Lord of Nan Elmoth by Harp_of_Gold  

| | |

Chapter 18


The choice was made; it could no longer be undone. A child was dead because of him—am I a kinslayer now? Maeglin wondered. He didn't see any better way this could have gone; he wasn’t sure that made it right. Mairon was coughing; flecks of blood appeared on the snow, but Maeglin couldn't see to him yet. The remaining child was stirring, and he waited, holding still so as not to frighten him. The boy looked from him to Mairon and back.

“Are you Fëanorians?” His voice shook, and he was scrambling backwards before he’d even managed to sit, but the wide tree trunk stopped him.

“No,” Maeglin said gently. “We're here to help you.”

“They killed Ada! They killed Nana too.” He started to cry, choking on his sobs. “They cut Ada's head off. It was rolling on the floor. I saw it!”

Maeglin swallowed down his horror and every protesting memory of his mother's childhood stories. “Hey, come here.” He held out his arm without moving any closer. “Can you tell me your name?”

“Elurín.”

“Elurín,” Maeglin repeated, not sure he'd heard it right through the boy's sniffles. “Elu…like Thingol?”

Elurín eyed him warily. “That’s Great-Grandda. He's gone too.”

“Yes. I'm sorry.”

“Dior’s son, then. Son of Lúthien and her pet human,” Mairon told him with silent venom.

Maeglin gave him a slight nod of acknowledgement. “You know what that makes us?” he said to Elurín. “My Adar was cousin to Thingol. That means we're family too. I'm your Uncle Maeglin.”

“Oh.” The boy started to approach, but hesitated and looked around.

“You never told me you were related to her.”

“You never asked? What have you got against Lúthien?”

“Oh, nothing.” He rested his hand on the scars on his throat that Maeglin had tended long ago. “She's the one who did this to me, but you know. Nothing that matters.”

“Mairon—”

“Where's Eluréd?” Elurín whimpered. “Where's my brother? He was right here! We have to find him; what if the Fëanorians—” He spotted the remnants of his brother's clothing where he had lain beside him. “WHERE IS HE?!” he screamed.

Maeglin scooped the wailing child into his arms. “I'm sorry,” he murmured into his hair. “I'm so sorry. He didn't make it. He…it's just you now. I'm going to take care of you. You're not alone.” Nothing he said did anything to stem the screaming, so he just held him, rocking back and forth.

Mairon watched impassively. He hadn’t moved.

“Is my cousin going to be a problem?” Maeglin demanded.

Mairon's pause was uncomfortably long, but when he answered, his mental touch was much softer. “No.”

Elurín coughed hard, and Maeglin thought he would start wailing again, but he got his breath back enough to manage whole words. “He can't be d—gone.” He tugged on Maeglin's shirt. “He can't be! He was right with me, I could feel him there, and then something was pulling him away—what did you do?! Did you let the Fëanorians take him?!”

Maeglin was scrambling after words, but Mairon was faster. “You've been here sleeping a long time. The Fëanorians are far away; they won't hurt you any more. I'm afraid your brother faded away and left this world long ago. See, weren’t these his things, just as he lay here? You were in a very special sleep, and it saved you, but he couldn't sleep so long.”

“No. No. I felt him. He was there…”

“Time does strange things in your dreams,” Mairon said with surprising gentleness. “I'm sure he's with your Ada and Nana now. But you're alive, and you're going to be okay.”

Elurín began to cry again, less frantically and more forlorn.

“You don't think he deserves the truth?” asked Maeglin.

“And how do you mean to explain it? Do you want him to run away and die in the woods alone? He has to trust us.”

Maeglin didn't like it, but he supposed Mairon was right. “Let's get you home,” he murmured. “We need to warm you up and get you something to eat.” He stood, hefting Elurín onto his hip, and wished heartily that the house wasn’t so far. Night was fast approaching, and they’d lingered too long in the cold already. He could envision it so clearly, the house nestled safe and sound in the dim little clearing, smoke trailing from the chimney. His clothes were damp from the snow and Elurín's tears, and he wouldn't be able to stave off his own pain and weariness much longer. Need filled him until he could almost taste it. “Mairon? You'll carry us?”

He gestured in the house’s direction, and the forest realigned. With a yawning groan and the tinkle of ice falling on snow, a path opened between the trees, and the house appeared a short distance away. Elurín’s quiet gasp stirred them to motion. Mairon was studying Maeglin intently; he shook it off, and as soon as Maeglin and Elurín were on his back, he trotted down the path, covering in mere steps what Maeglin knew should be miles.

Elurín held onto Maeglin tightly. “The forest back home would do that for Grandma when I was little,” he whispered.

Maeglin shivered and wondered just how much was possible that no one now living could show him. He thought of fine white threads of hyphae. “I've a feeling the forest will listen to you too, when you’re older.”

*

Elurín didn't stop sniffling all evening, but Maeglin got him through a bath and into an overlarge but clean and dry tunic without much difficulty. Mairon had offered to cook, more to avoid being asked to participate in any sort of direct childcare, Maeglin suspected, than anything else, but at least he hadn’t disappeared again. The silence felt awkward as he led Elurín to the kitchen table and they waited for Mairon to finish. Maeglin thought he should say something comforting, or at least make the child feel more welcome, but he had no idea what that might be. What comfort was there when you’d lost your whole world? With bitter fondness, he wondered if Turgon had felt the same way after Aredhel's death. They'd certainly shared plenty of silences. Would he have some great wisdom to offer if Maeglin asked him now, or would he admit his total helplessness?

Mairon handed the child a small bowl of what looked like particularly thin porridge. “Here. Try to eat slowly.”

Elurín took a bite and pushed it away. “Tastes awful.”

“You need to eat it anyway.”

Maeglin tasted it himself. Elurín wasn’t wrong. Was that a slight on him, or the child, or stinginess born of caution for the winter ahead? Or maybe he was simply exhausted too. “Mairon…?” He hurriedly reached for a lighter tone. “I think you forgot to taste this while you were cooking.” He began readying himself to stand and look for something to make it vaguely more edible, but he could tell moving was going to take effort, and it was going to hurt.

“I forgot nothing. He's been asleep without eating anything solid for something like three years. This is what he needs. Other food will make him sick. Trust me on this. It’s carefully optimized to restore an elf who’s been starved.” His smile was unpleasant. “You can ask me how I know if you want. You won't enjoy the answer.”

Elurín’s eyes were growing wider and wetter. “I'm not sick.”

Maeglin bit down on the reply he wanted to give Mairon.

“I'm not sick! Ada never made me eat nasty food when I was sick!”

“Mairon just wants to make sure you don't get sick,” Maeglin soothed. “What if we fix this with a little maple sugar?”

Mairon caught his wrist and took the jar from him. “A little. If it means you'll eat.”

Elurín looked doubtful, but he nodded once, and with some careful consideration, Mairon spooned out what seemed a paltry amount to Maeglin. It did the trick, though, and Maeglin resigned himself to his own bowl.

“I'll make you something else if you want,” Mairon offered silently.

“It’s fine,” Maeglin assured him. “I doubt he’ll keep eating if he sees me with something else.”

“Later?”

Maeglin shrugged and swallowed another spoonful. It wasn't so bad with the sugar. “Thank you,” he murmured aloud. “I wouldn't have known there was danger to avoid.”

Mairon poked half-heartedly at the fire.

“Is your throat all right? I saw you were coughing blood, earlier.”

“Too much of Melian. I'll be fine. It's more unpleasant than damaging.”

Maeglin wondered if that was entirely true, but he didn't push. He tucked Elurín into his own bed for the night; he hadn’t used it since his fight with Mairon. They could rearrange later. He was prepared to sit and keep Elurín company for a while, but the boy was asleep the moment he grew still. Such exhaustion was kinder, Maeglin thought, than lying awake with grief, and he was grateful for it for Elurín's sake. He pulled the blankets a little higher over him and blew out the rushlight. The Moon was glinting through the windows, and that was enough to find his way.

The aches he had tried to tune out all day were catching up to him as he made his way downstairs; his shoulders burned and every little movement set pain gnawing at his hands. At the bottom Mairon was pacing back and forth. He rounded on Maeglin immediately.

“You lied to me.”

Maeglin’s stomach twisted. He couldn't deal with this tonight. “About Lúthien? I didn't mean to hide it. You never brought her up.”

“Not that. The forest boundary. All this time, you had me believe you’d bound me.” He grabbed Maeglin’s arm and pulled him close, staring down at him with a predator’s eyes. “All this time I've tread so very carefully avoiding where I thought the borders might be, and it was for nothing.”

“Let go. That hurts.”

Mairon released him as quickly as a hot coal. Turning away, Maeglin rubbed at the imprint of Mairon's biting fingers and tried not to think of how desperately he’d wanted a different kind of reunion. “I'm sorry. I was going to, I just—I couldn't—I’m sorry.”

“Stop wilting away at the slightest push!” he growled. “If you're going to make choices for me, the least you can do is stand by them!”

Wearily Maeglin raised his eyes to meet Mairon’s. “I don't understand you tonight. I said I'm sorry. I'm going to bed.”

“What's even the point of all that power you hold if you don't have the balls to use it?”

Maeglin stopped. “I shouldn’t have to,” he said quietly. “I shouldn't have to enforce anything on you. It shouldn't matter whether you're bound or not. You offered me your obedience, and I told you not to leave my domain.”

Mairon's lips curled in a sneering grin. “So there is steel in there somewhere. I was starting to wonder if I'd imagined it all. You could be a proper little tyrant if you tried harder. Go on, then. Tell me how little my convenience matters. Tell me you don't care how angry I am.”

“But I do care. When you're angry it's terrifying and upsetting, and I'm not going to pretend otherwise for the sake of—whatever game this is.”

“Well, I'm not going to pretend not to be angry.” Mairon's teeth were bared, but the light in his eyes seemed more excitement than fury now. He leaned in. “So what are you going to do about it?”

“Is…that what you want? To…to be put in your place?”

Mairon’s threatening smile never slipped. “Or are you nothing but big words, princeling?”

“I won't.”

“Am I nothing to you?!” The Maia's tone turned frantic, and Maeglin wasn’t sure where he'd misstepped.

“Why would you think that?! What have I ever said or done—”

“Because it appears I have lost so much favor that I am not even worth the effort of punishment.”

“That isn't—”

“What do you want from me?! What are you waiting for?” Mairon started pacing again. “Am I supposed to grovel first? Is that it?” He turned to Maeglin. “You were right.” He spat the words with great distaste, but once they left him, they seemed to take all his rage with them, and he looked diminished; uncertain and fragile. “Does that satisfy you? You were right. Everything you said about me. I don't know what I'm doing. I can't fix things for you. I can't put you back and make you well again. I can't make things right, and you won't punish me. How are we supposed to live like that?!”

Maeglin hastily reconsidered everything he'd thought about the conversation. “And you couldn't just talk to me instead of picking a fight? Is that why you wouldn't stay home?”

“I don't deserve to be near you.” Mairon couldn't look at him. “You’re angry and you shouldn't have to deal with my failures. I knew that I wanted you, that you were unbelievably precious, and I hurt you anyway, and now your life and your body are ruined because of me and it's all my fault, and you won't even punish me!”

Maeglin reached for him tentatively, but he flinched from Maeglin’s touch.

“Is there no way back from failure with you?”

The question hurt Maeglin’s heart. He kept his silence. Too many words and feelings and thoughts were crowding his mind, and he didn't want to give way to the wrong ones. Mairon looked increasingly anxious, but he didn't push Maeglin to speak before he was ready, and that, more than anything, gave him courage. “Come with me,” he said at last. “I can't keep standing like this.”

Mairon padded after him into the kitchen. Maeglin sat upon the hearth and patted the stones beside him, but instead Mairon knelt before him. Gingerly Maeglin leaned back and stretched, wincing as his tight ribs creaked.

“You’ve been hurting all day again and pretending you don't?”

“You said it was important. And it was.”

Mairon sighed and bowed his head.

“I'm not refusing to punish you because I don't think you're good enough to bother with,” Maeglin said carefully. “That's what you assumed?”

“Why else?”

“I don't believe punishment is a terribly good solution most of the time. Especially not for someone you love and care about.” He very deliberately wasn't thinking of his father. He didn't need to add anything to the mess of his emotions.

“I know you're squeamish. I know you think my master was too harsh. It doesn't have to be bloody. There are other ways—”

“What ways? Sure, I've given extra duties to people who were making nuisances of themselves. Is that what you're after? You’re already doing far more than your portion of the work so we can survive here. You already are addressing what your actions brought about, which is all I'd ever demand. And…I would never want you to come to think of taking care of me as a punishment. That would…it would feel horrible. I couldn't abide it.” He studied Mairon and the thick tangle of shame and distress roiling around his mind. “No. You still meant pain.”

A morose little sound escaped Mairon, and his fingers tightened on his thighs.

“I have no desire to see you suffer. I don't want to be a person who hurts other people because I'm angry and disappointed. I don't think it would improve things.”

“So you are, then. Angry and disappointed. You don't get it. I'm suffering now, and punishing me would end it.”

“Dear one…”

Mairon shuddered.

A knot of dread was tying itself tighter in his stomach. “I'm not Melkor.”

“Believe me, I am very aware.”

“Do you want to…”

“Stop asking me that. Please,” Mairon said before he could finish.

“You have to stop asking me to be him,” Maeglin murmured almost too softly to hear. “You have to stop expecting it.”

“I don't know how to do this. If I can't help but fail, and I can't be punished for it—I—” Quietly, without moving to hide or stem his tears, Mairon began to cry. Threading his fingers into Mairon's hair, Maeglin gently pulled him down to lay his head in his lap. “How do I come back from that if you give me no way to pay my debts? How is anything supposed to be right between us ever again?”

He coughed, and Maeglin saw there was still blood. He stroked Mairon's hair and let his fingers trail down his back.

“It's been so long since I got anything right,” Mairon whispered through his tears. “I'm so tired. I'm tired of always failing. Of never being enough.”

“You left all that behind.”

Mairon scoffed. “I haven't done any better since. I did a shit job of rescuing you. You only needed to be rescued because of me. I had to rescue you from me.”

Maeglin couldn't argue with that.

“Tell me what to do. If you aren't willing to punish me, tell me how to make it right. Please.”

“I...I think…we both just have to take care of each other—and Elurín, now—and do our best to make each other's life happy and comfortable. I’m not sure there's any right left in the world beyond that. For us, anyway. That's all I ask. It's all I really want. That you're here with me. That you try.” He drew a careful breath, his fingers tightening in Mairon's hair. “Please don't leave me alone again.”

Mairon looked up in weary disbelief. “But you were angry.”

“You were being cruel and unfair.”

“Yes, that's not…” He sighed and hid his face again, mumbling into Maeglin's shirt. “He never wanted to see me when he was angry. Not until he was done punishing me. And you wouldn't.”

“I thought you'd decided I wasn’t worth being around anymore.”

Mairon surged upright and cupped Maeglin's face in both hands. “Stop that. Who taught you no one could want you?”

“Not many people ever really did. I’m not very pleasant to be around. Or so they say.”

“But they're wrong. I told you I'm yours, and I don't go back on that easily.”

Maeglin couldn't watch his earnest expression. “It's different now, though. You said yourself. I'm ruined.”

“Sweetling…”

“What if I can never manage a hammer again?” Maeglin pressed. “What if I can never go down a mine?”

Touching him with great care, Mairon raised Maeglin's fingers to his lips. “Then I'll be exceedingly sorry I took that away from you. It's not…I…” He paused. “Those aren't the only reasons I care for you. It…isn't all you are. My loyalty does not rest on your hammer skills. And if nothing changes…if you need it...I'll be your hands. There's work we can share that you don't have to carry out yourself. We’ll deal with it together.” He fell silent, searching Maeglin’s expression. “Will that be enough?”

Maeglin leaned forward and kissed him, soft and long. “Yes,” he whispered. “It will.”


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment