New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
“Did you know about all of that?” Celebrimbor asked tiredly. He lifted his head from his arms that were crossed on the table in the uppermost row of seats in the auditorium. He and Annatar were sitting in comparative privacy, since the upper rows had been all but abandoned. Downstairs, a throng of people was still crowding Wraith and Ossy.
“No,” Annatar said, throwing a long look down where the cat and the A.I. were currently giving interviews like two grandes dames at an opera house. “I had no idea.”
Celebrimbor glanced up, searching for dishonesty in his features, but the Maia seemed to be genuinely non-plussed.
“You did say that development was your Maiarin domain,” Celebrimbor said slowly. “Only I hadn’t imagined it extended … this far. And that it worked this fast.”
“Neither had I.” Annatar sat down on the desk next to Celebrimbor’s left elbow. “I did want the transmitter to be optimized for Wraith’s requirements. I had, however, neither the intention nor any idea that the Ring would take the optimization process into its own hands.”
Celebrimbor ran a hand down his face. By Varda, he was exhausted. “I feel like we should have expected something along those lines.”
“Probably,” Annatar said absently. He was still staring at the tower machine. It was rare for him to be caught off-balance, but the spontaneous emergence of an artificial sentient being had done the trick.
“On a positive note,” someone behind them said, “Wraith and Ossy seem to have confused your aunt so thoroughly that she has forgotten to be angry at you.”
Annatar and Celebrimbor turned around.
Daeror sauntered up to them and perched down on the narrow sliver of desk remaining free next to Annatar. “You have to look on the bright side of life, friends.”
“I’m not sure whether there is a bright side to all of this,” Celebrimbor muttered. “What if this allegiance issue is going to become a problem? This thing could turn on us and become evil.”
“Evil?” Daeror repeated. “Ossy? Oh please. That thing is about as evil as a puppy and as intelligent as a piece of cardboard.” He glanced at Annatar. “No offence intended.”
“He does seem kind of naïve,” Annatar said, fluently switching from neutral pronouns to ‘he’ with a nonchalance that Celebrimbor found very unsettling. Next thing they knew, they were going to be discussing the personhood of a gold ring inside a piece of iron. “I wonder if he’s going to become smarter with time.”
“That’s a given,” Celebrimbor mumbled. “Just look at your cat.” He sighed and ran a hand through his hair. “We shouldn’t have done this.”
“Well, he’s here now, so you’re not getting rid of him anytime soon,” Daeror said with a smile. “Besides, I do get the impression that he’s quite popular already.” He nodded downstairs, where about fifteen grown-up students had graduated from asking Ossy scientific and philosophical trick questions to playing ‘I spy with my fiery eye’ with him.
“It figures that if you two were to somehow produce an offspring, it would be the weirdest progeny imaginable.” Daeror laughed. “Then again, I don’t know what else anyone should have expected of you.”
Annatar’s facial expression did something weird and Celebrimbor threw the bard a flinty look.
“I refuse to take any responsibility for the robot,” he said.
“Takes two to make a kid.”
“I did not make him. It was my cousin and Annatar who brought this thing into the world.”
“Oh wow.” Daeror leaned back with surprise and sized Annatar up with a long top-to-toe look. “Didn’t think you’d go for young Galadrim.”
Annatar elbowed him off the desk. “Shut your trap, Deukalion.”
Daeror snickered as he caught his balance. “Oh, but how could I, when you two are my prime source of amusement on this planet?”
“Do you know what else is amusing?” Celebrimbor asked darkly. “A sudden fire at the local theatre. Fire guard came too late, only ashes and charred walls remain. Most unfortunate.”
“Piano, piano, Curufinwë,” Daeror said, holding up his palms. “I know you come from a line of pyromaniacs, but that doesn’t give you the right to make it your coping strategy whenever you’re angry.”
Celebrimbor muttered disagreement under his breath, but refused to deign it with another reply.
“On the contrary, you should try to find good things in live wherever you can! Amusement especially!” Daeror said, because the bard was, as always, chronically unable to shut his mouth. “Especially now that you are freshly minted parents of what might or not become a superintelligent robot. I’ve heard told that life with a child is quite hard, and, oh, the consequences for love life alone – I shudder to think about it. But then again, that was never up your alley, wasn’t it?”
Celebrimbor was just about to get up and bodily eject Daeror from the auditorium, when Annatar spoke up, and in the most bored tone imaginable said, “No, and we got that out of the way in any case.”
Both Celebrimbor’s and Daeror’s head jerked around and they stared at the Maia.
“Annatar –” Celebrimbor started.
“You did what?” Daeror asked, incredulous.
Annatar shrugged. “We tried it out.”
Daeror looked like his brain had just blown multiple fuses in critical places. He stared at the Maia. Blinked. Stared some more. “You’re having me on, right?”
Annatar met his gaze, frowning. “No? Why would I?”
“You?” Daeror repeated. “Had sex?”
Annatar shrugged. “I guess.”
Daeror stared into the middle distance for a while. “Okay. That – was not. I did not expect that.”
“Excuse me,” Celebrimbor cut in. “Could you two kindly stop talking about –”
“And? How was it?” Daeror asked.
Annatar thought about this for a moment.
“This is not – ” Celebrimbor started.
“It was objectively alright but, personally, not my cup of tea, and I’m not going to do it again,” Annatar said dispassionately, because apparently Maiar had about as little understanding of Incarnate modesty when it came to these topics as a normal person would have had discussing their choice of boots.
Daeror looked at them and blinked, then burst out in shocked, incredulous laughter. “‘Alright’? That … has to be the most lukewarm endorsement of anything I have ever heard. Were this a recension of a work of mine from a critic I valued, I would throw myself out of a window.”
“Oh, would you?” Annatar asked, intrigued, like a man who’d seen a whole universe of new possibilities open up before him.
“You know, it would pain me less if you would have hated it.” Daeror shook his head. “By the gods.” He put his palm against his forehead. “You two. Seriously. Where is the passion, even in hatred? Where is the emotion? I am surrounded by stone trolls! Romance is dead!”
“Do you want me to write the obituary?” Annatar asked. “‘Alas, we hardly knew ye’? If we hurry, we could get it into tomorrow’s edition of the Holly Mirror.”
Daeror snorted. “You are terrible. Simply terrible.”
“So I’ve been told.”
Daeror shook his head and rubbed his fingers over his eyelids. “You two,” he repeated. Then froze. Looked up and stared into the middle distance, clearly doing some mental calculation.
“Wait, when was this?”
“Can you stop asking about our –” Celebrimbor growled.
“About three weeks ago,” Annatar said, once again being way too forthcoming with facts that were absolutely private. “I didn’t think to tell you. It didn’t seem relevant, especially because we’ve been up to more important things in the meantime.”
Daeror calculated again, then he suddenly straightened and slammed his hands down on the desk so hard that both of them jumped.
“Do you two blockheads mean to tell me that you did this immediately after you –,” he accusingly pointed at Annatar, “ – hit your partner over the head with the revelation of what your version of ‘sins of one’s youth’ looked like –”
“Deukalion –”
“ – both of you clearly in a mentally unstable state, when what you should have been doing was reevaluating your relationship in peace and give it some time to acquaint yourselves with those facts! And also, also completely and utterly ignoring the negligible fact that perhaps you should have been taking a brief minute to figure out which direction you actually want to take this relationship in, and, oh, do so beforehand?”
Daeror was clearly getting unreasonably worked up about this, as showcased by his worrying tendency to inject an increasingly excessive amount of italics into his speech.
“ – and instead you decided to jump the cannon and throw yourself into an affair that at neither of you was mentally equipped to handle, let alone the physical aspect that has been causing you so many problems!”
“You know, when you put it like that –” Celebrimbor tried.
“You make it sound so negative.”
Daeror raised one eyebrow in a very accusing, are-you-even-listening-to-yourself way that stopped their excuses short.
Celebrimbor wanted to argue but then realized that he was about to die on the hill of an exceptionally dumb argument, which reminded him way too much of his own grandfather and father. As such, he really, really tried to avoid repeating the same mistake in his own interactions. He let out his breath with a rush. “Maybe it was kind of rushed in hindsight,” he admitted.
Brooding silence followed, and the three of them spent a minute staring intently at their shoes.
“Wait, we are very intelligent people,” Annatar said suddenly, looking up and turning to face Celebrimbor. “How come we are so bad at this?”
“I beg to differ,” Celebrimbor said. “You are very bad at this.”
“Excuse me? Who’s chronically unable to confront his own –”
“I can’t believe it!” Daeror threw out one arm in an upset gesture. “I thought you two were smart! How do you have no impulse control at your age?”
Annatar and Celebrimbor bristled, pointed at each other and said at the same time, “Well, he started it!” They froze, glared at each other, then looked back at the bard.
“I don’t believe it, I don’t believe it,” the bard muttered, half to himself. “Everyone is talking about the general intelligence of a machine construct; why is nobody ever talking about the very specific stupidity of supposedly intelligent people? I wish this degree of stupidity was a criminal offence, so I could drag you in front of a tribunal for this. Only I cannot, since you seem so intent to directing it against yourself. I will, however, have a lawyer I know review whether I can claim some sort damages in the form of harm to my own mental integrity, because this is beyond wilful negligence and veering into the territory of malicious intent. Oh, how can you be so thoroughly stupid about relationships?”
“I do not see how our relationship is in any way your concern,” Celebrimbor interjected, rather sharply.
“But it is!” Daeror exclaimed. “This goes way beyond the two of you! Don’t you remember the bets? The speculation? The histories and fables spun around the greatest Maiarin-Eldarin romance of our age?” He raised his gaze to the ceiling, as if appealing to a deity perched there like a house spider. “By Vairë, what shall become of it?”
“Wait, how is the gossip industry in Eregion our problem now?” Annatar asked.
Daeror looked at him, disbelief on his features. “Think of the people, Annatar! I know you do not tend to do that, mildly autocratic tyrant that you are. But I’m not even speaking of compassion, I speak of history! Do you want ‘alright’, to be the legacy you leave behind?”
“I do hope our collective legacy as a guild will amount to more than our public standing in gossip columns,” Annatar said, his tone bone-dry.
“Bah.” Daeror waved it off. “Whoever is interested in science? You need to get at the heart and soul of the people, and this is something you achieve by speaking to their emotions! But why did I expect you to understand this?” He shook his head in desperation. “Dear Valar, ‘leave it to the scientists’, they keep saying. As if any expertise on important things could be expected from people who get excited about wiggling things in small glass dishes and number charts!” He made a dismissive gesture. “But I see I am talking to the wrong people here. When has someone so pathologically and disgustingly ‘intellectual’ ever understood what lies at the heart of the Incarnate condition?”
“Cardiac valves,” Celebrimbor muttered.
“See, that is exactly what I mean!” Daeror snapped, quite intentionally deciding not to understand sarcasm, grabbing the metaphorical sword by the blade and swivelling it around to point back at the attacker. “You cannot be trusted with this, clearly!”
“Trusted with what?” Annatar asked.
“ – all rationality and no emotions, and then have the audacity to wear it like a badge!”
“Trusted with what?” Annatar repeated with increasing irritation.
“To give people what they need!” Daeror grabbed him by the shoulders and for a moment, Celebrimbor thought that he was going to shake the Maia.
“Notwithstanding that I do not even care about all those faceless gossips,” Annatar snapped, plucking the bard’s fingers off his shoulders, “What are you even talking about? What do they need?”
“Well, a story, of course!”
Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “A story?”
“Quite!” Daeror exclaimed. “They need their story! They need joy and emotion, and most of all, closure and a happy ending!”
“I still fail to see how it is our responsibility in any way, shape, or form to provide a script for a nondescript number of people who are overly invested in personal matters that aren’t their business,” Annatar retorted.
“Yes, and this is why I must take your legacy in my own hands,” Daeror said and slapped his hand down onto the Maia’s shoulder, hard. “It is a heavy burden to bear, but it forever remains the duty of us writers to tell what otherwise would go untold, to unravel, and unveil, and to nurture the beating heart of all that is living. Worry not, I shall take it into my own hands! Your legacy shall not fall into the darkness of insignificance!” And with that he turned around and stormed off.
“He said, ‘worry not’,” Celebrimbor repeated slowly.
“He did.” Annatar kept staring after the bard.
“I am very worried.”
The Maia did not respond immediately. “It can’t be too bad,” he said after some moments of thinking. “He’s probably going to spread some tall tale about eternal love, and spin it in a way that makes him win all the bets that he mentioned.” He tapped his chin pensively, thinking about this for a few seconds. “We could blackmail his winnings out of him.”
Celebrimbor sighed. “I know you’re a lot older than me, but at some point, you will learn not to say ‘what’s the worst that could happen?’ It never ends well.”
Annatar threw him a side glance. “I didn’t take you for someone to fall prey to superstition.”
“The word you’re looking for is ‘empirical evidence’.”
“If you say so.” Annatar noticed something out of the corner of his eye and turned to look at a rush of movement down in the centre of the auditorium. “Speaking of the worst that could happen – your aunt finally got bored of the robot, and I think she wants to talk to you.”
Celebrimbor groaned and let his head sink into his hands. “Could you stay with me? I don’t think I can face her alone.”
“Do you really think that’s smart?”
“Honestly?” Celebrimbor looked up. “I don’t know what’s smart anymore, and I’m not sure I care either way. My supreme desire right now is that I do not want to be alone in a room – or a conversation – with her.”
“I have utmost faith in your ability to withstand her ire,” Annatar said pleasantly. When Celebrimbor threw him a disappointed look, he continued, “But yes, of course. I’ll stay. Back in the First Age, I was very good at drawing enemy fire away from where it was meant to go. Battle tactics are a forte of mine.”
“Please do not mention your service of Morgoth in the presence of my aunt.”
“Valar forbid.” Annatar grinned wolfishly. “I wouldn’t want her to get a wrong impression of me.”
Celebrimbor rolled his eyes, then laughed despite himself. “Implying there is a right impression to be had.” He stood from where he had been slumped at the desk. “Out of the frying pan and into the fire, then. Shall we?”
“Of course. After you.”
Artanis was coming up the stairs, Celebrían following behind her.
Celebrimbor straightened to his full height, preparing himself to answer a lot of sharply worded questions about genetical engineering on cats and species uplift without proper consideration for the consequences.
As was typical for her, Artanis asked none of these questions, all of which would be logical and expected. Instead, as was even more typical for her, she verbally wound up a knock-out punch in his blind spot, then clocked him violently and ruthlessly over the head with it:
“So what is that Ring the cat was speaking of?” she demanded, her voice dangerously pleasant.
Annatar and Celebrimbor shared a glance that spoke volumes about musings on mortality despite being immortal.
They turned back to face Artanis, who raised an eyebrow expectantly. “Do explain, if you would. I am dying to hear this story.”
As it turned out, Annatar’s famed tactic of drawing fire did not work in a situation in which someone decided to indiscriminately bomb the entire battlefield.