New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Celebrimbor had a little-known supernatural power – so little-known that not even his closest kin knew about it, in fact.
To explain: Usually, his mind worked in the way of a greedy octopus when it came to learning new things: it was eagerly making grabs all around with all appendages it had, trying to incorporate and ingest as much information as possible.
However, Celebrimbor had a mental switch. He could throw this switch voluntarily. Whenever he did so, the octopus vanished and was replaced by a consummate bureaucrat. The consummate bureaucrat was also a consummate arsehole in that he was never responsible for anything, that it was always past office hours, and if you so much as handed him something to process, he would throw it into a waste bin under his desk unread.
This worked great most of the times when he wanted to get people off his back with topics he did not want to talk about. Most got the message within a few moments and backed off.
Right now though Annatar did not get the message. Did not want to get the message, as Celebrimbor was beginning to suspect. Neither did he back off.
Instead, the Maia kept handing the mental bureaucrat a sheet of paper on which I AM SAURON was written in capital letters over and over again, and the bureaucrat was slowly but surely getting angry and anxious because he couldn’t ignore that information anymore and also his waste bin was flowing over and about to spill a hundred crumpled copies of I AM SAURON right over his office floor. Where he would have no choice but to read it. And understand what was written there.
The bureaucrat realized with horror that he was inefficient.
Celebrimbor realized that he had no choice but to intervene. He switched gears.
“Stop,” he said.
Annatar snapped his mouth shut.
“Stop,” Celebrimbor repeated, turning around from where he had stood staring out of the high window, hands clasped behind his back. “I heard you the first time.”
“You didn’t react,” Annatar said acridly, his fingers digging into the upholstery of the armrests of his chair.
“Aptly observed,” Celebrimbor commented. “Nonetheless, I have gone neither dumb nor deaf, so consider your information shared and your secret revealed. Thank you for your candour.”
Annatar stared at him. A few seconds ticked by in loaded silence. “Is that all that you are going to say?”
Celebrimbor narrowed his eyes, trying very hard to talk about a topic without spending time thinking about the topic, which was proving increasingly and irritably harder every second. “Excuse me, is there more that you wanted to hear?”
Annatar threw out his hands. “I don’t know! Probably! Maybe I expected to hear something that demonstrates that you have indeed heard and understood what I just told you – the weight of what I just told you!” He sounded agitated. He sounded desperate. Celebrimbor had never seen him like this before. He knew that Annatar needed something. To hear something, probably. Celebrimbor looked inside himself and found only a hollow place. He had nothing to give right now.
“What do you want me to say?” Celebrimbor asked flatly.
“I don’t know!” Annatar repeated. “Just –” He broke off. “Did you even understand what I was saying?”
“I understood you just fine.”
A few seconds passed in silence.
“So what?” Annatar said, rising from his armchair. “You don’t care?”
Celebrimbor went back to staring out of the window. His gaze snagged on the three peaks of Khazad-Dûm, black under the star-strewn night sky. He wished he could be there. If not in the city itself, even the frozen peak would do. Or somewhere else. Rhûn. Númenor. Lindon. Anywhere but here.
The image of a door kept rising inside his mind. A locked door, with no light seeping out from under it. Only pure darkness.
“Tyelperinquar.” Annatar’s voice sounded closer. Celebrimbor felt a vein pulse at his temple, his mouth twitched. Couldn’t the Maia let this go for just one minute?
“What,” Celebrimbor said, impatiently, and turned around.
Annatar was standing directly in front of him, his eyes too bright in the gloom of the dark room.
Celebrimbor didn’t flinch.
“Do you,” Annatar repeated, “not understand or do you not care about what I have just told you?”
“Don’t insult me,” Celebrimbor said quietly. “I have heard and understood you, Gorthaur.” The world felt like slicing his own tongue open with a serrated knife. A white-hot blade drove into Celebrimbor’s brain and for a moment, he had to fight to keep his balance, for a moment he had to fight to cling to his body, as his spirit seemed to want to catapult itself into the empty ether –
The Maia visibly recoiled.
“Is that proof enough for you?” Celebrimbor added sharply, secretly reaching out for the windowpane behind him to steady himself until he felt sure on his feet again.
For a moment, Annatar did not speak. “You aren’t –” he said. “You act like you are not even surprised.”
Celebrimbor remained silent. He stared at a point over Annatar’s shoulder, a piece of wall on the other side of the room where a crack had formed in the plaster.
“Tyelperinquar.” Annatar reached out, then quickly drew his hand back, as if he had thought better of touching the elf. “Speak to me.”
Speak to me.
About this?
There was door in his mind and dark things were behind it and something was pushing against it from the other side, trying to force it open, trying to let the dark things out, even though he had spent so much time and effort herding the things inside and locking the door after them and now – and now the darkness was seeping out and the lock was about to break and –
Celebrimbor pushed off the window, closed his eyes and took a deep breath, before turning back around to face Annatar again. “I am going to speak of this once, and then we are never going to mention it again,” he said. “Are we clear?”
Annatar did a strange thing then – for the briefest of moments, he half-turned around and his eyes flitted to the open door leading to Celebrimbor’s study behind him, as if he was expecting it to slam shut by some unknown force – as if Celebrimbor was capable of locking them both in here in the first place. It would have been disconcerting in any other moment, and he could have, should have wondered why a lesser god had it somehow ingrained in his brain to keep open escape routes – but right now the concern didn’t manage to reach the place where it would have stirred something inside Celebrimbor.
His mind and soul had gone cold and hard and reflective like a sheet of ice – or glass. Nothing found purchase, and the world and everything in it were one step removed, seen through a clear wall that separated him from everything.
The Maia regained his composure. Faced him. Nodded.
“I’ve known who you were ever since you stepped foot in this city for the first time,” Celebrimbor said.
Annatar went rigid.
“My aunt advised me to throw you out,” Celebrimbor continued, unfazed. “So did the High-king. Even though they didn’t know. All they had were suspicions.” He shrugged. “But I knew.”
“You knew?” Annatar said, almost inaudible. He took one step back. Then another.
“I did.”
“How?”
Celebrimbor smiled thinly. “You forget that I spent my childhood in Tirion having none other than Morgoth himself prowling the perimeter of our grounds. There are auras you do not forget in a lifetime. Its shadows were clinging to thickly to you that you might as well have been carrying them as a cloak. They do not just go away. My grandfather and my father never managed to get rid of them, either.”
Annatar was silent for a brief moment. “Half of the population of your city carries the same shadow. I could have been a prisoner in Angband.”
“Possibly.” Celebrimbor gave a one-sided shrug. “And I think your excellent lie by omission had many people fooled and led them to assume the seemingly obvious. The best lies are those with a kernel of truth, after all.” He smirked humourlessly, then the expression dropped off his lips. “But there were only so many Maiar that had gone to Beleriand and were unaccounted for or missing. Of those that had ties to Aulë and yet carried Morgoth’s darkness around their shoulders like a shroud – there were even less. Comparable to Gorthaur’s rank and power – only the one.”
Annatar didn’t speak for a long time. When he did, his voice was searching, uncertain, as if feeling its way forward in the dark in an unknown place.
“Why – why didn’t you chase me away?”
“Why indeed? What could propel someone to make such a clearly deranged decision?” Celebrimbor gave him a dark smile. Annatar did not smile back. His face was blank, devoid of any readable expression.
“I’ll tell you why,” Celebrimbor said, ambling closer. “Because I found you interesting. Incredibly, uncontainably dangerous, an unknown quantity, almost assuredly evil, yes, but interesting. Why had you come? What did you want? Were you pretending to have had a change of heart, or had you truly changed your ways? How did you intend to follow through with your grand claims of the grandest gifts given this side of the sea? What did you have to offer in that game you were clearly playing? I didn’t know. But I wanted to find out, and it is not as if I had much to lose either way. Which is why I let you in. And which is why I allowed you to stay.”
Annatar stared at him. For a moment it seemed he couldn’t speak. “‘You didn’t have much to lose?’ You wagered your own life.”
“You presume that it was something I put value in at the time.”
Annatar briefly hesitated, as if to argue, then went on, “You wagered an entire city and its people. Because you found me interesting.”
“I did. Which should tell you everything you need to know about judging the Fëanorians’ character.” Celebrimbor bared his teeth in a what was the caricature of a smile.
“But – but it was madness.”
“It was – but so what?” Celebrimbor shrugged carelessly. “Fëanor’s line has never had a great claim to sanity.”
“I – this.” Annatar halted. “You should have done it. It was dangerous. Is dangerous. You cannot allow a known enemy to get this close to you. This is going to kill you one day.”
Celebrimbor gave him a considering look, cocking his head slightly in an inquisitive manner. “Perhaps it will kill me. Then again, I don’t know. What say you, though? Is it going to kill me one day, Annatar?”
Annatar took a step back. “Are you implying – no – of course not.”
“Good.” Celebrimbor sat back down in his armchair and crossed his legs. “Then it seems I have nothing fear from you, doesn’t it?”
Annatar was still hovering around the doorframe, as if he was considering turning around and fleeing. He seemed to want to speak, seemed to grasp for words.
“But if you knew – if you were keeping up an act the entire time,” he asked haltingly. “What about the people around you? What about – everything else? Anything you said or did during this time – were we ever … was anything ever real?”
Celebrimbor regarded his fingernails. “Oh, I don’t know. I’m only the second most capable liar in this room right now. What would you say? Was anything ever real?”
Annatar reeled. He took a step back, nearly stumbling then caught himself on the doorframe. “Of course,” he croaked. “Of course. It might have started out as – as an experiment. But in time it turned – into something else.”
“There you go,” Celebrimbor said pleasantly. “I am relieved, I must say. I’d hate to think that I bound my soul to yours for nothing. Coincidentally, I’d also hate for you to think that I would do the binding for nothing else than sport and manipulation. I might have my bad sides, but I’d like to believe that I’m not quite as nihilistic and careless with myself as that.”
Another unwitting gesture – one that Celebrimbor was now sure that Annatar hadn’t realized he was making: the Maia’s hand twitched towards his sternum, where, as Celebrimbor now knew, the broken bond to Aulë had forever left its mark on his ëala and fana in the shape of a huge scar that spanned nearly his entire ribcage. Looking for a new tie, a new bond, a new fetter that he had gotten himself caught in, like a bird getting tangled in one of Ungoliant’s webs.
“I am not going to use it against you,” Celebrimbor said drily.
Annatar quickly pulled his hand away, caught.
“Except, of course, in case you would attempt to do harm to me or mine,” the elf added. “Which, I believe, you swore not to do three minutes ago.”
Annatar’s eyes flashed to him. “Did you do it on purpose? For that purpose?”
“No. I did it because I love you. I didn’t think of it as a weapon at the time.” Celebrimbor shrugged, then crossed one ankle over his knee.
“And yet here we are, each of us the other one’s dead man’s switch.”
“You know, you could just call it a soul-bond and make it sound a little less nefarious. The Eldar do it all the time when they marry.” He made an off-handed gesture. “Besides, the Severing is perfectly survivable. My mother and father lived, after all; I doubt it’s going to kill a god.”
“Except if the bond went deeper in a god than a mortal,” Annatar said sharply. “And if it were tied even more tightly and destructively to the very essence of their being.”
Celebrimbor considered this. “Yes,” he allowed. “Excepting that. There’s no precedence for a god breaking such bond. So I guess it would be wiser to simply … not try.”
Annatar’s eyes narrowed. “I didn’t think cruelty came so easily to you.”
“I told you before: I didn’t think of the bond as a weapon when I created it,” Celebrimbor said.
“I do not mean the bond. Or at least not only the bond.” Annatar crossed his arms, leaning against the doorframe of the open door to Celebrimbor’s study behind him in a very unconvincing display of anger and nonchalance. “You risked yourself for curiosity; and your entire city and your friends on top of that. You welcomed Gorthaur, knowing fully well who he was. So either you cared nothing for the lives of those you claim to love and for your own; or you do care and you still decided to take the risk. In any case, I didn’t think you were capable of being so ruthless.”
“That’s just the thing,” Celebrimbor said quietly. “You have no idea what I am capable of.”
The door in his mind was straining against something dark and fell throwing itself against it from the other side. Soon, if he didn’t walk away and stopped thinking about the things behind the door and thus agitating them, something would give, and all the darkness would come pouring out.
“I cannot fault you for it,” Celebrimbor added, almost absently. “You or anyone else. I am very good at acting the part, so most people think I am kind.”
Annatar raised both eyebrows. “You are implying you are not.”
“Not implying.” Celebrimbor looked at him. “I am not a good person. Never have been. I’ve merely had a few thousand years to realize that being nice will get me farther than being as antagonistic as my father and grandfather have been; and another few millennia to practice the pretence until it became second nature. It was a learning experience.”
Celebrimbor smiled coolly. “Practiced pleasantries. Measured, well-intentioned manipulation – of myself and others. Learning to relent. Coercing myself to cede ground. Learning to care for the concerns of others, even and especially if their desires ran contrary to my own. Studied selflessness – putting myself last and forcing myself to learn that I’m still going to get what I want and need, eventually.” He leaned back.
“I like to think that I succeeded. At times I manage to fool even myself into believing that I am a decent person.” He paused. Thought about this for a second. “But make no mistake – nothing of this came naturally to me. The person that you see here, now is the result of me taking hammer and chisel to my innermost self over the span of millennia and shaping something sympathetic and pleasant out of something that was thoroughly foul and broken.”
Annatar crossed his arms tighter. His shoulders were hunched, his posture tense, his lips a thin line. “Having to learn how to act according to societal norms doesn’t make you a bad person. It is the result that counts. You are a good man. If you weren’t before, you certainly are now. You are willing to learn. To do better. That has to count for something.”
Celebrimbor shook his head. “Even if it were so…” He trailed off. “Even if it were so, it doesn’t undo the things I have done.”
“What things?” Annatar asked. “What could you possibly have done that warrants –”
Celebrimbor grimaced, looked away.
He could no longer not think about it.
He could no longer not remember.
The door in his mind began to burst and splinter. Before it could break, Celebrimbor yanked it open, and the things he had locked away for thousands of years came pouring out like a tide of black tar.
“What could I possibly have done?” Celebrimbor stood from his chair. “I would have sworn the Oath, if my father had not forbidden me from doing so, and I would have done it gladly.” With every sentence, he took a step towards the Maia. “And yet, even if my father would not let me swear, I was determined to prove my worth to the cause of retrieving the Silmarils. By any means necessary. I was in the vanguard that invaded Alqualondë. I was the first at the side of Maedhros and Celegorm in the harbour. We cut loose the swan-ships, and when the sailors came out to stop us, we cut them down. And when their families, their friends, heard their cries, we cut those down, too.” Celebrimbor had stopped, standing three steps from Annatar, his eyes locked onto the past, unseeing in the present.
“The streets ran red with blood. The sea itself was foaming with it, like a stain of red wine that kept spreading upon a white tablecloth. That night the stars went dark, for not even Varda could bear to look upon what we had done.”
He paused. “I saw all this. I did all this. I heard their cries of anger, their pleas for mercy.”
He hesitated. “And I didn’t stop.”
Another pause.
“I did not even regret. I did not care. Not for – so long. Not until I realized the extent of the doom we had wrought. Until I stood at the new shore of a broken land where Beleriand had been before, and realized that this world would break ere the violence could end. But – ” His voice came out stumbling, nearly choked. “But where my uncles and my grandfather could at least claim to have been driven by the Oath –”
A strangled noise, almost unnatural coming from a living being. “I had been free. Nothing and no one had forced my hand, and what I decided to do with this freedom was to go forth with a sword in my hand and turn the Swan-havens into a site of slaughter.”
He looked up at Annatar. “Do you understand now?”
The Maia didn’t reply. Didn’t move. His eyes were fixed on Celebrimbor’s but nothing showed that he had heard or reacted. He seemed to be made of stone.
“This is what I did when given a free decision to act as I please,” the elf said. “This is where my innermost nature, free of fetters, took me. I can never undo this.”
There was a long silence.
“Then how do you go on from this?” Annatar asked, almost inaudibly.
“You don’t,” Celebrimbor replied. He buried his face in his hands. “You don’t. There are some damages that are too great to be fixed, some wrongs too terrible to be undone. There is nothing to repair, because what you broke is broken for good. There is nothing to forgive, because those who would have the power to forgive are dead.” He dragged his palm down his face, forced himself to stand upright even though he wanted to crumple up and vanish and cease to exist.
“I cut it off from me,” he continued. “Put it away, forgot about it, because there was nothing more to be done. I locked it up in a place where I would not have to look at it, gave myself the pretence of a clean slate, and I started over. Taught myself to be different. Taught myself to act and think differently. To do better, to be better – not out of hope for redemption, because it was either being buried by the past or burying the past instead. I chose the latter. I know it doesn’t solve anything. At the same time, nothing remains that can be solved.”
He looked at his hands. “There was nothing to be done. I have gone too far and now I must live with this. With the knowledge of my deeds. With the burden of my guilt.” He curled his fingers, then slowly uncurled them. “Some things, once done, are done.”
Annatar still hadn’t moved.
Seconds, minutes ticked by in silence. Or maybe they didn’t, and time had frozen like ice in midwinter, and this was the new forever – an eternity of wrongs never made right, of chances forever missed, of a discord never resolved. A melody whose last note would always be missing. Caught forever in stasis like a scene in a snow-globe.
As if on cue, thick white snowflakes began to fall outside. Heavy clouds drew a shroud over the starry night sky.
“You said you had no hope for redemption,” the Maia said at last. “Then why are you doing – this?” He made a slow, wide gesture, encompassing the room, the tower, the city outside, their projects, these high, ethereal dreams of a better world. “What does it matter even if we managed to make our plans come true and unmar the world – when you say that you are doomed anyway for the things you have done in the past? Why bother?”
“Just because I have committed atrocities in the past doesn’t mean I have grown incapable of doing good. Even if I can never be a good person, I can be better – in the time that remains to me.” Celebrimbor threw him a long glance. “Even without hope for redemption, I feel it would befit me to do good without the prospect of personal gains. If I stand to gain nothing from it, I can at least be sure that my motivations are genuine rather than self-serving.” He averted his gaze, looking out at the greying night. Already the roofs of the spires and houses below were paling to white.
“What about you?” Celebrimbor asked at last. “Why did you bother?”
Annatar wasn’t looking at him. He was staring at a point on the floor about three feet from the tips of his left white boot. “I was bored,” he said at last, not looking up. “After the disaster of the First Age I had been wandering aimlessly, without goal or objective. I wanted a diversion.”
Celebrimbor crossed his arms and leaned back. “And? Have we been suitably entertaining? What is your verdict after five hundred years of having your own animated dollhouse to play with?”
Words like knives. If only it weren’t so easy to use them.
Annatar threw him a glower, and yes, briefly, there was something else visible in his eyes – something that Celebrimbor had heretofore artfully ignored, but spoke of darker fires, buried deep. “You know you are not a plaything.”
“I certainly started out as one.”
“Things can change. You said so yourself.”
“I did. Speaking for and of me.”
“I changed as well.”
“Did you now.”
“You’re not bound and chained in a cell, for one, but standing here and mouthing off to me.”
Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “Excuse me. I wasn’t aware that your standards for betterment were this atrociously low.”
“You know what I mean,” Annatar snarled. “I have made an effort to change. It might have been a masquerade in the beginning, but it – became something else.”
“While that may be true, you and I remain the same,” Celebrimbor said. “We are not magically different people. We are horrible beings who once made terrible choices – and now made different ones that are hopefully better. We are our past as much as our present and future.”
He rubbed his closed lids, suddenly feeling empty and very tired. He went back to his armchair and sat down, resting his elbows on his knees and watching the snowflakes fall and shroud the world outside in white.
He was silent for a while. “Maybe that was one reason why it was so easy to let you stay. I … saw myself in you. And I deserved you. The best of you … but the worst, too. If I could believe in someone like you turning his life around, there had to be hope for me, as well.”
Soft footfalls told him that Annatar had followed. Not very far, not nearly as close as he would have stood on any other day, but he had moved from his post at the door to stand a few steps behind Celebrimbor’s seat.
“You are nothing like me,” the Maia said quietly.
Celebrimbor shrugged. “I think we’re very much alike.”
“I disagree.”
“You are free to do so.”
Silence.
“Did it never occur to me to send me away? Didn’t knowing who I was affect your view of me in any way?”
“No.” Celebrimbor kept staring at the snowfall, his eyes losing focus, the flakes dissolving into mesmerizing patterns, fractals, spirals, as if there was a higher mind, a great divine geometry and intention behind it all. Valar, he was so tired. “I lock these things away. The First Age. Who I was then. Who you were. Many other things. I know of them, but I do not think of them. I have to keep looking forward, or else – ” He broke off. “I have to keep looking forward.”
“Except for tonight.”
Celebrimbor nodded. His feet and hands felt cold. He would have to pay for opening that door in his memories – if not right now, then later. But it couldn’t be helped.
Some things, once done, are done.
He would survive the aftermath of this, as he had always done when the door had opened in the past, and he would lock the room full of dark memories once more, and life would go on as it always did.
“Does anyone else know?”
Celebrimbor turned his head, glancing at the Maia who was watching him, shrouded in shadow.
“I didn’t tell anyone.”
“That is not the answer to my question.”
Celebrimbor shrugged. “I don’t know. I am certain that my aunt would have put two and two together, had she gotten to know you any better and gotten a sense of the real extent of your power. The same goes for the High-king, for she has his ear and his trust. They were suspicious. Remain so, to this day. But I guess distance was and remains your best disguise. You cannot unmask someone who is beyond your arm’s reach.”
“There are more people in the world than your aunt. Smarter ones, too.”
“Not many.”
“And yet.”
Celebrimbor thought about it. “And yet.”
Half of Ost-in-Edhil’s population was comprised of survivors of Angband: people too damaged and broken to ever find a place again in this world – or so they had believed. Until they had found a place among like minds and hearts, and found that there might yet be a nook for them in this day and age. They bore the shadow of Angband on their hearts, and they recognized its likeness in others with the ease and instinct of wolves of the same pack knew each other’s scent.
Celebrimbor had no doubt that the former prisoners recognized something in the Maia: somethingt that must seem at first glance like a terrible likeness of kinship in pain, in imprisonment. To a sharper eye, however, a damaged soul, sensitive to any shadow of remembrance, to an echo of an old torment –
One might have seen – recognized – remembered – and still, and still –
There were so many reasons to remain silent. So many ways to lose your memories, to lose your voice. To lose your will to act. Chief of them self-delusion, hope against hope, that things were not the way all your senses told you that they were. A rabbit cowering in the grass, a shadow falling across its trembling form, and yet it kept thinking, Let it not be the fox, let it not be the fox, and if it is the fox, let it not have seen me; and if it has seen me, let it not be hungry, let it be full and content, just curious, not out for harm –
Celebrimbor sighed. “I do not know about any of the others,” he said. “I am not going to ask. If you need to assuage any fears on that front, you will need to do it yourself.”
Silence followed in the wake of that statement. Fabric rustled softly when Annatar moved. Quiet steps. Closer.
“What –” Annatar broke off. Another few seconds passed in oppressive stillness. “How do we go on? From here?”
Celebrimbor shrugged, watching the snow fall outside. “As we always have. Nothing has changed. We’ll go on as we did before. The past is past.”
For a moment, nothing happened. Then, suddenly, there was a shadow between him and the still panorama of falling snow against a midnight sky. Golden eyes glared down at him.
“You will not pretend that tonight did not happen.”
“I’d ask you to leave the decision of how I go about dealing with personal matters to me,” Celebrimbor said, frowning. He resisted the impulse to stand, instead looking up at the shade staring down at him.
“I will not.”
“How I deal with tonight – or any other night, for that matter – is not your concern,” Celebrimbor replied, a sharp edge creeping into his voice, like a sword sliding out of a sheath. Not yet a threat, but a warning that could quickly complete the transformation.
Annatar leaned down, gripping the armrests of Celebrimbor’s chair, effectively locking him into his seat. “No,” he hissed. “Because this concerns me as much as it concerns you. I came to you because I wanted to be honest with you. You will not pretend that this never happened, even if you did know before. I will not have my decision thrown back in my face and made irrelevant by your refusal to face unsavoury parts in either of our lives.”
“Careful there,” Celebrimbor murmured, glancing down at Annatar’s fingers, which were digging into the upholstery like claws. “We wouldn’t want those unsavoury parts to make a reappearance, would we, Annatar?”
Annatar recoiled as if the elf had struck a whip across his face. Then his expression darkened. “Come out and say the name, if you can bear it, Curufinwë. But do not play craven games with me.”
“I’m merely reminding you that I have not forgotten who you are,” Celebrimbor said, remaining seated even though his instincts screamed at him to get to his feet and defend himself, or run, or fight.
“Good,” Annatar growled. “Then face it. Remember it. Throw me out or let me stay, abhor me or love me. Do it because of who I am, or in spite of who I was, if you so choose. But you will look at me when you make your choice. At all of me.”
Celebrimbor’s mouth twitched in anger. “What, just because you decided tonight that you were done living a lie you will force me to do the same? Who made you the tyrant of truth?”
Annatar stood stock-still. For a moment, Celebrimbor wondered whether the Maia would be able to hold on to his fraying patience. He could feel a pressure in the room, a building heat, as if they were locked in a sealed crucible, the heat of the fire outside growing, and it was only a matter of time before everything in the crucible woupd be unmade: every bond of affection between them dissolved im the white-hot furnace of truth and fear and wrath.
“That you should name truth ‘tyranny’ is all the answer you need,” Annatar said at last. “I will not be either tolerated or loved in ignorance, even if it be wilful.” He stepped closer and reached out.
Instinctively, Celebrimbor flinched back, but when Annatar’s hand landed on his shoulder, there was no violence in his grip. It was firm, but painless.
“I cannot force you to look at me, Tyelperinquar,” Annatar said. “But I can say that neither do I want nor am I able to do what you did and pretend that nothing has changed.” His grip tightened. “I will not be held hostage by my past any longer – and I would want you to not be, either.”
“It might not be possible to be free from it,” Celebrimbor responded quietly, meeting the Maia’s gaze.
“I seem to recall the saying, ‘Impossible is just an excuse to tell yourself so you can stop trying in good conscience’.” Annatar inclined his head slightly.
Celebrimbor raised his gaze. “Bold of you to quote my own father at me right now, Annatar. Tactless, I might even say.”
“Does being tactless make what I said any less true?”
That, at last, forced a shade of a smirk out of Celebrimbor. “No. It doesn’t.” He sighed and ran a hand through his hair, serious once more. “I have tried to work through this, Annatar. For years and years. I have little hope that I would succeed, given another try.”
“Then do away with hope,” Annatar said curtly. “I seem to recall that spite is an excellent motivator for you Curufinwës.”
That startled a laugh out of Celebrimbor, more surprised than amused. “Of all the moments to bring this up! You could have appealed to my better nature, you know.”
“I know better than to scream into the void. Let us work with what we have.”
“What do we have?” Celebrimbor replied. “Mistakes and horrors and broken things.”
“Then we work with those,” Annatar said simply. “We are good enough to do that. We are the best there are.” He grabbed Celebrimbor’s hands. “And after all, what was your goal if not to create something beautiful of the wreckage of a bygone age? If there is anyone who can turn all his faults around into something good, it is you.”
Celebrimbor stared at their joined hands. “You really want to believe in this,” he said.
“I have to,” Annatar replied. “Who else am I supposed to believe in at this point?”
Celebrimbor nodded almost absently, then it struck him what Annatar had said.
Who. Not what.
His eyes widened and he looked at the god standing before him.
Annatar’s face was serious.
“I –” Celebrimbor began. “I might not –” He broke off once more, because how did you tell a god – who had decided to simply turn the ways of the universe on their head and put his faith in a mortal – how did you tell anyone who had chosen to believe in you, of all things, that they were wrong, their trust misplaced, their hope in vain?
Ah, but perhaps we must truly do without hope.
Celebrimbor shook his head, running his hands down his face.
“I cannot promise anything,” he said. “I will not swear.”
“I do not want you to swear,” Annatar said. “I want you to try.”
Celebrimbor nodded. Only now did he notice that cold sweat had drenched his clothes and stuck his shirt to his back, that his hands were clammy and his fingers stiff. He exhaled, long and slow.
“So, Tyelperinquar Curufinwë,” Annatar said. “What do you want me to do?”
Celebrimbor glanced at him out of the corner of his eye. This black shade with golden eyes, this nightmare of so many that were no longer around to tell of it. The past seemed to have caught up with Morgoth’s lieutenant, and the darkness seemed to have consumed him.
What shall it be?
Stay or leave? Abhorrence or love? Or both, divided in equal measure to the parts deserving it, respectively? A cloven existence, both of memory and of perception?
How was a sane mind to achieve this? How was a sane spirit to unite such violent opposition within itself?
Celebrimbor had no idea.
For now, he recalled only what Annatar had told him:
Throw me out or let me stay, abhor me or love me. Do it because of who I am, or in spite of who I was, if you so choose. But you will look at me when you make your choice. At all of me.
Celebrimbor looked at the Maia, darkness peeling back before his Eldarin sight, revealing the familiar face, the golden eyes and hair, the white robes, a being nearly shadowless in its appearance. A stark contrast to the shade with burning eyes.
And yet, that is not the truth either, is it?
Celebrimbor turned around to face the Maia fully.
“Show me who you are,” he said quietly. “Who you truly are.”
For a brief moment, there was surprise on the Maia’s face. Annatar had always shied back from being seen, retreated behind layers and layers of defence and deflection. All his attempts to lay himself bare he had either resisted or unwittingly subverted. And yet, tonight he had asked for it. He could not back away now, and he knew it.
“It is not a pleasant form to look upon,” Annatar warned. “It was made before mortals came to be, and was not made for their eyes to behold.”
“I know,” Celebrimbor said evenly. “I wish to see it. Show me.”
Annatar regarded him for a moment, then he nodded in acquiescence, and, perhaps, surrender. He closed his eyes. The shadows pulled across him, a darkness that not even Celebrimbor’s eyes could penetrate – and then there was light. Red and gold. Wheels of fire. Something like clockworks of iron, interlocking with black spikes and turning in more than three dimensions at once, folding into themselves like in hypergeometry, more machinery than living thing. Veins of magma running through channels like hot iron in a forge along things that were not limbs, plasma lightning flashing along the contours, jumping in white-blue arcs across the form. Something like two great wings unfolded, lines of fire running along joints spreading like the fingers of a hand, and the primordial void before creation was in its membranes. Higher dimensions kept clipping through the form of the eldritch horror, and the ceiling and walls of the room were suddenly far removed, as if the world itself had bent away to accommodate that which had no place in it.
And there were wounds. Celebrimbor could see them, absences, voids, tears in reality where something had once been and had been taken away, twisted, mangled. A bleeding red, pulsating star in the middle of the creature’s … body, for lack of a better word. It was an old wound, bleeding an ancient pain that was nearly as old as existence itself, and far older than this world that they were now standing in. Then: chains. Shadow and void, not truly there and yet all over the creature like mist overlaying it – broken in some places, strong and cruel in others. They wrapped and wafted around it, ghostly, intangible, yet unable to be shaken. Where they touched the essence of the eldritch creature, they erased it. An Unmaking, a destruction that was so thorough that it bordered on deletion, echoing backwards into time, as if there had never been anything there at all. The youngest wound was another tear, another bleeding indent near the head of the creature – it was more real than the others, forcing the eldritch form into something resembling… corporeality in its immediate vicinity. Puncturing holes, arranged in two great arcs. The bite marks of a giant hound.
But there was also something else: where the red pulsar glowed dully in the void at the centre of the Maia’s chest, there was another glow: white and bright and radiant, and from it emanated - not a ray, but something glowing and woven, almost like a tether. It ran away from the creature’s form, crossed the space between them, and found it’s ending point in another point of light that glowed just where Celebrimbor’s heart was beating inside his ribcage.
As Celebrimbor looked at the being in front of him, its form shifted, its indefinite, incomprehensible hyper-dimensional form shifting slightly into something that was a little less eldritch, a little more familiar. The room returned to its usual dimensions.
Celebrimbor could discern something that was a head, a torso, four limbs. There was still fire, there were still wheels of iron – but he thought he could begin to see how the first layers of a form had been created from a being that was so far removed from anything comprehensible to mortal eyes. Magma steamed and hissed as it flowed along the form of the creature, the veins lighting up and dimming almost with the rhythm of a breath. In its ribcage something flashed through interlocking cogwheels, the black iron braces, the veins of fire that flowed along its form. The wingspan took up the entire room, its tips burning scorch marks into the ceiling.
ARE YOU AFRAID, TYELPERINQUAR?
The voice resonated directly in his mind, and even though Celebrimbor knew that the primordial spirit had already softened its might so as not to drive him mad, the immediacy of it was nigh-enough to shake every sensible thought apart into madness and instinct and reflex.
And yet he let none of it show on his face. Slowly, Celebrimbor stepped up to the creature. “Do you think that I would still be here, if I had an ounce of fear of you in me?” He raised his hand and laid it onto the cheek of the eldritch face. Under his fingers, it began to flow and transform into the features of a being he should have hated until the end of time, and yet had chosen to love until his very soul was destroyed. He touched his other hand to the bite marks of Huan, ran his fingers along the chains of Morgoth on the creature’s arms, the bleeding scar of Annatar’s severed bond to Aulë in the middle of his chest. Something in the Maia’s essence recoiled, but in the end, the spirit remained where it was. Celebrimbor sensed an old, ancient desire to hide and cloak and shadow, but the Maia stayed how he had been – bright and open and burning.
Celebrimbor regarded the marks imprinted on this form: witnesses of a lifetime that was so far beyond his comprehension like a ship that had gone beyond the horizons of Eldamar would have been to Men or Dwarves.
“So we were both right, in the end,” he said quietly. “You needed to show yourself. I needed to look.”
Annatar’s eyes looked back at him, the one familiar thing in an otherwise unknowable entity.
“I see you now,” Celebrimbor said.
The creature was very still.
“And I you,” Annatar’s voice replied at last.
Celebrimbor smiled. Then he stepped forward into the fire, and the flames leapt to meet him. The great wings closed around him like a chrysalis of flame and void, enveloping both him and the spirit, and then he was gone.
Tl;dr of this chapter:
Annatar: i am basically sauron and i'm sorry but you're locked in here with me now
Celebrimbor: yeah no see that's where you are wrong. you are locked in here with me
Annatar: fuck
(does it show that I like semi-dark Celebrimbor)
Also, I'm probably unreasonably proud of "Who made you the tyrant of truth?"