New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Maeglin fell asleep beside the fire with an armful of warm, furry wolf pressed against him. When he woke, he'd been moved, thick stack of quilts and all, to a settle in the great hall. He tried to stretch, but his feet met the carved oak of the armrest. Slowly the day before came back to him. He had a child now. How was that supposed to work? How was he to care for someone so small and helpless and alone when he could barely take care of himself? His throat tightened at the immensity of it all.
Sounds drifted from the kitchen: voices he couldn't quite make out and the clink of silverware on dishes. Mairon was still there. He'd stayed, like he'd said he would. No. Sauron was there, the former lieutenant of Morgoth, and Maeglin had left him alone with a child. Just because he felt reasonably sure Mairon was no danger to him—He forced himself into motion, caught his breath with a pained whimper, and gingerly lowered himself back onto the settle. Bit by bit he adjusted his position until, if he focused on keeping his ribs still, he could breathe with only a little discomfort.
He'd have to leave Mairon to it, whether or not he deserved his trust. He reminded himself that Elurín wouldn't be there at all if not for Mairon. And hadn’t he sworn his loyalty? If he didn't believe it would extend to those under Maeglin’s protection, how much did it really mean? The hard back of the settle kept him from turning over, and the fierce ache in his hands was gnawing its way up his arms, but he nestled deeper under the blankets, and in moments he was once more asleep.
The next time he opened his eyes, Elurín was sitting on the floor, watching him intently. “You’re awake!”
Maeglin groaned and rubbed his eyes. The cast of the dim light told him it was past noon already, but he felt like he’d barely rested at all. “Sure.”
“Mairon said you were sick and I had to be very quiet until you woke up.”
“Nice of him. Nice of you.”
Elurín nodded. His eyes were red, but his face had been washed clean of any tears. Mairon’s patience must be exceptional today. “Are you a peredhel like me?”
“No, my parents were both Elves.”
“Oh. I thought Elves didn't get sick.”
“Not very often. But it can happen sometimes.”
“Did you know Mairon is in my Grandmama's and Grandda's story? He used to be Sauron, and he had Grandda locked up in his tower, and Grandmama came with Huan-the-hound-of-Oromë, and he turned into a wolf to fight Huan, but Huan grabbed him by the throat and held him down and shook him until he was crying like a little baby, and he had to give Grandmama his tower, and that's how she rescued Grandda.”
“He told you that?” Maeglin really ought to get the whole story sometime. He’d wondered last night how they would handle Mairon’s identity and promptly pushed the whole mess away to deal with later. He hadn’t expected Mairon to simply reveal himself.
“Well, no. That's how Ada told me. Mairon said that Morgoth captured him a long time ago and turned him into Sauron and made him do all sorts of bad things, and after Grandmama defeated him and took his tower away, Morgoth dragged him back to Angband and put him in chains, and then you came and snuck into Angband just like Grandmama and stole him away and set him free, and now he lives with you and never has to be Sauron or do bad things again. And that's what made you sick, because you went to Angband to save him.”
“Ah. I see.”
“Did you fight werewolves?!”
“Oh, no. The werewolves love Mairon, so they helped us. They even let me pet them. And then they ate up all the orcs who chased after us.”
Elurín leaned closer and whispered, though he wasn't actually much quieter. “Mairon let me pet him when he was still a wolf this morning. Did you know his ears are very soft?”
Maeglin smiled. “They are very soft.”
“Eluréd and me were going to get our own dog for our begetting day. A little one with soft, droopy ears like Nana's. But—but that was before…” His face crumpled, and broken sobs quickly followed his tears.
“Oh, sweetheart.” Maeglin eased himself upright, though pain still stole his breath. “Do you want me to hold you?”
After a moment, Elurín nodded and clambered into his lap. Maeglin kept him there until he ran out of tears.
*
“That's quite a story you told Elúrin.” Maeglin seated himself near the hearth where Mairon was preparing dinner.
For a moment, Mairon looked confused. “About how I came to be here? The child needed an explanation that would satisfy him and make him feel safe. So I gave him one.”
“I notice very little of it was true.”
Mairon scoffed. “Come, now. You were a lord of Elves and a councillor in the Hidden City. Don't pretend you don't understand what's required to manage people.”
“I didn’t generally rely on making things up completely.”
“Are you going to criticize every decision I make? What was I supposed to say? ‘Hello, small child, I'm the scary bad man from your bedtime stories?’ Pretend I'm someone else entirely and deal with the terror and betrayal when he starts asking too many questions? I thought you’d be glad I’d handled it.”
“No, I didn’t...that’s not where I meant this to go. Sorry. I am glad. I only…I would've liked to be consulted before gaining a whole new feat of bravery I could never actually live up to.”
Mairon pursed his lips as he added a handful of crumbled dry herbs to the thin soup he was stirring. They smelled distinctly medicinal. “You showed great bravery in my hands. And after. That took every bit as much as in the version I told.”
The quiet reply unsettled him. “I suppose you tell me what you want me to believe, too. Am I so easily managed?”
Setting down the ladle, Mairon finally turned to him. “There is little I could hide from you, Maeglin, if you ever put aside your qualms and turned your full gaze upon me.”
“I don't know what you mean. You keep your mind quite capably closed off.”
Mairon said nothing.
“It doesn't work like that!”
Turning back to his soup, Mairon tasted it and added a little salt. “This’ll be ready by the time we've dragged our new charge to the table.”
Maeglin considered arguing, but if the Maia was going to be stubborn, he decided there was little point. “I'll see where he's gotten to.”
It didn't take him long. With a moment's thought, he could feel the boy's presence like a spot of brightness against his eyelids. Elurín sat outside on the front stoop, next to the massive old yew growing against the side of the house, and the tree offered its senses to Maeglin readily. It knew the child for his and drew branches closer to shelter him. Maeglin opened the door and paused. Elúrin clutched a massive stick that must have been at least as tall as he was and stared intently into the forest. The yew was catching most of the snow before it could reach him, but a few flakes had collected in his hair.
“Elúrin?”
He jumped.
“Ah. Sorry to scare you.”
Elúrin looked up and scowled. “I didn't hear you!”
“I'm very quiet. An old habit.” He carefully lowered himself to the ground. “What are you up to out here?”
“Guarding.”
Maeglin’s heart twisted at that, but he tried not to reveal it. Perhaps that's what all children played at these days, with what the world had come to. “I see. I'm sure you’re doing a good job of it.”
“Not really. If you snuck up on me, so could something else.”
Maeglin considered the way Elúrin was huddled around his stick, the way his eyes flicked toward the lengthening shadows. “Mairon and I aren't going to let anything bad sneak up on you here.”
Elúrin sighed, but he allowed Maeglin to put an arm around him. “It doesn't matter,” he said quietly. “I should be dead too. I want to be dead. Then I'd be with my brother again. And Ada, and Nana, and little Elwing.”
Maeglin remembered the sharp wind on his face as he looked down from Caragdûr night after night after night, and how nothing Turgon said to him had ever felt anything but laughable. “They'll be waiting in Mandos a long, long time, and I think they'll be hoping you don't join them there too soon.”
“Not Eluréd. What will he do without me? He’ll be so lonely.”
“I'm sure he misses you horribly. But he’s got your Ada and Nana and…your little sister?”
Elúrin nodded.
“They'll all look after him and keep him company. And maybe he can see you sometimes in Vairë's tapestries.” Maeglin wondered if any of the stories were true, or if everyone simply repeated them as he was doing now, to dull a pain that could not be quenched.
“Will Ada have his head back?”
“I'm sure he will,” Maeglin lied.
“But what about me?” Elúrin whispered. His sniffles became outright sobs that shook him as he pressed himself into Maeglin's chest. “Maybe I could die of sadness like Grandmama. I bet I could if I tried.”
“Well. Maybe.” Maeglin had seen people die of grief, after the Nirnaeth. Some wasted away in a despondence they could not break. The determined ones went faster. “But even if you really want to, it doesn’t have to happen right away. You can always die later, you know? There's always next week, or next month, or next year, and maybe in the meantime you'll find something you want to stick around for. Just for a while.”
“I don't think there's anything.” He rubbed his face on Maeglin’s shirt while he thought. “But I guess I could wait. If it's just for a while.”
“Just for right now, you might feel a tiny bit better if we go have supper together. What do you think?”
Elúrin made a face. “Only if it's better supper than last night.”
“I'll make sure of it.”
*
Later that night, when he'd tucked Elurín into the bed Mairon had prepared for him in what had been a guest room long ago (though Maeglin couldn't remember any guests staying in it), he came back to the kitchen to finish washing up while Mairon swept the hearth and banked the fire to last the night.
“I would have taken care of that,” Mairon groused. “I don't need you making yourself worse.”
“I can manage this much. The hot water’s good for my hands, I think.”
“Good. Then you won't be needing me to warm them later.”
Maeglin contained the words that scrambled up his throat. He was beginning to suspect Mairon was at his most snappish when he was feeling panicky and insecure, but he pushed down the deep-seated need to leap to smooth things over and soothe him. He would not fear his Maia's moods.
“You've been unhappy all evening,” Mairon spat when Maeglin went on washing silently. “What have I done now?”
“I'm worried about Elurín,” Maeglin answered, a little proud of how steady and calm he kept his voice. “He told me earlier he wants to die.”
“Oh.” A chair was shoved into place under the table with more force than Maeglin could imagine was necessary. “Well that’s easily dealt with.”
“Is it?”
“We bind his fëa; I developed enchantments for that long ago. He can't slip away by grief or pain or distress then, and any injury will take longer to—but. There are some…deleterious effects. On the mind. And sense of independent will. Which is why I never used it on you. So…you probably don't want that.”
“It sounds like it wouldn't achieve what I'm looking for, no.”
In silence Mairon finished sweeping, then joined Maeglin at the sink, taking each dish from him and drying it. “I don't understand Elvish children well,” he said after a while. “But I have seen Elves survive things you wouldn’t believe out of sheer stubborn spite.” He chewed his lip. “I'll talk to him tomorrow, if you want.”
Maeglin hesitated—Sauron. I am talking about a child’s wellbeing to Sauron—then shrugged. “It can't be worse than the foolishness that was all I had for him.”
Mairon glanced at him with narrowed eyes, but said nothing. When the last dish was put away, he hung up his towel with perfect, even folds. Watching him filled Maeglin with the sort of quiet he usually only found underground. Sauron, he insisted again. The soft, settled feeling didn't leave, and it couldn't even be shaken by Mairon's prickliness. There was definitely something wrong with him.
“I didn't mean what I said about your hands,” Mairon offered without turning fully to meet him. “If you’re in pain, of course I'll—”
“I'm always in pain now,” Maeglin corrected. “But it isn't actually bad this moment. Thank you, all the same.”
A shadow crossed Mairon’s face, but he didn't argue. “Your bed upstairs is freshly made and ready for you. We did a lot of cleaning and rearranging while you slept, the child and I.”
“Thank you for that, too. I…Mairon—it means a lot, all you’re doing for me. I don't think I've said it enough. I'm very grateful.”
Mairon scoffed. “You expect too little.” But a redness lingered about his ears that Maeglin didn't think had been there before.
Maeglin started toward the stairs, but stopped when Mairon didn't follow. “Aren't you coming with me?” He held out his hand.
A terrible, aching hopefulness shone for a moment in his eyes before he snuffed it out. “You'll be plenty warm without me. I've imposed on you enough.”
“But I like having you there.”
“I'm going to find you your own wolf fur so you don't need mine.” His features began to lengthen as his fingers curved into paws.
“Mairon.” Maeglin couldn't see any farther into his mind, but he felt certain for once he was reading the Maia aright. “It's fine if you’re more comfortable that way. But you're welcome in my bed just as you are.”
The wolfishness retreated. He breathed a small “Oh,” and without another word, he took Maeglin’s hand and let him lead.
*
Maeglin never discovered exactly what Mairon said to Elurín, but they took up daily sword lessons together, in easy, short sessions at first. Mairon crafted him a wooden practice sword that balanced and swung like the finest of blades, and Elurín carried it everywhere. He seemed to grow stronger day by day, though he spent many hours in weeping, and soon Mairon declared him ready to eat whatever he liked and to train harder. Maeglin kept a close watch on Mairon’s teaching, but though he was at times both stern and demanding, he was never cruel, and his eyes often wandered to Maeglin's as if to confirm he had not crossed that line.
Maeglin tried to engage Elurín in lessons of his own, writing and sums and the scraps of Sindarin history and poetry he retained; all the things a young elf prince had a right to know. But Elurín's attention was only for the sword, and he could be convinced to sit and work at other things for mere moments at a time before he slipped away and took to wandering the cold hallways like a wraith again. Most days Maeglin let him. It didn't seem worth a fight, not when he knew what kind of pain the child bore and how all-consuming it could be, nor would he ever try to beat knowledge into another person in the same house where it had been done to him. Elurín could learn when he was ready.
So the winter days blurred together, piling one atop the next, none very different from the one before, while snow piled about the house and the world around them slept.