Fun and Games... by Grundy  

Elrond - Never Have I Ever - Considered Choosing Mortality

Elrond sighed. He had always expected it would be difficult to explain the Choice to his children. They would be curious, of course. It was inevitable.

He just didn’t know how to explain to Arwen that his choice had been far different than theirs. It hadn’t been something he had grown up with or always known of, it had simply been sprung on him and his brother suddenly, with no warning, and the expectation of a swift response.

He had never considered mortality in any seriousness. He had been among elves all his life. It hadn’t even been a question.