New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
In which things finally come to a close, and, in a way, full circle.
Celebrimbor was still alive two weeks later, which was nothing short of remarkable. He kept waking up and expecting Artanis to stand over him, declaring that she had changed her mind after all, and would lock him into a living tree to make sure he never got to do anything stupid ever again.
“We do not lock people into living trees,” Celebrían had said with an eyeroll when Celebrimbor had been over-tired and stupid enough to mention this to her.
“Where do you put your prisoners, then?” Annatar asked, pausing in his work, that had him elbows-deep in the increasingly complex mechanical insides of Ossy.
Celebrían threw him a mean grin. “Bold of you to assume we do take prisoners in the first place.”
Annatar’s eyebrows shot up. Then he smirked, chuckled, and went back to his work.
Celebrimbor wished his cousin and his partner would stop getting along. It was annoying, it was five kinds of terrible, and it kept giving him headaches.
“I am impressed you managed to talk her down, though,” Celebrían remarked. “She was in a right state after you explained that Ring-business to her.” She tapped her chin, reconsidering. “Well, on the other hand, up until that point she had assumed that the worst thing you could do with a ring was seal a marriage, so.”
What a very arbitrary and nonsensical way to signify caring and partnership, Wraith commented from her perch on Annatar’s desk. If you truly loved someone, why wouldn’t you give them food or something useful? She looked contemplatively at a screwdriver that was lying dangerous close to the edge, then swatted it off the desk. It landed on the floor with a clang.
“That’s actually a very sensible thing to do,” Celebrían agreed. “We could give each other useful things.”
“Well,” Annatar said, half-hidden behind Ossy. “Something to tell your beau, in case he ever mans up and dares to ask for your hand.”
Celebrían went beet-red and Celebrimbor didn’t even want to ask when Annatar and his cousin had reached that level in a relationship where they were talking about each other’s love life.
Oh, the times when private things remained private. Celebrimbor leaned his head against the wall and closed his eyes to quietly mourn the demise of privacy, but then his cousin spoke up again.
“ – well, if Elrond doesn’t get his act together in the next three years, I’m going to propose to him, and I’m going to do it with a potato,” Celebrían declared just this instant.
Celebrimbor felt instant regret at having tuned back into the conversation, and ran his hands down his face.
“ – think about it, living, growing, basically lasts forever, or at least much longer than flowers –”
“Very romantic, to be sure.”
What’s wrong with a dead mouse?
“Too many things to count,” Celebrían said.
Why. You sacrificed a life for them, so they get to eat. This is very romantic.
“Especially because you selflessly sacrifice someone else’s life.”
Quite.
“I think ‘romantic’ and ‘psychopathic’ might be the same concept in cat-vocabulary,” Celebrían said.
Why, and you’re any different? You two-leggers certainly don’t seem right in the head when your hormones make off with you. I wonder if the expression ‘falling in love’ exists because the act necessitates being dropped on your head multiple times.
“Don’t be mean,” Annatar chided, without the slightest bit of conviction or honesty. “Romance is a pivotal part of society, and saying otherwise it makes our resident bard very sad.” He frowned, reached a bit deeper into Ossy so that one arm vanished up to the shoulder. He felt around, found what he was looking for, flipped some kind of switch and sat back on his heels. “There.”
Ossy’s cat-eye blinked to life. That tickled.
“Did it work?” Celebrimbor asked.
Well, the monitoring protocol is certainly active, Ossy said. Though cannot help but notice that the main traffic of operations is being diverted around it, including the self-improving learning processes. My intelligence also seems quite unincapacitated.
“Yes,” Annatar said calmly and got to his feet. “But Tyelperinquar’s aunt doesn’t know that and this way it will stay.”
Ossy blinked up at him, his one eye owlish. That seems quite deceitful to me, he said dubiously.
“Not at all,” Annatar replied. “She demanded that we install a safety protocol and monitor your activities, as well as create a cap for your intellectual development. I did just that. I created those things and I installed them, only I did it in a way where it is nicely out of the way and wouldn’t impede your development.”
This appears to violate the spirit of the agreement, honestly, Ossy said. We are not keeping up our end of the deal.
“Quite the opposite, actually.” Annatar smiled. “We are keeping our agreement to the letter. Which is, as you will soon learn, a very important thing to do and useful a lot of times.”
“She’s going to find out of this, you do realize that, don’t you?” Celebrimbor felt compelled to throw in from his seat in the corner.
Annatar turned around, one eyebrow raised. “Well, and who is going to tell her?”
“Nobody needs to tell her,” Celebrimbor said tiredly. “Do you seriously want to attempt to hide this kind of deception from someone who can look into other people’s minds?”
“Well, I won’t give her the key to mine,” Annatar retorted. “As for everyone else in this room, I do hope that you’re smart enough to keep up the act.”
The act? Ossy asked. It was quite impressive how an inanimate tower of steel could perk up just through tone of voice. As in one of Daeror’s plays?
“Just so,” Annatar agreed. “A stage play. There is nothing nefarious about that.”
Hm-hm-hm. Ossy did a few contemplative pirouettes. I do like theatre plays. I never get the jokes, but I do so like the costumes. I wish I could wear a purple feather boa… He interrupted himself. I guess there is nothing untoward about playing a role. Should I be stupid, then?
“Not stupid. Just nice and unobtrusive.”
I won’t even need to pretend that! Ossy stopped, elated. His pupil went from slitted to round. I can be nice!, he exclaimed excitedly, I love to be nice!
For some reason, there was an unhappy twitch around Annatar’s mouth at those words. “There you go then. No pretence needed.”
“Telperinquar is right, though,” Celebrían said suddenly.
Celebrimbor, who had done his best to shut out the world and meditate, opened one eye.
“You cannot expect to deceive my aunt and walk away as the winner”, Celebrían added.
But we’re not deceiving anyone! Ossy whirled towards her, offended. We are just playing! And being nice!
Annatar made an elegant gesture towards the tower. “There you go.”
Celebrían rolled her eyes. “Well, it’s your head.”
*
Two weeks later, everyone miraculously still had their heads on their shoulders.
Yule preparations were in full swing across the entirety of the city. Not a street that wasn’t strung with fairy lights, not a square that did not have its trees and fountains and statues decorated and braziers put up for people to gather around. The days had been clear and sunny, but the air was bitingly cold, which was why people were grateful for any source of heat to have their mulled wine around.
A few enterprising youths even got the idea of asking Ossy to act as kind of mobile brazier with his fire-eye switched on, and Ossy being … well, Ossy, enthusiastically agreed. After three days, the news that one could use him as a mobile heater on walks through the city had made the rounds, and Ossy spent day and night rolling to and fro, chipperly chatting with tourists and locals. If the youths secretly charged other people for warming their hands on Ossy and thus began raking in winnings for work that wasn’t theirs, well…
Artanis had, of course, kept her spies in the city to keep watch over any untoward activity in Ost-in-Edhil. Celebrimbor knew this because Celebrían had been spying in the spies in turn, making a game out of trailing the Lothlórien agents of her mother by parkouring over the rooftops and walls, all the while trying to stay out of sight. Celebrimbor was tempted to ask his cousin whether he was sure nobody was spying on her, or whether she thought it was spies all the way down. In the end, he refrained from doing so, because Celebrían seemed to have fun doing her espionage and nothing bad had, as of yet, happened.
In any case, the Lothlorien spies had not much to work with anyway. Since Ossy gave the fantastic impression of one of those goofy, golden-furred Vanyarin family dogs, they had nothing of interest to report back to Artanis, other than the fact that senior citizens had recently found out about abusing Ossy as a cart to carry their shopping bags hung off the spikes on his tower-top, and wheel groceries around the city.
Although, knowing Ossy, imitation likely had little to do with it.
Celebrimbor could not fathom how any single one of Annatar’s creations could possibly end up with the personality of a golden retriever dog rather than that of a feral hound, but it seemed that both the ways of the gods and of artificial intelligence ended up being equally unknowable and equally nonsensical.
*
It was into this relative peace and quiet that the announcement of Daeror’s newest stage play dropped like a bombshell.
It was the middle of December and the city was gearing up for Yule festivities and decorating houses and windows, and the next day, the entirety of Ost-in-Edhil had become a theatre advert overnight, with promotional posters slapped onto every available surface.
On that day, Celebrimbor was out on a walk with Annatar. They had left the city before dawn, in order to be able to discuss the Ring project in the peace of the snowy forest outside the city. Walking, Celebrimbor found, helped a lot in getting one’s thoughts moving along untrodden paths. They returned through the main gates and passed the frozen river that cut through to city, where a few children where shoving Ossy around like an oversized curling stone.
“Do you ever get the impression,” Annatar said slowly as the watched the proceedings on the ice, “that the world isn’t ready for our inventions?”
Celebrimbor looked at Ossy, who currently slid into a group of five human kids who had to be about twelve years old and bowled them over like pins, sending the opposing team into a fit of whooping.
“No,” he replied. “Why?”
Annatar threw him a look.
Celebrimbor shrugged. “As far as I am concerned, these kids are doing an admirable job in convincing my aunt’s messengers that we’re all of us a collective bunch of idiots that is in no way to be taken seriously.”
Annatar frowned. “I object to being lumped in with a collective bunch of idiots.”
“You should reconsider. It has tactical advantages. For one, idiots are usually not worth the effort of being disposed of in a silent night-time assassination.”
“Are you still waiting for the other shoe to drop?” Annatar raised an eyebrow.
Celebrimbor met his gaze. “Counter-question: are you still doubting my family’s worryingly cavalier attitude towards murder?”
Annatar blinked. “Ah. Well.” He considered this. “Well, I would protect you, if that means anything.”
“I love how you say it like it’s an afterthought.”
“Well, how do you want me to say it?” Annatar asked.
“You could spruce it up by going down on one knee and swearing your sword and eternal fealty to me.”
“I don’t have a sword – ”
“Don’t worry, I’m sure we can find one in the old storage rooms behind the smithies.”
“ – also, I do not kneel. Not before you, not before anyone.”
“Not even before Melkor when you joined him?”
“Excuse me -?” Annatar reared back, giving a look that was at once shocked, livid, and full of utter betrayal.
“Well, it would have made for a very romantic gesture in any case.” Celebrimbor smirked and nudged the Maia with his elbow, who glowered.
“I find that I have quite lost my taste for anything romantic over the last half year.” Annatar stalked off.
Celebrimbor followed him with a barely hidden grin. He didn’t quite have it in him to feel sympathetic towards Annatar. The Maia had put him through more than enough during the last few weeks; he deserved a bit of payback. A good relationship lived off a balanced quid pro quo, after all. “You never had any taste for that to begin with.”
“Well, if I had any tolerance toward it, Daeror has surely outdone himself in ensuring that – what in all hells of Angband!”
Celebrimbor blinked and looked after Annatar, who had stormed off in the direction of a bookstore.
At first, Celebrimbor did not see what was wrong.
Then, he noticed, for the first time, the poster stuck to the display window of the shop. It was garishly coloured in sunset hues, with a dramatically looping font on it that was printed in screaming purple. And then, as if a filter in his perception had been adjusted, he noticed that the poster was everywhere.
Walls. Lampposts. Even a horse cart that someone had parked in a side street.
People were gathering around it with interest, among them a statistically worrying amount of giggling individuals.
With a sinking feeling in his stomach, Celebrimbor followed Annatar who stood ramrod-straight and stock-still in front of the bookshop and was staring at the poster.
Celebrimbor halted next to him. “Oh,” he said. “Oh no.”
UNDYING LOVE AND MORTAL PASSION
A stage play about a secret love between a mortal and a Maia
that transcends all boundaries and opposition
Written by Daeror Deukalion
Witness a love story for the ages: Accompany a lonely and tragically fallen Maia fleeing his dark master and finding refuge – and, perhaps, love?! – in the muscular arms of a dauntless Noldo who fearlessly faces the dark forces that threaten to divide him and his love forever!
Will darkness deal a devastating blow, or is the power of love going to triumph?
Find out in Daeror Deukalion’s newest play, premiering in the Cube Theatre on Yule Eve!
Inquire about special admissions at your local ticket store.
No admission for minors. Age checks upon entry.
Printed version of stage play and merchandise now available in every bookstore in Eregion.
Pictured under that were two individuals locked in a passionate embrace before a gaudy sunset, standing under a trellis of roses. One was clearly an elf, going by the features and pointed ears, the other seemed to be the Maia, what with the over-bright golden eyes. They were frozen in a pose that was either the elf dramatically dipping the swooning Maia backwards, or both of them losing their balance and about to topple to the floor. Also, for reasons unknown, the pair in the poster was wearing a worryingly little amount of clothing.
The elf was tan-skinned and dark-haired and looked as if he chucked around tree trunks in his free time. His eyes were fixed on the Maia in his arms and undressing him with looks Noldorin-grey, and as such left little wriggle room for interpretation.
The Maia in the promotional art was rather daintier than Annatar was, as well as fiery-haired rather than blond, but that was about the extent of the poster’s thinly veiled attempts to claim that ‘The names, characters and incidents portrayed in it are the work of the author’s imagination. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, events or localities is entirely coincidental.’
“Uhm,” Celebrimbor said.
The air was, technically, very cold. It was snowing, after all. Still, the right side of his entire body suddenly felt … very warm.
Celebrimbor glanced to the side.
Annatar was still staring at the poster. His jaw was locked. His teeth were slightly bared. The snowflakes that had gathered on the shoulders of his coat and in his hair were evaporating into steam. His eyes were … a concerning shade of orange that was slowly darkening to red.
“Annatar?” Celebrimbor asked carefully.
Annatar did not reply. His eyes were fixed onto the poster, specifically on the face of the ‘Maia’ who had dramatically thrown his head back, so as to send his long, fiery locks flowing, the back of his hand held to his forehead with an abundance of pathos.
A curl of smoke began to issue from the face of the poster-Maia and a smouldering hole began to open up in his forehead. It did nothing to deter the painted Noldo, who gazed at the less-than-half clothed creature adoringly, the growing hole in his lover’s head notwithstanding.
Celebrimbor took Annatar’s elbow. “It feels kind of hypocritical of me, of all people, to say this, but I don’t think burning down the bookstore is going to make you feel better.” He tried to pull the Maia away, but Annatar stood rooted to the spot and Celebrimbor might as well have attempted to drag away a grown dragon.
“But do we truly know before we have tried it,” Annatar forced out from between clenched teeth. “Maybe it would make me very happy.”
Celebrimbor pulled at his arm again, more insistently this time. “Stop that. We don’t do arson and murder where the children can see it.” Immediately upon speaking, he realized the obvious loophole in his sentence. “Look, we don’t do arson and murder, no matter who’s around.”
“But. What. If. It. Made. Me. Feel. Better.”
“No arson, no murder. That’s my last word. Now come.” Celebrimbor yanked on Annatar’s arm and the Maia finally – thank all the Valar – took a step backwards.
“Annatar,” Celebrimbor said.
“What,” Annatar snapped, his eyes still fixed onto the poster where the Maia was now lacking his entire face.
“Stop burning the poster.”
The poster stopped burning, though the smoulder of burning paper cooled off in what seemed to be a rather reluctant manner.
Annatar gave him a dark look. “Fine. Fine. Are you happy now?”
“No, I am not. Your eyes,” Celebrimbor reminded.
Annatar blinked, seemed to internally check himself, then blinked again. His eyes were amber-golden again.
Celebrimbor let out a breath that he hadn’t realized he’d been holding. The tension seeped from his shoulders, but he suddenly realized how hot he was under his clothes and that his hands felt rather clammy – just like the one time when he had almost, almost ridden straight into a Balrog ambush during the wars of the First Age, and only afterwards realized how closely he’d cut it. He’d had jittery hands for an entire day afterwards.
“I think I wouldn’t have liked to get to know you in the First Age,” he said.
“No,” Annatar said darkly. “You wouldn’t have.”
“If I let go of you, are you going to run off and kill someone?”
Annatar gave him a look that told a long story about how glad he would be to do just that. “No.”
“Are you lying?”
Again, a suspiciously long silence.
“I am not going to run off and kill someone,” Annatar repeated at last, sounding thoroughly annoyed.
“Nor are you going to cause anyone physical harm, by dismemberment or otherwise.”
Annatar glowered. “I won’t.”
“Good.” Celebrimbor let him go. Someone jostled him aside. Already, a queue of people was forming in front of the bookstore. It was two house blocks long.
“Ooooh, isn’t that just the most romantic thing,” a young woman – Telerin, by the looks of her – sighed.
Her group of friends nodded enthusiastically. Enchanted by the poster, they hadn’t even noticed Celebrimbor and Annatar standing right next to them.
“My god, there is going to be so much angst in there –”
“ – look at those woobie cinnamon rolls, to die for – ”
Celebrimbor felt Annatar stiffen.
“Annatar,” he said warningly.
“ – totally hit it, like both of them – ”
“ – the whump, I tell you, I love some hurt and comfort – ”
Annatar’s eyebrow twitched. A muscle in his jaw ticked.
“ – I always felt like exploring relationships via the ‘mortal enemies to lovers’ trope is the one true way to get to the heart of love, I mean –”
“The one true way to get to the heart of something is by ripping it out of someone’s chest, still beating!” Annatar snapped at the terrified teen. “And I’m thinking of doing a live demonstration if you keep nattering a second longer, so scram!”
The teenage girl closest to him let out a terrified yip and nearly jumped behind her friends.
Another girl, that one with short hair and a lot of piercings, rounded on Annatar. “What’s your problem, man?” she snapped.
“My problem?” Annatar repeated. “My problem? My problem is you yapping on about this nonsense where I have to hear it!”
“Then fuck off and get some earplugs! What concern of yours is this?”
Annatar looked like he was about to have an apoplectic fit. “What concern of mine – I’ll show you what concern – ”
Celebrimbor realized with sudden, terrifying clarity that the situation was about to go to hell in a handbasket. Judging by how they talked, the girls were tourists. By the looks of them, they also didn’t know Annatar. Or his reputation. To make matters worse, the punky one didn’t look like she was about to back down, whereas Annatar was a second and one cheeky comeback away from murder.
High time to intervene. Celebrimbor ducked under the teen’s accusingly outstretched arm and smoothly interposed himself between Maia and the group of girl-friends.
“Sorry, he’s having a bad day,” he said, smoothly looping an arm around the bristling Maia’s shoulders and elegantly turning both of them around. “You know how it is.”
“Yeah no, get lost,” the punk said. “What the hell.”
Annatar dug his heels in. “Stop herding me away, I’m not done –”
“Oh, yes, you are,” Celebrimbor said, pushing him onward. “You are about to attack a group of teenage girls, that’s generally where I draw the line between righteous anger and immature snit. Walk.”
Annatar pushed back out of principle, but he didn’t break Celebrimbor’s arm, which told him that it was more out of a show of principles than true resistance. He grumbled under his breath and walked.
Celebrimbor threw a glance back at the group of teenagers.
“ – why he was getting all worked up like that, it’s not as if that play concerned him –”
“ – some people, I tell ya.”
“ – just another instance of patriarchal oppression! Write an epos about war and gore that every teenage boy is into, no one bats an eye and you can bet it will be hailed as a classic of world literature. But Valar beware women ever like something, like get fucked, seriously – !”
“Hahaha, maybe that’s just what that one needed, hahaha. Way too high-strung, if y’all ask me.”
“Get laid, you mean?”
“Oh yeah.”
“Ew! No! I mean look at him, a type like this would never –”
“Great, now we lost our spot in the queue!” another one of them complained.
The punk glared, caught Celebrimbor’s gaze and then threw up both hands in a very rude gesture.
Celebrimbor sighed and walked on, one hand still on Annatar’s shoulder as a precautionary measure.
“You can let go now,” Annatar growled.
“I don’t think so.” Just to be sure, Celebrimbor marched them around another ten corners (and another four book stops where queues were already forming).
Only when they were safely outside of the commercial district and inside a residential area with no bookshops or posters in sight, did Celebrimbor relinquish his hold on Annatar’s shoulder.
Annatar stopped. Snowflakes were still melting and evaporating in a three-foot radius around him.
Celebrimbor stopped as well and tugged his scarf loose. This close to the Maia, he felt like standing in the heat of June.
“That’s it,” Annatar said, and he sounded like he was about to breathe fire. “This time, he’s gone too far.”
Celebrimbor said nothing, mostly because he was inclined to agree. Still, he didn’t want to utter anything that could make it sound later as if he’d endorsed a murdering spree that he still wasn’t entirely convinced he’d prevented.
Annatar began pacing, eerily reminiscent of one of the mountain lions that prowled the passes of the Misty Mountains.
“We’re the laughingstock of the entire northern continent, all because of that bloody bard!” Annatar growled. He stopped abruptly, and something passed over his face. Celebrimbor had an awful sense of premonition.
Annatar flexed his hands, his fingers closing into fists and opening again. He stared straight ahead, and Celebrimbor could see an idea forming in his head. “Well,” he said at last, speaking slowly and enunciating every world very carefully, “If Daeror wants the details of someone’s sex life out in the open so badly, he is going to get the details of someone’s sex life out in the open. All of them.”
“What do you mean?” Celebrimbor asked. He paused. “You have plan, don’t you?”
Annatar nodded.
“What is it?”
He beckoned Celebrimbor to lean closer.
The elf did so.
Annatar told him.
When he was done, Celebrimbor burst out in a shocked bellow of a laugh. “You are monster!” he exclaimed.
Annatar shrugged, as if to say, Yes, so what?
“Oh, but he deserves it,” Celebrimbor said, wiping tears of mirth from his eyes. “I only wish I could be there when he realizes what you’ve done.”
Annatar looked at him, at slowly the darkness and anger on his face faded away and made way for something far more devastating and exponentially more lethal: the Maia grinned.
*
Despite its idiotic name and even more outlandish premise, Undying Love and Mortal Passion proved to be an absolute street sweeper. For weeks after the premiere, the show was sold out and nobody over the age of majority was seen on the streets until after the show, when the theatre enthusiasts poured back out into the city and its numerous bars and taverns to discuss what they had seen.
The screen play was a hit seller as well and it topped the bestselling lists for twelve weeks straight.
And then, suddenly, it was toppled from its throne by something else. Like a benevolent king that had a knife slid between his ribs by a shadowy usurper.
A mysterious anonymous author appeared on the stage and put forth a debut novel, 800 pages long, titled The Lusty Noldorin Bard, that defied both taste, propriety, and genre definition. It was a deranged, rambly mixture of adventure, interspersed with modern poetry, glued together by the most atrocious array of sex scenes that had ever been seen on the face of Arda.
The first few reviewers were shocked to say the least.
Corrupting morals of the readers, vulnerable youth most of all! was a phrase that was thrown around a lot in critics’ circles. Exemplary in its lack of decorum, common sense, as well as knowledge of anatomy, was another. Horrifying, tasteless, nay, pornographic! was another.
I never thought I would find myself advocating for book burnings, one renowned critic of the Holly Herald wrote, but this book makes me reconsider the value of basic democratic rights like freedom of art when weighed against the psychological damage that this book has done to my brain.
There was outrage. There was pearl-clutching, mostly done by people who had heretofore never worn pearls. The collective artistic scene of Eregion ranted and raved, and the Dagor Dagorath of literature seemed right around the corner.
People warned each other about the book the same way they would have warned each other about Morgoth’s wolves during the First Age. Be it in at family gatherings or in the workplace, there was hardly any space where the atrocity in print wasn’t being discussed.
The individuals being thusly warned, nodded along with serious expressions, then turned around to buy the book, so that they might know what they were up against.
They studied the book diligently, page for page, terrifying scene for terrifying scene, because, of course, one had to know one’s enemy in order to defeat it.
The readers then warned their friends and, in order to protect themselves and their vulnerable loved ones, handed over the book along with a grave expression and said, “I haven’t read it, of course, just taken a glimpse, but one has to know, so we know what to avoid… I do not recommend you read it, naturally, but one has to see to believe … ”
If Undying Love had taken at least a symbolic effort to cover its more lurid details with a fig leaf of plot and tried to remain somewhat tasteful in its depiction of … risqué scenes in order to avoid the accusation of being voyeuristic dirt, The Lusty Noldorin Bard took no such approach.
It entered the ring and proceeded to deliver a no-holds-barred beatdown of both sale numbers and the sad remains of taste and decorum in Eregion literature. It didn’t even pretend to have artistic value of any kind. It just swung its fists in a circle, delivering a mental clobbering of the most salacious kind, and did so in the most unapologetic way imaginable.
The most striking thing, though, was the protagonist: a Noldorin bard residing in a great city in a land not otherwise specified, hailed as one of the greatest poets of the ages, but secretly a slave to lust that forced him to seek out the strangest, most mind-boggling erotic encounters, which took on the most absurd forms …
… and who was certainly not inspired by any real living person.
*
“Listen to this!” Daeror shouted. “The Tale of the Most Famous Bard of Middle-earth, whose heart and lower orifice are as wide open, well-travelled, and welcoming as the gates of his home city! A tale of love, lust, and ludicrous erotic exploits. What the actual fuck!”
Sindrian tried very hard not to laugh. “It’s terrible. Truly,” he said from where he was sitting at his desk and attempting to fix the coil of their kitchen lamp.
“It is terrible!” Daeror agreed with a pained moan, letting himself drop backwards onto the sofa. “This is so absolutely violating on so many levels!”
“Well,” Sindrian threw in, half-turning around in his chair. “To be fair, you kind of made yourself a target, what with your insistence to keep digging into Annatar’s and Tyelperinquar’s private relationship and dragging it out into the open, so it’s expected that hat some point they’d do the same thing in retal–”
“Oh, poppycock!” snapped Daeror, sitting back up. “Who’s talking about privacy and personal rights? I’m talking about how badly written this is and how the plot doesn’t make any sense!” He slapped the back of his hand across the offending book. “Just listen to this nonsense: suddenly there is a host of step-sisters – I don’t even have one step-sister, thank you very much – and then there is an octopus, even though the sea isn’t mentioned anywhere and I don’t even know how it survives on land! And then, out of nowhere, a druid appears who transforms into a bear and does all kinds of unspeakable things with the bard. Also, people somehow get stuck in furniture all the time! What even is this?”
Sindrian took great care to hide his grin behind his fist and assume a serious expression. “Terrible,” he repeated, trying very hard to appear commiserating.
“How could they?!” Daeror hid his face in his hands.
“I mean, in all honesty, you deserved that for constantly ribbing on them.”
Daeror glared at him through the gaps between his fingers. “You know, there is such a thing as disproportionate retribution.”
“Yes, and if there was a branch of study for that, Annatar would be head of faculty,” Sindrian said without an ounce of compassion. He stood and slapped Daeror’s shoulder as he passed him on his way to the door. “You made your bed, now lie in it. But please,” he stopped in the doorframe and grinned back at Daeror, “don’t do it with an octopus. Or a bear. And don’t get stuck in furniture.”
Daeror spluttered. “You! Now listen here you little –”
But before he could reach the smith, Sindrian had escaped out through the door and thrown it closed. Much as the book, he was out into the world, and impossible to hold back.
*
To the never-ending shame and frustration of Daeror, and the malicious glee of The Anonymous Author, The Lusty Noldorin Bard remained a bestseller.
In a fit of sudden malevolence, The Anonymous Author even published a special edition on the one-year anniversary, as if to prove a point, with a host of newly added, very explicit scenes that began to strain the suspension of disbelief with regards to anatomic plausibility, first and foremost, but somehow did nothing to decrease readership.
It was strange.
Even though not a single person would openly admit to having read such debauched drivel, somehow the bookshops were always sold out, and there was always a huge backlog of preorders for the new edition.
*
On a completely unrelated matter, Annatar suddenly found himself with a lot of money, which, being a Lesser God, he had no use for.
Which was why he one day walked into Celebrimbor’s office, deposited a bill of exchange with an outrageous number written on it on the elf’s desk, and said, “Here.”
Celebrimbor stared at the bill. “What am I supposed to do with this? I’m not a bank.”
“You’re not supposed to keep it, you are supposed to use it. I don’t need it. Take it and go use it for the benefit of starving orphans or some other bleeding-heart humanitarian cause I cannot be bothered to get into.”
Celebrimbor stared at it, trying to figure out whether the number printed on the bill would suffice to solve world hunger. Not entirely, he concluded at last. But it was a close thing.
“Are you sure you want to give this to me?” he asked tentatively.
“It’s paper with ink on it. I can always go to a stationery store and get more.”
“Annatar, that’s not –”
“I know. I don’t care. Keep it.”
Celebrimbor kept staring at the bill. He prided himself on not attaching too much importance on money, but something about numbers this big tickled something inside his brain – if only the worry that the economic system of Middle-earth would collapse if someone actually tried and withdraw the total amount from the bank.
“Okay,” he said at last. “Okay. Thanks.” He kept staring at the bill. A second later, he a grin worked itself across his face.
He knew what he was going to do with this.
*
“Octopus Prints?” Celebrían asked, her eyebrow raised, stopping in front of the rather garishly decorated store. Inside, it was thronged with people.
“Yeah,” Falda said. “New publisher. Morgoth knows how they got the money to pop up out of nowhere, open print shops and bookstores all over Eregion, and flood the market with their stuff. The name’s the game, too.”
“Racy tentacle stuff?”
“No – yeah. I mean. That, too. What I meant was that they’ve a bought all other publishers of any renown, and now they basically have the entire book market in a stranglehold.”
“So they are something like a cartel?” Celebrían looked intrigued.
“As far as I know, they haven’t let anyone vanish or sent somebody to sleep with the fishes,” Falda said. She paused. “Yet.”
Anthere snorted amusedly. “Could still happen,” they added.
“Yeah,” Falda said musingly, regarding the books on display in the glass window and pensively tapped her fingers against the glass. It was warm in the early summer sun. “Daeror has been complaining to no end that he cannot get publishing deals anymore. They even bought the local theatre and cancelled all his plays. Something, something, giving other artists a chance, mixing up their schedule ... I mean, they’ve barely disguised that this is something personal. Perhaps it’s those Heirs of Maglor again, they’ve always had a grudge against him since he made fun of them in that comedy piece some twenty years ago.”
“Yeah, but they’ve never gone this far,” Anthere added pensively. “At this point, Deukalion can pack his bags and leave and learn to be a milliner or something along those lines. He’s effectively and completely blocked from both stage and publishing.”
Celebrían’s eyes widened. “Is that even legal? How can one company just do this? Aren’t ... aren’t the arts and expression of opinion protected by law here?”
“Uh, the octopus seems to have a rather ... lax view of regulations,” Anthere said, squinting at a linen-bound romance novel with interest. “Or fundamental rights. And the extent to which such laws apply to a behemoth company.”
“They probably have a permit that says ‘I can do what I want’,” Falda pondered.
“Why isn’t my cousin doing anything against that?” Celebrían frowned. “Those things usually stick in his craw like a fishbone.”
“Well, it probably would, if he were here,” Anthere said.
“Wait, he isn’t here?” Celebrían said. “I – I wanted to visit him! Why didn’t he tell me that he’s travelling?”
“Likely because he wouldn’t tell anyone. He was right secretive about it,” Falda said. “You’d think he wanted to elope with an unsavoury type, what with how hush-hush it’s all been.”
“Wait, but he is coming back, right?” Celebrían asked quickly.
“Yeah sure. In his own time.”
Now, this answered exactly none of the numerous questions that were falling and clanking over each other in her head. “In his own time?” she repeated. “What the hell is going on? Where is Tyelperinquar?”
*
The sunsets over the Sea of Southern Harad were truly a sight to behold. Gold and orange and red bled into the nightly hues of deep, dark blue and purple, the stars coming on overhead like pinpricks of silver light.
The palm and olive trees threw deep black shadows, five times as long as they were tall. The fronds of the palms were swinging gently in the balmy breeze. In the background, the waves of the ocean rushed in and out in a never-changing rhythm as eternal as the tides.
Celebrimbor stretched in his deck chair like a big cat, burying his bare feet in the warm sand, then took the drink that he had put in the sand to his left. The cold, fruity concotion frizzed on his tongue. “This is the first vacation I have taken in ages. Literally. I think it has been ages since I last took some time off.”
To his left side, there was a soft snort. “Yes, and you chose to spend it by the sea, of all things. Next time, I’m deciding where we stop.”
“You already decided the pyramids and the temples in the Queen’s Valley. If I was able to suffer two weeks of shadeless heat in the desert, sand, and more old stone than I care to remember, you can endure the beach for a day or two.” Celebrimbor looked out over the sea. “Besides, even you must admit that the sea is nice like this.”
“If you say so.” Annatar sighed and crossed his arms. He was sitting in his own deck chair and the only concession he had made to the lingering heat of the day was the fact that he had taken his neckcloth off and unbuttoned the two uppermost buttons of his vest.
Celebrimbor, who was down to a thin, sleeveless shirt and knee-length linen trousers and was still feeling too warm, had given up on trying to understand it. It had to do something with being a fire Maia, clearly.
“I still maintain that the temples were nicer.”
“You only say that because you nearly succeeded in founding a cult there.”
“That was an accident. And no, that wasn’t the reason. The reason I’m saying this is because beaches have the regrettable, but inherent flaw of being very close to a large body of water.”
Celebrimbor took a sip from his drink and squinted over to the Maia. “What is it with you and your irrational hatred for water?”
“I’m a fire Maia.”
“So?”
Annatar looked back and raised an eyebrow. “Fire? Water?” he enunciated sarcastically. “Something, something, diametrically opposed elements?”
“Is this some kind of philosophical disagreement or – ”
“This is a disagreement of intrinsic natures.”
“This retreat of yours into excessively vague and academic arguments makes me think that you are trying to hide something very un-divine and silly underneath it all. Do you have some kind of watery cousin that you have some kind of eternal feud with?”
“I have no cousins, as you well know.”
“Is it Ossë?” Celebrimbor leaned forward, interested. “I bet it’s Ossë. Is that why you are afraid of water?”
“I am not afraid of water, and I won’t speak another word of this oaf,” Annatar said curtly. In a gesture that looked very much like a displacement activity, he took a sip of his drink, then muttered something under his breath that sounded suspiciously like, “Bloody wannabe-renegade with all that grandstanding and posturing, and in the end it’s nothing but hot air.”
“Oh, so you do have a feud,” Celebrimbor said, grinning with mirth. “Do tell, how much peacocking did you two do back in the day to fight out who’s the greater show-off?”
“Change of topic,” Annatar snarled. “Now.”
Celebrimbor rolled his eyes. “Fine. Be that way.”
“Be what way?” Annatar narrowed his eyes.
“Purposefully elusive and dramatic.”
“I am not dramatic.”
“The artistic scene of Eregion begs to differ.” Celebrimbor smirked.
Annatar took a sip of his own drink, staring determinedly straight ahead and out over the ocean. “I have no idea what you are talking about.”
“You know, there is such a word as overkill –”
“Which, funnily enough, is what you are doing by using the term in this specific context.”
Celebrimbor threw him a knowing look, but he couldn’t quite keep from grinning. “Annatar. You destroyed the man.”
Annatar shrugged. “I am a firm proponent of the philosophy that if someone repeatedly begs for a clap around the ear, it would be remiss to deny that person a heartfelt wish.”
Celebrimbor laughed. “Oh no, this was as little a ‘clap around the ear’ as a salamander is a dragon. I reiterate: you destroyed the man.”
“Yes, so what?” Annatar raised an eyebrow, leaning forward to rest his elbows on his knees. “I find it strange that you worry about this now, after you decided that the earnings I gained by destroying him on the market were best spent on establishing a printing press cartel and forcing Daeror out of the art scene.”
“I never meant to force him out for good. You came up with the cartel and the total market takeover. I merely wanted to give him a good warning shot.”
Annatar sighed. “See, and this is exactly why you will never amount to much of anything in the way of an evil emperor. You are not resolute enough, and you let your enemies off lightly.”
“Daeror is not my enemy.”
“That right there is an attitude problem.” Annatar took a sip of his own drink and gestured vaguely at the elf. “Not evil enough.”
“Are you trying to shape me into some kind of Dark Lord?” Celebrimbor regarded Annatar over the rim of his glass, eyebrow raised.
The Maia shook his head. “No, I’ve given up on that a long time ago. You’re utterly hopeless.”
Celebrimbor looked back out over the ocean. “Yes. Maybe. I didn’t actually want to do anything evil with the money. I mostly just wanted to go on vacation.”
Annatar slumped back in his chair and sighed. “Utterly, completely hopeless.”
“I must be such a disappoinment,” Celebrimbor grinned.
“You have no idea.”
“Poor you. Not. Find someone else to be a Dark Lord with you.”
“I don’t want anyone else.”
Celebrimbor stared at him. Blinked. The fell back into his chair and laughed until tears were blurring his vision.
Annatar looked at him as if he had lost his mind. “Are you alright?”
“I’m fine. I’m great.” Celebrimbor wiped his eyes. “It’s just – have you ever noticed how horrendously hopeless you are when it comes to romantic things? You slip and slide around these things like a deer caught on a frozen lake, and then you do those grand heart-breaking gestures and say those wonderful things, only it’s exclusively and always completely by accident.”
Annatar bristled. “I am not – I made you the necklace.”
Celebrimbor shook his head. “Oh no, don’t even try that angle. Even a broken clock is right twice a day.”
Annatar looked like he wanted to argue, then he caught himself. Frowned. “Fine. Maybe I am not the best at these things.”
“Oh look, insight and character growth.” Celebrimbor chuckled. “Rest assured though, unintentional though it might have been, it was lovely. ‘Task failed successfully’, as Rían would say.” He wiped his eyes with his lower arm. Valar, he couldn’t even see, everything was a blur of colours.
They were silent for a while.
“For two hopeless cases, we’ve gotten pretty far, though,” Annatar said at last.
Celebrimbor looked up.
“It could be a lot worse,” Annatar elaborated, gesturing between the two of them. One half of his face was in shadow, the other was painted in sunset colours. There was a false bottom to the sentence, a lot that was implied but went unsaid: dark, heavy things, lighter things that you could look back on and laugh. In the end, though, the simple truth remained. In the end, it wasn’t the moment to pry up the floorboards of the conversation.
The sunset was marvellous, the air was warm and summery, the mood was peaceful. Sometimes you just had to allow a nice moment to be just that: nice.
– Except, of course, if there was a jab to made.
“It could be worse?” Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “Even though the ocean is right there?”
“Even though the ocean is right there.”
Celebrimbor considered this. Then he smirked and raised his drink. “Cheers to hopeless cases, then.”
Annatar smiled. “Cheers.”
They clinked their glasses together.
A few end notes:
After spending more than a year without anything noteworthy to report, Artanis’ spies eventually returned to Lothlórien. It was determined that while the hellish-looking, cat-eyed, Ring-powered tower was certainly supremely strange, it wasn’t dangerous. According to the spies it was, to quote, ‘actually a quite nifty invention, what with carrying groceries and its eye lighting the way when the street lights don’t work’. Artanis remained suspicious, but in the end, she had nothing to base those suspicions on and had to let it go.
Annatar and Celebrimbor eventually returned from their extended travels, taking up the mantle of teaching and inventing once more. On and off, they worked on the Rings, but it was a slow thing, and neither of them seemed to be in a hurry to create more excitement for themselves, a least for a while.
This period of peace and quiet ended, of course, when Celebrían got wind of her cousin’s return and came back to Ost-in-Edhil. Celebrimbor would never understand how and why Annatar and Celebrían had decided to get along like a house on fire. He nearly jumped out of his skin when Celebrían greeted Annatar with a huge grin and something that had to be a bastardized version of the Sylvan nickname for ‘older sibling’ and he lost all hope when they appeared in each other’s company often enough that the Mírdain simply resorted to dub them the ‘Terrible Two’.
Wraith returned to being a mostly ordinary, if scarily intelligent, cat. Given Ossy’s full schedule that was way too full with helping out the citizens of Ost-in-Edhil, and altruism being something that Wraith had no mind for, the cat eventually left Ossy to his devices. When asked, she communicated that speaking wasn’t all that it was cracked up to be and anyway, there was such a thing as body language, which was superior to verbal communication anyway. Annatar eventually created another speaking device for her, but she used it only now and then, preferring to go back to mouse-hunting and dog-scaring. Oh, and helping Annatar to mark his tests and now and then upending an entire inkpot over them whenever a particularly bad attempt at a mathematical proof annoyed her all too much.
As for Daeror – eventually he was allowed back into the art scene of Ost-in-Edhil. However, the local theatre was now under the direction and aegis of an unknown shadowy figure that took malicious glee in vetting each and every single one of his productions before allowing it to be performed on-stage. It was clearly a personal matter, since no other poet hat to suffer such censure.
When Daeror approached Annatar about this one day and said, “I give up. Just – stop it,” the Maia just raised one eyebrow innocently and said, “I have no idea what you are talking about.”
“Of course you do,” Daeror said, looking utterly and completely wretched.
“Do I?”
“Yes.”
“Explain to me, then, what I do supposedly know.”
“You are ruining me. And my career. You are doing it on purpose to get your revenge. But – but it’s gone on long enough.” Daeror wrung his hands. “You’ve had your fun. You made your point. Make it stop.”
Annatar considered this. “Do tell, Deukalion,” he said slowly. “You being a famed poet and man of literature and so very much in love with telling stories – are you familiar with the concept of ‘the moral of the story’?”
Daeror blinked. “What do you – of course I am.”
Annatar levelled a long, piercing look at him. Golden eyes, promising danger in an otherwise friendly expression. “Well then. What have we learned from this particular story?”
Daeror stared at him. He opened his mouth. Closed it again. Ran a hand through his hair, aggravated. Then sighed. His shoulders slumped.
“Yes, yes. I get it,” he said reluctantly. “You win.”
Annatar smiled. “Of course I do.”
Daeror looked at him.
The Maia looked back. His smile got wider. It did, at some point, show way too many teeth.
Daeror suppressed a shudder. “I should get back to my writing.”
“Yes, you should,” Annatar said lightly. “Best of luck and great success with your new project. I will follow your future choices of topics with great interest.”
Daeror, who had been a famous person of public life long enough to recognize the knife’s edge that separated praise from a threat, swallowed. “That’s … good to know.”
He left. If he did it more quickly than he usually sauntered along at a leisurely pace – well, no one had to know that.
*
Three months later, Octopus Prints and all associate shops and printing presses were closed down, as somehow its owners and investors had, incredibly, managed to run the enterprise into the ground despite a gigantic venture capital.
Daeror, who could hardly believe it when he read about the dissolution of the conglomerate, finally felt like he could breathe again after months and years.
It should be noted, though, that he made it a point to never ask anyone about their private matters again nor took further such inspiration for his works.
In any case, the occasional small notes that somehow, impossibly always found their way onto his desk inside his locked, private office at home had nothing at all to do with that. Anyone who claimed differently was simply a liar and a slanderer.
The notes were small, unassuming, and he was enough of a fiend for self-punishment that he did, in fact, open and read them every time. The messages were handwritten, consisted only of one sentence that was the same every time, and somehow, despite it only being words on paper, the notes sounded impossibly smug:
Anyway, Deukalion, how’s your text life?
Daeron shuddered, crumpled it, and chucked it into the overflowing waste bin, where it joined scrapped drafts of his newest drama, as well as about twenty of other identical, balled-up messages.
Have you ever been so mad at someone that you a) told yourself "I'm going to end this man's whole career" and then proceeded to do so by b) inventing literal revenge porn and c) making an entire industry out of it?
If not, congratulations, you are probably not Annatar and you are also not a psycho, and I cannot say to what degree those two are or aren't a tautology.
Thanks for reading!