New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Maeglin couldn’t stop crying, ragged, choking, panicked sobs that tore through his parched throat. He was bleeding from scores of tiny cuts, and every nerve in his body was screaming. It had gone on for what felt like hours of nightmarish intimacy as Mairon worked his way over every inch of his flesh with his collection of delicate blades and implements that lit deep pain wherever they passed. Maeglin had lost his capacity to speak long before the end; even if he’d wanted to betray his home, he couldn’t have done it then. Now he lay on a thin pallet in a different, equally dark and comfortless cell where Mairon had deposited him. Exhaustion and pain wore heavily upon him, and though he thought his fearful, jerky breathing would deny him rest, he sank at last into an uneasy sleep.
The Maia was sitting on the floor beside him watching when he woke. Maeglin shrank away until his back touched the wall and he hissed in pain.
“I’m sorry about that,” Mairon said softly. “I would have liked to give you more time to think it over, but I couldn’t afford to look too gentle. It might get you taken from me.”
Maeglin blinked up at him incredulously.
“I did warn you. You shouldn’t have made it necessary.”
“Give me water.” His throat hurt with the effort of speaking.
Mairon considered. “All right. But don’t get used to it. If you don’t decide to comply, you won’t be getting it often.”
Maeglin said no more, and after a moment Mairon rose and stepped outside. He returned with a cup in his hand, and he put an arm under Maeglin to help him sit and held the water to his lips. He wouldn’t let Maeglin gulp it down all at once the way he wanted, but made him take it in slow sips. This close, he could see the soft glow of the Maia’s eyes. When he emptied the cup, Mairon filled it again, and by the end of the second one, Maeglin was beginning to feel slightly less terrible.
“I loved you.” He didn’t think he could lie to himself here. Mairon held him and didn’t answer. “I loved you, and I saved your life.”
“And I’m very grateful for what you did for me.” Mairon sounded like he had on the mountainside. Sincere. Caring. Maeglin resolved not to be fooled by him. He couldn’t afford to trust him ever again. “But I can’t let my attachments get in the way of serving my lord. You have to understand that.” He moved back, careful not to jostle Maeglin’s aching body. “I would like nothing better than to shower you in favor and be your dear friend once more. But I can’t do that until you tell me what you know.”
“But I don’t know anything. I’ve never heard of that place—what did you call it?” His voice wavered annoyingly. It didn’t sound convincing, even to him.
Mairon laughed gently. “Oh no. You’ve already confirmed you’re who I need. People who really don’t know anything tend to start screaming that right away. They don’t summon up that beautiful defiance.”
Maeglin winced. He’d fucked up already, without even noticing.
“But truthfully…where else could you have come from? We’d driven the last bandits from Taur-nu-Fuin some years before.” He reached for Maeglin’s hands and clasped them soothingly, and Maeglin realized they were the only parts of him that didn’t hurt. “It’ll be all right,” Mairon continued. “I’m sure there must be a few people there you care about and don’t want to see harmed, but it will only be worse for them the longer this war is dragged out. Let me bring them under their rightful king, and you could reign as their prince, answering to me. You can help them. It doesn’t have to be the end of everything you know. It will be painful at first, but the world is going to be better for it.”
Maeglin shook his head. “What makes you think I would ever be willing to serve you after this?”
Mairon laid a warm hand on his cheek, and Maeglin found himself leaning into the touch. He shuddered, but didn’t pull away. “Love can survive a little pain. We’ll look back on this time and laugh someday. You’ll ask why you ever refused me.”
“I’m not going to help you destroy my home.”
“You realize I can’t allow you to say no.” The Maia’s voice turned cold and bitter, but Maeglin caught a frantic note that he tried to hide.
You’re afraid, he thought.
“I will have to change your mind, and you won’t enjoy it.”
Very carefully, Maeglin traced the edge of the bruise on Mairon’s face. “Did he hit you?”
Mairon jerked back. He couldn’t fully suppress his pained gasp at the sharp motion. “It’s none of your business.” He flexed his hand, tucked it behind him, then gave in and raised it to adjust the golden band around his neck.
A clarity Maeglin had rarely known was settling upon him, as if every step in an impenetrable dance were unfolding itself in sequence, and he had only to follow. He pressed closer. “I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to startle you. Is that hurting you?” He slipped a protective arm around the Maia and leaned in to inspect the gold. His breath froze. Inside the finely-wrought jewelry, sharp golden spikes pierced the Maia’s skin. Mairon had packed a strip of gauze underneath, where it couldn’t be seen, and it was crusted with his blood.
Mairon had stiffened against him, but he slowly relaxed and let himself be held. “Love can survive a little pain.” He murmured it like a well-worn litany, as though it was some kind of explanation.
“Why—what is that?!”
“My punishment.” Mairon seemed to grow in confidence as he spoke. “And one that was just. I lost my lord a Silmaril through my failures. I needed something to keep my attention on him and my duties, and away from…distractions. When I lay Gondolin at his feet, he will take it off.” He twisted out of Maeglin’s embrace and stared at him with gleaming, predatory eyes. “So you see, there is little I will quail from to obey him.”
“People who love you aren’t supposed to hurt you.” Maeglin was quiet but firm. “Not like that.”
“We’re here to discuss you and the secrets you’re going to tell me.”
“It doesn’t get better again, after he starts hitting you.”
“Have you ever seen what a whip can do to a person’s back?”
“You don’t deserve to be hurt like this.”
“Think about just how much pain you’re willing to bear for people who don’t care about you,” Mairon spat as he stood. “Think about it very hard before we speak next.” He shut the door loudly behind him, and Maeglin heard the lock click. He laid his head back against the wall and took long, slow breaths. The darkness closed in, so thick he could almost choke on it.
*
The light hurt his eyes. The orc who had come to fetch Maeglin jerked him roughly to his feet, paying no mind to the way he swore and tried to shield himself from the torch’s glare while his hands were bound behind him. Mairon met them at the flung-wide double doors of a vast smithy. Maeglin knew the smell of coal smoke before he set foot inside, and a wave of longing for his days in Dwarven cities tugged at him. No coal had been found in Gondolin’s mountains. Their forges burned charcoal made from coppiced hazel and willow, stands of cultivated trees whose fellings and regrowings ran on carefully calculated cycles of years. He hadn’t smelled a coal fire since his childhood, and he wished fiercely that he could close his eyes and be there again instead.
Mairon fell in beside him, but the orc did not release him, gripping Maeglin’s arm uncomfortably tight to propel him wherever Mairon chose. “All this and more will be yours to use as you please as soon as you’ve shared what I need,” Mairon said without further greeting. “Come, let me show you some of the equipment I’ve invented to speed my work.”
He acted as if the orc steering Maeglin were invisible, and Maeglin couldn’t shake the surreality of it. He stayed silent as Mairon explained his inventions and demonstrated each machine. Now that he knew what he was watching for, he could see how gingerly the Maia moved. He’d always been preternaturally graceful, but today every step and every gesture seemed calculated to keep the collar he wore from sliding or shifting on his neck. Maeglin wondered how he managed to forge with it on, or if every hammer stroke was an agony Mairon simply accepted. He remembered the time his father had struck him and knocked him into the anvil hard enough to break his rib, and how he’d been made to keep working anyway, each breath a fresh stab in his side.
“Are you listening to me at all?” Mairon demanded, pulling him from memories.
“Little hard to concentrate when I’m hungry, thirsty, and in fear for my life.”
“It’s your choice to suffer those things, and you can end them whenever you want.”
“That’s not a real choice.”
“You’re the only one I have who could truly appreciate this part of my work. No one else can understand the art of it, and my Master—” He shook his head. He looked so upset that Maeglin wanted to reach out and ask him to say it all again, but he quickly caught himself.
“You lost any right to my appreciation when you forced me here and tortured me.” It felt too easy still, this back and forth, despite his anger, despite the wrongness of what they discussed.
Mairon’s eyes narrowed. “Then I suppose there’s no point in dragging this out.”
With a wave of his hand, he gave an order, and the orc hauled Maeglin across the smithy and into a smaller room, where he stripped off Maeglin’s shirt and tied him to a waiting upright frame with his back bared to the open space. Maeglin heard Mairon’s familiar footsteps a few minutes later. He was shaking already, and he flinched when Mairon laid a hand on his shoulder.
“I don’t want you to be so afraid, my dear,” he murmured in Maeglin’s ear. “I don’t want you to need to be afraid. But this is a terrifying experience. It has to be. It’s going to be incredibly painful, and it would be untrue and against my purposes to let you think otherwise.”
A soft whimper slipped from Maeglin’s throat, and he bit down on his lip. Mairon’s touch was steadying, and he hated that it should feel so.
“All the comforts in my possession will be yours if you’ll let me end this.”
“I’m not stopping you,” Maeglin whispered. “And there is no comfort for betraying my people.”
Mairon sighed. He thoroughly checked over the restraints around Maeglin’s wrists, testing the tightness and the position, then ran the edge of his nail over Maeglin’s fingertips. “Can you feel that? With each finger?”
“Yes?”
“Good. We wouldn’t want anything going numb.”
Maeglin’s bemusement faded quickly when Mairon stepped away. He took a deep breath and tried to brace himself. The first lash cut across his back like a line of fire, and he couldn’t withhold a little cry. He’d thought it wouldn’t be so much worse than his father’s belt, but he’d been wrong. Or maybe he’d just gotten used to not being hurt.
“When my father married my mother, he told her she wouldn’t see the Sun again.” He spoke in gasps between blows, words he’d spent hours in the darkness crafting and rehearsing with the vision of the cruel band Mairon wore ever in his thoughts.
Mairon paused. “Are you ready to talk, then?”
“She thought he didn’t really mean it, and that it was an agreement she could live with for a while.”
“Is this leading up to Gondolin?”
“For a while, life was good, and he seemed caring and considerate. But he kept cutting off more and more of her world over the years. Tightening his control. The first time I know of that he hit her, I was sixteen and had slipped and said a Quenya name in front of him. Once he started though, it got easier, and he did it more. She begged, once, to come with us to Nogrod. He told her she wasn’t allowed out of the forest, because he didn’t trust her to be good.”
Maeglin swallowed hard. His mouth was dry, and it hurt to speak so much after days of silence. Squaring his shoulders, he drew on everything he’d learned in persuading Turgon’s council. “I realized, eventually, it was never going to get better. And I realized it was because when he looked at her, he didn’t see a partner, someone with whom he could exchange love and trust and care. He didn’t see a person, not really. He saw a thing. A possession. Something for him to control and use and mistreat when it didn’t do as he wanted. And it couldn’t get better, because as long as he saw us as possessions, he was never going to care about our opinions or our desires or our choices. He didn’t care whether she loved him as much as whether she obeyed. And he couldn’t love her the way she wanted to be loved, as a person, as someone he respected.”
“A sad story. I’m still waiting.”
“Are you a person to the master you love so much? Or are you one more thing he owns?”
Mairon didn’t answer, but he brought the whip down hard.
“I don’t think he sees you.”
Another searing agony.
“I don’t think he cares.”
Blood was running down his skin and drying in sticky trails.
“He isn’t ever going to return your love.”
The next strike wrapped around his ribs and caught the tender flesh over his side. Maeglin screamed, and whatever else he might have said fled his mind. He wanted it to stop. He needed it to stop. He wasn’t sure he could endure another moment, and it would be so easy to end it.
Maeglin pushed that thought away as hard as he could. He’d endured as a child, and if this was many times harsher, he was stronger now too. He’d prepared for this. A rhyme he’d often recited silently to himself to escape from a beating, if only in his mind, was there and ready for him, and he sang it under his breath, grabbing onto the words and the rhythm and focusing on them like a shield.
“Oak and beech whose branches sway
Where only starlight touches loam
Hear me, hide me, guide my way
Shelter me and bring me home.”
He reached the end and repeated it, letting the dark, comforting branches overhead and the sound of trees singing in the breeze fill his thoughts. Every blow now fell where his back already burned and throbbed, and he started to wonder how bad it would be if Gondolin were attacked. Plans for surviving a siege had been laid long ago, and were updated and stores maintained every few years. No no no. You can’t. You can’t even think it. He started one of his favorite songs from when he’d first come to the city, a ballad of Maedhros and Fingon he’d sung constantly during his work.
“Then Fingon rode from farthest West
The Sun shone brightly on his crest
Beloved of Manwë, archer fair
Golden ribbons in his hair
He came where Maedhros mourning hung
And to his bow an arrow strung
But greater mercy heard his prayer
Beyond the seas, above the air—
“Beyond the seas, above—above the…” He didn’t remember the rest. Nothing but pain existed anymore, and he hoped for nothing.
When Mairon finally released him, he stumbled and almost fell. Mairon held him up and brought him back to his cell himself, letting Maeglin lean against his side, still sobbing and barely aware of anything but how much he hurt. He stayed by Maeglin’s side, stroking his hair while he slowly calmed.
“Why do you sing of Maedhros, little smith? Do you really think anyone will show up to save you?”
Maeglin hazily gathered his scattered thoughts. Everything felt fuzzy and far away. Vaguely he wondered if it were possible to be drunk on pain. “Fingon came for him even though Maedhros betrayed and abandoned him.”
“No one’s coming for you.”
“No. I don’t expect they are. But I would carry you away if you’d let me.”
A complicated mix of emotions passed over Mairon’s face. “You’re not Fingon here.”
“I didn’t think so, back then. I used to…to dream of being Maedhros, when I was new in—” He cut himself off from the forbidden name. Too close. Too dangerous. “I dreamed someone who loved me would steal me away from my grief and scoop me into their arms and make everything better.” He coughed and wiped at his face. “I still want that. But I’m older and stronger now, and I think—I know if I could give that to someone else, I would be very happy.”
“Fingon died alone on a battlefield because of his ill-chosen devotion to Maedhros. That’s the reward for people like him. That’s what happens when you let feelings warp your judgment.”
Maeglin couldn’t quite parse what was wrong with his words. Maybe Mairon was right. Maybe it didn’t matter. “Are you going to kill me?”
“I don’t want to.” He twisted the rings on his fingers, red gems glittering in the light of Mairon’s lantern. “I can’t afford to fail him again,” he whispered.
“When’s the last time anyone touched you tenderly?” Maeglin softly asked. His Maia looked miserable, and he didn’t like it.
Mairon stared at him, wordless.
“Here.” He opened his arms, and the Maia hesitantly crawled into them. Maeglin cradled him close, careful of his neck, nestling Mairon against his chest. It was better like this; if nothing could save him, at least he could comfort his friend. Quietly the Maia began to weep. Maeglin pressed a gentle kiss to the top of his head and let his own tears fall on the Maia’s hair.