes grew mischievous and he set the cup aside. “In keeping with the conversation, lord, I will tell you a tale we sing at harvest—of the god of song whose love is given to a farmer’s son. We too mingle gold and iron, you see,” he added with a wry twitch of his lips. “Though when we tell it, our voices rise in praise of the defiance—for we ourselves are brittle blades unalloyed, and it is in such mingling that we see a way to strength.”
“Do you indeed? Sing on, then, I would hear your hymns defiant and learn whether their melody tends sweet or discordant—and we shall see then if my noble cousin sits corrected.” Maglor nodded toward Fingon with a grin.
“It is myth, not argument, lord,” Balan replied, laughing. “I beg you do not hold a threshing tune to such a measure.”
“But is not myth itself a form of persuasion?” The king’s glance fell upon him, debate dancing merrily upon his tongue. “Or does the aithan-hropit hang as a tale only and not an exhortation?”
“My lord presses his advantage. He understands far more of our lore than do I of his philosophy.” Balan met Finrod’s gaze with a one brow lifted. “Of what wouldst thou be persuaded?”
“Of what wilt thou tell?”
“Tässil and the god of Song.” Balan chuckled and held his eye in challenge. “It tells of how Satheweis was drawn in curiosity to the meter of his scythe and so came down from the air to learn what it might be. Love sprang out at once, each for each, but the gods may not mingle with the flesh they created and so in their embrace Tässil was consumed, burned up in light and his soul grafted into the divine. We left Estolad before the harvest, lord, else thou wouldst have heard it ere now. It is the story we tell of how our people were granted song—for ever after that, the music drifting through the world held a mortal soul within it; and each of ours, then, is held in kinship with the god of song.” His eyes had fallen away from the king’s as he spoke and now followed his finger as it traced the pattern of leaves around the stem of his chalice. “And so we sing it at every harvest, for we hold that cutting and threshing should ever be bound with music—the myth embodied and the marriage of mortal and divine.”
As he spoke, he had shifted his hands to the table before him and began drumming a quiet rhythm upon the boards: two steady beats, a double-beat, another slow, as though echoing the sound of feet plodding behind the scythe. Then quietly his voice began to chant the melody.
“To sickle’s sound our tongues will sing
a threshing song, a cadence bring
to flail and scythe. We sound the drum
as fly the grains amid the hum
of voices hoarse.
Now beat the grain as tell the wise
of Tässil fair and Satheweis
who saw him there in golden fields
and there at once his heart did yield
to death’s fell course.
The god of Song, the Speech divine,
did founder then as though with wine
besotted. Swift he donned the shroud
of flesh as quiet Tässil plowed
through choking gorse.
He follows him. And in the gloaming
goes to him, the music roaming
through the grasses and the rye.
Bewildered, Tässil lifts his eye
and knows the source.”
As though in obedience to the melody, he felt Nóm’s gaze upon him, the drum of the king’s pulse in his ears more resonant than his own hands’ rhythm against the board. It was an impertinent choice of tale certainly, Balan admitted as fire pricked at his own blood and coursed with the wine through his veins; but it was an intoxication of its own to be able call up the other’s dizzy longing with such ease. Nóm had asked for persuasion, had he not?
Balan let his mind drift to the pines and the embers while he sang, the silver light of a half-moon in the summer night, the waking dream beside the fire. Scattering memory to tempt the blaze. And the king, wandering still amid his thoughts, was caught at once by the sly teasing—the pulse quickened, the slender fingers suddenly restless upon the table—and it was with an effort that Balan kept a grin from tugging at his lips.
“In beauty there before him stands
bright Satheweis and by the hand
he takes him, draws him near,
and there in breath against his ear
the song grows hoarse.
Then Tässil burns as down the spine
desire ripples. Lips entwine,
and trammeled there in bitter fate
he feels the warning sound too late
to change his course.
The darkness breaks. Upon the wold
the air is shifting. Wind and gold,
now from them spilling, sharp and bright:
their flesh burnt up in holy light
above the gorse.
And now we chant through threshing long
to weave the sickle and the song
forever bound. With scythe and flail
we mark them still as o’er the vale
our music soars.”
Balan’s voice trailed off and for a time the rhythm alone continued in the quiet, echoing through the courtyard. Then it too fell silent and all that remained was the wind rustling through the ivy leaves.
“Well, my lord,” he said after a moment, eyes lifting at last to glance toward the foot of the table, “what is thy judgement? Have I brought us nearer virtue or mired us firmly in our vulgarity?”
“Far be it from me to name song’s acquisition an unvirtuous act.” Maglor sipped from his cup with a smile. “But I am fascinated by the merging of soul and divine spirit; that your myth would posit the consuming—the consummation, if you will allow the inference—as merging and not destruction. If the tale sets forth the mingling of god and mortal as impossible, would not the soul too have been caught within the holy fire?”
“Our understanding of this is otherwise than among the Eldar, lord.”
“Is it indeed. And what meaning, then, do your people set upon it?”
“That death is not our master. He may claim our frail flesh, but we will defy him in that destruction, whether as soil from which the new life arises—as my lord has seen in our burial rites—or more directly as Tässil’s spirit weaving us within the divine. And so thou art proved in the right as well,” he said, turning to Finrod with a quick smile, “for after all, it is the same is it not? Tässil’s soul and the aithan-hropit?”
“By such breath a promise was laid,” Nóm recited, and where the tendrils of thought lay mingled, Balan felt the memory of the other’s hand clasped within his own, the cold of winter’s midnight within his lungs, the press of a carved cow’s bone lashed against his feet. “May we all be remembered so: beloved children here in the darkness.”
❈❈❈
Arien had settled below the horizon and Tilion was far upon the same road before they began to disperse at last, breaking off by twos or threes—Angrod and Aegnor engrossed in a game of chance with Fingon, Maedhros looming beside them or drifting beneath the shadowed cloister, Maglor teaching Finduilas to play a curious little instrument, somewhere between a pipe and a mouth harp, while the others sipped wine and laughed beneath the stars till the night had nearly slipped away.
By the fourth watch, only a handful remained: the three still intent upon their game, Maedhros looking out over the dark highlands, the king walking the length of the courtyard to ease the stiffness in his leg.
His pain had lessened in the week since the skirmish, but the dull ache was growing increasingly insistent as the night waned and he fell to limping before crossing half the distance. With a grimace, he shifted his steps and made instead for the southern edge of the terrace, only a stone’s throw away. It lay open beyond the peristyle, defended by a precipice that fell away before its feet, and was rimmed with a stone balustrade along its length. The expanse of Dorthonion spread out beyond this and it was here that Maedhros stood, arms propped against the stone and face unreadable as he gazed out into the night.
Finrod shuddered despite himself. There was an eeriness in seeing his cousin outlined against the sheer drop, some scent of another’s memory, and a nameless dread pricked again at his gut.
Scars trickled down the other’s jawline like ivy along the arch columns behind him and Finrod’s own jaw clenched against the thought of their origins. They were more pronounced here than they had been at the table, where candlelight played upon the tunic’s pattern and drew one’s eye away from the face and onto the ornate designs. Deliberate, of course. But those embellishments were dulled here in the starlight and Finrod let himself sit for a moment with the horror.
“If thou hast wish to join me, Arto,” Maedhros said without turning, “then join me. Do not hover like a gnat behind my sight.”
“I knew not if company would be welcomed.”
“Tis thy feast, is it not? I would not have come were I not braced for the possibility.” He glanced back then and there was a flash of mirth in his eyes. “Don’t be a fool. I mind thee not.”
Finrod smiled in return and moved to join him along the balustrade. “High praise indeed.”
There was a low sound, distantly akin to a laugh, then Maedhros turned back toward the highlands. “I’ve wheedled the tale from Edrahil,” he said after a long silence. “Nay, be not angered. Quite a fear thou didst set in him by thy folly.”
“He is vexed with me still, I deem.”
“Yes. And no wonder.” The wind ruffled his hair, ruddy-brown and trimmed close about his ears, and he frowned into the night. “Their passage out from the fell above Rivil—twas sealed, was it not?”
“It will be done. I left orders with Arminas for it to be pulled down and blocked. One of the captains of the Cened Beraid,” he explained when Maedhros glanced at him in query. “He holds the tower nearest Rivil’s Well.”
“Do not be complacent merely because their number was small. They pour out from those cracks like rats when the need takes them.”
“I have seen it.”
“If there is one passage, there will be many.”
“I know. I have set a guard upon it and they are scouring the highlands anew.” Finrod shifted his weight and tried not to let irritation creep into his voice. “My captains are not unseasoned, Maitimo. Nor am I careless in my charge.”
“Twas great care indeed, leaping upon a practiced force with naught but a knife in hand.”
“Two knives,” Finrod corrected, the aching leg and night of wine leaving him more peevish than was usual, “and the terrain to my advantage.”
“And thy wits half-intoxicated with rage.” Maedhros straightened, removing his arms from the stone and reaching back with a grimace to reposition his shoulder. “I’ve seen thee battle before in such a fury and it is fearsome, undeniably. But thou art heedless, Arto, unreserved and reckless when it holds reign of thee. Do not trust to it.”
“Should I have held back then? Let him be dragged into that darkness?” Finrod’s voice had grown low, and sharp about the edges. “Surely thou wouldst not counsel so.”
There was no change to the other’s face, only a sudden thickness in the air as though a gale moved upon the horizon. “Thou art fond of him, I know,” Maedhros said after a long silence, his words clipped and carefully measured. “But they take him and they have a toy. They take thee and all lies on the knife’s edge of thy fortitude. And believe me when I tell thee it is ever less than one hopes. It is thy responsibility as a prince of our people to place their wellbeing before personal grief.”
“He is my responsibility as well.”
This was dismissed with a snort.
“They are sworn to me, his people, as much as I am to ours. He dwells with me as emissary on their behalf and I have given my word to his sons that no harm shall come to him in that charge.”
“Then twas a promise rashly given. It is the duty of a liegeman to fall in service of his lord—and so he is sworn, is he not?”
“He is nothing so utilitarian.”
“So I can see. But thy duty is to the whole, not the one—no matter what arrangement thou hast with the mortal.”
Finrod’s glance was sharp. “I do not take thy meaning.”
“No?” Maedhros’ gaze remained on the hills, but there was a wry twitch at the corner of his mouth as he saw his cousin’s hands move to grip the balustrade before him. “The vassal’s tongue is very skilled,” he murmured, amusement trickling back into his voice. “And not for naught, I think, hast thou trained it in the Exiles’ speech.”
“So thy jest was laid to trap him?” Ice laced through Finrod’s voice and his knuckles whitened against the stone. “There is no arrangement,” he insisted and felt his own words tangle as the other laughed, choked between anger at the teasing and despair at the truth in his own denial. “There is not. Do not mistake my objection to a prejudiced argument with an embrace of folly. Tis easy to parry in debate, but I am not such a fool as to believe one could wed across the chasm of fates.”
“I did not suspect thee of wedding him.”
“Then truly I understand thee not?”
“No? Ever thy father’s son thou art—and ever the Vanya he.” The twist of Maedhros’ lips was both amused and pitying. “Tis binding only if the oaths are taken alongside, Cullingwincë. Or hast thou thought Finno wed these long years?” He laughed again when the other was silent and turned toward him at last. “Ai, poor Arto, thou hast. Come then, look in my eye. Am I bound?”
Finrod’s grip tightened upon the balustrade as some remnant of childish fury rose within him at the nickname—little goldfish, small and helpless, ignorant and other. His cousins had taken it in turns then, tossing stones to determine whose lot it was to explain the particular manner or tradition, word or jest, and he felt the earnest mortification working again at his throat. He pressed his palms against the stone, holding his gaze stubbornly on the highlands. “There is no arrangement,” he repeated.
Maedhros studied him for a long moment, letting the silence grow heavy before he pushed away from the rail. “As thou wilt,” he said at last, turning back toward the others. “But mind thy steps, Satheweis. Thou art foundering.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
adatheg: [S] uncle
Elinkë: [Q] “little star,” a nickname drawn from Elárato, the approximated Telerin form of Gildor
almien: [Q] cheers, (lit.) to good fortune
lumas: [S] time-bread
Elárato: [T] approximated Telerin form of Gildor
naug: [S] dwarf, stunted-one
cadhad: [S] Dwarf, from Khuzd
eledh: [S] Elf
Anarimaitë i tanoron lamba: [Q] “the craftsman’s hammer is very skilled” where Maedhros uses lamba (an alternate form of namba) for “hammer” so that it can mean either “the craftsman’s hammer” or “the craftsman’s tongue”
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
- Sama’nd sá: good/abundant life be unto you (see Here in Our Frailty)
- aithan-hropit: “mother’s-cry,” holly (see Here in Our Frailty for the background myth
MISC NOTES
- See No Gentler Pain for the background on Finduilas’ commentary on Finrod’s short hair.
- Special thanks once again to the linguistics channel in the SWG discord for their help with constructing lumas!
19. Now the World Runs On Swiftly
Finrod attempts to bring Balan to Menegroth as emissary of the Edain, the Girdle does not approve, and Finrod has words with Thingol on the matter.
Read 19. Now the World Runs On Swiftly

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
Neldoreth
Váya’s coat shimmered like mist as she moved beneath the tall beeches. The sun’s tendrils snaked alongside her, golden and warm and dropping cross-hatched shadows between the trees. It had been a relief to pass the eaves earlier that day, for the heat of summer grew oppressive in their ride across Dimbar and they had all been glad to tarry when they reached Mindeb’s ford, horses and riders alike. The water was deep, nearly to Váya’s shoulders, and they lingered long in the reprieve of its current before moving at last toward the tree line.
It was disorienting, no matter how many times he travelled through his uncle’s kingdom. The seasons began anew when you passed these borders, always slightly disconnected from what you knew a moment before. Here at midsummer, spring still held sway, bluebells carpeting the forest floor in a riot of color, their scent dizzying the senses while bright songbirds flitted from branch to branch. Finrod ran a hand along Váya’s neck and filled his lungs. The air here quenched thirst, deep draughts of light that coursed through the veins as Melian’s spirit coursed through each bough and twig, and its hold on him was near intoxication.
He closed his eyes and let his head fall back while Váya’s gait rolled onward—in her movement he felt the Sea of her name, and for a moment believed he was sailing forward through the bluebells’ waters, a pilgrim of his mother’s people still held in Uinen’s embrace.
Through the haze of light, his thought reached for Balan’s and drew him in against his own spirit. It was warm, the touch of the other’s heart, earthen and steady, and he felt the caress returned in kind even as it summoned him back from his dreaming—one intoxication exchanged for another. It was reckless, he would have said before Rivil’s Well, this renewed freeness of spirit; it was tempting doom, allowing this passion to burn unhidden between them. But lovers in soul, they had said, and as a lover he wound himself within the other’s embrace: heart against heart, spirit within spirit, thought chasing after thought in giddy pursuit and tumbling together through the space between their flesh.
Mind thy steps, Satheweis.
Finrod pushed Maedhros’ words aside in annoyance. He had kept the conversation hidden away in the back corners of his mind, locked amongst those paths where Balan’s touch did not tread. But in the weeks since, when he found himself alone, he would take up the memory of his cousin’s words and turn them over, peering at this facet or that, prodding at tone or phrase or gesture as though to learn whether each had been trustworthy or in jest. To contemplate whether his own ardor would dare the trial of it.
His lips were burning and he pressed them quickly between his teeth to still the thought of the other’s kiss, soft and eager against his own. Balan would agree without hesitation, there was little doubt, for he had offered as much already, there beside the waters of Ivrin with hope shining undimmed within his gaze. Had Finrod been a fool after all to refuse him? Little goldfish, clinging to naivety and naming it conviction?
Nay, Maedhros might know the truth of custom, but Finrod knew the truth of his own heart. He would never be sated while there was anything left lacking, he would find no contentment save in the whole. He had proven it well enough these past months. Granted friendship, his passion had seized a kiss. Granted a kiss, he had plead for a heart. Granted a heart, he now longed only for the body.
If granted that, he knew he would yearn ever for that final bond yet withheld.
Thou art foundering.
Finrod opened his eyes to the canopy above him, lace-woven with the sky tracing rivers through the leaves. There had been a rustle of confusion from the thought against his own, a flicker of alarm.
“Nóm?”
“Mm?” He lifted his head and turned toward the other in query, only to find him drifting toward a close thicket, lined still with mist, and looking around in growing concern. “Ai! Balan, do not stray. These paths are readily missed if you know them not and we might easily spend a day in search of thee.”
“There you are.” For a moment Balan lapsed into Taliska in his relief. “Fay creature! You lecture me on wandering while you flit about like shades?” He guided Elmorë back to ride at the king’s side with a smile. “Stay where I can see thee and I’ll not stray.”
“So I have done,” he protested, and then illumination trickled over him. Of course—it was the power of Melian’s spirit. His own senses were ever loose and giddy when he passed through the Girdle; and how much stronger, surely, that must play upon a mortal’s thought. “Sídhon,” he called, laughing, “come ride at his right. We’ll corral him together and give the lie to these rumors of negligence.”
Balan attempted to match the laughter, but his glance remained wary and he rode nearer than before. “What is it about this place,” he asked at last, “that the air shifts and deceives like a fever?”
“Lest melian,” Sídhon answered in a low voice, “where the nightingales sing in time with the spirit of the queen—she of Aman who was once handmaid to Estë and Vána the Ever-young, and who is herself of the race and kin of the Valar.”
“I thought your gods did not set foot on this side of the Sea?”
“Stewards,” Finrod’s correction slipped out in reflex.
”Not since before the Sun was born,” Sídhon continued with an amused glance at the king. “But Melian departed long ago from the gardens of Lórien, in those days when the Quendi woke beside Cuiviénen, and she came instead to these silent lands, filling them with her song. And with her came the nightingales.”
There was a flutter, a rush, and as though in chorus with his words, a watch of them took flight from the low bracken, surrounding them for a moment in a bright cacophony.
“She remained when the others had gone,” Sídhon continued when the melody faded once more into the boughs, “and dwells still within the heart of Doriath, and all this land is girded ‘round by a fence of her enchantment. None may pass it, save at her will.”
“Why linger?” Balan’s eyes still followed the arc of the nightingales’ flight. “When even thine own folk were summoned away?”
“Elwë Singollo.” There was an almost languid note in Finrod’s voice, caught still in the heady draught of light and song and spirit, and his gaze too had trailed the birds into the boughs. “Elu Thingol as he has been since. Beneath the trees of Nan Elmoth she found him…and captured there, each by each, they passed long years unmoving while the stars danced overhead, and all his people sought the paths of the sea, thinking him lost—my mother’s people, for he is of my kin—but here they dwell yet, Ainu and Elda; and here her power holds sway to guard their kingdom from any who would enter without Thingol’s consent.”
“Not Satheweis, but the goddess of song…” Balan murmured with a sidelong glance as they ducked below the branches. “So there are such tales among thy people after all.”
Finrod glanced back and met his eye, a brief flash of smile before they dipped into the shadows. The boughs had grown together here to form a thick archway, low and covered in flowering ivy, and the nightingales’ chorus rose to a deafening pitch as they passed beneath. It was the length of two horses perhaps, no more than three, and in only a few strides the king emerged into a new clearing. “Steward,” he corrected again when the birdsong had eased, grinning still over his shoulder, “not goddess.”
But it was Sídhon whose horse stepped out from the canopy, Edrahil following after him, then Gelmir and Canneth and Lithui.
“Balan?” Finrod drew Váya’s head about with a frown and rose in the stirrups to look over the others’ heads.
“Nóm?” The reply was muffled as though he spoke through wool, off to the right and behind, and the fear in Balan’s voice was palpable. “Nóm!”
He was halfway across the far glade, dismounted now and leading Elmorë by the reins while he searched the trees in alarm, and every few steps he staggered as though the ground shifted beneath his feet.
“Here!” Finrod called back and lifted his hand to catch the other’s eye, then he glanced at Sídhon in frustration. “Did I not tell thee to keep him between us?”
“I never shifted.” Sídhon shook his head, bewildered. “He entered before me—I understand it not.”
“Nóm, where are you?” Balan’s tone was growing panicked and his eyes swept past them. “Why do you not answer? Sídhon! Canneth!”
“Here, Balan, to the left of thee!” This could not be explained by confusion. Time too must have bent in the shadows to set him so far afield and without their notice. Even distracted as they were by the ivy and the nightingales’ melody, surely he could not have strayed so far without—the nightingales sing in time with the queen’s spirit. Truth rushed over him and he leapt from the saddle with a cry. “Balan! Stand, move no further!” He was sprinting toward him, pressing the command urgently into the other’s thought.
“Nóm!” Balan’s eyes darted in the opposite direction and he stood frozen, breathing fast. “I cannot see thee…”
“I am here.” For a moment Finrod heard the trees’ song turn dissonant in rebuke, then he closed his ears and reached out to grasp Balan’s wrist.
And all the world changed about him.
It was the same forest, the same glade bright and golden beneath the beeches, but it had grown slippery somehow, at once too sharp and too fluid. His eyes darted from tree to tree as the scene before him rippled like cloth in the breeze, and he clutched Balan with both hands now, his breath hissing between his teeth.
“Elbereth…It has been so for thee all this time?”
“Aye.” Balan shifted so he could grasp Finrod’s arm in return. “I thought it was the same for thee, that thou hadst learned to weather it.”
Finrod shook his head and felt his stomach lurch. He had been seasick only once as a child, the first time he sailed through a torrent of Ossë’s fury, and he found the same nausea rising within him now. Each tree he focused on shimmered like a mirage, each bluebell bled into the next before standing out in uncanny clarity—too crisp, as though formed of glass and not soft flora.
“Why canst thou see it now?” Balan clutched at him as the glade rolled like a wave beneath them. “The forest knows thee well enough.”
“I am numbered among the strangers in this—it cannot let me pass so long as I have hold of thee. The lest melian may confuse by enchantment or in the various currents of Time, but it cannot wrench a grasp by force.” The shadow of the beech behind him loomed with increasing menace and he glanced over his shoulder, his fingers tightening. “Or so I deem.”
“Arto?” Sídhon’s voice cut through the haze with surprising clarity. The group of them had halted at the edge of the clearing and were looking about with consternation.
“Nor may the others pass if I cannot,” Finrod added in revelation when the other’s words were not muffled, and his own voice was rich with both disquiet and fascination. “Each of us move as linked threads woven together: their passage permitted while journeying as my guests, mine permitted by kinship and grace…but bind one thread and the whole cloth is tangled.”
“If we are so caught, lord, then let us not risk separation.” Sídhon turned his horse about and urged it a step nearer the others. “Come back, the both of you—and swiftly.”
“He is right,” Finrod murmured, “though I suspect the forest’s power will be little wont to allow it.” He shifted so that one hand gripped Balan’s arm above the elbow, the other his far shoulder, and tucked him firmly against his side. “Hold fast to me, even should we fall—loose the horse first, should it come to that. He will meet with no harm in these woods.”
Then he drew him forward, passing each foot carefully along the grass to hold their balance. Finrod found himself remembering a corridor in the palace at Tirion where the marble was polished to such a shine that the walls themselves turned to mirrors when Treelight poured through the eastern windows. He had been halfway along it one day when the hour struck and the dizziness left him clinging to the nearest wall. He had steadied himself then by closing his eyes and walking the passage by memory, but he dared not attempt it here when every bough shifted in treachery and the world seemed to change between one blink and the next.
“This way,” he breathed, setting his eye firmly upon Váya’s sheen. “Steadily, and do not take thine eye from them.”
One swath of bluebells was crossed, then another. The thud of Elmorë’s hooves was unnaturally loud as they shuffled through a patch of sunlight, but they had passed the midpoint and—
A raven’s cry sounded from the thicket to their left. Through the bewitched air it seemed to their ears to be the voice of one of their companions and Finrod looked sharply around, only to see the bird flutter its wings and send out a short series of croaks as though in laughter through the trees.
Finrod swore under his breath. The moment he looked to the side, all the glade had gone off-kilter and he swayed against Balan’s arm.
There was a wide stream running along the edge of the clearing and he found his eyes drawn irresistibly to its path. Earlier, when they rode along the banks, it had danced over rocks and branches—even now his ear found a distant whisper of that music—but the water here appeared still as glass, not even a ripple creasing the surface.
The nightingales took flight again, rushing from one set of boughs to another and in the water their reflection was pristine. The stream was a flawless mirror, still and shimmering, beckoning, its slight distortion no different from the unnatural sharpness of the world above. In fact, it was more natural, was it not? Nay this stillness was the world and the other was the brook’s reflection, alternately wobbling and sharp as it was. He had become disoriented by the forest’s song and nearly led them astray. Fill the lungs. Find the bend of the archway—there, where Edrahil and Medlineth stood beside their horses, speaking in low voices and glancing warily between the trees. Right the gaze and settle the senses. His arm tightened about Balan and drew him forward beside him. One step, two, they were nearly to the clearing’s edge.
Then the trees danced before his eyes in sudden waves, blurring and scattering, and he realized with a shock that his legs were wet to the knees.
“Back!” He dragged Balan from the center of the stream and they scrambled together up the side of the bank where Elmorë had stubbornly dug in his hooves. “Tis no good,” he called back to Edrahil, closing his eyes for a moment and shaking his head in a futile attempt to clear the mirage. “Once separated, it means to keep us so.”
“Stay still, lord.” Edrahil had held up a hand in warning. “The less we move, the less web is woven. Medlineth is right.”
“The Marchwardens will not be far.” A tall Elf stepped forward, broad-shouldered and dark haired, and took up the explanation. “We have ever met them within a short distance of the eaves and if our own sight could light upon Bëor while he was caught within the Girdle—and ourselves yet free—then they too would find us should they come near.”
Finrod nodded as his eyes scanned the trees, squinting into the shadows. “Sound a horn,” he directed. “They know our call and will come if they hear it sent up in distress. Each of you take hold of another,” he added glancing down at Balan and shifting to clasp his hand within his own. “At the least, I will not have us scattered like seeds.”
Medlineth nodded and reached out to grasp Edrahil’s cuff, then lifted a small, silver horn to her lips. Its call was bright amidst the beeches, a voice more so than a blast, and with it the light seemed to grow beneath the boughs. Thrice she sounded it, and with each ring of its melody they felt their hearts strengthen, the world about them steady. Even when its echo drifted off into the canopy, the woods remained less sinister than before.
“And now we wait.” Finrod drew his thumb along the edge of the other’s hand and a smile played at the corners of his lips. Balan had twined his fingers between the king’s, their hands out of sight in the shadows between them and, to his chagrin, he found himself momentarily grateful to the Girdle for trapping them so. “Though it will not be long, I deem.”
Indeed it seemed a scarce passage of time before the birdsong had returned—gradually, so that they were hardly aware until it neared its former volume—and the brook resumed its chattering, leaping in eddies once more unhidden from their eyes. The air too had eased, its new, stifling weight lifted, and even the earth grew trustworthy beneath their feet. Only Balan now remained mired in the haze.
“How came you here, lord?” The glade had been empty one moment, the next a tall Elf stood before them, brown-haired and silver-eyed with a spear resting at the ready beside him. “I knew not that you could fall foul of my Lady’s guard.”
“Mablung!” Finrod turned swiftly at the other’s voice and relief flooded through his own. “Hail to thee, and well met! I failed to send word ahead of us that my friend traveled among our number, and so he has been caught unwitting in the Lady’s labyrinth—and ourselves with him when we would not part ways.”
Mablung turned in curiosity toward the man at his side. “You are Balan, Beldar’s son, of the eboennin?”
“I am.”
“I am Mablung, chief captain of Elu Thingol and Marchwarden of this realm. You have met my friend Beleg, I believe, on our southern borders.”
“Aye, my greetings to him,” Balan replied and the hint of a smile creased his features, though he glanced about warily as another dozen or so emerged from the trees behind Mablung, dressed likewise in the colors of the forest and bearing spears and bows in their hands. “I will be glad to meet him again, should he be in your lord’s halls.”
“He is.” There was a brief hesitation and Mablung’s eyes moved back to the king. “Is it your intention for the abonnen to journey on with you into Region?”
“He comes as emissary of his people to greet the king—and as my sworn liegeman and ally.”
“Then forgive me, lord.” The Marchwarden held up his hand as Finrod stepped forward, palm outward and adamant. “Your Guard are welcomed as ever, and Inglor’s son as well. But by command of the king, Doriath’s borders are closed to the Secondborn.”
For a moment Finrod stared at him, lips parted and words choked with fury. “On what grounds?” he managed at last. “They have come peacefully among us and no ill have they done either against this kingdom or its master.”
“I know naught but the orders I was given, and to those I am bound. If you would learn my lord’s counsel, then it is to Menegroth you must appeal.
“And leave Bëor trammeled like an enemy amid these webs?” Finrod’s grip tightened about Balan’s arm.
“Nay, I give you my word that your companion will be escorted in safety to the banks of Sirion.”
“Then escort us together, for I count myself a stranger too in any land where he is unwelcomed.”
“If such is your posture, then your road ends here before me,” Mablung said, but his face clouded and for a moment the formality gave way. “Though it grieves me to be thus set against thee, Angolodh.”
“And it grieves thee not to be appointed an unjust enforcer?”
“I am a servant of the king.” The familiarity was gone at once and Mablung’s demeanor grew stern. “Not an advisor to pass judgment on my lord’s command.”
“Perhaps not. But to my own will I hold.” Finrod held out his hand and Váya crossed the green to brush her nose against his palm and stand ready at his side. Yet at the touch, regret seemed to wake within him and he turned back to Mablung with a penitent grimace. “Forgive me, I have spoken harshly in my anger, but I hold no grievance with thee for thy duty. We take our leave willingly.”
“Hold a moment,” Balan drew Finrod back when he moved to mount his horse. “Forgive me this brief discourtesy,” he murmured with a quick glance toward Mablung, then slipped into his own tongue as he turned back to the king. “Do not be rash in this. And don’t snort, my lord condescension, as though I cannot see the risk—you break with him if you depart this way. My pride is not equal to what the loss of this allegiance would cost you.”
“Yet the pride is more dear to me.”
“And is it my pride or yours?” His voice was sharp, but a ghost of amusement played at the corners of his mouth. “Mine is a fair cost to keep you in his goodwill.”
“Should I wish the goodwill of one who bars you at his gates?”
“Aye, if it is in my interest.” Balan was quiet for a moment. “My people live on his borders, Nóm, in ever increasing numbers. Who will mediate between us if you break with Thingol now? Shall we do it ourselves, shouting peace from his borders and hoping our words reach through the trees? Or shall it be your other kin—those who name us Engwar, Apanóar, Usurpers? And who, I might add, are also barred from his gates?”
“Vinegar is sweeter on the tongue than your wisdom,” Finrod snipped, turning away toward the brook, then he raked his fingers through his hair and grimaced in resignation. “I choke upon it but must nonetheless confess its merit.”
“And spoiled wine more savory than your praise,” Balan retorted with a chuckle before returning to the Elven tongue. “Go, lord, and see your errand through. Hear his grievances, however unearned, and I will ride ahead and await you at Estolad.” Then turning toward Mablung, he crossed his arms over his chest and bowed. “Bear my greetings to your lord—both my own and on behalf of my people. And if you will, bear too my promise of our lasting goodwill, and the hope to one day greet him with my own words, whether within his borders or without.”
“It shall be done.”
Finrod’s hand moved up to rest at the nape of Balan’s neck, as when he had led him through the darkness of the Annon Aearon, and there was now a fierce protectiveness in the touch. “I’ll not have thee cast out to hazard the leagues alone.”
“I will go with him.” Gildor urged his horse forward to join them in the clearing. “For I too find myself little minded to tread those paths my friend is denied.”
The king looked from one to the other, then turned to Balan with a tone of grudging acquiescence. “Thou art satisfied with this?”
“Aye. My pride is stung, but my dignity unharmed. I will go to my sons.”
Finrod watched him in silence for a long moment, then at last he sighed and turned back toward the Marchwardens. “Very well. If Bëor is content with such an arrangement, then I hold myself answered and will seek your lord in Menegroth—that I might learn what charges lie at the root of his counsel.” For a moment his grip tightened on Balan’s shoulders and again he shifted to Taliska. “Go with caution, Balan, though the lands from here to the ferries are well preserved. Loth am I to send you where I cannot see to your wellbeing.”
“Nigh fifty years of the sun I wandered ere I had you as guard dog,” Balan retorted with a chuckle. “I won’t melt away the moment I’ve gone from your sight.”
“Ride with vigilance nonetheless.” He held himself carefully detached, one hand loose at his side, the other shifting from Balan’s neck to rest upon the hilt of his sword. “For my sake,” he added and again reached for the other’s heart, drawing it close and tangled into his own, and Balan nodded.
“I’ll await you beside the Celon,” he said—a brief tease of memory, the hint of a grin. “Do not tarry overlong.”
“I will not. Balan—” he broke off and pressed his lips together as the other drew Elmorë forward and swung into the saddle.
“Ghomenno?” The old merriment danced in his eyes and he turned back, looking down at the king.
Finrod found his own words had fled and he stood motionless, heart burning beneath the other’s gaze. “May goodness keep you,” he managed at last, the formal Taliska heavy upon his tongue, and set his hand briefly against Balan’s knee, “and mercy preserve you.” Then he stepped back as Gildor’s horse moved forward through the shallow water and Balan guided Elmorë swiftly in his wake.
“And may the stars shine upon the end of thy road,” Balan called over his shoulder, echoing the king’s solemnity with a quick smile, then the trees wrapped in about him and he was gone.
❈❈❈
Light blazed from the branches overhead, stone-carved and glistening, and an illusion of breeze rustled their stems as Finrod strode between the columns. The fountains were laughing, he thought, pleased and chuckling with their master’s edicts even as the birds, perched in the boughs above the queen’s head, sang in mockery that same melody which sent Balan stumbling from his side. He skirted the last fountain and drew up abruptly before the dais.
“Thou art wroth with me, kinsman.”
“Yes, lord.” Finrod’s eyes blazed as he dipped a shallow bow before the king’s chair.
“And what ill have I done thee, son of the Ñoldor, that you have come hither so burdened with ire and speak in accusation before my throne?”
“None, lord. But by your order a dear friend was turned from these borders—and for no offense but that his blood differs from yours.”
“From thine as well.” The hint of a smile crossed the king’s face and his tone was near teasing. “Or hast thou forgotten of which children thou art?”
“I admit not such bounds upon courtesy.”
“No indeed. Thine ire in defense of these children of the sun is more by far than thou didst show when twas thine own kin and self turned away.”
“And justly so, lord.” Finrod’s hands clenched involuntarily at his sides as the nightingales began their song anew. “No shade of wrong have Bëor’s people done against you, nor against any of your people. They have come peaceably into Beleriand and dwell willingly within those bounds your edicts have set. For what cause, then, have you named them in enmity?”
The silence stretched as Thingol’s eyes rested upon him, but when the king spoke again his voice struck a tone near pity. “Tell me. What knowledge hast thou of what passes beyond the Ered Luin?”
“Much. I have spoken long with Bëor on matters that—”
“Of thine own people, Angolodh. Whom among ye have sojourned there or have spoken in counsel with those who do?”
“Bëor’s people are my own, sworn to me and I to them.”
“And what dost thou know of them, save by their own telling?” Elu’s voice remained soft, despite the flash of fury upon his kinsman’s face. “Many of the Quendi who remained in the East were of my people first, and messages pass between us still, even in these perilous times—thy missives of the apanóar were not the first to reach my ear. They are not as thine open-heartedness would see them.”
“Nor am I a green shoot to be so easily beguiled. I have dwelt among them, and for nigh two years Bëor has walked at my side—long by their people’s reckoning. Wherefore should I give credence to rumor when by the witness of my eyes and heart I know it to be false?”
“He has not told thee, then, that they worship what we hold in enmity? Or that such worship has defiled them, turned them Man against Man till they spill each other’s blood like water and drain all kinship into the parched and thirsting earth?”
“He has told me indeed of their strife, for among those it claimed were some most dear to him. And of the darkness that lies behind this, he…” Here for a moment Finrod faltered. What did he know, in truth, save that Balan could not—or would not—impart the tale? We have turned our backs upon it, and we do not desire to return there even in thought. “I know that they flee it,” he finished at last.
“The hare is fodder who trusts the jackal’s word.”
“And by such reasoning have we become jackals to our own lost and shunned those few who escape the Hells of Iron.”
“Am I answerable to thee, Angolodh, for how I mind my own doors?”
“I am answerable to Bëor’s people.”
“Thou art answerable to Elu Thingol while sojourning in his halls.”
A hush drifted over the merry clamor as the two held each other’s eye in silence, their wills’ clash running like the taste of lightening through the hall. For long minutes they remained so, till at last the king’s manner shifted and he rose, descending the dais to stand before Finrod, tall and imposing and looking down at him in chilly compassion.
“Thou art young yet, Eärwenion,” he said after a long pause, and laid a hand upon the other’s shoulder, “and youth’s blood runs hot. Go now in peace. Rest awhile and we will speak again on the morrow when tempers have cooled.”
Finrod’s eyes flashed and his lips parted in retort, but a cool touch pressed against his thought and he felt the words evaporate as quickly as they rose.
“Come, Ingoldo.” Galadriel slipped her hand within the crook of his arm and drew him back. “I will go with thee.”
He would have held despite this, locked still in strife with the king’s gaze, but his sister’s grip tightened about his arm and with it he found he was master of his fury once more. “As you say, lord. I am weary from the road and my temper runs thin.” His bow was formal now and deep with all the marks of deference, but as he rose, the queen’s gaze caught his own and he faltered, transfixed. They were uncanny, Melian’s eyes, wide like a bird’s with irises shifting in hues of green and brown, and to his surprise there was recognition in their depths. A sharp, unexpected stab of pity.
For a moment he was left shaken, but his sister’s thought pressed in again and he thrust the puzzle aside for another hour, and returned his gaze to the king’s. “I thank you for your forbearance,” he said, then bowed to the queen in turn and let Galadriel lead him out from the hall.
❈❈❈
“Supercilious pretense…” Finrod paced from one end of the room to the other as the attendants set the final tray upon the table and closed the door behind them. “Arrogance! Am I a child to be sent away for cakes and shushed into bed?”
“Canst thou deny it would do thee good?” Galadriel cut a slice from the nearest and glanced up at him with an arched brow as she moved it onto a plate.
“I am master of my realm as much as he of his.”
“And in his realm thou art.”
“As lord to lord we have ever spoken—king to king—and now he would make of me some petulant boy to be placated.” He yanked a chair from the table and sat, glowering at the slice of honey cake that Galadriel slid across the table. “My grievance is just. He condemns them on hearsay and punishes them for crimes that are not their own.”
“His caution is not groundless.” She retrieved a decanter of wine and began to fill the two chalices resting beside the trays. “There are tales from the East—I too have heard the Moriquendi speak and found no lie in their messengers’ eyes—and indeed there is some darkness that lurks with the Secondborn. The Night-fearers, they name them, and it is Elu’s own fear that Men have already proven themselves weak and more easily swayed to the Darkness’ will, that he shelters vipers at his flank.”
“And what is that but the Foe’s council in another guise? Twas Morgoth who whispered such poisoned honey in our own ears—the Third Theme embodied, short-lived and malleable. Easily swayed. Feckless.” He took the cup she offered and gripped its stem till the pattern marked his skin like a brand. “I’ll have none of it,” he said, then drank.
“Eat once of a rotten fruit and the hand is slow to the tree thereafter?”
“The hand is slow when the eye sights the same worm in the orchard.” He broke a bite from the slice of honey cake, chewing sharply as though begrudging its pleasant flavor. “Balan is no servant of the darkness. Twice the seasons have spun their dance in the time I’ve dwelt alongside him. His heart is true—as are the hearts of his people.” Finrod trailed off as he lifted another bite from the plate and let it linger this time upon his tongue. He had found naught but a haze each time he reached for the other since parting amid the Girdle’s mirage, and Balan’s absence had lodged like a sharp hunger in his gut. He did not like the thought of him returning to Estolad alone. It prickled at a small, frightened part of him, the wariness that still watched from the corner of his eye, wondering whether this river or that, tomorrow’s dawn or the following would be the one where Balan took the road leading from him.
But nay, that was Ivrin’s fear. It was the dove’s message that drew Balan back to Estolad now, not a rift between his heart and the king’s. The bird had arrived on Sirion’s isle a fortnight past with a dispatch from Meril—the messengers that passed between Estolad and the Narog had brought word that their chieftain would wed at midsummer. Balan’s face had been a mask when Finrod read the missive aloud, but in council the next morning he had queried whether his lord might release him for a short time that he might try the journey and learn whether his presence was welcomed. His lord would not, Finrod had rejoined with a quick smile, for it was to Estolad that his own road now lead. He had never witnessed an Atani marriage—did Balan imagine he would pass an opportunity to learn of their rites? And so they had ridden out when midsummer drew nigh: Balan, the king and his Guard, Sídhon as attendant, and Gildor who had grown close in friendship with Belen during his sojourn in Nargothrond. He was glad of it, Balan had confessed on the eve of their departure, glad to return as he had departed, with Nóm at his side, that he needn’t face the reunion alone.
Finrod’s anger blazed again. Yet here he was, caught in the webs of politics while Balan rode on in need of him.
Would the journey be kind? Would Baran?
More in reflex than in hope, he stretched out a tendril of thought, beckoning after the other. And to his surprise, there was a brush of familiarity amid the fog. His heart leapt even as the haze settled in once more and stillness rushed over his soul like warmth returning to limbs. It had recentered him, that brief touch; the steady assurance of Balan’s heart against his own grounding this restless fury.
What was it he had said to Aechenon on Sirion’s isle? His heart had ached after Balan then as well, the other’s laughter bright beneath the red and gold of Anar’s descent…and Finrod had lifted an eyebrow and retorted that it is the mainstay that anchors the mast through the gale.
“Where is Celeborn?” he asked abruptly, only now remembering that he was not alone. “I saw him not among those gathered in the hall.”
“He is with Beleg along the eastern marches.” Galadriel had nearly finished the slice upon her own plate and was watching him with a singular expression. “There have been roving wolves of late, north of Arthórien, and they have ridden to the hunt.”
“North of Arthórien?”
“Put thy worry to rest.” Her lips turned in amusement. “They will root them out long ere they might cross the Celon.”
Finrod frowned. He should have anticipated the ease with which his sister would pluck out his thoughts and turn them over in the sharp light of her curiosity. In the past it had comforted him to be so incisively known—seen and teased and understood. Now he batted her away.
But she laughed at this sudden prickliness and her smile was warm. “Poor Ingo, thy patience is tried enough already. I shall tease thee no more.”
“Whyever not?” Lúthien’s voice tripped toward them along the stone, bright with amusement, and both Finrod and Galadriel turned sharply toward the door. She must have entered sometime while they spoke—for she stood well within the room now, watching them with sparkling eyes, but neither had perceived the slightest movement. Not for the first time, Finrod found himself half-pondering whether her mother had bequeathed some ability to pass through the stone unseen. She crossed and kissed him lightly on each cheek. “I am sorry I was not in the hall to ease thy welcome.”
“To ease my welcome or to witness it with thine own ears?” he queried, returning her greeting with a smile, and Lúthien laughed.
“I see thy tongue’s blade has been left unsheathed,” she retorted, then moved to the divan and sat, drawing her legs up beside her and lifting a quizzical brow. “Who has mistaken thee for a sheep, cousin? Thou art quite shorn.”
“Indeed, the Foe strikes ever at that which is most dear to us.”
“Come now, Ingo,” Galadriel cut another slice from the cake with a sidelong smile and divided it between the plates, “there are ills aplenty to lay at the feet of the glamhoth without adding thy braids to the tally. Twas thine own recklessness wielding the shears.”
“I spoke not of the hair,” Finrod protested, laughing as he leaned forward to refill his cup. “And how camest thou to know of it?”
“I know of all thy follies, brother.”
“Dread thought!” He reclined in the chair once more, sipping from his wine, and met her eye with a grin. “But how, in truth?”
“Edhellos writes.” Galadriel admitted, shifting to the Sindarin form in Lúthien’s presence, and her glance at him was affectionate. “Her last spoke much of the skirmish—and of this anorhín who drew thee to it.”
“Now thine own words lay blame where none is owed. Twas my negligence set him in their hands and no fault of his own.”
“I recant,” cried Galadriel laughing, “I recant! Now let us leave it be ere I become the next in these caverns thy tongue seeks to flay.”
“Nay, tell on,” Lúthien interjected, “for I would know of them as well.”
“My follies?” he asked with a quick smile.
“The anorhíni. Do not willfully misunderstand me.”
Finrod laughed and took another sip of wine. “Thou wouldst set me further afoul of the king, cousin.”
“Say rather I would set myself in that knowledge from which he seeks to shield me.”
She held his eye with a peculiar smile and, as in the hall when his gaze had met the queen’s, he knew again that brief brush of affinity—only now the surprise and recognition were his own, and instead of pity, he felt a burning, eager curiosity echoing back from Melian’s daughter. It unnerved him, this sense of kinship, muddled and loose. A ripple from a stone lying yet upon the palm.
“Thou art my window beyond the eaves, Finrod.” Lúthien’s voice broke through his reverie, bright and sure of her success. “Let me see these Children through thine eyes.”
“Very well,” he said at last, and tried to dismiss the chill trickling down his spine. “There are few, I think, who could ever find it in their strength to deny thee. What is it thou wouldst have me tell?”
“All,” she said, her smile alight with mischief. “But for tonight I will content myself with generalities. What kind of folk are they?”
“They are…” Finrod paused again, brows furrowed as he let himself slip into the memory of Estolad, then further still to a moonlit glade beside Thalos. “They are a solid people, like the earth itself, steady and warm and burning so fiercely with life that it took my breath when first I knew them. They slept while I wove my steps between their huddled figures, but even so the glade pulsed with it still. Like midsummer’s sun against flesh—or the scent of loam, fresh-turned and teeming with the life it could hold.”
He fell quiet for a moment and his eyes were distant as he walked again through the woodland and saw their forms spread out around him, familiar now and beloved, with each bundle now recognizable—Eimet snoring a short distance from the dying fire, Hathus curled in the shelter of his cart, a spear planted in the earth beside him and one arm draped over Gelvira’s hip, Weiv a stone’s throw from them, Masci beyond, unmistakable with his shock of red hair and missing leg. Finrod had lowered himself to the grass beside the coals, had lifted a small harp from where it lay upon the earth. The wood was carved with little skill, but use had worn it smooth and it rested comfortably against his palm—and it too hummed with the same vibrant heat; a summons, a hunger, a warning. It drew his fingers irresistibly along the strings, drew his voice alongside the melody, drew his eyes once again to the clustered figures.
A tousled bundle near the embers holding its blanket bunched about the ears: Baran attempting to block out Eimet’s snores. Then a smaller bundle beside him, the cloth brightly woven with embroidery dancing about its edges; Belen’s work—and Belen himself, childlike in his slumber and curled against the nearest bundle which had already begun to shift, which turned and lifted its head and looked into his eyes.
Finrod’s heart was pounding and he felt Lúthien’s gaze resting upon him, curious and canny; he felt his sister’s too, though toward this he dared not look from fear of learning what of his thought she had already seen. Instead, he smiled and met the query in his cousin’s eye.
“They are defiant too, proud and steadfast when they have chosen their way. Stubborn to a fault,” he added with a chuckle, “but with a deep wellspring of loyalty and love that I confess has been a balm to my heart. And yet for all that, they burn up like leaves set to the hearth—a swift light, blinding like the new sunrise, and racing on in its arc to the west.”
“My father thinks it their own doing.” Lúthien rose and lifted Finrod’s chalice from the table. “May I?” she asked, then returned with it to the divan before receiving an answer, curling once more into the cushions and sipping from the wine. “He calls them the Self-cursed.”
“Tis thine, an thou wilt.” A smile played at his lips as Galadriel slid her own chalice to rest in the space between them and he leaned back, his fingers tracing along the grains of wood. "But why should he believe their brevity to be aught but their given nature? The beasts and the grasses—yea, even those beeches and nightingales of Neldoreth that so snared our path—are numbered in their seasons and years. Why then should we deem it otherwise when found amongst our kin?”
“He has been told a shadow stalks in their wake.”
“And voices from the east carry rumor of their ill doings—I too have heard him say it.” Finrod reached absently for his sister’s cup and took a deep draught from the remaining wine. “Not all voices of warning speak truth,” he said at last. “Nor is it always certain that a whole people must be held guilty for a faction’s crimes.”
Galadriel’s glance at him was sharp and he felt the flicker of warning against his thought.
“Is it not more likely,” he pressed on despite this, “that it is the Shadow itself who weaves such lies to set enmity between the First and Secondborn? We have seen it here as well, and in Aman—the grains of truth kneaded in amongst the poison, that its taste might seem palatable upon the tongue.”
“So thou hast surmised already,” interjected Galadriel, retrieving her chalice and refilling it from the decanter. “But ill news is not always the work of the Shadow. Do not be so quick to dismiss caution for friendship’s sake.”
“Or friendship for caution’s sake.” He felt Lúthien’s eyes turn on him again as he spoke and his skin prickled under the acuity of her gaze. She had reached out this time in thought as well, the presence of her mind resting like a cool palm against his own, turning it in fascination that she might examine each facet. For a moment reflex drew him back, but her touch followed after him, swift and curious, and as ever he found himself bowing to her wish, and he let the barriers drop.
She darted in at once, a quick brush here, a query there, whirling through his memories with dizzying speed as she gleaned every vision of Estolad, studying each face as her thought stepped in time with the rhythm of their midsummer dances, as she listened rapt alongside him to the benedictions of the Longest Night.
Again he was shaken by the wash of affinity as she moved through his mind, and again he felt the gnawing unease creep behind his ears. Her delving had paused before an image of Balan’s face, shining silver in the moonlight, and upon this memory she lingered longest—confound her, she knew at once that he held this dearer than any of the others—until at last, hesitantly, Finrod offered her the voice as well: Balan’s laughter in the woods, the warmth of his accent rolling Elven words upon his tongue.
“It is not unfounded counsel,” his sister had continued while Lúthien passed through his mind. “Or at least not in all aspects. The eboennin too receive protection from the Girdle—which doubtless was thine intent in planting them close within the bend of the river—but so far they have done little in Doriath’s eyes to earn such shelter. By granting them those lands which ere our people’s return were counted his own, Elu deems his hospitality sufficient already for what they have shown in return.”
“Tell me,” said Finrod, and his voice had grown tight, “for I have had no word of it: when have the lords of Beleriand ruled that safety from the dark lord should be an earned right?”
“The lords of Beleriand have ruled naught save for the Eldar. And many would say thou dost presume much to hold our mores applied to the eboennin.”
“Are they too not Eruhin, even as we?”
“I did not say that I held it a presumption.”
“He has had dreams.” Lúthien did not shift her eyes as she spoke and Finrod looked at her askance, thinking for a moment that she spoke his own mind aloud until she continued. “Dreams of the Secondborn, and what they herald. He will not speak to me of their nature, but they trouble him more than the rumors from the East.”
“The tread of Doom, the dirge’s call…” Finrod trailed off into silence, then took another sip from his sister’s cup and a mirthless chuckle slipped from his lips. “Does he imagine that only he is visited by such portents?”
“Ingo?” Galadriel’s features grew sharp.
But Finrod waved his hand dismissively. “Orë úna sossë,” he murmured, forgetting himself for a moment in the tangle of thought, then glanced at Lúthien in quick apology for the lapse.
“Once before I have heard thee speak in such a tone,” Galadriel added in a low voice, ignoring the maxim and returning instead to his former words, “and then, as now, I found myself filled with dread. Say it plainly if thou art to hint in this way.”
For a moment he hesitated, the unease huddled thick against his lungs, but at last he shook his head and passed the cup back to his sister. “Nay, it is but weariness turned to words—the day’s frustrations have left me maudlin and I fear I am no fit company.” He drew his hands along his face and at last managed a smile. “But do not let my poor temper set thee to worry, Nerwen. Join me again on the morrow and I will be more amiable. My word on it.”
“And to it I shall hold thee.” Galadriel rose and refilled her chalice, then leaned down to kiss the top of his head. “Dear fool,” she said, and brushed her free hand through the cropped gold, tugging lightly at the shorn ends. “I would have been very cross with thee hadst thou ended thus.”
He laughed and caught her hand affectionately in his own. “This I knew—and dared not risk thine ire.”
“May that fear at least be indeed thine heart’s counsel,” she retorted and set her palm lightly against his cheek, then retrieved the cup of wine and crossed toward the door.
Lúthien delayed for a moment longer, her eyes meeting his once more as she dipped a final plunge through his thought. Then she too rose and moved to depart, and he shivered as her mind withdrew from him.
“Whatever Doom there is,” Finrod’s voice drifted after her, little more than a murmur as they passed through the archway, “it will find us whether we flee it or no. And I would meet it with my conscience clean.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
lest melian: [S] the Girdle of Melian
eboennin/abonnen: [S] After-born
engwar: [Q] Men, (lit.) The Sickly
apanóar: [Q] the After-born
Annon Aearon: [S] the gate of the sea (see Children of the Sun)
yrch: [S] Orcs/host of Orcs
anorhín/anorhíni: [S] child/children of the Sun
orë úna sossë: [Q] the guidance of the heart is not fear
MISC NOTES
- Edhellos is the Sindarin form of Eldalótë
20. Far Have You Roamed
Balan felt a twinge in his chest as he looked out over them, first of pride in his son’s work, and then of loss—that this land which held his early love for Nóm had been changed now beyond return.
Bëor and Gildor travel to Estolad while Finrod is occupied in Doriath. The two discuss their similar griefs and Bëor must face seeing his people - and his eldest son - for the first time since passing down the clan's leadership.
Read 20. Far Have You Roamed

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
Estolad
The fields stretched out before them, a sea of purple rippling against their horses’ legs. They had been golden the first time he saw them, when his people threaded their way along the faint trails with Nóm at their head—his own gold blending with the sunset and the rolling flax, as though all the world had turned molten. Balan walked in awe at his side then, Baran at his right, and the hope dancing before them had leapt forward in this same vast, unending expanse.
But it was blooming flax that swayed in the breeze as he and Gildor rode through the meadows, and the barley was now a swath of green.
And beyond that, the palisade cut a dark line against the river.
Balan drew a hand along his face. A cold knot had settled in the pit of his stomach, growing ever tighter as they moved across the plains—and there was another league still, or more, of riding in full view of the settlement before he would learn what form of his son awaited him. He shuddered and shifted in the saddle.
They had camped beside Aros and Celon the previous night and in the gloaming beside the rivers’ confluence he had plunged both head and shoulders beneath the current, scrubbing the dust and sweat from his scalp and lingering till his breath was gone; then he rose up, gasping, with Celon’s water once again running down across his lips.
There was an outcropping of rock at the intersection point, a line of jagged knots like the spine of some ancient sea-beast, curled at the meeting of the rivers. An unnerving thing to set their camp beside, he joked when Nóm had chosen the place on the journey west. It unnerved him still more on a second viewing. Like so much of this path it was a mirror of that former road, glimpses of his departure reflected as Elmorë’s feet retraced their steps and drew him ever nearer the fields of Estolad. Hunger for that reunion consumed him; dread of it ran through his every fiber.
Would he know his son still? Or would the year’s absence have frozen that parting shock into estrangement?
It had been on that same riverbank where he remembered the little otter, his legs dangled in that same current when the gasping remorse first washed over him. Or no, it had been further down the shore, by the carpet of moss where he nearly slipped when stumbling from the waterside in search of the toy. It had been Nóm who sat where Balan plunged his head into the river, and the grey eyes had danced bright alongside the sun’s reflection while he drew handfuls of water to wet and braid his hair. It had been Nóm whose arms wrapped about him through the long night and held the shattering at bay. And it was Nóm whose embrace was far from him now, arms and heart alike shrouded behind the giddy haze of Doriath.
He shivered and shifted in the saddle. It had been a relief that morning when they turned into the river bend and were at last out from the shadow of those eaves. All the days they rode along the Aros, he had felt that the trees were watching him, looming from the far side of the river and leaving the back of his neck prickling. He had scowled across the water at their boughs, glaring as though his sheer indignation might force them to yield and return the king to his side.
“Ingoldo has told me that we bear a similar wound.” Gildor’s voice was quiet as it broke through his reverie, hesitant but tumbling swift along the breeze and Balan glanced toward him in query. His companion’s knuckles were white about his horse’s reins and his eyes were fixed on the settlement, gauging its distance with the air of one who, having steeled himself for a conversation nevertheless delays it until the last possible moment. “That is, he has told me your parents too were taken from you,” he murmured in hasty clarification, then the grey eyes flickered and glanced over to meet his own. “I hope he did not trespass upon your confidence in the telling?”
“Nay, not a bit of it.” Balan slowed Elmorë’s gait and held his eye with a reassuring smile. The boy looked lost against the wide expanse, small and forlorn despite the confidence of his seat—a boy he ever thought him, though Gildor too had known the world ere Balan’s own kind awakened—and he felt the urge to reach out and rest a hand in comfort upon the nape of his neck, as though Gildor was one of his sons. “I was older by my people’s reckoning than you by yours,” he said quietly as Gildor dropped his own horse’s pace to match, “less than a year shy of my apfsael—how would you call it, a coming of age perhaps? It is the rite by which my people mark our passage out of childhood or into full membership within the clan.”
“Yes, we would call it so.” Gildor hesitated as though a further question lingered, but no words formed and he pressed his lips together once more.
“My people dwell in many factions east of the mountains,” Balan said after a pause, answering what was not asked, and he drew back on the reins to slow their pace even further, “some nomadic as we’ve been, others who held in fixed villages and lands since before I knew the world; and there is strife between many of them. My own people had taken a rest from our wanderings and dwelt for a time in the same valley. It must have been nearly a decade all told—the last of my childhood and all of my adolescence—and I find those tall grasses and ash trees still sway through my dreams. I’d gone with my uncle one morning to trade with another clan on the far side of the fell, and as we climbed it again that evening, we saw the clouds glowing red in the dusk. We thought it was the brush of sunset at first and marveled at its beauty, but it wasn’t long before we scented the smoke and knew it for what it was.” He fell quiet for a moment, then continued on with an effort. “It was a party of raiders, we guessed, some one of the roving bands that lived on pillaging, though we never learned for certain. They’d plundered the village and made off with whatever animals they didn’t kill, then fired the unharvested crops and left the village to burn with the dead. By the time we reached it, the fires raged too tall for us to do anything but sit through the night and watch while it all fell to ash. By morning, the remainder of our folk had found us and we passed through the embers together, salvaging what little remained—mostly bones, collected and named where possible, then laid to rest in the meadow beside the stream. I was never certain which were my father’s, but we found his knife and his ring in the rubble and knew he must have been among those we buried. I still wear them,” he added, laying one hand upon the ox horn hilt at his waist and raising the other to indicate the iron band about his middle finger. “My mother’s body was outside our home, burned, but there were two garnet earrings with the body and so we knew her. After that, we never held permanent dwellings—we might remain a year or two in one place, but rarely any longer than that, not till Nóm found us and stilled our feet here beside the Celon.” The calls of linnets warbled in the flax around them and Balan watched as a murmuration passed winding toward the river. Then after a moment he added in a near-whisper, “It never eases, does it?”
“No,” Gildor said. “It does not.”
They were quiet again, then after a time Balan ventured tentatively, “Do you think of it often?”
Gildor hesitated, then nodded. “I lived only because they lay on either side of me.” His fingers continued to fiddle at the reins—an echo of the king, Balan noted with affection—and his voice grew tight as he pressed on. “They slipped from me while I slept on, sheltered by their warmth, and I knew it not till the sounds of the readying host woke me. Even then I did not believe it, or rather I refused to let myself consider it. Their faces were so peaceful that I thought…I clung to the hope that so long as I did not move or try to wake them, I could believe them sleeping still.” He paused to let the wind pass through his lungs, steadying him as his hands returned to their restless pattern. “It was Ingoldo’s cry that broke the illusion. He had come to seek my father when we were not among the others of our company and of course he knew the truth of it at once.”
“Yes, he has told me of it,” Balan stepped in when Gildor’s words faltered, “and of the years that followed. No child should ever find themselves in such a place,” he added, thinking of Baran’s hands gripping the rough-hewn pole of Esrid’s bier, and his eyes fell again on the nearing settlement. Would Baran have heard by now of his approach? Would he be waiting at the barrier to greet him? Or, more likely, would he remain in the Hall, chieftain instead of son, a lord awaiting his vassal’s report?
“I have been angry now for many years.” Gildor’s voice held all the bitterness Balan dared not utter, and he shuddered to feel it resonate through his bones. “Others I knew lost one parent or the other on the ice, but how could both have gone from me at once? Did one spirit feel the other’s departure and follow for love of it? Did mine, lingering in the exile they chose, bear no staying weight?”
Balan’s heart blenched and he shifted in the saddle. This is the whim you choose above your sons? Above your duty? Estreth’s voice cut through his memory, sharp as the day he walked out through these same fields, and he felt a twinge of affinity with Inglor’s corpse upon the ice. If it lay within his power, would he not follow Nóm’s spirit too on whatever road it led? Would he remember to reckon first the tally of what he left?
“Can you remember them?” The question pulled him back from his brooding, the earnest curiosity of Gildor’s demeanor once more reminding him of his own youngest son.
“My mother and father? Aye, though not as I once did. There are many ways I carry them with me—my father’s ring and knife as I told you, my mother’s knowledge. She was among the Wise of my people and taught me all I know of our lore, including the story of Aelthes that you favor, and nearly all those I’ve passed on to my lord. But now…well, now I find their memories have gone slippery. I see them in snatches at the corners of my eyes, but they fade when I turn toward them, or if I look too closely at their faces, there’s nothing but a blur.” He paused for a moment, then glanced at the sharp profile outlined against the sunset beside him. “Can you?”
“Not as I would. I have scattered recollections, like shards of a painted glass, but that is not as my people are meant to remember—holding the past pristine, treasuring what is gone and bearing its living memory forward through the years. But I remember warmth. Music. My father singing. He sang often before the Darkening, but my mother would only hum while about her work, the melody like bees buzzing through a garden, ever present and weaving in and out with the rhythm of her hammer. She was a stone carver, which is how she knew my father, for Ingo met her while about his own learning and my father would visit while he worked.” The brittle melancholy seemed to have eased as they spoke and a laugh escaped him. “And now I’ve shown you my hypocrisy—for they left Aman as much for Ingoldo’s sake as from any rebellion of their own, and yet my anger does not burn toward him. It will in its time, he tells me, but I believe him not.”
Balan chuckled. “Nor will my own fury hold long against him—no matter how he might provoke it.”
Gildor snorted. “Sorely indeed, I should think.”
“Should you, lad?” Balan glanced at him in amusement, a brow lifted in query. “And how so?”
To this he received only another laugh in reply, silvery and melodious and melding into song as the other trotted ahead, his voice trailing back in the breeze,
“O! Merry is love
and sweet is its physic
in spring by the waters,
in summer’s sweet music.
O! Tarry not, heart,
but join in the singing:
the water is warm,
the music is ringing!
O! Why is he brooding,
the king in his chambers?
Wherefore is he—“
“Impertinent cub!” Balan cut him off hastily. “My lord should set you as jester,” he added with a laugh, then yielded at last to familiarity and cuffed him lightly as he would Baran or Belen. “You’ve a pungent enough wit.” But despite his grin, Balan’s face had gone ruddy at the last stanza and he loosed Elmorë into a swift canter before the melody could resume, Gildor’s laughter rippling after him once again as his own horse leapt forward to keep pace.
Acid shot through his stomach at the realization that the other was privy to the truth and he felt his ears burning with the shame of the spurned. For Gildor knew that truth as well if he had paired it thus with sorely provoked fury. Impertinent indeed, he thought again, and hoped the galloping wind had eased the unwonted color in his cheeks. And did Nóm realize his foster-son knew of the infatuation? Surely not, he concluded, recalling the haste with which he had ever released him whenever Gildor or one of the others drew near—and for a moment found his heart touched that the boy was free with him in ways he dared not tease the king.
The low palisade was clear before them now as their horses flew forward through the linseed blossoms, for in his haste to avoid the remainder of the song, Balan had forgotten his apprehension and already they had nearly overtaken the bordering stream. It glistened in the falling sun, light dancing from every ripple, and in the shallows alongside the ford a group of children were playing, kicking great splashes and shrieking with laughter as they chased each other through the water. The light danced upon them as well, shimmering like gems from the droplets caught within their hair. Was the foremost there Sichar’s boy? He could not be, surely. Hûl had hardly reached Balan’s hip when he rode out from Estolad the previous spring and this lanky child was nearly as tall as Avina. But nay, he could see that it was, and that must be his younger brother beside him—a babe in arms when he had left. Avina too retained little of the round-faced child he remembered from that first winter beside the Celon.
“Dára!” She had sighted him now and waved her arms in excitement, splashing toward the path as the horses approached. “Dar Bëor!”
“Haelis, Avina!” Balan lifted his hand toward her in return as he slowed Elmorë to a trot and passed into the ford. “Hûl!” He smiled again as Sichar’s boy ran to join her. “Sama goleins.”
“Sama goleins, dára.”
Balan’s throat tightened at their greetings and he urged Elmorë forward onto the bank before they saw the sudden wash of feeling across his face. Baran and Belen had run in this same play through streams long gone from his recollection, Sichar and Galla chasing at their heels and little Sabil watching in disapproval from the shore. Now Sichar’s sons splashed through the ankle-deep water and Sabil was to wed with his own.
“Haelis, Esa!” he called back over his shoulder to the third child, then raised his palm again in parting as Gildor’s horse clambered up the bank after him and joined him on the well-trodden path. They were trotting past arrays of huts now, distributed throughout the nearer fields with crops and pens scattered in clusters around them. It was nearly unrecognizable from the hastily constructed encampment he remembered. Each plot was laid out along an orderly grid, weaving with the curves of the land, and the trailing creeks had been coaxed to run like veins between them. It was a marvel what Baran had managed in a turn of the seasons. Of course, the methodical structure was only true of these nearest the palisade, but already there were signs that work had begun to shape the further fields after the same design.
Balan felt a twinge in his chest as he looked out over them, first of pride in his son’s work, and then of loss—that this land which held his early love for Nóm had been changed now beyond return. It was strange, he thought, that what they saw before them should lie nearer to Gildor’s memory of Estolad than to his own. A shiver rolled along his shoulders and he was cold, even beneath the late evening sun.
This was to have been his own duty. He was meant to serve them till his final breath, as his father had done, as had his father’s father, as had all those who went before him.
Even the means of his return was wrong, drifting here upon the work of another’s legs. Where was the path against his feet? Where the ache in his heels, in the balls of his feet, in the depths of his hips? Where was Melishk’s voice guiding him from the trodden clay?
Balan drew back on the reins, slowing the stallion to a halt, then slipped from his back to let his soles meet the packed earth. “I’ve no grudge, you know, it’s only custom,” he murmured as he unhooked the halter and looped it among the saddle bags, even as Nóm had done when they set out a year before. “Come, night sky,” he added, reaching out to run a hand over the velvety nose, and the ghost of a smile played at his lips, “walk with me. We will return together as we left.”
It was steadying to have the ground beneath him, firm and familiar against his feet. He knew himself walking like this, his legs swinging easily into the old rhythm and dispelling the fear that this intoxication had muddled some core part of him. He wished now that he had carried Baran’s little otter with him instead of leaving it nestled on the shelf in Nargothrond, so that he might hold it in hand when he greeted his son, that Baran too might remember when he saw it clutched within his father’s palm. He shivered despite the evening’s warmth and clung to Nóm’s reassurances—other feuds had been mended before now, other sons had forgiven their fathers.
“I know that Belen did not tell me all.” His voice drifted out haltingly, his own delayed query now unavoidable, and Gildor glanced toward him in surprise. “I do not hold it against him, he was torn between loves and sought to spare me pain. But because of it I know little of how it stands with his brother.” He walked a few more paces in silence, then fixed his eyes on the ground ahead of him and pressed forward. “You’ve no cause to spare my heart, Gildor—tell me truly, what awaits me here?”
Gildor hesitated. “It is not my custom to bear tales,” he said at last, “and half-news is a dangerous gift, for oft is truth bent unwitting when one speaks outside the fullness of knowledge.”
“The king’s student indeed,” Balan chuckled, wry and resigned, and cast a sidelong grin at his companion.
“So I am.” Gildor’s own smile darted back in kind and there was sympathy in his gaze as he slid from his own horse’s back to walk beside him. “But it is for the king’s sake too that I will risk some small accounting, strange though that may seem. When I met him in the winter months, your son bore much anger, as I see in your face you have guessed already—both toward you for the initial break and, to a lesser extent, toward his brother for heeding your summons. I will not hide from you that they argued ere we set out, nor that Belen rode against his brother’s wishes.” Again he hesitated, and shifted uncomfortably as he walked. Then he seemed to come to a decision and filled his lungs, pressing on with an effort. “But if I am to speak thus plainly of his ire, I feel myself bound to speak too of what his brother told me on our road to Nargothrond, and it is in this that I fear I may break confidence. Yet to do otherwise is to leave you with a false understanding, and I deem that may cause the greater harm, for he told me that his brother’s grief was more plain in these arguments than his anger, that it was love for you that brought on his fury and that he had wept even as they quarreled—and indeed I can tell you of my own witness that there was no guile in his eye when he told Belen to greet you with his love. Be of good hope, my friend,” Gildor added when grief tightened across the other’s face. “Far deeper than this are the rifts that have been mended between father and son—it may be that winter’s anger too has been thawed with the spring. But now ask no more of me. Already I have spoken beyond what is prudent and my heart fears lest I set your path to ill through unwary speech.”
“I thank you, it is kindly said,” Balan managed at last, but his voice grew flat as they came around the last bend and the palisade gate lay in full view before them, and with it a cluster of people gathered upon the path—Eimet and Masci, Meyla and several others—shouting greetings as they approached. “But it is of no matter. He has not come, nor has his brother; and that, it seems, is to be my answer.”
“Bëor, that does not—”
But the other had already quickened his pace and was striding toward the little group, plunging his grief beneath the brightness of their welcome, arms flung wide and grinning despite himself as first one friend and then another pulled him into the riot of embraces. It was a clamor, merry and impossible to follow, and for a moment his melancholy was overrun by the exuberance of it. Meyla’s arms were about his neck now, a quick kiss on each cheek before she laughed and held him at arms length for inspection—as though she was aunt or mother and not his younger by two score years. Gods all, how long since his own tongue had been the common language about him? The wordplay of Eimet’s joke washed over him, warm as sunlight, and his heart ached at the sound. He was home, here amidst the cadence of his childhood, here in the rough affection of Masci’s grip upon his shoulder, in the damp splotch across his side where Avina’s sprint from the stream had caught up at last and collided against him in greeting.
He stammered out answers as best he could through the jumble and laughter, the steady stream of questions each layered incomprehensibly over the other and impossible to follow, till at last Eimet caught his arm and hauled him forward through the gate.
“Come, truant, you’ve dawdled long enough here. Baran will be in the Hall yet, I’d wager, and cross if he finds we’ve not brought him word.”
Balan’s face lifted. “He knows not that I’ve come?”
“Aye doubtless he knows, but not that you’ve reached the fence. Hûl!” he called as the boy ducked through the wicket and darted after Avina. “Come take their horses to water and bring the bags after us to the Hall. Follow me,” Eimet stepped aside, allowing the stallion to pass around them before drawing Balan onward, “though I dare say it’s not so much changed that you’ll have forgotten the way. You as well, my good princeling,” he added, beckoning to Gildor with a grin. “They’ll be relieved to learn this time you’ve brought back one of our own rather than summoning another away.”
“Small merit to me,” Gildor laughed in unsteady Taliska. “As Bëor’s friend I’ve ridden, not an overseer—he’d have come even without a shepherd.”
Eimet snorted and glanced at Balan with a sidelong grin. “Baran’s japes have long tongues.”
“Or my pride long ears.” Balan retorted with a mirrored chuckle, then blinked as the curve of the river flashed with the sunset’s reflection. The Celon! His pulse quickened to see it stretched there before him, rolling wide and supple through the meadow. Those fields at least had remained unchanged in the intervening months, the water’s green borders still waving in the breeze and summoning his heart to lie once more along the riverside, Nóm’s warmth beside him and the intoxication of a snowdrop’s fragrance dancing through his senses.
The lack of Nóm’s steady presence against his thought was an unlooked for consequence of their parted ways. It had faltered nearly as soon as he and Gildor bade the others farewell and grew fainter with each step toward the edge of the Girdle’s haze, till nothing was left at all, save a brief brush that first night. Lovers in soul…his spirit reached out in yearning. He felt unmoored without the other’s touch, dizzy, the foundation of his thought cold. It was unnerving to return here bearing that same gnawing emptiness that had plagued him in the weeks before his departure, and it was a conscious effort to hold down the rising dread that lurked in its wake.
He passed now through the rows of huts as one half in a dream. Some he knew at once, but a thicket of new structures had leapt up in the intervening year and left the settlement nearly unrecognizable. Here was one of the hastily erected storerooms, now turned to a shelter for some of the smaller herds. There a larger byre, which spoke to the new cattle Belen had told him drew their plows. And on this hither side, the little slope leading down to the well. The stone ledge had been built out to encompass the whole, the original wooden frame reinforced with rock and clay. Nóm’s carved hound remained, Balan noted with a smile and a quick stab of longing. The boulder had been shifted to make room for the new swath of paving stones, but its opened mouth still smiled, its tongue still lolled in search of the water trough.
And there was his own old hut. Balan’s stomach lurched as it came into view. It was little changed from what he could see, though it was flanked now by two sturdy structures, each more than twice its size. These were plank-walled rather than the woven hazel and daub that crafted the original settlement; and beneath the thatch of the nearest, skeins of freshly dyed wool had been strung from the eaves to dry, while on the perpendicular wall, madder-red linen flapped in the wind. Beyond this, piles of bulrushes had been laid out to dry on strung netting, and a boy was making his way along one edge, trimming the brown ends and cutting each to size.
Hathus’ forge was past these, and this too was as he remembered it—low mudbrick walls, the angled overhang which still sat cockeyed from the haste of its construction, a scattered array of tools hanging from the rafters. He clenched his jaw as a lump grew in his throat.
Eimet had been keeping up a steady stream of conversation while they walked and Balan found himself struggling to follow, nodding and mumbling brief replies as his eyes darted through the sprawling settlement. He gathered them hungrily, each detail he had hardly noticed throughout the previous decades, now desperately dear and filling his heart nearly to bursting.
His people. His home.
They had passed the forge now and were nearing the green, memory whispering up from the ground with every step—drums and bone flutes in the glow of the Longest Night, Estreth’s laughter, the arch of her brows wry then and not yet turned on him in fury, Belen leaping masked over the fires, his own joy to see him whole. Baran’s face in the firelight, boyish and smiling while Balan raised a cup in blessing…
Leader truly in spirit, as chieftain you shall be in blood. The lump in Balan’s throat grew thicker as he remembered the words rolling from his lips, the warmth of the spiced mead upon his tongue. Kind as you are valiant, son of my wandering.
His breath caught in a gasp. They had passed round the grandfather oak and the new Hall lay sprawling before them, tall and imposing against the darkening sky. The golden thatch shone red in the sunset’s last light and Balan found himself squinting against the brilliance as he stopped mid-step, staring at the structure before him in awe. They had built longhouses before in their wandering, indeed there had been one in the village where Balan spent his youth, but this was another thing entirely. It followed the same pattern as their earlier halls, but Baran had broadened it and introduced new height, adding a wide overhang as well that looped around the full perimeter. Sturdy trunks had been shaped into pillars along the edge of this and the two foremost, nearly twice the thickness of their fellows, showed the beginnings of carved patterns twisting about their circumference. It was majestic—and his heart strained with pride that none of it was of his own doing. Baran had designed it from the start. He had begged his father to be entrusted with the task when they first laid out the hasty settlement and worked all throughout the long first winter to lay out plans in the back corner of the little hut. But even the intricacy of those clay tablets had not prepared him for the detail and size of the building before him.
Eimet laughed as he glanced back over his shoulder and saw his charge standing slack-jawed at the edge of the green. “Aye, your lad set us quite the task in that,” he said, looking from Balan to the Hall with a grin. “But glad we are of it now, and all proud to have been in the making of it.”
“As you should be,” Balan murmured, his eyes taking in the carvings that also decorated the tie beam and lintel as he began once more to move forward across the green. “I’ve never seen its like.”
“Nor had we till he set us to raising it. But he had every detail in his head, clear as day.”
Balan chuckled. “Aye, so I remember. A whole night he spent trying to make me understand how he could eliminate the chief post if he planked the outer walls and bound the collar ties in a different way. I never did follow it.”
“No more did I—but we’ve done it nonetheless. It’s all held in the bearing posts and the walls. Not a center post in sight.”
“Then all hail to Baran’s collar ties. Perhaps I’ll understand them at last now that—” Balan broke off with a hiss, for Baran himself had emerged from the door, dressed in the same madder-red cloth that hung beside their old home, with the chieftain’s torque gleaming about his neck, the bronze carefully polished, the emblem worn with pride. He stopped abruptly at the sight of his father and the two men stood frozen, eyes locked, and the sudden pounding of Balan’s heart left his senses reeling. This vision had appeared without warning, his own beautiful boy, that same head which once rested soft and tiny within his palm now held high with command upon his brow, and all Balan’s practiced words dried up before the sight.
How readily authority sat on him! How easy his confidence, how natural his bearing—a lord at his threshold with the great Hall towering behind him—and Balan’s heart swelled with pride; and in the secret, hushed part of him where she dwelt still, he saw Esrid’s smile as well, the way her eyes would shine if she too could see their boy standing so. A tremor rippled along his own lips and he pressed them together, attempting to hold the emotion at bay as he stepped forward hesitantly and began to close the distance between them.
Gods all, how he longed to reach out and gather him in his arms, to clasp him close as he had clung to Belen in the woods above Nargothrond. Oh, my son…
But his steps faltered as he neared and his mouth turned dry. Would Baran welcome such a greeting now? Or would it be a slap at his son’s dignity to approach with familiarity first instead of deference? It would be a slight to his leadership, surely, after how they parted. An indication that Balan still considered himself outside of Baran’s authority. He remembered his own first years as chieftain, awkward and uncertain, feeling ever caught between his youth and the authority he was meant to grasp. He remembered too his uncle, his mother’s brother, taking a knee before the gathered kindred with wells of kindness in his eyes, setting his lips to the ground at Balan’s feet and marking him with the formal obeisance of their people ere any doubt could take root.
And then without thought he felt his own posture bend, his own knees seek the clay path before his son. He would do his duty now as Bero had done beside the village ashes, and all his people would know the pride he held in his son’s command. He crossed his arms upon his chest.
“Don’t!” Baran’s voice was a choked whisper and his grasp fumbled for his father’s shoulder. He caught a handful of shirt instead and dragged him upward in entreaty. “Have I offended you, vatta?”
Balan staggered back to his feet, his heart pounding and hot nausea rising through his gut. It was all wrong, of course it was all wrong. What folly had possessed him that he thought this would ease a rift and not rend it? “No,” he stammered at last, staring helplessly at his son. “No, I—“
“Vatta!” Belen’s voice tore through the air, then Belen himself came into view, sprinting from the far side of the settlement and barreling into his father’s arms.
“Bel!” For a moment he staggered backwards with the force of the collision, then found his breath and folded his son in his arms with all the desperate affection he had doubted a moment before.
“I’d ridden Kaseis to the north fields or I’d have been with Eimet to meet you.” Belen’s embrace was tight, but his eyes darted apprehensively toward his brother as though taking a swift assessment of what damage may have occurred already in his absence. “You’ve made quick time!”
“Aye.” Balan managed a smile as Belen drew back, this second meeting a reverse of their first with his son now the one taking him by the shoulders and looking him over for any change. “The days were mild and Gildor a good guide.”
“So he is.” Belen turned to his friend with a grin and clasped his arm in greeting. “And swifter about it when he’s no need to fish anyone from a river.”
Gildor laughed, and his answering grin was merry. “Well met to you, Belen.”
“Well met,” Belen echoed, and embraced him before turning back to his father. “We didn’t expect you till the morning at least.”
“We rode with the sunrise. I was eager to see you—and your brother.” Balan’s eyes once again sought his elder son, but the other’s face was unreadable.
“As were we for your return,” Baran said, and he smiled, though its warmth did not reach his eyes. “But come, the meal has only just begun. We didn’t hear of your approach until after the meat was laid out or we’d have held it for your arrival.”
“I’m glad you didn’t. It was thoughtless of me to push on with such poor timing.” Of course. The feasts of Iuthap that heralded midsummer, each beginning with the last light of day, and in the complications of their journey and doubt of his own welcome, Balan had overlooked that their arrival would fall in the midst of these. Guilt crawled along his neck as he followed his sons over the threshold. How had it slipped his mind so quickly? He had marked these customs each year of his life till the last—the threshing dances, the longest night, turning day with its green garlands and raucous sprints, midsummer and the sun goddess’ bounty when they threaded golden calendula in their hair and Esrid and her sister would turn their people’s whirling dance till the last of the sunset’s light…
Remember who you are. The memory of Baran’s parting words drummed in time with his footsteps, and Balan once again clenched his nails against his palm—both distraction and some whim of self-reprimand for his inattention. But as they passed the first partition wall, his grip fell slack and he drew up short, awestruck.
“Gods all…” he breathed, his eyes wide as they took in the expanse of the room. It was twice the breadth of any they had built ere now, with beams leaping up from the timbered walls and disappearing within the shadow and thatch. A large hearth had been constructed in the center of the room, while raised platforms ran the length of each side, already nearly filled with those gathering for the meal. The higher of these, set along the northern wall, bore a row of five tables with benches placed at their back, while the lower was lined with pelts and woven rugs where the larger share of people sat. A bustle of merry conversation rumbled across these, while the last light of evening gleamed through the southern windows and cast beams from the upper wall to the floor.
“How now, vatta?” Belen caught his arm with a laugh and hooked it within his own as he drew him forward. “I’ve seen you gape less at your pillared caverns than this.”
“Aye,” Balan breathed, his eyes passing along the wall to his right, which had been whitewashed with linseed oil paint and showed the beginnings of rudimentary figures depicted along its length. “But those were not hewn by my own people, nor drawn by my own sons…”
“And so the skill did not surprise him.” Baran glanced back at his brother and though his voice moved with a jest’s cadence, Balan flinched at the words.
“Nay, I looked on those halls with a stranger’s wonder,” he said. “This holds my reverence.”
Belen watched him with a curious expression, somewhere between warmth and wistful reflection. “Your face is as I pictured it,” he said at last, and there was a quick press of his fingers where they gripped Balan’s arm. “We held a feast when the main structure was finished and all the while I imagined what you would have thought of it.” He grinned and bumped his shoulder affectionately against his father’s. “I was right.”
Balan was silent. He reached out to press his son’s hand in return, but found any reply choked in his throat. It was here Bel said they had passed the Longest Night, was it not? Here where the memorial for the dead had reminded his boy of that lingering absence he knew not how to mark. Balan cast his eyes about the room, attempting to discern where the empty plate and chalice might have been set. There, of course, opposite the high seat where the bear’s pelt was now spread, where Hathus sat in the place of honor with Alna upon one knee, laughing at some antic of Fina’s and sipping from the horn of ale in his hand. There had been pensive sorrow in Belen’s voice, the same as in the winter when he had confessed that conflicted mourning, and Balan’s heart was stung by the sound.
But Belen was grinning now, Esrid’s smile warm as Iuthap’s light upon his face, and he tugged at Balan’s arm when he lagged. “This way, vatta,” he said, drawing him forward onto the taller platform.
Baran was there already, standing behind the chief table with one hand fidgeting at his sash and the other resting atop the foremost seat, a sturdy oak chair draped in sheepskin and carved with braided patterns along both stile and arms. He looked momentarily lost despite his poise, a boy still amid this great Hall he had built, and once again Balan hardly held back the impulse to fold him close within his arms. Instead, he risked a tentative smile when their eyes met, and to his surprise saw the cold stoicism falter, his son’s features soften. It was only a brief glimpse before the mask was set again, but it sowed a new kernel of truth through Gildor’s words and for the first time Balan let himself ponder whether they had been more than a kindly meant fabrication.
“You’ll have my place.” Belen drew out the chair at his brother’s right, one of three placed along the chief table, and steered Balan toward it. “It will be tight with both of us on this side together,” he added apologetically, dragging a small barrel to the foot of the table to serve as his own seat and the grin flashed out again as he perched atop it. ”But I won’t mind it if it doesn’t bother you.”
“Nay, lad, not a bit.” He reached out to rest his hand briefly behind Belen’s neck, the old gestures of affection as easy here as they were fraught toward his brother, and he felt himself steadied by the familiarity.
“You should not keep them waiting longer.” Estreth’s voice cut like ice through Balan’s musings and he looked sharply to his left, knowing even as he did so that the words were not for him. She was seated just beyond Baran in the table’s third chair, one arm resting upon the table and her eyes set firmly on her nephew’s face. “Not if you wished to keep the iuthan bida. The light is fading fast.”
He saw Baran nod out of the corner of his eye, but Balan’s own gaze did not shift from Estreth. Her expression was sharp, taut and unreadable in the firelight, and he found himself unsettled by the sight of grey strands running though her hair. She had always remained in stasis in his mind, the girl tucked under Esrid’s arm in the days following Geberic’s death, fierce-eyed and determined; or the woman at his side when it was Esrid’s death that left them unmoored, those same eyes following after him and holding him to his duty. But like Belen, she too was less recognizable in the intervening year and it left him with an inexplicable sense of dread. Or no, had his memory played him false in this as well and merged her memory with that of her sister? Hair ever jet-dark, eyes warm, features soft and rounded rather than this keen expression before him…gods all, he had. She was little changed after all, only the brush of grey standing out in difference—and he felt a fool to have been surprised by it. Surrounded by the fixity of Nóm’s people, some unconscious part of him expected to return home and find it still in the moment he had left it. But he had dwelt longer away from Celon’s shores now than beside them and the reality of that distance settled over him, cold and heavy.
Baran was filling a drinking bowl from the wooden bottle that sat in the center of the table, globed and carved with symbols of the gods around its sides. The mouth was rimmed with a rare portion of silver, crafted into a six-point that wrapped like fingers about the vessel’s curve, and the mead ran out from it like new honey. It was the same ritual Balan himself had performed each year, but in Baran’s hands it seemed to hold a new weight, a solemn rite that matched the dignity of the Hall and brought the gathered crowd to silence.
So engrossed was he in watching his son that he flinched in surprise when Hathus’ spear struck six beats upon the wooden floor. This was yet another change, he noted, for in all their previous longhouses the floor had been made of packed clay. Here in Baran’s hall it was lined with wide planks fitted carefully between the raised benches.
“Radiance of Iuthap, guide our way.” Hathus stood just opposite the high seat with his chief warriors gathered about him and his voice was resonant within the timbered walls. “Sight of Iuthap, mark our path with truth. Beneath the sun we have grown and prospered, and beneath your dance our journey is formed from clay unto clay. Set us in the path of wisdom here at the seasons’ height where the sun’s light holds all the world under her reign.”
Sei lagjan an staiga nóman…Balan mouthed the words silently, repeating it over and again as Hathus continued the litany—set us in the path of wisdom, set us in Nóm’s path. It was half-sacrilege, his drifting prayer, contrary both to his gods and the king’s own propriety. Nay, Balan, no god am I. It was the first time he had seen the earnest flush rise in Nóm’s cheeks, trickle up along his ears. He had laughed at Balan’s reverence beside Thalos’ waters, dismissing it with a smile and a brief flash of trepidation. Do not tease me so or I will grow insufferable. Balan too had laughed and never spoken so again, but both knew there had been naught of jesting in that early veneration—nor was there now in this new invocation. Sei lagjan an staiga Nóman…
“…even now as we stand in the warmth of your remembrance.”
“Radiance of Iuthap, guide our way.” The crowd responded in one voice and Balan came back to himself with a start. He had lost the ritual’s thread while his thoughts wandered and quickly cast about to recall his place.
“Sight of Iuthap,” the people recited again, “mark our path with truth.”
Of course, Hathus had finished his final words and this was the hallowing of the cup. “Light of Iuthap, bless—” The words rolled from his lips without thinking, resounding in a decades-long reflex through the quiet of the Hall, and it was only when he heard Baran’s voice lifted in unison that he realized the gaffe and stammered into silence.
“Light of Iuthap,” his son began again, carefully reining in his glance of annoyance, “bless our gathered kindred here at the waxing of your reign.”
Estreth’s eyes had turned on him. Balan could feel the indignation like heat against his skin and dared not look toward her, but fixed his gaze instead on the wooden plate before him.
“Light of Iuthap, bless this cup that we may set our sight by your sight, for our days are numbered in the steps of your dance.” Baran raised the bowl into a last shaft of light spilling from the far windows, holding it cupped within his palms. “By the sun’s blessing we drink to her. In the sun’s blessing we find our path set.” He bowed once, bringing his own head briefly into the same bright wash before lifting the drink to his lips. For a long moment he let the silence hang heavy between them, then turned formally toward his father and held out the bowl. “From day’s rise to day’s rising,” he said and Balan winced at the brittle civility in his tone.
“May you be found in goodness and in peace.” He reached out to take the vessel in his hands and at last forced himself to look up and meet his son’s eyes. Shame’s nausea rose at once, for gone was the softened countenance of a few moments past and in its place the sharp mask had risen once more. Balan’s gaze faltered and his eyes fell as he brought the bowl to his own lips, sipping from the midsummer mead beneath the same beams where a year before he had passed the chieftain’s torque into his child’s hands and watched this mask harden upon his face. Sei lagjan an staiga Nóman…
The phrase echoed bitterly now and his knuckles whitened about the bowl as he turned, passing it into Belen’s hands.
“From day’s rise to day’s rising,” he murmured, his voice faltering as he saw the tense line of his shoulders, the boy's eyes wide and watching them both in concern.
But at once Belen attempted a smile, brushing his fingers reassuringly against his father’s as he took the vessel and raised it in salute. “May you be found in goodness and in peace,” he said, then drank.
❈❈❈
There were flagstones along the threshold, pieced together in precise patterns that reminded him of the dark shale his mother had once set in the ground before their own door. These, however, were made of thick rock, wide and carefully shaped with corners rounded and runes of protection carved along each edge. Balan paused as he reached the last of these and looked out over the settlement. Dawn had crept in with the weary relief that heralds the sleepless, grey and heavy, and mist still lingered like fleece about the trees and fields.
A few hours’ sleep was more than expected at the outset, he reflected with grim optimism and rubbed one hand against his eyes. Everything in him had been restless—even exhaustion had done little to ease the anxious hum when he retreated from the feast and stretched across the bed. He could not stay still. Lying at rest, his mind assessed each moment since his arrival, repeated every fault and blunder. Pacing, he found every step left him increasingly convinced of his own imposition. At last he began looking through the room’s contents, embroidered hangings covering the walls, a little collection of stones, items stashed along the many shelves—anchored shelves held fast to the walls, no longer the hanging rope and board he remembered—other miscellany scattered upon the table or floor or window sill, a small bowl of apples, a pile of wood beside the clay hearth. But even in this he found each new item dogged him in accusation for his unfamiliarity, for it was Belen’s room they had given him.
The residential quarter was a low structure, sprawling perpendicular to the eastern end of the Hall with one passage running the full length and rooms facing out from it toward the open fields. Of these, Baran had noted when he and Belen guided him through the new construction, only the first two were structurally completed. The third remained empty. It was walled in and partially timbered, but as yet served merely to house spare supplies. Balan had tried not to hear an edge in his son’s tone. He knew well enough why the design had been drawn up with three rooms, and why the last had been left unfinished. But he had pressed this aside, smiling as the various features were pointed out to him while they walked, little innovations in the structure, the meticulous carvings that had begun adorning the pillars and beams throughout the hall. Baran listed them off with seeming disinterest, as though grasping at the nearest safe topic of conversation.
But Belen had laughed at the careful indifference in his brother’s voice and bumped his shoulder against the other’s with an affectionate grin. “He’d have you believe it’s as mundane a task as sowing or shearing, but proud as a plumed jay he is. You should have seen him when he finished the fore-lintel carvings.”
“I was relieved to have it over with. The balance was unpleasant.”
“Ignore him. He grinned more than when he bested Hathus in the throw.” Belen had glanced warmly at his brother as he spoke. “And well he should—it’s fine work.”
“Don’t play the fool, Bel, they’re nothing compared to what he sees in Nóm’s caves.”
Balan flinched and pressed his fingers to his eyes once more. It was pointless to keep going over each exchange as though that would somehow show him a remedy. Time would be the only physic here, if physic there was. He stepped off the flagstones and rounded the corner, following the line of the hall till he stood beneath a tall ash tree, wide as the span of his arms and soaring out in curving branches, each as thick as a trunk. For a moment he stood looking up into the expanse, then turned his attention to the ground and scuffed his boot through the grass and soil till he found the place he recalled—a flat stone resting more or less level between two roots.
The altar his grandmother built had been raised, he remembered as he knelt and brushed the dirt away, a little stack of shale behind their hut with a likeness of Melishk balanced at its crest. He had ground his heel into the charred remains of the goddess when they gathered bones from the village, kicking at it till his mother’s brother pulled him away in fear that his fury would call down further hardship.
Earth or altar, it mattered little. His gods would hardly heed his prayer now, regardless of the means, for any piety had been neglected when he chose to break from his people’s path. When was the last time he had sought them in earnest? He grimaced and drew out a small figure which he then set upright upon the stone.
It was laughably small, he thought, crudely cut and out of place beside the dignity of the wide ash tree. Though there was little surprise in that, after all; he had carved for expedience, not detail, a means to pass the night. But the likeness before him was recognizable enough for the purpose, arms wrapped in the customary embrace, hair encircling her face with its tendrils radiating outward in mimicked light. Iuthap, placed on a rock before the towering ash and draped with the dawn.
He had pulled the chunk of wood from a pile beside Belen’s hearth, halfway through the night and desperate. His thoughts would not slow, he could not sit, he could not walk, he could not sleep, he could not abide with himself, he could not escape himself. Light of Iuthap, bless our gathered kindred…He had slammed his palms against the beam over the hearth, then turned and rummaged through the firewood until he found a branch that would suit. If it was in prayer to Iuthap that he had misstepped, perhaps it was in prayer too that he might mend it.
Balan brushed aside the remaining dirt from the stone and sat back on his heels, uncovering a little clay bowl and blowing gently to reignite the ember inside. This he placed on the stone before the carving, then drew a small knob of incense from within his sash and placed it carefully atop the coal.
“Blessed Iuthap, queen of every dawn,” he murmured under his breath as the thin strand of smoke began to rise, “may my prayer find favor and my words rise to you. O great one, may it please you to look kindly upon the hope of my heart.”
And was that Nóm or was it resolution with his son? He balked for a moment, watching the white trail curl into the air, and tried to remember which hope had been foremost in his thought when he spoke the words. No, Iuthap was not fickle as Fon would be; sun was a constant, fire leapt and darted with an imp’s mischief, burning the hand as gladly as it would warm it. But the goddess would not make merry with such trickery.
The scent of balsam resin muddled his memory through a litany of former prayers. When was it that he had brought himself to offer incense again after the village burned? That had been balsam too, a short year after he was wed, set before Melishk as the prayers poured fervently from his lips. Esrid had told him the evening before that she was with child, and in that mingled joy and fear his agnosticism had faltered and he fell in penitence before Weiv’s intricate clay likeness of the goddess. And so he had done every day after till Baran’s birth, waking each morning to offer entreaties while Esrid slept, then returning when she woke to set his ear to her belly and feel the fluttering movements against his cheek. He had laughed the first time a solid kick caught him unawares, running his palm over the taut skin and singing as his own mother had, may peace ever lie down beside you, may I in wisdom’s arm’s find you…and so Baran had known his voice when he emerged into the world at last, tiny fists clenched and yelling with all his might, and in the weary first months would calm nearly at once when Balan held him tucked against his chest and sang those same melodies till he slept.
“Blessed Iuthap,” he began again, tears stinging the corners of his eyes as he whispered this new plea, “queen of every dawn—”
The sound of sliding wood came abruptly behind him and he glanced back, startled. It was only the shutters of the nearest window, he realized, shamefaced at his alarm. A hand was all that showed on the far side of the beams, reaching up from below to push the panel aside before disappearing once more into the shadows. This was followed at once by a groan of protest as the light fell through the open slats, then a rustle of cloth, an unintelligible grumble. Baran, he recognized with brief amusement—how often he had heard that same complaint when he tried to shift his eldest from sleep.
“Brute.” Baran’s voice was muffled, sheltered undoubtedly beneath a pillow. “Put the sun away, I don’t want it.”
“Scorning a goddess? And on her feast day no less.” Sabil’s voice now, low and amused. “You’ve some gall.” There was another rustle, then a squawk.
“Alright! Leave off, I yield,” Baran’s words were garbled with laughter. “Leave off, I said. I’m awake.”
The hint of a smile played at Balan’s lips at the exchange and he reached out to turn the bowl over on the stone, then retrieved the little figurine and shifted by degrees, attempting to move away in silence.
“You’d think you were about to face thieves’ lashes, by the look of you,” Sabil chuckled, “not rising to go about a celebration.”
“Mmph. I’d take the lashes sooner than spend another hour watching him mince his knife through every bite like he’s one of the damned Nómin.”
Balan froze halfway up from the ground, caught both by dread’s curiosity and by the concurrent realization that there was no angle from which he could rise without alerting the two of his presence. And to do so after Baran’s last words seemed, he told himself, needlessly unkind.
“Don’t be petty.”
“Petty?” Baran snorted. “We’re not meant to have two chieftains at once. There’s good reason it’s not been done before—none of our customs fit within it.”
“And it’s not been done now. You are chieftain—none of your people think otherwise. He’s given it over to you in full.”
“Aye. And then greets me by mocking it, goes on as though the rites are still his…”
Balan felt the tightness rising through his throat again as his son’s voice grew in vehemence. So that was what he had seen in the gesture—ridicule and not honor, a sham and not a father’s pride. He clenched his jaws against the protest that welled up within him and lowered himself carefully back to the ground. It was cruel to listen like this, unintentioned as it was. The room’s western corner was only a few strides away; he could crawl, perhaps, and move along the undergrowth until he was safely out of view.
“He’s led the iuthan bida for more years than we’ve lived, Baran. It was habit, not spite.”
“I know.” Baran’s voice had grown muffled again and Balan could see the familiar gesture in the sound—hands pressed over his face, a moment to resettle his will, the fingers trailing down and falling away once more. “I do know it. I—gods all, I rushed out the moment I heard and would have run to the fence like a boy in search of him if he hadn’t reached the Hall already…but then he had that damned shirt and Nóm’s device on my grandfather’s knife, and greeted me like his master not his son…”
Balan looked down in bewilderment. He had not bothered to change amid the sleepless night and the shirt hung about his shoulders still, a pale bluish green—like the Sea, Nóm had said when he gave it to him, and Balan loved it all the more on that count—with tiny kelp fronds stitched in gold and green about the hems. He had chosen it without thought the morning before, rummaging through the clean items in his pack and drawing out the first his hand touched. Gods of vengeance, was every choice to go amiss?
He was to the corner, out of sight at last, and drew himself stiffly to his feet. For a moment he lingered still, torn between the itch to listen further and learn the extent of the rift and the overwhelming compulsion to run; but flight pulled the harder and he dipped into the angle between the living quarters and the Hall, and found himself face to face with Estreth.
“Gods all!” he hissed with a start and felt his color rise at her look of cool evaluation. “How long have you been there?”
“Long enough.”
He swore under his breath and tried not to avert his gaze. The voices still drifted through the air, but they had grown quiet since the outburst and he could no longer discern any words within their cadence. That was for the best, Balan told himself, pressing down his frustration and resisting the urge to slip back around the corner. What he had heard had been accidental. It had been unavoidable. He shifted uncomfortably under Estreth’s appraisal and forced himself not to look away.
“You’d best come with me,” she said at last, the set of her lips somewhere between resentment and pity, and he followed her without question toward the village.
❈❈❈
Estreth’s hut was little changed from Balan’s memory of the previous spring, and this he found to be an unexpected comfort. The same rugs covered the packed clay floor, woven with the bright patterns of her people’s craft. The same thicket of herbs and blossoms hung drying from the far rafters beneath the thatch. The same table sprawled along the wall to their left, rough-hewn and scattered with a flotsam of small pots and pestles and bowls of half-ground seeds.
She crossed at once to the hearth and squatted beside the circle of stones, raking the coals into the center and feeding them from a basket of twigs and dried thistle heads. “Come in if you wish,” she said, sparing him a sharp glance before returning her attention to the kindling, “or don’t. But you needn't linger on the threshold, I would like the light.”
Balan stepped aside apologetically and moved to stand near the hanging shelves instead. Estreth’s hands flew deftly about the little hearth, snapping twigs to size, adding a broken log, then another, blowing the embers back into flame.
“The covered one there,” she said shortly, nodding toward the shelf beside him.
Balan followed her gaze and retrieved a clay crock, three-legged and bulbous with a chipped lid resting over the mouth. He carried this to the hearth and set it over the stacked kindling, which had begun crackling merrily and was now spreading its flames to the rest of the pile.
“It won’t need long,” she added, “it’s a small portion remaining.”
“You needn’t feed me, Estreth, I can wait till bread is laid in the Hall.”
“I know.” She rose and crossed to the table, then uncovered a coarse loaf and cut a chunk from one side, setting it tersely in a bowl. “Take the gesture while I’ve an inclination to offer it.”
He shifted uncomfortably as she returned to the fire, tangling one hand in the back of his hair and looking down at the dancing flames, their crackling punctuated only by the sound of a wooden spoon scraping along the sides of the crock. “I’m glad to find this still as I remembered it,” he said at last. “I’d have thought Baran would have moved you to the Hall instead.”
“He would have if I’d agreed to it.”
“Ah.” The ghost of a grin twitched at Balan’s lips. “But as it is, you’ve no stomach for my leftovers?”
Estreth glanced at him under her brows, but let the joke lie pointedly unanswered.
There was a long silence then, and gradually Balan let his eyes resume their exploration of the hut. Once within, it had quickly become apparent that more alterations were undertaken than he initially thought. A grain ark sat where the bedroll had been, a new layer of daub had been spread over the walls—smoother this time and freshly whitewashed, and a doorway had been cut in the further wall, leading to an additional room beyond. Balan moved slowly toward this last, for the opening was covered with a cluster of strung beads, both clay and wood painted brightly and swaying in the breeze, and his hand reached out impulsively, the beads passing like water through his fingers. An involuntary sob caught in his throat.
“They are her work, not mine.” Estreth had glanced back at the sound and now sat watching him with one arm propped over her knee even as her sister had once done.
“I know them.” His voice was husky as his fingers traced along the patterns, their brilliant reds and yellows and trails of woad blue reminding him sharply of Belen’s embroidery. It never ceased to startle him when these echoes of her leaped from their boys; the lines of her determination mirrored in Baran’s frown, her laugh rolling from Belen’s lips, especially these little unlooked for bequests. He turned a speckled oval between his fingers and tried not to think of the cluster she had woven in her hair the day they were wed. Those had been blue as well, striking against the jet black braids, and he had worn one of them on a cord about his neck for years until it shattered in a fall. “I’ve dreamed of her all through these months, more than since Bel was a boy.” He was surprised to hear the words slip from him, hoarse and barely audible even in the stillness of the hut. “She sits by me while I sleep, sets my hand in hers, and I wake with the brush of her kiss still warm against my lips.”
“Balan…”
“I’ve mourned her afresh this past year and it’s seemed as new a wound as the morning that hillside passed from our sight.” There was a laden pause, then he shook his head and passed his hands over his face. “I’m sorry. You don’t want to hear this from me. Let me say instead I’m glad you’ve hung it now—I regret having hidden it away as I did.”
Estreth rose and watched him in silence, then gave a brief nod and turned to retrieve the bowl, filling it with broth from the pot and placing it once more on the table. “Sit.” She pushed a stool toward the open space with her foot, but the ice had gone from her voice now and there was almost an air of welcome in the gesture.
Balan crossed to the seat as directed, breaking a piece from the bread and dipping it into the broth. “Thank you,” he said after a few bites, a tentative smile spreading over his lips. “I’ve missed the taste of our own food.”
She snorted and filled his cup from a nearby ewer. “As you’ve missed a hard bedroll, I suppose, or waking before the winter’s dawn.”
“I have.” He grinned up at her, accepting the proffered drink and taking a long draught. She had placed crushed lemon balm within the jar, as was ever her way, and the flavor weaving through the water made him ache with the taste of home.
“Liar.”
“Aye, a bit.” He turned his attention back to the broth and bread. “I’ve not missed sleeping on stones, but I think most days about this broth and Meyla’s mutton pottage. And khüld and bread…”
“You sound far too hopeful,” she retorted. “Broth I’ll grant you, but you’ve a far road before khüld yet.”
“Fair enough.” He broke off another bite of bread and felt the knot in his chest begin to ease. The old look of teasing had returned to her eyes and he had seen the hint of a smile when she turned away. “How much of the king’s gold would I need to pilfer, do you think, for Liuvar to let me barter the spices from him?”
“More than you’d dare, that’s for certain.” Estreth filled her own bowl with broth and carried it back to the table, resting her back against the wall and sipping carefully as she watched him. “So he will be trailing after you, I take it?”
“Aye. He meant to arrive when I did, but I doubt he’ll be more than another day, perhaps two.”
“Hmph. Then I owe Baran the return of his good hunting knife.” She took another sip of broth, then looked at him with a raised brow. “How did you mislay him?”
Balan glanced up at her, a brief ripple of annoyance crossing his features, both at the wager and at the prospect of confessing the failed journey. “Diplomacy,” he managed at last, half-obscured behind another sip of broth.
“I thought diplomacy was a duty you could only fulfill at his side. Or have we been led by a falsehood these many months gone?”
“It was no falsehood. This parting was in service of the same.” Balan fidgeted beneath her scrutiny and knew his irritation was growing plain. “Elu Thingol holds his borders against any of our kind,” he mumbled at last, “and will not suffer any passage without persuasion.”
“And so the pet was dismissed at the borders.” She moved to fill her own cup and the twinge of a smile crossed her lips.
“I took my own leave or he’d not have gone a step further.” Balan drained the remaining broth from his bowl. “We need his intercession too dearly to let him make a principle of my passage.”
“Intercession for what? That we might bind ourselves to another’s rule? Be gathered in as so many pups for the lordly ones to see which might grow useful in the hunt?” She watched him darkly. “We’ve not come through the years of wandering, through blood and trial, to resign our peace to another’s tending—not to the forest tyrant nor to the cold pride of the seven brothers, nor yet to the honeyed hand that feeds you.”
“Can you think him so mercenary?”
“I think he recked little of what his whim would cost when he coaxed you beneath the hills.”
“Nay, you hold him answerable for my own debts. He made no demand for service, put forward no expectation of anything save friendship between our peoples—don’t scoff! It was I who begged him to take me on, begged him over and again until he granted it.”
Estreth turned to fill her own cup and disdain creased her face. “Melishk formed your spine of sand.”
“And your show of hospitality wears thin.”
“It was threadbare from the start.”
Once again, Balan drew his hands over his face, the exhaustion of the previous night pressing in at the sides of his eyes, then leaned in to rest against the table and took a deep breath. “He will not hold a record of aid to leverage some later advantage, if that is what you fear.”
She snorted. “I fear ambition, not leverage.”
“Nóm will not—”
“Leave his pet name at my threshold. He’s earned it not of me.”
“Whereas I’ve earned any names I may be given?”
“You’ll not warm your pity at my hearth, Bëor.” She crossed to the fire as she spoke and scooped a handful of wood ash from the cooled edge, then dusted it over the empty bowls. “This was what you wanted.”
“Was it?”
She made no reply, but poured a splash of water into each and began scrubbing the wood vehemently with a cloth.
“I don’t know what it was I wanted.” He rested his forehead wearily against his palms. “To go on unchanged, I think, all of us as we were—together here and content. A naive wish. He was always meant to leave at some point.”
“And you were not.”
“No,” he assented quietly. “No, I was not.”
There was a long silence. Estreth set aside the cloth and rinsed the bowls in a nearby pail, then turned them over on the table to dry and rested her own palms against its edge. “Far have you roamed,” she murmured at last, her voice half-chanting in its cadence as she recited the old tale. “Far have you roamed, Otker the wanderer, and deep in the dread wood have your straying feet ventured.”
“As water from spring-wells pours into vessels…”
Her knuckles whitened around the tabletop. “I do not think I will ever forgive you.”
“I know it.”
“What was it for?” she hissed after a pause, and her arms shook with the grief of her fury.
Balan shook his head helplessly and could not reply.
“Then why do you go on as his tame hound?”
“Why do you go on without a husband?”
Estreth’s eyes flashed but the retort caught in her throat as she heard the sudden roughness in his voice and with a wash of cold recognized it for what it was—not the sharpness of scorn, but pain grasping desperately at some guessed kinship. She stared at him incredulously and he could not hold her gaze, but stood and crossed to peer through the door.
“I hear riders.”
“Balan, you fool.”
“Yes, I know.” The pity in her eyes cut more sharply than all the previous scorn and he flinched, reaching out to grip the door frame.
“Does he know?”
“They are drawing near,” he said, then glanced back at her with a bitter smile and was gone.
Chapter End Notes
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
Dára: lord or chieftain. Also seen in the form “dar” when it is used as a prefix or paired with the individuals name (as in Dar Baran etc).
haelis: hello, greetings
sama goleins: good greetings
vatta: father
iuthan bida: sun’s blessing/sun’s prayer
Sei lagjan an staiga nóman: set us in the path of wisdom
Nóm: Wisdom, the name given by the Atani to Finrod
MISC NOTES
- Otker the wanderer: see Atanatárissë, chapter 4 and the myth of the ghomennin
21. Blade's Peril
"I’ve missed this life more than I’ve dared tell you, and I’ve come back and found it gone. It will not have me back. He will not have me back—and no wonder. Where am I meant to put this hunger?"
Finrod arrives in Estolad and does his best to dispel the conflict between Balan and his eldest son. The Atani teach him a drinking game as they celebrate the eve of Baran's wedding.
Read 21. Blade's Peril

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
Estolad
Nóm had arrived with all the speed of a gale, galloping ahead of the Guard like an arrow loosed from their bows, and did not slow till Váya was within twenty paces of the palisade. He leapt from her back at once then and darted forward on his own feet to greet them—for it was the children who had rushed out first at his approach, a little pack led by Avina and Fina that swarmed him as soon as he reached the ground. He caught them each in a warm embrace, then with a yelp he let them topple him, laughing and bewildered at how they had grown in his absence.
When Balan had first glimpsed him, he was nearly to the green, three children perched atop Váya and another hoisted upon his own shoulders, grinning as Avina and the others ran ahead to ensure the whole village knew he had come. It had set the old ache prickling through Balan’s stomach to see him among them again, to linger within the shadows and watch him move seamlessly into the easy familiarity of Thalos or those early days here beside the Celon—and with the memory, his intoxication had risen anew and left him awash with all the heady devotion of new love. Dizzy and burning, breathless and awed.
And so he was now as well, standing to the side as Sídhon and Gelmir carried in the king’s pack and saddlebags, resting them at the foot of the bed and drawing out their contents. His own few items were carefully shifted aside, tucked within his bag or placed in neat piles on the table beside it, for Belen’s room was now to house the king. That had been an unexpected wrangle. Baran had met them halfway along the green and Nóm strode forward without hesitation, arms flung open and meeting him with a warm embrace—and Balan had felt the sting of it at once; the gesture was simple and commonplace when he watched another enact it, why had he held back in his own greeting? At least, he mused in hindsight, deference had kept Baran’s anger from extending to the king.
But custom and cordiality had found themselves at odds once they passed into the Hall. Baran had insisted straightaway that his own rooms would be given over for the king’s stay, as the principles of his people’s hospitality demanded. The king had been aghast at this—he could not in good conscience rob their chieftain of his chamber on the eve of his wedding. Besides, he had added with a grin, he had been happy enough to make shift on grass or bedroll when he dwelt with them before, why should Baran think he required anything other upon his return? The silence had been uncomfortable then, offense lingering in the wake of each’s words, until Balan had chuckled from the edge of the group and leaned back against the head table.
“It’s custom, Nóm,” he had interjected at last. “You found us while we were about our journeying, when all sheltered alike. But here we are settled. Baran can no more set you to lodge in a hut than he could turn you from the gate and still hold his honor—he’d be shamed for setting himself above a guest and stashing a king in a hovel while he sleeps abed in comfort. Our traditions demand it.”
“And my duty as your lord demands that I take not unduly from your own holdings, nor prosper myself through your loss.” Finrod had turned back to Baran and smiled, holding his hands outstretched before him. “It is your wedding feast, my friend; allow your lord the indulgence of offering his due in gift.”
“It is in my people’s estimation, Nóm, not by my own reckoning, that the judgment is rendered.”
“And they’ll know it not so long as he is granted lodging in the Hall.” Balan pushed away from the table and moved to join them. “They’ll have no opposition to my old bones sleeping in a hovel. Give me my own hut back—Bel said yestereve it’s empty still—and Nóm shall have the room you gave me.” He glanced at his son with a sidelong grin. “We’ll pacify hospitality and he’ll not spend the week in distress at having robbed you of your marriage bed.”
He had the satisfaction then of seeing Baran’s careful poise slip for an instant before his son nodded and returned Finrod’s smile, conceding the arrangement.
Balan shifted aside as Sídhon emptied the second saddle bag and crossed to the little table beside the hearth, having somewhere appropriated a cloth with which he began sweeping the wood shavings to one side.
“Nay, I’ll see to it.” Finrod rested one hand lightly against Sídhon’s arm and shifted him back. “Go and seek thine own accommodations, thou hadst as long a ride as I—the both of you.”
“As you will, lord.” He folded the cloth in a quick motion and set it neatly beside the mound of shavings, then dipped his head in salute and passed back into the corridor, Gelmir following in his wake.
“I should have cleared it myself.” Balan brushed the parings into his palm and scattered them over the dull coals. “Poor Bel kept it neat as a wren’s nest and here I’ve muddled it after a single night. I’ll owe him a—” He broke off then, for Nóm’s arms had found him at once, crossing as soon as the door was drawn to, and for a moment his breath was lost in the close crush of the other’s embrace. “Gods all, m’lord,” he managed after a moment, chuckling, “I was only three days from your side.” But his own arms had twined about him in return, the scent of him coursing like wine through Balan’s senses, and when the familiar nudge brushed against his thought, he welcomed it in relief.
“Short were the days,” Nóm murmured, slipping into his own tongue as he buried his face within the other’s hair, “but keen thine absence. I rode the moment courtesy allowed.”
“Mm. That same courtesy which guided thine arrival.”
“Gaitch.” Finrod brushed his lips affectionately against Balan’s scalp. “Shall I amuse thee and confess my sister dislodged me ere my full anger held sway?”
“Good.”
“Led away like an errant pup caught by the nape of its neck.”
“Twas no more than was good for thee—though my grievance with the lord of the wood is the greater for having robbed me of the sight.” Balan drew back with a grin, then looked up to meet the other’s eye in curiosity. “Was thine own grievance answered?”
“It was.” Finrod turned to a small bag resting across the chair beside him and flipped the clasp. “Answered but not appeased.”
There was a long silence and Balan watched while the other lifted each item from the pack and placed them in neat lines along the table. “Nor to be shared?”
“Hm? Ah forgive me, I was lost in thought.” Finrod withdrew the last item, smoothing the bag along its folds and setting it aside. “How shall I say it? He hearkens to rumors and has built edicts on the murmurs of messengers. And having thus deemed you more easily swayed to the Foe’s will, he fences the Girdle against you.” Finrod crossed to the bed and sat, the lines of his face tight with indignation. “Hearsay and contempt. It is unjust.”
“What rumors?”
“Tales from the east. They tell him there is a darkness that hangs about your people and a shadow hounding your steps.”
“Little to surprise thee in that.” Balan turned to the chair beside him, then finding both it and its companion occupied by the other’s possessions, he shifted instead to sit on the table. “It’s near enough what I’ve told thee myself.”
“And in this he believes me perilously credulous for not questioning thy word upon it.”
Balan laughed. “Thou? Not questioning me?” He laughed again and rested his palms against the table’s edge with a grin. “He knows thee little, then, for I’ve never yet met a hound so eager on its trail. What does he suspect me of concealing from thee?”
For a long moment Finrod remained silent, his arms resting on his knees and the tips of his fingers placed carefully together. “Missives of warning have reached him from his own kin in the east, that the second Children have come indeed, but that they are bound in worship to that evil we have sworn to destroy.”
It was Balan now who fell quiet, his grin faltering as his grip wrapped harder about the wood and he held the other’s gaze with effort. “Aye,” he said at last, “there are those who serve the Nameless—many in the lands we have forsaken. But not I, Nóm, and never my people.”
“And yet thou didst keep it from me.”
“Would thine actions towards us have been otherwise had I told thee sooner?”
“No. Full well dost thou know it.”
“Then what does it matter? We flee it—is that not enough?”
The corners of Finrod’s lips eased, and after a moment he looked up to meet the other’s eye with a faint smile. “It is,” he said, the same warmth moving through his voice. “Of course it is. And so I told the lord of Doriath.”
“Who, I take it, was not persuaded.”
“I may keep my own doors as I see fit, he tells me, but a knave’s word will not set the rule of his.” Finrod snorted. “He believes I settled you beside the Celon deliberately, so that you might glean unsanctioned from the Girdle’s protection.”
“And didst thou?”
“Certainly. But if he grumbled not when my cousins’ people reaped that harvest, then it is two-faced of him to protest it now.”
For a moment Balan watched him with amusement, then slid from the table and retrieved his bag. “And rich of thee to act wronged when an undisguised scheme is perceived.” He crossed to a tall trunk that spanned the wall beside the door and chuckled at the other’s sharp glance. “A knave’s japes are cheap,” he added with a sidelong grin, “mind me not.” He lifted a shirt from the pile atop the trunk, heaped haphazardly where he had emptied his bags the night before, and rolled it loosely before returning it to his pack. The spare breeches followed, then a pouch and two small palm-sized boxes, one of his old tunics next. This he folded with more care, turning in the edges and sleeves and spreading it along the trunk before rolling it in turn. “My mother always held that our wandering was folly. We bore death’s mark in our souls, she said—from father unto son, mother unto daughter; did we think we could evade him so easily? One more hill, one more league to the west…” He placed the rolled tunic within the bag, then lifted his knife from the wood beside it. “My father was determined though. It was not his to ask why we journeyed, but simply to hold the duty he received from his own father, from his father’s father. Flee the Darkness. Hang the aithan-hropit. Remember the promise. Follow the sun into the west.” He turned the knife over in his hand and traced a finger along the well-worn hilt. “And the path of penitence will set your wandering aright.”
“Had you ever any knowledge of what it was you fled?”
“Death. The dark. The Nameless one.” Balan gestured vaguely. “They are all one, are they not?”
“Perhaps,” said Finrod quietly, but Balan’s attention had returned to his father’s knife.
“I was my mother’s child in that debate. My father had taught me a chieftain’s skills—to manage a people’s rations, to arbitrate and discern, to judge a path over hill or wilderness—but it was at my mother’s side that I learned our songs and tales, the long thread of our people that I loved. And my heart was drawn ever to her way in this as well; to settle and stay, to find roots in the earth. It was for us, I think, that he held back the march for a time—nigh ten years it was.” He trailed off and stood unmoving for a long moment, his eyes resting on the bards’ marks tattooed along the backs of his fingers. Then he shook himself and dropped the knife abruptly into the bag, turning once more to roll the remaining clothing. “I went back to our wanderings once they were gone, from some half-held sense of duty, and after that we never lingered more than two harvests in a place.” The last item was returned to the pack and Balan shifted to lean his back against the trunk. “No, that is not quite right. I would have had us stay by the shores of Andanahti-marei if my people had agreed to it. I was tired of running from our own shadows, and the water was cool and wide. There was peace in the hills.”
“Yes, I have heard Belen speak oft of it.”
“We remained three winters before the others grew restless and pressed me to move onward again. They had heard tales from the lake people of another range west of the bordering hills, and of travelers who had come through their passes. If we too could cross those peaks and leave this land of our wandering behind us…In the end I promised I would lead them over the mountains, but no further.” A small smile eased the weariness in his eyes and he looked up to meet the other’s gaze. “And so thy song found us.”
The king’s mind was warm against his own and Balan let him linger, drawing him alongside through the rolling memories; the trees with their twisted roots wading out into the water, the green hills woven with heather and grasses and swaths of airna-akran berries, the lake-scent riding on the wind and reaching like hope into his lungs, his boys’ laughter in the two-roomed hut beside the shore. It had been Baran’s first endeavor, outlined in the coarse sand while they watched the sun fall to slumber, then again on the blocks of thick clay he drew up from the lakebed and hardened in the sun. They had built it in the long days of late summer and it was home, as no place had been since he watched the old village burn in the night.
“Do you regret it?” Nóm’s voice was gentle, no plea or accusation in its cadence, and he had returned to Taliska in harmony with the other’s thought.
A faint spasm crossed Balan’s face and for a moment he pressed his lips between his teeth to still the surge of homesickness. “Sometimes,” he whispered at last. Then memory shifted and Nóm’s voice wove a song through his sleep, his heart pounded as Nóm’s eyes fell upon him in the dark, and he shook his head. “No.” His voice broke and he drew a hand over his face. “May they forgive me for it.”
Finrod stood without a word and crossed to take him in his arms, smoothing the hair back from his face as Balan leaned into the touch.
“Elenya…”
“Beloved.” Finrod cupped Balan’s face within his palms and tipped it up to look into his own. “Have the days been very trying?” he asked, then flinched as Balan laughed aloud, a wry snort somewhere between mirth and pain.
“Has it been trying? Gods all, Nóm, the way you choose your phrases.”
“Forgive me, I meant no offense.”
“It’s every breath I utter, it seems. I’m a creature of corners, sharp and awkward because I’ve disjointed all the places I should fit.”
“Nay, Balan, you are too harsh.”
“I’m too mild. I’ve missed this life more than I’ve dared tell you, and I’ve come back and found it gone. It will not have me back. He will not have me back—and no wonder. Where am I meant to put this hunger?” His voice faltered as the king’s thumb traced a line along his cheekbone, and despite himself the tangle within him began to ease. He turned his face in against the other’s palm and another laugh escaped him, mirthless now and bitter. “Has it been trying…”
Finrod drew him in again, cradling the dark head against his shoulder, and passing his hand over and back along the path of his spine. “How long since you have slept?”
Balan snorted. “You find the old man tired and ill-tempered?”
“Balan.”
The shiver was involuntary, but with it he gave up any remaining pretense and let himself lean wearily into the other’s embrace. “Barring the hour or so before dawn…the night ere last, I suppose. By the rivers’ meeting.”
Finrod’s arms tightened about him. “Ai Anarinya,” he said, slipping into his own tongue and turning his face into the other’s hair. “I should have been by thee.”
“Nay, thy path was in the right—and mine too, I deem. This was the fruit of my choice, thou shouldst not reap it for me.”
There was a long silence then, and the king’s fingers reached up to trail through the other’s hair as they stood unmoving, the beat of each’s heart falling in time with the other. “Come,” he said at last, “I’ve no need of the room till the day is done. Rest here awhile and I will wake thee before the noon meal is set.”
“And desert thee the moment thou art arrived?” Balan protested, but he suffered himself to be led back to the bed and sat obediently when the other directed. “There are duties I must see to, surely.”
“Nay, tis no desertion. I’ve matters to discuss with Baran and I can turn to those straightaway. Take thy rest, lest the evening’s celebrations be a burden to thee.”
“I see.” A hollow feeling settled in Balan’s gut as he slipped the boots from his feet and lay back, allowing Nóm to sit at his side and draw the blanket up over his chest. The wool felt rough after the cloth of Nargothrond, the rustling straw that once set his body at ease now seemed to crackle in protest as he shifted on the mattress.
“I think it best that I speak with him alone,” the king said softly, answering the other’s sinking thought rather than his words; though his voice was half-lifted in query.
“Aye, doubtless.”
“He is young and still new in his charge.” Finrod brushed the stray hairs from Balan’s forehead and sympathy spread like warmth along the lines of his face. “And no doubt anxious to learn whether his position holds in more than name when thou and I art come among them once more.” He rested his palm against the other’s cheek. “Let me show that I count him the unquestioned head of your people and perhaps some of these tensions may ease.”
“As thou wilt.” Balan felt his eyelids growing heavier and exhaustion was once more pressing in at his temples. “Like as not thou hast the right of it, but I’ve little hope of any change.”
“Sleep, then. For oft in dreaming’s embrace we find that hope which waking eludes us.”
Balan chuckled, but found he was too weary to summon the usual wry parry and instead let his eyes fall shut beneath the other’s touch, his mind ease as the quiet melody drifted over him and sent him gently into oblivion at last.
❈❈❈
It was unexpectedly quiet when Finrod slipped out through the door of the residential quarter and reentered the hall. The tables were bare and scrubbed, a small crock of white flowers placed at the center of each catching the sun where it fell from the windows. Those beams reached down through the haze of lingering smoke and seemed almost to form a second set of buttresses along the walls, hewn of light instead of timber. Finrod’s gaze was captivated by the illusion and he drew up short, lips slightly parted and lost in contemplation, so that long minutes stretched before he noticed he was not alone.
“Is sunlight so rare in your burrows, then?” A low voice cut through the stillness and Finrod turned with a start. Baran sat not twelve paces from him, an assortment of painted stones spread across the table before him and the hint of a smile played at his lips as he watched the king.
“Oft-seen is no less beautiful,” Finrod retorted with an answering grin, then crossed to the table and looked in curiosity at the bowls of pebbles. “What is it you do here?”
“I’m making a tally of the herds’ increase. Have you never seen vatta use these?” Finrod shook his head and Baran lifted a small pouch, emptying its contents onto the table. “Here, it’s quite simple. Each color represents a quantity, which allows you to consolidate as the tally increases. So this,” he quickly sorted the new pebbles into groups and pointed at each in turn as he listed them, “tells us the herdsman has a flock of thirty seven sheep. The plain stones are each counted as one, the whitewashed are five, the black ten. Now I add them into my own tally. The plain pebbles join the others in the first bowl. These three black stones add to the four I have already and that changes for one yellow instead, which is fifty. I add that to the next bowl and leave the remaining two black stones where they are. We have two yellow now, so that changes for one red—and so on. Simplistic, no doubt,” he added with a grin, “but far better than trying to carry the number about in your head. Each herdsman provides a count at midsummer, after the harvest, and at winter’s end; and in that way we can learn our losses and gains and form our plan from those.”
“I see.” Finrod sorted the new cluster of pebbles that Baran poured from the next purse. “A clever method. Such knowledge would surely have been a great help amid your travels.”
“Aye, no doubt.” There was a brief twitch at the corner of Baran’s lips as he dispersed the stones within the bowls. “Though in those days we did not hold the count.”
“Ah," Finrod looked over at him with a smile, "so it is of your making. May I?” He rested his hand on a chair with a glance in query, then drew it out and sat when the other nodded. “It was wisely done and will serve you well, I deem.”
“So I hope. Though thus far I’ve done little but grant myself a tedious task.”
The king chuckled and leaned back in his chair, watching as Baran emptied and counted several more pouches. “I was hoping to find you,” he said after a time. “I know not how much your father disclosed upon his arrival as to the cause for my delay…”
“He said you were detained in Menegroth upon matters of governance.” Baran’s brow lifted in a sardonic arc. “I assume that was to avoid confessing he found himself turned away.”
“You knew it?”
“Aye, I’m no fool,” he chuckled. “We had sent envoys before the harvest, offering tokens of peace and friendship—I went with them myself ere winter came—but each time we were stopped at the borders and told the same: the Lord of Beleriand would suffer no Man to enter the heart of his realm, nor would he treat with them in friendship.”
Finrod nodded and a flicker of anger passed over his face. “I learned of it when they denied your father’s passage. I would have gone to Menegroth far sooner had I known it was so.”
“Which is why I did not send word.” A quick sidelong smile flashed across the table. “Call it pride if you will, but I wanted to make the attempt first, to see whether we might not be accepted on our own merit.” He pushed the remainder of the pile aside and stretched his back, then settled into the chair and looked to the king. “Have I done ill?”
“Nay, not in the least. They were fine gestures of good will and any ill-doing is on my kinsman’s part. To speak frankly, you have shown yourself a far more gracious lord than he in this.”
“Will he bend, do you think?”
“Not in your lifetime, I deem; but do not hear that in blame, Baran, it is no reflection upon you. He has conceded some small matters—he will open the river crossings to the west so that your messengers may pass between us without requiring my people in escort—but he will not loosen the Girdle, nor will he allow trade between your folk and the Iathrim.”
“It is some progress, at least. Though I still fear to be driven out, should his disaffection turn to aggression.”
“That fear you may put to rest. The lord of Doriath is ill pleased, to be certain, but he will never assault without provocation. And even then it would require sore provocation indeed for him to risk open war with Nargothrond. Which he now knows would be at stake.”
“I thank you for that.” Baran fell quiet for a long moment and fiddled absently with one of the spare stones. “What would provoke him, Nóm? We stay peaceably enough here where you’ve planted us, but one man’s calm may easily enough be another’s offense. And I don’t doubt we could cause a grave affront before ever knowing it was a trespass. How do we keep from galling him further?”
“Short of gathering your herds and children and turning back to the mountain passes?” Finrod laughed despite himself, then shook his head. “His accusations were rumors and fears, there were no solid complaints. Go on as you are now. You are a wise leader and already the Marchwardens think well of you and of your people.”
Baran snorted and sat back in his chair. “A pity that couldn’t be the merchants.”
“Yes, I have heard all is not well there.”
“They’ve shifted their routes to the south or east now; or if they do venture near, they ask thrice the worth others pay—and offer a pittance for our own goods. At his guidance, no doubt. We have seen many pass the eaves without hindrance.”
“On that, at least, I may bring some small relief. There are trade accords I hold with many of those who cross the Sarn Athrad, and by right of your father’s oath your people are entitled to the same. They have not honored these so far in their dealings with you, but I made it clear to those I met in Doriath’s court that it is not theirs but mine to determine who is counted among my people.” He reached into the wallet at his side and drew out what appeared to be a silver bluebell flower, half the length of his thumb, and held it out to Baran. “For all the others, this should be sufficient.”
Baran took it and turned it over on his palm. Each petal was meticulous in its detail, curving outward in gentle arcs, and beneath these was a flat seal, imprinted with the mark of the king’s house and embellished with a small sun above the top point.
“Many of my lords carry a similar token,” the king added with a smile when he saw the surprise on the other’s face.
“Aye, but—” He caught himself as his voice slipped back to its old jesting, then closed his hand solemnly about the signet. “It is an honor, lord, and a gift I do not hold lightly.”
“Nor I the bestowing.”
Baran was silent then, setting the silver blossom beside the bowls of pebbles and turning it round and about as though studying each carefully wrought vein. “It was simpler when it was the messengers, you know,” he said at last, a curious smile passing over his features. “You remained Nóm and my lord Felagund was a voice without a presence—a kindly one, but one I only knew through other’s words.”
“And now he has donned my face and arrived at your door?”
“Aye—and I’m still accustomed to treat you as kin.”
“And I you,” Finrod assented with a laugh. “But why should that be otherwise now? Your father gave his oath by the feet of the mountains, I was your lord through all those months we dwelt here beside the Celon.”
“I was only his son then.”
Finrod lifted one brow in teasing. “You were half chieftain since long ere I met your people.”
“Is that what he’s told you?”
“Yes, and with great pride in it.”
“He exaggerates.” Baran snorted, but a pleased flicker softened the set of his lips. “And that is different from standing as the voice of my people. Besides, you were living as one of us then, not a visiting lord.”
“I would do so now as well, would your custom allow for it.”
“Aye, fair enough.”
The quick smile again. It was his father’s smile, boyish and bright, the right corner lifted a hair’s breadth higher than the left, and Finrod felt his heart contract to see the same strain drawn within its lines. His spirit still pulsed warm with Balan’s memories of the hut beside the shore, and the sharp ache of the other’s longing lingered like the tang of copper within his mouth. What must Baran think of him, in truth? For it was undeniable that the blame for their rift had its root at his own feet. He who had blinded himself to the signs of danger, whose resolve had broken at the first trial. He who had crept into their camp like Estreth’s ghomennin and drawn the unwary wanderer from his people. This distance was his doing, he reflected, and the self-reproach was bitter.
“On the subject of your father,” he managed at last, his fingers tracing restlessly along the table’s patterns, “I have not yet thanked you for conceding him to my service. I am deep in your debt, for his counsel has been invaluable as I’ve sought to build peace between your kin and mine, and I know you have borne the primary burden of this absence.”
“Nay, lord,” Baran’s tone was once more measured and cool, and the line of his shoulders tensed, “my father was clear that following you was the duty he owed our people. This is merely my own duty to the same. You owe me no thanks.”
“Sacrifice is of no less weight for having been born of duty. Nor is gratitude the lesser for bending toward it.” Finrod watched as Baran’s grip tightened against the edge of the table and felt his own old sorrow twinge in harmony. “He is more proud of you than he knows how to say, Baran,” he added after a long hesitation. “And keenly does he feel the parting. I have watched its toll on him.”
Baran’s sharp laugh broke through the air. “The toll on him!” He shook his head and turned to meet Finrod’s eye once more. “I do not hold you to blame in this, Nóm, but forgive me if I find little sympathy with his woe. He may rename duty to fit desire if he so pleases, but it serves only to fool himself that he’s done aught but shrug it onto another’s shoulders.”
“Forgive me, I have spoken out of turn.”
“He’s lived with an intimate knowledge of what it does to a man to inherit like this, and yet he chose it for me still. He was younger than Belen when he took it up, has he told you that?”
“And if it was Belen who was left with the charge, he would not have gone. Nay!” Finrod held up his hand as Baran’s eyes flashed. “Not from preference—I’ve said it poorly. Your brother is strong and great of heart and wise beyond his years, but he would be crushed beneath the weight of what you bear with skill. Belen is as like to your father in spirit as you are to him in face.”
“And so he believes I would not feel it as he did.”
“Yes.”
“Because he knows I’ve wanted it since I could understand I was the chieftain’s son…But that doesn’t mean I—“ Baran’s voice broke and for a long moment he sat in silence, his eyes fixed absently on a knotted board a few paces from the center of the Hall. “I thank you for your concern, Nóm, and I know you mean well in this. But you do not understand the hurt.”
The ghost of a smile tugged at the king’s lips and he kept his gaze on the table. “How is it you imagine I found myself the head of my people?”
Baran looked up sharply and his lips parted in surprise; but before he could summon a reply, there were footsteps from the far room and Sabil passed through the partition door.
“I’ve told Hathus to put the casks along the southeastern wall. Will that suit or do you want them within?” She saw the king then and drew up with a smile. “Haelis, Nóm! Forgive the interruption. Belen said you’d gone to rest.”
“Haelis, my lady, and well met.” Finrod rose, her smile mirroring onto his face, and crossed his arms in the Atani greeting. “Your company is no disruption.”
“We were on about family and governance,” Baran added with a grin, his eyes warm as she reached out to rest a hand along his shoulders.
“And so any interruption is counted a boon?”
“Aye. Though I should not like my lord to hear me say it,” he added with a teasing glance at the king.
Finrod laughed. “Then your lord shall provide an interruption of his own and spare us all the task.” Reaching into the wallet at his belt, he drew out a small bundle, twisted in silk and bound with a thin, silver cord. He slipped a finger beneath this and eased it loose till the wrapping fell away to reveal a sapphire, large as a quail’s egg and polished in flawless curves that caught the light and turned it back in a brilliant sheen. It was held within a setting of winding golden flowers, each of which clasped a tiny diamond at their center, and strung from a chain of plaited gold. He lifted it gently from the silk and spread it upon his palm. “The stone is what we call lúilë, blue as the heart of the Sea, and was brought out from the veins of the Pelóri ere the Darkening of Aman. In our custom, we hold it as a symbol of steadfast truth, of strength and loyalty and of the wisdom of its bearer.” He held it out toward Sabil and the lines of his smile bent into sheepish joy. “I had it placed in a new setting when I heard of your coming marriage and have brought it with me now as a token of blessing for your union…” He trailed off, for recognition had sunk in at the sight of the gem resting upon his palm, the fine chain draped around his fingers. His father had offered Eldalótë’s gift even so when the families gathered in the days approaching Angrod’s wedding. Finrod’s mouth was suddenly dry as dust, and heat burned along the edges of his ears as he looked down and found his hand a near mirror of Arafinwë’s, the jewel a sapphire now instead of a faceted diamond but the gesture itself indistinguishable. It was the place of Baran’s father to bestow such a gift. It was a brash impertinence of him to do so, and he felt his color rise as he silently thanked the Valar that none of his own companions had been near to recognize it as he had.
Sabil too was staring at the outstretched hand, her eyes wide with confusion and surprise. “Nóm, I—my lord, rather—I don’t…”
Finrod flinched in a self-deprecating grimace as she stammered into silence. “You needn’t accept it if the gesture is in excess.” He glanced at Baran with an apologetic smile. “Your father tells me I am a poor judge in that regard.”
“A poor judge?” Baran laughed incredulously. “No judge at all, I’d say.” But his voice was warm and he smiled as Sabil reached out to take it from the king’s hand. “Yet if I was to begin making a principle of excess, I’d be obliged to hand half the stuff of my village back to your keeping.”
“It is a great kindness, Nóm,” Sabil added, tracing a finger along the winding flowers, and her voice was quiet as she returned to the familiar address, “and we will treasure it—both gift and blessing.”
“As will I the friendship between our peoples, and the love your kin have shown me since I was a stranger come among you.” He stepped back with a smile. “And now, with your pardon, I will take my leave, for I see Hathus lingering by the entry with the look of one holding back a pressing query—and furthermore I have been lax and not yet greeted my friends among the herd. Honeg will be ill pleased with me for the neglect.”
Baran laughed. “You’ll find their pasture in the northwest corner now.” Then he grinned and added, “There’s a barrel of early apples just beyond the partition wall.”
“Only one?” Finrod raised a brow in mock-disappointment.
“Aye, I’ve hidden the others lest you indulge the little beasts with our whole store.”
“Thwarted ere a plot was full-formed! You are a pitiless master.”
“And you an overindulgent lord.” Baran retorted, then lifted his hand in parting as the king’s laughter drifted back from the doorway.
❈❈❈
“We call it Blade’s Peril.” Eimet drew out his knife and set it before him on the table. “It’s simple enough. There’s the ale horn here in the middle, a cup of your own, and enough hrögemetheilit to see us through. The knife spins to decide your fate,” he added with a grin, sending his own whirling with a flick of his wrist, “and if it stops with the blade to the right, you drink your own cup. Hilt toward you, the gods are kind and you pour yours into the ale horn. Blade toward you and you’re at their mercy and drink everything that’s collected in the horn.”
“And if the blade lies to the left?” Finrod sat beside him, one elbow propped upon the table, and his eyes evaluated the knife in curiosity.
“Ah. Well in that case, m’lord, your neighbors drink theirs.”
“Sán gahail,” Hathus chuckled and raised his cup toward the king with a nod.
“Do they indeed.” Finrod reached for his own cup with an amused grimace at the offending blade, then returned Hathus’ salute and brought the drink to his lips. “Sán gahail,” he echoed. It was a mercy the cups were small, he reflected as the liquor burned along his throat. Blade’s Peril indeed. Even the scant splash these held would compound quickly in the common cup.
“I’m surprised we’ve not taught you sooner.” Hathus spun his knife in turn and watched as it came to rest hilt toward him. “It was a long winter you spent among us.”
“We’d only the held-over crocks then,” Balan reminded him. “You’d not begun the new lot till just ere we left.”
“True enough. Ay!” He clapped a hand over his cup as Eimet attempted to slip a pebble over the lip. “No.”
“What are the stones?” Finrod asked as Hathus poured out his cup and refilled it from one of the clay bottles.
Eimet shook his head and grinned. “You’ll learn that as we go on.”
“You can’t set him loose without explaining it,” Belen protested, then turned to Finrod. “They’re each marked with a rune—n on yours, you see, be on mine, ei is Eimet’s, then ha, e, si, and so on. We give vatta the v so we don’t muddle him with Baran.”
Finrod rolled the pebble over on his palm. “And presumably the goal is to introduce them to a cup without the drinker’s notice?”
“Aye. Then ask them any question you wish and they’ve the choice of answering or drinking an extra cup.” Belen grinned. “The more vulgar the better.”
“You’re a one to talk,” Estreth remarked as she spun her knife. “I don’t think I’ve heard you manage worse than a polite insinuation.” A look of triumph passed over her features as the knife came to rest hilt-nearest and she emptied her cup into the ale horn. “Though you’ll best Nóm in it, no doubt.”
“Don’t dismiss Nóm too easily,” Balan spun his knife and turned toward her with a grin. “I’ve heard him turn a bawdy joke.”
Estreth raised a brow. “One?”
“It’s more than you expected,” Balan retorted, then took stock of the blade and drained his portion. But the drink had hardly passed his lips before he flinched and turned it to let the pebble roll out onto his palm. “Fairly caught,” he chuckled and saw a smile twitch the corners of Baran’s mouth. “I’m at your mercy.”
“That’s heartening.” Baran paused for a moment as a shaggy hound ambled over to rest its head upon his knee, and he reached down to scratch contemplatively behind its ears. Then a light of mischief flickered in his eyes and he leaned in to refill his father’s cup. “When we traveled alongside Marach’s people—”
Balan swore and dropped his face into his hands with grim resignation. “Melishk open the earth beneath me,” he muttered.
“Was it Emrach’s wife or sister they found you with in the thicket beyond the encampment?”
“Sister,” Balan replied hastily, and refilled his cup again. “And I’ll take the drink as well if we’re bringing that into the game before the first round is done.” He raised it to his lips at once and tried not to notice the uncomfortable flicker of surprise in the thought resting against his own. “It’s to you, Hfaskebel.”
“Back to you, rather.” Belen grinned as his knife came to rest leftward. “A bad start, vatta, that’s three in a row.”
“And decades of practice,” his father countered as he and Baran both drank. “Don’t think you’ll have me out so easily.”
“Gildor!” Belen called, beckoning him over as he saw him enter the Hall. “Come spare Nóm from being the only Elf among us. We’re teaching him uncouth ways in honor of Baran and he’s quite out of his depth.”
“Thank you.” Baran murmured in dry amusement.
“Be flattered.” Sichar whirled his knife in turn as Baran drained his cup, then gestured at the torque around his friend’s neck. “If you’re as coarse as the rest of us still, it means that’s not gone to your head.”
“What is the game?” Gildor crossed to stand beside Belen and watched in curiosity as Sichar emptied his drink into the ale horn.
“A poor decision, I fear.” Finrod winced as his knife came to a stop with the point toward him and a clamor of cheers and laughter passed around the table. “Almien,” he added as he reached for the ale horn and raised it toward his foster-son with a grin.
“Mind you drink it in one,” Balan noted, a quick flash of devilry in his grin. “No sipping to ease it down.”
“Gaitch…” the king murmured, then set the horn to his lips and drank. “Blessed Varda,” he rasped as the last of it passed down his throat. “You may as well swallow an ember.”
“Be glad it was only three.” Belen grinned when the laughter subsided and he shifted to make room for Gildor on the bench. “Vatta once had a horn of seven.”
“We do not speak of that.” Balan leaned forward with a snort and took the vessel from Finrod’s hand, returning it to its place at the center of the table.
“You spoke plenty at the time, though.” Eimet chuckled as he drank his turn and nodded across the table. “Mind yourself, Estreth.”
“Hm?” Estreth glanced down, then swore under her breath as she saw the pebble Balan had slipped in her cup when he reached across the table. She studied it for a long moment, then plucked it from the amber liquid and dropped it on the table before her neighbor. “Do your worst, then.”
“Shall I?” The corners of his eyes were already creasing with mirth as he watched the firelight play along the edges of his cup. “In that case, my own question back to you.” A bunched cloth struck him in the face and he broke off, ducking to the side with laughter as Estreth’s throwing arm lifted again. “Emlach’s wife or sister?”
But she had reached for her cup this time and lifted it to her lips. “Eat rocks,” she said, then downed it in a single motion.
“If you expect us to believe that wasn’t a confession…” Hathus spun the blade and added his portion to the horn with a sidelong grin, then laughed as she turned her hand toward him in a crude gesture before whirling her own knife to rest leftward.
“Sán gahail,” she retorted, and a smug smile played at her lips as Balan and Hathus both drank.
But Balan’s spin followed the same path and the smugness shifted to dance along his face. “The nectar of justice,” he murmured as she swore and reached for her cup, then he turned with a chuckle to watch Gildor try a hesitant sip. “Nay, you’ll never manage that way. Tip it quickly and don’t let it linger on the tongue.”
Gildor downed it with a shudder, then cast a pained smile toward his foster-father. “Miru na naur, you named it?”
The returning grin was both contrite and impish. “I did warn you.”
“A few more and you’ll hardly feel it,” Balan added, then laughed as Gildor’s knife came to rest toward the right and he lifted the nearest crock to refill the other’s cup. “Gods save you, lad, I didn’t mean all at once.”
Gildor swore under his breath and drank, then a moment later set his face in his hands and laughed aloud when Belen’s spin fell to his neighbors. The cup was filled a third time and he raised it to meet Baran’s salute with grim determination, then drained it in a quick motion. “Ossë’s eye,” he coughed, still laughing, and shook his head as he glanced toward Balan, incredulous. “Hardly feel it?”
“A few more before that yet, I fear.” Baran’s knife rumbled through its spin and he lifted his cup as it slowed, then saw the rune resting beneath the amber liquid. “I make one lapse…” he mumbled, drinking around it then turning it out onto the table in front of Sichar. “I should know better than to let you from my line of sight. Out with it.”
Sichar chuckled. “The gods are fickle—I only catch you when I’ve not thought up a question.” He stared at the far wall for a long moment, then shook his head. “Worst fear?”
Baran’s cup was refilled and once more raised to his lips before he paused and seemed to reconsider. “In earnestness?” he said, returning it to the table with a resigned snort. “Isolation.”
“Fon’s ashes, Baran, I thought you’d say rats or some such.” Sichar shook his head at the other’s solemn tone. “I should have asked you about Sabil’s nethers rather.”
The dry smile flashed out again and Baran’s gravity dissipated as swiftly as it had come. “No business of yours.”
“Or of yours till the morrow.” His father glanced down the table with an arched brow and a grin.
“Rest easy, grandfather, I’ve not trod a step beyond any virtue you’ve shown me.”
It was a momentary lapse, their old banter surfacing by reflex despite the estrangement, but Finrod could feel warmth coursing through Balan’s heart at the ease of it. How different this was to the wearied spirit that leaned in against his own that morning! He drained his cup when Sichar’s turn fell and found to his surprise that the sting of the hrögemetheilit had grown nearly pleasant as the game went on. This too must have been colored by the warmth of Balan’s joy, he reasoned, for it was a comfort to see them jesting again, a balm to find a thread of that wry affection still lingering. He caught Balan’s eye across the table and smiled.
“There’s only one lurking in the horn, Nóm, you needn’t fear.” Baran’s voice cut through his musings with a chuckle. “Or have you reached your fill already?”
“Hm?” Finrod turned back toward him, puzzled, then laughed as it became clear the others were waiting on him. “Nay, nay, my attention may be flagging but my constitution remains strong.” He spun the knife and poured his portion into the common cup with relief. “I am not vanquished.”
“Yet,” Eimet added as his knife spun to his neighbors, then he frowned. “Can your kind be cup-shot?”
There was only a sidelong grin in answer as the king refilled his portion and downed it without a pause.
“Aye,” Balan replied in his stead, glancing toward Eimet in amusement.
“There’ll be a fine tale there, I shouldn’t wonder.”
“Nay, nothing worse than—ai!” Finrod broke off with a sharp exclamation and his hand darted forward to catch Balan’s wrist. “Traitor,” he laughed, prying the stone from the other’s fingers before he could drop it into the cup. But at once he heard a quiet plip behind his arm and turned sharply to find Eimet beaming at his elbow and a little stone resting in the center of his cup. He looked back at Balan in mock betrayal. “You did that deliberately.”
“As one of us you said, lord.” Balan drew his arm back with a grin. “Or have you reconsidered?”
Finrod held his eye for a long moment, then chuckled and plucked the stone from his drink, setting it deliberately upon the table. “As you will, then.”
“This calls for thought,” Eimet murmured, studying him intently. “Like as not it’s the only time we’ll catch him.”
“Age?” Belen looked up in curiosity. “I’ve never yet gotten him to answer.”
“No, no,” his brother objected, “don’t waste it on a triviality. What does that matter if he’s deathless?”
“The worst lie he’s told,” suggested Sichar.
“You plague me with Emlach’s wife and let him off with untruths?” Estreth snorted. “Useless, the lot of you.” Then a glint of mischief flickered in her eyes and she leaned in to rest her forearms against the table. “I’d think one could manage a startling number of lovers if death was not holding you back,” she added as Balan shifted uncomfortably beside her.
“How many do you wager?” Baran grinned at her and balanced the hunting knife on the back of his fingers. “He’s had all the years of the sun at least, and that could make for quite a collection.”
“Seems a moderate sort,” Hathus mused. “One per decade? One per century?”
“Three is hardly impressive.”
“I’d say a dozen.”
“Two-score at least.”
“Are we near, Nóm?” Sichar laughed at the bemused glance that met his query. “No? How many, then?”
“None by your measure.”
“What was that?”
“None.”
“That does not count as my question!” Eimet cried in protest.
Estreth’s brow lifted. “How many by his own measure?”
“And does he like fair haired or dark?” Hathus added.
“Merry or solemn?”
“Men or women?” Baran leaned back in his chair, pointedly ignoring the sharp glance this earned from his father.
“Or perhaps,” Eimet interjected with a grin, “we can at last put to rest the anatomical debate that has plagued the—”
“Sán gahail,” Finrod muttered quickly and emptied his cup to a roar of laughter.
Eimet threw up his hands in feigned offense. “Your scheming’s cost me my question, woman!”
“Gaitch.” Estreth snorted as Hathus spun his blade. “Mine was answered. Any loss was your own doing.”
“True enough, true enough,” Eimet muttered as the knife came to rest toward the left, then lifted his cup to Estreth with a wink. “I drink from contrition.”
“You drink from ill luck.” Hathus said as Estreth poured her portion into the ale horn. “Fon smiles where he will—I, you see, have never yet drunk by my own roll.”
“His smiles are all of amusement then,” Eimet retorted. “You’ve had more from your neighbors’ blades than I from any.”
“A plague upon neighbors’ blades,” Gildor muttered as Balan’s turn fell to him, but his eyes were merry and he lifted the cup to his lips. “And upon this fell menace you call a game.” Then he whirled his own knife and watched in dismay as it slowed to rest with the point toward him.
“Give it here, Elinkë,” Finrod laughed as the group erupted in raucous drumming along the table, and he reached for the ale horn, “I’ll take your lot. You’ve had more than is wise already.”
“And you’ve not?” Gildor retorted as he drew it quickly out of the king’s reach, then scrunched his face into something between a grimace and a grin and raised the horn in salute. “To my lord’s health,” he said and drank.
The drumming turned to cheers at this and Belen clapped him on the back. “Let no one doubt your fortitude!” he cried, laughing. “Nóm has the benefit of trying our brew before—you’ve come in untested and matched him drink for drink.”
Gildor’s eyes watered as he returned the ale horn to its place, but managed to hold back a cough as he laughed in turn. “The more fool I.”
“Aye perhaps, but a courageous fool.”
“Which is a fine compliment,” Baran interjected with a grin, “until you learn that Bel here has no need of courage in this Peril. I’ve never yet seen him drink more than thrice in a game.”
“We’ve made him play with other knives just to be sure it wasn’t a cheat,” Sichar added, “but he does the same every time.”
Baran swore as his brother’s spin landed toward him and raised his glass with a laugh. “To the gods’ favorite little hedgehog.”
❈❈❈
It was not until the small hours of the night that Balan found himself stumbling back across the green. He had managed well enough before the last two rounds, but the year’s absence had left him out of practice and now the shadows swam about him as he passed beneath a cluster of trees. The night bugs’ hum grew deafening, their chorus swept down from the boughs and dizzied his senses.
He tripped on a tree root.
He swore.
It had been a balm to feel himself home at last, to toss the well-known jibes about the table, to hear the sound of Baran’s laugh unhindered. Damn the drink—and damn his own weakness. Why had he not let it lie?
You will stand as witness?
He had turned back to retrieve his knife from the table when Baran’s question cut through the air, quiet and carefully detached.
“I’ll have Nóm if deference calls for it, but I’d sooner it was family.”
Balan had gaped for a long moment before finding his voice, and the hesitance wove through it in a stark contrast to his son’s. “Nay, he’d reck little of deference in this—I’m certain of it. He would have it as you choose.”
“And you?”
“I would have thought you’d prefer Belen.”
“You might allow that I am the better judge of what I wish.”
Balan had flinched at the sudden sharpness in his son’s tone. “Of course. I didn’t mean to imply otherwise, only that I’d not be offended if—I mean I’d have understood it if you wished to have…” The words trailed off and he had dragged his fingers through his hair. “Gods all, Baran,” he burst out at last, “I cannot say a word but it goes awry.”
“What is it you mean, then?”
“That losing you is more than I can bear.”
Baran had snorted and turned away.
“It is my own doing, I know it.”
“Aye.”
“And I cannot change what has gone before. But neither can I change that I love you, I am proud of you. I miss you with all my being.”
Balan stumbled on another root and caught himself by the trunk, cursing the bark as it left a raw stripe across the back of his knuckles. Those words too had all gone awry, of course, each attempt to clarify his meaning seeming only to widen the rift. He had tried to tell him of the otter toy then, of being reminded of the childhood rhyme while he sat beside the river and weeping against the willow when the meaning of Baran’s farewell at last found its mark.
“I nearly turned back then,” he had confessed in a near-whisper, “and in some ways I wish that I had. But that would have have been to rob you of this—of all you’ve built here, and this vision of yours would be tethered still to my doubt and delay. It’s a marvel what you’ve done, Baran.”
His son had not looked at him, but sat scratching the ears of his wolfhound with an air of boredom. “Are you quite finished?”
“Don’t be a child. I’m trying to apologize.”
“Typically that includes some hint of remorse.”
“Which you might have heard if you’d listened to a word of it rather than making a show of your grievance. There is nothing I regret more than our parting, yet I cannot count it all an ill. Few fathers have the chance to know the fruits of their sons’ labors.”
“And that justifies it?”
“You have brought a far greater good to our people than my leadership could give.”
“Not a hard measure to surpass.”
Balan had laughed then, sharp and hollow, and turned a bitter smile upon his son. “Well,” he said at last, turning toward the door, “it seems six rounds marks the limit of your charity.”
“And twelve horses the price of your virtue.”
“Virtue!” He had spun back around and the gaze set on his son was fire. “What is it you suppose my position to be?”
“I would imagine that is determined at the pleasure of the king.”
“If you mean to say it, say it plainly.”
“Have I not?”
Balan drew up at last before his old hut and leaned with a palm against the lintel, pressing the remainder of the conversation from his mind. How could he have been such a fool? There had at last been a flicker of ease between them and instead of clasping that hope and withdrawing from the game with it intact, he had gone round after round in some half-thought attempt to prove he was no different than the man they knew before. And who was that meant to convince? Baran? Himself? A failure on either count, clearly.
He fumbled with the door, setting his shoulder to it in reflex, then remembering when it did not budge that it was his apartments in Nargothrond that turned inwards. Their own huts had ever opened to the outside, conserving the scant space within. This lapse of memory too struck in accusation and he swore as he dragged the door open and shuffled over the threshold. Why had he come back? All he had accomplished by it was to provoke his son still further—and to prove beyond a doubt that he was no longer of use to his people.
He stood blinking for a moment in a wash of unexpected light: the hearth had been lit in his absence and filled the low structure with a quiet glow, dim in truth, but his eyes smarted after the moonless night. Had he lit it himself before departing and forgotten? Nay, it had been hours since he left for the Hall. That would have burned out long since. It was Belen’s work most likely, pausing for a quick kindness on the walk back to Estreth’s hut where he had lodged since the day before. Here was a bitter trick of conscience, Balan reflected as he pulled the door back to its latch, that he should feel as guilty to find one son’s love constant as he did to find a break in the other’s. He drew his hands over his face and pressed his fingers to his eyes, then let out a jagged breath and shifted away from the threshold.
It was only then that he noticed the figure seated behind the fire and he jumped with a gasp, swearing and stumbling back against the wall. “Gods all, Nóm!” He shook himself free of the surprise and turned toward the other in exasperation as the sound of laughter filled the hut. “What are you doing here?”
“Waiting for you,” Finrod managed through his mirth as he rose and crossed unsteadily to meet him. Then he reached out with a grin and traced a finger along the pattern of Balan’s shirt. He had changed to one of his own old tunics before emerging for the noon meal, and a bright trail of embroidered leaves danced along the line of the collar. “Though if I recall, there is a thicket beyond the west pasture if that is more to your—”
“Don’t be an ass.” Balan pushed him away, half in affection, half in annoyance, and crossed to the clay washbasin.
It was Finrod who caught himself by the wall this time, laughing again, then he winced and leaned back with his head tipped toward the ceiling. “Ai…” The exclamation trailed off into an inarticulate sound and he passed his hands over his face. “I had forgotten how it burns in the veins. Fire itself would course more kindly.” He shifted to lean against one shoulder, his head now propped sideways against the flaking daub, and watched with unhidden devotion as Balan poured water into the bowl and drew handfuls to douse his face. He found himself strangely moved to see him here once more, here in the home they had shared throughout the long months of that first winter—he, Balan, the boys—where they had dwelt with all the intimacy of a family. It was only now when confronted with its distance that he learned how dearly he held it. What was it Balan had said of Andanahti-marei and their settlement beside the shores? I was tired of running from our own shadows…and there was peace in the hills. It was home, as no place had been home since the walls of childhood crumbled; the burning village, or the pearl quays painted in blood.
And like all he had seen of the village so far, this too had shifted from how he remembered it. A permanent bed had taken the place of the old bedrolls, only two of the old benches remained beside the center hearth, the walls were in dire need of a new layer of daub and limewash. But Balan’s movements held the same familiar patterns, the warmth of his skin shone with the same richness in the fire’s light, and Finrod was nearly overwhelmed by his own longing. He turned to the shelf beside him in search of distraction and lifted a small figurine in his hand. It was roughly carved, the rays uneven about its head and the hands three-fingered, but there was something pleasant about her as she looked up from his palm. “What is this?”
Balan glanced back, water dripping from his beard. “Iuthap,” he replied shortly, then turned back to the basin and the line of his shoulders stiffened. “And if you’re next in line to berate me,” he growled after a moment, shaking the water from his face and moving his hands to grip the sides of the table, “then have it out and let’s be done with it.”
“Berate you?” Finrod’s grin faltered and he stared at the other in confusion. “Whatever for?”
Balan shook his head sullenly and his knuckles whitened against the wood.
“You are unwell.”
“Leave it, Nóm, I’m only tired.”
The silence grew pointed and Balan felt the king’s presence like a weight against his thought. “I do know when you lie to me.”
Balan swore, then turned away in resignation. “I argued with Baran.”
“You seemed in fair harmony when I took my leave. What came between you?”
“It matters not.” He waved a hand dismissively as he slipped off his boots and kicked them to the side. “The price of horses.” But the drink had left his thought unguarded and the memory seeped through before he could hold it back.
“Ai…melmenya…” Finrod fell back into his own tongue as the other’s hurt wove within him. It was growing difficult to hold the senses apart; the world had gone soft about him, rippling in quiet waves, silken and fluid. It was the hrögemetheilit’s doing. The hum had risen as their game drew on—nay, not a hum, but rather the impression of a hum, every movement slow and smooth—and ever since Belen’s victory he had felt wrapped in its warmth, like summer’s sunlight resting heavy upon his skin. Gradually he grew aware that he had begun slipping between his own mind and the other’s with the same fluidity, watching as Balan drew the knife from his sash and stowed it on the old rope and board shelves above the bed, feeling the clenched anger in the other’s gut and tasting Balan’s bitterness upon his own tongue—of being assumed the king’s lover and reaping all the ramifications that followed from it, while in truth holding nothing but his own longing and lack.
Balan’s sons had seen it, Finrod acknowledged with a pang of mortification, Balan’s people had seen it. They had all known the truth of his devotion sooner than his own soul had discerned it. Standing here in the familiar hut with the taste of hrögemetheilit lingering upon his breath, it seemed impossible that his oblivion could have outlived that mirrored night in midwinter. Their hands clasped beside this same fire, tears and thoughts mingled alike, the vision of Balan’s face caught within the web of blood and ice—how had he seen that image in his soul and not known?
He shifted forward without thought, and each motion was like passing through waves, weightless as he had hovered beneath Ivrin’s waters, or caught amid the Celon where every moment had slowed now to long hours in hallowed memory.
Balan turned as he approached and Finrod took the other’s hands within his own, he drew them gently to his mouth. “One for comfort,” he whispered with his mind still half within the Longest Night, and he kissed the first palm, lips burning with the touch, the slight taste of the other’s skin. “And one for company.” The second palm as the first, then traveling down to the wrist, the inside of the forearm. Oh Valar, he could still feel Balan’s lips tracing this same path along his own wrist, his own arm pinned in the sighing grasses where the airna’akran trickled like blood along his skin, pulse pounding as Balan’s pulse did now beneath his touch. As his own drummed again at the prickle of the other’s beard against his fingers, at the little hiss of intaken breath. As though in a trance, he watched his fingers trace slowly over Balan’s neck, then down across the collar bone and the top of his chest, along the honey-brown skin burnished bronze in the firelight. He was drunk on this as well, he found—on the nearness of him, on the warmth of him—and in that dizzy intoxication he let desire course unchecked, racing with the hrögemetheilit’s fire in his veins.
His hands had strayed again and were passing now along the woven sash, were finding the knot, working it loose. He was letting it fall to the floor and gathering Balan’s shirt within his grasp, drawing it away—
But Balan’s hands closed like a vice about his wrists and shoved him aside with unexpected vehemence. “No,” he hissed. “Keep your pity.”
Finrod staggered back from the force of the rebuff, staring in stunned silence till at last he shook his head and held out his arms, bewildered. “Balan?”
“After all that has gone between us, you come here now and offer me crumbs?”
“It is not pity, I—Balan!” He caught his hand as the other stepped away. “Please…”
“What is it you want of me, Nóm? I cannot understand you.”
Finrod reached out to cradle the other’s cheek within his palm. “Beloved,” he whispered at last, his voice hoarse and shaking, “There are things that…things that I have always understood to be true, or rather that I have never thought to question, that I…” He trailed off helplessly. The amusement in Maedhros’ eyes lingered vividly in his memory. The chuckle, the half-affectionate condescension. Mortification was already trickling up his throat, embarrassment washed hot upon his cheeks and he shrank from the thought of confession. Ever thy father’s son thou art—and ever the Vanya he. That amused pity would weave through Balan’s eyes, through Balan’s laugh when he knew the truth, and any trust would surely be shattered.
But the other’s spirit had begun drawing in about his own, comforting and heavy, and he realized with a start that the edges of his mind still lay loose and unguarded within the haze. That Balan had reached into his own thought with as much ease as Finrod had slipped in and out of the other’s. He froze.
The wry chuckle washed over him, but this mirth was tender and not sardonic; the gaze compassionate, not patronizing, and the only condemnation was a mild reproof for his weeks of silence.
“Balan,” he breathed at last, and laid the whole of the memory open, “it is not pity.”
“No,” Balan reached out with a wan smile to cup the other’s cheek within his palm, “it’s the damned hrögemetheilit. Thou wouldst only rue it on the morrow, and then where would I be left?”
Finrod raised his hand to rest over the other’s. “I mightn’t,” he whispered.
But Balan took Finrod’s hands within his own. “I know thee,” he said, bringing them up and returning the kiss to each palm. “Given a choice, I would remain thy desire sooner than become thy regret. I am content to have thine heart.”
“Liar.”
“Aye.” A grin spread over Balan’s face at last and he ran his hand affectionately through the golden hair. “But I’ve grown accustomed to what I have. And I would not risk its loss.”
Finrod caught hold of the other’s hand and moved it to rest over his face, hid his eyes behind it, his lips to the palm and a smile playing at the edges of them. “I am a fool.”
“Yes, lord.” Balan laughed quietly and squeezed the face in his hand so it distorted and the other laughed. “Thine own droll court clown.” He slid his hand to rest along the jaw in a caress. “Elenya,” he murmured fondly and drew him down till he could touch his lips to Finrod’s forehead.
“Beloved…”
“No.” Balan shoved him lightly. “Now go sleep, or whatever it is your kind does when you’ve had more than you hold.”
“Mmph.” Finrod clasped Balan’s hand for a moment longer, then he seemed to shrug the heaviness aside and sprang onto the nearest bench, backing nimbly along its edge and beginning the same drinking melody Balan had loosed upon that first winter’s ice,
“O come! Be merry, my lad,
there’s drink to be had,
there’s mead and ale in good measure…“
Balan watched with amusement as he hopped to the second bench without so much as a glance behind him.
“Aye there, lass, fetch us some!
And when you’ve so done—“
“Have a care, you fool, or you’ll find yourself in the fire. What are you doing?”
“Why, naught but your own instructions.” Finrod leapt to the floor as he reached the end of the bench and glanced back at Balan with a smile. “I go to lie besotted amongst the heather blossoms and sing your people’s melodies unto the dancing stars.”
“And good riddance to you,” Balan retorted, laughing as the king swung the door open and turned back to dip a formal bow.
Then he slipped like a shade over the threshold and was gone.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
lúilë: [Q] sapphire
almien: [Q] cheers, (lit.) to good fortune
miru na naur: [S] wine of fire, see Here in Our Frailty
Elinkë: [Q] “little star,” a nickname drawn from Elárato, the approximated Telerin form of Gildor
melmenya: [Q] my love
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
gaitch: swine
Andanahti-marei: evening/twilight-lake
vatta: father
haelis: hello, greetings
sán gahail: (to) your health
Hfaskebel: hedgehog (needle-mouse)
MISC NOTES
- Regarding the gift of a pendant stone, see the Laws and Customs Among the Eldar in which it is stated that “[a]mong the Noldor also it was a custom that the bride's mother should give to the bridegroom a jewel upon a chain or collar; and the bridegroom's father should give a like gift to the bride.”
- “cup-shot”: an archaic term for intoxication
22. All of Gold Woven
Had they not promised as much already? Were these not the words of his own soul on the battlements of the Cened Beraid, caught in the other’s arms behind a shroud of rain? His eyes drifted from the joined hands to find Balan’s face. I pledge to you fealty of my heart…
Midsummer in Estolad. Baran and Balan address their conflict, games are somewhat fraught, and the vistors join in the celebrations for Baran's wedding.
Read 22. All of Gold Woven

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
Estolad
He woke slowly, blinking as sleep ebbed, and gathered the blanket in some half-thought reflex that his grip on the wool would hold oblivion too from slipping away. His fingers felt thick and clumsy. There was a sharp ache in the small of his back, a throbbing that had settled somewhere behind his right eye, like a taut band strung between one temple and the other. He groaned and turned his face into the straw mattress.
Sunlight was pouring from the window along the eastern wall. Gods all, why had it been cut there? Three other walls they had, yet they placed it here where the light’s blade would pierce most keenly. In the fog of waking, he felt a moment’s certainty that Baran had done so deliberately and was now taking a smug satisfaction to see his work come to fruition at last.
Baran.
Apprehension rose with the nausea in his gut and he rolled back, opening his eyes with an effort. This was not dawn’s pale light, but the bright warmth of mid-morning. How late had he slept? They would not have let him drift through the celebrations, surely? Nay, Belen would have seen to it. Nóm too would not have let him be forgotten. Unless, Balan pondered dubiously, he had been equally afflicted with the night’s consequences and lay abed yet in this same wretchedness.
He pushed up from the bed and promptly swore, leaning his elbows against his knees and dropping his face into his hands as the room tilted dangerously. What had possessed him? Age had no business playing at youth’s folly—and heavily had he dipped from that well in the night. Nausea rose again as the memory of his argument with Baran pressed through the fog and he groaned, drawing his hands slowly along his face and willing the room to steady. They had struck at each other with adolescent pettiness, each jibe more vicious than the last, and the recollection of it left fresh weals along his spirit, the pain in his son’s voice biting like barbs upon the lash.
Balan stood with an effort and shuffled the short distance to the wash basin. Had he washed when he returned in the night? He must have, he reflected in bemusement, for the basin was filled already, the ewer beside it half-empty. His balance swayed and he gripped the edges of the table, the motion sending ripples through the water and his jaw tightened against the nausea in response. This was no more than he deserved—reason had warned him well enough at the time but he shrugged it aside, amused and confident in the arms of tradition. He dipped his hands into the basin with a snort and lifted a handful of water to douse his face. Tradition’s embrace was fickle.
He drew a second handful and let it linger against his brow. It was cool upon his eyes, soothing the ache even as it had the liquor’s giddy blaze in the small hours of the night. How it burns in the veins. The echo of Nóm’s laugh trickled through the air behind him. Fire itself would course more kindly.
Oh gods all. That memory too materialized from the haze and he laughed in disbelief, bitter and hoarse. Fool! He plunged his head beneath the water in full now, sloshing it over his neck while his fingers scrabbled against his scalp to clear the muddle. Had he spent two years in hopeless longing only to turn him away at the crisis? A flicker of vindication kindled in some quiet, bruised corner of himself, and he tugged the shirt from his shoulders, toweling his face roughly then casting it aside. Good. Nóm too should know the sting of denial.
The lethargy had eased somewhat with the water’s chill and he began dressing methodically, chewing sprigs of lemon balm to settle his stomach as he bound first braies, then breeches, then slipped his arms through a loose linen shirt. It was grounding, the ritual of these simple tasks. They drew him back to himself, each piece lifted from the haze and brought again to the whole, and by the time he worked cedarwood oil through his beard, he knew himself once more.
Balan rubbed the excess oil into his forearms, then bent to retrieve his sash. It lay in a jumble, still coiled on the packed earth where Nóm had let it fall, and for a moment he lingered, passing the cloth through his fingers and letting the shiver burn once more along his spine. What if he had not thrust him away? His rebuff had been from anger after all, not prudence—at least in that first reflex. What if he had yielded? If beyond hope he had awakened at his side? The touch of the other’s hands lingered still at his waist, fingers brushing over the skin when they gathered the cloth away.
His breath drew in with a hiss and he rose, shaking free of the memory as he wound the sash and cinched it tightly. Yielding would have gained nothing. He would have awakened at Nóm’s side, to be sure—but awakened too to the sight of remorse spooling like ink through the other’s eyes, spreading outward till the whole was stained with its shadow. The image was as vivid as the flaking daub before his eyes, the cold panic of the other’s soul as tangible as the rough-hewn door boards against his palms.
What I want is the whole of thee. He paused with one hand on the lintel, one on the stile just above the latch, while Nóm’s words circled through him as they had since the waters of spring.
Nay, Balan’s heart had ever countered, what I want is anything of thee.
But this new certainty weighed heavy, settled and sure in his bones and as true of his own soul now as it was of the other’s. He too would never be satisfied by anything less than the whole.
Long he lingered, forehead resting against the timbers and allowing despair a moment’s confluence with the exhaustion in his veins, till at last he collected himself, then took a breath and eased the door open. The sun pierced into the hut like a blade and he flinched, lifting a hand to shade his eyes and swearing as he shuffled into the mid-morning light.
His son was there.
He sat perched atop a low rock wall, arms propped against his knees and turning a cup in his hands while he watched a group of chickadees pluck seeds from the path. He looked up at the sound of the latch and Balan faltered as shame scraped against his spirit, their previous night’s quarrel once more fresh in his mind. But Baran’s gaze was mild and he straightened, holding out the cup like a peace offering and his father moved tentatively to cross the distance between them.
“I thought you’d have need of it.”
Balan took the drink with a grimace, the scent of vinegar and eel wafting through the air. “Your aunt’s brew?”
“Aye.”
He snorted. “That will please her.”
“Aye.” A ghost of amusement passed over Baran’s lips. “Though she’s no notion I meant it for you. I asked for double and she seemed to think my own state dire enough.”
Balan’s lips twitched in turn and he drained the mixture, then returned the cup with a shudder. “Gods all, it’s vile, isn’t it?” A pouch of willow bark was offered next and he shook a quantity onto his palm with murmured thanks, then hoisted himself onto the wall while his son resumed fiddling with the empty cup.
“I spoke unfairly in the night.” Baran’s voice was quiet, and he held his gaze on the birds who had fluttered back to continue their gleaning.
“Nay, lad, it’s I who should—”
“I spoke unfairly and I am sorry for it.”
“And I.” It was with an effort that Balan held back the urge to contradict him, to insist that any blame should be set on his own shoulders instead. But he knew it needed only a hair’s weight to shift the momentary balance into conflict, and so he bit back the reflex and shook his head. “You were not wrong,” he added instead. “Or rather you were, but I would that you were not, which amounts near enough to the same.”
“A fine thing to hear from one’s father,” Baran muttered dryly, then the implication struck him and his surge of indignation was nearly palpable. “Does he think you beneath him?”
The anger in his son’s voice spread like a balm along his soul. It was the first time since their parting that his ire had been summoned in defense and not reprimand—and Balan felt a nearly irresistible urge to reply in kind. His own bitterness was ever just beneath the surface and it would take little to stoke that wound into flame and give vent to his lingering sense of injury, that through a shared offense he might hold this camaraderie with his boy for a few moments longer. But as he hesitated, his mind drifted to the image of Nóm beside the fire in their old hut, laughing as he and Baran traded jests through the winter; or the proud affection in his voice when he told Balan the night before how glad he was to see Baran’s skill flourish. “No,” he said at last, knowing he could not willingly set them at odds, even if it was in service of his own reconciliation, “don’t think poorly of him in this. That’s not the reason.” He passed his hands along his face, then shrugged with a dry laugh. “Though to speak truly, it would be simpler were it so.”
“If he’s scorned you, I’ll think poorly of him whatever the reason.”
Balan felt the corners of his mouth twitch with warmth at his son’s continued defense and he shook his head. “Not scorned exactly. It’s more that—I mean he believes that it would…that it isn’t…” He trailed awkwardly into silence and grimaced, regretting the words almost at once. How could he possibly explain the maze of Nóm’s principles or make sense to another of this precarious balance they had found? Baran, practical and determined, would have little patience for that circuitous labyrinth. Already, he noted, his sons’ lips had pressed into a thin line and the crease between his brows was deepening. And no wonder—it was laughable to find oneself in this bind; it must be mortifying to find one’s father so. He swore and shifted on the wall as the silence drew out uncomfortably between them.
“Belen told me about the goblins.”
“Belen?” The question was nearly an exclamation and Balan looked toward his son in surprise.
“Gildor let it slip to him yestereve when the game was done,” Baran explained, amusement tugging at the corners of his mouth, and he chuckled. “Poor Gildor. Nóm should have given him a better warning before letting him join in.”
“And Bel reported back to you.”
“Of course he did. My father was very nearly our first casualty of the Nómin’s wars. It was his duty to do so—his duty both in love and fealty.” Baran’s voice was carefully measured, but sharp nonetheless with suppressed feeling. “You should have told us.”
“And handed you a further grudge against the both of us?”
“You nearly died.”
“I didn’t.”
“And if you had?”
“He made sure I did not.”
“Vatta…”
Balan looked back toward his son and in an instant his heart was pierced with guilt. It was the same face still, lips pressed together and fear held stubbornly at bay, the same boy who had huddled at the fire beside him each long night following Esrid’s death, and whose grief he had not known even then how to comfort. He felt the same knot catch in his throat and, when he regained his voice, shook his head in concession. “I’m sorry,” he managed at last, avoiding the other’s eye. “I didn’t want you to know. I’ve no good reason for it.”
Baran was quiet for a time, then at length he nodded and the silence stretched more easily between them, long minutes rolling each into the other as insects buzzed in the summer grasses and the sounds of the village drifted along the breeze. Balan filled his lungs with the rich, green scent and found himself longing, not for the last time, that he had come home to stay.
”Are you happy?”
The question was almost contemplative, and Balan turned in surprise at the earnestness in his son’s voice. Baran’s gaze had returned to the chickadees and he was no longer fidgeting with the empty cup, but held it clasped within his hands.
“It isn’t a trap,” he added when he saw the other fumbling for a reply. “I mean it sincerely.”
Balan tried to chuckle at this, but all he achieved was a rasping snort. “Difficult to say when I don’t know the answer myself.” Again he drew his hands along his face, searching for words that might knit another span across this rift, but his mind was leaden still with the lingering fog. Here at last was the answer to his prayer beneath the ash tree—and perhaps after all there was something of Fon’s impishness to the goddess, for her blessing came only now while he was too muddled yet to find his way through the pitfalls of reconciliation. He bit back a curse and shook his head. “Do you remember how we would sit on the old cart when you were a lad? You’d wake when the first light brushed the horizon and come find me—every morning, as though you knew somehow by instinct the dawn was nearing—and we’d sit together with our feet propped like this against the wheels and watch the new day rise from the lands we’d left.”
“I remember.” Baran looked back at the cup in his hands and a grin tugged at his mouth. “I thought men didn’t sleep when they were grown. You were always there already, no matter how early I woke. I don’t know how you managed all this on so little sleep.”
“Mmph,” Balan snorted with a wry twist of his brow. “Well, I didn’t manage it well.” A second flight of chickadees swooped through the clearing and he watched as they soared on over the heart of the village. “It wasn’t flattery, you know,” he added after a moment. “I’ve no idea how you’ve done it all in a year’s span, but it truly is a marvel.”
There was only a noncommittal grunt in reply and Balan watched his son’s knuckles whiten about the carved cup in his hands.
He fell quiet again, but the lingering question weighed all the more insistently in the silence, till at length he rested his hands against the wall beneath him and drew an unsteady breath. “Am I happy?” he repeated with reluctance, gripping the stone till it bit into his palms. “No.” But as soon as he had forced the admission from his mouth he knew it for a lie, and shook his head. “And yes. I don’t know. I sleep,” he added with a dry chuckle, “which is more than I could say of the years gone before, so there must be some measure of peace, I suppose. But happiness?” He pressed his lips together for a long moment in an unconscious mirror of his son, then shook his head once more. “Not since I lost your mother have I loved—leastwise, not like this—and then too I loved in hopelessness.”
Baran glanced over in query and his father’s lips twitched with self-deprecation.
“Have I not told you that before? It wasn’t till you were a babe in arms that I knew she thought of me as aught more than a necessary task.”
“Aye, you’ve told me. I’d forgotten it.”
“And not till Bel that I believed her.” A little shower of dirt cascaded down the stones as he shifted again to sit more comfortably. “That is one of my greatest regrets: I should have told her what she was to me from the beginning—as you’ve done.”
There was another long silence and Balan tried not to think of that far hillside with its rolling waves of grass where Esrid’s bones rested beneath the soil. Or of her laugh when she had traced a hand along his cheek, eyes dancing in amusement as she took in his earnest surprise. Sometimes you’re dense as stone, Bal. I’d have relied on charity a hundred times over sooner than wed you if I didn’t wish it. Or of that nearer laugh, the holy spring chuckling while Nóm’s tears had dropped onto his cheeks, the feel of his face cupped within the other’s palms. Let me remember thee ever as this, here in the light and the water’s music, here with the words still half-upon thy tongue.
“Sabil is a good woman,” he said, coming back to himself with an effort and managing a faint smile. “I’m glad to find you’re a braver man than I.”
A faint grin tugged at Baran’s mouth, tinged with the same self-deprecation as his father’s. “You know damn well I’m nothing of the kind.”
“No?” Balan chuckled and glanced fondly at his son. “Well, whoever’s work it was, I’m glad of it.”
“Aye.” The other’s smile warmed and he rolled the cup along his palm once again. “It was she who convinced me to come find you this morning—and in no uncertain terms. So you’ve her to thank for that as well, I suppose. She was right, of course,” he added with grudging acquiescence, “but I’d not have done it without her bidding.”
“Then I’m deep in her debt.” Sabil had been quick to greet him on that uneasy first evening. She was seated on the far side of her father, halfway along the row of high tables, and slipped down as soon as she saw him meander out with Belen onto the main floor of the hall. Goodness go with you, dára. Her arms had been crossed formally as she spoke the usual greeting, but then she stepped forward with a smile and kissed him on each cheek. I am glad to see you home again—Baran and I both, for all he’s a stubborn mule about it.
His son sat on in silence till at length he slid from the wall, then brushed the dirt from his legs and moved away with a nod toward the path. But he had only managed a few paces before he slowed and turned, lingering uncertainly and scuffing little furrows into the dirt. “Vatta, will you stand as my witness?” he asked at last, eyes faltering when he tried to meet his father’s gaze. “I asked it already, but you knew well enough that was only obligation.”
“Aye, lad, if it’s what you wish. I’ll do it gladly, obligation or no.”
Baran nodded and turned over another furrow with his toe. “I’ve not forgiven you, mind,” he added quietly as he kicked the dirt flat once again, “nor am I certain that I mean to. But I can’t bear to break with you either.”
A knot of emotion tangled in Balan’s throat, muddled between grief and hope, and it was a long moment before he was able to speak. “It’s kind of you to say it. I did not look for even that much.”
“Nor I.”
“Baran.” His son turned back again as he reached the path and it was Balan now who could not bring himself to meet the other’s eye. “I’ll stay if it will do aught to set it aright between us.”
Baran watched him for a time in silence, then shook his head with an effort. “No,” he said at last. “No, it’s too far gone for that.”
❈ ❈ ❈
His mother had first passed on the tale when he was too young to remember it, small and round-cheeked and wrapped in a sheepskin upon her lap. He would watch from the bundle with wide serious eyes as she chanted, and frown and move his lips as though trying to mimic the patterns of hers. Or so she had told him. His own memory was of himself at Fina’s age, or Avina’s, sitting beside the winter hearth and prodding at the embers in time with his mother’s voice.
Luftu the Great One is the goddess of wind,
the goddess of wind is the breath of all life.
The brother of Luftu is Vris the Fell,
the spirit of winter, the god of cold.
When Men were young yet in the land of their making,
and the clay of their flesh still soft from Melishk’s hand,
Vris grew jealous of the dwelling they were given,
and his anger burned toward the Great Ones.
For Vris had been forbidden from entering the world,
lest the ice of his presence cause life to fail
or wither the bounty that grew from the land.
So he looked with envy on the bright earth beneath him,
and brooded and thought much on what he was denied.
And lo! when Iuthap leapt in dance through the firmament,
and Luftu and Satheweis sang in the air;
when Melishk and Guënid drew life from the loam,
Vris gathered the Dark of the timeless about him
and slipped down thus shrouded like a cloud through the sky.
As he passed, Iuthap’s light was darkened at midday,
obscured like a stain o’er the midst of the sun.
Day turned to night as he ran laughing onward.
Clay cracked and hardened, water slowed into ice.
Men fled before him, the fruit of earth withering.
They cried out in fear for the gods to come to their aid,
that the warmth of Fon’s presence might save them from dying.
And Fon hearkened at first to the prayers of his people
when they offered oblations of felled trees and branches,
of dried grass and tinder spread on the ground.
Gladly he passed from one hearth to another,
melting the frost and holding the winter at bay.
But fire is fickle and beholden to no master—
save Guënid alone, who lay chained by the ice—
and easily swayed is the bent of his thought.
Thus ere long he grew restless
and flickered and tested his bounds.
He lept from the hearthstones and chased after Luftu
whenever her breath in the air passed him by,
eating the forests instead of the offerings.
Then Men despaired and to Iuthap turned in their terror
with prayers for the warmth of her light to preserve them.
Long it was ere their voices wound through the darkness,
but at last to the goddess’ ears they ascended
and her heart was moved to pity at the sound of their suffering.
She could not herself descend to deliver them,
for the earth would burn should she dare tread so near.
Thus down from the firmament she sent five of her maidens
and one by one they bore their spears in Vris’ path.
The first to reach him was beaten back with laughter
and bound beside Guënid in the frozen streams.
The next struck a blow and drew a howl from the spirit,
cleaving one finger from each of his hands.
But she too was driven back and chained with her sister,
for heavy was the dark gathered still ‘round their foe.
The third and the fourth fared better,
hewing each at his hold on the shadows,
till they too were overcome and bound in the ice.
But Vris’ grip had been loosened
and the darkness pulled free of him.
It raced through the firmament till it could hide
once more behind Iuthap and preserve
its tender clouds from the brilliance of her face.
Naked now, Vris cried out as the fifth set upon him
and he was matched blow for blow upon the withered grass.
For his strength till then had been in the shroud of the shadows
where his opponents swung blind and he struck without risk.
Swiftly she fought him and swiftly she triumphed,
swiftly he was bound and flung on his face.
Swiftly too was the—
Pain shot along Balan’s fingers and he stumbled, swearing as his opponent’s staff slid over his own and drove his spear to the ground.
“Your skill’s lapsed, old man.” Hathus called from the edge of crowd gathered around the green, his lips turned in amusement as he watched Balan stagger back from the blow. “You’re out of practice.”
He twisted to the side and managed to take the follow-up thrust in the thigh instead of the gut. “I’m practiced enough,” he retorted, short-winded as he abandoned the center and drew out of range, “only you’ve pitted me against a menace. You know I’ve not bested him since he was a lad. Besides,” he added with a snort, “winter isn’t meant to be the victor.”
“No.” Sunlight glinted from the beaten copper as Baran lifted the mask and wiped sweat from his brow, grinning. “But he is meant to put up a fight.”
“Gaitch.” Balan glanced down at his left thigh. A bright line of red madder marked the cloth above his knee and the skin beneath it smarted from the impact. “Vris never had to raise spear with a headful of hrögemetheilit. Nay, I’m bested,” he cried with a laugh, pulling back when Baran dropped his spear into the attack once more, “leave off!”
“One leg marked is hardly bested, vatta.”
“Near enough at my age.” He cast a quick glare over his shoulder at Estreth’s bark of laughter. “Oh, aye? Then come stand in my place if you think you’d fare better.”
“Much better. But then it’s far more more amusing to watch you flail than to be your deliverer.”
Balan swung his own spear into position and there was a resounding crack as the two staves met. Quickly, he shifted his over the other to break the bind, but his son’s staff fell away beneath him and wheeled around, the butt striking his shoulder and the ball of madder-dipped cloth arcing over to rest just below his jaw.
There was a moment’s pause before Baran tapped the cloth lightly against his father’s throat. “Now you’re bested,” he said, mirth once more softening the set of his features; then he grinned in full as his gaze drifted beyond Balan’s shoulder. “Nóm,” he called, and there was an unreadable flicker in his eye as he beckoned toward the king, “you’ll stand as his champion, won’t you? I’ve kept him three bouts beyond his wish and I fear I’m well nigh losing his love.”
A surge of discomfort rushed through Balan’s veins at the realization that the king had joined the crowd without his notice, and he felt his color rise as Nóm stepped from behind Sídhon and into the periphery of his vision. Gods all in Iuthap’s mercy, he implored silently, let him have been lurking there through the earlier bouts as well, when he had at least parried his son’s blows and held his own in the dance awhile.
“Gladly.”
The king’s voice was blithe as he moved to stand at his side, and Balan glanced at him in thinly veiled irritation. The Elf had been singing garbled melodies and dancing over hearth benches last he set eyes on him—Nóm had no business being any less cropsick than he.
“The rules are the same as at Thalos?”
“Aye. Though we tip the ends with madder when we have it so there’s no bickering over hits scored.” Baran dipped the knotted cloth in a nearby pot and held it up in demonstration. “You should mind your shirt,” he added in warning as Finrod moved to take the sparring staff from Balan’s hand, “it’ll stain the cloth.”
The king mirrored his example, dousing the blunt end in the dye, then glanced toward him with amused confidence. “Only if I permit you a strike.”
“I scored three at Thalos,” Baran retorted and shifted his grip on the pole with a grin.
Finrod laughed, then shrugged with the air of one humoring another’s whim and returned the spear to Balan, reached back, and drew the tunic over his head. “I was only defending my own honor then,” he quipped with a thin smile, but Balan heard the perilous note that had crept into his voice.
“As are you now, lord,” he interjected. His own tone was carefully wry, but the glance toward the king was sharp in warning as he took the shirt from his hands and stepped back toward the edge of the green. “Mine has fled the game long since and needs no tending.” While he spoke, he saw his son’s eyes drift to the scar stretching over the king’s shoulder, where the mottled red and pink had left an eloquent tale scrawled across the pale flesh. There was a brief tightening of Baran’s jaw as its origin dawned on him and Balan felt an unaccountable discomfort at the other’s revelation. The scars begotten in that skirmish had grown sacred somehow, intimate in his memory—the wound whose blood had soaked through his own tunic in the close press of the other’s embrace, the faint white line lingering across the back of his own hand where one cord had cut deep, where Nóm had unbound the linen wrapping and cradled the hand within his palm…
“I’ll wager a garnet hilt-ring on your lad still.” Hathus’ voice brought him back to himself with a jolt, and for a moment Balan blinked in confusion before managing a snort in response.
“What, and have me take odds against my own son?” He bent to retrieve a cloth from the grass and began scrubbing ineffectually at the various dye marks.
“You would swift enough if it wasn’t a sure loss.” Hathus chuckled and leaned against his sparring pole. “He’s bested me twice already, to say nothing of the bloodbath you’ve just left. And Nóm doesn’t look full fit.”
“Rot.”
“So you say, but you’ll not defend him with a wager? A tin-bladed vassal you make.”
This won a laugh as Balan gave up his attempt to remove the madder and retrieved his shirt instead. “Go haggle your wares at a less-fraught market,” he retorted when his head emerged from the tunic, matching Hathus’ grin with one his own. “I’m not buying.”
A series of cracks echoed abruptly from the green and Balan turned sharply. They had begun while he was distracted with the cloth and were now circling—lunging and dodging with dizzying speed as each gained, then forfeited control of the center. His heart caught in his throat. He had assumed this would mirror their bouts in the foothills by Thalos, when Nóm had marked that first midsummer beside them and joined good-naturedly in each custom. He had been a merry opponent then, laughing as he sparred, merry in victory or defeat, his motions more akin to dance than to combat. But the contest before him now was fierce. Nóm moved with the same catlike speed he recalled from the ravine in Dorthonion and Balan was amazed to see his son keep pace, each strike met and parried or dodged and forced anew.
“My king has told me these games are to recall winter’s defeat at the hand of your sun goddess.” Sídhon nudged the conversation into neutrality with a smile. He had shifted unobtrusively to Balan’s side as they spoke and observed the proceedings with curiosity. “But if exile was his reward, how then do your histories account for the yearly cold?”
“Rather simply: Vris was indeed bound and dragged before Iuthap, but the tale has it that he held four of her handmaidens captive—and Guënid too still caught in the ice.” Balan’s breath caught with a hiss as the blunted spear-end struck Baran’s arm and he watched in apprehension as his son drew back from the blow. Nay, it was only a thin line of dye, he noted with relief, a glancing blow that would not be counted toward an end. “The Great Ones consented to let Vris join them, as was his wish, in order to purchase the others’ freedom. But it was decreed that it could only be for a small portion of each year, lest Men be destroyed and all the work of the Great Ones be for naught.” Balan flinched as his son twisted to the side, once more dodging what seemed to be a certain hit. “He is allowed to run through the earth each winter, holding his temporary dominion—each midwinter we mark that his reign is bounded, and we chase him from our homes each spring with alder branches and dancing.”
Nóm’s blows were relentless. He had driven Baran back to the far edge of the crowd and the clatter of pole-strikes was a swift percussion over the green.
Or no, it was Baran gaining now. He had nearly scored a hit to the king’s leg, but Nóm shifted faster than sight and Baran stumbled below the other’s spear with the force of his miss. That sudden dip brought him out of range, however, and in the brief respite it gained he snatched the mask from his face and cast it to the side, freeing the full range of his vision.
“What does the game represent, then? It was the maidens who defeated the spirit, if my lord recounted the tale aright, but the guise seems to be the sun herself.”
“Aye, it’s a game, not a direct retelling. The victor of the bout wins the mask and faces the next comer. And so on until they remain unchallenged. It’s played every midsummer.”
An uneasy weight pressed at the bottom of Balan’s stomach as he watched them circle. The uncertainty stood out in Baran’s eyes now that the mask had been drawn away, and Balan found himself unaccountably anxious at the thought of either outcome. The contest between them had been a draw in Thalos—Nóm claiming the first bout, Baran the second—and only now did Balan understand what he should have seen at the time; that Baran had won his round because it was a celebration, because Nóm saw what pride the lad held in his skill and chose to leave it intact. Balan watched this new onslaught with awe and trepidation mingling in his gut, and found it a marvel that Baran could manage to hold the other at bay.
He took a deep breath. If Nóm had spared dignity for the sake of festivity, then surely he would relent here too in deference to the day. Baran’s marriage was a greater call for goodwill than a yearly festival had been. Was it not? Balan brushed a tentative query against the king’s thought, then pulled back at once as though he had touched hot iron. The ordered quiet he was accustomed to find was churning instead, the world sharp and dissonant in the other’s perception, and every motion reverberated at a volume that set his teeth on edge. Perhaps after all, Balan noted with a twinge of vindication, Nóm had not escaped wholly unscathed from the hrögemetheilit.
The hrögemetheilit. Clarity struck with the thought of the previous night and he nearly swore aloud. Nóm knew naught of the morning’s conversation. He had leapt into the contest with all the earnest fury of one of Sídhon’s hounds, determined somehow to level the scale and soothe the sting of Balan’s shame. Oblivious, thrice-beloved idiot! Did he think wounding Baran’s pride in recompense would do anything to set it aright? Hastily, Balan reached out again, pressing restraint into the other’s thought and gritting his teeth against the cacophony—it was jagged still with anger and spilling over with a piercing sensitivity to every detail about him. Birdsong on the far side of the village. An insect crawling. The scrape of metal within the Hall where food was stirred in iron pots. A blade of grass whistling in the wind. Gods all, he thought with a shudder, a throbbing head and nausea were far preferable.
Baran was beginning to falter. He still managed to block most of the king’s strikes, but there were telltale lines of madder dye showing along each arm now, one particularly ugly mark brushing the outside of his chest. And no wonder—he had fought seven bouts before Balan joined the games, to say nothing of the five he held against his father when no others would challenge him. He was weary and it was growing increasingly clear that he could not hold the pace, but Nóm did not relent. If anything, the volley had quickened and Baran was driven back again to the far side of the green.
Anger began to seep through Balan’s chest and he let it trickle into the space where his thought touched the king’s. There was answering twinge, defensive and righteous, a hot roar of indignation, focus. Balan thrust back against it in exasperation. He did not need a champion. He did not need Nóm to fight his battles for him. He did not want a guard dog.
He felt the other’s fury blench in the face of his own and saw the slight fumble as Finrod blocked the incoming stave, then leapt back to slow the bout.
“You look anxious as a mother wren.” Sídhon glanced down at him in amusement, chuckling at Balan’s responding snort. “Be easy. My lord is no fool—watch.”
The shift was barely perceptible, a slight easing by degrees that Balan would have missed were it not for the new tone in the other’s thought, or for the months of watching him spar in practice with Edrahil and the Guard. To all others it seemed that Baran had found a new store of strength in the face of the onslaught and now he was driving the king back in turn, his own determination blazing with all the heat of Nóm’s tethered vengeance.
They were only a few strides from him now. Baran ducked beneath the strike, Finrod leapt a hair’s breadth beyond the return. Baran’s staff turned like a wheel, swinging again before the king could raise his own beyond defense and the staves struck, caught in a bind.
Then the brush of Nóm’s thought moved like a quick smile, bright and brief and nigh impish in its concession, and Balan nearly cried out as he watched the drop and strike that should have knocked Baran’s spear to the side. It came up short. There was a clatter of poles, a turn, a blur of motion. Nóm’s head snapped backward with the blow and he staggered to the side, only just holding his balance as Baran’s spear came to rest with the cloth point against his chest.
Finrod glanced down as though in surprise, then he laughed. “Yours was sound advice after all.”
“Aye.” Baran drew the spear away and lifted it to rest on the ground, allowing himself a grin as he caught his breath. “So it seems.” The madder had left a dark smear just above the other’s heart and dye was beginning to trickle down over his ribs. There was another bright thread trailing from the king’s lip and Baran swore as his eyes fell upon it. “That last struck you in earnest, lord, forgive me.”
“A pardon granted in full.” Finrod dipped an exaggerated bow before moving back toward the others, the line of blood crinkling as his lips twitched toward a smile. “I concede the sun’s victory.”
“Better his lip than yours,” Estreth remarked as Baran joined them, then retrieved the sun-mask from the ground and passed it back to his keeping. “I gave Sabil my word I’d deliver you whole.”
“Good luck to you,” Balan chuckled, lifting an eyebrow toward her as his son snorted in protest.
“A split lip never put off a wedding.”
“Aye, but it might put off a wife.”
“Gaitch.” Baran passed the spear to Sichar and retrieved his shirt and tunic from the ground. He let his eye drift briefly to the king, then turned toward his father with an arch grin. “Do you think so?”
“I think you are overdue for a wash,” Balan retorted with a surge of color along his ears. “At least if you intend to make your way to the rites soon enough for it to be a question.”
Baran shrugged, lighthearted still in the rush of victory, then caught sight of Nóm attempting to scrub away the madder and laughed aloud. “Nay, lord, you’ll make no progress with cloth and water. You need lard.”
“Or vinegar preferably,” Balan added. “If you’ve some to spare.”
“Aye, there’s a barrel or two of sour mead ‘round the far side of the Hall.”
Balan nodded, then collected Finrod’s shirt from the ground and started across the green, waving it after him in summons. “Come along then, my liege,” he beckoned with dry amusement, “let’s see to your wounds.”
“See to your own ere you dictate another’s,” the king rejoined, but he laughed as he trailed obediently in the other’s wake.
“What was thine aim?” Balan chuckled when they neared the Hall, shifting to the other’s tongue from some instinct of privacy. “Flatten the lad to the green for besting me in a fair match?”
“For the price of horses,” Finrod retorted hotly. “And for taunting thee in his victories—it was needless humiliation, and deliberate.” He broke off as they rounded the corner and glanced down at Balan in belated chagrin. His voice softened, even as his eyes gauged the other in concern.“I’ve vexed thee.”
“Not overmuch.”
“Scant reassurance in that.”
Balan snorted. “Didst thou think it would placate him to be humiliated in return? Before half his people, on his wedding day?” He drew up before a pair of barrels and turned with one brow raised, the hint of a grin tugging at his lips. “We should have dubbed thee nórja instead of Nóm,” he added with amusement, lifting the lid from the nearest, “for all the forethought brought to this.” He filled a horn cup he had retrieved from the collection beside the well, then nodded toward the second barrel and Finrod moved around him to perch atop it.
“He should not have goaded thee.”
“The child who will not his sire obey, marks himself the ghomennin’s prey…” Balan took the cloth from the other’s hand and dipped it into the cup of vinegar. “As unsparing as Estreth’s rhymes thou art—poor Baran.” Finrod twisted toward him in protest and Balan gripped him by the shoulder with a grin, turning him firmly where he could reach the stain once more. “Stay still, ghomenno, it takes scrubbing.” He returned his attention to the dye, working the vinegar into the skin and rubbing it away by degrees. It seemed indecent somehow, the flawlessness of that flesh, silken and pale as cream beneath his fingers. Even the sun’s light seemed to brush a caress as she reached over the shadow of the Hall to drape across his chest. Balan wiped away the mead and dipped the cloth again, dabbing it over each bit of pigment. “We’ve spoken,” he said after a time, the edge gone from his words and his tone gentler now, warm. “He was waiting when I left the hut this morning—with an apology, if thou wilt believe it.” Balan chuckled and glanced briefly at the king. “Sabil’s doing, of course, but he seemed in fair sincerity.” He turned the cloth and scrubbed again, more forcibly now, until the skin grew pink from the scouring and only a slight tint of dye remained. “My son and I can fight our own battles, Nóm.”
Finrod met his eye in silence for a long moment, then at last he nodded. “Pride would have me protest the interference was to own my part in the rift, but too well dost thou know my heart for such pretense.” He reached out to brush a stray strand of hair from Balan’s face and tucked it behind his ear with a smile. “I’ll not do it again.” Then he fell quiet once more, watching thoughtfully as Balan wiped away the remaining vinegar and folded the rag, then dipped a fresh corner into the cup. “I fear I too owe thee an apology for my conduct in the night.”
This was dismissed with a snort.
“I do. I should have taken thought first of how—“
Balan passed the cloth over Finrod’s lips, silencing him in an instant as he caught the other’s chin within his palm. “Leave it be,” he said, gently wiping the dried blood and dirt from the split edge of his lip. “There’s naught between us that needs mending.” He rewetted the fabric and dabbed it carefully onto the remaining blood, then slowly he drew it down and back along the king’s lip till the wound was cleaned thrice over. Still he lingered, turning the cloth to dry the skin, passing it down to wipe a drop of vinegar that had trickled onto the collarbone.
Then at last he set the cloth aside and lowered his hands to rest atop the other’s knees. They were warm in the afternoon sun, the dark hose soaked in the noon hour’s rays and grown hot to the touch.
Summer bugs were buzzing in the tall grass behind him.
The air was still, heavy, draped about him like a blanket; and before he was aware of his own movements, Balan was shifting in, his palms sliding from knees to thighs as he found Nóm’s lips and kissed him with the same unhurried precision that had tended the dye and blood. A shiver ran through the other’s limbs, but this time he did not pull away and Balan kissed him again, and again after that, drawing the lower lip in between his own.
Finrod flinched, yet still he did not draw back and leaned his forehead in against the other’s. “That hurts,” he murmured with feigned petulance, and Balan chuckled.
“Serves you right,” he said, then kissed him carefully on the uninjured corner of his mouth and stepped back as the sound of children neared the corner of the Hall.
❈ ❈ ❈
“Earth and water, mark the making.” Balan’s voice drifted over the green, warm and resonant in the evening air. He held his son’s hand cradled within his own and drew a thick line of clay from wrist to knuckles along the palm, then collected more red ochre on his thumb and added two smaller lines crossing over the middle. “Fire and light, meet and kindle; wind and song, sustain our breath.”
It had begun in the late-afternoon. Two small tents were erected at the east and west ends of the settlement—fashioned, Balan had grumbled as he fought with the unwieldy anchors, after those his people used in the first days of their wanderings—and Baran and Sabil had each retired to these for the customary preparations while the rest of the town continued on in the midsummer celebrations. Finrod had wandered then, Balan having followed his son into the western tent, and passed slowly through the huts and pastures, visiting old haunts, joining in the children’s dances along the green, sitting patiently while Meyla wove calendula blossoms into his hair and reprimanded him for cutting away the length. A fine pattern it would have held had he left it whole, she chided, whereas now she could only make do with the semblance of a crown. He had laughed and teased in return that he wished all crowns could be so pleasant.
And so the hours passed as he meandered, until at last, as the sun began her descent toward the horizon, the sound of cheers and of light drums could be heard moving toward them along the main path, interspersed with laughter and voices raised in song. It was a little group, no more than six or seven, and Balan walked at their head as his son’s chief witness for the rites, Belen behind him, then Sichar and several others. A small crowd had gathered behind them as they walked and Finrod joined these as they moved toward the eastern end of the village. They passed a second procession moving westward as they crossed over the green—Sabil’s sister leading a mirrored group of women toward the west. This was the beginning of the rites, he discovered as he trailed in the mens’ wake: each witness processing with the kunitha, the kin or friends deemed near as kin, to call the intended spouse from their tent to the communal gathering.
When they reached the far shelter, Balan had continued a few steps beyond the others. He had raised the clay lamp in his hand and called out three times, and Finrod felt the whole meadow grow resonant with the cadence of his voice: summoning Sabil to the path untrodden, to the wanderer who waited to learn his way. He had made an august figure in the strip of golden sunset, his embroidered tunic a fine deep blue, a bronze armband gleaming above his elbow and the calendula blazing out like fire from the midnight of his hair.
Finrod had first seen him so at Thalos, all throughout the midsummer's festival as he led the rites at the head of his people and called out the iuthan bida in the last of the light. He had been clad simply then—plain linen rather than this finely decorated tunic—and the golden flowers had been his only ornamentation. But even so, then as now, Finrod had been unable to shift his gaze from the other’s face; and as he watched Balan call out these new rites in the darkening meadow, it seemed that the two moments had bent in upon each other, weaving with the golden light as though they encircled the intervening years in a close embrace.
The blossoms shone with that same fire as they stood gathered now on the green and Balan traced the ceremonial clay upon his child’s palm. Sabil’s sister had since done the same and they brought the two hands together, matching clay to clay, palm to palm, life to life.
“Here marked with clay wrought of earth and of water,” Baran’s voice was quiet as he began the the oath, and although there was a rough edge to every word, he held it steady and did not quaver, “I pledge to you fealty of my heart. I pledge to you fidelity of my body, sworn in faithfulness to you and to you alone till my days’ ending.”
Finrod’s pulse was beating in triplet and he felt his chest grow hollow with the ever-present ache. He could taste the words upon his own tongue. His palm was warm with the thought of Balan’s clasped tight against it, prickling as it would with the slight abrasion of clay. Had they not promised as much already? Were these not the words of his own soul on the battlements of the Cened Beraid, caught in the other’s arms behind a shroud of rain? His eyes drifted from the joined hands to find Balan’s face. I pledge to you fealty of my heart…
“This is my word and my vow.” Sabil finished her own recitation of the oath and Finrod drew his attention back to the current rites with an effort. Each witness was marking a new line of clay around the outside of the hands—a line unending binding them, as Balan had explained on the road from Tol Sirion, within the eye of Melishk and of Guënid and naming them as one clay till they were returned to the soil.
They were a striking sight in the last glow of midsummer, Baran and Sabil both clad in madder red—the only of their people to don it during these rites—and the light danced from the twisted bronze decorating the hems and clustered designs. There was bronze too on Sabil’s skin, powdered and painted along the outside of her ears, in patterns across her cheekbones and chin; and resting below her neck was a small medallion with the chieftain’s labyrinth raised across its surface.
Belen moved forward and placed a clay vessel into his father’s hand. Then he stepped aside as a barrel of new mead was opened and Baran filled a cup from this, pouring it carefully into the little pot, which was then passed to Sabil’s sister and the process repeated. What was it Balan had said? The libation to Melishk, the first drink of the celebrations offered to the earth in token of the bond—the paths of each mingled inseparably as the mead that runs down through the soil—and in prayer that she would grant to them long life and fertility in the union.
The mouth of the vessel was plugged with clay as he watched, it was passed to Sabil.
She paused, holding Baran’s eye for a long moment, then raised it in the air between them and called out over the growing cheers, “Melishkan mathár!”
“Melishkan mathár!” the crowd repeated, and Sabil hurled the vessel to the ground where it shattered, the mead pouring out into the earth at her feet.
“Melishkan mathár!” Baran shouted in turn, then the people rushed in, encircling them as a barrage of drums and the deep, bellowing calls of ox horns filled the air. It was a cacophony, laughter and cheering and music all clamoring together over the green as the throng scrambled to join hands and form a series of circles around the pair. It was like watching a flight of starlings shift to reveal a murmuration, Finrod thought as it unfolded before him: chaos one moment, and then by the next they were moving in concert, interlocking wheels sweeping in opposite directions—three steps, one back and across, three more and another backstep—faster and faster as the music too whirled into cohesion and Baran caught Sabil in his arms, kissing her at the center of the whirlwind.
Balan was in the first ring, Belen at his left and Estreth at his right pulling him forward as they careened around the circle. Gildor was there as well, Finrod observed with a smile. Belen must have dragged him in when the crowd converged on the green and he was caught in the midst of it now, sprinting in time with the others and laughing as he began to master the steps.
Then with a shout it was over as swiftly as it had come about—a clamor of voices, a crescendo—and both people and instruments fell away until only Baran remained at the center, dancing as the drums rolled a swift tattoo through the night air. It was the same dance Finrod recalled from the midwinter revelries, a pattern of steps beating eight points on an unmarked square, and Baran turned easily through the sequence. Gradually a handful of others began to move in from the edges of the crowd, each bearing a decorated hazel branch, and one by one they took turns darting in and attempting to strike his legs while he danced. They were Sabil’s brothers, Finrod realized with amusement; or rather more than that—her brothers, her father, her uncles—and they were laughing as Baran grinned and leapt nimbly around their switches, not missing a step.
It reminded him of a game they had played as children. They would form a circle on the shoreline and swing stalks of kelp criss-crossed between them, slippery and luminescent in the twilight, while each took a turn in the center, skipping between the strands as they sang.
One the vessel
Two the sails
Three the wind of Ossë’s gale
Four bright lanterns
Five at the rails
Six beyond to—
A shout sounded from the far side of the crowd and Finrod’s attention snapped back to the present. Two lines had begun moving onto the green, each facing outward and chanting in time as they slammed every fourth step against the earth. Sabil danced at the head of the right column, Balan led the left, and together they continued forward until they cut between Baran and the hazel branches and drew him seamlessly into their number, merging him into the dance at the end of Sabil’s line.
And then the whole crowd surged out, drums thundering as a wild melody leapt from the musicians: bone flutes, rattles, a collection of single-stringed instruments—the luvan tagl—at each corner of the gathering. Finrod was drawn forward with the rest of the throng, caught up in the jostling merriment, and he laughed as he stumbled along in their midst. They were dancing, they were all of them dancing now, their laughter mingled with his own and his heart swelling as though it would burst. Ai Valar, how he had missed being amongst them! He closed his eyes as they whirled about him, and let the weight of their souls brush against his own, deep and earthen and filled with all the hope of spring. They broke over him like sunlight and he nearly sang aloud from the joy of it.
“Nóm!”
He came to with a start and found Balan there before him, laughter in his eyes and a roguish grin upon his lips.
“Do you mean to dance, then, or only to contemplate it?”
Finrod laughed and flung his arms open toward the gathering. “If the soul dances, shall not the feet soon follow?”
“Aye, provided you’ve not been trampled first by those who lead with feet instead.”
He laughed again and felt the exultation pounding through his veins as Balan lingered before him, smiling. His hair was bound back in a small knot at the base of his head, as it had been since the afternoon’s sparring, and the calendula wove through it like embers in the dark. How bright and fierce was that spirit against his own, burning swift as daybreak. How steady the hold of his heart, the warmth of his smile.
Oh Manwë, Varda, and all the holy…how he loved him.
“Show me, then,” he managed after a moment and held out his hand, “that soul and feet might dance as one.”
It was Balan who laughed now and caught the king’s hand within his own. “Nay, you’ll manage as we all did,” he called over his shoulder as he dragged him forward into the fray. “You find your own step or go under!”
They ducked beneath arms and twisted out of the paths of other dancers till the movement engulfed them and drew them into its current. It was swift and percussive, a mixture of footfalls and clapping palms—this too was earthen in some way, Finrod thought, and found himself falling into its measure with ease, first one foot and then the other slammed against the soil alongside the downbeat. Balan was before him; Balan was on the far side of the group; Balan was turning with the rhythm and grinning as he dodged beneath another set of arms, nearly colliding with Hathus before they both swung back into step. Balan was beside him again, each motion a near mirror of his own, and his heart spilled over in laughter to feel so near, bound in the current of the melody, in the pulse of the drums.
But almost at once the crowd was parting, an aisle unfurling down the center of the green as cheering rippled back from each edge. Balan had him by the hand again in an instant and hauled him forward till they reached the front of the crowd, just in time to see Baran and Sabil come careening down the length of the clearing. It was an iteration of the same dance, only now they flew through it at a sprint till they came up at the end of the lines, laughing and dizzy, and stumbling to one side.
Sichar and his wife came next, then Hathus and Gelvira, Eimet and the weaver’s son, Belen with little Fina giggling as he swung her by the arms. Each pair raced down the green as the cheers followed them, and each line inched upward as the foremost took their place. Estreth and Hûl now, Meyla’s sister and her wife, Esa and Avina.
Balan was at the head of the line before Finrod had half taken in the pattern of steps, and suddenly they were in the center of the green, hands clasped and cheers rising from those about them.
“Find your step,” Balan called again over the melody, the mischief glinting from his smile once more, “or go under!”
Then they were racing along the grass, circling and dipping beneath each other’s arms, their feet drumming out the rhythm as they flew past blurred faces on either side. Finrod’s heart was pounding. His breast was alight with giddy fire, every vein kindled and a press of joy rushing in like the tide, nearly stopping his breath. He caught Balan’s hand, he wheeled beneath the wrist. Balan clasped his other hand in turn and mirrored him; next the clapping—three sets of two—the patterned steps, the quick double-turn, the—
“Too precise!” Balan shouted as he swung past his ear. “It’s not meant to be beautiful, Nóm, it’s meant to be loud.”
“And meant to be taught,” Finrod retorted, feeling his hair lift straight outwards with his speed as he threw himself into the turn. The steps that followed were a muddle—hurled against the earth, loose and fumbling—but Balan was grinning when they reached the edge of the green.
“Better,” he laughed as the king stumbled through the final sequence and caught him by the arm. “You’re nigh a match for Fina now, I’d reckon,” he added with a wink, then pulled Finrod aside as the next pair came rushing down the gap. “Again!”
Time ran on without measure after that; looping up and back along the shifting lines, flitting through their breath as they ran like children through the night. The last light faded into the horizon and Estreth turned a whirling dance in the midst of the gathering—a custom that she and her sister had carried on in remembrance of their people. There was a wedding loaf, sweetened with honey and kétheinan fruit and fine spices, and with it blessings were exchanged after the manner of the Longest Night. Balan spoke a litany of well wishing over the newly joined pair. Belen taught Gildor something called the dance of the bear, a lumbering set of steps that drew laughter from all the Nargothrondrim as they watched, then Sídhon and Gelmir led the Guard onto the green to dance as they had at Tol Sirion, the king this time among their number.
It was a joyous havoc—as were all these celebrations of the Atani, Finrod mused as he withdrew at last to the edge of the green—imbued with the same bright, burning intensity that colored all their days. He wove his way through the crowd till he reached the well and filled a cup from the bucket.
“Keeping to water tonight, then?” Estreth was perched atop the wellhead a few steps away and watched with amusement as he drew a second cupful.
Finrod laughed. “Hard-learned is the path of prudence,” he replied, then raised the draught toward her in salute and drained the cup. “I find the lord of waters smiles more kindly upon his children.”
“Whereas Fon’s blessing is as fickle as his brew?” Estreth chuckled and shifted to make room as he leaned against the stones beside her. “Aye, true enough.”
They rested in silence then, watching the others move through various forms of game or dance; listening, quiet as laughter and song drifted through the firelight. Children scampered in and out of the crowd, and amid these darted another mottled pack—Sídhon’s hounds, who had befriended their shaggy kin among the Atani and were now chasing after one other between the huts, as though they too had been caught up in the spirit of revelry.
“I’ve seen dozens of these in the years I’ve spent with Balan’s people.” Estreth broke their silence, pensive as her gaze followed Baran and Belen through the crowd. “And yet each still puts me in mind of Esrid. Of her first marriage, that is,” she corrected in afterthought. “There was naught of this at the second. That was a practical arrangement.”
The king found his own eyes drifting to Balan at the far edge of the green. He was laughing as he danced, one of twelve in a square that folded in and back upon itself with the rhythm, and a wash of melancholy shrouded Finrod’s mirth. Balan should have had a feast like this. He should have had dance and laughter to mark his own joy as well, not some perfunctory rite, quiet and restrained in the shadow of another’s loss. He should have that still, conviction whispered, and again guilt’s knife stabbed deep.
“It is strange,” Estreth murmured again, her eyes still following the group as they broke apart and stumbled laughing and out of breath toward the waiting mead barrels, “to remember she has been gone for more years now than she was not.”
Finrod nodded and felt a tangled knot constrict his throat. “It is truly a grievous wound,” he managed at last, “to outlive those we love.”
She gave only a noncommittal grunt in answer, and again a long silence fell between them before she spoke further. “There was a woman among the Haladin, a few years before we crossed the mountains. I nearly stayed behind when Balan gathered the herds, but in the end I told her I couldn’t bring myself to leave Baran and Bel—or Balan either, then. They were all I had left of kin.” Her voice had grown thick, as though the words forced themselves out against her will. “It was not a lie, but the truth was all I could think of was Esrid’s cry when they carried Geberic back from the field; or the memory of Balan numb and shaking when we lost her.” She clenched her hands and shuddered despite the summer’s warmth. “Love is loss—and I couldn’t face it.”
Balan was walking toward them now, a carved horn cup in each hand and a few trailing calendula blossoms still clinging to his hair. “Love is also choosing,” Finrod replied with an effort, and was surprised by the hoarseness in his own voice. “And oft is wisdom’s purchase the dearer price.”
“Aye, so I thought.” Estreth was quiet for a long moment as Balan drew nearer, then she looked over and met Finrod’s eye pointedly. “And I’ve never regretted any decision more.”
“Yarrow and lavender!”
Finrod jumped as Balan’s voice sounded beside him and turned sharply to find the other a few steps away, holding out one of the cups with a grin.
“Just as I promised. I may be a year late in its delivery, but I’ve not been proven false.” He passed the drink to Finrod’s hand and leaned against the well frame between them, lifting his own to his lips. “Sán gahail, wingildi.”
For a moment Finrod blinked at him in confusion, then the aroma of honey reached his nose and summer’s sunlight washed through his memory, the sound of water, the fragrance of a snowdrop blossom suspended in the air between them. “Like wildflowers in mead,” he murmured with a smile and lifted his cup in turn. “Sán gahail.” Balan’s arm was resting lightly against his own, just as it had in the meadow beside the Celon, and Finrod felt the touch like light, spreading through his spirit in the same way the taste of summer mead spread over his tongue. “You were right.”
Balan chuckled and leaned his head back against the squared timber. “Of course I was right.”
“Of course he was right,” Finrod parroted with a grin, then took another sip.
“Melishkan mathár,” Estreth muttered, and from the corner of his eye Finrod saw Balan jab his elbow sharply against her side. But before any further retort could be made, the clamor on the green grew suddenly hushed; then the music too fell away until only a single drum remained, tapping out a slow pulse as Baran and Sabil stood alone in the center of the gathering, arms raised before them, elbows bent upwards with the backs of their hands turned toward the other. It went on until it reached discomfort—the breath held beyond bearing—and Finrod filled his lungs reflexively when a solitary luvan tagl lifted its song through the air.
“Thradu Samana Staiga,” Balan murmured, leaning nearer to keep his voice from carrying beyond the other’s ear. “The Woven Way. It’s held over from an old legend, one form of the tale of Melishk and Guënid.” His son reached out to draw a line with one finger along Sabil’s left forearm. “This is the water. And this,” he breathed as Baran cupped her elbow within his palm, “is the sure foundation of the earth beneath us.”
Sabil reached out in a mirrored gesture, her right hand tracing along Baran’s left, slipping beneath his elbow.
“Each is now the other’s right hand; and still each hand seeks for the other.”
Their right arms bent to meet in the middle, palms meeting, fingers twined. They turned with the fluid melody of the luvan tagl, toes dragging through the dirt to form interlocking arcs as their path moved forward, back, around to the starting point and on again.
“They move as the water moves over the earth, as Guënid’s tendrils pass through the soil. The current of each is set by the movement of the other, the movement of each drawn by other’s current.”
Finrod found himself mesmerized by the looping steps, lulled by the warmth of Balan’s arm resting firmly now against his own, by the rhythm of the other’s voice passing over his ear. How much longer could he carry on in this breathless flight against his own beckoning current? He was tiring. He felt it through every fiber of his body, it ached in every crevice of his soul.
Balan was so near. The scent of him washed like wine through his senses, the loose strands of his hair tickled against Finrod’s chin and he shivered at the touch. Eru, merciful and almighty, his heart cried out the unremitting prayer, why have you sundered your children? He leaned in as though listening more closely to Balan’s explanation and let his eyes fall shut, his lips rest against the other’s scalp.
“They are each the clay from which the other has been formed, we say. Molded together in the first dance of Melishk and Guënid and returned to each other here by the grace of time’s whim.”
“And if time’s whim was to cruelty?” He had not meant to speak, but he heard his voice trickle in a hoarse whisper through the other’s hair.
“If?” Balan shifted and a wry smile tugged at his lips. “Time’s whim is always cruel to my kind. But we glean our joy nonetheless,” he added, drawing his fingers lightly along Nóm’s forearm in the shadows between them. “Even if it is in small measures.”
❈ ❈ ❈
It was quiet in the meadow alongside the shoreline. The revels had dwindled as the night grew old, until now there was only the sound of water against the stones, or the buzzing trills of bugs gathered in the reeds, the chorus of chirping frogs.
Balan lingered with his feet ankle-deep in the shallows and drew the night air in like a draught of water. Gods all, he had missed this place. All the months he was gone from it he had pressed down the feeling, but in truth Belen’s intuition had been his as well—this was their home, here the earth welcomed them and called them by name.
It was this, perhaps, that had brought on his long-lapsed piety; returning to this peace, to a sense of the land’s benevolence settling in his bones with every step of his return…it had raised an image of Melishk in his heart that defied his agnosticism. He bent to retrieve a clay lamp from the bank and cupped it thoughtfully within his palm. Was this piety, in truth? Or was it a far simpler thing—he was weary, he was homesick and heartsick and clinging to the rituals of his childhood that he might believe himself whole.
He rested a barley cake over the mouth of the bowl, careful not to snuff the wick, then crouched down and set it gently afloat in the current. “O great waters,” he breathed into the night, “life-blood of all, may you welcome this offering in your embrace. Holy Guënid, sustainer of life, may my petition find favor—let your blessing rest upon my son. Spare him from my own griefs, grant him a double portion of my joys. O great one, may it please you to look kindly upon the hopes of his heart.”
The lamp bobbed in the water, flickering as it was drawn out from the shore, and Balan watched its progress with breath held. It would be a sluggish journey at this pace to reach the heart of the river—a good thing, he reminded himself as the flame guttered, then righted itself. It was more likely to gain the open flow if it was not jostled and hurried along. Carefully, he rose to his feet and filled his lungs as he looked out over the Celon. Fireflies were blinking their unhurried patterns along the shoreline and the lamp’s light seemed to echo these as it glinted across the ripples, filling the night with warmth.
“Do many reach the center?” Nóm was perched on a rock along the bank, legs drawn up under him like a tall, nested water bird, and his eyes too followed the little flame as it ventured into the current. He wore the calendula still, and as the night breeze rose off the water they too seemed to flicker and dance about his head like the fireflies drifting through the meadow. Lamp, flowers, fireflies, hair—each lit with an inexplicable light, and all of gold woven.
“Some,” Balan replied, shifting back toward the shore. “Of my own offerings, perhaps five? Seven? If it finds its way to the main current, your petition is heard. If your gift is accepted, the water takes it under once it’s there. Most scuttle before they’ve made it an arm’s length from the shore.” He chuckled as he turned back to watch the lamp dwindling toward the middle stream. “It couldn’t be too easily attainable, I suppose, or we’d count every plea granted.”
Nóm rose from the bank and crossed to stand behind him, his gaze still held by the drifting flame. It tottered and for a moment he feared it would sink, then it gave a sudden lurch and was swept into the flow, turning merrily with the current until it toppled and was drawn under. “Eight now,” he murmured, and rested his hands on Balan’s shoulders. “The river finds you persuasive.”
“Mm.” Balan leaned into the touch and the old self-deprecation wove itself once more between his words. “For the moment.”
Nóm wound his arms around him and drew him in, reseting his chin gently within the dark waves. “My mother’s people say that water is as the heart: changeable in its passion, turning in eddies when you think it smooth. Whereas stone is as the will: a sure mooring, immovable and bound to Arda’s foundations.”
“And yet your caverns were carved by water,” Balan countered, mischief in his voice as he settled in against the other’s chest. “And water may wear the sharpest boulders smooth.”
“So it does.” He fell quiet for a long moment, and Balan felt the other’s breath pass like a breeze through his hair. “And thus the saying continues—earth is where we find the meeting of the twain, where stone has been shaped to beauty by the water’s passage, softened by the life of Yavanna’s creations. It is where each has shaped the other that there is life.”
“In stillness, in earth Man’s flesh is grown,” Balan murmured, the childhood rhyme falling without thought from his tongue. “In movement, in water his truth is known.”
There was a quiet rumble against his back, laughter rippling through the other’s embrace. “Shall I confess twas not till the Celon that I knew the truth of my own heart?”
“Aye, you dense creature,” Balan chuckled in turn and leaned his head back against the king’s shoulder, “I’d worked that out long before now.”
Nóm buried his face against Balan’s neck in feigned chagrin. “As ever, thou hast seen my heart with greater clarity than I.” Then his arms tightened impulsively about the other and a sigh escaped his lips, some hoarse sound between laughter and vexation. “It was right of thee to stop me,” he murmured at last, “but ai…in my weakness how I wish thou hadst not.”
Balan tipped his head to the side, resting his nose teasingly against the other’s for a moment, and the roguish grin tugged once more at his lips. “I could be weak now…”
Finrod laughed aloud, then brushed his lips against Balan’s neck, lingering in a kiss just below his jawline. “Dance with me,” he breathed in his ear a long moment later, then turned Balan to face him in the shallows and raised his arms, bent at the elbows with the backs of his hands shining in the moonlight. “I have not yet had my fill.”
Balan watched him in silence at first, then slowly he lifted his own arms in the mirrored gesture, he reached out and traced a line along the king’s left forearm, he clasped the other’s palm against his own and turned with the movement of the water as the Celon drew them into his steps.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
wingildi: [Q] foam-fay, see A Heady Fragrance of Honey for its context within Atandil
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
gaitch: swine
vatta: father
nórja: rashness
iuthan bida: sun’s blessing/sun’s prayer
Melishkan mathár: Melishk bear witness
luvan tagl: “singing hair” (lit: singing hair-strand)
Melishkan mathár: (second use) Melishk bear witness as in footnote [x] above. In this context the phrase would serve as a quip similar to the modern “get a room”
MISC NOTES
- cropsick: archaic term for hungover
23. In Wisdom's Arms Find Me
“I felt it within me, the terror and despair of the shackled; and twas as though it had been fitted to my soul—my own horror and not the recollection of another’s. I have never known such a fear. It choked me, some heavy, skulking thing bearing copper’s taste upon the tongue.”
Finrod, Balan, and the Guard encounter an escaped thrall while returning to Nargothrond, and foresight rears its head.
Read 23. In Wisdom's Arms Find Me

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, SUMMER
Estolad
There had been mulberry trees in the vales around Tirion, clustered in winding groves with branches arcing overhead, as though each reached for the others and twined their fingers in an inseparable grasp. He had grown lost among them during a childhood visit and wandered hours within their labyrinth before at last stumbling on his cousins sprawled in a glade, a mound of berries piled in the grass between them. Have a care, Cullinwingë, Curufin had muttered from behind the pages of a book, his voice garbled by the fruit, they are poison to Vanyarin blood. My father grew them.
He had stayed far from the groves after that, till one afternoon he saw his father reach for a cluster of mulberries in the king’s garden and caught him by the wrist with a cry, jerking the hand away before any could be consumed. Arafinwë had knelt beside him with a laugh when the explanation was stammered out, his smile hovering between warmth for his son’s earnest concern and sorrow at the trickery. Nay, he had said, brushing a strand of hair behind Finrod’s ear, he had eaten of those trees all throughout his own childhood. They were the groves of the former queen, planted to cultivate her silkworms, and no more poisonous than the pear he ate that morning. Arafinwë had held out the berries then, shining like black opals upon his palm, and Finrod had taken one tentatively, forcing down the fear as he brought it to his lips.
That same flavor washed over him now, sweet and earthy with a passing tartness along the tongue, and he slipped a second handful into his mouth instead of adding them to the makeshift cloth basket slung over his arm. It had been long since he felt his father’s absence strike so keenly. That had become a dull bruise, tender if pressed but mostly benign; yet it throbbed through him now like a new wound. Naught but his just deserts, Finrod thought with a touch of bitterness—the wages for drawing another father from his son.
The gloaming hour had washed the Andram with gold, burnishing Sirion’s spray as it rose through the air; while here beneath the scattered mulberry trees the light danced in shades of rose and blue, each twig outlined in sharp silhouette against the clouds. Finrod lingered with one palm resting against the puckered bark and filled his lungs with the green scent. Mist drifted over him with the roar of the falls and, lulled, he let his mind wander within its song.
It had been petty to return by this route—the ferries at Aelin-uial were nearer, the path across the Guarded Plain a far swifter road than the Long Wall’s meandering way—but Balan had seen nothing of the Andram beyond Narog’s gorge and the Falls of Sirion were a wonder, six furlongs of tumbling cliffs over which the Meres poured in a seemingly endless curtain. Sídhon had laughed when Finrod proposed the altered journey, but Edrahil was meticulously polite. It would add only an enquië to the journey, he had conceded, and certainly Bëor should see the passage of the Falls. The Dwarven road itself was a marvel.
Finrod grimaced. The mannered tone had left little doubt that Edrahil perceived the impetus of his lord’s suggestion, and little doubt too as to his opinion of that distaste for accepting Thingol’s hospitality at the crossings. It was petulant, of course; he knew that well enough. But he could not suffer the image of Balan’s pride humiliated once again for expediency.
Youth’s blood ran hot—and on that point he granted his uncle’s veracity.
Balan, for his part, had merely watched him with mild amusement as they remounted, then turned Elmorë’s nose to the south in Sídhon’s wake. Even that simplest of gestures had sent the giddy relief pooling once more in the king’s heart, for he had not known his fear till they were well on their way, half a day out from Estolad and wending their path through the sea of tall grasses that ranged along the Celon. There had been a myriad of small signs—the way Balan’s fingers rested on each familiar item, the ease of his laugh when he fell into the old banter with Eimet and Hathus or, as the days went on, with Baran and Estreth, the longing in his eyes whenever he looked out over the encampment or followed the lines of his son’s carvings across the Hall’s timbers. Without his own notice, Finrod had grown convinced that Balan would not ride west when the time came; so that when talk did turn at last to their departure and the other’s heart flinched against his own, he had been surprised by his reluctance to answer that it must be soon, that he had sent word ere they set out from Tol Sirion that he would return to Nargothrond no later than the start of Iavas.
His eyes were following Balan’s shadow over the meadow when the wave of realization engulfed him at last, and he had nearly gasped aloud from the force of his relief. Balan was among them. Elmorë’s hooves echoed in time with Vaya’s footfalls. His heart still rode at his side.
That joy had spilled out into song when they reached the open plains south of Aros and he loosed Váya into their expanse with a clear cry, laughing as the others galloped in his wake, as they passed him and fell behind again and all raced on together through the blossoming fields.
Again, that soaring joy caught him up within its embrace and he leaned back against the tree, slipping another berry into his mouth. The summer wind had risen along the ridge, warm and fragrant, and his eyes fell shut as it lifted his hair and brushed gently along his cheeks. In the boughs, the leaves sighed with the same voice as the falls in the gorge beyond. He was glad after all to have come this way. It was long since he heard this measure of the river’s music, and its rolling timpani pulsed through his veins like wine.
There was a tickle along the back of his hand and he opened his eyes with a start. A large silkworm was making its way across his knuckles, pausing now and then to lift its head and crane about, as though perplexed by the lack of foliage on this branch it had chosen. “Further on, little friend, further on,” he murmured, lifting his hand carefully toward a patch of leaves. “Naught wilt thou find here to thy liking.” He watched as the worm investigated, then caught hold of a stem and gradually inched its way back onto the branch, suspicious still of its shifting surroundings.
They had waited till Arien crested the hills that morning before beginning their descent, so Balan might be sure of his footing on the Serpent’s Stair—the thin, coiling road that cut forwards and backwards down the sheer face of the Andram’s gorge—and even then he had shuffled forward with a dubious caution that reminded Finrod of the silkworm returning to its perch. They had progressed only one turn of the stair before he dismounted and shifted in against the cliff, one hand gripping Elmorë’s reins and the other palm pressed against the rock face. It’s high enough already without adding the horse. I’ll trust to my own feet.
At the midpoint of the cliff, however, his apprehension had given way and he swore under his breath as the road opened out before them, wide archways springing up behind the falls where they poured over an outcropping in the rock. There were two great pillars on either side of the opening—stout, bearded cadhadrim with arms lifted easily above their heads, as though bearing the weight of the precipice was of little consequence to them. Balan had lingered at the entrance in fascination, studying the carvings as the others passed him by. He had seemed almost a graven image himself with his face upturned and shining in the lamplight, and Finrod had paused to watch him in awe.
And there amidst the roaring passage, he found himself consumed by a desire to set Bëor’s visage too in stone, to make of him a monolith that would stand against the years—even as he was now, etched before him in the pale-blue of the Guard’s lanterns, lips parted and a boyish wonder spilling over his features.
Then the illusion had broken. Balan turned through the haze of Sirion’s spray and swung once more onto Elmorë’s back. He had met the king’s eye, and he had smiled.
He was warmth and he was movement, flesh and no relic to be cut in granite. Fear was the craftsman who sought to imprison a single moment. Love’s work was in living memory.
A flutter disturbed the leaves above him and once again Finrod came back to the present with a start. There was a crow perched an arm’s length away and it looked from the king to the silkworm, from the silkworm to the king.
“Nay, my greedy one,” Finrod greeted the new arrival with a smile, but reached out quickly to cup his hand over the worm. “There are berries and seeds aplenty. Let him be.”
The bird blinked at him, then hopped forward and pecked lightly at his fingers with a protesting squawk.
Finrod laughed and reached into the knotted cloth, retrieving a mulberry and offering it on his palm. “Be appeased,” he said, running a finger along the sable back once the crow had retrieved the fruit. “In mercy thou wilt find the greater bounty.” The bird grumbled out a short series of squawks, then fixed him with one eye and tilted its head as though evaluating the merit of this assertion. But a moment later it leapt from the branch, soaring out over the gully with an alarmed cry as Balan emerged from the thicket, a bundle of branches tucked beneath one arm.
“It’s impossible to find anything dry,” he muttered as he approached, then grinned at the sight of the king gazing ruefully after the receding crow. “Beg pardon, Elenya, I’ve cost thee thy companion.”
“One of them.” Nóm turned back and lifted his hand from the branch to reveal the silkworm, which once more craned about in curiosity before returning to its meal. “Though a rather fraught brotherhood we made, I fear.” The quick smile flashed out as Balan joined him beside the tree and he glanced down with teasing in his eye. “No doubt thou wouldst have gleaned the greater friendship. He shared thine impatience for platitudes.”
“And yet I find my affinity tends rather toward the worm.” Balan lifted a brow at the king’s bemusement and gestured to the branch. “Clapped beneath thine hand at the first scent of danger.”
Finrod laughed again at this. Then uncertainty prickled along the back of his neck and he wondered whether the other was offended in truth; for while there was no doubt the words held the cadence of a jest, there was a fragrance too of candor in the brush of Balan’s thought that set him wavering. Infuriating creature, it was ever so—each jest half sincere, every sincerity woven through with self-deprecation.
A chuckle pulled him abruptly from the circling thoughts and he saw that Balan was watching him in amusement, a smile playing at the edges of his lips and his eyes warm with mischief. Infuriating creature, Finrod thought again, fondly this time, and felt the other’s grin mirrored in his own. “Very well,” he retorted, “if thou wilt find offense in devotion, then I shall leave thee at the mercy of the crow in future.”
“Mm. And a merry hour we’ll pass at the expense of thy truisms.”
Finrod opened his mouth to retort, but alarm struck before a sound could leave his tongue, crashing from the woods like a breaking wave, and he swung back toward it with a hiss.
“Nóm?”
He held motionless for a moment longer, then they both heard the shout from the trees and the Elf leapt forward, his thought rushing ahead of him to brush each of them in tally—Gildor, Sídhon, Hilyo, Medlineth, Canneth, Gelmir…
“Hold back, my lord.” Bëor’s hand closed firmly about his arm and hauled him back, the abrupt formality of his address slowing the king more effectively than the grasp. “Let me go first.” He shouldered ahead before the other could protest this reminder of owed fealty and led them forward through the trees, one hand brandishing his knife at the ready, the other stretched behind him to keep the king from outpacing him.
There was a rustle to their left and both swung round to see one of Sídhon’s hounds fly through the brush, tossing a brief bay in alert as she passed them. Medlineth and Edrahil appeared swiftly in her wake.
“Gwethrim.” Edrahil drew up beside them to flank the king, sword in hand, while Medlineth turned toward the clearing and called back to the Guard with a sparrow’s trill.
“As far as this?” Finrod fell into step with the captain and the tense set of his shoulders seemed to ease with the news. “Only once have I met any of their number south of the Teiglin—and even then we were no more than five leagues from the crossings. How many?”
“One at present. But the hounds will soon learn if others are hidden near.”
“You’ve set hounds on the wretches?” Balan could not disguise the rebuke in his tone and Medlineth glanced at him sharply.
“To seek and report, Hîr Bëor, not to give chase.” Insult warmed her own voice at his assumption and Finrod saw the line of Balan’s lips tighten in response.
“He has been tracking us since the plains,” Edrahil cut in before anything further could be said. “There have been signs, but he was canny and swift and we thought we were mistaken till Gelmir and Lhúgnil came upon him by chance.”
They crossed into the clearing then, and Finrod drew a sharp breath at the scene before him. Gelmir was seated on a fallen trunk, blood trickling from a gash over one eye, while Sídhon knelt before him and set a bloodied cloth aside, crushing a handful of leaves between his palms before lining them carefully along the wound. A tattered form lay sprawled on the grass a stone’s throw from them, and over this Lhúgnil knelt with one knee pressed into the captive’s back and holding his left arm bent back in restraint. Two other guards stood at the ready beside him.
“What goes on here?” The king strode forward at once and his gaze darted between his guards before coming to rest on the prostrate form in the grass. The captive lay motionless, his breathing ragged and terrified beneath the weight of Lhúgnil’s knee and blood ran freely from his scalp, from the corner of his mouth. “Loose him!”
The guardsman looked up in surprise, then turned a questioning glance toward his captain. “He has not been searched, nor have we yet—“ He broke off as he felt the blaze of fury in the king’s eyes and his own fell in apology. “Forgive me, lord. As you will it.” He hesitated a moment longer, then withdrew, shifting cautiously to stand beside the flanking guards, sword in hand, but the captive did not move.
He was a pitiful sight stretched amidst the clover. The tunic that hung loose across his shoulders only barely merited the word, threadbare and stained and mended beyond recognition, and his spine stood out in knobs beneath its scant shroud. A handful of lingering strands claimed that his hair had once been dark, but now was dwindled to a pallid grey, falling thin and coarse about his shoulders.
There were thrall’s marks upon his arms.
Finrod pressed down the anger knotting in his chest and moved forward by slow degrees. “You may rise if you wish, friend,” he said, his motions and voice both carefully calm. “I apologize for the haste of our welcome. We purpose no harm toward you, if none is in your purpose toward us.”
“It is not.” The voice that drifted up from the clover was cracked and rasping, and Finrod shivered involuntarily at the sound. “I swear to you, it is not.”
“My Guard tells me you have followed us from the plains.”
“In hope, lord.” The thrall slid his hands forward and the fingers that dug into the grass were emaciated. With an effort he pushed himself upwards until he sat huddled in a crouch before the king. “In the North, I was given to understand you would be most like to show mercy to one such as myself.” There was a long hesitation; then, as though sensing the skepticism from the surrounding guards, he added, “It was said in disparagement, lord, when they turned me away.”
“Well do I believe it, if your path led you through Aglon as it seems.”
“Through Thargelion.” The correction was little more than a whisper and he seemed to withdraw further into himself at its speaking.
“Ah.”
“My king.” Edrahil was at his elbow once more, and the low murmur of his voice was insistent. “Trusted or no, he should be searched—if only for his own sake to dispel the suspicion amongst us.”
Finrod was quiet for a long moment, then gave a short nod and Lhúgnil returned to stand beside the captive with one hand extended.
“By your leave.” His intonation was nearer a command than a request and the thrall too seemed to understand it as such, for he made no answer but to stretch his arms wide, palms turned open toward the king. He stiffened as Lhúgnil’s hands passed over him in swift inquiry, flinched when they paused below his breast and drew out the short-bladed dagger tucked within the rags.
“He carries a blade.”
“And used it not when you came upon me.” His arms began to tremble as the protest spilled from his lips. “I used it not!”
Lhúgnil made no reply, but turned instead to Edrahil and held out the weapon in accusation. “No blade of Angband lies here. This was taken from one of our own folk.”
“He is one of our own folk.” Finrod’s reprimand was quiet, but the thrall looked up in gratitude at the words.
“I did steal it, lord. I confess that. But it was while they slept, not as the spoils of a kill.”
The king lingered a long moment in silence, then moved back and lowered himself onto a boulder jutting out from the center of the clearing. A toppled tree had continued in stubborn growth about it and the branches it sent up curved and twisted behind him—like a serpent uncoiling, Balan thought, or the swans’ necks of the throne that awaited him beneath the hills. As if guided by this thought, Nóm laid his hands upon his knees and the Guard drew in to form a line on each side of the captive; and abruptly the little glade took on all the gravity of the Great Hall. The king’s court seated in judgment.
“There have been those who, in desperation, have opened their hearts to the mind of the Foe.” Finrod’s voice was quiet as he watched Lhúgnil continue to search the thrall’s garments, drawing out the scarce provisions and little oddments and exposing them in a naked line along the grass. “Those who reached the last exhaustion of pain, who were tormented beyond any foothold of hope. They come among us from time to time and their treachery has been a double-bladed grief: returned beyond hope, lost beyond recall.”
“He carries nothing besides the blade.” Lhúgnil rose and dipped his head in deference toward the king, then stepped back to take his place alongside the others. Finrod acknowledged this with a brief nod, but did not shift his gaze from the figure before him.
“How am I to trust, friend, that you are not of their number?”
The thrall was silent, his gaze fixed on the pitiful collection, and only by an effort of will did he seem able to restrain himself from scrambling forward to regather the items. He lifted his eyes and met the king’s. “I was once Tultamo, son of Tírthon the smith,” he began at last in a trembling whisper. “I was of the people of Nolofinwë—a soldier in the fourth company of my lord’s cavalry. I was taken, along with three others, in the fifty-second year of the new sun’s reckoning.” His voice broke and he shook his head, then clasped his hands in plea. “I know those of whom you speak, the broken who bowed before the black throne; and I will not hide from you that some were those I knew and loved. Nor will I hide that I too have known that temptation in the bleak solitude, battered as we were—mind and body—by the venom of his presence. But I swear to you, lord, I mean you no malice. Nor have I given over my soul to such a purpose.”
“Others have spoken so before now, vandatar,” Gildor murmured, his arms crossed as he stood at the king’s shoulder, “and a poisoned honey it was when their children lay dead by their hand.”
“Peace, Gildor, I too know the tales.” After a moment, Finrod rose and crossed to stand before the huddled figure once again, looking down at him in pity. “Your words ring true, son of Tírthon, and my heart finds no deception in your eye. But as king, I am entrusted not only with my own life, but with the lives of these around us and of every one of my people. You understand, my friend, that I must seek further.”
A shudder passed through Tultamo at this, but he did not look away. “I understand.”
Finrod nodded, then slowly he closed the remaining distance and knelt, till his own face drew level with the captive’s. Only then did Tultamo’s gaze falter, and a little choked sound escaped him as he clenched his eyes shut.
“Must it be all?” he whispered, twisting handfuls of his tunic within his grasp.
The king made no reply, but reached out and set his palm to the side of the other’s head, and remorse was woven within the touch. “Look at me, Tultamo,” he said at last, his voice little more than the breeze around them; then carefully, gently he reached out for the other’s mind. “Do you mean to kill me?”
❈ ❈ ❈
Balan awoke with a start.
Nóm.
He pushed up from the bedroll and looked frantically about the glade, only to find the king slumbering still where he had left him, halfway across the clearing with his back against a boulder. Safe, and watched over by three guards who fanned out along the creek’s bank.
He settled back into the grass with relief and drew the blanket around his shoulders, his heart pounding. A nightmare, then. Nothing more. He shifted irritably as he sought to recover his former comfort and found instead that every sense was still racing in alarm. There had been such terror in that phantom cry. Balan could not shake the press of urgency, nor shift the lingering dread that clung to him like sweat. He could hear it still, the desperate gasp of one who feels the plummet seize him.
He rolled onto his back and looked up at the stars, his eyes drifting in their old pattern to seek out the curved sickle in the sky above him. It seemed a thin comfort now—all works of the Dark shall be for naught. What did that make of the thrall’s perseverance save to reduce it to meaningless pain? What hope was to be found in that? He shut his eyes against such a threat. He would sooner take the promise of Melishk’s soil than be wielded as such an instrument. That, at least, held the balm of oblivion. He shuddered and pushed aside the memories Nóm had once shared of the tortured, broken ground before Thangorodrim, of his horror at the roiling slag when they marched out of the West with the first sunrise. No, he pondered grimly, not even as soil could one escape this twisting darkness.
Balan jumped as something cold and wet butted against his cheek and he opened his eyes to find Greweg looking down at him. The hound whined in concern as their eyes met, then nosed at him again and turned in a circle.
“What is it, lad?” He followed the earnest eyes toward the boulder, then scrambled to his feet when his gaze fell on the king’s bedroll, now lying mussed and empty beside the stone. He stumbled forward, peering anxiously through the dark for any sign of Nóm’s passage.
“It takes him this way, ever and anon.” Sídhon had come up without a sound and Balan swore despite himself to find the other suddenly at his side. “Especially if there is any shade of doubt. But be at ease, he will return by the morn.”
Balan glanced toward where Tultamo lay huddled in the center of the clearing, wrapped in a borrowed pair of blankets and sleeping fitfully. “Is it safe for him to go off alone with all that’s passed?” He realized in an instant the accusation implied in the question and grimaced in apology. “Beg pardon.”
“None called for.” There was amusement in the other’s voice as he reached down to scratch behind Greweg’s ears. “And nay, he is in no danger. Hilyo knows his duty full well—as he knows too my lord’s proclivity to wander. It will not be unforseen, nor will Arto stray far.”
Balan nodded, but his eyes had already drifted back back to search between the trees, tall birches standing like bones in the moonlight. He shivered and chewed at his lip, disquieted.
“The spring that summons this brook lies only a short walk from here,” Sídhon added after a long moment, his own eyes lifting to watch the branches dance in the breeze as the other glanced toward him in confusion.
“Does it?”
“Mm. A peaceable glade, it seemed to me.” A brief smile passed along his lips, then he dipped his head in parting and slipped back into the night’s shade, his departure nearly as unsettling as his appearance.
Balan looked after him for a time, contemplative, then turned back at last when he felt Greweg's expectant gaze looking up at him. He reached down to ruffle the fur behind the hound’s ears with a resigned snort. “Lead on then, lad, if you’re so keen about it. No doubt you’re in the right.”
Greweg’s tail thumped a few beats against his leg, then he trotted forward along the line of the running stream, while Balan followed at a more restrained pace, picking his steps carefully over the stony bank. He had forgotten how much he enjoyed wandering with a hound through the night. It had been years since he had last done so—not since Baran’s old bitch Mischief had died, and that was well before they tried the mountain passes. She was a good creature. Baran had dug her resting place within the red cedar grove by Andanahti-marei, an unusual rite to be granted an animal, and Balan swallowed back a lump in his throat at the memory of his son’s tireless labor. Mischief had been by his side since Esrid’s death and the loss of his companion had struck Baran keenly.
It had been good to see him keeping company with a new hound during their stay in Estolad, a shaggy creature, thick and wolfish and far removed from Mischief’s rangy spirit. Fitted to the man, Balan reflected with a pang, and no longer the boy.
His own companion slowed at the edge of a clearing and looked back over his shoulder, dark eyes canny and tail wagging through the tall clover as he waited for Balan to join him, which he did a short moment later and reached down to rest a hand between the silky ears in acknowledgment. Then, after another brief hesitation, he shifted into the moonlight.
It was bright after the forest’s shroud and Balan found himself blinking at the sudden clarity about him. Trees reared up like sentinels around the perimeter, arms raised in reverence toward the stars above them. Crocus blossoms nodded in the breeze, their furled heads soft in Isil’s glow, and the tall grasses bowed and danced between them like water. Mesmerized, he moved forward into the glade and filled his lungs with a rush of scent, crushed petals and clear water tumbling over the rocks; then slowly he let his eyes drift back along the brook to its source.
The spring was small, little more than a trickle burbling out from the base of a rock fall. It spread sluggishly through the sedges before yielding its path to the slope and cutting a bed into the soil, cascading downward toward their camp and the falls beyond. And there, a stone’s throw from the boulders, sat the figure he sought, knees drawn up to his chest and hunched against an old oak tree fallen on its side. His hair was mussed from sleep and hovered in unkempt tufts above his shoulders, once again imbuing him with that boyish vulnerability Balan knew he kept under careful guard. Even so, the starlight caught within the tangled strands and lit his face with a fay radiance, so that it was a long moment ere Balan realized that tears too glistened on the other’s cheeks.
His languor was broken in an instant and he strode swiftly to the fallen tree, kneeling at Nóm’s side in concern. A wordless exclamation slipped from him as he cupped the other’s cheek within his palm. “What’s all this, then?” Balan murmured gently, turning his face into the light.
“Naught.” The king’s voice was rough and he pulled away, passing a hand quickly over his eyes to dash away any signs of weeping. “I am well.”
“Liar,” Balan retorted, but there was no accusation in his tone, only warmth, and he took the other’s face once more in his hands, thumbing away the lingering tears. “I heard thee.” Finrod looked up at him in query and Balan shrugged. “Saw thee, felt thee…whatever sense that was. In thy dreaming.”
Surprise and shame vied for control of the other’s face. “That reached thee?”
“Aye, like a shout. I thought thou hadst cried out in earnest and woke certain that foes had come upon us in the night.”
“Nay. Nay, there was no danger.” He fell quiet and reached out to grip Balan’s shoulder, his arm, his hand, as though reassuring himself that the other was present in truth, then released him with an apologetic grimace. “I beg forgiveness. I’d no intention of waking thee.”
“Don’t be a fool.” Balan shifted to sit at his side and nudged his shoulder against the other’s. “This is of more worth to me than a few hours’ slumber—and well enough shouldst thou know it. Though I’ll leave thee in peace if solitude was thine aim.”
The ghost of a smile passed over Finrod’s lips and he shook his head, turning to bury his face in Balan’s hair. “I am glad of the company.”
They sat on in silence for a time, listening to the chattering of the brook and the tree frogs’ chorus passing from branch to branch. An owl’s query from the far side of the clearing. The distant rumble of the falls. Balan found himself lulled once more by the night’s music and his eyes grew heavy despite his resolve as the slow minutes stretched on with the moonlight fluttering through the leaves.
“The hour is evil,” Nóm’s voice broke the silence at last, little more than a whisper brushing over his scalp, “and your road leads to sorrow that ye do not foresee.”
“Hm?” Balan blinked hard to clear the drowsiness and shifted his face so that he could see the other’s. “What’s that?”
“The words of the messenger in the dark of our madness. The curse of my people.”
Balan reached over to brush the hair back from Nóm’s face, setting his lips briefly to his forehead. “Surely the day’s not been so bad as all that.” There was only a noncommittal snort in reply and Finrod turned his face in against the other’s neck. Balan pressed down a smile as he laid his cheek against the mussed gold, drawing a finger over the half-hidden jawline, and felt the other’s head grow heavy upon his shoulder in response. It lit a fierce warmth in him to spend an hour as the one granting solace, when so often it was his own grief fleeing to Nóm’s arms in search of the same. He rested a hand on the other’s neck possessively.
“Canst thou recall the night I dragged thee from the ice?” Nóm asked after a long pause, his voice still muffled beneath the other’s chin.
“Aye, with clarity. Twas the only time I’d seen thee so till now.”
“I was careless with thee.” He shook his head and pressed forward when Balan’s mouth opened in protest. “I set thee within my own memory with little regard for what pain thou wouldst carry from it.”
“That was forgiven in the same moment it was done, Nóm. Do not carry it forward needlessly.”
Finrod was quiet again for a time, then shifted so that he could look out over the brook, avoiding the other’s eye. “But thou canst remember the lucidity of it? That inseparability of thine own sense from the one recalling it?”
“Aye?” Balan frowned. “But I’ve told thee already I do not hold it against thee, nor should—” The cause for this trail of questioning overtook him with a wave of nausea and he broke off, cupping his palm once more to the other’s cheek. “Oh, Elenya…”
“I should know to expect it by now. Tis far from the first time I have had need to search a captive’s mind.” A shudder passed through him and his hold on Balan’s arm tightened. “But it would be a greater ill, perhaps, to find oneself so well guarded as to be insensate to another’s pain.”
“Beloved.” Balan trailed his fingers through the other’s hair, smoothing the contrary strands that continued to drift over his eyes. How achingly young he seemed in the moonlight, the careful poise cast aside and fear writ plain upon his face. Balan felt a fierce protectiveness rise like hackles along the back of his thought. Nóm had knelt for nigh an hour with Tultamo in the clearing, silent and motionless while the sun dipped toward the horizon, until at last he broke free with a gasp. Edrahil had been at his side at once, catching his elbow to steady him—to keep him from collapse, Balan saw now, observing in hindsight how Nóm had swayed to the side when he pulled away, how he had leaned heavily against the captain’s grip before rising and offering Tultamo his hand outstretched in peace. Anger burned in his breast. How could they demand this of him to quell their own mistrust? Were they not meant to take his word and heed his judgment? What right did they have to require more from him?
“I am their king,” Finrod murmured, and a brief smile twitched his lips when Balan startled at the answered thought. “They may require all from me.”
“But thou art a man first. They should not forget it.”
“And they do not. This I require of myself.” He reached up and turned Balan’s face to meet his eyes, a quiet laugh escaping him when the other’s scowl persisted. “Now which of us is playing the guard dog?”
“Sídhon’s runt,” Balan retorted. “The hound rooted me out of my bedroll and hauled me straight to thee.” He traced his fingers along the lines of the other’s face, outlining each feature with care, and gradually his expression softened. “Why is it so needful? From thine own lips I’ve learned even I can shut thee out with ease. What good does this accomplish? It cannot prove innocence.”
“No, it cannot.” Finrod stretched his neck with a grimace, then shifted to lean against the trunk once more. “But it anchors perception, and by such may counsel the heart’s discernment. It is knowledge, Balan, pure and simple, and I covet every grain of it when faced with such a choice. And besides,” he added after a brief pause, lifting a twig in his hand and worrying it absently, “long and weary were the years he bore this pain alone. What manner of lord should I be to refuse that burden now?”
“A fairly common one, I would say.”
“I am nothing of the kind.”
“No indeed, nor a humble one either.”
Finrod snorted. “Surely neither of us holds any lingering illusions on that point,” he quipped, managing a self-deprecating grin before turning his focus back to the twig. He chipped away at the bark, peeling it by degrees until it lay smooth and pale as a bone across his palm. This he regarded for a time, till at last he broke the silence in a flat voice. “I felt it within me, the terror and despair of the shackled; and twas as though it had been fitted to my soul—my own horror and not the recollection of another’s. I have never known such a fear. It choked me, some heavy, skulking thing bearing copper’s taste upon the tongue.”
A tickle of dread crept along Balan’s spine and he shook away the image of the yawning crevice on the fell. “I can imagine it.”
The other seemed to sense the bent of his thought and his knuckles whitened around the stick in his hand. “And I. No rest would I have known, Balan, no peace or forgiveness had they succeeded in—”
“They did not. Let it be, Nóm. Do not conjure further horrors than those already pressed upon thee.” Balan watched him thoughtfully, then at length reached out and brushed a strand of hair from his eyes. “This is what plagued thy dreams, then?”
“Yes.“ Finrod tipped his head back against the trunk, fixing his gaze on the tracery of branches above, then grimaced when he could not let the half-truth stand. “And no.”
Balan reclined beside him and turned his face to watch the king’s, letting the silence grow heavier between them until he could all but see the other squirm. “Well?” he asked at last with a trace of teasing. “Wilt thou tell me of it now or hold it till the dawn?”
“Incorrigible,” Finrod muttered to the sky, then lifted his head as Greweg meandered out from the underbrush and ran a hand over the hound’s ears. “Harken to him, old friend! With such a nose for inquisitiveness tis little wonder thou didst claim him as a brother.”
Balan chuckled and shifted so that he too looked up at the canopy overhead. “We both know thou wilt tell me ere the night is out. Why not escape the deliberation and have it out now?”
The king huffed, though amusement creased the corners of his eyes, and he pointedly turned his attention to scratching Greweg’s neck. The hound had curled at his side while they spoke and now lay with his muzzle draped affectionately across Finrod’s thigh. They made a pleasant image, Balan thought, restful and homely in the moonlight with the grasses sighing around them in the wind. He understood why the other had chosen this place for solace, and found himself uncertain now of drawing out the dream’s poison into this refuge. Perhaps it was better after all to let the water’s music comfort in his stead.
But Nóm’s voice drifted through the silence before he could retract the question. “I stood naked before a great abyss,” he said, his voice little more than a breath, “upon a moldering bluff it seemed, and each movement of my limbs cost an effort I could not sustain; yet I knew the edge would claim me should I cease even for a moment. I thought thee there beside me, but I could not reach thee.” He shuddered and an note of panic crept into his voice. “I was blind in the dark, Balan, blind in the dark…with the weight of my limbs growing ever greater till I could scarce draw breath.”
Balan said nothing, but reached out and gathered the other’s hand in his own, pressing it firmly between his palms to still its trembling.
“Each moment I felt certain I could bear it no longer, but each led to another and then another still, till there came a roaring wind and a vast darkness—darker even than my blindness—rushed like smoke from the abyss, overwhelming me, and I was falling.” He broke off and filled his lungs with a sharp hiss, his pulse pounding within their clasped hands. “I was falling endlessly. Only when the light of Aman failed have I known such a Night.”
“Aye, I felt the terror when it woke me.” Balan reached out with his free hand to brush the other’s hair back in comfort, but Finrod shook his head.
“No. Twas not yet that I called out for thee.” His eyes closed for a long moment and he buried his fingers in Greweg’s fur to steady his resolve. “Amidst the plummet, it seemed to me the darkness became a wave, cresting over the horizon and climbing, climbing, ever higher till there was nothing about me but its shadow. And my heart knew then that it had come for thee and I had failed. It would consume thee.” His grip on Balan’s hand tightened to the point of pain. “And all would be lost.”
“There now, I’m here,” Balan murmured, laying his hand atop the other’s once more and stroking his knuckles soothingly. “I’m here. Nothing is lost.”
He shook his head again, this time with greater vehemence. “I did not seek this knowledge. I have no wish to bear it.”
“Then bear it not, love. It was only a dream. All is well.” To this the other made no reply, but something in his silence sent a shiver of unease through Balan’s senses. “Is it not?”
For a time this question too hung unanswered in the air between them, till at last Finrod drew his knees up to his chest, resting his chin atop them and gazing out over the water. “I told thee once—when we burned the orqui, I believe, on the road from Thalos—I told thee then of órë, did I not?”
“Órë…”
“The heart’s knowledge.”
“Aye. Messages from your gods, I thought it was.”
“Say rather the influence of the One, or of his servants, upon our understanding.”
“Call it what thou wilt. But a nightmare is not a portent.”
“No. Not all of them.”
“Dear one.” He laid his hand along the other’s cheek once again, surprised to hear Esrid’s endearment slip out in his own voice. “Thou art overwrought with another’s pain. Do not let it draw thee to—“
“I am not a child in fear of a nightmare.” Finrod’s eyes flashed and his voice was sharp as he pulled free. “There have been others before this, and I have seen those visions grow to fruition—and reaped well enough of their bitter harvest. I know of what I speak.” Then, as abruptly as it had arisen, his anger seemed to falter and he rested his head wearily against his knees. “Forgive me. I know thine intent was kindness.” He raked his fingers back through his hair, gripping it in handfuls at the base of his scalp, till long minutes passed and he sighed, raising his eyes to the spring once more. “They were not all tidings of ill,” he conceded in a low voice. “Indeed, the first I recall was of the sun. On the Ice, in the bitterest cold, I would see Yavanna while I slept, reaching over the waters with her palms cupped and light spilling over to wake the works of her hands.” His voice faded to a whisper. “I dreamt too of clay figures that rose from the ground to greet the new light. The first I understood when Arien rose triumphant in the sky, and as we marched I sang aloud from the joy of knowing it elucidated before me. The second I have dreamed over and again through the years, and until meeting thy people I understood it not—and there too what gladness I knew in the recognition.”
Balan nudged his shoulder. “Sentimental pup,” he muttered with a grin, and Finrod managed a wan smile in return.
“It cannot be denied.” He reached down and began sorting pebbles through the moss, and Balan watched in fascination as the little groups took shape: smooth, small, rough, middling, grey, speckled. It was a languid process and he felt a blanket of peace settle over him with each movement of the other’s fingers.
“And the others?” he asked at last, pulling back with an effort from the growing reverie. “What of those?”
“What wouldst thou hear?” Finrod shuddered and his words were strained. “That my greatest certainty is doubt? That the haven I have delved is merely a buttress against some day of evil when all the Siege shall surely go down in ruin? Or wouldst thou hear that this retreat too shall fail, and I and all my kingdom be undone? How, I cannot tell thee; but it shall be so. It weighs with an unflinching conviction in my bones.”
“Nóm…”
“Wisdom!” he hissed, and his restraint seemed to break with the exclamation. “Wisdom? I see hints and shadows, or in these rare moments of clarity a certainty settles in my heart, but even these must be half-truths and muddied. ‘Sorrow that ye do not foresee,’ quoth the messenger. Why, then? Why burden us with foreknowledge when from their own tongues we know that naught will ready us? Is it meant to be a mercy? Some kindness bestowed overlate that we might not think ourselves cast off utterly from the One’s guidance?” He drew his hands over his face and shook his head. “I want it not, Balan.”
It was unnerving to hear him speak of his gods with such bitterness—stewards, Balan’s mind corrected in reflex, and he was momentarily amused by how thoroughly the other’s voice had lodged within him. But this outburst was more akin to his own acrid grievances, aching and lonely and angry at his own desperation, and he found himself torn between pity and a vague annoyance. How did Nóm understand mortality if not as the certain foreknowledge of ruin’s shadow? Balan’s people needed no dreams to call forth such a spectre. That darkness loomed over every day’s horizon; and they too had never been offered any choice in the knowledge.
The image of Sabil rose in his mind, seated in the clover beyond the hall with both hands extended, laughing as Estreth spread clay slip across her palms. He had not heard what Estreth foretold from the cracks and patterns when it dried, but the brief glimpse of them lit a question within him that burned till the day’s rites were done—till he caught Estreth amid the feasting and shamefacedly begged of her what it was she once divined for his wife. Nothing, she had answered him. She’d told the clay’s fortune on the day her sister was bound to Geberic, but when wedded to Balan in turn, Esrid had refused the tradition. Better to walk blind, she had said, than to shackle each day to the prediction of what would come. He had longed then to ask what it was she saw in the clay of that first marriage, but he saw the wariness in Estreth’s eye and dared not risk the question.
Was that how Nóm too understood this knowledge? Every hour fettered to the coming calamity, with never enough clarity to change its course…Balan shuddered and reached out despite himself, resting a hand upon the other’s back. He should understand this despair, he chided himself, not dismiss it. It was no less of a cruelty for Nóm to face this than it was for his own people. He rubbed slow circles along the other’s spine till gradually he felt the ragged breathing steady.
“My mercy will be a cruelty,” Nóm whispered at last, his face still hidden within his fingers. “That was my waking certainty.”
A new wave of unease prickled at Balan’s gut, but he kept his motions steady. “What does it mean?”
Finrod shook his head helplessly.
“The thrall?”
“I know not.” The king shivered, then turned to meet his eye and there were lines of desperation creased into his face. “Yes. So my heart tells me. But I cannot turn him away, Balan, not after…not when he has…” he trailed off, shaking his head and gripping his hair in handfuls once again till it pulled tight against his scalp. “How am I to judge my way?”
“As thou ever hast.” Balan reached out and drew the other’s hands free, clasping them gently within his own to still their worrying. “I am no stranger to a doom inescapable, Elenya—nor are any of my kind. But this I know: good and ill do not change for all the future’s looming shadow. Choose as thou ever hast. Do what is right from what thou canst discern before thee; then choose the next right thing and the next after that.” He brushed a strand of hair from Nóm’s face and tucked it behind his ear with a faint smile. “And so is a man’s path laid.”
“And if I pave a road into darkness?”
“We are doomed to such days regardless. Let us meet them from mercy, if meet them we must.” Balan could feel the other’s hands trembling within his palms, the pulse drumming against his fingers, and he tightened his grasp. “Beloved…”
Finrod clutched at him in return and his lips pressed into a thin line as he stared out over the clearing, his breath shaking and the clenched muscles standing out along his jaw. “I am afraid,” he whispered at last, his voice small as a child’s, and Balan gathered him at once in his arms.
“Aye, love,” he murmured into the other’s hair. “Aye, I know it.” He held him as he wept, cradling the king’s head against his shoulder and letting the bitter tears soak into his shirt; and he did not loose him even when the surge of grief was spent. In the moonlight the grasses waved and tossed, a grey sea stretching before them toward the dawn, and at length Balan drew the other down gently to rest upon his lap. He combed his fingers through the flaxen strands. He traced each contour of Nóm’s cheeks, jaw, nose, brow—just as his mother had done when he was a wakeful child. And with that familiar rite, her voice rose too within him and quietly he began to sing.
“When dawn through the old oak is breaking
And lilies and birdsong are waking
I rise with the wind in the branches
And measure my steps in time’s dances
“May peace ever lie down beside me
May you in wisdom’s arms find me
May valor not be denied me
And mercy’s temperance guide me
“May melodies of your song quiet me
May twilight’s shade calm and hide me
May joy through my sorrowing find me
And goodness lead and delight me
“When noon in the white sky is blazing
And the herds slow and drift into grazing
Still the path stretches unending
The toil and journey unbending
“May peace ever lie down beside me
May you in wisdom’s arms find me
May valor not be denied me
And mercy’s temperance guide me
“May melodies of your song quiet me
May twilight’s shade calm and hide me
May joy through my sorrowing find me
And goodness lead and delight me
“When dark falls the midnight around us
And shadows shift and confound us
Yours are the ears that I sing to
And yours the path that I cling to
“May peace ever lie down beside you
May I in wisdom’s arms find you
May valor not be denied you
And mercy’s temperance guide you
“May melodies of my song quiet you
May twilight’s shade calm and hide you
May joy through the sorrowing find you
And goodness lead and delight you.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
enquië [Q] the Elven six-day week
cadhadrim: [S] Dwarves, from Khuzd
gwethrim: [S] people of the shadows: wherein gwath (shadow) is pluralized to gweth
Hîr: [S] lord, master
MISC NOTES
- Regarding Balan’s use of the term “man” (lowercase) to reference Finrod in the final section, this takes precedent from Chapter 9 of the Silmarillion where Tolkien describes Galadriel as a “woman of the Noldor,” setting up the use of man/woman as separate descriptors from Man (capitalized) or Elf.
24. Mirröanwi
”Thou hast set a fracture within me already, canst thou see it not? Broken along the line of my own self. It is the soul’s bond that would be our unmaking, thou sayest—yet thou it was who named us lovers in soul, who holds me still in that bond while denying its effect. I shall rend already at the parting. Wilt thou not?”
After returning to Nargothrond, a welcoming feast for the returned thrall triggers a progression of crises.
Read 24. Mirröanwi
Mirröanwi: Quenya, incarnates, those (spirits) 'put into flesh'
[…] the Mirröanwi are made of a union of body and mind, of hröa and fëa, or as we say in picture the House and the Indweller. For what is the "death" that you mourn but the severing of these two? And what is the "deathlessness" that you have lost but that the two should remain united for ever?
- The Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, AUTUMN
Nargothrond
The king stood beneath a tall elm tree, a brooch laid upon his opened palm and a smile softening the line of his lips. It was a marvel of artistry, Balan reflected. The trunk and branches had been carved whole of a column jutting from the cavern floor and a blanket of ivy wove over the limestone, dangling its leaves between the boughs and completing the illusion of life. Tultamo stood opposite him, his own palms held outstretched in answer and a basket looped over one arm.
“Take now this emblem,” Finrod said, his voice reverberating through the Third Hall where they were gathered, “in token of your lord’s favor and as a remembrance to all of your welcome in this city: above reproach and in full esteem among us.” He reached forward and pinned the brooch over the other’s heart, his lips moving in a blessing that Balan could not discern.
It had been little more than a month since they found the thrall trailing them through the Andram’s pathways, whereupon they had returned at speed to Nargothrond and given him over to the care of the king’s healers. He had spent the intervening weeks in the quiet of their cloisters, and though he still appeared pale and withdrawn beneath the boughs of hanging ivy, there was a growing substance to his movements, a flicker of life rekindled in his gaze.
The king held his hands spread open once more in the space between them, and at this signal a group of Elves moved forward to stand beside him. The first of these, the Warden of the Doors, placed a key on the waiting palm, to which Finrod carefully attached a silver bulla of his insignia, then passed it to Tultamo. “Where once there was bondage, may there now be liberation.” A loaf of bread was next, transferred from Meril’s hands to the king’s, and again from thence to the former thrall. “Where there was scarcity, may there be bounty. Where there was pain,” he retrieved a small amphora of honey from Celiel and offered it when Tultamo had transferred the loaf to the waiting basket, “may there be a balm. Where there was darkness, may you now carry light.” The lamp that Faelon placed in his hand was small, a shapeless lump of blue crystal from which the caverns’ starlight spilled between the king’s fingers.
Tultamo’s face was lit in stark outline as the stone passed into his grasp, and for a time he stood unmoving, staring down at his glowing flesh while the white scar-lines seemed to take on and mirror the pale light.
“Where there was isolation,” the king continued when this token too was at last stowed alongside the others, “may there be love.”
Guilin stepped forward bearing a carven cup, which Finrod took from him and brought solemnly to his lips. It was shaped of some smooth, dark wood, nearly black, and inlaid in silver with a circle of dancing figures whose heads were wreathed in flowering garlands. These, Balan surmised, had been wrought of gold—else it was some trick of the light that had caught the reflection of the king’s hair and warmed the silver with its sheen. Two trees there were as well, around which the figures danced, one on each side of the vessel, and their boughs burgeoned upwards till they wove together into a curious brim where Nóm’s lips rested as he drank of the wine. A moment later it was lowered, the king’s lips softened in a smile, the cup of friendship extended toward the former thrall.
“And may there be fellowship,” Finrod finished as he placed it into the other’s hands, then inclined his head in deference when Tultamo drank in turn. The wine was passed around the gathered group until each had partaken and the empty vessel returned to Guilin’s keeping. Then Finrod knelt beside the little stream of water that babbled from the rock face at their feet. He dipped two fingers into the current, then rose, laying his dry hand upon Tultamo’s shoulder. “Where once you were voiceless, Tultamo son of Tírthon,” he said, gently anointing the other’s lips with the water, “may you again be One Who Speaks.”
A cheer erupted from those assembled—both from the king’s attendants and those of the Third Hall’s residents who had gathered to witness their neighbor’s welcome—and Tultamo flinched involuntarily at the sound. The king’s hand tightened momentarily around his shoulder in reassurance, then he released him and took a sprig of lilac from Meril’s hands.
“Let us give thanks for the newly returned,” he called out, lifting the branch in the air before passing it to Tultamo, “our brother, restored to us beyond hope!”
“To light and to life!” the crowd rejoined. “By Eru’s bounty we welcome him among us.”
The formality slipped away with that exclamation, and the low rumble of conversation grew about them as the crowd began to mingle throughout the open area. The hall’s market was held here most days, but on this afternoon it had been cleared away and a feast laid out in its stead—rugs and cushions draped in clusters across the thick moss and boards spread with fruit and fresh bread, with wine and with meat from the hunt. It was the welcoming feast, a bounty spread for any who dwelt within the Third Hall where Tultamo had been given lodgings, and served to establish him as one among their number.
Nóm had explained it earlier that day when he drifted into Balan’s chambers from the garden, bare-headed and dazzling in the morning light. There was ever a specter of doubt when one of the gwethrim came back among them. The instances of true betrayal, of course, were fewer than the rumors and fears made them, but the Foe’s deceit wielded a subtle blade and terror spread rampant from that grain of truth. Tultamo’s father had turned him from his family’s door in Mithrim, and many among Nóm’s own people shared the same impulse throughout the years. It was why he had begun the rite of the returned, he confessed, that all might gather and see the king’s blessing laid on each former thrall, and know that any discrimination was to malign one in whom the king had placed his trust.
It was a well-intentioned effort, Balan reflected as he watched Finrod thread his way through the crowd at Tultamo’s side, but he found himself skeptical as to its efficacy. Prejudices were not so easily set aside, nor were such fears as these likely to be quelled by decree. Nóm knew this too, of course. What more could he do but rule by example and hope to see his people follow? He let his eyes drift across the cavern, noting the sidelong glances, the children tarrying near their parents, the low voices carrying on in stilted pleasantries. At least there was no open hostility.
There was a stir at the far edge of the market square and he turned to see a small group intersect with the king’s path, three soldiers and a fourth in traveling garments, and heard the echo of Finrod’s glad cry as he stepped forward and flung his arms around the foremost in greeting. They bore the High King’s livery, Balan noted, the golden wheel on blue leaping like flames in the cavern’s lights—this was surely the expected delegation from Barad Eithel. They had been dispatched, Nóm told him, after he sent word to his uncle requesting Tultamo be released from his vows, that he might be sworn instead to the lord who now sheltered him.
Their leader stepped back from Finrod’s embrace and turned at once to the former thrall at his side, confirming Balan’s supposition as he dipped his head in salutation and held out an offering on the flat of one hand. It was a pity Sídhon had relieved Tultamo of his basket when the rites concluded, Balan thought with wry sympathy, at this rate the poor wretch was like to be overrun with tokens of one kind or another ere the meal had begun.
He pilfered a few berries from the nearest board and slipped them into his mouth as he drifted through the crowd, his steps bending gradually toward the king and his companions. Nóm was clad still as he had been that morning: loose pants cut in an echo of Balan’s own, a shirt of some unknown cloth, fine as silk and lily-pale, a heavy outer robe which fell open in the front and had been embellished across its surface with the rich golden thread he favored.
Gods all, you’re lovely.
It had slipped from him unthinking on the heels of a jest, his guard down as he held his own shirt in hand and teased the king appreciatively for this new turn of dress, and the sudden awkwardness in the other’s demeanor had turned his smile cold. It was not deliberate, Nóm had stammered out; that is, it was not his intention to cause—Balan had cut him off with a curt reassurance and turned abruptly to finish his own attire so the other might not see the mortification burning along his cheeks. He had willed himself to keep a distance after that, polite and aloof, to prove he was impervious to the king’s ever-shifting demeanor. But it was no good. Nóm was incandescent in the cavern’s light and Balan drifted toward him like a mayfly to the fire.
“I had not heard thine interests were turned to diplomacy,” the king was saying as Balan drew within earshot. “Finno spoke nothing of it when last I saw him.”
“Little mystery in that. He spoke not of it because he knew naught of it—though in truth no more do I, for I cannot claim any such change in myself.” The newcomer’s eyes were bright and he leaned in to brush a kiss to the king’s cheek in a more conventional greeting. “I heard hints from thy cousin of this den of thine, and I confess I offered myself for the task so I might look upon it with my own eyes and sate my inquisitiveness.”
Finrod laughed and clasped him by the shoulder. “I should be wroth with him for spreading tales of what is best left unspoken, but I find myself deep in his debt rather. Thou art most welcome here, my friend.”
“And my heart is gladdened to know it.” He drew back with a smile, then his brows lifted in curiosity as Balan reached them and met his gaze.
Finrod glanced around to see what had piqued the other’s interest and caught Balan’s arm at once with a glad exclamation. “And here thou art at last! I wondered what had become of thee.” He drew him forward eagerly and held out a hand in introduction. “Here is one I would have thee meet. This is Írimo Arandur—ah, forgive me, I fear my tongue is bound up in memory—this is Írui of Eryn Gwedhion, a lord of my uncle’s court. He is a dear friend of my cousin, Fingon, and a companion from my own youth as well.”
“In goodness our paths have crossed, Hîr Írui,” Balan said, crossing his arms after the manner of his people and bowing in welcome. “In peace may their journeys lead.”
“And may Elbereth smile upon them.”
Balan turned expectantly toward the king, but he was watching the newcomer still, bright and eager and seemingly unaware that anything was left wanting. “I am called Bëor,” he added when Nóm made no move to complete the introduction. “I dwell here as an emissary of my son, who is chieftain of our people.”
“And as my friend,” Finrod broke in quickly, his grip tightening for a moment around Balan’s arm, and he glanced down in contrition for the lapse. “He has been an invaluable companion as we work to build a lasting alliance between our peoples.”
“On this matter my prince spoke much,” Írui said with a smile, reaching out to clasp Balan’s hand in greeting. “He holds you high in his esteem, Bëor, and I am honored to greet you on his behalf.”
“And I to hear it, lord—I thank you.”
“Have they offered thee refreshment?” Finrod asked, turning again to Írui and seeming to notice for the first time the other’s travel-marked clothing. “Nay, I see they have not—thou art fresh come from the road and it is thoughtless of me to have kept thee here talking in such a state.”
“Am I so unkempt as all that?” Írui laughed and the twist of his smile was arch. “Varda…not fit for a picnic even?”
“Brute. Thou art twisting my words,” Finrod retorted in kind, grinning, “and full well dost thou know it.” He motioned for the others to follow and led the way toward where Tultamo and Sídhon waited on the nearest spread of rugs. “Thy penance shall be to join me at board—and I shall not release thee till thou hast had thy fill.”
“As merciful as the tales name thee.” Írui stood aside till the king had chosen a cushion then lowered himself to sit at his left, leaving Tultamo in the place of honor at Finrod’s right and Balan to take up the remaining space opposite the messenger. Sídhon had already filled the cups from a decanter of wine and Finrod leaned forward when all were seated and began portioning out the meat.
“Yavanna’s bounty, by Oromë’s grace,” he murmured as he placed the first cut on Tultamo’s plate. “Take and know that you are welcomed at this table.” He turned next to Írui and passed the second serving. “Yavanna’s bounty, by Oromë’s grace…”
Balan’s eyes followed each motion and he tried not to feel slighted by the ease with which another had claimed his usual place. Pettiness, he chided himself as the king set a portion before him and met his eye with a smile. Rank, adolescent pettiness. It would have been a more telling insult by far had Nóm displaced the High King’s representative in his stead. Diplomacy was not personal, this was not a slight. He shifted on the rug and reached out to tear a strip from the nearest round of cambas, a blistered flatbread strewn in piles along the table, and glanced over at the newcomer in appraisal. His appearance was unremarkable, at least in so far as one might compare him to others of his kind, with dark, wide-set eyes and a nest of curling brown hair hovering just below his jawline; a pleasant-featured Elf of medium build, perhaps a hand’s breadth taller than the king. Unlike the others of his company, he was not clad in the patterned blue and gold of Fingolfin’s livery, but wore instead a simple vesture of traveling hose and a loose outer tunic, beneath which a shirt of midnight blue was fitted closely about his arms. Like the king’s robe, this too had been embroidered in fine detail along its length—silver stars and lily-of-the-valley trailing in a delicate dance toward each of his wrists—and the tunic was belted at his waist with a matching strand of silver flowers. Hardly the travel-stained disorder Nóm’s words had implied.
He dipped the cambas into a paste of spiced lentils, scooping up a large portion as he had seen the others do and using this to enfold a bite of meat and bring it to his mouth. There were as many different turns of etiquette as there were varieties of meals, he reflected irritably while he studied Sídhon’s movements from the corner of his eye. It was a constant dance of mimicry to navigate each without a gaffe. This, thankfully, seemed to be near kin to the begetting day feasts, with only a detail changed here or there. It held a certain kind of logic, he supposed: the marking of a new life and the marking of a life renewed. Edrahil leaned in to share a dash of wine as the blessing passed around the table, and Balan found himself unexpectedly moved by the poignance in these mirrored rituals. Nóm’s doing, he recalled as he tipped a portion into Sídhon’s cup, for these rites had originated here in his kingdom. He raised the cup to his lips and met the king’s eye, a brief smile flickering between them as he let the warmth in his heart seep through into the other’s thought.
The toasts were fewer in this form of the tradition, and evidently limited to a predetermined group. Finrod had risen first, giving a blessing after the manner of his earlier benedictions; then Meril spoke, as did Celiel and another healer. Last of all, Írui had risen and offered a blessing on behalf of his lord, that Tultamo would know the High King’s immeasurable gratitude for the courage and fortitude he had shown, that life might spring anew from the shadows, and Tultamo find the peace and welcome so long denied him.
Solemnity was swift to fall away after that and a lightness of heart settled over the gathering once no further formality seemed required of them. Tultamo especially showed visible relief as he sequestered himself in a quiet conversation with Celiel and the other healer, and something near a smile began to grow at last upon his face. Beside them, the king and Írui drifted into a meandering discourse, touching on this friend or that, the latest of the High King’s councils, the varied skirmishes upon Ard Galen or the equally varied indiscretions of Barad Eithel’s court. Balan found himself unreasonably irritable with their conversation. Nonetheless, he attempted to follow the thread of it until their barrage of unfamiliar names and places made the endeavor hopeless, and he busied himself instead in half-thought pleasantries with Gildor and Edrahil, all the while keeping one ear tuned to the king’s voice.
But in the end, it was Írui’s words that carried his attention back to the exchange. The meal had dwindled by degrees until only a few of them remained, stretched at ease upon the rugs or meandering through the lamplit green. Tultamo had retired to his new lodgings some time past, weary and overladen with the sounds of celebration, and was accompanied by the two healers who wished to see him safely settled before returning to their own halls. Meril sat with one arm resting along the table and looked out with a tolerant smile at the group spread before her. Gildor had woven clusters of grapes into his hair and declared himself warden of the vintage, appropriating the remaining carafe of wine and bestowing it with regal dignity to each as he saw fit. Sídhon, by contrast, lay on his back, gazing up at the panoply of draped cloths overhead—great swaths of reds and yellows and oranges—while Edrahil and Balan amused themselves by tossing berries in a vaguely successful attempt to replenish the bowl he held balanced on his chest. Across from them the king reclined against a stone tree, the outer robe now folded as a pillow behind his back, and Írui lay stretched on the thick moss at his side.
“This rather puts me in mind of the lumas at Endillos,” the latter said, reaching out to touch the ring on Finrod’s left hand—a golden sprig of enameled leaves, wrapped ‘round and clasping a large, asymmetrical pearl within their blossoms, “the year Finno brought Turvo and thee to join us.”
“Does it?” Finrod’s tone was carefully neutral and he leaned forward to retrieve a plum from the table, cutting a thin wedge before glancing down at the ring in question. “I suppose the petals do bear a similar hue.”
Írui chuckled and took the proffered slice from the king’s hand. “And the pearl a similar cast.”
“Hm?” Finrod shrugged, then shook his head with a dismissive laugh. “Truly, I do not recall.”
“O how he lies, our noble lord!” Írui grinned up at him. “Hearken to the rose blooming on this serene visage. Sídhon,” he called, shifting onto both elbows so he might see past the table, “thy memory will support me in this. What—“
“Nay, I’ll not be baited into thy fooling,” Sídhon cut him off with an amused glance. “As fortune has it, I was not yet among your number and therefore cannot be called in witness.”
“Thoughtless of thee, but I suppose it cannot be helped.” He turned toward Meril with a beatific smile. “Surely you recall the pearl in question, Amillë Merillë?”
“With more ease than thou wilt ever recall propriety,” she returned, but there was mirth in the lines of her eyes as she turned to sip from her wine.
“No hope for that, I fear.” He winked at her, then cast a penitent glance toward the king. “Poor Ammalincë, I believe we were quite horrid to thee.”
Finrod handed over another slice of plum with a snort. “Not thou, at least. Though I confess a lingering grudge with thy cook for indulging my schemes.”
“You see?” Írui crowed. “He does remember.”
“Ammalincë?” Gildor queried, and the arch of his brow was comical beneath the drooping collection of grapes.
“Yes, he was quite the little goldfinch in those days—nay, truly thou wert! Clever and bright and the most amiable child I’d ever set eyes on.”
“I was not a child.”
Írui looked up in feigned surprise. “Not ever?”
“Pest. Not when I earned the name of thee.”
“Not in thine own eyes, certainly.”
“Nor thee in thine.”
Írui laughed and lay back in the moss. “And deluded cubs were we both.”
“That I will concede.” Finrod laughed too then, and tossed the plum pit toward the other before reclining once more against the limestone tree. The wine had drawn a slight flush to his cheeks—as though he had just ducked in from the snow, Balan thought fondly, the memory of Estolad still near in his heart—and his laugh was unusually bright, his eyes shining. He was fiddling with the pearl ring that began the exchange, slipping it loose, turning it on his finger, pushing it back into place; and ever so often cast a glance at his companion while a smile flickered at the corners of his lips. Balan held back a chuckle. For all his protestations, Nóm was radiating youth in every motion—king of all this grandeur, yet fidgeting as nervously as Baran whenever Sabil came near him as a lad. A cold, sickening weight unfurled in his gut. Oh gods…he had passed more than enough meals at Nóm’s side to know it needed far more wine than this to color his cheeks so, or to set him in such a fey spirit…
“You see?” Gildor held the wine carafe aloft and there was laughter from the group as he gestured toward the king. “He has distracted us once again. A cup to whoever will speak the tale.”
Balan could hear his heart pounding and hastily closed the other from his thought before Nóm could investigate the cause. A needless precaution. The king continued on, seemingly oblivious to the sudden surge of alarm in the mind against his own, and Balan felt his despair deepen.
“Let Ingoldo tell it,” Írui suggested with a grin. “No doubt he will need the cup in solace.”
“And will give a far more accurate accounting than thou wouldst manage.” Finrod scowled at him in feigned annoyance, then reached for another plum. “We were friends in our youth,” he began after a pause, “Finno, Íryo, Turvo, and I. Or rather, Finno and Íryo were friends and we followed them about like eager shadows; we had each one foot still in boyhood and they were nearly come of age—a quite predictable worship. One spring we were gathered at Írui’s family home for his begetting day feast and I, having brought a token in gift, found upon facing him that I was too timid to present it in person. So I contrived instead to hide it within the lumas where he might come to find it for himself. Which, as you have no doubt surmised, he learned with his teeth.” He collected his cup from the stone beside him and held it out toward Gildor with a smile. “My due, warden.”
“What he does not tell you,” Írui interjected through the laughter, setting one hand on the king’s arm and using the other to block Gildor from refilling the chalice, “is that the token was an unconscionably fine pearl set in filigree netting. Nor that he spent the full afternoon befriending our kitchen folk, convincing them not only to conceal this menace alongside the fig, but furthermore to add a seventh petal to the flower which sat above it, that he might know where in the loaf they were to be found.”
“How else was I to ensure it wandered not to Finno’s plate instead?”
“How indeed?”
Balan affected to laugh with the others but he could not shift his eyes from Írui’s face, save to watch as the other’s hand came to rest once more against the king’s arm. How well he knew that gesture! How often had he done the same, letting his touch linger just a moment beyond prudence. An unspoken claiming. Laughter came again and he realized he had let himself lose the thread of the conversation.
“But even with the diversion,” Írui was saying, “he could hardly hope to change the pieces unnoticed; a sleight which, of course, my lord Fingon observed at once—though still too late to prevent my own discovery. Poor Ingoldo,” he added with a sympathetic grimace, “we teased him so mercilessly that he fled to the gardens without enjoying so much as a bite of his stolen cake.”
“Where, to his credit, our host sought me out in short order, with the offending token strung in honor from his neck and a gracious but entirely undeserved word of thanks upon his tongue.” Finrod cast a warm smile down at his neighbor. “Thy kindness, at least, I have not forgotten—much as I would unlearn the rest.”
Írui chuckled and leaned back on his elbows. “A recounting which, I confess, is far more flattering than my own recollection, so in vanity I’ll say thou hast the right of it and let thy telling stand.”
“And the strategy hadst thou not been discovered?” Gildor asked as he added a splash of wine to the king’s chalice in payment.
Finrod mumbled something unintelligible and drained his cup.
“What was that?”
“The pearl’s luster was meant to catch in the light when he cut into the lumas, not to go unnoticed while he was distracted by Fingon’s accusation.”
“And?”
“I thought to let one or two speak first in surprise, and then—” he broke off with an uneasy chuckle and hid his face in one hand before continuing. “Then I thought to add in reflection, ‘As the music of the Ulumúri are those lives upon whom the Lord of Waters sends his blessing—a joy to the spirit of those who hear them, and held ever in the heart thereafter’.” His cheeks burned with no small flush now and he held out his cup without uncovering his face. “There, Warden, that has earned me another.”
Sídhon let out a whoop of laughter and Írui collapsed onto the moss with the force of his own. “Light of Varda, Ingoldo,” he gasped at last, “that was thy scheme? Oh Valar, to have seen it—a room full of thy cousins and half the court of Tirion, and the ardent child at my side reciting the most pious false flattery one could devise.”
“Thankfully they spared us all the ordeal.” Finrod drained the second cup as swiftly as the first, then sank back against the tree, drawing his hands self-consciously over his cheeks as he joined in their mirth.
Balan felt a tickle on his wrist and glanced down to find the handful of berries he was holding lay crushed now within his palm. Little wonder. The familiarity and affection of their exchange churned bile in his stomach and his teeth ground when he lifted his eyes to the pair once more. Írui was laughing still, trading banter with Gildor and looking toward the king in open admiration. His earlier evaluation held, Balan decided, attempting to wipe the berries discreetly on the ground behind him; but while this intruder was unexceptional—plain, he would have said, if one could use the term of any of the Nómin—there was a vibrance about him when he moved and spoke that lit his features and left him undeniably lovely. Damn him and his unending youth. Damn his laughter and damn his charm, and his fingers hovering along the king’s arm yet again.
“More wine, Bëor?” Edrahil had appropriated the carafe while Gildor’s back was turned and tipped it toward him with a canny smile playing at his lips.
“Ai,” Gildor cried before Balan could find a reply, and snatched the carafe from Edrahil’s hand, “only the Warden may grant or deny! Thankfully I am of a benevolent sort,” he added, turning to Balan with a grin. “Ale we have not, but for thine ails I’ll grant a drop.”
“Menace some other,” Balan rejoined, chuckling despite himself and redirecting the wine toward his neighbor. “I’ve learned the danger of these casks long ere now.”
“Do your people not ferment drink, Bëor?” Their exchange had drawn Írui’s attention and he was propped on his elbows once more, looking across the table with a smile.
“We do,” Balan answered shortly, then heard the coldness in his voice and tempered it with a smile. “Though ours are not so potent.”
“I see.”
“Not even a horn of seven?” Nóm met his eye across the gathering, mischief flickering in his grin, and Balan’s heart turned over at the allusion to the hrögemetheilit’s folly.
“Estë preserve us,” Gildor murmured with a shudder. “Remind me not of that devil’s brew.”
“She has done a work already that thou canst recall it.” Sídhon dodged the grape that arced toward him and laughed as he rolled onto his stomach. “I was set a fine task corralling the both of you.”
“Then a poor shepherd thou wert,” Gildor retorted. “I woke with one arm ‘round an apple barrel and my lord slept the night on a hillside.”
“Pillowed by heather and content as a babe when I found him on the morn.”
“Much as you find me now,” Finrod’s laugh cut through their banter, “peaceful and rested and in fine company—and much recovered from my earlier follies.” With this last, he tossed his empty cup to Gildor with a grin. “For what more could I wish but this?”
❈❈❈
Balan stared down at the sea of glass. It sprawled across the stone in shattered fragments, each piece catching the lamplight and turning it back in distorted patterns. A fitting sight.
He had kept his composure in the moment, dipping his head with a placatory smile when the group rounded the garden’s edge, then murmuring a greeting before slipping by them and escaping into the passages. But now, alone in the quiet of his own apartments, the helplessness overmastered him and he was choked with his own futility.
As spent and withered as though he was of the Engwar…
Gelmir had sighted him first and blanched even as the remark left his companion’s lips. It was Nélloth at his side, one of the recurrent emissaries between Nargothrond and Estolad. Till this, Balan had always found her pleasant and courteous—carrying back tokens the village children sent for him, seeking out spices he mentioned in passing, murmuring the settlement’s gossip in his ear while her captain passed the formal report to the king.
So engrossed had they been in their whispers of the former thrall that they failed to notice the garden was not empty until Balan sat in full view, and by then it was too late to censor their speech.
As though he was of the Engwar…
He had slammed the door when he reached his chambers and stripped away the ornate tunic as though it burned him, crossing the room with some half-formed thought to scrub the words from his skin. But as on that first morning in the caverns, his eyes fell by happenstance on the reflection before him; and again he froze and stared in disgust. His face was weathered. The lines within it were deep, harsh accusatory markings that told of every year and weighed each day in measure, the skin beneath his eyes looser than he recalled, the eyes themselves weary and dull. His rage turned in on himself and he felt his soul lash out at the image he saw. What mad delusion had come over him? What doddering senility that he believed himself of sufficient worth to tempt a god? For so the other seemed to him again in his despair—pristine beneath the crystal waters, singing in the dying firelight, the unnerving depths of his eyes. How clear it was when he saw him paired with one of his own. Beauty for beauty, light for light, lives that wove in tandem through the tapestry of years.
The mirror was hurled through the air before he realized his own intentions, and for a long moment he stood in shock, surrounded by the wreckage and breathing hard. Then his eye came to rest on one of the larger shards, fallen at an angle against the frame, and its skewed reflection rekindled his fury in an instant. He kicked it to the side with a wordless exclamation, shattering it against the wall, then flew at the remaining debris with the heel of his boot, stamping over and again and grinding them into dust as the door swung open.
“Balan!”
His wrath turned next to the mirror’s frame—and this too was kicked away, leaving the delicate ivy twisted and bent against the stone.
“Balan, stop!” The king’s arms wrapped around his chest and hauled him back.
“Leave me be!” There was a confused struggle, then he wrenched free and thrust the other away with an unexpected vehemence. “Go! I want thee not.”
Finrod staggered back against the wall, confusion spreading over his features as he stared back at Balan in concern. “What is it?”
“I said go.”
“What has happened?”
The haze had begun to clear and Balan felt a lump of humiliation growing at the base of his gut. What was it after all that had set him in such a state? He had heard far more disparaging evaluations of his people than Nélloth’s comparison, and he was certainly past the age where a petty jealousy should rankle to such a degree. Shame deepened at the thought and he dragged his fingers through his hair, staring down at the broken shards. Gods all, surely he had more dignity left than that. Everything had grown disjointed, emotions ranging through him with an intensity that scorned reason, griefs that had been tamped down—till one final blow loosed the dam and left them roaring so loudly he could hear nothing beyond their clamor. He shook his head in disgust and turned away. “Nothing of import.”
There was a long silence and the weight of the other’s worry bore down like a yoke across his shoulders, till at last there was a rustle of fabric and he glanced back to see the king disappear into the adjoining room. A short moment later he emerged with a damp cloth and a bathing brush in his hands. “Forgive me if I find that unlikely,” Finrod said quietly, then crossed to kneel beside the debris, sweeping fragments carefully to the side and wiping away the dust.
“Leave it, Nóm, I can tidy my own wreckage.”
“I am aware.”
“I’ll do it—”
“You will wash the blood from your hand and sit ere you damage something more precious.”
Balan glanced down, then bit back his retort in surprise when he saw blood trickling along the backs of his fingers. It was a shallow cut, little more than a scrape in truth, but it bled stubbornly and had already left several droplets on the floor. The knuckles must have snagged on one of the gilded leaves when he wrenched the mirror from the wall, he mused, then grimaced as he recalled the intricate metalwork and the likely expense that had gone into its creation. “Was it a very costly piece?”
Finrod looked up at him with an unreadable expression, then swept the last of the shards aside and stood. “I spoke not of the mirror,” he said, bringing Balan’s hand briefly to his lips before he turned to dispose of the cloth.
“I thought thou wert recovered from such earlier follies.”
The king drew up mid-step and his lips parted in dismay. “Oh Balan no. Hast thou thought all this while that I meant that for thee? I spoke of the game, the drink…”
“And the fool who thought thine advances sincere.”
“No.” Finrod dropped the cloth where he stood and crossed to take Balan by the arms. “The fool was I for following on Gildor’s banter and never thinking how it would ring in thine ears. It was a jest, Anarinya—a thoughtless jest, but a jest, in truth. There are none I hold closer than thee.”
“Jesting still, I see.” Balan snorted and pulled away. “None closer than I—who cannot even address thee by thine own name. I’m trammeled still by an epithet I dubbed thee ere we knew a word of each other’s tongues. A child’s nonsense, pointing and declaring in monosyllables.” He gestured about the room in exaggerated demonstration. “Stone! Tree! Wall! Nóm!”
“Wash!” Finrod caught the other’s hand with a teasing smile and guided it back to the bowl and ewer, where he cupped the water in his palm and trickled it over the cut till it was clean. Then he lifted a clean cloth from beside the basin and carefully dabbed it dry. “What need have thou or I for words between us?” he asked at last, wrapping Balan’s hand within the linen. “I was known to thee from the moment thine eyes met mine, my soul bared to thee as to no other—whether I would or no.” He reached out and laid a hand along the other’s cheek. “It is my name, Balan; discerned ere thou didst know me and given anew by thy tongue. All those who love me call me Ingoldo.”
Balan twitched his face away from the other’s touch. “So I have seen.”
For a moment there was silence, then illumination flickered over the king’s face. “Ah. So that is what has vexed thee.”
“The virtue of his name comes to him at last,” Balan muttered, then unwound his hand and crossed to the shelf to find a more suitable bandage.
“It was a boy’s infatuation. He was kind and did not shame me for it—I feel gratitude toward him, that is all.”
“And what was I meant to feel toward him, this one on whom my lord of waters smiles with such ardent admiration?”
“Jealousy ill becomes thee.”
“No less than shameless flirtation becomes thee.”
The king reddened. “Even sight has been mired by this imagined grievance, then,” he exclaimed. “There was no flirtation.”
“Then pray, what name would you ascribe to the dalliance we all witnessed between you?”
“Dalliance!”
“Aye, so I said.”
“For greeting an old friend with gladness?”
“And fawning with no less warmth than I received by the Celon, ere you saw the truth of it and fled.”
“I see. And should I have so berated thee when I sat in the Hall and listened to Baran’s jests of thine own former intrigues—exploits in truth and no mere child’s adulation?”
“I thought you were not a child.”
“And neither was I his lover. Nor have I any wish to be.”
“Does he know that?”
“I’ve never presumed to ask.” The sharpness of his own retort startled Finrod back from his anger, and at once he was stung with regret. Balan’s shoulders were set in a bitter line, his hands gripped the edge of the shelf till his knuckles whitened, and a new trail of blood trickled over the damp skin. Finrod let his eyes fall shut as he took a steadying breath, then crossed quietly to stand at his side. “Balan. Beloved.” Gently, he brushed the hair back from the other’s face and tucked it behind one ear. “Call me whatever name pleases thee. I care not what, save only that it is thy voice which names me.” He traced his fingers down Balan’s jawline, then let his palm linger once more along his cheek. “We are bickering over the trappings of pain, Anarinya. Where does the real wound lie?”
For a long moment Balan remained silent, then a strained chuckle slipped from his lips and he shook his head. “Here,” he said at last, and lifted his hand to tap the other’s where it rested against his cheek. “Here.”
“I do not understand.”
“No? It is this, all of this—thine actions even now. This refusal to choose, while telling me all the while thy choice is made.” He drew the king’s hand from his face and turned away, busying himself with a thin strip of linen that he began binding around his skinned knuckles. “It grieved me when thine answer was no, but I understood it. I thought thee in error, but I have lived long enough with the pain of another’s absence that I cannot make light of such a specter. If friendship is all thou canst offer, then with friendship I can be at peace.” He secured the end of the bandage, then pressed his palms against the shelf once more. “But how can I when thine every action belies the claim? Or half thine actions, I should say. I never know from moment to moment which form of thee will meet me in the next.”
“Balan…” Finrod pressed down the urge to gather him in his arms and instead reached out to lay a hand hesitantly on the other’s shoulder.
“Don’t.” Balan shook off the touch, his voice low.
The king let his hand fall back to his side and watched him with growing dismay. “I feared this would prove the self-serving choice. A barter for my own benefit that recked too little of that pain which must surely follow for thee.” He shook his head as the other opened his mouth in objection. “Truly, Balan, twas this fear that made me flee Estolad and not, as I think thou hast ever surmised, a reticence to face my own desire. On which road lay the lesser damage, when damage must surely follow upon either way? Alas that I did not see the danger until we were both of us too fast bound to be spared its bite. It was as I told thee then, my reason was a tempest and I knew not how to distinguish my heart’s wish from wisdom’s guidance. Eru forgive me, I chose the former, for I knew it to be thine as well, and less then did I understand the fate of thy people.”
“Else thou couldst have spared thyself the wrench of such fleeting creatures.”
“Canst thou know me so little? Beloved, the pain of our sundering was inescapable well before any decision was made. Whether our parting was to be wrought by my choice or the doom that summons thee hence, I have known from our first halting words that I would mourn thee all my days.”
Balan remained long in silence as he looked down, expressionless, at the patterns in the smoothed stone beneath his hands. “Then what, lord, is the regret of which you speak?” he asked at last, his formality pointed. “As yet you have named only the decision that granted me these months at your side.”
“Yes.” Again Finrod felt the longing to fold the other within his arms, as though that shelter might hold some power to shield him. “I chose to set thee here to dwell amongst us, the one mutable shoot in a changeless wood. I granted my heart rule of me in Estolad and so have consigned thee to the greater price. That is my regret. Better I had left us both with a hard parting but a dear memory than to have brought thee here to a deeper anguish than thou wouldst otherwise have known.”
Balan snorted and turned away. “You are blinded with the sight of your own kind. For mine there is never a bond between us that does not bear such a price: it is the cost of any love to know it is one with the story of death. That has been a revelation to you, I know, but we who ever watch the hunter’s knife mark our flesh have learned it well enough. This is no new anguish.”
“But amongst yourselves it is a burden shared.” Finrod reached out again and this time Balan did not pull away, but let the other’s fingers trace along the telltale creases in his face. “You may look upon one other and see kinship reflected, time’s marks in tandem, even as I might look upon my brothers and recognize in their eyes the same changes I know in myself. Whereas here, isolated from thy kin, thou must see it marked only upon thine own visage until what was ordained a gift weighs a fetter and chain.”
“What do you know of it?” Balan’s voice was dismissive, but immediately he felt a gentle pressure in his thought, a brush of pity, and knew that the roots of his earlier fury had slipped through to the other. A wave of fresh helplessness rose up and his brows drew together, pressing it once more into his sharp and ready anger. “Is there nothing you’ll not learn of me before I’ve the chance to speak it?”
Finrod blenched as though he had been struck. “I meant no trespass…forgive me, I thought thou hadst shared it by intent.”
“No.” Balan pulled away and dragged his fingers through his hair, his voice shaking as he began to pace. “Or perhaps I did. I know not. I do not know thee from one moment to the next—how am I to know my own mind toward thee?”
“Dost thou truly think me so changeable?”
“When in one breath I am named beloved and in the next vassal? When thou wilt seek me out in the dark of Estolad, then turn from me in thine own home for naming thee lovely? Aye, Nóm, I think thee so!”
“Didst thou not speak only a moment past of understanding? I grant thee what I may—and Eru knows my every breath is a plea that he might mend the chasm between his Children.”
“Enough!” Balan stayed his pacing and turned on him, fury flashing in his eyes. “Thine own kinsman took to wife a Spirit of power, yet thou canst speak to me of chasms and kinds? Does not the hypocrisy choke thee?”
“There is a difference in—“
“What difference? Tis but the gulf seen from another vantage, with ye now upon the nether edge. To the frailer creature the crossing ever appears justified. So turn back, Nóm, and look upon me with that same vision.” His expression darkened as his mind ran ahead in the reasoning. “Or is it so simple as this: that when the twain are both created undying, the cost of sundered fates is more palatable to thee?”
“Cold are thy words, Balan.”
“And cold is thy love.”
“Elu is constrained to Arda, as are the Powers and their servants. As am I. Thy people and thee…where you go I know not, but reason tells me it is from Arda and not within it. If I were to bind myself to thee, what should become of each soul, caught thus together across the gulf? Should the departing linger beside the remaining, an unhoused spirit held back by its troth? Or should the remaining find its bond to the body decaying by the memory of that second bond which beckons it away? Or, and perhaps this is worst of all, should it rend the spirit of each and leave one or both maimed till the end of ends? In every eventuality it is a severing of body and soul. It would break us.”
“Would? Should? Feign not ignorance, it aids thee not. How canst thou plead such a defense when I am laid thus broken before thee: beckoned ever close in spirit, the spirit’s vessel held ever at bay. Thou hast set a fracture within me already, canst thou see it not? Broken along the line of my own self. It is the soul’s bond that would be our unmaking, thou sayest—yet thou it was who named us lovers in soul, who holds me still in that bond while denying its effect. I shall rend already at the parting. Wilt thou not?”
“Yes. And carry the grief of it in me till the ending of Arda.” Finrod’s voice wavered and he drew a shuddering breath, moving a step nearer the other. “But lovers in soul is not wedded in soul, Balan—we are each our own still. We will break, yes, but as a bone that may be set with the hope of healing.” He faltered, then reached out and took the other’s hand as tears slipped loose onto his cheeks. “A mending which I see now I have unwittingly denied thee. Beloved,” he managed at last, shifting gently to Taliska, “would it be better if you returned to your kin?”
Balan’s laugh broke bitterly into the stillness. “All this, and now you send me away at last.”
“Balan—“
“No. Do not feign the words were other than what you spoke.”
“There is no feint. It was a query, not a pronouncement.”
“You overlook your own teaching, then: a door once opened sets a path either may tread.” Balan’s voice was tight with restrained anger as he pulled back from the other’s thought. “I know full well your question carried intent. Dismiss me if you will, but do us both the dignity of forthrightness.”
“I have done so in every word.”
“Have you?”
“Canst thou doubt it?” Finrod’s frustration broke loose at last and he fell back to his own tongue as his voice rose. “What more can I say of truth than I have laid bare already? I love thee. I have harmed thee. Though it break me, I would give thee what remedy there is to bring restitution to that.”
“Restitution—to send me out to starvation?” Balan stepped forward until his face was inches from the other’s, his eyes alight. “I knew nothing besides the life I had. I was content with it. I was born, I grew, I had joy in the dim light of those foundering years; I had my sons, and a grudging peace with the future allotted my kind.” He rested his palms against the other’s chest and felt him shudder at the touch. “But then I saw thee rise from the dark before me, some phantom vision of a god beside the embers, and I turned toward thee as a tree reaches for the open sun. Now I need that light, who before could flourish through a shroud—and thou, my own heart, would consign me back to the darkness?”
“Not to the darkness, beloved; to the light of thine own.” He felt Balan’s hand travel up to rest beneath his jaw, bringing his face forward until their lips nearly met.
“When eyes have once seen the dawn,” Balan whispered, and Finrod’s heart pounded as the breath of the other’s words passed over his mouth like a caress, “how can they be satisfied thereafter with rushlights?” He turned away bitterly and crossed to stand before the hearth.
Silence held them then, heavy and stale, and when Finrod at last spoke again his voice was nearly a whisper. “I was certain thou wouldst remain when the time came for us to leave Estolad. That, having returned to what was lost, thou wouldst find a second parting too much to bear—and rightly so. In my fear I stayed silent, and by my silence I chose again, selfishly as I did at the first. Twice now have I kept thee when I had no right.” His voice broke and it was a long moment before he could continue. “Go to thy people, Balan, to thy sons. I have robbed them of thee long enough. Go, while there may yet be peace for thee.”
Balan kept his eyes on the dancing flames and shook his head. “I will have no peace,” he said at last, reaching out to rest his hands along the hearth shelf. His voice was weary, flattened of its earlier fervor, and Finrod was jarred by the sudden change. “I will have no peace now, wherever I go—only the memory of thee in every fleeting hour.”
“Is that not a comfort?” Finrod whispered, holding himself back with an effort from crossing again to the other’s side.
“How should I be comforted by remembering that only the lingering shreds of youth were beloved; that memory was better than constancy? Strange ever is thine heart. It is the part of love to bear through hardship; at least so it is amongst my people. Is there no joy yet to be found in the hours of twilight?” He let the quiet hold for a long moment, then squared his shoulders when no reply came and gripped the mantel in fury. “No, of course. You’ve gathered already the threads to weave your fair and bright memory. My part then is the dignity of any stricken creature, to limp away to some secluded burrow and finish my dying tactfully out of sight.” He laughed mirthlessly and turned back to face the other. “Estreth was right to name me your pet. Tame hounds for the hunt are we all, useful for your purpose until we’ve shown our frailty.”
For a long moment Finrod’s poise held against the other’s rage, silent and resolute in the fire’s light. Time slowed. In the hearth, a log gave way with a flutter of embers and drew the remainder down into a new configuration atop the ash; and then, as though its whisper had served as a summons, lines of exhaustion cracked along the king’s face and he shuddered. “As thou wilt,” he said at last, and his words too were heavy with resignation. “I will trouble thee no longer.”
“Gods all!” Balan scoffed and threw his arms up in exasperation. “Still you dodge the burden. Do not try to shift your choosing into my hands—this is not my decision.”
“No,” Finrod said in a dull voice as he turned for the door. “It is mine.”
“Nóm…” Balan stepped forward as a sudden foreboding gripped his gut. “Nóm wait, don’t go like this. I didn’t mean for—please!” This last broke out as a gasp when he felt the other’s thought break from his own and he lurched after him with belated urgency. But Finrod crossed into the passage without a glance behind and closed the door firmly in his wake.
Balan slammed his palms against the panels with a cry and sank down the stile, choked sobs wracking his throat as he fought for breath and felt the cold spreading through his spirit. It was the same throbbing emptiness which had left him begging on a hilltop for this life he had just scorned, the same deadened hopelessness. I would choose it again…let me be thine, lord, as whatever thou wilt. Oh gods, what had he done? Nóm was gone, his heart so thoroughly stripped from Balan’s that he could find no trace of it in the darkness—not only closed, but hidden from him, fortified against him…
He was gone.
❈❈❈
It was quiet in the small hours of the night; still, save for the scattered frogs in the sinkhole garden trilling their calls into the dark. Finrod drew the blanket close about his shoulders. It was cooler beside the window than he expected for this early in the season and he pushed back into the corner, stomach dizzy and hands trembling. He had lost all perception of how many hours had passed. Several, surely.
He had kept the same measured pace through every step between Balan’s chambers and his own, propelled forward by the meter of that rhythm and the certainty that his resolve would crumble should he let it lapse for a moment. Both doors to his rooms were opened and closed in the same measure, his path across the chamber as well. It was only when he stepped down into the little arboretum that his feet stumbled and he found himself drawing in great gasps of breath, clutching at the shelves where bowls of seedlings were laid out in careful rows along the wall.
Time had slipped after that.
He remembered pacing, he remembered sprinkling crumbs into the fish pools, brushing his fingers over the wide leaves of the larger plants and forcing all his perception into the sense of their textures—rough, silken, waxy, velvet.
He remembered crushing one bitter leaf after another between his teeth and meditating on the taste, choosing the most pungent that it might hold his focus.
At some point he had abandoned these attempted distractions and curled on the stone seat beside the window, dragging a blanket over himself and shivering as he stared out into the night. Balan’s name hovered on his tongue with the lingering herbs, bitter flavors both. It was a pulse, pressing at his lips, breaking through his breath; a plea, fruitless and vain.
He drew his knees up to his chin with a groan and raked his fingers through his hair. How had he allowed himself such folly? This was a wound of his own making, dealt by a blade his own hands had forged. Had his heart not warned him from the moment of Celon’s embrace that this was a precipice which should never be tempted? But he had chosen his own wish over the warning, had closed his counsel to its voice, closed his ears to the water’s wisdom and leapt willfully onto the crumbling edge, certain of his own skill to balance. It was ludicrous, then, to feign surprise when he found himself looking up from its wreckage.
Balan.
Even in the wretched days of Ivrin’s wake they had not been fully severed. He could drift against the other’s anger, sharp ice though it had been, and take some comfort from the pain of that touch.
Balan.
He dared not reach for him now. Oh Valar, to have the comfort of the other’s palm against his cheek…to be drawn to rest upon his lap while the steady fingers combed through his hair, to hear again the sound of his song, rough and earthen and quieting.
Beloved.
A wordless entreaty fell from his lips, some strangled half-hearted thing that caught in his throat, and he kicked the blanket aside in frustration. This circuitous jumble served no one, least of all his own resolve. Where now was his dignity? Where his wisdom, his convictions, his fortitude to accept constraint? He paced from one end of the room to the other, gripping the back of his neck and berating himself in every breath. He was a coward if he could abide the principle only, but not the cost of its enaction.
“Love is choosing,” he whispered to himself as he drew up beside a fish pool, clinging to his father’s voice amid the tempest of his grief, “it is choosing.“
And I’ve never regretted any decision more. Estreth’s reprimand echoed hard on the heels of his recitation and he gripped the walls of the basin, staring down at the little flashes of silver which darted hither and fro beneath his reflection. The image in the water gazed back at him, drawn and weary, and he was unnerved to find it seemed a stranger to his own eyes. When had he strayed so far from himself? Was this the visage that peered in awe through the pines of Ossiriand? These the lips that kissed Celon’s waves when the bitter truth came clear? Nay, this was an imposter. A fool. A vain child. This was no one of his knowing.
He tried to turn away, but the reflection held him fast and he could not budge. The mirrored lips twitched in amusement at his plight. The eyes looked back at him, canny and unsparing as they forced on him that knowledge which was his already: that he had felt his restraint slipping and had fled in fear, embracing a mimicry of himself as though by outrunning the truth he might know it not. Coward! Even Balan’s accusations of his conduct found their root in this. He caught sight of an old friend and in that moment yearned so keenly for the boy he once was, for the safety and clarity of childhood, that he had escaped into that memory of himself without thinking how it would seem to others.
A fish surfaced briefly, sending ripples through the likeness in the water, and Finrod shivered as it danced in the lamplight—like the atna-ahma of Balan’s tales, he thought, and grew dizzy at the comparison. He lifted one hand to touch his face, watching in the water’s mirror as the damp fingers brushed across his lips.
And of the water Aelthes drank. A healing draught, a cleansing balm…
He gripped the stone harder, reeling as his own admissions washed over him with the tale’s cadence.
Balan was wrong. This had all been a charade.
For there had never been any refusal to choose—he had made his decision long ere now, long even ere their griefs had been poured out beside the holy well. Nay, his way had been chosen the moment he crossed to Balan in the dark of Estolad, in the instant when he sat at his side in the fire’s light and let the whispered yes fall from his lips.
All the rest had been nothing but delay, a sacrifice offered up in obeisance to his fear.
He was walking before he knew his own intent and passed through the chambers as one caught in a dream. The first door, the connecting hallway, the second door. The main passage now. It was laughable, really, how near he had kept Balan to his own rooms. There was only a handful of steps, a slight curve of the hallway before he found himself facing the other’s doorway once more—sea birds and ocean rays with wings spread in adulation as they soared across the timbers. How Nerwen had laughed when she saw them, when these rooms were yet meant for her use. How she had teased him for the choice of adornment: gulls, the messenger birds of the water’s lord; giant rays sweeping in migration beneath the waves, a Falmarin symbol of returning home. Did he mean to draw her back beneath his wings, then? Nay, the hunt was still running, she was a kestrel and no gull.
Finrod reached out and drew his fingers along a bordering frond of kelp. It had been in presage of his own path that he carved them here, or so it seemed to him now, heart pounding in his chest as his fingers followed their curves. He was the wanderer returning, his the spirit summoned home to himself—which was to Balan, to his heart, to the truth he had known since that first glimpse of firelight through the trees. His hand traced down through the kelp and coral till it closed around the latch ring and he felt the scales of the iron serpent press into his skin.
He turned the latch.
The room was still. Two bags lay half-filled with the other’s possessions against the further wall. The pile of glass had been swept into one corner. The bed remained untouched, the lamps dark, while in the hearth the fire burned low, sending its crackling in afterthought through the silence. And there in the half-light sat the familiar silhouette, one elbow propped against the curved end of the bench and staring into the coals, expressionless. Finrod’s heart beat in triplet as he gazed across the chamber. It was just as he had first seen him—features sharpened, skin warm and burnished in the fire’s glow, face turned into the light.
He slipped into the room without a word and eased the door closed. It fastened soundlessly and for a moment he faltered, trembling; then drew a slow breath and slid the bolt as well.
Balan did not look up as he crossed toward him into the light. Nor did he shift his gaze when the king knelt on the woven rug, when he bent to set his forehead to the ground before him, to kiss each foot in turn. Long they remained in stillness, two carven images atop the cavern’s stone, till at length he straightened and held out his hands, pressed palm to palm in an echo of Balan’s own plea on the crags above the flax fields.
“Oiastaro,” Finrod said quietly, and Balan’s eyes shifted at last to meet his in query. “My name,” he clarified, color rising in his cheeks as he knelt beneath the other’s gaze, “the one of my choosing. We bear three in my people’s tradition: given, seen, and devised. The first two thou knowest already, but the last of these is held closely; a private name, never used without invitation.”
“Oiastaro.” Balan spoke the syllables slowly, a new taste rolled skeptically across the tongue.
“It is most often reserved for one’s family—father or mother, sisters or brothers.” He faltered, then added in a hoarse whisper, “Spouse.”
Balan flinched and his eyes fell shut as a tremor ran along his jaw. “Do not toy with me.” His voice broke and he passed his hands over his face. “Please, Nóm. No more.”
“I am not. I will not. Oh Balan—” A sob choked his words and he leaned forward to rest his face against the other’s knees. “Thou hast entrusted thine heart to a poor steward.”
A snort slipped from Balan’s lips despite himself, but any amusement was deadened in its tone. “I fear I’ve no inclination left to reason thee from the claim.”
“Attempt it not; I’ve come here to own it.” Finrod’s hands slipped gently behind the other’s calves, his face still buried against the cloth and long-pent tears dampening the wool. “In selfishness have I kept thee here. A little longer, I would think. A little longer and I’ll counsel him to return. A little longer and I will release him…and all the while I’ve been stealing thy life from thee while I danced about the doom. I thought in my pride that I could both keep thee and hold myself aloof. If I patrolled the signifier, then I would not transgress the signified.” He drew a ragged breath, then lifted his head and forced himself to meet the other’s eye. “Thou hast seen it truly, of course, and named it so: I am a fool. And have wasted precious days I should have given to thee. For I am thine already, Balan, body and spirit. I have always been thine." He placed his palms together once more and stretched them trembling into the space between them. “Or have I broken this now beyond repair?”
There was a stunned silence as the other stared down at him, speechless. Then, swift as striking, he felt Balan catch him behind the neck, felt himself hauled forward till he was clasped within the other’s arms, his own hands tangling in Balan’s hair as he met the kiss with abandon and gasped a small sound of acquiescence into his mouth.
So many ways had he imagined this—a simple vow in the quiet of the old hut; declared before his people with some grand gesture of devotion; a passion overflowing, as in that first desperate longing beside the Celon; or, in his more measured moments, a dream of riding out till they found a secluded cove in the Falas, of exchanging oaths beside the sea’s chorus when twilight fell, when the waves held the same hue as the waters of his childhood and all was warmth and peace in the briny air.
Never had it been thus—falling together in the exhaustion of spent fury with eyes swollen and weeping still as their mouths found one another, their hands tugging desperately at the other’s clothing and clumsy as boys in their sudden haste. Balan had wrapped himself in one of his old tunics against the chill and Finrod fumbled with the carved toggles, muttering curses under his breath as the last of these refused to yield. But the other reached down and batted his hand aside, snapping the binding with a quick jerk, and Finrod nearly laughed aloud despite himself. He was home. Here, here at last he was home—in the solid warmth of Balan’s embrace, in the softness of his lips, in the rough brush of his beard and the fervor of his soul bright against his own. The tunic was loose now. It slid down from the broad shoulders, beckoning, and Finrod caught the rough undershirt in fistfuls as he pulled him nearer and dragged this too free from the sash.
“Nóm…” Balan caught hold of his wrists, kissing him still as he drew the other’s hands away to each side. “Promise me. Promise me thou art in earnest…”
“I am in earnest.”
“This is not a whim? It is not the wine?”
“It is not, I swear it—as Manwë is my witness and the One may hold me bound.” He pulled his hands free of Balan’s grip and clasped the other’s face within his palms. “Balan,” he begged, his voice hoarse, “let me swear it to thee.”
A wave of longing passed over Balan’s face, but he held himself back with an effort. “Make trial of it first. See whether thou might’st not remain unbound.”
“I would not have it so.”
“No?”
A slow smile spread over Finrod’s face and he stroked his thumbs along Balan’s cheeks, the sensation running like needles along his scalp. “Thou hast my soul already,” he whispered. “What more is there to take?”
Balan was in his arms again in an instant, his fingers weaving through Finrod’s hair as he kissed him with abandon, slipping from the bench and allowing himself to be drawn down laughing before the hearth. “Oiastaro,” he breathed, and though his voice stumbled over the unfamiliar name it was a claiming, fierce and possessive, and Finrod felt it kindle in his soul as he pinned the other beneath his embrace.
“Beloved…” He passed his lips over Balan’s chest, kissing feverishly along his neck, the rim of his shoulder. Balan’s skin was amber in the firelight, it was honey, it was golden bronze and filled with summer’s heat. “Nieninquë,” he murmured, sunlight and snowdrops coursing through his thought into the other’s, and he felt Balan’s laugh ripple through him, flesh and soul. Oh Valar, oh sun and stars and seas above, he would break apart… He muffled a wordless gasp against Balan’s neck and felt the arms tighten about him, Balan’s legs wrap about his waist.
He would break apart—from joy or from fate’s judgment he knew not, but he was shattering, his soul cracking like glass…
And light streamed in like water between the fragments.
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
gwethrim: [S] people of the shadows: wherein gwath (shadow) is pluralized to gweth
cambas: [S] “hand bread”
lumas: [S] time-bread (see The Warning Sounds Too Late)
Amillë Merillë: [Q] Mother Meril, where Írui chooses a form of amil that would rhyme with the Quenya version of Meril’s name
Ammalincë: [Q]: little yellow bird
Engwar: [Q] “the sickly,” one of the names given to Men. See The Silmarillion, Chapter 12: “Of Men"
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
atna-ahma: water sprite
MISC NOTES
- Írimo Arandur being the Quenya name and title that Írui would have born while he dwelt in the king’s court at Tirion, where Arandur serves as a title (servant of the king/king’s man).
- For more background on the begetting day blessings, see The Warning Sounds Too Late
- Endillos: an invented place name, intended to be Írui’s family home in Aman
- For the reference to hrögemetheilit and Balan’s “horn of seven,” see Blade’s Peril
25. We Shall Be Gathered
“I should have let it bide in memory as was thy counsel, static and finished. I might toy with a future I did not have, imagining it this way or that, but within it she remained the same, ever as she was and thus ever a clear fable.” He winced as he swallowed the mouthful of hrögemetheilit. “Now I have seen her face, and I can never be free of the truth of it: breathtaking as in her youth, changed in all those ways I should have known at her side. Never has the path I scorned seemed more tangible than in that sight.”
In the days following Finrod’s confession, Aegnor comes to his own decision and the brothers discuss their differing paths.
Read 25. We Shall Be Gathered

409th YEAR OF THE SUN, Summer
Barad Tirnen, the Fortress of Aegnor
The rain quickened as Aegnor swung down from the saddle and led his horse through the gate. It had begun halfway through his return and he welcomed it then, loosing the stallion into a gallop and relishing the water’s lash against his face. Its sting steadied him, drew his senses out from his heart and into his skin, held him firmly in the moment. But as he approached the stables, he found it oppressive; it grappled at his neck with cloying fingers and thickened the heaviness about his soul.
Contrary to his usual custom, he left his horse to the groom’s care and trudged across the courtyard by the shortest path. Pain was a circle. The wound, the easing, the acceptance, the quiet throb. The gash reopened and widened by his own choosing, the cycle begun anew. Eternal. He passed inside the tower and shut the doors against the downpour. How long till all of this was rubble? He peeled the sodden cloak from his shoulders and cast it in a bundle beside the nearest bench, then reached out to run his palms across the timbers, the iron bars, the walls. It was transient, all of it; each stone echoing already with the sound of its ruin, every beam shuddering along veins that would split. Yet this was what he had chosen, again and again he cleaved to it in the face of any desire, till it had become his presiding compulsion, an iron will bending not even to his own. The rain’s laugh whispered through arrow loops high in the stair behind him and his fingers dug harder against the stone. How senseless it was to hold such a devotion to one’s own prison.
He pushed away from the wall with a stream of oaths hissed under his breath and crossed the passage to ascend the stair. Where else, he thought bitterly, should he seek solace but with the knife that knew the wound?
The guest chamber was just off the first turning. It was eastward-facing, built to look out toward the promise of the dawn—its eyes cast too toward the vales of Ladros—and its lintel was embellished with that same vessel of Arien, wound about with trailing vines of those flowers which had blossomed at her first rising. His brother’s work. Nearly all the fortress’ adornments had been so wrought, he recalled with a fleeting touch of affection. Each visit brought with it a new flourish on this wall or that; a similar rope of vines embracing the arches of the hall, a line of hares racing across the stretchers of the back corridor, a thicket of trees burgeoning up the western stair. Ingoldo had laughed over his shoulder when Aegnor came across him chipping a mischievous fox beside the larder; even in wariness, he had said with a smile, there must always be made time for joy, for beauty. Else to what end was the toil of their Siege?
Aegnor pushed through the door without preamble, casting a brief glance toward the silhouette at the window while he latched it again, then discarded his waterlogged boots and crossed to stand before the hearth. He was not chilled, he thought, but his teeth had nonetheless begun an unwonted chattering and he pulled his shirt free from the hose, letting it hang loose from his shoulders as the fire’s warmth gradually began to dry him.
“I’ve been to Ladros,” he said at last when the shivering had subsided enough to speak in a steady voice.
“I know.” Finrod remained curled on the window seat, legs drawn up and chin resting atop his knees as he gazed out into the rain. “I saw thee ride out with the dawn.”
Aegnor nodded shortly, but did not reply. Of course his brother had been watching. In the three days since that inciting confession they had both carefully avoided the topic, but nevertheless its presence coursed a steady river beneath every exchange. As had Ingoldo’s concern, quiet and staid and ever-present, hovering in the air between them like a vigilant hound. It filled the room now despite his brother’s clear effort to hold it in check and Aegnor stared pointedly into the dancing flames until he felt his own will steady. Then he shuddered and turned back to the table where three chalices and a carafe of wine were gathered on a tray. He filled one of these and took a sip, then emptied it in a long draught. “I could not bring myself to pass the ridge.”
Finrod looked back at him in silence for a long moment, then rose and crossed to a chest opposite the bed, drawing from the depths of it a squat clay bottle and two plum-sized cups, the latter of which were chipped and scarred across their surface from long years’ use. He carried these to the table, all the while working the wax and cork loose with a knife.
“Miru-na-naur…” Aegnor snorted with a mirthless laugh. “I must make a wretched sight indeed.”
“Hrögemetheilit,” Finrod amended as he filled each cup, then sat. The ghost of a smile passed over his lips and he lifted the cup briefly toward his brother. “Sán gahail,” he added, then emptied it.
Aegnor echoed the motions, then watched impassively as his brother filled the cups again. “From how she spoke of herself to thee, I thought to find the change so marked I would not know her.” He turned the cup round and about on the table, not meeting his brother’s eye. “I did, of course—at once. Her hair was caught in the wind and she was laughing. She was chasing three children across the green.”
“Emeldir and her brothers most likely. Adanel’s grandchildren.”
“Yes, there were two lads and a lass.” He retreated to the hearth with his cup, resting one arm heavily against the mantel. “I should have let it bide in memory as was thy counsel, static and finished. I might toy with a future I did not have, imagining it this way or that, but within it she remained the same, ever as she was and thus ever a clear fable.” He winced as he swallowed the mouthful of hrögemetheilit. “Now I have seen her face, and I can never be free of the truth of it: breathtaking as in her youth, changed in all those ways I should have known at her side. Never has the path I scorned seemed more tangible than in that sight—Oh Valar…” he broke off in a hoarse whisper and hid his face against his arm.
“Wilt thou not return, then?” Finrod could not hide the surprise in his voice. “I thought…”
“I saw her joy.” He shook his head and shifted to grip the mantel with both hands. “I had forgotten—Manwë damn my folly—I had forgotten that it would be as present as her grief. I rode with every intention of falling at her feet and begging that I might be allowed the opposite choice yet, for she is younger still than Bëor when thine own way was chosen. There would be years wherein…” He trailed off and closed his eyes against the fury of tears that threatened. “‘Thou shalt live long in the order of thy kind,’ were not those thy words? ‘Thou shalt live long, and he will go forth before thee.’ And when is the dam to burst? A year from now? A decade? On the morrow? I saw her joy, Ingo,” he repeated in a hoarse voice. “How could I take that life from her?”
“A fair price, she would say.”
“Wouldst thou counsel me so?”
“I would not counsel thee at all—from such a branch did this bitter fruit blossom.”
“Then allow that I know my mind and have chosen through the pain, not because of it.” Finrod blenched at the words and Aegnor watched him silently for a long moment before crossing to the table and filling his brother’s cup in turn. “That was barbed, forgive me. But I do know my duty in this.”
“Náro—“
“Nay, hear me; I no longer have the cover of ignorance. I would be choosing this for her purposely were I to let my heart rule me now. Would Bëor have laid this path upon thee had he known it would end thus?”
“He knew.” Finrod emptied the cup in a quick motion, then turned it restlessly in his hands. “We both knew. He made certain it was my choice.”
Aegnor snorted and filled his own cup, carrying it back to set it on the mantel untouched. “The barb is on thine own tongue now, brother.”
“Only to defend him from the accusation.”
“Defend thyself rather, for well didst thou know I would have laid the choice before her when it was still mine to offer.”
“I cannot undo what was done.”
“No.” He sighed and leaned his head in against the stonework. “Nor I.” Thunder growled and rumbled in the distance, and the plink of rain grew ever sharper against the panes, filling the room till at last Aegnor spoke again. “Do not mistake me. I do not seek to exclude her from the choosing—I know her answer full well, as thou hast quoth to me already: that every hour is worth its cost. But as I am master only of my own will, so she too of hers. Both hearts are ventured in this, both must be free to decide.” He pushed back from the stones, but did not meet his brother’s eye. “I have not the courage thou didst credit to me.”
“Thou art grieved and weary—and poor is any measuring rod cut from that tree. Do not judge thyself by its appraisal.”
“My life is bounded within this Siege; thou hast seen it, I have seen it.” He took a small sip from the hrögemetheilit and shook his head. “Once joined we would not be parted—and I could not face what is before me were it to mean choosing for the twain. I would flee it were she at my side, I know this. I have not the fortitude to watch her meet such an end.”
“Fortitude cannot be plumbed until the hour is upon you.”
“I am not willing.” He downed the remaining liquor in a quick draught and gripped the mantel again. “I will not hazard that hour. That is my own heart’s choice: I will not wed her only to leave her.”
The resulting pause was sharp, and when he spoke again an edge had crept into Finrod’s voice. “As Bëor did, if I infer thy meaning aright?”
Aegnor remained silent, but made no effort to correct him.
“Thou deem’st his decision self-serving.”
“Canst thou deny it?”
“I can.” Finrod rose and crossed to the window, watching the grey sheets of rain drift outward across the highlands. “I do. I have told thee already this path was of my own choosing.”
“Which he should not have accepted—if he guessed, as thou sayest, what lay ahead.”
“It was no more than he had borne already.” Finrod’s eyes still followed the downfall, drawn back in memory to a parapet amongst the Cened Beraid, to the breathless relief of Balan freed and at his side, holding him as the rain whispered against the stone. I will rest within thee yet, deathless in thine heart as my people have held all those who went before us. “He was well acquainted with such an end—to love, to lose, to grieve. To find joy again.”
“Then you were both deluded. I saw thine eyes when I came to thee for counsel, and there was only emptiness in thee, not joy. That glimpse persuaded me more than any of our speech.”
“Yes.” He reached out and unlatched the window, easing it open so that the scent of rain flowed in with the breeze. “That I will not deny. Belen had followed his father only a short time ere we spoke; the wound was…quite raw in those days.”
“In those days? I see thee now, Ingoldo. Or was it some other who told me not three nights gone that he would still have tried to spare me?”
“And who told thee too that he was wrong—that such impulse found its roots in his own cowardice.”
Aegnor snorted dismissively and turned away.
“It is not posturing, Náro, I—” Finrod dragged his hands back through his hair, frowning into the distance as he sought for words. “How might I say it…On the Ice when Fánarusco lost an arm, he spoke of the lingering sensation, dost thou recall it? An ache in fingers that were no more, an itch along a missing wrist. I feared the presence of such a phantom and so I hid, drawing my pain like a shell about me and hardening my convictions that none might crack it and loose what lived on inside. It was an emptiness wrought and not entailed.”
“Yet it shackles thee nonetheless.”
“I concede it. But the bonds are otherwise than the bent of thy thought.”
“And I say to thee: of what consequence is the chain’s metal when iron and steel serve alike to hold thee fast?”
Finrod was silent, watching as the twilight deepened its shroud about the hills’ shoulders; then he rose and crossed to fill his cup. “Two years it took from the time my soul held the knowledge till my heart would allow it.” He drained it silently and placed it in the center of the board. “Two years of doing homage to fear and miscalling it discernment—if we are to speak of bonds, then let that not go unnamed! Those are the manacles thou wouldst point out, and they bed their anchors here and not in the years of loss.” His fingers began turning the cup by slow increments and his eyes never shifted, as though the restless movement held him engrossed. “I escaped them in his arms—for a time. He never pressed me, only held to his convictions till at last I understood they were mine as well. His heart beside me, his soul within mine…any cost was defanged in the light of it.” Finrod filled the cup again, but watched the amber liquid settle within its bowl rather than lifting it to his lips. “Like a fool I fled back to the same pattern the moment he was gone, for twas an easier thing by far to mire in self-blame than face that this was a wound in which no fault was held. It would have bled no matter which path was chosen.”
“Swift as a brook is thine ever-changing counsel.”
“So it is. Swift and cascading till I myself am nigh drowned in its current. All the world is changing, it seems,” he added in a murmur after he paused to sip from the liquor. “There is nothing now her words have not touched—oh the marvel of it!”
“No mood have I for riddling, Ingo. Speak thy mind, or do not.”
“Believe me an thou wilt, I am endeavoring to do so.” He felt the hrögemetheilit coursing through his veins and its familiar heat wrapped about his shoulders like an embrace. “I believed that I had happiness in these after-years despite the loss of him; that all the joy I have found amongst his people, his sons and his daughters, was wrung from the darkness with clenched teeth. Defiant and hard-won. But as Andreth spoke to me I felt light turned upon my folly once more, as it was when I gave way at the first, and lo! it was as he had asserted all along—the memory of him did not bind the shackles closer. It was his lingering presence that loosed me from them as he ever did in life. And all these years I have fled before it, Náro, like a hart before the wolf’s howl, when all the while it was the very thing which would have set me free. And so it should be! For truly the working out of these melodies, these choruses of First and Secondborn within the Song, can be none other than this: a release from bondage, each of each.” He fell quiet, watching the fire’s light play along the strands of his brother’s hair; and when he went on again, his voice had dwindled as though speaking to himself. “I begin to think now that even the grief itself is a kind of hope—what is our mourning but sorrow clasping hands with estel and calling out for that which must be restored? And so too in such a light the cleaving of souls across that boundary must be held not as a further rending of the divide, but an act of trust rather—nay a prefigurement of what healing must surely come to pass!”
Aegnor cast an evaluatory glance over his shoulder, then snorted. “Thou art well into thy cups.”
“No more or less than thee,” Finrod retorted in reflex, gesturing toward the other with the empty vessel in hand, then shook his head with a faint smile. “Nay, brother, I have pondered this soberly—take the word as thou wilt—every hour since I parted from her. And through each of those hours my understanding has shifted so thoroughly that I find I must learn all the world anew. How can I not, when beyond hope this voice has reached our ears?”
“The echo may reach us, I grant thee, but it tells thee naught save that the note was once sounded. Death, surely, has dampered it since.”
“I do not believe it.”
“No? Then I fear thou hast forgotten the words of Manwë on that statute which wrought our own begetting: you deal with Arda Marred—in Arda Marred Justice is not Healing.”
“And upon the same parchment it is not also inscribed that in Justice there must be Pity, and in Healing ever the thought of Arda Unmarred?”
“A thought which was never brought into being.”
“Yet nevertheless is that Hope upon which the Elder King instructed us to order our ways. And if it is hope, then it must reside before us as well, not merely as a lost path held in memory.” Finrod’s fingers strayed again to the iron band about his finger. “I believe the One to be merciful—we were made by His will and hold such as virtue among us, our nature drawn from His own. And if He is merciful, he will not purpose grief upon His children.”
“And yet in grief do we find ourselves. I too have pondered her words in the days since thou saw fit to disclose them, and I confess my view is less propitious than thine.” Aegnor turned incredulously from the hearth to search his brother’s eye. “Truly, thou art convinced of this belief?”
Finrod held the other’s gaze in silence, then at last he nodded. “Yes. So I have chosen.”
“Despite the evidence of thine own injury?”
“Nay, because of it. Hast thou heard nothing I have said? I will not give up all Arda as lost. I cannot. We are children of the One, Aikanáro; their purpose is not in vain.” His voice caught and he looked down, then slowly let his fingers begin to follow the grain of the table, tracing the swirling eyes that ran dark as ink within the rosewood. “I dream of it every night now,” he murmured into the quiet, his gaze moving with the wood’s winding path, “every time I set my mind to rest. It stretches out before me: Arda remade. Not the stasis of Aman or the tired nostalgia of Cuiviénen, but a living, changing, growing thing—the discord resolved into harmony. Not a haven preserved against the shadow, but creation unshadowed. Sometimes in the dream I see him there waiting, he the one to find me in my own wandering. Other times I see many persons all around me, a sea of reunions—thee in thy bliss—but nowhere is he to be found. It is my punishment, I think in those moments, I the first transgressor of these bounds. I who was meant to shepherd them and who instead desired what was placed in my care." He reached out for the clay bottle and refilled first his brother's cup and then his own. "Foolishness, of course, for Arda remade would not be whole were any of her children absent. Each speck of dust, we shall be gathered...if any are to be so. He shall be there."
Aegnor remained silent, watching the other impassively. The rain had lessened now and a last finger of sunset reached through the clouds to brush against his brother’s cheek, setting the sheen of his hair alight where it hung loose about his shoulders. It reminded him oddly of the beacons that had lined the coast between Alqualondë and the horn of Araman, their curved panes covered in hammered brass and shining with borrowed light to warn mariners of the looming coast. They had set their path by them after the blood of the Swan-haven, flickering and wan in the Darkness till Ossë’s wrath had pulled the greater number down into the sea they guarded, leaving the prodigals to wander aimlessly till the messenger came and spoke their doom.
Fitting, he thought bitterly, for so too was this Old Hope his brother touted: bright in its origins, but foundered within that very force which should have borne them to safety.
“What was it?” he whispered at last, his voice choked and bitter. “What did they do? What set it all awry?”
His brother shook his head mutely and Aegnor’s fingers curled into helpless fists.
“Did she not…” his voice broke and he pressed on with an effort. “Did she not say more to thee than was put to quill? I know you are close. I know she trusts thee with more of such knowledge than was ever granted me—and I know too thou wouldst have given her thy word of silence had she asked it of thee. Is that the genesis of thine hope, then? That thou hast some answer to this riddle, though thou canst share it not?”
“I do not.” Finrod looked up to meet his eye at last, the lines of grief mirroring across his own features. “And on this I give my word to thee: I would tell thee were I so bound.”
“Did not Bëor speak of it in the years at thy side?”
“No.” Then Finrod grimaced and passed a hand over his face. “Or perhaps he did and I heeded him not, thinking still that my wisdom was greater than their lore.” He rose slowly and returned to the window, resting one hand upon the casement. “There were many fables he told me in those days, many myths that were meant to account for it…I collected them like stones along the seaside, fascinated by their curiosity, but failing to heed their consequence.”
Silence came between them again, and for long there was no sound but the wind sighing through the pine boughs, the distant rumble of thunder over the far fells.
“Ingoldo. What brought us to this?”
A patch of sky had opened as the storm moved off toward the eastern hills and Finrod watched as first one star and then another materialized from the void. “Memory, perhaps.” From the corner of his eye, Balan’s ring stood out against the pale granite; and without a second thought he found himself reaching over to draw it from where it had lain this half-century, sliding it to rest instead upon the index finger of his right. Let others assume what they would. He was done with the charade of discretion. “Might it not be that even as the Secondborn retain in their hearts an image of that vision, of Arda Complete through which they see all this darkened world, that we too carry in our beings a whisper of that same remembrance?”
“So we might taste a double bitterness?”
“Nay, that our souls might sing with recognition when we come face to face, finding each other despite the Shadow!”
Aegnor sank onto the bench beside the table and he leaned heavily against its timbers, face hidden against his palms. “I would I had thine hope,” he said at last, his voice choked and bitter. “But, Nienna in her mercy, I cannot see my way to it.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
Miru na naur: [S] wine of fire
<i>Cened Beraid</i>: [S] Looking/seeing towers
26. Such Barters
How different this was to that first embrace beneath Rivil’s crags, when all was desperation and relief, the ache of his wounds inseparable from the press of the other’s lips. It was almost strange now to know the caress as joy only and not interwoven with pain. And how different too was Nóm’s heart unbarred; reticence gone, desire unshrouded, all the cold and guarded distance now warm and yielding within his arms.
Balan wakes to a new and unexpected life.
Read 26. Such Barters

312th YEAR OF THE SUN, AUTUMN
Nargothrond
He woke slowly, a hollow ache rising through his gut as it did any morning that followed such dreams. Gods all, there was even the sensation of the other’s arm draped over him as he imagined it before waking, firm and comforting against his ribs. It was oddly specific that a slight itch remained where sweat would have gathered had skin truly rested long against skin, and it angered him to find it lingering so persistently. Needless taunting. Was the dream itself not goading enough?
Balan reached up in annoyance to scratch his chest and end the illusion, then lurched aside in shock when his fingers met another’s flesh instead. Laughter drifted over him and he turned in disbelief to find Nóm watching him, hair strewn like light across the pillow and an impish smile playing at his lips.
“I am sorry,” the vision said after a moment, a hint of penitence in his voice as he reached out to brush a stray strand of hair from Balan’s eyes, “should I have left thee? Thou wert asleep ere I thought to ask and I could not bring myself to wake thee.”
“That wasn’t a dream.” He had intended it as a statement, but his voice lifted in question as he stared at the other agape.
“No, not a dream. Though I confess myself flattered thou might’st mistake it for one.”
Balan looked around the room in disbelief, attempting to orient himself. It was morning—late morning judging by the hue of light spilling in from the garden. His two bags remained propped against the opposite wall, half-filled with only those things he had brought out from Estolad. The formal tunics, the writing paper and quills, the arm bands and hilt rings and all other gifts the king had continually pressed on him, these he had left where they lay for Nóm to do with as he would when Balan was gone.
When he was gone. He had meant to leave ere the dawn; he had been quite adamant about it.
Memory flooded in like a tide; jealousy, their argument and bitter break, the hopelessness of the subsequent hours, the heat of Nóm’s lips against his own in the late watches of the night, the other’s skin like silk beneath his palms. A trail of clothing caught his eye, scattered haphazardly about the hearth, and another item joined the growing tally of evidence. He was, he realized with a start and a fresh rush of warmth along his ears, entirely naked beneath the bedlinen.
Finrod’s laugh rippled out again as Balan’s gaze drifted back to him, wide-eyed and cautious as though still half-convinced he had not truly wakened. “You look at me as though I am a phantom,” he quipped, shifting to Taliska and arching a brow in feigned complaint.
“Aye, so you are—phantom, spirit, apparition…” Balan regained his voice at last, a strange giddiness rising through him with the torrent of joy, and he pushed up onto one elbow, prodding the other doubtfully in the chest. “You seem solid enough.”
“Naught but flesh and blood, my love.” Finrod grinned up at him from the rumpled nest of pillows. “The fact of which I should be glad to remind you, have you forgotten it already.”
It was Balan who laughed now and slipped his hand beneath the other’s neck, turning so that he rested against him and looked down into his face; and as suspected he found the king attired in the same manner as he. A blaze of fire joined the giddiness in his veins and he leaned down to brush a kiss against the waiting lips.
He had meant to follow it with a jest, some wry responding quip about feigning inattention that he might be granted the lesson, but all such thoughts fled at the touch of the other’s skin. There had been a boundary before, defined edges where Balan ceased and Nóm began—disregarded of course and more often crossed than preserved, but the demarcation had nonetheless existed. Now it was like plunging beneath a river where any movement was wrapped within the current, or where two halves of clay were smoothed till the seams became indistinguishable amidst the whole. He had been overwhelmed by it, he recalled, shaking and dizzy in the small hours of the night when each touch had carried with it the harmony of the other’s senses, every joy had rung out with his lover’s jubilance, echoing one to the other and compounding like voices through a canyon till he had lost all bearing save the grasp of the other’s arms.
They encircled him again now and, as in that first discovery, his heart pounded as though it would burst. Dizzy, he wrapped himself around the anchor of Nóm’s body; and dizzy, he kissed the parted lips, the brow, the lids of his eyes and the sharp line of his cheekbone, sun-painted with the lattice’s pattern in the morning light.
“Or thou canst do the reminding.“ Nóm’s voice slipped out as Balan’s hands found his wrists and drew them up onto the pillows beside his head. “I’ll not object.”
Balan shifted over him with a chuckle. “Well do I know it,” he replied, his trove of recollections now unquestioned, and bent to claim another kiss; long and deep this time, unabashed. How different this was to that first embrace beneath Rivil’s crags, when all was desperation and relief, the ache of his wounds inseparable from the press of the other’s lips. It was almost strange now to know the caress as joy only and not interwoven with pain.
And how different too was Nóm’s heart unbarred; reticence gone, desire unshrouded, all the cold and guarded distance now warm and yielding within his arms.
He brushed his lips against the king’s palm, letting the kiss trail down and cross the pinioned arm. “It needs but a word from thee,” he murmured in teasing, but complied even before the hoarse please brushed his ear, for he had felt its harmony thrum already through every touch of the other’s skin, heard it in every murmur, in the gasp as he drew his mouth along his collarbone, traced the ribs’ cleft with the tip of his tongue.
When Nóm had once attempted to explain this affinity of souls, Balan presumed it was simply that one moved through life with two sets of senses, those innate to the self and those innate to the other they joined. But the actuality of it was something quite different from his anticipation. He did not perceive in double, at least not in the way he conceived of it. This was a chord, not a duet. An added note to the existing senses, a deeper resonance within his own. It was the silk of Nóm’s skin that Balan felt as his lips traveled past the other’s hips, but there was an elation singing within it, a shivering brightness that arose, he knew somewhere within himself, from the tickle of his beard against that selfsame flesh. And he knew too that it was as much the warmth of his own hunger for this as it was the other’s thrill at the touch of his mouth that called up the sharp gasp, or caused the Nómin's strange, half-holy swears to slip in ragged whispers from the king’s lips.
Is this how it’s meant to be? He had loosed the question at some point in the night, Nóm’s head pillowed upon his shoulder with one hand casually tracing the tattooed patterns on Balan’s chest. The half-felt sense of the other’s perception hummed within him as Nóm’s fingers trailed through the coarse hair and Balan nudged that feeling toward the other’s mind. Or would it be more distinct wert thou joined with one of thine own kind?
In truth, I know not. Nóm had drawn one finger along his breastbone with a smile, up over his neck, hovered at the summit of the chin. I’ve never wedded another. He had walked his fingers to Balan’s mouth and traced the bottom lip from end to end, and Balan had shivered with the mingled sensation. But I am happy, I am content. Art thou not?
He was, he thought as Finrod’s grasp tangled urgently in his hair, and felt every fiber of himself ringing with the other’s exultation. Happy beyond all hope. Content beyond any expectation. Home. His own joy washed over them in chorus and he gave himself up to its oblivion, letting his mind drift rudderless through the torrent.
It was not until some while later, drawn back sated and breathless to rest upon the other’s chest, that time began to assert its presence once more. “Nóm,” he murmured at last, “how much of the morning is gone?”
“Somewhat more than a moment and rather less than a day.”
“Gaitch,” he snorted with a grin, “I’m in earnest. Surely thou wilt be missed?”
“Nay, I have no obligations till the common court—and that is not held till the noon meal is passed.”
“That’s nigh enough.” Balan once again took in the hue of light and gauged the hour well past midmorning. “And how if Edrahil or one of the Guard finds thy chambers empty ere then?”
Finrod laughed and brushed his lips against the other’s forehead before gently extracting himself from the bed. “Then they will go about their morning little surprised. I fear I am rather known for wandering—scroll to scroll, cavern to cavern, realm to realm…”
“First to Secondborn…”
“Even so.” He leaned down with a smile and his kiss lingered long on Balan’s lips. Then he straightened and rounded the foot of the bed. “But for the moment there is no need for thee to worry, my wandering leads merely to the bath.”
Balan chuckled and watched affectionately as the other crossed the chamber, then he too untangled himself from the linen and meandered after him to the adjoining room. It was perhaps a quarter the size of the main chamber, two steps down and slanted so that any overflow remained corralled within its walls. The majority of the space was occupied by the bath itself. Its sides stood nearly level with Balan’s hips, each end slightly raised where the craftsmen had followed the natural curve of the trunk, and the wood was polished nearly to crystal’s sheen. One end was situated near the shaft to the hot spring, and a trough spanned from the pulleys’ outflow to a divot in the bath’s shoulder through which it could be easily filled or reheated. A low bench had been carved within reach of the hot well, beside which was a similarly formed shelf bearing an assortment of items: a large pot of coarse salt, a pile of herbs, several jars of scented oil, a sponge and a pair of combs, a lump of lye soap Balan had brought back with him from Estolad, a palm-sized stone adorned with a relief of twisted vines. On the perpendicular wall, a shoulder of rock curved out into a natural bowl, above which water spilled down from some unseen crevice to run along the mottled limestone, passing through the basin and flowing onward from there, down and around till it found an exit through a small slit at the base of the floor.
He lingered in the doorway, letting his eyes follow as the king filled a pail from the hot spring and carried it back to the the stone basin. A handful of herbs was rubbed between his palms and added to the steaming water, a quantity of salt shaken into a bowl, a few more leaves crushed into this as well and oil poured over top, stirred together with his fingers. Like most of Nóm’s methodical habits, Balan found the ritual soothing to watch—each motion careful and deliberate, the hands sure, the sequence precise, the fresh scent of herbs lulling Balan’s senses as a smile curved along his lips. Bit by bit, Nóm portioned out the salt mixture, scrubbing it over his arms and torso, his legs, his back, then ladling hot water from the pail over his shoulders to clear the residue.
Balan pushed away from the door frame at last and crossed to join him beside the basin. “Thou art certain they’ll not mark thine absence?” he asked, plunging his arms into the chill water with far less ceremony and drawing up handfuls to douse his chest and abdomen.
“I said not so. Only that it would take a far longer absence than this to draw any true concern.” He reached for the vine-carved stone and rasped the porous underside along his back, then flashed a sidelong smile. “Besides, any curiosity will be assuaged soon enough when they learn I have wedded thee.”
Balan snorted but made no reply, turning instead to dip his head beneath the water. “I thought that was decoration till now,” he added when he reemerged, gesturing toward the stone in the other’s hand as he shook the water from his hair, and Finrod glanced at him in amusement.
“Truly? Hilyo told me he had explained it all to thee when thou wert first settled here.”
“Aye, he did well enough. But he could hardly, in good politeness, instruct me in the particulars without implying I’d no notion how to bathe myself.”
Finrod laughed. “A sound point. And one which suggests I have yet again been remiss in my own duties.” He turned to refill the bowl of salt mixture, then reached for the other’s arm and drew him nearer. “Come here,” he said, and spread the salt over Balan’s forearm, scrubbing gently until it began to dissolve, then moved on to his upper arm and shoulder, repeating the process on the other side. He had finished these and moved on to Balan’s back before he spoke again, and when he did there was a hint of timidity in his voice. “I thought perhaps…perhaps at Yestarë we might hold the feast.”
“Hm?”
“Traditionally there is meant to be a year’s wait between pledged intent and oaths, but as we’ve sworn the latter already I see little need to delay it on a pretense. If there are any complaints, we can simply say it was chosen as a meeting point between thy people’s customs and mine.” He drew a ladle of hot water and poured it slowly along Balan’s shoulders, smoothing away the remaining salt with his other hand, then set his lips briefly to the convergence of neck and spine. “I will tell the lords today, of course, and no doubt they will have opinions on the matter.”
“Nóm…”
“I’ve wedded thee already so they cannot sway me on the primary point. But it may be that I will need to surrender some lesser concessions to quiet any difficulties.”
“Nóm.”
“It could be sooner if that is thy preference—Baran and Belen will have the sowing to take into account, and I would not have them excluded. No, Yestarë is a poor choice after all. Perhaps—“
“Ingoldo.”
This at last cut through the torrent of words and Finrod looked at him in surprise as Balan turned to meet his eye.
“It should not be made known.” The stunned silence that followed spread like a wound through Balan’s heart, and it was with an effort that he forced himself to continue. “Don’t tell the lords, do not hold a feast.” Finrod’s lips parted in query, but no sound followed through them. “There is no need to show any change between us.”
The king continued to stare at him in confusion, then at last he shook his head. “Have I angered thee, Balan?”
“No.” Balan clasped the other’s hands quickly and drew them to his chest with a fleeting smile. “Do not think it.”
“Then I understand thee not.”
“Aye, in the king’s mind of thee thou dost.” He reached out to trace a caress down the other’s cheek. “Think on it dispassionately. There are long years still to rule when I am gone, and this will do naught but estrange those who would otherwise be thine allies.”
“I have thought on it already and I disagree. If their friendship is so easily swayed, then it will be broken by some other strain as readily as this.”
“Thy ties with Thingol weathered even the revelation of bloodshed ere being nigh breached in defense of me. And what of thy nearer kin?” he pressed on as the king opened his mouth to object. “I recall they made their opinions on such a union unmistakably clear.”
“They have tolerated other matches they deemed unpalatable ere now. I will not hide thee away as though in shame.”
“Nóm—”
“In thine own example Elu conceded my doors were mine to keep as I saw fit; and I intend to keep my bed in the same manner.
Balan grinned despite himself. “So thou shalt,” he murmured with a brush of his lips against the others, “provided I am the one kept.” Then he recalled himself to the conversation at hand and sobered again, passing one hand along his face. “But gossip recks little of intent.”
“And I reck little of gossip. I will not reorder my convictions from fear of a scandalmonger’s tongue. Let them talk if it amuses them. It costs me naught but annoyance.”
“More than that, I think. But it is my sons who would bear the heavier price.” Balan turned away to hide the spasm of pain that crossed his face. “Please, Nóm. I’ve left them a hard enough path as it is. Let me at least not rob Baran of ruling on his own merit.”
For a time Finrod was quiet and Balan could feel the tension as the other’s thought raced unwillingly over the possible outcomes, and when at last he spoke again the resignation was heavy in his voice. “It needn’t compromise him if we are forthright.”
“It needn’t, but it would.” Balan did not look back at him, busying himself instead by retrieving the lump of lye soap and lathering it over the remainder of his body. “Any aid, any friendship or care beyond a lord’s given duty would add to the whispers—indulged and favored only because his father shares the king’s bed.”
“No one who has seen him at the head of your people could doubt his merit.”
“Few of these would bear witness to it.”
“And the majority, thou wilt say, would glean their knowledge from hearsay.” Finrod hugged his arms about his chest and watched disconsolately as Balan rinsed away the soap before turning at last to meet his eye.
“Thou knowest I am right.”
“I do, but I have not the heart to concede it.”
“I know.” Balan crossed to him again and and attempted a smile as he reached out to tuck a damp strand of hair behind the other’s ear. “I will be thine in quiet, love, but no less truly.”
“The king’s vaen-hlaiba?”1 Finrod asked in a dull voice.
”Aye, I suppose. But thou and I will know the truth of it.” He cupped Finrod’s face within his palms and rested his forehead against the other’s. “Oiastaro,” he breathed, “I am thine. Utterly. Whether any other knows of it makes no difference to that.”
“I know it.” Finrod reached up to rest his hands atop the other’s and pressed them tightly to his cheeks. “I do know it. But oh my heart, I would claim thee before all—let me grieve the loss of it.”
“Dost thou imagine I do not long to take thee before my own people and draw the clay about thine hands? To dance the Woven Way on the open green instead of in the river with night’s shroud about us?” For a moment Balan allowed himself to linger within the vision and felt the chord of the other’s thought rise in harmony with his own. The night sky was clear. The luvan tagl2 sang through the breeze that ruffled the other’s hair and the drums matched his pulse, both steadier than the current pounding in his chest. Belen was grinning at the edge of the crowd with Gildor and Sídhon beside him; and Baran was there as well, his brow creased but the animosity gone from his eyes. Estreth was smug—this he traced to Nóm’s thought in confusion before being drawn back to the imagined dance, hand in hand, arm in arm, the clay rough against his palm as they turned, and turned, and—
He drew a shuddering breath and crumpled in against the king’s chest. His own grief had grown suddenly insistent, a choking thing tangling within his throat, and he clutched at the other helplessly. “Ruthless gods,” he rasped out at last, “what cruel fate was it I found thee not till half my life was spent?”
For a moment the hands tightened their grip, then little by little they shifted until he found himself gathered in the other’s arms, his head tilted back as Nóm’s lips sought his own. It was a careful kiss at first, tentative still and uncertain of this new ground, but Balan’s hands slid swiftly to weave through his hair and drew him back against the wall till they clung to each other with all the desperate fervor of that first embrace against Dorthonion’s blood-soaked stone. And here too Balan welcomed the rock pressing into his back, the dull pain that grounded him and held him anchored in the truth of his senses.
“Nay, what grace,” the words washed over him with the caress, murmured into his mouth as he twined his arms about Nóm’s shoulders, “what grace that led me to thee while there were years yet to have.”
“Beloved…”
“Please. Do not run always ahead, I beg of thee. Stay with me, do not live half-present in the end ere it has overtaken us; look not to it, Balan, look at me.” Finrod cupped the other’s face within his hands, brushing away tears Balan had no recollection of weeping, and when he smiled there was no shadow of grief in his eyes. “We have chosen our way, Anarinya,” he said, and kissed him again. “We will have our joy.”
❈ ❈ ❈
The lamplight scuttered over the wine’s surface, golden fireflies darting from the polished silver to the ripples and back again, as though dancing to the sound of the king’s voice. In truth, Balan reflected as he tried to keep a smile from lingering too persistently on his lips, everything about this meal was a dance. They had wound their way through each course, the polite conversation, the careful adherence to their previous demeanor, cheerful without being exuberant, restrained without appearing secretive. It was simpler for the king, of course. Any giddiness could pass as little other than his usual gaiety; whereas for Balan, though a mostly amiable presence at earlier dinners of the king’s household, such joviality would be far beyond the expected.
And so he had picked his path carefully through the hours, focusing his mind on the flavor of the meat, what spices were rubbed into the roasted radishes, the carvings upon the wall, the dancing light flitting through his wine; and trying in vain not to hearken too closely to the music of Nóm’s voice, nor to find his eyes drawn to the bright smile, to the promise of his lips, to the hearth’s light playing across his fingers as he lifted his cup toward the high king’s emissary—oh how the firelight had touched his skin even so when every inch of it lay bare before Balan’s own hearth and he could trace the wavering glow with his kiss, over breastbone and neck, rib and shoulder...
Balan lifted the wine hastily to his lips and drank deeply. He was glad there were few of them this evening—only eight come together in the Swan Chamber to join Balan and the king at his board. It helped his composure little that the brightness of the other’s joy rested against him like a hand to the small of his back. It was contagious; sharp and brilliant, dazzling as light on clear water, and Balan found himself struggling to hold the conversation’s thread.
“What flavor do I taste in this?” Írui asked as he sampled a decorative loaf, brought to the table alongside the sweet course. “I am unfamiliar with it, but it fares pleasantly on the tongue.”
“Falléfraiw,” the king replied, “or so I have heard it called—‘heart-seed’.”
“How then?” Balan’s attention snapped back to their exchange and Finrod laughed as he caught up a piece of the bread and sniffed it suspiciously.
“It is a spice used among Bëor’s people,” he added in clarification.
“And by what sorcery didst thou come by it?” Balan exclaimed, amusement woven through his voice as he set the portion onto his plate. “I badgered Liuvar for a vial of it all throughout those weeks and he laughed me out of his hut.”
“Twas naught underhanded. I expressed a liking for it and was presented with a small quantity in gift at our departure.”
“A small quantity?”
“A box—nay, regard me not with such betrayal! Tis no larger than the length of my thumb.”
“Aye, only such—as thy coronal is made merely of gold.” Balan took a second piece, laughing, and shook his head. “High indeed art thou risen in their esteem.”
“I know it,” Finrod replied quietly as warmth tugged at the corners of his mouth. “And high indeed are they in mine.”
Again Balan felt the giddiness pressing at his lips and threatening to spill over in laughter as his gaze lingered upon the other. He was dressed with more formality than was his custom at these intimate meals of his household, a blue undertunic clinging close about his forearms, a loose robe which was woven whole of golden thread and summoned the light to him—as though he was the brilliance and the hearth’s glow the swarm drawn irresistibly to hover about his shoulders, his hair, and bathe him in its sheen. Atop the rest, a blood-red sash draped a casual embrace across one shoulder and Balan found his eyes tracing its movement with longing.
“I know this from midsummer, do I not?” Gildor’s voice lifted at his side and saved him from the reverie. “In Baran’s wedding loaf?”
“Aye. It is brought out to mark those times when dust and divine meet—birth, death, a union.”
“And for those rites we marked yestereve?” Meril asked, an unreadable query in her gaze as she turned toward him.
“Those are of your own folk’s devising and not among our traditions; but yes I would think of them as such. As would my lord, it seems,” he added, glancing at Finrod with one brow cocked, “for no doubt that is the reason he’s set it before us tonight.”
Finrod met his glance with a smile and an impish flicker lit his eyes. “I thought it was fitting to mark the day.”
“So it is.” Balan raised his cup toward the other and let the grin dance loose across his lips once more. “Melishkan mathár.”3
“Melishkan mathár,” the king returned with an answering salute, and drank.
“I take it the spice is dear to come by?” Írui slipped another morsel into his mouth and looked at the king in curiosity, sensing that some jest lay beneath their words but unable to trace its thread.
“In this I must commend thee to Bëor’s knowledge. I know little of its origins.”
“Which is meant to absolve thy generosity, I suppose.” Balan turned to Írui, smoothing his grin into a polite smile. “It is rare, aye. We do not cultivate it ourselves, but bartered for it with caravans that crossed our way. It grows only to the south and, as far as I can tell, east of those mountains which brought us here, for my lord knows it not and neither, my son tells me, has it been found among those traders who come up the Gelion from beyond the Silent Woods.”
“Then I count myself privileged in the partaking. How came it to hold such status in your rites if it was not native to your people?”
“It was, once.” Balan paused to sip from his wine before continuing. “My lord has told me often of how your people first came to be. In the tales passed down by our wise and bards, it’s said that the place of our own awakening lay also to the east—but east and south, in warmer lands where the sun holds reign. There the fruit trees that bear the falléfraiw grow unhindered; and they say it was there that our earliest traditions took root.”
“So it is a remembrance, then?” Sídhon asked. “A practice which ties your present to your beginnings?”
“It is many things—that amongst them.”
“Your tales say they were the first trees drawn from the earth,” Finrod added as he lifted a slice onto his own plate, “do they not?”
“Some hold it so. Others say they sprouted where Fon’s sparks fell upon the soil when he danced about our first forefathers, and that is why the groves were ever after dear to him.”
“I thought this was the fruit he set within the clay figures’ lips?”
“To bestow the warmth of flesh—that is the variation I told thee, aye.” Balan turned back to Írui with a chuckle. “You’ll find we’ve as many forms of it as we have tellers of the tale. To his credit, my lord has managed to hold all the elements within his memory, though I fear even he struggles to keep the kernels of each sorted within their baskets.”
“Then I confess little hope of my own success in it.” Írui smiled and the glance cast toward the king was both warm and penitent. “Ingoldo is the loremaster among us, and his the insight against which our own must be measured—and found wanting.”
“I beg of you,” Gildor interjected with a grin, “flatter him not. He is far too certain of his skill already.”
“Is he indeed?”
“A merited pride, to be sure, but insufferable nonetheless.”
“Why then he must be put to the test at once, that we might sift talent from vanity—for his own betterment, and poor Gildor’s relief. Ingoldo!” he charged, turning to the king at his side, “we shall have a tale of thee; a full basket of kernels rightly sorted. Bëor shall name the one but thine will be the telling, while we listeners keep a count of how oft he must correct thee.”
Finrod laughed and inclined his head in acquiescence, even as he felt Balan bristle at the familiar naming. “As thou wilt,” he said, letting amusement ripple back into the thought threaded through his own, “only tell me first how the tally shall be reckoned so that my stumbles are in truth only and not by mischance.”
“That depends on the nature of thy bondsman’s corrections, of course. We are relying on you, friend,” Írui added in an aside to Balan. “Choose whichever one he knows least.”
“As bondsman, surely I must be loathe to lay a pitfall before my lord’s feet.”
“And yet think on what a merry snare it would be.”
“What of the Theft of Fon’s Groves?” Gildor suggested, refilling his chalice as he turned toward Balan in query. “I knew it not till Belen told me, so I would hazard it lies outside his favored hoard.” He glanced back at Írui with a grin. “My loyalty, you see, is of lesser mettle than my neighbor’s.”
“Hear, hear!” Írui laughed and raised his chalice in salute. “And so are we all appeased: Bëor in his fealty, thou in thy cleverness, and I in my needless whim. Thou shouldst be the emissary, Gildor, and not I, thy nature tends far more to the conciliatory." He reached for the decanter and filled Finrod’s cup with a wink. “Come then, Ingo—the Theft of Fon’s Groves for our edification and thy trial. Bëor’s fealty will, I trust, bend enough to be our jurist?”
“Aye, I’ll set him aright. I was sworn to our Wise long ere ever I was his vassal.”
“An allegiance torn between Wisdom and the Wise…there is a sore trial for any man.” Írui chuckled and settled back in his chair, shifting to one side so that he had a full view of the king. “I fear thy fate is sealed, Ingoldo, and his loyalty will not save thee.”
Only a brief glance did Finrod permit himself to meet Balan’s eye across the table, but his thought passed along the other’s with all the warmth of a caress and he was relieved to feel amusement returned along the mingled threads. “Would it be loyalty to allow my lingering in error?” he asked, smiling, then took a breath and began in a quiet voice, low and melodic, echoing the Atani chants,
“The elm and the beech lie broken, ash-feathered
Cracked and crumpled the clay of the gods
where weary wanders the wailing grief
Fire-ravaged Now fog shrouding
the bodies and home-husks Broken the vow
A mother in mourning makes of grief fashioned
a stow tall of earth-bones a stone altar raised
to Luftu breath-giver Gwelwen’s4 great master
the wind and the weaver wakeful and fleet
in the mist-shorn morning where the ash over Melishk lies heavy…”
He broke off with a grimace and shook his head. “Nay, I’ve mislaid the meter. Where ash and...where in ash the…”
“Where Melishk ash-shrouded,” Balan prompted and Írui grinned.
“Mark one tally down in our favor, Gildor.”
Finrod cast him a look of feigned aggravation, then pressed on,
“…where Melishk ash-shrouded
shows wounds in the light Woe! On the altar
behold the small body unburned, undamaged
breath stilled, life lacking the little one cold
Hear the wails and weeping whispers of…the whispered…in whispers the pleas
Gathered as…clinging like dew on cloth of….of…
Again he trailed off and this time spread his hands wide in resignation. “I fear I’ve not the talent to render it properly without longer practice. I concede my defeat.”
“Rot.” Balan watched him in amusement from across the table. “Leave off the verse form and thou wilt have it right enough.”
“In verse was it told to me.”
“And they test thy memory for a tale, not thy swiftness in translating to meter.”
Írui laughed at this and set his hand lightly to the king’s arm. “Leave off the game itself, Ammalincë,5 I am as much in foolery as thou art in earnest.” He leaned forward to refill Finrod’s chalice. “I find myself far more interested to hear it through than to triumph in a whim. Tell the tale however it pleases thee.”
“Mark one tally in my own column, Gildor,” Finrod quipped, shifting his arm unobtrusively from the other’s touch. “We’ll hold it a draw.”
“Not a forfeit?”
“Neither yet.” Balan settled back in his chair with a rogueish grin. “You’ve appointed me as judge, my lords, and a judge cannot rule till the tale is told.”
Finrod chuckled. “Unassailable logic,” he said, then leaned in to rest his elbows atop the table and, after a moment, propped his chin against his folded hands. “The story, as I understood it, proceeds roughly thus: Once there was a child who died in a village fire and her mother brought her to the altar of Luftu, the goddess of wind. Since she appeared unblemished, having been taken by smoke and not touched by the flames, her mother begged the goddess to restore the breath of life in her. To this request Luftu agreed, for she too was angered with Fon, the fire’s god, because he had chased her through her favored groves and in so doing burned the oaks and willows to the ground. If the mother would travel to Fon’s own valley where he kept his sacred orchard, if she would fell the beast that kept guard at the gate and bring back a fruit in token that the task was done, then Luftu would restore the child’s breath.
“To this the mother agreed and journeyed long through six days and six nights till she reached her goal. She hafted her arrow with a thorn hallowed by Luftu’s breath, for only by such a weapon could the beast’s flesh be pierced. But even as she nocked her bow and readied her shot, lo! Fon appeared before her and laughed. He told her that Luftu sought only her own vengeance—a grove for a grove—and had tricked the mother into doing her will, for it was not possible to both kill the beast and retrieve the fruit. The same enchantment which bound the creature to the orchard also caused all within the walls to rot and wither if his heart was stilled. But Fon agreed to give her one fruit from the orchard, if in return she would leave the beast alive. The mother would have the falléfraiw fruit to uphold her bargain, Fon could keep his monstrous companion, and Luftu would be cheated by her own trick.
“The mother thought for a time, knowing that Fon was crafty as a fox, until at length she agreed to what he proposed. She took the fruit and turned away with her arrow still unshot, then fled with all speed until she reached the river’s ford and stood within the water, Guënid’s protection swirling about her ankles. And just as she supposed, the beast was close at her heels. As the god of fire had known, the enchantment bound it not to the orchard but to the fruit itself, and so it was free from the orchard wall when the falléfraiw was carried in her hand. As she had counted on, it faltered at the water’s edge, afraid like its master of Guënid’s power, and in that moment the mother loosed her arrow to lodge within its heart. Fon howled in fury, but his orchard swayed unwithered in accusation behind him: the goddess of wind had not been false.
“And so the woman returned, journeying back through six days and six nights, and carried the fruit to where the goddess preserved her daughter’s body upon the altar, pristine as the dawn she was borne out from the ash. And Luftu breathed breath into her lungs.”
There was silence then, as was customary at the completion of a tale, until at last the king reached for his chalice and took a sip from the wine. “Well?” he asked, meeting Balan’s eye above the rim as a smile played at his lips.
“Well, it’s a foreshortened telling to be sure—and Guënid’s role neglected till nigh the end—but I’ll not hold thee in err for it. All the main bits were accounted for.”
Finrod laughed, and felt the brightness of that mirth cascade down Balan’s spine like water. “Hearest thou what glowing obeisance I reap from his fealty? Thou need’st have had no worry on that count, Íryo: his loyalty is ever to hold me grounded.”
“My lord would not have it otherwise,” Balan countered with a grin and the king laughed again.
“Indeed he would not. May all who presume to rulership be granted such an anchor amongst their courtiers as thee.” He lifted the chalice to his lips once more and for a moment let himself linger in the warmth of the other’s smile, where the intoxication of memory coursed more potently than the wine on his tongue. Balan had been an anchor then too, in the heady hours of the night; steady and sure against his uncertainty, confident where Finrod was uncharacteristically timid, and the calloused palm had quieted him as it turned in slow patterns around his ribs, along his chest. He laughed when the touch crossed his neck in turn and murmured in giddy confession that he had once watched Balan draw his hand even so beneath Elmorë’s jaw and never till that moment had he known one could harbor such jealousy toward a horse. Balan’s grin had widened, wry and mischievous. The one rival I never thought to suspect…he had murmured, his brow arching as he traced a deliberate path down from the collarbone. Not to worry, my lord, I’ve a fair bit more in mind for thee.
Finrod drew himself back to the present with an effort. Discipline, he chastised himself as he laughed at a jest of Írui’s and sipped once more from his wine. This duality would need far more practice if he was ever to cleave to Balan’s wish in it—his mind was drifting toward the other with all the insistence of a tide. Balan’s own gaze, meanwhile, was carefully set on Írui and Faelon to the king’s left, while a curve in the line of his lips left Finrod certain that every current of his thought had been followed and known. He felt the color rise in his cheeks and was glad to find the discourse shifting now to a riposte between Sídhon and Gildor.
“Will you convene again in council on the morrow?” Írui’s voice was unexpectedly quiet beside him and Finrod glanced toward him in query. “There was more beyond the thrall’s release that I was charged to convey to thee. I thought to raise it when I joined you today, but time ran short.”
“I can summon them again, certainly.” The king replaced the chalice on the table and turned to his neighbor with a smile. “But fortune is in thy favor, it seems—thou hast found us convened here already, and so art spared the tedium of another council.”
“A benevolent serendipity indeed,” Írui rejoined, then bent nearer the other’s ear. “But this, I deem, is an inquiry best plumbed in more limited company.” His eyes darted meaningfully across the table and Finrod’s expression darkened.
“If thy meaning is to say when Bëor is not among our number, then I protest the distinction. Anything thou wouldst say to the gathered council may be said in his presence. He has my full trust.”
“I am glad to know it. Nevertheless, given the matter in question…”
“A matter touching on the Atani it would seem.”
There was an awkward pause as others began to attend to their words and Írui offered up a placatory smile. “I have raised the question prematurely. I beg thy pardon, Ingo—and thine as well,” he added with a nod toward Balan. “I should hold my words till another hour.”
“Rather a two-faced precept, Iryo,” Finrod said with an answering smile, and though his tone was light and teasing, there was an irritable glint in his eye. “Thou didst speak openly of the trade disputes with Faelon here beside thee, and that less than an hour gone.”
“No doubt the restriction is not of his making, Nóm,” Balan interjected, adding a jab against the other’s thought that reminded Finrod sharply of his reprimand during the midsummer games. “I fear in thy fondness thou hast overlooked that he is among us as emissary and not thy friend.”
“As both, I hope.” Írui cast a grateful glance across the table. “Though I pray I am found to have more skill in the latter than I have evidenced in the former.”
Finrod chuckled as he reached out to refill the other’s chalice and the tension seemed to ease. “A sore trial indeed for thy disposition, my friend. Thou art far too open-hearted for diplomacy.”
“Whereas we find thine own skill on full display,” Írui countered, laughing. “Never with milder words have any reminded me that my propensities bend rather to gossip than the dance politic. But Bëor here has lit upon the truth of it, I confess, and I am bound to discretion whether I would or no.”
“Then so are we all held.” The king refilled his own cup as well and leaned back in the chair, a smile playing at the corner of his lips. “For ‘twould be a two-faced precept of my own to expect discretion from my messengers while demanding candor of others. I relent. Stay on when the meal is done and thou canst bend my ear with no threat to my uncle’s command.”
“Nay, speak on as you will. I shall not keep an emissary from his duty.” Balan drained his cup and rose. “I have long since felt weariness calling me and, though my curiosity chafes at it, it is past time I sought my bed.” He dipped a brief bow to the table, then again with more formality to the king. “By your leave, lord?”
“Granted. But assuage thy curiosity, for, as in fair truth I should also warn my lord’s ambassador, thou art my advisor in all things regarding thy people and so my ear shall doubtless prove but a conduit to thine.”
“At which admission thy lord’s ambassador should certainly voice an objection,” Írui added with a grin. “However, I regret to inform thee he is a lax sort and cares little what is done with the words once freed from his lips—provided his own duty has been discharged as ordered.”
“There, Íryo, it seems thy nature is proved as conciliatory as Gildor’s after all. Perhaps thy constitution lends itself more readily to thy current work than we might expect.”
“Valar forbid it!” He threw up his hands in mock horror. “Not a word of that to thine uncle lest he see fit to shackle me to it in earnest. I should be forced to conjure a truly portentous scandal to be freed from it.”
“A burden which I doubt not thou wouldst weather with admirable fortitude,” Sídhon murmured.
“Fie! I marvel at thee, Felagund, to allow such slander at thy board.”
“And I that thou wouldst count it slander,” Finrod retorted, laughing. “But the secret of thy skill rests in safety—naught will he hear of it from me—and so thou must seek thine entertainment by another means.”
❈ ❈ ❈
He could feel Meril’s eyes on him as the quiet of the room deepened. She had stayed on when the others dispersed and sat motionless in the chair at his right, watching while he fiddled restlessly with the twined serpents about his finger. Neither had spoken a word, and the silence bore down like a weight against his shoulders.
“Findaráto.”
Quiet as it was, he flinched as the sound cut through the stillness. Then, a long moment later, he turned in resignation to meet her eye. “It can be seen, then?”
“Didst thou expect it to be otherwise?” Her voice was uncharacteristically cold and his gaze fell away again as she continued. “It is faint, but present. I doubt any would notice were they not seeking its signs.”
“And you were?”
“To reassure myself there was no cause for concern.”
“There is not.”
She snorted mirthlessly. “I knew thou wert taken with him, but I did not think thee a fool.” His glance toward her was sharp, but the censure in her own eye did not falter. “Thou hast a duty to thy people, a duty of life and service thou didst swear to them when they took thee as king.”
“I have not shirked it.”
“Thou hast risked its very foundation.”
“Prithee, how—by consorting with the Secondborn?” He pressed back his rising anger with an effort. “Have I lived to hear the prejudice of Tirion from even your lips?”
“Not from mine. But this will loose again what scarce was dammed by his fealty. What becomes of that oath now, supplanted as it must be by this? Wilt thou feign it still and hope that none see past its illusion? Or carve a second seat beside thee and set him there as consort and prince above the lords of thy realm?”
“I would.”
“And yet thou canst say to me that—”
“I would, but he will not allow it.”
Her expression did not change, save for a slight lifting of one brow. “Eru, in his mercy, granted one of you prudence.”
Finrod rose abruptly and paced away from the table, drawing up with his palms against the mantle. “Surely it is cowardice, not prudence, that would lead your counsel to place the higher value on others’ prejudice.”
“Only my counsel and not his?”
“His is given for the sake of his sons.”
“And mine for the sake of thy subjects. Thou art well versed, Ingoldo Arafinwion, in what freedoms thou didst forfeit when thine head bent to a crown. Thy duty is to thy realm, not to thine heart.”
“I do not see that they are in opposition.”
“Then thou art willfully naive. Think on it: not only an abonnen,6 but one who was wedded already and who retains children from that union. A dead wife and a living son—sons in this case—and loyalties torn between these and any new bond.”
“Do not raise that specter here, I am not he.”
“It is she to whom they will compare thee. The children of Indis bearing forward in their turn that selfsame fruit.” Meril held up her hand as his mouth opened in outrage. “I was a friend to thy father and foremother both. I do not chastise thee lightly.”
“I marvel that you would dignify the thought with words.”
“And I that thou wouldst choose with such selfish disregard for thine obligations. Is it thy wish to incite a new schism between the princes of the Noldor? For truly I cannot fathom what other end thou couldst achieve by this road.”
“Perhaps I do not seek an end, but merely the bond itself.”
“Fie! Thou hast not the luxury to reason as a child. Thy kingdom is held by thy conduct and thou wilt risk estranging even thy staunchest allies should this become known. The goodwill of Doriath has been jeopardized already by thy stubbornness before the Marchwardens—and what greater follies am I to anticipate now thou art bound in earnest?”
“A poor example, for that principle I should have upheld for any one of his people, down to the smallest child.”
“And yet thou hast set them in the path of thine own peril. Canst thou see it not? Elu is unlikely to strike at thee directly in his ire, but they have no such security.”
“They are my sworn subjects and bear the same rights and protections as any in my realm.”
“Not if he does not acknowledge it.” Meril’s eyes were alight with indignation and a streak of red had risen along each cheek.
Finrod looked away. He found this uncharacteristic vehemence far more unsettling than any of the accusations themselves. Her level, steady presence had been ever-constant in his life since his first memories, and never till now had he witnessed its breaking. How had he overlooked it? Had he been so wrapped in the joy of the moment that he could laugh on, oblivious, while beside him it smoldered ever more dangerously as the hours drew on?
“Dost thou imagine it will go otherwise with Fëanor’s sons when they learn an Aftercomer wields such influence over thy throne?” She held her hands clasped together in her lap, the grip so fierce that the fingers had begun to whiten. “They will not sit quietly by with the largest realm of Beleriand now subservient to a Man.”
“Then they would do well to learn the difference between husband and servitor.”
“A distinction diligently maintained in thine own affairs. Surely it cannot have escaped thee that this jeopardizes Bëor’s standing as well. If the marriage is known, it will call into question not only the legitimacy of his role as ambassador, but any aspects of our alliance he has negotiated on their behalf. Indeed, his continued occupation of the role itself is a grave breach of integrity.”
“And to shift him from that employ would be to raise the very questions you seek to avoid. I remind you that this marriage is not common knowledge, nor shall it be, and furthermore is known to you only because you felt entitled to excavate my private concerns.”
“A king does not have private concerns. But I know from thine own lips that this policy is upheld only by his insistence—and a fragile course it is if thine attempt at impartiality before Írimo was any evidence of its practice. Twas only by fortune that he is untried as a king’s emissary and marked it not. Beleriand’s unity is a web of gossamer, and what strands of it will hold if thou art toppled?”
“Many, I should think.”
“Few.” She rose at last and crossed to stand before him, and the firelight seemed to him a spirit of wrath upon her face. “This is no time for false humility, Findaráto, thou art the keystone of this brittle peace.”
Finrod turned back toward the hearth, his hands clenched till the nails bit into his palms, and felt the tempest of her anger roiling ever more fiercely at his side. “I know not what it is you would—“
“What shall remain of thee when he is dead?” Her voice cut through his with a hiss and all the pent up rage seemed gathered together in the words. “When thy spirit buckles beneath the weight of absence, what road will be thine?”
“Do not—“
“Death will call for thee then, it will sing in thine ears of oblivion’s balm and every moment that passes will press on thee the promise of that release. What will thy people do in such an hour?”
“They will hold claim of me as they ever have. Can you think so poorly of my integrity as to believe I would choose this path had I not chosen too to steel my will against such temptation? I know my duty, Massánië.”7
“But not the cost, I think. Hearken to me! I know what it is to be bound to one who is gone beyond reach.”
Finrod spun back toward her and his eyes flashed with outrage. “That is not the same.”
“It is a parting of souls till the end of all things; that is similarity enough.”
“It is utterly different, and you know it full well.”
Her voice lowered dangerously. “Why? Because thy Bëor will die in a form thou canst recognize?”
“Because he is as he was created! And when he parts from me it will be at the One’s summoning, not as a corruption of—” He bit back his outburst as an image of Meril rose vividly in his mind, her silhouette stark atop the cliffs of Alqualondë and the bitter melancholy of her song spooling outward across the waves. East, ever East. She had been an reluctant traveler when the Valar summoned them from Cuivienen to Aman, and had joined his mother’s people only when they heard the rumor of those dead who were rehoused and walked among them again. But alone she had retraced that journey, and alone she had crumpled to her knees in Lammoth when the Orcs first set upon them, her lips forming the soundless name over and again as the truth at last settled over her. The stark horror of it would ever be seared in his memory.
Here, then, must lie the root of this inexplicable fury. If she truly believed the comparison, then what an affront to find one she loved choosing willingly that agony she had been unable to escape.
“Breaking is breaking.” Her voice was harsh as it wrenched him back to the present. “I do not warn thee from prejudice. I speak of what I have lived—and of what I fear thou canst not now be spared.”
“It is nothing alike.” Finrod fought to keep his words under control, for her pain was now a tangible blade in the air between them and even in his fury he could not bear to drive it deeper. “He is a mortal; a mystery of the One, not the Foe’s vile mockery for our torment.”
“He is finite. He will die, and it will be an utter ending. And do not think the pain will spare thee because thy loss comes to thee in more palatable trappings.”
“I do not seek to be spared.”
“Easily spake the heart ere the day has come.”
“Valar’s mercy! What is it you would have of me? It is done, and cannot now be undone—nor would I recant it were it within my power. I am his, as surely as the tree knows its roots or the river the path of its bed.”
“No,” she met his eyes with a gaze of steel, “thou art a king. What honor canst thou claim in it now to have chosen this full-knowing?”
All warmth seemed to rush from the chamber and even the fire’s light cowered within the hearth as he glared back at her with blazing eyes, towering suddenly beyond his own height. "You think me sullied? Fine! Have it so." His voice resonated from every crevice of the room, a furious whisper and a rumble both. "But if you have no other purpose to this converse save to upbraid me for a path already chosen, then I will not hear another word of it.” He turned on his heel and strode for the door, then drew up with his hand on the stile and cast a furious glance over his shoulder. “Bring a motion before the lords if you consider me so unworthy to rule,” he hissed, then swept into the passage without waiting for a reply.
His hands were shaking when he rounded the corner and he reached out for the wall to steady himself. Meril’s counsel had ever been his guidepost, she the adviser through whom all others’ wisdom was gauged. What was he to do if the rift held? To be so viscerally at odds with her set his world reeling. It was not, he granted as he pushed away from the stone and turned toward the royal quarter, that the concerns lacked merit; in truth, he could not find fault with them. Had he not wrestled these same misgivings? Had not Balan named them even this very morn? But what Finrod might concede to him in grudging admission seemed nothing but slander in another’s tongue.
He turned through an archway and strode along the hall, the lamplight glinting from veins of quartz and mica lacing the walls, and once more the fury rose like bile in his throat. How could she have carried the reasoning so far? How dare she draw such a parallel? The very idea was obscene, to align the work of Ilúvatar’s hands with the Enemy’s slow arts of cruelty…He slowed as he neared Balan’s door and forced himself to press down the seething outrage lest it seep through to the other’s thought and raise suspicion that some new thing had gone amiss. He traced his fingers along the same frond of kelp that had welcomed him the night before, letting his anger dissipate into the curving tendrils and seabirds’ wings. The fallout from this conflict was a predicament for the morrow to hold. For tonight there was only the peace of the chamber beyond, the familiarity of Estolad permeating the room, the haven of Balan’s bed, the sleepy warmth of his lover resting heavy within his arms.
He eased the door open and slipped into the room, fastening it soundlessly behind him lest he risk disturbing the other’s slumber. But to his surprise, Balan was awake yet, curled comfortably on the floor and skimming herbs from a steaming cup on the hearthstones before him. It was ever so, Finrod thought fondly as he tarried at the threshold to savor the image. Balan had adapted quickly to the luxuries and conveniences of the city, but whenever left to his own rest he always returned to the old patterns: crouched before the fire with the familiar tools of his former life, quiet and content. The horn cup was one Finrod recalled from their earliest days together, a squat vessel roughly the size of his palm with a pattern of grazing animals carved around its base. This same aroma of steeping yarrow and mint had likewise filled the hut in Estolad most evenings—a libation to the memory of sleep, Balan had quipped on one particularly restless night. It was a comforting scent, earthen and fresh.
He crossed to the hearth and bent down to kiss the top of other’s head in greeting. “I thought to find thee abed.”
“Aye, I thought so myself.” Balan grinned up at him as he pulled away. “And yet here I sit.”
“I am glad of it.” Finrod shifted to lean against the stone shelves and watched the firelight ripple like water across the other’s skin. “I confess I have been jealous to be in sole possession of thy company since the morn.”
Balan shook the last leaves from the spoon and set it aside. “Greedy despot,” he murmured, letting his palm linger affectionately against the king’s chest as he rose, then crossed to the far shelf and retrieved a jar of honey. “How fared the ambassador’s assignment?”
“Well enough. Twas naught but to say that the Haladin have crossed into our lands and established settlements north of the Ascar, which we learned already from Baran at midsummer.”
“That was what could not be said in my presence?”
“He was charged to glean my untempered assessment of their integrity and whether their allegiance should be cultivated.” Finrod snorted. “Foolishness still—and so I told him—for I have never met a man of them, whereas thou hast spent full seasons by their side. He should have asked thee rather.”
Balan shook his head with amusement and drizzled a small quantity of honey into the cup. “And what did my Lord Pearl say to that?”
“What, not jealous still?”
“A little, perhaps.”
Finrod chuckled, resting his head against the stone as he watched the other carefully swirl the cup till the honey dissolved. His own limbs felt leaden in the wake of spent fury, his spirit dulled and heavy, and he found it a continued effort keep the melancholy from seeping into their exchange. “When I’ve already given thee horses?” he teased, trying to force a lightness into his tone. “And what must be considered, I believe, a frankly damning quantity of gems.”
“Damning for whom?”
Balan turned back toward him with a grin and a raised brow, but when their eyes met there was a canny sympathy in his that sent a jolt through Finrod’s chest. Of course he saw. It had been absurd to think he could veil his mood from the other’s notice. Balan had always seen him with a more incisive perception than most, and since the night before that skill had seemed to increase ten-fold. In truth, he found it almost a relief to have his dissembling brushed aside with such ease, much as he shrank still from the thought of baring the quarrel to the other’s sight. But the weight of Balan’s gaze was gentle, and he set the cup aside, crossing to him slowly and reaching out to tuck a stray lock of hair behind his ear. A little sound of amusement slipped from Finrod’s lips, for he was reminded at once of watching his cousin calming a skittish colt—the careful, soothing movements, the quiet patience. He leaned his head in against Balan’s with a smile.
“I never said it was a justified envy,” Balan murmured as he drew his fingers along the other’s jaw.
And with that touch, as his lover’s lips found his own, the anger boiled through him once more, for how dare she peddle accusations of schism and undue influence when here Balan stood, quietly reassuring him that he would never press beyond what the king was willing to share. Would such concerns have been raised, Finrod fumed to himself as one of Balan’s hands drifted suggestively down the path of his sash, had he wedded from the Sindar instead? The other’s mouth brushed along his earlobe and his breath caught in a hiss, the fire in his veins surging from ire to longing as Balan’s fingers began to loose him deftly from the formal robe. There were any number of lords who had bound themselves across those cultural lines, and they had been lauded as heralds of unity and healing. Why should it be only the Atani who were held suspect for daring to seek the same union? The hands had found their way beneath his tunic now. They were warm and calloused against his skin and he shivered as they traced along his waist, his hips. How dare she lecture him on his duty as though he had not sacrificed years already to its specter? He tangled his fingers abruptly in Balan’s hair as he drew him in and kissed him feverishly, spending his fury into passion while Meril’s words rankled in his heart. The largest realm of Beleriand now subservient to a Man…
“No.” He was surprised by his own hoarse gasp as Balan began to shift downward, and he caught him insistently by the arms, turning him to change places and pressing him deliberately back against the stone. “No,” he whispered again, fiercely this time as he sank to his knees, his eyes never leaving the other's. “This time you stay where you are.”
Chapter End Notes
TRANSLATIONS
Q = Quenya, S = Sindarin T = Telerin
4Gwelwen: [S] air (as space as opposed to substance)
5Ammalincë: [Q]: little yellow bird. See Mirröanwi
6Abonnen: “After-born,” a term for men given by the Elves
7Massánië: [Q] lady, breadgiver. This is Meril’s title in the king’s household as the keeper and distributor of lembas. She holds this role in the absence of a queen.
TALISKA INVENTIONS
For the most part, all faux-Taliska is loosely inspired by or modeled on Germanic-Gothic
1vaen-hlaiba: paramour, slang (lit.) bed-companion. See In These Holy Waters.
2luvan tagl: “singing hair” (lit: singing hair-strand)
3Melishkan mathár: Melishk bear witness
MISC NOTES
- Yestarë is the first day of the year in Elven calendars, also the first day of spring. See In These Holy Waters.
♡♡♡
I'm so delighted that you've posted the rest of this here! (And I do hope Atanatárissë will follow since it feels such a complementary part of this series.)
I am thoroughly enjoying my reread and loving all the marvellous details that are standing out more now with "hindsight", and also seeing things with a different lens this time.
As always, your incredibly detailed and original worldbuilding is so rich and delicious, and the interactions and private thoughts and feelings of the characters are so relatable, I'm so loving being able to get so thoroughly immersed and slip from one fic/chapter to the next.
Picking up with part 3 here!
Hello! (It’s coffee-shop from Tumblr!) I’m so glad to be able to continue the Atandil journey despite the AO3 situation, so here I am for Unfriends. More fascinating texture and worldbuilding again right out to the gate with the legends of the deer men and the paintings and the skull! I can certainly relate to Belen getting attached to mysterious old stories and so excited and invigorated by finding a way to feel connected to them - what is fandom if not us sort of enacting the same thing! (Also, he always gets nauseous at the idea of killing on the hunt??? So sweet, I hope he can always keep that tender heart in a cruel world!) But the tragic outcome of it is so upsetting - though, to me, immediately understandable. I’m glad Finrod could see that and stop any harm from coming to Orndaer, whose willingness to be held accountable I found very admirable.
I can easily see how this opportunity for Finrod to play a key role in the saving of Belen will only further ingrain his place in Balan’s heart, though I appreciated both that you still created a sense of uncertainty around the outcome (it was clear that Finrod felt himself reasonably in control of the situation but also not overly confident, particularly as his knowledge of human mortality is still developing) and that you didn’t have his elven expertise supersede Estreth’s own skill and wisdom. He’s not an outside savior on whom they’re all wholly dependent, because they have their own intrinsic knowledge and talents as well. That seems important to me.
Balan’s further education about osanwe was fascinating to watch. It’s such an inherently vulnerable thing to allow and it felt like watching two people engaging in a real act of intimacy — just like a first sexual experience, it had all the same nervousness and sense of discovery and delight in finding a new way to achieve closeness. And it was certainly brave on both their parts to let the other one in, where they might find the *special* way they think of each other (I could never with my own crush!). All of their interactions are always so gentle and rooted in kindness, it makes them so easy to cheer for as a pair (even while my grubby human brain still bristles a little at Balan’s continued occupying of the short end of the power dynamic between them as Elf and Man). The oath between them at the end of the chapter is so stirring and yet also tinged with foreboding, as even in this solemn moment of bonding they are still discovering things about each other that they didn’t know or don’t fully understand. What more is out there that they don’t know and can’t quite comprehend? I don’t know, but that’s so narratively exciting! This was another lovely entry in the broader work — full of intriguing detail and beautifully crafted, both in words/imagery and how easily the story flows along (not saying it was easy to write it that way, but it reads as effortless!). I loved it!
Just realized i didn't have…
Just realized i didn't have my notifications correctly enabled on here and missed your comment till now! I'm so glad you're still enjoying the series!
I love your comparison of Belen's attempt to connect with the old stories with writing fic. I would not have thought of that on my own, but it feels so right. I was just talking with a friend about how writing fanfiction feels like "collecting live Elves" and these two ideas are shaking hands in my head now.
Oh I am SO glad to hear that he didn't come off as an "outside savior." I really wanted to avoid that and I wasn't sure if this had managed to land well or not - so thank you for saying that!
Thank you so much for the lovely comment!
A couple of years ago I had…
A couple of years ago I had read up to No Gentler Pain before stuff happened that made reading a non-relaxing experience, so I've been delighted that my readability returned and that I've been able to savour this remarkable series again ... and continue with all the new instalments. (Lucky me; I've just finished We Shall Be Gathered and I get to dive right back in to where Mirröanwi left off earlier this year.)
I always want to comment on each little bit and then become overwhelmed and shy of my inadequate knowledge language terminology and my inability to figure out what the correct labels are for feelings evoked, so this time instead of waiting till that mythical time when I'll magically feel I can adequately express myself and leave long comments on each chapter, I'll just let what comes out come out...
There are just so many things I enjoy in this: the story itself, of course, and its themes, and Finrod's and Balan's oh-so-painfully-relatable internal experiences. But then there is the incredible loving detail with which you fill in the massive gaps in Tolkien's comparatively rough canon. (I often think of the Silm as being viewed from an eagle's eye view and Silmfic flying in at ground level, but the image I have of Atandil is of a half-timber frame house where Tolkien's work forms the beams and you've infilled the walls with the most gorgeous, and detailed, designs.) I so love the mythology and stories and songs sprinkled throughout (and many of your faux-Talkiska words stick in my mind -- hrögemetheilit stuck because I kept sounding it to figure out how to pronounce it and gaitch has been useful) and many of the little details stood out even more during my second read, especially after reading Adanatarisse. Your descriptions, of places, of objects, of people, of actions, of feelings ... all so vibrant and vivid I see and feel them rather than words. (And so long to be there too!) Oh, and the midwinter and midsummer, and wedding and funeral traditions. As a misplaced mongrel with no strong culture I can call my own, and even just a citizen of this crazy modern life, reading them made me long for long-abandoned community and culture and ritual.
And then there is their connection, Finrod and Balan, and their utter conviction of their respective love and desire (even if they are/were unsure of the reciprocity, oh plight of lovers everywhere!) I love the light touch of osanwe, and its naked honesty and reassurance in so many ways, and then also its intensity if unleashed. The way they can see and hear and feel through each other is just so divine! And yet that still does not instil an omniscience, and uncertainties and insecurities and jealousies still lurk (oh so deliciously for us readers!) Oh! And speaking of delicious, Finrod as a whirling wildcat with claws extended when he takes on the Orcs! But even more delicious was the feelings evoked as he realised the danger Balan was in, issuing an order to Sidhon and running to find him. And of course the way they mutually expressed their relief in the aftermath. Yummy!
When Balan lost his temper and broke the mirror ... this was an interesting experience for me. I felt embarrassment on his behalf for acting like a toddler (projecting my own feelings when I've acted similarly). But then, seeing how justified is his anger and frustration, and under it all, his hurt, it made me realise how from a child I had been taught that the anger and the expression of it was the crime and not the crime that triggered it. The message (from the perpetrators) that it is wrong to be affected by things that hurt us and at the very least any feelings of hurt must be hidden. (I know this mis-message is so widespread, which also makes me very angry.) What a balm it was to observe Finrod's response to Balan's feelings here! All of them, the fight, the shut down of feelings and bond, the deep thinking, the insights and realisation ... It was so very very beautiful, the whole build-up to that point, and then the apology, the plea, the acceptance ... Oh! My heart.
And then the bookend, revisiting Aegnor, his response and his insights.
Ahhh! You have provided me with so much more enjoyment and comfort and food for thought and feels than I can possibly express. Thank you!
I just discovered I had my…
I just discovered I had my settings weird on here and only now am seeing your comments!
Thank you so much for sharing all your thoughts like this! It was truly a joy to read all of what you've noticed and enjoyed throughout here. I continue to be so floored that something I wrote could resonate with people like this. Thank you ❤️
The way you described the timber framed house in comparison genuinely made me tear up. That is such a kind thing to say and encapsulates so well what I had been hoping to accomplish here. That meant so much to hear.
Aaahhhhh so glad you liked my feral Finrod!! That scene was so much fun to work on.
"from a child I had been taught that the anger and the expression of it was the crime and not the crime that triggered it" Oh my goodness yes. This echoes so much of my own experience too.
Thank you so much for such a thoughtful comment. It truly meant so much to read what you've felt about the story ❤️
just on part 2!
Only just started reading by chance, and I am truly lost in this fic and its richness. I truly do not think I can say enough to give this work justice and I am only on the second chapter. Absolutely in love with the dialogue and atmosphere you express through this. I was going to talk about how vivid Aegnor and Finrod's conversation felt in terms of emotion and dialogue, but after the end of chapter 2 and the really profound discussion between Balan and Finrod I also want to say that your attention to worldbuilding and these characters interiority—especially the human perspective—is beautiful. In both these scenes (and generally the whole story) there is a thoughtful and atmospheric focus on the fabric of this world you're writing, especially on the emotional/philosophical levels. I feel like I could write an essay if I wished and it still wouldn't capture everything.
This is also one of the first Silmarillion related fics I have read in a long time, and your writing has really stirred up my appreciation for how talented and scrupulous this fandom's authors are. I'm absolutely captivated and really don't want to do much else than sink into this story for the immediate future.
Oh my gosh, thank you so…
Oh my gosh, thank you so much! This was such a lovely comment to receive. I've been feeling a bit low about writing at the moment and this was such a shot of encouragement. I'm so glad you're enjoying the story! Thank you again so much for saying this - it truly meant a lot!