New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Celebrimbor didn’t see Annatar for a full week. They had not parted on bad terms, but on the clear note that each of them needed some time to think. At times, they passed each other in the hallway, acknowledging each other with a nod, and then going their own way, but neither had attempted to approach the other. In Annatar’s case, Celebrimbor suspected that it was because the Maia did not want to encroach where he was not wanted. Which was not true, per se. But.
Time and distance had been ... not a good thing, but necessary.
Not good, because it meant he had to work through everything that their conversation had ripped open if he wanted to go back to his everyday life.
Necessary, because he needed to work through everything that their conversation had ripped open if he wanted to go back to his everyday life.
That being said, the past days had been less than pleasant, and he was glad that no one else had been around to see it. Now, a week later, on a comparably mild day at the end of November, with silver-gold winter sunlight streaming through his windows, Celebrimbor finally felt like the world had readjusted itself on its tracks, and was turning at its normal, calm pace again.
A stark contrast to the fits and starts the week before, when past and present had overlapped, and jumped and jolted – forward, backward – and then he’d lost a whole day again, or awoken in the darkest hours between night and morning, and couldn’t remember whether he had fallen asleep at his desk while grading papers or simply gone elsewhere and fallen into a stupor that had lasted for hours.
This night, he had at least manage to fall asleep in his bed. Which was. Something.
When he sat up and rubbed his eyes, he felt slow and tired, but in the way one had after having normal night’s sleep, not the lethargic disorientation that had thrown the past few days into a chaotic, directionless blur.
Celebrimbor thew back the blankets and padded over to the hearth, throwing fresh logs onto the coals to keep the fire going. The heated water piping did a great part in keeping the tower warm, but as winter approached, additional heat was always welcome. Afterwards, he left the bedroom and exited into his study, half of a mind to go to the lecture halls – when he realized that he didn’t know what day it was. He hunted down his calendar in the absolute chaos of his usually organized workspace, and learned that it was, indeed, a Saturday and that he didn’t actually have any obligations today, teaching or otherwise.
Which would have sent a spike into his mind and chest only one day earlier, but today... today he might be able to deal with having some time to himself, untethered from obligations and activities that kept his mind from being thrown back on itself.
Celebrimbor threw the calendar back onto the desk-top. He’d clean the mess later. A shower, first.
It was also under the shower when the message reached him. It came so suddenly and unexpectedly, he chucked the bar of soap straight across the room. Fine, so maybe his nerves had not yet entirely settled down.
Celebrimbor cursed externally, while internally, he re-established the rapidly cut connection of osanwë and asked politely, Could you repeat that, please? I was distracted.
This did not feel like a distraction, his aunt Artanis spoke drily. More like somebody ambushed you.
The disadvantage of osanwë was, clearly, that it did not allow one to think things like, Well, you did, while in mental conversation, so Celebrimbor stowed away the thought with a frown, and instead decided to have a friendly, fruitful conversation with a dear relative.
What can I help you with, Aunt?
There was a suspiciously long silence, during which Celebrimbor could colourfully and life-like picture Artanis staring out into the trees from her flet, contemplating whether she should force the issue. He sensed the moment when she decided against it.
I have been trying to reach you for quite some time over the past few days, but was unable to.
I was busy, he replied.
Hm. Disbelief flooded their shared connection, but again, Artanis kept her silence. Thankfully. Are you well?
Perfectly fine, thank you for asking. Yourself?
Adequate. Your consideration is appreciated. Artanis used the tone of someone who was thoroughly fed up with something, but was too polite or too private to elaborate upon it in company. I was trying to talk to you about Celebrían.
Celebrimbor shoved a few strands of wet hair out of his face and raised an eyebrow. Rían? What’s with her?
Yule is approaching, Artanis said, as if that explained anything at all.
It is. And?
She wants to visit you. One of the travellers had put some ideas into her mind how nice the city is in the weeks leading up to the Yule celebrations, and now she has gotten it into her head that she wants to spend Yule in a – and I quote – ‘cosmopolitan, lively place for once, not this woody backwater where nothing ever happens’.”
Celebrimbor grimaced and fought a grin at the same time. It was a weird feeling on his face. That is … harsh.
I’ve had harsher, Artanis replied blandly. It is the nature of privileged youth not to recognize privilege.
Kids will be kids, I suppose. Celebrimbor reached for his towel and wrapped it around his waist.
In less lofty terms, yes.
And? Are you going to let her?
As my daughter informed me yesterday, the days when I can ‘let’ her or ‘forbid’ her from doing something are apparently rapidly nearing their end, Artanis responded flatly.
Oh, that age. Celebrimbor couldn’t quite hide a grin when he stepped out of the tub and then went in search of the soap that had unexpectedly gone on travels.
Quite.
So, is she coming or not? Celebrimbor took a circuit of the bathroom, then another when he came up with nothing.
She wants to arrive in the city on the first of December. I wanted to give you an early notice, because as I have been informed, she is going to write to you and ask for your permission to come.
Oh, and my permission she’s going to heed? Celebrimbor thought back, sceptical, while rubbing his hair dry with a second towel.
That remains to be seen. Things being as they are, the words of cousins apparently outweigh the word of a parent.
Huh. My condolences.
Thank you.
There was an awkward silence. Celebrimbor stopped in his steps.
You are not going to ask me to turn her away, are you?
Another, even longer pause.
I would be happy to have her, Celebrimbor continued; faster, more urgent. She can run with Falda and Anthere, they are basically of the same age cohort of their kind. I could ride out with her. Or go to the archery range and to the fencing hall, if she still likes that.
It is not, Artanis responded pointedly, my daughter’s entertainment schedule I am worried about.
Celebrimbor’s heart sank. I ...
He broke off. He couldn’t exactly tell his aunt in good conscience that Annatar posed no danger to her daughter. Because if push came to shove, Annatar was able level the entire city with a thought. And yet – so could have done Melian, if she so wished. Maiar, being basically sentient forces of nature, were inherently dangerous to be around. But what they chose to do or not to do had to count for something.
On the other hand, his aunt had warned him away from Annatar since day one, and look how well-founded her suspicions had turned out to be. Which also had to count for something.
Why couldn’t anything ever be easy?
I would not leave her alone around Annatar. Or I could even avoid them meeting in the first place, he offered, even though the very thought rankled him. I can keep them apart.
Artanis was silent.
I guess, she responded at last, it would be too much to ask to request your support in not exposing my daughter to potential harm.
Celebrimbor’s jaw tightened. Young or not, Celebrían is her own person. If she wants to come, she will turn up at the gates no matter what you or I say.
She certainly will not get into the city if you close the doors to her and send her home.
She’s just going to set up camp outside the walls, or scale them during night-time, and you know it, Celebrimbor said. Besides, the gates of Ost-in-Edhil remain open. Always. To everyone.
His aunt did not respond immediately. I see, she said at last, the connection turning cold. I told you what I wanted to tell you. Expect my daughter’s letter, then.
Something inside Celebrimbor’s chest – something age-old, that had never really learned how to deal with discord among family – clenched painfully. But he was angry, too, and the anger did a fine job at keeping him steadfast and propelling him onward.
I will. Thank you for letting me know in advance.
Artanis did not respond to his thanks. Keep them apart, she said instead. I will know if you go against my word. Ost-in-Edhil might be your city, but this is my daughter we are talking about.
Your wishes will be respected, Celebrimbor acceded, because what else was he supposed to say? He couldn’t even tell his aunt that she was wrong with all her suspicions about Annatar – indeed, they were even worse than what she, in all likeliness, suspected. I’ll keep her safe.
Do not begin anew your family’s regretful tradition to make promises you cannot keep, Artanis said. Do your best, and leave it at that.
And with that, the connection broke.
Celebrimbor sighed, and buried his face in the towel, briefly shutting out the outer world that was insisted on causing problems he had never asked for. After a few seconds, he dropped the towel, hung it over a hot-water pipe, and then went on searching the soap bar.
The soap bar, in turn, proved irrationally resistant to being found. It has to be here somewhere; it cannot physically have vanished.
However, the soap bar did not seem to concern itself with such trivial matters as physics and impossibility. After five more minutes of fruitless search, Celebrimbor finally admitted defeat and abandoned the search, yielding the soap to the inscrutable, ever-hungry pocket dimension that devoured quills, buttons, and left socks.
There were more important matters to attend to. Like the fact that his younger cousin would be spending all of December in Ost-in-Edhil, which was an unexpected delight. Despite the persistently polite-but-lukewarm relations between Ost-in-Edhil and Lothlórien, Celebrían’s and Celebrimbor had always been close. The vast age difference between them and the fact that they rarely saw each other notwithstanding, their rapport was cordial and characterized by easy familiarity. They were also surprisingly similar in character. Celebrían had, for a long time, been too young to be interested in politics, and now that she was nearing adulthood, it had turned out that she simply didn’t care about diplomatic machinations, regardless of her age and lineage. Which was superb, because Celebrimbor loathed politics with a passion, and would rather talk about anything else on any given day.
However, Celebrían was also unfortunately similar to Celebrimbor in the aspect that she couldn’t sit still for a single minute, and tended to be drawn to pastimes that were either risky, downright dangerous, or explosive, or a combination of all three. Which meant that he had to figure out how to keep his cousin from tearing down the archery range and-or the laboratories on her first day. And, to top this off, she’d be he here for a whole month, without a father or a mother to rein her in. Celebrimbor smothered the slight flicker of panic, wondering how this was how his parents had felt as soon as they had realized what type of son they were currently rearing.
Unwittingly, though, Celebrimbor defaulted to the masterplan of every parent or parental figure hopelessly out of their depth, all across the world, across all eons: Eh, I’ll cross that bridge when I get to it.
Very satisfied with this solid plan, he was able to divert his attention to present matters. Like the knocking on his door.
Celebrimbor walked over and pulled it open, coming face to face with a very taken-aback looking Annatar.
“Hello,” Celebrimbor said.
“Good... morning,” Annatar responded, his eyes roving over Celebrimbor once, then schooling his features into something resembling equanimity. “Out of polite interest, what would you have done if someone had come calling upon you in an official function?”
Celebrimbor inclined his head. “What do you mean? I would still have opened the door, of course.”
“Yes,” Annatar said, the world slightly drawn-out. “I do wonder, though, whether you would have bothered to put on clothes before answering the call.”
“Put on – oh.” Celebrimbor looked down at himself and only now did he remember that he was still merely dressed in a bath towel, and that his long, damp hair was plastered to his scalp, shoulders and back. “Well, damn it. I apologize for the improper state of dress.”
“Don’t worry, the view could be worse,” Annatar said, and leaned against the door frame, his arms crossed. “Though I remain undecided on the matter of how coherent any ensuing conversation with the proposed visitor would be.” The corner of his mouth twitched with amusement.
Celebrimbor looked up at him. “Hard to tell. How distracted are you?”
“Truth be told, I completely forgot what I wanted when I came here. My mental capacity is right now fully occupied with the question whether you’d forget your head at home if it wasn’t attached to your neck.”
Celebrimbor raised both eyebrows. “And I’m supposed to believe that?”
“Believe whatever you want to believe. Just let me say right here and now, that you are not allowed to come crying to me the day when you walk down into the lecture halls and your students flee in terror because you forgot to put on clothes.”
Celebrimbor’s mouth twisted into a grin. “Well, now I’m almost tempted to try it out just for the hell and havoc of it.”
Annatar grinned back. “Notify me when you do, so I can record it for the annals of Eregion.”
And just like that, they were back at a point that Celebrimbor had wondered about how long it would take them to reach again. He had imagined stiffness, distance, caution, perhaps even fear – and yet here they were, right back in their usual rhythm and closeness, as if nothing had happened.
Or, perhaps, as if something groundbreaking, something earth-shaking had happened, but it had simply not been enough to destroy this.
Celebrimbor’s grin turned into a smile. He stepped back and made an inviting gesture into his rooms. “Do you want to come in?”
“If I may.” Annatar’s smile, too, had transformed into something quieter, smaller. Something warmer, more private. Expectant, hopeful, but not demanding.
“Always,” Celebrimbor said and opened the door a bit further. He waited for something to happen – for fear to raise its head, for worries, for the pit to re-open in his stomach, when Annatar passed him by, but ...
Nothing.
Just warmth and white-gold winter sunlight falling in through the high glass windows, making the room seem high and bright and clear, and seeking its like in Annatar’s hair, his eyes, his white robes, now trimmed with white light.
Annatar took a few steps into the room, then turned around. “How have you been?”
Celebrimbor gave a one-sided shrug. “I’ve had worse.”
Annatar frowned, for a few moments clearly on the verge of pressing the matter, but then decided to let it go. “But now? You are better?”
“Yes,” Celebrimbor said and surprised himself by how much he meant it. How true it sounded. He felt alright. Strong. Healthy. Awake. A world away from the shaking, stumbling, hollowed-out hull of person swamped in their darkest memories that had been dragging itself through the last few days.
“I don’t know how long it will last, or if there will be – there certainly will be ... worse days. Again. At some point. But it doesn’t matter. There always are. For now, I’m good.” Celebrimbor tried to smile, and found, to his pleasant surprise, that he could do it and mean it.
Annatar had been watching him intently while he spoke. Now, the Maia looked him up and down once more from top to toe; scrutinizing, looking for something that was off. There was no telling whether he found something or what he was thinking. At last, he nodded.
“And you?” Celebrimbor asked, when his friend didn’t speak.
Annatar did not answer immediately, clearly contemplating how forthright he should be, seeing how Celebrimbor himself had forgone honesty in lieu of something curt and light and socially acceptable that one could quickly move on from.
“I was worried about you,” he said at last.
Celebrimbor stilled.
“I knew you were going to be alright. Eventually. You are strong. Stronger than anyone I have ever known,” Annatar said, crossing his arms – perhaps unwittingly. “Nevertheless, it was ... unpleasant to watch. Unpleasant to know that I had been the cause of this.”
“It’s fine.”
“I know. But I could have done without ‘fine’ being preceded by pain.” There was tension in the line of Annatar’s shoulders and a shadow on his face. Celebrimbor did not like it. It had no place here, in this sun-flooded room, on this wonderful winter morning, where everything was silver and gold and light.
He stepped up to Annatar, took his hands and gently pried them out of their stiff cross of defence against the Maia’s chest. And when that was undone, he stepped even closer until they were almost nose to nose, intertwining their fingers. “No shadows,” Celebrimbor said softly. “Not today.”
At first, Annatar seemed taken aback. This close, Celebrimbor could see the shades of gold and amber and honey-brown in his iris, shifting with every minute movement of his face, could see how the golden waves of his hair caught fire in the winter sun, every strand backlit by corona of white light.
It was breathtaking; nearly painful to behold.
He was the most beautiful thing Celebrimbor had ever seen.
Just then, in this soft silver-golden silence, something like understanding crossed Annatar’s face. “No shadows,” he agreed, his voice low, barely above a whisper.
Celebrimbor nodded, leaned in, and kissed him.
Annatar, who had heretofore strictly kept to his own space, paying great attention not to get too close in, to overstep – froze. But just for a moment. And then, rapidly, suddenly, wonderfully – changed. It was like winter turning into spring, ice turning into water. The stiffness, the hardness, the coldness, all of it went away, transformed into something soft and warm and pliant. He leaned in, leaned close, his centre of balance for the first time coming towards Celebrimbor, instead of shying away from him. Reached back, his heretofore unresponsive fingers tightening around Celebrimbor’s, before letting go, wrapping his arms around the elf’s shoulders, holding on, pulling closer, as if he didn’t intend to let go again.
At some point, they let go of each other’s hands. Palms cupping faces, fingers burying into hair.
At some point, Celebrimbor was up against the wall of his study, Annatar’s mouth a searing, hot burn on the side of his throat. Their hands were joined again, their fingers intertwined. Celebrimbor’s knuckles pressed against the wall where Annatar had pinned his hands, their palms as hot against each other as if they were holding liquid fire.
How had they gotten here?
At some point, Annatar looked up at him and said, “You are still wearing it”, his fingers feather-light under the necklace he had given Celebrimbor, and there had been something in his voice that Celebrimbor didn’t remotely comprehend, and it nevertheless nearly broke him, when he breathed out, “Of course I am. Of course –” And that was as far has he got before Annatar’s mouth on his own silenced the rest of his words, and the cool wall at his back was nothing against the blazing heat against his front.
At some point he became aware that they had switched locations again. They were now in his bedroom, the door to the study closed, quiet enveloping them. Quiet and light. Outside of the tower: the ice-blue sky, nothing else.
At some point, Celebrimbor became suddenly, and violently – as these things sometimes happened – aware of his own breathing, of his own stumbling heartbeat, of this intimate, overwhelming embodiment into muscle and bone, air and heat.
Nearly at the same time, he became aware of something else. Another heartbeat, drumming an off-beat rhythm with his own. Another heart, pumping blood, blood rushing like a wild torrent through veins. Breaths not of himself, but pushed out by a different set of lungs. His hands ran across skin – skin that was somehow more ... present than what he was used to.
The haze of light and warmth lifted, and he could see that Annatar was before him, was in his arms – was, somehow, impossibly, physically there, more than he ever had been. He was also down to a thin white tunic that was half unlaced at the front – who had done this and how? – and white linen trousers. He was barefoot, and bare under his tunic, and the skin Celebrimbor felt was the skin of Annatar’s arms, the welts of scars, the texture of skin, the warmth of a living, breathing, incarnate body –
“What–?” Celebrimbor began. Broke off. Tried again. “What are you doing?”
Annatar smiled wryly at him – a thing that was, at once, private and coy, dazzling and devious and dangerous in this enclosed space between them, between heaving chests, racing hearts, heavy breaths.
“I am trying new things.” He rested his forehead against Celebrimbor’s. “I am trying to be more like you.”
“More like me?” Celebrimbor let out a laugh. “Impulsive, impetuous, and far too quick with important decisions?”
Annatar pulled back to look at him. “No. Open." He hesitated. “Braver. Not - hiding away.” He looked away.
Celebrimbor’s smile faded slightly.
Annatar visibly worked through what he wanted to say, before he continued, “You have seen the worst there is to me and still decided to open your door to me once more. Against wisdom, against better judgement.”
“Love has little to do with wisdom, as I’ve come to learn.”
Annatar looked up, at last. “But love without truth is a mummer’s farce.”
And if there was anything extraordinary in this, if there was anything unspeakable and unbelievable in being seen and daring to be seen – without veils, without masks, without lies, without shadows – neither made any mention of it. It felt like falling into the sky, it felt like sunlight on rippling water, crystal-clear, like a flower opening in mid-winter.
Celebrimbor was silent for a moment. “That is ... wonderful. But you realize - we don’t have to do this.” He gestured between them. “This has nothing to do with being brave. Or open. Or what we are to each other.” He reached up and brushed his knuckles against Annatar’s chin, up his cheek, then tucked a wayward strand of hair behind his ear. Annatar caught his hand with his own and pressed them both against his cheek, before turning his head and kissing Celebrimbor’s palm, his eyes closed and his frame very still for a moment.
“I know,” Annatar said, speaking into Celebrimbor's palm. “I know. I was just thinking that perhaps I could - ” He broke off, then ran his fingers down Celebrimbor's arm before brushing them over his knuckles. “Being close like this is so different from the ways I know.” He paused. “Perhaps we could try. Just the once.
“We can,” Celebrimbor said. “But we do not have to. You are under no obligation to do this. Not to me, not to yourself.”
Annatar opened his eyes. “I know,” he repeated.
Celebrimbor regarded him for a few moments, then he smiled. “That being said, feel free to go along with what you feel like doing. Don’t worry on my account. I am curious where you are going to take this. I hardly know the side of you that puts curiosity over caution.”
The Maia quirked up one eyebrow, his head slightly inclined as if he was regarding an amusing puzzle. “It’s a rather new approach for me. I will freely admit as much. There is one last thing I have to tell you, though.”
“What would that be?”
Annatar held his gaze for a few long moments, then gravely, solemnly, pronounced, “I have no idea what I am doing.”
An incredulous bout of laughter burst from Celebrimborʼs lips. “Welcome to the mortal experience,” he said, still laughing, then pulled the Annatar towards him into another kiss.