New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
When Celebrimbor woke up, he was alone. A low, quiet pang of disappointment surged in his stomach, but it was quickly replaced by relief when he spotted Annatar in one of the armchairs standing by the hearth, one leg drawn up to his chest, the other stretched out, a book in one hand, while the was supporting his temple with the other. He was back in his usual robes, and he did not look up when Celebrimbor sat up, obviously too focused on what he was currently reading.
He threw aside the blankets and padded over to the god lounging in his armchair. The room had cooled off during the night, and the cold air seeped through his thin clothes he had slept in.
He leaned his lower arms on the back of the armchair and bowed down. “Good morning. What are you reading?”
Annatar acknowledged his presence at last, turning around and looking up at him. “Theories on transmission of information in general, and osanwë in particular.” Annatar briefly flipped the book close, this forefinger still marking the page he was at, and looked at the author’s name stamped on the cover. “Ylva Háldursdóttir has some interesting thoughts on the aspects of quantum entanglement that might play into it.”
“So, perfectly light reading for a Sunday morning.”
“Hmh.”
“That was meant ironically.”
“I am aware.”
Celebrimbor laughed and dropped a kiss on the Maia’s head. “How are you?”
“Fine,” Annatar replied. “I’m fine.”
Celebrimbor looked down at Annatar, then reached out, combing his fingers through the fine golden strands. They slid through his fingers like silk, like water, not catching in the slightest. “Are you sure? Yesterday was … a lot.”
There was the fact that they had spent the entire day in here, up until the early hours of the morning. Which had been intimate, and interesting, and all other kinds of pleasant things. But there was also the fact that they had been so caught up in this rush, in each other, that they had charged past boundaries they probably should have taken more time to examine and explore, rather than leaping over them at a run and without looking back. There was also the very real fact that they had crashed into some of these obstacles at full speed, and found no way to surmount them. Like the fact that things went rather well as long as Annatar was leading and Celebrimbor followed, but fell to pieces the moment they switched. Or the fact that control was very much a thing, and tangled up in a snarl with all other kinds of issues, buried in experiences that neither was willing or ready to touch, and that they probably should have slowed down at some point rather than steamrolling over it. Or the fact that Annatar had noticeably phased out of true corporeality multiple times, but had refused to stop and acknowledge it in the moment.
If they were to continue their relationship along this line (and that was a big “if” to begin with), there was a lot of work to be done, and it would have to be handled differently than screwing one’s eyes shut, gritting one’s teeth, and blazing through it with wilful blindness and sheer stubbornness. And they both knew it.
Annatar didn’t answer immediately, looking straight ahead at the door to the study, still closed, his thoughts apparently running along similar tracks. “I’m fine,” he repeated.
Celebrimbor waited. He knew the Maia well enough to be able to tell when he wasn’t saying everything.
When Annatar had not replied after what had to be a full five minutes, Celebrimbor rounded the armchair and sat down on the right armrest. He nudged Annatar with his elbow.
“You know,” Celebrimbor said, trying a cheerful tone. “Time and time again, I do try to be patient, and time and time again I find out that I simply do not have the temper for it. What is it? Out with it.”
Annatar stared at the book. “Nothing is wrong.”
“I would hope not. But that wasn’t what I was asking. What is on your mind?”
Annatar finally looked up at him, and his expression was an odd amalgamation of annoyance, doubt, and trepidation. “I don’t regret what we did,” he said.
“Wonderful. Still not the question. I’m hearing an unsaid ‘but’ waiting in the wings.” Celebrimbor held Annatar’s gaze. He had a feeling that he knew where this was going, but he wanted the Maia to come forth and said it himself.
Again, a few moments passed in silence, with Annatar noticeably sorting through his talking points like someone else might arrange tools in a workspace before he begun an assembly of complicated machinery.
“Would you think it terribly strange or illogical,” Annatar said at last, “if I told you that yesterday was acceptable, with no notable objective negative; that it was all perfectly bearable, and I do not have the slightest desire to ever repeat it?”
Celebrimbor fought the strange, sudden urge to laugh. He schooled his features into a serious expression, though, knowing that the moment was delicate. “Given what I know of you – given that I know you, colour me terribly, horribly unsurprised.”
Annatar glanced at him askance. “You do not mind?”
“Annatar, I am old and mature enough to hold apart the two very unrelated principles of your personal preferences and my hypothetical expectations.” Celebrimbor shifted his weight on the armrest and interlaced his fingers around his right knee. “Besides – and I do not want to be the one to say ‘I told you so’ – but I did in fact tell you so months ago. I do not mind. Never have, never will.”
Annatar looked at the book again. Tapped the cover. “Good,” he said at last. He tapped the cover again. “I truly wanted to try it,” he said. “To see. To know. If it would work. If I could.”
Celebrimbor waited if more words were forthcoming. When nothing came, he said, “I understand the desire to try. However, you didn’t have to prove anything to the world, or to me. Or to yourself, for that matter.”
Annatar’s silence was telling.
“And even if you absolutely had to,” Celebrimbor said, “you already did. Now do the science where you look at the results and draw your conclusion.” He nudged the Maia with his elbow again.
“I don’t understand it,” Annatar said, but did not elaborate. “I do like to have you close to me – there is nothing bad about – it wasn’t bad – why –” He broke off again.
Celebrimbor remained quiet. There was nothing he could add to this. Annatar knew what he needed to know. The facts were there. He was smart. Some puzzles just needed a bit of peace and quiet to be assembled; and some truths needed a bit of time to sink in. And solitude. Being alone and being honest with oneself, most of all.
When Annatar looked up, his expression was tense. “I hope I did not do any damage.”
Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “Damage? How ever do you mean that?”
“By creating a false perspective,” he said. “For you. Me. Both of us. False expectations.”
“I already told you – I do not mind. Tell me how many times I have to repeat it until you believe me, and I shall do it now to get it out of the way.”
“I do believe you,” Annatar said, frustrated. “But I also know that forcing the issue like this was probably not … right. I was – ” He looked at his hands. “Relieved. Glad. To see you. To have you back. To have you look at me and know that you still wanted me here, despite … everything. I got carried away.”
“So did I. It happens.” Celebrimbor gingerly put an arm around Annatar’s shoulders. “You are not exempt from emotions just because you do not feel them in the exact same way or in the same situations someone else does. You feel things. You want things. You try them on, see if they fit you or if they don’t. And if they don’t, there’s no harm done. We are allowed to express ourselves. We can change our minds, backtrack, reevaluate, and decide that some things are not for us, after all. That’s the one beautiful thing in this largely limited, often painful, and thoroughly senseless mortal coil.”
Annatar did not reply.
“Give it some time,” Celebrimbor said gently. “Some truths are larger than others. They take a bit more time to sink in.”
A few seconds of silence ticked by.
“You’ve thought a lot about this,” Annatar observed, his tone flat.
“I have been Incarnate all my life. I was also – a long time ago – young and wondering where I fit into the world. In a lot of ways. All of us Incarnates do.”
Annatar made a derisive sound. “I feel given my status and age, I should have done better. Known better.”
“You had and have the luxury of being able to bend the world around you to your will,” Celebrimbor responded. “At what point would it ever have made sense to you – let alone been necessary – to ask yourself those questions?”
Annatar thought about this, then, with a nod, conceded the point.
“Don’t drive yourself mad over it,” Celebrimbor said. “It’s fine. You are fine as you are.”
“You don’t need to coddle me, Tyelperinquar.”
“I don’t. But I know doubt is an ugly thing; and if you cannot believe yourself right now, perhaps you can believe in an outside perspective.”
Annatar thought about this, then nodded again. “Thank you.” He took a breath. “So how do we – Do we just go back to how we were?”
“That has worked out quite well for us up until now, wouldn’t you say?” Celebrimbor said amicably. “We work well like that. So yes, let’s go back to how we were.”
“Just like that?”
“Just like that.”
“Oh,” Annatar said, obviously confounded by the simplicity of the decision. “Well then. Yes. I’d like that.”
After a few minutes spent with each of them pensively plodding along their respective trains of thought, Celebrimbor’s mind snagged on something.
“Strange, though,” he said under his breath.
“What is strange?” Annatar asked, looking up at him.
“Your excuse,” Celebrimbor said, and a broad grin spread over his lips.
“What excuse? What are you even talking about?” Annatar frowned.
“‘I got carried away’?” Celebrimbor repeated, then change his tone to imitate Annatar’s arch, stilted tones. “What happened to ‘Everything I do is intentional and premediated, instincts are for those who can’t do better, I don’t even have a knee-jerk reflex that I didn’t decide on three hours ago and isn’t part of some millennium-old-scheme to –”
“Oh, get lost, Tyelperinquar.” Annatar shoved him off the armrest with a bit more force than necessary.
Celebrimbor stumbled and caught his balance, laughing.
“You are such an –” Annatar broke off, then grumbled something inarticulate to himself.
“I am everything you want, and everything you deserve,” Celebrimbor said cheerily. He circled the small table and threw himself into the one opposite of Annatar. Which was, incidentally, when the book Annatar had been reading caught his eye again. “So. Osanwë? You still want to enable that cat of yours to talk to everyone and their dog?”
“Yes.”
Celebrimbor rolled his eyes, but grinned. “If you’ve gotten it in your head to do something …” He trailed off with a shake of his head. “So, go on. Do tell, what did you discover? Did you develop and apparatus that is able to make use of quantum entanglement to mentally communicate beyond osanwë?”
Annatar looked suddenly and inexplicably like someone had caught him with the hand in the cookie jar. He looked down at the book, frowned, then closed it, before setting it aside on his armrest. “Remember the thought-to-speech project I had told you hadn’t worked?”
“Yes, I remember. So?”
“I lied.”
Celebrimbor lifted an eyebrow.
“It worked too well, rather. It also was based on an artifact I decided not to create after. Er. Abandoning my plans of.” Annatar had the grace to look discomfited.
Celebrimbor’s eyebrow climbed higher.
“Conquering Middle-earth,” Annatar finished stiffly.
Celebrimbor blinked twice, then looked out of the window with an empty stare. After a while, he sighed and turned back to look at the slightly-too-unrepentant Maia sitting opposite of him and looking at him with growing defiance.
Annatar had never been good at expressing regret, much rather choosing to jump onto whatever barricade presented itself and defending his actions down to blood and bones. Not necessarily because he still stood by his views and decisions, but because he was terminally unable to admit mistakes. Celebrimbor doubted this was going to change. As it was, raking Annatar over the coals for his abandoned plans of world domination probably wouldn’t do much, other than cause an unproductive argument, which Celebrimbor really wasn’t in the mood for.
“What artifact?” he asked instead.
Annatar, who had visibly been expecting an attack, deflated a bit. “A Ring,” he said.
Celebrimbor’s gaze darkened. The perceived temperature in the room suddenly plummeted below freezing. “You didn’t.”
“No, I didn’t.”
“You did not intend to take over the other Rings we have been making, you did not intend to drag our shared work into the dirt by doing this.” His fingers dug into the armrests of the chair. His voice might or might not have come out as a growl.
“As I said, I didn’t do it,” Annatar said, effortlessly managing the turnabout from being defensive into being offended.
“You planned to.”
“I –”
“That is vile.”
“I didn’t do it, Tyelperinquar! I burned the designs, if you must know!”
“I appreciate the gesture,” Celebrimbor said. “But you must agree that it doesn’t mean much coming from a being who never forgets about anything. You write down notes for the benefits of others, not because you would ever forget something.”
“I’m sorry, I don’t have more than gestures! How else am I supposed to prove my goodwill?”, Annatar shot back. “Do you want me to – what – lobotomize myself to make the point?”
Celebrimbor didn’t reply, mostly because that was a good point and he despised it. His fingers dug a bit further into the armrests. Something cracked, probably something in his finger joints. He consciously, deliberately, relaxed his grip.
“Fine,” he said at last. “Fine. And this project just so happened to make a resurgence when you sought ways to enable Wraith to speak?”
“Aspects of it came up again,” Annatar corrected. “For example, the ability to reach into the mind of another being and speak into it without the aid of osanwë.”
“I cannot express strongly enough how thoroughly intrusive and loathsome I find the idea of mind-controlling device,” Celebrimbor said slowly, every world placed with the deliberation and finality of moving a chess piece. He was trying very hard not to get angry. He was only halfway successful.
“Yes, which is why I discarded it.” Annatar crossed his arms. “Even I don’t want to live in a world where Wraith has a Ring that enables her to dominate the mind of living beings, thank you very much.”
Celebrimbor couldn’t help a humourless laugh escaping his lips. “How glad I am that we have finally unearthed where you draw the line on immoral behaviour.”
Annatar’s eyebrow twitched. “Did you want to know where I was going with this or are we going to dissect my moral failings for the rest of the morning? It might take us some time.”
Celebrimbor closed his eyes, took a deep breath to dispel the black snarl of anger and disappointment growing in his chest, and waved his hand in a permissive gesture. “Do go on.”
“Thank you. As I was saying, I might have come up with a solution to enable her to speak with everyone. Or rather, not enable her to speak with everyone, but create a proxy through which she can do it.”
Celebrimbor opened his eyes. “As in, a loudspeaker? A translator?”
“Something like that,” Annatar said.
Celebrimbor sat up straighter, intrigued despite his misgivings about everything he had just heard about Rings and mind-control. He was vaguely aware that he shouldn’t discard this so lightly, but he was way more acutely aware that something in his brain had just been prodded awake and found that it was hungry. Very hungry. For knowledge that it didn’t yet have.
“This could arguably be worse than giving her opposable thumbs, you do realize that, don’t you?” Celebrimbor asked, but to be honest, it was more for the sake of token opposition rather than because his heart was truly in it. His mind was already whirring with the possibilities of applicability – how far could one extend communication if transmission and translation were no longer an issue? The mute survivors of Angband were almost a given, but what of other sentient beings, what of nature, what of going even further and finding a what to translate intent to molecular structures and –
Annatar’s voice cut off this train of thought before it could barrel away, derail, and crash somewhere in a ball of fire.
“I know. It also brings with it a host of other hazards that a normal – let’s called it ‘Ring’ – wouldn’t have, what with energy consumption to establish the connection and to do the translating and transmitting. Or the fact that one would have to override the separation of naturally discrete minds, which mortals other than Eldar possess, and the damages that could occur in the process.” Annatar’s gaze was fixed on something far away, before returning to the here and now, and to Celebrimbor. “Which I do realize is inherently dangerous and transgressive. It is the reason why I didn’t want to go forward with it,” he added. “Or, at least not without your approval.”
The unspoken question was hanging in the air between them.
Celebrimbor looked at Annatar. Annatar looked back, one eyebrow arched in silent inquiry.
Celebrimbor was very aware that this kind of knowledge might have been better off not being touched with a ten-foot pole. In fact, the responsible, the sensible thing to do would probably have been to forget about ever having had this discussion in the first place, and move on.
Annatar was still looking at him. Waiting.
His own brain was still whirring, already stumbling over itself with questions and hypotheses he wanted to try and verify and –
Ah well.
It wasn’t as if he had spent his long, long life making smart decisions.
*
True to her announcement via letter, Celebrían did arrive on the first of December. Celebrimbor was there to meet her at the gates, and subsequently nearly thrown off his feet when his younger cousin leapt off her mare and rushed at him into an embrace that was going to bruise a few ribs (probably), was against all rules of proper conduct and protocol when welcoming a lady of Celebrían’s status (very likely), and would make it back to his aunt’s and uncle’s ears via the guards that had accompanied her (with almost absolute certainty, much to Celebrimbor’s dismay).
They both laughed when the momentum swept them around in a circle, and Celebrimbor set her down again. Which was not as far down as it used to be only a few decades ago.
“Stars, you’ve grown,” Celebrimbor grinned. “Keep at it and you’ll surpass your mother.”
Celebrían grinned back. “One of my life goals.”
He ruffled her silver-blond hair, against all Eldarin custom cut short to fall to her shoulders, and one of the guards of Lóthlorien flinched. However, there was such a thing as superior social status, and though Celebrimbor usually loathed its implications, there were situations when clout and power came in handy. Like now.
He turned towards the guards, all composed formality. “Thank you very much for escorting my cousin on her way here. You must be tired after the long journey. We will find you some suitable accommodations where you can rest.”
Which as polite a “Get lost and leave us alone” as anyone would ever be able to manage, and honestly, Celebrimbor was quite pleased with himself for thinking of it.
The guards shared furtive glances, clearly conflicted. Celebrimbor knew that they had been ordered to stay close to Celebrían and shadow her every step. However, they also couldn’t very well defy the order of a lord in his own city.
Celebrimbor didn’t envy them their quandary. He had also no intention of resolving it for them in his cousin’s disfavour. He had promised his aunt to keep Celebrían away from Annatar – he had not promised to allow her to be surveilled and chaperoned in every moment she spent here.
Celebrían in turn, assumed a posture and expressions befitting of lady of Galadrim, and turned to her guards as well. “I thank you for your company and your protection. My cousin will take care of me for now. I am in good hands.”
The weight of an order of their own lady dropped with the weight of a millstone onto that of Celebrimbor’s dismissal. He noticed one guard grimacing at the Galad to her left, then the leader of the little company stepped forward, her expression pained.
“We have no reservations about entrusting Lady Celebrían to your care, Lord Tyelperinquar,” the guard said. She was good, there was almost no way to discern that she was lying through her teeth.
“However, the Lady Artanis has requested we be present for every journey of Lady Celebrían into the city or the guild quarters. So I ask your forgiveness that we will have to accompany her while she is outside of her private quarters.”
No way around Artanis’ authority, then. Even here, so far from the realm of the Galadrim. Or, rather, no direct way.
Celebrimbor and Celebrían shared a long look and a silent communication passed between them, exclusively reserved for siblings or cousins that had gotten into trouble together more times than merited counting. He knew that they were thinking the same thing.
Nearly at the same time, they turned back towards the guards.
“My apologies,” Celebrimbor said smoothly. “If those are the orders you have been given, my aunt’s authority shall, of course, be respected. You shall accompany my cousin, then, as soon as she sets foot outside the door of her private chambers.”
Which was a very specific kind of truth. But Celebrimbor was very good at using bespoke truths to his advantage, which is why nobody noticed. And it was not as if the poor guards were ever going to find out about it.
*
The full moon was high in the sky, surrounded by the distant, silver dots of far-off stars. The air was cuttingly cold, cold enough to transform his breath into white clouds.
The complex of towers, roofs, bridges, and walkways of the massive building that housed the guilds stretched out below him. Even further below, there was the city with its flickering yellow lights.
Celebrimbor gauged the distance to the next roof ridge with no small amount of apprehension. The gap between the two roofs yawned like a chasm. There was also snow everywhere. If he slipped, it wouldn’t be a short or pleasant fall.
Celebrimbor grimaced. Nothing for it.
He took two steps back, then broke into a run. His left foot hammered into the roof ridge at the last possible moment, then, for three seconds, there was only air and horrifying void below his feet – and then he landed, rolling over his left shoulder and coming back to his feet with a groan where his shoulder blade had dug into the tiles.
“I’m getting too old for this,” he muttered, rolling his arm in its socket until something, thankfully, popped back into place.
“Come now, I hope it will be another few millennia before a bit of roof-jumping stops you from having a bit of fun.”
He looked up to see a cloaked silhouette on the roof of a little turret, slightly to the left and about eight feet above where he currently stood. The shape was wearing a cowl and a cloak, pitch-black against the night sky. As he was looking, the shape shifted, then elegantly dropped down from its perch, rolled, and came back to its – her feet.
Celebrían threw back her cowl, her silver-gold hair bright in the moonlight, a few strands plastered across her forehead. She grinned.
“You do realize that if your mother finds out about this, she’s going to kill both of us,” Celebrimbor said flatly. “So I’d ask for a bit more gratitude. I’m subjecting myself to a lot of danger and repercussions here.”
Celebrían snorted. “Since when do you care about danger or repercussions?”
Which, okay, fair point.
“Your guards?” Celebrimbor asked instead.
“Stationed outside my door and none the wiser,” Celebrían said, squinting up at one of the higher towers in the building. “The door is locked, and I closed the window behind me, so the cold will not tip them off.” She crossed her arms. “Ah, windows. For all that they are unnecessary, one has to appreciate their existence in cities.”
Celebrimbor followed her gaze to the tower. It was quite a climb. He had no idea how one made it without ropes, hooks, or climbing cleats. But then again, he was a Noldo, and thus of a people that were more prone to delving underground than climbing. The Galadrim were, at their heart, tree-people, and if that extended to their princesses being able to climb sheer brick walls like squirrels, then who was he to question it?
“Well then,” Celebrimbor said. “Where do you want to go?”
“Does that one tavern still exist?” Celebrían asked. “In the artisan’s quarter, the one that’s supplied by the Dwarven brewery of Khazad-Dûm?”
“The Foundry?”
“That one, yes.”
“In business and thriving, and as always open at ungodly hours for every kind of clientele.” Celebrimbor grinned. “Want to go?”
“Why are you even asking?” Celebrían pulled her hood up again, then gestured grandly at the horrible, mortally dangerous descent across multiple roofs and ten-story-drops ahead of them. “After you.”
Celebrimbor sighed deeply.
*
They reached the tavern, and did so without broken bones or sprained ankles, which was a pleasant surprise.
However, Celebrimbor certainly felt like he’d be black and blue and sore all over from running, skidding, and braking, and more leaping and rolling than he cared for in a good day. As they walked down an empty street in the outer perimeter of the city, he kept prodding at his aching ribs and grimacing.
Celebrían watched it with barely concealed amusement. “My, perhaps you are getting old, Tyelperinquar.”
“Contrary to you, I don’t spend my days hopping around trees like a squirrel,” Celebrimbor grouched as he hobbled down the dark street, only lit by intermittent pools of yellow light from the street lamps.
“No, you’ve just turned into a complete and utter lab-rat, unable to manage such basic things like jumping roof-tops, let alone surviving for one day out in the wild,” Celebrían needled, then let out an aborted laugh-screech, when Celebrimbor quickly turned around and hooked his arm around her neck, pulling her into a headlock.
“What’s that you said?” he asked, while her fists drummed quite ineffectively against his back. Laughter was, luckily, sapping the strength of her punches considerably. “How’s that for lab-rat, then, you loudmouth?” he asked, looking down at her struggling against his grip.
Celebrían responded by hooking her ankle around his and yanking, and nearly tipping them both off-balance. Which was smart, because Celebrimbor had to let her go in order not to tumble face-first into the wall to their left.
He caught his balance just before that happened. “You also fight like a squirrel.”
“And yet you had to let me go. What does that tell us about squirrels and rats?” Celebrían righted herself and combed her hair back into some semblance of order, her face red and her mouth stretched into a bright grin.
“That rats have better manners and fighting etiquette.”
“You wish, old man.”
Celebrimbor made another attempt at grabbing her, but Celebrían quickly slipped out of his reach.
Their good-natured quarrelling was interrupted when they reached the tavern. In the spirit of being both unobtrusive and appearing like normal members of society, they composed themselves, pulled their hoods up, and entered.
Their arrival didn’t draw a lot of attention. The Foundry was one of those taverns where you could leave your hood up, no questions asked, pay for a room without leaving a name, and have the owner forget about you as soon as you walked out of the door. It was not dodgy, per se, but it was a place to have a drink and a conversation in private, which was exactly what they were looking for.
After getting their drinks they slid onto the benches bracketing a corner table.
Celebrían stared down at her tankard of Dwarven brew. “Stars, Mother would hate this.”
Celebrimbor arched an eyebrow. “What, the fact that you are drinking beer?”
“No, everything.” Celebrían gave a one-sided shrugged. “The fact that I broke out – which I am sure she already suspects. But also the other implications: that I am not behaving the way I should, that I am throwing some kind of wrench in the works by not being a complete carbon copy of her and father, that I want to come here in the first place. Many things.” She took a sip, trying – and failing – to sound unaffected.
Celebrimbor studied her. “She means well, you know.”
“I know.” Celebrían set her tankard down with quite a bit more force than necessary. “But that doesn’t help when everything I say or do makes me feel bad about myself. I constantly feel like I should be different, act differently, want different things – especially when it comes to you and Ost-in-Edhil. Is it so wrong to want things to be normal for once?”
“This city is always going to be a sore spot for her and your father,” Celebrimbor said. “It’s the same for me. We try to avoid it, but some things, like you coming here, simply force the confrontation with the conflict we’ve been trying to bury.”
Celebrían looked up at him from under her hood, her grey eyes wide, and for a moment, she looked much younger than her years. “Did you not want me to come here?” she asked, her voice small, and Celebrimbor’s heart broke a little.
He reached over the table his fingers closing over her hand that had turned to a white-knuckled fist on the table. “Of course I wanted you to visit. More than anything. I wish you came here more often. Stars, I wish your mother and father would visit more often – just without all the … baggage. But just because that isn’t going to happen and having you here is always going to cause some friction doesn’t mean that it isn’t worth it three times over when it means I get to see you.”
Celebrían held his gaze, searching his face – perhaps for dishonesty, perhaps for something else – then a small, tentative smile tugged at her lips. “Alright,” she said. Then, “Thank you.”
Celebrimbor arched an eyebrow. “For what? You’re paying, I hope you know that.”
Her smile turned into a grin. “Cheapskate.”
“I sacrificed my health and bodily integrity in bringing you here. You can stand to sacrifice a few silvers in turn.”
Celebrían stuck out her tongue at him, but didn’t argue further, instead taking another sip. “So,” she said when she set down her tankard once more, “how have you been?”
Celebrimbor shrugged. “Bad folk always live well, don’t you know that?”
“Don’t I know,” she chuckled. “How are you experiments coming along? Mother seems perpetually worried that we’re going to wake up one day and find out you’ve blown up the city.”
Celebrimbor thought back to the experiments he and Annatar we’re currently undertaking, and elected not to respond to that.
Celebrían cocked her head to one side. “What? Are you planning to blow up the city?” She sounded fascinated more than scandalized, which was probably one of the chief points why Artanis wanted to limit her daughter’s exposure to Celebrimbor. Again, he could not really fault her for it.
“Why,” he asked instead, “would I want to blow up my home?”
“I don’t know. I’ve certainly had the urge more than once,” Celebrían said with a shrug. “What are you working on?”
Celebrimbor thought briefly about how much to tell her, then decided that the truth would do, albeit without the finer details. “My friend wants to make cats talk.”
There was a brief silence as Celebrían processed this. “Make. Cats. Talk,” she repeated.
Celebrimbor nodded. “He has a special cat. She is … strange. She learned osanwë, for one. She can also read, and reason and argue, and I have the suspicion she is plotting a cat uprising, but that’s an issue for another day.”
Celebrían’s eyebrows had climbed to respectable heights already, but at “cat uprising”, they vanished under the fringe of her hair. Celebrimbor became suddenly and acutely aware how thoroughly mental his everyday life must seem from an outside perspective.
“I … see,” Celebrían said. “And this cat who knows osanwë is now supposed to … talk? Like we are talking right now?”
“No. Physical limitations. But we are thinking –”
Oh Valar, when had ‘Annatar has this idée fixe that a super-powered communications device could aid a cat in transcending limits when it comes to mind-to-mind conversation with mortals’ become ‘we are thinking that’?
Celebrimbor sighed. “He thinks he can engineer a device that allows her to mentally speak to mortals like humans or Dwarves.”
Celebrían gave him the look of someone who was trying very hard not to stare judgmentally at someone clinically insane. “I see. That’s … a project, I guess. I don’t know why I ever thought you’d be doing something useful and groundbreaking with your time.” She paused. “But why? This sounds worse than giving them opposable thumbs.”
“That’s just what I told him!” Celebrimbor said, feeling, all of a sudden, very vindicated in his barely-expressed, half-hearted reservations.
“Your scientist friend sounds like someone who’s so preoccupied with whether or not he could do the thing that he didn't stop to think if he should do the thing,” Celebrían observed.
“He very much is.” So, incidentally, was Celebrimbor, but it seemed like a bad moment to bring this up.
“And?”
“What?”
“Did you try to stop him?”
“Er.” Celebrimbor stared into his tankard. “We’re … actually. We are about to try out the prototype tomorrow.”
He could feel Celebrían’s stare boring into his forehead.
Silence stretched between them.
“Your friend,” Celebrían said at last. “This is the shady Maia that my mother is so worried about?”
“He’s not shady.”
“Noooo, he just pranced around Eregion, offering every leader of note the collaboration and knowledge that would make their most secret of desires come true. That’s not shady at all.”
Celebrimbor did not appreciate the sarcasm. He appreciated even less that his cousin had a point. “Fine. So maybe he is a little bit shady. But he’s working on it.”
“On getting less shady.”
“Yes.
“What a relief.” Celebrían drummed her fingers on the thick wooden table. Then her eyes flitted towards him. “I think I’m going to come and take a look at this demonstration, if you don’t mind.”
Celebrimbor felt a sinking feeling in his gut. He had promised his aunt to keep his cousin out of danger and, most importantly, away from Annatar. He also really, really did not want to say no to Celebrían, but at the same time he really, really didn’t want her in the same room during an experiment with a prototype that could potentially blow out a wing of the engineering quarter.
He also knew, given that the two of them had just broken out of the guildquarters together, that he had no chance of stopping Celebrían from getting anywhere.
Oh well. It seemed like his life wasn’t done balancing between impossible options.
You can pry Celebrían Auditore da Firenze from my cold dead hands.