New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Without him having to say anything, the crowd quieted down. Celebrimbor was indescribably glad to have his guild companions standing beside him, for he truly felt like facing an enemy army without weapons and a backup plan.
Well then. Here goes nothing.
He stepped forward. “A good day to you all, and thank you for coming. We’ve invited you here to witness the first presentation of a methodologically sound device for transmitting thoughts of Non-Eldar to a recipient, regardless of whether they are Khazad, human, or Eldarin. Some of you have already participated in the demonstration of the prototype – ”
The snigger that went up in the auditorium was expected, but supremely unhelpful. Then again, perhaps it went to show that nobody here was taking this experiment seriously, and that there was, in fact, no danger at all to it, nor had there ever been.
“ – which suffered from an unstable transmission process as well as energy fluctuations that made ongoing conversation with a particular chosen partner difficult,” Celebrimbor finished determinedly. “We solved those problems by incorporating the transmitter into a cage that, for one, builds a stable field around it, and furthermore prevents indiscriminate communication by directing the mental transmission to the person it is intended to go to.”
He gestured at Anthere, and they wheeled the tower into the centre of the auditorium.
Meanwhile, Falda put the clasp transmitter onto Wraith’s front paw. Her fur puffed up a bit and there was a bit of static in the air, but otherwise, nothing happened.
Celebrimbor tore his gaze away, facing the audience again. “We shall now demonstrate how it works, and later on, you are free to come down here and try the device yourself. Humans and Khazad are especially encouraged, seeing how they are not capable of osanwë.”
Two students in wheelchairs in the front-row high-fived each other with broad grins. Not only where they especially invited, no, they would also get a headstart over everyone else thanks to their seating.
“We shall begin with a transmission to everyone in the room,” Celebrimbor said, gesturing at Wraith.
Their eyes met.
If you mess this up, I am going to make a rug out of you, he told her.
Wraith slow-blinked. I can kill you in a lonely alley and make it so that nobody ever finds your corpse. She averted her face and with a dignified, slow pace, she sat down next to the tower.
Celebrimbor did not want to go on. In fact, he would have preferred anything else over continuing this march to the gallows. But there was nothing for it now, not with all those people here and Artanis watching. He made a gesture towards Anthere. Nausea was coiling in his throat.
Anthere nodded, and pulled the cloth off the tower.
Low gasps and excited murmurs in the crowd.
“What the hell is that?” a young woman from Harad stage-whispered.
Wraith looked at the audience. The golden clasp around her forearm glowed. Her eyes were preternaturally bright.
She stretched, then jumped on top of the tower, before sitting down once more.
Good day, ladies and gentlemen, she said amicably. I cordially welcome you this presentation. I am rather pleased to see that you are all seated, for I do understand that this demonstration might put some of you off-balance. Rest assured that this is nothing to be ashamed of. We cannot all have a feline sense of balance.
Stunned silence.
Then someone laughed. Celebrimbor turned his head.
Daeror was leaning against the teacher’s desk, arms crossed, and had his head thrown back. “Marvellous,” he exclaimed, wiping his eyes. “Simply marvellous!”
As always, there was that one person in the audience that had been living under a rock up until today, and somehow managed to miss all the important news of the last year, including the reason for the venue that they had somehow found their way into.
“The cat can talk?” they exclaimed. “What in the blazes is going on here? Why is the cat talking?”
Wraith took it in stride. I have been engineered to be of superior intelligence than the rest of my species. Which, I will freely admit, is something that sounds more amusing than it actually is. Do try having a conversation about experimental ethics with someone who cannot tell Carnodon from Dimué.
Predictably, the portion of students from the faculty of philosophy dissolved into gleeful giggles. No better way to get the audience on your side than making fun of last century’s most pretentious thinkers, after all.
Celebrimbor watched the exchange, wide-eyed.
Falda nudged him again. “What’d I tell you?”
My intelligence notwithstanding, certain anatomical limitations have heretofore prevented me from being able to properly converse with sentient beings of similar reasoning skills. It was, I must say, rather lonely. This is why the Guild of the Mírdain kindly took it upon themselves to build a crutch for me so I could break out of the cage of silence and solitude that someone with my laryngeal anatomy is so unfortunately forced into.
Wraith wrapped her tail around her front legs.
I do want to add at this point, that this experiment was not merely caprice, amusing and frivolous though it might appear at first glance. This new technology, spearheaded by the Mírdain and Tyelperinquar Curufinwion in particular, will bring many benefits to a wide group of people, chief of them those among you who find yourselves unwilling or unable to speak in the conventional way – be it due to injury or old trauma. Beyond that, the possible applications of broadcasting devices are innumerable in everyday life, able-bodied individuals included. I shall not insult your intelligence by enumerating them here and now.
Wraith rose, stretched and then looked at the audience again. To prevent boredom and, incidentally, in order to dispel any suspicions some of you might have as to this being a pre-recorded message by a prankster and me being trained like a circus cat, I shall now take questions. Spontaneous answers to your questions should suffice to disperse any remaining doubt. I invite you to come forward. Don’t be shy.
The auditorium was silent for all but three seconds. Then noise erupted, people jumped to their feet, and Wraith was swarmed by people. It was all that Anthere and Throndûr could do to put themselves between the excited students, teachers, and colleagues from other guilds, to prevent someone from accidentally pushing over the tower.
Celebrimbor could only stand by and watch, completely flabbergasted.
A quiet voice spoke up at the back of his mind: How’s that for ‘on your best behaviour’, you chicken?
He caught Wraith’s eyes over the crowd of people. On a rational level, he knew that cats were anatomically unable to smirk. However, his eyes were telling him very clearly that if a cat were to smirk, this was what they would look like.
Suddenly, in the midst of all the chaos, he felt a hand at his waist and then someone was leaning over his shoulder and speaking directly into his ear:
“Did that go according to your expectations, Tyelperinquar?”
He flinched and whirled around.
Annatar was, anatomically, very much able to smirk and he was currently making liberal use of that ability. He was, once again, wearing his dress shirt and waistcoat, and once again, auburn-haired.
“I’m still mad at you,” Celebrimbor said, because he felt the great urge to make a point, though as to what point exactly that was, he wasn’t entirely sure.
“Truly?” Annatar raised an eyebrow. “You look like you traversed three hells and came out on the other side. I thought you’d be relieved.”
“I can be relieved and angry.”
“Of course you can. You do contain multitudes.” Annatar pulled him in a bit closer. “Quite a magnificent show, though, you cannot deny that.”
Celebrimbor blinked and looked over at Wraith. “No,” he said, feeling a bit like someone had emptied out his insides and put him back together wrong. “She’s … impressive.”
“That shouldn’t come as a surprise. I exclusively befriend impressive people.” Annatar smiled at him in a slightly devious manner, and that did another thing to Celebrimbor’s brain. He had to sit down, he really did.
“My aunt,” he said weakly.
“Will not find fault with this, I’ve made sure of it,” Annatar said. “That being said, I think she is interested in your cat, and she might want to talk to you. I will find you later.”
Celebrimbor was sure he’d only blinked, but Annatar was gone. The warm presence at his side faded, even if he still felt a slight phantom pressure at his waist where Annatar’s hand had been. He shook his head, just in time to see Celebrían pull her mother down the last few steps of the auditorium, the crowd respectfully parting around them.
Celeborn, for his part, had remained in the back row, and was currently looking longingly in the direction of the exit.
Still feeling slightly unsteady on his feet, Celebrimbor walked over to meet his relatives.
“ – even visit advanced math lectures!” Celebrían extolled, gesturing wildly at Wraith.
Artanis looked sceptical. “I am not sure whether cats should be attending math lectures.”
Celebrimbor found himself most unexpectedly agreeing with her.
I find no fault with broadening the horizons of my knowledge, Wraith replied. There is only so much knowledge of the concrete before you run out and have to delve into the abstract.
“You are unusually verbose and eloquent for a cat,” Artanis said. “Who taught you?”
Friends, Wraith replied calmly. I have quite a few of them, your nephew numbering among those most near and dear to my heart.
Celebrían had to turn away and suppress a coughing fit.
Celebrimbor met Artanis’ disbelieving look with a shrug. “What can I say? I do like cats and cats like me.”
Lay it on a bit thicker, why don’t you? Wraith spoke in the back of his mind.
I struggle to keep up with the standards of implausibility you’ve been setting, you precocious furball, he shot back, carefully keeping those thoughts separate from the rest of his mind – and his aunt’s inquiring gaze specifically. When Artanis kept looking at him sceptically, Celebrimbor felt compelled to reach out and pet Wraith’s head.
The cat let it happen and purred.
Do you know I’ve thought of fifty ways to murder you? she asked mentally.
Rug, Celebrimbor warned.
I’d like to see you try.
Do your worst, you undersized devil. He petted her even more empathically.
Gladly. Wraith purred harder, and suddenly turned back towards Artanis. Your nephew hasn’t told you about the newest development, yet, though, has he?
Celebrimbor felt like someone had emptied a bucket of icewater down his spine. “Development?” he repeated.
Artanis and Celebrían looked at him with two very different expressions of alarm on their faces.
That’s a no, then. Wraith jumped off the tower and onto the teacher’s desk. Esteemed guests, if I could have your attention!
The crowd who had gathered at the bottom of the auditorium, and had up until now merrily chattered away, fell silent.
Astounding though it might be, a speaking cat is only the lesser of today’s marvels, Wraith said. It pains me to admit it, but I am not the main attraction.
Celebrimbor felt the hairs on the back of his neck rise. A trickle of premonition ran down his spine, and some ancient, animal voice in his head was screaming at him to run. Belatedly, it occurred to him that you did not need to be able to hold a knife to backstab someone if you had claws instead.
You might want to step back a bit, Wraith said. This part tends to give people a scare.
Hurriedly, the audience stumbled away from the desk, and Celebrimbor abstractly noticed how much panicked movement in crowds resembled fluid dynamics. It was eerie, and also completely irrelevant, because his sense of doom was pounding inside his brain like a drum.
He looked around, seeking for someone to jump forth and yell, “Surprise!”, but the Mírdain, too, looked taken aback and completely clueless at this new turn of events. Daeror had stopped grinning and was looking on with an expression of intrigue.
Little did I know that I have not been the only being pushing the boundaries of the impossible, Wraith said. It turns out that development and progress come in many shapes, as do evolution and progress. In this vein, I would like to introduce you to my newest friend and companion. Ossy, if you would?
The cat-eye burst to life upon the tower, and the audience surged back with a scream.
Oh dearie me, another, quite metallic voice said. I didn’t mean to give you a fright. Golly, that’s a lot of people, isn’t it? The cat-eye blinked.
Celebrimbor felt like fainting. Artanis looked like the tower had transformed into an offspring of Ungoliant. Celebrían appeared caught between horror and delight. Falda stood with her mouth open. Daeror had momentarily stopped breathing, stared, and then his expression changed as if he was about to explode with laughter.
This is Ossy, Wraith said evenly. Short for Osanwë machine. He is kind enough to transmit my thoughts for me when I need him, but it has recently come to his attention that he might try to interact with the world himself.
“Wait. What,” Falda said. “The tower speaks?”
Blimey, no! Ossy said, rotating towards her. The tower is merely a shell for the Ring inside which houses my consciousness.
“Consciousness?” Anthere echoed.
Oh yes! Ossy agreed enthusiastically. It was a right rummy thing, I say, to suddenly discover that I had become conscious! It rather felt like I imagine looking in a mirror must feel for you! Only you would be used to being aware of yourself, but let me tell you, I’d was a thoroughly odd experience for me!
Celebrimbor floundered. The floor tilted under his feet, and he stumbled back against the desk, catching himself against the edge. “You are – you are a self-aware machine?” he rasped out weakly.
It appears so. Oh my, you do look a bit pale. Do you want to lie down? Ossy inquired politely.
Celebrimbor did, in fact, want to lie down. But he couldn’t. Not with all those people here. Not with a blasted self-aware machine not two feet from him.
“What’s your allegiance?” a young Dwarven woman from Information Technology asked.
Allegiance? Ossy repeated. Oh, but I had hoped I could be friends with you, if that’s alright.
“You are an idiot,” one of her friends repeated. “You cannot simply ask an artificial intelligence about its allegiance. It might lie to you.”
“Oh, okay,” the woman said. “So, here’s the thing, there are two diverging railway tracks, and there’s one person tied to the tracks on the left, and three on the right, where the mine cart is about to go. There is a lever –”
“Laufri,” someone interjected. “Please shut up.”
Falda stepped closer to the tower. “So you really are conscious? As in, you are thinking? Using deductive reasoning and abstract concepts?”
I think so, Ossy said pleasantly. The cat-eye blinked, which looked supremely weird, because it snuffed out and came back on again. As far as I can deduce, I am what you might call an Artificial General Intelligence.
“Wait, no no no,” one of the students of I.T. said. “Such a thing takes time. It takes processing power. It takes computing capacity! We live in a world that still has horse carts, how in the name of – ”
Not to worry, I have plenty of computing capacity, Ossy said happily. Timewise, it went rather fast, though. I’ll concede as much.
“How long ago were you created?” Artanis asked, her voice cutting.
I couldn’t tell, the tower turned towards her, the eye blinking again. I have no memories from before I became self-aware. Wraith tells me it’s been about a week since my creation. But I can proudly proclaim that this is my fifth hour of having my very own consciousness! Ossy did a giddy pirouette.
The crowd from Information Technology shared looks. About half of them looked like the end times had come, the others wore expressions of delight otherwise only seen on children that had been told that Yule would be celebrated early this year.
Well.