New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
The house still stood deep in the middle of the forest, overgrown with ivy and moss. Some of the slates on the roof had been knocked loose, and the window sashes sagged. The door hung open, lopsided on its hinges, and Maeglin wondered if Eöl had left it that way in his haste to hunt them down. Surely Cwileg, who’d looked after the horses and helped Eöl in the forge, would have closed it up? Or Brôg, who’d burned charcoal from fallen limbs and taught him the names of mushrooms? They must have left long ago when Eöl never came home; Maeglin hadn’t expected to find Eöl's tiny handful of followers living here in isolation after so many years, so he wasn’t disappointed when he saw how thoroughly abandoned the place was. It was fine. They'd never so much as suggested to Eöl that perhaps he shouldn't hit his child, so Maeglin didn't miss them.
Maeglin set down his pack and carefully stretched. They’d slept beneath the dense, dark branches of a yew, in the hollow of its roots. Clad in wolf fur, Mairon had curled around Maeglin and kept him warm. He'd whimpered continually in his sleep, and Maeglin knew his wounds must hurt, though he said nothing of them. Maeglin himself had woken with his ribs aching so fiercely he could barely breathe, and his hands and arms had only gotten worse. It should probably be concerning, he thought, that his left hand, that had never been broken, hurt so much too, but he brushed it aside. They were safe now, and they both had time to heal.
As he walked around the cottage, Maeglin pulled aside the vines to peer into the mostly-intact windows and inspect the walls underneath. It seemed reasonably weatherproof, despite the passing of years.
“Aren't we going inside?” Mairon asked when he made no move to cross the threshold.
Maeglin sighed. He could put it off no longer, though he had little wish to gaze once more upon the stage where most of his worst memories had played out. Well. Perhaps he could allow Angband to vie for that honor. “I’d like to burn the whole place down.”
“Where else could we go? I can’t…I might get through the winter as a wolf, but I can't sustain us both, and—”
“No—I'm not going to do it. I just wish I could.” He swept the hanging cobwebs aside and shoved back the door. The hinges needed repair, but the wood was sound. “This house was so full of pain.”
“Are things of pain only fit to be cast away, then?” Mairon murmured.
Maeglin reached for his hand and squeezed it. “Sometimes they just need to be aired out and scrubbed well.”
Mairon's lips twisted into a smile, and he let Maeglin pull him inside. A thick layer of dust covered everything. It smelled musty and earthen, but no note lingered of the sharp metallic cologne Eöl had often worn. Maeglin breathed in deeply. He didn't know how he would have managed if the place still smelled like him. This, he could handle.
“How long's it been since you were here?” Mairon asked, eyeing the desiccated remnants of someone's last meal with distaste.
“About a hundred years. I was a child still when my mother and I fled, though I thought myself very wise and grown.”
A bird had built its nest in one of the bookshelves. Or several generations of birds, from the amount of dung heaped beneath it.
“Where’s a battalion of orcs when you need one?” Mairon grumbled. “Fire might be preferable to this much cleaning.”
“We don't have to do it all at once.” Maeglin peered into the kitchen, taking note of all the corners that might still hold preserved food. “We just need to make a little space habitable enough to start with.”
Heading up the stairs, he walked down the hall and opened the door to what had once been his bedroom. All was as he'd left it those many years ago, in one sense. Time had left its mark here too. He'd never made his bed the day they escaped, and the thrown-back covers were moth-eaten and shredded by mice that had made their home in his pillows. He lifted the edge of the mattress and dumped the mess on the floor. The mattress itself seemed intact, at least enough to work with.
The trunk at the foot of his bed was sealed, and when he lifted the lid, he found the enchantments had held. Digging through the contents, he found his thickly-woven winter coverlet, the colorful quilts he had helped his mother piece, lengths of fine wool fabric and pale green forest linen spun from nettles. He remembered the day Aredhel had tucked them away, teasingly swearing she wasn't cutting new clothes for him again until he finally stopped growing. He tried to breathe through the knot in his chest. She'd want him to have them now. Wouldn't she? Or would she be disappointed that he’d returned in the end, unable to escape the shadow of the trees that had bound her? At the bottom of the trunk, where he'd tucked it away when he decided he was too old to keep it on his bed, was the toy moth she'd stitched for him with embroidered silken wings. He took it out and sat back heavily. He was too big now to wrap himself in the wings like the whisper of her hug, but he held it against his heart and let his tears fall.
Mairon, who had stood in the doorway watching, approached quietly and sat beside him. He reached to take Maeglin's hand, but stopped when he flinched from the touch. Even that light pressure was too much.
“I'm sorry,” Maeglin murmured. “It just hurts. All the time. It's not you.”
“Don't. It's fine.” He put his arms around Maeglin instead, moving carefully, and though he seemed distant and uncertain, Maeglin found it comforting all the same. “Thought you didn't miss this place.”
“I miss her. My mother. I…miss the times we were happy. Before I learned what kind of person my father really was.” He thought of how the trees remembered Eöl, and the early mornings, before he had a name he could be called aloud, when his father had sat at his bedside, singing soft lullabies and telling him stories of forest creatures until he slept. “Sometimes I even miss him, and then I feel like a terrible person who's betraying my mother’s memory.”
“I think I know what you mean.” Mairon did not elaborate.
“He used to lock me in my room, right here, sometimes for nights at a time, when I'd displeased him. He threatened to put me in shackles if I ever tried to see my mother's family, and I never doubted for a moment he'd do it.” Maeglin didn't know why he told the Maia these things. After his first mistake or two, he never spoke of them in Gondolin; he'd learned quickly that much of his childhood horrified people, but then he’d be treated like some strange object of pity or told his father's deeds were bad enough without him making up more. To Mairon…it probably wasn't half of what he accepted as proper.
“There…are other rooms, are there not? You don't have to take your old one again if it makes you uncomfortable.”
Maeglin glanced up. Mairon's brow was furrowed in concentration and concern. Feeling lighter, he let himself lean back against Mairon's chest, knowing Mairon would hold him. “It was mine, though. And no one will ever lock me away again.”
Mairon pressed him closer. “No. Not while I live.”
Maeglin thought he could rest there forever, but the day wouldn't last. “We’ll fix up a place to sleep here, and then we'll clean out the kitchen and get the fireplace in working order. You can go through my parents’ room—the one at the end of the hall—and see what there is to salvage later if you want. I don't think I can go in there.”
Mairon nodded. “Let me see how you're healing.”
Maeglin held out his right hand, grateful for the gentleness of his touch. Out came the little tin of salve, and Mairon sang softly as he massaged it into Maeglin's skin.
“The bones are knitting together well,” he announced with a hint of forced brightness. “I did a good, clean job putting you back together. There's no swelling, no scarring. You've been under a lot of strain in the course of our journey, but I think you'll finish healing up swiftly now, and the pain should go away soon.”
“Thank you.” Maeglin said nothing of the pain in his left hand or his chest. That was probably the strain, too. “I would never have guessed you a healer.”
“You learn much in the course of reshaping living creatures.” Mairon shrugged as if the words did not bring visions of torture and vivisection to life in Maeglin's mind. “Plenty of healing required there. And…my master’s—Lord Melkor's—his hands were never well again, after the Silmarils. I spent a great deal of time on research to aid him, little use though it was.” He stared down, all of his put-on cheerfulness dropping away. “That was one of my great failures too. I haven't Estë's gifts; I can't restore what is destroyed. I can amplify and guide the effects of medicines; I can speed what the body would do on its own. That wasn’t enough for him. It wasn't…I wasn’t good enough. I've always wondered, if I could have spared him his pain…maybe I wouldn't have lost him.” He sighed and met Maeglin's eyes. “You’re an easier case, thankfully.”
“I did see how careful you were to protect my hands. I…I know you did what you did to get me out of there.” Mairon bore plenty of blame still, but he could recognize that much and be grateful.
Mairon raised Maeglin's hands to his lips and laid a delicate kiss to his fingertips. “Of course. You’re an artist.”
They spent the day sweeping and scrubbing the floor, wiping away the dust, tearing down tattered curtains, emptying the disintegrating feathers from Maeglin's mattress, washing the heavy cover, and gathering armfuls of hanging moss to dry for fresh stuffing. Maeglin was barely standing by the time they finished, but he didn't want to look like he was refusing his fair share of the work, so he forced himself to keep going. They had to have a clean place to sleep; everything else could wait, but he couldn't abide the smell of dust and mice coating his throat all night. By the time they started scrounging though the remains of the pantry, Maeglin's hands were shaky, and he was having a hard time focusing on Mairon's words.
“Sit,” Mairon told him sharply. “You've done enough. Tell me if there's anything likely to be worth looking through.”
“There should be.” Maeglin rubbed his eyes. When was the last time he’d actually eaten? Had it been before they reached the plains…? “Eöl was always afraid of being cut off from trade and kept under pressure from Angband. Or the Noldor. He had stores put up to last a long time. The…the stone tubs, at the base of the shelves.”
Mairon found them and pushed back a heavy lid. Sacks of glistening grains and nuts filled most of the space, with smaller amounts of other foods, dried or salted or cured tucked alongside. Mairon broke a chunk of maple sugar off a hardened slab and handed it to Maeglin. “Start with that.”
He remembered buckets after buckets and walking for miles with the weight of sap on his shoulders and songs around the fires that burned all night and day to boil the sugar down every winter’s end. He didn't know if he could do it on his own. “It will be hard to get more.”
“Yes. Eat it anyway.”
Maeglin didn't think anything had ever tasted so good. It revived him, if only a little, but Mairon insisted he stay put. Mairon ground enough barley to mix into some thin round cakes he baked on a flat stone outside, and they sat by the fire eating them with blackberry jam that was even more precious than the sugar, since Aredhel had made it the summer before she died. The night was loud with the song of crickets and cicadas. Nightingales had sung here once, but though Maeglin listened for them, he didn’t hear any now. Without them the woods felt hollow and queer. Soon enough, the year would fade, and they’d need to put up all the food they could before then. Eöl's old stores would sustain them for a while, but he didn't want to use them all and be left with nothing. There was the work of tending the forest, and he couldn't delay taking Eöl's place in it any longer; the trees wouldn’t sustain their goodwill long if he didn't do his part. At some point he'd have to open the forge and see what supplies there might be to work with, and find out if anyone was left alive to trade with in the wasteland Morgoth had made--
“What is it?” Mairon murmured. “You look horribly overwhelmed all of a sudden.”
“There's so much to do.” The thought of it made him immeasurably tired.
“We’ll get there. A little at a time, like you said.”
With the mattress taken apart and drying over several tree branches, they settled into a nest of blankets on the floor. Maeglin lay with his eyes wide open, staring up into the familiar rafters he'd thought he'd left forever. Part of him couldn't help listening for raised voices downstairs, despite knowing he wouldn't hear them unless it was in his dreams. Mairon was pressed comfortably against him, though Maeglin noticed how gingerly he positioned himself to protect the whip burn on his side. His hand slid under Maeglin's shirt. Maeglin sighed softly at the caress. It felt good just to be touched like this, as if it soothed some long-standing, desperate wound he hadn’t realised he carried. Distantly he marveled at how easily he let his torturer near him; surely he ought to shrink away in terror. Maybe there was something wrong with him. He'd always suspected it.
Mairon's hand dipped lower, under his waist band, and wrapped around his cock.
“Wait, what are you doing?!” His cock was already hardening, and the sharp arousal heating in him was not altogether pleasant or welcome. He put his hand over Mairon's to still him, but he didn't push him away.
“Shh, you don't have to do anything. Just let me please you.”
“I don't—I…” It wasn't that Mairon had become any less alluring or irresistible, but he hadn’t figured out quite how he felt about him, and they were both hurting and weary, and if he used the wrong words, Mairon would turn away, cold and rejected, and he didn’t want that—
“You need to relax and get to sleep. It'll help.”
“But…”
“I can use my mouth if you like,” he purred. “I’m very skilled; I'm certain you'll enjoy it.”
“Are you offering because you really want to, or because you think you need to please me?”
“Is there a difference?” He said it lightly, as if in jest, but Maeglin felt the puzzlement and irritation underneath.
“Yes. Yes, there is, and you need to understand it if we're going to do this. In the future, when we both actually feel up to it.” Gently he removed Mairon's hand and twined their fingers together instead.
They lapsed into awkward silence for a while. Maeglin’s body resented the loss of promised pleasure, and he half wished Mairon was elsewhere so he could take care of himself quickly and find oblivion, but the prospect of lying in the dark alone was worse than any thwarted desire.
“I don't know what you want from me,” Mairon murmured low and anguished against his cheek. “I don't know what you want me to be to you.”
“What do you want to be?”
“I don't know!” He rolled onto his back, putting a little distance between them. His golden eyes glowed softly in the darkness. “I've been his Lieutenant for so long. I don't think you need a Dread Lieutenant, Master of Torment, Lord of Werewolves, and Bringer of Order to the Pits of Despair.”
Maeglin's heart was in his throat. It had been easy to forget, in the course of traveling side by side, that his friend, petulant and caring in turns, was a preternatural being of such immense power, accustomed to unquestioned command. What was he thinking, asking him to be content with a life of bare survival in an abandoned house in the woods? He chose this, he reminded himself. He chose me. “I do not,” he answered carefully. “But I do need the companion who would argue smithcraft with me for hours. I need the brave and clever wolf who set me free and delivered me through many dangers. I hope I may have the friend who showed me his grief and pain and allowed me to help.”
Mairon made a small sound of disbelief at this, but he did not interrupt.
“I hope…” Maeglin wasn’t sure he could give voice to the next words. Setting himself so high could only lead to an equally great fall. But the darkness and the warmth of the Maia nestled at his side made him bold; hadn’t Mairon seen him at his most pathetic already, and had not turned away? “I hope I might have the one who treasured me enough to leave everything, and that I might treasure him in turn.”
“Oh, little sweetheart…” Mairon gently stroked his thumb along Maeglin's jaw.
“You are all those things already,” Maeglin whispered. “You don't have to be anything else. You don't have to be anything you aren't. I wouldn't ask it; I know how much it hurts—”
Mairon was leaning in, and Maeglin did not stop him as he closed the distance with a soft kiss.