New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Annatar found Daeror in his music room, which was no surprise, since the bard basically lived there, with the exception of hours that he spent annoying the Guildmembers and Annatar in particular.
For some unfathomable reason, there was a billiards table in the middle of the room right next to the grand piano, and the orchestral instruments were gathered in a half-circle around the table like schoolchildren watching and waiting for their teacher. Meanwhile, Daeror was perched at the table, a sheaf of sheet music next to him that he was scribbling away at fervently, while absent-mindedly pushing the cue ball around entire table in a perfect rhombus across three banks.
Throw. Tock. Tock. Tock. Return to the hand. Throw. Tock. Tock. Tock. Back in his hand. And again.
The bard didn’t even look up while doing so, rolling around the ball with his left hand, while filling the lines and lines of music sheets with his indecipherable handwriting with his right.
Annatar stood and waited until the bard looked up and noticed him. Which he did only after Annatar lost patience after waiting for about ten minutes without acknowledgement and cleared his throat.
Daeror had seen better days – that much could be said for any intense period of work right before he finished another piece – but it was quite pronounced this time around. His clothing and usually artfully styled hair were dishevelled, his eyes bleary, and his gaze took a few seconds to focus on Annatar.
“Well, hello there,” the bard said, a grin working itself over his tired face. “What brings you here into the venerable halls of music and melody?”
Annatar shrugged as he walked closer, dragging his finger across the open lid of the grand piano, inspecting it for dust, finding nothing, and coming to stand beside Daeror, close enough to be able to peer over his shoulder. “Nothing in particular. What are you working on?”
Daeror pulled an empty sheet over the last page he had written on. “My newest masterpiece. Which you are going to have to wait for until Yule, like everyone else.”
“Pity.” Annatar looked around the music room. “I will not ask why you are sitting at a billiards table, or the logistics or sense of getting it into the middle of a practice room intended for the orchestra. I will, however, ask why you called a conference of instruments in order to compose.”
Daeror looked at the instruments arranged in an orderly semi-circle, and frowned as if it was taking him some time to remember who put them there and why. “Ah. Well. You see, we can work on the arrangement better this way. Keeps them from talking all over each other. The violins especially tend to get disorderly. Little spotlight-hoggers. Just because they feature prominently this time. Immediately went to their pegs, so I had to take them down a few notches by placing them in the back.”
Annatar acknowledged the mention of talking, sentient instruments with the same equanimity of everyone who had spent more than a year around Daeror. He tore his gaze away from the violins, which weren’t look very penitent, if he was being honest, and focused on the bard.
“And they are more well-behaved if you arrange them in a circle like school children?”
“Surprisingly yes. Ordered placement seems to translate to orderly behaviour, and that way the strings don’t shout over everything else and mess up the colours.” Daeror looked down at his sheet music.
“The colours.”
“Yes. I can see it in my head when the colours of the melodies and chords don’t match. This means that the music will be bad.”
Annatar thought about this. They had composed together, before. They had not talked about synaesthesia.
“Not colours for you, then?” Daeror asked, eyebrow quirked.
“No.” Annatar shrugged. “Multidimensional matrices. Also functions. If they’re holomorphic, the music tends to sound better. Probably because they’re differentiable at any given point, so holomorphic music sounds smoother. Also there is the possibility of variance through analytic continuation.”
“I won’t even pretend that I understood anything of what you just said,” Daeror said.
“You could, if you deigned to use your brain for something useful for once.”
“Music is useful.”
“Within limitations.”
Daeror looked up at him. “I will never be able to understand the fact how you, a god, can malign the finest and oldest of the arts. I mean, you were literally there when the universe was Sung into being. You took part in it.”
“I do not malign music. I just like math better,” Annatar replied. “Besides, they are two sides of the same coin anyway. I just happen to prefer the more analytical side of it.”
“Colour me outrageously and egregiously unsurprised.”
“I live to unsurprise you.”
“I know.” Daeror squinted up at him. “Alright. Out with it. Why are you really here?”
“Can I not visit my best friend to have a brief chat?” Annatar drawled.
“Now I’m scared.”
“I’m being nice.”
“I know. That is why I am scared.”
Annatar huffed. “I wanted to see how you were doing.”
“You know, I know what you sound like when you lie.”
Annatar raised an eyebrow. “Do you now?”
“Yes. From one professional liar to another, you have to step up your game.” Daeror stood and walked over to the grand piano with three pieces of sheet music in hand, stared intensely at the keys for a moment. Some unheard communication seemed to pass between him and the big instrument, then Daeror laid the paper on the frame and scribbled down some notes.
As the bard wrote, Annatar’s eyes were, against his will, drawn to Daerorʼs hands. Contrary to what one might expect of a professional musician whose livelihood depended on them, they were neither fine-bonded nor hale. Instead, the skin was scarred in multiple places, healed in ugly welts and criss-crosses. There was a burn scar across the back of his hand. The joints were swollen and crooked in places, as if his fingers had been broken multiple times and healed badly.
Annatar looked away, closed his eyes, drew a breath, and opened them again. “Speaking of lies,” he began.
The scratching of Daeror’s pen stopped and the bard looked up. “Hm?”
“The old story that an ex-lover of yours slammed the piano lid on your hands and that this is why your hands look like this. That was a lie, too, wasn’t it?”
Daeror blinked, then looked down at his hands. “Ah,” he said. “Well.”
Annatar crossed his arms. Leaned against the piano, but didn’t look at the bard directly, fixing his gaze on the tips of his shoes instead.
Out of the corner of his vision, he saw Daeror put the pen aside, then turn over his hands. “A half-truth, though fairly transparent one, I guess.” Daeror looked at Annatar. “Good enough to provide an explanation to turn most inquiring gazes aside, fragile enough to fall to pieces at the first instance of real scrutiny.”
There was a loaded pause.
“Isn’t that right?” the bard asked.
Annatar didn’t reply for a few moments. “I don’t remember your face,” he said at last, his voice very quiet, his tone flat.
“I didn’t expect you to,” Daeror replied, slowly sitting down on the piano stool. He examined his fingers. “What are faces in a world full of masks? Craftsmen remember their handiwork, though, don’t they?” He looked down at his hands.
Annatar didn’t flinch, but it was a close thing. He kept his gaze lowered, fixed on his boots. He found he couldn’t look at the bard. “I don’t remember your hands, either.”
“Which is a good thing,” Daeror said. “Because I wouldn’t be here if we had met face to face before. There were torture chambers you could walk – be carried back out of. Yours didn’t number among them. Thankfully I was never important enough to merit your attention.”
Annatar took a deep breath. “Why did they catch you?”
“I was part of a travelling circus back then. I was alone, they needed someone to structure their acts and build a cohesive story around them.” Daeror shrugged. “Also, I can be a mean cardsharp if I want to be, which is always good for additional income. They warned us against travelling the North. We did it anyway, thinking the people there might need some levity the most. We were right, of course. But so where those who had warned us. There was an ambush. Near Tol Sirion.”
“So – wrong place, wrong time?”
Daeror nodded. “I never found out another reason for the capture. Which, frankly, is probably the only reason a third of us made it out alive. We were never important. We were simply collateral damage in a war that wasn’t ours. Playthings. Toys to break for cruel children, but never enough to warrant the attention of the architects who created the war. Lucky me, right?”
There was another silence, longer this time.
Annatar stood very still. Still with his arms crossed. Still staring at the floor. “For what it’s worth,” he said. “I am sorry.”
It was a bizarre apology, and equally as inadequate. Like throwing a bucket of water onto the ruins of a house that had burnt down a century ago. Too little, too late. The house should never have been set on fire in the first place.
“Thank you. That means a lot.”
At that, Annatar forced himself to look up. Daeror wasn’t looking back, he had gone to staring at the keyboard of the piano, trying out a melody. It began as something slow and sad, then, abruptly, inverted into a joyous arpeggio that crashed like a violent discord into the gloomy atmosphere in the room.
“I think I’m going to use this,” Daeror said to no one in particular. He didn’t take his eyes off the keys. He also did not get up to write the melody down. He probably didn’t need to, considering his eidetic memory. However, there were probably other reasons why he stayed seated.
Like the fact that his face had lost all colour and his hands were trembling so hard on the keys that he kept pressing them inadvertently.
“Oh no. This is bad,” Daeror said, his tone strangely dispassionate as he regarded his shaking hands.
Annatar hesitantly pushed off the piano. “Are you – you are not fine.”
“I don’t think I am.”
Annatar hesitated. “Do you need – should I leave?”
“Ah. No. Stay. Just don’t come any closer for the moment. I need to ... Hm. Work. Through This. Give me a minute.”
“You are having a panic attack.”
“Thank you, dear, I would never have realized.”
Annatar halted – and forewent saying whatever he had been about to say. He turned around, walked a few paces away and sat down on one of the stools for the violinists, out of sight from behind the grand piano. Sighing, he buried his face in his hands. And waited.
A few minutes passed in agonized silence. Suddenly, Daeror jumped up and hurried over to his chaotic sheaf of sheet music on the billiards table and began writing something down with almost manic speed.
Annatar straightened a bit, letting his hands drop. “Are you better?”
“I am going to kick myself if I don’t write this down,” Daeror said, which was an absolute non-sequitur to anything that had happened, and thus didn’t merit a response.
Annatar walked over to him. “Does this mean that you are feeling better?” he repeated instead.
Daeror waved it off. “Water under the bridge,” he said, scribbling away. “I’m fine.”
“At the risk of digging my own grave here, I do not think that you can describe anything about this as ‘water under the bridge’.”
“I can, and I will.” Daeror looked up, his green eyes very bright. His smile did not reach his eyes. “The past is past. There is no use dwelling on any of this. Therefore I shan’t.”
“But –”
“Annatar, I’ve had control taken away from me in the First Age in every aspect imaginable. My body was no longer mine, my life wasn’t, not even my mind. The only thing I can do now is to choose how much I am going to let this past affect me. And I am going to exert the full extent of that liberty, because I can. So yes: water under the bridge.”
And just like that, the past had been neatly put in a box, sealed thrice, and shoved aside in a mind-boggling sleight of hand.
Daeror kept on writing.
Annatar watched him work a while longer, and was summarily ignored.
“I could heal your hands,” he said at last.
“And offer you an easy way out of the guilt plaguing you that could, by your own admission, never ever be water under the bridge?” Daeror didn’t look up. “I think not.”
“You are only hurting yourself by keeping the wounds. I do not care either way.”
“I’m not hurting anymore. I have not been hurting in a long time.” Daeror paused. “Or if I have, I hadn’t noticed. You get used to these things.” He frowned. “Anyway, don’t you think I am going to leave an even greater mark on history if I remain one of the best composers and musicians not because of my physical haleness, but on the contrary, despite my defective hands?”
“So they are defective.”
“I’m not as nimble with my fingers as I used to be. One reason why I abandoned card tricks, to be honest. I could never again do them the way I did when I was younger.” Daeror gave a snort that was supposed to sounded amused, but fell flat in the ensuing silence. “And yet, I am still better than the lot of those modern upstarts that would name themselves the ‘heirs of Maglor’. Really, how inflated does an ego have to be?” He shook his head, clucking his tongue.
Annatar let him write on a few moments longer, then he could not keep silent any longer. “You were afraid of me. Just now.”
“I am afraid of you all the time,” Daeror corrected calmly.
Annatar rested his hand on the edge of the billiards table. He picked up the black ball that lay abandoned at the edge of the table, then set it down again. “How, then?”
“How what?”
“Everything. You do not act afraid. You do not look afraid. You keep riling me up. You tease me. You never take me seriously. If you had asked me yesterday, I am certain I would have claimed that there was not a thing in the world that could scare you.”
“Good,” Daeror said. “Then the mask worked as intended.”
“But –”
“Masks, Annatar,” Daeror chided gently. “Do I really have to explain the idea to you, of all people? Showing fear in the face of a dragon rarely ends well.”
“Neither does poking it with a stick.” Annatar grabbed the bank of the table, his fingers digging into the green cover fabric. “And yet you do it all the time.”
“Yes,” Daeror said pensively, his hands sliding from the notation lines for the piano up to the woodwinds. “I do.”
“Why. It doesn’t make sense.”
“Doesn’t it?” Daeror looked up, staring at a point in the middle distance. “I think ... if I keep poking the dragon and it doesn’t eat me when it is angry at me, it stands to reason that it will not do so in any other situation, too. Then I know for sure.”
Annatar regarded him, his brows drewn together. “So you push until something gives.”
“Or doesn’t give, as it were.” Daeror threw him a sideglance. “Either way, if I know what I am in for at the breaking point, I know what I am in for in every other moment.”
And what was left to add, to that? In a capricious war that had killed and maimed millions without rhyme or reason, sacrificed like so many worthless pawns on chessboard populated by a few cruel, overwhelmingly powerful queens and kings, certainty became a currency rarer and more valuable than gold.
But would care about the nameless? Who would even think to ask what they needed? Who would offer to grant it?
The history books belonged to the kings and queens, the lords and gods, the shakers and movers; not to the lowly common folk, whose only appearance in history, whose only acknowledgement came in the form of population counts, army sizes, death tolls. Theirs were lives written in the margins of the existence of the great ones, fates reduced to statistics, names to numbers.
Nobody cared about the fate of the smallfolk. Not then, not now. So who were the mighty ones to deprive the dispossessed of the last bastion they could hold, even if it was as miserable and lowly as being able to stake out the conditions and perimeter of death and danger, if absence of fear itself had become impossible?
Annatar let out a long breath and did something he rarely did: He let the point go. Granting, in his limited, lacking way: certainty, if nothing else. If only for this moment, here and now.
“Having tested my nerves far beyond their breaking point, does that mean you can stop annoying me now?” he asked instead.
The grin that broke across Daeror’s features this time was genuine. “Annatar, I will never stop annoying you. This is no longer about testing you, this is a matter of principle. You deserve every second of me annoying you, and then some.”
“I guess I do.”
“I am thrilled that you agree.”
“Acknowledgement does not equal agreement.” Annatar gave him a flinty side-glance. “And it absolutely does not equal approval.”
“I can live a fulfilled, happy life without your approval, my snarky, slightly evil friend.”
“Unfortunately.”
“Ah, come now.” Daeror got up and stacked the mess of his papers into a incrementally neater pile. Which still looked horrible. Which Annatar would have pointed out, if he had been feeling mean. “You would miss me the second I was gone. In fact, I am sure you would resurrect me instantly, were some ill fate ever to befall me, because you cannot go on living without me.”
Annatar rubbed his temple. “Who am I to shoot down your self-delusions?”
“Exactly.” He walked over to where the Maia was standing. “Come, let us walk. I’ve been cooped up in here for days; I desperately need some air.”
*
They went into the gardens situated in the Third Ring. At this time of year, it was the washed-out dreary panorama of mid-November, the radiant colours of nature in summer and autumn reduced to the near-monochrome of winter. The sun was a pale, nearly white coin in an endless white-grey sky.
At first they didn’t speak much, just walking next to each other in pensive silence. Daeror kept throwing glances down into the city, then walked over to the wall and leaned on it, looking down at the sprawl of houses and streets, fates and lives beneath them, a microcosm in miniature.
“Is this like gods feel when they watch us?” Daeror asked. “I am only a lowly mortal bard, so what I experience must needs be a shadow of the truth, but oftentimes writing feels like looking down at a world small enough to hold in the palm of my hand, and everything on the pages existing at my will and whim.”
Annatar followed him. “Writing is more artful than divinity,” he said flatly. “Divinity doesn’t reason, there is no grand design at the end, no moral of the story. It is no more sophisticated than a child twisting a stick until it either bends or breaks.”
“The proverbial stick being creation itself?”
“In a matter of sense, yes.”
“Oh.” Daeror looked up. “I’ll admit, I am a bit disappointed that there is no grand design, no grand finale intended for us by the Valar or Eru himself. Then again, there is no god of Story, is there?”
“The Weaver, possibly.” Annatar shrugged. “Whether she can hold her own against the combined idiocy of her kindred I wouldn’t know. You’ve seen what Morgoth alone did to the world.”
“I assumed his siblings stood against him because they wanted something other than chaos.”
“Opposition to a foreign agenda is not a standpoint”, Annatar said acridly. “It is an echo, a reaction. But it doesn’t create substance where there is only void. They have no agency that hasn’t been given to them by the one they call ‘Eru’, and no goals other than to thwart their brother. You will notice how absent they have been ever since Melkor has been thrown into the void.”
Daeror’s face was pensive. “True. I assumed it was because their desire for peace had been restored. But I guess the next thing you’ll say is that stasis and peace are not an agenda, either.”
“Yes.”
Daeror threw him a side-glance, dark mirth in his eyes. “Don’t I know you well,” he said slowly.
“The entire guild knows me well enough to be able to make this prediction.”
“Touché. We know and adore our Maiar obsessed with plans and efficiency.”
Annatar raised an eyebrow. “You have more than one? I am devastated. Here I was, thinking you’d be true to me, and only me.”
“Ah, well, you know what they say about contingencies...”
“Contingencies are for cowards.”
“So you say we should release the backup Maia we’ve been keeping locked up in the cellar all the time?”
“Yes. Let them out. I am the best there is anyway.”
“And the most humble.”
“Yes.”
“Not to forget the smartest.”
“Mhm.”
“The craftiest.”
“Quite.”
“The nicest.”
“Well...”
“The bestest, smartest, craftiest, fluffiest Maia.”
“What.”
“You heard me.”
Annatar glared at the bard. “I am not fluffy.”
“Says you. But who’s to say that you aren’t spiky on the outside and fluffy on the inside?”
“I am not fluffy.”
“That you know of.”
Annatar turned on his heel and walked away.
Daeror laughed under his breath and jogged after him. “Wait up!”
Annatar didn’t reply. Perhaps he even walked a bit faster. Celebrimbor was right: spite was an excellent motivator. Unfortunately, Daeror wasn’t one of the sports-averse artists that were reduced to huffing and puffing by a brief sprint. No, he also was despicably athletic, and like everything else about him, his vigour seemed to exist for the sole purpose of destroying the last bit of Annatar’s nerves and patience.
“You simply abandoned me,” Daeror complained.
“Yes, that was the intention,” Annatar replied drily, looking straight ahead. “Unfortunately, my plan did not go as I would have liked.”
“Standing up your date is bad form. I don’t even know how Tyelperinquar puts up with you.” Daeror frowned. “Speaking of which, where is the good fellow?”
Annatar hesitated, the moment’s good cheer suddenly evaporated. “He ... he isn’t feeling well.”
“Is that so? I could have sworn I saw him walk to his lectures yesterday.” Daeror raised his eyebrows. Out of the corner of his vision, Annatar noticed the bard looking at him intently. “He did not look ill.”
“He is not ill,” Annatar said curtly. “He was not feeling well. And the lessons were a welcome distraction, I wager.”
“Ah. So that is...” Daeror fell silent. Annatar chanced a sideglance at him, and even though he could not, per se, look into anyone’s head on a physical level, against all claims to the contrary, he could sense the bard’s brain going into overdrive, assembling facts, filling in the blanks with conjecture, and coming to conclusions, all with a speed that would leave the vast majority of mortals green with envy.
The exact moment when Daeror drew the correct conclusions was visible in the slight tensing of his features, a dimming of the cheerful light in his eyes.
“Oh. So you finally talked.”
Annatar took another deep breath. He did not need to, but he found these small mortal habits helpful to regulate the flow and rhythm of a conversation, including breaks and pauses where there need not strictly be some, but were a welcome reprieve nonetheless.
“We did.”
Daeror ran a hand through his hair. “How did he take it?”
“About as well as could be expected.”
“Ah.”
“You know, I cannot help but notice a glaring lack of surprise in these conversations,” Annatar said flatly. “Does everybody here know?”
Daeror shrugged. “Why are you asking me? I guess there is at least a few who put two and two together, but it is not as if we go around talking to each other about it.”
Annatar gave him a flabbergasted look. “Why? Is everyone here either insane or do you all simply not care?”
“The opposite of caring is not always indifference,” Daeror said slowly. “People had to move on, Annatar. They had to survive. Can you really fault them for not wanting to dig deeper?”
“Wilful ignorance doesn’t help! I told Tyelperinquar as much.”
“Then Tyelperinquar will have told you that some knowledge does not help, either,” Daeror countered. “What do you think would it do to someone who escaped Angband’s torture chambers to know that the Torturer is here? Sitting next to them at dinner? Teaching their child’s class? Deciding the fate of the city they have decided to build a second life in? What good would it do, other than blasting the foundation of their new life to pieces once more? To shatter every trust in having escaped, to resurrect old fears and old wounds, knowing that the arm of their Doom is so long that it will reach them even here?”
“Figures that the bard would advocate for lies,” Annatar said acidly.
“Lies are not inherently bad,” Daeror said, stopping in his tracks. Annatar did the same. “Do you know why we use masks in theatre, Annatar?”
“To hide your true face behind them. To pretend, to lie, to become someone else.”
“Yes, and?”
“What, ‘and’?”
“What else?”
“You tell me,” Annatar shot back. “Since you are obviously just waiting to lecture me.”
“I am lecturing you, but only because you desperately need a lesson in mortality, other than flouncing around in a make-believe body and pretending you understand being Incarnate.” Daeror crossed his arms. “Why else?”
“I don’t know.”
“To tell the stories we could not tell otherwise,” Daeror said softly. “To ourselves, and everyone else. To become the character in the story as it is supposed to be told, and not how it would unfold in real life.” He gestured at the gardens, at the city around them. “This is our illusion, this is our stage, our story. We escaped, we lived. We built this city. We can go on from this. And so we act out the story we so desperately want to write for ourselves. We don the masks, we play the play.” He smiled, sadly and bitterly. “We lived when we should have died, we survived when we should have been broken. And if it isn’t true beyond the stage – well, we do not have to know that, right?”
Annatar stood frozen, any reply that he might have had dead on his tongue.
“The act doesn’t have to stop, especially if it helps so many people,” Daeror said. “As long as the limelight is on and the audience is in shadow, you need not look at what is beyond the stage. The stage is all there is. You can be the survivor, the hero, the one who got away. And if it isn’t true, if it is all just smoke and mirrors ... well.” Daeror turned away, looking out over the city, white and black and grey under them, almost like a charcoal drawing. Almost like a scenery prop in a stage play.
“Some people have only their mask left,” Daeror said, turning back towards Annatar. “Do not take it away from them. Do not force them to take it off. Often enough, there is nothing more behind it after all they have suffered. So leave it be. Leave them in peace.”
Annatar did not speak for a long time. He crossed his arms. The cold wintry winds were blowing across the high gardens, whipping through their hair, catching in their sleeves, the long trails of Annatar’s robe. He didn’t feel it.
“I told Tyelperinquar I wanted truth,” he said at last, staring at the ground. “And now you tell me to continue the lie.”
“Not all lies are cruel. Some are gentle. A kindness even, and the world would be darker without them.” Daeror cocked his head aside. “And they lived happily ever after.”
The cold wind sheared across the gardens like a knife blade. Cutting. Cold.
“I am neither gentle nor kind,” Annatar said, drawing his robes closer around him.
“Well then.” Daeror’s mouth quirked up at the edge, the sardonic cousin of a smile. “Time to craft a new mask then, aye?”
Annatar stared at the ground, and slowly shook his head, frustration warring with disbelief. “From deceit to masquerade.” He let out a mirthless laugh. “Between Tyelperinquar, you, and those nameless others you mentioned, I’m beginning to think that the entire city is a stage where truth is rarer than mithril, everyone is a mask, and everyone realized it except for me. Congratulations for beating me at my own game.”
“That’s the thing, Annatar,” Daeror said with a sad smile. “We’re all actors here. And excellent liars.”
Annatar scoffed. “That explains why I felt right at home here from the moment I stepped through the gates.” He shook his head. “To think that I truly wanted to try honesty.”
“You were honest where it mattered,” Daeror said. “But there is a time and place for stripping away illusions, and there are times when it is kinder to let people marvel at the magician’s tricks.” He walked back over to the wall and braced his hands on the stone, looking out over the city below. With a slow exhale, he added, “And allow them to believe.”
He threw a side glance at Annatar who had followed him. “The show must go on, right?” He grinned with too many teeth.
Annatar followed his gaze down at the sprawl of cities, houses, destinies entangled. People who needed comfort more than truth. “I guess it must,” he said at last.
Annatar getting hoodwinked by his own tactics will never not be funny to me.
Also, isn't he secretly well and truly the fluffiest Maia?
In the spirit of me being destroyed by the game, I had of course hide a reference to Clair Obscur in there. Kudos if you manage to find it.
Also, twice the kudos if you also manage to spot the Amadeus reference.